You are on page 1of 7

Powder Metallurgy

ISSN: 0032-5899 (Print) 1743-2901 (Online) Journal homepage: https://www.tandfonline.com/loi/ypom20

Axial fatigue testing of Ti–6Al–4V using an


alternative specimen geometry fabricated by
metal injection moulding

J. Soyama, O. M. Ferri, T. Ebel & K. U. Kainer

To cite this article: J. Soyama, O. M. Ferri, T. Ebel & K. U. Kainer (2016) Axial fatigue testing of
Ti–6Al–4V using an alternative specimen geometry fabricated by metal injection moulding,
Powder Metallurgy, 59:5, 344-349, DOI: 10.1080/00325899.2016.1251060

To link to this article: https://doi.org/10.1080/00325899.2016.1251060

Published online: 08 Nov 2016.

Submit your article to this journal

Article views: 169

View related articles

View Crossmark data

Full Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at


https://www.tandfonline.com/action/journalInformation?journalCode=ypom20
Axial fatigue testing of Ti–6Al–4V using an
alternative specimen geometry fabricated by
metal injection moulding
J. Soyama∗ , O. M. Ferri, T. Ebel and K. U. Kainer
The hourglass-shaped specimen, which is commonly used for axial fatigue testing, cannot be
easily fabricated by metal injection moulding. Consequently, this work aimed at evaluating the
performance of an alternative specimen (dog bone geometry) for fatigue characterisation.
Additionally, an effort towards the assessment of the fatigue damage with specimens fatigued
until halflife was made. The alloy used in this study, serving as an example for the test
validation, was Ti–6Al–4V. The feasibility of using the specimens for fatigue testing was
confirmed with a narrow scatterband, however, only in the range of 105 cycles. The crack
initiation sites were always found on the surface associated with quasi cleavage facets.
Specimens fatigued until halflife showed a decrease in ductility in conventional tensile testing;
nonetheless, the ultimate tensile strength remained unchanged.
Keywords: Ti–6Al–4V, MIM, Axial fatigue testing

Introduction type of specimen is very hard to be fabricated by


MIM without machining operations and consequently
Ti–6Al–4V presents attractive properties such as high loss of the as-sintered surface. Not only is the sample
specific strength at room and moderate temperatures, integrity compromised because of the thinner cross-sec-
good corrosion resistance and biocompatibility.1,2 The tion in the middle, but also is the concentricity affected
applications of Ti–6Al–4V, however, have some con- during sintering, which negatively influences the
straints related to raw material and processing costs. measurements of fatigue properties. Therefore, the possi-
Wrought alloys are the most commonly used; neverthe- bility of using alternative specimen geometries, which
less, other processing routes that do not need extensive are easily produced and that have a representative as-
machining and avoid material waste are gaining popu- sintered surface, would widen the choices of tools for
larity. One of the most prominent processes that allow fatigue characterisation of MIM components.
cost-effective near-net shape fabrication of complex geo- A significant characterisation effort, regarding the fati-
metries corresponds to metal injection moulding (MIM). gue properties of MIM components, was carried out by
It has been recently shown that MIM-processed tita- Ferri et al.3,8,9 using the smooth bar geometry in four-
nium alloys can achieve ultimate tensile strength point bending configuration. Niinomi et al.10 employed
(UTS) of approximately 850 MPa and ductility of flat specimens with a rectangular cross-section in axial
around 14% with 3.5% of residual porosity.3–6 Addition- loading and achieved results in the same range. Recently,
ally, with a close control of the process, the overall Horke et al.11 reported fatigue measurements in a rotating
impurities and especially the oxygen level can be kept bending configuration using machined hourglass speci-
sufficiently low. mens from MIM pre-forms. However, no related publi-
Up to now, however, the fatigue behaviour of MIM cation could be found, in which the common MIM dog
components in axial loading was only scarcely charac- bone-shaped specimen was used for fatigue testing. In
terised. The most common geometry for axial fatigue comparison to bending, axial loading offers the advan-
testing corresponds to the hourglass shape, which has tage of a larger volume of material under maximum
a continuous radius between the grip ends with the mini- load in addition to a more homogeneous stress distri-
mum diameter at the centre. To guarantee crack bution along the cross-section.
initiation inside the gauge length, the cross-section of In this work, axial fatigue testing of Ti–6Al–4V was
the grips’ area should be at least four times that of the conducted using dog bone-shaped specimens (ISO
test area, according to the ASTM E466 standard.7 2740). Fatigue tests were also stopped at halflife, and
Owing to the special geometrical requirements, this the specimens were ultimately fractured by tensile test-
ing. Fractographic analyses were applied to find the
Helmholtz-Zentrum Geesthacht, Institute of Materials Research, Max- crack initiation sites and identify the fatigue initiating
Planck-Straße 1, D-21502 Geesthacht, Germany defects, as well as measure the stable crack propagation

Corresponding author, email julianosoyama@gmail.com length.

© 2016 Institute of Materials, Minerals and Mining


Published by Taylor & Francis on behalf of the Institute
Received 29 September 2015; accepted 15 October 2016
344 DOI 10.1080/00325899.2016.1251060 Powder Metallurgy 2016 VOL 59 NO 5
Soyama et al. Axial fatigue testing of Ti–6Al–4V using an alternative specimen geometry fabricated by MIM

Materials and experimental procedures number was then compared to the unit length of the test
line and as a result, the mean α colony size was deter-
Ti–6Al–4V grade 23 pre-alloyed powder with particle size mined. The determination of the limits of the colonies
<45 µm, produced by gas atomisation, was used to pre- (colony boundary) was done manually. In total, four
pare the specimens. The powder was supplied by TLS different pictures with the same magnification (200×)
Technik GmbH, Bitterfeld, Germany. The binder system were used.
comprised paraffin wax, stearic acid and polyethylene
vinyl acetate. The preparation of the feedstock was done
at the ratio of 35 vol.-% of binder system to 65 vol.-% Tensile and fatigue testing
of metallic powder. Dog bone-shaped tensile specimens were used for fatigue
Figure 1 shows the dog bone-shaped tensile specimens testing of Ti–6Al–4V. The experiments were carried out in
according to ISO 2740 prepared by MIM. First, the feed- air at room temperature using a resonance machine fabri-
stock was produced by mixing the metallic powder and cated by RUMUL, Neuhausen am Rheinfall, Switzerland
the binder system in a Z-blade mixer under argon atmos- (Mikrotron 654-H, 20 kN). The sinusoidal waveform was
phere for 2 hours at 120°C. After pelletising, the feedstock applied under load control at a frequency of approxi-
was injection moulded with an Arburg 320S machine. In mately 100 Hz. The stress ratio used was R = 0.2, which
order to remove the paraffin wax component, a chemical means that the specimens were ideally subjected only to
debinding was conducted in a bath of heptane at 40°C for axial tensile–tensile loads. The maximum load applied
20 hours. Thermal debinding and sintering were con- was 400 MPa. Grips that were specially adapted for this
ducted in a single-step heat treatment run. Sintering was experiment are shown in Fig. 2.
carried out at 1400°C for 2 hours in high vacuum In order to ensure that fatigue failure would happen
(10−4 mbar). within the 30-mm gauge, the regions of the specimens in
Density measurements were carried out by the immer- contact with the grips were shot-peened by zirconia
sion method. The theoretical density taken for compari- spheres with a diameter of 500 µm. Shot-peening induces
son was measured on the specimens produced by MIM residual compressive stress and also provides a better sur-
from the same pre-alloyed powder under the same con- face quality, thus crack initiation should take place within
ditions used in this study, which were additionally hot iso- the as-sintered region. The fatigue tests were conducted in
static pressed (HIPed) in order to eliminate the residual a set of two experiments:
porosity. The value obtained was 4.41 g cm−3. The poros- I Specimens loaded until fatigue failure.
ity was calculated by subtracting the specimen’s densifica- II Specimens loaded until the halflife of the previous
tion (measured density divided by theoretical density) experiment.
from 100% (full dense condition). Additionally, the pore The first experiment (I) focused on determining the fati-
size distribution was calculated with the aid of a software gue life with the testing conditions applied (400 MPa of
for image analysis (Olympus Soft Imaging Solutions, maximum loading and R = 0.2), whereas the second
AnalySIS Pro, Olympus, Tokyo, Japan). Four pictures experiment (II) was used for the evaluation of microstruc-
were used in order to obtain a representative amount of tural damage at halflife. The specimens from the second
pores analysed. The contents of interstitial elements (O, experiment (II) were thus pulled in a tensile test machine
C and N) were measured using a conventional LECO to induce final fracture. Consequently, a picture of the
melt extraction system. The amount of nitrogen and oxy- fatigue damage at 50% of life was evaluated by tensile
gen was determined using the TC – 436AR, while carbon testing. This procedure is valid considering that, once fati-
was quantified by the CS – 444. gue damage is introduced, the specimen should rupture
In order to characterise the microstructure of Ti–6Al– right at the place of the propagated crack (weakest
4V, an investigation using light microscopy was carried spot). The measured stress–strain curves for fatigue
out. Four dog bone-shaped specimens were initially cut damaged and normal conditions were then compared. A
in representative regions of the cross-section. The pieces servo hydraulic machine Zwick 050 with a load capacity
were subsequently mounted, ground, polished and ulti- of 50 kN was used for the tensile tests. The tensile tests
mately etched for 7 seconds using Kroll’s reagent. The α were carried out in air at room temperature with a strain
colony size measurement was performed with the aid of rate of 1.2 × 10−5 s−1. The testpieces had their 30 mm
the same image analysis system as mentioned before. gauge length attached to a mechanical extensometer.
The principle used by the software was the intercept Fractography investigations were conducted using the
method, as described by ASTM E112 standard.12 A series scanning electron microscope DSM962 from Zeiss in all
of five straight lines were horizontally drawn on a picture, fracture surfaces obtained. The recorded images were sub-
and the number of colonies intercepted was counted. This sequently used to find the fatigue crack initiation sites by
closely examining the outer area of the fracture surfaces.
Fatigue crack initiation sites in Ti–6Al–4V usually show
specific microstructural features (the quasi cleavage

1 Dimensions in mm of a sintered dog bone-shaped tensile


specimen 2 Grips used to hold the dog bone-shaped tensile specimen

Powder Metallurgy 2016 VOL 59 NO 5 345


Soyama et al. Axial fatigue testing of Ti–6Al–4V using an alternative specimen geometry fabricated by MIM

3 Statistical data of porosity for Ti–6Al–4V sintered at 1400°C for 2 hours in vacuum: a pore size distribution; b form factor of the
pores

facets)13,14 that help uncover their location. The fatigue size of 128 ± 13 µm. The colonies consist of laths of α tita-
crack propagation length was measured by the image nium with ribs of β titanium arranged in a coarse lamellar
analysis based on the morphology of the different areas pattern. The round shape of the porosity indicates that
between stable (smooth) and unstable (dimple-like) sintering got to its final stage. However, owing to the
crack propagation. The starting point was always the fati- high temperature used in the process (1400°C), the α colo-
gue initiation site after which the smooth area (stable nies were significantly larger than observed in previous
crack propagation) followed. studies,3,8 in which sintering was conducted at 1250°C
leading to α colony size in the range of 90–100 µm.
Results and discussion
Mechanical properties and fractography
Porosity, interstitial elements and analysis
microstructure Table 3 shows the amount of cycles to failure of the speci-
Table 1 displays the sintered density of the MIM pro- mens that were subjected to fatigue testing. At the con-
cessed Ti–6Al–4V. Clearly, a high densification was ditions applied, the defined endurance limit for high-
achieved, indicating that the sintering parameters applied cycle fatigue of 107 could not be reached. The results,
were adequate for this alloy. Porosities in this range were however, display a narrow scatterband for the moderate
also reported previously.3,8 Additionally, Fig. 3 shows the lifetime of 105 cycles. The crack propagation length before
statistical data of porosity for sintered Ti–6Al–4V, con- final failure was on average 1839 µm corresponding to
firming that sintering was successful. The pore size distri- almost half of the specimen’s diameter.
bution was relatively fine with about 90% of the pores The results of the first experiment (I) demonstrated the
containing sizes below 300 µm2 (Fig. 3a). The majority feasibility of using tensile specimens for fatigue testing in
of the pores were also round with at least 60% showing an axial tension–tension configuration. Nonetheless, this
form factor close to 1 (Fig. 3b). was proved only for fatigue lifetime of 105 cycles. The
Table 2 shows the amount of interstitial elements (O, C low performance of the tensile specimens at higher cycles
and N). The analysed pieces were cut from different was due to the friction between the grips and the clamped
regions of one tensile specimen. Each value was averaged specimen, which caused fretting fatigue and induced fail-
from three measurements. Since the starting powder cor- ure outside the test area.
responded to an extra low interstitial (ELI, grade 23) Niinomi et al.10 obtained lifetimes of 105 cycles at a
with interstitial oxygen around 1000 µg g−1, the oxygen maximum stress of 500 MPa with Ti–6Al–4V, thus
pick-up was approximately 1000 µg g−1, whereas the car- 100 MPa higher than the value measured in this work.
bon and nitrogen contents were within the range of the A possible explanation corresponds to the significantly
grade 23 alloy. Considering that a high-sintering tempera- smaller specimens used by Niinomi et al., which led to a
ture was used (1400°C), the sintering atmosphere was suf- smaller volume tested under cyclic loading. The surface
ficiently clean to prevent extensive pick-up of interstitials quality had supposedly only a minor influence, consider-
elements. These interstitial levels are also at the same ing that the specimens from Niinomi were also tested in
order of magnitude from previous works.3,8 the as-sintered condition and with similar colony sizes.
Figure 4 shows a micrograph of the MIM processed Ti– Ferri et al.3 obtained a similar result (105 cycles at
6Al–4V alloy. The microstructure consists of pores (dark 500 MPa) with four-point bending using smooth bar
roundish areas) and large α colonies with an average

Table 2 Contents of interstitial elements from the powder


Table 1 Density measurement and the porosity of Ti–6Al–4V and sintered piece
prepared by MIM
Element O/µg g−1 C/µg g−1 N/µg g−1
Sintered density/g cm−3 Porosity/% Densification/%
Starting powder (max.) 1300 800 500
4.26 3.32 96.7 Sintered piece 1917 ± 30 577 ± 13 147 ± 9

346 Powder Metallurgy 2016 VOL 59 NO 5


Soyama et al. Axial fatigue testing of Ti–6Al–4V using an alternative specimen geometry fabricated by MIM

4 Sintered microstructure of MIM processed Ti–6Al–4V

Table 3 Specimens tested until fatigue failure


5 Fracture surface of a fatigue-failed specimen. The line deli-
Cycles to Crack propagation mits the stable crack propagation area
Specimen failure (105) length/µm

1 1.98 1871 previous experiment. There is no scatter in these values,


2 0.84 1821 because the test was manually stopped. The crack propa-
3 1.07 1861 gation length was significantly smaller than before with an
4 1.17 1804 average value of 304 µm.
Mean value 1.3 ± 0.5 1839 ± 32 Figure 6a shows a typical fracture surface from second
The maximum stress was 400 MPa, R = 0.2. experiment (II), in which the specimens were ultimately
fractured by tensile testing. It is possible to identify the
specimens of Ti–6Al–4V in the as-sintered condition. The crack initiation site and the stable crack propagation
lower value measured with the dog bone-shaped speci- area, which was significantly smaller than from first
mens could be attributed to the larger volume under fati- experiment (I). Figure 6b corresponds to a picture of
gue and the different configuration of the fatigue test crack initiation site, whereas Fig. 6c shows, in higher mag-
(axial loading). On the other hand, Horke et al.11 reported nification, the fatigue initiating defect. The fatigue initiat-
very similar values to the ones presented in this paper. At ing defects could be easily identified by the fracture
400 MPa, the amount of cycles to failure was in the order surface analysis. These defects were always found at the
of 105 cycles using the rotating bending configuration. surface of the specimens associated with quasi cleavage
Figure 5 shows a representative fracture surface of Ti– facets that represent a typical sign of fatigue crack
6Al–4V from the first experiment (I), in which rupture initiation in Ti–6Al–4V. The facets result from the separ-
took place by fatigue failure. The fracture surface in ation of intense slip bands under the action of a tensile
Fig. 5 confirms that failure really occurred due to fatigue stress normal to the plane of slip.13 When a favourably
since a region of stable crack propagation is clearly distin- oriented grain is stressed, the dislocations glide until
guished, which extends almost until the middle of the they meet a grain boundary causing a pile-up, leading
specimen’s cross-section. The crack initiation site (indi- to facet formation.
cated by a white arrow) is followed by a large stable It is widely accepted that for high-strength materials
crack propagation area on the left-hand side, which when low oscillating loads are applied (high-cycle fatigue
extends almost until the middle of the specimen. This regime), the most critical contribution corresponds to the
region is characteristically flatter than the final fracture fatigue initiation, which could take as much as 90% of the
area that consists mainly of dimples (right-hand side). fatigue life.15 Considering such premise, if this condition
Table 4 shows the number of cycles of the specimens would hold in the case of the material tested, the speci-
that were fatigued until the halflife measured in the mens loaded until the halflife should not show any sign
of fatigue cracks. Nonetheless, that was not the case, as
can be seen in Fig. 6. Not only crack initiation took
place, but also a small stable crack propagation area
Table 4 Specimens tested until the fatigue halflife could be identified (the smooth area on the fracture
Number of Crack propagation
Specimen cycles (105) length/µm Table 5 Mechanical properties of Ti–6Al–4V in different
conditions
1 0.65 206
2 0.66 235 YS/ UTS/
4 0.66 394 Condition MPa MPa Elongation/%
5 0.65 380
Mean value 0.66 304 ± 97 Reference (undamaged) 744 ± 5 852 ± 2 14.7 ± 0.7
Fatigue damaged until 753 ± 6 858 ± 2 11.1 ± 3.7
The maximum stress was 400 MPa, R = 0.2.
halflife

Powder Metallurgy 2016 VOL 59 NO 5 347


Soyama et al. Axial fatigue testing of Ti–6Al–4V using an alternative specimen geometry fabricated by MIM

6 A characteristic fracture surface of a specimen fatigue tested until the halflife. Final fracture was caused by tensile testing: a
fracture surface of the specimen’s cross-section displaying a small stable crack propagation area; b the crack initiation site; c
detail of the fatigue initiating defect and the quasi cleavage facet

surface). In fact, Fig. 6 actually depicts a situation where et al.,8 the fatigue endurance limit can be significantly
crack initiation and propagation took place because the improved by modifying the as-sintered surface with
length involved is large (around 400 µm). Instead, if shot-peening.
only crack initiation would have taken place, this length In contrast to the replica technique16 in which an image
should be in the order of magnitude of the microconstitu- of the surface is imprinted in a tape or the direct obser-
ents, e.g. α colony size, corresponding to a microstructu- vation of the specimens’ surface on the microscope,17
rally short crack. The fast crack initiation process could the post-mortem fractographic observation of fatigue
be attributed to fatigue testing with the as-sintered surface crack initiation provides the advantage of examining the
that contains many irregularities. As reported by Ferri crack length inside the specimen. Additionally, it allows
tensile testing of fatigued specimens, which can be used
to roughly assess the fatigue damage. Figure 7 shows
the typical stress–strain curves obtained by tensile testing
of an undamaged and a fatigue-damaged specimen.
Clearly, there is a decrease in ductility of about 4% in
the fatigue-damaged specimen; however, the shape of
the tensile curve remained unchanged.
Despite the decreased ductility of the fatigue-damaged
specimens, the yield strength (YS) and UTS remained the
same, as shown in Table 5. Considering that the fatigue
crack at 50% of fatigue life was, on average, about
300 µm, the results show that the Ti–6Al–4V alloy pro-
cessed by MIM is quite damage-tolerant under tensile
loading.

Conclusions
(i) Axial fatigue testing in tensile–tensile configur-
7 Typical tensile test curves of as-sintered Ti–6Al–4V and ation using a common dog bone-shaped speci-
fatigued until halflife mens prepared by MIM is feasible; however, the

348 Powder Metallurgy 2016 VOL 59 NO 5


Soyama et al. Axial fatigue testing of Ti–6Al–4V using an alternative specimen geometry fabricated by MIM

defined endurance limit for high-cycle fatigue 6. D. Zhao, K. Chang, T. Ebel, M. Qian, R. Willumeit, M. Yan, and F.
could not be reached with these specimens due Pyczak: ‘Titanium carbide precipitation in Ti–22Nb alloy fabricated
by metal injection moulding’, Powder Metall., 2014, 57, 2–4.
to fatigue fretting at the contact with the grips. 7. ‘Practice for conducting force controlled constant amplitude axial
(ii) Fractography analysis of the surfaces revealed the fatigue tests of metallic materials’, 2007, E466-07, West
fatigue initiating defects at the as-sintered surface, Conshohocken, PA, ASTM.
as well as a region of stable crack propagation. 8. O. M. Ferri, T. Ebel and R. Bormann: ‘Influence of surface
quality and porosity on fatigue behaviour of Ti–6Al–4V
(iii) Specimens subjected to fatigue until the halflife components processed by MIM’, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 2010, 527,
contained cracks in the order of 300 µm, which 1800–1805.
decreased the ductility measured by tensile testing 9. O. M. Ferri, T. Ebel and R. Bormann: ‘The influence of a small
but did not change the UTS. boron addition on the microstructure and mechanical properties
of Ti-6Al-4V fabricated by metal injection moulding’, Adv. Eng.
Mater., 2011, 13, 436–447.
Acknowledgements 10. M. Niinomi, T. Akahori, M. Nakai, K. Ohnaka, Y. Itoh, K. Sato
and T. Ozawa: ‘Mechanical properties of α + β type titanium alloys
The authors thank all those that actively contributed to fabricated by metal injection molding with targeting biomedical
the realisation of this work: Andreas Dobernowsky, applications’, Proc. ‘TMS Annual Meeting’, 2007, Orlando, USA,
209–217.
Dirk Matthiessen, Hamdi Tek, Dr Jan Bohlen, Jürgen 11. K. Horke, B. Ruderer and R. F. Singer: ‘Influence of sintering con-
Knaack, Manfred Horstmann, Petra Fischer, Wolfgang ditions on tensile and high cycle fatigue behaviour of powder injec-
Limberg, Uwe Lorenz and Dr Uwe Zerbst. tion moulded Ti–6Al–4V at ambient and elevated temperatures’,
Powder Metall., 2014, 57, 283–290.
12. ‘Test methods for determining average grain size’, 2013, E112-13,
References West Conshohocken, PA, ASTM.
13. M. R. Bache: ‘Processing titanium alloys for optimum fatigue per-
1. G. Lütjering and J. C. Williams: ‘Titanium’, 2nd edn, 1–12, 2007, formance’, Int. J. Fatigue, 1999, 21, 105–111.
Heidelberg, Springer. 14. R. K. Nalla, B. L. Boyce, J. P. Campbell, J. O. Peters and R. O.
2. C. Leyens and M. Peters (ed.): ‘Titanium and titanium alloys: fun- Ritchie: ‘Influence of microstructure on high-cycle fatigue of Ti-
damentals and applications’, 1st edn, 1–35, 2005, Weinheim, 6Al-4V: bimodal vs. lamellar structures’, Metall. Mater. Trans. A,
Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. 2002, 33, 899–918.
3. O. M. Ferri, T. Ebel and R. Bormann: ‘High cycle fatigue behaviour 15. U. Krupp: ‘Fatigue crack propagation in metals and alloys: micro-
of Ti–6Al–4V fabricated by metal injection moulding technology’, structural aspects and modelling concepts’, 1st edn, 99–129, 2007,
Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 2009, 504, 107–113. Weinheim, John Wiley & Sons.
4. G. C. Obasi, O. M. Ferri, T. Ebel and R. Bormann: ‘Influence of 16. S. G. Ivanova, R. R. Biederman and R. D. Sisson Jr: ‘Investigation
processing parameters on mechanical properties of Ti–6Al–4V of fatigue crack initiation in Ti-6Al-4V during tensile-tensile fati-
alloy fabricated by MIM’, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 2010, 527, 3929–3935. gue’, J. Mater. Eng. Perform., 2002, 11, 226–231.
5. D. Zhao, K. Chang, T. Ebel, M. Qian, R. Willumeit, M. Yan and F. 17. X. Demulsant and J. Mendez: ‘Microstructural effects
Pyczak: ‘Microstructure and mechanical behavior of metal injection on small fatigue crack initiation and growth in
molded Ti–Nb binary alloys as biomedical material’, J. Mech. Ti6Al4V alloys’, Fatigue Fract. Eng. Mater. Struct., 1995, 18,
Behav. Biomed. Mater., 2013, 28, 171–182. 1483–1497.

Powder Metallurgy 2016 VOL 59 NO 5 349

You might also like