Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Batterywastemanagement
Batterywastemanagement
net/publication/331915207
CITATIONS READS
9 11,804
2 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Umesh Chandra Sharma on 21 March 2019.
ABSTRACT
Batteries are hard to displace in modern world by virtue of their entry in every walk of
human life. These batteries contain several heavy metals such as cadmium, copper, lead,
mercury, nickel or zinc, which are all hazardous to human health and environment. The
casual dumping of spent batteries into landfills eventually result in percolation of heavy
metals and other toxic compounds into soil and water, contaminating food and water
supplies and making them unhealthy for use by mankind and wildlife. The erroneous
incineration results in release of certain toxic metals into air through stack gases or
accumulation in the ash produced by the combustion process. Therefore, the proper disposal
of battery wastes is far more important compared to battery production; but it is often a
neglected issue, particularly in developing and poor countries. There are three established
methods to prevent and control the adversities developed by reckless disposal of spent
batteries. These are three R’s: Reduce, Recharge and Recycle. The present article first
discusses the human health and environmental effects of battery wastes and then concentrates
on methods to restrain them.
Key words: Basel convention, Freedonia, Frost & Sullivan, Hazard, Household hazardous
wastes, Lead-acid batteries, Rechargeable batteries, Non-rechargeable batteries, Reduce,
Recharge, Recycle, Three R’s, Toxic metals, Hydrometallurgical process, Pyrometallurgical
process, Mercury distillation process.
INTRODUCTION
A battery is a device to transform the chemical energy contained in its active materials
directly into electrical energy by means of an electrochemical oxidation-reduction (redox)
reaction [1]. Batteries have a unique mechanism as there are no moving parts but they still
manage to carry electric current through circuits. The batteries are usually classified into two
main categories, namely primary non-rechargeable (e.g. zinc-carbon, magnesium-manganese
dioxide, alkaline-manganese dioxide, alkaline zinc-mercuric oxide, cadmium-mercuric oxide,
zinc-alkaline electrolyte-silver oxide, zinc-air batteries, lithium-sulphur dioxide, lithium-
thionyl chloride, lithium-sulphuryl chloride, lithium-manganese dioxide, lithium-silver
vanadium oxide, lithium-iodine, etc.) and secondary rechargeable (e.g. lead-acid, nickel-iron,
nickel-cadmium, nickel-zinc, nickel-hydrogen, zinc-silver oxide, cadmium-silver oxide, iron-
silver oxide, zinc-alkaline-manganese dioxide, etc.) batteries, depending on their capability of
being electrically recharged. The batteries are so closely integrated with human life that there
will hardly be an area without their applications. A partial list of these applications include
electric watches, clocks, calculators, hearing aids, medical appliances and implants,
flashlights, toys, power tools, portable radio and television, mobile phones, camcorders,
laptops, tablets, scooters, motor cycles, cars, trucks, buses, tractors, fork-lift trucks, electric
Environ. Sci. & Engg. Vol. 5: Solid Waste Management
vehicles, golf carts, missiles, submarines, satellites, aircrafts, spacecrafts, auxiliary and
emergency power supplies, uninterruptible power systems, load levelling, remote relay
stations, meteorological equipments and signals and alarms [2].
Frost & Sullivan (2009) estimated the revenue in global battery market at massive
$47.5 billion and predicted that this figure will reach $74 billion in 2015. In 2009, primary
batteries accounted for 23.6% share of global market with other 76.4% share going to
secondary batteries. Frost & Sullivan predicted a decline of 7.4% for primary batteries in
revenue distribution by 2015, while the market share for rechargeable batteries was likely to
increase to 82.6% by 2015 [6].
Freedonia group (2012) estimates the size of global battery industry at $89.4 billion
which is expected to reach $132 billion in 2016 with 8.1% annual growth rate. China will be
the largest national market by size while India followed by South Korea will register the
fastest growing rate. The secondary rechargeable batteries will exceed the primary non-
rechargeable types due to demand driven by mobile phones, personal entertainment gadgets,
laptop computers, electric bicycle and motor vehicles [7].
When waste batteries are thrown away in the trash, they end up in landfills. The toxic
heavy metals/compounds in these batteries can contaminate the environment by leaching into
soil and water, polluting water bodies and making them unfit for use by mankind and
wildlife. When incinerated, certain toxic metals might release into air through stack gases or
can accumulate in the ash produced by the combustion process. The possible effects of
hazardous battery wastes on human health and environment are given in Table 1.
Table 1 (Appendix)
WASTE MANAGEMENT
United States’ Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) list of common household
hazardous wastes includes a wide range of products such as drain and toilet cleaners, laundry
bleach, paint thinners, photographic chemicals, rat poisons, insecticides, herbicides,
fungicides, mercury thermometers, fluorescent light bulbs, kerosene, diesel, gas/oil mix,
motor oil, antifreeze, refrigerants, batteries, automotive batteries and electronic wastes [15].
Among all these items, spent batteries constitute the most general article of common
household hazardous wastes.
heavy metals inside batteries might leach into the ground, contaminating soil and water,
affecting human health and environment. If incinerated, heavy metals can concentrate in the
ash or enter the atmosphere through stack emissions. When the ash is disposed, the toxic
metals can leach into the soil and ground and surface water [16].
Table 2 (Appendix)
The Solution
As there are multitudes of problems associated with disposal of spent batteries, there
are at least three established methods to prevent and control the substantial amount of spent
batteries from throwing away in to trash bins. These are three R’s: Reduce, Recharge and
Recycle.
Reduce - Reducing the generation of spent batteries is by far the most effective way in
protecting the environment than finding ways for perfect recycling or proper disposal after
they have been created. The use of batteries should be reserved for those applications only
where electric power cannot be used such as automobiles, calculators, wrist watches, hand-
held remotes, children toys, military devices, etc. It will always help if a user checks his stock
of batteries available at home or in store (in case of bulk user) before proceeding towards
purchasing of more. In addition, the consumer should have clear answer of following two
questions: (i) What type of battery do I really require for my application? and (ii) How many
batteries do I exactly require for my application? If possible, one should purchase batteries
containing less/no toxic substances to reduce the amount of potentially hazardous wastes
requiring special disposal methods [17]. The primary non-rechargeable batteries should be
replaced with secondary rechargeable batteries. A sensible selection and use of household
equipments and appliances can greatly reduce the demand for disposable batteries. LED
based lighting systems, for example, greatly decrease the need for disposable dry-cell
batteries [9]. The batteries should be removed from the equipment if the equipment is not to be
used for long periods of time. Batteries should be stored in cool and dry conditions. Storage
at low temperature extends battery life because the chemical reactions stagnate at this
condition. Prior to use batteries must be returned to room temperature to gain maximum
voltage [12].
Recharge - The demand for secondary rechargeable batteries has enlightened considerably in
recent years with the increased use of portable devices such as cell phones, tablets, laptops,
cordless power tools, etc. Earlier, rechargeable batteries were inconvenient as they needed to
be charged prior to use and were less long lasting compared to current generation of
rechargeable batteries. Newer low self-discharge rechargeable batteries hold their charge for
several months and are usually charged by the manufacturer to about 70% of their rated
capacity before shipping [18]. While every rechargeable battery will eventually die, but state-
of-the-art technology assures that a rechargeable battery manufactured today can be used
hundreds of times spanning over a period of several years. The care should be taken that a
rechargeable battery is charged using a charger specifically designed for the size and type of
battery for smooth hassle-free operation and long life [12].
Battery Waste Management
Recycle – Recycling diverts thousands of tonnes of waste batteries from landfills and
incinerators. Batteries contain one or more of several valuable metals, like nickel, cadmium,
cobalt, copper, zinc, aluminium, silver, etc., which can be reused as a secondary raw material
after recycling. Apart from metals, a wide range of other substances such as different acids,
salts and plastics which are also contained in the batteries are separated and diverted from
municipal waste for regulated disposal. Recycling not only gives new life to discarded
products, but it prevents toxins such as lead, mercury and cadmium from contaminating the
air, water and soil [16].
The use of recycled metals in battery production reduces demand for virgin metals and
so the pollution and loss to natural habitats and wildlife due to mining of the virgin
metals also reduce significantly.
2. Economical benefits: Recycling of used materials is economically cheaper than
production of virgin materials and hence the cost of production for the virgin materials
used in batteries is saved by the use of recycled materials. Further, recycling reduces
the dependence on imported materials, a big saving on country’s import bill. The
disposal costs related to landfill and incineration operations are saved due to higher
levels of recycling. The recycling cost also comes down due to higher collection rates
and economies of scale.
3. Conservation of natural resources: Natural ore deposits are finite and will eventually
exhaust some day. The recycling extends the lifespan of these deposits. Nickel,
cadmium, cobalt and silver are valuable metals; their reclamation and reuse enable us to
save resources. The recovered cadmium, at a 99.95% purity level, is used to produce
new nickel-cadmium rechargeable batteries [16]. Furthermore, since most of the virgin
metal extraction processes are highly energy intensive depending largely on fossil fuel
supplies, the recycling processes provide means for conservation of fossil fuel
resources.
4. Energy conservation: Barring the service period of a battery life cycle, 65% of
primary energy is used in the manufacture of batteries, while 32% is used in the
production of raw materials and less than 1% is used for inspection, collection and
sorting [22]. The recycling processes make it possible to reclaim the metals from spent
batteries with less energy compared to extraction and refining of the virgin metals.
Recycled cadmium, zinc and nickel, for example, require respectively 46%, 73% and
75% less primary energy in extraction than virgin metals. These figures become more
important in the light of fact that the primary production of metals is responsible for
about 10% of global carbon dioxide emissions. Table 3 illustrates the percent
reductions in primary energy consumption through recycling of materials such as
aluminium, nickel, copper and steel.
Table 3: Energy consumption for primary and secondary material production [23]
Material Primary material Secondary material Reduction in
production production energy
(million BTU/tonne) (million BTU/tonne) consumption
Wrought aluminium 157.3 40.7 74.1%
Cast aluminium 132.9 39.0 70.7%
Nickel 124.7 31.2 75.0%
Copper 94.2 34.3 63.6%
Steel 38.6 29.1 24.6%
several established processes for recovering valuable metals from spent batteries, the details
of which can be found extensively in literature. Here only a brief introduction of some
principal process methodologies is given.
Hydrometallurgical Process
Hydrometallurgical processing of waste batteries involves a mechanical step and a
chemical step. In the mechanical phase, the batteries are shredded in order to separate the
metals, paper, plastic and the black mass. The black mass is further chemically processed to
produce a solution, which undergoes electrolysis or leaching, in order to separate out the
dissolved metals [3].
Pyrometallurgical Process
Pyrometallurgy or the use of heat for the waste treatment includes smelting and
roasting. It involves heating in a blast furnace at temperatures above 1500ºC to convert waste
to a form that can be refined. The oxide waste is heated with a reducing agent, such as carbon
in the form of coke or coal; the oxygen of the metal combines with the carbon and is removed
as carbon dioxide gas. The waste material in non-metallic parts is called gangue; it is
removed by means of a substance called a flux which, when heated, combines with it to form
a molten mass called slag. Being lighter than the metal, the slag floats on top that is skimmed
with a slag arm or drawn off [24].
batteries can be reprocessed using a number of different methods, which include smelting and
other thermal-metallurgical processes to recover the metal content, particularly the zinc [26].
CONCLUSION
Batteries are an integral part of every one’s life from children to youths to middle
aged peoples to senior citizens in urban and rural areas as well in the form of diverse
applications in toys, mobiles, laptops, tablets, portable music systems, electric watches,
calculators, flashlights, radios, cameras, implanted medical devices, power tools,
automobiles, satellites, submarines and many more. Several billion tonnes of new batteries
are produced and sold every year globally and several million tonnes of spent batteries are
disposed every year. Human health and environmental impacts of nonchalantly disposed
batteries are extensively researched by scientific communities and are also known to educated
masses. Though most of the nations have stringent regulations on disposal of spent batteries,
but negligence on the part of law enforcing authorities and ignorance on the part of the
proletariat prevails in the developing and underdeveloped nations. Whereas, developed
nations effectively collect and recycle over 90% of secondary rechargeable spent batteries.
Primary non-rechargeable batteries don’t have a recycling method and are disposed of in
landfills along with other household garbage. Despite being non-recyclable and a burden on
environment, the primary batteries are difficult to displace owing to their characteristics of
low price with good shelf life and zero maintenance and safe operation. Researchers might
find some technologies in future to recycle these batteries also.
REFERENCES
[1] Linden, D. and Reddy, T. B. (ed.), Handbook of batteries, 3rd edition, McGraw-Hill,
New York, 2002.
[2] Vincent, C. A. and Scrosati, B., Modern batteries, 2nd edition, Butterworth-
Heinemann, Oxford, 2003.
[3] Fisher K. et al., Battery waste management life cycle assessment, Environmental
resources management, 2006 (www.epbaeurope.net).
[4] Battery recycling in Canada, Environment Canada, 2009 (www.ec.gc.ca).
[5] Machinery statistics, Ministry of economy, trade and industry, Japan
(www.meti.go.jp).
[6] Global battery markets (www.batteryuniversity.com).
[7] Industry study - world batteries, 2012 (www.freedoniagroup.com).
[8] Malavika C.R., Environmental effects associated with battery disposal, 2004
(www.frost.com).
[9] Battery disposal (www.rpc.com.au).
[10] Battery recycling (www.wyre.gov.uk).
[11] Crowl D.A. and Louvar J.F., Chemical process safety, 2nd edition, Prentice Hall PTR,
New Jersey, 2002.
[12] Environmental guideline for waste batteries, Department of environment, Government
of Nunavut, 2011 (http://env.gov.nu.ca).
[13] Treatment of batteries within the Basel convention, 2009 (www.nema.org).
[14] Dillon C., The ecological impact of batteries, 1994 (http://repository.cmu.edu/ece).
Battery Waste Management
Please cite this article as: Kuchhal P, Sharma UC. Battery waste management. In: Gurjar
BR, Sharma UC, Singh N, editors. Environmental Science and Engineering Vol. 5 Solid
Waste Management, Texas: Studium Press LLC; 2017, p. 141−155.
Environ. Sci. & Engg. Vol. 5: Solid Waste Management
Appendix
Lithium Lithium-ion batteries Non-toxic ▪ Causes major disturbance in water balance in ▪ Interferences in carbohydrate metabolism and
Lithium polymer batteries body. changes in growth and pituitary hormone of
▪ Can block synthesis of thyroid hormone. rodents.
▪ Causes drowsiness, speech disorder, tremors, ▪ Physiological and immunological irregularities
unsteady gait, muscle twitching, increased muscle leading to infectious diseases.
tone, sweating and fever. ▪ Birth defects like cleft palates, skeletal
▪ Affected children might suffer from weight gain, anomalies and exencephaly.
vomiting, headache, nausea and tremors. ▪ Stunted brain growth in test animals.
▪ May cause both acute and chronic kidney failure.
▪ Adverse effects on pregnant women.
▪ Lithium-infected infants may experience shallow
breathing, hypotonia, lethargy, cyanosis and
bradycardia.
Manganese Lithium-manganese Non-toxic ▪ Causes cough, abdominal pain and nausea on ▪ Combustible, fine dispersed particles form
dioxide batteries exposure. explosive mixtures in air.
Zinc-manganese dioxide ▪ Responsible for neuropsychiatric disorder called ▪ Affects the immune system of marine
batteries ‘manganese madness’ or ‘Parkinson-like’ disease. invertebrates.
Lithium ion-manganese ▪ Can induce iron deficiency in some algae
oxide batteries leading to inhibition of chlorophyll synthesis.
Alkaline manganese ▪ Causes disorders in some crops, such as crinkle
batteries leaf in cotton and stem streak necrosis in
potato.
Potassium Potassium ion batteries Non-toxic ▪ Eye contact results in redness, watering, itching ▪ Highly flammable in presence of moisture,
and corneal damage or blindness. open flames and heat sparks.
▪ Skin contact produces inflammation, itching, ▪ Fire will produce irritating, corrosive and/or
scaling, reddening and blistering. toxic gases.
▪ Inhalation causes irritation to gastrointestinal or
respiratory tract characterized by burning,
sneezing and coughing. Over-exposure causes
lung damage, choking, unconsciousness or death.
▪ May be toxic to blood, lungs and upper
respiratory tract.
Battery Waste Management