Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Handbook of Sustainable Engineering Compressed
Handbook of Sustainable Engineering Compressed
Kun-Mo Lee
Editors
Handbook of
Sustainable
Engineering
1 3Reference
Handbook of Sustainable Engineering
Joanne Kauffman • Kun-Mo Lee
Editors
Handbook of
Sustainable Engineering
The future of our planet, how we live and interact with each other and the world
around us, and how we hand it on to the next generation is a concern that has
seldom been so widely shared at all levels of society throughout the history of
human civilization. Although how we do this remains a subject of intense debate
both within and between nations, there is growing recognition of the need for
new, innovative pathways to development. As we come to the conclusion that we
must take a longer-ranging view regarding our use of resources and become more
aware that the choices we make can have irrevocable consequences for the world
and therefore to humanity, interest in sustainability in its broadest sense is on the
increase. To promote awareness of the problem is one thing; to tackle the issue
itself is something else. It is a positive development that the sustainable option is
increasingly being sought and given preference as a matter of course to solve the
problems and challenges we meet in many academic disciplines and professional
fields today.
This Handbook of Sustainable Engineering, edited by Joanne Kauffman and
Kun-Mo Lee, offers a practical and timely tool outlining for many detailed topics
and subjects where the current dangers lie and what the possibilities for alternative
solutions are. It points the way forward to where more research is needed, as well as
to sometimes surprisingly simple and low-cost options that are already available if
we but consider going beyond conventional practice. Topics such as policy-making
and management as well as product development and rethinking energy use and
infrastructure all find a place here. Engineering is a discipline that touches on many
aspects of everyday life for everyone, and therefore, sustainable engineering is one
of the best ways to make a change for the better in a relatively short time.
I applaud the editors for taking on the task of advancing sustainable engineering
and recommend this work to all those who at any level or in any way shape our world
with their inventions, products, and decisions. Thinking outside the conventional
box is no longer a luxury but a necessity, and this book can act as a way to immerse
oneself in and acquaint oneself with new criteria for solutions to old problems.
I hope this pioneering compilation of knowledge will find its way not just into
academic libraries but also into the thinking and creative scientific process of the
next generation of engineers all over the world.
The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has been instrumental
in raising awareness of the imminent dangers of the present way of using resources,
v
vi Foreword
and it is particularly gratifying to see that indeed changes are now being made and
that seeking sustainable solutions is becoming the norm. Still, we have a long way
to go, and the sooner we can make the necessary changes in our thinking and in
doing business as well as in day to day life, the better it will be for us all.
I warmly recommend this work and hope it will contribute to a better, fairer,
brighter, and more sustainable world.
R. K. Pachauri
Director General, The Energy and Resources Institute (TERI) &
Senior Adviser, Yale Climate and Energy Institute (YCEI)
Preface
vii
viii Preface
such as human behavior of service providers and customers must also be taken
into account. Several chapters discuss fundamental concepts while others present
engineering methodologies for modelling, designing, simulating, and evaluating
PSS and examples of PSS.
Volume II of the Handbook begins with the section on policy and decision-
making, a driving force for sustainable production and consumption. In this section,
section editor Karel F. Mulder argues for more critical thinking in the engineering
community to address sustainability issues and to promote better policy-making.
The chapters in this section present a tableau of means for identifying and dealing
with the tough questions and trade-offs that engineers must consider if they are
to contribute to the twenty-first-century sustainability paradigm shift. Chapters in
the section provide building blocks for development of a sustainable engineering
strategy and practice.
The section on energy sources for the future recognizes the limitations of
dominant practices and focuses on alternative sources of energy. As energy section
editor Fabio Orecchini notes we must get beyond the present era in which 80% of
the world energy system is based on sources that are exhaustible, geographically
inequitably distributed, and major sources of greenhouse gases. For this reason, the
section focuses on sustainable alternative sources of energy and ways to achieve
them. In each case, the authors focus on the development and implementation of
decentralized, small-scale, efficient, and effective engineering solutions for meeting
energy needs.
In the Handbook’s final section on new materials, section editor Atsushi Suzuki
points out that the two major global risks that concern climate and resources
are attributable to climate change arising from greenhouse gas emissions and to
the limited supply of natural resources of rare-earth elements and commodity
substances. Solutions to averting these two risks will include the introduction of
environmentally friendly new materials for materials selection and consumption,
sustainable production and products, and social infrastructures in general. This
section focuses on three main areas of concern: energy, resources, and eco-
friendly materials design; renewable and biodegradable materials technologies; and
alternative materials.
It is clear from a perusal of the chapters selected and solicited by our section
editors that the need for engineering skills applied to the promotion of sustainable
development is acute. Today’s engineer must decide if he or she wants to contribute
directly to solving the world’s climate, pollution, energy, and water resource
problems in ways both large and small or to focus exclusively on meeting consumer
demand. Young engineers, practitioners from industry, researchers, and students are
encouraged to use the Handbook with a view to integrating the principles of sustain-
able engineering and the practices revealed in the handbook into their own work.
As coeditors in chief, Joanne Kauffman and Kun-Mo Lee have been equal
partners in developing the handbook. We owe deep appreciation to Springer for
its support of the project and in particular to our publisher, Nathalie Jacobs for
her enthusiasm and wisdom in shaping the whole effort and to our associate
editor at Springer, Neha Thapa. We are especially grateful to our collaborators, the
x Preface
section editors, who share our belief in the importance of advancing sustainability
principles in engineering education and practice, and to the contributors, who have
prepared constructive, provocative, and tightly argued chapters. It is ultimately to
them to whom we and those who use the handbook are most grateful. No single
encyclopedia, handbook, or reference can possibly address all the engineering
challenges that the world, in its quest for a more sustainable future, requires
and seeks. We view this handbook as an organic document, one that can grow
to encompass more examples of sustainable engineering in response to emerging
challenges and to which colleagues throughout the world will continue to contribute.
In the meantime, we thank with deep appreciation all those who have helped to take
at least this first step forward.
Professor, Dr. Leo Jansen, who passed away in August 2012, was a pillar
of sustainable development at Delft University of Technology and a beacon to
those concerned about the sustainability of the planet worldwide. Throughout a
long career, he maintained that the pursuit of sustainable development was not
incompatible with technological development but, rather, presented new challenges
to the engineering profession. Enthusiastic and tireless in the pursuit of innovative
solutions that he advanced with great technical, political, and social skills, Leo
Jansen is an inspiration to scholars, students, and professional engineers who seek
a sustainable pathway to development. Inspired by his example, we dedicate the
Handbook of Sustainable Engineering to Leo Jansen.
xi
xii About the Editors
xv
xvi Section Editors
Volume 1
xix
xx Contents
Volume 2
xxv
xxvi Contributors
Juan C. Lucena Liberal Arts and International Studies, Colorado School of Mines,
Golden, CO, USA
Keijiro Masui Advanced Manufacturing Research Institute, National Institute of
Advanced Industrial Science and Technology (AIST), Tsukuba, Ibaraki, Japan
Mitsutaka Matsumoto Center for Service Research, National Institute of Advanced
Industrial Science and Technology (AIST), Tsukuba, Ibaraki, Japan
Carolyn S. Mattick Center for Earth Systems Engineering and Management,
School of Sustainable Engineering and the Built Environment, Arizona State
University, Tempe, AZ, USA
Dorothy Maxwell Founder and Director of Global View Sustainability Services
Ltd., London, UK
Lecturer at Imperial College London MSc Environmental Science, Centre for
Environmental Policy, London, UK
Wei Meng Chinese Research Academy of Environmental Sciences, Beijing, PR
China
Andrea Micangeli Interuniversity Research Centre for Sustainable Development,
CIRPS – University of Rome “Sapienza”, Rome, Italy
Nozomu Mishima Graduate School of Engineering and Resource Science, Akita
University, Akita, Akita, Japan
Hiroshi Mizuseki Institute for Materials Research, Tohoku University, Sendai,
Japan
Guenter Moeller Unternehmensberater (Business Consultants), Munich, Germany
Toshiyuki Mori Fuel cell materials group, Battery materials unit, National institute
for materials science (NIMS), Tsukuba, Ibaraki, Japan
Hetro-interface design group, batteries and fuel cells field, global research centre
for environment and energy based on nano-materials science, National institute for
materials science (NIMS), Tsukuba, Ibaraki, Japan
Ruth Mourik DuneWorks, Eindhoven, The Netherlands
Karel F. Mulder Technology Policy and Management, Delft University of Tech-
nology, Delft, The Netherlands
Masaru Nakano The Graduate School of System Design and Management, Keio
University, Yokohama, Kanagawa, Japan
D. J. Ndegwah Institute for Social Ministry in Mission, Tangaza College, Lang’ata,
Nairobi, Kenya
Jun Nishijima Faculty of Engineering, Laboratory of Geothermics, Kyushu Uni-
versity, Nishi-ku, Fukuoka, Japan
Contributors xxix
The term sustainable development stands for a new age in human cultural
development, following the industrial and post-industrial eras. Emblematic of such
development is “sustainability,” a sociocultural movement toward a new lifestyle
paradigm that is based on three fundamental principles: respect for natural systems,
the promise of a humane living base for all humans, and the development of a
circular flow economy to support material life. Thus, Sustainability is not a new
discipline or academic field of study. Rather, it is a future-oriented principle, one
that involves all human actors in any field of activity at any place on our earth.
In the framework of such a conceptual paradigm, it is clear that education plays
a pivotal role. In traditional education systems, which are rooted in a technological
and economic growth paradigm, individuals are trained to think primarily in terms
of personal gain and focused careers. Thus, in education one witnesses increasing
specialization into specific disciplines and the withering of an overarching goal of
a humane future for all. Higher education systems in particular do not adequately
prepare young people for a socially and environmentally responsible life due to
the lack of a holistic approach that entails cross-disciplinary knowledge sharing,
development of core social and professional skills and values, and an appropriate
ethical framework for future actions. The educational gap between traditional,
monodisciplinary learning methods and the need for a socially responsible, future-
oriented, and broader approach can be bridged with new, multidimensional and
multidisciplinary learning tools that are being developed through a concept of
Education in Sustainability and Sustainable Development (ESD). This educational
concept seeks to embed the goals of technological advancement into the social,
economic, and ecological realities of today and into the forecasted needs of a future
sustainable pathway. This shift in educational focus may be advanced either through
the addition of specific courses or, even better, by incorporating sustainability
R. Baud
ACTIS – Activating Talent in Sustainability, Zürich, Switzerland
e-mail: roger.baud@sl.ethz.ch
aspects into the existing curricula of any field of study. In other words, ESD
should be made an integral part of any modern learning environment. While ESD is
needed at all educational levels and for all members of society (including managers,
institutions, organizations, and the public at large through, e.g., lifelong learning
and continuing education initiatives), the most important sector for targeted ESD
education is young academics.
They are the future leaders who will be responsible for leading societies into
the new sustainability paradigm. Engineering, converting technology into useful
practice, is a particularly sensitive field when planning for a sustainable future of
mankind. Today’s engineering students and professionals must be prepared with
the knowledge and skills they need to take account of the impacts their work will
have on the future of the planet and to fully understand why this preparation is
essential. At the very least, today’s engineers must have a basic understanding of
resource depletion, holistic life cycle thinking, social responsibility, and care for
the environment. This implies the need for education that goes well beyond the
provision of skills necessary to develop new and better technologies. Engineers
need to open up their disciplinary system boundaries to a more holistic perspective,
reflecting real social needs according to local, regional, and global priorities.
They have to develop standards following the precautionary principle.
Outreach, in the context of this chapter, means to walk the talk as well as to
widely disseminate best practices and experiences so that consumers and practition-
ers may learn and can experiment with new forms of a more sustainable lifestyle
and new models of material usage. Education is the cradle of the new sustainability
age, while communication about and testing of new behavioral patterns under
principles of sustainability is the way forward to meaningful action. As psychology
shows, nobody will easily give up traditional habits as long they are not given the
chance of testing a new pattern on a low-risk and low-cost basis and as long as
they do not see any benefit in making such a change. The same psychological
mechanism may apply as well to social organisms, enterprises, and institutions.
Social and individual change will come about not only as the result of cognitive
knowledge and understanding but just as importantly through emotional bonds
and practical experience. Communication and outreach are the vehicles that will
contribute to the dissemination of knowledge as well as to experimentation with
new and more sustainable lifestyle choices and practices across all sectors of society
from individuals to government, business, and social organizations. Just as a more
holistic and innovative educational approach is needed to promote a paradigm shift
into the era of sustainability, changes are also necessary in the way best practices,
good governance, research results, and positive solutions are communicated.
This chapter of the Handbook of Sustainable Engineering presents examples of
creative educational and outreach experiments and discussion of their results in
various sectors, with a particular focus on the creative thinking that is needed and
how these questions are handled at selected universities.
In Blueprints for Teaching Ecodesign and Sustainability to University Students
by Charles Pezeshki, Jitesh Panchal, and Gaurav Ameta, the authors describe new
approaches and models at the undergraduate and graduate level of courses in
1 Education and Outreach: Introduction 5
ecodesign and on how to integrate such models into existing curricula. As many
others, they claim that there is a lack of widespread acceptance of the basic
principles of product life management and that most efforts in curricular change end
up booged down. They propose with concrete and practical examples some type of
frameworks to be established that allows both students and professors a larger, more
coherent approach to the field.
The questions raised in Transdisciplinary Approaches to Engineering R&D:
Importance of Understanding Values and Culture by Alan Colin Brent from
Stellenbosch University in South Africa goes beyond a specific methodology in
product design and life cycle analyses. Along a case study in the bioenergy field, the
author refers to sustainability-oriented problems based on transdisciplinary research
and development (R&D) efforts, whereby coproduction transgresses boundaries,
and science becomes visible before it becomes certain. He explores the collaboration
between disciplines to identify, structure, analyze, and deal with specific challenges
so it can grasp the complexity of problems, including not only engineering
knowledge but as well as social values and cultural influences.
With very concrete examples, Braden R.Allenby and Carolyne S.Mattick from
Arizona State University present excellent alternative views on how to incorporate
sustainability into engineering education in Teaching old Disciplines New Tricks:
Sustainable Engineering Education. Their provocative statements base on the fact
that engineering education provide students with understanding of problem-solving,
but does not begin to prepare them for problem-defining, as one of the most difficult
phases of any engineering project. The authors also elaborate some models of
lifelong learning, as an urgent request in a challenging world with exponentially
increasing information. Along their basic definition, engineering could be thought of
as the application of science in service to society. Regarding the systems complexity,
good engineering can no longer merely provide a technological solution to an
immediate problem; it must challenge itself to consider the larger context, and long-
term implications, of the design.
A very concrete example of an educational initiative that brings university
students together with practitioners from the industry is given by Rainer Züst em.,
professor of ETH Zürich, in his article Ecodesign in Swiss Machining Industry:
A Collaborative Learning Process for Effective Outreach and Education. After a
broad introduction into the basic elements of a modern approach in ecodesign
and new product development, the author is pointing out that modern education
in engineering must include the direct contact with the industry. The future lies in a
learning process in which industries and universities collaborate. In a process of col-
laboration between experts and students, both sides will benefit: the industry sector
for implementing new scientific knowledge in their R&D projects, and students and
university teaching by basing their education in a practice-oriented way.
Finally, there are two articles in this chapter which are directed concretely of
including engineering and material flow technologies into the educational systems
at universities.
Jeff Steinfeld and Amanda Graham from MIT Cambridge in their presentation
Implementing New Teaching Models at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology
6 R. Baud
refer to the fact that the old model of educating engineers at universities may not be
adequate to address the issues and challenges of global sustainability. Accordingly,
for ESD to succeed in its purpose, we must find ways to bridge the gaps among
multiple disciplines and to develop students’ capacity to synthesize the viewpoints
these bring to sustainability. The authors describe a variety of multidisciplinary
teaching methodologies and some innovative activities at MIT that embodies the
institute’s motto of mens et manus (learning by doing) and makes use of the campus
itself as a laboratory for learning. Among the examples described here are project-
based courses and tutorials for beginning and advanced students that address topics
ranging from energy-saving projects on campus to global environmental issues;
the infusion of energy and environmental topics into basic course requirements
in science, engineering, and social science; and making use of the Research
Opportunities Program to engage students in current research activities on these
topics.
An even broader educational approach, addressing all aspects of the sustainabil-
ity concept, by reflecting engineering and technology in the full context of today’s
social, political, and economic realities, is presented by Michelle Grant from ETH,
Zürich on the case study Youth Encounter on Sustainability: A Transdisciplinary,
Multicultural, and Immersive Education Program. Over the past 10 years, the Youth
Encounter on Sustainability (YES), starting in 2000 as an educational initiative by
ETH – Zürich, MIT – Boston, University of Tokyo, and Chalmers University of
Technology – Gothenburg, is a unique and intensive 18-day course program that
brings together students from all over the world to learn, debate, and discuss the
multiple facets of the sustainability concept and to plan for future options and
actions including questions on how to integrate engineering and technology into
the needs of today’s and tomorrow’s societies. Over 1,200 students from more than
120 different countries have gone already through this learning process and, after
their training at YES, are linked in a network for ongoing discussions and activities.
Blueprints for Teaching Ecodesign and
Sustainability to University Students 2
Charles Pezeshki, Jitesh H. Panchal, and Gaurav Ameta
Abstract
There can be little doubt that if ecodesign and sustainability principles are
going to be adopted, a great accelerator would be fundamental curriculum
reform in engineering degree-granting institutions across the globe. But for
most individuals involved with institutions of higher education, daunting hurdles
exist at all levels – departmental, college, university, as well as accreditation
by certification agencies. And because of the work burdens extant in academic
jobs, most individual faculty members do not have the time to jump through
the procedural hoops that would result in real change. Additionally, because
of the lack of widespread acceptance of the basic principles of product life
cycle management, or the need to take valuable real estate from other topics,
most efforts in curricular change end up bogged down. There are a rapidly
increasing number of programs that offer some complement of sustainability
courses at the graduate level, and some nascent efforts at the undergraduate level.
However, the largest problem with single-course offerings is that they effectively
pigeonhole “green” engineering into a vanishingly small part of the curriculum,
where what really needs to happen is a systemic overhaul of all classes so that
ecodesign and sustainability become systemic in the way that engineers operate
themselves.
But in order for this to happen, some type of framework must be established
that allows both students and professors a larger, more coherent approach to
the field. Such a model is presented in this chapter. This approach is both
inclusive and extensive. After presentation of the model, this chapter offers the
educational practitioner some examples of application of the model – one is a
model for curriculum reform primarily at the undergraduate level, with examples
for potential from the USA, Europe, and India. The other is a template for two
more typical sustainability courses that would be offered at the graduate level.
1 Introduction
The origins of this work began with the Dassault Systems Ecodesign Fellowship
project. This was launched in 2007 with the appointment of the first author to de-
velop a framework for a coordinated ecodesign curriculum to share across European
and US institutions. An assessment of ecodesign education best practices over the
past decade indicated that education and dissemination of best practices continued
to lag behind method development in this field. For example, a 2001 analysis of the
state of implementation of ecodesign in Europe found that ecodesign education was
mainly taught at universities in postgraduate education courses.1 Most technical,
design, and business programs failed to provide basic ecodesign education in under-
graduate programs. Even further behind lagged smaller academies and schools. The
exceptions were large, design-centered technical universities in leading countries,
such as the Netherlands, Austria, UK, Australia, and Germany.
Similarly, the state of ecodesign education within North America is fragmented
and lacks avenues for dissemination. There are many examples of innovative design
educators integrating ecodesign into courses,2 but engineering education continues
to play catch-up. Industry demands for first-year engineers with product life cycle
management skills (PLM) continue to grow, particularly in light of the global
environmental regulatory environment, such as the Waste Electrical and Electronic
Equipment (WEEE) and Reduction of Hazardous Substances (RoHS) directives of
the European Union, that will restrict markets to producers who can successfully
satisfy the engineering and life cycle requirements in the year 2011.
At the outset of this project, ecodesign education was still playing catch-up.
In fact, many of the familiar pockets of innovation were not being disseminated
to the wider global engineering education community (see Fig. 2.1). With this in
mind, an ecodesign social network in Europe was developed. In order to build a
common understanding, a number of practitioners and academics pose the following
questions:
• What is ecodesign?
• What is driving ecodesign?
• What is the role of ecodesign in industry, education, government, and research
groups?
• What are the barriers to innovation in industry and education, and what are the
success stories?
• How do we move toward integration of these areas in order to
– Improve ecodesign education?
– Move industry from compliance to innovation?
• What, specifically, can we do as a community of educators, and university-
industry partners, to address these problems?
2 Blueprints for Teaching Ecodesign and Sustainability to University Students 9
Global Warming
Peak Oil
Economic Fallout
INTEGRATION
Research Groups
Government
Consultancies
Policy
Sustainable
Regulation
Development Orgs
Industry
Education
Products &
Training
Processes
Innovation
PLM Technology
Global Warming
Peak Oil
Economic Fallout
INTEGRATION
INTEGRATION
2 Background
In the preliminary stages, the current leaders in the field were identified, from
both academia and industry, to collaborate on the development of an inclusive
ecodesign framework to aid faculty, programs, and institutions in the process
of integrating ecodesign into the undergraduate curriculum. Leading institutions
served as models to guide the process because they have the highest percentage of
specialized education courses, graduate and undergraduate programs, cutting-edge
10 C. Pezeshki et al.
2.1 Method
For this project, a survey of institutions and industry partners included collecting
sample curricula, video interviews, and casestudies and was compiled in an
online electronic-portfolio format.3 University partners included Delft University
of Technology, Technical University of Vienna, Technical University of Denmark,
University of Technology Sydney, ETH Zurich, and Washington State Univer-
sity. Industry partners included Priestman-Goode, UK, InterfaceFlor, USA, Engel,
Austria, Avaloop, Austria, and OMODO, Germany (see Fig. 2.2).
The data was evaluated across formats. For example, video “mashups” were
created from individual footage to answer community questions. Curricula were laid
out side by side to compare core competencies, structure, and sequence. Finally,
case-study analyses provide a backdrop for understanding the current and future
goal state of ecodesign in engineering education and a foothold of inspiration.
Finally, a conceptual framework and example curriculum templates from Europe
and the United States were developed from the data.
In order to innovate ecodesign and sustainability education, one must first un-
derstand what it is. And while there are many potential taxonomies, what we
discovered was that often when one talked about participating in either ecodesign
or sustainability education, the subject areas were usually one of four categories.
These four categories are as follows:
1. Core science, such as the search for a new eco-friendly material.
2. Facilitative strategies, which were often computer tools that made making an
eco-friendly choice more likely, or an easier digestion of design trade-offs.
3. Canonical ecodesign philosophy, which offers the designer or engineer a more
complete methodology for designing an eco-friendly or sustainable product.
4. Conceptual knowledge, which takes into account that often major innovations
in eco-friendliness may occur outside the ecodesign/sustainability framework.
For example, the Boeing 787 Dreamliner was not designed at the start to be an
eco-friendly aircraft. However, by reducing fuel consumed per passenger mile by
2 Blueprints for Teaching Ecodesign and Sustainability to University Students 11
Industry
SPO
Technische Universität Wien creativity engineering Dassault Systemes (Education)
NSO
ecodesign
dissemination
R
Wolfgang Wimmer Spin-off C Maarit Cruz
olla
Technische Universität Wien bo Dassault Systemes (VirTools)
r
at
Hoat University
ion
s
EcoDesign
Chuck Pezeshki Curriculum Roger Baud
Washington State University Adaptation ETH Zurich
leadership training
ecodesign
Kelley Racicot visualization case study Douglas Tomkin
China
Washington State University University of Technology, Sydney
parametric
Hessam Ostad ecodesign Reiner Anderl
Technische Universität Wien Technische Universität Darmstadt
sustainability
Niki Bey Royal Philips Ab Stevels
Technical University of Denmark Delft University of Technology
20%, the resultant reduction of CO2 emissions from a fleet of aircraft stands to
be enormous (see Fig. 2.3).
The following are examples of each category collected during our visits across
Europe:
1. Search for a working fluid that fits a Rankine cycle process that can be used
for small biomass facilities. This is basic science in that understanding the basic
thermodynamics and chemistry are important for developing a system that will
promote sustainable behavior on the part of people interested in power generation
(Fig. 2.4).
2. Development of tools that will aid in developing a Super-Light car, being
completed at the TU-Darmstadt in Germany. This work integrates tools into a
conventional Product Life cycle Management system that enables engineers to
make decisions that affect sustainability on-the-fly during the design process
(Fig. 2.5).
12 C. Pezeshki et al.
Ecodesign Framework
Conceptual
Canonical Knowlege
EcoDesign Big Ideas for making
Facilitative
Philosophy products that have less
Strategies
Core Science environmental impact,
Tool Development: using Decision making improved economic and
EcoDesign processes that integrate social benefits
building blocks core science to
understand and make core science and
decisions facilitative strategies to
make better design Paradigm Shifts
decisions Big changes in
understanding how the
environment works
Core Science
EcoDesign
building blocks
• material replacement
• basic biophysics
planetary &
atmospheric
Turbine/Generator
Example: Heat Exchanger
• CO2
upper atmosphere
lower atmosphere
Piero Colonna, Delft Heat
• Phthalate replacement Heat
Organic Rankine Cyle Input
Rejected
endocrine disrupters
Working fluid replacement Feed
Pump Condenser
Eu Consortium Goal:
Facilitative 30% weight reduction in the
Strategies C-class car models
Tool Development:using
core science to TUDarmstadt role:
understand and make Linking technical, cost, and
decisions environmental information in
the concept development phase
• automated CO2
loading scale
• design for
environmental
compliance
Department of Computer
Integrated Design (DiK)
4. Back-engineering breakthrough products, such as the Boeing 787, that use 20%
less fuel than a typical aircraft per passenger mile, and attempting to apply such
lessons across other object/consumer good categories (Fig. 2.7).
Example: Canonical
EcoDesign
Philosophy
Decision making
processes that integrate
core science and
facilitative strategies to
make better design
decisions
• QFD
• systematization
• regulatory information
in the decision-making
Wolfgang Wimmer system
EcoDesign Pilot • deciding where to
devote most of your
engineering effort
Fig. 2.6 Developing ecodesign and sustainability design processes for consistency
Example:
Conceptual
Knowlege
Big Ideas for making
products that have less
environmental impact,
improved economic and
social benefits
Paradigm Shifts
Big changes in
20% less fuel understanding how the
environment works
New technologies in
carbon and
plastics Paradigm-breaking
products that don’t
necessarily follow the
New advances in usual design philosophy
systems track
integration Bottom-up lessons
technologies for learned by
optimization of post-production
manufacturing benchmarking and
reflection
Graduate level study in ecodesign and sustainability occurs around the world and is
voluminous in nature. Because of the inherent flexibility of graduate education – the
universal emphasis on a thesis or dissertation, no governing bodies that can dictate
particular content, and the rapidly growing interest in the field – the task of designing
applicable coursework becomes much more tractable.
A larger discussion on all the potential coursework to be done in graduate
education is beyond the scope of this chapter. In fact, an independent course could
probably be implemented for every chapter of this handbook. But in the interest
of providing templates for universities wishing to implement a course, or courses
in sustainability at the introductory graduate level, two case studies, with syllabi,
are offered. The first course presents a top-down perspective toward understanding
life cycle assessment and sustainability. The second course discusses a bottom-up
approach on these same issues.
Earlier in the chapter, various strategies for infusing sustainability topics within
existing courses were discussed, particularly at the undergraduate level. If it is
possible to include one or two additional courses on sustainability, the key objectives
should be:
(a) Understanding the needs and challenges of sustainability in a product life cycle
from a systems perspective
(b) Understanding the strategies adopted for systems design for sustainability
16 C. Pezeshki et al.
Table 2.1 US Mechanical Engineering Curriculum (Sample taken from Washington State Uni-
versity, School of Mechanical and Materials Engineering)
Course Semester # Current elements Modifications
Gened 110 [A] GER 1 University general Influence of environment-
World Civilizations 1 education material forces on history
requirement – history as a side topic (resource
of the world depletion, weather
changes, Little Ice Age,
emphasis on materials as
a key societal definition)
Resource Consumption
Availability over
Time!Books – Guns,
Germs and Steel, Jared
Diamond
ME 120 Innovation in 1 Small-scale projects – Introduction to PLM –
Design Innovation in Solids Modeling
Design 2 Introduction
to engineering
disciplines, problem
solving, design,
teamwork, and ethics
Chem 105/115 Chem I 1 Stoichiometry, Modification/Discussion
General University structure, gases, of examples to include
Requirement liquids, solids, 25% environmentally
solutions, related chemical reactions
thermodynamics,
kinetics, equilibrium,
volumetric, and
gravimetric analysis
Chem 106/116 Chem II 2 Acid-base, ionic, Ecodesign/Sustainability-
General Engineering molecular, solubility, related case studies for
Requirement oxidation/reduction example: Combustion
equilibria; kinetics, Cycles, Ozone Depletion
electrochemistry; Causal Chains of events
systematic chemistry Major Env. Chemical
of the elements; Impact Classifications
coordination (IPCC – Int’l Panel on
compounds Climate Change)
ME 103 Engineering 2 CAD/CAM Basics – Introduction to PLM –
Graphics Orthographic theory, Solids Modeling, Basics
conventions, and of PDM
visualization;
isometric and oblique
pictorial; geometric
dimensioning and
tolerancing,
computer-aided
drafting and solid
modeling
(continued)
2 Blueprints for Teaching Ecodesign and Sustainability to University Students 17
Table 2.2 Indian Mechanical Engineering Curriculum, Indian Institute of Technology, Guwahati,
India, Department of Mechanical Engineering
Course Semester # Current Elements Modifications
Chemistry 101 1 Basic Chemistry Modification/Discussion
of examples to include
25% environmentally
related chemical reactions
ME-111 Engineering 1 Basic Engineering Introduction to PLM –
Drawing Drawing Solids Modeling, Basics
of PDM
EC-101 Electrical Sciences 1 Electrical Circuits Case studies of changes in
the electronics industry
due to environmental regs.
Energy Consumption –
Standby Issues
BT-101 Modern Biology 2 Basic Biology Nanoscale, Chemical
Scale, Large Scale
Biological Phenomena
and their effect on the
world and its biosystems
Topics such as effects of
plastics in ecosystems –
phthalates, estrogenizers,
Global Warming, ocean
impacts and changing
climate Causal Chains of
Events
ME-202 Engineering 4 Introductory Toxicity, environmental
Materials materials science impact of select materials
for case studies – minor
content addition. Eco-data
associated with
materials – recyclability,
real cost of extraction and
processing
ME-301 – Manufacturing 5 Manufacturing Examination of toxicities
Technology processes of varying metalworking
processes. Analysis of
by-products from
manufacturing processes.
Introduction of ideas of
Industrial Ecology and
parallelization/pipelining
of process waste as a
supply stream
ME-322 Applied 6 IC Engines and Gas Cursory evaluation of
Thermodynamics – II Powered Systems traditional associated
costs (fuel, performance,
environment) of all
cycles – minor content
addition
(continued)
20 C. Pezeshki et al.
(c) Getting familiar with the broad sets of metrics and tools for sustainability
evaluation
(d) Gaining in-depth knowledge of a few metrics and tools
(e) Understanding how to achieve trade-offs between conflicting objectives in
making design decisions
The emphasis should not be on delivering all the available information to the
students. Much of the knowledge is not only extensive but also domain-specific.
The emphasis should be on creating a solid foundation and providing direction for
the students to promote self-discovery. In other words, the emphasis should be on
“Learning to Learn.” The case studies listed below are the results of these efforts.
The contents of this course are suitable for an entry-level graduate course or a senior-
level undergraduate course. The key segments within the course include:
1. System Life cycle: In this first segment of the course, the students are familiarized
with the systems design process and the phases in a system life cycle. The
systems engineering Vee model is covered. Specific topics within this segment
include requirements management, system architectures, and interfaces. This
segment provides the necessary foundation for the students to think about the
system-wide issues rather than focusing on individual issues in isolation. Tools
for systems modeling such as SysML can be included in this segment.
2. Classification of different sustainability efforts: In this segment, the students
are educated about the systemic needs and challenges associated with sustain-
able design. A variety of efforts for addressing sustainability are introduced.
These include environmental engineering, pollution prevention, environmentally
conscious design and manufacturing, design for environment, life cycle design,
2 Blueprints for Teaching Ecodesign and Sustainability to University Students 21
Table 2.3 European Mechanical Engineering Curriculum (sample taken from the TU Wien, AT)
Course Semester # Current Elements Modifications
Chemistry for mechanical 1 Electrochemistry and Show how/why chemicals
engineers Corrosion, Basic contribute to
Organic Substances, environmental impact.
Lubricants and Impact categories such as
Additives, Production global warming,
of Energy, Fuels and acidification, ozone
Exhaust Fume depletion: how were they
Treatment caused, which chemicals
contribute to each impact
category and why;
chemical reactions
Fundamentals of 1 Overview of Influence of material
Manufacturing Engineering production choice to manufacturing
technologies as a technologies, impact of
basis for manufacturing
understanding life technologies, Introduction
cycle modeling of manufacturing as part
of the product’s Life
Cycle; impact of
manufacturing processes
Fundamentals of engineering 2 First intro of Where and when to start
design Ecodesign; basics of with Ecodesign,
design as a introduction of Life Cycle
prerequisite to thinking, introduction of
understand product implementing
development and environmental aspects
possible product into product development.
improvements Introduction of different
tools such as QFD, TRIZ
could be possible
Machine Elements and 3 Further design Including Life Cycle
design classes specialization in thinking into design and
machine elements design concepts, the cases
to be designed by students
could already include
Ecodesign-based
calculations and
methodologies, Life
Cycle Assessment for
parts and larger
assemblies
Fundamentals of electronics 3 Components of Standby consumption and
electronics, relation to electronic
optoelectronics, circuits, how/why does
sensors and digital standby occur,
technique and power Introduction of directives
electronics with related to electronic
practical applications design, etc. (EuP,
RoHs,. . . )
(continued)
22 C. Pezeshki et al.
Learning objectives:
A student who has met the objectives of the course will
be able to:
• Identify and account for relevant environmental
issues related to a product or a service
• Analyze and assess environmental impacts of a
product in a life cycle perspective
• Describe the social and institutional conditions of
product-related environmental issues
• Carry out a systematic mapping of a product life
by using adequate tools to describe actor-network
relations, users, and activities
• Establish a product life gallery which integrates
contributions and trade-offs between the above
mentioned elements
• Consider opportunities of improved environmental
performance through combining product and ser-
vice approaches
• Synthesize an environmentally improved solution
as a product/service concept
Use scenario methods to identify the necessary condit-
ions for the implementation of a concept
Product life and 5–6 This course is where the students are explicitly in-
environmental troduced to environmental issues and theories. The
issues [theory-based students are trained in thinking environmental issues
course] (elective) into their product designs, on a level par with other
dispositional (DFX) considerations (e.g., quality, cost,
manufacture, risk, etc.). The course has the following
main goals:
• To give insight into strategies and tools for handling
environmental problems in connection with the
design of products and product life systems
• To introduce environmental issues into the activity
of product life design
• To identify and analyze relevant environmental
and resource-related problems and their regulatory
origins
• To analyze product life cycles, especially with
respect to the involvement of relevant stakeholders
• To use methodical tools for product life–oriented
design (DFX) with a particular focus on ecodesign
• To generate scenarios and strategies for the real-
ization of improved environmental situations, in
relation to products and usage situations
(continued)
26 C. Pezeshki et al.
3. Strategies for systems design for sustainability: In this segment, the focus is on
providing details of a few approaches for sustainable design. Specific guidelines
and steps are discussed. Examples include product system life extension, ma-
terial life extension, material selection, reduced material intensiveness, process
management, efficient distribution, and improved management practices. This
segment can be linked to a project or an assignment. Specific decisions and
associated trade-offs are identified.
4. Metrics and Indicators: Within the context of sustainable design decisions, this
segment focuses on metrics and indicators for quantifying the impact of different
design alternatives on different environmental factors. Frameworks such as Eco-
Indicator 99 and ISO 14031 Indicator Framework are discussed in detail.
5. Specific sustainability tools: The emphasis in this segment is on core tools used
in sustainability such as Life cycle Analysis (LCA) and Life cycle Cost Analysis
(LCC). These tools are covered due to their breadth and domain-independence.
The students either can use these tools for their projects or can include an
assignment.
6. Multi-attribute decision-making frameworks: Since systems-level sustainabil-
ity decisions are invariably associated with trade-offs, the role of systematic
multi-attribute decision making is significant. In this segment, decision-making
frameworks such as Utility Theory6 are covered. The students are educated
about mathematically rigorous ways of modeling preferences, alternatives, and
2 Blueprints for Teaching Ecodesign and Sustainability to University Students 27
In this course, the focus was kept on addressing sustainability assessment at the
design stage of a product. In the design stage, a product is not only planned for
its use and manufacturing but also maintenance and disposal. Therefore, the basic
introduction to the course should include educating the students about engineering
design and planning. After laying down the basics of engineering design, the next
aspect to discuss would be sustainability, its meaning, and various aspects related
to it. Although sustainability is talked about as triple bottom line of economy,
environment, and society, it can only be achieved by developing and utilizing the
right technology in a right manner. Therefore, the triple bottom line should be
viewed with a technological lens.7
The next step is to introduce economic, sociological, and environmental aspects.
Economic aspects are taught in many undergraduate engineering design courses,
so these aspects will not be discussed in this course. Environmental aspects are
considered by learning about Life Cycle Assessment and discussing various labeling
28 C. Pezeshki et al.
4 Conclusions
Ecodesign and Sustainability advances are being only slowly integrated into under-
graduate curricula around the world. In order to improve the rate of dissemination,
two things must occur: First there must be a clear taxonomy of what is actually
meant by ecodesign and sustainability. Second, what must occur is that faculty in
2 Blueprints for Teaching Ecodesign and Sustainability to University Students 29
these areas must take a pragmatic approach toward adoption by re-engineering and
adapting current courses to give a focus across the curriculum toward the concepts
in ecodesign and sustainability, instead of working to add new courses. Finally,
if the only immediate alternative for introduction of this type of material into the
curriculum is the addition of another course, two potential courses are offered for
discussion. This chapter is hopefully a small step forward in providing discussion
jump-off points for all these larger directives.
References
G. Ameta, S. Rachuri, X. Fiorentini, M. Mani, S.J. Fenves, K. Lyons, R. Sriram, Extending the
notion of quality from physical metrology to information and sustainability (article in press).
J. Intell. Manuf. doi: 10.1007/s10845-009-0333-3
IDSA Ecodesign (2009), http://www.idsa.org/whatsnew/sections/ecosection/selectedlinks.html.
Accessed 31 Aug 2009
R.L. Keeney, H. Raiffa, Decisions with Multiple Objectives: Preferences and Value Tradeoffs
(Wiley, New York, 1976)
C. Pezeshki, K. Racicot, Understanding ecodesign. https://mysite.wsu.edu/personal/pezeshki/
Ecodesign/default.aspx
Tree Hugger. Eco Design Studies http://www.treehugger.com/files/2005/07/qa a eco design.php
A. Tukker, P. Eder, M. Charter, E. Haag, A. Vercalsteren, T. Wiedmann, Eco-design: the state of
implementation in Europe, conclusions of a state of the art study for IPTS. J. Sustainability
Prod. Des. 1(3), 147–161 (2001)
W. Wimmer, ECODESIGN Pilot (Kluwer Academic, 2001)
Ecodesign in Swiss Machining Industry:
A Collaborative Learning Process for 3
Effective Outreach and Education
Rainer Züst
Abstract
Since more than 20 years, ecodesign experts in mechanical industry have been
concerned with the question of how industrial products and especially machines
can be improved in an ecological sense. As some products are often used in
different ways by different clients, usage itself has to be hypothesized as a
variable entity. Ecodesign, therefore, requires consolidated system know-how
and engineering targeted toward the system and system performance. This is
about more than just “filter and recycling”; much rather better products are
required. Once you start looking at machines, respectively production systems,
the complexity of the product increases enormously.
For ecodesign in the machine industry, specific know-how is essential – know-
how which is not yet or only partly available. This is why new ways have been
investigated. The solution lies in a learning process in which the industries and
universities collaborate, i.e., collaboration between experts and students, who
gradually acquire the necessary know-how and implement it directly in R&D
projects and also integrate it into university teaching in a practice-orientated way.
The objective of this chapter in hand is to illustrate this learning process
by means of the example of the “Swiss machine industry.” The chapter is
based on many years experience from being a university professor and leading
courses and projects for product managers in manufacturing companies. The
innovative aspect of this learning concept is the fact that specific knowledge is
collaboratively developed by experts from the industry and universities. Joint
analyses, discussions, and especially approaches, which concern new planning
methods as well as new technical solutions in particular, are at the center of
this. So first, to make this happen, a sense of mutual trust between sometimes
competing companies and universities has to be established.
R. Züst
Züst Engineering AG, Seegräben, Switzerland
e-mail: rainer.zuest@zuestengineering.ch, rainer.zuest@bluewin.ch
1 Introduction
mobility
moving
stationary
kind of use
passive active
Fig. 3.2 Classification of a few ecodesign objectives based on specific product characteristics
(Züst 2010)
Ecodesign deals with the following question – how, in a certain context, can more
be achieved while using fewer resources?
When looking at the historic development of ecodesign, one can see that initially
ecodesign objectives were promoted without really looking into the specific situ-
ation, i.e., specific ecological strengths and weaknesses of a product (Winterberg
2011).
– As early as the 1990s, ecodesign methods and planning tools were intensively
developed. Before 1996, these were predominantly contributions to DFX, pri-
marily focused on “integrated product development,” which had to fulfil various
requirements. At that time, ecodesign was rather about making propaganda for
different strategies, for example, a long life expectancy, recyclability, being free
from toxic substances, etc.
– Shortly before but especially after 1996, meaning after the introduction of
ISO 14001 (and in connection with this also of ISO/TR 14062: Ecodesign),
the topic ecodesign was discussed more widely. As a first stepplanning tools
with tips and checklists were compiled and published. The appropriate process
was documented. The “analysis of weaknesses,” which was now required, was,
however, not (yet) carried out in a consistent way despite being specified in the
relevant standards. After the revision of ISO 14001, more value was attached to
this aspect – it was referred to as “direct and indirect impact on the environment,”
which the individual companies had to improve. “Indirect” here refers to taking
the implications of one’s own products in future usage into consideration.
– In the following years, an increasing number of “analysis tools” were compiled
and published, for example, LCA – life cycle assessment (in compliance with
ISO 14040ff) or screening methods like CED (cumulated energy demand, and as
a result thereof the CO2 calculator). All these methods have the problem that it is
difficult to deduce a sensible scope for the system and the system boundaries, i.e.,
a “proper” system model, which is then evaluated. In the early planning phases,
for example, only few or no concrete information about the future product is
available. What are needed here are appropriate estimates.
– Currently, the question is how to devise systems that are ecologically orientated
from the outset. There is a lack of basic methodical principles as well as tools
(cf. Fig. 3.3 below). A central problem is still usage phase. Especially when the
product use is variable, it is difficult to deduce sensible usage scenarios as part of
product development.
The above statements are based on the analysis of a total of nearly 50 articles on
ecodesign methods, guidelines, projects, and similar published between 1996 and
2011. More in-depth analysis can be found in the figure below:
The analysis shows the following:
– For the evaluation of individual components or simple products, valuable meth-
ods and tools have been developed in recent years – especially in the area of life
cycle assessment.
3 Ecodesign in Swiss Machining Industry 35
Fig. 3.3 Number of available, i.e., published, ecodesign methods sorted by application area
(Winterberg 2011)
Despite a lack of methods and tools, the challenge to improve the resource
efficiency of productive equipment and to fill university curricula and train-
ing in the industry with new contents for teaching still remains. For this
36 R. Züst
The first step, therefore, was to clarify how far-reaching the potential of
ecodesign is and where it is advisable to intervene.
“Actually how big is the ecodesign potential for machines and equipment in
Switzerland? And how would you have to train engineers and designers so that
they can build these resource-efficient machines and equipment?” These questions
were the starting point for an explorative study within the Swiss machine industry
followed by an intense discussion with industry experts about the topic of ecodesign
know-how. The goal was to jointly generate together with interested companies new
know-how benefitting the industry.
The machine, electrical, and electronic industries are the biggest industrial
sectors in Switzerland contributing 48% of the industrial creation of value. Their
proportion of the GDP was 9.3% (2009). Their average export quota is 75% (2009),
thus having reached approximately 35% of the total Swiss export (2009). The
Swiss mechanical and electrical engineering industries provide 330,000 jobs, 95%
of which are in small and medium-sized companies with less than 250 employees
(Swissmem 2009).
The total production of the Swiss mechanical and electrical engineering indus-
tries adds up to 80,000 million CHF (2009); machine tools (2/3 for metals; 1/3 for
other materials) account for 8,000–10,000 million CHF (approx. 10%). Twenty to
twenty-five percent of these machines are used by Swiss customers. To improve
these machines and their operation at the customer’s plant with regard to material
and energy consumption is the goal of ecodesign.
Swiss equipment especially machine tools is used all over the world. A correspond-
ing consumption of energy and raw materials at the customer’s site is directly linked
to this usage, while this consumption of resources is higher or lower depending on
the design, technological standard, and area of application of these products.
3 Ecodesign in Swiss Machining Industry 37
Examples taken from the area machines/machine tools show that optimized
machines can save more energy and resources during their expected useful life than
can be saved during their own production due to:
– Long service life (30,000 h and more)
– Partly high energy consumption (often 20 kW and more)
– Partly big production runs (annually up to 50,000 production machines of
different sizes are manufactured in Switzerland)
A brief estimate in reference to this:
– For the evaluation, the following assumptions have been made:
Electricity price: 0.10 e
100 g CO2 per kWh in Switzerland
500 g CO2 /kWh in EU
– Assumptions: Average consumption of 10 kWh for the abovementioned ma-
chines and an economization of 25% with the help of ecodesign
– The reduction would be about four billion kWh over the use of these machines
for a 1-year production.
– For the EU, this is the equivalent of a 2 million ton reduction in CO2 ,
corresponding to a saving of 400 million e
(Remark: Switzerland is responsible for 45 million tons of CO2 emissions per
year, a reduction by two million tons CO2 by using optimized Swiss production
machines therefore equals a reduction by 5%.)
4500000.0MJ
4000000.0MJ
3500000.0MJ
3000000.0MJ
2500000.0MJ
2000000.0MJ
1500000.0MJ
1000000.0MJ
500000.0MJ
0.0MJ
raw material purchasing & transportation starting phase use end-off-life
production
Fig. 3.4 Energy profile for a production machine (Züst et al. 2010)
For many companies, the task of drawing up eco- or energy profiles is new.
Especially life-cycle-thinking and mapping out a practicable system boundary
is painstaking. Employees in the industry as well as students are not used
to comprehensively envisaging the individual life phases of a product which
would enable them to recognize unintended situations, which in turn would
allow them to make sensible system boundaries. Such a “holistic” way of
3 Ecodesign in Swiss Machining Industry 39
After the energy profiles were created, the question, where to reduce consump-
tion with only minor changes and how big the total savings potential is overall, was
interesting for all parties involved. The next step was to determine the improvement
potential of different approaches and – as an estimate – to quantify them. Twenty
six profiles formed the basis for the subsequent evaluation. Eighteen profiles
concerned production machines; eight other products were domestic appliances
(coffee machines, washing machine, etc.) as well as furniture systems.
Production machines and appliances often are “active products,” which consume
a lot more energy while being run than is used during their own manufacturing pro-
cess. In detail, the following factors, which were essential for further understanding
and know-how transfer, can be deduced from the study:
Electricity consumption during usage as compared to consumption during manu-
facturing process (electricity consumption during usage by factor xy greater than
for manufacturing) (Berger Strategy Consultants 2009):
Factor 5: Average of all analyzed machines and appliances within the machine,
electric and electronic industries in Switzerland
Factor 2: Machine tools for (very) high precision manufacturing (cutting)
Factor around 20: Machine tools for high precision manufacturing and high
productivity
Factor 20–40: Machine tools for high speed cutting and high productivity
Factor 30–100: Machine tools for high productivity using higher temperature
(pressure die casting, photonics, etc.)
(More details in: ISO/TC 39/WG 12 N 22, 2010: results of the study above have
been integrated in this standard)
The focus of ecodesign for production machines clearly lies on the usage
phase. This is where ecodesign measures have the biggest impact. The energy
consumption for manufacturing this production machine varies between 1% and
5% of the total consumption and is, therefore, almost negligible.
Energy consumption abroad in comparison to Switzerland (Züst et al. 2010):
Factor 3: As 80% of Swiss machines are exported and constitute 50% of
created value in Switzerland, Swiss machines abroad consume an amount of
energy which is by factor 3 higher throughout all their life phases than for the
production in Switzerland itself.
40 R. Züst
If there is a high percentage of exports and at the same time a low percentage
of real net output in one’s own country (and this is the case for many highly
industrialized countries), the reduced energy consumption will mostly occur
abroad.
Relationship between CO2 emissions abroad in comparison to Switzerland
(Züst et al. 2010):
Factor 15: The European energy mix causes a CO2 production which is by
factor 5 higher than the one in Switzerland. That is why Swiss machines abroad
will cause a CO2 footprint which is on average 5 times bigger. If one also takes
into account that 3 out of 4 machines are exported, the factor increases to 15.
Depending on the regional energy mix in countries outside the EU, it can even
increase further.
With regard to CO2 emission, further distinctions can be made. Countries with
mountainous regions have a high percentage of electricity generated by hydro-
electric power stations available, which has an extremely tiny CO2 footprint. If
these countries export machines with clearly lower electricity consumption, what
is indeed exported are CO2 sinks. (So far) this achievement is not taken into account
when calculating the amount of CO2 each country produces.
In the context of the explorative study, ecodesign measures were discussed
together with the companies involved – constituting a further important element
of know-how increase and know-how transfer. Especially for components or
functions with high energy consumption, they were looking for new solutions. The
participating engineers were to understand the core elements of ecodesign as quickly
as possible so that they could help find solutions.
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
−5%
2009 2011 2013 2015 2017 2019
Fig. 3.5 Improvement potential with regard to electricity consumption for the machine building
industry (Züst et al. 2010)
For each one of the analyzed products, improvement measures were discussed,
and the potential for improvement within the next 10 years was estimated. This
makes an additional evaluation with regard to individual ecodesign strategies and
ecodesign measures possible; these can then be measured against the overall
improvement potential.
The explorative study shows that there is an improvement potential for the
machine building industry of 25% within 10 years (Fig. 3.5).
For the domestic appliance sector, the improvement potential is enormously
bigger, for the field of electric and electronic equipment somewhat smaller. The
majority of improvements can be realized at the user end as optimized usage. The
improvement potential at the production site, however, is relatively small.
If the calculations also include material consumption during usage and its grey
energy, the potential is reduced down to approx. 15%. The reason for this is the
significantly higher percentage of material costs, and therefore, the improvements
that have been implemented so far are with regard to material or wastage. When
estimating the improvement potential, a rise in efficiency, which is purely based on
an increase in production, has not been taken into consideration.
Already during discussions with the companies involved as well as during the later
evaluation, it becomes obvious that not only incremental improvements are possible
but also a further increase in efficiency or even radical changes involving new
technologies and solutions. In the following, the approaches that were discussed
will be divided into three areas or levels of innovation:
– “Face-Lifting” – Improvement of a (existing) product: Individual parts and
assemblies are changed. Typically, toxic substances are replaced, materials
42 R. Züst
which harm the environment are reduced, and the production process at the
manufacturer’s end is improved.
– “ReDesign” – Redesigning the product: The whole life cycle is scrutinized and
optimized. The focus is clearly on an existing product, respectively on selected
functional principles.
– “ReThink” – Implementing new functional principles: Also the functional prin-
ciples and the functions themselves are scrutinized and if necessary replaced by
innovative solutions.
Among others, the following approaches have been discussed and evaluated with
regard to their improvement potential for the three levels of innovation:
Face-Lifting (Züst et al. 2010):
– Optimizing the supply chain; shorter transport routes.
– Different materials, less material consumption, and more efficient production
process at the manufacturer’s end.
– The majority of these are incremental improvements of the product or its produc-
tion processes. Overall, these are improvements, which are easily implemented
but have little ecological use.
ReDesign (Züst et al. 2010):
– Optimizing the process (with regard to the product/the machine), more efficient
process cycles, etc., effective at the customer’s end
– Optimizing standby, more efficient drives, asynchronous motors, optimized drive
systems
– Less waste, better process control, etc., at the customer’s end
– The majority others of redesign involves measures to increase efficiency of
products, so that their user can achieve a higher or better value. Ideas for this
are widely known; in addition their implementation has partly already been
planned. The ecological benefits are existent; however, they do not really suffice
as strategic competitive advantage.
(Remark: In the VDMA, studies, which were already mentioned, show a 9%
increase of efficiency within the next 10 years due to a closer cooperation
between suppliers and customers.)
ReThink (Züst et al. 2010):
– New production and process technologies are used.
– Optimizing the system (machine/product as a whole is optimized); system
network and using symbiotic relationships.
– Lightweight design especially for quick translational and rotary changes of
movement.
– New/different kinematical arrangement of components and tools, change from
single- to multispindle machining.
– Optimizing the operational readiness/availability (energy saving mode, only offer
requested function); using power electronics; replace traditional transformers.
– Optimizing or replacing hydraulics, optimizing or replacing compressed air
and vacuum systems, optimizing extraction systems, optimizing high-pressure
cooling systems; alternative cooling systems; dry machining
– Others
3 Ecodesign in Swiss Machining Industry 43
Fig. 3.6 Achievable improvements in energy efficiency (Züst et al. 2010). Different levels of
innovation measures (shown in red)
– The majority of these are innovative approaches and new technologies for
more efficient processes to be used with MEM products (products of the Swiss
mechanical and electrical engineering industries). The risks when implementing
these measures and the related investment costs are partly considered as high;
however, the economic and ecologic potential is also high, and in addition to
this, the strategic competitive advantage achieved by rethink is undisputed.
The figure below (Fig. 3.6) shows the savings corresponding to the different levels
of innovation. In this context, it is interesting to see that improvements of 25%
or more within the next 10 years are only possible if “radical improvements” are
implemented as well. And for production machines, this means optimizing whole
systems rather than just individual components. It does, therefore, not suffice to
further optimize existing solutions. New solutions, especially in the field of “system
optimization,” are necessary.
It should also be noted that over the last 10 years, the energy consumption of the
mechanical engineering sector has already been reduced by 25%.
Two further independent studies show that with the help of product ecodesign,
a lot of energy can be saved, and the CO2 emissions can be reduced in the
sector of the manufacturing industries. The studies by Roland Berger Strategy
Consultants (Berger Strategy Consultants 2009) as well as the study by Prognos
AG (Prognos 2009), done by Prognos AG, ordered by VDMA 2009, which
were both commissioned by VDMA (industry association of German machinery
manufacturers), show a savings potential of approx. 80–90 million tons of CO2 on
the supplier’s as well as on the customer’s side for the manufacturing industries in
Germany within 10 years. The explorative study by Rainer Züst shows an annual
savings potential of ten million tons of CO2 until 2020 for the sectors of mechanical
engineering, domestic appliances and electrical, and electronic equipment, which
is an equivalent of approx. 50% of the Swiss mechanical, electrical, and electronic
industries. Ten million tons of CO2 is the equivalent of slightly more than 20% of
the current CO2 footprint of Switzerland (Züst et al. 2010).
This ecodesign potential is indeed considerable. That is why the mechanical in-
dustry has an important role to play in climate protection and resource conservation.
44 R. Züst
This is a challenge for ecodesign. Thanks to a broad analysis of potential within the
Swiss industry, the companies have been even further motivated and have started to
build up an initial ecodesign know-how.
Power
7
5
Power [kw]
4 ca. 1/3
2
ca. 2/3
1
0
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
time
Fig. 3.7 Data from one machining cycle: consumption of energy (Sandeep et al. 2010)
The project to process ecodesign knowledge and to establish it with a broad basis
in the Swiss industry is made easier by the high percentage of fixed consumption:
Shortening the machining cycles (D increase in productivity) is the daily challenge
for the users. With this strategy, the energy consumption of current machines can be
reduced at the same time. Only after a massive reduction of the base load it could
become interesting again to reduce productivity (e.g., in off-peak periods).
Do you know BON? BON stands for “Betrieb ohne Nutzen” (D operation
without benefit). It aims at a presence and demand-dependent management
(logic) of all energy-consuming functions.
In many cases, it is better to “simply” turn off the components that are not
needed outside the actual process itself. If there is no machining job, one could
turn off as much as possible or at least turn it down. With regard to production
machines, the components concerned are especially cooling lubricant pumps
and compressed air (which is often used as sealing air to protect sensitive
machine parts from overpressure). If no machining process is running, no
cooling system needs to be running. And if the cooling system is not running,
no or little sealing air is needed. The same question is always of interest – is
there a real demand for a certain performance or function? If there is not –
turn it off; if there is – how little is actually necessary (and not how much is
possible)?
Experts in building automation have been looking into this question for
some time. An ISO standard does already exist for this (SIA 386 110,
respectively EN 15 232), which simply shows how the vast thermal and
electric improvement potential can be used with the help of presence and
demand-dependent management (D logic). In the case of a lecture hall, for
example, which currently is not actively regulated, an optimized management
could save 50% thermal energy and approx. 10% electric energy. “All” that it
needs is an intelligent management.
Machine tools have got a high percentage of fixed energy consumption because
the demand for high quality requires temperature stability. One may ask how this
“overhang” can be reduced. To date the discussions with different companies have
produced four starting points for this question – two with regard to the machine
setup (especially the production process) and two in reference to the running of the
machine (especially the optimized management of energy-consuming components).
The approaches are the following:
(a) Structure/system architecture (e.g., cinematic structure/design)
(b) Type of components (e.g., degree of energy efficiency)
(c) Management of individual components (intelligent management strategies for
starting and stopping)
(d) Monitoring (optimization by user)
3 Ecodesign in Swiss Machining Industry 47
Fig. 3.8 Estimated optimization potential (estimates based on results from 18 data collections in
2010 and 2011)
Some measurements and calculations show that 10% of energy consumption can
be saved that way. This aspect is attractive as there is a strong synergy effect with
economic interests, i.e., an increase in productivity.
It is currently not easy for manufacturers of machine tools to recognize the
optimization potential in the abovementioned four areas, especially during the early
phase of product development. Additional services, methods, and know-how are
needed to make visible specific possibilities for improvement at the right time.
Since early 2011, working groups with representatives from the Swiss industry
and university experts exist with the aim to jointly develop know-how for certain
problems, to devise planning guidelines, and to intensify outreach and education.
Currently, there are three working groups, which jointly develop creative solutions
for the following topics:
– Dealing specifically with waste heat: Production machines create waste heat,
which then has to be dissipated in a complex way. The idea is to develop different
approaches – depending on temperature level and machining power. For higher
waste heat temperatures and higher machining power, a heat recovery system
could well make sense, however, not for lower temperatures. That is why a
planning tool is currently being developed, which contains a decision tree and
which leads the planner in the industry as well as university students to the “right”
topic depending on the specific planning situation. For each one of these solution
areas, the necessary know-how, options for appropriate action, and an example
are formulated.
3 Ecodesign in Swiss Machining Industry 49
The idea for an independent competence network in the area “sustainable engineer-
ing” dates back to 2008. Since 2009, this network consisting of 50 researchers from
various institutes and universities as well 100 interested companies mainly from the
machining industry and environmental technology is up and running. The network
is financed by a funding institution of the Swiss Confederation. After a successful
start-up phase, the aim now is to improve and extend its services. The following
service areas are new:
– Scouting: Companies, which are interested in sustainable engineering and an
active know-how transfer with universities, are directly approached. An effective
push-pull process is at the center of this. Up to now, these activities are to be
found at www.eco-net.ch
– Project initiation: A “marketplace of ideas,” i.e., bringing together companies
and universities in the sense of a brokerage event, as well as support in initiating
new projects, is at the center of this. As the topic sustainable engineering is new
to many companies, the network puts various different experts at their disposal.
If this is successful, new R&D projects are created, which help the companies,
the universities, and also the network to enter new markets. Up till now these
activities are to be found at www.sustainableengineering.ch
50 R. Züst
– Expertise and support for investors: Outreach is another area that is to be newly
established and which especially concerns the specifically market implementa-
tion. Many people depend on technical expertise and further services in order to
lower the implementation risk. Only then is it possible to implement new and
also sustainable solutions.
MSc and BSc students are called upon for these tasks.
A third area of future “outreach and education” is concerned with feasible methods,
for example, simple and purposeful methods of analysis, modeling and simulation
tools, as well as methods and tools for effective “green marketing.” At the moment,
further methods and tools intended specifically for the Swiss machining industry
are developed by the network “Sustainable Engineering Network Switzerland”
indifferent projects, which are financed by the Swiss Confederation. The focus is
on modeling and simulation tools, which make a first critical evaluation of a new
machine concept possible in a very early planning phase.
Additionally, practical-oriented training is a work in progress. This course of
action enjoys the broad backing by the whole network.
References
Der Beitrag des Maschinen- und Anlagebaus zur Energieeffizienz; bearbeitet von Roland Berger
Strategy Consultants im Auftrag des VDMA, 2009
Energieeffizienz in der Industrie – eine makroskopische Analyse der Effizienzentwicklung unter
besonderer Berücksichtigung der Rolle des Maschinen- und Anlagebaus; bearbeitet von
Prognos AG im Auftrag des VDMA, 2009
3 Ecodesign in Swiss Machining Industry 51
Abstract
It has been widely observed that Education for Sustainable Development (ESD) –
or, as some prefer, Education for a Sustainable Future – presents a challenge
to existing systems of instruction and curricula. The empirical, reductionist,
discipline-based model which now forms the basis of university faculties has
served well in the past, leading to enormous expansion of human knowledge,
technology, and – with some exceptions – the global economy. However, this
model may not be adequate to address the issues and challenges of global
sustainability, and indeed many feel that this growth in human activity lies at the
root of the problems now faced by humanity. Accordingly, for ESD to succeed in
its purpose, ways must be found to bridge the gaps among multiple disciplines,
and to develop students’ capacity to synthesize the viewpoints these bring to
sustainability.
A variety of approaches are being taken to meet this challenge. These range
from wholesale restructuring of curricula and creation of new courses of study in
“sustainability science” or “energy systems” to incremental changes in existing
courses, along with supplementing formal curricula with research, networking,
and other opportunities for intensive experiential learning. This chapter describes
some of the innovative activities that have been undertaken at the Massachusetts
Institute of Technology (MIT). MIT’s approach is fundamentally discipline-
based and multidisciplinary, embodies the Institute’s motto of mens et manus
(learning by doing), and makes use of the campus itself as a laboratory for
learning. Among the examples described here is a graduate level subject on
sustainable energy (recently adapted to include undergraduates), a project-based
J.I. Steinfeld
Laboratory for Energy and the Environment, Department of Chemistry, Massachusetts Institute of
Technology, Cambridge, MA, USA
A. Graham
MIT Energy Initiative, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA, USA
subject for beginning students that addresses topics ranging from energy saving
projects on campus to global environmental issues, the infusion of energy and
environmental topics into basic course requirements in science, engineering, and
social science, and making use of the Undergraduate Research Opportunities
Program to engage students in current research activity on these topics.
1 Introduction
These concepts are essential for addressing the problems that face human society
and the natural environment.
The idea of interlinked knowledge is important here. Rather than the typical
portrayal of sustainability science as lying at the intersection of (usually) three
disciplines in a Venn diagram, the model of the Borromean Rings shown in Fig. 4.1
provides a better representation of the intellectual dynamic. All three realms of
science, technology, and social sciences (including economics) are connected and
all are needed to prepare students to work in these fields. Together they form a strong
educational base; remove any one of them and the structure falls apart.
Realizing that this goal presents major challenges, Yoshikawa (2010) has argued
that problems of sustainability cannot be adequately addressed by subsuming their
study within traditional disciplines. This has been called a “transdisciplinary”
approach, which may be described as
. . . a cohesive, holistic, and democratic approach to scientific research, an approach that
is necessary if we are to achieve the aims of sustainability science to create knowledge for
action that will contribute to the well-being of the planet. The model includes multiple actors
from the three classes of natural, engineering, and social science in a process that refines
information with each cycle to produce actionable knowledge for sustaining humankind and
the planet we inhabit (Yoshikawa 2010).
Creating entirely new disciplines, and the academic departments and educational
programs to go with them, is a costly and time-intensive process which entails
lengthy and far-reaching negotiation with existing academic stakeholders. Never-
theless, some institutions of higher education have responded to this challenge by
56 J.I. Steinfeld and A. Graham
1
The ensuing discussion uses the standard MIT terminology as follows: a course is a specified
program of study within a Department or Division; a subject is a specific one-semester or half-
semester class taught by one or more faculty and staff. Courses are designated by numbers from
1 through 24 and some additional acronyms such as “ESD” for Engineering Systems Design.
Subjects within courses are further designated by numbers “following the decimal point.” For
example, the Chemistry Department is known to every MIT student as “Course 5”; subject 5.60,
discussed later in this chapter, designates Thermodynamics and Kinetics as taught within the
Chemistry Department. MIT students typically enroll in four or five subjects per semester.
4 Implementing New Teaching Models at MIT 57
of science, technology, and social sciences as they relate to energy and associated
environmental challenges.
She/he will have specific expertise and the understanding of the broader context, tradeoffs,
and realms of action required to create, evaluate, and advocate meaningful solutions to these
challenges and effect change.
Indeed, this could be said to be a desirable outcome for any graduate of a degree
program.
The following section illustrates how some existing educational programs and
classroom subjects are being so redefined in the context of the MIT Energy
Initiative’s Education program, specifically the Energy Studies Minor established
in Fall 2009 (Energy 2009).
The Energy Studies Minor consists of a core curriculum based on three interlinked
subjects (as was suggested in Fig. 4.1) covering the realms of energy science
foundations, social science foundations, and energy technology and engineering in
context. In addition, students are required to take from 2 to 4 additional energy
electives from a list of 24 subjects. The curriculum is not based in any one School
or Department, but includes subjects across the Institute, representing all of the five
Schools. Some of the subjects have been developed specifically for the Minor, but
others have been taught for many years and have been reoriented to focus on energy
issues.
This section gives several examples of these subjects. Many of them are
undergoing continuous development as the needs of the students become more
clearly defined, but a good impression of their content can be obtained from listings
on MIT’s OpenCourseWare (OCW 2010). MIT OpenCourseWare (OCW), a web-
based publication of virtually all MIT course content, is open and available to the
world and is a permanent MIT activity. One thousand nine hundred different subjects
are currently listed in OCW. For each of the examples described, we give the OCW
url for the most recent listing of that subject.
http://ocw.mit.edu/OcwWeb/Chemistry/5-60Spring-2008/CourseHome/index.htm
Understanding the laws of thermodynamics is essential for calculating the
amount of useful energy that can be obtained from any process, from the burning
of oil and natural gas to the reactions in photosynthesis that convert light into
charge separation (and thus chemical energy). These laws provide information about
whether a process is spontaneous or not, and afford upper bounds on the efficiency of
that process. Thus, thermodynamics provides a unifying framework for considering
the energy balance and flow in all processes (Silbey 2009, private communication).
58 J.I. Steinfeld and A. Graham
The subject, 5.60, has been taught in the Chemistry Department for many
years, originally under the rubric of Chemical Thermodynamics. Thermodynamics
is a core competency for chemistry, since it allows prediction of equilibrium
coefficients and concentrations and correlates a wide range of material properties
(pressure, volume, boiling point, melting point, surface tension, electrochemical
potential, etc.). As taught at MIT, the subject also points out the connection
to the microscopic, molecular properties of matter through statistical mechanics
(Beattie and Oppenheim 1979). Thermodynamics is also essential for understanding
biological and biochemical processes, and recent years have seen an increasing
proportion of the curriculum devoted to biological applications, to the extent of
co-teaching the subject with faculty in the Department of Biological Engineering.
To meet the requirements of an Energy Minor core subject, 5.60 has been
refocused on teaching students how to think about the energy challenge. In doing
so, the subject has returned to its origin as a means for understanding the amount of
work that can be carried out in a cyclic thermal process (Carnot 1824). New notes,
lectures, and homework problems have been developed to realize this objective.
Some of the topics and exercises covered in the energy centered version of 5.60 are:
• Calculation of the energy content of a range of fossil and non-fossil fuels from
First Law thermochemical cycles, and linking the result to the market price of
the fuels and to net carbon emissions
• The energy requirements and efficiency of a heat pump system
• Comparison of Rankine, Sterling, and Otto engines in terms of Carnot cycles
• Electrochemical work in a galvanic cell and a fuel cell
Additional topics and modules are being developed on an ongoing basis and will be
placed on the OCW Web site in due course.
http://ocw.mit.edu/courses/chemistry/5-92-energy-environment-and-society-
spring-2007/
“Projects in Energy” is an introductory subject designed to equip students with
a fundamental understanding of the energy landscape and provide opportunities to
work with cross-cutting teams of faculty, staff and teaching assistants on developing
solutions to concrete energy challenges.2 The class was originally offered in 2007
as part of an experiment in Project Based Learning supported by internal MIT
educational innovation funds, and has been “recycled” to meet the requirements
of the Energy Studies Minor. Students are introduced to energy systems and their
2
The “J” designation indicates that the same subject is offered jointly through two or more
departments. In this case, 5.92J/10.191J was offered by the Chemistry Department (Course 5)
and the Chemical Engineering Department (Course 10) in Spring 2010. This is often advantageous
for students in a particular course, who are required to complete elective units within their own
School or Department. Additional examples of “J” subjects will be given in this section.
4 Implementing New Teaching Models at MIT 59
major components through guest lectures by researchers from across MIT and then
apply that knowledge in their projects. Lectures and presentations on basic energy
science and technology, project design and management, and communication and
presentation of findings include topics such as:
• Energy supply and demand, sources, conversion, and uses
• Estimation of individual carbon footprint and greenhouse gas emissions using a
Personal Energy Calculator developed for the Youth Encounter on Sustainability
(Ecospeed 2010; ACTIS 2010)
• Introduction to (or review of) basic thermodynamics principles, abstracted from
the 5.60 subject content (v. supra)
• Basic concepts of energy economics
• Relationship between energy production and climate change, using the “C-Learn”
interactive simulation tool (C-Learn 2010)
• Alternative and renewable energy options
• Practicums on public speaking and presentation, and on writing for the customer
and the public
Students are involved in all aspects of project design from the refinement of
problem statements to data collection and analysis, determination of conclusions,
and presentation of findings. Project teams work closely with experts, including
local stakeholders and leading technology companies. In Spring 2010, projects
carried out by students in the class included:
• Analyzing the “carbon footprint” of ongoing activity at MIT and designing
strategies for reducing greenhouse gas emissions at the institutional and personal
level, carried out with the assistance of the Campus Energy Activities (“Walk the
Talk”) task force.
• Evaluating wind energy resources at various locations on campus, preparatory to
installing wind turbines on campus which will generate significant amounts of
renewable energy, thereby displacing electricity from the gas-fired cogeneration
plant or that would need to be purchased from local utilities.
• Developing an energy strategy for a rural village in Limpopo Province, South
Africa, and writing the script for a documentary film about the project which will
be produced on location in Summer 2010.
• Designing renewable energy systems for a sustainable rural housing community
in the District of North Kohala, Hawaii. Both resources that can be integrated
into an island-wide grid and stand-alone off-grid energy systems will be con-
sidered. This project is a collaboration among faculty from the Department of
Architecture, the MIT, the MIT Public Service Center, and a local NGO in the
North Kohala District.
The subject concludes with a capstone exercise in which each team makes a public
presentation of its findings and recommendations.
In May 2010, MIT announced a partnership with its electric utility provider
to reduce on-campus electricity consumption by 15% over 3 years (Nstar 2010).
Significant faculty, staff, and student collaboration is envisioned as a major part of
this effort, and it is expected that the “Projects in Energy” subject will play a key
role in that regard.
60 J.I. Steinfeld and A. Graham
http://ocw.mit.edu/courses/physics/8-21-the-physics-of-energy-fall-2009/
This subject is designed for MIT sophomores, juniors, and seniors who want
to understand the fundamental laws and physical processes that govern the sources,
extraction, transmission, storage, degradation, and end uses of energy. The subject is
accessible to any MIT student who has completed the physics, math, and chemistry
components of the General Institute Requirements.3
8.21 is not aimed specifically at physics majors. It is designed for any MIT
student, including, for example, an engineer, scientist, social scientist, or man-
agement, architecture or planning major, who wants to get a firm foundation in
the physical principles that constrain the energy landscape. The subject enables
students to approach energy issues in a sophisticated and scientific fashion, but
without having to take advanced subjects in thermodynamics, quantum mechanics,
or nuclear physics beforehand. Key features of the subject include:
• 8.21 focuses on the fundamental physical principles underlying energy processes,
and on application of these principles to practical calculations. Many important
quantitative analytical tools are introduced and applied. 8.21 is not intended to
be a survey course.
• 8.21 focuses on the physics. Tough political, economic, social, and ethical issues
have to be resolved if the “energy crisis” is to be ameliorated. Although they
are not discussed directly in 8.21, the subject provides the scientific foundation
for intelligent evaluation of those important considerations, and is intended to
provide the necessary background to approach those issues with a broad and
functional perspective on the physics of energy.
• Rather than following the traditional physics format of theory followed by
application, 8.21 integrates fundamental physics with practical applications to
energy systems of contemporary relevance throughout the semester. Much of the
reading and background material for 8.21 has been created specifically for this
subject, since existing introductory books and resources on energy physics do not
seem to be advanced enough for MIT undergraduates.
The first part of the subject focuses on end uses of energy. Analysis of basic energy
needs such as transport, heating, and lighting provides a context for reviewing basic
principles of mechanics and electromagnetism from introductory physics classes.
Also included are some aspects of quantum mechanics and thermodynamics which
are central to understanding questions in energy physics such as limits to efficiency
of conversion from heat energy to mechanical energy in an automobile engine.
The second part focuses on sources of energy. Further development of quantum
mechanics provides the background for an in-depth introduction to the physics of
nuclear power. The progress of solar energy is followed from its release in nuclear
3
The General Institute Requirements, required of all students for a B.S. degree, include six science
subjects, a laboratory subject, two restricted electives, and eight subjects in Humanities, Arts, and
Social Sciences (http://web.mit.edu/catalog/overv.chap3-gir.html)
4 Implementing New Teaching Models at MIT 61
fusion reactions in the Sun, through radiation to the Earth and absorption in terres-
trial systems, integrating material from several branches of physics and including an
introduction to the physics of semiconductors and photovoltaic technology. Basic
fluid dynamics is developed and used to describe the physics of wind and other
renewable resources including hydro, tidal, wave, and ocean power. Also considered
are the physics of hazards associated with some energy technologies, in particular
global warming and nuclear radiation.
The third part of the subject integrates a deeper study of thermodynamics with a
study of energy conversion, storage, and transmission methods. A complete list of
lectures can be found at http://physicsofenergy.mit.edu/students/schedule.php.
The “J” designation in this case indicates that the subject is offered and taught jointly
by the Departments of Chemical Engineering and Philosophy – perhaps the only
such classroom subject that exists. Using a wide range of assigned readings and
short papers, the class examines concepts such as the development of the concept
of energy; in what sense does energy “exist”; how thermodynamics affects one’s
view of reality; and whether mathematics elucidates or obscures these questions.
The readings range widely from Aristotle, Descartes, Newton, Francis Bacon,
and Friedrich Nietzsche to Lavoisier, Sadi Carnot, J.P. Joule, Ludwig Boltzmann,
J. Willard Gibbs, and Ilya Prigogine.
Students taking this class receive credit toward their Institute-wide Humanities
and Social Science requirement and their communications skills requirement, as
well as being challenged to think hard about fundamental issues relating to energy.
One further perspective that would be of some interest is how these concepts link to
energy as a six trillion dollar per year global industry (give or take a trillion or so),
but the technology and social/economic subject requirements of the energy minor
help students to make these additional connections.
3.5 10.391J/1.818J/2.65J/3.564J/11.371J/22.811J/ESD.166J2
Sustainable Energy
http://ocw.mit.edu/courses/chemical-engineering/10-391j-sustainable-energy-
spring-2005/
During the late 1990s, discussions at MIT’s Energy Laboratory (subsequently,
the Laboratory for Energy and Environment) made it clear that there was a strong
need for an interdisciplinary graduate-level subject that “quantitatively presented
energy in a broad framework and addressed today’s sustainability challenges”
(Tester et al. 2005). The Sustainable Energy subject has been taught at MIT
since then. As the designation above indicates, the subject is offered jointly by
five Departments in the School of Engineering (Chemical, Mechanical, Materials
Science and Engineering, Nuclear, and Civil and Environmental), the Department
62 J.I. Steinfeld and A. Graham
of Urban Studies and Planning, and the Engineering Systems Division. Enrollments
have typically been robust and have drawn graduate students (and a few undergrad-
uates) from departmental majors across all of MIT’s five Schools. For Fall 2009
and beyond, an undergraduate section of this subject was developed with support
from the Energy Education Task Force. Course materials have been published in
a textbook, Sustainable Energy: Choosing Among Options (Tester et al. 2005) and
updated on the OpenCourseWare system.
The curriculum includes:
• Overviews of energy demand, sustainability, resource availability, global change
(including climate change), and regional air pollution issues
• Specific energy technologies, including geothermal, hydropower, nuclear, biomass,
fossil fuels, wind power, solar power, and energy storage
• Energy use in buildings, road transport, and industry, with trade-off and policy
analyses
• A “toolbox” including assessment methodologies for resource availability, en-
ergy supply and demand scenarios, and economic feasibility; life cycle analysis;
and thermodynamic constraints
In addition to problem sets and exams, grades are based on students’ term papers
and presentations for projects chosen from a wide list of options. Among many
suggested topics are the following:
• How can policy instruments increase the deployment of renewable energy?
• Is a “zero net energy” building a realistic sustainable goal?
• Are hybrid and/or all electric vehicles a viable option for personal transportation?
• Can CO2 be successfully sequestered in the deep ocean, in depleted oil and gas
wells, or in aquifers?
• How much oil is there in the world?
• Is hydropower from Quebec a sustainable energy option for the Northeast USA?
• Can India meet its energy needs to support a developing industrial economy?
Clearly, these project topics all incorporate the scientific, technological, social, and
economic dimensions needed to address sustainable energy issues.
One of the earliest programs of its kind in the United States, MIT’s Undergraduate
Research Opportunities Program (UROP) cultivates and supports research partner-
ships between MIT undergraduates and faculty. As “UROPers,” undergraduates
participate in each phase of standard research activity: developing research plans,
writing proposals, conducting research, analyzing data and presenting research
results in oral and written form. UROP projects take place during the academic year,
as well as over the summer, and research can be done in any academic department
or interdisciplinary laboratory. Projects can last for an entire semester, and many
continue for a year or more. UROP students receive academic credit, pay, or work
on a voluntary basis. MIT students use their UROP experiences to become familiar
with the faculty, learn about potential majors, and investigate areas of interest. They
4 Implementing New Teaching Models at MIT 63
gain practical skills and knowledge they eventually apply to careers after graduation
or as graduate students. Eighty to ninety per cent of all MIT undergraduates take at
least one UROP during their program of study.
The MIT Energy Initiative sponsors and coordinates a range of UROP projects
specifically focused on energy efficiency and sustainability. The Campus
Sustainability UROPs (CS-UROPs), sponsored by MIT’s Environmental Programs
Office, help operational units such as the Department of Facilities and MIT’s
Environmental, Health, and Safety office address pressing sustainability challenges.
The Summer Energy UROPs, supported by MITEI member companies and donors,
can be conducted in any academic department or interdisciplinary laboratory. In
summer 2009, 16 undergraduate researchers worked on projects that included
developing organic materials for solar cells, modeling the performance of MIT’s
battery electric vehicle, and estimating cost curves for new natural gas sources.
Further information is available at http://web.mit.edu/mitei/education/urop.html.
Examples of UROP projects that have had substantial impact at MIT and in the
wider community include:
• Reducing energy consumption by fume hoods
Fume hoods, widely used by high-tech industries, hospitals, and universities,
help keep laboratory workers from breathing harmful chemical vapors but
consume a lot of energy by continuously drawing heated and cooled indoor air
through the face of the hood. A single fume hood running 24 h uses as much
energy as a typical single-family home in the Northeast USA.
Mechanical Engineering senior Steven Amanti surveyed fume hood use in
MIT’s Chemistry Department and found that many hoods were left in the fully
opened position even when laboratory personnel were not present. His analysis
showed that “If the unused hoods were closed, the consumption of electricity,
steam, and chilled water would be decreased by approximately 17% and save
the Institute $350,000 a year in utility costs.” (Amanti 2006) When this was
brought to the attention of MIT administrators and Department heads, a campus-
wide campaign was initiated to change the behavior of hood users in order to
conserve energy. A follow on UROP project concerns the use of SF6 as a tracer
gas for air flow in hoods. While non-toxic and unreactive, SF6 has a Global
Warming Potential in excess of 20,000 relative to CO2 and is simply vented to
the atmosphere when used in this way. The UROP project seeks to find a suitable
replacement tracer gas that will not contribute to global warming.
• Campus energy footprint
Numerous UROP projects and student theses have sought to quantify MIT’s
energy use and greenhouse gas emissions. Most have focused on building
operations and, to a lesser extent, on purchasing decisions. A recent UROP
study estimated carbon dioxide (CO2 / emissions generated from air travel by
MIT students, staff, and faculty. Working with data provided by the MIT Travel
Office for travel supported by the Institute’s research and education programs,
the analysis revealed that emissions from air travel are a significant source of a
university’s greenhouse gas emissions. It was estimated that the CO2 emissions
due to air travel by MIT personnel are approximately 58,111 metric tons, or
64 J.I. Steinfeld and A. Graham
17% of MIT’s total CO2 emissions in 2003. This analysis offers an important
supplement to MIT’s current greenhouse gas emissions inventory, which is based
on Mechanical Engineering graduate thesis work by Tiffany Groode (2004) and
did not include air travel. As the data on air travel improves and methods for
analysis develop, MIT will better be able to quantify its overall carbon footprint,
and develop strategies for mitigating and/or offsetting these emissions.
• On-campus wind turbine assessment
MIT is considering installing a utility-grade wind turbine at one of its research
sites, and needs assistance in carrying out a feasibility assessment of the financial
and wind resource requirements. This UROP, which will review and assess the
necessary data to make recommendations for project development, is closely
linked with the 5.92J Projects in Energy subject described earlier.
These are just a few examples of the on-campus projects carried out by MIT
students collaborating with staff and faculty. By using the campus as a learning
laboratory, students are able to gain practical experience and to synthesize the many
varied skills and disciplines required to carry out a real-world energy project.
4 Summary
There are many and varied incentives for changing what is taught to students, and
the way they are taught, to emphasize sustainability as a core goal and value of
education. On one level, this is an eminently practical imperative for the future
career advantage of the students, as well as for the well-being of the economy
as a whole. It has been noted that “an expanding employment spectrum deals
with the survival of people, plants, and planet” (Science Careers 2009), and that
“transforming our economy through renewable energy, energy efficiency, mass
transit and rail, a new smart grid and other solutions to global warming, has the
potential to create millions of jobs, while reducing global warming emissions and
moving America toward energy independence” (Blue Green Alliance 2010).
The educational innovations described in this chapter, and many others being
developed at MIT and other universities, meet this challenge in several ways. First,
they are transdisciplinary (Yoshikawa 2008, 2010), linking elements of science,
technology, and the social sciences in the context of sustainability. The content is
rigorously developed, making use of quantitative, analytical methods such as life
cycle analysis and quantitative risk assessment when appropriate. And many of the
classroom subjects are results and application oriented, especially when linked to
educational strategies such as project-based learning and undergraduate research
projects.
There is an additional dimension to this transformation of the educational agenda,
namely, the moral and ethical imperative underlying sustainability. As Harte (1993)
has noted, science cannot remain value neutral when it comes to the applications
of science to technological systems which are capable of profoundly altering and
damaging global systems. This is especially true today, since modern technology
has provided the means to extend such damage worldwide, to other persons we have
4 Implementing New Teaching Models at MIT 65
never met directly, and to jeopardize the well-being of future generations (Harte
1993). The moral obligation to repair this damage has ancient roots. The mediæval
Kabbalah (Scholem 1974) speaks of “the breaking of the vessels,” which can be
understood in a modern context as the breakdown of connections between human
individuals, human society, and the larger natural systems of which we are all a part.
If human society is to survive and prosper, this breakage has to be succeeded by a
repair process called tikkun olam – literally, the repair of the world. This concept
of tikkun or repair has become a foundational principle of many environmental
movements, whether grounded in secular or spiritual principles, and should be a
foundational component of the educational system as well.
Today’s industrial society is, in fact, a complex, multivariate, global-scale
experiment testing the hypothesis whether human society is capable of achieving
a sustainable relationship with the natural environment. The outcome of this
experiment is still unknown, but the difficulty of carrying it out in a dispassionate,
objective manner is that the experiment can only be performed once, on a single
system – the Earth System – and if the experiment turns out badly the sample
cannot be returned to the Manufacturer for a free replacement! The outcome of
the experiment, therefore, needs to be “biased” to ensure, as best as can be devised,
the long-term well-being of humanity’s home on Earth, which makes its continuing
existence possible. The most effective “bias” that can be introduced is to educate
the next generation of leaders who are now and will be entering schools, university
classrooms, and laboratories in such a way that they will have the understanding,
the tools, and the moral outlook to make sustainability a reality.
5 Cross-References
Acknowledgments
The authors wish to thank Jennifer DiMase for preparing Fig. 4.1.
References
ACTIS, The Youth Encounter on Sustainability (2010), http://www.actis-education.ch/index.php?
option=com content&view=frontpage&Itemid=53. Accessed 18 Nov 2011
B. Allenby et al., Sustainability Sci. 4, 7 (2009)
S. Amanti, Potential Energy Savings on the MIT Campus, SB Thesis, 2006
J.A. Beattie, I. Oppenheim, Principles of Thermodynamics (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1979)
Blue Green Alliance (2010), http://www.bluegreenalliance.org/home. Accessed 18 Nov 2011
N.L.S. Carnot, Réflexions sur la puissance motrice du feu et sur les machines propres à développer
cette puissance (A. Blanchard, Paris, 1824)
C-Learn (2010), http://climateinteractive.org/simulations/c-learn. Accessed 18 Nov 2011)
66 J.I. Steinfeld and A. Graham
Abstract
Engineering as a profession unquestionably contributes to the welfare of hu-
manity, yet it is becoming more and more evident that the standard engineering
curriculum, a product of the post-World War II era, is no longer optimal for the
globally competitive, entrepreneurial firms of the knowledge economy. Further,
as engineered systems become more widespread and increasingly coupled with
cultural and natural systems, the impacts of new technologies become more
unpredictable. Engineering in such a complex and rapidly changing environ-
ment requires engineers that are increasingly sophisticated with respect to the
challenges of sustainability and complex adaptive systems. Thus, an educational
system appropriate for the Anthropocene (the “Age of the Human”) is one that
builds adaptive capacity into the curriculum itself as well as its graduates. This
chapter suggests that a framework – a sustainable engineering method – might
facilitate the evolution of engineering education and constitute a structure for
imparting competencies to students that will prove valuable and relevant in the
twenty-first century. Though it cannot address all issues surrounding engineering
education and is therefore not a comprehensive solution, it is meant to serve as
a reference for educators as they conscientiously design each curriculum to meet
the needs of students, their future employers, and the world at large.
It is not the strongest of the species that survives, nor the most
intelligent that survives. It is the one that is the most adaptable
to change.
Charles Darwin
Engineering is a powerful societal force. As engineers conceive and create the built
environment, they inevitably influence social and environmental change. However, a
number of groups and individuals have recently expressed concern that engineers do
not sufficiently understand the context and implications of their work and that both
engineering practice and engineering education have failed to adapt to the needs of
a world that is growing in both population and complexity (National Academy of
Engineering 2005).
In this chapter, it is not assumed that engineering and its curriculum are failing or
need to be “fixed” in any way. On the contrary, modern life in developed economies
provides daily reminders that engineers are competent and responsible: Aircraft take
off and land safely; potable drinking water is readily available; communication
networks are fast and reliable. Engineering is among the somewhat unfortunate
professions that go unnoticed if done well. Attention is paid to it primarily when
mistakes are made – or when the public becomes disillusioned with the products (or
unintended consequences) of engineered systems.
That said, while engineering and its professional preparation may be adequate for
the moment (though some dispute this), there is always room for improvement. The
goals and paths to improvement are often elusive, however, and that is the topic of
this chapter. Hence it will provide an overview of some of the criticisms of existing
curricula followed by a discussion of calls for more sustainable engineering practice.
Throughout the text, a single framework – a sustainable engineering method – will
be offered as an example of one possible path toward a curriculum that meets the
needs of a complex and changing world. The goal of this engineering method is to
instill several competencies in students, which will be discussed below. Ultimately,
the framework remains one of many possible solutions and is itself merely a
preliminary concept. Moreover, the focus on incremental improvement presented
in this chapter does not obviate the possibility that radical rethinking of engineering
education may be necessary and desirable (Allenby 2011).
to conduct research and teach, the number of practicing engineers on the faculty
dwindled. Simultaneously, classes that stressed engineering science, theory, and
mathematics replaced the design-oriented courses of the 1940s and before (Lattuca
et al. 2006). The legacy of this transition is ambiguity as to whether universities
are “creating practicing engineers, or pre-professional engineering talent” (Yunhe
2010, p. 118). That is, depending on the school, engineering professors may be
primarily focused on research and not able to provide the examples and coaching
that a professional engineer would.
This may be the reason that most engineers today undergo two phases of
education: undergraduate study followed by apprenticeship. The undergraduate
experience is well known for teaching “the basics” underlying the practice of
engineering. Then, upon graduation, students generally enter into an apprenticeship
or mentoring relationship where they learn about the practice of engineering: design
processes, industry best practices, how to communicate with clients, etc. In some
cases, this apprenticeship may be formal and defined as in graduate school and
some companies. In other cases, young engineers may simply take a job where they
learn company expectations, methods, and technologies from a manager, through
corporate training, or on an ad hoc basis. Whatever form it takes, the value of this
largely unspoken and implicit tradition is underscored by the Professional Engineer
licensing process, which requires 4 years of engineering practice, typically under the
supervision of a licensed engineer (National Council of Examiners for Engineering
and Surveying n.d.).
This model might have worked in the mid-twentieth century when engineers
stayed at one company for their entire careers, industrial employers could afford
such an investment, and when what was expected to be learned on the job was
elaboration of skills and knowledge already learned by the student. Today, however,
a combination of accelerated turnover, increasing international competition, and
rapidly changing technology has rendered that paradigm obsolete. Today’s more
nimble and entrepreneurial firms need graduates who already have professional
skills and can hit the ground running (Kennedy 2006). Further, employers want
well-rounded engineers; they repeatedly emphasize the need to instill good com-
munication abilities, as well as more traditional business skills such as teamwork,
project management, leadership, decision making, and assertiveness (Finley 2005;
Fischbach 2008). They additionally indicate that engineers of the future will need
to foster innovation and be able to manage teams in a global context (Finley 2005;
Kennedy 2006). Many of these necessary skills and capabilities are currently not
taught well either by firms or by engineering schools. Moreover, to the extent that
the skills that are missing are not elaborative, but fundamental – the ability to write
well, for example – on the job training is simply inadequate. Good communication
skills are a product of years of education, not simply a module of a corporate training
program.
So even though apprenticeships are unquestionably valuable, and some on-the-
job training will be unavoidable due to technologies, processes, and expectations
unique to each firm, this economic environment has presented an opportunity, even
70 C.S. Mattick and B.R. Allenby
necessity, for engineering education to adapt. Thus, in the last decade, a number
of groups have called for reformation if not transformation of the engineering
curriculum, based in part on the changing needs of the workplace (Grasso and
Burkins 2010; Sheppard et al. 2009). Among their recommendations are the
introduction of problem- or project-based learning, the hiring of professors of
practice as instructors, limited-term appointments (i.e., the elimination of tenure)
for engineering faculty, and the development of closer relationships between
engineering schools and industry. Others are calling for a more sweeping redesign
of engineering education. The National Academy of Engineering has suggested
that the engineering undergraduate degree should become a liberal arts degree (a
“preengineering” or “engineer in training” degree), with the master’s degree con-
stituting the professional degree, similar to medicine or law (National Academy of
Engineering 2005). Indeed, it is likely that programs will experiment with multiple
strategies as they revamp their engineering programs. It is against this background
that one possible seed of a methodology for the professional engineering degree is
presented.
At the end of the nineteenth century, law schools transitioned from away from a
lecture-textbook method of teaching and took up the case method, requiring students
to take a more active engagement in classes (Stein 1981). Some view this as an
evolution away from teaching laws per sé and instead “teach[ing] students how
to think like lawyers” (Grasso and Martinelli 2010, pp. 14–15). Whether or not
physical laws are analogous to social laws is a matter for debate. Nonetheless,
if students are going to enter the workplace “ready to engineer” (Crawley et al.
2007, p. 6), then the challenge for engineering programs in the twenty-first century
is to impart the fundamental technical knowledge and skills of their discipline while
simultaneously instilling the processes of the discipline. That is, teach students how
to think like engineers – and, given the time and resource constraints on engineering
education as an undergraduate program, winnow the traditional curriculum to make
sure this can happen.
Although the ABET Engineering Criteria 2000 standards have resulted in
some positive changes (Lattuca et al. 2006), inertia and opposition to curricular
innovation mean that most coursework is still limited primarily to solving well-
defined problems through the application of specific techniques covered in a lecture
and assigned reading (Duderstadt 2010). This has the ultimate effect of creating
knowledge silos that are unconnected to each other and are difficult to transfer to
the real world. Courses requiring design and synthesis are currently in the minority
and may constitute a solution that is both too little and too late.
University of Illinois professor David E. Goldberg (2010) has observed students
struggling with seven skills when presented with a real-world senior design project
from sponsoring industrial firms. These include the ability to ask questions in order
5 Teaching Old Disciplines New Tricks: Sustainable Engineering Education 71
to fully understand the problem and its boundaries, the ability to label the design
challenges and associated technology (this may come from a fundamental ignorance
of technology despite a demonstrated competence in science and mathematics), the
ability to model problems quantitatively (above and beyond routine engineering
calculations), the ability to decompose design challenges into smaller subproblems
that are more easily solved, the ability to gather relevant data via simple experiments
or library visits, the ability to generate ideas and visualize solutions, and the
ability to communicate solutions – both verbally and in writing. He suggests that
“the basics” of engineering should be reconsidered and perhaps retooled to make
thinking skills “more central to the engineering canon” (Goldberg 2010, p. 149).
James Duderstadt, University of Michigan President Emeritus agrees, stating,
“Clearly those intellectual activities associated with engineering design – problem
formulation, synthesis, creativity, and innovation – should be infused throughout
the curriculum,” and adds, “This will require a sharp departure from conventional
classroom pedagogy and solitary learning methods” (Duderstadt 2010, p. 28). Thus,
just as there is an intellectual divide between engineering students and practicing
professionals, there is a gulf between existing engineering curricula and those that
would promote integration of knowledge and holistic engineering skills (Grasso and
Martinelli 2010). The introduction of an engineering method as a central theme
in engineering education might be a first step in bridging both distances. In fact,
many firms utilize a basic engineering design process. Teaching engineering within
a similar framework could ease the transition from student to professional. Within
universities, an engineering method could become the scaffold into which existing
courses fit. That is, a course on basic kinematics could be expressed as providing
modeling and analysis tools whereas a design course would incorporate all steps
of the method. As the curriculum evolved, a larger subset of the method could be
introduced into more courses.
One final benefit afforded by an engineering method is that it provides a
process through which other important skills may be incorporated. Among these
are teamwork, communication, creativity, problem definition, lifelong learning, and
an active understanding of stakeholder values. The latter three warrant additional
discussion.
have been defined as, “the built infrastructure is insufficient to support vehicle traffic
flow.” However, working together, Stockholm and IBM redefined the problem as,
“how can more people be moved into and out of the city while simultaneously
reducing traffic jams?” As a result of this change in perspective, a “tax and drive”
system was implemented that had the effect of reducing congestion and pollution,
and increasing public transportation ridership (Grasso and Martinelli 2010).
Problem formulation has been called the phase “where technological skill meets
the uniquely societal demands of restricted budgets, regulatory frameworks, public-
private collaboration complexity, public safety impact, historical context, and public
understanding” (Grasso et al. 2010, p. 161). Therefore, regardless of the specific
engineering method used, great emphasis should be placed on problem definition in
engineering schools.
to the public welfare (Florman 1994), and engineers tend to be very ethical people
(Allenby 2012), a failure to recognize that not all groups have values that match
his or her own – nor even each other’s – could result in anger, resentment, project
delays, or worse. The engineer should therefore seek out and respect the input of
stakeholders, while realizing that even the stakeholders may not agree. Balancing
conflicting values and requirements is a difficult task, but a project that conflicts
with stakeholder values will not be successful (Allenby 2012).
At a social level, in order to serve cultural groups well, engineers should
seek to understand them. In short, the application of science has the potential to
greatly improve the welfare of people, “but such technological interventions will
not succeed if they are applied in the absence of cultural or social understanding”
(Koshland 2010, p. 58). A solution that does not meet the needs of a culture will not
be used and will therefore be a waste of resources.
2 Sustainable Engineering
Social Impacts
Operating Environment
(e.g., dispersed communities)
Infrastructure Technologies
• Built Infrastructure (e.g., roadways)
• Supply Infrastructure (e.g., electrical grid)
Automobile System
• Manufacture • Use • Recycle
Automobile
Subsystems
(e.g., motor, batteries) Economic
Impacts
Local scale Global scale
Environmental
Impacts
Fig. 5.1 Example of multiple system boundaries for an electric automobile design. The layers are
interconnected; changes made at one level affect all others (Based on: Graedel and Allenby 1998)
Just as the layers in Fig. 5.1 are interdependent, they are also coupled with external
social, technological, and natural systems. The complex interactions between these
systems can result in emergent behaviors that are difficult to predict but can lead to
serious consequences (Allenby et al. 2009). For example, the expanded production
and use of corn-based ethanol for transportation in the United States in 2007
and 2008 resulted in higher food prices, followed by political instability abroad
(Allenby et al. 2009). Thus new technologies, being so integrated into the fabric
of society, have both positive and negative impacts, as well, often, as unintended
consequences. While engineers cannot be expected to be omniscient, they remain
in the best position to consider system-wide impacts and implications. Very often,
when deployed on a large scale – perhaps to a global population of seven billion
people – solutions to today’s problems create new problems tomorrow. Therefore,
as part of the normal design process, scenario projection may be employed as one
possible means to anticipate unintended consequences so they can be addressed as
part of the design (Wise 2010).
Calls for engineering reform suggest the need to introduce an engineering method
into undergraduate education but this also provides an ideal framework in which to
incorporate sustainability principles. The outline of one such method is presented
below and is based on a system engineering methodology provided by Wise (2010,
p. 233). However, the development of a method appropriate for a specific curriculum
is at the discretion of each individual school and represents a good opportunity to
collaborate with industry, government, and professional engineering organizations
(Donofrio et al. 2010).
Step 1. Analyze customer requirements. This step should entail asking questions
of the client in order to understand their expectations. Moreover, stakeholder
input should be actively sought and their values should be understood. In some
cases, there will be opposing viewpoints, consider why do these exist and how
can conflict be managed. Time should be spent researching the history of the
culture, the geographical, and or the issue to be addressed.
Step 2. Define the problem. Do the customer requirements address the actual
problem? Are there alternative solutions?
Step 3. Plan the technical effort. Define the boundaries of the system of interest.
Identify other systems integrated or coupled with the system of interest and
define other boundaries defining larger spheres of influence. Given these coupled
systems, identify potential risks associated with the project.
Step 4. Define potential solutions and conduct trade studies. Identify design
challenges and conduct research regarding solutions. Brainstorm to generate
high-level design ideas. Consider the alternatives in a systemic context and
evaluate social implications as well as lifecycle economic and environmental
76 C.S. Mattick and B.R. Allenby
4 Summary
References
D. Allen, B.R. Allenby, M. Bridges, J. Crittenden, C. Davidson, C. Hendrickson, et al.,
Benchmarking sustainable engineering education: final report (US Environmental Pro-
tection Agency, Washington, 2008), http://syracusecoe.org/csengine/images/allmedia/BSEE
Final Report 31Dec08 No Appen D.pdf. Retrieved 8 July 2011
B.R. Allenby, Rethinking engineering education, in Proceedings of the International Symposium
on Sustainable Systems and Technology (IEEE, Chicago, 2011)
B.R. Allenby, Theory and Practice of Sustainable Engineering (Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River,
2012)
B.R. Allenby, C.F. Murphy, D. Allen, C. Davidson, Sustainable engineering education in the United
States. Sustain. Sci. 4(1), 7–15 (2009). doi:10.1007/s11625-009-0065-5
C.T. Christ, What is happening in liberal education? in Holistic Engineering Education, ed. by D.
Grasso, M.B. Burkins (Springer, New York, 2010), pp. 69–79
E.F. Crawley, J. Malmqvist, S. Östlund, D.R. Brodeur, Rethinking Engineering Education: The
CDIO Approach (Springer, New York, 2007)
5 Teaching Old Disciplines New Tricks: Sustainable Engineering Education 77
Michelle Grant
Abstract
Tangible approaches to multi- and transdisciplinary teaching and learning are
gaining significance as the world becomes aware of the importance of education
in equipping society with the skills to address global challenges. The Youth
Encounter on Sustainability (YES) has been successfully running for 10 years
and provides a proven approach to solution-oriented, multi- and transdisciplinary
sustainability education for university level-students. To date, 1,200 young
leaders from over 110 different countries have been trained in the program and
form the active YES Alumni network.
This chapter presents the unique framework, approaches pedagogical method-
ologies and learning objectives that lie behind the YES program, and shows how
they have been implemented in various contexts. Furthermore, it explores how
the knowledge and skills acquired by the participants of the program equip and
inspire them to take the lead in addressing global challenges.
1 Background
In the year 2000, the Alliance for Global Sustainability (AGS) started an initiative,
under the title “Youth Encounter on Sustainability (YES),” to carry out 2-week
academic short courses to build the capacity of university students to address the
challenges of sustainable development. The aim was to bring together students from
all over the world to discuss, debate, and share diverse cultural and disciplinary
experiences. A key learning objective was for the students to plan their own visions
of a sustainable world and to explore their roles as emerging leaders.
A pilot version of the course was launched in Braunwald, a small alpine village in
Switzerland, during the summer of 2000. The course brought together 28 upper level
M. Grant
ACTIS (Activating Talent in Sustainability), Zurich, Switzerland
Until 2009, the YES courses were operated by the AGS through ETHsustainabil-
ity, the Center for Sustainability at the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology (ETH)
Zurich. In 2009, a specially created organization called ACTIS – Activating Talent
in Sustainability – was given leadership for running the course, though collaboration
with the AGS partner schools to deliver the program continues.
We live in a time when over half of the world’s population is under 25 years of age
(UNFPA 2009). Of this youthful population, those fortunate enough to receive a
university-level education will be the leaders of tomorrow who will be tasked with
finding solutions to the polycrises currently facing the world. Unfortunately, the
majority of university education programs are still grounded in monodisciplinary
teaching that rarely bridges the gap between theory and practice. In short, most
universities are not preparing today’s youth to be tomorrow’s leaders.
As a product of the current system, many students believe that higher learning is
a relatively passive process where they are simply consumers and not also producers
(Ovens et al. 2011). In order to foster real leadership capacity, students must
be challenged to work collaboratively while also being independently motivated
learners (ibid.). Furthermore, in the current, system individuals are trained to focus
primarily on personal gain and career prospects, with little emphasis on the goal of
ensuring a humane future for all within the ecological limits of the planet. Instead,
learning is focused within specific disciplines and individuals are encouraged to
become increasingly specialized in a particular field. Through this process, students
lose the connection to larger issues and lack the skills to make linkages between
systems and design appropriate solutions that take into account social, cultural,
economic, policy, technological, and environmental questions.
The YES courses were developed to address the deficiencies in higher education
systems around the world to nurture leaders who have the skills and knowledge to
address global challenges and develop appropriate solutions. As it is an ongoing
process to mainstream Education for Sustainable Development (ESD) into institu-
tions of higher learning, the YES program aims to provide an alternative during this
transitory process, focusing on students in the tertiary stages of their education.
The importance of university-level students as stakeholders in the sustainable
development debate is well established. As tomorrow’s leaders and decision makers,
they will be the ones who must live and deal with the impacts of choices made
by previous generations and who have to chart the course for a more sustain-
able way of living. At this level of education, the students are well placed to make
82 M. Grant
MISSION:
Equip Young Leaders to Address Global Challenges
connections and begin to understand the world from a systems thinking perspective.
Furthermore, this is a very important time in an individual’s life where they make
important decisions about their future careers and directions. For this reason, the
YES courses have always focused on university-level students or recent graduates
as the target market.
The YES course implements the principles of Education for Sustainable Devel-
opment (ESD) through a unique model. ESD differs from conventional environ-
mental education in that it further addresses complex social issues, such as the
links between environmental quality, human equality, human rights, peace, and
the underpinning politics (Fien et al. 2004). Furthermore, development toward a
more sustainable society entails conceptually planning for new forms of future
living where every citizen has the necessary knowledge, understanding, skills, and
values for a productive and rewarding life in an educated, just, and open society
(Baud 2004). Thus, ESD must develop competencies for people to deal with highly
complex, ill-defined problems with a high degree of uncertainty. In order to address
this, the ESD model utilized in the YES program addresses three fundamental tiers,
as illustrated in Fig. 6.1.
The first tier of the model (Knowledge) addresses the need to establish a
cross-disciplinary knowledge base of our society and the environment, which
many students do not receive during their university education. This includes
an understanding of the natural sciences, technology, politics, economics, social
sciences, and the humanities, organized around sustainability concepts and issues.
An emphasis is placed on making connections to real-life situations and on the
6 Youth Encounter on Sustainability 83
complexity and interactions within and between natural and social systems rather
than the teaching of monodisciplinary knowledge.
The quest for sustainability demands alternative approaches where people are
engaged in new ways of seeing, thinking, learning, and working (Tilbury 2003). The
second tier of the model (Core Skills) highlights the need for ESD to nurture certain
core skills, such as the ability to think critically and systemically, to communicate
effectively across disciplinary and cultural boundaries, to cooperate and work in
partnership with others, and to move from awareness and knowledge to action.
Arguably the most challenging, yet most important, aspect of ESD is the need to
foster a moral and ethical set of values to reorient individuals and societies toward
more sustainable lifestyles. This aspect is addressed in the third tier of the model
– values. Although closely tied to culturally specific traditions, beliefs, and social
normative systems, we can identify a number of important values that are relevant
to sustainability throughout the global community. These include a respect for
human rights, the natural environment, democracy, peace and nonviolence, equity
(both intra- and intergenerational), biological and cultural diversity, and social and
economic justice. Innovative didactical and pedagogical methodologies are required
to address this aspect of ESD that consider the basic psychological assumption that
behavioral change can only be induced when the learning process involves both
cognitive and emotional elements.
The entire YES course has been developed around a series of guiding principles,
which are considered key to achieving the goals of the program. These include:
• Creating a long-term impact on personal and professional lives of participants
• Targeting young leaders with demonstrated capacity to be change makers
• Creating a platform that is multicultural, multidisciplinary, and collaborative
• Having a solution-oriented approach
• Creating a solid alumni network for continued support
• Offering opportunities for continued learning and support
• Delivering immersive and intensive programs
• Maintaining content at a high academic level
• Integrating social, cultural, and creative elements
In order to implement the theoretical ESD model of the YES course within the
guidelines of these principles, three aspects have been given particular attention:
firstly the content framework, secondly the pedagogical approach, and thirdly the
course setting and logistical components.
5 Content Framework
In terms of the content framework, the YES course is set up under the um-
brella theme of “Living for 10 Billion people by 2050” and is structured in
four modules. These modules complement each other and are based on the
84 M. Grant
Physical Needs
• Energy and Materials
• Nutrition and Health
• Living Space
Institutional
Economy Sector
Drivers
Social-
Civil Society
framework shown in Fig. 6.2. The methodological approach of the YES course
is based on a gradual progression of thinking, proposing, and working out prac-
tical solutions to guide humanity toward a sustainable future. To realize this
goal, throughout each module students develop a basic understanding of the
key concepts, examine the potential goals relating to SD at local, regional, and
global levels; and think about possible solutions to reach these goals. Social
drivers play a pivotal role in the realization of solutions, and for this reason, the
course takes an integrative approach to look at the role of three core “social-
institutional drivers” – the economic and private sector; civil society; and local,
national, and international governance as crosscutting themes for each module (see
Fig. 6.2).
6 Pedagogical Approach
experts, cultural events, field trips, artistic and creative activities with a professional
artist, and small-group case study and project work. These differing methodologies
seek to engage the students through a holistic approach involving both cognitive and
emotional learning processes that encourage creativity and new styles of problem
solving. An important focus of the program is to facilitate processes whereby the
students themselves contribute to and drive the learning process. In this manner, they
are encouraged to become self-motivated learners while learning from the diverse
experience and backgrounds of the other members of the participant group.
Within different modules of the course, students are required to work in
small multicultural and multidisciplinary groups to address challenging, real-world
problems, for which there is no single or simple solution. In working together
to investigate the problem and formulate a solution, the students must cross
disciplinary boundaries and play roles that differ from their traditional ones. In this
manner, instructors facilitate, rather than teach, and students are encouraged and
given tools to become self-directed learners (Lipson 2006). For the duration of the
course, participants work in a project group on one large case study, culminating in a
final report and presentation to the plenary at the end of the course. In recent courses,
this has involved the students looking into one particular issue covered in the
program modules and developing a concrete initiative to address the challenge. The
initiative could be project based or involve establishing an organization; however,
the focus was on a tangible activity that the students can continue to develop and
implement when they finished the YES course. Coaching is also provided around
project development, implementation, and fund-raising.
Another important component of the course is the inclusion of practical activities
such as workshops, field trips, and role-playing. In the energy and materials module,
for example, the students participate in a hands-on ecodesign workshop where they
calculate energy consumption in various stages of a product’s life cycle and then
work on improving the design and production process in order to minimize the
ecological footprint. When possible, this is conducted in partnership with a company
located locally, and a field trip is arranged where participants can see the production
process firsthand and then present their recommendations to the management.
A professional artist joins the group for the duration of the course to encourage
back reflection on their experience in the course and to help participants process the
course content. The artist guides the students in painting and drawing activities in
small groups to reflect on their cognitive and emotional growth and transformation
during the program. Over the duration of the course, the participants work together
to produce a mural which helps them process their experiences in the program and
how it has shaped their conceptualization of sustainable development.
Over the 10 years that the YES course has been running, the organizers have
identified a number of critical aspects for the success of the program, as outlined
below.
86 M. Grant
Each YES course includes participants from, on average, 27 different countries. The
participants are grounded in a wide spectrum of cultures, ethnic backgrounds, and
religions. The YES approach has always been to encourage this cultural diversity
and provide a platform through which understanding and mutual respect may
flourish.
The difficulties of the poor of our planet are a significant part of sustainable
development concerns, and the YES organizers give special attention to helping
students lacking financial resources. The approach is to look at each individual
case so as to offer opportunities to students from poor countries but also to
those who may face financial difficulties as citizens of wealthier nations. The
aim is for each participant to contribute something as part of the total fee. The
participation fee includes all food, accommodation, local transport, and activi-
ties for the duration of the program. Participants fund their own international
travel.
The first priority of the YES organizers is to select a group of participants based on
merit and leadership capacity. A wide variety of criteria are used in the selection
process including educational, extracurricular, and professional experience and
demonstrated leadership capacity. At the same time, the organizers aim to create a
participant group that is disciplinary and culturally diverse. In addition, the selection
process aims at keeping a balance between male and female participants.
6 Youth Encounter on Sustainability 87
YES students are certainly capable of formulating theoretical analyses and reports,
but they are not limited to this. The YES team addresses this potential in its
participants during the course by involving them in practical exercises, introducing
them to existing alumni initiatives and start-ups, and offering them support as
members of the alumni network (now over 1,200 in number) to initiate activities
themselves following the course.
Discussions with guest speakers are an important feature of YES. Experts in-
volved in sustainable development from governments, media, business, NGOs, and
academia are invited to engage in dialogue with the participants in an open and
participatory format.
The physical location where the course takes place contributes significantly to the
educational experience. The YES course locations have included the Swiss Alps,
Mt Fuji in Japan, the countryside surrounding historic Bratislava in Slovakia, the
Rift Valley in Kenya, an ecovillage in South Africa, the Sinai Desert in Egypt,
and the coffee-growing region of Colombia. Each of these locations combines
unique natural and man-made settings and provides opportunities for outdoor
activities in connection to the content of the course. An ideal environment for a
holistic educational experience is one that encourages attentiveness and reflection
through group interaction and personal activities, promoting the development of a
collective feeling of a need for action. Having students live and work together in an
isolated and inspiring environment plays an important role in building a connected
community of dedicated leaders.
88 M. Grant
8 Outcomes
Most programs I wouldn’t consider life changing – I would consider YES an exception.
YES Student, August 2006 Course
The true success of the YES program is demonstrated through the outcomes from
the course and the pool of alumni, currently numbering 1,200 individuals in 110
countries. Through its unique approach, the YES course makes participants feel
they are a part of a global community, committed to addressing the challenges of
sustainable development. Too often, youth working in these fields feel marginalized
and like they are dealing with enormous and complex global issues in isolation. The
YES experience makes them feel a member of a community of youth around the
world from many different cultures and disciplines who can support one another to
continue and strengthen their endeavors.
Evaluations that have been conducted by ETHsustainability and ACTIS with
alumni after their completion of the course have demonstrated a wider impact of
the YES program. Many participants redirected their professional and personal lives
after attending the course, for instance, by starting sustainability-related programs
at their own universities, completely changing their career paths toward issues of
sustainable development, becoming more involved in ESD, integrating sustainable
practices and concepts into their projects, and by trying to reduce their own
ecological footprints.
In addition, alumni have gone on to create their own projects and organizations
as a direct result of the course. A recent survey (ACTIS 2011) identified that
approximately 40% of alumni have gone on to start their own organizations or
projects after the course. For example, the highly successful “myclimate” (see www.
myclimate.org) was started by a group of YES Alumni students based at ETH
Zurich in 2002. Focusing on CO2 compensation for air travel in the voluntary
market, the group has now become an industry leader. They have now expanded
their operations into climate-neutral companies, events, and products, including
large-scale events such as the 2006 FIFA World Cup and the World Economic
Forum in Davos.
Another notable initiative is the “Latin American Forest Policies and Research”
project initiated by a group of YES Alumni, through an organization they estab-
lished, called the “International Student Initiative for Action on Climate Change
(ISIACC).” This group has dedicated itself to researching and developing policy
recommendations for governments across Latin America, which aim to address the
issue of avoided deforestation and climate change. The group had great success with
policies being adopted in Mexico, Colombia, and high-level policy negotiations
carried out in Brazil. The group is currently in the process of legally establishing
local chapters across the region to further their activities.
These few examples of the many actions of the large pool of YES Alumni
students are testament to the success of the ESD approach taken in the YES course
to build up the capacity of the next generation of decision makers to address global
challenges. This group of individuals is an exceptional resource of committed agents
of change, and there is currently a focus on efforts to leverage this talent pool.
6 Youth Encounter on Sustainability 89
A social networking platform has been launched as a formal means for the members
of the alumni to communicate and collaborate around the world.
Additionally, ACTIS has developed a suite of special courses for YES Alumni
that offer participants an opportunity to deepen their knowledge and practical
experience in a particular focus area, gain training on project management and
implementation, and further develop their leadership skills. Such courses have
been held on water and sustainability (Sinai Desert, Egypt), food security and
sustainable agriculture (Stellenbosh Ecolodge, South Africa), and social enterprise
for sustainable development (El Eje Cafetero, Colombia).
Participants are selected into the program based on a number of criteria, including
leadership capacity. The course further strengthens this capacity and also provides
the individual participants with access to a global network of like-minded peers,
which opens up further work and education opportunities. The 2011 survey of YES
Alumni (ACTIS 2011) identified that approximately 43% of alumni have gone on
to hold leadership positions such as CEO, Founder, Director, or Manager in diverse
organizations.
9 Conclusion
The Youth Encounter on Sustainability (YES) has been a resounding success, but
it is just the beginning. The concepts of ESD must be integrated into teaching and
learning at all levels if we are to develop the capacity to address the challenges
we face as a global community. ESD must not become a specialized discipline in
itself, but must be diffused into our educational practices in schools, universities,
and all learning institutions. It is, in the end, simply effective education that fosters
the capacity for individuals to be responsible world citizens.
References
ACTIS Global Survey of YES Alumni, Research & Analysis: Rodrigo Santos (2011)
R. Baud, ‘Y.E.S. – student education in sustainability’ public education in a knowledge society:
creativity, content, and delivery mechanisms. Delhi sustainable development summit, New
Delhi, February 2004
J. Fien, R. Guevara, J. Lang, J. Malone, Australian country report UNESCO-NIER regional
seminar on Policy, Research and Capacity Building for Education Innovation for Sustainable
Development, ESCO Australian National Commission. Education for sustainable development,
Tokyo (2004)
A. Lipson, Project Based Learning Literature Review (MIT Teaching and Learning Laboratory,
MIT, Cambridge, 2006)
P. Ovens, F. Wells, P. Wallis, C. Hawkins, Developing Inquiry for Learning: Reflecting Collab-
orative Ways to Learn How to Learn in Higher Education (Paperback) (Routledge, London
2011)
D. Tilbury, Emerging issues in education for sustainable development, in Education for Sustainable
Development in Nepal: Views and Vision ed. by B.B. Bhandari, O. Abe (IGES, Kanagawa,
2003), pp.29–40
UNFPA, Factsheet: young people and times of change (2009), http://www.unfpa.org/public/home/
factsheets/young people
Transdisciplinary Approaches to
Engineering R&D: Importance of 7
Understanding Values and Culture
Abstract
The emerging classification of Sustainability-oriented Innovation Systems places
an emphasis on the social elements of change, as well as the technological. How-
ever, sustainability-oriented problems are too vast for one person or discipline
to comprehend; thus people tend to want to collaborate, meaning they form
teams. As a further extension to address sustainability-oriented problems, there
is an increasing emphasis on transdisciplinary research and development (R&D)
efforts, whereby coproduction transgresses boundaries, and science becomes
visible before it becomes certain. To reach the objectives of transdisciplinary
R&D efforts will require two key concepts: the gathering of information from
experts, namely, knowledge transfer; and making connections between them,
namely, knowledge integration. Nevertheless, challenges have been noted in
terms of academic tribes that impede teamwork, and, importantly, the lack of
combined thought and action in R&D. This chapter explores the collaboration,
between disciplines, that has been described as the means of meeting the
requirements of transdiscplinary R&D to identify, structure, analyze, and deal
with specific problems in such a way that it can: grasp the complexity of
problems; take into account the diversity of life-world and scientific perceptions
of problems; link abstract and case-specific knowledge; and develop knowledge
and practices that promote what is perceived to be the common good. However,
the latter brings into question how values and culture influence collaboration
and thus transdisciplinary R&D efforts. The chapter subsequently builds on an
introduced conceptual framework to understand how the values and culture of
individuals in a transdisciplinary R&D team, as well as those of the organization,
A.C. Brent
Centre for Renewable and Sustainable Energy Studies, Faculty of Engineering and the School of
Public Leadership, Faculty of Economic and Management Sciences, Stellenbosch University,
Stellenbosch, South Africa
e-mail: acb@sun.ac.za
determine the potential success or failure of the R&D effort. A case study in the
bio-energy field is used as basis. The R&D project, which spanned over 3 years
in South Africa, required a transdisciplinary team of engineers and scientists of
various fields to collaborate with stakeholders outside the R&D team. The case
emphasizes that the lack of engineering disciplines to recognize, understand, and
incorporate values and culture into R&D practices will lead to project failure;
pre-empting and managing expectations of social change (often) far outweigh
the necessity for technological change. A number of recommendations are thus
made to improve sustainable engineering R&D practices.
1 Introduction
It is now well understood that the dominant systemic features of the current global
economic system are unsustainable (Soderbaum 2009; Swilling 2010). Numerous
indicators show economic activities to be direct causes of global instabilities,
including, among others, climate change, resource depletion, and ecosystem and
habitat destruction (UNEP 2010). The increasing need for economic system tran-
sitions toward more sustainable trajectories is evident and a pressing concern for
decision- and policy-makers worldwide (Elzen et al. 2004). Many private and public
sectors, thus, now pursue the potential opportunities offered by the global “green
economy” (UNEP 2011). These sustainable transitions in the economic system
would necessitate appropriate (engineering) research and development (R&D)
efforts that are transdisciplinary in nature; such efforts require knowledge co-
creation with societal participants that are intrinsically involved with real-world
complex problems that require solutions (Regeer and Bunders 2009). However, from
a sustainability perspective it would seem that current R&D efforts are (often) not
focused on, or well organized for, real societal needs to address the problems of
sustainable development (Brent and Swilling 2011). Specifically, engineering R&D
practitioners now need to understand how values and culture influence collaboration
and (potentially) impede transdisciplinary R&D efforts. This chapter intends to
deepen this understanding by applying a conceptual framework, which has been
developed to analyze the influence of values and culture on R&D projects, to a case
study relating to engineered bio-energy options for rural areas in South Africa.
The dominant view of innovation over the past two decades relates to techno-
logical progress, competitiveness, and economic growth (Acs 2000; Coenen and
Lopez 2010). This strong tradition stems from an era where resource constraints,
and ecological and social pressures were not as apparent as they are today.
Environmental pressures and social inequalities are precisely the reason that narrow
understandings of innovation, and innovation systems, are being challenged to
include alternative, wider and more suitable conceptions (Lundvall et al. 2009).
The agglomeration of several and aligned incremental or radical innovations is thus
required that results in system innovation and, at a macro level, a national system of
innovation (NSI), which is increasingly supported as a capable avenue for achieving
sustainable economic growth (Stamm et al. 2009), or “decoupling” (see Fig. 7.1).
Where transitioning toward sustainable development is concerned, the innovation
literature (Geels 2002; Smith et al. 2010) places much emphasis on the multi-level
perspective (MLP) as a theoretical framework for understanding the dynamics of
this transition.
The MLP has been criticized for its select focus on (physical) technology
and the exclusive focus on the emergence of system innovation within niche
environments. Although the MLP provides a valuable framework for the integration
of a variety of theoretical perspectives on innovation and evolutionary economics, it
can be improved upon. Nevertheless, the MLP framework accommodates two useful
levels, namely: the socio-technical landscape, or exogenous context, that brings
about pressure upon the socio-technical regime, consisting of policy, regulation,
technology, industry, science and culture; and socio-technical niche innovations, or
small networks of actors, which support the introduction of novel ideas, concepts,
products, and processes (Peter and Swilling 2011). This notion fits into an emerging
classification of Sustainability-oriented Innovation Systems (SoIS) that places an
emphasis on the social elements of change, as well as the technological (Elzen
et al. 2004; Stamm et al. 2009), thereby providing for a more vibrant culture of
innovation. Such a SoIS, in turn, then requires a different, concerted approach to
R&D to address sustainability-oriented problems that are identified in the NSI with
the transition to a green economy.
94 A.C. Brent
Aasen et al. (2010) describe the development of R&D practices, and highlight
that, since the 1990s, R&D has shifted its focus based on an increasing recog-
nition that the practices need to be more oriented toward strategic goals (of
society) and the production of relevant knowledge (Hessels and van Lente 2008).
The concept of “Mode 2” knowledge production was then introduced to denote
“knowledge produced in the context of application, by so-called transdisciplinary
collaborations” (Hessels and van Lente 2008). Such coproduction efforts transgress
boundaries (see Fig. 7.2), and science becomes visible before it becomes cer-
tain (Collins and Evans 2002). In “Mode 2” (see Table 7.1), the distinction
between basic and applied R&D is no longer relevant, and the overall objective
is to respond to perceived needs for new applications, involving the necessity of
taking into account the different requirements, values, and demands of collab-
orating partners (in society). R&D teams are then guided by societal concerns,
rather than being driven by techno-scientific possibilities with vague promises
(see Fig. 7.3); thus, there is an increasing emphasis on transdisciplinary R&D
projects.
society
science
discipline
knowledge
production
society
science
discipline
knowledge
production
Fig. 7.2 Transdisciplinary R&D projects transgress boundaries (Source: Brent and Swilling 2011)
7 Transdisciplinary Approaches to Engineering R&D 95
Table 7.1 The distinction between “Mode 1” and “Mode 2” knowledge production (Source:
Aasen et al. 2010)
Mode 1 Mode 2
Academic context Context of application
Disciplinary Transdisciplinary
Homogeneity Heterogeneity
Autonomy Reflexivity/social accountability
Traditional quality control (peer review) Novel quality control
Soc
Soc
Soc
Soc R&D
Soc Soc
R&D
R&D
Soc
R&D R&D
Fig. 7.3 The R&D shift from a techno-scientific orientation to that of societal concerns (Source:
Voß 2009)
This chapter utilizes a conceptual framework that was derived to analyze the effect
of values and culture in transdisciplinary R&D efforts. The framework, which is
summarized in Fig. 7.4 and described in greater detail elsewhere (Brent and Swilling
2011), highlights, for the engineering R&D practitioner, the complexity in the R&D
process (Voß 2009):
1. R&D processes should refer to real-world problems, which involves the chal-
lenge of translating nonscientific questions into issues that can be addressed
scientifically, and taking knowledge from outside the realm of science into
account.
2. Researchers participate in “social experiments” and thus face the challenge of
taking into account the attitudes, beliefs, notions and perceptions, interests,
and capabilities of persons and groups within society whereby nonscientific
knowledge and normative aspects are integrated into the R&D process.
In terms of the latter, a dynamic environment for continuous experimenting
and learning must be allowed whereby transdisciplinary R&D efforts then adhere
to the principles of learning organizations. Two issues emerge from the literature
(Williams 2008) as important to support the building blocks of learning organiza-
tions, namely:
1. Organizational structure. Lipshitz et al. (2002) look to roles and procedures
that enable organizational members to collect and analyze data, and Reger and
von Wichert-Nick (1997) argue that organizational learning needs hierarchy-free
communication and flow of information.
2. National culture and internal organizational culture. Lipshitz et al. (2002) found
that the cultural values that promote learning are transparency, integrity, issue
orientation, inquiry, and accountability. Similarly, Reger and von Wichert-Nick
(1997) emphasize that learning requires a culture of supporting teamwork, which
supports experimentation, and is open to risks.
7 Transdisciplinary Approaches to Engineering R&D 97
Complexity of
R&D efforts
Systems
Number of
People relationships
Values and Number of
bellefs parts
Nonholonomic
Capabilities constralnts
Interests
Non- linearity
Asymmetry
Notions and
perceptions Hierarchy and
emergence
Communication
and control
Fig. 7.4 Conceptual framework to analyze the effect of values and culture in transdisciplinary
R&D efforts (Brent and Swilling 2011)
in particular, Roux et al. (2010) emphasize that, only once a proper understanding
(not necessarily agreement) of the various stakeholders’ contexts and perspectives,
basic trust, and a common language are achieved, are the stakeholders ready to
transform the knowledge that is produced at a disciplinary level to have meaning at
a pragmatic or normative level; and coproduce the new knowledge that transcends
disciplines and contributes to broader societal goals.
van Haaften (2003) emphasizes that the management of transdisciplinary R&D
efforts needs to acknowledge cultural biases and facilitate communication if the
common goals are to be achieved. Also, from an organization structure perspective,
as stated above, learning needs hierarchy-free communication and flow of informa-
tion (Reger and von Wichert-Nick 1997). Hollaender (2003) also argues that careful
planning and active management of communication and coordination are vital to the
success of transdisciplinary R&D projects. To this end, the conceptual framework
builds on the recommendations that were made by participants of transdisciplinary
R&D teams; these outcomes inform the requirements for organizational structure
in Fig. 7.4.
Fig. 7.5 The analytical framework of BIOSSAM showing the cycle of active learning and R&D
for the assessment, management, and monitoring of bio-energy interventions (Source: Stafford
2011)
The BIOSSAM R&D effort was undertaken over a 3-year period from the second
quarter of 2008 to the first quarter of 2011. The research team comprised of over
ten individuals, through the different phases of the effort, from various disciplines,
including engineering, environmental, economic, social, and business sciences. A
specific case study was used as basis to develop the range of BIOSSAM methods,
which focused on the utilization of invasive alien plants (IAPs) on the Agulhas
Plains of the Western Cape Province of South Africa (see Fig. 7.6) to produce bio-
energy for different applications (Stafford 2011). The entity that was used to engage
the various stakeholders was the Agulhas Biodiversity Initiative, which, in turn,
comprises of business owners; commercial farmers; rural communities, including
subsistence farmers; and ecotourism entrepreneurs; among others.
Invasive alien plants (IAPs) are one of the greatest threats to plant and animal
biodiversity. Of the estimated 9,000 plants introduced into South Africa, 198
are currently classified as being invasive. It is estimated that these plants cover
100
Fig. 7.6 The location of the Agulhas Plains at the southern tip of Africa
A.C. Brent
7 Transdisciplinary Approaches to Engineering R&D 101
about 10% of the country and the problem is growing at an exponential rate
(Stafford 2011).
IAPs result in a net loss of value amounting to some US$100 million per year to
the Cape Floristic Region (CFR) in the Western Cape Province of the country. This
includes significant costs due to the impact of IAPs on water resources (utilizing
7–13% of the available surface water) and the loss of income for the wild flower
and tourism industry. The cost of clearing IAPs represents a considerable burden,
and farmers are unlikely to clear IAPs due to financial reasons unless there are gains
from clearing their lands (such as aesthetic values) or appropriate incentives are
put in place (such as payment for ecosystem services). The flora of the CFR is
highly threatened and designated as a biodiversity conservation “hotspot.” The Cape
Action for People and the Environment (C.A.P.E.) Program unites government and
civil society in a strategy to conserve biodiversity, while creating benefits for all the
people of the CFR. The Agulhas Biodiversity Initiative (ABI) is a pilot landscape
initiative that builds on a partnership between South African National Parks and
Fauna and Flora International; the partnership was initiated in 2004.
The BIOSSAM intervention explored the opportunity to reduce the cost and
burdens of clearing IAPs by producing bio-energy, referred to as IAP2Energy.
Multi-stakeholder engagement and a process of planning for sustainability (see
Fig. 7.5) developed the vision, principles, criteria, and indicators that can be used to
guide the assessment and management of IAP2Energy-related projects. The vision
was established as:
Landowners, business, government, civil society and communities in the Agulhas Plains
area are working together to enable the sustainable production and use of green energy
derived from invasive alien plants to conserve biodiversity, restore the land, and promote
resilient and continuous livelihoods for the equitable benefit of all (Stafford 2011).
The top four issues or sustainability indicators that both stakeholders and the
R&D team considered most important were identified as:
1. Minimize impacts on natural ecosystems
2. Job creation
3. Skills development
4. Certainty of benefits to local people of the Agulhas Plains
A key aspect is the delicate balance between ensuring that the process is
economically feasible without being driven by market demands that would create
the dependency on IAPs and provide incentives for the farming of IAPs. IAPs are
considered a nonrenewable resource since the eradication of IAPs is the ultimate
objective that complies with government legislation so that the farming of IAPs
will not be permitted. In this IAP2Energy pre-feasibility assessment, the project
lifetime was 20 years in order to synchronize the IAP2Energy technology lifetime
with the proposed period of IAP biomass eradication (resource depletion). Four
areas on the Agulhas Plains were identified (to minimize transportation costs), and
the available IAP biomass stocks within these areas were estimated to have a total
energy content of 25TJ, which could generate 12MW of electricity and thereby
provide sufficient energy for at least 20,000 people over a 20-year period, about
102 A.C. Brent
half the people resident on the Agulhas Plains. This indicates a considerable bio-
energy potential and there are established commercial technologies available that
can generate valuable bio-energy products from these IAPs; examples of thermal
conversion process are given in Table 7.2.
The technology options were explored and developed into feasible scenarios
(see Fig. 7.7). The scenarios were scored and ranked using weighting values that
were determined by the stakeholders, using a Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis
(MCDA) technique, and performance data for the defined IAP2Energy scenarios,
using a life-cycle approach where the entire value chains (production to end use)
were analyzed. The most appropriate IAP2Energy scenarios (in order of preference)
were:
1. Compressed logs
2. Pyrolysis for charcoal
3. Gasification for electricity
4. Combustion for electricity
This choice was largely determined by the preference for localization and
resource efficiency in terms of minimizing impacts on natural ecosystems. The
smaller, modular technology approaches are localized, namely, using wood chips
directly in efficient combined heat and power stoves, and have the added benefits of
developing local skills and capacity in their manufacture, sales, and maintenance.
Changes in the practices of usage can greatly improve the overall efficiency, for
example, more efficient stoves and energy efficient appliances. All stakeholders,
Mobile chipper
Combustion in stove (or braai)
Ca 20-30mm
for cooking and space-heating
wood-chips
(hot-water)
Grinding
Carbonisation Oven-dry
Long-haul machine Briquette
making Briquettes
transport
5. Household combustion for Combined Heat and Power Combustion in stove for cooking
Hot-water and space-heating,
Basic electricity for 2-4 lights and
Cell- phone/radio
Fig. 7.7 The IAP2Energy scenarios (1–5) showing the bio-energy value chain from IAP biomass harvesting to the end use of the bio-energy product (Source:
Stafford 2011)
103
104 A.C. Brent
therefore, recognized that the implementation strategy should more carefully con-
sider end user energy efficiency, preferences, and needs.
The R&D team was engaged, after completion of the IAP case study, to obtain some
insights in terms of how cultural values, and organizational structure, including
communication, affected the transdisciplinary R&D effort. The comments that were
received are summarized in Table 7.3 according to parameters of the conceptual
framework (of Fig. 7.4).
The R&D effort was very exploratory-oriented and therefore evolved, as a
project, over the 3 years. However, on reflection, the R&D team members felt
strongly that the project was not explicitly conceptualized from the outset as a
transdisciplinary R&D effort and communicated as such. The consequence was
that the transdisciplinarity of the R&D effort was not internalized by all the team
members and the organization. Values and culture subsequently influenced the
R&D effort, overall, in a negative way. In terms of the values and culture of
the stakeholders and team members, the most important parameters that must be
considered to improve the outcomes of transdisciplinary R&D efforts are:
1. Focusing on the priorities of the overall R&D effort, rather than sub-components
thereof, to encourage some cohesion and common purpose
2. Instilling a tolerance for uncertainty and ambiguity and thereby stimulate more
innovative thinking
3. Striking a balance between “doing” and “being” orientations, to ensure that the
R&D effort strives toward the common purpose
As to the values and culture of the organization, the most important parameters
that must be adhered to are transparency, accountability, teamwork, and, especially,
openness to taking risks. Because these issues were not addressed adequately, in the
BIOSSAM case, the team members, of the different work packages, easily retreated
to disciplinary domains, or comfort zones, rather than consciously engaging with
the transdisciplinary nature of the work of the project as a whole. To this end
it would be useful to have a scene-setting workshop at the beginning of the
project, with at least annual refreshers, where transdisciplinarity and integrative
thinking and focus are emphasized as the points of departure. This would include
engaging with the different world views and perspectives of each of the team
members, and the stakeholders. Being aware of these upfront, rather than to discover
them through conflict and contestation in the project work, would significantly
improve the productivity and outcomes of transdisciplinary R&D efforts. The case
thus emphasizes that the lack of engineering (and other) disciplines to recognize,
understand, and incorporate values and culture into R&D practices will lead to
project failure; pre-empting and managing expectations of social change (often) far
outweigh the necessity for technological change.
Table 7.3 Reflections on the outcomes of the BIOSSAM transdisciplinary R&D effort pertaining to the IAP2Energy case study on the Agulhas Plains of South
Africa
Positive
effect on
the R&D
Parameter effort? Reflection based on comments received from the R&D team members
Stakeholder values/culture:
Acceptance and expectance of Expectations, and acceptance, of power distribution had to change through the process, which caused
power distribution friction. For example, although the participating stakeholders and the R&D team members engaged on an
equal footing, which was experienced as overly positive, the situation did arise where the team leader had
to make judgments on taking the research forward, which was met with resistance, particularly if such
decisions were perceived to infringe on disciplinary discourse
Focus on own priorities or that of The dominant culture was that of fulfilling one’s own needs, which meant that the holistic vision and
the larger system goals of the larger system was difficult to achieve. Individual team members felt that it was extremely
difficult to influence the overall R&D process to encourage some cohesion and common purpose, despite
the logical necessity for doing so. Eventually they felt compelled to focus on their own priorities (and
7 Transdisciplinary Approaches to Engineering R&D
merely had information extracted from them and received nothing in return
Team work It was agreed that the organization attempts to instill teamwork that is multidisciplinary in nature, but, still,
scientists (and engineers) battle with teamwork unless the team members all have similar world views and
points of engagement.
Open to risk The organization is extremely risk-adverse, and this manifested in, especially, the R&D team members’
behaviors
(continued)
107
108
7 Summary
References
T.M.B. Aasen, O. Amundsen, M. Mølnvik, G. Tangen, in Innovation in Transdisciplinary and
Heterogeneous Collaborations: Exploring New Ways of Organizing Environment-Friendly
Energy Research. COMBI2010 Conference Proceedings (Vantaa, Finland, 2010)
Z. Acs, Regional innovation, knowledge, and global change (Pinter, London, 2000)
A.C. Brent, M. Swilling, An Investigation into the Challenges of Transdisciplinary R&D: Values,
Culture and the Case of the BIOSSAM Project. R&D Management Conference (Norrköping,
Sweden, 2011)
L. Carlson, Crossing the line. Altern. J. 33(5), (2007), available from: http://www.
alternativesjournal.ca/articles/crossing-the-line
110 A.C. Brent
L. Coenen, J.D. Lopez, Comparing systems approaches to innovation and technological change for
sustainable and competitive economies: an explorative study into conceptual commonalities,
differences and complementarities. J. Clean. Prod. 18(12), 1149–1160 (2010)
H.M. Collins, R. Evans, The third wave of science studies: studies of expertise and experience.
Soc. Stud. Sci. 32(2), 235–296 (2002)
T.K. Das, R. Kumar, Interpartner sensemaking in strategic alliances: managing cultural differences
and internal tensions. Manag. Decis. 48(1), 17–36 (2010)
B. Elzen, F.W. Geels, K. Green, System Innovation and the Transition to Sustainability: Theory,
Evidence and Policy (Edward Elgar Publishing, Massachusetts, 2004)
F.W. Geels, Technological transitions as evolutionary reconfiguration processes: a multi-level
perspective and a case-study. Res. Policy 31, 1257–1274 (2002)
L.K. Hessels, H. van Lente, Re-thinking new knowledge production: a literature review and a
research agenda. Res. Policy 37, 740–760 (2008)
G. Hofstede, Dimensions do not exist: a reply to Brendan McSweeney. Hum. Relat. 55(11), 1355–
1361 (2002)
K. Hollaender, Success factors in inter- and transdisciplinary research: selected results from
the program Urban Ecology. in Interdisciplinary and Transdisciplinary Landscape Studies:
Potential and Limitations, ed. by B. Tress, G. Tress, A. van der Valk, G. Fry. DELTA Series,
vol 2 (Delta Program, Wageningen, 2003) pp. 91–99
R. Lipshitz, M. Popper, V. Friedman, A multifacet model of organizational learning. J. Appl. Behav.
Sci. 38, 78–98 (2002)
B-Å. Lundvall, K.J. Joseph, C. Chaminade, J. Vang, Handbook of Innovation Systems and
Developing Countries: Building Domestic Capabilities in a Global Setting (Edwar Elgar,
Massachusetts, 2009)
K. Nortje, Understanding the research and thinking process of a multi-disciplinary group planning
for sustainability. Working Paper, Natural Resources and the Environment, CSIR, Pretoria,
2011
M. Peneder, Technological regimes and the variety of innovation behaviour: Creating integrated
taxonomies of firms and sectors. Res. Policy 39(3), 323–334 (2010)
C. Peter, M. Swilling, Greening the South African growth path: Transitioning to sustainability.
Development Bank of Southern Africa, Midrand, 2011
C. Pohl, G. Hirsch Hadorn, Methodological challenges of transdisciplinary research. Nat. Sci. Soc.
16, 111–121 (2008)
T. Quinlan, P. Scogings, Why bio-physical and social scientists can speak the same language when
addressing sustainable development. Environ. Sci. Policy 7, 537–546 (2004)
B.J. Regeer, J.F.G. Bunders, Knowledge co-creation: Interaction between science and society.
A transdisciplinary approach to complex societal issues. Advisory Council for Research on
Spatial Planning, Nature and the Environment (RMNO), 10e, 2009, available from: http://eeac.
hscglab.nl/files/NL-RMNO knowledgecoop Jun09.pdf
G. Reger, C. von Wichert-Nick, A learning organization for R&D management. Int. J. Tech.
Manag. 13, 796–817 (1997)
D.J. Roux, R.J. Stirzaker, C.M. Breen, E.C. Lefroy, H.P. Cresswell, Framework for participative
reflection on the accomplishment of transdisciplinary research programs. Environ. Sci. Policy
13, 733–741 (2010)
P. Sillitoe, Interdisciplinary experiences: Working with indigenous knowledge in development.
Interdiscip. Sci. Rev. 29(1), 6–23 (2004)
A. Smith, J.-P. Voß, J. Grin, Innovation studies and sustainability transitions: The allure of the
multi-level perspective and its challenges. Res. Policy 39(4), 435–448 (2010)
P. Söderbaum, A financial crisis on top of the ecological crisis: Ending the monopoly of
neoclassical economics. Real-World Econ. Rev. 49, 8–19 (2009)
W.H.L. Stafford, A pre-feasibility study prepared for Agulhas Biodiversity Initiative (ABI)
Energy Working Group, 2011, Council for Scientific and Industrial Research report no.
CSIR/NRE/RBSD/IR/2011/0034/C, available from: http://www.biossam.org/resources/
7 Transdisciplinary Approaches to Engineering R&D 111
W.H.L. Stafford, A.C. Brent, An introduction to BIOSSAM – the South African Bioenergy
Systems Sustainability Assessment and Management portal. J. Energy South. Afr. 21(4), 32
(2010)
A. Stamm, E. Dantas, D. Fischer, S. Ganguly, B. Rennkamp, Sustainability Oriented Innovation
Systems: Towards Decoupling Economic Growth From Environmental Pressures? (German
Development Institute (DIE), Bonn, 2009)
M. Swilling, Sustainability, poverty and municipal services: The case of Cape Town, South Africa.
Sustainable Develop. 18(4), 194–201 (2010)
C.R. Swindoll, Great Attitudes! 10 Choices for Success in Life (Thomas Nelson Publishers,
New York, 2006)
United Nations Environmental Programme (UNEP), Decoupling and sustainable resource manage-
ment: Towards a conceptual framework. UNEP International Panel for Sustainable Resource
Management, Paris, 2009, available from: http://www.unep.fr/scp/rpanel/publications/
United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP), A brief for policymakers on the green economy
and millennium development goals. Prepared for the UN Summit on MDGs, Green Economy
Initiative, Geneva, 2010, available from: http://www.unep.org/greeneconomy
United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP), Towards a green economy: Pathways to
sustainable development and poverty eradication. Green Economy Initiative, Geneva, 2011,
available from: http://www.unep.org/greeneconomy
E.H. van Haaften, Disciplinary perception and interdisciplinary communication in management of
natural resources. in Interdisciplinary and Transdisciplinary Landscape Studies: Potential and
Limitations, ed. by B. Tress, G. Tress, A. van der Valk, G. Fry. DELTA Series, vol 2 (Delta
Program, Wageningen, 2003) pp. 107–113
J.-P. Voß, Barriers to research and innovation for solving social challenges: Lessons from social-
ecological research in Germany. CSTP Expert Workshop, OECD, Paris, 2009, available from:
http://www.oecd.org/dataoecd/28/2/43278129.pdf
T. Williams, How do organizations learn lessons from projects – and do they? IEEE Trans. Eng.
Manag. 55(2), 248–266 (2008)
Section II
Water
Sustainable Water: Introduction
8
Keith R. Cooper
K.R. Cooper
Department of Biochemistry & Microbiology, Rutgers, The State University of NJ,
New Brunswick, New Jersey, USA
e-mail: cooper@aesop.rutgers.edu
Population Growth
Agricultural Demands Demands
Potable
Climate Change Water
Supplies
Engineering &
Technology
Advances To
Industrial Demands Increase Available
Potable and Reuse
Water Supplies
Fig. 8.1 Impacting factors (red) that decrease freshwater supplies and engineering remedies
(green)
1 Cross-References
Exploring technology for the environment and society is an essential activity within
the research applied in International cooperation.
Some important work has been done toward community-level disaster readiness
which ensures contingency plans are in place. This level of planning leads to more
applicable designs due to consideration of local knowledge and constraints prior to
a disaster event (Droste 1996; Foster 2000).
Greater disaster preparedness can therefore create the opportunity for longer-
term success of emergency interventions (Luff 2001a, b).
Generally speaking, “technology for self-reliance” refers to processes, structures,
and products aimed at developing a social pattern that still finds its basis in
technological principles, instruments, and models.
Self-reliance and access are two core issues in “technology for self-reliance”:
• Access (financial, social, and technical) is to be guaranteed to the public.
• Self-reliance is the result of the process through which effective capability and
social functionality have been developed.
Self-reliance means building productive social relationship instead of dependent
relationship. Self-reliance process must guarantee the ecological and social self-
reliance of its components.
The described project solves a problem and makes the beneficiary free from an
external support.
Differently, the project would fail because it could not create real development
but rather further dependency. Our aim was to increase sustainability, meaning the
autonomy of the project and its efficiency. This can be achieved first by identifying
the correct technical solution and shifting all possible costs to the start-up phase,
combined with external help that requires minimal running costs over the years and
can be maintained by the beneficiary (Esposto 2009).
Thereafter, the resources required during the life of the project should be
monitored to determine whether they are internal or external, with a preference for
internal resources that can be supplied by the community and/or local authority, i.e.,
Gaza Municipalities.
In order to survive, mankind must ensure that the ecosystem of which we are part
remains functional. This will require not only responsible use of natural resources
such as water, but also implementation of a wide range of measures that will allow
future generations to maintain their ability to cope with the ever-changing conditions
with which they will be faced.
CIRPS, the Interuniversity Research Center on Sustainable Development of
University of Rome “Sapienza,” has been working on supporting these two pillars.
In particular, the activities and the studies for International Cooperation run by the
CIRPS focus on:
• Small social environment
• No environment-impact energies
• Chlorine self production
• Disadvantaged work groups
• Permanent area of crisis or of social tension both urban and rura
Chlorine gives an additional disinfecting potential by the residual active chlorine,
an important factor to ensure tap water to be consistent within the quality standards
(Oussedik 2001; Porteous 1996; Semiat 2000).
A useful technology that can be applied is the on-site production of chlorine
through electrolysis (OSEC) (Esposto et al. 2004). Many NGOs in India, Asia, and
South America experimented this system in various villages (Lantagne et al. 2001).
It consists of a mature technology used in the private sector for chlorine production.
The only requirement for its proper functioning is common salt and electricity,
available in Gaza by the Grid or by Photovoltaic System. The maintenance of the
titanium electrodes is easy and many devices have the inverse-polarity system for
cleaning and avoiding scaling.
A difference in capital cost will be accepted by the external actors for the sake of
reaching a sustainable development level. All the options considered can guarantee
a supply of water comparable to the SPHERE standards or beyond (World Health
Organization 2011).
Possible problems related to presence of metals like excess of iron or nitrates in
the water are not considered (Esposto and ICRC 2009).
The Research Unit CIRPS offered a technical and scientific collaboration to the
NGO CRIC (Centro Regionale d’Intervento per la Cooperazione) for the project
“Improving living conditions of Bedouin communities living in Gaza Strip by
enhancing the economy of most vulnerable households and food security” (cod:
ECHO/-E/BUD/2007/02033).
Between the 7th and 14th of October 2008, CIRPS and Palestinian Hydrology
Group worked together in Umm Al-Nasser village in order to carry out the following
activities:
• Establishment of one grazing area in Umm Al-Nasser village
• Assistance in the installation of an On Site Electro Chlorination (OSEC) System
9 Chlorine Self-Production Plant Solution 119
As matter of fact, chlorine and its compounds have the following well-known
features:
• Effectiveness as oxidizing agent.
• Simplicity and rapidity in the measurement of the strength and concentration of
the chemical agent in water allowing a constant monitoring of the trial.
• Persistence of residuals (i.e., a residual concentration in treated water), providing
an important protection against recontamination.
The presence of a free chlorine residual of 0.2–0.5 mg/L in water ensures that
postdelivery contamination is minimized; this is particularly important in contin-
gency situations or in developing countries, when families buckets or containers for
water storage are not very clean.
Other treatments as ozonization and especially ultraviolet irradiation can be very
effective at the delivery point but leave no residual disinfection capacity.
The process of sodium hypochlorite electrochemical production in situ has
several advantages in supporting rural developing communities if compared with
processes such as chlorination by gaseous chlorine or concentrated hypochlorite
solution.
Hypochlorite generation solves some of the problems associated with the avail-
ability of imported products. Moreover, it allows to avoid the hazards in case
of accidents during transportation by trains and trucks, both those associated
with the storage of gaseous chlorine and those related to the handling of such
chemicals.
Commercial chlorine compounds, Ca(ClO)2 tablets, and NaOCl bleach are
characterized by high concentrations in order to reduce transport and storage costs;
particularly in case of high temperatures, the stability of the solution decreases as
the available chlorine content increases.
Hypochlorite generation overcomes the instability of commercial disinfectants,
since it has a lower chlorine concentration and is produced on a daily basis (Khelifa
et al. 2004; Khouzam 2000; Kraft et al. 1999).
Anyway, even though hypochlorite solutions are less hazardous than those
employing chlorine gases, utmost precaution should be adopted in order to avoid
contact with skin and to protect containers against physical damages, given the high
concentration of the solutions.
Before using active chlorine, the content should be checked due to the reduction
of strength occurring during the storage phase.
Installation of OSEC system means:
• Continuous supply of reliable disinfectant
• Increased autonomy for local population
• Employment of local skills for managing the process of chlorination
• Independence from foreign importation of chemical agents.
Then, the most appropriate system for the production of chlorine in an isolated
environment and emergency situation, such as the Gaza Strip, was the OSEC system
122 A. Micangeli et al.
(MK4CM model), produced in Italy and assembled on site with the help of the local
partners (PHG and the Municipality of Umm Al-Nasser); villagers have been trained
in its use and maintenance.
The Treated Waste Water Filtration System (TWWFS) used until 2006 in the
community of Umm Al-Nasser is very simple and consists of few component parts
(see Fig. 9.3).
The water was extracted from the lake through a 20-m-long pipe and connected
to an electric centrifugal pump, prevalence of 30 m, capable of a range of more than
200 m3 /day. The suction head of the pipeline was abandoned on a raft, at a sufficient
depth to avoid any aspiration of sand. Furthermore, on the head a protective grating
was placed to avoid clogging due to bulk solids.
From the pump, the water was sent directly to the purification system, consisting
of two filters in series: the first a sand filter with a porosity made up of silica particles
with diameters ranging between 1.5 and 5 mm, the second a double plastic disk filter.
Once being filtered, water went through a PVC pipe about 800 feet long and 6 in.
in diameter to reach the fields to be irrigated.
The main pipe, located underground, was divided into many sub-pipelines,
located underground, from which there were pipes ending with a diameter of 16 mm
and discharging water into a basin of about 8 m2 . A plant diagram is shown in
Fig. 9.4. This water was available for irrigation.
The water coming out of this plant presented problems in terms of amount of
suspended solids and coliform bacteria, because no disinfection was provided in
the purification cycle.
Chemical and physical water analysis were made from 2003 to 2006 with a
frequency of three times per year. These tests showed a gradual worsening over time.
Table 9.1 shows the main parameters not covered in the international standards
which render the water unusable and hazardous to health: the 5-day biochemical
oxygen demand (BOD5) and chemical oxygen demand (BOD) tests are a measure
of the relative oxygen-depletion effect of a waste contaminant, the total suspended
solids (TSS) is the mass of dried solid remaining on the filter (Passino 1995).
As it can be seen the number of total fecal and E. coli coliforms, pathogen
indicators, have a very high value. Data concerning the chemical analysis of water
for the period from 2003 to 2006 show a deterioration of water quality mainly due
to the multiplication of colonies of coliform bacteria, which cannot be folded down
using a simple filtering system, as it is the case for BOD and suspended solids.
1: Treatment plant
9 Chlorine Self-Production Plant Solution
20 metri
Terreno
800 metri
Fig. 9.4 Diagram of the TWWFS water treatment plant in the Umm Al-Nasser area
The water coming out from the plant, elusively treated by filtration, presented
problems in terms of suspended solids and coliform bacteria because no disinfection
was provided in the purification cycle. In fact, the plant was capable to remove
40–50% of BOD and 50–70% of total suspended solids.
In the framework of this project, a new area for grazing was defined and with the
technical contribution of CIRPS and PHG (Palestinian Hydrology Group) the water
treatment plant was renewed. Two new filters were installed and a chlorine self-
production plant was installed for an appropriate disinfection of the treated water to
be used in irrigation (Fig. 9.5).
An area of grassland of 35 Dunum was created on land belonging to the
Palestinian Authority, run by the Municipality of Umm Al-Nasser, divided into
blocks by 1 Dunum each and managed by 35 different families in the village. The
land was cultivated with alfalfa seeds and harvest collected twice a provided fodder
for animals at 10 days per block (see Fig. 9.6). The entire community has benefited
from the overall project.
Through the construction and renovation of the plant filtration it was possible to
filter up to 100 m3 per day and a new system for disinfection was added.
The device used is an OSEC (On Site Electro Chlorination) designed to provide
a solution of sodium hypochlorite (NaClO) in continuous mode from salt water.
Chlorination is necessary to reduce or destroy the presence of pathogens in the
9 Chlorine Self-Production Plant Solution 125
water and the disinfection of the water with plain chlorine helps to permanently
standardize the sewage treated at healthy levels.
There is no impact of chlorination on the soil or the groundwater, because the
amount of brackish water required for the system is small (100 m3 /day) and can be
126 A. Micangeli et al.
OSEC Device
Hypochlorite
transportation
Storage
20 metres
P.D.
Land
800 metres
Fig. 9.7 Diagram of the renewed water treatment plant in the Umm Al-Nasser area
stored in small tanks near the system. Water is electrolyzed to obtain completely
sodium hypochlorite and hydrogen, the first used in the disinfection process and the
second developed without impact on the slopes.
The release of sodium hypochlorite in the pipeline takes place through a metering
pump from a storage tank, located in the same environment of the filters.
For security reasons the OSEC device was placed in the Municipality, in a
suitable environment, making it necessary to transport the tanks of the solution.
A schematic diagram of the system taking into account the changes implemented
is shown in Fig. 9.7.
After the application of electric current to the electrodes begins the oxidation and
reduction, respectively, of:
Sodium, present near the cathode in the form of ion, binds to the hydroxyl group
(OH) to form sodium hydroxide (NaOH), which reacts with chlorine gas (Cl2 ) as
sodium hypochlorite.
So, at room temperature, the process occurring in the cell can be summarized
with the following expression:
Usually, this reaction is immediate and the development of chlorine gas is very
low. The hydrogen gas produced can be recovered in order to use it in one or more
fuel cells. The energy produced by such cells can be used to reduce the energy
consumption of the production of sodium hypochlorite or for other purposes.
The gas is ejected into the atmosphere in small quantities and the sodium
hypochlorite is pumped into a collection tank.
The output from the cells to the collector on top of the cell is fed to a sprinkler on
top of the cooling tower (see diagram in Fig.9.8). From there, the solution falls down
to the base of the tower and is cooled by an upward air flow from a blower. At the
base of the tower, a second pump feeds the hypochlorite solution (recirculation),
through a flow meter, back again to the electrolytic cell. This cooling action is
necessary considering that each cell dissipates approximately 250 W.
9
4
1 3
2 11
5 10
1; 000
Amount of treated water (L/h) D amount of chlorine produced (g/h)
FAC.mg=L/
The release of sodium hypochlorite in the pipeline (Fig. 9.10), containing the
wastewater for field irrigation, is also done by the pump from a storage tank and
occurs in succession to the filter system.
The turbulent flow in pipes instauration means that the wastewater is filtered and
the disinfectant are mixed in a nearly uniform way: This mixture will be the final
solution of the system.
Chemical and physical water analysis were performed to test the efficiency of
the treatment plant, as shown in Table 9.2, demonstrating the correct operation of
disinfection.
130
DOSING PUMP
9 Chlorine Self-Production Plant Solution
HYPOCHLORITE
STORAGE TANK
Fig. 9.10 Release of chlorine in the pipeline (picture and outline made on site)
131
132 A. Micangeli et al.
The only maintenance necessary regards the formation of scale deposits (calcium
carbonate) in the electrolytic cell and on its outlet piping.
During electrolysis at the cathode, the calcium salts (bicarbonate and sulfate)
become insoluble (due to high pH) and precipitate forming a solid deposit on the
cathode. The polarity reversal produces a dissolution of this deposit (at the anode
the pH is acidic). In this way the electrode is maintained clean, but part of this
precipitate flows into the outlet piping of the electrolytic cell and, if in large quantity,
could cause a possible obstruction to the liquid flow.
The maintenance consists in checking the scale formation in the outlet pipes of
the electrolytic cell, which are transparent. To eliminate the scale there is a two-step
procedure:
1. The electrolytic cell power supply has to be turned off and, leaving the pumps
running, the whole system should be flushed with some unsalted water in order
to eliminate any hypochlorite solution in the system.
2. After this a 5% solution of hydrochloric acid (about 10 L) should be prepared
and flushed through the whole system until the scale deposits disappear. Before
being operated again, the system should be flushed with clean water and then
with some brine.
The frequency of this operation depends on the water hardness. With a medium
hardness of 8–15ıF (French degrees), the frequency could be once every 15 days–
1 month.
In case of hard to very hard water (15ı F to >30ı F), this operation becomes too
frequent and time consuming. In this case, it is suggested to install a commercial
water softener unit that eliminates any scale problem.
9 Chlorine Self-Production Plant Solution 133
In the first part of the project, local technicians took an entry survey in order to test
their knowledge of chlorination and OSEC.
During the course, each piece of the unit was explained through theory and
practical examples on how to assemble the unit to make the technicians aware of
its complexity.
Once the unit was assembled, the first analysis results showed that the plant was
working properly.
Participants could see the plant working and various investigations on the treated
water and free residual chlorine were carried out.
The Team discussed with the beneficiaries on some technical specification such
as electrolytic cells, equivalent chlorine production, other chlorine concentrations,
brine composition and salt consumption, sodium hypochlorite storage, power
supply, and scale protection.
The Team discussed with the technicians and water managers about the OSEC’s
usage (Fig. 9.11).
The Team discussed OSEC Plant maintenance problems and organization of the
work to be done.
Then the participants were given time to answer specific questions. The techni-
cian took the impact text and SOTU test (Survey on technology users) at the end of
the lesson.
The global access to water, underlying its importance, was showed to the 35
beneficiaries of the grazing area in Umm Al-Nasser village. The beneficiaries were
interviewed to understand the situation of water access in the Umm Al-Nasser
village. Some relevant pictures were showed to the public in order to introduce the
following questions:
• From where do you bring water? From which kind of sources? Who brings water?
• How much water do you use for domestic use?
• How much water do you use for drinking, eating or cooking?
• Where do you store water at home?
• Do you clean water tank? How many times in a week?
• How do you preserve water well or pipes?
• Do you think that certain diseases are caused by lack of water?
• Do you think that certain diseases are transmitted by dirty water?
• Are food cases utilized only for this purpose?
• Are water tanks utilized only for this purpose?
• Which kind of latrines are available?
• Where do you wash your clothes?
The main features for recognizing a drinking water were exposed to them:
• Chemical characteristic: rubbish contamination
• Physical characteristics: temperature and being without solid material
• Microbiological characteristics: fecal contamination
• Organoleptic characteristics: odorless and colorless
A certain kind of rudimental filters that people can easily build without any
technical tools or knowledge, such as sand filters, candle filters, cloth filters, and
porous stone filters, were introduced to them.
Acknowledgments
References
R.L. Droste, Theory and Practice of Water and Wastewater Treatment, 1st edn. (Wiley Text Books,
New York, 1996)
S. Esposto, The sustainability of applied technologies for water supply in developing countries.
Technol. soc. 31(3), 257–262 (August, 2009). http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.techsoc.2009.06.009
S. Esposto, A. Micangeli, S. Grego, Sustainable water treatment and chlorine production in
emergency conditions in South Iraq (MARRAKECH, MOROCCO May 30–June 3, 2004,
EuroMed 2004, Desalination 165c, 2004), pp. 123–132
S. Esposto, On-site electro-chlorination application for water treatment in North Iraq (Water
Science & Technology: Water Supply -WSTWS 9.4, 2009)
R. Foster, Clean water renewables, in Village Power (Southwest Technology Development Institute
College of Engineering, New Mexico State University, Las Cruces, 2000)
N. Iannuzzo, A. Dell’Era, S. Tuzzi, A., Micangeli, Hydrogen recovery for the self-sufficiency of a
PV powered On Site Electro Chlorination system (International Conference on Applied Energy,
Perugia, Italy, 2011)
A. Khelifa, S. Moulay, F. Hannane, S. Benslimene, M. Hecini, Application of an experimental
design method to study the performance of electrochlorination cells. Desalination 160, 9l–98
(2004)
K.Y. Khouzam, Demonstration of photovoltaic powered salt water chlorination system for
swimming pools (Queensland University of Technology School of Electrical and Electronic
Systems Engineering, Brisbane, 2000)
A. Kraft, M. Stadelmann, M. Blaschke, D. Kreysig, B. Sandt, F. Schroèder, Electrochemical water
disinfection. J. Appl. Electrochem. 29, 861–868 (1999)
D. Lantagne, P. Oates, N. van Zyl, Point-of-use water filtration in rural Haiti (MIT Environmental
Engineering, MIT Media Lab Development by Design Conference, Cambridge, 2001), http://
www.thinkcycle.org. Accessed July, 2001.
S.M. Oussedik, Demineralization of brackish water at albien well “Aı̈n Sahara” for portable water
supply for touggourt city, Desalination 137(1–3), 103–111 (2001)
R. Luff, Oxfam Water Supply Scheme for Emergencies – Coagulation and Disinfection (Oxfam
Technical Manual, Oxfam Humanitarian Department, Oxford, UK, 2001a)
R. Luff, Oxfam Water Supply Scheme for Emergencies – Filtration, (Oxfam Technical Manual
2001, Oxfam Humanitarian Department, Oxford, UK, 2001b)
R. Passino, Manuale di conduzione degli impianti di depurazione delle acque (Zanichelli/ESAC,
Milano, 1995)
A. Porteous (ed.), Desalination technology. Dev. Bull. Electrochem. 12, 327–328 (1996)
R. Semiat, Water Int. 25, 54–65 (2000). Res. Bull. 10, l–10 (1993)
P.A. Wilderer, Sustainable water resource management: the science behind the scene. Sustain.
Sci. (2007). doi:10.1007/s11625–007–0022–0 Integrated Research System for Sustainability
Science and Springer (2007)
World Health Organization, Guidelines for Drinking-Water Quality, 4th edn. (World Health
Organization, Geneva, 2011) ISBN 978 92 4 154815 1
http://www.severntrentdenora.com
www.aquaclor.net
Fundamental Toxicology Methods and
Resources for Assessing Water-related 10
Contamination
Keith R. Cooper
Abstract
This chapter provides a brief overview of basic toxicological methods and
approaches which can be used by engineers in the field to make a rapid
environmental risk determination. In addition, Internet sites which deal with
specific contaminants, standard operating procedures, and methods for assessing
deleterious effects on organisms living and depending on ecosystem resources
are provided.
1 Introduction
K.R. Cooper
Department of Biochemistry & Microbiology, Rutgers, The State University of NJ,
New Brunswick, New Jersey, USA
e-mail: cooper@aesop.rutgers.edu
Fig. 10.1 Worldwide population density map (Map Source: Center for International Earth Science
Information Network) and water severity areas (arrows)
United States (300 million), Indonesia (240 million), and Brazil (200 million). Water
sustainability is driven by having sufficient quantities of usable water to maintain
human needs, crop irrigation, livestock, and ecologically important animals and
plants. The density of a population also can result in threats to sustainability of
local and regional resources (Fig. 10.1). Water usage is directly related to population
density, agriculture, and ecosystem needs, and if demand outstrips supply then the
ecosystem is not sustainable.
Water is essential for all life and both chemical and biological contaminants from
both natural and anthropogenic sources can dramatically limit the suitability of
water for human, animal, and plants. It is important to realize that local actions
(eutrophication, overfishing, altered food types, industrialization, and fossil fuel
usage) can impact water and water-related resources both locally and in some cases
on a worldwide basis. The interconnectivity is due to the sharing of the air sheds,
watershed, and oceans. The ramifications of economic prosperity, unfettered indus-
trialization, and increased dependence on fossil fuels without proper environmental
controls and regulations can result in both local and international water supplies
becoming contaminated. The health and well-being of humans and all other species
is inseparable from the health and well-being of the world ecosystems (Edwards
2005). Human beings have the responsibility to maintain the quality of water,
air, and soil to enhance the well-being for all species (The Netherlands National
Environmental Policy). For any successful sustainable program there are Four E’s:
Ecological sustainability, Economic sustainability, Equitable resource allocation,
and Education of the population. All of these concepts need to be included in any
sustainable engineering approach that will be successful over the long term. If any
of the Four E’s is not met, then long-term sustainability is unlikely. Therefore, it is
essential that novel engineering approaches be developed to remove both biological
and chemical contamination, as well as recycle water and limit natural resource
damage.
10 Fundamental Toxicology Methods and Resources 139
Airshed
Long and Short Range Transport
Volatile Compounds
Suspended Particles & PRECIPITATION
Volatile Compounds
Watershed
BIOTIC FACTORS
Humans, Animals, Plants & Microbes
EROSION &
DIRECT DISCHARGE
Fig. 10.2 Pathways for contaminant movement (arrows) between the abiotic matrices comprising
the ecosystem. Biotic factors can modify fate and transport of contaminants within an ecosystem
by increasing or decreasing bioavailability
This chapter provides a brief tutorial on basic toxicological concepts, tools, and
information that are important for an engineer to be aware of when determining the
suitability of a treatment process or the threats to a community or its ecosystem.
This chapter provides a brief overview of both human and ecological toxicolog-
ical approaches and standard sample collection methods. These topics are too
expansive to be adequately covered in a single chapter; therefore, references
to additional resources are provided throughout the text and within Table 10.1.
140 K.R. Cooper
Table 10.1 Listing of standard operating procedures (SOPs) and other resources used in toxico-
logical assessments from various government agencies
Agency Information available
WHO: IPCS WHO works to establish the scientific basis for the safe use of chemicals,
and to strengthen national capabilities and capacities for chemical safety.
http://www.who.int/ipcs/en/
USEPA Emergency SOPs for sampling air, water, sediment, and soil along with specific
Response Team methods for analysis: general field sampling, sampling equipment
decontamination, general air sampling, surface water sampling,
groundwater well sampling, sediment sampling, and soil sampling. www.
ert.org
USEPA: NCEA The mission of NCEA is to provide guidance about how pollutants may
impact our health and the environment. The compound of interest can be
searched to see if a review has been carried out. http://www.epa.gov/
ncea/index.htm
USEPA Duluth, ECOTOX database released in 2000 by the USEPA and managed by the
Minnesota USEPA Duluth laboratory has extensive ecological data both for
terrestrial and aquatic species. http://www.epa.gov/ecotox/ecotox home.
htm
US National Park Environmental Contaminants Encyclopedia, Ed. Roy Irwin Discussing
Service www.nature.nps.gov/hazardssafety/toxic//
NOAA (USA) NOAA Status and Trends and Mussel Watch. http://ccma.nos.noaa.gov/
and UN about/coast/nsandt/welcome.html and International Mussel Watch. http://
ccma.nos.noaa.gov/stressors/pollution/assessments/as intl mw study.
html
Syracuse Research Chemical, physical, and fate data on specific compounds PHYSPROP
Corp. (USA) and BIOLOG for microbial degradation database
http://srcinc.com/what-we-do/efdb.aspx
Oak Ridge National Ecological Risk Analysis: Guidance, Tools and Applications (www.esd.
Laboratory ornl.gov/programs/ecorisk/ecorisk.html)
ATSDR (USA) Provides individual chemical Toxicological Profiles (www.atsdr.cdc.gov/)
ATSDR Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry, ICPS International Programme
on Chemical Safety, NCEA National Center for Environmental Assessment, NOAA National
Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration, USEPA United States Environmental Protection
Agency, WHO World Health Organization
The approaches described in this section are standard operating procedures (SOPs)
used in toxicology assessments and will be useful in designing assessment protocols
at any location. The sampling protocols are from a number of different government
agencies and are listed in Table 10.1. Depending on the availability of resources, the
SOPs can be modified to allow for some level of assessment with the understanding
that the robustness of the results could be affected. The country in which an
engineer is working may have SOPs that are available through the Environmental
Ministry or comparable industries. It is important to realize that rules and regulations
promulgated in highly developed countries for individual contaminants may not
be appropriate or achievable for less developed countries since the relative risks
from different pathogens or starvation may far out way the risks from an individual
contaminant. There are a number of USEPA Web sites with specific compound
10 Fundamental Toxicology Methods and Resources 141
ecosystem can be impacted both by physical parameters and COCs. Because of this
fact the EPA’s (1992) Framework for Ecological Risk Assessment includes “stressor
response” which would include physical parameters as do later EPA documents
(USEPA 1993, 1995, 1997a, b, 1998). The classic example of this is the effect
of pH in freshwater systems and the loss of species dependent on pH tolerances.
These physical parameters are easily measured and should be incorporated into any
monitoring plan, since they have profound effects on COCs’ bioavailability and
uptake (Rand et al. 1995; Schwarzenbach et al. 2003).
The selection of the animals and plants to be used in the risk assessment will be in
some cases site specific. Generally, there will be both terrestrial and aquatic species
and associated toxicity data used for determining which, if any, COCs pose a hazard.
The selected species may also be used as indicator species that can be collected and
analyzed for COCs. The sampling may be done to determine if COCs are reaching
elevated levels. This will also allow for COC trends to be developed. Samples of
10 Fundamental Toxicology Methods and Resources 143
water, soil, sediment, and air may be collected in concert or as independent samples
to establish reference or baseline levels. In many locations, there is no plan in place.
High volume air samples and semipermeable membrane water and soil samples
could be added if grab samples would not be able to detect COCs (Huckins 2002;
Petty et al. 2000; Sun et al. 2008).
Pollutants can enter an ecosystem through both human activities and from naturally
occurring processes (weathering of rocks, volcanic activity, and others). While
knowledge of sources will give you important information on the type of con-
taminants your environment might be exposed to, the concentration or dose of a
compound will dictate the response observed in the wild (Crane and Newman 2000).
As all toxicologists know “The Dose Makes the Poison” and once this level has
been exceeded, toxicity will be observed (Di Giulio and Newman 2008; Eaton and
Gilbert 2008). In all of the different matrices (surface and groundwater, sediments,
and terrestrial soil), there are both point and nonpoint sources of contamination.
Ecosystems are impacted from contamination contributed from atmospheric, terres-
trial, and aquatic sources (Suter 1993, 1998). Below is a brief description of sources
of contaminants entering into the different media and illustrated in Fig. 10.2.
The conceptual diagram shown in Fig. 10.3 illustrates the requirement that the
chemical can be bound or in a free state during exposure. Generally if the compound
is sequestered on a particle or other organic material, it is not available to be taken
up by an organism since the compound must be free to be able to be transported
across a biological membrane. A number of factors, such as charge and size, as well
as others, can determine whether a compound will be taken up by an organism. The
free compound must diffuse or be transported across the membrane. Once inside
the cell, the compound can be metabolized, stored, or excreted. If the compound
reaches a target tissue where it causes toxicity at sufficient concentration then
sublethal or lethal effects may be observed (Lehman-McKeeman 2008) (Fig. 10.4).
The physical/chemical environments in which they exist can dramatically alter the
chemical species which is available for accumulation (Spacie et al. 1995; Sprague
1985). These general principles apply to organic compounds as well as metallic
compounds (USEPA 2007).
Atmospheric contamination can enter the terrestrial soil and surface waters
through precipitation (wet deposition) or from suspended particulates (dry deposi-
tion) (Loganathan and Kannan 1994; Scheringer 2009). There can be a contribution
from both the terrestrial soil compartment and the surface water compartment into
the atmosphere via particle suspension and volatilization processes. The contamina-
tion of the terrestrial soil from atmospheric deposition or from crustal compounds
(background) can flow into the surface waters and end up in suspension or
depositing on the bottom as sediment. Groundwater can become contaminated from
compounds leaching into the groundwater (Burgess et al. 2010). Surface waters
can also contaminate groundwater when they are in direct contact (e.g., saltwater
intrusion) or as the groundwater is being recharged. Groundwater contamination
144 K.R. Cooper
M
E
M
B
R
A
Bound to N Metabolism, Storage or
Particle Free E Excretion
Fig. 10.3 Conceptual diagram for evaluating bioavailability to organisms from a compound (suns)
present in the environment in a bound (NOT BIOAVAILABLE) and free state (BIOAVAILABLE)
for exposure, uptake across the biological membrane resulting in bioaccumulation within the
organism, and subsequent internal transport and distribution
can reach surface waters in the basal flow of rivers and through seeps. The ability
of a compound to move between these different compartments is determined by
the physical/chemical properties of the individual compound. Biotic factors can
result in modifying the amount of a COC that could be released from any of
these compartments. Regional point sources (cities, superfund sites, and industrial
activity) of contamination can result in contamination spreading into several of these
compartments.
The movement of contaminants through the different matrices and ultimately into
plants and animals (environmental fate) is determined by the physical characteristics
of the compound (molecular weight, lipophilicity, chemical species) and that of
the environmental compartment it is entering (Fig. 10.4). Bioavailability is an
important concept that determines what levels of specific compounds will be present
in the biota inhabiting contaminated and noncontaminated environments (Birak
et al. 2001; Rand et al. 1995). Bioavailability is determined by many factors that
determine how much of the compound or metal is in a free state that can be taken
up by an organism or plant. Physical/chemical properties of the matrix into which a
compound is associated and the properties of the surrounding medium will affect the
level of compound that is free to be taken up by the organism. Factors such as pH,
total organic carbon, and acid volatile sulfides can dramatically effect the uptake of
a compound (DiToro et al. 1990). A full discussion of release from a specific matrix
10 Fundamental Toxicology Methods and Resources 145
100
LOAEL
Percent Response
50
NOEL
LC 50 = 40 mg/L
0
10 50 100
DOSE mg/L
Fig. 10.4 Dose-response curve with no observed effect level (NOEL). Lowest observed adverse
effect level (NOAEL) and LC50 indicated on the graph
which a compound can be broken down in the environment (e.g., hydrolysis, auto-
oxidation, photolysis, and enzymatic biotransformation). The rate of breakdown
of a compound will determine the half-life in any particular medium (Newman
and Unger 2003). Persistent organic pollutants (POPs) are generally recalcitrant to
physical, chemical, and biochemical transformation (e.g., PFOA/PFOS, DDT/DDE,
PCBs, and 2,3,7,8-sustituted dioxins). However, in some instance, metabolism (e.g.,
Benzo(a)pyrene, dieldrin) and photolysis (e.g., petroleum hydrocarbons) can result
in activation of a compound to reactive chemical species that can result in cellular
transformation leading to cancer, developmental effect, or acute toxicity.
Metals are nonbiodegradable and do not breakdown in a similar fashion to
organic compounds in the environment (Faustman and Omenn 2008). Metals can
exist as multiple converting species that are determined by the environmental
chemistry of the medium they are located in. In the case of metal contaminants,
they also are persistent and their ionization state will affect their residence time
and transport within the environment (USEPA 2007). USEPA’s Framework for
Metal Risk Assessment (http://www.epa.gov/osa/metalsframework) is a document
that discusses in great detail each of these issues and should be referred to when
dealing with metal risk assessments (USEPA 2007). In the case of mercury, the
metabolism to methyl mercury results in at least one bioavailable and toxic form of
the metal. The presence of other metals such as selenium can antagonize the uptake
of mercurial species (Dang and Wang 2011). Metals that are deposited onto the soil
or into sediment can have very long residence times and may become mineralized
and not biologically available. It is important to note that geological deposits,
and the earth’s crust, are comprised of a number of metals that contribute to the
general background concentrations for a specific region even without anthropogenic
contributions. Background levels of metals in the earth’s crust are summarized
in Table 10.2. Background metal concentrations can vary over several orders of
magnitude based on the soil type, geography, and other factors. Additional sources
of regional and state soil metal levels can be obtained from U.S. EPA ecological soil
screening levels (EcoSSLs) document (USEPA 2003). Site-specific assessments will
require gathering information on naturally occurring levels and the metals potential
to impact flora, wildlife, and humans. A good case study of human activities and
geochemistry is the arsenic levels present in Bangladesh that has contaminated
groundwater supplies and is a major health issue (Burgess et al. 2010).
2.1.1 Atmospheric
The air shed that overlies a watershed can contribute large quantities of contam-
inants that are associated with particle deposition, gases, or as dissolved in rain
or snow. The sources of contamination can be from both local and long distance
transport. Incineration of waste and production of energy using coal and other
sources can contribute to atmospheric contamination. Other sources include internal
combustion engines, pesticide use on production agriculture, and volatile organic
compounds that are used in refrigerants, solvents, and industrial processes. The
magnitude of toxic chemical releases that may occur on a yearly basis into the
atmosphere is often not appreciated, nor the resident time that these contaminants
have in the atmosphere (Loganathan and Kannan 1994). From anthropogenic
10 Fundamental Toxicology Methods and Resources 147
sources it is estimated that 6 billion tons of CO2; 100 million tons of SOx , 68 million
tons of NOx , and 1.1 million tons of chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) are released.
Regional and local sources often contribute to higher local concentrations and
corresponding higher concentrations entering surface water, soils, and biota.
2.1.2 Soil
Contamination of soil can occur through deliberate contamination from dump-
ing of industrial and municipal wastes (metals, organic compound radioactive
material), direct application of pesticides or herbicides, application of sewage
sludge (heavy metals, nitrates, phosphates, detergents) and other soil amendments,
and atmospheric deposition of long- and short-range contaminants (metals, sulfur
dioxide, nitrogen oxides, dioxins, and furans and other organic compounds). The
soil characteristics (organic content, buffering capacity) can affect the fate of the
contaminants deposited on the soil and their impact on flora and fauna (Travis and
Arms 1988). Erosion of soils is one of the major means by which contaminated
soils can reach surface waters and also contribute to sediment contamination.
Because watersheds represent large drainage basins, upstream soil contamination
can impact downstream water and sediment quality, as it is deposited at the
mouth of the rivers and bays or simply deposited in a slow moving portion of
a stream. In many instances, soil acceptable levels of contamination are based
on human and or terrestrial wildlife risk assessments and exposure is assessed
differently for terrestrial pathways. But those same concentrations in soils, when
deposited into aquatic systems, can cause deleterious effects to aquatic organisms.
In some instances, studies indicate aquatic organisms are more sensitive to certain
compounds in sediments, when the same level in soils would not elicit a response in
terrestrial organisms.
For metals, it must be recognized that they naturally occur in the earth’s crust
and represent nonanthropogenic background levels (Table 10.2). The values in this
table allow for a quick reference benchmark for comparison to a soil sample. It
should be emphasized that these are just general numbers and regional background
levels should be consulted. Background levels can be directly compared to collected
samples to determine if the collected samples are significantly higher and could
indicate a local source. The actual concentrations would then have to be examined to
see if the levels are at a toxic threshold level or higher. This result would determine
what actions might be taken.
2.1.4 Sediment
Particulates can be either suspended in the water column and or deposited along
the bottoms of rivers, estuaries, and depositional areas (sediments) in the ocean.
Sediment originates from the contribution of soil washing into the surface waters
and from breakdown of organic matter in the receiving waters. Sediment can become
contaminated from land sources, as well as from contaminants that accumulate in
organisms and or adhere to the sediment from the water column (Fig. 10.4). The
physical and chemical characteristics of the sediment will influence the amount
of contamination. Sediments with high organic content and or charge will have
elevated levels of organic and metals, respectively. The smaller the particle size, the
greater the surface area to volume ratio and the higher the contaminant enrichment.
Therefore, sediments with large grain size containing mainly sand will have little or
no metals or organic contaminants associated with them. Sediment particle size also
influences contaminant bioavailability both from physical/chemical characteristics
and an organism’s size-specific particle selection. Bioavailability can be reduced
in clay and silt sediments compared to coarser sediments. Thus when conducting
sediment analyses, it is important to evaluate both grain size and total organic carbon
(TOC) in order to assess your contaminant results effectively.
(Problem Formulation and Analysis Phase) will affect the extent and uncertainty
of the Risk Characterization that can be made and what management options are
available. There is a need to follow up on any action that is taken to determine if the
chemical effects are remaining the same, improving, or declining.
In aquatic ecosystems where the main route of exposure is through the water
column, then the BCF is an appropriate means to estimate body burdens. If food,
abiotic media, and ambient water concentrations are important exposure routes, then
(10.2) should be used to calculate the BAF. In the case of terrestrial organisms BCFs
and BAFs can also be calculated, but require more detailed information (Sample and
Suter 1994; Sample et al. 1996; Suter 1993). In the majority of cases, the BAF (10.2)
is the appropriate value to be calculated for terrestrial wildlife.
10 Fundamental Toxicology Methods and Resources 151
The approach follows closely that proposed by Suter (1993). In the first tier, a
screening assessment is performed where concentrations of contaminants in the
environment are compared to a no observed adverse effect level (NOAEL)–based
toxicological benchmarks. These benchmarks represent concentrations of chemicals
(i.e., concentrations presumed to be nonhazardous to the biota) in environmental
media (water, sediment, soil, food, etc.) that should not result in an adverse effect.
One of the principal sources for the values that are used for this calculation is the
NOAA Screening Quick Reference Tables (SQuiRT), which are available online
at (response.restoration.noaa.gov/book shelf/122 squirt cards.pdf) for reference. If
site-specific values or more recent literature based information is available, then
152 K.R. Cooper
these values can be used for screening purposes. Within the NOAA SQuiRT tables
are background levels for inorganic (p. 2) and organic compounds (pp. 5–8) in
freshwater and marine sediments, fresh and saline surface water and ground water.
These tables also give different effect levels: threshold effects levels (TEL), probable
effects level (PEL), and effect range medium (ERM) which provide increasing levels
of effect. This document also contains two tables summarizing specific extraction
and detection methods for inorganic trace elements (p. 9) and organic compounds
(p. 10) and a summary table listing appropriate containers for each analyte,
preservation methods, maximum holding times, and required sample size (p. 11).
Tables 10.3 and 10.4 are quick references for matrix and acceptable methods and
holding times and storage parameters.
In practice, when contaminant concentrations in food, water, soil, and sediment
resources are less than the threshold toxicological benchmarks, the contaminants
may be excluded from further consideration Buchman (1999). As stated above, this
assumes no additive or synergistic effects from similar contaminants. The PEL and
ERM values allow for comparison to the increasing likelihood of an effect on the
biota. In the case of sediment values, the levels are provided both for freshwater
and marine sediments for inorganic and organic compounds sampled by NOAA.
Another source for freshwater sediment screening values is MacDonald et al.
(2000). To determine which contaminants pose a risk, an HQ is calculated, where
HQ D media concentration/benchmark. If the HQ 1, contaminant concentrations
are sufficiently high that they may produce adverse effects. This basically means that
the concentration observed in the environment is greater than or equal to a threshold
or known effects level (i.e., PEL or ERM) and there is an increased likelihood of
that compound may have an adverse effect on the organism and warrant further
investigation. An HQ < 1 means there is no risk based on the laboratory derived
values.
Example Calculation:
Values in ppb (ug/Kg) dry weight.
Arsenic would be considered a chemical of concern since it was above the TEL
value. If the PEL and ERM had HQ > 1, the detected concentration would indicate a
probability of increasing toxic responses to benthic organisms. Scientific judgment
needs to be exercised when multiple compounds of similar mechanisms of toxicity
10 Fundamental Toxicology Methods and Resources 153
Table 10.4 Summary of collection and holding requirements based on analyte and specimen
Analytical Container type and
parameter Matrixa volumeb Preservation Holding times
Pest/PCB S 8 oz glass 500g 4ı C 7/40 days
TAL metals S 8 oz glass 10–100g 4ı C 6 months
TAL metals XE 8 oz glass 10–100g 0ı C 6 months
Pest/PCB XE 8 oz glass 10–100g 0ı C 7/40 days
Pest/PCB XM Foil/Ziploc 500g 0ı C 7/40 days
TAL metals XM Foil/Ziploc 100g 0ı C 6 months
Pest/PCB SD 8 oz glass 500g 4ı C 7/40 days
TAL metals SD 4 oz glass 100g 4ı C 6 months
Pest/PCB XF Foil/Ziploc 500g 0ı C 7/40 days
TAL metals XF Foil/Ziploc 500g 0ı C 6 months
Pest/PCB XI Foil/Ziploc 100g 0ı C 7/40 days
TAL metals XI Foil/Ziploc 100g 0ı C 6 months
Pest/PCB W 1 L amber 1,000 mL 4ı C 7/40 days
TAL metals W 1 L poly 1,000 mL 4ı C 6 months
Lipids X Foil/Ziploc 1–10g NA 7 days
Grain size S,SD 32 oz glass 10–1,000g NA NA
TOC S,SD 8 oz glass 1–10g 4ı C 28 days
a
Matrix: S soil, W water, SD sediment, XE earthworm tissue, XF forage fish, XI invertebrate,
X animal lipids, XM mammal
b
The container type is indicated but the amount needed is determined by the selected analytical
technique and anticipated concentration level. The values listed in the table are recommendations,
and actual amounts should be discussed with the analytical laboratory carrying out the analysis.
The amounts collected can change the detection limit for each analyte
154 K.R. Cooper
may be present in a sample or another factor may result in greater sensitivity of the
organism to a contaminant.
Therefore, if the concentration of a contaminant exceeds a benchmark, HQ 1
that contaminant should be retained as a contaminant of concern (COC).
Conversely, if the HQ < 1, the contaminant would not be retained as a COC.
In the case where there is only LD50 data, either examine the slope of the line
and extrapolate to the x-axis or apply a larger uncertainty factor (100 or 1,000) to
estimate the value. The difficulty with extrapolating from these values is that the
degree of uncertainty is greatly increased, but if no other value exists it may be the
only alternative to estimate whether a contaminant potentially poses a risk.
The presentation of toxicity data on an mg/kg body weight (BW)/day basis allows
comparisons to the calculated levels for a particular species of interest. If the levels
that are calculated exceed the LOAEL, then the levels in these matrices would pose
a hazard to that particular species and be considered a COC. When calculating
these values, care must be taken to convert any dry weight concentrations to wet
weight by applying the appropriate water content values for specific prey species
or determined by the analytical laboratory at the time of analysis. The USEPA has
developed a benchmark dose approach (BMD) to provide a more quantified method
for determining critical points along the dose-response curve. A more detailed
description and a computer model can be viewed and downloaded at http://www.
epa.gov/ncea/bmds.htm.
10 Fundamental Toxicology Methods and Resources 155
Trophic level evaluation is not required for all compounds, because there are certain
characteristics which preclude biomagnification up the food web. Compounds
that are rapidly metabolized, are poorly absorbed from the gastrointestinal track
or epidermis, or are rapidly eliminated generally need not be examined in a
trophic model. In these cases, the compound can be compared to the LOAEL for
determining if the concentrations are above a threshold of concern (as described
in the previous section). In the case of trophic level evaluations, the organism
being impacted is through direct contact with environmental matrices and through
their food sources (bioaccumulation). Therefore, when calculating the daily intake
of a compound, the sources of the contaminants include the following: water,
sediment/soil, and food. Airborne exposure is not included in these calculations.
In this way, representative organisms at different trophic levels can be selected and
their daily intake calculated and compared to effects levels. By using this approach,
the total daily intake can be calculated using both actual data from organisms
collected on- or off-site or through estimated prey body burdens or matrix values.
When the TDI (total daily intake of a compound) from all the sources is calculated,
these values can be compared to the LOAEL value derived from the literature. When
the TDI exceeds this benchmark effects value, the compound should be considered
a COC. This is a highly conservative approach since it assumes that all of the food
consumed is contaminated at a set level and that there is 100% uptake and retention.
In the real world, it is unlikely that an organism will be exposed continuously
to contaminated sediment/soil and prey at a constant level; there is never 100%
uptake due to metabolism and elimination pathways. This conservative approach
will help protect wildlife especially when tissue dose data for specific organisms is
lacking.
In some instances where there is virtually no data on a chemical, the approach
undertaken may have to be very simplistic. The Aquatic Food Chain Multiplying
Factor (FCM) described below is such an approach (Sect. 4.2). If a large amount of
data is available on actual matrix values (i.e., water, sediment, or soil contaminant
concentrations) and lower trophic level prey dose, then a better estimate of the
predator dose can be calculated using the estimated dose from all source inputs
(Sect. 4). Because of the complexity of food webs even in the simplest of ecosys-
tems, there is a need to select sentinel organisms that can represent large classes
of organisms and also reflect the ecosystems being evaluated when determining
compounds that have a potential to bioaccumulate.
If the BCF is not available for a specific compound, then the following relationship
developed by Lyman et al. (1982) can be used based on the octanol-water partition-
ing equation (10.4).
156 K.R. Cooper
The BCF values using (10.4) and (10.5) will allow for an estimated value to be
calculated, but actual tissue and matrix concentrations are more accurate for BCF
determinations.
The FCM is also a very simplistic approach where the concentration in a matrix is
used to estimate the level in biota at different trophic levels. This approach does not
differentiate between a bioconcentration factor (BCF) and a bioaccumulation factor
(BAF). The differences between a BCF and BAF have been previously discussed
in Sect. 3.1.
In order to estimate the tissue concentration in different trophic levels, the only
information needed is the Log Kow for a chemical of interest (Sample et al. 1996).
Although the FCM is a very simple approach, it is based on the assumption that
the primary uptake route of these compounds is through passive diffusion, which
is controlled by the lipophilicity of the compound. It is a conservative estimate
since it assumes 100% uptake and does not take into account factors affecting
absorption, metabolism, or elimination for different species. Estimates can be made
for concentrations in zooplankton (trophic level 2), small fish (trophic level 3), and
piscivorous fish and top predators (trophic level 4). Table 10.2 shows the multipliers
for estimating the amount of a compound that will accumulate in each of the
higher trophic level organisms based on the Log Kow . The FCM approach may be
applicable for some metals if the organometallic forms (i.e., methyl mercury) are
known to be biomagnified in higher trophic levels based on Log Kow (USEPA 1995).
The FCM approach is useful when there is a new compound that is identified
and there is very little data on levels in higher trophic level organisms. By obtaining
the Log Kow from the literature or even doing a simple partitioning experiment one
can obtain this value. It must be realized that depending on the method from which
it was derived, there can be differences in the actual Kow values; however, they
are generally fairly similar. This value is then used to determine what multipliers
(Table 10.5) for each trophic level. This is an approach that does not take into
consideration any elimination pathways and will overestimate tissue levels when
metabolism does play a major role. The estimated FCM tissue value can then be
compared to the LOAEL value determined from literature values.
For example, if a new compound has a Log Kow D 6:0 (see Table 10.5 for
multipliers for each trophic level and is detected at 10 mg/L in water, then it is
assumed that zooplankton (level 2) will have 10 mg/Kg body levels (1 10 mg/Kg
10 Fundamental Toxicology Methods and Resources 157
Table 10.5 Aquatic food chain multiplying factors (Taken from Sample et al. 1997 which was
modified from USEPA 1993)
Log Piscivorous Log Piscivorous
Kow Zooplankton Sm. fish fish Kow Zooplankton Sm. fish fish
2 1 1.005 1 5.7 1 7:962 10:209
2.5 1 1.01 1.002 5.8 1 8:841 12:05
3 1 1.028 1.007 5.9 1 9:716 13:964
3.1 1 1.034 1.007 6.0 1 10:556 15:996
3.2 1 1.042 1.009 6.1 1 11:337 17:783
3.3 1 1.053 1.012 6.2 1 12:064 19:907
3.4 1 1.067 1.014 6.3 1 12:691 21:677
3.5 1 1.083 1.019 6.4 1 13:228 23:281
3.6 1 1.103 1.023 6.5 1 13:662 24:604
3.7 1 1.128 1.033 6.6 1 13:98 25:645
3.8 1 1.161 1.042 6.7 1 14:223 26:363
3.9 1 1.202 1.054 6.8 1 14:355 26:669
4 1 1.253 1.072 6.9 1 14:388 26:369
4.1 1 1.315 1.096 7.0 1 14:305 26:242
4.2 1 1.38 1.13 7.1 1 14:142 25:468
4.3 1 1.491 1.178 7.2 1 13:852 24:322
4.4 1 1.614 1.242 7.3 1 13:474 22:856
4.5 1 1.766 1.334 7.4 1 12:987 21:038
4.6 1 1.95 1.459 7.5 1 12:517 18:967
4.7 1 2.175 1.633 7.6 1 11:708 16:749
4.8 1 2.452 1.871 7.7 1 10:914 14:388
4.9 1 2.78 2.193 7.8 1 10:069 12:05
5.0 1 3.181 2.612 7.9 1 9:162 9:84
5.1 1 3.643 3.162 8.0 1 8:222 7:798
5.2 1 4.188 3.873 8.1 1 7:278 6:012
5.3 1 4.803 4.742 8.2 1 6:361 4:519
5.4 1 5.502 5.821 8.3 1 5:489 3:311
5.5 1 6.266 7.079 8.4 1 4:683 2:371
5.6 1 7.096 8.551 8.5 1 3:949 1:663
Trophic Level 2 D zooplankton; 3 D small fish; 4 D piscivorous fish, including top predators
since 1 L equals 1 Kg). Trophic level 3 organisms would have 105.56 mg/Kg and
level four would have 1,689 mg/Kg. Based on the estimated total dose these values
can then be compared to LOAEL and or NOAEL values for representative species.
If for some reason there is no known Kow; then an alternative would be to find a
compound with a similar structure and use that compounds’ Kow for the estimation.
These estimates can also be used for calculating levels in higher trophic level
organism as described. It is important to realize that the more assumptions that
are made, the less reliable the calculated body burdens. That is why it is critical
to not rely solely on these estimates without actual determined tissue levels from
field samples.
158 K.R. Cooper
As shown in Table 10.6 are some examples of calculated values for chemical
BAF values for trophic level 3 and 4 organisms. These calculations are based on
(10.4) and the FMC values presented in Table 10.5.
As shown in Table 10.6 with acetone, acetone would not be expected to
bioaccumulate into higher trophic levels. Both aldrin and benzo(a)pyrene would be
assumed to accumulate into the higher trophic level organisms. This model assumes
that for most trace metals there is no bioaccumulation in higher trophic levels.
Care should be exercised when there is evidence for specific metal bioaccumulation
from prey species or where the metal may not be bioavailable such as with Cd
(DiToro et al. 1992). In the case of organo-metals, there can be bioaccumulation in
higher organisms, as seen with methyl mercury (USEPA 1997b). Selenium is also
accumulated in part due to its similarity to calcium and using these transporters
and sequestration areas within the cell. Using this method, the calculation of
tissue concentrations can be used in estimating body burdens in these trophic level
organisms for comparison to LOAELs to calculate a HQ. These values can also be
used to estimate concentrations in prey species for terrestrial mammals (including
man) and piscivorous birds.
5 Conclusion
It cannot be overemphasized that the approaches proposed in this chapter are only
an initial approach to a very complex problem. In most environmental samples
there are complex mixtures of compounds that can be assessed on an individual
chemical basis, but there are likely complex chemical interactions that will influence
the toxicity. These contaminants, although dealt with on an individual compound-
by-compound basis in toxicology, does not preclude the possibility that chemical
10 Fundamental Toxicology Methods and Resources 159
compounds can result in less than additive, additive, or greater than additive effects
when an organism is exposed to multiple chemicals from an environmental mixture.
The exception to this is when the chemicals act through a common mechanism
and the literature supports an additive approach. This is the case for dioxin-like
compounds, but in the majority of cases such information is not available (Van den
Berg et al. 2008). The difficulty in dealing with complex mixtures is that there
is no way short of testing the mixture to determine how the chemicals interact
in the biological system. The reader should also appreciate that both chemical
contamination and species have a spotty distribution in the environment that can
effect the establishment of baseline values. It is important in any assessment to
understand the activities that have historically or are currently ongoing (off-site
and on-site) that could introduce chemicals into the exposure pathways. With the
continued growth in world population in regional areas, there will be sustained
pressure for water resources between competing groups.
6 Cross-References
References
P. Birak, K. Yurk et al. Travis and Arms revisited: a look at a widely used bioconcentration
algorithm. Toxicol. Ind. Health 17, 163 (2001)
L. Brown, Plan B (Earth Policy Institute, Norton, New York and London, 2003), p. 283
L. Brown, M. Renner, C. Flavin, Vital Signs (World Watch Institute, Norton, New York and
London, 1998), p. 207
M.F. Buchman, NOAA screening quick reference tables, NOAA HAZMAT Report 99–1, Coastal
Protection and Restoration Division, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration,
Seattle, 1999, pp. 1–12
W.G. Burgess, M.A. Hoque, H.A. Michael et al., Vulnerability of deep groundwater in the
Bengal Aquifer System to contamination by arsenic. Nat. Geosci. pp. 83–87 (2010).
doi:10.1038/NGE0750
M. Crane, M.C. Newman, What level of effect is a no observed effect?. Environ. Toxicol. Chem.
19, 516 (2000)
160 K.R. Cooper
F. Dang, W.X. Wang, Antagonistic interaction of mercury and selenium in a marine fish is
dependent on their chemical species. Environ. Sci. Technol. 45, 3116 (2011)
R.T. Di Giulio, M.C. Newman, Ecotoxicology, in Toxicology: The Basic Science of Poisons, 7th
edn., ed. by C.D. Klaassen (McGraw-Hill, Health Profession Division, New York, 2008),
pp. 1157–1187
D.M. DiToro, J.D. Mahoney, et al. Toxicity of Cadmium in Sediments: The Role of Acid Volatile
Sulfide. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 9, 98 (1990)
D. DiToro et al., Acid volatile sulfide predicts the acute toxicity of cadmium and nickel in
sediments. EST. 26, 96 (1992)
D.L. Eaton, S.G. Gilbert, Principles of toxicology, in Toxicology: The Basic Science of Poisons,
7th edn., ed. by C.D. Klaassen (McGraw-Hill, Health Profession Division, New York, 2008),
pp. 11–44
A. Edwards, The Sustainability Revolution: Portrait of a Paradigm Shift. New Society Publishers,
Philadelphia, 207p (2005)
E.M. Faustman, G.S. Omenn, Risk assessment, in Toxicology: The Basic Science of Poisons,
7th edn., ed. by C.D. Klaassen (McGraw-Hill, Health Profession Division, New York, 2008),
pp. 107–127
R.E. Grumbine, J. Xu, Mekong hydropower development. Science 332, 178 (2011)
J.N. Huckins, SPMD technology (2002), www.aux.cerc.cr.usgs.gov/SPMD/spmd overview.htm
S.E. Jorgensen et al., Handbook of Ecological Parameters and Ecotoxicology (Elsevier, Amster-
dam, 1991)
L.D. Lehman-McKeeman, Absorption, distribution and excretion of toxicants, in Toxicology: The
Basic Science of Poisons, 7th edn., ed. by C.D. Klaassen (McGraw-Hill, Health Profession
Division, New York, 2008), pp. 131–157
B.G. Loganathan, K. Kannan, Global organochlorine contamination trends: an overview. Ambio
23, 187–191 (1994)
W.K. Lyman, Transport and transformation process, in Fundamentals of Aquatic Toxicology, ed.
by G.M. Rand (Taylor and Francis, London, 1995), pp. 449–492
W.J. Lyman et al. Handbook of Chemical Property Estimation Methods: Environmental Behavior
of Organic Compounds (McGraw-Hill, New York, 1982)
D.D. MacDonald et al. Development and evaluation of consensus based sediment quality guide-
lines for freshwater ecosystems. Arch. Environ. Contam. Toxicol. 39, 20 (2000)
M.C. Newman, M.A. Unger, Fundamentals of Ecotoxicology, 2nd edn. (CRC/Lewis Press, Boca
Raton, 2003)
J.A. Peterson, A.V. Nebeker, Estimation of waterborne selenium concentrations that are toxicity
thresholds for wildlife. Arch. Environ. Contam. Toxicol. 23, 154 (1992)
J.D. Petty et al., Considerations involved with the use of semi permeable membrane devices for
monitoring environmental contaminants. J. Chromatogr. A 879, 83 (2000)
G.M. Rand et al., Introduction, in Fundamentals of Aquatic Toxicology, ed. by G.M. Rand (Taylor
and Francis, London, 1995), pp. 3–66
B.E. Sample, G.W. Suter II, Estimating Exposure of Terrestrial Wildlife to Contaminants (Oak
Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, 1994) ES/ER?TM-125
B.E. Sample et al. Toxicological Benchmarks for Screening Contaminants for Wildlife (Oak Ridge
National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, 1996), 227pp. ES/ER/TM-86/R3
B.E. Sample, et al., Methods and tools for estimation of the exposure of terrestrial wildlife to
contaminants. Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge TN. ORNL/TM-13391 (1997)
M. Scheringer, Long-range transport of organic chemicals in the environment. Environ. Toxicol.
Chem. 28, 677 (2009)
R.P. Schwarzenbach et al., Partitioning to living media-bioaccumulation and baseline toxicity,
in Environmental Organic Chemistry, 2nd edn., ed. by R.P. Schwarzenbach et al. (Wiley,
Hoboken, 2003) pp. 331–386
A. Spacie et al., Bioaccumulation and bioavailability in multiphase systems, in Fundamentals of
Aquatic Toxicology, ed. by G.M. Rand (Taylor and Francis, London, 1995), pp. 493–521
J.B. Sprague, Factors that modify toxicity in Fundamentals of Aquatic Toxicology ed. by G.M.
Rand, S.R. Petrocelli (Hemisphere Publishing Corporation, Washington, 1985), pp. 124–163
10 Fundamental Toxicology Methods and Resources 161
H. Sun et al., Temporal aggregation of interpolated daily climate grids: An error assessment.
Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 27, 103 (2008)
G.W. Suter, Ecological Risk Assessment (Lewis, Boca Raton, 1993)
G.W. Suter, Introduction to ecological risk assessment for aquatic toxic effects, in Fundamentals
of Aquatic Toxicology, ed. by G.M. Rand (Taylor and Francis, London, 1998) pp. 803–816
C.C. Travis, A.D. Arms, Bioconcentration of organics in beef, milk, and vegetation. Environmental
Science and Technology 22, 271 (1988)
US Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA), Framework for ecological risk assessment,
Washington D.C., 1992, EPA/630/R-92/001
US Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA), Wildlife exposure factors handbook, Volume 1
office of research and development, Washington D.C., 1993, EPA/600/R-93/187a
US Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA), Guidelines for Ecological Risk Assess-
ment. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Risk Assessment Forum, Washington, DC,
EPA/630/R095/002F, DRAFT 1995 FINAL 1998
US Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA), Great lakes water quality initiative criteria
documents for the protection of wildlife, Washington D.C., 1995, EPA-820-B-95–008
US Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA), Ecological risk assessment guidance for super-
fund: process for designing and conducting ecological risk assessments, Interm Final, USEPA,
Edison, 1997a, EPA 540-R-97–006
US Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA), Mercury study report to congress, Vol VII:
characterization of human health and wildlife risks from mercury exposure in the United States,
Washington D.C., 1997b, EPA-452/R-97–009
US Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA), U.S. environmental protection agency, risk
assessment forum, Washington, D.C., 1998, EPA/630/R095/002F
US Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA), Guidance for the development of ecological soil
screening levels. Office of Solid Waste and Emergency Response, Washington, D.C., 2003;
OSWER Directive 92857–55
US Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA), Framework for metals risk assessment (2007),
http://www.epa.gov/osa/metalsframework
M. Van den Berg, et al. The 2005 World Health Organization Re-evaluation of Human and
Mammalian Toxic Equivalency Factors for Dioxins and Dioxin-like Compounds. Toxicol. Sci.
93, 223 (2008)
Wada et al. Global depletion of groundwater resources. Geophys. Res. Lett. 37, L20402 (2010).
doi:10.1029/2010GL044571
Micro Hydro in Emergency Situations:
A Sustainable Energy Solution at La 11
Realidad (Chiapas, Mexico)
Abstract
The project purpose was the development of a 50kW Micro Hydro plant
and a 150 liter per day On Site Electro Chlorination (OSEC) System at “La
Realidad”, a little village in Chiapas, a conflict geographic area in Mexico.
The local people involvement was a key aspect of the project; the objectives
has been reached also by applying the Matching Person and Technology Model
to the technical encharged for the maintenance of the turbine. Survey On
Technology User analysis was used to support decision on the choices of
technology used.
The projects described in the following deal with the hydroelectric energy produc-
tion and chlorine self-production in La Realidad, a little village in the Lacandona
Forest, in Chiapas, the South-East State of Mexico near to Guatemala.
The local Zapatistas organization proposed a two steps local study on the energy
and water purification needs, deciding in both cases for the installation of a locally
made plant, with community-based construction and management: a Micro Hydro
Plant and an On Site Electro Chlorination (OSEC) System.
This is an example of long-term sustainable development activity even more
significant because it was managed in conflict areas and was made up of two
and for the local community on something not extraneous to their skills and culture,
providing the community itself with the instruments to understand and manage it.
The Chiapas inhabitants are the Mexicans who receive the least social protection
and services. It is sufficient to underline some meaningful numbers: every 1,000
people, there are 0.5 doctors, 0.3 beds in hospitals, and 0.2 medical consultants.
Chiapas has the national primacy of the highest mortality rate, the main causes being
malnutrition and intestinal and respiratory infections.
Moreover, Chiapas has the greatest number of illiteracy of the state: currently
only the 71.3% of children in school age attend school, the 30.4% of inhabitants are
illiterate, and the 63% of them are women.
La Realidad community belongs to the autonomous Municipio San Pedro
Michoacan where resides the Juntas del Buen Gobierno Hacia La Esperanza
which groups and coordinates four autonomous Municipios and is responsible for
organizing and managing all villages belonging to the community of Selva and
Fronteraliza.
La Realidad community started growing 60 years ago, when some families
established there, and today 800 people speaking tojolabal language live here.
The community basically lives of agriculture, with mainly of corn and beans
and secondarily of coffee, sugar, cacao, chayote, lemons, bananas, mangos, and
pineapples. Some families raise cows, horses, poultries, pigs, and rabbits.
Community daily activity organization and related works are demanded to the
local authorities, each of which established for a specific field: the health one, the
education one, and a committee of women who manage the comedores – places
where they offer lunches – and tiendas, few little shops. The community has also a
small school.
In the village resides the Caracol, a public place where the Juntas del Buen
Gobierno Hacia La Esperanza acts. The Caracol is the heart of the community social
life where also people from the nearby villages come to attend events as festivals
and training courses. The village health consultant point with the herbs storage used
to produce traditional medicines is located there.
Thanks to the Caracol center and the presence of the Juntas del Buen Go-
bierno, acting in La Realidad community has an important effect not only on
the community itself but has an immediate influence also over other nearby
communities. The Juntas del Buen Gobierno gives services to all community in
the area.
Daily life in La Realidad is timed by the work in the fields, both in family’s fields
and in fields belonging to the community. Women of the community take care of
children and domestic animals and are responsible for wood and water collection
too. They work in the fields only when it is the harvest time.
Families are quite numerous and in the same house may live up to four
generations. Daily food is based on corn, beans, fruits and vegetables, eggs, and
chicken. Rarely they eat bovine or swine meat.
The health promoters are the focus point for any healthy problem, and the main
diseases are anemia and intestine, skin, and respiration infections.
In the health self-system development, health promoters have collaborated for
a long time with the association Ya Basta highlighting the community need for
preventive advisor on health themes in order to give population the instruments to
prevent local disease.
11 Micro Hydro in Emergency Situations 167
The political situation in Mexico was so serious that in 1994 the native communities
started to organize themselves in order to undertake an independent path. The
indigenous path known as EZLN The Zapatista Army of National Liberation
(Ejército Zapatista de Liberación Nacional) acted to improve indigenous conditions
earning lands and rights to reach a dignified life.
Since 1994, the history of woman and men in the south-east Mexican mountains
has been locally, nationally, and internationally known as the “Zapatista fight.”
From that year, all independent Zapatista municipalities that since 2005 have been
called Juntas del Buen Gobierno have experimented a daily organization of self-
government with a great capacity to manage health, education, and productive
activities. Their route has been difficult and complex but have led the indigenous
Mexican communities to be a real laboratory of social experiments.
In February 1996, an important agreement known as “San Andrés agreement”
was signed with the purpose of the acknowledgment from the Mexican government
of indigenous community rights. Later the government rejected the agreement and
cut off the dialog, being the dialog the only helpful element to bring peace.
In the meanwhile Chiapas was characterized by a type of war called “low
intensity,” where paramilitaries have been involved with the purpose to divide the
indigenous force and where violations of human rights have occurred. The indige-
nous lands were constantly occupied by the military force. Paramilitaries were one
of the biggest problems and were responsible for the worst dirty jobs. Indigenous
people complained that paramilitaries bring violence, drugs, and prostitution in their
territories. As a matter of fact, the definition of low-intensity war comes from the
presence of a serious and violent reality although there were not acts of war.
The political situation of Chiapas is still complicated even if the Zapatista
movement acts in nonviolent and political way and in the indigenous community
defense.
The two projects Micro Hydro and On Site Electro Chlorination System (see
chap. 88) were born in the context described above.
The used technology can be considered innovative due to the combination of
an hydroelectric plant and an OSEC system, but what is even more innovative is
the process of self-construction, the collective designing, and the communitarian
realization and maintaining of the plant.
All these phases have been run by local sources of energy, water, and also by a
strong community involvement.
In fact, the entire process was slow and difficult in many phases, but it should
be considered as a best practice example for sustainable engineering, as it has
given results on a period of 15 years without affecting natural resources and with a
minimum of external aid during this period, as explained below.
168 A. Micangeli and M. Cataldo
The encargados are the men chosen by the community assembly to follow the
project (Fig. 11.2). In 1998, they were involved with Italian volunteers and Mexican
engineers in land surveys to draw a map of the site (Fig. 11.4).
A zone with the presence of a small river together with some small waterfalls was
chosen as the place to intercept the water flow to the future powerhouse; in Fig. 11.3
is shown the design of the plant and its components, including the powerhouse.
A drop of about 18 m was measured as shown in the following figure (Saccardo
Italo 1996).
After this first phase, the encargados began to measure the river flow over the
months, using simple and appropriate techniques collected in literature. As a result
of this work, the duration curve (see Fig. 11.5) and the flow profile (Fig. 11.6) were
estimated to evaluate the available water drawn off with the intake (Vismara et al.
1996),
where
• H0 D 20 m
• H1 D 19:5 m
• H2 D 19 m
• H3 D 16 m
• H4 D 2 m
The amount of available power (P) can be estimated as follows (Hydraulics
Engineering Manual 1990):
PŒout D PŒin I
Fig. 11.2 The local community shows enthusiasm when the turbine was installed (Picture from
A. Micangeli)
11 Micro Hydro in Emergency Situations 169
C
I
NORD
collina B
La Realidad
collina A
Alluvioni Recenti
Alluvioni (32°)
Travertino
Arenaria Limonitica
Copertura
(Arenarea-Limonitica)
Sondaggio
(75°)
T
Fig. 11.4 Micro Hydro Plant design based on the land survey done by the local community of the
Italian and Mexican volunteers and engineers (From A. Micangeli)
170 A. Micangeli and M. Cataldo
Duration curve
2.5
maximum flow
available flow
2
flow (m3/s)
1.5
0.5
0
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350
duration (days)
L1 Block 1
H1 L2
H0
Block 2
H2
L3 Block 3
H3
Turbine
L4
H4
where D loss
PŒout D PŒin Œtot
where
[tot] D system efficiency
[tot] D [in] [turbine] [pipe] [generator] [transmission]
11 Micro Hydro in Emergency Situations 171
With an estimated efficiency of 50, [tot] D 0.5, and so, knowing the capacity
Q, defined as:
Q D VŒmc=tŒs D vŒm=s SŒmq
it is obtained
P DQhg
being P = E/t, where E represents the energy:
where
g = acceleration of gravity
h = the jump
Then,
resistances that are dipped in the water of the river exiting the turbine. In this
way, the voltage is kept constant to the grid. The ballast resistances are connected
to the first and second phases, and one to the third phase (IREM 2009). The
Electronic Load Control (ELC) keeps the balance between the three phases using
the resistances. Traditionally, complex hydraulic or mechanical speed governors
altered flow as the load varied, but more recently developed ELC has increased
the simplicity and reliability of modern micro-hydro sets. A further benefit is that
the ELC has no moving parts and is very reliable and virtually maintenance-free.
The electric grid (posts and lines) was built by the community itself in cooperation
with Mexican and Italian volunteers (Electrical Installation 1994). There are two
transformers, a step-up transformer near the power house to raise the tension from
260 to 23,000 V and a step-down transformer in the community 1 km far. Every
house but the houses of the families that for political reasons did not take part in
the works has its own electric line. The only safety devices are fuses to avoid short
circuits.
Being the encargados in charge of maintaining and managing the electric grid
and the electricity production, some of them attended an electric course in San
Cristóbal de Las Casas, but due to cultural background, they met several difficulties
to finish. Thus, LITA decided to satisfy the knowledge gap holding in La Realidad
courses on electricity and on turbine plant maintenance for encargados, women, and
children.
Ten years after the beginning of the study for the hydroelectric plant, the target of
the project was the self-production of chlorine, a very common good that is usually
sold in the tiendas, with the purpose of disinfection.
Chlorine is the first choice to disinfect water in emergencies and is available in
the following forms:
• Chlorine gas, normally used in conventional water supply schemes of substantial
size. Chlorine gas dosing equipment is expensive to install and complicated to
operate and maintain, and it can be dangerous if not handled properly. Chlorine
gas is unlikely to be used in an emergency water supply.
• High test hypochlorite (HTH) – calcium hypochlorite granules supplied in drums
(70% available chlorine).
• Sodium hypochlorite – supplied in liquid form as:
• Household disinfectant (Chloros, Parazone, Domestos, etc.) 5–15% avail-
able chlorine.
• Laundry bleaches 3–5% available chlorine.
11 Micro Hydro in Emergency Situations 173
The main problems were technical, and some of them could not be predictable.
The river, after 1 month of plant running, has gone around the small dam built,
digging a hole in the ground on the right side of the river, just opposite the intake.
This part was not protected by gabions because the plant roots on this side were
supposed to prevent erosion as well but they did not. The side was rebuilt, filling the
hole with stones and soil. Later gabions were installed to protect the riverside. The
community was coordinated by experts and volunteers sent by LITA who performed
all the operations described above working in strong collaboration with the local
population so to make them understand the decisions taken.
174 A. Micangeli and M. Cataldo
As for the electric grid realization, some problems came up from the step-down
transformer due to a lightning that fused the transformer itself and to the wrong
winding corrections performed at first.
The last problem solved by LITA in collaboration with the local community was
the wrong running of an ELC, which was replaced.
The first maintenance activity was in November 2006. A maintenance plan was
prepared in Italy, before going to La Realidad, in a meeting with the IREM
responsible, the turbine maker company.
During the meeting with IREM, they carefully analyzed the photos of the plant
and decided to change numerous pieces and send specialized technicians in order to
make a complete checkup of the plant. Another aspect foreseen by the maintenance
plan was to train local people on substitution of critical parts of the plant.
Once the maintenance plan was finalized, IREM provided all the necessary parts
of the plant, and with the help of the local people in contact with Ya Basta, it bought
in Mexico all the necessary instruments for the substitution. All instruments were
then left to the community to be self-sufficient in the maintenance.
The delegation left Italy in October 31st, flying to Mexico City with all the
technical material. After all practices with the customs, they rent a vehicle to
transport everything to Chiapas.
When they arrived in Tuxla, they contacted a specialized mechanical to arrange
the transportation to the mountains with an appropriate rent vehicle.
Once arrived in La Realidad community, a meeting was organized with Juntas del
Buen Gobierno to plan the working schedule. The following morning works started
(Fig. 11.7).
Firstly, the deviation of the river water in the channel was investigated observing
what it was necessary to reinforce the filtering network, substituting the grid with
a thicker one, building a support with bags of stone, in order to permit a greater
filtering of the water in the channel.
It was asked to accurately clean the whole concrete channel which drives the
water to the conduct. The entrance of the conduct was checked out, and also there it
was necessary to build a new filtration network.
All cleaning, revering works of the channel were executed by local people.
The second step was to disassemble the turbine. While disassembling, all
damages caused by limestone, in all its components, were detected. In particular
the main damage was to the tile which contains the impeller that allows the power
regulation of the entering water.
Actually this piece of the turbine was not in the list of pieces brought from Italy.
Then it was decided to go on with the plant working and to order the tile from Italy.
The piece would be available in La Realidad only by the end of that year.
Once the turbine was completely disassembled, reducers, bearings holders, and
bearings were substituted.
11 Micro Hydro in Emergency Situations 175
All components have been cleaned from limestone, and each component was
lubricated.
In the meanwhile the five resistances were substituted, and the holes where they
resided were cleaned. The little channel where the water goes out from the resistant
holes was rebuilt to guarantee that resisters lie in clean water.
Once all the components of the turbine were revised, cleaned, and lubricated,
they were assembled once again.
While assembling the whole turbine, it was explained how to correctly collocate
the tile at its arrival in the community .
Once the review of the turbine completed, all the electric cabinets were examined.
When the maintenance works were completed, the plant was turned on. Thanks
to a flying dam located in the river in order to grow the quantity of water and
compensate for the absence of the tile, the plant started supplying an average
of 24 W.
The whole phases of assembly and de-assembly have become a useful training
on field mainly thanks to the presence of IREM people. The people in charge of the
plant had the opportunity to learn a lot about it even if they had no good technical
knowledge.
In the final phase of the work, a meeting was organized with the Italian delegation
and the local responsible of the turbine to summarize the maintenance job and to
176 A. Micangeli and M. Cataldo
discuss the issue of the presence of limestone which represented the main problem
for the plan. In the same meeting, a schedule for the next maintenance plan was
discussed.
The main decisions were to clean the channel every 15 days, to disassemble
and to lubricate the pieces once a month, and finally to plan a new intervention to
assemble the tile at the end of December.
In Italy, a study on the solution for problems related to the cabinet was carried
out as well as the research of a solution for the presence of limestone.
The aim of the second maintenance event, performed from 3 to 7 of January 2007,
was the installation of the tile to regularize the flow and the definitive check-out of
the machine.
The installation was done by the local responsible with the supervision the of
University of Rome “Sapienza.”
In this second intervention, the piece from Italy was carried directly by Andrea
Micangeli, responsible of the project, in order to avoid any cost of transportation.
All the activities of the machine disassembly and tile assembly (and consequent
regulation of the flow) were completed in 2 days. In addition the reduction axe was
changed, and the electric cards were substituted.
All the disassembly and assembly work was carried on by local people who
demonstrated a complete mastery of mechanical staff maintenance, even when
complex. At the end of the work, a check plan to do all necessary maintenance with
daily, weekly, and monthly and annual jobs was provided. This planning of plant
monitoring together with the completed training of the responsible local people will
avoid the problems occurred in the first phase. One issue is still open and needs to
be deeply investigated: the huge production of limestone, responsible for the main
problems of the plant. In fact the limestone problem can be avoided by a constant
maintenance and cleaning of the machine but also by researching a system to prevent
an overabundance production of limestone.
After this second maintenance intervention, the turbine works fine and produces
the electric energy sufficient to face the community needs, the Caracol activities, in
particular internet point, herbs laboratory, education, etc.
and school courses in different Italian towns as well as in the community at every
step of the project.
The ways of communication have been verbal by drawings and by practical
training and mainly consist of:
• Community meetings on electricity use, saving, potentiality, and limits
• Training on electricity and related dangers
• Training on the Micro Hydro technology
• MPT survey on technology user (MPT 2003)
• Trainings on self-chlorine production in eco-friendly methods
The preliminary stage was realized, thanks to an assessment form: check list
interviews were carried out on the beneficiaries in order to highlight key information
for the project implementation such as:
• Population typology (demographical and social composition)
• Institution typology (local economic, political, and social institutions)
• Utilized energy sources
• Way of energetic supplying
• Estimated forecasts (recently implemented programs or to be implemented in
close future)
• Local communities directly or indirectly involved in the project
• Other significant elements for the project
An interesting experiment was the application of the Matching Person and
Technology (MPT) Model to the technicians in charge of the maintenance of the
turbine.
This instrument, usually utilized to evaluate the right choice in case of technology
delivering to disadvantage people, takes into account three principal areas that are
the MPT model components:
1. The final user characteristics
2. The technology
3. The social and natural environment where people have to interact with the
technology
The Survey On Technology User (SOTU) analysis was used to take into account the
following influences that have been weighted in general terms in order to decide the
possible use or nonuse of technology by the user:
• Technologies frequently used by the final user of the new technology
• Past user experiences of the technologies currently used
• Approach to any new technologies
• Most typical user daily activities
• User’s personal and social features
5.1 Training
The training was the most important part of the project to introduce electricity in the
village in as much as possible sustainable way (Fig. 11.8).
178 A. Micangeli and M. Cataldo
In summer of 2002, two courses were held in the community by two Italian
engineers, one for the men and women living there on the opportunities and dangers
of electricity, and another one, more technical, for the encargados, on the future
management of the plant.
After the courses, the project could be considered finished. The plant is working
fine, although not to full power (30 kW), because the load is not high yet. The loads
connected to the grid are exclusively resistive (i.e., for illumination), for a peak of
power engaged of 10 kW. The connection with the local carpentry engines and the
realization of the vulcanizadora, to repair the lorry tires and for other mechanical
repairing, are foreseen in the next future.
La Realidad has its own power supply; the community has been trained to
maintain it in the proper way and solve the future technical problems.
Anyway, the partners that have worked in the project will continue to be in
contact with the encargados in case of extreme failure.
One of the main results, obtained thanks to stakeholder collaboration and useful
technology made up of cheap and local material, was to free the community
from energetic dependence and create a kind of local self-development. An Indian
community of Mexico has now its own hydroelectric energy production and chlorine
self-production, reducing costs and dependency and being able to handle both
plants.
This represents a success from the technological, political, and social point of
views. The involvement of the local people in all phase of the work has been so
11 Micro Hydro in Emergency Situations 179
important to leave the community with the complete understanding of the whole
process.
The project is a good example of a efficient cooperation among different
organizations and people coming from heterogeneous backgrounds.
From the beginning of the project (more than 10 years ago) up to now, the plant
has always been monitored, maintenance activities to solve problems occurred have
been scheduled, and the community has not been left alone, during all these years.
Acknowledgments
References
INEGI, XI Censo General de Poblacion y Vivienda (INEGI, Aguascalientes, 1990)
INEGI, El sector energetico en mexico – edicion 1996 (INEGI, Aguascalentes, 1997), p. 332
Saccardo Italo, Cautele nell’utilizzo dei metodi di stima del deflusso minimo costante vitale, in
L’Acqua, n˚ 2/1996, pp. 59–64 (1996)
R. Vismara et al., Impatto ambientale dei prelievi di acque superficiali, in L’Acqua, n˚ 2/1996,
pp. 45–54 (1996)
Micro-Hydro Design Manual, a guide to small-scale water power schemes – 2008 ISBN 978-1-
85339-103-3
Micro-Hydro power sourcebook – (1986) ISBN 946688486
Hydraulics Engineering Manual, MHPG Volume 2 – (1990) – ISBN 3908001137
Electrical Installation: principles and practice – (1994) ISBN 333601602
IREM – Microcentrale idroelettica Ecowatt AC4/FI : Manuale di installazione ed uso (2009)
MPT, Matching Persons and Technologies, Marcia Sherer, – The Institute for Matching Person and
Technology, Webster, NY (2003)
Khennas, Smail and Barnett, Best practices for sustainable development of micro hydro power in
developing countries (2000)
Bartolazzi, Le Energie Rinnovabili, Hoelpi (2010) ISBN 978-88-203-3587-8
Micangeli et al., SENECA Method for a Social evaluation of Energy Projects, IEEE Catalog
Number 00CH37043 (2000)
Groundwater Contamination: Role of
Health Sciences in Tackling 12
Chiho Watanabe
Abstract
Groundwater contamination creates huge problems in many areas over the world.
This chapter will use the arsenic contamination problem as a typical but the
largest among such problems and discuss the importance of role of the health
science or human biology for implementing sustainable, and especially small-
scale, mitigation measures. Although the chapter will concentrate on arsenic,
the chapter should have significant implications in considering not only other
chemicals but also nonchemical (e.g., microbiological) contaminations.
Based on the authors’ experiences in Bangladesh as well as on recent
literature, the chapter will discuss the importance of dose-response relation-
ship, a conventional component for risk assessment, focusing on (1) important
modifying factors particularly associated with developing countries, where such
problems are often encountered, and on (2) exposure evaluation. The chapter
will discuss these two rather conventional issues under a new light and will try to
show how the information from health science/human biological science can be
utilized to devise adaptive approach in implementing engineering options.
Discussion of modifying factors including biological attributes (e.g., gender or
genetics) and cultural/behavioral factors (as nutrition) will show that such mod-
ifying factors could pose substantial impacts on the dose-response relationship
and will suggest such factors should be considered as an intrinsic part of the
dose-response relationship rather than assuming a “universal” dose-response and
its modifiers.
Discussion of exposure evaluation will include significance of non-water
exposures and chemical speciation. The former will emphasize the exposure
through food and may potentially lead to substantial revision of the mitigation
measures, while the latter may show the practical importance of rapidly evolving
C. Watanabe
Department of Human Ecology, School of International Health, University of Tokyo,
Tokyo, Japan
1 Introduction
While provision of safe water is one of the most fundamental conditions for the
sustainability of healthy population, more than one billion people throughout the
world are still having a hard time to find appropriate water sources for daily living.
As a result, diarrheal diseases presumably arising from poor water and sanitation
are estimated to bring about 1.8 million deaths in 2002 (WHO 2006). Another
estimation shows that water-associated diseases, including both those associated
with unsafe water and those with poor sanitary facilities, account for 4% of total
diseases burden in the world in terms of disability-adjusted living years, DALY
(Young 2005).
It is estimated one-third of the world population is depending on groundwater
(WHO 2006). While it is relatively free from biological (bacteriological) contam-
ination compared to surface water is, chemical contamination occurs either due
to chemicals migrating from the (soil) surface or leaching from the soils/rocks.
Compared to biological (bacteriological) contamination, population at risk due to
chemical contamination is less, but chemical contaminations, at least some of them,
pose long-term and serious health effects such as cancer, which would hamper the
sustainability of affected communities.
Arsenic is one of such chemicals and has been associated with the largest
groundwater-associated chemical problems in the world. The problem has been
mainly found in developing countries in Asia (including India, Bangladesh, Nepal,
Vietnam, Thailand, Taiwan, and several regions in China) and Latin America (Peru,
Argentina, and Chile), but it could account for substantial portion of waterborne
outbreaks in developed countries such as USA (WHO 2006). In Japan, arsenic is
one of the most frequently detected contaminants that affect the water quality of
wells, only second to nitrite nitrogen, which is an indicator of biological (i.e., not
chemical) contamination.
Since the arsenic contamination causes various health outcomes including
serious ones, any solution of this problem should be compatible with reducing health
risk to acceptable levels. To define this level, knowledge of health sciences will be
required. While information is available regarding the risk associated with arsenic,
this chapter will discuss some issues to be considered in delineating the risk and
applying the risk knowledge, which would be also informative to tackle with similar
problems with other type of hazardous chemicals.
12 Groundwater Contamination: Role of Health Sciences in Tackling 183
3.1 Toxicology
While many chemical forms of arsenic exist, only arsenite and arsenate are
the chemical forms found in contaminated groundwater. Effects of these toxic
compounds vary with dose, and most of the groundwater contamination cases are
associated with long-term, relatively mild extent of exposure, where “relatively
mild” means that the dose would not lead to acute death. At this level, the most
widely known effects are skin lesions, including keratosis in the palm and sole,
and abnormal skin pigmentation – melanosis as well as leukomelanosis on the
trunk. Effects on microcirculation are also known. The most serious consequence of
such long-term, low-level exposure will be the development of the cancers of skin,
kidney, bladder, and lung (even exposure through ingestion). Also, iAs is considered
to be a risk factor for diabetes, hypertension and pulmonary diseases. Recently,
several groups report neurological as well as developmental effects. Interested
readers should consult with available reviews as already mentioned.
Arsenic found in the environment exists in a variety of chemical forms including
both inorganic and organic ones. Arsenic compounds in groundwater exist as
arsenite or arsenate, depending on the physicochemical condition of the water.
Some marine organisms contain high amount of arsenic, which are usually in
organic forms like arsenosugar, arsenolipids, or arsenobetaine. Forms in terrestrial
organism (food) are also various with higher proportion of inorganic forms (EFSA
2009). Toxicity of the arsenic compounds reflects these differences in the chemical
forms. Importantly, when ingested by human, the inorganic arsenic compounds
undergo metabolic changes. The basic changes are described as methylation, but the
metabolic pathway and its toxicological significance have been given new aspects
in the last decade. Regarding the pathway, it has been assumed that the inorganic
arsenics will be oxidatively methylated twice in the body, but this traditional scheme
has been questioned recently by a report suggesting the involvement of glutathione
in the methylation step (Fig. 12.2). Regarding the toxicological relevance of the
metabolism, the whole process had been considered as detoxification process since
the methylated forms showed much less toxicity in terms of lethality. Actually,
trivalent methylated species (both for MMA and DMA) are found to be as
toxic as and even more toxic than arsenite in some assay systems (Styblo et al.
2002). While the importance of the chemical forms and the metabolism will
be described in later sections, it should be noted this is still an ongoing basic
research issue.
12 Groundwater Contamination: Role of Health Sciences in Tackling 185
For many chemicals including arsenic, inorganic arsenic (iAs) to be exact, there
are various useful sources, which provide health risk-associated information on
the web. Many international and national organizations have been evaluating the
health risk of iAs, and most of them has been updated time to time. In case of iAs,
such organization includes, although not exhaustive, Integrated Risk Information
System (IRIS) of EPA (USA), Toxicological Profile of ATSDR (USA), WHO Fact-
sheet, IPCS-Environmental Health Criteria (IPCS 2001), IARC monographs, Joint
WHO/FAO Expert Committee on Food Additives (JECFA 2010), and European
Food Safety Authority. By consulting with these risk assessments, succinct answers
to the question, “what is the level that is thought to be safe?,” may be obtained.
Currently, EFSA (CONTAM Panel) concludes BMDL1:0 values as ranging from
0.3 to 8 g/kg bw/day, while US EPA indicates BMDL0:5 3.0 g/kg bw/day. Both
of these bodies indicate that the current Provisional Tolerable Weekly Intake of
15 g/kg bw/week is not appropriate.
Most of the cases, these risk assessments are based on currently available and
reliable information, collected under certain exclusion/inclusion criteria determined
by each assessment body. The most sensitive and serious, serious in view of the
health consequences, effects are identified, information providing doses-response
relationship will be archived, and after considering the uncertainty of the infor-
mation in various manner, the assessment will come to the final critical value, the
definition of which varies one assessment/organization to the other. The procedure
per se is quite well established, although it has been modified/changed according
to the updated scientific knowledge. While final conclusion would sometimes differ
among such assessments, reflecting the fluctuation of the knowledge bias, difference
in the basic assumption of the dose-response models, or standpoint of committee
(e.g., taking more precautious principle side or not), etc., these assessments provide
a very good basis for taking or not taking any action on the real field.
186 C. Watanabe
While these procedures are well established, and most of the assumptions used in
deriver process are explicitly shown, there are implicit assumptions that unevaluated
or unmeasured parameters would not affect the assessment substantially. Generally
speaking, for example, genetic differences and/or environmental differences are not
taken into account at least in a quantitative manner, although they are sometimes
mentioned. To rephrase, most of the assessments try to establish a universal
assessment, at least in the past. This hidden assumption appears to be gradually
changing recently. For example, summary from the 72nd meeting of JECFA (2010)
pointed out that nutritional status as well as other lifestyle associated factors
(although not identified so far) could be the sources of uncertainty. The recent
EFSA evaluation (2009) concluded that skin lesions found in south Asian countries,
long considered as the most common manifestation of the arsenic toxicity, may not
be caused by iAs alone but caused by iAs combined with other factors like poor
nutritional status; exposure to iAs is necessary but not sufficient condition to cause
skin lesions.
For several reasons these issues should be taken seriously into the risk assessment
in real world. First, including iAs problem, many of the sustainability problems are
observed in developing countries, where many conditions including genetic make,
nutritional status, coexistence of other environmental threats including hazardous
chemicals, culturally specific behaviors (Bae et al. 2002) are different from those
in the developed countries, where most of the “background” studies in the past
risk assessments had been conducted. Second, compared to the past events like
Minamata disease, most of the current risk issues are dealing with subtle health
effects. This is exemplified by recent assessment of the health consequences of
in utero methylmercury exposure on offspring. Sophisticated neurobehavioral test
batteries (Grandjean et al. 1997) including Brazelton test (Suzuki et al. 2010)
assessments could detect minute effects associated with low-level exposure to
mercury. Third, which is also related with the second point, exposure would not
occur with only a single chemical, usually exposure to multiple chemicals should
be assumed regardless this fact should be incorporated in the assessment or not.
In the following sections, these issues will be considered in two approaches. The
first one is to discuss the “modifiers” of iAs toxicity, which directly assess the issue,
and the second one is to discuss the issue in terms of exposure. In the latter approach,
it is hoped that the link between the exposure and these issues will be clarified along
with the discussion.
One of the prominent features of arsenic toxicity is the large variation of its manifes-
tation both across populations and across individuals. In the field situation, there are
sometimes households within which only some of the members are severely affected
by arsenic, while other members are not at all, despite the fact that all members drink
the water from the same source and share the food. Some researchers even think iAs
may not be a sufficient factor of so-called arsenic symptoms (Mead 2005; EFSA
2009). There are a variety of candidate reasons why populations and individuals
12 Groundwater Contamination: Role of Health Sciences in Tackling 187
respond so differently with each other. These reasons could be either biological or
social/environmental (Tseng 2009). Identifying such reasons may sometimes lead
to elucidation of the toxic mechanism of arsenic. Although, often, classification into
two (biological vs. social) might not be meaningful and even misleading, these will
be discussed separately below for sake of discussion.
Effects of the age and sex have long been the targets of investigation in the risk
assessment field. In case of arsenic, a clear sex differences have been described in
many papers (Vahter 2007). The figure shows the sex difference in the prevalence of
dermatological lesions induced by arsenic in Bangladesh and Nepal, where females
show higher tolerance to arsenic toxicity than males do.
Mechanisms for the sex difference have not been elucidated. It has been
known that difference in the water intake, behavioral difference like smoking, or
alcoholic consumption cannot account for the sex difference. Hormonal effects
should have the primary importance; other factors like sex-dimorphic brain structure
or, nonbiological factors like differential intake of food (leading to differential
nutritional status between sexes) or labor intensity may be among the candidates.
Recently, it has been found that Bangladeshi women using estrogenic contraceptive
exhibit suppressed iAs-induced oxidative stress compared to their non-contraceptive
counterpart (Sultana, unpublished).
While these studies suggest the importance of sex hormones (or estrogenic
activity), it awaits further confirmations. If such mechanisms will be identified, this
could lead to a development of the “antidote.” One of such candidate mechanisms
is associated with the metabolism of the ingested iAs. It has been known that
ingested iAs will undergo a series of metabolic changes, where the compound
will get methylated twice (Fig. 12.2). The metabolic change was understood as a
detoxifying pathway since injection of the resultant methylated species revealed
much less toxicity compared to the “parent” iAs species. This long held view
has been challenged and eventually changed during the last decade; it has been
found that an intermediate species mono-methylated, trivalent arsenic (As(III)) are
as much toxic as the parent iAs like arsenate in a variety of experimental assays.
The methylation status can be inferred by examining the urinary profile of the
excreted arsenic species using HPLC-ICP-MS system, which will be described later.
Finally, it should be noted that although the sex difference in skin lesions, i.e.,
higher susceptibility of males, have been reported by many researchers, this may not
be the case for some other endpoints. For example, in arsenic polluted area in the
Terai region, the lowland Nepal, a negative correlation between the arsenic intake
level and BMI, an indicator of general nutritional status (presumably reflecting
energy balance) was found (Maharjan et al. 2007). While there were sex difference
in terms of skin lesions, no sex difference was found in the BMI suppression.
Interaction between the genetic make up vs. environmental factors become
one of the hot fields in the environmental health sciences. Since above-described
metabolism of iAs contains some enzymatic processes, researchers focused on
188 C. Watanabe
Table 12.1 Some of the genetic polymorphism potentially associated with metabolism or toxicity
of inorganic arsenic
Polymorphism Effects Reference
Arsenic methyltransferase Associated with metabolism, Engstrom et al. (2011),
cancer risk, or with DNA Sampayo-Reyes (2010),
damage Agusa et al. (2009), and
Fujihara et al. (2009)
Glutathione S-transferase M1 Deletion may be associated Ghosh (2006) and MacCarty
with modified metabolism et al. (2007)
Glutathione S-transferase T1 Deletion associated with higher Kile et al. (2005) and
body burden; but, increased risk MacCarty et al. (2007)
Purine nucleoside Increased sensitivity to skin De Chaudhuri et al. (2008)
phosphorylase lesions
XRCC3 Protection against skin lesions Kundu et al. (2011)
associated with polymorphism
Heme oxygenase-1 Shorter GT repeat may be Wu et al. (2010)
associated with reduced risk for
cardiovascular mortality
Cystathionine-ˇ-synthase Some SNPs associated with Porter et al. (2010)
metabolism
People are never exposed to a single chemical. They are immersed in “en-
vironment,” which means they are exposed, not only to iAs, the chemical of
concern, but also to numerous environmental biophysical and social factors. It is
natural that consequence of the iAs exposure would be different under different
environmental settings/parameters. For example, the absorption of cadmium or
lead is depending on the iron nutrition of the person presumably due to the
competition between the iron and these elements (Kordas et al. 2007). Inves-
tigation of such interaction among numerous factors is, however, impractical,
and investigator needs to focus on most relevant variables. Currently, this focus-
ing task is “handmade,” i.e., conducted empirically, and there is no systematic
12 Groundwater Contamination: Role of Health Sciences in Tackling 189
5 Evaluating Exposure
The exposure status needs to be examined to decide whether the situation needs
some intervening actions or policy implementations. While the established dose-
responses relationship and health risk assessment are given in the form of abstract
information, exposure evaluation reflects regional specificity and local context.
A good reference for arsenic exposure in general population can be found in
a nationwide survey conducted in USA, which also provides information about
chemical forms of arsenic (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention 2009).
Since arsenic contaminates the groundwater, most of the attention has been paid
to iAs in the water sources. Also, most of the epidemiological studies have used
the iAs concentration (multiplied by water intake, in some cases) in groundwater
as dose indicator. Here, examined was the relationship between urinary arsenic
concentration, a frequently used good indicator of exposure, and iAs concentration
in the well water. When whole range of the dose was examined, the two indicators
show a good correlation as expected, but they show deviation in the lower end of
the dose ranges (Fig. 12.3). Such deviation suggests there are sources of iAs other
than the groundwater. A calculation based on some limited number of food samples
show substantial amount of arsenic come from food items. If it is assumed that
the arsenic contained in the food items are predominantly iAs, then the amount in
the food will exceed the Provisional Tolerable Weekly Intake (PTWI) (Watanabe
et al. 2004).
In fact, arsenic contained in the food items exists in a variety of chemical
forms. Based on an extensive survey of food arsenic measurement, the EFSA
concluded that overall estimate of the proportion of iAs against total arsenic is 70%,
ranging from 50% to 100% (EFSA 2009). Seafood has much lower proportion of
iAs compared to the terrestrial species. While fish and marine organism contain
high concentrations of arsenic, less toxic chemical forms like arsenobetaine is
predominating (Borak and Hosgood 2007). Among the marine organisms, however,
hijiki, marine algae, is unique in that it contains high proportion of iAs, which
might pose non-negligible cancer risk on hijiki-consuming Japanese population
(Nakamura et al. 2008). Therefore, it should be kept in mind that the proportion
of iAs varies considerably depending on the food types.
Most of the mitigation attempt has been focusing on the removal or arsenic from
water sources or changing water sources per se. To reduce the exposure is important,
but current strategies restricted to water arsenic might not be enough, and additional
strategy to reduce arsenic intake from food might be required. At this point, there
are missing information including the speciation of arsenic and the origin of arsenic
12 Groundwater Contamination: Role of Health Sciences in Tackling 191
SV males
SV females
SP males
1000 SP females
Urinary As conc.
[µg/g creatinine]
100
10
1 10 100 1000
As in tubewell water [µg/L]
Fig. 12.3 Correlation between the urinary concentrations of arsenic of residents living in arsenic-
polluted area (vertical) and concentrations of arsenic in the respective well water used by these
residents (horizontal). Note both axis are drawn in logarithmic scale
in various food items. The latter, the origin of arsenic, will be related with the
environmental behavior of arsenic and mechanism of mobilization of arsenic from
soil (e.g., see Neuman et al. 2009).
There are two approaches to evaluate the exposure: environmental monitoring and
biological monitoring. While the former relies on the amount of the (hazardous)
materials of concern in any environmental media including air, water, food, and
even soil, the latter uses “biological media” such as blood (whole blood, plasma,
or serum), urine, saliva, hair, nail, and breast milk. The relative usefulness and
appropriateness of each medium vary according to the purpose of the evaluation
and substance of concern (Table 12.2). In case of multimedia exposure, where the
exposure occurs through more than one route, the biological monitoring will provide
easier way for quantifying the individual exposure, while it cannot pinpoint the
major source of exposure that needs to be regulated. In so-called arsenic polluted
areas, while majority of exposure occurs through ingestion of contaminated ground-
water, exposure through the food items may not be negligible as discussed above.
Therefore, accurate quantification of exposure requires exhaustive quantification of
both arsenic in major food items and amount of food consumed, which is labor
taking and virtually impossible in most of the field situation.
192 C. Watanabe
Table 12.2 Biological media commonly used for biomonitoring of hazardous chemicals
Medium Invasiveness Handling Storage/transportation Others
Blood Large Infection Infection risk Rich information. Blood cells
risk and serum will give different
type of information
Urine Little Degraded if left Not appropriate for lipophilic
substances. Effect of dilution
and condensation
Hair Very little Easy Easy External contamination
Saliva Little Infection risk Relatively scarce information
100
100 1000
Urinary As measured in Nov 1998
[ng/mg creatinine]
7 Summary
References
M. Bae, C. Watanabe, T. Inaoka et al., Arsenic in cooked rice in Bangladesh. Lancet 360,
1839–1840 (2002)
J. Borak, H. Hosgood, Seafood arsenic: implications for human risk assessment. Regul. Toxicol.
Pharmacol. 47, 204–212 (2007)
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Fourth National report on human exposure to
environmental chemicals (2009)
EFSA, Scientific opinion on arsenic in food. EFSA J. 7, 1351 (2009)
P. Grandjean, P. Weihe et al., Cognitive deficit in 7-year-old children with prenatal exposure to
methylmercury. Neurotoxicology 19, 417–428 (1997)
IPCS, Arsenic and Arsenic Compounds (Environmental Health Criteria, UNEP/ILO/WHO,
Geneva, 2001)
JECFA, in Summary and Conclusions 72nd Meeting, Rome (2010)
K. Kordas, B. Lonnerdal et al., Interactions between nutrition and environmental exposures: effects
on health outcomes in women and children. J. Nutr. 137, 2794–2797 (2007)
L. Li, E.-C. Ekstrom et al., Nutritional status has marginal influence on the metabolism of inorganic
arsenic in pregnant Bangladeshi women. Environ. Health Perspect. 116, 315–321 (2008)
M. Maharjan, C. Watanabe et al., Mutual interaction between nutritional status and chronic arsenic
toxicity due to groundwater contamination in an area of Terai, lowland Nepal. J. Epidemiol.
Community Health 61, 389–394 (2007)
M. Mead, Arsenic: in search of an antidote to a global poison. Environ. Health Perspect. 113,
A379–A386 (2005)
S. Mitra, D. Mazumder et al., Nutritional factors and susceptibility to arsenic-caused skin lesions
in West Bengal, India. Environ. Health Perspect. 112, 1104–1109 (2004)
Y. Nakamura, T. Narukawa et al., Cancer risk to Japanese population from the consumption of
inorganic arsenic in cooked Hijiki. J. Agric. Food Chem. 56, 2536–2540 (2008)
R.B. Neuman, K.N. Ashfaque et al., Anthropogenic influences on groundwater arsenic concentra-
tions in Bangladesh. Nat. Geosci. 3, 46–52 (2009)
C.D. Rice, Overview of modifiers of methylmercury neurotoxicity: chemicals, nutrients, and the
environment. Neurotoxicology 29, 761–766 (2008)
M. Styblo, Z. Drobna et al., The role of biomethylation in toxicity and carcinogenicity of arsenic:
a research update. Environ. Health Perspect. 110(suppl 5), 767–771 (2002)
K. Suzuki, K. Nakai, T. Sugawara et al., Neurobehavioral effects of prenatal exposure to
methylmercury and PCBs, and seafood intake: neonatal behavioural assessment scale results
of Tohoku study of child development. Environ. Res. 110, 699–704 (2010)
C.-H. Tseng, A review on environmental factors regulating arsenic methylation in humans. Toxicol.
Appl. Pharmacol. 235, 338–359 (2009)
M. Vahter, Sex difference in the disposition and toxicity of metals. Environ. Res. 104, 85–95 (2007)
M. Vahter, G. Concha et al., A unique metabolism of inorganic arsenic in native Andean women.
Eur. J. Pharmacol. 293, 455–462 (1995)
O.L. Valenzuela, H.H. Borja-Aurto et al., Urinary trivalent methylated arsenic species in a
population chronically exposed to inorganic arsenic. Environ. Health Perspect. 113, 250–254
(2005)
C. Watanabe, A. Kawata et al., Water intake in an Asian population living in arsenic contaminated
area. Toxicol. Appl. Pharmacol. 198, 272–282 (2004)
WHO, Protecting Groundwater for Health (IWA, London, 2006)
T. Young, Population Health: Concepts and Methods, 2nd edn. (Oxford University Press,
New York, 2005)
Sustainable Earth System Engineering:
Incentives and Perspectives 13
Peter A. Wilderer, Martin Grambow, and Wei Meng
Abstract
Sustainable earth system engineering (SESE) is defined as deliberate, careful,
and science-based management of the three major components of the life
support system of the Earth: climate, biodiversity, and stability of societies
and economies. Unintended interventions into these basic assets have led to
major global crises. It appears that mankind is confronted with four major,
widely interrelated problem areas. Keywords in this context are water and food
deficiency, societal and economic instability, loss of the self-regulation capacity
of ecosystems, and last but not least the crisis caused by global warming and the
resulting climate change. Growth of the human population in conjunction with
global changes of life style is the underlying reasons for the evolvement of such
crises. A holistic approach is to be taken to counteract the mankind’s impacts
into the generic life supporting system of the Earth. This chapter describes the
interrelationships to be considered when planning to direct the development
of the Earth system toward a steady-state which enables the multibillion size
humanity to maintain its niche.
1 Introduction
In September 2008, a 4-day reflection meeting entitled “The art of dealing wisely
with the planet Earth” was held in a resort near Wildbad-Kreuth, Germany. The
conference was organized by the Technical University of Munich, the EU Chapter
of the Club of Rome, and the European Academy of Sciences and Arts. About 40
representatives of science, economy, and politics attended the meeting. The result
of the discussions was condensed in a declaration which was discussed by the
participants at the highest peak of the German Alps, the Zugspitze, thus coined
“Zugspitze Declaration” (Fig. 13.1). It was resolved in November 2008 after some
weeks of intensive further discussions via internet.
The participants of the workshop agreed that awareness of the complexity of the
world crises brings a unique quality into the discussion of necessary and globally
effective measures. As mankind is confronted with not just one but very many
Zugspitze Declaration
on the Responsibility of Humanity for the Functioning of the Earth System
Faced with serious challenges to the Earth system, a group of scientists, politicians and business representatives
met for four days in Wildbad Kreuth, Germany, at a workshop on “Earth-System Engineering - The Art of Dealing Wisely
with the Planet Earth.” After follow-up communications they came to the following conclusions and recommendations:
§1 Our Global Crisis
Global climate change threatens the life-enabling functions of the Earth system.
interconnected crises, science and policymaking can not only concentrate on just
one target, reduction of green house gases for instance. Moreover, it is important to
take a holistic approach based on scientific knowledge, foresight, and a strong sense
of responsibility.
In the following, a number of smaller reflection meetings were held particularly
on the issue of responsibility taking by scientists, engineers, and politicians when it
comes to the formulation and execution of programes to solve the world crises. In all
of these meetings, the participants agreed that to become effective, counteractions
must obey the sustainability axiom. It was further agreed that the self-regulation
capacity of ecosystems can hardly be replaced by technology. Advanced technol-
ogy is required, but large-scale application of innovative technology designed to
manipulate the Earth system must be made dependent of the outcome of a dialogue
across disciplines and together with the civil society.
2 Background Considerations
By the end of the year 2010, the size of the human population on Earth exceeded the
seven billion margins, and it is not to be excluded that by the year 2050, more than
nine billion people will live on Earth. Growth of population is inevitably associated
with growth of the demand for resources, especially for water, food, energy, and
land. Water is needed to satisfy domestic and industrial demands. Moreover, water
is needed for irrigation of agricultural land, for production of industrial goods, for
heating and cooling, and, last but not least, for the generation of energy. Thus, it
is to be assumed that the demand of water, land, and energy in relation to global
warming and climate change is inextricably linked (Hoffman 2004).
Although there is plenty of water available on Earth, dramatic water shortage
situation are threatening mankind in such areas of the world where people accumu-
late in vast numbers and where the size of local water resources is insufficient with
respect to the local demand. By 2009, more than 50% of the world’s population
lived in cities, small and large. The tendency is rising.
Severe water shortage situations develop particularly in the course of long-
lasting droughts. It appears that global warming causes drought situations to
become more frequent and widespread. According to recent findings (Makarieva
and Gorshkov 2001, 2007, 2009), there is another reason for droughts and the
resulting desertification to be considered, namely, deforestation and the concomitant
loss of the capacity of forest ecosystems to regulate atmospheric humidity and
rainfall. Many striking observations indicate that in the past, clear-cut of coastal
forests led to a significant decrease of rainfall intensity in the hinterland. Obviously,
humanity has to deal with a threateningly dilemma. On the one-hand side there is a
necessity to leave land for ecosystems to fulfil their climate regulation function. On
the other side, the human society claims right to use land for settlements, industrial
installations, roads, and for agriculture purposes.
198 P.A. Wilderer et al.
Fig. 13.2 Graphical representation of causes of global change and resulting effects
The demand for energy, water, food, and land is amplified by a global change of
lifestyle. Telecommunication and global transportation means made it possible to
spread information about how people live in other parts of the world. Experience
proves that the lifestyle which has developed in the industrialized countries became
a model for the whole world.
Figure 13.2 illustrates the network of causes and effects to be considered. It is
a major challenge for decision makers of political and economic institutions to
understand the complexity of this human induced network, to draw appropriate
conclusions, and turn conclusions into action on the global as well as on the
regional scale. It is important to derive decisions on in-depth system analysis
(Siaou et al. 2010).
should clarify that such a sectoral assessment obscures the problems mankind is
actually facing.
It is reasonable to assume that the problems deriving from global warming and
climate change can be solved only when taking a holistic approach, when taking
in consideration not only green house gas emissions but the global challenges as a
whole (Bierbaum and Zoellick 2009). Particular emphasis is to be placed on factors
such as:
– Population size: According to today’s estimates, within a few decades, up to
about nine billion people will be accessing the limited resources of the Earth
(mineral resources, fossil fuels, water, air, land). In simple terms, the more people
are living on Earth the more resources are consumed and the more the Earth
system loses its capacity to regulate the life enabling conditions on land, in water,
and in the atmosphere.
– Atmosphere: Of concern is not only CO2 but other greenhouse gases as well,
water vapor, methane, nitrous oxide, ozone, and fluor-chlorohydrocarbons in
particular. The global warming potential of methane is about 20 times higher
compared to CO2 . Nitrous oxide is 300 times more effective. The strongest green
house gas, however, is water vapor which is affected by the warming of the
atmosphere and the surface waters and regulated – according to Gorshkov et al.
(2000) – by ecosystem function.
– Land has already become a scarce resource. Land is burdened through com-
petitive uses. Land bared of native vegetation gets easily lost by erosion. In
future, habitable land might be swallowed by the rising sea forcing millions of
people to migrate toward regions of higher elevation. Deposition of pollutants
on agricultural land and salinization of soil hampers food supply and aggravates
spread of poverty.
– Resources: It is most likely that in the near future, mankind will run out of
easily accessible raw materials such as coal, oil, gas, copper, and phosphate.
Among many other negative feedbacks, availability of fertilizers and thus supply
of people with food is jeopardized, particularly in those parts of the world which
are threatened by droughts and poverty.
– Water: Over-abstraction of water from aquifers, rivers, lakes, and reservoirs is –
in many parts of the world – the usual but ill-considered and unsustainable
answer to the locally increasing demand for water. For instance, in northern
part of India, 54 ˙ 9 km3 of groundwater is lost per year due to over-abstraction
(Mervis 2009). Seawater intrusion into aquifers causes sea level to rise. Over-
abstraction aggravates water shortage situation particularly in coastal areas where
the majority of people lives, presumably more than 80% of the global population.
In Fig. 13.3, the four major and most crucial demands of the global human society
are highlighted: the demand for energy, water, food, and living space. Form these
areas of demands, four global crises can be derived, crises which mankind and
nature alike are confronted with:
1. Global warming and climate change
2. Water and food deficiency
3. Ecosystems and biodiversity loss
4. Loss of societal and economic stability
200 P.A. Wilderer et al.
population growth
root
migration
of the
urbanization
problem
lifestyle change
ecosystems
causes CO2 water food &
emission deficiency deficiency biodiversity
loss
global warming
climate change
social &
droughts rise of loss of economic
flooding sea level habitable land instability
Fig. 13.3 The four major demands triggered by population growth and life style changes and the
resulting four major global crises
It has to be realized that all these crises are tightly interwoven (Fig. 13.4). Therefore,
a holistic approach is to be taken to tackle this system of crises. For political
reasons, it might be advisable to emphasize distinct limitation of, for instance,
global temperature rise (<2ı C) and subsequent CO2 -emission rate, but it should
be understood that such measures are insufficient if not supplemented by measures
addressing the other three crises as well (Grambow et al. 2009).
Climate change causes an abundance of critical transformations. Along with
natural catastrophes such as droughts and flooding, far-reaching interferences in
the biosphere, in particular the ocean and forest ecosystems, might cause long-
term disruption of the life-supporting systems of the Earth (Gorshkov et al. 2000;
Gorshkov and Makarieva 2002; Lovelock 2007). In addition, it is necessary to
take into account interferences with the anthroposphere which includes the factors
“economy” and “society” including culture, traditions, religious believes, and greed.
Tensions caused by societal and economic imbalances may be termed a “silent
crises.” Social explosives which result through the increasingly widening gap
between poor and rich, and other destabilizing mechanisms, are described by
Radermacher and Beyers (2007) and Welzer (2008). The financial crisis and,
much more, its underlying breaking points in the global economic system am-
plify the threat of destabilization. At the same time, the effects due the other
global crises, primarily water shortage and food problems, hurt the socially weak
considerably.
13 Sustainable Earth System Engineering: Incentives and Perspectives 201
Fig. 13.4 Sustainable earth system engineering: measure to overcome the four major global crises
The evolution of the Earth crises, with their consequences for mankind at large,
is the result of unintended but far-reaching anthropogenic forcing. Impacts on the
Earth system function were posed by mankind unintentionally and, at least in
the past, also unexpectedly. For instance, neither people nor industrial or political
leaders wanted to warm the Earth through the emission of CO2 , and it was certainly
not intended to put the prerequisite of life, the presence of liquid water on Earth,
into jeopardy.
Realizing the consequences of anthropogenic forcing, far-reaching and weighty
countermeasures are currently discussed and partly already enforced. Among them
are various mitigation and adaptation strategies. The problem is, however, that
introduction of those strategies takes time – may be too much time to become
effective. Realizing the discrepancy between the speed of changes and the rate by
which politically and socially accepted mitigation and adaptation measures may
take effect scientists and entrepreneurs propose another option to manage the Earth
system (Keith et al. 2010). Keywords used in this context are climate engineering or
geo-engineering. Both are focused on deliberate changes of the regional or even of
the global climate by applying physical and/or chemical methods. In the contrary,
Earth system engineering considers not only the physical and chemical dimension
of the Earth system but biological dimension as well including the human dimension
(see Fig. 13.4).
202 P.A. Wilderer et al.
The complexity inherent in the Earth system can only be countered through a
commensurately complex solution. The common lack of understanding of the multi-
connected, complex relations of the Earth crises is one possible reason for an
eventual failure of running the Earth system by means of technical intervention.
Another one is the reliance in “one track minded” technical solutions. The real
ultimate formula for handling global crises, however, is sustainability, which is
demanded in Sect. 7 of the Zugspitze Declaration (see Fig. 13.1), and further
explained as follows: “The purpose of the new frontier of Earth system engineering
must be to promote improved management of the global commons. The global
society must find a relationship between the natural environment and human
endeavours that ensures sustainability” (Anonymous 2008a). Human societies have
to find a sustained effective relationship between the natural environment and human
endeavors.
To overcome global crises and to approach a state of sustainability at the global
as well as on the regional scale, source control needs to get lifted up to the
top of the political agenda. As shown in Fig. 13.2, the true reason of the global
crises is overpopulation of the planet Earth. According to Lovelock (2009), the
bearing capacity of the Earth is in the range of 200 million. Gorshkov et al.
(2000) calculated the maximum number of people the Earth might carry to about
650 million. Wackernagel (WWF 2008), considering the resources consumed and
wastes emitted, came to the conclusion that humanity used in 2008 the equivalent
13 Sustainable Earth System Engineering: Incentives and Perspectives 203
of 1.3 planets already. Whatever number one might adopt, it is obvious that radical
changes are necessary. For ethical reasons, innovative methods are to be identified
and enforced – methods which allow accommodation of even nine billion people
on Earth under strict rules of sustainability. No measure is allowed that lead to
conditions which hurt mankind afterward, however.
Limitation of emissions and technical interventions into the climate system
of the Earth (geo-engineering) must be paralleled by changes on the ethical,
societal, and economic level. Klaus Toepfer, the former director general of the
united nations environmental program (UNEP), suggested giving highest priority
to education of women followed by career chances and family care programes
(2009, Toepfer K., personal communication). An ethically well-founded decline of
the global population size is likely to be the result as demonstrated by population
size changes in many of the industrialized countries of the world.
Such a process takes time, and because global warming and climate change will
progress, measures are to be identified and brought into operation which promise
short term effects. Examples are:
– Technology supporting sustainable development: Objective is further develop-
ment and deployment of energy-saving, resource-considerate, and low-emission
technologies in all economic sectors. In this context, used materials, gaseous,
liquid, and solid materials alike, shall be considered as raw materials for further
use and returned in the cycle of materials much more resolutely than today.
– Land use management: To revitalize the climate regulating function of forest
ecosystems, it appears to be necessary to provide ample space for reforestation.
To make these possible, innovative agricultural practices should be developed,
providing high crop yields on a minimum of land. Likewise, city planners should
work on further compaction of municipal areas while combating isolation of city
dwellers. A livable city should be the goal to avoid population density driven
social frictions.
– Legislation supporting sustainable development: The Zugspitze Declaration
proposes establishment of a United Nations body authorized to enforce measures
capable of preserving the life-enabling functions of the Earth system. Keith et al.
(2010) proposes as a first step a “transparent, loosely coordinated international
programme supporting research and risk assessment by multiple independent
teams.”
– Economic measures supporting sustainable development: Proposals for a sustain-
able free market economy have been made by von Hauff (2009). Radermacher
and Beyers (2007) and many others call for fair trade, distributive justice, and for
changes of consumer habits.
Most importantly, mankind must take action, before the tipping point has crossed.
The members of the Wildbad-Kreuth workshop stated in Sect. 3 of the Zugspitze
Declaration (Anonymous 2008a): “There is no excuse for delaying implementation
of available state-of-the-art technologies. While there is need for innovation in cer-
tain areas, proven, established and sustainable responses already exist for handling
large parts of the global crisis. The signatories of the Zugspitze Declaration want
to motivate those who have solutions, in order to share this knowledge with the
204 P.A. Wilderer et al.
±10 °C
Fig. 13.5 Schematic illustration showing the three minima of the Lyapunov equation representing
stable stationary states of the Earth’s climate system. Oscillations (˙10ı C ) around the relative
minimum at 15ı C occurred in the past, but the Earth system eventually returned to the stable
position (Adapted from Gorshkov et al. (2000))
global community so that implementation can begin now.” One may add that not
only state-of-the-art technologies are already available, ready for implementation,
but state-of-the-art economic and societal measures as well.
Thus, the objective is enforcement of sustainable Earth system engineering
(SESE) build upon tested and secured methods capable of turning back the screw
of overloading of the Earth with the unnecessary. As mentioned, it is not only
technology which provides solutions. A more productive relationship between
natural, social, and economic scientist is overdue (Anonymous 2010).
Whether state-of-the-art methods alone are capable of keeping the Earth system
in balance is questionable, however. Over more than two billion years the Earth
system was subjected to massive changes but returned back to a stable state
characterized by a mean surface temperature of about 15ı C. It would be disastrous
if the Earth system, for whatever reason, would slip over either one of the two rims
sketched in Fig. 13.5, and it would be unforgiveable if mankind would cause the
Earth system to slip over either rim and fall down to the stable climatic states typical
for Venus or Mars, respectively. The world needs innovative measures, but these
measures are to be rigorously examined and tested against any undesirable effects
prior to implementation. Long-term costs are to be evaluated, a legal framework has
to be established, and acceptance by the public has to be secured by participatory
endeavors.
13 Sustainable Earth System Engineering: Incentives and Perspectives 205
As strong and stringent commitments of the community of states are still rather
weak, the call for technology as a means of salvation is getting aloud. Is climate
engineering the right answer to global warming?
Jonas (1979) gives an answer when he writes “The existence[of mankind] may
not become a stake for a wager on action . . . . An action to save the unalienable
with the risk of losing everything can be morally justified, even necessary, [this
however stands] under the proviso of defence against the greatest malady but not
procurement of the greatest benefit.” In other words, application of a risky global
climate modulation is acceptable after a devastating strike of a meteorite, but climate
engineering is unacceptable when justified as a measure to preserve nonsustainable
consumer behavior.
In the Zugspitze Declaration (Anonymous 2008a), the response to climate
engineering is formulated as “Such initiatives with potential global effects need
rigorous risk assessment and authorization by a process of international consensus
to which all nations are supposed to participate. Climate engineering must never be
seen as an alternative to the necessity to solve the global crisis at its roots.”
A negative example for non-holistic solutions is the fertilization of oceans; using
iron salts, nitrate, or phosphate is an example of technologies which has to be
very critically assessed. Triggering algae growth by distribution of fertilizers in the
world’s oceans is certainly a possibility to sequester CO2 in the attempt to bring the
world’s climate back to “normal.” While assessing this and some other proposals,
Lenton and Vaughan (2009) made clear that fertilization is only promising if it
is carried out worldwide over very long periods of time using large quantities of
nutrients. Fertilization means eutrophication. In Europe and elsewhere, billions of
Euros have been invested over the past years to establish nutrient removal processes
in wastewater treatment plants. Action had to be taken to prevent algae growth in
rivers, lakes, and coastal waters. This was done in order to avoid loss of ecological
and economic value inherent in surface waters. Eutrophication of oceans bears the
risk of diminishing biodiversity. Decrease of fish population may provoke further
increase of the food crisis in coastal areas. Besides, emission of greenhouse gases
such as methane will increase when algae eventually die off and get anaerobically
degraded in oxygen deficient waters. In summary, it can hardly be expected that
ocean fertilization is a contribution to sustainable development of aquatic and
terrestrial ecosystems. Most likely, this methods, and some others as well, will
amplify the global crises rather than solve them.
This leads to a dilemma. Progressive/unconventional technologies applied to
solve global crises bear the risk of detrimental State authorities are supposed
consequences for mankind. The imperative of responsibility forces State authorities
to reject those technologies, although it has to be admitted that technology is
unavoidable as long as mankind has not committed itself to far reaching behavioral
changes.
Evolution of traditional technologies toward sustainability-conform technologies
might be a way out of the dilemma. So far, traditional technologies are focused on
the production of commodities. They enable mobility and communication; provide
infrastructure, shelter, clothing, food, and safe water; and allow conversion of
206 P.A. Wilderer et al.
used materials into reusable materials or into end products which can be safely
disposed. Further development of traditional resource-considerate and low-emission
technologies should be aimed to energy saving, recovery of valuable materials and
energy, and reuse.
In order to get the Earth crises under control, it is necessary to:
– Accelerate introduction and propagation of “traditional” sustainable technologies
in all sectors and disciplines; the focus of research should lie on their further
development.
– Gain better knowledge on the Earth system itself.
– Support decision makers (politicians, regulators, leaders of profit and nonprofit
institutions) with solid, well-balanced information.
– Strengthen competence of the civil society to evaluate solutions proposed by
specialists. Proposals should be presented as pictorially as possible in order to
make today’s actions justifiable. Life-long learning and preservation of ethical
norms appears to be particularly important in this context.
education policy
holistic
“Gaia”
Earth System
Geochemistry
Mechanical
Geophysics
Economics
Philosophy
Chemical
Ecology
Politics
Civil
...
...
...
multidisciplinary
Fig. 13.6 Graphical representation of the multifacet system to be established and brought into
action with the aim to foster sustainable development of anthroposphere within the limits of the
Earth system. The term “Gaia” stands for the self-regulation capacity of the Earth system enabled
by the sum of ecosystems on Earth (Lovelock 1979). This figure has been prepared by Axel
Kleidon, MPI Jena, Germany
13 Sustainable Earth System Engineering: Incentives and Perspectives 207
3 Summary
Growth of the human population in conjunction with global changes of life style
entails increase of the demand of resources such as energy, water, food, and land.
Land is used for various human purposes but at the expense of ecosystems and the
associated biodiversity which both are shrinking in size and extent. Subsequently,
ecosystems lose their capacity to regulate the world’s climate. Excessive use of
fossil fuels, in parallel to intensification of agriculture, causes tremendous emission
of greenhouse gases, carbon dioxide, methane, and nitrous oxide in particular. This
in turn leads to global warming causing the sea level to rise and habitable land to get
lost. The climate is changing on the global and on the regional scale. Thus, hunger
and thirst is spreading, and so is poverty. People are forced to evacuate from their
homelands, causing the population density in the receiving areas, particular in urban
settings, to further increase. In many parts of the world, this already causes the social
and economic stability to decline.
It appears that mankind is confronted with four major, widely interrelated global
crises: the water and food deficiency crisis, the societal and economic stability crisis,
the crisis resulting from the loss of the self-regulation capacity of ecosystems, and
last but not least the crisis caused by global warming. A holistic approach is to
be taken to combat the problems resulting from this system of crises. The keyword
used in this context is sustainable Earth system engineering defined as the deliberate,
careful, and science-based management of the three major components of the life
support system of the Earth.
In this context, the Earth system is considered to encompass not only a physical
and chemical dimension but a biological and a human dimension as well. To permit
counteractions to become effective, the sustainability axiom must be obeyed. The
term “sustainability” stands for human activities kept in the limits of the generic
capacity of the Earth’s life supporting system – the capacity to deal with resources
taken for human consumption in particular. Usage of nonrenewable resources such
as fossil water and fossil fuel can only be tolerated as a temporary solution.
Emphatic and straight forward attempts are to be made at the highest possible speed
to develop and implement substituting technology and behavioral changes among
the users.
208 P.A. Wilderer et al.
4 Cross-References
References
Anonymous, Zugspitze Declaration. International Expert Group on Earth System Preserva-
tion (IESP), Munich (2008a). http://www.waterlink-international.com/download/Zugspitze
%20Declaration-26-09-08.pdf
Anonymous, Climate Change 2007 – Fourth IPCC Assessment Reports (Cambridge University
Press, Cambridge, 2008b)
Anonymous, Mind the gap. Editorial published in Nature 426, 825–826 (2010)
R.M. Bierbaum, R.B. Zoellick, Science 326, 771 (2009)
A. Gore, An Inconvenient Truth (Rodale, New York, 2006)
V.G. Gorshkov, V.V. Gorshkov, A.M. Makarieva, Biotic Regulation of the Environment
(Springer/Praxis Publishing, London/Chichester, 2000)
V.G. Gorshkov, A.M. Makarieva, Interactive comment on Greenhouse effect dependence on
atmospheric concentrations of greenhouse substances and the nature of climate stability on
Earth. Atmos. Chem. Phys. Discuss. 2, 236–239 (2002)
M. Grambow, W. Meng et al., Korr. Wasserwirtschaft 2(10), 556–561 (2009)
M. Hauff, Von der Sozialen zur Nachhaltigen Marktwirtschaft – Ein neues Leitbild für das 21.
Jahrhundert (From social to sustainable market economy – A new guideline for the 21st
century). Policy paper 31, Stiftung Entwicklung und Frieden, Bonn, (2009)
A. Hoffman, Energy Security Journal, IAGS, 13 Aug 2004
H. Jonas, Das Prinzip Verantwortung - Versuch einer Ethik für die technologische Zivilisation
(Principle of Responsibility – Approach to an Ethic of the Technological Civilization) (Insel
Verlag, Frankfurt a. M., Germany, 1979)
D.W. Keith, E. Parson, M.G. Morgan, Research on global sun block needed now. Nature 463,
426–427 (2010)
T. Lenton, N. Vaughan, Atmos. Chem. Phys. Discuss. 9, 2559–2608 (2009)
13 Sustainable Earth System Engineering: Incentives and Perspectives 209
J. Lovelock, A New Look of Life on Earth (Oxford University Press, Oxford/New York, 1979)
J. Lovelock, The Revenge of Gaia (Penguin Books, London, 2007)
J. Lovelock, The Vanishing Face of Gaia (Basic Books, New York, 2009)
A.M. Makarieva, V.G. Gorshkov, The greenhouse effect and the stability of the Global mean
surface temperature. Dokl. Earth Sci. 377(2), 210–214 (2001)
A.M. Makarieva, V.G. Gorshkov, Biotic pump of atmospheric moisture as driver of the hydrologi-
cal cycle on land. Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci. 11, 1013–1033 (2007)
A.M. Makarieva, V.G. Gorshkov, B.L. Li, Precipitation on land versus distance from the ocean:
evidence for a forest pump of atmospheric moisture. Ecol. Complex. 6, 302–307 (2009)
J. Mervis, Northern India’s groundwater is going down. Science 325, 798 (2009)
F.J. Radermacher, B. Beyers, Welt mit Zukunft – Überleben im 21. Jahrhundert (The World with
Future – Survival in the 21st Century) (Murman Publisher, Hamburg, 2007)
K. Siaou, R. Chiang, B.C. Hardgrave, Systems Analysis and Design: People, Processes, and
Projects (M.E. Sharpe, Armonk, 2010)
H. Welzer, Klimakriege, Wofür im 21. Jahrhundert getoetet wird (Climate wars – What-for People
will be Killed in the 21st Century) (S. Fischer Publisher, Frankfurt, 2008)
WWF, Living Planet Report 2008 (World Wide Fund for Nature, Gland, 2008)
Sustainable Rehabilitation of Water
Infrastructures in Southern Iraq After the 14
Second Gulf War
Andrea Micangeli, Simone Grego, and Stefano Esposto
Abstract
In southern Iraq, the water shortage is an old problem and the Second Gulf War
(2003) made the situation worse. The main problems affecting water provision
are the salinity of the water and the lack of maintenance of the preexisting water
treatment plants (WTP) and compact units (CU).
The most common water treatment used consists in lowering the turbidity
and sterilizing the water to avoid the presence of bacteria using pressurized sand
filters and chlorinating units. However, the main problem of this system is the
lack of adequate supply of chemicals and sand.
During the postwar period (May–December 2003), the Italian NGO “Un
Ponte Per. . . ” (UPP) and the “Interuniversity Centre for Research on Sustainable
Development” (CIRPS) developed a strategy to rehabilitate eight among WTPs
and CUs in the Basrah governorate, in southern Iraq, where the main source of
water for domestic use is the surface water from the channels connected to the
Shatt Al Arab or the Shatt Al Basrah.
In a second phase of the project, in 2009, CIRPS and “Gaia Ricerche” gave to
ICRC, the International Red Cross Committee, an On Site Electro Chlorination
(OSEC) System to be installed in the area.
1 Introduction
The main sources of water in Iraq are the Tigris and Euphrates rivers. Other water
sources include water wells drilled in some locations.
In the District of Basrah, in southern Iraq, the main water source for domestic
use is the surface water from the channels connected to the Shatt Al Arab or the
Shatt Al Basrah. The Shatt al Arab is formed by the merging of the Tigris and the
Euphrates. Most of the population lives either along the river or in areas served by a
network of channels connected to it. There are also inland villages served by wells
(20–30 m deep).
However, the high salinity of the Shatt Al Arab water makes it undrinkable.
The main water supply system for drinking purposes is the conventional water
treatment with sedimentation, filtration, and disinfection. The treatment process
matches western standards, but often, the chemicals supplied for the correct
treatment cannot be found easily in emergencies.
Many European companies had worked in Iraq in the installation of sophisticated
technology, such as remote control or fully automated systems.
Relief agencies and support organizations using water sources to supply potable
water to displaced communities need reliable and durable treatment systems.
The ranking of criteria related to water supply during a crisis can be summa-
rized as:
• Coverage: water must be available every day.
• Quantity: a minimum daily requirement of water must be available (Sphere
standard).
• Sustainability: water must be available during years or at least months (durability
and reliability).
• Quality: water should comply with health-related quality standards (Sphere
standar).
• Cost: treatment and supply system must be affordable, particularly if their
ongoing operation has to be a responsibility of the community.
In addition to costs, also, the type of maintenance required has to be taken into
account. This consideration does not imply great change when the water treatment
system has to be installed in the western world, but it becomes crucial when a water
problem has to be solved in developing countries. If the operation and maintenance
lead to high costs and, above all, require resources not locally available, the project
is facing a probable quick failure (Esposto 2009).
Sustainable development in this “focused meaning” involves maximal use of
local resources while factoring in the limits of exploitation in the life-span of
the project (development), all the while increasing the autonomy of the project
from external factors and ultimately creating a link between the project and
the beneficiaries (sustainability). All these considerations aim to fulfill the needs
according to reasonable and sometimes agreed-upon standards. Unfortunately, not
all the resources necessary for the running of a project can be internal; thus, the aim
should be to reduce the external ones to the possible extent.
14 Sustainable Rehabilitation of Water Infrastructures in Southern Iraq 213
Nowadays, sustainability is the fifth and most important criterion for the
evaluation of project for the European Commission Humanitarian Office, one of
the major donors in humanitarian aid and development.
Sustainability of a project and the wider concept “sustainable development”
involve the idea that an action aimed at supporting or assisting a specific population
should be considered in all its future consequences, taking into account the planning,
the implementation, as well as all the possible countermeasures for guaranteeing its
durability.
The main parameter to be taken in consideration is the origin of the resources
(energy, fuel, chemicals, manpower, and technical knowledge) necessary to run a
project after its completion. They can be classified as “internal resources” if they
are locally available and easily accessible by the beneficiaries, while “external
resources” are those that are not locally available, therefore requiring external
supply or help for their provision. The external resources requirement constitutes
a weak point for a project because the beneficiaries or the community will always
be dependent on external help. Once the external help terminates, the project is
affected.
During the postwar period (May–December 2003), the Italian NGO “Un Ponte
Per. . . ” (UPP) and the “Interuniversity Centre for Research on Sustainable Devel-
opment” (CIRPS) developed a strategy to rehabilitate eight among water treatment
plants (WTP) and compact units (CU) in Basrah governorate (in a radius of 60 km
from Basrah City).
All the rehabilitations can be described as “full,” meaning that plant conditions
at the end of the work were similar to the factory conditions.
Target plants were located in four different districts:
• Abu Al Khaseeb (15 km South of Basrah city, 5 CU)
• Medaina (80 km North of Basrah City, 1 CU)
• Qurna (60 km north of Basrah city, 1 CU)
• Tannouma (1 km East of Basrah city, 1 WTP)
The complete list of plants is reported in Table 14.1.
214 A. Micangeli et al.
Iraq, with a total area of 438,320 km2 including 924 km2 of inland waters, is
surrounded by Iran to the east, Turkey to the north, Syria and Jordan to the west,
Saudi Arabia and Kuwait to the south, and the Persian Gulf to the southeast.
Topographically, Iraq is shaped like a basin, consisting of the Great Mesopotamian
alluvial plain of the Tigris and the Euphrates rivers. (Mesopotamia means, literally,
the land between two rivers). This plain is surrounded, in the north and the east, by
mountains reaching altitudes up to 3,550 m above sea level, and, in the south and the
west, by desert areas that account for over 40% of the land area. For administrative
purposes, the country is divided into 18 governorates, 3 of which are gathered in an
autonomous region.
The total area estimated to be used for agriculture is 8 million ha, which is almost
93% of the cultivable area. However, due to soil salinity, fallow practices, and the
unstable political situation, it is estimated that only 3 out of 5 million ha are actually
annually cultivated. In 1993, the area actually cultivated was estimated to be about
3.73 million ha, 3.46 million of which consisted of annual crops and 0.27 million
consisted of permanent crops.
The total population is about 20.4 million (1995), 25% of which is rural.
Average population density is estimated to be 47 inhabitants/km2 but ranges from
5 inhabitants/km2 in the Anwar province, in the desert in the western part of the
country, to more than 170 inhabitants/km2 in the Babylon province, in the center
of the country. The average population growth rate was estimated at 3.6% during
the period (1980–1990), but emigration of foreign workers and severe economic
hardship have reduced this growth rate since 1990.
In 1989, the agriculture sector contributed only 5% to the gross domestic product
(GDP), which was dominated by oil (61%). Today, about 20% of the labor force is
engaged in agriculture.
The climate is mainly continental, subtropical semiarid, with the north and north-
eastern mountainous regions having a Mediterranean climate. Winters range from
chilly to cold, with a day temperature of about 16ı C dropping at night to 2ı C with a
possibility of frost. Summers are dry ranging from hot to extremely hot, with a shade
temperature of over 43ı C during July and August, yet dropping at night to 26ı C.
Rainfall is seasonal and occurs mainly between December and February except
in the north and northeast of the country where the rainy season is longer, from
November to April. Average annual rainfall is estimated at 154 mm but ranges from
less than 100 mm over 60% of the southern country up to 1,200 mm in the northeast.
216 A. Micangeli et al.
The only river basin in Iraq is the Shatt Al-Arab basin. The Shatt Al-Arab is the river
formed by the confluence downstream of the Euphrates and the Tigris and flows
into the Persian Gulf after a course of only 190 km. Before their confluence, the
Euphrates flows for about 1,000 km and the Tigris for about 1,300 km, respectively,
within the Iraqi territory. Nevertheless, due to the importance of the Euphrates and
the Tigris, the country is generally divided into three river basins: the Tigris, the
Euphrates, and the Shatt Al-Arab (referring in this case to the part downstream of
the two rivers confluence).
Both the Tigris and the Euphrates are international rivers originating in Turkey. The
Tigris river basin in Iraq has a total area of 253,000 km2 , representing 54% of the
total river basin area.
The average annual flow of the Euphrates as it enters Iraq is estimated at 30 km3 ,
with a fluctuating annual value ranging from 10 to 40 km3 . Unlike the Tigris, the
Euphrates receives no tributaries during its passage in Iraq. About 10 km3 /year are
drained into Hawr al Harnmar, a marsh in the south of the country.
As for the Tigris, the average annual runoff as it enters Iraq is estimated at
21.2 km3 . All the Tigris tributaries are on its left bank and are listed, from upstream
to downstream, below:
• The Greater Zab: it originates in Turkey and is partly regulated by the Bakhma
dam. It generates a runoff of 13.18 km3 at its confluence with the Tigris, and 62%
of the 25,810 km2 of its basin is in Iraq.
• The Lesser Zab: it originates in Iran and is regulated by the Dokan dam (6.8 km).
The river basin of 21,475 km2 (74% of which is in Iraqi territory) generates about
7.17 km3 , 5.07 of which of annual safe yield after the Dokan dam construction.
• The Al-Adhaim (or Nahr Al Uzaym): it drains about 13,000 km2 in Iraq. It
generates about 0.79 km3 at its confluence with the Tigris. It is an intermittent
stream subject to flash floods.
• The Diyala: it originates in Iran and drains about 31,896 km2 , 75% of which
in Iraqi territory. It is regulated by the Darbandikhan dam and generates about
5.74 km3 at its confluence with the Tigris.
• The Nahr at Tib, Dewarege (Doveyrich) and Shehabi rivers: they drain together
more than 8,000 km2 . They originate in Iran and bring together about 1 km3 of
highly saline waters in the Tigris.
• The Al-Karkha: its course is mainly in Iran and, from a drainage area of
46,000 km2 , brings about 6.3 km3 yearly into Iraq, namely, into the Hawr Al
Hawiza during the flood season and into the Tigris river during the dry season.
The Karun river, originating in Iran, flows with its mean annual flow of 24.7 km3
into the Shatt AlArab. It brings a large amount of fresh water into the Shatt Al-Arab
just before it reaches the sea.
14 Sustainable Rehabilitation of Water Infrastructures in Southern Iraq 217
The Euphrates and the Tigris are subject to large and possibly disastrous floods.
The level of water in the Tigris can rise at the rate of over 30 cm/h. In the southern
part of the country, immense areas are regularly inundated, levees often collapse,
and villages and roads must be built on high embankments. The Tharthar reservoir
was planned in the 1950s to protect Baghdad from the ravages of the periodic flood-
ing of the Tigris by storing extra water discharge upstream of the Samarra barrage.
2.6 Dams
In 1977, the on-river dams, all of which located in the Tigris river basin, had a
total capacity of 13.7 km3 . During the 1980s, there was an important program of
dams construction in Iraq. The program consisted in the construction of the Saddam
dam on the Tigris (11.1 km3 /, the Kadisiyya (Qadisia) multipurpose dam on the
Euphrates (8.2 km3 /, the Bakhma dam on the upper Zab, one of the Tigris tributaries
(17.1 km3 /, the Badush dam on the Tigris river (0.5 km), and several other desert
dams totaling about 0.5 km3 . The total on-river storage capacities thus amounted
to 42 km3 for the Tigris and to 8.2 km3 for the Euphrates, for a total of 50.2 km3 .
However, the Bakhma dam was completely destroyed. At present, the Al-Adom
dam, with a capacity of 3.8 km, is under construction on the Tigris.
Two off-river storage lakes were created with the construction of the Tharthar
dam (85 km3 / in the Tigris basin, filled with the Wadi Tharthar waters and,
since 1985, with Euphrates waters, and the Habbaniya dam (3.3 km3 /, filled from
upstream Euphrates waters and draining into the Euphrates downstream.
1.5 million ha of agricultural land, from north of Baghdad to the Gulf, between
the two main rivers (the Euphrates and the Tigris). The length of its watercourse,
completed in December 1992, is 565 km, with a total discharge of 210 m3 /s. Other
watercourses were also constructed to reclaim new lands or to reduce water logging.
Total water withdrawal was estimated in 1990 at 42.8 km3 , 92% of which was
used for agricultural purposes, 3% for domestic supplies, and 5% for industrial use.
According to the most recent estimates, 85% of river water withdrawal is used for
agricultural purposes.
In 1991, safe water supplies reached 100% of urban areas but only 54% of rural
areas. As a result of the two Gulf Wars, the situation of the water supply and
sanitation sector has deteriorated, due also to shortages in chlorine imports for water
treatment.
Irrigation dates back to 7,500 years ago in the land between the Tigris and the
Euphrates, when the Sumerians built a canal to irrigate wheat and barley fields.
Irrigation potential was estimated in 1990 at over 5.5 million ha, 63% of which
in the Tigris basin, 35% in the Euphrates basin, and 2% in the Shatt Al-Arab
basin. Considering the soil resources, it is estimated that about 6 million ha are
classified as excellent, good, or moderately suitable for flood irrigation. Following
the development of water storage facilities, the regulated flow has increased and
changed the irrigation potential significantly, since, in 1976, it was estimated at
4.25 million ha.
The total water managed area was estimated at 3.5 million ha in 1990, all of it being
equipped for full or partial control irrigation.
The areas irrigated by surface water are estimated at 3,305,000 ha, 105,000 of
which (3%) in the Shatt Al-Arab river basin, 2,200,000 (67%) in the Tigris river
basin, and 1,000,000 (30%) in the Euphrates river basin. However, it should be noted
that all these areas are not actually irrigated since a large part has been abandoned
due to water logging and salinity. Only 1,936,000 ha were estimated to be actually
irrigated in 1993.
14 Sustainable Rehabilitation of Water Infrastructures in Southern Iraq 219
The areas irrigated from groundwater were estimated at 220,000 ha in 1990, with
18,000 wells. About 8,000 ha were reported equipped for micro-irrigation, but these
techniques were not used.
2.12 Salinity
Salinity has always been a major issue in this area, and it has already been recorded
as a cause of crop yield reductions about 3,800 years ago.
It is estimated that in 1970, half the irrigated areas in central and southern Iraq
were degraded due to water logging and salinity. The absence of drainage facilities
and, to a lesser extent, the irrigation practices used (flooding) were the major
causes of these problems. In 1978, a land rehabilitation program was undertaken,
comprising concrete lining for irrigation canals and installation of field drains and
collector drains. By 1989, a total of 700,000 ha had been reclaimed at a cost of
around US$2,000 /ha.
Nevertheless, recent estimations have shown that 4% of the irrigated areas were
severely saline, 50% medium saline, and 20% slightly saline, i.e., a total of 74% of
the irrigated areas suffered from some degree of salinity. The Ministry of Irrigation
estimated in 1995 the amount of salt transported by the Saddam river to the Gulf
at 17 million tons. Irrigation with highly saline waters (more than 1,500 ppm) has
been practiced for date palm trees since 1977. The use of brackish groundwater is
also reported for tomato irrigation in the south of the country.
2.13 Crops
Two main sprinkler irrigation projects were planned in 1990: the Saddam irrigation
project, supplied by waters from the Third river, was designed for a total area of
250,000 ha while the El Jazira irrigation project should have covered an area of
325,000 ha.
Moreover, the Um Almaarik river in the south west region has recently been
excavated in order to irrigate 20,000 ha upon completion.
220 A. Micangeli et al.
Another main issue in water resources management is the water quality protec-
tion. The level of salinity in the Euphrates is high and is expected to increase with
the development of irrigation in the basin and, as a consequence, the diminution of
the water flow particularly in the dry season.
Treatment of municipal and industrial wastewater is considered as one way to
preserve river water quality. Reuse of treated wastewater for irrigation was also
envisaged before 1990. Some industries were already obliged to desalinate the
Euphrates waters before using it.
Other measures which could be undertaken would need regional cooperation for
a better management of the flood waters and the dams.
2.15.1 Introduction
The Tigris and the Euphrates meet in Qurna City, 65 km north of Basrah, creating
Shat Al Arab River. The governorate is rich in surface water resources even
though the population suffers from lack of no salt treated water. As a matter of
fact, the problems affecting water provision are the water salinity and the lack of
maintenance of the preexisting WTP and CU. The mechanism that leaded to the
high salinity in water is strictly connected to the disappearance of the Mesopotamian
Marshlands.
The Mesopotamian Marshlands are a part of a major international river system,
the Tigris and the Euphrates, one of the great cradles of civilization and the largest
river system in southwest Asia. Modern water works and associated agricultural
schemes have led to extensive environmental change in the basin. These changes
have not only restructured human activities, but dams and drainage schemes have
also drastically transformed the landscape from fertile terrain to salt-encrusted
desert. The Mesopotamian Marshlands have been devastated by the combined
impact of massive drainage works and upstream damming. The Central and Al
Hammar Marshlands have completely collapsed with, respectively, 97% and 94%
of their covered lands transformed in bare land. The left areas are also under high
risks of disappearance due to upstream activities.
The impact of marshlands desiccation on wildlife has been equally devastating
with several endemic species becoming extinct or seriously threatened.
Marsh Arab society, whose livelihood has been entirely dependent on the wetland
ecosystem for millennia, has been dealt a shattering blow. The numerous economic
benefits provided by the marshlands, from fishing, haunting, and rice cultivation
have been lost. As life-supporting ecosystem vanished, at least 40,000 of the Marsh
Arabs fled in Iran, while the rest linger in unknown condition in Iraq. As a result, a
5000-year-old culture is rapidly disappearing.
Another problem affecting the marshlands due to the latest development projects
is the general decline of the Tigris and Euphrates water quality. The main cause
of degradation is the return of saline waters from newly commissioned irrigation
schemes. It is not possible to forecast with precision the extent of the changes in
14 Sustainable Rehabilitation of Water Infrastructures in Southern Iraq 221
Al Shatra
6.5k
18.6km
Tigris River
40km
Pump
station 1
Euphrates River
Al Nasiriyah
61km Pump
station 2
78km Shatt Al Arab
R Zero
Railway
Railway
Sweet Water Basrah
112km 125km 198.5km
Canal Rivers
184km 220km
Fig. 14.2 Channel connecting RO pumping station and WTP with PS2 pumping station
The RO system, that theoretically could resolve the problem of water salinity in
the region, is only a partial solution. In fact, RO is connected only to the main CU
and WTP in the governorate, thus neglecting the minor plants that bring water to
most of the rural areas. As a consequence, most of the 123 among CU and WTP of
14 Sustainable Rehabilitation of Water Infrastructures in Southern Iraq 223
the Basrah governorate are fed with brackish water and produce, after the treatment,
sterilized nondrinkable water.
Moreover, the erratic supply of electricity as a direct consequence of the fuel
shortage and generators oblige the technicians of the station to reduce the total
amount of pumped and treated water to about 50% or less of the designed capacity.
The main outcome of this frustrating situation is the growing of several private
RO stations scattered all over the region. As a matter of fact, RO is the only way to
produce drinkable water in this region and is becoming a major business in the area.
Unfortunately, RO water is too expensive for most of the people living in the rural
areas (prices ranging between 7 and 10 USD/m3 / and cannot be considered a valid
and sustainable solution to face the emergencies.
Moreover, with most of the stations being private, no control on the water
quality is performed. Local water authorities reported that, in some cases, tankers
distributing water were commonly used to clean sewages and that, in most cases,
no chlorine was added at the end of the RO process. Nevertheless, even if the
production would be regulated by local authorities, RO cannot be considered as
a solution for water supply in the region being too expensive and energy consuming
and needing specialized technicians and spare parts to function properly.
Generator
Chlorinator
Distribution
Sedimentation
chamber
Fig. 14.5 Mehailla CU: three parallel lines and six sedimentation tanks, two per line, are shown
areas are in the worst conditions. More than 25 assessments conducted in the region
in the period May–October 2003 enlightened that the sections of WTP and CU
usually more exposed to wear were the following:
• High and low lift pumps and electrical motors: most of the pumps showed
problems in alignment with the electrical motor and most of motors were burned.
• Sedimentation tanks: most of damages come from rust, shells, and bullets.
• Sand filters: the average age of these media is around 20 years.
14 Sustainable Rehabilitation of Water Infrastructures in Southern Iraq 225
• Chlorinators: most of chlorinators were looted in the days after the collapse
of Saddam’s regime but curiously, in some cases, they reappeared after some
months.
• Alum mixers: as chlorinators, most of them were looted and in some cases
reappeared later.
• Pipe fittings and valves.
• Generators.
CU has three pressurized filters with the following four layer composition while
the water flow is from bottom to top:
• A layer of 60 cm with sand d D 0:6 mm
• A layer of 10 cm with sand d D 2:5–6.5 mm
• A layer of 10 cm with sand d D 6:5–9.5 mm
• A layer of 10 cm with sand d D 9:5–13 mm
Unfortunately, due to poor technical skills of local water department personal,
the plants were designed in such way that water flux goes from the top of the filter
to the bottom. Dirty water meets first the thickest layer of sand, characterized by
closing spaces between grains, and in a second stage is purified by the sand with
bigger diameters. The main consequences of this absurd design are:
• The thin layer of sand gets dirty very fast and thus requires frequent backwashes.
• The lower sand layers are completely useless and act only as a support.
• The flux of the water is reduced due to the absence of a proper backwash system.
The lack in electricity supply due to both, damages caused by the last war and the
embargo and the irregular supply of fuel for generators, where these are available,
constitutes an additional problem.
The exposed technical problems are worsened by the inadequacy of the Iraqi
bureaucracy to administrate such a complex water-supplying system. Up to now,
the Basrah Water Department does not have a complete list of the WTP and CU
in the Governorate. This fail has obstructed the rehabilitation work in the postwar
emergency, obliging NGOs and UN agencies to long and dangerous researches and
assessment of almost unknown plants.
The logical framework matrix of the main project with which the rehabilitation
was financed is summarised in Table 14.2.
The rehabilitation work was similar for each plant and followed the steps below:
• Installation of new low lift pumps, which includes:
• Installation of new pipes from the intake to the pumps
• Construction of new concrete basement
• Installation of new pump and fittings
• Assembling and installation of starters and control panels
• Bypass of filters and sedimentation tanks: this operation allows pumping non-
treated water to the villages while filters and sedimentation tanks are under
maintenance.
• Cleaning, repairing, sandblasting, painting, and filling of sand-filters: the paint-
ing of the internal surfaces is performed with three layers of special epoxy
nontoxic paint, while the painting of external surfaces follows the same rules
than the one of pumps and pipes.
• Cleaning, repairing, sandblasting, and painting of sedimentations tanks: the
guidelines to be followed to paint sedimentation tanks are the same as sand
filters.
• Installation of new high lift pumps, which includes:
• Installation of new pipes from the tank and filters to pipes
• Construction of new concrete basement (where necessary)
• Installation of new pump and fittings
• Assembling and installation of starters and control panels
• Civil works: in some plants, new structures like bricks fences, storage room, and
toilets have been built.
• Installation of alum mixers, which includes:
• Installation of motors for dosing pumps
• Installation of dosing pumps
• Installation of plastic tanks for mixing alum sulphate and water
• Assembling and installation of starters and control panels
• Installation of chlorinators, which includes:
• Installation of motors for dosing pumps
• Installation of dosing pumps
• Painting of pipes and pumps: metallic items, like pipes and pumps, are painted
with a layer of special antirust paint (green) and a layer of normal paint (blue).
• Installation of diesel generators: to supply to the malfunction of the electric grid,
diesel generators of high capacity (150–400 kW) have been installed in most of
the plants.
The above steps can be performed in parallel or in serial way, depending on the
available funds.
Working in parallel requires more manpower and is consequently more expensive
but allows time saving.
If serial way is preferred, works must start with items requiring more time to be
completed, like sand filters and sedimentation tanks.
Table 14.2 Logical framework for UNHCR project. The financed amount was 260,000 US Dollars
Intervention logic Objectively verifiable indicators Sources of verification Risks and assumptions
Principal – To rehabilitate the water sector, – Nı of rehabilitations on 123 – Unicef reports – Good coordination among
objective quite close to emergency, in the CU and 12 WTP – Governorate reports NGOs, National and
governorate of Basrah before the – Waterborne diseases decrease International Organizations
situation get worse especially for among refugees – Security in Bashra area
the new presence of returned remains the same of the last
refugees months in 2003 or better
Specific – Returnees and the other – 2 plants fully rehabilitated – Department of water reports – Collaboration of the
objective beneficiaries in Al Medaina and in – 4,500 children have the booklet – Surveys in the villages department of Water of Basrah
Tannouma have access to water for – The security in the villages
domestic use and primary courses remains the same of the last
on safe water use months in 2003 or better
– Increased awareness on water
issues among children
Expected – Rehabilitation of 1 WTP in – Turbidity of the water below – Test at the output of the plants – The plants rehabilitated is
results Tannouma and 1 CU in Al Medaina 5 NTU on chlorine dosage and turbidity maintained by operators of the
– Distribution of booklet for – Total residual chlorine value at level with digital instruments department of water
children the output of the plants in – Sample test with portable kit – The Department of water of
according with the request of the in the villages for E-Coli Basrah supply the chemicals
14 Sustainable Rehabilitation of Water Infrastructures in Southern Iraq
department of water of Basrah presence in the water and the fuel for the correct
– Water quantity for each person running of the plant
above the 20 L/day
– 5,000 booklet printed
227
228 A. Micangeli et al.
Fig. 14.6 Balad Slam plant before the beginning of rehabilitation works. Note the rust on the
sedimentation tank and the absence of any kind of fence for the protection of the plant
Fig. 14.7 Balad Slam sand filter after the first open
• Immediately after the war (April–May 2003), a diesel pump (Q D 500 m3 /h,
h D 50 m) was installed in the intake by the local engineers of “Un Ponte
Per. . . ” to pipe directly nontreated water to the villages when electricity from the
230 A. Micangeli et al.
network was not available (sometimes for 22 h/day). The pump has been working
as a diesel pump until the generator was installed (August). Starting from that
moment, the pump worked only when generator was in standby for maintenance.
• A brick fence for Balad Slam and Mejran was built (see Fig. 14.10).
• Chlorinator (1 kg/h) was shifted on the outside of the steel container.
Donor
The rehabilitation work was funded by ECHO- European Office for Emergencies.
Fig. 14.10 Balad Slam plant after the rehabilitation. Note the new fence, the cement basement,
a new storage room on the right, and the shade to cover chlorinators
Fig. 14.11 Mejran plant before rehabilitation (May 2003). Note the fence condition and the
abandoned sand filter on the left. The fence was substituted with a brick one, which responded
to the requests of the Water Department. The same filter was rehabilitated and added to the two
already installed in the plant
14 Sustainable Rehabilitation of Water Infrastructures in Southern Iraq 233
Fig. 14.12 Maintained filter and new basement in Mejran Plant. Note on the left the new
chlorinator (10 kg/h) connected with Cl2 cylinders
Slam (see Fig. 14.10). The original design of the plant foresaw three filters, one of
which was not in use when the plant was assessed in May 2003 (see Fig. 14.11).
Since the installation of the plant in the early 1980s, sand had never been changed.
Once opened, the filters showed the complete absence of sand and the presence of
solidified mud. Both high-lift pumps were working when the plant was visited for
the first time.
A full rehabilitation was performed for Mejran CU. All the pumps were
substituted by identical ones available on the local market. Part of the rehabilitation
started in May 2003, just few days after the end of the war. For this reason, some of
the purchased items were used and not always in good conditions. In such cases, a
full rehabilitation of the item was performed.
The following list details some particularities in the rehabilitation process:
• A second-hand generator of 250 kVA was installed and maintained to feed Balad
Slam and Mejran Plant located in the same field.
• The intake was completely redesigned to rationalize piping (see Fig. 14.12).
• The third filter was fully rehabilitated. The rehabilitation consisted in:
• Sandblasting and painting
• Welding a new plate for nozzles
• Welding new metallic legs
234 A. Micangeli et al.
• The area of the filters was enlarged with the construction of a new basement
(approx. 10 5 m).
• A brick fence for Balad Slam and Mejran was built (see Fig. 14.10).
• A room for guard and operator was built (see Fig. 14.10).
• A new chlorinator (10 kg/h) was installed on the new basement (Fig. 14.9).
Donor
The rehabilitation work was funded by ECHO- European Office for Emergencies.
Fig. 14.13 On the top, new guard room in Mejran. On the bottom, the new intake structure
236 A. Micangeli et al.
Fig. 14.14 Steel cover and outlet valves of the Hamdan Jissar sedimentation tank destroyed by an
explosion during the Second Gulf War
Fig. 14.15 On the left, repaired steel cover. On the right, repaired outlet valves
Donor
The rehabilitation work was funded by ECHO- European Office for Emergencies.
Fig. 14.17 On the left, view of channels in Jecor. On the right, children playing in Jacor
238 A. Micangeli et al.
Donor
The rehabilitation work was funded by ECHO- European Office for Emergencies.
14 Sustainable Rehabilitation of Water Infrastructures in Southern Iraq 239
Fig. 14.20 On the left, Jecor generator. On the right, Jecor chlorinator
Once clarified, water passes through three sand filters (horizontal cylinders, length
6 m and diameter 2 m) with a parallel process, is chlorinated, and then pumped in
the network by two high-lift pumps (Q D 200 m3 /h, h D 50 m). The high-lift pumps
are in a concrete structure (see Fig. 14.22) which also hosts a small office, toilets,
and a control panel’s room.
Fig. 14.23 On the left, brick fence in Al Swaib Plant. On the right, part of the mud removed from
the sedimentation tank
• Rehabilitation of sedimentation tank took more than 2 months due to the huge
amount of precipitated mud (see Fig. 14.23).
• The room for guards and operator was rehabilitated.
• A new chlorinator (10 kg/h) was installed.
Donor
The rehabilitation work was funded by ECHO- European Office for Emergencies.
Fig. 14.24 On the left, Shat Al Arab sedimentation tank (front) and water reservoir (back). The
reservoir is not in use. On the right, the sand-filters room
small (25–50 m3 /h) CUs, which need constant maintenance and trained operators
to run.
The plant is inside the city of Tanouma (actually inside Basrah city) and is built
3 km far from the intake in Shat Al Arab river. Three low lift pumps (Q D 500 m3 /h,
h D 20 m) work together to bring 1,500 m3 /h of raw water to the treatment plant.
Water is pumped in a huge circular concrete sedimentation tank (see Fig. 14.24),
where it is mixed with a concentrate Al2 (SO4 /3 solution and then flocculation
occurs. Once clarified, water passes through six sand filters (concrete basins, see
Fig. 14.24) with a parallel process, is chlorinated, and then pumped in the network
by three high-lift pumps (Q D 500 m3 /h, h D 50 m).
Donor
The rehabilitation work was funded by UNHCR, project number 03/SB/IRQ/RP/
332.
14 Sustainable Rehabilitation of Water Infrastructures in Southern Iraq 243
Donor
The rehabilitation work was funded by UNHCR, project number 03/SB/IRQ/RP/
332.
Fig. 14.25 On the left, view of Al Medaina CU from the intake on the Tigris river. On the right,
the internal surface of the sedimentation tank
244 A. Micangeli et al.
3 Summary
On one side, the shortness of energetic, hydro, and natural resources produces social
tensions and national and international conflicts. On the other side, the exploitation
of such resources at the present rate and with the present technologies has an impact
on natural and human environment. Both conflicts and environmental issues act on
the capabilities of populations to satisfy their needs using resources.
Wars and postwar consequences, like embargos, seriously affect the infrastruc-
tures necessary to exploit directly and indirectly specific resources. Environmental
issues usually affect the quality and the quantity of available resources. Both these
effects have serious consequences on the possibility of human beings, in specific
areas, to use all the necessary resources for their development, and this again
generates conflicts. The drawn picture is a circle which needs to be broken. This
difficult challenge is the main task of all the sciences dealing with sustainable
development.
Within this framework, summarised in Fig. 14.26, the attention of this project
was focused on the specific task of water treatment in poor, remote, and emergency
areas.
Figure 14.27 shows the concept illustrated in Fig. 14.26 applied to the specific
case study of water purification in Iraq after the Second Gulf War.
Projects implemented in Iraq are a partial solution to the problem of conflicts,
because they act on the consequences of the war, without taking in account, and
Environmental
Impact
Climate change
Use of Decrease of
energy quality and New technologies
resources quantity of
resources
Resources Consequences
Natural
on the ability
Hydro
Energetic to use the
resources
Shortness of
Infrastructures to
resources
exploit resources
affected by
conflicts
Conflicts
Rehabilitation
Works
Fig. 14.26 Scheme of the relations between resources, conflicts, environmental issues, and the
capability of a population to use the resources for its development. Note that the activities presented
in this work interact with both mechanisms which affect the ability of some populations to use
resources for its own development
14 Sustainable Rehabilitation of Water Infrastructures in Southern Iraq 245
Environmental
Impact
Climate change
(Increase sea level) Decrease of
Use of High Salinity in Tigris quality and Desalination
fossil fuels and Euphrates quantity available
water
Dry of Marsh
Arabs
Consequences
Resources on the ability
Natural to purify water
Hydro
Wars and Embargo
damage water
infrastructures in
Shortness of Oil Iraq
Conflicts Rehabilitation of
WTP in Southern
First (1991) and Second Iraq
(2003) Gulf War
Fig. 14.27 Scheme of the relations between resources, conflicts, environmental issues, and the
capability of a population to use the resources for its development for the specific case of Southern
Iraq. Note that the activities presented in this work interact with both mechanisms which affect the
ability of some populations to purify water
thus acting on, the causes. Nevertheless, the huge number of beneficiaries (250,000–
300,000), the applied methodologies (community participation, time of intervention,
etc.) and the innovative partnership (university and NGO) assure the overall quality
of the project, its sustainability, and the innovation.
Acknowledgments
References
J. Davis, R. Lambert, Engineering in Emergencies – A Practical Guide for Relief Workers (ITDG
publishing, London, 2002)
S. Esposto, Sustainability applied to the design of water treatment plants in Iraq. Sustain. Sci. 4(2),
293–300 (2009)
Sustainable Water Management in
Response to Global Changes 15
Peter A. Wilderer, Martin Grambow, and Wei Meng
Abstract
Presumably, sustainable water management is the correct answer to the changing
precipitation patterns resulting from global warming and to the rapid increase
of the global water demand caused by population growth and lifestyle changes
on the global as well as on the regional level. To minimize volume and rate
of abstraction from aquifers and man-made reservoirs, elementary improve-
ments are recommended concerning water usage, water transportation, and
pricing. Innovative water-efficient agricultural practices are to be developed
and introduced. Concerning urban water management priority is to be given to
maintenance, cascading use of water and water reuse. In water-deficient areas,
wastewater has to be considered as a potential source of water. City planners,
architects, investors, and representatives of water authorities are called to join
forces. It needs to be understood that methods tailored to the specific climatic,
hydrological, economic, and cultural situation at the spot are superior over
traditional methods described in major textbooks. Sustainable solutions can be
expected to materialize when up-to-date knowledge and wisdom meet.
1 Introduction
Water in appropriate quantity and quality supplied to people, industry, and agri-
culture is to be assumed as backbone of global and national security. Sustainable
water supply plays an important role not only in quenching thirst and hunger. It is
the prerequisite of economic development, and it is a major handle in the attempt to
keep social and economic systems in balance. In this context, water supply is just the
one side of the coin termed “sustainable water management.” The other but equally
important side of this coin represents purification, direct or indirect reuse, and safe
discharge of the used water – also termed sewage or wastewater. Safe discharge of
the used but appropriately purified water into natural water systems is important to
maintain the basic function of aquatic ecosystems which are to be envisioned as an-
other backbone of global and national security since ecosystems are known to secure
life enabling conditions on earth (Lovelock 1979, 2006, 2009; Gorshkov et al. 2000).
Remarkably, most of the water-related problems are very well known all over the
world, in principle at least. In many cases, it is possible to give exact advice how to
deal with them. Contemporary scientific knowledge and the technical means built
upon this knowledge make it possible to monitor the local and even transboundary
water system, to protect surface waters and aquifers, and to purify the used water
prior to reuse or discharge. Nevertheless, in many parts of the world, the water
systems are in a catastrophic shape. Presumably, more fresh water is “consumed”
by pollution than by using it for drinking, irrigation, and industrial production.
As stated in Sect. 3 of the Zugspitze Declaration (see chapter Sustainable
Earth System Engineering: Incentives and Perspectives) deeds must follow words
to overcome water-related problems. Sustainable water management is a most
promising measure to satisfy the food and water demand in the world, leading out
of the world water and food deficiency crisis (Sect. 7 of the Zugspitze Declaration).
Sustainability is an expression which is not unknown in the water sector. For
instance, the concept of Integrated Water Resources Management – often referred
to as IWRM – (Anonymous 2000a; Wilderer 2004, 2007; Grambow 2008) – is an
application of guidelines which were set by the United Nations at the conference
in Rio de Janeiro in 1993 (Agenda 21 1993). In parallel, the Water Framework
Directive was issued by the Commission of the European Union (Anonymous
2000b). It became the guideline of water management activities in Europe and
beyond. In response to the world crises, further development of the IWRM is in
progress. It is advisable to design and implement comparable management methods
to combat the four world crises highlighted in Fig. 3 of chapter Sustainable Earth
System Engineering: Incentives and Perspectives.
The term “sustainable development” originates from forestry science (von
Carlowitz 1713). In some respects, sustainable water management is a method
which reflects the way water is naturally used, reused, and temporarily stored in
forest ecosystems (Fig. 15.1). It is a method which obviously has been successfully
applied in natural forest ecosystems for millions of years. Thus, proper transforma-
tion into modern day civilization bears the chance of solving the complex problems
of urban areas under threat of rapid expansion.
15 Sustainable Water Management in Response to Global Changes 249
components processes
– trees abstraction & processing of water, CO2, nutrients
– epiphyton emission of oxygen & water vapor
– underwood cascading use of water
– animals temperature control by evapo-tanspiration
– bacteria temporary storage of water and carbon
– soil
Fig. 15.1 Major components and processes characterizing the function of forest ecosystems (artist
unknown)
In many parts of the world, urban areas are rapidly growing, mainly as result
migration and immigration. People move into cities in expectation of a better
life compared to what they have experienced in their homelands. Cities grow. In
contrast, the locally available water resources (aquifers, rivers, lakes, reservoirs)
are a given asset with respect to quantity. These resources are rather shrinking in
size and quality because of pollution, over-abstraction, and reduced rainwater and
melting water infiltration caused by surface sealing and droughts and – in coastal
zones – by intrusion of seawater. Industries, power plants, and agriculture compete
for the available water which aggravates water supply in urban areas.
The traditional attempt to solve water supply problems in cities and agriculture
is excess abstraction. The long-term consequences are disastrous. As mentioned
in chapter Sustainable Earth System Engineering: Incentives and Perspectives the
groundwater level in Northern India has been decreasing over the past years at a rate
of up to 4 cm per year (Mervis 2009). The annual net loss of groundwater in a 2,000-
km-long stripe stretching from Pakistan to Bangladesh accounts to 54 ˙ 9 km3 . But
the problem is not only the loss but the growing distance between the groundwater
table and the root zone of plants growing or expected to grow at the surface. In
agriculture, the increase of the distance to the groundwater table makes it necessary
250 P.A. Wilderer et al.
2.1 Agriculture
In many parts of the world, only a fraction of the crops grown on agricultural
fields makes it to the consumers (Asit Biswas, 2006, personal communication). A
significant fraction is rotting on its way from the field to the consumers because of
the lack of proper transportation and cooling facilities. Any degree of improvement
on this side would help overcoming the food supply shortages and decrease the
water demand of agriculture.
Secondly, transformation to water saving agricultural practices would reduce the
water consumption of agriculture even further. Development and deployment of
innovative concepts such as rooftop farming (growth of vegetable on top of high-rise
buildings) is to be encouraged (Kauffman and Bailkey 2000; Wilson 2005).
2.2 Municipalities
Because ill maintenance of water distribution systems, the loss of water caused
by leakages is high, sometimes extremely high. Fixing leaks would diminish local
water scarcity problems significantly.
To further overcome water shortages in cities, it is recommendable to consider
cascading use of water and reuse practices – at least in new urban development
areas. Figure 15.2 provides a graphical representation of the three, currently
widely discussed and partially already applied approaches toward water reuse in
urban areas:
1. Return of water after advanced purification to the reservoir or aquifer feeding the
central water works (Tortajada 2006)
15 Sustainable Water Management in Response to Global Changes 251
CeSa/R
use of treated wastewater
Centralized Sanitation for industrial purposes
& Re-use
WW
WWTP
DeSa/R
Decentralized Sanitation & Re-use
Fig. 15.2 Two options to reduce the amount of water to be abstracted from natural resources such
aquifers and lakes or man-made resources such as reservoirs
encompassing all the water relevant sectors including regulation, finance, and, last
but not least, the civil society as the major end user of water (Wilderer 2009).
Closing the water cycle in an urban setting reduces the stress imposed to the
regional hydrology. However, closing the loop bears serious risks with respect
to public health. It is unavoidable that chemical substances accumulate in water
kept in circulation. Components formerly rated as trace substances are already
present in enhanced concentrations, specifically in areas downstream major rivers
where water is unintentionally reused. Of particular concern are pharmaceuticals,
hormones, pesticides, heavy metals, and nanoparticles. As in earlier times, when
modern water supply and sanitation system were invented, it keeps being of primary
importance that pathogenic organisms and viruses are removed from water supplied
for potable use. The rapid development of membrane technology makes it possible
to control, better than ever before, the spread of waterborne pathogenic organisms
and viruses. Further technological developments are necessary to solve drawbacks
still associated with membrane systems such as fouling, scaling, leaking, energy
consumption, and last but not least costs.
With respect to decentralization of water treatment and water reuse, development,
testing, and responsible monitoring of the respective technology are required.
Decentralized sanitation and reuse systems (DeSa/R) have to be particularly robust,
reliable, and affordable. Continuous education and training of design engineers,
operators, regulators, and end users is a must. To make sure that decentralized water
and wastewater treatment systems work reliably and cost-efficiently, it is necessary
to develop robust sensors to provide electronic information about the performance of
the dispersed treatment plants (Fig. 15.3). The signals might be electronically or via
GSM transferred to a central monitoring station where advanced signal processing
and innovative control engineering are performed. The results are to be displayed in
a visual form readily understandable by even low-profile service staff.
In conclusion, the need for research and development in the field of water
technology is enormous but often underestimated by the respective funding institu-
tions. Research and technology efforts are to be encouraged. Successful mitigation
of water stress in urban and rural areas, in industry, and agriculture depends on
advances of science, technology, management practices, legal frameworks, and
public perception.
Even so urban areas pose a big challenge – not only with respect to water manage-
ment – the rural area surrounding cities, the “hinterland” requires special attention
and sustainable development as well. According to the law of symbiosis, a city
cannot survive without a healthy environment beyond its outskirts. In this context,
the term “healthy environment” stands for a balanced interrelationship between
human activities and factors enabling nature to perform its generic function. Even at
relatively small scale, it is important to give room to well-functioning ecosystems,
forests, and wetlands in particular. These natural assets are prerequisites for the
preservation of a climate favoring well-being of flora and fauna but also well-being
15 Sustainable Water Management in Response to Global Changes 253
DeSa/R 1 DeSa/R n
DeSa/R 2 DeSa/R 4
central monitoring
& service
DeSa/R 3
Fig. 15.3 Centralized monitoring and control of decentralized sanitation and reuse plants
(DeSa/R) on the basis of an innovative sensor and control concept using electronic transmission of
performance data
of the human society and economy. Innovative concepts of land management and
land use planning are required to satisfy the needs of nature and man alike.
The Water Frame Work Directive of the EU may be considered as a valuable
tool of managing the hinterland. It is a guideline designed to stabilize the function
of ecosystems with the aim to convert and maintain natural water bodies in “good
shape” and at “high ecological potential.” Thus, the EU Water Framework Directive
serves as a tool to overcome the water and food deficiency crises as well as the
ecosystem and biodiversity crisis while strengthening the economic and social status
of rural areas in relation to the embedded urban areas.
It is essential to underline that the complex threats of the four Earth crises (see
chapter Sustainable Earth System Engineering: Incentives and Perspectives) can
only be solved in a sustainable, holistic, and integral way. Answers will be partially
of technical nature but as important are methods which facilitate political decision
making in the attempt to overcome negative feedback caused by nonsustainable
254 P.A. Wilderer et al.
behavior. The traditional generic obligations of the State to provide its citizens
with favorable living conditions is valid and important, but it is insufficient taking
into perspective the threats posed by the four Earth crises. The State authorities
are now responsible for the functioning of the anthroposphere but also for the
preservation of the entire ecosphere, at least within the boundaries of national
jurisdiction.
A two-step strategy appears to be taken: Appropriate technical and organizational
solutions have to be developed and implemented at the national or transnational
level. Moreover, it should be realized that the availability of sustainable solutions
affects the world market, assisted by the theoretical knowledge about the pressure
and the translation into the national and international policy. In the light of this
process, it is necessary to increase the dialoge between science, engineering, and
the political decision makers including the governmental regulators.
5 Concluding Remarks
Decentralized systems to treat and reuse water require special attention by water
authorities responsible for public health. To be developed and implemented are
not only high-quality appliances and treatment processes but also management
structures to provide remote control, safety, and convenience.
This applies for the urban as well as for the rural areas. The latter are known
to contribute substantially to the sustainability of the whole water system. In
consequence, rural areas have to be developed with the same wholeheartedness.
Taking all such issues into account, it is obvious that the water sector has not
reached a mature state. On the contrary, the R&D demands of the water sector, the
need to invent and implement innovative concepts and techniques, and the need
to educate operators, regulators, and people in general are even greater as global
warming, urbanization, lifestyle changes, and the desire for comfort are proceeding
at an increasing rate. It is time for investment in research, technology development,
innovative infrastructure and management methods, and a shift in public attitudes.
And last but not least, turning away from the well-established but ill-conceived
anthropocentric worldview is a must.
6 Cross-Reference
References
Agenda 21: Earth Summit – the United Nations Programme of Action from Rio, United Nation
Publications (1993). ISBN 13: 9789211005097
Anonymous, Integrated Water Resources Management (Global Water Partnership, Stockholm,
2000a)
Anonymous, Directive 2000/60/EC of the European parliament and of the council establishing a
framework for the community action in the field of water policy. Off. J Eur. OJ L 43(327) 1–72
(2000b)
P. Cornel, Semi-centralized supply and treatment systems for fast growing areas. in Water Supply
and Sanitation for All, ed. by H.H. Huber, P.A. Wilderer, S. Paris (Hans Huber AG Berching,
2007). ISBN 13978-1-84339-514-0: 211–212
V.G. Gorshkov, V.V. Gorshkov, A.M. Makarieva, Biotic Regulation of the Environment (Springer,
London, 2000)
M. Grambow, Wassermanagement, Integriertes Wasserresourcenmanagement (IWRM) von
der Vision zur praktischen Umsetzung (Water Management, Integrated Water Resource
Management (IWRM) from Vision to Practical Implementation) (Vieweg Publishing, Wies-
baden, Germany, 2008)
A. Hoffman, Energy Security Journal, IAGS, 13 Aug 2004
J. Kauffman, M. Bailkey, Farming Inside Cities: Entrepreneurial Urban Agriculture in the United
States. Working paper, Chicago (Lincoln Institute of Land Policy, Cambridge, 2000)
T.A. Larsen, W. Gujer, Waste design and source control lead to flexibility in wastewater
management. IWA World Water Congress, Paris, book 5 (IWA Publishing, London, 2000)
pp. 93–300
J. Lovelock, A New Look of Life on Earth (Oxford University Press, New York/Oxford, 1979)
J. Lovelock, The Revenge of Gaia (Penguin Books, London, 2007)
15 Sustainable Water Management in Response to Global Changes 257
J. Lovelock, The Vanishing Face of Gaia (Basic Books, New York, 2009)
J. Mervis, Northern India’s groundwater is going down. Science 325, 798 (2009)
C. Tortajada, Water management in Singapore. Water Resour. Dev. 22, 227–240 (2006)
H.C. von Carlowitz, Sylivicultura oeconomica: anweisung zur wilden Baumzucht. Reprint (2000)
TU Freiberg, Germany, Report 135 (1713)
P.A. Wilderer, Applying sustainable water management concepts in rural and urban areas: some
thoughts about reasons, means and needs. Water Sci. Technol. 49(7), 7–16 (2004)
P.A. Wilderer, UN water action decade: a unique challenge and chance for water engineers. Water
Sci. Technol. 51(8), 99–107 (2005)
P.A. Wilderer, Sustainable water resources management: the science behind the scene. J. Sustain.
Sci. 2, 1–4 (2007)
P.A. Wilderer, Climate change and its consequences for water and wastewater management.
J. Front. Env. Sci., Springer 3(1), 1–11 (2009)
G. Wilson, Singapor’s new business oportunity: food from the roof (2005), Retrieved from http://
www.greenroofs.com/archives/gf nov-dec05.htm. Accessed 12 March 2012
Section III
Sustainable Products and Sustainable
Production
Sustainable Products and Sustainable
Production: Introduction 16
Kun-Mo Lee
K.-M. Lee
Department of Environmental Engineering, Ajou University, Suwon, Korea
e-mail: kunlee@ajou.ac.kr
“QFD for Environment (QFDE)” consists of four phases. Designers can find out
which parts are the most important parts to enhance environmental consciousness
of their products by executing QFDE phase I and II. Furthermore, a methodology
to evaluate the effects of design improvement on the environmental quality require-
ments can be found in QFDE phase III and IV. The results obtained from the case
study of an integrated circuit package show that QFDE can be applicable in the
early stage of assembled product design, because most important component from
the viewpoint of the environment is clearly identified and multiple options for design
improvement are effectively evaluated.
Chapter Sustainable Product Design and Development: TPI-Based Idea Gener-
ation Method for Eco-Business Planning and Eco-Product Development introduces
Total Performance Design (TPD) method which focuses on the balance of cus-
tomer’s utility value of a product and its resulting environmental load and cost
throughout entire life cycle. Total performance indicator (TPI) which represents
environmental and economic performance of a product throughout its entire life
cycle is used as an objective function and a design solution is derived as a set of life
cycle options (e.g., reuse, recycling, upgrading, extension of physical lifetime) for
each component, specification for each functional requirement, and product lifetime
that maximizes TPI under a given business environment.
Consideration of various eco-business strategies (e.g., product sales, lease and
rental, and function selling) also plays an important role to improve TPI. For
example, adequate control and management of operating conditions are effective
for products which consume large quantities of energy and materials during their
use stage. In this case, providing products with energy-saving service (e.g., ESCO
business) is a promising approach. In addition to the operating conditions, product
lifetime and its physical wear and deterioration rates are also insufficiently con-
trolled by product design alone. Therefore, idea generation and decision making
process for eco-business strategy, as well as design of a target product itself, should
be focused on.
This chapter provides a designer with a set of eco-business rules and case base
extracted from the Japanese eco-business cases. The applicability of each rule
is described in relation with 17 business parameters that represent the situation
(pattern) of a given business environment. Referring to the rules and the cases of
which patterns are similar to a given business environment, the designer can easily
generate adequate eco-business ideas. The designer can also determine the product
performance specifications that are suitable for the generated eco-business ideas
through the analysis of these parameters.
Chapter Sustainable Design by Systematic Innovation Tools (TRIZ, CAI, SI,
and Biomimetics) introduces design method using tools such as Theory of Inventive
Problem Solving (TRIZ) and computer aided innovation (CAI). Fostering creativity
in design practice was in the realm of random process, namely, serendipity. One of
the gigantic steps for systematic innovation was possible by introduction of TRIZ.
This chapter introduces the concepts and accomplishments of applying the efforts
toward somewhat paradoxical systematic creativity named CAI on sustainable de-
sign. Firstly, the history and current state of CAI, SI, and biomimetics are described.
16 Sustainable Products and Sustainable Production: Introduction 265
Secondly, literature review of papers on the cross area of sustainable design and CAI
is presented. Thirdly, bio-inspired design approach (encompassing biomimetics)
which aims at finding wisdom from man-made world is discussed. Fourthly, efforts
to correlating TRIZ and biomimetics are presented. Finally, the innovation story
of a paper production industry where material and energy consumption is huge
and critical is introduced as an example of the sustainable design by SI tools.
The example shows that radical innovation toward ideality can be considered as
an epitome of sustainable design.
Chapter Remanufacturing discusses method for remanufacturing of used parts
and components for a product. Remanufacturing, a process of bringing used
products to “like-new” functional state with matching warranty, is being regarded as
a more sustainable mode of manufacturing because it can be profitable and less
harmful to the environment than conventional manufacturing. The practice is
particularly applicable to complex electro-mechanical and mechanical products
which have cores that, when recovered, will have value added to them which is high
relative to their market value and to their original cost. Because remanufacturing
recovers a substantial fraction of the materials and value added to a product in its
first manufacture, and because it can do this at low additional cost, the resulting
products can be obtained at reduced price. Remanufacturing however is poorly
understood because of its relative novelty in research terms. This chapter clearly
defines the term “remanufacturing” by differentiating it from alternative green
production initiatives. It provides an overview of the remanufacturing concept,
significance, and practice.
Chapter Reuse of Components and Products: “Qualified as Good as New”
focuses on “qualified as good as new (quagan)” method for the design of a product
using reused components. Reuse of components and products offers attractive
economic advantages provided that those components are quagan. A quagan
component, deployed in a second life in a new product, can have a higher degree of
reliability than the new ones because early failures have been already eliminated by
its previous life.
This chapter provides guidelines to convince quagan consumers of getting a
technically up-to-date product, the quality assessment procedures, including the
ones to fulfill the safety requirements, and their documentation. It explains how
“design for recycling” can work and what should not be reused. Also it explains the
state of the software of more complex product systems and the importance of their
upgrading process.
Application of the sustainable product design and sustainable production part
shows the actual application of the above two parts to the industrial practices.
It addresses practical application to the sustainable product and production process
design.
Sustainable Production: Eco-efficiency of Manufacturing Process sustainable
manufacturing technologies and their application to the development of industrial
parts. Requirements for practical manufacturing technologies include satisfying
high quality, low cost, and low environmental impact simultaneously. Environmen-
tal issues are important; however, quality is the key feature in deciding whether the
266 K.-M. Lee
Abstract
In ISO TR 14062 “Integrating environmental aspects into product design and
development,” company strategies and product strategies are clearly described
but design strategies are barely mentioned. There are many “design for X
(DfX)” approaches, the rules from experience, life cycle thinking, and other
potential design for environment (DFE) solutions. Many of these propagate to
make DfE complicated. Besides environmental impact considerations, structural
elements like modularity should be taken into account which has no effect on the
environmental impact. Product structure is important for disassembly and in the
end for the product lifetime.
A systematic product design approach is introduced in this chapter. Highlights
of the design strategies include:
• A product should be simplified in structure and complexity. Three design
strategies are distinguishable: design for functional units, design for a fewer
number of materials (target: one plastic, one metal), and a design with
standard components from the market combined with disassembly analysis to
simplify the product structure. Starting from a reference product, not only en-
vironmental impact but also disassembly time which offers information about
the structural quality of the product are taken into account. In reality, many
manufacturers have no real choice which way to go because they purchase
most of the components and do not engage in product design and development
much by their own. Often, there is also a mixture between these strategies but
an optimized solution could exist for each manufacturer situation.
• It should be mentioned that the result of application of the rules from
experience is part of the ecoprofile of a product. If possible, the rules of design
for recycling (DfR) are to be integrated in product design process.
F. Quella
Siemens, retired, DKE/ISO/ZVEI, formerly headed workgroups/projects, Ottobrunn, Germany
e-mail: Qusaeng@t-online.de
J. Kauffman, K.-M. Lee (eds.), Handbook of Sustainable Engineering, 269
DOI 10.1007/978-1-4020-8939-8 115,
© Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht 2013
270 F. Quella
1 Introduction
of LCA does not indicate a path for further improvement in contrast to the rules of
experience.
Another approach is to use the rules from experience. Here, one finds rules for the
reduction of environmental impacts like energy or resource consumption and other
more structure-oriented rules like improving modularity, upgradeability, or avoiding
screws, adhesives, and many more. Starting initially with company specific rules,
summary of those internationally agreed rules is published in IEC 62 430 (2009).
The advantage of such rules is that an engineer can quickly improve his product
using the knowledge of many experienced engineers. As the rules of experience are
often only a mere collection of different rules and not embedded in a tight scheme of
design a beginner may be confused by the rules and do not know how to apply them.
The situation, however, was improved by applying only very few selected rules or
by applying them in the order of life cycle. In any event, application of the rules can
answer the question: How can the benefit of an improvement on the environmental
side be converted into benefit on the product sales or marketing side? With nearly
every “reduce” or “avoid” rule, potential environmental impact and cost reduction
are connected. Also, with the structure-oriented rules about modularity or simple
connections, better repairability or chance for separation of recyclable materials can
be realized.
In the end, there are different tools to choose for product improvement including
LCA, “Design for X (DfX),” rules from experience, or life cycle thinking. But
it remains unclear how these tools should be applied together and how they are
interrelated.
These principles can be applied to all components for material reduction or energy
saving. These are generalized rules from experience as such they can fulfill the
requirements to be applied to an overall Ecodesign process. In addition, these
principles should be combined with a multicriteria approach because Ecodesign
requirements should be part of the overall product specification.
There will be only one design process, although environmental contribution is
discussed in this chapter in more detail. In Wimmer et al., “avoidance” refers to
“omitting a certain key element or function of a product, often connected with a
totally new product concept.” “Substitution” refers to the exchange or replacement
of a component, but can also refer to substituting one certain function of a product
for another. “Reduction” refers to using less material or less energy. If these
three general principles are combined with more detailed rules from experience,
significant improvement of a product might be achieved quickly. But again the
structural change is not systematically investigated, and a product simplification
is not a real target, although it might be the result in the end.
A new product design requires structural and environmental evaluation and selec-
tion of the type of product. According to Melzer (2005), products produced in
mass or consumer products are designed preferentially in optimizing functional
components, whereas capital goods are better designed optimizing refurbishment,
reuse, and recycling. This general approach might be a picture of the current state
of the art in product design.
But in general, for capital goods and consumer products, the same kind of design
principles could be applied. This is the case when manufacturers purchase most
components and no or minimum effort is given to its own product design and
development. Then, products are only assembled with many components available
on the (spot) market. Design in this case concentrates widely on the housing.
Therefore, this design strategy depends strongly on the market situation of the
manufacturer which is often not taken into account when the question is put how
to apply Ecodesign.
In this chapter, the design approach selected is slightly different. Three main
principles exist in the design approach: (1) divide product into functions; (2) reduce
types and parts: target one kind of material; and (3) “use standard components from
the market,” All three approaches can be used for improvement of the environmental
attributes of a product. From these principles, the following design strategies are
derived (Fig. 17.1).
Here, the first step is the evaluation of environmental impact of a reference
product. Next step is the disassembly analysis of this product. Standard software
programs for disassembly time calculation are available on the market to identify
the problematic connections consuming time. The calculation results show also on
which product level connections should be changed or whether which product levels
are to be eliminated. Modern software tools correspond also to the computer-aided
17 Ecodesign Strategies: A Missing Link in Ecodesign 273
Disassembly analysis
Optimization of parts
Optimization of units and connections Optimization of
and connections connections
Disassembly
analysis
Fig. 17.1 Strategic design approaches: (1) Functional design, (2) Simplification by types and parts
reduction, taget: one kind of material, (3) Using standard components from the market
in such a way that the component becomes an inlay in the housing and the housing
possesses extra functional content. Not only screws are avoided but also material is
saved and the size of the functional components is reduced.
Another idea behind the creation of functional components should be simple
exchangeability of a component for repair, reuse, or recycling. Nowadays, as repair
costs are often quite high, a functional component can be created and optimized by
concentrating, for example, most of the electronic components on the wall of the
product. Thus, new function is the sidewall, for example, of a dishwasher, and for
repair of electronics, the sidewall is easily and completely changed. But high cost
of such an exchange component makes customers better think about buying a new
dishwasher than about environmental impact of such an exchange. In any event,
product life has been prolonged and the solution could become an advantage for the
customer and the environment.
The “types and parts” reduction programs concentrate on the elimination of com-
ponents occurring only in small volume. After a Pareto or Always Better Control
(ABC) analysis where parts are classified according to their volumes occurring in a
product in categories A, B, C where A parts are with the highest and C parts with the
lowest volume the C parts are eliminated. This is a typical step of a “design to cost”
program. It is obvious that this procedure has nothing to do with environmental
improvement of a product, although a certain reduction of environmental impact
might occur.
The target shown in route 2 is to reduce the manifold of materials with a target
of very few, ideally only one, material, for example, one plastic and/or one metal.
If a product requires electric power, it needs a minimum of two materials: one
insulator, a plastic, and one conductive material like copper. For example, rather
cheap thermoplastic materials like PE, PP with different color, and additives are
normally included in a standard electronic product. This might have been applied
to take advantage of the cheapest possible material for a specific mechanical
application. Maybe the housing is made from a more valuable ABS or a mixture
of PC/ABS. If an engineer now would look into different applications and plastic
properties and compare the mechanical requirements, he could find out that all or
nearly all materials could be made from one plastic. Maybe the engineer chooses
more valuable ABS which would increase the product costs. Although ABS is more
expensive, the company could buy now only ABS in one color like black which will
result in cost savings for storage, by buying higher volume of material or by getting
better recyclable plastics.
In the first step, those parts are identified which could be produced from the same
material, for example, same plastic, although they are present in the former product
with many other plastics. A good choice could be ABS which covers properties of
PE, PP, and others. In the next step, the engineer can combine different parts to one
or a few new designed parts or to integrate them into housing if the housing consists
17 Ecodesign Strategies: A Missing Link in Ecodesign 275
Fig. 17.2 Improvement of an old subrack (left), a holder of printed circuit boards consisting of
4 materials and 66 parts, to a new version consisting of 1 material and 17 parts with significantly
reduced environmental impact and costs (Source: Siemens AG)
of the same plastic. The advantage will be to save material and reduce production
costs for injection molding. With fewer parts, disassembly could become easier and
recyclable material does not require intensive sorting.
An example is given in Fig. 17.2 to show the principle of reduction of types
and parts and in consequence reduction of manifold of materials. In this example,
a subrack to hold printed circuit boards and plastic and metal parts are combined
in a simple construction consisting of only one material: stainless steel. Although
stainless steel is more expensive, the new solution is nearly 80% cheaper than the old
version and the subrack can be reused many times or recycled. The environmental
impact of the new solution is much lower than that of the previous product.
Sometimes, reduction of manifold of materials may be impossible in the case of
a railroad car. In this case, application of compatible plastics in the product only
for recycling is a solution to simplify the recycling process. Several systems of
compatible plastics exist. “ABS system,” for example, consists of polymers like
ABS, PC, PET, PMMA, and PVC. Other systems are based on PP or PUR. The
blends are not as valuable as pure material. Simplification is only achieved for
recycling and not in the manifold of materials. It must be mentioned that before such
solutions are applied, it should be checked whether there are recyclers interested in
the material and whether their capacities are sufficient.
The third route is the route taken for many consumer products like personal
computers, phones, or printers. Here, manufacturers often only buy components
mostly on the spot market. These companies have low developmental capacity
276 F. Quella
Washing,
Drying in oven
Print Solder
b
Paste
Fig. 17.3 Solder process of a printed circuit board from the raw circuit board till assembly of the
completed printed circuit board. (a) Normal process at about 260ı C, consuming approximately
80% of the soldering process energy; deviation 20ı C; (b) Apply energy-saving solder oven with
stand-by mode and better temperature characteristics, deviation 5ı C; (c) Changed process to for
example crimping, compression soldering or new circuit board materials
mean light-weight material, less energy consuming components, and with good
recyclability of materials. A version with more valuable material might also be
reused widely after 30 years of operation. If the manufacturer has no opportunity
to take the valuable material back, then the value of the plastic is lost for him.
The use of cheaper plastics, not recyclable plastics where only energy is recovered
by incineration, might then be more environmentally compatible and creates also
cheaper product for the customer.
It should be mentioned that most of the recycling concepts concerning material
reuse are only applicable if these materials can be nearly completely collected in
sufficient volume and be transferred to the manufacturer again. This is often the case
if the product is sold domestically. Some engineers were very astonished to hear that
their wonderful recycling concept did not work because the planned recycling was
not possible. The engineer should do market analysis with recyclers before starting
Ecodesign.
In many Ecodesign approaches, the effects of cleaner production are not
considered. If, for example, solder is changed from lead containing to leadfree,
the new soldering process has to be designed additionally. This broader view is
often overlooked. In Fig. 17.3, a suggestion is made on how a new manufacturing
process could look like. Table 17.1 shows the product design and development
process according to ISO TR 14 062 (2002). Under the “conceptual design” phase,
278 F. Quella
Table 17.1 Typical phases of product design and development process and possible measures
related to the integration of environmental aspects into product design (ISO TR 14 062 2002)
Phase Corresponding measure
Planning Get facts, prioritize according to benefits and feasibility, align with
(design ideas) organization strategy, consider environmental aspects, life cycle
thinking, formulate environmental requirements, analyze external
factors, choose appropriate environmental design approaches,
check chosen approach against the basic issues, and make envi-
ronmental analysis of a reference product
Conceptual design Brainstorm, conduct life cycle-oriented analyses, formulate mea-
(design concept) surable targets, develop design concepts, meet environmental
requirements, consolidate into specifications, and apply results
from analysis of a reference product
Detailed design Apply design approaches, and finalize product specifications,
(design solution) including life cycle considerations
Testing/prototyping Verify specifications by testing prototypes, and review life cycle
considerations for prototype
Production/market launch Publish communication materials on environmental aspects, best
use, and disposal of the product. Consider possible environmental
declaration and its requirements
Product review Consider and evaluate experiences, environmental aspects, and
impacts
Table 17.2 Relationship between different design tools, their purpose, and to which element of
Ecodesign they may be used or applied
Tool Purpose Use/application
Design for durability, Directed more to product Ecoprofile
optimizing functionality, design
avoidance of hazardous
substances, energy
efficiency, DfR, software
analysis
Design for cleaner Directed more to life cycle Process changes,
production, DfM or a process in life cycle (ecoprofile)
Life cycle thinking
Rules from experience Directed to product design Ecoprofile, product structure
and life cycle
Disassembly analysis, DfR Easy disassembly, extract Suitability of product structure
reusable components review
LCA Measures the design result Review, ecoprofile
4 Additional Steps
At the end of all the analysis and after defining the ecoprofile as part of the
requirements specification, all necessary changes for product and process should
have been defined. Thus, further discussions should no longer be necessary.
Nevertheless, as already mentioned, two aspects should be considered in more
detail: the role of production and the role of software applied.
Consideration of the role of production can best be explained by citing an
example. It might be a hazardous substance like lead in electronic components. This
substance is restricted in an application to the electronic product and then usual
solution to the problem will be changing the solder. This might cause some troubles
but anyhow a change will be made, and, for example, a tin-silver-copper solder can
be chosen as a substitute. Afterwards, a big discussion will start in the company
because of higher cost for the change and development of the new process.
But new idea is to see such changes always as an opportunity for improvement of
the whole process often with many advantages for reducing environmental impact
and for lowering cost. This is not part of the Ecodesign process as it is applied today
but in future companies who want to achieve better improvement results could use
such opportunities.
Figure 17.3 shows a typical soldering process. If a soldering process is analyzed
using the aforementioned new solder, the result might be that solder temperature is
slightly different. Thus, for normal process, ovens with temperature deviations in
the range of about 20ı C can be applied. But for the use of new solder, temperature
should be close to 260ıC and should not deviate more than 5ı C.
Therefore, the first idea is to buy an improved oven which could not only show
improved heat transfer characteristics but also switch to standby mode when not
in use. Another question might be whether other technologies like crimping or
compression soldering could be applied. Then, oven might no longer be necessary.
Material for printed circuit boards could be changed from halogen-containing
material to halogen-free material. Two advantages occur: Halogen-free materials
can have higher temperature resistance which is nowadays often required for new
electronic products, and also material could be saved if thickness is reduced. One
could find out that washing of raw board in the first step will not be required.
Also for soldering, non-oxidizing nitrogen atmosphere might be required. But is
the nitrogen flow controlled? If not, a lot of money can be wasted. Also, proactive
medical investigation of workers is no longer necessary because they do no longer
deal with lead.
In short, if most of these potential changes would not be applied, environmental
impact and cost could be reduced anyway. If for an own new development costs
are too high for one company, cooperating with other companies might be possible
to develop, for example, an energy-saving product together. In addition to the
production aspect, there are also other opportunities for additional environmental
improvement such as maintenance or service of the product.
Other aspect to consider is software which draws more and more attention to
Ecodesign. Software controls standby mode, battery loading, or kind of printout.
17 Ecodesign Strategies: A Missing Link in Ecodesign 281
Table 17.3 The route to ecoprofile according to the Ecodesign Directive (row 2) or according to
the view of a manufacturer for the main life cycle stages (row 3)
Analytical stages (acc. to Pro-phase to analyze (acc. to
the Ecodesign Directive) the Ecodesign Directive) View of producer: examples
Raw material generation Resources consumption: Types/parts reduction; manifold of
material, energy, water materials, hazardous substances
(avoidance)
Manufacture Waste generation Efficiency, suitability for process,
redesign of process
Packaging, transport, Physical effects like noise, Volume of packaging, customer
supply EMF, vibrations, information, take back of waste
product
Installation and Emissions (soil, water, air) Concept; life time: equipment,
maintenance parts; spare parts requirement;
consumables (cleaner, lubricant)
Application, use Consumption Energy consumption
End-of-life Reusability, recyclability As-new parts in new machines;
take back and recycling concept
(also batteries, lamps)
All processes Software applicability and Total energy consumed by
influence of software on energy software; loading or printing
consumption commands; chances for power
consumption control; reuse of
software in reused equipment
There is often no assistance for the consumer to decide whether he wants a high
energy consumption caused by software or a low one. As software was for a long
time considered as not part of the environmentally relevant attributes, this aspect
should now be investigated. Especially energy consumption is driven or controlled
by software. Also, software itself might contribute to energy consumption as it can
be seen during the Internet use. A standard for an energy-saving software design
is not available. Also, if older hardware is reused, it is often accompanied by an
old software which might not be substituted for a new energy-saving one. For this
purpose, a standard procedure is missing for how to embed it into a bigger software
system or how to improve its environmental behavior.
It should be mentioned that ecoprofile as described in political nature like in the
Ecodesign Directive (2009) and that of practical nature like in the manufacturer is
different (Table 17.3). It is not enough to say, for example, to a design engineer that
he should reduce energy consumption. This leaves many opportunities unexplored.
But after some of the universal and well-known improvement possibilities like using
energy-saving lamps or eliminating standby energy were applied, then the idea
pool might soon come to an end. A busy engineer requires automatically either
company’s own rules from experience which show what to reduce or what strategies
to adopt for the reduction. One of these strategies is not only reduction of the
manifold but also miniaturization of the components or structures which will save
resources at once.
282 F. Quella
In the bottom row of Table 17.3, the subject of software application is newly
added by the author because it is missing in the Ecodesign Directive scheme.
Software is a general subject for all life cycle stages with consequences for
environmental impact. It could be applied for energy reduction or it could cause
high energy consumption.
5 Conclusions
Product structure and environmental impact are closely linked. Therefore, a proce-
dure is proposed which combines the existing Ecodesign tools like LCA, the rules
from experience, disassembly analysis, DfR, and other design tools to a logical and
potentially successful product design strategy. Importance of such an integrative
design strategy was not seen during the development of ISO TR 14062. This is the
reason why this chapter discusses about a “missing link” in Ecodesign.
It might be an interesting task to collect all the “Design for X” approaches, not
only for deriving environmentally valid and a hierarchical recommendation for an
integrative design approach but also taking into account potential trade-offs. One
result could be that the rules from experience could be better clustered.
After the discussion in this chapter, an international standard for the development
of a design strategy is desirable. A tool for the analysis of environmental impact
caused by software is still missing in Ecodesign.
The first step of the Ecodesign strategy is to reduce complexity and create
simplicity. This has to be achieved for the whole product and not only for recycling.
The strategy has to work throughout the whole product specification and not only for
the environmental part of the product specification: This means that design strategy
should not be geared too specific to environmental aspects.
Ecodesign is a complex process. In IEC 62 430, it covers products and product
systems including their life cycles. By the word system in combination with product
here does not mean a complex system like Internet but periphery of the product or
product system. Also, hardware products are very different. Thus, applicability of
the Ecodesign strategy to consumer products and capital goods might be different
and requires flexible approach as shown in the design strategy. The software
application and energy control of the equipment by software could also play an
important role.
Plants like those for product production are more complex and require additional
elements for Ecodesign. Still more complex products like product systems including
energy distribution or Internet can hardly be described. Thus, the outlook for future
work should focus on these new areas of Ecodesign.
6 Summary
The application of the LCA tool and the rules from experience to the Ecodesign of
a product soon might come to such an end where improvement might no longer be
possible. With the LCA tool, engineers can obtain only the environmental impact
17 Ecodesign Strategies: A Missing Link in Ecodesign 283
result of a product but no clue on how the improvement should be made. The
engineer could look into the LCA results of those components or existing functional
components causing the highest impact and finding solution to reduce its impact. An
example is to reduce the energy consumption of the functional component “motor,”
but the “know how” behind would require not only substituting the motor but also
installing a drive (a software-controlled motor) which will save much more energy.
With the rules from experience like in IEC 62 430, improvement is much quicker
because an LCA analysis is not really necessary and a collected knowledge of
the company with reduction possibilities could be applied. If all rules have been
applied and other ideas are no more available, then a structural product change like
avoiding screws or designing modular is required between these two approaches.
Disassembly analysis helps in both cases to find out where structural problems
occur.
Doing Ecodesign only from the viewpoint of recycling as it is done by DfR
does not cover all potential environmental improvement. General design strategy
takes out complexity of a product by optimizing functional components, reducing
manifold of components and materials, or optimizing structure of a “purchased”
product. The recommendations by the DfR should be included. Part of the strategy
is disassembly analysis.
Additional steps are the analysis of the environmental impact caused by software
and a complete restructuring of the corresponding production processes as a result
of changes in a product like elimination of hazardous substances.
An extension of the design strategy to plants and complex systems might be a
future step. But Ecodesign of plants and systems are at first glance not covered
by the design strategy described above. Anyway, the design of the hardware of
a plant or a system could be made in the same way as described. Usually, many
components in plants and systems are commercially available products which can
be designed as in the proposed strategy. But it is essential for the reduction of the
environmental impact of a plant to concentrate on the energy drivers like drives,
cooling, or heating elements. For still bigger systems, energy control via a network
might become decisive for energy consumption of the total system like Internet.
Also, software design and application is generally a subject for the organization of
the system.
7 Cross-References
References
Monographs, standards, and legislation:
Ecodesign, Directive 2009/125/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 21 October
2009 establishing a framework for the setting of ecodesign requirements for energy-related
products (recast), OJ of the EU of 31 Oct 2009, L285/10–35 (2009)
IEC 62 430, in Environmentally Conscious Design for Electrical and Electronic Products and
Systems, International Electrotechnical Commission, Geneva (2009)
ISO TR 14 062, in Environmental Management System – Integrating Environmental Aspects into
Product Design and Development, International standardization organization, Geneva (2002)
K. Melzer, Integrierte Produktpolitik bei elektrischen und elektronischen Geräten zur Optimierung
des Product-Life-Cycle, (Meisenbach, Bamberg, 2005)
F. Quella, F. Belli, Reuse of components and products – “qualified as good as new”, in
Sustainability Handbook, Chapter 42 (Springer, Amsterdam, 2012)
VDI 2243, Recycling Oriented Product Development (Verein Deutscher Ingenieure, Beuth, Berlin,
2002)
W. Wimmer, K.M. Lee, J. Polak, F. Quella, Ecodesign – The Competitive Advantage (Springer,
Amsterdam, 2010)
Environmental Quality Function
Deployment for Sustainable Products 18
Keijiro Masui
Abstract
The twentieth century saw remarkable progress in scientific technology that our
way of life was drastically transformed; the products humans made and the
processes used to manufacture them had a considerable effect on the natural
environment. Being aware of this, manufacturers are now trying to develop
and commercialize manufacturing processes that produce as little environmental
impact as possible (“cleaner production”). In addition, manufacturers are con-
ducting life-cycle assessments (i.e., assessments of the product’s whole lifespan
from cradle to grave) that specify processes that are considered to have the least
environmental impact and maximum “eco-efficiency.” However, these techniques
cannot be properly evaluated unless attempts are made to understand what is
presently unknown with the use of social science, corporate ethics, and science
and technology. Even when these concepts are established, there is still a long
way to go before theory can be put into practice. Since 1994, the Study on the
Introduction and Promotion of Design for Environment (DfE) techniques has
studied the evaluation criteria for environmentallyconscious products in Japan.
After studying this aspect until the end of the twentieth century, the study
continued to develop and examine techniques for DfE. In the twenty-first century,
as a final step to developing activities associated with DfE, the development of
a technique called QFDE (Quality Function Deployment for Environment) was
completed.
This chapter presents a methodology to apply Quality Function Deployment
(QFD) for environmentally conscious design in the early stage of product devel-
opment. This methodology has been developed by incorporating environmental
K. Masui
Advanced Manufacturing Research Institute, National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science
and Technology (AIST), Tsukuba, Ibaraki, Japan
e-mail: k-masui@aist.go.jp
aspects into QFD to handle the environmental and traditional product quality re-
quirements simultaneously. “QFD for Environment (QFDE)” proposed consists
of four phases. Designers can find out which parts are the most important parts
to enhance environmental consciousness of their products by executing QFDE
Phase I and Phase II. Further, a methodology to evaluate the effects of design
improvement on environmental quality requirements was developed as Phase III
and Phase IV. The results obtained from the case study of IC package show
that QFDE could be applicable in the early stage of assembled product design,
because the most important component from the viewpoint of the environment
is clearly identified and multiple options for design improvement are effectively
evaluated.
1 Introduction
Conceptual design
Detail design
Production
When designers improve their products environmentally, they will listen to the
voice of green consumers. There are several research works on green marketing
(Stevels 2000); however, the requirements for the environment from the consumers
are not strong so far. On the other hand, in recent years, many companies are
extending their responsibility to consider the upstream environmental impacts of
manufacturing and the downstream impacts of consumer use and disposal of
products. OECD’s (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development)
work on Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) began in 1994, and the trend
is toward the extension of EPR to new product groups (OECD 2001). Here, EPR
is a policy approach under which producers accept significant responsibility –
financial and/or physical – for the treatment or disposal of post-consumer products.
Assigning such responsibility to manufacturers could provide incentives to form
partnerships with customers and recyclers to work on making changes that reduce
the environmental impact. Eagan and Finster (2001) identified two categories of
customers who might represent the environment. The first category includes the
customers who speak directly for the environment like environmental regulators and
green consumers. The second category includes the customers whose behavior and
actions support the environment such as recyclers and end-of-life disposal plants.
Based on the EPR policy approach as mentioned above, not only consumers
(users) but also recyclers, the government, the environment are considered to be
customers in this chapter. The author investigated what kind of requirements and
attributes should be considered from the environmental point of view through a
whole product life cycle, and then integrated those environmental items into a set
of feasible environmental VOC and EM, and their correlation factors. The selected
environmental VOC and EM are to cover most of the environmental problems, so
that designers have only to consider them to incorporate environmental aspects into
product development. Also, they are designed for a generic, not specific product.
Therefore, designers can use them effectively by ignoring some of them or dividing
one into multiple items in more details depending on the type of the product.
Furthermore, designers who are not familiar with the environmental science can
understand the environmental VOC and EM. It should be noted that these VOC and
EM can be employed by incorporating with VOC and EM for an ordinary design
with no modification to the framework of traditional QFD. The environmental VOC
and EM are explained below. In terms of the environmental VOC, it should be
noted that several statements sound like rather technical solutions than typical cus-
tomer requirements. When recyclers and the government are treated as customers,
the voice of recyclers and regulation are often expressed as engineering terms
directly.
18 Environmental Quality Function Deployment for Sustainable Products 289
2.2.2 Environmental EM
1. Weight: the weight of the product
2. Volume: the volume of the product
3. Number of parts: the number of parts in the product
4. Number of types of materials: the number of types of materials in the
product
5. Likelihood to get dirty: the speed of change of the exterior color by the effect
of dirt
6. Hardness: the hardness of the parts in the product
7. Physical lifetime: the physical lifetime of the product
8. Amount of energy consumption: the amount of energy consumption along all
the life-cycle stages
9. Rate of recycled material: the rate of recycled materials in the product
10. Noise, vibration, electromagnetic wave: the volumes of the noise, vibration,
electromagnetic wave given out during the use of the product
11. Mass of air pollutant: the mass of emission of air pollution substances along all
the life-cycle stages
290 K. Masui
12. Mass of water pollutant: the mass of emission of water pollution substances
along all the life-cycle stages
13. Mass of soil pollutant: the mass of emission of soil pollution substances along
all the life-cycle stages
14. Biodegradability: biodegradability of the materials of the parts to be landfilled
15. Toxicity of materials: toxicity of the materials of the product
Tables 18.1 and 18.2 show examples where QFDE is applied to the design of a
hair drier (Ishii 1997). Table 18.1 shows the deployment of VOC to Engineering
Metrics (EM) (Phase I). VOC items in the table include the environmental VOC
items such as “less material usage” as well as requirement items from customers
such as “dries quickly” and “quiet.” Usually VOC items are weighed based
on market survey to show the “Customer Weights.” “9” shows that it is very
important, “3” shows it is important, and “1” shows it is slightly important. The
degree of importance of environmental VOC is dependent on the concept of
developed product or the context of product life cycle. Further, they might be
decided based on the result of LCA, which is the quantitative evaluation method,
applied to a similar product. On the other hand, EM items include new items
such as “amount of energy consumption” as well as traditional items such as
“air flow.”
At crossing points between VOC items and EM items are shown numbers
indicating magnitude of both factors called “Relational Strength” determined by the
designer. Similar to the weighing of VOC items, “9” shows the relation is strong,
“3” shows it is relatively strong, and “1” shows weak relation. Here, at the crossing
points between the environmental VOC items and environmental EM items, the
values of relational strength prepared by the author are provided for designer
to help their decisions. The total of the sum multiplied by “Customer Weights”
and “Relational Strength” is the “Raw Score” for each EM item. Furthermore,
“Relative Weight” for each item is obtained by the Raw Score/Sum of the Raw
Score. This example shows that “air flow,” “air temperature,” and “amount of
energy consumption” are relatively important as EM items to satisfy customer
requirements such as “less energy consumption,” “high durability,” and “harmless
to living environment” as well as traditionally required quality items such as “dries
quickly” and “comfortable to hold.”
Toxicity of materials
Mass of air pollutant
Customer weights
Physical lifetime
Biodegradability
Balance (torque)
Number of parts
Air temperature
QFD for
environment
Hardness
Phase I Air flow
Volume
Weight
Voice of customer
Dries quickly 9 9 9 9 9
Quiet 3 9 9 9
Operates safely 3 1 9 3 1 3 9 9
Operates easily 1 3 1 1
Comfortable to hold 9 1 9 9 9 1 3 1
Reliable 3 1 1 3 3 9 9 1 1
Portable 1 3 9
Less material usage 1 9 9 1 3 9
Easy to transport 1 9 9 3
and retain
Easy to process and 3 9 9
assemble
Less energy 9 9 9 9
consumption
High durability 9 1 9 9
Easy to reuse 1 9 9
Easy to disassemble 3 9 9 3
Easy to clean 1 9 3
Easy to smash 3 9 9
Easy to sort 3 9 9 3
Safe to incinerate 1 3 9 3 1 9
Safe to landfill 3 3 3 9 9 9 9
Harmless to living 9 9 9 3 9
environment
Safe emissions 1 9 9 3 9 9 9 9
Possible to dispose 3 1 1 3 9
at ease
Raw
276
282
115
120
171
171
273
229
93
91
78
39
18
27
39
37
27
72
score
Relative
0.13
0.13
0.04
0.05
0.06
0.04
0.04
0.02
0.08
0.08
0.13
0.01
0.11
0.01
0.02
0.02
0.01
0.03
weight
Switch/wiring harness
Heater elements
QFD for environment
Phase II
Housing
Fan asm
Motor
Engineering metrics
Air flow 0.13 9 1 1 1 1
Air temperature 0.13 3 3 9 1 1
Balance(torque) 0.04 9 3 9
Weight 0.05 9 3 3 1 9
Volume 0.06 9 3 1 1 9
Numbers of parts 0.04 1 1 1 9
Numbers of types of materials 0.04 1 1 1 9
Likelihood to get dirt 0.02 3 9
Hardness 0.08 9
Physical lifetime 0.08 9 1 9 3 9
Amount of energy consumption 0.13 9 1 9
Rate of recycled materials 0.01 9
Noise, vib., electromagnetic wave 0.11 9 3 9
Mass of air pollutant 0.01 9 9 1
Mass of water pollutant 0.02 3 3 1
Mass of soil pollutant 0.02 3 3 1
Biodegradability 0.01 3 9
Toxicity of materials 0.03 3 3 1
Raw
0.36 6.15
0.09 1.58
0.20 3.48
0.05 0.94
0.30 5.14
score
Relative
weight
When design engineers improve their product from a viewpoint of the environment,
evaluating the effects of design changes on environmental aspects is an effective
process after identifying the important components. In this section, a method to
evaluate the effects of design changes for parts or components on environmental
aspects (Phase III and Phase IV) is introduced.
In Phase III, the effect of a set of design changes on the engineering metrics
(EM) items is estimated. In general, design engineers can make several alternative
18 Environmental Quality Function Deployment for Sustainable Products 293
Housing
Fan asm
Motor
Score
Engineering metrics
Air flow 0 0.00
Air temperature 0 0.00
Balance (torque) 0 0.00
Weight 0 0.00
Volume 0 0.00
Number of parts 0 0.00
Number of types of materials 0 0.00
Likelihood to get dirt 0 0.00
Hardness 0 0.00
Physical lifetime 0 0.00
Amount of energy consumption 9 9 18 0.95
Rate of recycled materials 0 0.00
Noise, vib., electromagnetic wave 9 9 0.43
Mass of air pollutant 0 0.00
Mass of water pollutant 0 0.00
Mass of soil pollutant 0 0.00
Biodegradability 0 0.00
Toxicity of materials 0 0.00
plans. There are two approaches when design engineers decide where they should
first focus on. One approach is originated from a target VOC. If they have already
had a target of “less energy consumption” VOC for example, they should seek the
parts which can suppress in terms of “amount of energy consumption.” The other
one is examining the most important components identified in Phase II. Table 18.3
shows an example of Phase III for a hair drier. Here, priority was assigned to the
environmental aspects, and the design improvement plan was mainly set from the
viewpoint of the amount of energy consumption. If it is assumed that the energy
consumption of a motor and a heater is reduced and then the noises caused by
a motor are reduced, the numbers indicating the relational strength in Phase II
(Table 18.2), at crossing points between the target engineering metrics and parts,
294 K. Masui
remained as shown in Table 18.3. The improvement rate to each EM item mrj is
obtained from (18.1):
P
K
bj;k cj;k
kD1
mrj D .j D 1; : : : ; J / (18.1)
P
K
bj;k
kD1
where
K: index number of a component
J : index number of an EM item
bj;k : relational strength between j th EM item and kth component in Phase II
Cj;k : improvement rate of j th EM item to kth component
Here, Cj;k is originally allowed to take the real number from 0.0 to 1.0. To make
it simple, Cj;k can take binary numbers as shown in (18.2):
P
J
mrj ai;j
j D1
vri D .i D 1; : : : ; I / (18.3)
P
J
ai;j
j D1
Toxicity of materials
Customer weights
Numbers of parts
Physical lifetime
Biodegradability
Balance (torque)
Air temperature
QFD for
environment
Hardness
Air flow
Phase IV
Volume
Weight
Voice of customer
Dries quickly 9 9 9 9 9
Quiet 3 9 9 9
Operates safely 3 1 9 3 1 3 9 9
Operates easily 1 3 1 1
Comfortable to hold 9 1 9 9 9 1 3 1
Reliable 3 1 1 3 3 9 9 1 1
Portable 1 3 9
Less material usage 1 9 9 1 3 9 0.00 0.00
Easy to transport 1 9 9 3 0.14 0.14
and retain
Easy to process and 3 9 9 0.48 1.43
assemble
Less energy 9 9 9 9 0.32 2.85
consumption
High durability 9 1 9 9 0.00 0.00
Easy to reuse 1 9 9 0.00 0.00
Easy to disassemble 3 9 9 3 0.14 0.41
Easy to clean 1 9 3 0.24 0.24
Easy to smash 3 9 9 0.48 1.43
Easy to sort 3 9 9 3 0.14 0.41
Safe to incinerate 1 3 9 3 1 9 0.00 0.00
Safe to landfill 3 3 3 9 9 9 9 0.00 0.00
Harmless to living 9 9 9 3 9 0.13 1.16
environment
Safe emissions 1 9 9 3 9 9 9 9 0.05 0.05
Possible to dispose 3 1 1 3 9 0.00 0.00
at ease
Improvement rate of
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.95
0.00
0.43
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
engineering metrics
Amount 2.09 8.10
296 K. Masui
Tables 18.5 and 18.6 show the matrices of Phase I and Phase II of QFDE,
respectively. In the shaded parts, environment-related items are shown, while others
are the items to be considered in traditional design. The results from Phase I
show that the important engineering metrics (EM) in this product are (1) radiation
capability, (2) high frequency characteristic, (3) toxicity of material, (4) physical
lifetime, and (5) amount of energy consumption. The results from Phase II show that
the important components are (1) core printed-wiring board (PWB), (2) insulation
resin, and (3) inner wiring.
The study team proposed two DfE options with consideration of the results of
Phase I and Phase II and an identical economic constraint.
IC resin
core PWB
outer
terminal
Toxicity of materials
Mass of air pollutant
Radiation capability
Customer weights
QFD for
Physical lifetime
Biodegradability
Number of parts
environment
Phase I
I/O density
Hardness
Volume
Weight
Customer
requirements
High I/O density 1 1 3 9 3 3 1 1
Small size 3 1 1 3 3 9 3 1 3 1 1 1 1 1 1
Good radiation 1 9 1 3 1 3 1 1 9
capability
Ability of protecting 9 9 9 1 1 9 3 1
IC
Light 3 1 1 3 9 3 3 1 1 3 1 1 1 1 1 1
Reliability 9 3 3 3 1 1 1 1 9 3
Good high frequency 1 3 9 3 1 1 9
characteristic
Less material usage 1 3 1 3 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9
Easy to transport and 1 3 3
retain
Easy to process and 1 1 1 1 9 1
assemble
Less energy 9 3 1 1 9
consumption
High durability 9 9 9 1 1
Easy to reuse 1 1 1
Easy to disassemble 1 1 1 1 1 1 9 9 3
Easy to clean 1 1 1
Easy to smash 3 1 1 1 1 1 1 9 9
Easy to sort 3 1 1 1 1 1 9 9 3 3
Safe to incinerate 1 3 1 1 1 3 9 3 3 3 9
Safe to landfill 3 1 1 1 1 3 3 9 9 9 9
Harmless to living 9 1 1 1 1 3 1 1 1 1 1 9
environment
Safe emission 1 3 1 1 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9
Possible to dispose at 3 1 1 1 1 3 9
east
Raw
240
235
112
179
158
186
90
95
82
71
19
84
18
79
51
63
63
63
score
Relative
0.13
0.12
0.06
0.05
0.05
0.04
0.04
0.01
0.04
0.09
0.08
0.01
0.04
0.03
0.03
0.03
0.03
0.10
weight
298 K. Masui
Insulation resin
QFD for
Outer terminal
Heat spreader
Bonding wire
Inner wiring
environment
Core PWB
Phase II
Engineering metrics
Radiation capability 0.13 3 1 1 3 3 9
High frequency 0.12 3 3 3 3 3 1
characteristic
I/O density 0.06 9 3 9 3 1 1
Weight 0.05 1 1 3 9 3
Volume 0.05 1 1 3 9 3
Number of parts 0.04 1 1
Number of types of 0.04 1 1
materials
Likelihood to get dirt 0.01 1 1 1
Hardness 0.04 9
Physical lifetime 0.09 9 9 3 3 3 3
Amount of energy 0.08
consumption
Rate of recycled 0.01 1 1
materials
Noise, vibration, 0.04 3 3
electromagnetic wave
Mass of air pollutant 0.03 9 9
Mass of water pollutant 0.03 3 9 3 3 3
Mass of soil pollutant 0.03 3 9 3 3 3
Biodegradability 0.03
Toxicity of materials 0.10 3 3 9 9 3 3
Raw
0.18 2.86
0.12 1.93
0.17 2.82
0.19 3.05
0.20 3.22
0.15 2.42
score
Relative
weight
Table 18.7 The calculation in Phase III for DfE option I in IC package design
Parts characteristics
Insulation resin
Outer terminal
Heat spreader
Bonding wire
environment
Inner wiring
Core PWB
Phase III
Score
Engineering metrics
Radiation capability 0 0.00
High frequency characteristic 0 0.00
I/O density 0 0.00
Weight 3 3 0.18
Volume 0 0.00
Number of parts 0 0.00
Number of types of materials 0 0.00
Likelihood to get dirt 0 0.00
Hardness 0 0.00
Physical lifetime 9 9 0.30
Amount of energy consump- 0 0.00
tion
Rate of recycled materials 0 0.00
Noise, vibration, electromag- 0 0.00
netic wave
Mass of air pollutant 0 0.00
Mass of water pollutant 0 0.00
Mass of soil pollutant 9 9 0.43
Biodegradability 0 0.00
Toxicity of materials 9 9 0.30
The improvement effect for the VOCs with their weights was calculated for each
DfE option through Phase III and Phase IV. In this case study, the scores of 5.30 and
6.15 were obtained for option I and II, respectively. The team concluded option II
to be the best.
300 K. Masui
6 Summary
References
Y. Akao, Quality Function Deployment (Productivity Press, Cambridge, 1990)
P. Eagan, M. Finster, Creating business value by linking industrial ecology with business strategy
and product design, in Second International Symposium on Environmentally Conscious Design
and Inverse Manufacturing (EcoDesing2001) (IEEE Computer Society, Los Alamitos, 2001),
pp. 842–847
K. Ishii, Design for Manufacturability: Product Definition. Course Reader for ME217 (Stanford
University, Stanford, 1997)
P. Jean, R. Coulon, D. Timmons, Building an EcoDesign toolkit for the electronics industry, in
First International Symposium on Environmental Conscious Design and Inverse Manufacturing
(EcoDesign ’99) (IEEE Computer Society, Los Alamitos, 1999), pp. 701–706
OECD, Extended Producer Responsibility: A Guidance Manual for Governments (OECD Publish-
ing, Paris, 2001)
B. Rapoza, T. Harjula, W.A. Knight, G. Boothroyd, Product design for disassembly and environ-
ment, Ann. CIRP 45, 109–112 (1996)
A. Stevels, Green marketing of consumer electronics, in Joint International Congress and
Exhibition Electronics Goes Green 2000+ (VDE, Berlin, 2000), pp. 539–544
UNEP, ECODESIGN: a promising approach to sustainable production and consumption, United
Nations Publication (1997)
Green PCB Manufacturing Technologies
19
K. C. Yung
Abstract
More and more green legislations were adopted in the global community. These
legislations have notably affected the electronic industry supply chain. Printed
circuit board (PCB) as a critical part in electronic products or systems receives
some of most severe impacts.
The legalization of RoHS leads to lead-free solder material development in the
past 10 years. However, the lead-free alloys require higher reflow temperatures,
which translate to higher energy costs as well as environmental loading in terms
of carbon footprints. The high solder reflow temperature also forces changes in
PCB base material and may require new equipment to fabricate them.
The legalization of WEEE requires electronic waste to be recycled. PCB is
used to be one of the most difficult parts to be recycled. WEEE also stipulates
separation of components containing brominated flame retardants from other
electronic waste prior to disposal or recycling. PCB fabrication companies
have to stop using brominated flame retardants within the PCB base materials
and prepregs and to develop substitutes. Further, to facilitate recycling, some
toxic substances have to be avoided in PCB processes, for example, cyanide in
gold plating and formaldehyde in electroless copper plating. These all demand
changes and result challenges in PCB manufacturing.
Global shortage of fuel and energy sources call for environmental friendly
production processes, with less energy used and more precious metal recovered
within the production cycle. Subsequently, alternative processes are to be
developed to promote greenness in PCB fabrication.
K.C. Yung
Department of Industrial and Systems Engineering, The Hong Kong Polytechnic University,
Kowloon, Hong Kong
e-mail: mfkcyung@inet.polyu.edu.hk
• TBBPA
• Antimony
• DecaBDE
• Phthalates
• PVC
On the other hand, the European Commission’s WEEE Directive requires
that member states reuse, recycle, and recover all waste electrical and electronic
equipment rather than simply disposing of it in landfill sites. WEEE consists of a
wide variety of equipment, including, for example, washing machines, televisions,
computers, mobile telephones, electrical tools, medical equipment, and control
instruments.
Lead has been comprehensively used as a solder for electronic components and
PCBs and PCB assembly industries for many years. The legalization of RoHS would
inevitably lead to electrical and electronic (E&E) products and/or components
produced without the intentional use of lead in any raw material form in processing
or in assembly. Thus, there have been lead-free solder materials developed in the
past 10 years in the market. Unfortunately, the leading Pb-free alloys require higher
reflow temperatures, which translate into higher energy costs and longer cycle time
(reduced productivity). Such high reflow temperatures will force changes in the base
materials and components and may also require new equipment.
On the other hand, halogen flame retardants may be identified as potential
dangerous substances. As required in WEEE regulations, E&E original equipment
manufacturers (OEMs) have to take back and dispose of the equipment at the
end of its life. The WEEE has approved separation and recovery standards for
electrical and electronic equipment, which require the separation of E&E equipment
from unsorted waste. It also stipulates further separation of components containing
brominated flame retardants from the other E&E waste prior to disposal or recycling.
304 K.C. Yung
Thus, E&E OEMs have to make a decision to move away from any type of
brominated flame retardants within the base materials and prepregs.
Further, to facilitate recycling, some toxic substances have to be avoided in PCB
processes, for example, cyanide in gold plating and formaldehyde in electroless
copper plating. These all demand changes and result in challenges in PCB manufac-
turing.
The global shortage of fuel and energy sources call for environmental friendly
production processes, with less energy used and more precious metal recovered
within the production cycle. Subsequently, alternative processes are to be developed
to promote greenness in PCB fabrication.
Section 2 focuses on the material development in PCB base materials suitable
for a lead-free soldering environment as well as reduction of toxic solvents in
PCB materials. The current status and research on PCB flame retardants are also
discussed. Section 3 briefly presents a few examples of green processes in PCB
manufacturing. Section 4 discusses different methods to recycle PCBs and to
recover metals in PCB processes.
reducing the coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE) down to very low values. Some
example of metal hydroxide flame retardants are:
(i) Aluminum trihydroxide Al(OH)3 – Rather high loadings are necessary to
achieve the necessary fire performance. It has moderate thermal stability
(decomposes at about 200ı C). Combination of aluminum trihydroxide with
other FRs is common.
(ii) Aluminium monohydrate AlOOH – Unlike aluminum trihydroxide, aluminum
monohydrate has a good thermal stability up to 340ıC. Laminates produced
with aluminum monohydrate feature very high temperature stabilities, result-
ing in very reliable products. Aluminum monohydrate is usually combined
with other flame retardants because of its low flame retarding efficiency.
• Metal Phosphinates and Polyphosphates
Metal phosphinates are a new class of nonhalogenated flame retardants which can
be used for rigid as well as flexible PCBs or other applications in this area. Metal
phosphinate is not hygroscopic, nontoxic, has an extremely low solubility in water
and common solvents, and does not hydrolyze in the presence of water. The latter
point is especially crucial since the release of phosphoric acid is not tolerable in the
E&E applications.
Further key aspects are the high phosphorus content (>23%) and its good
thermal stability (>300ıC) which makes it compatible with lead-free soldering
operations. Electrical properties show virtually no impact on dielectric constant
(Dk)/dielectric loss (Df) even at frequencies well above 1 GHz. However, the metal
phosphinate cannot be used alone to achieve a UL 94 V0 classification; therefore,
it is usually combined with N-synergists such as melamine polyphosphate, with
modified (phosphorus or nitrogen containing) epoxy resins, or blends with other
polymers (cyanate esters, benzoxazines, phenylene ether (PPE), or others). Metal
phosphinates are also suitable for flexible printed circuit boards (FPC).
Nitrogen-based flame retardants are typically melamine and melamine deriva-
tives. They are often used in combination with phosphorus-based flame retardants.
• Reactive Flame Retardants
Reactive flame retardants are chemically bound to the polymer and eliminate most
of the migration problems such as vaporization. Some examples of reactive flame
retardants are:
(i) DOPO (dihydrooxaphosphaphenantrene) – is a cyclic hydrogenphosphinate
containing a P–H bond. It is monofunctional, but several modifications are
possible, which, when properly catalyzed, can be grafted to C=C linkage or
reacted with epoxy groups. Today, DOPO can be regarded as the major building
block used to make phosphorus containing epoxy resins (Tg up to 150ı C).
DOPO is commercially available from different suppliers in global capacities.
(ii) Poly(1,3-phenylene methylphosphonate) – Due to its hydroxyl groups, it can
react into the polymer and act as a curing agent for epoxies. It is recommended
in combination with aluminium tri hydroxide (ATH) or aluminium oxide
hydroxide (AOH). High temperature stability is reported (high Tg, pressure
cooker test).
19 Green PCB Manufacturing Technologies 307
(ii) Glass transition temperature (Tg) – Temperature at which the material changes
from a semirigid to a softened state. It can be determined using several methods
such as differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), dynamic mechanical analysis
(DMA), and thermal mechanical analysis (TMA).
(iii) Coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE) – Dimensional change of materials
as a function of temperature. All FR-4 materials will expand with thermal
excursion. Measurement of this expansion is referred to as (CTE). It is
measured by TMA. A material with a higher Tg will delay the increase in
CTE through thermal excursion for that resin system, but total expansion
can be significantly different for each material type. Expansion of the entire
assembly during reflow and assembly will be drastically increased with the
introduction of Pb-free solders and the corresponding requirement for higher
peak temperatures and an extended time above the Tg of the materials.
(iv) Thermal decomposition temperature–(Td) – The temperature at which the
actual chemical and physical degradation of the base resin begins. It is usually
measured by a “thermogravimetric analysis” (TGA). Td is calculated based on
5% weight loss of the sample. Studies have found that similar resin systems
having the same Tg can have a significantly different Td. Td is now recognized
as an important tool in determining the performance and overall reliability of
materials.
PCB substrates, also known as copper-clad laminates, are made of organic laminated
materials consisting of a particular resin, usually an epoxy or phenolic, embedded
with some type of reinforcement, either glass or paper, and they have copper
foil attached to the outer surfaces (Permadi and Castro 2004). When a multilayer
PCB is manufactured, several PCBs are stacked and bonded together by prepregs,
which basically consist of partially cured organic material impregnated in the
reinforcement used to make the laminate.
The conventional process of manufacturing prepregs and laminates has several
drawbacks:
(i) The first step in the lamination process is impregnating fiberglass with an
epoxy resin mixture. The fiberglass is run through several rollers and dipped
into an open epoxy resin bath. The epoxy is dissolved in a solvent, typically
acetone or dimethylformamide. The solvents are used to lower the viscosity
for improved impregnation and to dissolve the catalyst in the epoxy system.
These solvents are not environmentally friendly. As a result, great care must
be taken in their use and disposal. Moreover, these solvents are harmful to the
operators.
(ii) After the impregnation, the fiberglass impregnated in the epoxy resin is passed
through a heating chamber, which is called a treater, to dry off the solvent
and partially cure the resin. Not only is this not environmentally friendly, but
because the glass impregnation is not performed under pressure, it is difficult
to properly impregnate the glass bundles; this brings the possibility of voids
forming inside the glass bundles, which are called cigar voids. In addition, if
the resin is dried too quickly, the solvent boils and leaves spherical voids.
(iii) Another related problem of this process is treater fires. The main cause of
treater fires is the burning of organic material that accumulates in the treater
wall (treater dust) because of solvent boiling. The treater dust also contributes
to prepreg inconsistencies. Voids produce product variability, which leads to
the so-called internal registration problem. This is one of the major causes of
scrap in a board shop. Internal registration basically refers to the misalignment
of drilled holes and inner-layer circuit features.
(iv) Another problem is that if the drilled holes hit a void, the copper solution used
to plate the holes may flow into the void and cause a short circuit.
310 K.C. Yung
Filters
+ Curing
Resin Agents
Mechanical
Energy
Glass Copper
Rolls Impregnation Foil Force
Mixing Belt Clamp
B-staging Die
Copper Clad
Laminate
Cooling
Glass Working
Region
Impregnation B-staging Heat
Zone Force
Zone Heat
Prepreg
A new continuous solventless process has been developed based on the concept
of injection pultrusion. The impregnation is performed by the injection of a
solventless resin system into a die under pressure instead of the fiber being dipped
into a solvent-based system in an open pan. This approach can eliminate cigar voids.
In addition, because no solvent is used, there will be no solvent boiling. From the
die, the prepreg can be fed into a continuous lamination belt clamp to manufacture
the copper clad laminates or it can just be stored. Figure 19.1 shows a schematic
diagram of the process.
To develop this new process, a chemical system needs to be identified and char-
acterized. It consists of DER (Dow Epoxy Resin) 383 [nonbrominated diglycidyl
ether of bisphenol A (DGEBA)] and DER 542 (brominated DGEBA). As the curing
agent, a resin based on phenolic novolac is included. The catalyst is 2-ethyl-4-
methylimidazole. The resin system melts at 105ıC, and no reaction occurs below
110ıC. It also has a low enough initial viscosity to make the impregnation possible
through a closed die and to minimize the pulling force. The new breed of resin
systems has acceptable Dk –Df values and less void content than found in a standard
prepreg.
Displacement
Neutral Soft gold
Purity >99.9%
Non-cyanide Electroless (as metal) Hv >90
Na3 Au (SO3)2
NaAuCl4
Chemical reduction Alkaline
Autocatalytic type
Substrate-catalysed type
possible to operate the bath in a lower pH range of 5–8, rather than >8 for a bath
containing no amine.
The gold(I)-sulfite complex has also been used to formulate electroless gold
plating baths. Both conventional reducing agents and less common ones have been
used successfully.
conveyorized systems are also available. Figure 19.3 shows the process flow of the
conventional electroless copper plating process.
Graphite-Based Process
Graphite methods disperse graphite (another form of carbon) onto the substrate
surface. Similar to the carbon method, a conditioner solution creates a positive
charge on the substrate surface, including the through-holes. Graphite particles
are then adsorbed onto the exposed surfaces. Graphite has a three-dimensional,
crystalline structure as opposed to the amorphous, randomly arranged structure
found in carbon black. This crystalline structure creates a conductive layer covering
both the copper and the nonconductive surfaces of the outer layer and interconnects.
A copper microetch removes the unwanted graphite from the copper surfaces,
leaving a conductive, graphite layer on the glass and epoxy surfaces of the vias. The
graphite process typically is operated in a conveyorized mode but can be modified
for non-conveyorized applications. Figure 19.6 shows the process flow of graphite-
based process.
Palladium-Based Process
The organic-palladium process uses a water-soluble organic polymer to form the
colloid around the palladium particles. This protective layer surrounds the individual
palladium particles, preventing them from agglomerating while in solution. After
the particles have been deposited onto the board, the protective colloid is removed,
making the layer of palladium particles conductive. Organic-palladium can be
operated successfully in either conveyorized or non-conveyorized modes. The
process is compatible with all common substrates.
Tin-palladium processes use tin to form the colloid with palladium. After the
adsorption of the tin-stabilized palladium colloid, the tin is removed, creating a layer
of conductive palladium particles on the surface of the substrate. Tin-palladium
processes are similar, up to the accelerator step, but use different methods to
optimize the conductivity of the palladium deposit. Tin-palladium can be operated
successfully in either conveyorized or non-conveyorized modes. Figure 19.7 shows
the process flow of the palladium-based process.
Regenerated Cu
Etchant Solution Solution
pump
Cu+ Cu+ pump
Fig. 19.8 Schematic diagram of copper recovery in PCB etching process (HKPC 2007)
radicals which efficiently oxidized cuprous ions and regenerate the copper etchant.
Figure 19.8 shows a schematic diagram of a copper recovery process.
The market demand for the production of electric and electronic equipment (EEE)
is increasing rapidly. PCBs are widely used in EEE. In recent years, the average rate
of worldwide PCBs manufacture has increased by 8.7%, and this number is much
higher in Southeast Asia (10.8%) and mainland China (14.4%). Meanwhile, both
technological innovation and intense marketing continue to accelerate updated EEE
and shorten the average lifespan of EEE. As a result, the amount of waste PCBs is
dramatically increasing. The UN Environment Programme estimates that the world
generates 20–50 million tonnes of waste electric and electronic equipments each
year, and the amount is rising three times faster than other forms of municipal waste.
Thus, there is a need to recycle scrapped PCBs.
However, recycling of waste PCBs is a challenge due to the fact that PCBs are
diverse and complex in terms of type, size, and shape of materials and components.
This section discusses the technologies of recycling PCBs (Huang et al. 2009).
N2
Temperature
controlled
Furnace
Plastic sample
Fig. 19.9 Schematic diagram of a fixed bed reactor (Hall and Williams 2007)
to prevent the formation of toxic gases. However, precautions should be taken for the
hazardous substances released in the process such as BFRs (tetrabrombisphenyl-A
(TBBA)) and heavy metals (lead, chromium, mercury, cadmium, etc.).
Physical recycling of the NMFs is a promising recycling method without
environmental pollution and with reasonable equipment investment and low energy
cost.
PCB: ground
Leaching
Solvent
Extraction
Electrowinning
Fig. 19.10 Process flow chart showing the copper recovery from printed circuit board (Oshi et al.
2007)
exchange membrane. The cell should consist of two platinum electrodes and the
purified solution. The current density is similar or slightly higher than that of
the conventional copper electrowinning from a sulfuric acid/copper (II) sulfate
electrolyte and is close to the value which previously had sufficiently low power
consumption in synthetic ammonia sulfate and chloride solutions. In order to prevent
oxidation by air, deoxygenated gas is introduced into the electrolytic cell before and
during the electrowinning. The resulting copper cathode is dried after successive
rinsing in an ammonia chloride solution mixed with tap water and deionized water.
Experiments show that the total metal impurity using this leaching method of
recycling can be as low as the ppm level (Oshi et al. 2007).
Crushing and
Separating
Cu particles
waste PCBs
nonmetallic materials
Fig. 19.11 Metallic fractions and nonmetallic fractions of pulverized waste PCBs (Guo et al.
2008). (a) Cu particles. (b) Nonmetallic materials
The advantages of physical recycling methods are that the processing is relatively
simple, convenient, and environmentally sound and the equipment investment and
energy cost is low.
5 Summary
References
M. Doring, J. Diederichs, Innovative flame retardants in E&E application, non-halogenated
phosphorus, inorganic and nitrogen flame retardants, pinf a – Phosphorus, Inorganic and
Nitrogen Flame Retardants Association, 2010, pp. 23–27
J. Guo, B. Cao, J.Y. Guo, Z. Xu, A plate produced by nonmetallic material of pulverized waste
printed circuit boards. Environ. Sci. Technol. 42(14), 5267 (2008)
W. Hall, P. Williams, Separation and recovery of materials from scrap printed circuit boards.
Resour. Conserv. Recycl. 51(3), 691 (2007)
322 K.C. Yung
HKPC, Development of a re-circulate copper etching system to enhance the precision of the HDI
PCB manufacturing. J. HKPCA 25, 16 (2007)
R. Horne, J. Gertsakis, A literature review on the environmental and health impacts of waste
electrical and electronic equipment, RMIT report to the Ministry for the Environment,
Government of New Zealand, 2006, pp. 22–24
K. Huang, J. Guo, Z. Xu, Recycling of waste printed circuit boards: a review of current
technologies and treatment status in China. J. Hazard. Mater. 164, 199 (2009)
Institute for Interconnecting and Packaging Electronic Circuits, Specification for base materials for
rigid and multilayer printed boards, IPC-4101C (2009)
International Electrochemical Commission (IEC), Definition of Halogen-Free, IEC 61249-2-21
(2003)
K. Masaru, Y. Okinaka, Some recent developments in non-cyanide gold plating for electronics
applications. Gold Bull. 37, 37–44 (2004)
Matrix US Inc. (2005), http://www.matrixusa.us/pdfs/solutions/Lead-Free Basics.pdf
Microelectronics and Computer Technology Corporation, Alternative Technologies for Making
Holes Conductive – Cleaner Technologies for Printed Wiring Board Manufacturers (U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Pollution, Washington, DC, 1998), pp. 3–8
I. Molyneaux, S. Ebnesajjad, Environmental aspects of PTFE based laminates in relation
to Halogen-Free (2012), http://www.taconic-add.com/pdf/technicalarticles-environmental
aspects of ptfe.pdf
P. Mou, D. Xiang, G. Duan, Products made from nonmetallic materials reclaimed from waste
printed circuit boards. Tsinghua Sci. Technol. 23(3), 276–283 (2007)
T. Oshi, K. Koyama, S. Alam, M. Tanka, J. Lee, Recovery of high purity copper cathode from
printed circuit boards using ammoniacal sulfate or chloride solutions. Hydrometallurgy 89, 82
(2007)
D. Park, REACH in Asia: a strategic approach, EM Asia Magazine (March/April 2010)
F. Permadi, J. Castro, Development of an environmentally friendly solventless process for
electronic prepergs. J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 91, 1136 (2004)
Underwriters Laboratories, Standard for safety of flammability of plastic materials for parts in
devices and appliances testing, UL 94, V0 (1996)
Eco-Packaging Development: Integrated
Design Approaches 20
Fabio Giudice
Abstract
The opportuneness of reinforcing strategies for the quantitative reduction and
reuse of packaging, which in general terms is the most efficient for environmental
protection, requires an intervention which begins at the phases of conception and
design of the packaging, and necessitates the reasoned and effective management
of an ever broader spectrum of design requisites.
Hence it is necessary to operate following integrated design processes which
take into consideration all the stages of the entire life cycle of the packaging,
from manufacture to disposal, balancing a wide range of factors and including all
the environmental aspects, beyond the direct competencies of the various actors
involved in this life cycle (packaging manufacturer, packer, logistics manager,
consumer, designated disposer). In this way the most effective environmental
strategies with which it is possible to intervene (quantitative reduction, reuse,
recovery) can be directly linked to design choices, and thus translated into
true and proper design strategies. Such strategies, operating on the variables
associated with the physical dimensions of the package (system architecture,
materials, shape and significant geometric parameters of components), allow the
pursuit of the desired environmental requisites to be incorporated into design
practice.
An effective management of the requisites for the eco-sustainable design
of packaging becomes therefore a key factor for a successful development of
design solution, and must allow to make choices which implicitly take into
account the various factors in play and the potential conflicts between them.
F. Giudice
Department of Industrial and Mechanical Engineering, University of Catania, Catania, Italy
e-mail: fgiudice@diim.unict.it
1 Introduction
In recent years the problem of waste production has become ever more pressing,
assuming particular importance in developed and developing countries. Although it
is difficult to quantify the problem on a global scale due to differences in the way
waste is defined and identified, reference can be made to estimate which, however
approximate, are indicative of the dimensions of the problem, such as that of four
billion tonnes of refuse produced in the single year 2001 by OECD (Organization
for Economic Co-operation and Development) member states (OECD 2006).
Actions directed at returning value to materials discarded and dumped, such as
separate waste collection and recycling, can play an indisputably strategic role in
meeting the waste emergency. More radical interventions must however concern the
very system of consumption, which needs to be rethought and adapted to environ-
mental demands if the much hoped-for condition of sustainability is to be attained.
In this context, the use and management of packaging plays a fundamental role
given the high percentage of packaging in the total quantity of refuse. According to
20 Eco-Packaging Development: Integrated Design Approaches 325
Fig. 20.1 Distribution of the production of packaging waste in the EU15 countries, in kg per
capita, year 2007 (Source: EEA 2010)
a %
100
90
26%
80
48%
70
14%
60
50 6%
40
30 60%
46%
20
10
0
1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
b 300
250
200
150
100
50
0
Fi rk
Po nds
G ny
D ium
Fr d
Ire e
nd
m ly
Sw ain
15
Sp l
en
Be stria
he urg
m
er e
ga
an
ec
G nc
xe Ita
a
do
a
la
EU
ed
rtu
m
N bo
m
rla
lg
re
nl
a
Au
ng
en
Ki
et
d
Lu
te
ni
U
Fig. 20.2 Packaging waste in the EU15 countries over the period 1997–2007: (a) Percentage trend
of treatments; (b) Quantitative trend of packaging waste, in kg per capita annually (Source: EEA
2010)
328 F. Giudice
2 Product-Packaging System
The arrangement of packaging for a product, with the aim of containing and protect-
ing it in the phases of transport, distribution, and sale, has become a true and proper
science which makes use of various disciplines such as physics, chemistry, mechan-
ical design, logistics, and marketing combined in what is now known as package
engineering (Hanlon et al. 1998), a specific branch of engineering arising over the
last decade which considers diverse aspects of packaging, from design and technol-
ogy to the materials used (Brody and Marsh 1997; McKinlay 1999; Soroka 2002).
A product cannot be developed without taking into account the need for its
containment and transport, and therefore the packaging which will contain it, since
all the design activities directed at guaranteeing its performance and quality could be
defeated by the damage incurred during the phases of the product’s life cycle from
production to sale, including those of handling, warehousing, and transport. On the
other hand, packaging cannot be developed except in correlation to the product it
contains, given that it must in fact perform the role of interface between the product
and the external environment from when the product is packaged, immediately after
production, until when it is used, immediately after sale. Over this time span, the
life cycle of the product and that of the packaging overlap (Fig. 20.3) and constitute
a single product-packaging system.
PACKAGING RECOVERY
RAW
LIFE CYCLE
MATERIALS
MATERIALS
PRODUCT PRODUCT
PROCESSING
RECYCLING
PACKING USE END-OF-LIFE
FINISHED
MATERIAL
MATERIALS
MANUFACTURE
REUSE
PACKAGE PRODUCT
PRODUCT
PACKAGE USE
MANUFACTURE
REUSE
PRIMARY
PACKAGING
SECONDARY
OR TERTIARY
PACKAGING
20 Eco-Packaging Development: Integrated Design Approaches
PACKING USE
TERTIARY
PACKAGING
TRANSPORT
characteristics of the product and can also become a (multiple) unit of sale, or be
used for stocking shelves at the point of sale.
– Tertiary packaging (transport package), created for the handling and transport of
sales units or multiunit packages, also includes the so-called unit load, consisting
of assemblages which facilitate transport in large quantities.
Depending on the product typology, the packaging levels described are not
always present, or clearly distinguishable one from the other.
During the phases of its life cycle where it is united with the product, packaging
must play the role of interface between the product and the external environment.
The functionalities required vary according to the life cycle phases that the
packaging and product share. Starting from this premise, a generic packaging must
provide and further the following principal functions:
– Containment
– Protection and preservation
– Handling and transport
– Information and identification
– Promotion and market appeal
– Usability
While the first are common functions to any typology of packaging, the functions
of promotion and usability (ease of packing, of opening, and, if necessary, of closing
again, ease of extracting the product contained) are typical of packaging in close
contact with the product, i.e., primary, or at most secondary, packaging.
In most cases, the functions of containment, protection, and handling predom-
inate over the others and the packaging is commonly called protective packaging.
The functions required of it are strictly correlated to the interaction of the pack-
aging both with the product contained and with the external environment. These
interactions are manifested in terms of stresses to which the packaging is subjected,
where stress is understood in a generalized sense, i.e., extended to include all the
phenomena which can cause variations in the state of the packaging and/or the
product.
In the case of stresses deriving from inside the packaging, which must be met by
its function of containment, the shape, volume, weight, and nature of the product
to be contained are decisive and can result in various types of stresses on the
packaging (not only mechanical, but also physical–chemical stresses, depending on
the typology of the product).
The stresses coming from outside the packaging, which must be met by its func-
tions of product protection and preservation, derive from the external environment
and include all the phenomena that can determine alterations to the state of the
product:
– Mechanical stresses (loads, impacts, vibrations, and abrasions)
– Biological contaminants (bacterial attacks, infestations)
20 Eco-Packaging Development: Integrated Design Approaches 331
3 Packaging Design
The design of packaging for a product has the strategic role of combining product
particularities and manufacturing requisites with the necessities related to logistics,
and in some cases to the marketing of the product itself and its perception on the part
of consumer. In order for this role to be fulfilled effectively, the packaging must be
designed taking into account a wide range of requisites which are clearly ascribable
to the analysis proposed above regarding the primary functionalities packaging must
guarantee. For example, the function of containment and protection corresponds
to requisites of structural resistance, capacity to absorb impacts and vibrations,
resistance to a range of temperatures, and stability of the materials under the
environmental conditions anticipated. To obtain such requisites, the designer must
operate on the fundamental design variables: materials, shapes and dimensions, and
the packaging structure.
As well as these requirements, at the root of packaging design there is that which
can perhaps be considered as the base requisite, apart from inexpensiveness: to
limit the weights and volumes of the packaging per volume contained. This last
parameter, volume contained, can be understood as the functional unit of packaging.
As in any other design experience, the key phase of the design development is the
specification of the requisites. It will guide all the subsequent phases, and must
therefore be operated with particular care. In the case of packaging, which as
discussed above involves particularly diversified necessities, the specification must
be undertaken in an equally diversified manner in order to avoid the predominance of
technical requisites, which are generally translated into restrictive constraints, with
the effect of limiting the domain of possible solutions too early in the development
332 F. Giudice
Table 20.1 Correspondence between phases of product-packaging life cycle, packaging func-
tions, potential risks, and damage (where not specified, damage refers to both packaging and
product)
Phase Function Risks Damage
Packing Usability Impacts and falls Breakage and deformation of product
Containment Internal stresses Breakage and deformation of
packaging
Handling Containment Internal stresses Breakage, deformation, wear of
packaging
Physical–chemical Variation in performance of
attacks packaging
Protection Vibrations Breakage and wear
Impacts and falls Breakage and deformation
Abrasions Variation in quality/performance
Warehousing Containment Physical–chemical Variation in performance of
attacks packaging
Protection Crushing Breakage and deformation
Preservation/ Environmental Variation in quality/performance of
isolation conditions product
Contamination
Transport Containment Internal stresses Breakage, deformation, wear of
packaging
Physical–chemical Variation in performance of
attacks packaging
Protection Vibrations Breakage and wear
Impacts and falls Breakage and deformation
Crushing
Abrasions Variation in quality/performance
Preservation/ Environmental Variation in quality/performance of
isolation conditions product
Contamination
Atmospheric agents
Sale Containment Internal stresses Breakage and deformation of
packaging
Protection Impacts and falls Breakage and deformation
Use Usability Impacts and falls Breakage and deformation
Abrasions Variation in quality/performance
So described, the specification phase requires a very wide array of information re-
garding five principal subjects: product, packaging life cycle, normative framework,
external environment, and materials.
As shown in Fig. 20.4, from the analysis of product properties and from the
planning of the packaging life cycle (which includes the life cycle of the product-
packaging system) there ensue, respectively, technical and functional specifications.
The particularities of the product and of the packaging life cycle determine
the reference framework of norms and the external environment with which the
product-packaging system must interact. From these there ensue, respectively, stated
purpose and scenario-based specifications. The set of information required must be
completed by data on the materials which can be utilized to produce the packaging,
derived from their characterization.
– For each potential risks to which the component is susceptible, determine the
resistance of the component (i.e., the limit stress value beyond which damage
phenomena may arise).
– Determine the economic value of the product and components.
The potential risks (Table 20.1) to which the product and its components can be
sensitive are functions of the product typology. Each risk to which a component is
susceptible must be associated with a characteristic index, which is utilizable as a
metric to evaluate the magnitude of the stress acting on it and its resistance.
Determining the economic value of the object is important because a product (or
component) of high value requires highly efficient packaging (packaging efficiency
is commonly expressed as the ratio between the number of products that are
anticipated to be integral at the end-of-life of the packaging and the total number
of products packed).
At the end of the product analysis procedure the product components can be
subdivided into classes of risk, resistance, and value. This will allow the designer,
in subsequent phases, to specify the packaging requisites in a more reasoned manner
and to choose the most effective solution.
modifies the potential risks. The life cycle represented in Fig. 20.3, and detailed in
Table 20.1 (packing, handling, warehousing, transport, sale, use) can be taken as
a reference. The life cycle planning also covers a strategic role with regard to the
aspect associated with environmental protection. To take the latter into account, the
planning and analysis of the packaging life cycle must be extended to also include
the phases of production and post-use. In particular, the interventions at end-of-life
most effective for environmental protection (reuse of the packaging, recycling of the
materials), which are also represented in Fig. 20.3, are particularly relevant to the
analysis of the resistance of the product-packaging system with respect to external
stresses (and, similarly, of its resistance with respect to internal stresses), because
of the potential deterioration in performance resulting from recovery processes of
this type.
In this way it is possible to evaluate the safety factor of each sensitive product
component, i.e., the ratio between its resistance and the stress to which it is
subjected.
The data analysis described above is decisive both for guiding the design devel-
opment, through the detailed definition of the specifications, and in the evaluation
phase, i.e., of assessing the degree to which the solutions developed meet these
specifications. Focusing attention on the primary function of protection, in general
terms packaging is necessary when the condition represented in Fig. 20.5 occurs,
i.e., when the capacity of the product to resist external stresses is lower than the
level of these stresses (the safety factor is lower than 1). Packaging, united with
the product in the product-packaging system, makes it possible to increase the
capacity of resistance. In this sense, the optimal condition of product-packaging
integration is represented by solution (1). Solution (2) is ineffective because it
leaves the product subjected to the risk of damage. Condition (3) is instead
inefficient because the packaging is excessive with respect to the real risk. These
Fig. 20.5 Packaging design: conditions of efficiency with respect to stresses from the external
environment
20 Eco-Packaging Development: Integrated Design Approaches 337
resources, emissions, and refuse whereby the life cycle, in its entirety, interacts with
the environment, determining its environmental impact.
By structuring packaging design in the appropriate manner, the environmental
strategies operated to contain its environmental impact over the various phases, its
entire life cycle can be directly linked to design choices, translated into true and
proper design strategies, which, operating on the variables relating to the physical
dimension of the packaging (system architecture, materials, shapes, and geometric
parameters of components), make it possible to pursue environmental requisites
(Giudice et al. 2006). In this sense, the phase of life cycle planning, already
present in traditional packaging design procedure (Fig. 20.4), assumes a strategic
role. In this phase, in fact, it is possible to extend the functional specifications,
complementing the set of requisites which interpret the expected conventional
behavior of packaging throughout the various phases of its use, with environmental
requisites, i.e., integrating requisites which interpret the expected environmental
behavior of the packaging over its entire life cycle.
The characterization of materials also assumes an important role in a design
intervention directed at introducing requisites of environmental protection. In this
case, the traditional characterization must be extended to include what can be called
environmental characterization, the aim of which is to define and assess the material
properties which determine not only its direct impact on the environment but also
its behavior with regard to strategies of environmental protection, e.g., reuse and
recycling.
Ultimately, for an effective design, all the environmental data and requisites must
be the subject of preliminary investigation, and placed in relation to those associated
with the primary functionalities described above, allowing the rational management
of a very wide spectrum of requisites during the design intervention. In all cases, the
process of development must take into account the fact that, above and beyond the
efficiency of the design, truly practicable strategies of packaging reduction and reuse
require radical changes in the patterns of production, consumption, and distribution.
The second case, that taken into consideration here, concerns strategies of
quantitative reduction in the production phase, and those of reuse and recovery in
the end-of-life phase (Fig. 20.3). In the design development, these strategies must
be translated into the most effective choices favoring their realization.
Quantitative reduction, which clearly results in both environmental benefits and,
more generally, benefits in performance, depends on the efficiency of the packaging
in terms of the ratio of packaging weight/volume contained, or of the ratio of overall
size/volume contained. This requisite of efficiency can be attained by operating an
optimal choice of materials, shapes and dimensions, and structure.
The reuse of packaging depends on the stability of its physical–mechanical
properties over time. Also in this case, therefore, the designer must operate in terms
of the choice of materials, shapes and dimensions, and structure, but also provide
for the necessity of guaranteeing the separation of the integral packaging from the
contents, and thus anticipate reversible packing and use.
Recovery, with particular reference to the recycling of materials, depends on
the intrinsic properties of the material, its suitability for recycling, and on the
technology underlying the recycling process. It is conditioned by the choices the
designer operates on the materials and on the structure of the packaging-system,
which must facilitate the identification and separation of these materials.
The environmental benefits (and economic sustainability) of the interventions
of reuse and recovery depend on the impacts of the collection, separation and
classification processes, and on the efficiency of the reverse logistics.
When the design problem includes such a wide and diverse range of requisites,
their management becomes the key factor for success in the design development.
This is all the more true if diverse requisites depend on shared design parameters,
a condition which frequently occurs and which usually gives rise to conflict.
This is the case under examination, where the various requisites which interpret
environmental strategies refer to all the principal design parameters and must
be harmonized not only with each other, but also with the requisites associated
with the conventional functionalities of packaging. This harmonization requires a
rational management of the various requisites and an integrated approach to design
development, in order to overcome conflicts which can already arise between the
environmental requisites alone. A design solution which limits the volume of the
packaging will satisfy requisites referring to quantitative reduction, but can also
result in shortening the useful life of the packaging, entering into conflict with
the possibility of its reuse; for their part, design choices directed at increasing the
useful life of packaging, favoring its reuse, can lead to the utilization of materials
unsuitable for recycling, entering into conflict with the need to guarantee preset
recovery quotas; in turn, the choice of using recycled materials can necessitate an
increase in the packaging volumes, due to the usually poorer performance of such
materials, entering into conflict with the principle of quantitative reduction.
340 F. Giudice
The optimal choice of materials is one of the key factors in design. If structured
in an appropriate manner, it can be operated implicitly taking into account the
most important geometric parameters and seeking to satisfy various typologies of
requisites, treated as objectives or as constraints.
Considering a generic packaging of the most common type, consisting of a
protective element (cushioning) and one of containment and protection (box), as
represented in Fig. 20.6, and focusing on the external container, it is possible to
structure the choice of material taking into account the following requisites:
– Protection of the product held by packaging
– Weight-volume efficiency of packaging
20 Eco-Packaging Development: Integrated Design Approaches 341
Fig. 20.6 Generic packaging and simplified loading model for analysis of stiffness
– Economic sustainability
– Limited environmental impact
The first two requisites, which are associated with the primary functionality
of packaging (protection of the contents, with the least weight and volume of
packaging itself), can be treated, respectively, as a constraint imposed on the
choice of optimal material and as an objective to achieve. Translating the protective
capacity of the packaging into its stiffness S, this must be such as to counter
deformations due to any forces applied externally, whether accidental or the result of
handling, transport, or warehousing. Applying the structural problem to the loading
scheme on one panel described in the lower part of Fig. 20.6, and considering it as
referring to the packaging surface of the greatest extension (and therefore the most
liable to deformation), the stiffness constraint imposes a maximum limit to bending
at the point where the force is applied. From this it is possible to derive some indices,
called material performance indices (Ashby 2005), which depend exclusively on the
properties of the panel material and which are able to express the efficiency of the
choice of material with respect to the diverse requisites under examination.
Considering as the first requisite that of limiting the volume, it can be translated
into minimizing the packaging thickness t, which on the basis of the stiffness
constraint is linked through a relation of proportionality to the index 1/E1=3 . This
indicates that for equal stiffness and other fixed geometric parameters (w and L
depend on the volume of the product to be packed), the thickness depends on
Young’s modulus E of the material, in the form expressed by the index. Considering
the second requisite to be that of limiting the weight, it can be translated into
minimizing the packaging mass m, which for equal stiffness and other fixed
342 F. Giudice
a
20
10 STEEL GLASS
PE, PC, PP, PS,PVC
5
m / mo
0.5
AL ALLOYS
0.2
PPS, PA, ABS WOOD
0.2 0.5 1 2 5 10 20 50
t / to
b
10000
10 PP, PS, PE
1
STEEL
GLASS
0.1
WOOD
0.01
0.01 0.1 1 10 100 1000 10000 100000
C / Co
Fig. 20.7 Integrated choice of materials: (a) Metrics for primary functionality; (b) Metrics for
economic and environmental sustainability (Graph created using CES Edupack 2006 software)
impact due to its high energy cost. Glass, which according to the analysis of the
metrics proposed could be a valid solution, is not suitable for the type of application
under examination due to its fragility. Of the plastic materials, the most interesting
from the point of view of primary functionality (PPS, PA, ABS) entail high costs and
energy impacts. Finally, the solution in steel could be considered only in the case
where a reduction in thickness is decisive, since with respect to the other metrics it
would be inefficient.
344 F. Giudice
The integrated approach to the choice of materials described above allows the man-
agement of different types of design variables (materials, geometric parameters),
taking account of various typologies of requisites, such as those under consideration.
Even if this approach is effective from the design point of view, it clearly limits the
reach of the environmental investigation given that only the impact resulting from
the production of the material is assessed (Giudice et al. 2005). It can therefore
complement a more complete approach which includes, in an organic manner, the
diverse environmental implications of the packaging, considering all the processes
making up its life cycle in which substances or energy are exchanged with the
ecosphere. For this purpose, it is necessary to turn to specific techniques such as Life
Cycle Assessment (LCA), which consists of an objective procedure for assessing
the consumption of resources and emission of wastes related to a generic industrial
activity, or rather to the entire life cycle of the product of such activity, through
the quantitative determination of all the flows of exchange between the product life
cycle system and the ecosphere, occurring in all the processes of transformation
involved, from the extraction of raw materials to their return into the ecosphere
as waste. Based on standardized procedures (ISO14040 2006), LCA makes use of
tools which in their most evolved form allow the elaboration of the quantities in play
and provide unequivocal impact indicators, e.g., the eco-indicators obtained using
the Eco-indicator 99 method (Goedkoop and Spriensma 2000). In this way it is
possible to
– Associate quantified environmental impacts to materials and processes using
unitary numerical indicators (respectively, for unit weight or volume, and for
unit quantity processed).
– Quantify the environmental impact of the various phases of the life cycle, as
a function of the principal design parameters and of the characteristics of the
processes operated during the different phases of the life cycle.
Through this complete approach to the life cycle and to its environmental
impact, it is possible to evaluate, at the design stage, the consequences which the
principal choices will have on the environmental impact of the packaging during the
main phases of its life and, ultimately, to design the life cycle with the objective
of reducing the overall impact. In general terms, this can be expressed in the
following form:
– EIPROD D eimat QCeiprss Q0 is the environmental impact of production, with eimat
the eco-indicator of the material, eiprss eco-indicator of the primary process, Q
quantity of material, and Q0 the quantitative parameter on which the impact of the
primary process depends. Thus, EIPROD depends on the materials, the quantities
in play, and the manufacturing processes.
20 Eco-Packaging Development: Integrated Design Approaches 345
– EIUSE is the environmental impact of use. It is not always definable, and for
this reason is sometimes ignored. In general terms, it can be ascribed to the
environmental impact associated with the consumption of fuel for transport,
linked to theP weight of the packaging itself per volume contained.
– EIREUSE D r .EIPROD / is the environmental impact of reuse. It quantifies
the recovery of impact EIPROD associated with the production of an equal
packaging which would have to substitute it, if it were not reused. The loss
coefficient takes account of the fact that the net impact recovered must be
evaluated subtracting the impact associated with the process of reuse (collection
and any reconditioning necessary). EIREUSE depends therefore on the materials,
on the quantities in play and on the manufacturing processes (as EIPROD /, on
the stability of the packaging performance (duration), which determines the
possibility of reusing it one or more times (r is the number of possible reuses),
and on the efficiency of the reverse logistics processes at end-of-life.
– EIREC D eiric Q C eiinc .1 / Q is the environmental impact of recovery.
The first term quantifies the impact of recycling the fraction Q (where is the
recyclable fraction), and generally is a recovery of impact (the eco-indicator
of recycling material eiric is negative, evidencing the environmental advantage
of recycling). The second term quantifies the impact of recovering the fraction
.1 /Q (where is the fraction which can be processed by incineration, with
consequent energy recovery), and generally also this is a recovery of impact (the
eco-indicator of incineration of material eiinc is again generally negative because
of the environmental benefit of recovering energy). Thus, EIREC depends on the
materials (recyclability and suitability for energy recovery) and on the quantities
in play, as well as on the efficiency of the recovery processes and of the reverse
logistics.
– EIDISP D eidisp .1 / .1 / Q is the environmental impact of disposal. It
quantifies the impact of dumping as waste the fraction .1 /.1 /Q which
cannot be recycled or processed for energy recovery. Also EIDISP depends on
the materials (impact of dumping eidisp , recyclability and suitability for energy
recovery) and on the quantities in play.
Through this type of modeling of the impact over the entire life cycle, the
designer is able to assess the environmental consequences of design choices.
Depending on these choices, the life cycle of the packaging can develop according
to various forms of the general model described by the graph in Fig. 20.8, which
represents the composition of the environmental impact of the life cycle. It describes
the complete case where the design of the packaging allows its reuse (r D 1), the
recycling of materials ( > 0), and energy recovery ( > 0). In this way, as well as
having both types of recovery of impact (from reuse and recovery strategies), there
is a reduction in the impact of disposal due to a reduction in the volumes dumped
as waste. With regard to the environmental benefit of reuse, it can be more or less
important depending on the duration and functional stability of the packaging and
on the efficiency of the process of reuse. In the optimal situation, where reuse is so
efficient that it allows a substantial recovery of the impact of production ( ! 1), it
is theoretically possible that the life cycle provides an overall environmental benefit
(EILC < 0).
346 F. Giudice
Fig. 20.8 General model of packaging life cycle and composition of environmental impacts
Modeling of this kind can support design choices, using the complete approach
to the life cycle and taking account of indicators of overall impact. It also
allows the integration of the requisites associated with primary functionalities with
environmental requisites. This happens because the metrics introduced depend
on the fundamental design variables, on which also depend the metrics used
in the conventional design of packaging directed at guaranteeing the primary
functionalities: the packaging structure, geometric parameters, and materials.
Referring to Table 20.1, the stresses of a mechanical nature to which the packag-
ing is subjected, such as impacts, vibrations, crushing, and abrasions, must be met
by properties of resistance which depend precisely on these design variables. The
properties of resistance to stresses of a physical–chemical–biological nature, due
to environmental conditions, contaminants, and atmospheric agents, also depend on
variables such as the packaging structure and materials, and in some cases also on
thicknesses and critical geometric parameters.
These design variables must therefore respond above all to the necessities
dictated by the primary functionalities. This prefigures a first approach according
to which the materials are chosen and the minimum geometric parameters defined,
therefore determining the minimum quantities of materials able to guarantee the
capacity of resistance required to meet all the stresses to which it is anticipated
the packaging may be subjected over the span of its life cycle. The properties of
the chosen materials and the quantities in play are referenced by all the metrics
introduced above to quantify the environmental impact associated with the diverse
phases of the life cycle, which can then be used to quantify the environmental impact
of the solution with minimal properties.
This approach to the design of packaging with minimal properties can be
effective for translating the environmental strategy of quantitative reduction into
20 Eco-Packaging Development: Integrated Design Approaches 347
design. In the case where it is decided to follow other strategies, such as the reuse
or recycling of materials, it is instead necessary to employ an approach which is
not strictly sequential. Here the choices regarding design variables must be made
operating by means of all the metrics, both those for primary functionalities and
those for environmental sustainability, simultaneously. Only in this way is it possible
to define efficient solutions. These do not necessarily minimize the quantities in
play, since they can also envisage an increase in the geometric parameters and
volumes with respect to the necessary minima or the use of the materials with better
performance than those strictly necessary to guarantee the primary functionalities,
if this will allow packaging to be reused at end-of-life (which requires an adequate
stability of performance over time), or its constituent materials to be recycled.
Only through this second approach is it possible to operate on a broad domain of
design solutions, in such a way to potentially contemplate the entire spectrum of
environmental strategies that could characterize the development of packaging life
cycle (Fig. 20.8).
As an example, using the modeling proposed in the design of packaging for
mobile telephones (Fig. 20.9), in the simplest case it is possible to compare two
SOLUTION 1 EI [mPt]
10
8
6
EIREC
4
2 EIPROD EILC
0
PRODUCTION END-OF-LIFE
−2
−4
−6 RED REC
SOLUTION 2 EI [mpt]
10
8
EIREUSE
6
EIPROD
4 EIREC
2
EILC
0
PRODUZIONE END-OF-LIFE
−2
−4
−6 RED REUSE REC
alternative solutions: The first envisages an external casing and internal support
in cardboard, both recyclable; the second has and internal support in plastic (PS),
potentially reusable as well as recyclable. In both cases, the ideal condition of
integral recycling was hypothesized ( D 1), so that EIDISP could be theoretically
neglected. Comparing the balance of the life cycle impact (evaluated using the cited
Eco-indicator 99 method, which allows the assessment of the eco-indicators in mPt,
a fictitious unit of measurement), although the second solution involves an impact
of manufacture more than double that of the first and is therefore less efficient from
the viewpoint of the strategy of reduction, in relation to the entire life cycle it can
be sustainable precisely in virtue of the reuse of the support (with an environmental
benefit estimated at D 0:7). This is therefore the more interesting solution of the
two, also because of its higher quality and greater appeal to the consumer. These
latter aspects make it particularly suitable for products at the higher end of the
market where a possible increase in the cost of packaging can be sustained.
6 Summary
When the problem of the environmental impact of packaging is taken into exami-
nation in a complete manner, not simply reducing it to the generation of solid waste
but extending its reach to consider the environmental impact associated with the
entire life cycle of the packaging system, it is possible to make use of a diversified
set of strategies for environmental protection, from quantitative reduction to reuse
and various forms of recovery of the resources used in the production of packaging,
including the recycling of materials and the recovery of energy. From this viewpoint,
the design intervention assumes a key role given that it only is able to tackle the
environmental problem in a proactive rather than a corrective way, making the
strategies truly applicable in that they are translated into design requisites and
implemented in the development of the solution, thereby operating directly on the
most important design variables in order to achieve the optimal packaging in terms
of these strategies.
It is necessary, therefore, to enrich the traditional design of packaging, introduc-
ing tools which aid the search for an environmentally sustainable solution. New
methodological and analytical instruments emerge which, using techniques for the
assessment of the environmental impact of the life cycle (Life Cycle Assessment)
can aid the designer in an intervention which deals with environmental aspects in the
most efficient and complete way possible, extending the analysis over the entire life
cycle of packaging, and at the same time correlating the environmental requisites
with those associated with its primary functionalities (containment, protection,
handling, and transport).
With these premises, the methodological statement of design tends to enhance
some aspects of the preliminary analysis of the data typical of packaging design,
in particular regarding the phases of life cycle planning and the characterization
of materials. These phases are broadened to include the information necessary to
predetermine the environmental behavior of packaging over its life cycle.
20 Eco-Packaging Development: Integrated Design Approaches 349
7 Cross-References
References
M.F. Ashby, Materials Selection in Mechanical Design, 3rd edn. (Elsevier, Oxford, 2005)
A.L. Brody, K.S. Marsh, The Wiley Encyclopedia of Packaging Technology, 2nd edn. (Wiley,
New York, 1997)
EC, European Parliament and Council Directive 94/62/EC on Packaging and Packaging Waste
(European Commission, Brussel, 1994)
EEA, Generation and recycling of packaging waste – March 2010 assessment (European Environ-
mental Agency, Copenhagen, 2010)
F. Giudice, G. La Rosa, A. Risitano, Mater. Des. 26, 9 (2005)
350 F. Giudice
F. Giudice, G. La Rosa, A. Risitano, Product Design for the Environment: A Life Cycle Approach
(CRC/Taylor & Francis, Boca Raton, 2006)
M. Goedkoop, R. Spriensma, The Eco-indicator 99: methodology report. (Pré Consultants BV,
Amersfoort, The Netherlands, 2000)
J.F. Hanlon, R.J. Kelsey, H.E. Forcinio, Handbook of Package Engineering, 3rd edn. (CRC Press,
Boca Raton, 1998)
M.P. Hekkert, A.J. Joosten, E. Worrell, W.C. Turkenburg, Resour. Conser. Recycl. 29, 33 (2000)
ISO 14040 Environmental management – life cycle assessment – principles and framework.
(International Organization for Standardization, Geneve, 2006)
W. Jedlicka, Packaging Sustainability: Tools, Systems and Strategies for Innovative Package
Design (Wiley, Hoboken, 2009)
G.M. Levy, Packaging, Policy, and the Environment (Aspen Publishers, New York, 2000)
D. Lutters, R. ten Klooster, CIRP Ann. Manuf. Technol. 57, 145 (2008)
A.H. McKinlay, Transport Packaging (CRC Press, Boca Raton, 1999)
OECD, Improving Recycling Markets (Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development
Environment Directorate, Paris, 2006)
S.E.M. Selke, Packaging and the Environment: Alternatives, Trends, and Solutions (CRC Press,
Boca Raton, 1994)
W. Soroka, Fundamentals of Packaging Technology, 3rd edn. (Institute of Packaging Professionals,
Naperville, 2002)
Material Flow Cost Accounting:
Significance and Practical Approach 21
Katsuhiko Kokubu and Hiroshi Tachikawa
Abstract
Manufacturers and other businesses are being placed under increasing pressure to
achieve higher productivity with reduced environmental impacts. Material Flow
Cost Accounting (MFCA), one of the major tools of environmental management
accounting, is considered to be an effective approach to meet such needs.
Being recognized as key approach for sustainability, MFCA was internationally
standardized to be ISO 14051 in September 2011.
MFCA promotes increased transparency of material use practices through
the development of a material flow model that traces and quantifies the flows
and stocks of materials within an organization in physical and monetary units.
This data can be used to seek opportunities to reduce material use and/or
material losses, improve efficient uses of material and energy, and reduce adverse
environmental impacts and associated costs. This chapter explains detailed
steps for MFCA implementation and shows actual case examples. Furthermore,
MFCA’s impact is not limited to a single entity. MFCA can be applied to the
supply chain where material wastage at one organization is occasionally sourced
from suppliers. Impact on supply chain is also described in this chapter.
Kokubu is convenor of the Working Group (WG8) on MFCA at ISO/TC207, and Tachikawa is
expert and assistant secretary.
K. Kokubu ()
Graduate School of Business Administration, Kobe University, Kobe, Japan
e-mail: kokubu@kobe-u.ac.jp
H. Tachikawa
Propharm Japan Co., Ltd., Tokyo, Japan
e-mail: hiroshi.tachikawa@propharm.jp
1 Introduction
MFCA traces all input materials that flow through production processes and
measures products and material loss (waste) in physical units using the following
equation:
Input = Products + Material loss (waste)
21 Material Flow Cost Accounting: Significance and Practical Approach 353
Electricity
Input Output
material input that flows into product and material loss. For example, as illustrated
in Fig. 21.2, of the 100 tons of material used, 70 tons flow into product and 30 tons
flow into material loss. Thus, the material distribution percentages of 70% and
30% are used to allocate energy and system costs to the product and material loss,
respectively. In this example, the material distribution percentage based on mass
is used to allocate these costs. On the other hand, all waste management costs of
$50,000 are attributed to material loss since the costs are caused solely by the subject
material loss. In the final analysis, the total cost of material loss in this example is
$270,000. This cost is not separated but included in the cost of the product in the
conventional costing; the subject cost is invisible without MFCA.
This resulting information, the cost of the material loss, can encourage or-
ganizations and managers to reduce the material loss. Through these activities,
simultaneous achievements of financial benefits and control of material losses (i.e.,
more effective resource use) can be achieved.
MFCA can be applied to any types of organization which uses materials and
energy. In other words, MFCA does not demand any specific requirements in
regard to type of products, services, size, structure, and location. A number of case
examples in Japan prove the effectiveness of the approach for multiple scales of
industries. In addition, MFCA can be expanded to multiple organizations belonging
to the supply chain. This will enable the organizations to identify even more
opportunities for material reduction as well as higher energy efficiency. Wider
MFCA scope than that for a single entity is especially helpful because waste
generation in an organization is occasionally derived from materials or specification
of materials provided by a supplier or demanded by customers/consumers. The
MFCA application for supply chain is further depicted in Sect. 5.
21 Material Flow Cost Accounting: Significance and Practical Approach 355
MFCA takes a number of implementation steps. The level of detail and complexity
of the analysis will depend on a number of factors, such as the size of the organiza-
tion, nature of the organization’s activities and products, number of processes, and
quantity centers chosen for analysis.
MFCA can be implemented in organizations regardless of implementation of an
environmental management system (EMS); however, the implementation process
is considered to be easier and faster within the context of an existing EMS as
the environmental management-related data typically contains material- and waste-
related data.
Further, MFCA can provide significant information in various stages of the
Plan-Do-Check-Act (PDCA) continual improvement cycle. For example, the use
of MFCA allows the organization to include financial considerations in setting
objectives and targets. The knowledge of potential environmental impacts and
financial impacts can enhance the quality of the evaluation, providing useful
information for organization’s decision-making.
Every project needs support from the company management for its successful com-
pletion; MFCA is not an exception. The company management should understand
value and practicability of MFCA in achieving an organization’s environmental
and financial goals. In order to be effectively implemented, management is highly
recommended to take a lead in the MFCA implementation; naming the project; as-
sign roles and responsibilities, including setting up an MFCA task force; providing
resources; monitoring progress; reviewing results; and deciding on improvement
measures based on the MFCA results. In addition, MFCA requires multiple types of
expertise, which can provide the diverse types of information that is required for the
analysis. The following are the typical expertise that is necessary for the successful
implementation of MFCA:
– Operational expertise from design, procurement, and production in relation to the
flow of materials and energy use throughout the target process
– Engineering and/or technical expertise on the material-related implications of
processes, including combustion and other chemical reactions
– Quality control expertise on various issues, such as frequency of product
rejects, causes, and rework activities, maintenance, and other quality assurance
data
– Environmental expertise on environmental aspects and impacts, waste types, and
waste management and other environmental management activities
– Accounting expertise on cost accounting data and practices, for example, cost
data and cost allocation
356 K. Kokubu and H. Tachikawa
MFCA brings about both environmental and cost-reduction impacts on the orga-
nization. In order to apply MFCA to an organization effectively, implementation
activity should be based on understanding of the fundamental concept of quantity
center and material balance.
Input Output
Material A Product (70 kg)
(40kg) Material A (30kg)
Material B (20kg)
Material B Material C (10kg)
(25kg) Material D (7kg)
Material E (3kg)
Material C Operation
(20kg) Material loss (30 kg)
Material A (10kg)
Material D
Material B ( 5kg)
(10kg)
Material C (10kg)
Material D (3kg)
Material E
(5kg) Material E (2kg)
Material Flow
Material balance
A material balance requires that the total amount of outputs (i.e., products and
material losses) is equal to the total amount of inputs, taking into account any
inventory changes within the quantity center. Ideally, all materials within the MFCA
boundary should be traced and quantified. However, in reality, materials that have
minimal environmental or financial significance can be excluded.
Based on collected material flow data, the MFCA boundary needs to be specified in
order to clearly understand scale for MFCA activity. The boundary can be a single
process, multiple processes, an entire facility, or a supply chain at the discretion of
the organization. However, it is advisable to initially focus on a process or processes
with potentially significant environmental and economic impacts. After specifying
the boundary, a time period for MFCA data collection needs to be specified. The
period for data collection should be sufficiently long to allow meaningful data to be
collected and to consider any significant process variations, for example, seasonal
fluctuations, or inherent process variances that can affect the reliability and usability
of the data. Several historical MFCA projects indicate that the appropriate data
collection period can be a month, a half year, or a year, depending on the analysis.
358 K. Kokubu and H. Tachikawa
MFCA boundary
Final
Input Process 1 Process 2 Product
process
Fig. 21.4 Material flow model for a process within the MFCA boundary
Material costs, energy costs, and system costs are assigned or allocated to the
material outputs (i.e., products and material losses) at each quantity center based
on the proportion of the material input that flows into product and material loss.
The material costs for each input and output flow are quantified by multiplying the
physical amount of the material flow by the unit cost of the material over the time
period chosen for the analysis. When quantifying the material costs for the outputs
(i.e., products and material losses), the material costs associated with any changes
in material inventory within the quantity center should also be quantified. As an
example, of the 150 tons of material used, 70 tons flow into product and 80 tons
flow into material loss as illustrated in Fig. 21.1. Thus, the material distribution ratio
of 70/150 to 80/150 is used to allocate energy and system costs to the product and
21 Material Flow Cost Accounting: Significance and Practical Approach 359
material loss, respectively. On the other hand, 100% of the waste management costs
are attributed to material loss since the costs are caused solely by this material loss.
In some cases, however, costs such as energy costs, system costs, and waste
management costs are often available only for an entire process or facility. In this
case, it will be necessary to initially allocate these costs to each quantity center,
and subsequently allocate them to products and material losses, in the following
two-step procedure:
1. Allocation of overall (e.g., process-wide, facility-wide) costs to each quantity
center
2. Allocation of costs to products and material losses
During each allocation step, an appropriate allocation criterion should be selected,
which should reflect the main driver for the costs being allocated as closely as
possible. When process-wide or facility-wide costs are being allocated to quantity
centers, appropriate allocation criteria may include machine hours, production
volume, number of employees, labor hours, number of jobs performed, floor space,
etc. For the second step, allocation of costs from a quantity center to products
and material losses, another appropriate allocation criterion should be selected,
for example, the total material distribution percentage and material distribution
percentage of the main material.
Table 21.1 Example of a material flow cost matrix for a quantity center
Cost Material (xxx%) Energy (xxx%) System (xxx%) Disposal (xxx%) Total (xxx%)
Product AAAAA DDDDD GGGGG N/A NNNNN
Material BBBBB EEEEE HHHHH LLLLL OOOOO
loss
Total CCCCC FFFFF KKKKK MMMM PPPPP
for example, in a material flow cost matrix. The data should first be summarized for
each quantity center separately. Table 21.1 illustrates a format of the summary of
the MFCA data for a quantity center.
In general, review and interpretation of the summarized data will allow the orga-
nization to identify quantity centers with material losses that are environmentally or
financially significant. These quantity centers can be analyzed in more detail (i.e.,
root cause for sources of material loss). Data from individual quantity centers can
also be aggregated for the entire target process being analyzed.
Once the MFCA analysis is completed, the results should be communicated to
relevant stakeholders. Most MFCA stakeholders will be internal to the organization.
Management can use MFCA information to support many different types of
decisions aimed at improving both environmental and financial performance. Com-
municating the results to the organization’s employees can be useful in explaining
any process or organizational changes that will take place as a result of the MFCA
findings.
In this section, a case of MFCA is explained. Nitto Denko Corporation, the first
major company that implements MFCA in Japan, was referred as an example. Nitto
Denko introduced MFCA in 2000 by attending the METI (Ministry of Economy,
362 K. Kokubu and H. Tachikawa
Suppliers
3
Solvent Gases
(100%)
Manufacturing
Materials Division
¥ 104,494.22 ¥ 72,936.90 2 1
Inspection &
Dissolution Batch Blend Coating & Drying Store Slitting Warehouse
Packing
Finished Products (912 rolls)
Two of materials Adhesive Mass Upper quantity Backing film
(Unit Kg) Finished Product
(Unit Kg) center Each size oof product Separator
Solvent, Polymer Adhesive tapes for
(Width x Length)
n Adhesive
Electronics
Plastic core
Application
Packaging materials
Waste Waste Waste Quantity 912 rolls
21 Material Flow Cost Accounting: Significance and Practical Approach
MFCA, like other methods of EMA, has been developed and disseminated on the
premise that it is to be applied to a single organization; and a large number of
effective case studies of its application have been accumulated (Kokubu 2008).
MFCA is, in principle, applicable to the entire supply chain, from the extraction
of resources to the disposal of products, rather than a single organization. In this
sense, an expanded scope of application would be more likely to contribute to the
enhancement of resource efficiency, encouraging single companies to expand the
scope of MFCA application to their supply chains.
Although it is likely that material loss does not occur, especially for final-
assembly manufacturers, which usually only assemble parts, the manufacturing of
materials and parts in actuality generates a tremendous loss. In addition, the final-
assembly manufacturers’ product specifications are often the fundamental cause of
losses of resources in the supply chain and have a significant impact on the amount
of loss in the entire supply chain. Therefore, since the possibility of reducing the
losses of resources within a single organization is rather limited, the reduction must
be the target of each unit of the supply chain.
Fig. 21.6 (METI 2011b) presents a model that shows the types of material
loss and the possibility of their reduction in the supply chain. This model places
Company B in the central, midstream company position, Company A in the
upstream company position, and Company C in the downstream company position.
It shows what kinds of responses are required of Companies A and C in order to
reduce material loss for Company B. The figure does not show all the types of losses
originating from the supply chain and shows just the major types: loss owing to the
shape of purchased materials, loss owing to quality standards, loss owing to product
design methods, and loss due to production information (ordered lots and sizes).
21 Material Flow Cost Accounting: Significance and Practical Approach 365
Material loss
100% in Company A
Material loss
in Company B
80%
Resource input by
Resource input
Material loss in
Company A assembly
manufacturer
40%
30%
Fig. 21.6 Transition of material loss in the supply chain (Source: METI (2011a))
METI had conducted a project to introduce MFCA into the supply chain from 2008
to 2011. In this project, MFCA was introduced to approximately 50 supply chains.
In this section, among those examples, a traditional success case (the case of Kyosha
Co. Ltd.) is picked up.
Case: Kyosha Co. Ltd.
Fig. 21.7 shows the supply chain of Kyosha which participated in the METI’s
commissioned project for FY2010, the supply chain resource conservation partner-
ship program.
Kyosha Co., Ltd., a manufacturer of printed circuit boards, purchases copper-clad
laminates from a material manufacturer, has the hole-drilling process applied to the
laminates by NC Industry Co., Ltd., has through-hole plating applied to the drilled
laminates by Sansui Electronics Co., Ltd., and lastly executes pattern formation !
resist printing ! mark printing ! external-form processing for shipment of the
double-sided printed circuit boards for home appliances. This is the supply chain
in which Kyosha purchases raw materials and has drilling and plating processes
executed by external companies.
As a result of applying MFCA to this manufacturing process, it became clear that
the result shown in Fig. 21.6 was obtained in the whole supply chain: the positive
product cost of good products was 66%, while the negative product cost of material
loss was 34% (Fig. 21.8)
Looking at these calculated results, Kyosha’s Kyoto factory manager,
Mr. K. Nakayama, said, “The visualization of ‘material loss cost’ using the MFCA
method made us realize with surprise that material loss was far greater than had
been imagined” (METI 2011b, p. 20). Therefore, how to reduce material loss was
discussed among the three companies participating in the supply chain, and as a
366
Double-sided
printed-circuit
board
inspection
Inspection
Inspection
Inspection
Mark printing
Resist printing
Material cutting
Drilling process
Pattern formation
High-pressure polishing
Chemical copper plating
Profilling process (press)
Material loss Residual resin (-baked) material Defective products (disposal) Press end scraps (disposal)
100%
System cost
90%
Energy cost
Material cost
80%
46.4%
70%
60%
40%
30% 5.4%
12.7%
46.0%
20% 2.2%
26.9%
10% 19.0%
0%
Input cost Cost of products Cost of material losses
Fig. 21.8 Result of MFCA calculations (before improvement) (Source: METI (2011b), p. 21)
result it was found that altering the standard size of a laminate would increase
the number of panels that could be cut out of it, realizing a significant reduction
of waste to about one-fifth of the previous amount of waste. It was clear that
this would contribute not only to Kyosha but also to the other two companies by
improving productivity, making it possible to enhance resource productivity in the
whole supply chain, which is a win–win solution. From MFCA’s simulation of the
effect of the improvements (shown in Fig. 21.9), it is estimated that negative product
cost could be reduced from 34% to 25%.
In response to this estimation, Mr. Nakayama, Kyosha’s factory manager, said:
The design of the divisional construction of material in manufacturing printed circuit boards
is an important factor, and, therefore, I had been confident there would be no more room
for improvement. As a result of this analysis and future cooperative activities, however,
further improvement was found to be possible. Through this, it is hoped that new mutual
relationships between companies in the supply chain will be constructed and further efforts
to improve our future business activities shall be made. (METI 2011b, p. 20)
From this statement by Mr. Nakayama, it follows that activities for improvement
to date had been premised on the standard size of a purchased material, and,
therefore, it was not until the introduction of MFCA that alteration of the standard
size was considered. Putting this result into consideration, Kyosha negotiated with
their upstream material manufacturer and succeeded in changing the standard size
368 K. Kokubu and H. Tachikawa
100%
System cost
90%
Energy cost
Material cost
80%
46.1%
70%
60%
37.6%
50% 7.5%
40%
6.1%
30%
46.4%
20% 8.5%
31.0% 1.4%
10%
15.4%
0%
Input cost Cost of products Cost of material losses
Fig. 21.9 Result of MFCA calculation (after improvement) (Source: METI (2011b), p. 21)
6 Summary
Climate change, material scarcity, environmental legislation, and the global com-
petition are in the headlines more than ever, highlighting the fact that effective
management of environmental and economic matters has become a vital social
issue on the global scale. In response, manufacturers and other businesses are under
pressure to increase productivity while reducing cost and environmental impact.
MFCA can help organizations to achieve such objectives by identifying emissions
and waste within a process in cost and physical terms. Such data can motivate
organizations to enhance material productivity and significantly reduce waste more
effectively than relying only on conventional production management and cost
accounting information. In addition, MFCA helps organization to reduce energy
use associated with the waste production.
21 Material Flow Cost Accounting: Significance and Practical Approach 369
Acknowledgments
7 Cross-References
References
Y. Furukawa, Material Flow Cost Accounting, Japan Environmental Management Association for
Industry (Tokyo, Japan, 2008)
K. Kokubu, H. Kitada, Introducing MFCA into the Supply Chain: A New Possibility. A Paper
presented at the 10th Northeast Asia management and economics joint conference, Chungnam
National University (Daejeon, Korea, November 2011)
K. Kokubu (ed.), Practical Material Flow Cost Accounting, Japan Environmental Management
Association for Industry (in Japanese) (Tokyo, Japan, 2008)
METI, Guidance for Supply Chain Inter-Company Partnership to Improve Resource Conser-
vation(Ver.3). Recycling Promotion Division, Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry (in
Japanese) (Tokyo, Japan, 2011a)
METI, Case Studies in the Supply Chain Resource Conservation Partnership Program. Recycling
Promotion Division, Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry (in Japanese) (Tokyo, Japan,
2011b)
METI, Introduction to Resource Conservation through Inter-Company Partnership. Recycling
Promotion Division, Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry (in Japanese) (Tokyo, Japan,
2011c)
M. Nakajima, K. Kokubu, Materials Flow Cost Accounting 2nd edition. Nihon Keizai Shinbunsha
(available only in Japanese and Korean) (Tokyo, Japan, 2008)
H. Tachikawa, Y. Furukawa, International Standardization of MFCA (ISO 14051). A Paper
presented at Eco Balance Conference (Tokyo, Japan, 2010)
H. Tachikawa, Material Flow Cost Accounting and Environmental Risk Management. Environ-
mental Management, vol 46(55) Japan Environmental Management Association for Industry
(Tokyo, Japan, 2010)
Product Life Cycle Assessment (PLCA)
and Product Carbon Footprint (PCF) 22
Kun-Mo Lee
Abstract
Ecodesign, an integration of environmental aspects into product design, requires
identification of significant parameters of a product in its entire life cycle.
Significant parameters are processes, materials, parts, activities, and life cycle
stages that contribute significantly (e.g., >1%) to the total impact of a product.
Product life cycle assessment (PLCA) is a tool that enables quantification of the
input and output from the processes and activities of a product, assessment of
their potential impact on the environment, and then identification of significant
parameters.
PLCA has two major applications: the identification of significant parameters
and the development of the environmental profile of a product. Significant
parameters can be used for clarifying the environmental needs for Ecodesign,
while environmental profile for assessing the Ecodesign results or eco-product
and environmental communication of the eco-product. Product carbon footprint
(PCF) is one of the most visible applications of the product’s environmental
profile by communicating to the market only the data related to greenhouse gases
(GHG) emissions.
Practical guidance and relevant examples related to the topics such as product
modeling, data collection and processing, data compiling, calculation of the
life cycle impact, identifying significant parameters, and development of an
environmental and carbon profile are given in this chapter to aid understanding
of the PLCA and PCF.
K.-M. Lee
Department of Environmental Engineering, Ajou University, Suwon, Korea
e-mail: kunlee@ajou.ac.kr
1 Introduction
Product modeling: defining functional unit, reference flow, and system boundary in each life cycle stage
Collecting and processing data from each process in the system boundary; material and energy input and
process emissions and output data
Compiling data by arranging them with respect to parameter and combine them for each life cycle stage
Product profile and significant parameters PCF profile and significant parameters (GW
(all impact categories) impact category only)
Fig. 22.1 Step-by-step approach for the implementation of PLCA and PCF
from the unit processes and activities in all five life cycle stages, and processing
them with respect to functional unit. The data compiling step includes arranging
processed data with respect to each parameter. The sum of each parameter data is
arranged in a matrix form.
There are two separate tracks to follow: PLCA and PCF for the calculation of
the life cycle impact and the impact of GHG emissions or global warming impact,
respectively. The PLCA track links the compiled data to the LCI database, while
the PCF track links the compiled data to the GHG emission factor database. The
calculation step includes calculating life cycle impact (e.g., characterized impact
(CI) and weighted impact (WI)) and the impact of GHG emissions of a product in the
case of PLCA and PCF, respectively. The identification step includes contribution
analysis to identify significant parameters of a product.
Significant parameters and environmental profiles encompassing broader spec-
trum of the parameters and environmental impact categories (e.g., acidification,
resource depletion, and global warming.) are main outcome from the implemen-
tation of PLCA. Meanwhile, product carbon profile and significant parameters
focused only on global warming impact category are the main outcome from the
implementation of PCF.
Last but not least, data quality assessment including uncertainty analysis must be
made before presenting final results of the PLCA and PCF. Normally data quality
assessment begins with the significant parameters identified. Qualitative assessment
such as the Pedigree matrix method can often be used. However quantitative
analysis using the uncertainty analysis method should be performed for those
uncertain significant parameters. The procedure involves assumption of the most
likely probability distribution of the uncertain input data followed by the simulation
of the artificially generated input data on the output results of a model equation using
the Monte Carlo simulation technique. A range of values, upper and lower bound
values, of a say 95% confidence interval are generated with the most probable mean
value. Since the data quality assessment including uncertainty analysis is a lengthy
subject, no further discussion will be made in this chapter.
2 Product Modeling
In order to quantify inputs of materials and energy into a process and outputs
including emissions from the process, a clear demarcation line or boundary shall
be defined prior to quantification. A product system is a collection of processes and
activities associated with a product of interest under analysis along its value chain or
entire life cycle stages. For the analysis of a product system, the very first thing to do
is to define functional unit of a product and setting up the product system boundary.
Functional unit is a unit that can measure functional performance of a product.
For instance, function of a beverage container such as bottle or can is to store
beverage. Functional unit is then volume or certain volume of the container, say
350 ml. Reference flow is an actual product that realizes the functional unit. Here
either a glass bottle of 350 ml or an aluminum can of 350 ml is the reference flow.
For comparative purpose, defining functional unit is of utmost importance because
22 Product Life Cycle Assessment (PLCA) and Product Carbon Footprint (PCF) 375
comparison must be based on the same leveling field. For others where comparison
is not involved, one piece of product under analysis is the reference flow without
needing to specify functional unit (Lee and Inaba 2004).
Next step is to define boundary of a product system. Defining system boundary
in accordance with the life cycle stage is the most practical approach. There are
five life cycle stages in any product system, provided the scope of the study is
from cradle to grave. They are: target product of the PLCA and/or PCF study,
upstream and downstream activities. The upstream activities include the use of raw
materials stage up to parts manufacturing. The target product is the manufacture
stage. The downstream activities include the distribution, use, and end-of-life stages.
A method for defining boundaries for each life cycle stage and accompanying
examples are given below.
Use of raw materials stage: Often this stage is referred to as the upstream
processes of a product system. This stage consists of the acquisition of natural
resources, the processing of the natural resources into raw and ancillary materials,
the manufacturing of parts, and the associated transport of parts and materials.
In order to set up system boundary of this stage, major parts, components, and
assemblies from the BOM data and/or disassembly data of a product should be
identified (Wimmer et al. 2010). List them on the descending order of its weight.
Calculate cumulative weight and cumulative weight percentage. Apply mass cut
off rule, say 95%, of the total weight below which are excluded from the product
system boundary. Those excluded are assumed to exert insignificant impact on the
environment. If this is not the case, parts, processes, and activities associated with
those excluded such as toxic substances or highly potent greenhouse gases (e.g.,
SF6 ) must be included in the system boundary.
Table 22.2 is an example of a product (toaster) composition. Here, cumulative
weight and percent (%) cumulative weight are calculated in order to apply the cut
off rule. Typically 95% or 99% cut off rule applies where remaining 5% or 1%
of parts and components are excluded from the system boundary, respectively. The
99% cut off rule was applied in this example as such epoxy resin was included but
control knob made of ABS excluded. In this case, product weight does not change
to 1,290 g but remains unchanged as 1,302 g. This simply means that data collection
is up to epoxy resin.
Manufacture stage: All processes and activities involved during manufacture of a
product from the entrance gate to the exit gate of the manufacturing site are included
in this stage.
Distribution stage: All activities from the release of products by the manufacturer
to the point of sale belong to this stage. Activities such as transport and storage in a
warehouse are examples of the distribution activities. A distribution scenario based
on the product weight and/or volume, mode of transport, transport distance, number
of products transported in one transport is normally made.
Use stage: A scenario for the product use by a product user should be made by
making reasonable assumption on the time of operation and the amount of material
and energy consumption per use. In addition, lifetime of the product is not the
technically feasible lifetime but useful lifetime where a product is actually used
by the user till its disposal.
376 K.-M. Lee
End-of-life stage: The type and weight of materials in each part of a product
dictates the collection, recycling, reuse, and disposal methods of the wasted product.
Thus, the end of life scenario based on the type of materials and weight of each
part should be made. Typical mode of operation in the end of life stage includes
incineration, landfill, recycling, and reuse.
Lastly set up a process tree consisting of the upstream processes up to the parts
manufacturing processes, product manufacture, distribution and use of the product,
and end of life of the wasted product (e.g., recycling, incineration, and ultimate
disposal). All the upstream processes and the processes and activities from other
life cycle stages are interconnected by following the hierarchy of the product in its
entire life cycle spanning from the use of raw materials to the end-of-life stages.
This is termed “process tree.” Figure 22.2 shows the process tree of a toaster.
All input data including raw and ancillary materials and energy, and all output
data including main, co- and by-products and emissions from all the processes and
activities in the system boundary should be collected. Data means data of actual
input and output such as the amount of galvanized steel, slag, electricity, steam,
and SF6 . The actual input and output are termed input and output parameters. Often
allocation is required during the data collection as such application of the transparent
and consistent allocation criteria is necessary. Collected data should be processed or
normalized to express in terms of functional unit or reference flow. Typical data
collection points considered in the five life cycle stages include:
Use of raw materials stage: Major outcomes from this stage are the materi-
als and energy parameters with their values. Thus, input and output data from
this stage should be quantified by gathering input/output data from individual
parts/components and their manufacturing processes.
22 Product Life Cycle Assessment (PLCA) and Product Carbon Footprint (PCF) 377
Toaster
Package
Body
Toaster
assembly
(manufacture)
Distribution
Use
End of life
Manufacture stage: Input and output data from the unit processes in the
manufacturing processes are quantified. Since the manufacturing process is well
known to the product manufacturer, here the producer who conducts the PLCA and
PCF study, unit manufacturing processes envisaged significant environmentally can
be chosen by the manufacturer. For each unit process chosen, identify relevant input
and output parameters and their values. Table 22.3 is a fictitious example of the
input and output data of the manufacture stage.
Distribution stage: Input and output mainly occur from the fuel combustion of
the mobile sources. For each mode of transport, identify the total product weight in
one load and distance traveled. Fuel consumption can be obtained by multiplying
transport distance by the fuel consumption coefficient and product weight or
volume. Table 22.4 is a fictitious example of the data of the distribution stage.
Use stage: Average material and energy consumption should be estimated by
taking into account the useful lifetime and consumed material and energy during
378
Table 22.4 Fictitious data of the distribution stage (Total load: x ton/transport)
Fuel consumption factor
Fuel Fuel
Transport Total consumption consumption
mode Distance load/transport (empty load) (per load) Fuel type Total fuel consumption
0:0066 kg kg
9 ton C 0:136 .500 km/
11.5 ton 500 km 9 ton 0.136 kg/km 0.0066 kg/ton-km Diesel ton km km
Truck at 80 D 97:7 kg
km/h
160:9 kg
8,000 TEU 12,000 km 65% of the full 160.9 (kg/km) Bunker C oil .12; 000 km/ D 1; 930; 500 kg
Container load capacity D km
ship at 5200 TEU
21 knots
Fuel consumption: 150
tons/day at 21 knots
21 knots D 38:85 km=hr D 932:4 km=day
150 tons
Fuel consumption D
day
day
D 160:9 kg=km
932:4 km
1TEU (twenty feet equivalent unit) =33m3
In the case of ocean transport there is no need to consider the fuel consumption for empty load and per load, for no ships operate with empty load.
K.-M. Lee
22 Product Life Cycle Assessment (PLCA) and Product Carbon Footprint (PCF) 379
the operation and maintenance of the product (e.g., on, off, and standby mode). For
each mode of operation, identify the time of operation, material and energy input.
The total operating time is multiplied by the unit material and energy consumption
in order to quantify the total material and energy consumption of the product during
its use stage (EC 2005). Table 22.5 is a fictitious example of the data of the use stage.
End-of-life stage: Arrange the type and weight of materials in each part of a
product in accordance with the treatment method including reuse, recycle, and
disposal and apply corresponding database to each of the materials and treatment
method. Table 22.6 is a fictitious example of the data of the end-of-life stage.
Data collected from each process and activity should be normalized by the main
output of the process. In other words, all input and output data from each process
and activity are divided by the total weight or energy content of the main output.
Normalized results are expressed as input or output data per kilogram or megajoule
of main output. In addition, multiplying the normalized data by the fractional
contribution of each process and activity to the final product yields input and output
data in terms of reference flow. Summing up all these data yields input/output data
in the use of raw materials stage.
Normalization of input/output data in each process in the distribution, use, and
end-of-life stages is not necessary. However, conversion of input/output data in
terms of reference flow is necessary.
4 Compiling Data
Once all input and output data in each of the five life cycle stages are gleaned and
processed, next step is to arrange them with respect to each parameter and then
compile them in each life cycle stage in matrix form as shown in Tables 22.7–
22.11. In the matrix, input and output parameters are listed in the row, while
380
Table 22.7 Fictitious example of the compiled input/output data in the use of raw materials stage (Per reference flow: one toaster)
Levela 2 Toaster body Package
Cable Supporting Main
Parameters Level 3 Shell PCB (Power) Chassis side Sum package Manual Sum Total
Unit
PP g 300 112 412 412
Steel g 57 290 347 347
Copper g 35 35 35
Epoxy resin g 62 62 62
PVC g 95 95 95
Cardboard g 215 215 215
Recycled paper g 124 124 124
a
Note: level 1 is the product, level 2 is the major parts/components, and level 3 is the sub-parts of the major part.
K.-M. Lee
22 Product Life Cycle Assessment (PLCA) and Product Carbon Footprint (PCF) 381
Table 22.8 Fictitious example of the compiled input/output data in the manufacture stage (Per
reference flow: one toaster)
Housing (injection
moulding, extrusion Packaging Heating part
Parameters Unit moulding) assembly assembly Sum
Electricity kWh 0.8 0.2 2 3
Table 22.9 Fictitious example of the compiled input/output data in the distribution stage (Per
reference flow: one toaster)
Parameters Unit Trucking Shipping Sum
Diesel g 14.1 14.1
Bunker C g 112.5 112.5
1:3 kg product
DieselW 97:7 kg diesel 9;000 kg load
D 14:1 g/product
3
0:01 m product
Bunker CW 1; 930; 500 kg bunker C oil
m3
D 112:5 g/product
.5;200 TEU/ 33 TEU
Table 22.10 Fictitious example of the compiled input/output data in the use stage (Per reference
flow: one toaster)
Parameters Unit On-mode Off-mode Sum
Electricity kWh 20.6 0 20.6
Table 22.11 Fictitious example of the compiled input/output data in the end of life stage (Per
reference flow: one toaster)
Parameters Unit Incineration Recycling Sum
Wasted PP g 412 412
Wasted steel g 347 347
Wasted copper g 35 35
Wasted epoxy resin g 62 62
Wasted PVC g 95 95
Wasted cardboard g 215 215
Wasted recycled paper g 124 124
processes and activities are in the column. In the case of a simplified matrix, all
five life cycle stages are listed in the column instead of all processes and activities,
while input/output parameters where each parameter value is the sum of the same
parameter data in a given five life cycle stage are listed in the column as shown in
Table 22.12.
One can assess the impact of the compiled data in Table 22.12 on the environment.
To be specific, impact on the environment means impact on the chosen impact cate-
gories such as global warming, acidification, and photochemical oxidants creation,
among others. The impact can be quantified through quantification process such
382 K.-M. Lee
Table 22.12 Sum of the input/output parameters and their values of the five life cycle stages (Per
reference flow: one toaster)
Use of raw
Parameter Unit materials Manufacture Distribution Use End of life Sum
Material
PP g 412 412
Steel g 347 347
Copper g 35 35
Epoxy resin g 62 62
PVC g 95 95
Cardboard g 215 215
Recycled paper g 124 124
Wasted PP g 412 412
Wasted steel g 347 347
Wasted copper g 35 35
Wasted epoxy g 62 62
resin
Wasted PVC g 95 95
Wasted g 215 215
cardboard
Wasted recycled g 124 124
paper
Energy
Electricity kWh 3 20.6 23:6
Diesel g 14.1 14:1
Bunker C g 112.5 112:5
X
CIi;j D Loadj eqvi;j and CIi D CIi;j (22.1)
j
Weighting factor (wi / that gives relative significance or weight to the impact
category under consideration is multiplied by the normalized impact in a given
impact category. Through weighting, differing units of each impact category are
harmonized into the same unit. This enables one to add weighted impact of the ith
impact category (WIi / across all the impact categories. The calculation of the WIi
and WI is shown in (22.3).
X
WIi D wi NIi and WI D WIi (22.3)
i
Based on the CI and WI results, one can determine significant parameters which can
be the starting points for the improvement of the product’s environmental perfor-
mance. Identifying significant parameters means identifying significant processes,
materials, parts, activities, and life cycle stages. Contribution analysis is a method
of choice for the identification.
In the case of using CI for the identification, every entry in each cell of the CI
matrix is divided by the total sum of the CI value and expressed as the percent. The
percent value in each entry represents the relative contribution of the entry to the
total CI value of the product. Any contribution from an entry greater than x%, say
1%, can be envisaged as significant parameters requiring improvement. Significant
384 K.-M. Lee
parameters identified from the CI matrix in Table 22.13 include the use stage,
manufacture stage, and steel used during the use of raw material stage of the product.
Outcomes from the PLCA track are an environmental profile of the product
and significant parameters for the environmental improvement of the product’s
environmental performance. The environmental profile can be communicated to
the market in the form of the Type III environmental declaration. The identified
significant parameters can be linked to the environmental improvement strategies
in order to formulate ecodesign tasks (e.g., things to consider in the design or
environmental needs) of the product (Wimmer et al. 2004).
instance, if 2 kg of CH4 was directly measured, then the GWP value of CH4; 25 kg
CO2 -eqv/kg CH4 is applied to calculate the GHG emission impact of CH4 , here
50 kg CO2 -eqv.
For an indirect calculation the compiled input/output parameter data in
Table 22.12 are linked to the GHG emission factors and GWP value of the
parameter. There are several tiers of the GHG emission factors available, depending
on the need of accuracy of the data. They are Tier 1, 2, 3, and 4 GHG emission
factors. For instance, the Korean Act regulating the control of GHG emissions
stipulate what levels of tier shall be used for specific sources of emissions (Ministry
of Environment 2011). When GHG emission factors are not available, then one can
convert the LCI database of a material in question into the GHG emission factor.
The GHG emissions impact can be calculated as in (22.4).
GHG emissions impact (kg CO2 -eqv) = input or output parameter data (unit)
emission factor (kg GHG/unit) GWP (kg CO2 -eqv/kg GHG) (22.4)
where,
Unit=kg or MJ of input or output.
If emission factor is expressed as kg CO2 -eqv/unit, then GWP value shall not be
multiplied. This is because the emission factor in this case already incorporated the
GWP value.
Both the directly measured and indirectly calculated GHG emissions impact are
combined to give total GHG emissions impact from each life cycle stage. The impact
of GHG emission of a product in its entire life cycle stages can be obtained by
summing up the GHG emissions impact from each of the five life cycle stages of a
product. Outcome of the calculation step is the product carbon profile or PCF and
possibly a single PCF value of the product.
9 Summary
data to the LCI (life cycle inventory) database to express them as elementary flows,
and identifying significant parameters of a product to be used in ecodesign and the
value chain management.
Conventional LCA has limited applications to the implementation of PLCA,
although its principles are embedded in the PLCA. In short, PLCA is a practical
and simple tool for the identification of significant parameters of a product, which
can be used for improving the performance of a product.
Outcomes of the PLCA implementation can also be used to generate an environ-
mental profile of a product (i.e., the list of input and output parameters in and out of
the product system). There is no linkage of these data to the LCI database, but only
the actual input and output parameters appear in the environmental profile. When
dealing only with the GHG emission impact of a product the environmental profile
can be converted into the PCF. PCF can be expressed in a single number. Because
of uncertainties embedded in the LCI database and in the assumed distribution, use,
and end-of-life stage scenarios, the PCF information needs independent third party
verification before releasing to the public for communication.
One aspect of the product embodiment design is to form BOM of a product by
choosing relevant parts and components and materials. Assigning GHG emission
impact values to each part, component, and material, one can create greenhouse gas
BOM or g-BOM (Song and Lee 2010). The use of g-BOM allows quick and easy
calculation of the impact of GHG emissions from a chosen design alternative during
the product’s embodiment design. Applying ecodesign to the embodiment design
stage is warranted for wider application of ecodesign. Thus, developing a design tool
such as g-BOM should be actively sought for acceptance of the ecodesign practice
by the product designers and developers.
References
European Commission (EC), Directive 2005/32/EC of the European parliament and of the council
of 6 July 2005 establishing a framework for the setting of ecodesign requirements for energy-
using products and amending Council Directive 92/42/EEC and Directives 96/57/EC and
2000/55/EC of the European parliament and of the council. OJEU L. 48(191), 29–58 (2005)
M. Geodkoop, R. Spriensma, The Eco-Indicator 99, A Damage Oriented Method for Life
Cycle Impact Assessment Methodology Report, 3rd edn. (Ministerie van Volkshiusvesting,
Ruimtelijke Ordening en Milieubeheer, Den Haag, 2001)
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), in 2006 IPCC Guidelines for National Green-
house Gas Inventories, NGGIP (the National Greenhouse Gas Inventories Programme), ed. by
H.S. Eggleston, L. Buendia, T. Ngara, K. Tannabe, Published IGES, Japan (Intergovernmental
Panel on Climate Change, Geneva, 2006)
International Organization for Standardization (ISO), ISO 14040; Environmental Management –
Life Cycle Assessment – Principles and Framework (International Organization for Standard-
ization, Geneve, 2006)
N. Itsubo, A. Inaba, A new LCIA method: LIME has been completed. Int. J. LCA 8(5), 305 (2003)
K.-M. Lee, A weighting method for the Korean eco-indicator. Int. J. LCA 4(3), 161–165 (1999)
K.-M. Lee, A. Inaba, Life Cycle Assessment: Best Practices of ISO 14040 Series APEC (Center for
Ecodesign and LCA (CEL), Ajou University, Suwon/Korea, 2004)
388 K.-M. Lee
Ministry of Environment, The Operational Guide for the Target Control of GHG and Energy
(Ministry of Environment, Korea, 2011)
Ministry of Knowledge and Economy, The Carbon Partnership Guide for Large, Small and
Medium Enterprises (Ministry of Knowledge and Economy, Korea, 2011)
J.S. Song, K.-M. Lee, Development of a low-carbon product design system based on embedded
GHG emissions. Resour. Conserv. Recy. 94, 547–556 (2010)
B. Steen, A Systematic Approach to Environmental Priority Strategies in Product Development
(EPS). Version 2000 – General System Characteristics (Centre for Environmental Assessment
of Products and Material System, Goteborg, 2000)
W. Wimmer, K.-M. Lee, F. Quella, J. Polak, Ecodesign – The Competitive Advantage (Springer,
Dordrecht/New York, 2010)
W. Wimmer, R. Züst, K.-M. Lee, Ecodesign Implementation – A Systematic Guidance on
Integrating Environmental Considerations into Product Development (Springer, Dordrecht,
2004)
World Resource Institute (WRI) and World Business Council for Sustainable Development
(WBCSD), The Greenhouse Gas Protocol, A Corporate Accounting and Reporting Standard,
revised edn. (World Business Council for Sustainable Development, Geneva; World Resources
Institute, Washington, DC, 2004)
Remanufacturing
23
Mitsutaka Matsumoto and Winifred Ijomah
Abstract
Remanufacturing, a process of bringing used products to “like-new” functional
state with matching warranty, is being regarded as a more sustainable mode of
manufacturing because it can be profitable and less harmful to the environment
than conventional manufacturing. The practice is particularly applicable to
complex electromechanical and mechanical products which have cores that,
when recovered, will have value added to them which is high relative to their
market value and to their original cost. Because remanufacturing recovers a
substantial fraction of the materials and value added to a product in its first
manufacture, and because it can do this at low additional cost, the resulting
products can be obtained at reduced price. Remanufacturing however is poorly
understood because of its relative novelty in research terms. This chapter will
clearly define the term “remanufacturing” by differentiating it from alternative
green production initiatives. It provides an overview of the remanufacturing
concept, significance, and practice.
1 Definition of Remanufacturing
The two general aspects to sustainability are living within the critical limits of
the ecosystem and balancing social, economic, and ecological goals (Yamamoto
1999). Because of the significant adverse impact of conventional manufacturing
M. Matsumoto ()
Center for Service Research, National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and
Technology (AIST), Tsukuba, Ibaraki, Japan
e-mail: matsumoto-mi@aist.go.jp
W. Ijomah
Design Manufacturing and Engineering Management, Faculty of Engineering,
University of Strathclyde, Glasgow, UK
e-mail: w.l.ijomah@strath.ac.uk
on the planet, for example, manufacturing generates more than 60% of annual
nonhazardous waste arising (Nasr and Varel 1996), sustainable development would
be impossible without sustainable manufacturing. Sustainable manufacturing is
being addressed by promoting secondary market processes. Such processes, also
known as component reuse or product/component recovery processes are defined
as the various production processes that use components from used products and
include repair and reconditioning as well as remanufacturing. The importance of
these processes is that they help limit landfill by prolonging the life of products and
components, so they take longer before needing disposal. Also, by integrating used
components into the production cycle they reduce the amount of virgin components
and therefore of virgin materials and energy used in production. Remanufacturing,
repair, and reconditioning are also known as disassembly processes because they all
involve disassembly. However, they are not equal but exist on a hierarchy based on
the quality of their output and the warranty given.
Remanufacturing is defined as “a process of returning a used product to at
least original equipment manufacturer (OEM) performance specification from the
customers’ perspective and giving the resultant product a warranty that is at least
equal to that of a newly manufactured equivalent” (Ijomah 2002).
There are various definitions of the term remanufacturing in circulation. The
importance of this version is twofold. Firstly, it for the first time clearly defines and
differentiates remanufacturing from repair and reconditioning, and secondly it pro-
vides a method for the purchaser to easily recognize that remanufactured products
have higher quality than repaired and reconditioned alternatives, and that remanu-
factured products have similar quality to new alternatives. Prior to the development
of this definition of remanufacturing (adopted by British Standards Institute (BSI)
in 2010) remanufacturing definition was ambiguous and insufficient thus creating
major problem for researchers and practitioners alike. It causes extreme difficulties
in undertaking effective research and in correctly disseminating knowledge about
the process (Melissen and Ron 1999). At the same time, many individuals are unable
to differentiate between remanufacturing, repair, and reconditioning and refuse to
purchase remanufactured products because they are unsure of their quality. The
following sections explain the ambiguity in remanufacturing definitions.
Previously, remanufacturing definitions fell into two camps (Ijomah 2002; Ijomah
et al. 2004):
1. Those describing remanufacturing as involving reconditioning (e.g., component
reconditioning). An example of this is the definition by Amezquita et al. (1996).
2. Definitions recognizing that remanufacturing could not include reconditioning
because they are different processes with different quality requirements. Exam-
ples from this group include Lund (1984a) and Haynsworth and Lyons (1987).
23 Remanufacturing 391
The inconsistency in the definition of secondary market processes and the ambiguity
of remanufacturing definitions can be illustrated by examining two of the most
popular definitions of remanufacturing, one by Amezquita et al. (1996) (group 1)
and the other by Haynsworth and Lyons (1987), (group 2).
Amezquita et al. (1996) describe remanufacturing as “The process of bringing
a product to like-new condition through reusing, reconditioning, and replacing
component parts.”
In the same paper they describe reconditioning as a process that is different from
remanufacturing and that produces products that are inferior in quality to those
produced by remanufacturing. However, since remanufacturers state that the quality
of a product is governed by the quality of its individual components, a product that
has within it reconditioned components can be described as remanufactured only
if remanufacturing and reconditioning describe the same process. If, on the other
hand, as proposed by Amezquita et al. (1996), remanufacturing is indeed superior to
reconditioning, then a product that has reconditioned components (i.e., components
that are below the quality standards of remanufacturing), must itself be below the
standards of the remanufacturing process. Such a product can therefore not be
described as remanufactured. Because the definition above has not differentiated
remanufacturing from reconditioning the definition by Amezquita et al. (1996) is
ambiguous.
The definition of remanufacturing as “The process of bringing a product to like-
new condition through replacing and rebuilding component parts” was published
by Haynsworth and Lyons in 1987. They go on to explain that “Products that
have been remanufactured have quality that is equal to and sometimes superior
to that of the original product.” Case studies and the literature clearly show that
this bringing of remanufactured products to at least original specification is one
of the important factors that practitioners use to distinguish remanufacturing from
repair and reconditioning. Because of this, definitions such as that by Haynsworth
and Lyons (1987) are much better than the previous group. However, they too
are inadequate because they do not provide a method for the purchaser to easily
recognize that remanufactured products have higher quality than repaired and
reconditioned alternatives, or that remanufactured products have similar quality to
new alternatives. Thus both groups of definitions are insufficient.
According to UK trade organizations, such as the Department of Trade and Indus-
try (DTI) and Federation of Automotive Transmission Engineers (FATE), the legal
performance requirement for secondary market products, where such regulations
exist, stipulates guidance about minimum quality levels only and producers are held
to account on the warranty that they give their products. Case studies in the UK
remanufacturing industry and telephone interviews of remanufacturers in Europe
showed that practitioners believe that a warranty serves as a guide to a product’s
quality. In fact, they stated that they give their remanufactured products at least the
same warranty as the OEM equivalent as a method of indicating that the quality of
their product is similar to that of the OEM equivalent. The practitioners believed
that remanufacturing, repair and reconditioning involve dissimilar work content and
produce products of dissimilar quality. They also believed that remanufacturing
392 M. Matsumoto and W. Ijomah
Table 23.1 Definitions of secondary market processes (Ijomah 2002; Ijomah et al. 2004)
Remanufacturing
The process of returning a used product to at least OEM original performance specification from
the customers’ perspective and giving the resultant product warranty that is at least equal to that
of a newly manufactured equivalent
Reconditioning
The process of returning a used product to a satisfactory working condition that may be inferior
to the original specification. Generally, the resultant product has a warranty that is less than that
of a newly manufactured equivalent. The warranty applies to all major wearing parts.
Repair
Repairing is simply the correction of specified faults in a product. Generally, the quality of a
repaired product is inferior to that of the remanufactured and reconditioned alternative. When
repaired products have warranties, they are less than those of newly manufactured equivalents.
Also, the warranty many not cover the whole product but only the component that has been
repaired.
obtains the highest quality of products followed by reconditioning, then repair. They
indicated that the operations could be differentiated using two factors:
1. The level of quality of the secondary market product when compared to that of
an equivalent new product.
2. The standard of the warranty of the secondary market product in comparison to
that given to the equivalent new product.
The rationale described above and the wide-ranging research within the remanu-
facturing industry including practitioners’ validation led to the development of the
definition above and its subsequent adoption by BSI (2010, BS 8887–220:2010 ).
Table 23.1 defines and differentiates repair, reconditioning, and remanufacturing.
The key advantage of remanufacturing over reconditioning and repair is that it
permits an organization to combine the key order winners of low price and product
quality, especially as remanufacturing also includes increasing the performance and
quality of the used product beyond that of its original standards when new.
Figure 23.1 shows the three processes on a hierarchy based on the work content
that they typically require, the performance that should be obtained from them and
the value of the warranty that they normally carry.
Remanufacturing is the highest of these processes because it is the only one
capable of bringing a used product to a standard equal to that of the new alternative
in terms of quality, performance, and warranty.
Remanufacturing
Reconditioning
Repair
Warranty
development. Research has shown that the major remanufacturing drivers are envi-
ronmental concerns, legislation – particularly landfill tax, and end-of-life directives
and economics. For example, Lund (1984a) illustrated that 85% of the weight of a
remanufactured product may come from used components, that such products have
comparable quality to equivalent new products, but require 50–80% less energy
to produce and that remanufacturing can provide 20–80% production cost savings
in comparison to conventional manufacturing. This accords with the findings of
other researchers, for example, Steinhilper and Haynesworth. Remanufacturing can
limit environmental impacts including greenhouse gases such as CO2 and methane
because for most goods, raw materials production and the subsequent shaping and
machining processes produce the highest CO2 emission. Remanufacturing, however,
bypasses these processes.
Remanufacturing’s societal benefits include reducing social exclusion caused by
poverty and lack of skills. The reason here are that remanufacturing
1. Creates employment across the board. However, its ratio of low to high skill
requirement is greater than for conventional manufacturing because many of
the tasks of remanufacturing such as sorting and cleaning are easy to learn.
Lund (1984a) indicates that in the automotive sector up to 60% of a typical
remanufacturing company may be skilled or unskilled.
2. Remanufacturing drives down production costs, thus, enabling producers to
reduce the selling price of their products. This facilitates the provision of high-
quality goods at prices that those on low income can afford.
Remanufacturing is also playing a critical role in the paradigm shift from product
sale to service industries that are occurring.
There are three types of remanufacturing practitioners: the original equipment man-
ufacturer (OEM), the independent (noncontract) remanufacturer, and the contract
remanufacturer.
The OEM remanufacturer makes and sells both new and remanufactured versions
of its own products. Noncontract remanufacturers are independent of the OEM
manufacturer. Such remanufacturers acquire used products that they did not design,
build, or develop and remanufacture these for resale. These independent remanu-
facturers often experience great difficulty in obtaining the design information that
they require to undertake remanufacturing because OEMs regard them as potential
396 M. Matsumoto and W. Ijomah
competitors and therefore withhold information from them. When OEMs refuse to
release product information, independent remanufacturers often attempt to obtain
required technical information by reverse engineering or by resorting to industrial
espionage. In this instance reverse engineering refers to the situation where a
remanufacturer analyses a correctly functioning product to obtain information with
which to rebuild it to the required specification on its failure. Both of these are poor
choices. The former is expensive, time consuming, and often ineffective while the
latter can result in substantial financial penalties. Contract remanufacturers bypass
intellectual property rights (IPR) restrictions by remanufacturing under licence to
OEMs. Contract remanufacturers operate very much as an extension of the OEM
company and can often substantially limit training costs by having the OEM train
their personnel in the more difficult aspects of remanufacturing. Additional benefits
that contract remanufactures enjoy include easier access to OEM cores and product
information. This increases their potential to remanufacture a greater quantity of
products and a range of component parts thus permitting them to take advantage
of economies of scale. Furthermore because a contract will stipulate the type
of products that will be received and often the quantity and time of arrival of
those products, contract remanufactures tend to experience less issues regarded
to uncertainty. Although the remanufacturing market is dominated by OEMs and
contract remanufacturers, the majority of remanufacturers are independent small-
scale operators.
4 Remanufacturing Process
Remanufacturing processes consist of the following seven steps: (1) collection and
inspection of used products, (2) disassembly of products, (3) cleansing and surface
processing of subparts, (4) inspection and sorting, (5) component remanufacture
and replenishment by new components, (6) product reassembly, (7) final testing
(Fig. 23.2).
Remanufactured products arrive at their customers with the same quality level,
performance, endurance, and warranty like a new product. Remanufacturing applies
many principles of manufacturing. This not only applies to quality assurance. Expe-
riences with production technologies and machine tools or with assembly sequences
and equipment known from manufacturing processes can also be transferred to
remanufacturing purposes. This is true mainly for the steps of component parts
remanufacturing and product reassembly in the seven steps.
Disassembly and cleaning are new technologies on an industrial level. Here
remanufacturing itself has set new standards and plays the pioneering role of
creating new solutions and adding technological know-how toward the closed loop
from an old to a like-new product.
The following shows the seven steps with an example of remanufacturing of al-
ternators – an auto parts. The pictures are taken at Shin-Etsu Denso Co. Ltd., which
is one of the largest remanufacturing companies of auto parts in Japan. Figure 23.3
shows an alternator before remanufacturing and one after remanufacturing.
23 Remanufacturing 397
2 Disassembly of product
5 Component remanufacture
(and replenishment by new components)
6 Product reassembly
7 Final testing
In the first step of remanufacturing, after collecting the used products (Fig. 23.4),
their remanufacturablity is inspected from their appearances. Used products that are
damaged beyond economic remanufacture are set aside. The ideal scenario is always
to avoid waste. Thus attempts will be made to put such products or components
toward other reuse options for example, reconditioning, repair, or recycle.
In the second step, a unit is completely disassembled to the single part level
(Fig. 23.5). Disassembly does not just mean reverse assembly, but means much
more because there is no easy reverse operation for assembly operations like gluing,
riveting, pressing, and welding.
398 M. Matsumoto and W. Ijomah
The third step in the remanufacturing process is the cleaning and surface
processing of all parts coming from the disassembly process to the remanufacturable
or reusable condition (Fig. 23.6). Cleaning includes de-greasing, de-oiling, de-
rusting, and freeing the parts from old paint. For this variety of purposes, many
cleaning methods are applied. These methods include washing in cleaning petrol,
hot water jet or steam cleaning, chemical detergent spraying or chemical purifying
baths, ultrasonic cleaning chambers, sand blasting, steel brushing, baking ovens,
and many more. Many cleaning processes have required the development of new
technological solutions by remanufacturers and their equipment suppliers. Shin-
Etsu Denso is doing cleaning and surface processing of subparts by washing in
23 Remanufacturing 399
cleaning petrol and hot water, and mechanical cleaning by glass bead or steel shot
blasting. Glass bead or steel shot blasting not only brings back a shiny surface of
the part again, but also hardens the surface. This results in a better resistance against
abrasion of parts.
The forth step in remanufacturing is to assess the condition of the disassembled
and cleaned parts as to their reusability or remanufacturability. Here reusability
is solely concerned with fitness for reuse. Remanufacturability on the other hand
will also consider the economic viability of undertaking the remanufacture of the
part. Depending on the various inspection results, parts are being sorted into the
400 M. Matsumoto and W. Ijomah
classes such as: (1) reusable without reconditioning, (2) remanufacturable, and (3)
not reusable or remanufacturable.
The fifth step is the remanufacturing of parts. The step ensures a like-new
condition on the part level (Fig. 23.7). For the remanufacturing of parts in most cases
only slightly worn components, metal cutting processes such as turning, milling, and
23 Remanufacturing 401
grinding are preferably used. Parts that cannot be brought back to specification are
replaced by new spare parts.
In the sixth step, the parts are reassembled (Fig. 23.8).
The final step is a functional inspection or test run of each remanufactured
product (Fig. 23.9).
The products are shipped together with the result sheets of the functional
inspection.
Justifiably called a “Hidden Giant,” the remanufacturing industry has good market
potential. However, companies that undertake remanufacturing have to overcome
certain obstacles to achieve it. There are at least three requirements for remanu-
facturing (Geyer and Jackson 2004; Lundmark et al. 2009). The remanufacturing
system consists of three parts – collection, the remanufacturing process itself, and
redistribution – each having its distinct challenges. For a company to undertake
remanufacturing, it must
1. Collect used products
2. Develop efficient remanufacturing processes
3. Cultivate demand for remanufactured products
In the following, two cases of remanufacturing businesses in Japan are outlined –
photocopiers and auto parts. Photocopy machines are one of the most representative
cases of OEM remanufacturing. Auto parts are, as described above, the most preva-
lent target products of remanufacturing in the world. The main remanufacturers
of auto parts are independent remanufacturers (IRs) rather than OEMs. In the
following, the remanufacturing business practices are reviewed, and companies’
efforts to overcome the obstacles above are highlighted.
leased to customers. OEMs take return delivery of leased products from the leasing
companies in abundance. In case of sellout products, since in general, customers
buy a new product in replacement of the old one, OEMs can reclaim their discarded
product. The OEMs form partnerships to collect and return each other’s used
products.
The companies implement design for remanufacturing (DFRem) of products to
facilitate remanufacturing, which substantially enhances the efficiencies of their
remanufacturing processes. The companies have also been renovating remanufactur-
ing processes and accumulating know-how. For example, a company has developed
a subparts cleaning method using chilled carbon dioxide gas. It is used to clean the
frames of the photocopier machines and it substantially shortened cleaning time in
remanufacturing.
Photocopiers are business equipments, and customers’ aversion to remanu-
factured products in business equipment is generally lower than that in con-
sumer products. In addition, product leasing could lower customers’ aversion to
remanufactured products. There are two types of remanufacturing in photocopy
machine remanufacturing. In one type, remanufactured products are made of reused
components. Thus, remanufactured products are distinguished from new products,
which are made exclusively from new components. According to a company, 93%
by weight of a typical remanufactured photocopy machine is composed of reused
parts. Companies doing this type of remanufacturing offer remanufactured products
with prices lower than those of new products. The price is usually 50–70% less
than prices of new products and profits from remanufactured machines are larger
than those from newly produced machines. In the other type of remanufacturing,
reused components are incorporated in new products. Thus, all products may include
reused components and there is no distinction between new and remanufactured
products. The merit of this type of remanufacturing is that demand for reused
components is not restricted by customers’ product selection. On the contrary,
when reused components are used solely in remanufacturing, if many customers
prefer new products and avoid remanufactured products, components are not
reused.
The companies’ thorough quality controls have earned trust from customers, who
show little dissatisfaction regarding products with reused components.
Regarding the business obstacles mentioned above, the following points were
observed.
• Collection of used products: Companies accept returns from leasing companies
in abundance and companies collaborate in collecting returns.
• Efficiency of remanufacturing processes: Efficiency has been achieved through
DFRem, process renovation, and know-how accumulation.
• Cultivation of demand: Companies provide products to business and leasing
customers, and they more readily accept remanufactured products than in-
dividual and sellout customers. Companies provide remanufactured products
with lower prices. In the other type of remanufacturing, reused components
are installed in all products, and thus demand for used components is not
restricted by customers’ product selection. Thorough quality controls have been
carried out.
23 Remanufacturing 403
Auto parts are the most prevalent target of remanufacturing in the world. In Japan,
however, remanufacturing of auto parts is less common than in other developed
countries. One reason is that the prevalence of automobiles in Japan is more
recent compared with the United States and many European countries and thus
auto parts remanufacturing has a briefer history. Auto parts remanufacturing saves
material and energy. Japan’s auto parts remanufacturers are primarily IRs. OEMs
are generally reluctant remanufacturers because remanufacturing conflicts with
sales of new parts. Profit margins on new auto parts are high whereas margins on
remanufactured parts are lower.
The case study of Shin-Etsu Denso, one of the largest auto parts remanufac-
turers in Japan, shows the importance of assuring collection of used products,
efficient remanufacturing processes, and demand for remanufactured products. This
company remanufactures alternators and starters and ships about 100,000 of each
annually.
To collect used products, the company supplies car maintenance shops with
remanufactured products in exchange with used products. In addition, the company
continually purchases and stocks used products from car dismantling compa-
nies. It stocks about 300,000 used products, which are essential for its business.
Figures 23.4–23.9 show the flow of the company’s remanufacturing processes.
Although the company has developed and accumulated know-how involving each
of its processes, its president indicated that know-how in cleaning and surface
treatment of subparts is primarily important. This estimate reinforces previous
studies showing that cleaning process is the most costly and knowledge-intensive
process in auto parts remanufacturing (Hammond et al. 1998). Products can be
remanufactured two to four times.
Until the early 1990s, there had been little demand for remanufactured auto parts
in Japan, and Shin-Etsu Denso shipped most of its remanufactured products to the
United States and Europe. However, since the late 1990s, the Japanese demand
has increased, and today about 45% of its shipments (measured in yen) are for the
domestic market. The company’s thorough quality control (Fig. 23.9) has enhanced
users’ confidence in remanufactured products and has helped to stimulate demand.
Auto parts remanufacturers are cooperating with suppliers of reused auto parts,
i.e., the car dismantling companies. The companies are forming networks to share
information about inventories (Matsumoto 2009). Car maintenance shops – the main
buyers of reused and remanufactured parts – pass orders to member companies in
the network. So partnerships with reused auto parts suppliers help remanufacturers
to stimulate demand. The Japanese end-users’ low recognition of remanufactured
products is problematic for increasing demand further; nearly 60% of Japanese
drivers know little about reused (including remanufactured) auto parts (Matsumoto
et al. 2010).
The auto parts case study presents the following observations:
• Collection of used products: Shin-Etsu Denso collects used products from car
maintenance shops (by shipping remanufactured products in exchange with used
products) and from car dismantling companies.
404 M. Matsumoto and W. Ijomah
The companies that are doing remanufacturing businesses are making efforts to meet
the above described three requirements for successful remanufacturing: (1) collect
used products, (2) develop efficient remanufacturing processes, and (3) cultivate
demand for remanufactured products. Companies’ efforts to meet these require-
ments include: (1) establishing a new collection channel, (2) developing reverse
logistics to collect used products, (3) designing products for remanufacturing
(DfReman), (4) accumulating know-how to establish remanufacturing processes,
(5) controlling product quality to stimulate demand for remanufactured products,
and (6) incorporating used components into new products to increase the demand
for remanufactured products (Matsumoto and Umeda 2011).
Many previous studies on remanufacturing have emphasized OEMs, which have
numerous advantages over IRs and perhaps greater incentive to remanufacture.
Lund and Skeels (1983) and Lund (1984b) pointed out the advantages unique
to OEMs: feedback on product reliability and durability, competition in lower-
priced markets, a manufacturer’s reputation for quality, and gaining advantages
over IRs in data, tooling, and access to suppliers. Similarly, Haynsworth and
Lyons (1987) envisioned how OEMs could realize the potential for remanufacturing
through appropriate marketing and product design and by developing a product
distribution and return system. On the other hand, OEMs face unique obstacles.
Remanufacturing may reduce sales of new products, and profits on sales of new
products often exceed profits on those of remanufactured products (Ferguson
and Toktay 2006; Linton 2008; Matsumoto 2009). In such cases, OEMs have
little incentive or have a negative attitude toward remanufacturing. OEMs lack of
incentive to remanufacture is a large obstacle in promoting remanufacturing in
society.
OEMs lack of incentive presents IRs with an opportunity, and in that case,
IRs are expected to lead remanufacturing businesses. If IRs successfully create a
market for remanufactured goods and stimulate consumers’ demand, OEMs could
be forced to become remanufacturers despite their reservations. In some countries
in some products, OEMs are already active remanufacturers. The same could
occur if end users demand more remanufactured products, and demand could be
cultivated through IRs’ remanufacturing practices. This is expected to happen for
many products worldwide.
23 Remanufacturing 405
Many of the key determinants of potential for refurbishment and reuse fall outside
the designer’s control. The major ones of these include legislation, demand,
fashion and manufacturers’ prohibitive practices. Legislation can have a positive
impact because it requires organizations’ to undertake added value recovery of
their products and is making waste disposal increasingly expensive and thus may
encourage manufacturers to design remanufacturable products. However, when
legislation bans the use of a substance, products containing it cannot be reintroduced
into the market and hence would not be remanufactured. Remanufacturing is only
appropriate where there is a market for the reworked product. Thus fashion-affected
products are inappropriate because users may prefer the newer product no matter
the quality and cost of the remanufactured alternative. Some customers demand
newness as a lifestyle choice thus products especially those requiring relatively low
406
initial financial outlay or that are in prominent locations in homes are generally
less amenable to profitable remanufacturing. Manufacturers’ prohibitive practices
such as patents, intellectual property rights, and anticompetitive manufacturing also
hinder remanufacturing. For example, some printer manufacturers have designed
their inkjet cartridges so that they self-destruct when empty thus preventing their
remanufacturing. However, if there are no old products to cannibalize or good
parts cannot be obtained from existing used products and the technology for
producing new parts becomes obsolete then remanufacturing of the product would
be impossible.
8 Summary
References
T. Amezquita, R. Hammond, M. Salazar, B. Bras, Characterizing the remanufacturability of
engineering systems, in Proceedings of ASME Advances in Design Automation Conference,
DE-vol. 82, Boston, 17–20 Sept 1996, pp. 271–278
J.-J. Andreu, The remanufacturing process. Manchester Metropolitan University, Manchester, UK
(1995)
BSI, BS 8887-220:2010 – Design for manufacture, assembly, disassembly and end-of-life pro-
cessing (MADE) and BS 8887-2:2009 – Terms and definitions, BS 8887-1:2006 – General
concepts, process and requirements. Produced by British Standards Institute technical product
specification committee (TDW/004/0-/05 Design for MADE BSI), British Standards Publica-
tions, Southam (2010)
M. Ferguson, L. Toktay, The effect of competition on recovery strategies. Prod. Oper. Manag.
15(3), 351–368 (2006)
R. Geyer, T. Jackson, Supply loops and their constraints: the industrial ecology of recycling and
reuse. Calif. Manag. Rev. 46(2), 55–73 (2004)
T. Graedel, B. Allenby (eds.), Industrial Ecology (Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, 1995)
R. Hammond, T. Amezquita, B. Bras, Issues in the automotive parts remanufacturing industry: a
discussion of results from surveys performed among remanufacturers. Int. J. Eng. Des. Autom.
4(1), 27–46 (1998)
H. Haynsworth, R. Lyons, Remanufacturing by design, the missing link. Prod. Inventory Manag.
28(2), 24–29 (1987)
408 M. Matsumoto and W. Ijomah
Abstract
Apart from benefits for environmental protection, reuse of components and
products offers attractive economic advantages, provided that components are
“qualified as good as new,” which (in this chapter abbreviated as “quagan”)
entails a new concept first introduced in the international standard IEC 62 309.
This standard has been initiated by the authors of this chapter, who have worked
out the quagan concept to overcome prejudices against and to promote reuse of
components and products.
Nowadays electronic components in most products have a considerably longer
life expectancy than required. Thus, a quagan component, deployed in a second
life in a new product, can have a higher reliability degree than the new ones
because of a simple fact: Early failures have been already eliminated by its
“previous life.” Taking this into account, it is evident that quagan concept
supports the interest of manufacturers, customers, and society at the same time.
• Manufacturers can make a profit by taking back used products and making
them “quagan” (a process we call “quaganized”), using the same test proce-
dures as they have for the new ones and, at the same time, fulfill legislative
requirements concerning environmental protection.
• Consumers get updated products for a lower price with the warranty granted
for new products.
• Government achieves higher recycling rates.
F. Quella ()
Siemens, retired, DKE/ISO/ZVEI, formerly headed workgroups/projects, Ottobrunn, Germany
e-mail: Qusaeng@t-online.de
F. Belli
EIM/E-ADT, Department of Electrical Engineering and Information Technology,
University of Paderborn, Paderborn, Germany
e-mail: Fevzi.Belli@adt.upb.de
1 Introduction
Reuse of electro and electronic (E&E) components and products is a very sustainable
process because of the following facts:
• Residual values within the components can be activated.
• Resources can be saved; the environment can be protected.
• Recycling ratios can be increased.
• Customers get high-grade products at a considerably lower price.
24 Reuse of Components and Products: “Qualified as Good as New” 411
2 A New Approach
The idea of reusing components also for the manufacturing of new products
arose many years ago in the copy machines industry. One of the most prominent
companies involved was Xerox. In spite of their good ideas, as compiled in their
internal company rules they did not initiate an international standard to promote
internationally comparable criteria for reuse.
The easiest way for a producer to practice reuse is to include all potential
“quaganable” components in the production line. In such a case the refurbished
components can be checked in the incoming inspection and be transferred directly
to the production line of the new product. To promote the idea of reuse of the quagan
components, the following processes were subject of standardization:
• Qualification of quagan components
• The definition of a new product with quagan components
• Documentation and information
• Guarantee
• Environmental aspects
Legal definitions for new products are different for various product groups. Espe-
cially for new cars a great deal of legal decisions has been published. The situation in
the E&E industry is entirely different. There, thermal pre-aging is usually applied to
412 F. Quella and F. Belli
new components and some products to avoid early failures. The new products built
using these components also intentionally contain “not-new” components. From
the viewpoint of quality and reliability science, it can be expected that products
containing reused components whose remaining operational lives are still within the
range of the application period behave similarly; that is, they are of higher quality
than the products that are produced using only new components, as was already
noted by Xerox in one of its Environmental Performance Reports (Xerox 1995).
Generally speaking, all kinds of products can contain components which are
potentially quagan. There might be a refurbishing step in between. Capital goods
are usually a better choice because they are often in a better state than cheap
consumer goods. The age of the product is often not decisive for a possible reuse.
Components of 30-year-old trains might be reusable. This might be true of computer
components after approximately 3 years of usage; whereas reusable components
of cellular phones are available after a single year. Further examples of capital
goods with reusable components or complete devices are optical machines, medical
devices, and telecommunication equipment. The list of consumer products with
potentially quaganable components is long and includes IT products; for example,
computers, printers, servers, cellular phones, and also household appliances. One
problem here is that those products might often not be in a good condition when
collected by municipal waste collectors and bulkily stored in their stations. Usually
some valuable plastic goods are also available that do not change their properties
much and can be quaganable. There is another quagan components market for
original spare parts. Forerunners in this field can be found in the automotive
industry.
The requirement for “quaganation” is that the remaining working life of the
component be at least the designed life of the new product. A manufacturer also
has to plan for several product generations ahead because the quagan components
will return after some years. Unfortunately, this represents a risk that a change of
technology excludes a reuse.
Figure 24.1 illustrates the fact that the state of “as-new” can be described in a
much easier way than the state of “used” because the only comparison for “new”
is the original specification. This also includes the estimation of the value of the
component. All of the other states of used can be specified in many ways which
might not necessarily be transparent to the customer.
The life of a quagan component ends if its remaining working life is shorter than
the new designed life for a new product. This situation is shown in Fig. 24.2.
Apart from the quality criteria for quagan IEC 62309 contains several examples
for reliability determination and test methods. The standard requires all processes
involved and available information on customers be documented. Documentation
also covers the quality information according to ISO 9001 (2008), including test
results (see Chaps. 4.2.4 and 8.3 of ISO 9001). Thus, the customer is informed
24 Reuse of Components and Products: “Qualified as Good as New” 413
New
component Reuseable but not
for new products
Waste:
Quagan
Only
material
value
Properties, characteristics
Normative range
Remaining
Working life of Working life of working life of
the new the quagan component too
component component small for quagan
(<ANDL)
Fig. 24.2 Relation between the designed lives for several product generations and the designed
lives of components (cf. IEC 62309). Legend: NDL: new designed life; ANDL: as-new designed
life
about the fact that the new product he or she buys contains quagan components.
This information describes also what has been done to realize quagan in order to
avoid any quality risks and to assure that the guarantee is the same as for a product
consisting entirely of new components.
To avoid misunderstandings which might be caused by the artificial word quagan
the customer can also be explicitly informed by a statement that the product “is a
new product containing components qualified as good as new in accordance with
IEC 62309.”
414 F. Quella and F. Belli
Refurbishment
Material
costs
Cleaning,
Q-Testing
Fig. 24.3 Example for costs of a new component compared to the potential costs of refurbishment
and the calculated final price of a quagan component
24 Reuse of Components and Products: “Qualified as Good as New” 415
some components are running out, for example, in plants where longtime service
contracts are common. Then, years later the production of new components will
have to be re-initiated with a special manufacturer, which might cause extreme
high costs. In such cases, the required components suddenly become overvalued.
To avoid this, a trace-back system can be established with customers. This enables a
tighter connection to customers to motivate them to return old products and provides
the opportunity to offer them new ones.
In IEC 62309 software dependability aspects are excluded; the standard describes
only the requalification of hardware. Nevertheless, nowadays almost any complex
product contains software. Together with the refurbishment the software needs
to be regularly upgraded. Moreover, compatibilities to interoperating components
have to be checked. Complex IT products including medical devices are to be
accompanied by a Device History Record (DHR) which identifies the present state of
their software and lists devices that are compatible with the new software upgrade.
After every upgrade a Device Master Record (DMR) is issued that documents the
new state of the software landscape to enable a continuous service.
A software application can consume a considerably high amount of energy in
the product it is embedded in. Thus, upgrades are to be checked for their energy
consumption. Annex A compiles recommendations for the reuse of software that are
not all necessarily environmentally protective. They are, however, useful to achieve
further improvements. Trends in legislation expect a manufacturer to integrate
means and measures for environmental protection, including energy saving aspects,
whenever a new release of the software is due during the lifetime of a technical
system. In cases in which the hardware of a product is kept largely unchanged
and the system is routinely checked for quality purposes, DHR and the DMR
become valuable documents. DHR lists updates, whereas DMR describes the total
documentation of the manufacturer. After comparison of the requirements and the
present state, the necessary installations and updates are managed to guarantee the
system to be resold is state of the art. The state to be achieved is the same as if
they were being put on the market for the first time. For details see the European
association of manufacturers of medical devices, COCIR (2009).
Legal regulations as to the RoHS (RoHS 2003), RoHS 2 (RoHS 2 2011) and the
WEEE Directives (WEEE 2003) in Europe require not only collection and recycling
targets, but also the reuse of components, even if not explicitly specified. At the
moment the targets present no problem in being reached without reuse but most
likely they are going to be set higher. However, not only legal demands but also
common sense should avoid the waste of valuable resources. Especially original
manufacturers can recreate these values which might also constitute a clear benefit
to the reduction of the weight of their waste deposition.
416 F. Quella and F. Belli
The diversity of materials must and can be reduced to simplify refurbishment and
reuse. The volume of valuable materials collected must be economically attractive
to make the recycling processes run. Many technically and economically practical
solutions have been developed; however, there is still a lack of collected material.
The cost of recycling depends on the number of different materials or compo-
nents to be reused or refurbished; the more there is of them, the more expensive
the process. Remaining materials and components that cannot be recycled will be
dumped or deposited if they cannot be thermally destroyed, that is, burned down to
disposable residue.
Note that a great amount of used thermoplastics can be quaganized at consid-
erably less cost than the cost of a new thermoplastic. The more expensive a new
thermoplastic is like PA, PBT, PC, PPS, or PPO, the less the costs for collection,
testing, and regranulation of a quaganized thermoplastic play a role for the resale. It
is still cheaper than the new material. But a limit is reached if the price for collection,
testing, and re-granulation becomes higher than that of the new plastics. This limit
is often at or a bit above the price of new ABS; new PE and PP are usually cheaper
than the whole process for refurbishment costs. Utilizing the energy in these plastics
is then the best way to recycle them.
Recycling targets for ten special E&E product categories are set in the WEEE
Directive. In the new WEEE Recast (2008), these targets are to be increased. Similar
legislation exists for other product groups, such as the automotive industry. Reuse
has been also set at the second highest place in political ranking, as expressed in the
new Waste Framework Directive (Waste Framework 2008).
Car manufacturers have to reach a recycling level that is theoretically achievable.
Similarly, manufacturers of E&E products are recommended to estimate the degree
of recyclability of their products although this is not yet legally required. So the
companies are expected to be able to answer questions from customers and the
public. The easiest way is a disassembly and recycling analysis offered by many
qualified recyclers often free of charge.
Limitations also have to be expected by the presence of hazardous substances like
those described by the RoHS Directive for E&E products. Such regulated substances
will no longer be allowed in new products or in new products with quagan
components. This can end a recycling circle over several product generations.
Reduction of energy consumption is one target of the Ecodesign Directive
(Ecodesign 2009) covering almost all products sold with volumes above 200,000
pieces in Europe. Restrictions are manifold and additional ones are continu-
ously being published with the progress of studies and implementing measures.
Environmental information about products is required if a product is affected by
the Ecodesign Directive. As a tool the Ecolabel standard according to ISO 14 021
(1999) can be used. The information about the content of quagan components and
24 Reuse of Components and Products: “Qualified as Good as New” 417
their contribution to the product’s effects on the environment can also be placed in
this declaration. In cases involving quagan the impact by the product itself is the
same as that of a new product, but the resources saved can be subtracted.
If the entire reuse process as explained in Fig. 24.4 is optimized the process be-
comes sustainable. Ideally, the new product is supplied when the old one is returned
to the manufacturer (1), where disassembly, and refurbishment is carried out.
Components can be integrated into the production or sent to suppliers (2a) or (2b).
In the ideal case the material could be completely reused by suppliers (3a) for the
same or other purposes or in their own production (3b).
As described in Sect. 7 these processes can be optimized using the Design
for Recycling (DfR) approach. Inefficient components/products or environmentally
incompatible components/products will be eliminated.
For reasons of quality assurance, the entire process of qualification from take-back
and evaluation of the component, disassembly and testing until reuse in a new
product or as spare parts must be described and include a quality management sys-
tem according to ISO 9001. Also an environmental management system according
to ISO 14 001 (2004) should be available. Part of the management system must
be a DfR process and a planning system for several product generations. COCIR
has listed in its guide Good refurbishment practice (COCIR 2009) many more
management processes to be installed to avoid risks with reuse that include an early
Reuse of
Reuse of Forward
material
components Backward
(3a)
(2a) Logistics (1) Customer
(3b)
(2b)
Disassembly/
Take back/
Recycling/Recovery Refurbishment
Supply from customer
(Original manufacturer)
Fig. 24.4 A sustainable, logistic path of a component and a product to a customer and back to the
manufacturer and supplier
418 F. Quella and F. Belli
One part within the Ecodesign process is the DfR. DfR enables an easier disassembly
which also largely means easy assembly. It is often achieved by a modular
construction of the product. As easier assembly means lower production costs.
DfR can also be seen not only as a tool for the reduction of the environmental
impact but as a synonym for cost reduction as well. Besides the required reusable
components DfR should also enable the easy collection of the valuable materials
without impurities for an efficient material recycling. Rules for DfR are described in
the standard of the Association of the German Engineers VDI 2243 (2002). Some
important rules are summarized in Annex B. They are usually integrated into similar
lists of companies’ design rules as assistance for the development engineers.
The disassembling and refurbishment of the product structure has to be carefully
planned in detail. This is important for an expeditious replacement of the desired
components not only for remanufacturing but also for shorter service periods. The
planning must consider not only one but several product generations. This means
24 Reuse of Components and Products: “Qualified as Good as New” 419
Table 24.1 Relation between building a structure of a product, connections selected materials,
and functional units for a three-level hierarchy (extended table version of IEC 62 309) in a DfR
concept
Building Functional
Level of detail structure Connections Materials units
General Recycling Non-destructive Ability to recycle Ability to reuse
concept disassembly
Product Modularity Connection cate- Utilization, Division into
specific gory, diversity compatibility functional units
Component Accessibility Dismantling Material diversity Ability to reuse,
specific depth, exchange or repair
dismantling
time
Material Separability Dismantling time Material Material diversity
specific selection within function
the type of component must be kept the same even if the product family or the state-
of-the-art of technology changes. An efficient take-back system has to be installed
to get the products back in good condition. Different models are applicable for a
take-back according to the quantities desired. Leasing is not the only method that
enables a return of the product after a certain time. Contracts could also be made to
continually offer customers an upgraded version of the product. In addition a close
connection to the customer is required and the sales department has to know where
the sold products are located. In the case of medical devices an exchange of used
products is also agreed upon between major companies to offer a competitor their
product if the product is substituted by another one. Depending on the life cycle the
take-back system and the changes expected in technology have to be considered as
well. Some parts of a train coming back after 30–50 years might have only one more
life; other parts might have three or more lives.
For the DfR the product structure can be split into its functional units, such as
engine, chassis, tubes, cables, etc. This procedure is now often standard within
the development engineers’ community. An extended procedure might now be to
construct these units so that the worn-out element can easily be replaced. Also the
functional unit can be designed to be so slim that most of the elements not required
in the unit are added to another unit that is not interesting for reuse. This can save
volume, time, costs of transportation and storage.
Level-specific points of view require corresponding rules. In Table 24.1 it is
explained what should be done to improve a product for better reuse. Three levels
are identified: the product, component, and material level. Modularity, for example,
on the product-specific level has influence on the connections and the utilization if
it is changed. Components should easily be accessible and dismantled. Too much
diversity of the materials is not acceptable. Materials should be easily separated.
It can be seen from this table that the more detailed a reuse is planned, the more
influence it has on product structure, materials, connections, and other things. For
every level of detail different characteristics are important.
420 F. Quella and F. Belli
Recyclers can not only disassemble components, but also store components as
spare parts if they employ experienced staff. Thus, they can expand into new
business fields and offer more interesting jobs.
As mentioned, DfR is only one part of Ecodesign (cf. Quella, this book,
chapter Ecodesign Strategies: A Missing Link in Ecodesign). Through Ecodesign
an overall reduction of the environmental impact should be achieved and experi-
enced over the entire life cycle. Such procedures are described in IEC 62430 (2009).
The Ecodesign directive will affect also the design because of its legal requirements
for energy-related products. The designers taking DfR into account should at any
rate try to minimize the environmental impact by their product through a complete
Ecodesign concept. For more general concepts see Wimmer et al. (2010) and
Quella (1998).
Rotating anode
Radiator housing
Vacuum with cooling oil
Thermal
problem &
Mechanical
problem
Fig. 24.5 An older model of an X-ray tube. Radiation cooling time is too long. High centrifugal
forces lead to an overload of the bearings in the rotating anode (Source: Siemens Healthcare)
24 Reuse of Components and Products: “Qualified as Good as New” 421
Fig. 24.6 Straton X-ray tube. Comparison of new and former product. Result of the new
development: 66% material saving, 33% higher scan performance, up to 40% recyclable parts
in new tubes (Source: Siemens Healthcare)
in Fig. 24.5 seen in the vacuum chamber were placed outside the vacuum chamber
in the new version. Now the worn bearings can be easily replaced. All these
components now can be more easily separated, disassembled, and refurbished with
strong cost reduction also for the customer.
In Fig. 24.6 some successful changes in the redesigning of an X-ray tube can be
seen at first glance in comparison with the old version. The target of several reuses
for the radiator and cooling was already anticipated during the development of the
new system. Reusing material saves costs. In addition body material consumption
was reduced by 50% and costs by 40% by switching to an injection molding guide.
Many companies have decided to refurbish their valuable products that they take
back. A large group of manufacturers belong to the medical sector. They offer many
advantages by providing refurbished systems to their customers. More refurbished
industry products can be found by an Internet search; not all follow the quagan
concept. Some should be considered with caution.
As special products require special conditions it was necessary to develop
special recommendations to convince people in the healthcare sector. COCIR has
therefore published rules for Good refurbishment practice which in part exceed the
requirements of quagan in the IEC 62309.
With the New Work Item Proposal for the reuse of software (IEC TC 56 (2009))
the gap between refurbished hardware alone and hardware plus software has been
closed.
422 F. Quella and F. Belli
The discussion about the failure curves over time (“bathtub” curve) is still going
on, but an updated theory would help to overcome many problems with the reuse of
electronic components. Before this is achieved it can only be recommended to apply
the results of one’s own reliability research. If such results are not available a reuse
of the components in question can hardly be planned.
In addition, the political situation has strengthened the role of reuse and set
it at the second highest level in the new Waste framework Directive. A stronger
promotion of the reuse of industrial goods has been announced as a first step.
We are convinced that the potential of reuse in the sense of quagan is much
higher as briefly described in this chapter. In order to extend this concept an overall
investigation of exchangeable components in the market is necessary. In addition
standard components from different products could be exchanged.
Annex
(In detail there might be limitations for the applicability of some rules.)
424 F. Quella and F. Belli
9 Summary
10 Cross-References
References
COCIR: Good refurbishment practice Version II (2009), http://www.cocir.org
Ecodesign, Directive 2009/125/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 21 Oct 2009
establishing a framework for the setting of ecodesign requirements for energy-related products
(recast), OJ of the EU of 31 Oct 2009, L285/10–35
IEC 62 309, Dependability of reused parts – requirements for functionality and tests (International
Electrotechnical Commission, Geneva, 2004)
IEC 62 430, Environmentally conscious design for electrical and electronic products and systems
(International Electrotechnical Commission, Geneva, 2009)
IEC TC 56, IEC 56/1332/NP (2009) Reliability of software products containing reused components
– requirements for functionality and tests (International Electrotechnical Commission, Geneva,
2009)
ISO 9001, Quality Management Systems – Requirements (International Organization for Standard-
ization, Geneva, 2008)
ISO 14 001, Environmental Management Systems – Requirements with Guidance for Use
(International Organization for Standardization, Geneva, 2004)
ISO 14 021, Environmental Labels and Declarations – Self-declared Environmental Claims
(International Organization for Standardization, Geneva, 1999)
F. Quella (ed.), Umweltverträgliche Produktgestaltung (Publicis MCD, Erlangen/Munich, 1998)
RoHS, Directive 2002/95/EC of the European parliament and of the Council of 27 Jan 2003 on the
restriction of the use of certain hazardous substances in electrical and electronic equipment; OJ
of the EU 13.2.2003; L37/19–23
RoHS 2, Directive 2011/65/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 8 June 2011 on
the restriction of the use of certain hazardous substances in electrical and electronic equipment,
OJ of the EU 2011; L174/88–110
VDI 2243, Recycling Oriented Product Development Beuth (Beuth, Berlin, 2002)
Waste Framework, Directive 2008/98/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of
19 Nov 2008 on waste and repealing certain directives; OJ of the EU of 12 Dec 2008; L312/3
WEEE, Directive 2002/96/EC of the European Parliament and of the council of 27 Jan 2003 on
waste electrical and electronic equipment; OJ of the EU of 13 Feb 2003; L37/24–38
WEEE Recast, Proposal for a directive of the European Parliament and of the council on waste of
electro and electronic equipment from 3 Dec 2008
W. Wimmer, K.M. Lee, J. Polak, F. Quella, Ecodesign – The Competitive Advantage (Springer,
Amsterdam, 2010)
U.K. Xerox, Environmental Performance Report 1995, Rank Xerox, UK, p. 16, 1995
Supply Chain Management for
Sustainability 25
Masaru Nakano
Abstract
Supply chain management for sustainability, or providing a sustainable sup-
ply chain, has become increasingly important with the growing awareness
on global warming and energy security. This chapter discusses management
issues such as sustainable supply chains, sustainable enterprises, and sustainable
manufacturing.
Viewing the subject from the perspective of manufacturing enterprises, the
conventional studies related to this area can be classified into two categories:
environmental issues and risk management. A supply chain that addresses
environmental issues is often called a green supply chain, and it incorporates
energy efficiency and reverse supply chain reducing waste and health problem
caused by hazardous substances. These issues are widespread and important
for a sustainable society in terms of global warming, energy security, and
pollution. A key approach is systems thinking – visualizing problems, defining
boundaries, setting goals, and simulating policies to predict their effects. A
methodology to tackle these issues should involve all stakeholders in the supply
chain, i.e., consumers and governments, as well as the product lifecycle, which
includes mining, refining, power generation, processing, assembly, logistics,
sales, maintenance, and recycling. Even if one sector reduces the environmental
load, the activities might significantly increase the environmental load in other
sectors. Other management aspects are the time, where policy and technological
developments work in the reverse direction from specific goals within a time
frame, and space, which is increasingly global.
Risk management for disruptive events in supply chains requires a methodol-
ogy of monitoring and resilience to mitigate disruptions such as natural disasters
M. Nakano
The Graduate School of System Design and Management, Keio University, Yokohama,
Kanagawa, Japan
e-mail: m.nakano@sdm.keio.ac.jp
1 Introduction
Constraints
Maintenance/ Marketing
Service/ research/
Recycle Business
planning
Product
design
Sales
Production system
design
Manufacturing
Distribution Operation
Suppliers
the idea is simply the sustainability of the supply chain itself. This is relevant to
business competition and concerns about supply chain disruptions. The sustainable
supply chain should be used to describe the sustainability of the supply chains;
therefore, this chapter avoids the term “sustainable supply chain” except in reference
to conventional studies. Another terminology issue is in the phrase “green supply
chain management (GrSCM).” Some researchers use the abbreviation “GSCM” to
mean SCM focused on green issues, but this chapter uses GrSCM to differentiate
it from global supply chain management (GSCM). Green leaves absorb CO2 and
emit O2 ; thus, the term green is largely related to global warming. However, a
convenient term is still required to explain the supply chain in terms of other energy
and pollution issues as well. Therefore, in this chapter, green refers to all environ-
mental issues. Section 3, the main text, describes current trends in green supply
chains.
A sustainable supply chain is referred to as a competitive supply chain in this
chapter, and is introduced in detail in Sect. 4. The section introduces conventional
studies on resilient supply chains or enterprises that mitigate the effects of disruptive
events, such as natural disasters and financial crises. The roles of collaboration and
competition are discussed in the section.
Metal resources are important issues to be considered in terms of their role
in supply chain management. Valuable metals such as rare metals cause business
problems in competitive supply chains through shortages and high prices, while
some metals such as cadmium produce pollution that is hazardous to human
health. A recycling-based society is the key to tackling both problems. The issues
related to metal resources and recycling are discussed in detail in Sect. 5; they are
social problems and the solutions require both competition and collaboration by
many stakeholders. Japan is well known for its advanced technology in pollution
control and energy efficiency. Section 5 describes Japan’s struggles with pollution
and energy costs in the 1960s, and how the experience brought about advanced
technology in Japan.
The entire supply chain should be managed to deal with green issues. Even
if energy consumption, CO2 emission, and material consumption are reduced
in factories, this effort might increase them in other parts of the supply chain.
Section 6 introduces examples to support this concept and proposes a systems
approach to obtain solutions. The author emphasizes that green supply chain
management requires a lifecycle approach, which includes both lifecycle assess-
ment and the 5Rs: reduce (material reduction in product design and manufac-
turing), reuse (product reuse with repair), recycle (recycle materials after end
of life), recovery (energy recovery), and remanufacturing (reproduction of parts
and products, which includes reassembly and reprocessing). The essence of the
systems approach is to prevent a disruption or hard landing, targeting a goal,
and designing the future backward. Moreover, not only forecasting the future,
but also designing systems for it, is essential. These strategies are summarized
in Sect. 7.
25 Supply Chain Management for Sustainability 431
2 Supply Chain
As shown in Fig. 25.2, the author proposes three supply chain axes: time, space,
and standardization. The time axis represents delivery; materials and products are
distributed to customers. The space axis represents the expansion of supply chains
due to globalization. The standardization axis represents the cooperation of multiple
enterprises. The scope of supply chain management is shown as follows:
• Design/production/distribution/sales/after-sale service
• Tie-ups with multiple corporations
• Value chain
• Business model
• Corporate information model
• Corporate strategies
• Corporate risk
• International standards
• Supply network infrastructure
Although the supply chain is often seen from the viewpoint of the original
equipment manufacturer (OEM), suppliers have relationship with multiple OEMs
and suppliers as shown in Fig. 25.3. Therefore researchers often prefer to use the
term supply network management instead of supply chain. This concept leads to
interesting topics integrating many enterprises and fostering of new business fields
by public sectors using standardization and subsidies.
Space expansion
Global optimization
Enterprise integration
Time reduction
Business speed up
Reuse of knowledge
Standardization
Infrastructure
Cooperation of tools
Supply chain
Supply network
A value chain is a supply chain that creates value throughout the entire process of
product development, manufacture, and customer service. The value of components
in the supply chain can be determined as follows:
– Check whether a process is effective and non-wasteful
– Concentrate resources on important tasks
– Check the value of the task
– Clarify business targets and their relationship to the process.
The following two criteria should be employed to evaluate the elements in a supply
chain:
Which elements make a valuable contribution to the results? (Value evaluation)
Which elements play an important role in overall efficiency? (Efficiency
evaluation)
Consider a supply chain that consists of the three suppliers as shown in Fig. 25.4.
Product X requires two suppliers A and C. The product price is $100 and the cost
is $80. Product Y requires three suppliers A, B, and C. The product price is $120
and the cost is $90. What is the value of supplier B? There can be various answers,
depending on the specific circumstances.
25 Supply Chain Management for Sustainability 433
A B C
This section defines several important keywords in the context of supply chain
management for sustainability.
There are some well known definitions of sustainability (Sutherland et al. 2008):
– “Sustainable development is development that meets the needs of the present
without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own
needs.” (Brundtland 2005)
– “Sustainability is the concept of robust future development in the ecological,
economic and social dimension of human existence” (German Parliament 1998)
– “The world has enough for everyone’s needs, but not enough for everyone’s
greed.” Mahatma Gandhi
It is believed that a corporation should contribute to social sustainability. Nike
CEO Mark Parker said: “Corporate Social Responsibility is for us a catalyst for
growth and innovation.” Currently, you see environmental reports and corporate
social responsibility reports (CSR) on many company websites. CSRs often describe
environmental issues but they also address worker education, support for the
disabled, gender equality, and sometimes raise funds for devastated areas.
This chapter differentiates environmental issues as “green” from sustainability
although green is one way of achieving sustainability.
434 M. Nakano
Sustainable
Green
Risky
Fig. 25.5 Sustainable, risky, and green have similar meaning and overlapping parts
Conventional literatures such as Seuring and Muller (2008) often use the term
sustainable supply chain, as the concept of a green sustainable supply chain;
however, the term is used in this chapter has the same meaning of supply chain
management for sustainability.
The requirements for a sustainable society have the same scope as that of GrSCM
in the conventional studies. Here the author’s perspective, which is based on
a systems approach, is discussed, within the context of a sustainable supply
chain.
The following topics are considered for the sustainability of society.
• Environmental issues such as biodiversity, pollution, global warming, famine,
and natural disasters
• Aging and healthcare
• Financial disruption
• Terror, civil war, and safety issues
• Digital divide
436 M. Nakano
If you think about virtual enterprises, the terms sustainable enterprise and sustain-
able supply chain have similar meanings. This is discussed in detail in Sect. 5.
Enterprises focused on a local optimum must change their attitudes toward global
optimization and risk management for the future to satisfy all stakeholders and
contribute to society.
Designing products that have less impact on the environment requires that product
engineers use appropriate materials and product architectures; they must consider
subsequent stages of production, use, disassembly for remanufacturing and end of
life as well as quality, cost, function, and delivery.
The specific design activities are as follows:
• Design for the Environment (DfE)
• Design for Disassembly (DfD)
• Environmentally Conscious Design (ECD)
• Ecodesign
25 Supply Chain Management for Sustainability 437
The carbon footprint or lifecycle assessment (LCA) is critical in the context of the
supply chain. Figure 25.6 illustrates the basic concept of performing the LCA of
a product. For each process from material production to end of life, material and
energy as inputs and emissions and waste as outputs are collected.
The major challenge is in standardizing the environmental impact calculation.
Today many companies provide information on the environmental impact in CSRs
or environmental reports However, companies seldom clearly explain how these
are calculated. Not only does this make it difficult to find environmentally friendly
companies but also it allows the companies to deceive consumers. Consider that
environmental taxes or tax reduction law for environmentally friendly products are
introduced under many false premises. In 2010, Japanese government implemented
the following measures to reduce greenhouse gases:
– Top runner mechanism
– Trial for carbon footprint
– Tax reduction law for automobiles
– Ecopoint for electric appliances
The top runner mechanism is a special regulation in Japan (Japan Energy
Conservation Center 2006). The Japanese government launched the Top runner
program according to the amended Law in 1999, under which the standards are set
based on the efficiency level of the most efficient product commercially available
438 M. Nakano
End of life
Material Remanufacturing
Manufacture Distribution Use
production Recovery
Energy
Emission Waste
(CO2)
in a given category. For each manufacturer and importer, the weighted average
efficiency of all units shipped within the same category must meet the standards
for that category by the target year decided for each category.
Because of globalization, it is clear that a global standard for calculating the LCA
is required.
Material Use
Production
(Recycle) Maintenance
The motivation is more often productivity than energy efficiency because, in most
cases, manufacturing with less energy results in higher productivity. Yet, this is
not always true. For example, the just in time (JIT) production system requires
more transportation of parts between OEMs and suppliers which can consume more
energy and thus can increase CO2 emissions more than in conventional production
systems.
Another example of contradictions between lean and energy-efficient systems
is in logistics. The Toyota production system encourages the use of small lots,
which leads to frequent transportation. In general, with increasing frequency of
transportation both energy consumption and CO2 emission increase. However lean
systems have low environmental impact in most cases.
It is important to emphasize that lean and energy-efficient manufacturing is
usually an effective approach. A good example is the concept of the microfactory
with low size of manufacturing machinery and systems to produce small and
precise products (Yuichi Okazaki 2010). Although big machines provide high-
speed processing for cutting, grinding, pressing, punching, or forging, they consume
more energy and space; for example, semiconductor line must have clean rooms
to avoid dust during the process. Such machines are good for productivity but
not energy efficient. These can be replaced by micro-manufacturing machines
that can work on desks; they are often referred to as a desktop factory. Such
machines are suitable for small-lot production and are reconfigurable because the
system is modular and can be quickly modified. These are lean and energy-efficient
systems.
440 M. Nakano
This section deviates from the environmental issues and considers the sustainability
of supply chains in global competition. A key word here is risk. As in risk
management, a risk in the supply chain is a risk for the enterprises involved in the
supply chain. Let us consider general business risks before discussing enterprise
risks in supply chains.
World Economic Forum (2008–2010) has announced key risks and themes for
people by summarizing human loss and economic damage in global risk reports over
the past 3 years. In those reports, the following are listed as economic damage:
1. 2008
• Asset price collapse
• Chinese growth slowing to <6%
• Fiscal crises
• Oil price spikes/supply shocks
• Rising and volatile food prices
• An abrupt, major fall in the value of the US dollar
2. 2009
• Asset price collapse
• Chinese growth slowing to <6%
• Fiscal crises
• Global governance gaps
• Chronic diseases
• Increase resource related risk (water, land and energy)
3. 2010
• Further falls in asset prices
• Chinese growth slowing to <6%
• Fiscal crises
• Global governance gaps
• Chronic diseases
• Underinvestment in infrastructure
The risks specific to supply chains are presented in the next section.
Nakano (2009a) surveyed enterprise risks and classified them into three categories:
– Inside the enterprise: Employee dishonesty; continuous risk management is
required to prevent and mitigate.
25 Supply Chain Management for Sustainability 441
Sustainable Society
Electronics
Chemical
Machinery
Manufacturing
(public, supply chain, and enterprise) may sometimes collaborate and conflict in
other cases.
The challenges are listed as follows:
For society
• Compatible technology for the entire world
• Compatible regulations for the entire world
• Estimation of R&D speed needed to match environmental fears
For supply chains
• Rapid response to prevailing risks across the world
• Find hidden risks and prepare for them
The following section describes the resilience to prevailing risks in supply chains.
The issue of managing disruptive events in supply chains has been studied from the
viewpoint of competitive advantage by overcoming damage from disruptive events.
Sheffi (2005) investigated the situations that suffered from natural disasters and the
following are some examples from this work and from recent information.
– Earthquakes: The Hanshin-Awaji earthquake hit the Kobe area close to Osaka
Japan in 1995. Japanese auto manufacturers stopped their production lines due
to parts shortage. In addition to Japanese manufacturers, the quake directly
affected companies such as Caterpillar, Texas Instruments, and IBM. Apple had
to slow down production of PowerBook personal computers due to interrupted
production of display monitors in Kobe. The Niigata-Chyuetu earthquake hit
Japan on July 16, 2007. Riken halted the production of engine piston rings
until July 22. All auto manufacturers halted their production lines. The Japan
Earthquake in May 11, 2011, which brought tsunami and nuclear crisis, resulted
in disruption of auto parts manufacturing, etc. It is said that the industry needs
more than a half year to recover the supply chains.
– Terrorism: Ford halted five factories following the events of September 11,
2001. Terrorism has also occurred frequently in Bali, London, Madrid, Istanbul,
Moscow and Mumbai.
– Fires: A Philips factory suffered an outbreak fire due to thunderstorm. Nokia
swiftly moved to get parts from Phillips but Sony Ericsson waited for Philips
to deliver parts. As a result, Sony Ericsson lost 15.5 billion dollars. In 1997, the
Kariya factory of Aisin Seiki Co. suffered a major outbreak of fire and completely
lost the production lines for bulbs for rear brakes. Toyota depends on the reliable
tierone supplier for essential parts. The drawings of the parts and production lines
were lost in the fire and took 2 weeks to recover.
The following are some cases related to metals and M&A.
– Metal prices: Metals are becoming more important for environmentally friendly
products. For example, electric cars consume three times more copper than
the conventional gasoline cars do and they also consume rare metals such as
neodymium, dysprosium and lithium. The metal price is very vulnerable due to
25 Supply Chain Management for Sustainability 443
strikes, demand change, and civil wars For example, the copper price increased
ten times in the 10 years from 1998 to 2007. Nickel price increased five times in
only 1 year, 1996.
– M&A: Key suppliers may be acquired by competitors. Mining companies may
merge, thus becoming a monopoly to control resource prices, for example, the
OPEC countries that control the oil trade.
To resist disruptive events, understanding the vulnerabilities and building flexi-
bility or redundancy, monitoring of disruptions, and quick response strategy should
be prepared a priori.
In the 1960s, people in Japan suffered from diseases due to pollution such as
mercury from a fertilizer plant that accumulated in fish, cadmium in drainage from a
mine, and sulfurous acid gas in the air from a chemical plant. During 1967–1973, the
Japanese government passed laws regarding air, water, waste and chemical disposal
(Nakano 2009b). The United Nations Conference on the Human Environment in
Stockholm in 1972 and the WHO International Program on Chemical Safety in
1978 discussed the topics worldwide. The EU issued directives of WEEE (Waste
Electrical and Electronic Equipment) in 2003, ROHS (Restriction of Hazardous
Substances), REACH (Registration, Evaluation and Authorization of Chemicals)
in 2007, and ELV (End of Life Vehicles) regarding hazardous and toxic materials in
2000.
The 5Rs are considered important for preventing pollution and solving the problem
of limited space for landfills. The lifecycle of the product is illustrated in Fig. 25.9.
Material recycling is often expensive, and disassembly or refinement can produce
large amounts of greenhouse gases. Therefore careful consideration should be made
as to whether it is better to recycle materials or to recover the energy by burning the
material.
Consider a case in the automotive industry. Clean energy vehicles such as electric
vehicles (EV), fuel cell vehicles (FCV), and hybrid engine vehicles (HEV) are
becoming popular. Electric bicycles are popular in China and many Chinese
companies want to compete with automobile global giants in electric vehicles.
However, in China, electricity is mainly produced using coal. Although EVs have
444 M. Nakano
Remanufacturing
Recycling
good advantages in the use stage they have drawbacks from the viewpoint of the
LCA for global warming unless enough renewable energy is provided.
In addition, EVs require copper and rare metals, such as neodymium and
dysprosium in their motors. The copper used in HEVs and EVs are two and three
times higher, respectively, compared to that used in gasoline engine vehicles (GEV)
(Nonaka 2010). Resource shortages result in the mining of low-quality ores, and
therefore increasing the energy consumption and the production of greenhouse
gases. Consider a material selection problem in the automotive industry. Aluminum
can be substituted for steel in car bodies more than it is currently. Aluminum is
environmentally more advantageous than steel due to its lighter weight; however,
its production is not suitable when considering energy consumption and water
resources. It is essential that all aluminum is recycled to the primary material. A
study related to this was conducted by NEDO (2005) using LCA. Plastic may be an
alternative material for car bodies. The following criteria should be evaluated in car
lifecycles, from mining to logistics, production, distribution, use, and end of life:
– Lifecycle CO2 emission (LCCO2)
– Energy consumption
– Material consumption
– Lifecycle cost (LCC)
– Change in supply chain and industrial structures required by alternative materials
– Change in the social infrastructure
– Change in economics such as GDP
There are many data sources and methods required to evaluate factors such as LCA
data, input-output tables, and computational general equilibrium modeling.
Consider the use of metals as an example for a general LCA framework. The price of
metals increases due to a gap between supply and demand which is increased by the
rapid development of emerging countries. Recycling plays a major role in mitigating
the gap as shown in Fig. 25.10. The rising price of metals makes recycling more
25 Supply Chain Management for Sustainability 445
Recycled material
Virgin
material
A motivation for a systems approach is the need to understand the overall effect
of changes in any one subsystem of large and complex systems. This requires an
approach that differs from conventional systems engineering methodology which
is based on large-scale project management (Forsberg et al. 2005; Haskins et al.
2007) and the holistic methodology for business processes (Nakano et al., 2005a, b).
Modeling and simulation techniques play an important role in evaluating and
designing the future in technology, policy and infrastructure in terms of economics,
social change, and the environment as well as in stakeholder analysis and deter-
mining core problems. To achieve a sustainable supply chain, it is important to
address these issues holistically by bringing together stakeholders and implementing
446 M. Nakano
measures throughout the supply chains. For example, smart grids are becoming
popular. The stakeholders are consumers at home, power generation companies,
housing companies, automobile makers, home electric appliance makers, ICT
companies, building companies, shops in malls, as well as the public sector and
suppliers.
A systems approach to sustainability should be based on lifecycle concept, as
described in Sect. 5. From the perspective of lifecycle, both product and service-
oriented business architectures can be considered.
The systems approach to sustainability should consider policy as well as
technology, that is, socio-technical systems. Carbon taxes and subsidies encourage
energy-efficient products such as electric vehicles and renewable energy generation
using solar and wind power. On the other hand, a carbon tax may decrease the GDP
in a region and a subsidy may cause side effects. Which policy should be introduced,
and where, and when, and to what degree? Which criteria or goals should be
employed? Energy security and preventing global warming sound similar but
sometimes have different requirements. Energy generation from coal may provide
energy security but does not prevent global warming. Modeling and simulation
techniques such as system dynamics modeling are important tools. These directions
are very promising and will attract researchers in the future. Systems approaches
for the environment are classified into the three levels shown in Table 25.1. The
intermediate or mezzo level is the most important for the green supply chain;
macroeconomic analysis is often conducted by governments and national institutes,
whereas at microlevel, enterprise environmental data analysis is basically conducted
by enterprises.
25 Supply Chain Management for Sustainability 447
7 Summary
Acknowledgments
This work was supported in part by a grant-in-aid from the Global Center of
Excellence Program for “Center for Education and Research of Symbiotic, Safe
and Secure System Design” from the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sport, and
Technology in Japan.
References
Brundtland, Work commission on environment and development: our common future, Brundtland
Report, Oxford, 1987
K. Forsberg, H. Mooz, H. Cotterman, Visualizing Project Management: Models and Frameworks
for Mastering Complex Systems (Wiley, Hoboken, 2005), pp. 1–480
25 Supply Chain Management for Sustainability 449
J.W. Sutherland, J.L. Rivera, K.L. Brown, M. Law, M.J. Hutchins, K.R. Haapala, Challenges for
the manufacturing enterprise to achieve sustainable development, in The 41th CIRP Conference
on Manufacturing Systems (2008), pp. 15–18
The Japan Machinery Federation (JMF), and Manufacturing Science and Technology Center
(MSTC), Research report on R&D issues for technology strategic map 2008, May (Japanese)
(2009), pp. 1–334
Y. Umeda (ed.), Special issue on design and manufacturing toward sustainability. Int. J. Autom.
Technol. (IJAT) 3(1), (2009)
E. Westkämper, L. Alting, G. Arndt, Life cycle management and assessment: approaches and
visions towards sustainable manufacturing. Proc. Inst. Mech. Eng. 215(Part B), 599–626 (2001)
World Economic Forum, Global risks 2008, 2009, 2010, a global risk network report, 2008, 2009,
2010
Yuichi Okazaki (ed.), Special issue on microfactory. Int. J. Autom. Technol. (IJAT) 4(2) (2010),
Fuji Press
Sustainable Design by Systematic
Innovation Tools (TRIZ, CAI, SI, and 26
Biomimetics)
Seung-Hyun Yoo
Abstract
As sustainable design is rather a new discipline, the necessity of creativity
implementation was conceived from the beginning. But few attempts to foster
creativity in design practice were successful, and it was in the realm of random
process, namely, serendipity. One of big steps toward systematic innovation
was possible by introduction of Russia-born TRIZ (Theory of Inventive Prob-
lem Solving). The efforts toward somewhat paradoxical systematic innovation
are now blossoming as CAI (Computer-Aided Innovation) including TRIZ.
Those developments also influenced greatly many of the modern technologies
that enable the increasing number of the patents with significant improvement in
their quality. Intimate relations of the innovations by these tools with sustainable
design are also observed. In this chapter, the attempt has been made to summarize
and analyze the accomplishments of applying CAI on sustainable design. At first,
the history and current state of TRIZ, CAI, SI (Systematic Innovation), and
biomimetics are described. Secondly, literature review on the cross area of
sustainable design and CAI is presented. Earlier practice of combining CAI
and conventional design practices, such as Design for X and present theoret-
ical concepts as well as methodology, have been discussed to understand the
knowledge enhancement in this regard. In addition to finding wisdom from man-
made world, the bio-inspired design approach (encompassing biomimetics) is
another direction to find good ideas from the nature. The systematic approach
of TRIZ has proven useful to develop innovative ideas that have been inspired
from the nature. Finally, two successful examples are presented to illustrate how
it can be applied to produce sustainable engineering outputs from daily life to
energy-intensive industry. It is hoped that this chapter can shed light on how to
make the world more productive in innovation toward sustainable design.
S.-H. Yoo
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Ajou University, Suwon, Korea
e-mail: ryseung@gmail.com; ryseung@ajou.ac.kr
1 Introduction
2 TRIZ
2.1 Definition
Although it is hard to define TRIZ in one sentence, there are many attempts to
provide succinct definition. TRIZ is an inductive methodology for creative problem
solving based on the study of many patents (Yoo 2004). It is summarized in 50 words
as follows: “Essence of TRIZ: Recognition that technical systems evolve toward the
increase of ideality by overcoming contradictions mostly with minimal introduction
of resources. Thus, for creative problem solving, TRIZ provides a dialectic way of
thinking, i.e., to understand the problem as a system, to image the ideal solution
first, and to solve contradictions” (Nakagawa 2001). As TRIZ provides vast tools
for solving innovative problems, it is conceived as a philosophy with a set of tools
(Mann 2007; Gadd 2011). Essentially, TRIZ is a new way of thinking and practicing
in solving inventive problems which should be adequately defined in terms of the
TRIZ system. Another definition is proposed as a human-oriented knowledge-based
systematic methodology of inventive problem solving (Savransky 2000).
2.2 History
It started in around 1940–1950 and evolved into classical TRIZ till 1990s. This tim-
ing can be explained with the biography of the founder, G. Altshuller (1926–1998).
Altshuller was an engineer, inventor, scientist, journalist, and writer who pursued
ways to help people make inventions by providing systematic methodology. As the
early concepts of systematic ways of invention later known as TRIZ started in his
20s, the birth of TRIZ was in 1940s. He always endeavored to find ways in guiding
people to make better inventions during his life with many vicissitudes. Altshuller
26 Sustainable Design by Systematic Innovation Tools 453
TRIZ education
from childhood
himself was a prolific inventor and worked as a patent officer in the Navy. As the
world history manifested, many patent clerks made important roles in science and
technology including Einstein. Altshuller is another example of important patent
examiners. He found that there were certain rules for successful transfer of various
inventions and solutions from one field of engineering to another. Altshuller and his
colleagues initially reviewed 200,000 patents and selected 40,000 as representatives
of inventive solutions. These patents were classified into five levels of inventiveness
based on the problem difficulty and the difference from earlier solutions in terms of
knowledge used from external field. The levels started from scale 1 where personal
knowledge was used for basic, routine improvement. The level 5 was for highly
innovative patents which came from new scientific discovery. It was natural that the
patents in level 2, 3, and 4 were focused on the investigation as level 1 examples
are too obvious and level 5 cannot be achievable by systematic ways. TRIZ is to
ensure accurate definition of a problem at a functional level and then provides strong
indicators toward successful and often highly innovative solution. TRIZ considers
innovation as a systematic process and not just flash of idea. Altshuller’s wisdom
and accomplishment are now structured as the classical TRIZ and shown in books
by him and other authors (Altshuller 1984, 1996, 1999; Gadd 2011; Cameron 2010;
Fey and Rivin 2005). Especially ARIZ (Algorithm of Inventive Problem Solving),
which is one of the core concepts in TRIZ, has been developed as shown in Fig. 26.1
454 S.-H. Yoo
(Orloff 2006). Versions were updated till 1985, and nowadays modern engineering
tools are combined together to produce more efficient system of innovation.
The most important findings from the patent analysis are three assertions that
the problems and solutions are repeated across the industries and sciences, the
patterns of technical evolution are also repeated across the industries and sciences,
and the radical innovations use scientific effects outside the field in which they
are developed. Consequently, important corollaries from these findings can be
summarized as follows: Rather a small number of inventive principles can provide
solutions to the hundreds of problems which appear repeatedly in the millions
of products and systems where the trends of technology evolution are highly
predictable. So TRIZ can alleviate the efforts of problem solvers and help them
overcome time-consuming trial and error method. TRIZ provides rich practical tools
for innovation compared with many other methods which give only declarative and
abstract suggestions. The contents of TRIZ may be categorized and applied into
problem modeling and solving stages. The main tools are briefly explained here:
• Contradiction: Problems are identified as inventive when they have contradiction
inside. The classical TRIZ identified 39 parameters which rule the technical
contradiction when two parameters are in conflict. The 40 principles are provided
as suggested solutions for each pair of improving and worsening parameters
in contradiction. A physical contradiction is a conflict between two mutually
exclusive requirements to the same parameter. TRIZ provides four separation
principles for this type of problems, namely, separation in time, space, relation
(condition), and at the system level.
• Resources: TRIZ provides creative utilization of the things which are available,
but not being used. Resources come from inside and outside, from all system
levels such as environment and super systems, from inexpensive materials, and
even from wastes. Also time and space should be counted as valuable resources.
• Ideality and IFR (Ideal Final Result): The concept of ideality is the most
important aspect of TRIZ in conjunction with the sustainable design. Same
concept appears in other discipline such as management and value engineering,
but only TRIZ uses this as a major tool for problem definition and solution stage.
The concept of the IFR is based on one of the laws of the technical trends: “The
development of all system proceeds in the direction of increasing the degree of
ideality.” Ideality can be shown in an equation as
X X X
Ideality D Benefits= Cost C Harms
Here, the numerator is the sum of all fulfilled useful functions and additional
benefits coming from the inventive solution. The cost in the denominator covers the
production cost and function cost. The harms are all unnecessary outputs except
26 Sustainable Design by Systematic Innovation Tools 455
useful ones. The right formulation of ideality to reach IFR gives a searching
direction and imagination of the best solutions. Practical ways to increase ideality
utilizing resources and the trends of technical evolution are well structured in TRIZ.
• Trends of technical evolution: The classical TRIZ found eight trends of technical
evolution. The first three are on the creation of a technical system: The trend
of increasing completeness of a system, energy conductivity, and harmonization
(increasing coordination). Remaining ones are for the growth and development
of a system: The trend of increasing ideality, uneven development of system
components, transition to the super system, transition to the microlevel, and
increasing the degree of substance – field integration.
• Effects: When the mission is to find ways to fulfill a certain required function,
the collection of scientific effects would be very useful. Here, effects are
the representative keyword of all scientific phenomena, laws, equations, and
formulas used in the technical solutions. As usual problem solvers know a
limited number (e.g., around 100) of scientific phenomena and the knowledge
is often confined to their own domain of expertise, the database of almost 10,000
effects which are already collected and well organized can help enormously find
practical solutions. In many softwares and references, the effects are classified by
corresponding verbs which properly describe a function. The effects have great
implication on the future of engineering education. As current discipline-based
engineering education given in the departmental system provides only handful
knowledge in a specified field, more convergent approach is needed to foster the
student’s ability to handle much more complex problems than the subject they
meet in the class. One direction is to dig deeply into a specific discipline, but it
should be balanced by the “need-based” education system which will heavily use
the effects module of TRIZ to find solutions in any field.
• Substance-Field (Su-Field) analysis: The important part of a technical system
can be graphically modeled with substances and fields by their interaction. The
interactions are in various forms such as effective, insufficient, excessive, and
harmful. The analysis based on this model is called as the Su-Field analysis. It is
very useful to see the whole picture of the system and helpful to identify the
characteristics of the problem. The nature of the problems brings 5 classes of the
problems and 76 standard solutions for each instance. The Su-Field analysis is
one of the core tools for the system modeling and solving process in ARIZ.
• ARIZ: The Algorithm for the Solution of Inventive Problem (ARIZ in Russian
acronym) is the step-by-step processes for nontypical problem which is consid-
ered as an epitome of the whole process. Although there are some people who
do not recommend as it is a quite long and time-consuming task, ARIZ has been
developed as a main tool in TRIZ till 1985 and proved to be useful for nontypical
difficult problems.
In addition to these main pillars of TRIZ, there are useful tools for problem
definition and solution which are not mentioned here. As TRIZ has inductive
nature, these tools are selectively favorable among the users depending on the
characteristics of the problems and solvers.
456 S.-H. Yoo
After Altshuller’s death, many modern tools are combined with TRIZ, and now
there are several new versions of TRIZ which are called as Modern TRIZ (Orloff
2006, 2012). TRIZ is regarded as the way of handling conceptual approach to a
problem. This is not only useful for identifying the problem but also for figuring out
the possible solutions. Currently, most TRIZ tools are realized in many commercial
softwares and e-learning systems enhanced with searching power of modern IT
technology. Some of them are as follows:
1. Goldfire (http://inventionmachine.com/products-and-services/innovation-soft
ware/)
2. Innovation Workbench (http://www.ideationtriz.com/new/iwb.asp)
3. CREAX (http://www.creationsuite.com/)
4. Pro Innovator (http://www.iwint.com/en/products/pro innovator-20081208-
211930.html)
5. STEPS (http://www.time-to-innovate.com/en/content/steps)
6. Modern TRIZ academy (http://www.modern-triz-academy.com/)
7. Target Invention (http://www.target-invention.com/Info/About-Target-invention/
TargetInvention.html)
One TRIZ site by T. Nakagawa is recommended which provides current status
of TRIZ worldwide and in Japan (http://www.osaka-gu.ac.jp/php/nakagawa/TRIZ/
eTRIZ/). An open source for TRIZ is also available http://www.opensourcetriz.
com/.
Although TRIZ is very active in some countries, it is still in the stage of
dissemination in the world. The featured article entitled “expanding the mind”
appeared in PRISM which is the official magazine of ASEE (American Society
of Engineering Education) exemplified the status of TRIZ in the engineering field
of USA. The author claimed that serendipity was the only currently available tool
for teaching creativity to engineering students and introduced Russian born TRIZ
as a new inventive tool (McGraw 2004). TRIZ is studied to make sound ground
theoretically and philosophically by serious researchers and applied to diverse
technical problems. And it is being elaborated to cover nontechnical problems and
to reach K-12 students.
3 CAI and SI
CAI and SI are envisaged as more general concepts incorporating TRIZ and other
methods in a unified way. A number of scholars interested in more general problem
solving and computer-aided innovation gathered and formed a working group
under the umbrella of IFIP (International Federation of Information Processing).
The WG (Working Group) 5.4 of CAI was formed under TC (Technical Com-
mittee) 5 of “information technology applications” in 2005 and holds biannual
conferences (Proceedings of IFIP CAI (Leon and Cho (2007), Tan et al. (2009),
26 Sustainable Design by Systematic Innovation Tools 457
Cavallucci et al. (2011)). The aims of these conferences and meetings are to
contribute for identifying the underlying scientific foundation of CAI and also
to evaluate their effectiveness and efficiency. They have been proved fruitful for
identifying the state of the art and trends of the CAI software and its tools and
methods by discussing organizational, technological, and cognitive aspects of the
application of the CAI methods and tools. These meetings promote the development
of the CAI software focusing on end-to-end product creation process with methods
and tools to ensure the feasibility and success of innovations, to address the main
motivations of the industrial sector regarding the engineering innovation activity
with computer tools and methods, and to address the main motivations of the
academic community regarding theoretical foundations of CAI. The scopes of the
WG are to promote regular working conferences, seminars, and workshops on
CAI calling for contributions for clarifying the role of computer-aided innovation
tools (http://www.computeraidedinnovation.net/). It can be easily seen that activities
should be highly relevant to sustainable design by nature of CAI, and papers on
the application to sustainable design appear in the CAI conference proceedings. In
another form of trial to identify innovation, schemes are systematically represented
by SI. This approach is to encompass TRIZ in a way and cover other conventional
tools in the same place. The society of SI is also organized and tries to collect and
disseminate information on SI (http://www.ssi.org.tw/EINDEX.htm).
4 Biomimetics
Biomimetics can be defined as the abstraction of good design from nature (Vincent
et al. 2006). It is also known as biomimes, biomimicry, bionics, or biologically
inspired design. At first, Schimidt in the 1950s coined the term “biomimetics,”
which is defined as transfer of ideas and analogues from biology to technol-
ogy. This concept has given some significant devices and concepts in the last
50 years. Leonardo Da Vinci first conceived the idea of a system/device which
can fly like birds, leading the Wright brothers to develop airplane. There were
many different stages involved before reaching to the stage of airplane. There
are other numerous examples where technology has been inspired from nature.
But this is still in empirical stage. There is no systematic approach available to
successfully mimic nature and convert to technology that can benefit the society
at large.
Fig. 26.2 Engineering solutions arranged according to size/hierarchy (Vincent et al. 2006)
combinatorial. The solution for the biological systems lies generally at lower level or
upper level of hierarchy. Technological systems are not very hierarchical in nature,
and rather the solution lies at the same level. Engineering is a result of decision-
making; it is prescriptive and generates rules and regularities. However, the thrust to
change in both the system may well be the same: the resolution of technical conflict
(Vincent et al. 2006). Major difference in the technological and biological systems
is that the technical systems are energy driven (Fig. 26.2), whereas the biological
systems are largely based on information and space, and consequently energy is not
predominant variable to find the solution (Fig. 26.3). The focus is on manipulating
energy uses to find solution of a problem (60% cases, Fig. 26.2) for technological
systems, followed by the change in material. Such summary and classification for
comparison between technical and biological system require enormous efforts of
observation, and it shows the importance of induction-based conclusion in the world
where deduction based teaching is prevalent.
Biomimetics is seen as a path from biology to engineering. The only path from
engineering to biology in current use is the application of engineering concepts and
models to biological systems. The transactions between biology and engineering are
based on energy; in biology, optimization processes are in partitioning the energy
between various functions of the organism, such as locomotion, reproduction,
repair, and growth. In engineering, there is again an array of optimizations so that
energy (cash) available is partitioned out among design, construction, management,
maintenance, etc. In both cases, there is a general principle of the survival of the
cheapest keeping to the evolutionary theme (Vincent and Mann 2002). Minimal
use of energy is, therefore, a really important driver when moving from biology to
engineering. Therefore, the ideas can be taken from biology not just as mechanisms
or materials but also the implementation of those mechanisms.
26 Sustainable Design by Systematic Innovation Tools 459
Fig. 26.3 Biological effects arranged according to size/hierarchy (Vincent et al. 2006)
TRIZ was conceived in and derived from the environment of things which are
artificial, nonliving, and technical. But biomimetics operates across the border
between living and nonliving systems. The reason for looking to nature for solutions
is to enhance technical functions, and conventional TRIZ is developed for the
classical problem solving for the technological system; thus it is true that TRIZ
does not contain many of these functions, and probably does not have the means
of deriving them for the biological systems. Despite the fact that TRIZ is the
most promising system for biomimetics, still there is a mismatch. This is conflated
by a number of factors that are currently not normally observed in the technical
system. When types of solution to particular pairs of conflicts which are arrived
at in technology via classical TRIZ and in biology are compared with, although
the problems commonly are very similar, the inventive principles that nature and
technologies use to solve problems can be very different. In fact, the similarity
between the TRIZ and BioTRIZ matrices is only 12%, where identity is represented
by 100% (Vincent et al. 2006). Only the principles of spatial composition are
significantly similar (73%) in biology and technology. The differences are in large
part to do with the pervasive presence of hierarchy in biological structures and
systems. But they are also to do with the degree of detail, and it is possible to
incorporate into a structure which, like an organism, is self-assembled and even
designed by the forces of molecular interaction (Vincent et al. 2005; Vincent 2009).
In order to develop TRIZ as a framework for biomimetics, firstly the biological
information should be made available within its structure by cataloguing and
classifying the effects of the actions and mechanisms of functioning. It needs to
modify and expand TRIZ so that it can cope with the extra varieties of input
460 S.-H. Yoo
information. For this task, the framework should be suitable for describing and
classifying both engineering and biological data (Bogatyrev 2002; Vincent et al.
2006). In general, it should:
– Find patterns in the solution of problems in technology (the original TRIZ
system)
– Find patterns in the solution of problems in biology (develop a modified,
BioTRIZ, system)
– Make these patterns compatible within a new general Biomimetic TRIZ
There are various studies available in the literature on biologically inspired
innovation by using the concepts of BioTRIZ conducted by various researchers.
An analysis of patenting activities in the field of biomimetics was conducted by
Bonser and Vincent (2007) and discussed the future trends in biologically-inspired
innovation. It has been seen from the analysis that number of patents has been
increasing in recent times in which the technology has been inspired from nature.
Mann (1999) examined the cases in nature which have solved the contradictions
by inventive ways in his work “Creativity as an exact Biomimetic science.” His
findings suggest that TRIZ can be expanded and enriched by including biological
knowledge. Craig et al. (2008) used BioTRIZ to study radiative cooling of building
passively by changing structure of the roof installation and found it to be useful for
studying such biomimetic application.
A comparative study of biomimetic design and TRIZ for designing of proton
exchange membrane fuel cell has been conducted by Currie et al. (2009). The Proton
Exchange Membrane (PEM) fuel cell is an attractive energy conversion device that
can provide efficient and clean electrical energy. The water management problem
of the PEM fuel cell has been analyzed in the design framework by both TRIZ and
biomimetics design methodologies. Both design methods produced two potential
solutions. The authors found biomimetic design to have more potential from bias
by the designer’s prior knowledge of biology. This bias can serve to either hinder or
help the design process. It has been observed that biomimetic design and TRIZ can
be considered mutually inclusive in the potential solutions generated. Vincent and
Mann (2002) have presented the case studies to illustrate benefits to engineers and
biologists for integrating biological knowledge into the framework of TRIZ. The
authors explain how TRIZ can help technologists develop artificial system which
takes nature as starting point and improve on the ways nature do it. Permaculture
(permanent + agriculture) is the conscious decision of artificial ecosystem which
possesses the productivity and benefits of the conventional agricultural system
combined with the self-dependences, elasticity, and self-serving features of the
natural ecosystem (Mollison 1997). Bogatyrev (2002) studied permaculture in
the conceptual framework of TRIZ and developed the basis for super organismic
bionics. Vincent (2009) in his book chapter on Biomimetics of skin in the book
“Functional properties of bio-inspired surfaces” describes the versatility of skin in
living beings such as its color, rheological effects, sensing capabilities, etc., and
explains the possible analogies which can be used to mimic interfacial material
layers with the capability of skin. The same author (2005) explains solution of
materials design problems in biology and technology by using the concepts of
26 Sustainable Design by Systematic Innovation Tools 461
Table 26.1 Animate and inanimate systems: two different idealities (Bogatyrev and Bogatyreva
2009)
Ideal technical system Ideal biological system Ideal future technology
1 Simple structure Complex structure Simple
2 Everlasting or have Mortal Everlasting
necessary life length
3 Easy to operate Difficult external operation Easy to operate
(deterministic) (due to stochastic)
4 Min. use of resources Max. use of resources Minimal use of resources
5 Min. waste production Min. waste production Minimum waste production
6 Max capacity reserve Available in abundance Max capacity reserve
7 Easy to repair Sustainable Self-repairing
8 Has different modes of Adaptive Adaptive
operation for different
environment
9 Automatic Self-regulated Self-regulated
10 Reliable Reliable Reliable
conventional TRIZ and the improved BioTRIZ. This work points out on the fact that
hierarchy is an important factor for biological system which is more or less ignored
for technical system and thus bared it to take advantage of hierarchy. Vincent
et al. (2005) have prepared a database of biological information for engineers via
biological patents. The specific features of the database are the following: they
include functions and their effect of different biological systems and their technical
analogue. Present focus in design is function-based design, and the biological
system can work as the resource for the technical system to achieve the desired
output. The five-dimensional database designed by authors covers objects parts,
environment in which these parts operate, the limits and causes of its action, the
ultimate purpose of the action, and the resources with auxiliary systems involved.
This database covers physical effects as well as intention and motivation.
Bogatyrev and Bogatyreva (2009) have discussed the concepts of evolution in
biology and technology and conclude that the evolution trends in technology and
biology have different strategies. They provided ten new design strategies for future
markets as shown in Table 26.1.
Table 26.1 presents difference in an ideal technical system and an ideal biological
system. The strategies to achieve the ideal state in both technical and biological
systems are quite different. In technical system, the ideal condition is to achieve the
decreased size without compromising in functionality, but biological system follows
this ideal in limited cases only as in the case of parasites.
The authors explain how TRIZ can bridge the gap between nature and tech-
nology. Analyzing the biological phenomenon, the authors found 40 inventive
principles and 72 solutions bio standards in biological systems in all levels of
complexity from cell to ecosystem. Table 26.2 presents the differences between
technical systems and biological systems.
462 S.-H. Yoo
Table 26.2 The differences between living nature and technology (Bogatyrev and Bogatyreva
2009)
S. No. Nonliving technical artificial system Living biological natural system
1 Operate within sufficiently wide Operate within relatively narrow
conditions, which are beyond the conditions of temperature, pressure,
limits of living creatures’ tolerance. chemical environment, etc. Utilization
Utilization of high-energy of high-energy electromagnetic fields,
electromagnetic fields, laser, radiation, radiation, and low temperatures is
extreme temperatures, and pressure is absent
widespread
2 Most human technologies are Complex living systems tend to keep
open-ended “cycles,” which cause balance – static (homeostasis) or
most of the problems in various types dynamic (homeorhesis) due to closed
of misbalance and lack of cycles of energy and substance
sustainability
3 Very fast and accelerating Relatively slow rates of evolution
development
4 Short term effectiveness (“here and Long-term sustainability
now at any price”)
5 Slow processes are considered as Slow processes are widespread
shortcomings
6 Economical forces make steady shift Complex ecological systems tend to
from K- to r-mode in products drift from r-(“cheap,” small, short
living organisms) to K-(large, long
living) mode
7 Contemporary industrial systems are Biological systems mostly avoid
unimaginable without massive global long-range transportation
transport flows
8 Evolution of technology goes from Living creature mainly participates in
mechanization via automatization all the processes in which it is
toward nearly total replacement of concerned as a central figure
humans in the technological process
9 Typically new technology substitutes The newly evolved biological systems
the old one to maximum extent do not necessarily substitute the old
ones, but often show the parallel
existence
10 The most common type of locomotion The most common type of
and manipulation: rotation manipulation and locomotion:
oscillation, reciprocation, pulsation
Table 26.3 explains the differences in evolution trends in biological and technical
systems. Technologists (engineers) mostly consider the future, while biologists
focus on the past. Living creatures adapt to the environment by changing them-
selves. They also change the environment for their needs. This leverage is not
available in technical system which is a major difference from the biological system.
Shu et al. (2007) discuss about the integration of function-based design and
biomimetic design for automatic concept generation. This includes a more complete
and systematic modeling that reveals additional aspects of biological phenomena
to be exploited. They have discussed about the functional modeling of a single
26 Sustainable Design by Systematic Innovation Tools 463
Table 26.3 The differences and similarities between the evolution trends in animate nature and
evolution of technology (Bogatyrev and Bogatyreva 2009)
S. No. Trends in technical evolution Trends in biological evolution
1 Transition of the working functions
from the macro- to the microlevel
2 Increase of the degree of ideality – the
more emptiness in a system the better
3 Systems change, while they grow System ontogenesis can be expressed
following S-curves in S-curve
4 Systems and products evolve toward Life started as a biochemical
the use of higher frequency energy and phenomenon and evolved toward the
use of fields: gravitational – active search for energy resources.
mechanical – acoustic – chemical – Single-cellular organisms started from
thermal – magnetic – electric – electromagnetic – electrical –
electromagnetic chemical – mechanical (multicellular
organisms) – acoustic (complex
communication) in their organization
and behavior
5 Dynamization, increase of the degree Decrease of the degree of freedom in
of freedom, and flexibility functions – species specialization. The
more primitive biological taxons are,
the more their universality
6 Mono-bi-poly cycles, i.e., Trends in the evolution of
polymerization of monomerical parts morphology: oligomerization of
effectors and metamerical parts of the
body
7 Segmentation: reduction of the unit Replication, reproducing, cloning,
metamerization: multiplication of the
units
8 Increase of automation and eventual Increase of the role of the central
exclusion of humans control and sophistication of the
nervous system. But decrease of
automation, increase the role of
feed-forward control
9 “Folding-unfolding” structural Morphological degradation of
complexity parasites and other super-specialized
species (“folding”) is the dead end of
the evolutionary line
10 Harmonization and coordination of the Also true for all living systems
system parts (materials, shape,
structure, information, rhythms, and
energy distribution)
11 Parts of systems (subsystems) evolve Species either change themselves or
nonuniformly, creating constantly change each other. Misbalance in
changing opportunities for innovation subsystems’ interactions causes
ecosystem catastrophes or individual
physiological stress, illness and
triggers changes or death
12 Shortening of the energy flow path Energy flow paths are getting longer in
the evolution of life on our planet
(continued)
464 S.-H. Yoo
sustainability for many years. Traditional engineering tools and concepts are ex-
tended to meet the requirements from the environmental restriction. The deficiencies
and criticism of this approach are also summarized (Leibrecht 2005; Knight and
Jenkins 2009). Then innovation tools are combined with the traditional tools (Chang
and Chen 2004; Justel et al. 2005). Trials toward whole integration of sustainability
and design with the innovation tools are now appearing and have started to produce
notable accomplishments. Modern tools equipped with the current IT technology
can help much on reducing environmental effects from design to manufacturing and
recycling.
More developments are expected by integrating the state-of-the-art innovation
technology such as TRIZ, CAI, SI, and biomimetics. CAI and TRIZ have been
used to enhance the processes in this direction in one way. Attempts to apply
TRIZ in ecodesign come from both sustainable design experts and TRIZniks. The
eco-guidelines are compared with the TRIZ tools such as 40 inventive principles,
and the eco tools such as Eco-Compass are being improved by TRIZ (Jones and
Harrison 2000). Integration with other tools for ecodesign is another approach
with Lean concept and LCA (life cycle assessment) (Kobayashi 2005). Analogies
between problem solving tools and the rules and suggestions coming from Design
for Disassembly, sustainability, or reuse are searched (Ikovenko 2004). Russo et al.
(2011a, b) tried to use the basic concepts of TRIZ into ecodesign. The TRIZ tools
used are the laws of evolution, resources, and IFR (Russo et al. 2011a), and those
are extended to provide practical tools for small- and medium-sized enterprises in
the manufacturing field (Russo et al. 2011b). The weakness of the current LCA
which is pointed out by experts and users including complexity (Russo et al. 2011a),
time-consuming, and high cost is overcome by introducing the simplified LCA
incorporating TRIZ concepts in the form of eco-guidelines. It is argued that all the
methods are effective in the assessment or improvement phases, but not in both.
This is also resolved using the TRIZ-driven concepts, such as the IFR index in the
assessment phase and eco-guidelines in the improving phase. A SUSTAINability
map is introduced to exercise systematic thinking of TRIZ in the first phase of
design and applied successfully to the case study of clothes cleaning (D’Anna and
Cascini 2011). TRIZ also uses an option generation tool for cleaner production
and applied for zero emission projects (Fresner et al. 2010). Case-based reasoning
(CBR) which is used to form the disassembly strategy, recycling strategy, cost
and benefit analysis, and environmental management is integrated with TRIZ to
accelerate preliminary ecodesign (Yang and Chen 2011). Experiences in introducing
biomimetics to students of industrial engineering were also reported with partial
success (Santulli and Langella 2010).
There are some variations of TRIZ such as SIT(Systematic Inventive Thinking),
ASIT(Advanced Systematic Inventive Thinking), and USIT(Unified Structured
Inventive Thinking), and those tools were also applied to the eco design and design
education (Turner 2009). The consolidation of CAI and sustainable design started
in a passive way that innovative applications are found to be very efficient in the
realization of a specific function and also a good solution in terms of sustainability.
Many times, the innovative outputs are not just a solution of a specific problem but
466 S.-H. Yoo
also a good product or process which have good properties in any criteria including
ecodesign. An innovation which is closer to ideality shows better characteristics
in all directions. These experiences bring innovators to adopt CAI for sustainable
design purposefully. So far, the perception that sustainability issue is different
from the traditional engineering activities has led to avoidance and low priority of
sustainability in practice. Insufficient knowledge of the existence of practical, robust
tools for problem identification and solving and impression of sustainability issue
as costly without gain also block the efforts in this direction. It is imperative to
adopt the principles and tools of the systematic innovation to overcome obstacles
to meeting the sustainability challenges. Now it is good news for corporations of
all sizes under the regulatory pressures to develop more sustainable products and
processes that such systematic innovation tools are available.
Here, two examples have been considered to illustrate the use of TRIZ in
sustainable design.
The first example is brought to show how innovation methodology can be applied
to the commodity with ease. The evolution of tools for function of holding several
pieces of paper can be easily seen on each one’s desk. Folding of the corner of the
papers, pins, clips, and fasteners is a common solution (Petroski 1994). Staplers are
used most because of its capability to hold fairly thick papers. But the efficiency
and ideality of the staplers can be questioned as staples are used and dumped.
Certainly, it is far from ideal as a fair amount of materials are wasted as staples. It
is cumbersome to use a staple remover for unstapling. So a stapless stapler has been
devised to avoid these shortcomings. It has been studied in terms of USIT which
is a dialect of TRIZ (Yoo et al. 2011). Even though the stapless stapler is good
for not wasting metals, still it is in the path of development to be ideal. It cannot
penetrate more than five sheets of paper, and sturdier design has been suggested.
These kinds of innovative stationery should be used more in daily life to conserve
precious material. It is astounding that the issue of ecodesign concept is keenly
perceived in a capstone design project, and an improved design can be produced by
university seniors in one semester using modern design engineering tools and TRIZ.
It is a good manifestation of the fact that TRIZ and CAI tools are really effective to
bring out the issue of problem finding and solution generating (Fig. 26.4).
The extremity of ideality is IFR, and it is the same purpose of eco- and sustainable
design to increase the ideality. As a routine and incremental design which is a
traditional engineering approach has limit to produce truly innovative solution, so-
called radical innovation is required to bring out greener product with big impact. In
this sense, here is one of the notable examples from paper industry (S. Litvin, 2011,
26 Sustainable Design by Systematic Innovation Tools 467
Fig. 26.4 A stapless stapler: (a) a currently selling model, (b) a stitched paper and (c) the
improved design
GEN3, Private communication). It is true that 99% of paper is still made using
a water-laid process although the paper industry has substantially improved its
technology in the face of increasingly stringent environmental requirements. When
paper is volume-produced using water-laid technology, the process is extremely
water and energy intensive; the water-paper slurry contains more than 99% water,
and the dryers consume large amounts of energy. This is important for deploying
extra capacity in the cyclical industry in a controllable manner. Historically,
sanitary-hygienic tissue was produced using 1 ton of water for every kilogram of
dry fiber. Water is needed for establishing hydrogen bonds between the molecules
of the cellulose fibers contained in paper, so wetting the fibers is a necessity. Water
has also been used to transport these fibers to the web used for paper forming.
This process was a very time-consuming and energy-intensive process that also
had significant sustainability disadvantages because of the aggressive chemical
additives added to the water. Paper manufactured by this method was too expensive
to successfully compete in the marketplace. The Su-Field analysis of TRIZ was
performed to identify the use of water in the transport of the fibers as detrimental.
This analysis suggested that the key was to find another substance to perform the
same function as the water, one without these harmful effects. However, the second
function performed by water, promoting adhesion of the cellulose fibers, could not
468 S.-H. Yoo
6 Summary
In this chapter, innovation methods such as TRIZ, CAI, SI, and biomimetics are
introduced. They have great impact on the creative problem solving and innovative
design. Those innovation methodologies can produce meaningful progress in ecode-
sign by combining sustainability with the traditional design techniques. Recent
publications on the study of finding the systematic steps for sustainable design are
summarized. The purpose of innovation methodology is in the same direction of the
sustainable design in nature. More ideal products from those tools have invaluable
characteristics to be more eco-friendly. Examples of a new type of stapler and a new
paper-producing technology are brought to show the impact of the radical innovation
generated by the TRIZ methodology. As the application of the innovative techniques
is in the stage of blossoming after the introduction and implementing steps, there is
much room to try for sustainable design.
7 Cross-References
References
G. Altshuller, Creativity as an Exact Science (Gordon and Breach, New York, 1984)
G. Altshuller, And Suddenly the Inventor Appeared, trans. by L. Shulyak (Technical Innovation
Center, Worcester, 1996)
G. Altshuller, The Innovation Algorithm: TRIZ, Systematic Innovation, and Technical Creativity
(Technical Innovation Center, Worcester, 1999)
R.H.C. Bonser, J.F.V. Vincent, Technology trajectories, innovation, and the growth of biomimetics.
IMechE 221 C, 1177 (2007)
26 Sustainable Design by Systematic Innovation Tools 469
N.R. Bogatyrev, TRIZ – is the missing link in super organismic biomimetics, in Proceedings of
TRIZ Future 2002 (ETRIA, Starabourg, 2002), pp. 75–80
N.R. Bogatyrev, O.A. Bogatyreva, TRIZ evolution trends in biological and technological design
strategies, in 19th CIRP Design Conference, Cranfield University, 2009
G. Cameron, Trizics: Teach Yourself TRIZ, How to Invent, Innovate and Solve “impossible”
Technical Problems Systematically (CreateSpace to TRIZICS, Lexington, 2010)
D. Cavallucci, R. De Guio, G. Cascini (ed.), Building Innovation Pipelines Through Computer-
Aided Innovation: 4th IFIP WG 5.4 Working Conference on CAI (Springer, Heidelberg, 2011)
A. Chakrabarti, P. Sarkar et al., A functional representation for aiding biomimetic and artificial
inspiration of new ideas. Artif. Intell. Eng. Des. Anal. Manuf. 19, 113 (2005)
H.T. Chang, J.L. Chen, The conflict-problem-solving CAD software integrating TRIZ into eco-
innovation. Adv. Eng. Softw. 35, 553 (2004)
S. Craig, D. Harrison et al., BioTRIZ suggests radiative cooling of buildings can be done passively
by changing the structure of roof insulation to let longwave infrared pass. J. Bionic Eng. 5, 55
(2008)
J. Currie, K. Fung et al., A comparison of biomimetic design and TRIZ applied to the design of
a proton exchange membrane fuel cell, in Proceedings of 2009 International Conferences on
Innovation and Practices in eng des and eng (2009)
W. D’Anna, G. Cascini, Supporting sustainable innovation through TRIZ system thinking. Proced.
Eng. 9, 145 (2011)
V. Fey, E. Rivin, Innovation on Demand: New Product Development Using TRIZ (Cambridge
University Press, Cambridge, 2005)
J. Fresner, J. Jantschgi et al., The theory of inventive problem solving (TRIZ) as option generation
tool within cleaner production projects. J. Clean. Prod. 18, 128 (2010)
K. Gadd, TRIZ for Engineers: Enabling Inventive Problem Solving (Wiley, Chichester/UK, 2011)
S. Ikovenko, TRIZ as Lean Thinking Tool, 4th TRIZ Future Conference, Florence, Italy, 2004
E. Jones, D. Harrison, Investigating the use of TRIZ in eco-innovation. TRIZ J. 2000, 9 (2000)
D. Justel, R. Vidal et al., TRIZ applied for eco-innovation in design for disassembly, in 1st IFIP
TC-5 Working Conf on CAI, Ulm, Germany, 2005
P. Knight, J.O. Jenkins, Adopting and applying eco-design techniques: a practitioners perspective.
J. Clean. Prod. 17, 549 (2009)
H. Kobayashi, Strategic evolution of eco-products: a product life cycle planning methodology. Res.
Eng. Des. 16, 1 (2005)
S. Leibrecht, Fundamental principles for CAD-based ecological assessments. Int. J. LCA 10, 436
(2005)
N. Leon, S. Cho (ed.), Trends in Computer Aided Innovation: 2nd IFIP Working Conference on
CAI (Springer, New York, 2007)
D. McGraw, Expanding the mind. PRISM (ASEE) 9, 30 (2004)
D. Mann, Creativity as an exact (biomimetic) science, in 4th Biomimetics Workshop, University of
Reading, 1999
D. Mann, Hands on Systematic Innovation (IFR, Claredon, UK, 2007)
B. Mollison, Introduction to Permaculture (Tagari, 1997)
T. Nakagawa, Essemce of TRIZ in 50 words, http://www.osaka-gu.ac.jp/php/nakagawa/TRIZ/
eTRIZ/epapers/eEssence50W010518.html
M. Orloff, Inventive Thinking Through TRIZ: A Practical Guide, 2nd edn. (Springer, Berlin, 2006)
M. Orloff, Modern TRIZ: A Practical Course with EASyTRIZ Technology (Springer, Berlin, 2012)
H. Petroski, The evolution of useful things: how everyday artifacts-from forks and pins to paper
clips and zippers-came to be as they are (Vintage, New York, 1994)
D. Russo, G. Bersano et al., European testing of the efficiency of TRIZ in eco-innovation projects
for manufacturing SMEs. Proced. Eng. 9, 157 (2011)
D. Russo, D. Regazzoni et al., Eco-design with TRIZ laws of evolution. Proced. Eng. 9, 311 (2011)
C. Santulli, C. Langella, Introducing students to bio-inspiration and biomimetic design: a workshop
experience. Int. J. Technol. Des. Educ. 21, 471 (2010)
470 S.-H. Yoo
J. Sartori, U. Pal et al., A methodology for supporting “transfer” in biomimetic design. AI Eng.
Des. Anal. Manuf. 24:483 (2010)
S.D. Savransky, Engineering of Creativity: Introduction to TRIZ Methodology of Inventive Problem
Solving (CRC Press, Boca Raton, 2000)
L.H. Shu, R.B. Stone et al., Integrating function based-and biomimetic design for automatic con-
cept generation, in ICED07: Proceedings of the 16th International Conference of Engineering
Design (The Design Society, Paris, 2007)
R. Tan, G. Cao, L.R. Noel (ed.), Growth and Development of Computer Aided Innovation: 3rd
IFIP WG 5.4 Working Conference on CAI (Springer, Berlin, 2009)
S.A. Turner, ASIT–a problem solving strategy for education and eco-friendly sustainable design.
Int. J. Technol. Des. Educ. 19, 221 (2009)
J.F.V. Vincent, Biomimetics of Skins, in Functional Properties of Bio-Inspired Surfaces, ed. by
E.A. Favret, N.E. Fuentes (World Scientific, Singapore, 2009), p. 3
J.F.V. Vincent, D.L. Mann, Systematic technology transfer from biology to engineering. Philos.
Trans. R. Soc. Lond. A 360, 159 (2002)
J.F.V. Vincent, O. Bogatyreva et al., Putting biology into TRIZ: a database of biological effects.
Creat. Innov. Manage. 14, 66 (2005)
J.F.V. Vincent, O.A. Bogatyreva et al., Biomimetics: its practice and theory. J. R. Soc. Interface 3,
471 (2006)
W. Wimmer, R. Züst, K.M. Lee, ECODESIGN Implementation: A Systematic Guidance on
Integrating Environmental Considerations into Product Development (Springer, Dordrecht,
2004)
C.J. Yang, J.L. Chen, Accelerating preliminary eco-innovation design for products that integrates
case-based reasoning and TRIZ method. J. Clean. Prod. 19, 998 (2011)
S.H. Yoo, Engineer’s Creativity (Ajou University Press, Korea 2004)
S.H. Yoo, N.R. Lee et al., Development of an improved stapless stapler – a case study of
the capstone course in the department of mechanical engineering, in The 2nd International
Conference on Systematic Innovation, Shanghai, China, 2011
Sustainable Product Design and
Development: TPI-Based Idea Generation 27
Method for Eco-Business Planning and
Eco-Product Development
Abstract
Environmental consciousness has been growing in recent years, and product
life cycle design that aims to maximize utility value while minimizing environ-
mental load and cost should be implemented in addition to the environmentally
conscious design of the product itself. In this context, many life cycle design
tools have been proposed in recent years. Examples include life cycle scenario
description tools, which support a designer in explicitly describing an expected
life cycle scenario for a product, life cycle simulation (LCS) tools, and design
guideline for product life cycle. However, it is not easy for a designer to derive
a practical design solution for the product life cycle (e.g., product specifications
and life cycle options for components) by using these tools. Life cycle scenario
description tools alone cannot calculate the optimal values for design parameters
and LCS tools, the model of which consists of a large number of interrelated
parameters, and are too complex to calculate these values. In addition, developing
a calculation model for a LCS tool is a time-consuming task.
To solve these problems, Total Performance Design (TPD) method has been
developed, especially focusing on the balance of customer’s utility value of a
product and its resulting environmental load and cost throughout the entire life
cycle. In this method, Total Performance Indicator (TPI), which represents the
environmental and economic performance throughout product life cycle, is used
as an objective function and a design solution is derived as a set of life cycle
option (e.g., reuse, recycling, upgrading, extension of physical lifetime) for each
S. Kondoh ()
Advanced Manufacturing Research Institute, National Institute of Advanced Science and
Technology (AIST), Tsukuba, Ibaraki, Japan
e-mail: kondou-shinsuke@aist.go.jp
N. Mishima
Graduate School of Engineering and Resource Science, Akita University, Akita, Akita, Japan
e-mail: nmishima@gipc.akita-u.ac.jp
1 Introduction
method. Although the PSS concept well structures possible configuration patterns
of products and services, it is too abstract for businesses to generate practical
ideas of the eco-products considering their most suitable eco-business models. In
order to solve this problem, the authors have been developing the TPI-based idea
generation method for eco-business planning and eco-product development, which
systematically gives the designer a set of eco-business strategies in addition to the
most suitable product performance specifications.
This chapter provides readers with a brief overview of eco-product design and
development methods at first. Then it illustrates the TPI-based idea generation
method for eco-business planning and eco-product development. Section 2 briefly
summarizes current eco-design and life cycle design methods. Section 3 explains the
basic ideas of the TPI-based idea generation method for eco-business planning and
eco-product development. Sections 4–6 describe the detail of the method; Sect. 4
describes Total Performance Indicator (TPI), which is used as an objective function
in this method, Sect. 5 explains 12 eco-business rules, by which the designer
generates eco-business ideas by consulting the eco-business case base, and Sect. 6
explains how to determine the product performance specifications that are suitable
for the generated eco-business ideas. Section 7 illustrates the design procedure of
the method with a simplified case study of a laptop computer business.
The methods and tools for eco-product design and development can be classified
into the following two categories: (1) design for environment (DfE) methods and
(2) life cycle design method for products and services.
So-called design for environment (DfE) methods focus on one aspect of a design
problem (e.g., recyclability of materials) at a time. Design for reuse (DfR), design for
recycling (DfR), design for maintenance (DfM), and design for assembly/disassembly
(DfAD) are examples of these methods. Among them, modular design method
(Baldwin and Kim 2000), which is widely used to meet a wide variety of customer
needs with relatively small design and production efforts, is one of the key concepts
for realizing highly reusable, recyclable, and maintenancable products.
scenario description tools (Yamagiwa 2004; Suesada et al. 2007), which support
a designer in explicitly describing an expected product life cycle scenario for a
product with easily understandable graphical representations, life cycle simulation
(LCS) methods (Umeda et al. 2000; Kobayashi and Kumazawa 2007), which are
utilized for evaluating the environmental and economic performance throughout the
product life cycle in addition to conventional life cycle assessment (LCA) and life
cycle costing (LCC) methods, and eco-design guidelines (UNEP 1997; Wimmer
et al. 2004) are examples of them.
The concept of product service system (PSS) (Goedkoop et al. 1999; UNEP 2002;
Sakao and Lindahl 2009) and servicizing (White et al. 1999) are also classified
into this category. PSS, which is often defined as “a marketable set of products
and services of jointly fulfilling a user’s needs” (Goedkoop et al. 1999) is seen as
excellent means for significant reduction of environmental load as well as enhancing
the competitiveness of the businesses. Three typical types of PSS, namely, product-
oriented PSS (e.g., advice and consultancy service provided with the products), use-
orientedPSS(e.g.,productlease,rental,andpooling),andresult-orientedPSS(e.g.,pay
per service unit), are good references for analyzing eco-products and their businesses.
However, it is not easy for the designer to derive a practical sustainable solution
for his/her given business environment based on these methods. Life cycle scenario
description tools alone cannot calculate the optimal values for design parameters
and LCS tools are too complex to calculate these values since their models consist
of a large number of interrelated parameters. In addition, developing a calculation
model for LCS tools is a time-consuming task. Strategies and guidelines suggested
by PSS concepts are also difficult to use because of their abstractness.
In order to solve these problems, the TPI-based idea generation method for
eco-business planning and eco-product development has been developed. The
method gives the designer a set of practical ideas for sustainable businesses in
addition to those for a target product itself by using a case base of sustainable
businesses in Japan. It also provides the designer with an easy-to-use evaluation
method for his/her ideas from both environmental and economic viewpoints. Total
Performance Indicator (TPI), which simultaneously represents the efficiency of
user value production from environmental and economic viewpoints, is used as a
performance measure in this method.
Eco-businesses are defined as businesses that provide greater user value at lower
environmental load and cost than existing ones, in this chapter. By using the Total
27 Sustainable Product Design and Development 475
UV
TPI D p (27.1)
LCE LCC
where LCE and LCC denote environmental load and cost throughout the entire
life cycle, respectively. Equation 27.1, above, is selected because (1) the evaluation
of environmental and economic performance is viewed as having the same level
of importance and (2) arithmetic average of LCE and LCC is not suitable due
to difficulties in converting LCE and LCC into the same unit. Even when LCE
can be converted into monetary unit referring to the prices for carbon dioxide
emission permits, the LCE value is too small to compare with that of LCC in
general.
In order to help a designer find eco-business ideas that effectively improve TPI, a
set of eco-business rules and conditions for applying them are provided. Figure 27.1
summarizes the basic idea of the method.
First, 17 business parameters, from which UV, LCE, and LCC are constructed,
are identified. Among them, a set of key (influential) parameters in a given business
environment is identified by sensitivity analysis of TPI and it gives a pattern of a
given business environment.
Second, the effect of each eco-business rule on these 17 parameters is analyzed
referring to 130 eco-business cases in Japan. Summarizing a general tendency of
each rule, the applicability of each rule is given by a rules-parameters matrix. By
using this matrix and consulting the business case base, a business designer can
easily find a set of business rules that effectively improve TPI in a given business
environment.
The procedure of the method is summarized as follows.
Step 1: Identification of business environment
First, the designer identifies customers’ functional requirements and calculates the
values for 17 parameters in a given business environment.
Step 2: Sensitivity analysis of TPI
The designer executes sensitivity analysis of TPI to find a set of key (influential)
parameters to be improved.
Step 3: Idea generation for eco-business
From the predefined eco-business rules that were derived by analyzing existing
eco-businesses, the designer selects a set of rules that improves the key parameters
derived in Step 2, and generates eco-business ideas by consulting the eco-business
case base, which describes how each rule improves these parameters in each
existing eco-business case.
476
Fig. 27.1 The basic idea of TPI-based idea generation method for eco-product
S. Kondoh and N. Mishima
27 Sustainable Product Design and Development 477
This section describes how to formulate UV, LCE, and LCC for calculating the TPI
of a target product.
4.1 Formulation of UV
where lt and V .t/ denote the lifetime and product value at time t, respectively.
wi .t/ D ai t C bi (27.6)
where ai and bi denote the obsolescence rate and initial importance of FRi ,
respectively. These values can be estimated by regression analysis on wi .t/ at
various times t.
Figure 27.2 depicts the time variation of value allocated to each FR. The
horizontal axis and vertical axis denote product use time, and value allocated to
FRi , respectively.
0
Time t
UVi Time integral of value
In general, a and b, which represent user preference for a product and its
time variation, respectively, are given by the market environment and cannot be
controlled by a designer, whereas c and d, which represent product performance
and its time variation, respectively, can be controlled by a designer. Thus, a designer
should select adequate values for c and d for given a and b.
Introducing mc and md , which are resultant vectors of a and b, ( 27.7) can be
transformed as follows by using scalar values: norms of mc , md , c, and d and the
angles between them.
UV D lt 2 m
E c cE cos.c / C lt m
E d d cos.d / (27.8)
1 1
m
Ec D lt aE C bE (27.9)
3 2
1
E d D lt aE C bE
m (27.10)
2
where kck and kdk represent physical deterioration speed and overall performance
of a target product, respectively.
c and d , which are called deterioration fitness and performance fitness in
this method, denote angles between c and mc and d and md , respectively. The
former and the latter (c and d ) represent adequateness of product deterioration
and initial performance in a given market environment (mc and md /, respectively.
Relationships among these vectors are depicted in Fig. 27.3. Note that c and mc
belong to different quadrants while d and md belong to the same quadrant. Thus, the
first term of the right-hand side of (27.8) is a negative quantity and the second term
is a positive quantity.
480 S. Kondoh and N. Mishima
FR1
b : Value evaluation
vector
d:
Performance
md vector
qd
qc
mc FR2
c: Deterioration
vector
a : Obsolescence vector
Fig. 27.3 Relationship among obsolescence, value evaluation, deterioration, and performance
vectors
Focusing on energy-using products, the longer a product is used, the higher its LCE
and LCC become. Thus, the simplest representation of LCE and LCC of a product
is given as follows:
where euse and fuse denote environmental load and cost during the product use stage
per unit time, respectively. eprod , edist , ecol , and eeol denote environmental load at
the production, distribution, collection, and end of life (EOL) treatment stages,
respectively. fprod , fdist , fcol , and feol denote the cost at production, distribution,
collection, and EOL treatment stages, respectively.
27 Sustainable Product Design and Development 481
As given in (Eqs. 27.8, 27.11, and 27.12), TPI is constructed from 17 parameters,
namely, kmc k, kmd k, kck, kdk, c , d , euse , eprod , edist , ecol , eeol , fuse , fprod , fdist ,
fcol , feol , and lt. Note that due to interdependency among these parameters,
each parameter cannot be controlled independently from the others. Therefore,
preferential improvement of the parameters with the greatest influence is an effective
approach. In order to find influential parameters among them, sensitivity analysis of
TPI should be executed. However, interdependency among the parameters which
construct UV and those which construct LCE and LCC is generally unknown in
mathematical forms. Thus, sensitivity analysis is conducted on the numerator and
the denominator of TPI, separately. A set of key parameters is selected from the
elements of sensitivity vector s given as follows:
@U V @U V @U V @U V @T L @T L @T L
s D kck ; kd k ; c ; d ; euse ; eprod ; edist ;
@ kck @ kd k @c @d @euse @eprod @edist
@T L @T L @T L @T L @T L
ecol ; eeol ; fuse ; fprod ; fdist ;
@ecol @eeol @fuse @fprod @fdist
@T L @T L @TPI
fcol ; feol ; lt (27.13)
@fcol @feol @lt
Now a set of influential parameters are chosen. The next issue is how to improve
these key parameters without affecting adversely other parameters. To do that, a set
of eco-business rules and conditions for applying them are provided to the designer.
To this end, 12 eco-business rules are identified from the analysis result of 130
eco-business cases in Japan (Kondoh et al. 2006). Then, their applicable conditions
are identified in relation with 17 business parameters by analyzing the effect of
each rule on the 17 business parameters in each case. Although the effect of each
rule on each business parameter differs from case to case, the general tendency of
its effect is summarized as shown in Table 27.1. The effect of each rule on each
parameter is represented by the symbols ı, , and * in each cell of the table.
482
Improved and deteriorated parameters after applying each rule are represented by
ı and , respectively. * denotes the potentially controllable parameters when a
designer applies rule (A) Management of life cycles.
(A) Management of life cycles
Proper management and control of product life cycle (especially, after they are
sold) can reduce both environmental loads and costs. Closed-loop manufacturing
of a one-time-use camera is an example of this rule. In this case, the business
provider takes responsibility for the collection and EOL treatment of a one-
time-use camera and thus can control LCE and LCC at these stages (i.e., ecol ,
fcol , eeol , and feol /, which are uncontrollable in conventional product sales
businesses. This rule is interpreted as changing a set of control parameters by
taking responsibility for the life cycle stages other than the production stage.
(B) Expansion of the business scale
As in traditional businesses, expansion of business scale reduces LCE and LCC
at the production, distribution, collection, and EOL treatment stages (eprod ,
edist , ecol , eeol , fprod , fdist , fcol , and feol /. Examples include sharing of the
logistic system (including reverse logistic system) among multiple firms. In
addition, this rule sometimes helps to improve performance fitness d because
the larger the scale of business, the easier it becomes to collect a wide variety of
users.
(C) Reutilization of wastes/use one more time
Reusable or recyclable goods and energy are sometimes thrown away because,
for instance, the amount is too small for them to be reused or recycled. If they
are used one more time, LCE and LCC at both the EOL treatment and the
production stages (eprod , eeol , fprod , and feol / are reduced. Utilization of waste
plastics as reductant in blast furnaces is an example of this rule.
(D) Utilization of knowledge and information
Utilization of knowledge and information about usage conditions can effec-
tively reduce LCE and LCC at the product use stage (euse and fuse / by
increasing the efficiency of energy and material usage. In addition, this rule also
improves product lifetime (lt) and durability (kck and c ) by providing adequate
maintenance or consultancy services on product use. Eco-drive training service
for a driver provided by an auto manufacturer is an example of this rule.
(E) Linkage and cooperation among various industries
Related to the rule Expansion of the business scale, cooperation among various
industrial sectors sometimes contributes to reduction in LCE and LCC at the
production, distribution, collection, and EOL treatment stages (eprod , edist , ecol ,
eeol , fprod , fdist , fcol , and feol /. The zero emission concept (Graedel and Allenby
1995), which aims at reutilizing wastes from a factory as resources for another
factory by organizing industrial clusters, is an example of this rule. In addition,
this rule sometimes improves utility value (kdk and d ) by creating a new
combination of services (related to the rule Combining various business values).
(F) Combining various business values
Providing multiple products/services bundled into a package sometimes im-
proves customer benefit (kck, kdk, c , and d ). In addition, product lifetime and
27 Sustainable Product Design and Development 485
LCE and LCC at the use stage (lt, euse , and fuse / can be improved by providing
products with maintenance and consultancy services.
(G) Technological innovation
Technological innovation is sometimes indispensable for implementing a busi-
ness idea described as a combination of other business rules. The overall
performance and durability of a product, and LCE and LCC at the production,
distribution, product-use, and EOL treatment stages (kdk, kck, c , d , eprod , edist ,
eeol , fprod , fdist , and feol / were improved by various technological innovations
in many cases.
(H) Outsourcing/contracting for environmental load
As eco-businesses often cover multiple life cycle stages (from cradle to grave),
firms cannot execute the entire tasks by themselves. Therefore, making the right
outsourcing decision is important for reducing LCE and LCC. Furthermore,
undertakers of the outsourcing can reduce their costs by applying the rule
Expansion of the business scale.
(I) Servicizing
Servicizing refers to selling a service or functionality rather than a product.
While the product is still owned by an eco-business provider, customers
pay for use or maintenance. E-learning and videoconference substituting for
transportation are examples of servicizing. This rule sometimes significantly
reduces LCE and LCC (euse , eprod , edist , ecol , eeol , fuse , fprod , fdist , fcol , and feol /.
(J) Timesharing
The capacity of products such as personal automobiles and industrial equip-
ment is sometimes underutilized. By encouraging users to abandon individual
ownership, more intensive utilization of products can be realized (i.e., a kind
of use-oriented PSS). This can reduce users’ procurement costs and risks for
disposal of products. Leasing and rental schemes are examples of this rule.
Assuming that m users with the same preference for a product (a and b) use the
same product in a lease and rental scheme under the same operating conditions,
kdk, kck, euse , and fuse become m kd k, m kck, m euse , and m fuse ,
respectively.
(K) Management of hidden bottlenecks
Identification and proper management of hidden environmental bottlenecks of
a user’s activities often reduce the user’s costs and environmental risks. An
example of application of this rule is the ESCO business (Edward et al. 1998),
where ESCO comprehensively manages the use of electricity by its user to save
electricity. This rule can improve the overall deterioration speed, deterioration
fitness, LCE, and LCC at the product-use and EOL treatment stages (kck, c ,
euse , eeol , fuse , and feol ).
(L) Application of cleaner methods to satisfy customer needs
Applying cleaner products or services to satisfy customer needs can improve
the environmental performance of products/services directly. Examples of this
rule include the introduction of green electricity such as photovoltaic power
generation. This rule improves LCE and LCC at the use and production stages
(euse , eprod , fuse , and fprod ).
486 S. Kondoh and N. Mishima
In addition to the 12 eco-business rules, a designer can also improve TPI through
the development of the eco-product which exhibits higher UV with lower LCE and
LCC than conventional ones. Although a product design can affect all the parameters
constructing TPI except kmc k and kmd k, the target performance specifications are
determined as a set of performance vector d and deterioration vector c in this
method. This is because the other parameters (euse , eprod , edist , ecol , eeol , fuse , fprod ,
fdist , fcol , and feol / are significantly affected by many factors other than product
design (i.e., production technology, logistic system, and user behavior).
As shown in (27.8), the higher the overall performance (kdk) becomes and the
smaller the physical deterioration speed (kck) becomes, UV of the product becomes
greater. In addition, as performance fitness (d ) reaches 0ı and deterioration fitness
(c ) reaches 90ı , the greater UV of the product becomes as described in Sect. 4.1.5.
Thus, preferential improvement of the functional performance or durability of FRs
which improves performance fitness or deterioration fitness is quite effective to
improve TPI. The designer determines each element of the performance vector d
and deterioration vector c comparing the directions of d and md and those of c and
mc , respectively.
Let assume that the designer changes the product’s performance specifications
so that d reaches 0ı without changing overall performance (kdk). TPI will be
increased by 1=cos .d /-fold as shown in ( 27.8). Note that c cannot reach 90ı
since c and mc belong to different quadrants as described in Sect. 4.1.4. Thus, the
improvement potential of deterioration vector c cannot be represented in general
form.
In order to illustrate the procedure of the TPI-based idea generation method for eco-
business planning and eco-product development, a case study of a laptop computer
business is described in this section.
(i.e., the performance of FR1: computing speed (1 GHz) was worth 58,650 yen)
and 36.95 (kJPY/GHz) for 2006. The weighting factor for FR1 is considered to
decrease due to technological innovation. Thus, the obsolescence rate of FR1 (a1 ) is
calculated as 0.45638 by substituting these two values into (27.6). Then, the value
is normalized to 0.77585 so that all elements of the performance vector d equal
to 1 as shown in the table. For the initial importance (weighting factor) of each FR
(bi ), the importance value in 2002 is used. c, which consists of deterioration rate
for six FRs, was assumed by referring to the physical lifetime of the constituent
components of similar products in the market.
LCE and LCC are assumed to be calculated as 163 (kgCO2 ) and 187 (kJPY),
respectively, in this case. Then, LCE value is converted to 0.325 (kJPY) assuming
that the price of 1 metric ton of carbon dioxide emission permits is 2,000 yen.
Product lifetime lt is assumed to be 48 months in this example. TPI was calculated
as 1911.
Figures 27.4 and 27.5 show the result of sensitivity analysis of UV and TL,
respectively. kdk, eprod , and fprod were selected as key parameters in this example.
Referring to Table 27.1, the designer selected the rules that improve the key
parameters determined in step 2. kdk can be improved by (J) Timesharing, (E)
Linkage and cooperation among various industrial sectors, (F) Combining various
business values, and (G) Technological innovation; eprod can be improved by (B)
Expansion of business scale, (C) Reutilization of waste/use one more time, (G)
Technological innovation, (H) Outsourcing, (I) Servicizing, (K) Management of
hidden bottlenecks, and (L) Application of cleaner methods to satisfy customer
needs; and fprod can be improved by (B) Expansion of business scale, (E) Linkage
and cooperation among various industrial sectors, (G) Technological innovation,
488 S. Kondoh and N. Mishima
20000
15000
10000
5000
0
||c || ||d || qc qd lt
−5000
Overall performance of
a laptop PC is the most
influential parameter. −10000
4.0E+00
3.5E+00
3.0E+00
2.5E+00
2.0E+00
1.5E+00
1.0E+00
5.0E-01
0.0E+00
euse eprod edist ecol eeol fuse fprod fdist fcol feol
(H) Outsourcing, (I) Servicizing, and (L) Application of cleaner methods to satisfy
customer needs. Referring to the eco-business case base associated with these rules,
the designer generated a business idea as follows.
27 Sustainable Product Design and Development 489
Performance fitness and deterioration fitness were calculated as 27ı and 130ı ,
respectively. Comparing the directions of md and performance vector d, the designer
noticed that enhancement of the functional performance of FR1: Computing speed
and FR5: Easily viewable was effective to improve the performance fitness. In
addition, the designer also noticed that improvement in durability of FRs other than
FR2: Compute large-capacity data contributed to the improvement of deterioration
fitness comparing the directions of mc and deterioration vector c. This is because the
product value associated with FR2: Compute large-capacity data obsoletes very fast
due to rapid technological innovation and the effect of its durability improvement is
very limited.
However, product performance specifications remained unchanged in this case
because deterioration fitness and performance fitness were not most influential
parameters.
Assuming that key parameters change as shown in Table 27.3, TPI was improved to
4,673. Thus, an approximately 2.4-fold improvement was achieved in this case.
8 Summary
References
C.Y. Baldwin, B.C. Kim, Design Rules, Volume 1: The Power of Modularity (MIT, Cambridge,
2000)
T. Daimon et al., Proposal of decision support method for life cycle strategy by estimating value
and physical lifetimes, in Proceedings of the 11th International CIRP Life Cycle Engineering
Seminar, Belgrade (2004)
L.V. Edward et al., International ESCO business opportunities and challenges: a Japanese case
study. Energy 23(6), 439–447 (1998)
M.J. Goedkoop et al., Product Service Systems, Ecological and Economic Basics. Report for the
Dutch ministries of Environment (VROM) and Economic Affairs (EZ) (1999)
T.E. Graedel, B.R. Allenby, Industrial Ecology, 1st edn. (Prentice Hall, Englewood, 1995)
P.E. Green, V. Srinivasan, Conjoint analysis in consumer research: issues and outlook. J. Consum.
Res. 5(2), 103–112 (1978)
K. Kobayashi, T. Kumazawa, A decision-making methodology for transition to reuse business. Int.
J. Environ. Technol. Manag. 7, 578–595 (2007)
S. Kondoh et al., Analysis of key success factors for eco-business through case studies in Japan, in
Proceedings of 13th CIRP International Conference on Life Cycle Engineering, Leuven (2006),
pp. 275–280
T. Sakao, M. Lindahl (ed.), Introduction to Product/Service-System Design, 1st edn. (Springer,
London, 2009)
R. Suesada et al., Development of description support system for life cycle scenario, in Advances in
Life Cycle Engineering for Sustainable Manufacturing Businesses, ed. by S. Takata, Y. Umeda
(Springer, London, 2007), pp. 29–34
Y. Umeda et al., Study on life-cycle design for the post mass production paradigm. AIEDAM 14(2),
149–161 (2000)
27 Sustainable Product Design and Development 491
UNEP, Rathenau Instituut and Delft university of Technology, Ecodesign: A Promising Approach
to Sustainable Product and Consumption. United Nations Publication, Paris (1997)
UNEP, Product Service Systems and Sustainability. Opportunities for Sustainable Solutions
(UNEP-DTIE, Paris, 2002)
A.L. White, M. Stoughton, and L. Feng, Servicizing: The Quiet Transition to Extended Product
Responsibility, Report Submitted to US Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Solid
Waste (1999)
W. Wimmer et al., Ecodesign Implementation: A Systematic Guidance on Integrating Environmen-
tal Considerations into Product Development (Springer, Dordrecht, 2004)
D.V. Winterfeld, W. Edwards, Decision Analysis and Behavioral Research (Cambridge University
Press, Cambridge, 1986)
Y. Yamagiwa, Sustainable Design. Maruzen (in Japanese), Tokyo, Japan (2004)
Structural Complexity Management
in Sustainable Engineering 28
W. Biedermann and Udo Lindemann
Abstract
Sustainable product development comprises several aspects. Beside
environmental, material, and production issues, market success and design pro-
cesses have to be taken into account. Methods for sustainable engineering have to
address all these aspects simultaneously. Structural complexity management as
a method allows for the modeling of different system aspects and their relations.
Thus, it is particularly suited for sustainable engineering by providing a means of
relating various concurrent perspectives onto a system. This chapter introduces
the basic concepts and discusses their application. The use case illustrating the
application deals with the development of a high-pressure pump.
Every system, for example, a technical product composed of parts, or a project
consisting of process steps, people, and documents, is characterized by depen-
dencies among the system’s parts. In practice, this collection of dependencies
makes systems difficult to handle and extremely complex.
Dependencies of a system form structures, such as a sequential chain of
dependencies, a loop, or a hierarchical tree. Such system structures show
characteristic behaviors in practical applications. System elements, interlocked
by dependencies in the structure of a loop, for example, may demonstrate self-
energizing or self-impeding behavior. Thus, if system structures are identified, it
is possible to predict system behavior.
A key characteristic of structural complexity management is the consideration
of multiple aspects of dependencies. Geometric and functional dependencies
between technical components, for example, can be processed jointly in order
to describe the system’s behavior. This possibility is addressed as the “multiple-
domain” approach and contrasts common “Design for X” perspectives in product
design, where the X stands for a large variety of optimization targets that do
W. Biedermann U. Lindemann
Institute of Product Development, Technische Universität München, Garching, Germany
e-mail: biedermann@pe.mw.tum.de; lindemann@pe.mw.tum.de; udo.lindemann@pe.mw.tum.de
1 Introduction
management is presented that closes the gap between the established methods and
allows the comprehensive analysis, control, and optimization of structure-based
complexity in product design. The approach contains a fundamental method and
suggests several known methods as special use cases.
The existing possibilities for interacting with complexity argue for the provision
of a systematic approach for managing complex structures in product design. The
procedure that is presented here bases on established problem-solving approaches as
provided by Daenzer and Huber, Ehrlenspiel, and Lindemann from an engineering
point of view and by Ulrich and Probst from a holistic cybernetics point of view
(Daenzer and Huber 1999, p. 96; Ehrlenspiel 2007, p. 79ff; Lindemann 2007,
p. 45ff; Ulrich and Probst 2001, p. 112ff). It enhances the systematic structure
analysis process for design structure matrices (DSMs), as proposed by Yassine et al.
(1999). Figure 28.1 shows the outline which comprises five general steps leading
from the initial problem to the improved system management or design.
The starting point can be a handling problem or a design problem. A handling
problem occurs if a product or a development process already exists, but the
demand for adaptation generates problems of system controllability. Even if a
specific adaptation request is clearly specified and appears to be simple, system
dependencies may lead to numerous subsequent adaptations (change propagation).
Such aftereffects are often unknown, and therefore not anticipated – leading to time
and resource shortages when attempting to accommodate the desired adaptation.
In order to minimize handling problems, product developers need a manual that
28 Structural Complexity Management in Sustainable Engineering 497
Handling or design
problem
System
definition
Multiple-Domain
Matrix
Information B
acquisition 3
A
1 2
Direct system
dependencies α
γ
β
Deduction of indirect
dependencies
Representation of
subsets
Structure
analysis
Significant
constellations
Product design
? ?
application
Improved system
management & design ? ? ? ?
Fig. 28.1 Procedure of the structural complexity management (based on Lindemann et al. 2009)
use cases, product structure requirements are not considered in the design process.
If systems become too complex and must be adapted, the structure management is
required. However, if product development already includes a proactive structure
development, clear design improvements can be realized, that is, less iterations
occur in comparison to passively emerged structures and change propagations are
locally restricted.
One of the central reasons for applying structural complexity management is that
handling and design problems cannot be clearly separated: If the system handling
is improved, optimization potentials may be detected that may lead to a new or
improved system design. Likewise, a system design that includes proactive structure
development also requires the handling of complex structures.
Once the type of initial problem and required solution is determined, a useful
system definition represents the first goal of the structural complexity management.
The multiple-domain matrix (MDM) serves to specify the scope of consideration
and provides the basis for all further steps of the approach. The creation of the
MDM includes the identification of required domains, the determination of system
elements and their level of detail, and the linking of dependency types, that is,
mapping logics between the domains. Generally, the objective of creating the MDM
is to identify required information sources and set up the basis for the systematic
extraction of knowledge and user access. For most analyses and optimization
scenarios, a MDM that coherently depicts information on multiple domains is
compulsory. Even if the structural complexity management in Fig. 28.1 is depicted
only as a sequential flow, iterative creation of the MDM can become necessary
in practical application. If, for example, more information on the system layout
becomes known later in the process, the suitability of the system definition, and
therefore of the MDM, has to be reviewed. A comprehensive system description
results when the MDM is compiled for a specific use case.
Based on the system definition by the MDM, information about the dependencies
between system elements has to be collected. Information may be acquired from the
existing data bases, modeling tools, or by interviews. The method depends on the use
case and availability of information. Interviews require time-consuming workshops
with experts. However, if the system in question only comprises implicitly known
experience knowledge or data that has not yet been documented, interviews are
the only way of capturing required information. The main challenge of such an
acquisition is to guarantee high data quality. This calls for applying methods,
which help to consider all relevant information and to avoid effects resulting from
symptoms of fatigue. In contrast to this, information acquisition by extraction
from available data bases or software tools seems easier, because it is partly
automatable. However, some requirements must be fulfilled in order to success-
fully interact with large amounts of data.The knowledge about the direct system
dependencies allows for deriving relevant indirect ones. Structural complexity man-
agement provides six cases for the computing. For example, a specific application
asks for the dependencies between developers due to their document exchange.
Such dependencies are indirect and are computable if the developers’ creation of
and need for documents are known. Whereas the indirect system dependencies,
for example, between people due to their document exchange, often provide the
28 Structural Complexity Management in Sustainable Engineering 499
relevant answers, it is generally easier to acquire the direct dependencies and com-
pute the indirect ones. If required data are on hand, they must be modeled in order to
allow user interaction. Requirements for preparation may include a comprehensible
visualization, possibilities of navigation in the structure, user-defined system views,
or highlighted structural characteristics. Numerous techniques are available and
chosen depending on the objective.
The structure analysis identifies the system’s characteristics, specifically by
applying the algorithmic graph theory. Several established analysis approaches
apply parts of the mathematical fundamentals, for example, matrix depictions that
are used for the identification of criteria by the realignment of rows and columns.
The structural complexity management approach integrates the available techniques
in a general methodology. Some analyses characterize the entire structure and its
behavior, whereas others deal with the structural embedding of single elements and
dependencies.
The product design application makes use of the results from system analysis
in order to provide solutions for a better handling or design of the initial problem.
In this step, a structure manual is created that provides a better understanding of
the system. Furthermore, structural optimization measures and ways to improve the
structural design are composed.
The procedure allows the systematic processing of problems of highly intercon-
nected systems. The procedure comprises several known methods but implements
them in a comprehensive approach.
In order to solve a problem resulting from structural complexity, the scope of the
system model in question must be clearly defined. This means that system domains,
the level of detail of the elements, and the meaning of the dependencies must be
determined. A clear system definition is necessary for the visual and computational
model representation and is indispensable for the application of analysis methods.
Although a multiple-domain matrix (MDM) is generally comparable to design
structure matrices (DSMs), the included items have to be defined. Figure 28.2
depicts them comprehensively. The MDM in Fig. 28.2 comprises three domains
(indicated by the red, green, and blue coloring and the circular, triangular, and square
forms of the elements). The domains represent the classification of the elements
in groups. Examples of domains are people or documents, and single elements
represent specific instances from these groups. As a MDM is a square matrix, the
order of domains as well as the order of elements within the domains is identical on
both axes. The intersections of rows and columns belonging to the same domains
represent DSM areas. Consequently, intersections of rows and columns belonging
to different domains represent domain mapping matrix (DMM) areas. Elements are
depicted in the row and column heads, and every element indicates a row and a
column of the matrix. In the intersection of both, self-reflexive dependencies, for
example, could be noted, but mostly these dependencies are not applied. Every other
intersection of a row and a column can represent a dependency between the elements
500 W. Biedermann and U. Lindemann
MDM A 1
A X DMM area
Native DMM
Domains
Logic of
indirect
dependency
1 X deduction
DSM area
Native DSM
of available analyses and possible interpretations for these network subsets, such
derived matrices are not further considered in the approach.
All items of a MDM are presented together in Fig. 28.2. With this representation,
product developers possess a solid basis for systematic depiction and consideration
of comprehensive information for complex interrelated structures. As different kind
of elements and dependencies are not merged in the subsets of a MDM, user-defined
computational analyses can be applied depending on the specific requirements.
This use case illustrates the development of high-pressure pumps and focuses
on solving a design problem. The aim was to optimize product structures of
several pump concepts. The optimization of the pump concepts was implemented
by modularization. The background motivation was improved integration of the
optimized pumps in a modular design concept. The optimization potentials had
to be incorporated into the creation of a new generation of pumps. The product
structure had never explicitly been considered before but had instead remained a
passive consequence of the design process.
High-pressure pumps (see Fig. 28.3) are a significant component of common rail
diesel systems. The main function of a high-pressure pump is to deliver a defined
quantity of fuel at the required pressure level. The pump contains a high level
of complexity, as several functions have to be fulfilled. One function considered
Fig. 28.3 High-pressure pump in a common rail system (based on Lindemann et al. 2009)
502 W. Biedermann and U. Lindemann
to be the primary driver behind the complexity is providing the interface between the
pump and the customer’s engine, that means designing the inlet and outlet of fuel,
the electrical control unit for metering the low pressure fuel inlet quantity, the high-
pressure fuel outlet, and so on. The properties of the high-pressure pump have to be
adapted to the specific requirements of each customer, which means implementing
changes to a complex system and managing the resulting consequences.
The primary goal of the tier one supplier was to meet the challenge of delivering
highly customized products while reducing the number of component variants.
The procedure of structural complexity management was applied to improve the
product design to better manage the increasing variety of customer requirements.
In general, modularity is a design approach aiming at assembling many products
out of as few individual components or subassemblies. The building blocks of
a modular system should be ordered by their function and possess standardized
interfaces. A modular design concept then serves to control increasing complexity
and diversity to product variants. It reduces the internal diversity in product variants
and at the same time maintains or increases the external diversity of variants from
the customer’s perspective. Synergy effects are achievable in design, procurement,
quality assurance, and assembly which are typical for sustainable designs.
CO has
geometric or CO has
Components CO implicates
spatial CO serves FU influence on
CO PBC
dependency FE
to CO
FU requires
Functions
--- FU (functional --- ---
FU
modeling)
FE has
FE has
Features influence on FE implicates
--- influence on
FE CO PBC
FE
= (CO→FE)T
PBC
Production PBC
determines PBC has
boundary determines FE
CO --- influence on
conditions (production
(production PBC
PBC constraint)
constraint)
No data available/required
Fig. 28.4 Domains and types of dependencies in the MDM (based on Lindemann et al. 2009)
The next project step identified and documented the elements within the domains
and their dependencies for several families of high-pressure pumps. This informa-
tion acquisition was carried out in workshops by interviewing the experts from the
involved departments. In total, more than 200 system elements were considered with
regard to their dependencies. Due to the large number of elements and dependencies,
software support was indispensable for acquisition and documentation. In addi-
tion, two moderators were required to ensure that the workshop ran efficiently.
504 W. Biedermann and U. Lindemann
The acquired information then served as a basis for visualization and analysis of
the complexity framework of the high-pressure pumps.
The following steps were taken with the MDM during the data acquisition. It
is usually recommended that the functions are examined first in order to gain a
quick overview of the functionality of a product. This was put into practice by
creating a functional model. A flow-oriented functional model was chosen. The
central flow was the substance flow of the diesel fuel. Energy flows and signal flows
are connected to this. The next step recorded the geometric dependencies between
components. These dependencies of geometry and package were most easily
determined using construction drawings and models. Then the DMMs connecting
components with functions and components with features were determined. These
can easily be filled in column by column. Thus, for each component, it is necessary
to determine what functions it contributes to and what product features it influences.
The information collection was carried out very efficiently thanks to several
favorable conditions. First of all, the expert software LOOMEO was deployed.
LOOMEO provides a specialized mode for data acquisition in matrices. The
possibility, in particular, to mark edges already discussed (see gray-shaded cells
in Fig. 28.5), prevents the work from being conducted twice. It was also particularly
important to have hand models, such as a rapid prototyping model of the drilling in
the pump housing and drawings of the pump concepts on hand at all times so that
discussions about ambiguous dependencies could be conducted extremely quickly
with direct reference to the object in question, enabling the resulting dependencies
to be rapidly identified.
Upon completion of the system definition, a knowledge network of high value
was achieved, which contained the complex dependencies of all elements in the
considered domains of the high-pressure pumps. Even information of nonexisting
edges in the matrix was kept in mind: It was often the case that the outcome of
a discussion concluded that a certain dependency did not exist. The reasoning for
this nonexistence of a dependency was recorded as commentary in the matrix as an
“edge detail” of this matrix cell, just like all other commentaries of existing edges.
The acquired dependency networks were then applied to deduce specific system
views. Figure 28.6 shows dependency views of the product structure (dependencies
between components) of one specific family of high-pressure pumps. Besides the
view of direct geometric dependencies, these views represent dependencies between
components that result from indirect dependencies by functions and features. As, for
example, denoted in Fig. 28.6 for geometric component dependencies, these views
will be considered for identifying specific clusters for modularization purposes in
later project stages.
For this purpose, the deduction of indirect dependencies was applied to derive
the views of dependencies between components. The deduction of dependencies
describes the procedure for computing dependencies between elements within
28 Structural Complexity Management in Sustainable Engineering 505
CO has
geometric or CO has
Components CO implicates
spatial CO serves FU influence on
CO PBC
dependency FE
to CO
FU requires
Functions
--- FU (functional --- ---
FU
modeling)
FE has
FE has
Features influence on FE implicates
--- influence on
FE CO PBC
T FE
= (CO→ FE)
PBC
Production PBC
determines PBC has
boundary determines FE
CO --- influence on
conditions (production
(production PBC
PBC constraint)
constraint)
Fig. 28.5 Information acquisition with LOOMEO (based on Lindemann et al. 2009)
one specific domain due to dependency chains leading through further domains.
The deduction of dependencies was applied especially to determine and visualize
the dependencies of components from the point of view of functional and feature-
based relationships. These kinds of dependencies within the components of the
high-pressure pumps are particularly relevant for modularization.
Figure 28.7 shows how the component networks were computed by applying
the MDM. For example, an indirect functional dependency is computed between
506 W. Biedermann and U. Lindemann
• functional
Product structure of high
view
pressure pump from a:
• geometric
view
• feature
view
Example:
Modularization of geometric
component dependencies using
cluster analysis
Fig. 28.6 Views of the product structure (based on Lindemann et al. 2009)
two components whenever both of them depend on at least one common function.
Thereby a weighting of the computed indirect dependencies is obtained. The more
functions two components have in common, the more heavily their computed
indirect functional dependency is weighted.
The objective of the analysis was to find modular structures, that is, the aim was
to find substructures which contained elements that were highly interlinked but
linked as little as possible to other elements or substructures. The structural attribute
“cluster” is suitable for identifying such modules. The structure analysis focused on
identifying clusters in the various dependency networks.
Carrying out a cluster analysis does not usually work by simply pressing a button
and starting a cluster algorithm in a software. The identification of clusters, and
respectively the separation of individual clusters, is rarely clear-cut. In most cases,
28 Structural Complexity Management in Sustainable Engineering 507
HPP family 1 CO FU FE
CO has
Components
CO serves FU influence on
CO
FE
FU requires
Functions FU
--- ---
FU (functional
modeling)
FE has
FE has
Features influence on
--- influence on
FE CO
FE
= (CO→FE)T
CO 2 CO 2 CO 2
FU 1 FE 1
CO 1 CO 1 CO 1
Fig. 28.7 Deduction of different component dependency networks (based on Lindemann et al.
2009)
508 W. Biedermann and U. Lindemann
Cluster analysis in
case of consideration
of all elements
Fine adjustment
Leaf nodes
Transit nodes
Fig. 28.8 Fine adjustments during the cluster analysis of geometric dependencies (based on
Lindemann et al. 2009)
Likewise, the significance of leaf and transit nodes becomes clear only in
combination with understanding the abstract structure in Fig. 28.10. Leaf nodes are
only connected to a single other node. Hence, they only possess one interface to the
rest of the structure. Transit nodes are connected to two components and, therefore,
possess only two interfaces to the rest of the structure. Leaf and transit nodes were
used as structural characteristics for identifying elements with a high potential for
being applied as carry-over parts.
Modular structures in products are characterized by the fact that they behave in a
modular manner not only with regard to one specific dependency type, for example,
geometric dependencies, as already depicted in Fig. 28.8, but as described in the
preceding explanations, this modular behavior has to be present in all views. Thus
the different views determined within the scope of the dependency deduction have
to be placed over each other to find an optimum for modularization that takes the
whole system into account. Not until the views of modular behavior correspond to
each other and can be proven in an aggregated view, can substantial modules be
built.
For carrying out the cluster analysis in the aggregated view, functional dependen-
cies between components play a decisive role and are thus chosen as a starting point
for cluster analysis, as shown in Figs. 28.9 and 28.12. The matrix comprising depen-
dencies within components due to functional reasons was reordered until clusters of
highly linked elements could be found. Then the same arrangement of components
was applied to the other matrices (representing geometric component dependencies
and component dependencies due to features). This procedure identified whether
dependencies due to features and geometry agreed with or differed from the clusters
formed due to functional dependencies. The evaluation of the identified clusters was
carried out in the following phase of product design application.
The next step in structural complexity management is to apply the findings of the
structural analysis conducted to the practical product design application. The results
of the structure analysis on hand were then discussed with design experts in the
product design application phase.
Each product is characterized by the implicit structures it embodies. So, in order
to be able to make suggestions for its improvement, it is necessary to first understand
its structural composition. Here, this understanding initially had to be created in
order to be able to make relevant statements about approaches to modularization.
The individual views as well as the aggregated component network generated from
placing various views over each other enabled the fundamental structure depicted in
Fig. 28.10 to be recognized.
The fundamental structure of the different pump families shows a specific
structural platform containing platform elements and platform modules as well as
coupling elements and modules. In its original sense, a platform can be described as
elements or subsystems that together form a common basis from which individual
510 W. Biedermann and U. Lindemann
Fig. 28.9 Superposition of component dependencies from different point of views (based on
Lindemann et al. 2009)
products can be derived. According to Schuh and Schwenk, the aim is to identify
those components, interfaces, and functions that can be combined over an entire
product family and are as stable as possible over time (Schuh and Schwenk 2001,
p. 87). From a structural point of view (see the graph representations in Figs. 28.10
and 28.11), the platform elements correspond to those elements that are located
in the core of the structure and possess numerous dependencies on the outlying
elements. Modular substructures can be identified within the platform as well as in
the platform surrounding.
As illustrated in Fig. 28.11, in this case, for each pump family, specific elements
can be identified, which should be applied as platform elements. They form the
specific structural core of each pump family and cannot be deployed outside their
family since the families differ too much. The claim within the pump families is
then to implement the platform elements with a maximum of robustness, so that they
remain unchanged in case of adaptation. It is recommended that those components,
in particular, whose development costs and quality control costs are relatively
28 Structural Complexity Management in Sustainable Engineering 511
Structural platform
Platform element
Platform element
Platform element
Platform module
Fig. 28.10 Identified fundamental structure of the different pump families (based on Lindemann
et al. 2009)
high, should be applied as platform elements. Thereby, these costs are distributed
over the higher quantities of the platform elements and sink proportionally. Single
components as well as identifiable modules of components that connect to the
platform with only a few dependencies (leaf and transit nodes) are especially suited
as carry-over parts.
In order to transfer the results from structure analysis to practical product design
application, the next step is to investigate the structures in detail. After a full
understanding of the background of the fundamental structure is in place, the
identified clusters, especially the cluster boundaries, have to be discussed. This has
to be done with the product design experts. It is important for building modules
to fix clusters that are formed from the aggregation of all the views involved. It is
necessary to determine in which cases such aggregated modules can be built, and in
which cases single geometric dependencies or dependencies due to features have to
be eliminated. In this way, any changes to the product structure can be generated in
order to optimize the overall high-pressure pump structure.
512 W. Biedermann and U. Lindemann
Edge coloring:
Platform element
• Red: functional dependency
Fig. 28.11 Application of fundamental structure to specific pump family (functional dependen-
cies considered) (based on Lindemann et al. 2009)
Optimization procedure:
1. Identification of clusters in aggregated view
→ deduction of aggregated modules in
product structure
2. Targeted elimination of dependencies due
to geometry and features
→ clear-cut modules
Geometric
dependencies
to be eliminated
Aggregated
module
Dependencies
due to features
to be eliminated
Fig. 28.12 Management of dependencies that augment the functional view (based on Lindemann
et al. 2009)
2. Drillings were assessed as dependent on each other if it was possible that they
“got in each other’s way” for certain pump layouts. For this case, corridors can
be defined, within which these drillings are allowed to vary.
3. A constructive possibility can be determined in which the geometric variation of
a drilling no longer has any influence on the other drilling.
Surprisingly, it is extremely rare that no ideas or solutions for dependency
elimination exist in the company. Rather, developers had no idea how to deploy
them because of the dependencies and the consequences they caused. In the drilling
case described, a constructive solution is the formation of a ring canal. One of the
drillings can vary arbitrarily in the circumference direction of the ring canal without
a dependency occurring.
The modularization of individual pump families provides the basis for the
identification of the potential for carry-over parts (COPs), which is the next step
for defining an efficient set of modules. The specifications of the interfaces have to
be carried out not only for one product family but for all families examined in order
to be able to identify overlapping potential for carry-over parts.
Figure 28.13 shows the product structures of two pump families (family 1 and
family 2) that were both analyzed by the approach, applying the geometric and
functional dependencies. In the figure, red indicates functional dependencies, dark
red indicates the parallel appearance of functional and geometric dependencies, and
blue indicates geometric dependencies between components. COPs can be identified
by comparing the structural embedding of corresponding components or component
modules.
A component or component module can be identified as a carry-over part if its
functional embedding is identical in both pump families and its interfering geo-
metric dependencies can be eliminated (e.g., by defining a standardized geometric
interface for both pump families). Of course, the dependencies between components
that result from shared features also have to be checked. For instance, a potential
carry-over part, a “metering unit,” would have to provide the required features (e.g.,
a maximum metering quantity) in every family of high-pressure pumps. Finally,
the underlying production boundary conditions, the fourth domain in the MDM in
Fig. 28.4, allow an overall economic assessment of carry-over parts.
A proposition for alternative modules in a modular design concept can finally be
derived by considering the following aspects:
• Modularization of high-pressure pump families from different views
• Aggregation of different views and analysis of structural embedding of compo-
nents and identified component modules
• Identification of potential carry-over parts by structural comparison of different
families of high-pressure pumps
Figure 28.14 shows how the components find their way into the modular design
system. They can be deployed in more or fewer pump families according to the
composition of the modules. The platform elements or platform modules are specific
to the pump concept, as shown.
The required differentiation of products of a modular design system should
generally be carried out with cost-effective, adaptable modules. Furthermore, it is
28 Structural Complexity Management in Sustainable Engineering 515
Fig. 28.13 Structural comparison of two families of high-pressure pumps for identification of
COP potential (based on Lindemann et al. 2009)
recommended that the drivers behind the variants are implemented as adaptable
modules that are specific to their function.
The application of structural complexity management allows for a better handling
of high complexity in the development of common rail high-pressure pumps.
516 W. Biedermann and U. Lindemann
HPP family 1
Integration of HPP families in
modular design concept:
• Functional component modules as
starting point
• Comparison of product structures
• Elimination of interfering
dependencies
COP
element
HPP family 2
COP
module
COP
Module
COP
Element
Module
4 Summary
The procedure introduced for the structural complexity management allows the
systematic processing of highly interconnected systems. The procedure comprises
several known methods but implements them in a comprehensive approach. The
procedure uses MDMs as fundamental system representation which comprises
DSMs and DMMs. With this representation form, product developers possess a solid
basis for systematic depiction and consideration of comprehensive information for
complex interrelated structures. As different kinds of elements and dependencies
are not merged in the subsets of a MDM, user-defined computational analyses can
be applied depending on the specific requirements.
The application of structural complexity management allows for a better handling
of high complexity in the development of common rail high-pressure pumps.
Product structures of different families of high-pressure pumps have been acquired,
visualized, and analyzed from different relevant views. These views of component
dependencies have been derived from the MDM initially described. The resulting
modularization advice and design recommendations have been derived by cluster
analysis of single and aggregated views. The aim of the modularization was a shift
and encapsulation of dependencies, and thereby also of complexity in modules as
independent of each other as possible. The physical and functional interfaces could
be optimized through a discussion of the structure analysis results with the experts.
The consideration of a significant part of the subsequent process chain becomes
feasible by incorporating dependencies due to features and dependencies due to
production boundaries. All that and especially the identification of potential for
carry-over parts leads to gains from economies of scale and forms the basis for
an optimized modular design concept.
Bases on the structural considerations concepts for sustainable pumps were
developed. The concept focuses on platforms, modules, and carry-over parts.
Consequent implementation of the concepts increases the sustainability of the
pumps, their development, and their productions. This is achieved by reducing the
internal variety and thus complexity of the pump design which results in reduced
efforts for design, production, procurement, and quality assurance.
References
W.F. Daenzer, F. Huber, Systems Engineering: Methodik und Praxis, 10th edn. (Verl. Industrielle
Organisation, Zürich, 1999)
K. Ehrlenspiel, Integrierte Produktentwicklung – Methoden für Prozessorganisation, Produkter-
stellung und Konstruktion, 3rd edn. (Hanser, München, 2007)
W. Kersten, Vielfaltsmanagement: Integrative Lösungsansätze zur Optimierung und Beherrschung
der Produkte und Teilevielfalt. München: TCW Transfer-Centrum 2002. (TCW-Report, Nr. 31)
M. Kreimeyer, U. Lindemann, Complexity Metrics in Engineering Design – Managing the
Structure of Design Processes (Springer, Berlin, 2011)
U. Lindemann, Methodische Entwicklung Technischer Produkte, 2nd edn. (Springer, Berlin, 2007)
U. Lindemann, M. Maurer, T. Braun, Structural Complexity Management – An Approach for the
Field of Product Design (Springer, Berlin, 2009)
518 W. Biedermann and U. Lindemann
Abstract
The term “Sustainable manufacturing” has gained increased attention in recent
years. In establishing sustainability in the manufacturing industries, ecodesign
of products is important. It is also important to focus on developing and
implementing actual manufacturing technologies. Requirements for practical
manufacturing technologies include satisfying high quality, low cost, and low
environmental impact simultaneously. Environmental issues are very important;
however, quality is the key feature in deciding whether the developed manu-
facturing technologies will be used in the industries. It is not easy to satisfy
the three aspects, since there are trade-offs among the three aspects. However,
breakthroughs in material technologies and fabrication technologies can be the
key factors in making manufacturing technologies industrially feasible. In the
first part of this chapter, several new material technologies and fabrication
technologies are discussed in order to satisfy high quality, low cost, and low
environmental impact simultaneously.
A method called “total performance analysis (TPA)” enabled product devel-
oper to quantify the value, life cycle cost, and life cycle environmental impact of
a product, or its eco-efficiency. Since the TPA method can take three aspects of
a product into account, it is envisaged suitable method for the evaluation of the
eco-efficiency of the manufacturing technologies. Thus, to some extent, the TPA
method can be applied to evaluate manufacturing technologies in the minimal
manufacturing area. Although developing actual manufacturing technologies
is the most important part of the minimal manufacturing, recognizing that
individual technologies are really “minimal” and industrially feasible is also
important. The TPA method was also applied to find an improvement target in
the manufacturing processes.
N. Mishima
Graduate School of Engineering and Resource Sceince, Akita University, Akita, Akita, Japan
e-mail: nmishima@gipc.akita-u.ac.jp
In the second half of this chapter, the TPA method was applied to an
innovative manufacturing process making ceramic products. In the example,
an improved method of making ceramic heat radiation plate made by silicon
nitride is analyzed and discussed. In the new process, by applying improved
manufacturing technology called “reactive sintering,” the energy consumption
and the cost of the total process were greatly reduced. The reduction of the
energy consumption is the main contribution in enhancing the eco-efficiency in
this case. Another example deals with the improvement in eco-efficiency which
mainly depends on enhancement of product functionality. Throughout the case
studies, the “total performance analysis” is proven effective in identifying the
bottlenecks of manufacturing processes and visualizing the effect of process
improvements.
1 Introduction
UV
TPI D p p (29.1)
LCC LCE
Where
TPI: Total performance indicator
UV: Utility value of the product
LCC: Life cycle cost of the product
LCE: Life cycle environmental impact of the product
defined by (29.2). The equation expresses the balance of the product value created
by the process versus the cost and the environmental impact necessary to fabricate
the product.
V
TPIprocess D i Dn (29.2)
Pp
MCEi MCCi
i D1
Where
TPIprocess : total performance indicator
V: Market price of the product or the part
MCCi : cost of the ith segment process
n: number of segment processes
MCEi : environmental impact of the ith segment process
In the manufacturing stage, it is usually difficult to know the life cycle facts of the
product such as the obsolescence rate, etc. Thus, in order to simplify the expression,
replacing the utility value by the market value of the product is proposed. The market
value can be measured by market price when the product is commercially available.
Then, (29.3) shows the simplified TPI of each segment process.
Numerator “Vi ” in (29.3) may vary due to process quality. For example, a
manufacturing process with higher profile accuracy may have higher value than
a similar manufacturing process with lower quality. Manufacturing quality also
has a strong relationship between cost and environmental impact of the process.
For example, it is known that the cost and environmental impact of machining
vary due to cutting conditions, and usually they are larger when the manufacturing
quality is higher. In addition, for these reasons, in evaluating the manufacturing
processes, it is necessary to consider the value of the segment process versus the
cost and environmental impact concurrently. It is possible to quantify how the target
manufacturing process is environmentally effective by calculating TPIsegment from
(29.3).
Vi
TPIith segment D p (29.3)
MCEi MCCi
Where
TPIith segment : total performance indicator of the ith segment process
Vi : value of the product or part added by the ith segment process
The relationship among the original definition of TPI, TPI of the total manufacturing
process, and TPI of the ith segment processes are shown in Fig. 29.2.
V
TPI of the total process
UV (area)
UVi
Original product value Modified value
1-2:Manufactring
quality enhancement
1-1:Reduction of Process B
environmental impact
ΔUVi 2:Alternative
process
combination
PE ⋅ PC
requirements and quality characteristics are shown in Table 29.1. Price of the filter
unit is assumed to be 20,000 yen.
Applying the QFD method (Akao 1990; Kondoh et al. 2007), it is possible to clarify
importance of each functional requirement of a DPF. Five functional requirements
(FR) and twelve quality characteristics of the filter have been set. Table 29.1 shows
the importance of each functional requirement to the customers. It also indicated
allocation of each functional requirement to the defined quality characteristics. By
considering the importance of each FR, it is possible to determine the value of FRs
among the total value of the product (20,000 yen). The chosen FRs are all important.
In other words, only important functional requirements were chosen. Therefore, the
analysis suggests that the value of every FR occupies one fifth of the total value of
the DPF.
The second step of the analysis is to know the contribution of each segment process
to the value creation. By identifying the relationship between each segment process
composing of the total manufacturing process and quality characteristics, it is
possible to calculate the value of the segment processes. The total manufacturing
process of the DPF was divided into six segment processes. They are “mixture,”
“ball milling,” “injection molding,” “binder removal,” “sintering,” and “bonding
of honeycomb unit.” Table 29.2 shows the calculation result of the process value.
526 N. Mishima
Table 29.1 Relation between functional requirements and quality characteristics of a ceramic
DPF
Functional
requirements
Reliablity (crack-free)
Product longevity
Total
Importance of functional
9 9 9 9 9 54
requirements
Value of functional requirements
(K yen) 4 4 4 4 4 20
Thermal conductivity 9 9
Coefficient of thermal 9 9
expansion
Thermal endurance 3 3 9 15
Quality characteristics of DPF
Pore rate 9 9 18
Specific heat capacity 9 9
Uniformity of distribution of 3 3 6
pores
Average diameter of pores 3 3
Surface activity of the 0
material
Mechanical strength 3 3
Profile accuracy (length) 9 3 12
Profile accuracy (section) 9 3 12
Uniformity of the material
9 3 12
composition
33
15
12
21
36
108
“Value of the segment process” in Table 29.2 was calculated by allocating value
of each functional requirement corresponding to the strength of the relation shown
in Table 29.1. “Environmental impact of the segment process” was estimated by
29 Sustainable Production: Eco-efficiency of Manufacturing Process 527
Table 29.2 Relation between quality characteristics and manufacturing (segment) processes
Segment process
Injection molding
Binder removal
Ball milling
Sintering
Total
Thermal conductivity 1 9 3 12
Coefficient of thermal
1 9 3 12
expansion
Thermal endurance 2.8 9 3 1 1 14
Pore rate 3.5 9 3 1 1 1 15
Quality characteristics of DPF
Specific heat
3 9 9
capacity
Uniformity of 1.2 1 3 3 3 1 11
distribution of pores
Average diameter of
0.4 9 3 12
pores
Surface activity of
0 3 1 1 1 6
the material
Mechanical strength 1 3 3 3 3 1 13
Profile accuracy
1.4 9 3 1 13
(length)
Profile accuracy
1.4 9 3 1 13
(section)
Uniformity of the
3.3 3 3 1 7
material composition
Value allocated to segment
20
8.95
5.72
1.38
2.41
1.25
0.29
process (k JPY)
Yield rate of the process
0.99
0.95
0.95
0.95
0.6
0.8
2.29
1.18
0.28
17.1
1.1
(k JPY)
Estimated environmental
0.1
5
1
1
8
9
1
1
process (k JPY)
528 N. Mishima
As indicated in Table 29.2, the values of the quality characteristics are calculated
first. The result shows that several characteristics such as “pore rate,” “specific heat
capacity,” etc. occupy relatively large portion of the value. Therefore, it is assumed
that a segment process contributing to achieve these quality characteristics has a
high value.
In an actual manufacturing process, the output of a certain process is usually
the input of the next process. These intermediate properties often do not affect the
quality of the final product but does affect following process. For example, ball-
milled slurry often has rather high viscosity and causes relatively big shrinkage
during “sintering.” Although the viscosity of the slurry will be meaningless after
“binder removal,” it strongly affects the quality of “sintering” and mechanical
properties of the product. It is necessary to consider these interactions between
segment processes. In order to express the fact that quality of the segment process
affects next segment process, “yield rate” is introduced. In the DPF example process,
“ball milling” has relatively low yield rate. It means that there are some uncertainties
in this process and some of the intermediate products of “ball milling” do not satisfy
the requirements of “sintering.” The low yield rate is reflected in Table 29.2 as the
“real value” of the segment process.
Since this manufacturing process is a practical process used in industry, it is
possible to measure the environmental impact and cost of each segment process.
However, since the purpose of this chapter is to introduce a procedure to evaluate
total performance of the manufacturing process and obtain suggestions for the
process improvement, showing only the example of the improvement should be
sufficient. Therefore, value, environmental impact and cost were roughly assumed.
By using the calculated value, assumed environmental impact, and cost, TPI of
segment processes can be calculated.
TPI graph can be drawn using the value, cost, and environmental impact of the
manufacturing process. Figure 29.5 is the TPI graph of the original manufacturing
process of the DPF. The solid line indicates unadjusted value after the corresponding
segment processes. The dotted line shows adjusted value when interactions between
segment processes are considered by introducing “yield rate.” A slope of a segment
line shows TPI of the corresponding segment process. A slope of the line connecting
between the starting point and the endpoint of the lines indicates TPI of the total
process. Comparing to the TPI of the total process, segment processes “binder
29 Sustainable Production: Eco-efficiency of Manufacturing Process 529
Unadjusted value
Real value
25
bonding of honeycomb unit
Value (K yen) 20 injection molding
15 ball
milling sintering
10 binder
mixture removal
5
0
0 5 10 15 20
(PE*PC)0.5
removal” and “sintering” have lower TPI, and the other processes have relatively
higher TPI. This is because “binder removal” and “sintering” need temperature
increase of the material using a furnace, which consumes large amount of electricity.
In addition, “binder removal” emits hazardous substances due to organic binder
material. Cost of elimination of the substances is considered in the cost of the
segment process.
Table 29.3 Process value, cost, and environmental impact of the new process
Segment process
Sintering
Total
Value of the process (K yen)
8.95
6.44
1.47
2.49
1.33
21
Yield rate of the process
0.99
0.95
0.8
0.95
0.95
0.95
-
Real value of the process
8.86
6.12
1.17
2.37
1.26
0.31
(K yen) 20.1
process (kg-CO2/unit)
had low viscosity and low reflocculation property had very high relative density and
showed very small shrinkage during sintering. Because of small shrinkage, yield
rate of the milling process will be greatly improved. A new fabrication procedure
with these new processes was named “compact process.” As a result of applying
“compact process,” both “ball milling” and “binder removal” were replaced by more
environmentally benign processes. The TPA approach should be able to explain the
effect of the improvement and to suggest the next target for the process renovation.
Table 29.3 shows the value, yield rate, cost, and environmental impact of the
improved manufacturing process. As it was mentioned earlier, “ball milling” was
replaced by “wet jet milling.” “Binder removal” segment process was improved to
reduce the amount of organic binder consumed, which contributed to the reduction
of the cost and environmental impact of the segment process. These improvements
are indicated as shadowed area in Table 29.3. Value of the other processes was
also improved. Since the yield rate of “jet milling” is high, value of every process
after “jet milling” was also enhanced. Figure 29.6 is the TPI plot of the improved
process corresponding to the improved values, costs, and environmental impacts in
Table 29.4. The solid line corresponds to the TPI of the improved process, and the
dotted line shows TPI of the original process shown in Fig. 29.5
The effect of “wet jet milling” and “improved binder removal” were simulated
in the TPI plot. It tells us that the TPI of the total manufacturing process was
29 Sustainable Production: Eco-efficiency of Manufacturing Process 531
Improved process
Old process
25
bonding of honeycomb unit
20
improved binder
Value (K yen)
removal
15 sintering
wet jet
injection
10 milling
molding
5
mixture
0
0 5 10 15 20
(PE*PC)0.5
Importance
customers
FR(kJPY)
Value of
= FRVi
= ui /T
(ratio)
= ui
FR4 Resistance
capability against 5 0.14 0.6
atmosphere
greatly improved. It is helpful to see that the new manufacturing process was
more environmentally benign and cost-effective and had higher quality than the
conventional manufacturing process. Without calculating the TPI, it is difficult to
know the improvement in cost, environmental impact, and quality simultaneously.
The analysis also pointed out that next improvement target is “sintering” since
theprocess has large environmental impact. In fact, improvement of “sintering” by
using microwave (Sato et al. 2007) has been proposed already.
532 N. Mishima
Like the first case study, by applying the QFD method, it is possible to clarify the
importance of each functional requirement of a heat radiation plate. Five functional
requirements (FR) were set. Table 29.4 shows how each functional requirement is
important to the customers. It also indicates the calculated price of each functional
requirement. Total price of the product (assumed to be 4.2 k JPY/kg) was allocated
to the functional requirements corresponding to the importance of FRs. The value
of each functional requirement can be calculated based on (29.4).
Where
FRVi : value of the ith functional requirement
V: value of the product
ui : importance of the ith FR
T: sum of the importance of all functional requirements
The second step of the analysis is to determine the contribution of each segment
process to the monetary value of each quality characteristics. By identifying
the relationship between segment processes of the total process and the quality
characteristics, it is possible to calculate the value of the segment processes. The
total manufacturing process was divided into six individual processes. The value of
each segment process is expressed by (29.5). Table 29.5 shows the results of the
calculation of the segment process value.
29 Sustainable Production: Eco-efficiency of Manufacturing Process 533
n
X
QVk D Vi .wi;k =Ti / (29.5)
i D1
Where
QVk : value of the kth quality characteristics
n: number of the functional requirements
Vi : value of the ith FR
wi;k : importance of the kth quality characteristics on the ith FR
Ti : sum of the importance of all the quality characteristics on the ith FR
The third step of the analysis is to determine the contribution of each segment
process to the realization of the quality characteristics of the product. Like the
first example, the value of each segment process is calculated for the six segment
processes of the manufacturing of a ceramic heat radiation plate including “material
supply,” “mixture,” “sheet forming,” “binder removal,” “sintering,” and “grinding.”
Table 29.6 shows the result of the calculation of the process value based on (29.6).
m
X
PVj D QVk .xj;k =Sk / (29.6)
kD1
Where
PVj : value of the jth segment process
xj;k : importance of the kth quality characteristics on the jth segment process
534 N. Mishima
characteristics (kJPY)
Resistance capability
Smooth and parallel
against atmosphere
Electric insulation
Value of quality
Hard-to-failure
capability
surface
= QVk
Value of FR
1.2 0.6 1.2 0.6 0.6 4.2
(kJPY) = FRVi
Heat
10 1.2
conductivity
Mechanical
10 1 1 0.37
strength
Quality characteristics of DPF
Fracture 10 1 1 0.37
toughness
Insulation 10 1 0.64
resistance
Dielectric
breakdown 10 1 0.64
strength
Surface 10 0.27
flatness
Surface 10 0.27
roughness
Corrosion 10 0.43
resistance
Sum of
importance
of all the
quality 10 20 20 22 14
characteristic
on the ith
FR = Ti
characetrsitics on the
sum of importance of
characteristics= QVk
Value of quality
Binder removal
processes =Sk
jth segment
Sintering
Grinding
Mixture
Heat 16
1.2 10 3 0 0 3 0
conductivity
Mechanical 20
0.37 3 3 1 3 10 0
strength
Quality characteristics of DPF
Fracture 0.37 3 1 3 10 0 20
toughness 3
Insulation 0.64 10 3 0 3 3 0 19
resistance
Dielectric 19
breakdown 0.64 10 3 0 3 3 0
strength
Surface 0.27 1 3 10 0 1 10 25
flatness
Surface 0.27 1 3 0 0 1 10 15
roughness
Corrosion 0.43 1 1 1 3 3 19
10
resistance
Value of the jth
1.80
0.64
0.17
0.34
0.89
0.36
segment process
(kJPY) = PVj
Table 29.7 Environmental impact and cost of the segment manufacturing processes
Segment process
Binder removal
Sheet forming
Material spply
Sintering
Grinding
Mixture
Total
Value of the
1.80
0.64
0.17
0.34
0.89
0.36
4.2
process
(kJPY)
Environmental
5
0.2
0.1
0.5
13.8
impact of the
process
(kg-CO2/kg)
Cost of the
1.1
0.4
0.8
0.2
0.6
0.8
3.9
process
(kJPY)
536 N. Mishima
Value increase
5
grinding
4 sheet forming
Value (K yen)
sintering
3
mixture
2 binder
material removal
supply
1
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
0.5
(MCE*MCC)
Corrosion resistance
Insulation resistance
Mechanical strength
Fracture toughness
Surface roughness
Heat conductivity
Surface flatness
SSN 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
Improved
(SRBS 1.2 0.9 1 2.0 2.0 1 1 1.1
N)
Corrosion resistance
Insulation resistance
Mechanical strength
Fracture toughness
Surface roughness
Heat conductivity
Surface flatness
SSN 1.2 .37 .37 .64 .64 .27 .27 .43
SRSBN 1.4 .33 .37 1.3 1.3 .27 .27 .47
Table 29.10 Value, environmental impact, and cost of the improved segment manufacturing
processes
Segment process
Binder removal
Sheet forming
Material spply
Sintering
Grinding
Mixture
Total
Value of the
2.62
0.89
0.17
0.53
1.12
0.36
5.69
new process
(kJPY)
Environmental
1
0.2
0.1
0.5
11.8
impact
(kg-CO2/kg)
0.2
0.4
0.8
0.2
1.6
0.8
4.0
Cost (kJPY)
4 Summary
Old process
New Process
6
sheet forming
5
grinding
Value (K yen)
4
sintering
3
mixture
2 binder removal
material
1 supply
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
(MCE*MCC)0.5
References
K. Akao, Quality Function Deployment (Productivity Process, Cambrige, 1990)
H. Hyuga et al., Mater. Lett. 62, 3475 (2008)
S. Kondoh et al., J. Adv. Mech. Des. Syst. Manuf. 1(1), 181 (2007)
S. Kondoh, K. Masui, M. Hattori, N. Mishima, M. Matsumoto, Int. J. Prod. Dev. 6(3/4), 334 (2008)
S. Kondoh et al., Int. J. Autom. Technol. 3(1), 56 (2009)
540 N. Mishima
N. Mishima, Journal of Japan society for Precision Engineering, 77(3), 245(2011). (In Japanese)
N. Omura et al., J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 89(9), 2738 (2006)
K. Sato et al., J. Ceram. Soc. Jpn. 113(10), 687 (2005)
K. Sato et al., J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 90(4), 1319 (2007)
Y. Zhou et al., Int. J. Appl. Ceram. Technol. 5(2), 119 (2008)
X.W. Zhu et al., J. Mater. Res. 19(11), 3270 (2004)
X.W. Zhu et al., J. Am. Ceram. 89(11), 3331 (2006)
Section IV
Sustainable Product Service Systems and
Sustainable Consumption
Product Service Systems and Sustainable
Consumption Toward Sustainability: 30
Introduction
Yasushi Umeda
Abstract
Sustainable product service system (PSS) and sustainable consumption are
indispensable concepts for achieving sustainability. They would be trumps for
changing the current manufacturing paradigm to sustainable one. This chapter
gives an overview of sustainable PSS and sustainable consumption as an
introduction of related chapters.
1 Introduction
Y. Umeda
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Graduate School of Engineering, Osaka University,
Osaka, Japan
e-mail: umeda@mech.eng.osaka-u.ac.jp
conscious manner, and choose the most appropriate combination of life cycle
options (e.g., maintenance, upgrading, reuse, remanufacturing, recycling, energy
recovery, and reclamation) during their usage and at the end of life of the products.
More importantly, such environmental behavior should be executed not only by
a few environmental leaders but also by the majority of consumers. At the same
time, manufacturers should make profits with the business of environmentally
conscious products. This means that collaborative interaction among manufacturers,
consumers, and recyclers determines whether such sustainable production and
consumption become successful or not. Since manufacturers, consumers, and
recyclers act independently based on their own behavioral principle without enough
communication with each other in the current mass production paradigm, barriers
among these three stakeholders prevented environmentally conscious products,
design methodologies, and technologies from working effectively. In order to realize
the sustainable production and consumption, we should establish life cycle industry,
which develops and manufactures products, manages product life cycle, and
circulates EoL (end-of-life) products in an integrated manner, by making alliance
between manufacturers and recyclers, and then establish co-creative communication
between consumers and the life cycle industry. The most hopeful enablers for this
paradigm shift are product service system (PSS) and sustainable consumption. On
one hand, PSS is the approach from industry side to consumer side by offering
a package of hardware and service. On the other hand, sustainable consumption
promotes consumers’ purchase and usage of products, and selection and execution
of life cycle options from the viewpoint of sustainability. Sustainable consumption
also aims at changing behavior of manufacturers, recyclers, life cycle industry as
an integrated form, and society through consumers’ behavior. In this sense, PSS
and sustainable consumption are complementary with each other and should be
integrated in future.
• The business opportunity of the manufacturer expands from just selling products
to various activities in a product life cycle such as maintenance, upgrading, life
cycle management, and providing supplies. This may increase profitability of the
business.
• PSS includes various types of business (Tukker and Tischner 2006) such as
product lease and pay per service. Some types of PSS business may reduce
life cycle cost of a customer. For example, while a customer should pay very
expensive price of a new electric vehicle (EV), to buy it in the traditional
automobile sales business, he/she is requested to pay the fee just on a mileage
basis in EV car sharing business.
• Since a manufacturer can take care of products after providing them, the man-
ufacturer can monitor and manage the conditions of products. The manufacture
can even collect and replace products if ownership of the products belongs to the
manufacture rather than to the customers. This will increase collection rate and
quality of end-of-use products. In this way, PSS is a quit effective measure to
realize environmentally conscious circulation of products.
3 Sustainable Consumption
The concept of sustainable consumption is more vague and broader than PSS. The
motivation is clear; not only the initiative from the manufacturer side, the initiative
from the consumer side toward sustainability is indispensable and may have stronger
influence on industry, government, and society. This is sustainable consumption.
While Chapters Design for Sustainability (DfS): Interface of Sustainable
Production and Consumption and Sustainable Consumption discuss the concept
of sustainable consumption in detail, the significance of sustainable consumption
toward sustainability may include:
• Consumers’ preference to environmentally conscious products in purchasing
phase and environmentally conscious recycling in end-of-life phase may motivate
manufacturers to develop such products and recyclers to execute such operations.
Consumers’ preference may be the strongest and the soundest drivers for
manufacturers and recyclers to move toward sustainability.
• Consumers’ usage patterns largely affect the length of lifetime of products
and environmental loads during usage (including energy consumption, CO2
emission, and consumption of supplies). For example, about 80–90 % of life
cycle CO2 of active products such as automobiles and refrigerators is emitted
during usage. Small shifts of individual consumption patterns may result in
large effect on sustainability in society. For example, a large electricity blackout
was expected in summer 2011 in Tokyo, Japan, because of nuclear power plant
stoppage after Fukushima nuclear accident. But any blackout did not happen as a
result of energy-saving activities of all kinds of stakeholders including citizens,
companies, and governments. Such shifts for individual consumption patterns
will lead to sustainable lifestyles.
546 Y. Umeda
The only way to change society sustainable may be accumulation of the shift
to sustainable consumption of individuals. In other words, although concepts,
methodologies, key indicators, and criteria of sustainable consumption have not
been well established yet, sustainable consumption has a huge potential to reach
sustainability.
4 Related Chapters
Many other chapters in this handbook discuss sustainable PSS and sustainable
consumption.
On one hand, some chapters discuss fundamental concepts of sustainable
PSS and sustainable consumption. Chapter Design for Sustainability (DfS):
Interface of Sustainable Production and Consumption gives a holistic overview
of “design for sustainability” including basic concepts of sustainable production
and consumption and clarifies the difference between sustainability-oriented de-
sign and the traditional environmentally conscious design. Chapter Sustainable
Design Engineering: Design as a Key Driver in Sustainable Product and Busi-
ness Development discusses sustainable design and sustainable production from
the viewpoint of business. Chapter Engineering PSS (Product/Service Systems)
Toward Sustainability: Review of Research gives an overview of sustainable PSS
and related engineering research. And Chapter Sustainable Consumption discusses
the importance and potential of sustainable consumption thoroughly.
On the other hand, many chapters introduce engineering methodologies for
modeling, designing, simulating, and evaluating PSSs and show some exemplars
of PSSs, since methodologies for sustainable consumption have not been mature
enough, at least in engineering domain. Chapter Product Design Considerations
for Improved Integrated Product/Service Offerings introduces a simple design
method for PSS with explaining the concept of PSS. Chapters Modeling Services
and Service-Centered PSS Design and Advanced Japanese Service Design: From
Elements to Relations introduce “service engineering” and PSS design method-
ologies based on service engineering. “Service engineering” is one of the major
methodologies in the domain of PSS design research. While Chapter Modeling
Services and Service-Centered PSS Design introduces core methods of service
engineering focusing on modeling of services, Chapter Advanced Japanese Ser-
vice Design: From Elements to Relations describes methods and examples of
application worked with their industrial partners. Chapter Life Cycle Simulation
for Sustainable Product Service Systems introduces “life cycle simulation” (LCS)
for supporting sustainable PSS design. LCS is a methodology for simulating flow
of resources, products, components, money, information, etc., throughout a product
life cycle and evaluating a product life cycle from environmental and economic
viewpoints. In this sense, LCS will be an indispensable tool for designing sus-
tainable PSS. Chapter Eco-business Planning: Idea Generation Method discusses
the necessity of business design for the success of sustainable PSS and proposes a
business design method. Without doubt, this is an important or the most important
30 Product Service Systems and Sustainable Consumption Toward Sustainability 547
aspect for realizing sustainable PSS in the real world. And Chapter Sustainable
PSS in Automotive Industry describes practical examples of PSS in automotive
industry with giving a holistic perspective of product life cycle and PSS.
5 Summary
References
C. Boks, Design for sustainable behaviour research challenges, in Design for Innovative Value
Towards a Sustainable Society, ed. by M. Matsumoto, Y. Umeda, K. Masui, S. Fukushige
(Springer, The Netherlands, 2012), pp. 328–333
M.J. Goedkoop, C.J. van Halen, H.R. te Riele, P.J. Rommens, Product Service Systems, Ecological
and Economic Basics (Dutch Ministry of Housing, Spatial Planning and the Environment,
VROM 990570, The Hague, 1999)
A. Tukker, Eight types of product-service system: eight ways to sustainability? Experiences from
suspronet. Bus. Strategy Environ. 13, 246–260 (2004)
A. Tukker, U. Tischner, New Business for Old Europe (Greenleaf Publishing, Sheffield, 2006)
Advanced Japanese Service Design: From
Elements to Relations 31
Yoshiki Shimomura, Koji Kimita, and Fumiya Akasaka
Abstract
Service is nowadays regarded as a way to achieve the “sustainability” of
businesses in manufacturing companies. The Service Engineering Forum (SEFO-
RUM) was established in 2002 as an industry-academic cooperative consortium
to advance service engineering research (see http://www.service-eng.org/). In the
third period of the SEFORUM (2008–2011), engineering methods to support
a service design process were proposed and applied to plural actual services.
This work reports these SEFORUM activities. In this work, methods to support
the service design process, which is composed of the three phases, requirement
analysis, service conceptual design, and service detailed design, are proposed. In
addition, the results of the case studies of these methods are also reported. An
overview of the methods for each phase follows.
For the requirement analysis, in which designers define the target customer
categories and extract the requirements, a method for negotiating various cus-
tomer demands is introduced. This method enables designers to analyze various
customer requirements and to effectively prioritize them. For prioritization, this
method relies on group decision-making, in which a plan is proposed to minimize
overall dissatisfaction (group decision-making stress) of all group members on
the basis of an original evaluation of the decision-makers and their priority.
In the case study, this method is applied to an elevator renewal service for
Y. Shimomura ()
Graduate School of System Design, Tokyo Metropolitan University, Tokyo, Japan
e-mail: yoshiki-shimomura@center.tmu.ac.jp
K. Kimita
Faculty of Engineering, Tokyo University of Science, Tokyo, Japan
e-mail: kimita@ms.kagu.tus.ac.jp
F. Akasaka
Tokyo Metropolitan University, Tokyo, Japan
e-mail: akasaka-fumiya@sd.tmu.ac.jp
1 Introduction
According to the discussion regarding service engineering (e.g., Tukker and Tis-
chner 2006), the service design process proceeded in three steps: “requirement
analysis,” “service conceptual design,” and “service detailed design.” In addition,
these steps are controlled and evaluated by a “service design process management”
from the viewpoint of customers (see Fig. 31.1).
In the requirement analysis, designers collect and arrange data to specify
customer requirements and constraints within a service. Defining and/or prioritizing
target customer categories is an essential activity in this phase to specify customer
behaviors and to extract their requirements. In the service conceptual design, subse-
quently, designers develop function structures that meet the customer requirements.
They, then, identify entities, such as human, organization, and physical products,
that can be used to actualize these function structures. In the service detailed design,
the designers determine relevant stakeholders involved in the service and their
relationships and, then, allocate resources for which each stakeholder takes respon-
sibility. For determining the details of the entities, in this phase, conceptual entities
determined in the previous phase are associated with actual entities in consideration
of resources of each stakeholder. According to the detailed information about the
entities, designers identify detailed service activities and product behaviors and,
then, draw up documents and/or manuals for the preparation of the service offering.
This service design process is unique in that it includes the management of the
design process from customer viewpoints. Many studies have reported that the
552 Y. Shimomura et al.
value of a service is always determined by customers (e.g., Vargo and Lusch 2004).
Therefore, the process and output of the phases, which are “requirement analysis,”
“service conceptual design,” and “service detailed design,” need to be controlled
and evaluated from the viewpoint of the customer.
With regard to each phase, in the following sections, methods that support
designer activities are provided and case studies in which these methods were
applied to actual services are introduced.
n
X
wi D 1 (31.1)
i D1
n
1X
ej D wi xij (31.2)
n i D1
m X
X n
SD .wi xij ej /2 (31.3)
j D1 i D1
i : a customer category (i = 1, 2, 3, . . . , n)
j : items of customer requirements (j = 1, 2, 3, . . . , m)
xij : importance of customer requirement j for customer category i
wi : priority of customer category i
ej : ensemble mean of customer requirement j
Since xij expresses the importance of requirement of each customer category,
this variable is considered a fixed value. As such, in (31.1)–(31.3), wi is the only
adaptable variable. This method assumes that wi , which minimizes S , is the
rational priority. Concretely, if (31.1) is given as a restriction, wi , which minimizes
( 31.3) (wi *), is derived by using an optimization technique, such as Lagrange’s
method of undetermined multipliers. In the case of applying Lagrange’s method of
undetermined multipliers, is assumed to be Lagrange undetermined multiplier.
As a result, wi * is calculated with (31.4)–(31.6).
0 1
xi1
B::: C
B C
B C
Xi D B xij C (31.4)
B C
@::: A
xi m
01
w1
B:::C
B C
B C
w D B wi C (31.5)
B C
@:::A
wn
554 Y. Shimomura et al.
0 11 0 1
.n 1/jX1 j2 ; .X1 ; X2 /; :::; .X1 ; Xn /; 1 0
B
B.X2 ; X1 /; .n 1/jX2 j2 ; :::; .X2 ; Xn /; 1 C B0 C
C B C
w B C B C
D B: : : ; :::; :::; :::; 1 C B: : : C
B C B C
@.Xn ; X1 /; .Xn ; X2 /; :::; .n 1/jXn j2 ; 1 A @0 A
1; 1; 1; 1; 0 1
(31.6)
Table 31.3 Importance of the customer requirements for each customer categories
Requirement number and its importance
Category R1 R2 R3 R4 R6 R7 R8
P1 0.141 0.037 0.068 0.382 0.169 0 0.203
P2 0.068 0.065 0.424 0.119 0.324 0 0
P3 0.049 0.041 0.240 0.155 0.515 0 0
P4 0.188 0.325 0.035 0.119 0.095 0.111 0.128
P5 0.266 0.391 0.122 0.046 0.041 0.104 0.031
P6 0.458 0.036 0.049 0.110 0.127 0 0.220
P7 0.353 0.306 0.057 0.056 0.066 0.162 0
P8 0.376 0.307 0.067 0.176 0.074 0 0
Table 31.4 Priority of each customer category and their opinion score
Category Priority (%) Degree of deviation from the mean Opinion score
P1 12:5 0.0% 0.197
P2 9:7 2.8% 0.204
P3 8:6 3.9% 0.211
P4 16:7 +4.2% 0.232
P5 13:7 +1.2% 0.265
P6 11:5 1.0% 0.269
P7 13:9 +1.4 0.274
P8 13:4 +0.9% 0.303
Table 31.5 Comparison between two types of importance for each customer requirement
Customer requirements
R1 R2 R3 R4 R5 R6 R7
Arithmetic average 0.237 0.188 0.133 0.145 0.176 0.047 0.073
After prioritizing 0.248 0.210 0.116 0.143 0.152 0.055 0.076
the degree of deviation of each score from the mean (12.5%). Table 31.5 compares
two types of importance for each requirement. The upper row in Table 31.5 shows
importance for each requirement calculated without the priority by using the arith-
metic mean. The lower row shows importance for each requirement weighted by the
priority. Table 31.6 compares two values: the overall dissatisfaction (S ) of resident
categories calculated without the priority and dissatisfaction in consideration of the
priority of each category.
Finally, portfolio analysis was carried out. In Fig. 31.2, the distribution of eight
resident categories is shown along with the priority (vertical axis) and the opinion
score (horizontal axis).
31 Advanced Japanese Service Design: From Elements to Relations 557
0.18
(b)
0.16 P4
P7 (c)
0.14 P1 P5
Priority
P8
0.12
P2 P6
0.10
(a)
0.08 P3
0.06
0.04
0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 0.30 0.35
Opinion score
In this case study, the residents were analyzed to extract their requirements and
prioritize and quantify them. Additionally, this case study shows the distribution of
the residents’ requirements visually. From the data shown in Table 31.4, it is shown
that P4, P5, and P7 have high priorities (16.7%, 13.7%, and 13.9%, respectively). On
the other hand, the scores for P2 and P3 are very low, 9.7% and 8.6%, respectively.
Therefore, for the calculation of importance of requirements for all the residents,
the importance of requirements for P4, P5, and P7 is given high priority, and those
of P2 and P3 are given low priority. This is due to the opinions of P4, P5, and
P7 being closer to the group opinion than are the opinions of P2 and P3. In order
to minimize overall dissatisfaction of the residents, therefore, designers need to
focus on requirements of residents who are given high priority, such as P4, P5,
and P7.
From Table 31.5, which compares the importance of requirements calculated
without the priories with that weighted by the priories, it is clear that the importance
of all requirements is changed. However, the rank order of the importance of the
requirements does not change. Therefore, designers should first consider the safety
of the system. As shown in Table 31.6, overall resident dissatisfaction obtained by
considering the priorities (0.0117) is approximately 8.2% lower than that obtained
without considering the priorities (0.0128). This indicates that this method can be
used to more reasonably decide the importance of requirements for all residents by
prioritizing them.
With regard to the distribution of the resident categories shown in Fig. 31.2, the
eight categories are divided into three groups: P1–P3 (Fig.31.2(a)), P4 (Fig.31.2(b)),
and P5–P8 (Fig. 31.2(c)). The importance of R2 (system safety) is low in group
P1–P3. On the other hand, in the P5–P8 group, the importance of R1 (interpersonal
safety) is high. This indicates that the method can extract common features of the
groups.
This case study revealed that the result of portfolio analysis enables designers
to determine the target requirements that should be investigated in the service.
This method can extract the features of an actual customer by reflecting the
actual customer demands. According to the result of the customer distribution and
grading scores to the customers, this method enables designers to determine an
558 Y. Shimomura et al.
elevator renewal plan that minimizes overall dissatisfaction of the residents. This
strategy, namely, minimization of overall dissatisfaction, is effective in a service
design where designers cannot focus on a specific customer category such as
public services. The elevator renewal service used in this case study has such
public characteristics, since users of the elevator include a broad range of customer
categories. From the viewpoint of minimizing overall dissatisfaction, as shown in
Table 31.5, designers need to focus on customer requirements of which importance
rose after prioritizing, such as R1 and R2. In order to add more value to the elevator
renewal plan developed on the basis of these results, however, designers need to
customize the plan to meet requirements of residents who are given low priority.
From this point of view, this method provides a platform that could be offered for
all residents in the renewal plan.
Required level
Pursuing social
requirements
Required level
in the completion
Physical Addressing physical
Perfomance
deterioration deterioration
Function recovery
by maintenance
In the early stage of use, maintenance repairs are possible. However, with extended
use, the frequency of failure increases. Furthermore, it is difficult for elevator
manufacturers and/or maintenance providers to keep an inventory of repair parts
for extended periods. Therefore, functional improvements with maintenance are
limited. The other reason is that social requirements for elevators change frequently
because of accidents and revised regulations. To meet such changes, it is often
necessary to install new equipment by conducting the elevator renewal.
However, at present, selling points that stimulate elevator users to conduct
the elevator renewal mostly rely on new functions of a physical product. Since
these selling points are limited, it is required for elevator manufactures and/or
maintenance providers to create new selling points that consist of functions of
physical products as well as functions of services.
In this case study, first, press releases were collected on the basis of requirements
for the elevator renewals. The press releases included the latest 12,000 articles that
were collected from six industry segments: IT, logistics, finance, manufacturing,
service, and construction. According to the requirements for the elevator renewals,
100 pertinent releases were identified to assist the designers, and then, these press
releases were made available for the designer to develop new functions of the
elevator renewal. As a result, as shown in Table 31.7, 18 new functions were
developed by the designer.
For example, as shown in Fig. 31.4, with regard to the requirement for the
elevator renewal service “guarantee the elevator’s safety,” a press release article
regarding energy saving facilities was obtained. From the contents of this article,
a new function “supply electricity by solar light to prevent users from being trapped
in an elevator in case of blackout” was developed. With regard to the requirement
“easy to understand the proposal of renewal,” as shown in Fig. 31.5, a press release
article regarding website of home manufacturer was obtained. From the contents of
this article, that is, “3D virtual experiences of room layout,” a new function “make
customers understand the design in the elevator by 3D virtual experiences” was
developed.
560 Y. Shimomura et al.
Fig. 31.4 Example of the developed functions for “guarantee the elevator’s safety”
31 Advanced Japanese Service Design: From Elements to Relations 561
Fig. 31.5 Example of the developed functions “easy to understand the proposal of renewal”
The articles that contributed for the function development were 17 from the 100
pertinent releases. The 17 articles were comprised of 8 from IT, 4 from logistics,
1 from finance, 3 from manufacturing, 2 from service, and 9 from construction.
Since the web-based database contained the press release articles from various
industry segments, the designer could develop functions that included not only
functions regarding physical products but also functions regarding services, for
example, as shown in Figs. 31.4 and 31.5.
each improvement plan for the purpose of maximizing customer satisfaction. Then,
based on the results of the allocations, the improvement plan can be quantitatively
prioritized.
Customer satisfaction CS
W1 W2
Values/Goals
(e.g., earn money) V1 V2
CR
RCR
11 RCR
22 R23
Customer
requirements
CR1 CR2 CR3
(e.g., work efficiency)
SQ SQ SQ SQ
R11 R22 R23 R34
Service quality
elements SQ1 SQ2 SQ3 SQ4
(e.g., usability)
n
X
CRj D SQi RjSQi (31.7)
i D1
m
X
Vk D CRi Rkj
CR
(31.8)
j D1
o
X
CS D Vk W k (31.9)
kD1
Fig. 31.8 Examples of sigmoid function. (a) Center: 0.5, Gain: 1. (b) Center: 0.8, Gain: 10
p
X
SQi D IPl RiIPl (31.10)
lD1
Table 31.8 Service improvement plans derived by interviews and its influences to service quality elements
N. Service improvement plans Resources Service quality elements
Monetary Time
The importance of customer values/goals was obtained with the analytic hi-
erarchy process (AHP) (Saaty 1980), which quantifies the relative importance of
elements on a subjective scale by conducting a paired comparison. In addition, to
determine the weights on the other arcs, two binary tables were prepared. In each
table, the degree of association among elements was comparatively evaluated using
the numerals 1, 3, and 5, with 5 indicating a strong association.
Other Setting
In this application, two cases were considered. In the first case, both of the amount
of time and monetary resources to be consumed in the improvement were set at 1.0,
respectively. On the other hand, in the second case, they were set at 3.0, respectively.
Here, the first case means a service improvement where a small amount of monetary
and time resources were consumed. In the second case, the provider tried to improve
his service with a large amount of both. In this application, the total amount of
resources was represented as relative values. Moreover, the settings in the GA were
designed empirically as follows:
• Possibility of crossover: 0.7, possibility of mutation: 0.01
• Number of individuals: 200, number of generations: 10,000
• One-point crossover and elite selection were applied
Results
Figures 31.11 and 31.12 illustrate the result of optimal resource allocation.
Figure 31.11 shows the results when the total amount of resources was 1.0, and
Fig. 31.12 gives results when the total was 3.0. The horizontal axis corresponds to
the list of improvement plans in Table 31.8, and the vertical axis corresponds to the
amount of resources. The left bar denotes the monetary resource, and the right bar
indicates time.
31 Advanced Japanese Service Design: From Elements to Relations 571
1.6
Amount of resources
1.2 Time resource
1
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Service improvement plans
1.6
Time resource
Amount of resources
1.2
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Service improvement plans
3 Summary
This chapter includes a report of the activities of Service Engineering Forum, which
is an industry-academic cooperative consortium for service engineering research;
in addition, methods to support the phases of the requirements analysis, service
conceptual design, and service detailed design are introduced. The case studies
revealed that these methods support designers to conduct activities in the service
design process and to manage these activities from the viewpoint of customers.
For the requirement analysis, the group decision-making stress method was
applied to a service to analyze various customers’ demands and prioritize them in an
effective manner. In the case study, the method was applied to the elevator renewal
service for a condominium building where its residents correspond to customers.
The residents were analyzed to extract their requirements and prioritize and quantify
them. The prioritization was carried out to minimize the overall dissatisfaction
(group decision-making stress) of the residents on the basis of their original
evaluation and priority. Additionally, this case study shows the distribution of the
residents’ requirements visually. Therefore, this method can be used to prioritize
customer requirements as well as to obtain a consensus among the customers and to
decrease customer dissatisfaction.
For the service conceptual design, the web-based database construction method
is introduced, and then it was applied to the elevator renewal service. As a result,
18 new functions were developed by the designer who takes responsibilities for the
development of elevator renewal services. Requirements extracted in this case study
were categorized into four abstract requirements: “safety,” “economic efficiency,”
“comfort and convenience,” and “reliability”; the functions were developed for each
requirement category. Therefore, this method enables designers to develop functions
from the viewpoint of customers.
For the service detailed design phase, a method to support service improvement
design with an optimum resource allocation is reported as a practical method used
in the detailed design phase. Furthermore, a case study that the method was applied
to a large-scale facilities maintenance service was explained. The notable feature of
this method is that its optimization purpose is “the maximization of the customer
satisfaction.” Namely, the optimization is not based on provider’s viewpoint such
as revenue maximization or cost minimization but strongly focused on customer’s
viewpoint, that is, customer satisfaction. Therefore, it can be said that the proposed
method enables service designers to carry out the detailed design with considering
customer viewpoint.
On the other hand in future work, topics mentioned below should be considered.
With regard to designing and evaluating a service quality, designers need to consider
its uncertainties. Quality in a service is likely to be influenced by the attributes
of service elements, such as the work performance of an employee. However, the
attributes of service elements vary in response to the situation in a service. For
example, when an employee is tired, his/her work performance declines. Compared
with physical products, the attributes of service elements easily vary, since service
elements include various human elements. In order to enhance and stabilize the
31 Advanced Japanese Service Design: From Elements to Relations 573
service quality, therefore, designers need to extract the attributes of service elements
that influence the service quality and cope with the variability of the attributes in the
design phase.
On the other hand, since the service elements consist of various entities, such as
employees, facilities, and infrastructure, a large amount of resources is required to
prepare, execute, and maintain a service. To maximize the cost-benefit performance
of a service, new and various types of stakeholders must be involved to realize a
collaborative service.
With regard to the uncertainty, a fundamental research to analyze the uncer-
tainty of the service quality and to simulate its variability has already launched
(Tateyama et al. 2010). With regard to the maximization of the service cost-benefit
performance, on the other hand, a design methodology for the collaborative service
is proposed (Watanabe et al. 2011). Therefore, future work includes applying
these methods to practical services and then realizing more comprehensive design
support.
References
F. Akasaka, S. Hosono, K. Yamamura, Y. Shimomura, T. Arai, A method for analyzing customer
requirements in a B2B service, in Proceedings of the 9th Japan Korea Workshop on CAD/CAM,
Okinawa, (2009), pp. 7–12
J. Gutman, A means-end chain model based on consumer categorization processes. J. Mark. 46(1),
60–72 (1982)
C. Hayashi, On the prediction of phenomena from qualitative data and the quantification of
qualitative data from the mathematico-statistical point of view. Ann. Inst. Stat. Math. 3(1),
69–98 (1951)
J.H. Holland, Adaptation in Natural and Artificial Systems (University of Michigan Press, Ann
Arbor, 1975)
E. Kinoshita, M. Nakanishi, Proposal of new AHP model in light of dominant relationship among
alternatives. J. Oper. Res. Soc. Jpn. 42(2), 180–197 (1999)
Y. Kitai, K. Oki, K. Kimita, K. Watanabe, R. Chiba, Y. Shimomura, A proposal for service
design support system using knowledge from web resources, in Proceedings of the 44th CIRP
Conference on Manufacturing Systems, CIRP, Madison, 2011, CD-ROM
T.J. Reynolds, J. Gutman, Laddering theory, method, analysis, and interpretation. J. Advert. Res.
28, 11–31 (1988)
M. Rokeach, The Nature of Human Values (Free Press, New York, 1973)
L. Saaty, The Analytic Hierarchy Process (McGraw-Hill, New York/London, 1980)
Y. Shimomura, T. Tomiyama, Service modeling for service engineering, in IFIP International
Federation for Information Processing, vol. 167 (Springer, Boston, 2005), pp. 31–38
J. Spohrer, P. Maglio, The emergence of service science: toward systematic service innovations to
accelerate co-creation of value. Prod. Oper. Manag. 15, 329–343 (2006)
H. Takeda, H. Sakai, Y. Nomaguchi, M. Yoshioka, Y. Shimomura, T. Tomiyama, Universal
abduction studio: proposal of a design support environment for creative thinking in design,
in Proceedings of the 14th International Conference on Engineering Design (ICED 03),
Stockholm, 2003, CD-ROM
T. Tateyama, Y. Shimomura, S. Mikoshiba, S. Kawata, Service flow simulator using scene
transition nets (STN) including satisfaction-attribute value functions, in Proceedings of the 30th
Computers and Information in Engineering Conference – CIE2010 –, CD-ROM, Montreal (The
American Society for Mechanical Engineering (ASME), New York, 2010)
574 Y. Shimomura et al.
A. Tukker, U. Tischner, New Business for Old Europe (Greenleaf, Sheffield, 2006)
S.L. Vargo, R.F. Lusch, Evolving to a new dominant logic for marketing. J. Mark. 68(1), 1–17
(2004)
K. Watanabe, S. Mikoshiba, T. Tateyama, K. Kimita, Y. Shimomura, Service design methodology
for cooperative services, in Proceedings of the 2011 International Design Engineering
Technical Conference – IDETC2011 –, CD-ROM, Washington DC (The American Society for
Mechanical Engineering (ASME), New York, 2011)
S. Yamamoto, K. Kimita, Y. Shimomura, An importance decision method of customer’s demands
for highly public service, in Proceedings of the 15th Design for Manufacturing and the
Lifecycle Conference – DFMLC2010 –, CD-ROM, Montreal (The American Society for
Mechanical Engineering (ASME), New York, 2010)
Design for Sustainability (DfS): Interface
of Sustainable Production and 32
Consumption
Joachim H. Spangenberg
Abstract
Sustainable development cannot be reached by incremental improvements; it
requires a trajectory change. This implies the need to redesign not only consumer
products and production infrastructures but also our daily behavioral routines and
consumption patterns.
Design for sustainability (DfS) goes beyond the established approach of
Design for the environment (DfE) by integrating issues of social context and
human quality of life into the design brief, in addition to environmental and –
of course – functional and economic aspects. Such a redesign of consumption
patterns need not imply a diminished quality of life, if the efficiency potentials
beyond production are systematically exploited: provision, use, and satisfaction
efficiency safeguard well-being while changing the consumption trajectories.
As guidance in this process, it is useful to distinguish human needs, almost
an anthropogenic constant, from the culture dependent satisfiers chosen to
meet those needs: a sustainable choice is one which is socially as well as
environmentally benign while equally satisfying needs.
These considerations have been used to develop SCALES, an integrative
set of design principles. It embodies existing design criteria, a wide range of
previously published criteria from the design for the environment, and design
for sustainability literature. Applying such integrative sets of design criteria is
a creativity-provoking strategy which will help designers meet the challenge of
working at the interface between sustainable production and consumption.
J.H. Spangenberg
SERI Germany e.V., UFZ Helmholtz Centre for Environment Research, Cologne, Halle, Germany
e-mail: Joachim.Spangenberg@seri.de, joachim.Spangenberg@ufz.de
1 Introduction
Never before in contemporary human memory had so many things gone wrong at
the same time: humankind has slipped into an intertwined crisis of the natural, social
and economic systems. That makes the overwhelming complexity of the crisis and
the difficulty to find adequate and workable solutions. As a result, the problems
are larger than the solutions proposed so far; a dangerous lack of imagination
prevents the recognition of risks as well as opportunities. Sustainable production and
consumption seems to be a far cry. What does that imply for the future of design?
For instance, the social reality of climate change – scientific debate, public
discourses, policy change announcements by government and business – is altering
the conditions not only for production and consumption, but also for design. Climate
change and peak oil will require revolutionary restructuring of the systems of pro-
duction and consumption and rapidly so. Thus, the challenge to production and con-
sumption patterns is not incremental improvements but a change of the trajectory, a
U-turn in the way societies have shaped and are shaping their natural environment.
This implies that humans change their expectations on how the future of living,
working, and consuming might look like – it will surely not be an extrapolation of
past trends, just richer and better. The future is no longer what is used to be. New
ideas about the future are needed (“redesigning the future”), including new ideas
about what and how to consume. Visions of future with more sustainable products,
processes, and consumption patterns are needed by business and consumers alike.
Since the nineteenth century, mass production of objects transformed design
from an art into a stakeholder coshaping the future of industrial, and later service/
knowledge, societies. Today, answering to the responsibility this implies must
include efforts to overcome designs which through their application in mass
production have generated negative social, environmental, or institutional impacts
(“mess production” by mass production). Tomorrow’s sustainable consumption and
production requires a massive redesign of consumer goods and industrial practices,
of services, and of infrastructures. Unfortunately, so far, design is not recognized
as a relevant factor in the sustainability discourse (see chapter Sustainable
Design Engineering: Design as a Key Driver in Sustainable Product and Business
Development).
The first postmodern design manifestoes referencing ecological imperatives
emerged in the 1960s (Jencks and Kropf 1997). Green and ecological design in
the late 1980s evolved into eco-design and design for the environment (DfE), with
an emphasis on eco-efficient ways of designing. By the late 1990s, the canon moved
on as design for sustainability (DfS) and gained credence. DfS comprises a wider
spectrum of objectives, adding a social, institutional, and ethical dimension to eco-
design. Design is a code of communication in product information, a function
of growing importance with the transition from an industrial to an information
society. Design for sustainability should not create false, untruthful, and misguiding
meanings nor use unsustainable means or support unsustainable ends. On the
contrary, it should provide people with tools to express their (chosen) identity in a
sustainable fashion. Doing so requires the skills to recognize, frame, restructure, and
32 Design for Sustainability (DfS) 577
The domain of production is the better understood one in terms of the innovations
needed for a transition toward sustainability (see chapter Sustainable Production:
Eco-efficiency of Manufacturing Process). For the environmental dimension, it is
well known that all along the product chain improvements are possible (and from a
sustainability point of view, necessary. The social and institutional dimensions are
usually represented by health and safety (H&S) and workers rights (job security,
co-decision, etc.) while profitability is the core of the economic dimension. It is the
profit motive, and not the desire to satisfy human needs, which drives the production
system.
Provision and production efficiency (see Fig. 32.1) are at the heart of the
environmental dimension of sustainable production (see chapter Material Flow
Cost Accounting: Significance and Practical Approach). In the most narrow sense,
eco-efficiency refers to production efficiency. It can be significantly increased by
process, product, and organizational innovations (the latter are often underestimated
but crucial) in the secondary sector. This is where increased processing efficiency,
in-house reuse and recycling, upstream product chain management, life cycle
assessment and costing are well-established ways not only to reduce resource
Consumer satistaction
Consumption efficiency = =
Resources activated
Consumer satisfaction x Services consumed x Services generated x Products produced x Physical input
Services consumed Services generated Products produced physical input Resources activated
3 Sustainable Consumption
wealth
standard of living
quality of life
design
engineering
Fig. 32.2 Efficiencies, their contribution to quality of life, and the contribution of design. The
influence of design is stronger closer to the consumer side as it shapes not only the product
but also the consumption behavior. Engineering is crucial for the development, functionality and
efficiency of products, including the provision efficiency. Product ownership has traditionally been
considered as material wealth, whereas the standard of living refers to the services enjoyed and can
include nonmarket services. Its environmental impact is determined by the production and product
efficiency, a focus of eco-design or, more precisely, design for the environment (DfE): parts of
eco-design have developed into the sphere of design for sustainability (DfS) which particularly
addresses satisfier and the use efficiency, adding the qualitative component and with it social and
institutional criteria (Source: Spangenberg et al. 2010)
requires a consumer identity based on access to and command over services – the
insistence on ownership is then somewhat anachronistic. Today, such a shift from
ownership to access is visible, but it is far from sure that it will indeed transform
consumption behavior; such trends flourish with confidence and optimism toward
the future and tend to be undermined by social insecurity and precarization, leading
to a retraditionalization of behavioral routines in times of crises (Kraemer 2002).
Finally, a point rarely discussed in efficiency terms, is satisfier efficiency: not
products or services as such, but satisfaction is the key to quality of life (this
concept of subjective life satisfaction is the most recent one, dating back to the
second half of the twentieth century). The level of life satisfaction (equivalent
to the quality of life, the psychic income or happiness, see Veenhoven (1983)
as an early example) is dependent on a number of object functions, including
functionality, usability, synesthesic sense functions, and the symbolic functions of
a product or service (including nonmarket goods and services, such as mutuality-
based or altruistic social relations, and public goods provided for instance by the
environment). Satisfaction in general is growing with access to goods and services
which are in line with consumers’ needs and support their individual and social
identity – such products are satisfiers. Symbolic functions often play a major role
in the formation, expression and communication of the given, chosen, or aspired
identities. Status products, distinction, and identity functions are important drivers
of current consumption. So the reputation of a certain good with the relevant peer
groups plays a decisive role.
32 Design for Sustainability (DfS) 581
As societies and economies change, altering the patterns of scarcity and the
relation of capital, labor, and the environment, the failure of consumers to adapt
to changing circumstances can lead to a lock-in, to sclerotic, outdated but quasi-
sacred consumption patterns. One example is the “American way of life” which
was maintained after neoliberal politics and the burst of the dot.com bubble
undermined its economic basis. Financing it with loans, mortgages, and credit
cards contributed to the high level of private debt and was one key factor for the
meltdown of the financial system in the USA. Such sclerotic consumption patterns
inhibit the adaptation of consumption to ever-changing extrinsic conditions and thus
the evolution of societies. DfS can smoothen the way out of this trap by offering
solutions which appeal to traditional habits but satisfy demands in an innovative,
more sustainable fashion.
In between production and consumption are the products (including services) and
the ways they are used. The volume of annual purchases constitutes the main
component of the GDP, and household consumption is often misinterpreted as a
measure of welfare (Stiglitz et al. 2009). However, much of the expenditure is
not voluntary: Tischner (2001) estimates (for household appliances) that although
90% of the life cycle wide energy consumption takes place in the use phase, this
consumption is up to 90% determined in the design phase. Here, the decision lays in
the hands of business managers and their “useful dwarfs,” designers and engineers,
with profits, not the satisfaction of human needs, the main driver.
It is a characteristic (and an irony) of our consumer society that the command
over certain products and services from mass production has become the means
to express individualistic identities. Design and marketing are driving this process,
but all too often, it is not satisfiers but pseudo-satisfiers (or even inhibitors) which
are advertised. Design for sustainability (DfS) must offer an alternative, providing
sustainable satisfiers and improving satisfaction effectiveness.
Unlike the impression given in much of the consumption debate, not only short-
lived goods are a reason for environmental and economic concern: the accumulation
of durables is problematic as well. The mere maintenance of long-lived goods and
infrastructures requires an increasing volume of monetary and resource expendi-
tures, without providing additional welfare. They need to be cleaned, upgraded,
repaired, or renovated to continue providing the same service while acting as a
restriction to behavioral options other than those foreseen at the time of their
construction. Furthermore, stockpiling new products on top of old ones does not
enhance the efficiency; thus, as much as innovation we need “ex-novation”, ways to
get rid of outdated, unsustainable artefacts and habits.
Being aware of the need to once buy but then maintain durables in order to
continuously yield the services they provide, already in 1906 Fisher suggested
not to count the purchases as the basis for welfare estimates, but the volume of
services yielded from the products, counting as positive what is increasing well-
being (and struggling with the difficulty of quantifying the results), while purchases
584 J.H. Spangenberg
and maintenance expenditure would be written off over their lifetime (Fisher 1906).
Long before the concept of GDP was developed during WW II as a means of
describing the combatants’ potentials of generating economic output, he thus offered
a kind of accounting that much resembles the current discussion on sustainable
consumption. Still his concept of “psychic income” could serve as the theoretical
backbone of a more elaborated theory of sustainable consumption.
4.1 Delimitation
DfS approach
Ecodesign approach
Incremental gains through a ÿ Technical innovations
preventive approach ÿ Seeks to re-design products or re-organise the way
the functions of a product or service can be provided;
ÿ Assesses the short and medium term environmental
and economic impacts for all stages of the life cycle
of the product or service.
Fig. 32.3 The challenge – from design for the environment to design for sustainability. Ten years
ago, the environment was considered the main challenge to the prevailing development paradigm;
social problems were taken to be under control, as well as economic challenges, at least in the
affluent countries setting a precedent for the rest of the world. Thus, environmental modernization
was seen as the solution: based on eco-design, technology improvements, and structural change
of the economy but not requiring changes in behavior, management, attitudes, and desires. This
has been used e.g., by Cucuzzella and De Coninck Cucuzzella and De Coninck (2008) to define
the dividing line between eco-design (enhancing efficiency as the core; technology as a reliable
means for success) and the more far-reaching innovation under the DfS paradigm. For reasons
of clarity, this delineation is useful, although some practitioners perceiving themselves as “eco-
designers” have since long moved into the domain of DfS (design, designers, and their methods
are dynamically evolving)
With its overlapping design foci on all four dimensions of sustainability (see
Fig. 32.4), DfS could and should play an important role in the transition toward
sustainable production and consumption as key components of the quality of life. As
a practice and a problem solving process in which designers include considerations
and impact assessment of the four dimensions, from the process of resource mining
to the final product and its consumption (with a focus on product, use and in
particular satisfier efficiency), DfS asks fundamental questions about consumption
586 J.H. Spangenberg
Fig. 32.4 The prism of sustainability. Each dimension has its own overarching normative
imperative, representing key measures to safeguard the resilience of the environmental, social,
economic, and institutional system. For the larger system, however, the interlinkages are just as
important. For the whole meta-system to function in the long run, they have to secure that none of
the four subsystems interferes with any other in a way undermining its sustained functioning
Why is this the case? The reasons are manifold. First of all, DfS broadens the
horizon and is perceived as a challenge to established practice (including hierarchies
and reputations), and rightly so. DfS requires rethinking of established practice and
the inclusion of additional criteria into the design process. It creates an additional
level of complexity and makes solutions less clear-cut and more “blurred.” The
additional challenge of DfS as compared to eco-design has been illustrated in
Fig. 32.3, demonstrating that DfS also includes taking risks (which are inevitably
linked to leapfrogging solutions, as compared to incremental improvements).
However, defensive motivations (defending habits and status) are not the only
ones. An analysis of the motivations behind the perceived obstacles has revealed
three basic suspicions which must be addressed in order to mainstream sustainability
in the design professions (Blincoe et al. 2009):
• Sustainability will not be accepted by designer’s clients (economic partners) as it
does not pay in the market (yet).
• Sustainability is value-laden and thus perfectly fine for a specific niche, but not
acceptable for the public at large, and hence for designers in general.
• Sustainability is restrictive, a barrier to creativity.
4.3.1 Opportunities
Fortunately, on closer scrutiny, all three perceptions can be proven wrong: With
broad public debates on climate issues all over European consumer societies, the
demand for personal response options, in particular in consumption, is increasing
significantly, opening the mass market to “green” and/or low-carbon products. A
multidimensional life cycle assessment covering also social and institutional aspects
as it should be usual in the framework of DfS whenever suitable can help providing
reliable decision support at a largely reduced effort for performing the assessment.
Furthermore, as sustainability is broader than environmentalism, product DfS
also responds to issues of justice and equity as illustrated in Table 32.1, which
are also prominent in any opinion poll (thus, policies promoting sustainable
consumption seem to find more support amongst consumers than among decision
makers, resulting in limited but significant voluntary actions such as the fair trade
movement). DfS could help mainstreaming such approaches.
Sustainability is indeed normative, but not ideological, (re-)presenting some
rather general ethical values (like the responsibility for distant neighbors and future
generations) on which most citizens might, but do not have to, agree. However,
although reintroducing values into science and design education contradicts the self-
perception and values of scientific/academic thinking, it brings design closer to its
end users: moral and ethics are an indispensable element of any social fabric.
Finally, hands-on experience gained by ICIS, The International Centre for
Creativity, Innovation and Sustainability in Hornbæk, Denmark, demonstrates that
substituting traditional design briefs for sustainability-oriented instructions broad-
ened the horizon of students and experts alike and led to an outburst of creativity and
588 J.H. Spangenberg
originality. DfS requires “thinking out of the box,” overcoming traditional habits,
and this is a significant creativity stimulus.
Even more challenging, this creativity stimulating function of DfS is not
restricted to designers but involves consumers as well (as indicated in Fig. 32.3).
Products are to be “fertile,” having development and adaptation potentials, involve
consumers in designing the final shape and function. DfS emphasizes ‘buy-in” over
“buy it,” psychological ownership feelings (identification) over legal and economic
ownership. While being effective satisfiers, DfS results provide choices for con-
sumers’ self-determination instead of intending to determine consumer behavior
(consumer empowerment). They offer new opportunities to express identities – and
their change over time and (social) context.
Given the current diffuse but widespread aspirations of change, being prepared
requires design not for current markets but for “conceptual markets” of the future
responding to these attitudes.
5 SCALES
For obvious reasons, there is a tension between strict rules and creative solutions.
Thus, instead of such rules, DfS is built upon normative sustainability principles
(as, e.g., the imperatives in Fig. 32.4), which in each case has to be interpreted
according to the circumstances and the agents involved.
Probably, the most comprehensive set of such principles is SCALES (Blincoe
et al. 2009); when compared with other systematiques for ecological and sustainable
design published since 1968, SCALES turned out to cover almost all of the criteria
they suggest while adding substance derived from the multidimensional perspective
it is built upon. The comparison revealed that the foci for manifestoes up to 1992
were largely around a holistic approach, awareness of system and context, and
eco-efficient production and resource use. Post-1992, more emphasis was given
to ethical responsibilities, ideas of learning together and synergy and co-creation.
The SCALES principles embraced additional focal areas – the importance of
communication and leadership, user empowerment, social aspects, and the creation
32 Design for Sustainability (DfS) 589
Vital for the DfS process is the context, the interrelatedness of the different levels
and aspects of the design problem and processes. It is important therefore to define
and analyse problems from multiple perspectives including the four dimensions:
economic, social, institutional, and environmental.
Special skills relate to eco-efficient and eco-effective production and resource
use, from developing technological, LCT, LCA, and cradle-to-cradle skills to be-
coming familiar with dematerialization, zero carbon concepts, new and sustainable
materials, and innovative waste issues (such as “designing high-quality waste” as the
basis for recycling and upcycling processes). Of equal importance is the integration
of efficient service provision by designing Product-Service-Systems (PSS) and
maximizing consumer satisfaction by appropriate material/dematerialized option
that expands user experience, emotion, relation, pride, self-esteem, and awareness.
Finally, special skills related to communication issues, as well as leadership, are
vital for the advancement and integration of sustainability practices in societies.
Designers have to become leaders, capable of communicating and presenting the
contexts, the considerations, and the pros and cons and working with clients,
customers, and other relevant disciplines such as engineers or economists. Making
a real impact requires understanding the context and culture of the stakeholders and
demonstrating and communicating the importance and advantages of sustainability.
590 J.H. Spangenberg
This principle encompasses the understanding of the expanded field of design and
its processes when implementing sustainability. The designer, in particular by using
the networks he or she commands and by fully understanding and communicating
the value-added outcomes of DfS, becomes a change agent and equips the client
to become a change agent too, yielding first-mover benefits. This can be achieved
by using approaches which provide significant, immediate, and visible benefits for
the client and consumers/society through Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR),
ethical consumer behavior, cost cutting, competitive edge, waste, and energy
reduction.
way of designing, where the designer becomes the facilitator rather than the creator
of design solutions – a challenge to design’s collaboration and communication
capabilities.
6 Outlook
Designers have limited power, but they are responsible for what they do with the
cards they have been dealt. Acknowledging this, which are the contributions design
can offer, what is the potential of design as a concept, an ideology (i.e., a means-
ends relation), a profession? What is the specific strength of designers in the process
of rethinking problems, reinventing the present, and rebuilding the future? What are
their competencies unmatched by other professions?
Designers will not be invited to provide solutions, but – in the best of cases – to
contribute to the process: are they team players enough to engage in this challenge?
Do they work with engineers, ecologists, economists, and consumers in an extended
codesign?
This question also implies that what designers suggest has to be workable in
policy terms, not only in economic ones: can they escape the Babylonian detention
to economic thinking, the fetter of design briefs – and could they do without? Can
they change their role from useful dwarfs of marketing to collaborators in problem
solving? Which skills are needed for that, are they provided by design education and
practice? If one challenge is a general overhaul of our social and economic systems
(including taxing not the goods but the bads, or, for climate, tax what we burn, not
what we earn), what has design to say about the ways to achieve this?
Only if designers learn to formulate what they have to offer in the language of
their putative partners (beyond colleagues and clients), will they be heard, and calls
for design policies beyond the national level will be perceived as a contribution to
betterment, not only as expressions of partisan self-interest. What do designers have
to offer to improve intercultural global cooperation networks – and how does that
justify the call for a networked design policy?
Or, in the end, will design as a profession remain restricted to limited fields
of application (but more than beautifying luxury products for the rich and scrap
for the poor)? This might not even be a bad solution, provided that the skills
of designing proper solutions are infiltrating those other professions with current
deficits (including politics). Which are those skills? Creativity comes in many forms
in almost all professions, but what is specific for design? From an outsider’s point
of view, it may be two things: an artistic mode of analysis, and a dedication to
visualize results. The latter is an indispensable skill in times when new concepts and
worldviews need to be communicated (in particular if the visualization is designed
to appeal not only to designers).
Design as applied arts, combining criteria of functionality (applied) with aesthet-
ics (art) to find not only new solutions, but innovative problem definitions may be the
key strength as well as the key problem of design in collaboration with other groups
of society. It is a problem, as the way of understanding a problem (let alone defining
it) is not as systematic as in other professional cultures, often more freewheeling,
turning problems around, even dancing around them, looking at them from different
594 J.H. Spangenberg
angles, drafting and dumping analyses with a kind of a gaming attitude, following
associative rather than deductive lines of thought and argumentation. Little wonder
then that they drive engineers and planners into desperation (intercultural learning
seems to be necessary on all sides). However, in particular in a time when old
explanations fail and established routines turn into dead end streets, this may
be the kind of creative unrest so urgently needed in all corners of our sclerotic
establishments.
Thus, inserting more design skills, attitudes, and thinking into policy and plan-
ning, into management and engineering may be better than condemning designers to
work in all these domains. Then the design profession might be best off by doing –
design, but design attitudes and skills should – if at all possible – spread through
other professions. Who could design such a process?
The future role of design, designers, and the design profession seems pretty
undefined. Designers should have a voice in defining it. However, they would be
well advised not to forget it is but one voice in a chorus, and what is to them a sweet
they offer may be a bitter pill to those who have to swallow it – and vice versa.
References
K. Blincoe, A. Fuad-Luke, J.H. Spangenberg, M. Thomson, D. Holmgren, K. Jaschke,
T. Ainsworth, K. Tylka, DEEDS: a teaching and learning resource to help mainstream
sustainability into everyday design teaching and professional practice. Int. J. Innov. Sustain.
Dev. 4(1), 1–23 (2009)
BUND/Misereor, Zukuftsfähiges Deutschland (Birkhäuser, Basel, 1996)
M. Cogoy, The consumer as a social and environmental actor. Ecol. Econ. 28(3), 385–398 (1999)
C. Cucuzzella, P. De Coninck, The precautionary principle as a framework for sustainable design:
attempts to counter the rebound effects of production and consumption. Paper presented at the
conference economic De-Growth for ecological sustainability and social equity, Paris, 18–19
April 2008
Design Council, (2006) Retrieved from http://www.designcouncil.org.uk, Jan 2007
EEA European Environment Agency, Household consumption and the environment, EEA report
11/2005 (EEA, Copenhagen, 2005)
EEB European Environment Bureau, SCORE! Blueprint for European Sustainable Consumption
and Prodcution (EEB, Brussels, 2009)
I. Fisher, The Nature of Capital and Income (Kelly Publ, New York, 1906)
J. Gotzsch, Product talk. Des. J. 9(2), 16–24 (2006)
IPCC Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, IPCC fourth assessment report; synthesis report
(IPCC, Gland, 2007)
T. Jackson, Consuming paradise? towards a social and cultural psychology of sustainable con-
sumption, in The Earthscan Reader in Sustainable Consumption, ed. by T. Jackson (Earthscan,
London, 2006), pp. 367–395
C. Jencks, K. Kropf, Theories and Manifestoes of Contemporary Architecture (Wiley Academy,
Chichester, UK, 1997)
K. Kraemer, Konsum als Teilhabe an der materiellen Kultur, in Nachhaltiger Konsum. Auf dem
Wege zur gesellschaftlichen Verankerung, ed. by G. Scherhorn, C. Weber (Oekom Verlag,
Munich, 2002), pp. 55–62
M. Kumar, P. Kumar, Valuation of ecosystem services: a psycho-cultural perspective. Ecol. Econ.
64(4), 808–819 (2008)
32 Design for Sustainability (DfS) 595
L. Mainwaring, Environmental values and the frame of reference. Ecol. Econ. 38(3), 391–401
(2001)
M. Max-Neef, A. Elizalde, M. Hopehayn, Human scale development. An option for the future.
Dev. Dialogue 1989(1), 7–80 (1989)
Miljöverndepartementet, Norwegian Ministry of the Environment, Report, Oslo Ministerial
Roundtable (Miljöverndepartementet, Oslo, 1995)
M. O’Connor, J.H. Spangenberg, A Methodology for CSR Reporting: Assuring a representative
diversity of indicators across stakeholders, scales, sites and performance issues. Journal of
Cleaner Production 16(13), 1399-1415 (2008).
V. Packard, The Hidden Persuaders (Pocket, New York, 1958)
L.A. Reisch, I. Røpke, Sustainable Consumption and Ecological Economics (Edward Elgar,
Aldershot, 2004)
I. Røpke, The dynamics of willingness to consume. Ecol. Econ. 28(3), 399–420 (1999)
F. Schmidt-Bleek, Wieviel Umwelt braucht der Mensch? (Birkhäuser, Basel, 1994)
J.H. Spangenberg, Sustainable development indicators: towards integrated systems as a tool for
managing and monitoring a complex transition. Int. J. Glob. Environ. Issues 9(4), 318–337
(2009)
J.H. Spangenberg, S. Lorek, Environmentally sustainable household consumption: from aggregate
environmental pressures to priority fields of action. Ecol. Econ. 43(2–3), 127–140 (2002)
J.H. Spangenberg, A. Fuad-Luke, K. Blincoe, Design for sustainability (DfS): the interface of
sustainable production and consumption. J. Clean. Prod. 18(15), 1483–1491 (2010)
N. Stern, The Economics of Climate Change. The Stern Review (Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge/New York, 2006)
J. Stiglitz, A. Sen, J.-P. Fitoussi, Report by the Commission on the Measurement of Economic
Performance and Social Progress (2009), http://www.stiglitz-sen-fitoussi.fr/documents/
rapport anglais.pdf, retrieved 10 Jan 2010
B. Stigsson, Sustainability made in Germany, presentation at the 2009 annual conference of the
German National Council for Sustainable Development, Berlin, 23 Nov 2009
U. Tischner, Tools for eco-design and sustainable product design, in Sustainable Solutions, ed. by
M. Charter, U. Tischner (Greenleaf, Sheffield, 2001), pp. 263–280
R. Veenhoven, The Study of Life Satisfaction (Erasmus University, Rotterdam, 1983)
S. Vihma, Products as Representations. UIAH Publication Series A, vol 14 (University of Art and
Design, Helsinki, 2002)
J. Wood, The wisdom of nature = the nature of wisdom. Could design bring human society closer
to an attainable form of utopia? Paper presented at the 5th EAD conference, ‘design wisdom’,
Barcelona, 28–30 April 2003 (2006) www.ub.es/5ead/PDF/8/Word.pdf. Accessed Dec 2006
WCED World Commission on Environment and Development, Our common future (The Brundt-
land report) (Oxford University Press, Oxford 1987)
Engineering PSS (Product/Service
Systems) Toward Sustainability: 33
Review of Research
Tomohiko Sakao
Abstract
This chapter gives a review of research on PSS (product/service system) and
its relation to environmental sustainability. The focus of this chapter is on
engineering, especially design, of PSS. It first explains why PSS gains attention
from the sustainability and business viewpoints and then moves on to what PSS
is. One definition of PSS is “a marketable set of products and services capable
of jointly fulfilling a user’s needs.” Importantly, from the engineering viewpoint,
service is beginning to be increasingly incorporated into the design space, an area
which has been traditionally dominated by physical products in manufacturing
industries.
In relation to environmental sustainability, PSS is argued to have potential for
decreasing environmental impacts in many cases. Among others, the “functional
result” type is regarded as the most promising. However, PSS is not always
environmentally superior to its reference offering based on product sales.
From the viewpoint of design, introduced are three dimensions of PSS design:
the offering, the provider, and the customer/user dimensions. In principle, any
PSS design is supposed to address at least part of all the three dimensions since
service includes the activities of customers and providers. Then, this chapter will
guide readers to the works on modeling, designing, and evaluating PSS with
emphasis on the differences to traditional product design. In sum, PSS design
is design toward value of stakeholders by utilizing various alternatives – either
product or service. This means that PSS design provides designers with new
degrees of freedom and covers an earlier phase of design that is not addressed
in design of pure physical product. The latter further implies the importance of
information to be available in design about product usage or service delivery.
T. Sakao
Environmental Technology and Management, Department of Management and Engineering,
Linköping University, Linköping, Sweden
e-mail: tomohiko.sakao@liu.se
For modeling and design, some examples of methods for supporting PSS design
are introduced.
In the end, the author’s recognition of important industrial challenges and
research issues about PSS are described based on the experiences of the author’s
group. They are from various areas such as business model development,
marketing and sales, R&D and PSS development, (re)manufacturing, service
delivery, supply chain management, organizational and managerial topic, and
energy and material consumption.
1 Introduction
(producer) – win (consumer) – win (environment)” has not been realized. Namely,
the present sustainable production in many cases does not accelerate sustainable
consumption. Producers should be more careful of their business aspect if they
pursue profitable activities through sustainable consumption.
To tackle this challenge, the concept of value is among the crucial pieces because
value is the interface between consumers and producers. Value can be defined
“what consumers (customers, users) get for what they give” according to classical
marketing literature (Zeithaml 1988). Then, what do they get? Much literature has
pointed out it is not a physical product per se but the result or performance of the
product in many cases (see, e.g., Stahel 1994). Therefore, there should be support
for companies to develop their offerings based on this idea. This type of support is,
however, a point that conventional Ecodesign methods/tools lack. What is another
weapon of manufacturers to create the result of a physical product than the product
itself? – Service. Manufacturers especially in developed countries today regard
service activities as increasingly important. Some manufacturing firms are even
shifting strategically from a “product seller” toward a “service provider.” Service
in this chapter includes operation, maintenance, repair, upgrade, take back, and
consultation. This combination of sustainability and business seems to be observed
background for how the concept product/service system (PSS) has gained high
attention for more than a decade. One definition of PSS is “a marketable set of
products and services capable of jointly fulfilling a user’s needs” (Goedkoop et al.
1999). In addition to this definition, Tukker and Tischner (Tukker and Tischner
2006) regard PSS as a value proposition, including its network and infrastructure.
What kind of discipline do PSS providers call for? A much bigger framework
is obviously needed than for Ecodesign because a business manner must be
changed ultimately. It may be impossible to tackle this problem by only one of
those disciplines such as engineering, marketing, and management. This is truly a
multidisciplinary subject. Especially, PSS design lies in a domain differing from
that of a product, and the research community has not yet established commonly
agreed methodologies. This chapter aims at guiding you to learn about this relatively
young but crucial concept of PSS in relation to sustainability from the engineering,
especially design, viewpoint.
This section gives you why PSS gains attention from the business viewpoint and
then moves on to what it is. First, especially in the developed countries, the
competition with hardware manufacturers in low-wage countries is severe, and
companies find services as critical measure for value added. Another reason from the
demand side is servicification of customers’ activities, which in some cases means a
shift from customers’ owning physical products to getting access to the functionality
of products.
According to a recent “white paper” on industrial PSS (Meier et al. 2010),
“In 10 years the following statements will be relevant: Result oriented business
600 T. Sakao
Through PSS, companies could attempt holistic optimization from the environmen-
tal and economic perspectives in a better way throughout the life cycle. In addition,
PSS would be more effective when products and services have been developed in
parallel and are mutually adapted to operate well together. This contrasts with the
traditional product sale, where the provider transfers control and responsibility to the
customer at the point of sales. PSS often creates close contact between the supplier
and customer, leading, for example, to offers being customized and improved to
better suit the customer. In many cases, the PSS provider retains responsibility for
the physical products in the PSS during the use phase. One example is when a client
does not own the machines installed by the supplier, but only uses them and pays for
the manufactured volumes; then, when the customer does not need them anymore,
the supplier takes back the machines. Such cases increase the provider’s interest to
33 Engineering PSS (Product/Service Systems) Toward Sustainability 601
Fig. 33.1 Tentative (environmental) sustainability characteristics of different PSS types (Original
source: Business Strategy and the Environment, vol. 13, (Tukker 2004) c Wiley and ERP
Environment)
ensure that the customer uses machines installed as long as possible and that any
disturbances, such as the need for repairs, are reduced. The increased responsibility
by the PSS supplier also potentially facilitates improvements identified and imple-
mented in comparison to traditional sales. This could lead to a product lifetime
extension.
You might think that PSS is automatically environmentally superior to its
reference offering based on product sales – it is not true. According to Tukker
(2004), PSS is in many types argued to have potential for decreasing environmental
impacts (see Fig. 33.1). Among others, the “functional result” type is the most
promising. On the other hand, the “product lease” type can be worse, because the
fact that the user does not own a product could even lead to negative effects, such
as a careless use, shortening its useful life span. Thus far, the relation between PSS
types and their influence on environmental impact has not been analyzed thoroughly,
though some works have been initiated (Lingegård et al. 2011).
Fig. 33.2 The three dimensions of PSS design (Original source: J. Manufacturing Technology
Management, Emerald, vol. 20, 2009 (Sakao et al. 2009c))
The offering dimension addresses the elements and activities in the life cycle.
It includes the lives of physical products that are part of the PSS, as well as service
activities. Successful design of PSS depends on a thorough understanding of the
solution life cycle and active design of beneficial linkages with the heterogeneous
systems involved.
The provider dimension addresses the evolution of product/service providers’
organizations and operations. This covers such issues as the setup of development
projects, organizational streamlining of the company for service delivery, and the
identification of partnerships needed for successful operation of services.
The customer/user dimension addresses the evolving needs of service receivers.
It is crucial for the provider of services and products to anticipate receivers’ reaction
to new offerings.
In principle, any PSS design is supposed to address at least part of all three
dimensions, since service includes the activities of customers and providers, and
because products are included. This characteristic of service is represented by the
term “co-creation.” As such, the three dimensions are fundamental to PSS design.
In addition, anticipating and utilizing the dynamics along each dimension is crucial.
This implies that the essence of PSS design, especially when compared to traditional
engineering design, lies in the utilization of the dynamics of and between offer,
provider, and customer. Figure 33.2 illustrates the links of some of the research
topics to the three dimensions.
33 Engineering PSS (Product/Service Systems) Toward Sustainability 603
Thus far, there has been relatively more work on PSS with the analytical approach
(see mostly analytical and not synthetic approaches in, e.g., Mont and Tukker 2006).
For instance, researchers in the EU-funded Suspronet project (Tukker and Tischner
2006) have contributed extensively to PSS research: They mainly take an analytical
view, which is indicated by their result of analysis in Fig. 33.1 (Tukker 2004). On
the other hand, the engineering approach on PSS is relatively new. The rest of
this section will guide you to the works on modeling, designing, and evaluating
PSS. Note that the first two, that is, modeling and designing, are basic targets of
engineering activities.
There are different approaches to modeling PSS. Two modeling methods are intro-
duced here from suggestion by the International PSS Design Research Community
(Web site). One of them especially allows designers to evaluate an intermediate
solution mathematically during PSS design (Sakao et al. 2009d) based on the QFD
(Quality Function Deployment (Akao 1990)) technique. This method models ser-
vices as service receivers’ transition of status, called the “receiver state parameter.”
Importantly, providing a product is also modeled as a service by this method and,
therefore, so is providing PSS. Then, it further allows a designer to model why
the state transition has value, concerned actors (provider and receiver), and how to
provide the value as shown in Table 33.1. Here, a service is defined as an activity
that a provider causes, usually with consideration (i.e., commercial transactions),
in which a receiver changes from an existing state to a new state that the receiver
desires in which contents and a channel are the means to realize the state change
(based on Tomiyama 2001). Service contents are provided by a service provider
and delivered through a service channel. Physical products and service activities
are either the service contents or the service channel. This provides designers with
a flexible modeling scheme by beginning with a receiver’s state transition so that
PSS can be modeled as well. Using this model, a computerized tool named Service
Explorer is also developed.
The other approach is called PSS Layer Method (Müller et al. 2009). This
aims at providing a framework to describe a PSS and is partly motivated by
the need to establish a common set of terminologies for PSS. This motivation
is linked to standardization on PSS design: For instance, the German DIN PAS
1094 (Public Available Specification) about hybrid value creation has been set
up by German researchers and has been released (DIN working group 2009).
PSS Layer Method assumes that nine dimensions can be defined that cover
most of the important PSS aspects – (1) customer need, (2) customer value, (3)
deliverables, (4) life cycle activities, (5) actors, (6) core products, (7) periphery,
(8) contract, and (9) revenue. These dimensions have relations to each other:
604 T. Sakao
Table 33.1 Information modeled by the method (Based on: Computer-Aided Design, Elsevier,
vol. 41, 2009 (Sakao et al. 2009d))
Information Modeling scheme
What Provided value/cost Receiver state parameter
Why Reasons for value to be Scenario model
effective • State transition of a service receiver
• Persona model of a service receiver
Who Provider and receiver Flow/scope model
How Measures to provide value View model
• Functions of physical products and service
activities
• Physical products and service personnel as
entities
Customer needs (dim. 1) are satisfied by customer value (dim. 2), which a customer
perceives. Such value is generated by deliverables (dim. 3) for a customer. The
deliverables are results of delivery processes, that is, life cycle activities (dim. 4).
To implement a life cycle activity, chain resources are needed. Actors (dim. 5),
core products (dim. 6), and periphery (like IT infrastructure or public transport
systems) (dim. 7) are such resources. Contracts (dim. 8) frame the entire value
creation process, including billing (dim. 9), offerings, and finally the entire business
model. This is a simple manner especially for multidisciplinary team members,
who have different focuses, to share the information of a PSS and discuss it during
design.
function
producer’s world
b consumer’s world
consumer's consumer's
action
previous state following state
function
producer’s world
Legend
Fig. 33.3 Differences between a typical Ecodesign of product and of PSS. (a) A typical ecodesign
of product. (b) The presented ecodesign of service (Original source: J. Cleaner Production,
Elsevier, vol. 15, 2007 (Sakao and Shimomura 2007)). Note: “service” in this figure means PSS.
The product function is realized during usage but is drawn on this figure with simplicity
This state change (from not having meat) can be realized by meat delivery service
just on time or by keeping meat purchased from a supermarket in a freezer. A typical
Ecodesign of products tends to focus on the function of a freezer (i.e., product)
without exploring other possibilities of services such as delivery service.
Figure 33.4 compares the phases for PSS design supported by existing CAD for
products and by CAD required for PSS, so as to show PSS design is different from
traditional product design. The two steps in the last half of this design flow are
relatively well covered by existing CAD. However, the first two steps, for analyzing
customers and then identifying functions, are insufficient. Existing CAD systems
can only cover a part of the second step (e.g., QFD (Quality Function Deployment)).
Virtually no CAD system supports design with targeting value by means of functions
of products or service activities. In addition, the first step for identifying value
through customer analysis is not covered either.
606 T. Sakao
Customer Segment
Conceptual Design in SPE
Analyzing Customers
Functions
Embodiment Design
Existing CAD systems for
Physical Characteristics of Structure
Products
Detailed Design
Product
Fig. 33.4 Different stages for PSS design (Original source: Computer-Aided Design, Elsevier,
vol. 41, 2009 (Sakao et al. 2009d)). Note: SPE stands for service/product engineering, meaning
engineering of PSS. “Service” in this figure means PSS
This part introduces some examples of methods for supporting PSS design. An
example addressing development issues is a methodology for product-service
systems (MEPSS) for companies to develop and implement a successful and
sustainable PSS (van Halen et al. 2005). MEPSS is a procedure for analyzing the
company systems, based on workshop sessions and supported by various tools.
Thus, it represents a strong practical approach to PSS development.
Two more methods are introduced here also from the International PSS Design
Research Community (Web site). One method is a structured and comprehensive
PSS design method now called SPIPS (toward solution provider – through integrated
product and service development) (Sakao et al. 2009a). The method addresses both
service activities and physical products as measures creating value for different
stakeholders and adopts a design-object model which represents critical concepts
such as value, costs (sacrifice), functions either of products or of service activities,
and entities introduced above (Sakao et al. 2009d). SPIPS realizes the idea men-
tioned above, new degrees of freedom for designers and an earlier phase of design
addressed. SPIPS has been validated with some empirical results obtained from
designing a PSS with companies – from both manufacturing industry and service
industry. It is at present being implemented at a large manufacturer of investment
machines.
As depicted in Fig. 33.5, SPIPS consists of seven steps (from 0 to 6), so that they
fit well with the information assets of a given company. If customers’ requirements
33 Engineering PSS (Product/Service Systems) Toward Sustainability 607
Possible solutions
6. Investigation of economy
Feasible solutions
Legend
Input to Step
Step
Output from Step
Fig. 33.5 Procedure of SPIPS (Original source: Int. J. Internet Manufacturing and Services,
vol. 2, 2009. dx.doi.org/10.1504/IJSTM.2009.022379 c Inderscience Enterprises Ltd. (Sakao
et al. 2009a))
on their value and costs already exist, Step 0 will be omitted. Step 3 adopts the
method to identify opportunities by Ulwick (2002), while Step 4 utilizes a method
to evaluate intermediate solutions by Arai and Shimomura (2005) as is explained
below. Step 4, named “translation to design parameters,” is among the core steps.
It uses the information from customers and specialists from the provider’s side.
The former information is represented by quantitative importance/satisfaction on the
given customer value/cost and can be collected by a simple questionnaire. The latter
is either about services or products provided by the company and can be gathered
using matrices similar to those used in QFD.
Once the design focuses are obtained from Step 4, brainstorming with employees
with specific knowledge and responsibility will be held as Step 5. This is followed
by Step 6, which is investigation of economic feasibility of possible solutions
generated from Step 5. Finally, feasible solutions are produced. Since some steps,
especially Steps 1, 5, and 6, are quite familiar to companies in general, the new
essence of these working steps exists in Steps 2, 3, and, particularly, 4. Thus, these
steps have proper contrivance; while they are familiar to widespread ways of
working in companies in general, they are adapted to addressing PSS.
608 T. Sakao
Fig. 33.6 Illustration of potential areas for providing services (Original source: Int. J. Services
Technology and Management, vol. 11, 2009. dx.doi.org/10.1504/IJSTM.2009.022379 c Inder-
science Enterprises Ltd. (Panshef et al. 2009))
Other methods are available to support PSS design (see, e.g., Sakao and
Lindahl 2009b; it provides methods from different disciplines such as engineering,
marketing, and innovation), one of which aims at identifying user activities and
reveals business opportunities for new services (Panshef et al. 2009). This method
has been applied to PSS design with companies successfully. Figure 33.6 depicts
the adopted profile, representing a structured view of the targets (x-axis: where),
resources (y-axis: who), and contents (z-axis: what) of the service activities.
As a way of using this profile, a 2D profile named taxonomy table is derived,
as shown Fig. 33.7 in a case for print production processes: prepress, press, post-
press, and logistics. The 2D profile allows designers to explore the consequences
resulting from uncertainty during the user process and enables the improvement of
existing service content (even removing the current service content and provider)
by recognizing and understanding the less significant service capability. On the
y-axis, all the possible levels of service escalation are derived. In this example,
three escalation fields have been defined: the user’s own resources; secondly, the
resources of the device manufacturer or the local service provider; and thirdly, the
resources of other service providers. In this case, a high concentration of the reactive
services was observed for the areas of press and post-press, and thus a new business
opportunity can be identified by the design of new service contents with focus on
the prepress area. For instance, in order to improve the reactive service contents in
the area of prepress, new service contents for “data handling” can be created and
provided by the “Central Service Network of the Manufacturer.”
33 Engineering PSS (Product/Service Systems) Toward Sustainability
Fig. 33.7 “Taxonomy table for value-chain-oriented service development” of the sub-model for print production, “reactive (Tier I)” (Original source: Int.
J. Services Technology and Management, vol. 11, 2009. dx.doi.org/10.1504/IJSTM.2009.022379 c Inderscience Enterprises Ltd. (Panshef et al. 2009))
609
610 T. Sakao
6 Evaluating PSS
Thus far, more research addresses PSS modeling and PSS design, while very little
addresses evaluation of PSS potential or consequences. This implies that there exist
research opportunities for this topic. In PSS research in general, the environmental
potential of PSS has been among the largest concerns. Furthermore, the potential of
not only environmental but also economic aspects is still a hot research issue. Social
effects of PSS are not researched intensively, so far.
7 Other Issues
Other than design which has been overviewed in this chapter, two issues related to
engineering are organizational structure and mindset (Sakao et al. 2009c).
7.2 Mind-set
Companies need to undergo major changes in their mind-set. Companies that have
a strong culture and pride in their products also have to build trust, and their
employees need to believe in their services. Services also need to have a high status
and be incorporated into the company. The importance of mindset and how it can be
built up in line with new company values will be an interesting research area.
8 Summary
manufacturing firms. Integration of services with products is among the most crucial
issues in ManuServ, where PSS is naturally a central topic.
The following is a list of topics and challenges:
1. Business model development: Identification and implementation of service-
based business model, structuring development process, building relationships
with customers, adapting to changing customer needs, and new mindset
2. Marketing and sales: Pricing of PSS, value visualization, top management
commitment, appropriate incentive system, and appropriate KPI used
3. R&D and PSS development: Service development, integrated development of
PSS, integration of PSS development and customer value management, and
evaluating R&D projects toward customer value
4. (Re)manufacturing: Adapting to return items with various types of uncertainty,
setting up remanufacturing, and setting up fleet management
5. Service delivery: Building service delivery organization with new competencies,
handling profit/cost center, building up service network, and lack of internal data
management
6. Supply chain management: Establishing reverse logistics to use return items
(return network, connection to forward network, and sorting) and balancing
returns and demands for them
7. Organizational and managerial topic: Understanding organizational changes
needed, increasing cooperation between service and product organizations,
reframing of the firm’s purpose, what to outsource, and working in an internal/
external network
8. Energy and material consumption: How to integrate/promote energy services and
product need modification for material efficiency
These challenges and research issues highlight the importance of the holistic view
to avoid local optimization within a firm or a group of companies within the same
value chain. In order to deal with one challenge, several other interdependent ones
frequently need to be coped with. For example, organizational and managerial
challenges often need to be overcome in order to succeed with new marketing and
sales practices, supply chain management, PSS and business model development,
etc. Likewise, PSS development and design processes and routines, marketing and
sales metrics, etc. may need to be revised in order to successfully implement
organizational changes. In other words, changes in one will affect the other, and
it ought to be possible to balance different parameters from different areas between
them. A PSS company cannot simply focus on one area to be successful – they need
to balance and modify parameters from all the described areas. The author’s group
believes that PSS research would be more successful with a more integrated and
holistic approach.
References
E. Abele, R. Anderl, H. Birkhofer (eds.), Environmentally Friendly Product Development, Methods
and Tools (Springer, London, 2005)
612 T. Sakao
A.W. Ulwick, Turn customer input into innovation. Harv. Bus. Rev. 80(January), 91–97 (2002)
UNEP, ECODESIGN: A Promising Approach to Sustainable Production and Consumption (United
Nations Publication, Paris, 1997)
United Nations General Assembly, Agenda 21, united nations division for sustainable development
(1992), http://www.un.org/esa/dsd/agenda21/res agenda21 00.shtml. Acessed 3 July 2012
C. van Halen, C. Vezzoli, R. Wimmer, Methodology for Product Service System Innovation
(Koninklijke Van Gorcum, Assen, 2005)
Web site, International PSS design research community (2011), www.pssdesignresearch.org.
Accessed 25 Oct 2011
V.A. Zeithaml, Consumer perceptions of price, quality, and value: a means-end model and synthesis
of evidence. J. Mark. 52(July), 2–22 (1988)
Eco-business Planning: Idea Generation
Method 34
Shinsuke Kondoh and Hitoshi Komoto
Abstract
From the point of view of sustainability as well as an economic perspective,
business planning, monitoring, evaluation, and communication with customers
and a wide variety of other stakeholders are becoming more and more important.
In this context, a growing number of methods and tools for sustainable product
and business design are proposed. Examples include design for environment
(DfE), product service system (PSS), industrial product service system (IPSS),
servicizing, function selling, service engineering, life cycle assessment (LCA),
and life cycle simulation (LCS) methods.
However, it is often difficult to determine business activities that actually
contribute to or harm the sustainability of the earth due to complexity of the
cause-effect chains observed in business activities among stakeholders. Rebound
effects typically show such indirect causality; for instance, the development of
fuel-efficient vehicles may contribute to the reduction of energy consumption
from a systemic perspective. However, the development sometimes increases
energy consumption, because users of these vehicles may be less aware of
the environmental loads of driving activities and drive more in consequence.
Furthermore, governmental subsidies that stimulate the market introduction of
these vehicles may result in the purchasing power of the potential owners in a
long term.
In such a case, it is crucial to configure the business economically and
environmentally feasible in a long term by introducing new activities (e.g.,
introduction of a user incentive scheme regarding the reduction of energy
consumption) accompanied with energy-efficient technologies. Consideration
of such direct and indirect influences of the development of energy-efficient
1 Introduction
Sustainable development (SD) has become a critical issue due to growing concern
about environmental problems in recent years, and firms are obliged to justify their
presence in society more than ever before (Karl-Henrik 2000). In this context, a
number of methods and tools for sustainable product and business design (Umeda
et al. 2009; Meier et al. 2010; Kobayashi and Kumazawa 2005; UNEP 1997; Umeda
et al. 2000; Wimmer et al. 2004; Hauschild et al. 1999; Lindahl and Olundh 2001)
are being proposed.
However, it is often difficult to determine business activities that actually
contribute to (or harm) the sustainability of the earth due to the highly complex
nature of the environmental and economic systems of society. As shown in the
abstract, rebound effects are typical examples showing such complexity. In order
to handle such complexity in a systematic and comprehensive manner in designing
eco-businesses, business planners (and product designers) need to explicitly deal
with cause-effect chains in the businesses and consider indirect influences as well
as direct ones in their decision-making and communication processes. To support
34 Eco-business Planning: Idea Generation Method 617
2 Eco-Business in Industry
a b
−
B’s share − A’s price
+
A’s share
B’s price
−
− Stock of A
R B
A’s price
B’s share −
+
−
Demand for A
A’s share −
+
Positive influence
− Negative influence
Delayed influence
Fig. 34.1 Examples of CLD (a) Reinforcing feedback (b) Balancing feedback (Modified from
Kondoh and Mishima (2011))
a CVP
+ User Value +
LAVP Profit
CAV R
Business activity
+ CPA
b LAEP Lall
CEP
LCE LACP R
CCP
− LCC − or 0
LAVP − or 0
+, −, or 0 User Value
+
+
CAC CAV CVP Profit
CAE
Business activity
+ CPA
CLD of an eco-business
c LAEP
CEP Lall
LCE R LACP C
−
CP
LAVP R
− −
LCC
R User Value +
−
CAE CAC CAV + CVP Profit
Business activity R
+ CPA
Fig. 34.2 CLD for an eco-business (a) CLD of a conventional business (b) CLD of an eco-
business (c) CLD of an ideal eco-business (IEB) (Modified from Kondoh and Mishima (2011))
34 Eco-business Planning: Idea Generation Method 621
Requirements for
1 + + + R
conventional business
Requirements for
2 − − or 0 +,−, or 0 − or 0 + + + R, B, or 0 R, B, or 0 R R
eco-business
Conditions of Ideal
3 − − − − + + + R R R R
Eco-Business (IEB)
Fig. 34.3 CLD of ESCO business (Modified from Kondoh and Mishima (2011))
LCC, and profit, is balancing loop). Although some users prefer green electricity
and are willing to pay more money for it, the volume of the users is insufficient to
compensate the increase in the power generation cost because only limited users
who live near from the plant can buy the green electricity. The CEP (causal links;
(vii) and (x)) is not strong enough to introduce green electricity. To solve this
problem, green electricity certificates organization, which is a different organization
from the power company, calculates the LCE reduction potential, divides LCE
reduction certificate into small pieces, and sells them to the other people and
companies who are willing to do something good for environment (causal links:
(v), (vi), and (viii)). The revenue is used to compensate the cost for green electricity.
By that way, CEP is strengthened in this example. This means that green electricity
certification business satisfies the requirements for eco-business but not for IEB in
terms of CAC and LACP .
626 S. Kondoh and H. Komoto
CEP is strengthen by
3. LCC adding other customers.
+ (vi)
(v) 6. Certification of
− green power 7. UV (Satisfaction of the
5. LCE consumer who cannot
+ directly buy green electricity)
+ (viii)
(iv)
(vii) (ix)
(ii)
4. Environmental − 8. UV (Satisfaction of (x)
green electricity user) + +
load at generation
−
− 9.Profit
(iii)
1.Green power
+ (xi)
2. Power (Hydro and wind
generation cost + (i) electricity etc.)
CAE consists of (iii) and (iv). CVP are (viii) and (x)
Fig. 34.4 CLD of green power certification business (Modified from Kondoh and Mishima
(2011))
The procedure by which the cause-effect pattern library is used to design eco-
businesses and to communicate the design with pertinent stakeholders is summa-
rized as follows:
• Step 1: Identification of current business environment
First, the business designer identifies a set of key parameters that describe the
given business environment in terms of UV, LCE, LCC, and profit, with causality
among these parameters and describes the situation using a CLD, so that he/she
can decide the types of causality among the seven causal links and identify
the gaps between the conditions necessary for an IEB and his/her business
environment.
34 Eco-business Planning: Idea Generation Method 627
In order to illustrate how to use the library to come up with eco-business ideas
(steps 1 and 2 in Sect. 3.4), this section presents a case study of an energy-efficient
vehicles business (EcoFleet). First, the designer identifies his/her customers, their
user value, and causal links among business activities, UV, LCE, LCC, and profit
as shown in the upper part of Fig. 34.5. Although energy-efficient vehicles such
as electric vehicles and hybrids have the possibility to reduce LCE and LCC in
many cases, they are more expensive than conventional vehicles. In addition, there
are no negative causal link between LCE and profit; environmental load reduction
itself makes no profit at all. Thus, the gaps to overcome in this case are insufficient
CAC and insufficient CEP . Referring to the cause-effect pattern library, the designer
finds two cases (ESCO businesses and a green power certification business) that
overcome these respective gaps. The business idea they arrive at by applying the
solution patterns from the successful businesses to this case is summarized as shown
in the lower part of Fig. 34.5.
The “EcoFleet” business provides a fleet management service to carriers based
on a long-term performance contract similar to those used by ESCO businesses.
First, EcoFleet determines the best mix of multiple types of vehicles based on the
628 S. Kondoh and H. Komoto
a
Delay in CAC − 5. UV
(Carrier’s cost reduction) (viii)
4.LCC (v)
+ + ᧧
6. Environmental load (ix) +
(iv) 8. LCE
at production
(ii) (x) + No CEP +
3. Price
(vi) +
7.Environmental load
+ 9.Profit
2. Cost at − at use stage
(vii)
use stage (iii)
1. Sales of energy-
− (i) efficient vehicles + (xi)
CAE consists of two sets of links; CVP is (viii).
(vii) and (x) and (vi) and (ix). CCP consists of (v) and (viii).
CAV consists of (i), (ii), and (v). CPA is (xi)
CAC consists of two sets of links; (i) and There are no CEP.
(ii) and (iii) and (iv).
CLD of energy efficient vehicle business
b
6.UV CEP is strengthened
(viii) by selling green
Delay in CAC is (v) − (Carrier’s cost reduction)
covered by the electricity certificates
business provider + 13. LCC to the
(xii) business provider
+ 5.LCC + 9. LCE (xiii)
᧧ (ix) (xiv)
(ii) + (iv)+ 7.Environmental + −
+ load at production +
(x) ᧩of
10.Certification −
4.Initial (vi) green electricity + 12.Profit
cost 8.Environmental + (xv)
−
load at use stage 11.UV (xvi)
3. Cost at + (vii) −
(Other customers’
use stage satisfaction)
(iii) (xviii) 2. Utilization of green
−
᧩ energy to charge
electric vehicles + (xvii)
(i)
1.Provides fleet +
(xi)
management service
CAE consists of three sets of links; CVP are (viii) and (xvi).
(vii) and (x), (vi) and (ix), and (xviii) CCP consists of (xii) and (xiii). (i)-(xviii) No. of causal link
and (x). Gaps to overcome
CPA are (xvii) and (xi).
CAV consists of three sets of links; ᧧ Positive influence
(i), (ii), and (v), (vi), (ix), (xiv), and CEP consists of (xiv), (xv), and ᧩ Negative influence
(xv), and (xviii), (x), (xiv), and (xv). (xvi)
Delayed influence
CAC consists of two sets of links; (i)
and (ii) and (iii) and (iv).
Fig. 34.5 CLD of EcoFleet business (a) CLD of energy efficient vehicle business (b) CLD of
EcoFleet business (Modified from Kondoh and Mishima (2011))
34 Eco-business Planning: Idea Generation Method 629
customer’s fleet usage pattern and replaces some of them with electric vehicles and
plug-in hybrid vehicles to reduce the fleet’s gasoline consumption. The investment
required for replacement is covered by reduced gasoline consumption, and there is
no need for initial investment by the customer. In addition, to enhance the profit from
the reduction of environmental load, green electricity such as solar or wind power
is used to charge the batteries of electric and plug-in hybrid vehicles. Selling green
electricity certificates to the people or companies who are willing to do something
good for environment increases the profit that can be earned from the environmental
impact reduction.
Global
statics DB Total Discrete event Multi Agent
Performance simulator Simulator
Analyzer (TPA) (DES) (MAS)
Life Cycle
Inventory DB
Cost DB
Fig. 34.6 Architecture of the case-based design support system for eco-businesses (Modified
from Kondoh and Mishima (2011))
630 S. Kondoh and H. Komoto
can modify the template so that the modified template can represent the environment
of the eco-business designed by the designer. The designer uses the modified
template in order to identify the gaps between IEB and the business environment.
The gaps are then used to identify a set of eco-business cases that can potentially
overcome them. The designer generates an idea of eco-business referring to the
identified eco-business cases and describes it in the form of a CLD. On LCM, the
designer models the eco-business in terms of activities defined in the life cycle
of products, which are used in the business. The model on LCM also includes
material, energy, and monetary flows caused by these activities. The model on LCM
helps the designer interpret the corresponding CLD from the perspective of life
cycles of products included in the business. EBE helps the designer evaluate the
environmental and economic performance of the eco-business modeled on LCM.
To provide such an evaluation feature, EBE includes three different tools, the total
performance analyzer (TPA) (Kondoh et al. 2008), a discrete event simulator (DES),
and a multi agent simulator (MAS). TPA, which has been developed by authors
group, is used for the evaluation of environmental and economic performance of
the business modeled on LCM. TPA provides the quantitative evaluation methods
of UV based on the multi-attribute utility theory (MAUT) as well as the LCE and
LCC based on the static life cycle of products. DES imports the activities defined
on LCM and simulates the dynamics of the business in terms of energy, material,
and monetary flows among the stakeholders. Chapter Life Cycle Simulation
for Sustainable Product Service Systems illustrates how to use DES for this
purpose. MAS is used to detail the interactions of stakeholders during the life
cycle of products. For example, the literature (Kondoh et al. 2009) represented the
variations in the preference for and purchasing behavior of personal computers and
investigated the environmentally and economically feasible reuse strategy for each
individual user considering the interaction among them, by using MAS. EBE is
also connected to a set of database including global statistics (e.g., gloss domestic
product and population), life cycle inventory of energy and materials, and cost.
6 Summary
various industrial sectors can become also sources for the library. In addition
to the business cases, macro level causality patterns (e.g., market reaction to the
environmental legislation or taxation and causal description of rebound effect)
are also indispensable for the method.
• Structuring the library in more detail:
As the number of the cases increases in the library, screening out the
adequate cases from the library becomes more crucial. To this end, more detailed
structuring is indispensable. It will be quite promising to identify the key
elements of problem-solution patterns such that most of the successful cases are
explained as their combination.
• Implementation of the system:
Implementation of the system is also included in the future work of this study.
In addition to TPA, eco-business case base, and MAS, which have already been
partially implemented, CLDE and LCM should be implemented and integrated
into the overall framework of the proposed system.
References
Association for ESCO Business Introduction in Japan, Committee report for ESCO business
introduction in Japan, Energy Conservation Centre Japan (1998)
Ecologicom (2012), http://www.ecologicom.com/first/index.htm. Accessed 25 May 2012
M.Z. Hauschild et al., Life cycle design. A route to the sustainable industrial culture? Ann. CIRP
48(1), 93–96 (1999)
R. Karl-Henrik, Tools and concepts for sustainable development, how do they relate to a general
framework for sustainable development, and to each other? J. Clean. Prod. 8, 243–254 (2000)
K. Kobayashi, T. Kumazawa, A simulation-based decision support methodology for reuse business,
in Proceedings of Eco-Design 2005, 3A-1-2F (CD-ROM), Tokyo, 2005
S. Kondoh, N. Mishima, Case based idea generation method for eco-businesses, in Proceedings
of the 3rd CIRP Conference on Industrial Product Service System, Braunschweig (Springer,
New York/Berlin/Heidelberg, 2011), pp. 69–74
S. Kondoh, K. Kurakawa, S. Kato, Y. Umeda, S. Takata, Analysis of key success factors for eco-
business through case studies in Japan, in Proceedings of 13th CIRP International conference
on Life Cycle Engineering, Leuven, 2006, pp. 275–280
S. Kondoh, K. Masui, M. Hattori, N. Mishima, M. Matsumoto, Total performance analysis of
product life cycle considering the deterioration and obsolescence of product value. Int. J. Prod.
Dev. 6(3/4), 334–352 (2008)
S. Kondoh, T. Tateno, M. Matsumoto, Multi-agent simulation of component reuse focusing on
variations in user preference. CIRP J. Manuf. Sci. Technol. 1, 287–293 (2009)
M. Lindahl, G. Olundh, The meaning of functional sales, in Proceedings of the 8th CIRP
International Seminar on Life Cycle Engineering, Varna, 2001, pp. 211–220
H. Meier et al., Industrial product-service systems—IPS2. CIRP Ann. Manuf. Technol. 59,
607–627 (2010)
Press release of Green Power Certification Council (2001), http://eneken.ieej.or.jp/greenpower/
eng/temp/04/01.pdf
J. Puckett et al., Exporting harm (2002), http://www.ban.org/E-waste/technotrashfinalcomp.pdf.
Accessed 25 May 2012, Basel Action Network
J.D. Sterman, Business Dynamics (McGraw-Hill, Boston, 2000)
632 S. Kondoh and H. Komoto
Y. Umeda et al., Study on life-cycle design for the post mass production paradigm. AIEDAM 14(2),
149–161 (2000)
Y. Umeda et al., Proposal of sustainable society scenario simulator. CIRP J. Manuf. Sci. Technol.
1(4), 272–278 (2009)
UNEP, Ecodesign: A Promising Approach to Sustainable Product and Consumption (United
Nations Publication, Paris, 1997)
W. Wimmer et al., Ecodesign Implementation (Springer, Dordrecht, 2004)
Life Cycle Simulation for Sustainable
Product Service Systems 35
Hitoshi Komoto and Nozomu Mishima
Abstract
Design of sustainable product service system (PSS) is a means for the
manufacturing industry to develop business models for sustainable production
and consumption through collaborations among the stakeholders involved in
them. Life cycle simulation (LCS) is a crucial tool to evaluate the monetary
flows among the stakeholders and material and product flows during the life
cycles of products. This chapter presents LCS used for the design and analysis
of sustainable PSS. This chapter presents the usefulness of LCS for the design
and analysis of business models in the manufacturing industry regarding the
profit of both manufacturers and product users. This chapter first explains PSS
design process and computational support employed in the process. As a part
of computational support, the chapter explains LCS focusing on the simulation
mechanism, theoretical background, and applications. Finally, the chapter applies
LCS to the evaluation and comparison of seven business models of a manufac-
turer of machine tools for mold component production. The business models
include service-oriented business model, functional sales, and shared services,
which are discussed in related PSS study as well as the traditional sales-based
business model.
H. Komoto ()
Advanced Manufacturing Research Institute, National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science
and Technology (AIST), Tsukuba, Ibaraki, Japan
e-mail: h.komoto@aist.go.jp
N. Mishima
Graduate School of Engineering and Resource Science, Akita University, Akita, Akita, Japan
e-mail: nmishima@gipc.akita-u.ac.jp
Abbreviations
1 Introduction
Product service system (PSS) is a system of products and services that satisfies
the needs and wishes of product users in a comprehensive manner (Mont 2002).
For instance, public transportation systems consisting of various stakeholders and
mobility channels are regarded as PSS. In the PSS, trains, cars, and bicycles
are regarded as service channels that directly provide mobility to customers.
Stakeholders of the PSS are not only the manufacturers of these service channels.
Effective collaboration among the involved stakeholders (e.g., supermarkets, adver-
tisement agencies, and end users) improves the quality of mobility and creates added
value in terms of various quality criteria (e.g., convenience and entertainment). Such
effective collaboration among the stakeholders and product users in PSS is crucial
for system-level innovation leading to environmentally friendly society (Ehrenfeld
2001). The degree of reduction of environmental loads realized by PSS is considered
larger than the degree realized by individual product and service innovation (Brezet
et al. 2001; Maxwell and van der Vorstb 2004).
For the manufacturing industry, PSS is crucial to develop their business with
focus on their services (Tomiyama 1997, 2001; Meier et al. 2010). Figure 35.1
shows the difference between the traditional business at the age of mass production
and PSS toward sustainable society. In the traditional business, the profit of manu-
facturers is determined by the number of products sold in the market. In other words,
the ownership transfer of products is the activity triggering the monetary flows.
In PSS, products are regarded as service channels to deliver not only function of
products but also service contents perceived from various aspects (e.g., convenience,
safety, and comfort). This is why production and ownership of products become less
dominant factors characterizing the profit of manufacturers.
PSS design is concerned with the design of such a system focusing on adaptation
of (often existing) products and services to economic, environmental, cultural, and
social contexts specified by stakeholders such as manufacturers, service providers,
and product users (Tukker and Tischner 2006). For instance, public transportation
systems adapt themselves to mobility users regarding their characteristics such
as age, purpose, and family structure. These characteristics specify the type of
mobility means and added value delivered to them. The design processes start with
the development of a qualitative business concept (conceptual design) followed by
the refinement of the business concept with consideration of quantitative aspects
(detail design). The research of service engineering has developed a variety of
computational tools to support both conceptual and detail PSS design stages.
35 Life Cycle Simulation for Sustainable Product Service Systems 635
Service CAD systems (Arai and Shimomura 2004, 2005; Sakao and Shimomura
2007, 2009; Komoto and Tomiyama 2009a) have been proposed so that they can
support the design of sustainable PSS at the conceptual PSS design stage, while
life cycle simulation (LCS) (Umeda et al. 2000) supports quantitative evaluation of
sustainable product service systems, which becomes crucial in the detail PSS design
stage.
The objective of this chapter is to provide an introduction to LCS in context of
sustainable PSS design. The chapter helps designers of sustainable PSS understand
the concept, mechanism, and applications of LCS and employ LCS for their own
PSS design processes in practice.
The structure of this chapter is as follows. First, it briefly explains PSS design
process and computational support employed in the process. Then it explains LCS in
terms of simulation mechanism, theoretical background, and applications. Finally,
the chapter evaluates and compares seven business models of a manufacturer
using LCS. The models include business models discussed in PSS study such as
service-oriented business model, functional sales, and shared services as well as the
traditional sales-based business model.
PSS design is concerned with the design of products and services that satisfy the
needs and wishes of customers as a whole, while considering business, environmen-
tal, cultural, and social contexts specified by stakeholders such as manufacturers,
service providers, and product users (Tukker and Tischner 2006). In the design
636 H. Komoto and N. Mishima
processes, designers gradually refine the attributes of products and services and their
interrelations in parallel with decomposition of the needs and wishes of product
users. The refinement and decomposition processes are similar to product design
processes traditionally studied in the field of engineering design (Pahl and Beitz
1996). Similar to traditional product design processes, PSS design processes start
with the development of a qualitative PSS concept (conceptual design) followed
by the refinement of the concept with consideration of quantitative aspects (detail
design).
The main tasks of designers in PSS design processes are shown in Fig. 35.2.
At the conceptual (qualitative) stage of PSS design, activities, stakeholders, and
service channels to satisfy the needs and wishes of product users are identified as
elements of a PSS concept followed by the identification of such needs and wishes.
Concretely, the characteristics of stakeholders, service channels, and users are
identified in parallel with development of the scenario of users. Quantitative analysis
of a PSS concept becomes crucial with the progress of PSS design processes,
because economic and environmental feasibility of a designed PSS concept cannot
be judged solely by the concept (without discussing quantitative configuration of
parameters in the concept) (Bartolomeo et al. 2002). For instance, in designing a
public transportation system, designers have to consider the quantitative aspects of
the system such as the frequency and capacity of trains, the number and size of rental
cars and bicycles and their parking areas, the number of qualified service engineers,
the price of each service included in the concept, and so on. Without consideration of
such quantitative aspects, even well-designed PSS concepts are not only inferior to
other alternative concepts delivering the same service contents but also suffer from
shortage and excess of service providers and channels to meet the corresponding
requirements.
35 Life Cycle Simulation for Sustainable Product Service Systems 637
Fig. 35.3 Computational support for PSS design in analogy of product design support
Life cycle simulation (LCS) (Umeda et al. 2000) is a technique to evaluate the
performances of life cycles (e.g., life cycle costs and environmental impacts) using
discrete event simulation. LCS simulates physical and functional deterioration of
individual products in a market. LCS also simulates execution of technical services
and activities performed by manufacturers and other service providers at the use
and end-of-life stages. These services and activities include maintenance, upgrade,
collection, trade-in, remanufacturing, reuse, and recycling activities. Simulation of
these services and activities enables PSS designers to consider relations among
them.
Figure 35.4 illustrates the simulation mechanism of LCS. LCS model consists of
entities and events. Entities represent products in a life cycle. The state of entities
is defined by a set of attribute values. The state of an entity is defined by its
lifetime, location, owner, the type of contract, and its performance from various
(e.g., functional, physical, and environmental) aspects considering its deterioration
(due to usage) and recovery (as a result of maintenance and upgrade services).
Events assign (and change) the state of entities and causes generation and disposal
of entities. In Fig. 35.5, for instance, Manufacture creates products (i.e., entities)
35 Life Cycle Simulation for Sustainable Product Service Systems 639
and Dispose deletes them. Use and Repair/Maintenance change the state of entities
such as functional and physical performances. The state changes considering the
stochastic properties of processes are realized with random number generation.
LCS is useful to predict the timing and number of event executions based on the
temporal state transition (e.g., deterioration mechanism) of products. For instance,
in a given market size, LCS can calculate the timing and number of Manufacture and
Transport of the next generation products considering Reuse of the first generation
products (see Fig. 35.4). According to the state of products, they are collected,
640 H. Komoto and N. Mishima
reused, disassembled, and recycled with the corresponding events. The state of all
entities and history of event executions are collected. The collected information is
used to generate statistical figures of the life cycle and visualized for users of LCS
to understand the behavior of products in the product life cycle.
3.3 Applications
Various LCS tools have been developed and applied to life cycle design such as
design of modular structure and product family of such white goods as refrigerators
and fax machines (Johansen et al. 1997; Umeda et al. 2000; Fujimoto et al. 2003).
They are reviewed in Komoto and Tomiyama (2009b). Among them, some focused
on the design of technical services during the use stage of products, which is
considered as examples of PSS design. For instance, LCS has been applied to design
of reuse business of personal computers (Kumazawa and Kobayashi 2006) and
shared business of washing machines (Komoto et al. 2005). In these studies, LCS
has been useful to deal with market segments with different needs, while considering
competitions regarding service offerings among producers and third-party service
providers. Furthermore, LCS has been applied to resource flow analysis considering
reuse and remanufacturing processes. The resource was not only material and
energy described as mass but also reusable parts in different physical conditions. The
tools developed in these studies are useful to analyze balance between the demand
and supply of reusable parts (Kondoh et al. 2005). The actual resource flow data of
reusable parts has been collected for the verification and rigorous analysis of using
these tools (Takata and Kimura 2003).
A
No Included in
Repair Service the tool price B
Provided
Yes Yes Repair fee Rare C
Repair
Excluded in
occurrence
Ownership the tool price
Frequent D
Tool repair E
No
Money flow No F
activities
Shared use
Tool usage G
Yes
flow between the producer and machine tool users at the activity. The tool usage
charge uT is paid by machine tool users to the producer per mold component
production (i.e., pay-per-function).
• Tool Repair: Repair service is necessary to deal with the deterioration of machine
tools. The service is triggered when the efficiency of machine tools reach a
threshold value, which will be explained later. Among the business models B–G,
which includes the activity, business models C–E assume the monetary flow at
the activity. In business models C–E, the repair fee and repair costs of a machine
tool, sT and rT , are 500,000 JPY and 400,000 JPY, respectively.
The deterioration of a machine tool is defined by decreases in the efficiency of
the machine tool eT in mold component production. The efficiency is owned by
individual machine tools. The efficiency of machine tools before deterioration (i.e.,
new machines) is 100%. As shown in Fig. 35.7, the efficiency of a machine tool is
partly included in the monetary flows, which indicates that the efficiency influences
the production costs of mold components with the tool cC /eT and the repair costs of
the tool rT /eT . For instance, a machine tool with eT = 50% doubles the production
costs of mold components with the tool and the repair costs of the tool.
Figure 35.8 describes the calculation procedure of the efficiency of a machine
tool. This example assumes that the efficiency depends on three parameters, fr1 ,
fr2 , and fr3 , which characterize the physical deterioration of a machine tool. These
parameters constitute the probability of a failure occurrence per single tool usage.
The probability is constant fr1 until the elapsed life time elt reaches the specific
period fr2 , and it linearly increases after the period (the time derivative of the failure
rate is fr3 / until the probability reaches 1. When a failure occurs, the efficiency
decreases by 1%. Since machine tools are used multiple times (100 times per
week in this example), failures can occur multiple times at a single simulation step
(i.e., a week). The probability characterized with these parameters is often called
the bathtub curve without the initial screening phase.
The occurrence of service is defined by the service request level SRL (%),
which is the minimum efficiency of machine tool guaranteed by the machine tool
manufacturer. In other words, the repair services are offered when the efficiency
644 H. Komoto and N. Mishima
fr1 0.001 1
Parameters characterizing the deterioration
fr2 300 Week behavior of machine tools
of machine tools reaches the service request level. The service request level is
constrained by the other values characterizing the monetary flow model in the
simulation, which will be described in the explanation of each business model
discussed below.
Table 35.1 summarizes the values of the parameters of the business models
explained below. The parameters characterize the monetary flows occurred to at
the aforementioned activities and the occurrence of the repair service.
In this traditional business model, the monetary flow between the machine tool
producer and users occurs at the delivery of the ownership of machine tools. No
repair services are considered in the model. Figure 35.9a shows the profit of the
machine tool producer per machine tool user (it is called the normalized profit in the
subsection) and the profit of tool users on average. Figure 35.9b shows the efficiency
of machine tools on average. As shown in Fig. 35.9, the maximum profit of tool
users on average reaches at et = 75%. It is because the production costs of a mold
component considering the deterioration of the tools do not exceed its sales price
(1,500 JPY/2,000 JPY = 0.75). The value is used as the minimum of the service
request level SRL in the other business models including the tool repair activity.
For the tool users, the optimal life time of the tool is 239 weeks on average, while the
35 Life Cycle Simulation for Sustainable Product Service Systems 645
a b
Profit [1,000 JPY] Efficiency [%]
10,000 100
90 Machine tool user
8,000 Machine tool producer
(normalized) 80 (average)
6,000 70
Machine tool user
4,000 (average) 60
2,000 50
40
0
30
−2,000 20
−4,000 10
−6,000 0
1 101 201 301 401 1 101 201 301 401
Elapsed life time [week] Elapsed life time [week]
economically feasible life time is between 177 and 297 weeks. The simulated return
of investment (177 weeks) is larger than 120 weeks, which is assumed without the
deterioration of the tools.
In this business model, the machine tool producer provides repair services to tool
users free of charge. The repair services are offered when the efficiency of machine
tools reaches SRL = 75%. The simulated profit and the efficiency in the business
model are shown in Fig. 35.10a, b. The profit of tool users becomes larger than the
sales-based business type (A), because the efficiency of machine tools is maintained
by the machine tool producer. The return of investment of tool users on average
becomes 142 weeks. In return, the costs of the machine tool producer increase as
the repair services are provided. The simulation result in Fig. 35.10a indicates that
the cumulative repair costs reach the total sales at 416 weeks, when the tool producer
loses the profit gained at the sales of the machine tools. In Fig. 35.10c, the number
of the occurrences of repair services is shown. The number increases, as the failure
rate of machine tools increases with the increase in the elapsed life time.
In the business models C and D, the machine tool producer offers the repair services
as independent services, which require the payment of repair fees. The number of
repair services depends on service request level SRL. Figures 35.11 and 35.12 shows
the simulation results of the business models with variations in SRL (75% in C,
90% in D). As shown in Figs. 35.11b and 35.12b, the efficiency of machine tools
646 H. Komoto and N. Mishima
a b
Profit [1,000 JPY] Efficiency [%]
10000 Machine tool user 100
Machine tool producer (average)
8000 (normalized) 90
80
6000
70
4000 60 Machine tool user
(average)
2000 50
0 40
30
−2000
20
−4000 10
−6000 0
1 101 201 301 401 1 101 201 301 401
Elapsed life time [week] Elapsed life time [week]
c
Number of repair service occurrences [1]
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
1 101 201 301 401
Elapsed life time [week]
on average converges 87.5% and 95%, respectively. The repair services occur in the
model D more frequent than those in the model C. As shown in Figs. 35.11c and
35.12c, the number of the occurrences of repair services increases, as the elapsed life
time of machine tools increase. The number in the model D is larger than the number
in the model C. The occurrences of the repair services influence the long term profit
of the producer and users. In comparison between Figs. 35.11a and 35.12a, it is
evident that the tool producer increases its profit by increasing the number of the
occurrence of repair services (i.e., by increasing SRL). However, the side effect of
the increase in the profit of the tool producer appears at the profit of the tool users.
The business model E treats the tool producer as a repair service provider.
The producer first provides machine tools to users free of charge. Then, the producer
35 Life Cycle Simulation for Sustainable Product Service Systems 647
a b
Profit [1,000 JPY] Efficiency [%]
10000 100
Machine tool producer
8000 (normalized) 90
80
6000
70
4000 60 Machine tool user
(average)
2000 50
0 40
30
−2000
20
−4000 Machine tool user
10
(average)
−6000 0
1 101 201 301 401 1 101 201 301 401
Elapsed life time [week] Elapsed life time [week]
c
Number of repair service occurrences [1]
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
1 101 201 301 401
Elapsed life time [week]
gains the profit by providing the repair services during the life cycle of machine
tools. The profit of the producer increases with increase in the occurrences of
the repair services. For this reason, in order to evaluate the maximum profit of the
producer obtained with the model E, SRL is set to 99%. This means that machine
tools are repaired immediately after the decrease in the efficiency is observed at the
weekly tool inspections.
This model requires the evaluation of the return of investment of the tool
producer. The simulation result in Fig. 35.13a shows that the producer should
continue the contract with the users regarding the service more than 410 weeks,
while the profit of the tool users on average reaches maximum at the 310 week.
This means that the model E is not feasible, because the users would terminate the
contract with the producer at the 310 week before the producer gains the profit in
the business. One of the possible modifications of the business model, which makes
the business model feasible, is to introduce variations in the repair fees with respect
to the use time.
648 H. Komoto and N. Mishima
a b
Profit [1,000 JPY] Efficiency [%]
Machine tool user
10,000 (average) 100
Machine tool producer
8,000 (normalized) 90
80
6,000
70
4,000 60 Machine tool user
(average)
2,000 50
0 40
30
−2,000
20
−4,000 10
−6,000 0
1 101 201 301 401 1 101 201 301 401
Elapsed life time [week] Elapsed life time [week]
c
Number of repair service occurrences [1]
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
1 101 201 301 401
Elapsed life time [week]
The business models F introduces a tool usage charge in the contract between the
tool producer and users. In the model, the producer has the ownership of machine
tools and provides the repair services free of charge. The service request level (SRL)
in the model is constrained by the tool usage charge uT and the price and production
costs of mold components pC and cC . Since the tool users need to gain profit at the
production and sales of mold components, SRL should be bigger than cC /(pC uT ).
Numerically, if the tool usage charge is 300 JPY, SRL should be bigger than 1,500
JPY/(2,000 JPY300 JPY) = 88.24% (SRL = 89% is used in the simulation). As the
simulated result in Fig. 35.14a shows, the return of investment of the producer is
147 week. The profit of the producer reaches its maximum at 374 week. The tool
users gain the profit as far as the efficiency is maintained above SRL. The profits
35 Life Cycle Simulation for Sustainable Product Service Systems 649
a b
Profit [1,000 JPY] Machine tool user Efficiency [%]
(average) 100
10,000
90
8,000
80
6,000 70
4,000 60 Machine tool user
50 (average)
2,000
40
0
30
−2,000 20
−4,000 10
Machine tool producer
0
−6,000 (normalized)
1 101 201 301 401
1 101 201 301 401
Elapsed life time [week] Elapsed life time [week]
c
Number of repair service occurrences [1]
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
1 101 201 301 401
Elapsed life time [week]
of individual tool users are slightly different because of the differences in the
production costs of mold components considering the machine tool deterioration.
The business model G introduces the sharing of machine tools among the users,
who have the pay-per-function contract based on the business model F. In the model
G, a machine tool is shared by two users. Consequently, 50 machine tools are
produced for 100 machine users, and each machine tool is used two times (i.e.,
production of 200 mold components per week). In Fig. 35.14b, the curve indicating
the profit of the producer per user is in parallel with the similar curve shown in
Fig. 35.14a. It is because the production costs of machine tools per user, which
are the initial costs of the producer, become 2,000,000 JPY per user (instead of
4,000,000 JPY per user) and that the weekly profit of the producer is as same as that
of the model F. As a result, the return of investment of the producer in the model G
is 73 week. Based on the simulation result, the business model G is better than the
business model F for the producer regardless of the benefit of the users. It is because
the business model G does not consider inconvenience for the users due to sharing
of the machine tools.
650 H. Komoto and N. Mishima
a b
Profit [1,000 JPY] Profit [1,000 JPY]
10,000 10,000
8,000 8,000
6,000 6,000
4,000 4,000
2,000 2,000
Machine tool user
Machine tool user
0 0 (average)
(average)
−2,000 −2,000
Machine tool producer Machine tool producer
−4,000 (normalized) −4,000 (normalized)
−6,000 −6,000
1 101 201 301 401 1 101 201 301 401
Elapsed life time [week] Elapsed life time [week]
Fig. 35.14 Pay-per-function business model (left) and its integration with shared service (right)
5 Summary
The chapter has explained the role of LCS in context of the overall PSS design pro-
cesses. Among the computational support for PSS design, LCS provides designers
with quantitative guidance in the detail stage of PSS design processes. The chapter
has explained the mechanism and theoretical background of LCS, and applications
of LCS to service and life cycle design, which are sufficient for the readers to
understand the concept of LCS in designing sustainable PSS.
This chapter has shown how LCS is used for the evaluation and comparison
of business models of a machine tool producer. The simulated business models
have been classified in terms of the contracts among the machine tool producer
and users, which determines the monetary flows at the delivery of the ownership of
machine tools, and the usage and repair of machine tools. The simulation results
have quantified the progress of the profits of the tool producer and users in each
business model and the dependency of the profits on the service request level to
determine the condition to offer the repair service.
Although the chapter has emphasized the use of LCS in the quantitative analysis
of business models in the design phase of sustainable PSS, LCS is used at the
conceptual design phase by providing quantitative answers to “what-if” questions
regarding the types of contacts among the stakeholders. LCS can be used at the
implementation and management phases of sustainable PSS, where the quantitative
analysis of sustainable PSS and the comparison among the alternative business
models become more important than the conceptual design of sustainable PSS.
LCS used at these phases will support decision making of the developers and
managers of sustainable PSS regarding the introduction of new stakeholders that
further decrease the resource usage and consumption in sustainable PSS.
35 Life Cycle Simulation for Sustainable Product Service Systems 651
References
T. Arai, Y, Shimomura, Proposal of service CAD system – a tool for service engineering. Ann.
CIRP 53(1), 397–400 (2004)
T. Arai, Y. Shimomura, Service CAD system – evaluation and quantification. Ann. CIRP 54(1),
463–466 (2005)
M. Bartolomeo, D. dal Maso, D. de Jong, P. Eder, P. Groenewegen, P. Hopkinson, P. James, L.
Nijhuis, M. Örninge, G. Scholl et al., Eco-efficient producer services—what are they, how
do they benefit customers and the environment and how likely are they to develop and be
extensively utilized? J. Clean. Prod. 10(3), 829–837 (2002)
H. Brezet, S.A. Bijma, S. Silvester, The Design of Eco-efficient Services: Method, Tools and Review
of the Case Study Based ‘Designing Eco-Efficient Services’ Project Design for Sustainability
Program (Delft University of Technology, Delft, 2001)
M.B. Cook, T.A. Bhamra, M. Lemon, The transfer and application of product service systems:
from academia to UK manufacturing firms. J. Clean. Prod. 14(17), 1455–1465 (2006)
J. Ehrenfeld, Designing ‘sustainable’ product/service systems, in 2nd International Symposium on
Environmentally Conscious Design and Inverse Manufacturing (EcoDesign 2001) (IEEE, Los
Alamitos, Calif, 2001), pp. 12–23
J. Fujimoto, Y. Umeda, T. Tamura, T. Tomiyama, F. Kimura, Development of service-oriented
products based on the inverse manufacturing concept. Environ. Sci. Technol. 37(23),
5398–5406 (2003)
D.E. Goldberg, Genetic Algorithm in Search, Optimization, and Machine Learning (Addison-
Wesley, Reading, Mass, 1989)
T. Hara, T. Arai, Y. Shimomura, Integrated representation of function, service activity, and product
behavior for service development, in Proceedings of the 13th Design for Manufacturing and the
Life Cycle Conference – DFMLC2008 –, Brooklyn, New York, CD-ROM (ASME, New York,
2008)
M. Johansen, Y. Umeda, T. Tomiyama, Life cycle simulation for verifying sustainable model of
products, in Re-Engineering for Sustainable Industrial Production, ed. by L.M. Camarinha-
Motos (Chapman & Hall, London, 1997), pp. 247–258
S. Kirkpatrick, C.D. Gelatt, M.P. Vecchi, Optimization by simulated annealing. Science 220(4598),
671–680 (1983)
H. Komoto, T. Tomiyama, M. Nagel, S. Slivester, H. Brezet, Life cycle simulation for analyzing
product service systems, in 4th International Symposium on Environmentally Conscious Design
and Inverse Manufacturing (EcoDesign 2005) (IEEE, Piscataway, N.J., 2005), pp. 386–393
H. Komoto, T. Tomiyama, Integration of a service CAD and a life cycle simulator. Ann. CIRP
57(1), 9–12 (2008)
H. Komoto, T. Tomiyama, Systematic generation of PSS concepts using a service CAD tool, in
Introduction to Product/Service-Systems design (Springer, London, 2009a)
H. Komoto, T. Tomiyama, Design of competitive maintenance service for durable and capital goods
using life cycle simulation. Int. J. Autom. Technol. 3(1), 63–70 (2009b)
S. Kondoh, M. Soma, Y. Umeda, Simulation of closed-loop manufacturing systems focused on
material balance of forward and inverse flows. Int. J. Environ. Conscious Des. Manuf. 13(2),
1–16 (2005)
T. Kumazawa, H. Kobayashi, A simulation system to support the establishment of circulated
business. Adv. Eng. Inform. 20(2), 127–136 (2006)
D. Maxwell, R. van der Vorstb, Developing sustainable products and services, J. Clean. Prod. 11,
883–895 (2004)
H. Meier, R. Roy, G. Seliger, Industrial product-service systems—IPS2. CIRP Ann. Manuf.
Technol. 59(2) 607–627 (2010)
O. Mont, Clarifying the concept of product service systems. J. Clean. Prod. 10(3), 237–245 (2002)
G. Pahl, W. Beitz, Engineering Design: A Systematic Approach, 2nd edn. (Springer, London, 1996)
652 H. Komoto and N. Mishima
Abstract
In recent years, manufacturers have dealt with various requirements of customers
and serious environmental problems. As an effective approach to deal with
those problems, the concept of product-service systems has attracted attention.
The authors have been conducting research on Service Engineering for effective
and efficient service design and development in an engineering manner. In this
chapter, the authors explain the service-centered design approach and concrete
design methods for product-service systems in Service Engineering. In addition,
the authors introduce a computer-aided design system of services based on these
design methods.
1 Introduction
As society ages, services and knowledge have become more important in many
industries (Tomiyama 1997). As the term “servitization” indicates (Vandermerwe
and Rada 1988), a service and knowledge provided through a product are regarded
as more important elements than the product itself even in the manufacturing
industry. Under such circumstances, “product-service systems (PSSs)” that create
value by coupling a product and a service have been attracting attention (Goedkoop
et al. 1999). For the effective and efficient design of PSS, the introduction of
engineering methods is considered as a promising approach. However, compared
Y. Shimomura ()
Graduate School of System Design, Tokyo Metropolitan University, Tokyo, Japan
e-mail: yoshiki-shimomura@center.tmu.ac.jp
K. Watanabe
Graduate School of System Design, Tokyo Metropolitan University (Currently: Center for Service
Research, National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Technology), Tokyo, Japan
e-mail: watanabe-kentaro@sd.tmu.ac.jp
with research on product design, there have been fewer studies on the design of
services from the engineering viewpoint (Shostack 1981; Aurich et al. 2004; Tukker
2004).
To correct this situation, several researchers have started to conduct Service
Engineering research (e.g., Shimomura and Tomiyama 2002). The aim of Service
Engineering is to provide a fundamental understanding of a service as well as
concrete engineering methods to design and develop it. In this chapter, the authors
first explain a concept of service and its design approach in Service Engineering.
Based on the concept and the approach, the authors introduce several service models
and design methods used in each service design phase. In addition, the authors
introduce a computer-aided design (CAD) system based on the proposed design
methods.
Higher Value
Design Object
Lower Value
Product Service
Fig. 36.1 Design operations with constraint between product and service
Before focusing on the design methods, the authors explain the overview of
PSS and service research. Research on services and PSSs ranges over numerous
subjects. Meier et al. summarized the PSS and service research (Meier et al. 2010).
Figure 36.2 shows the categories and concrete methods on PSSs according to their
classification. In this chapter, the authors mainly introduce the concept and methods
in the category “design and development,” including service modeling, design
methods, and a design process. Although the financial and management topics in
the category “business models, risk evaluation, and management” are important to
continue a service as business, they are not the target of this chapter. The analysis
and control methods in the category “delivery and use” are also beyond the present
focus. The utilization of design knowledge in the category “knowledge management
and life cycle issues” is partially discussed in this chapter.
4 Service Design
Traditionally, service design often means just the determination of the behavior of
service staff, even when some products are strongly related to service contents.
In the traditional design process of a service, products and service activities are
656 Y. Shimomura and K. Watanabe
separately designed, and the design actors of products and services are separated.
This causes insufficient fulfillment of customer requirements and inefficiency of
PSS design.
The service-centered design approach is a holistic approach to determine the
specification of service activities and products required for providing PSSs and
even pure services. For example, Aurich et al. propose integrated product-and-
service design processes (Aurich et al. 2004). The authors also have been developing
the integrated design methodology of service activities and products based on the
service-centered design approach, so that a single actor can carry out the core
processes of service design. In the context of the service-centered design approach,
“service” means not only intangible human activities to provide value to customers
but also the total performance of PSSs including products. In addition, “service
design” in the service-centered design approach is a designing activity to create such
expanded services. In this context, the authors explain required engineering methods
for service design, including service modeling methods, service design phases, and
related design methods.
5 Modeling Method
controls service contents and indirectly influences the state change of a service
receiver (see Fig. 36.3). Service contents and channels configure the realization
structure of a service.
Based on the abovementioned definition, the representation scheme of the state
change of a service receiver, contents, and a channel has been proposed (Shimomura
and Tomiyama 2002). This method expresses a service as the combination of
parameters and their relationships, and it provides three kinds of parameters,
namely, receiver state parameters (RSPs), content parameters (CoPs), and channel
parameters (ChPs). A set of RSPs represents a receiver’s state. Any RSP can be
defined if it describes a receiver’s state. However, for meaningful service design,
RSPs must be observable and related to the needs of a service receiver. The
adequate representation of a service receiver’s demands with RSPs is one of the
most important processes in service design. CoPs express contents, and ChPs which
express a channel affect CoPs and indirectly influence RSPs.
Provider
Flow Model
View Model
RSP
Receiver
Scope Model
Intermediate
Agent
Scope Model
Scope Model
Legend
Time to move to a destination
RSP (Receiver
Lend a bike State Parameter)
Rate of usable bikes Speed of bikes Function
parameter
Hire workers Prepare a rental place Prepare bikes Attribute
Treating Size of Size of parameter
time rental places bikes Relation between
parameters
Performance Size Size Function
Store staff Rental place Bike Speed
Entity
the realization structure of a service through the relationship between the RSP
and the functional structure. Figure 36.5 is a description of the view model.
The functions of channels and contents are expressed by function names
as lexical expressions and function parameters (FPs) as target parameters
of functions. Each function is related to another. The FPs that are directly
related to RSPs are recognized as CoPs, and those indirectly influencing
RSPs are ChPs. The most important role of service design is to clarify the
realization structure of a service represented through the relationships among
the parameters reported above (RSP, ChP, and CoP). In addition, by relating
the realization structure composed of CoPs and ChPs to artifacts, called
entities, the roles of actual entities in a service, as a channel or contents, can
be determined.
– Scope model
Since an actual service is composed of complicated mutual relationships
among providers and receivers, it is necessary to specify the active target range
in the design of the service (Shimomura and Tomiyama 2002). A scope model
expresses the target range of a service. A scope model is represented as a set
of RSPs specified by a designer and view models that are related to them.
– Flow model
As reported above, many services form complex structures consisting of
many stakeholders. Between a final receiver and a provider, there may be
many intermediate agents, since it is generally inefficient to provide a service
without the support of these intermediate agents. Since intermediate agents
also evaluate services as service receivers, values for intermediate agents must
also be designed.
The flow model describes stakeholder relationships (Shimomura and
Tomiyama 2002). The flow model consists of stakeholders, called agents, and
one-to-one relationships among them. The scope model depicts a one-to-one
660 Y. Shimomura and K. Watanabe
Legend
Customer
Start
Ask for a Receive a Paddle a event
bike bike bike
Activity /
behavior
Pool
Invisible Visible
Receive a
Store staff
Pass a bike
request
Sequence
flow
Unlock a
bike
Message
flow
Lock
Unlock
Bikes
Pedal
Rotate
The design activities of services can be categorized into three design phases, i.e.,
value analysis, embodiment, and evaluation. A variety of design methods to realize
and support the design activities is proposed in each phase.
1. Value analysis
In the phase of value analysis, a service designer specifies the stakeholders of
a service and analyzes their requirements and values. For that, the persona and
scenario models are effective. To simplify the process of value analysis, the value
analysis template has been proposed (Akasaka et al. 2009).
The persona and scenario models use a form of representation based on natural
language. Thus, it requires a certain amount of training, given the diversity of
vocabulary selection and the difficulty of determining synonymy. Therefore,
to describe these models simply, a design template has been proposed. This
template is a set of five subtemplates used to describe personas, scenarios,
and RSPs:
– Persona template
Persona template is to describe a persona with its demographic data and
psychological data.
– Character/intent template
Character/intent template is to configure characters and intents of the designed
persona with the prepared vocabulary list.
– Script template
Script template is to describe detailed activities of the designed persona to
identify his or her needs.
– Keyword template
Keyword template is to convert the script to keywords which are unified
lexical expressions.
– RPS extraction template
RSP extraction template is to determine RSPs by correlating them with the
keywords.
By filling these templates in order, a service designer can determine RSPs
easily.
2. Embodiment
According to the analyzed values of stakeholders, a service designer embodies
a service process and its realization structure. To extract and determine their
elements, the modeling methods reported above have been proposed.
In addition, several design support methods have been suggested to embody
a service. Applying the method for product design to service design has become
one of the typical approaches. Here, the authors introduce the following two
methods:
– Abduction-based creative design
Abduction is a reasoning method that generates the hypothetical knowl-
edge needed to explain a certain fact and is realized by analogy in many
cases (Takeda et al. 2003). Abduction by analogy has been applied to
662 Y. Shimomura and K. Watanabe
the creative design of not only products but also services by integrat-
ing knowledge from different domains (Oki et al. 2010). By using this
technique, a service designer can extract possible design ideas for service
design.
– Conflict detection and resolution
In the designed service models, there may be some conflicts. To avoid
them, a conflict-detection method has been proposed by analyzing objects
and predicates of functional expressions with a lexical expression database
(Shimomura and Hara 2010). To resolve such conflicts, TRIZ is commonly
used in product design (Mann 2002). TRIZ is a well-known methodology
for the detection and resolution of conflicts by means of the principles
and knowledge based on patent analysis. In several service studies, a part
of the TRIZ methodology is applied for service design. For example, a
list of inventive principles is used to solve the conflict (Shimomura and
Hara 2010).
3. Evaluation
After embodying a service, a designer evaluates and verifies it. Several methods
have been proposed to evaluate the efficiency and effectiveness of designed
services.
– Simulation
To evaluate the designed services, various simulation methods have been
proposed. For example, Komoto and Tomiyama applied a life cycle simulation
method for the evaluation of service processes (Komoto and Tomiyama
2008) (see chapter Life Cycle Simulation for Sustainable Product Ser-
vice Systems). In addition, a simulation method with a scene transition
net (STN) has been applied to service design (Tateyama et al. 2009).
STN is a graphic modeling method for discrete-continuous hybrid sys-
tems. It is suitable for a service process simulation, since it can describe
both the discrete-event transition and the state change of each stakeholder
simultaneously.
– Structure analysis
For the improvement of a designed structure model, a structure analy-
sis is also an effective approach. For example, a method to analyze the
importance of a design structure and parameters by means of QFD and
AHP is proposed (Shimomura et al. 2008). Quality function deployment
(QFD) is a systematic analysis method to translate customer needs into the
requirements and specifications of a design object (Akao 1990). Meanwhile,
the Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) (Saaty 1980) is used to compute
the importance of RSPs numerically according to bilateral comparisons
among parameters. By creating an importance matrix of a designed service
structure, essential points of the service structure can be identified for
improvement.
Figure 36.7 is an overview of the service design methods and processes
described above. As is evident, Service Engineering and its methods are based
on various existing approaches.
36 Modeling Services and Service-Centered PSS Design 663
Design phases
Step.1 Step.2 Step.3
7 Service CAD
The solution space of service design tends to be much broader than that of the
conventional product design. It makes the derivation of design solutions difficult. To
provide computerized support for service design, the authors have been developing
a CAD system for service design called a Service CAD.
The quality of design solutions and the efficiency of the design process depend
largely on the designer’s knowledge and design methods. Such issues on design
management have been discussed in various fields, such as the research on
knowledge-based CAD (Tomiyama et al. 1996). The existing design study regards
design knowledge as an important element to derive a creative design solution. By
providing design knowledge based on existing service cases and realizing a partially
automated design operation, Service CAD can support the design of a new solution.
Figure 36.8 shows a conceptual scheme of a Service CAD, which consists of the
following components:
1. Service case base
A database of existing service cases
2. Persona database
A database of personas and their detailed information
3. Function database
A database to store function prototypes related to their realization structures
4. Design rule base
A database of operational rules for service design
5. Reasoning engines
664 Y. Shimomura and K. Watanabe
Service Reasoning
Case Engine 1
Interface
Service Explorer and service design methods have been applied to various service
cases. Figure 36.9 shows the result of the functional design of an elevator main-
tenance service in the Service CAD. By decomposing a specific requirement of a
service receiver into detailed functions, the concrete realization structure to embody
a service can be described. Designed functions and their realization structures can
be used for the design of other services.
After describing the service structure, a service designer can evaluate the service
model in the Service CAD. Figure 36.10 shows the result of the importance analysis
method of a service model. The set of numbers in the left-hand area in Fig. 36.10
shows the importance values of function parameters. They have been derived by
means of the abovementioned importance analysis method. By visualizing the result
of evaluation in the form of graphs in Service Explorer, a service designer can
determine which part of a service structure should be modified.
Including the abovementioned design case, several projects of service design
have been performed. One of the projects is Project ReCSeEn (Research Con-
sortium on Service Engineering). This project was carried out by the Research
Consortium on Service Engineering, which is comprised of four companies and
three universities, in Japan in 2007/2008. In this project, the value analysis template
was developed and applied to four case studies.
8 Summary
In this chapter, the authors explained the service-centered design approach and its
effectiveness. To realize service-centered design, the authors introduced various
design methods for each service design phase: value analysis, embodiment, and
evaluation. In addition, the concept of Service CAD for creative and efficient service
design and its prototype were explained.
9 Cross-References
References
Y. Akao, Quality Function Deployment (Productivity Press, Cambridge, MA, 1990)
F. Akasaka, S. Hosono, K. Yamamura, Y. Shimomura, T. Arai, A method for analyzing customer
requirements in a B2B service, in Proceedings of the 9th Japan Korea Workshop on CAD/CAM
-Design Engineering Workshop-Okinawa, 2009, pp. 7–12
C. Aurich, C. Fuchs, F. DeVries, An approach to life cycle oriented technical service design. Ann.
CIRP 53(1), 151–154 (2004)
A. Cooper, The Inmates Are Running the Asylum: Why High Tech Products Drive Us Crazy and
How to Restore the Sanity (Sams, Indianapolis, IN, 1999)
M.J. Goedkoop, J.G. van Halen, H. te Riele, P.J.M. Rommens, Product Service Systems, Ecological
and Economic Basics. Report for Dutch Ministries of Environment (VROM) and Economic
Affairs (EZ) (VROM, The Hague, The Netherlands, 1999)
M. Havey, Essential Business Process Modeling (O’Reilly Media, Sebastopol, CA, 2005)
H. Komoto, T. Tomiyama, Integration of a service CAD and a life cycle simulator. CIRP Ann.
Manuf. Technol. 57, 9–12 (2008)
D. Mann, Hands On: Systematic Innovation (CREAX, Ieper/Belgium, 2002)
H. Meier, R. Roy, G. Seliger, Industrial product-service systems – IPS2. CIRP Ann. Manuf.
Technol. 59(2), 607–627 (2010)
K. Oki, K. Watanabe, R. Chiba, Y. Shimomura, A method for supporting service design based
on multiple domain knowledge, in Proceedings of the 2010 International Design Engineering
Technical Conference – IDETC2010, Montreal, CD-ROM, 2010
668 Y. Shimomura and K. Watanabe
Abstract
In society today, there is increased awareness about escalating environmental
problems, for example, climate change and pollution. The main reasons for these
problems are tied to society’s use of products. During the last two decades,
industry and academia have proposed and tried to implement a large number of
potential strategies and solutions to reduce these problems. One such promising
concept that has emerged is the Integrated Product/Service Offering (IPSO) (also
known as Product/Service System (PSS)). This concept is based on research from
several areas such as business economics, engineering design, and environmental
technology. An IPSO is “an offering that consists of a combination of products
and services that, based on a life cycle perspective, have been integrated to fit
targeted customer needs.” The focus is on providing a function, not a product
or service; this means that the provider can put more focus on optimizing the
total life cycle cost (both from the provider and customer perspectives). In many
cases, the service provider retains responsibility for the physical products in the
IPSO during the use phase.
The objective of this chapter is to introduce product design considerations
to consider when developing an IPSO. The chapter begins by providing insight
on why IPSOs require a new design mindset, followed by the presentation of
useful guidelines for developing IPSOs. These guidelines are illustrated with
three industry examples.
M. Lindahl ()
Department of Management and Engineering, Environmental Technology and Management,
Linköping University, Sweden
e-mail: mattias.lindahl@liu.se
E. Sundin
Department of Management and Engineering, Division of Manufacturing Engineering, Linköping
University, Linköping, Sweden
e-mail: erik.sundin@liu.se
This chapter is based on studies by the authors but also draws from studies
found in the literature. While the focus is on business-to-business IPSOs, several
of the proposed guidelines could also be valid for business-to-customer IPSOs.
1 Introduction
Representatives from academia have advocated that one way to overcome the above
challenges is for providers (companies) to take greater responsibility for their
products’ value chain, especially during the use phase and end-of-life. This will
also enable them to earn more profit along the value chain, and specifically during
the offering’s use phase (e.g., by services), and to use ingoing artifacts in a more
efficient and effective way, for example, by reusing and reducing the need for those
artifacts. The possibility to earn more money implies that an increasing number
of manufacturers, especially in developed countries, must transform their physical
artifact-focused production philosophies toward philosophies that incorporate ser-
vice content from a life cycle perspective.
Integrated Product/Service Offering (IPSO) is a concept which can be used to
obtain a larger share of the market and control a larger share of the offering’s value
chain. The focus is on providing the function, not a product or a service; this means
that the provider can put more focus on optimizing the total life cycle cost (both from
the provider and customer perspectives). An IPSO is “an offering that consists of a
combination of products and services that, based on a life cycle perspective, have
been integrated to fit targeted customer needs.” IPSOs often create close contact
between the supplier and customer, leading, for example, to offers being customized
and improved to better suit the customer. In many cases, the service provider retains
responsibility for the physical products in the IPSO during the use phase.
When developing an IPSO, it is important to, as the name indicates, do so with
an integrated approach or in other words develop the offering’s physical product and
service content in parallel. However, this is a challenge for many manufacturers that
have been traditionally focused on producing artifacts for as low a cost as possible
and with little or no contact with the final customer. In addition, they normally have
little or no experience with developing service content. In industry, there is a need
for support of ISPO design including concept selection; however, very little support
exists (Meier 2004; Aurich et al. 2006; Sakao et al. 2009; Sakao and Lindahl 2009).
672 M. Lindahl and E. Sundin
This chapter is an attempt to contribute to this support, with the objective to first
describe and illustrate some of the principle engineering-related reasons why it is
important to rethink the development of the physical products and services used for
IPSOs. These reasons create the foundation for some general guidelines that are
described and later illustrated with industry examples. It is important to note that
even though this chapter focuses on the design of the products, the product design is
still linked and discussed in relation to the design of the service content, something
also mentioned by Weissenberger-Eibl and Biege (2009).
This section describes the main engineering-related reasons why it is important for
IPSO providers to rethink their way of developing ingoing physical products and
services.
All companies have some sort of product development within their operations
that could have various levels of formality and regularity. Product development
has been defined by ENDREA (2001) as: “all activities in a company aiming at
bringing a new product to the market. It normally involves design, marketing and
manufacturing functions in the company.” Even though the word “product” is stated
in this definition, a product in this context can be both physical and nonphysical.
When developing new products, designers normally follow a procedure/model
(sequence of activities) that can be more or less defined, a so-called product
development model. Those procedures often describe when and how to perform
design, marketing, and manufacturing activities. The literature is full of various
forms of product development models (see, e.g., Ulrich and Eppinger 2000; Ullman
2002).
Today’s product development models are, for the most part, adapted to the current
predominant business model in the industrialized world. In other words, they are
based on the concept that the customer should buy the product (and pay for it
up front) and be responsible for the product’s use phase. This implies that the
focus in product development is normally on reducing costs for the manufacturing
company, for example, cutting down the cost of manufacturing and delivery in order
to get a competitive price for the customer. At the same time, this implies that
manufacturers pay little attention to the later phases of the product’s life cycle, for
example, the use phase (with activities such as use of energy and consumables,
service and maintenance, and upgrading) and end-of-life (with activities such as
material recycling, product and component remanufacturing).
From a customer perspective, however, this focus on the product development
process is often negative. Life cycle cost studies and life cycle assessments have
37 Product Design Considerations 673
Phases
Design Production Delivery Use End-of-life
Fig. 37.1 Example of the environmental impact accumulation over a product’s different life cycle
phases and the possibility to influence that environmental impact
shown that, for many products, the major costs and environmental impact for the
product occur during the use phase (in reality, often the longest phase of a product’s
life) and its related activities. Figure 37.1 shows, in a simplified way (different
products have different profiles), the environmental impact accumulation over the
product’s life cycle and the chance to influence that environmental impact.
When developing an IPSO, the basic principle is to consider all life cycle phases in
order to optimize the offering from a life cycle perspective, something which implies
new conditions for the development process. The main objective is no longer to
simply achieve the lowest total cost for the product or service but rather to achieve
the lowest cost for the total offering (the combination of products and service).
When the focus is expanded to cover more life cycle phases, for example, the use
phase, this implies that the number of potential offering solutions increases. This
is a possible challenge from a development perspective. At the same time, from
an optimization perspective, the increased number of solutions is positive since it
results in a greater possibility to optimize the total life cycle cost/environmental
impact of the offering. Costs are often associated with the use of materials and
energy, which in turn provide a negative environmental impact, implying that more
cost-optimized products usually have less environmental impact.
Figure 37.1 not only illustrates the different phases’ impact on the total environ-
mental impact but also the possibility to influence that environmental impact. The
674 M. Lindahl and E. Sundin
greatest influence potential is during the design phase, especially the early part of it.
This is at the same time logical, since it is in the early phases of product development
that the product specification is set and the parameters that must/should be focused
on are determined. As mentioned earlier, since in general the predominate way
of earning money is by selling products to customers, many manufacturers’ main
concern in their specifications is often how to optimize and improve the production
of their products and how to develop products that are not too durable (so their
customers will come back for new ones).
The initial product specification sets up boundaries for potential actions in the later
phases. Therefore, it is important to consider them thoroughly in order to avoid
unwanted lock-in effects. This boundary effect in the design process is often referred
to as the “design paradox,” a well-known fact for people working with product
development. The challenge is that when a new design project begins, very little
is known about the final product, especially if the product is a new one for the
designers. However, as the work on the product progresses, knowledge is increased;
at the same time, the scope of freedom of action decreases for every product decision
step taken, since time and cost drive most projects. This implies that costs for later
changes increase rapidly, since earlier work must be redone. Altogether, this forms
the paradox – when the general design information is needed, it is not accessible,
and when it is accessible, the information is usually not needed.
Figure 37.2 shows the principal relation between freedom of action, product
knowledge, and modification cost (Lindahl 2000). The figure is the author’s further
development of three figures: the design paradox (Ullman 2002), costs allocated
100
Freedom Product
of action knowledge
80
Percentage
60
40
Modification
20 cost
0
Timescale
Fig. 37.2 The relation between “freedom of action,” “product knowledge,” and “modification
cost” is shown (Lindahl 2000)
37 Product Design Considerations 675
early but used late in the project (Andreasen and Hein 1987), and the cost for design
changes as a function of time during the planning and production process (Bergman
and Klefsjö 2003).
The rate of technological and market changes has accelerated in the past decade,
with today’s companies facing increasing competition. In order to survive and de-
velop their business, they need to be proactive in rapidly responding to fluctuations
in demand (Collaine et al. 2002). A cornerstone to their competitive success is their
capability to develop new products (Gonzalez and Palacios 2002); improve, further
develop and optimize old products; and do so faster than competitors (Stalk and
Hout 1990). This puts pressure on designers to develop and proceed more rapidly,
while at the same time satisfying an increasing number of product demands.
One concept now commonly used in industry for managing these challenges is
Integrated Product Development (IPD). The basic idea behind IPD is to increase
efficiency in product development by more parallel activities and a higher degree
of cooperation between functions, levels, and individuals in an enterprise (Olsson
1976; Andreasen 1980). More parallel and concurrent product development pro-
vides opportunities to, for example, shorten the calendar time (from start to stop).
Norell (1999) characterizes the performance of IPD as follows: parallel activities,
cross-functional collaboration by multifunctional teams, structured processes, and
front-loaded development. The four characteristics above are in line with what
Wheelwright and Clark (1992), Wilson et al. (1995), and Cooper et al. (1998) regard
as important features for successful product development.
As highlighted earlier, in “traditional” product sales, there is a need to constantly
introduce new models and/or features, and do so at an increased speed to keep
competitors out and at the same time sell new products to both new and existing
customers. In order to provide a constant introduction of new models and/of features
companies generally do not want to include all potential technical improvements at
once in a new product but rather split them up over several versions to be able to sell
more products over time.
However, when developing an IPSO, this mindset is normally changed and
so are the conditions for the development process. The reason for this is that
when providing IPSOs, the focus is not usually on selling products but rather
on providing functionality to the customer. Added to that, the provider is also
often responsible (owns or controls) for the offering’s ingoing products during
the use phase. Furthermore, the payment is often based on the functionality and
performance during the use phase. For example, if the ISPO is not working, the
provider gets no payment; at the same time, the provider incurs a cost for getting
the IPSO into operation, for example, through service or maintenance.
Altogether, this implies that providers start to incorporate other issues and
considerations when developing their offerings. For example, once an IPSO is
sold to a customer, the provider wants the customer to use it for as long as it is
676 M. Lindahl and E. Sundin
economically interesting for the provider and wants the IPSO to require little service
and maintenance during the use phase. The longer the IPSO’s ingoing products are
used, the lower the initial investment cost for those products in relation to the cost for
the use phase. This increases the potential to earn money if the IPSO’s functionality
and performance are kept equal or close to its initial status.
This also triggers companies to implement their best technology at once instead
of taking it in steps. For example, if a company has a technology that can cut
down energy consumption during use, it will implement that in order to avoid the
customer coming back and asking for a new solution or abandoning the provider for
a competitor’s solution. Rather than spending time on developing different versions
of a product, with an IPSO, the company has, in principle, more time for developing
increasingly optimized offerings that are more cost-efficient and effective and thus
result in a reduced negative environmental impact. Nevertheless, it will still be
relevant for shortening the calendar time (from start to stop).
To summarize, Figs. 37.1 and 37.2 illustrate the importance of the design phase
as well as setting relevant requirements as early as possible in the development
process. It also shows the problem with traditional product development. Often,
little care is taken in product development (and in its specification) for future service,
maintenance, and end-of-life treatment (Sundin et al. 2009). Traditionally, the initial
focus is on developing the physical product; once that is done, a possible service
(intangible product) is developed, but this is hindered by the limitations set up from
the physical product. When developing an IPSO, the development is accomplished
in an integrated and parallel approach, as illustrated in Fig. 37.3 (Lindahl et al.
2006).
Economic issues
End-of-life treatment phase
Manufacturing issues
Production phase
Quality issues
Use phase
Environmental issues
Design issues
Marketing issues
Et cetera
Fig. 37.3 An integrated and parallel approach for developing an IPSO (Lindahl et al. 2006)
37 Product Design Considerations 677
When identifying requirements, this should not be done with a product or a service-
focused mindset but instead with a total offering-focused mindset (the mix between
products and services in the final offering solution should be set later). This implies
that the focus should be on what value the potential offering should provide and not
on what value its ingoing components, in the form of products and services, should
have.
Since the ISPO provider in many cases retains responsibility for the physical
products in the IPSO during the use phase(s) as well as during the end-of-life
treatment, this requires a life cycle approach when identifying requirements. In
traditional sales, the main source for requirements is the potential buyer (customer).
In relation to the above, however, it is crucial in the identification process to identify
all important actors in the offering’s life cycle that might have an influence on, or be
influenced by, the potential offering. It is important to identify their requirements,
perceived value, and willingness to pay for the IPSO. This also implies, for example,
that instead of viewing a customer company as a customer, it is important to see the
actors within that company. For example, the most important actor might be the
production manager or sales staff at the “traditional” customer company; it could
also be the customer’s production manager or in some cases, authorities or trade
associations that have set up certain rules that affect the “customers” business in an
IPSO-favorable way.
Traditionally, many companies first develop their physical products and then add on
service. When developing IPSOs, however, this should be an integrated process as
the name indicates, begin in the concept development process, and be based on the
identified actors’ requirements.
678 M. Lindahl and E. Sundin
When the requirements have been translated into functions that the IPSO needs
to fulfill, various potential solutions are developed. Those solutions could either
require physical products or services or, more likely, a combination of both. Then, as
in traditional product development, the aim is to evaluate and find the most suitable
solution that can be further developed into a complete IPSO.
When the solution (combination of physical products and services) to be further
developed is set, it is possible to accomplish this with traditional development
methods and tools. The requirements on each component (product or service) are
then set in the end, combined to the complete IPSO.
When developing and later evaluating a potential IPSO, the focus should be on
finding those that, from a life cycle perspective, result in the lowest environmental
and economic impact and at the same time, fulfill the set requirements. This implies
a changed mindset regarding, for example, the cost of production and how to handle
spare parts and maintenance. As mentioned above, in developing successful IPSOs,
one must have a life cycle perspective for both physical artifacts and the service
systems used during and between the customer contract periods.
In practice, this may imply that in order to reduce the need for service or spare
parts during the use phase, a decision is made to develop and produce an artifact
that is slightly more durable and costly. This could also imply that, instead of
incrementally introducing new technologies in order to be able to come out with
constantly new products, a more leapfrog, or in other words radical approach, is
taken. In contradiction to traditional selling, the IPSO provider is more concerned
that the artifact does not break down during use because it would lead to higher
costs when the artifact is not performing at the customer, resulting in paying for
the customer’s downtime and needing to provide them with repairs and spare parts
(Lindahl et al. 2005). With traditional selling, the customer was responsible for
most of these costs that also used to be lucrative for the manufacturer. The IPSO
concept, however, changes the manner in which the manufacturer/IPSO provider
earns money; with IPSO, previous revenues from the aftermarket are collected from
day one, when selling the IPSO. The IPSO provider can facilitate the maintenance,
repair, and service by addressing the following aspects:
• Design artifacts that are easy to service. For example, to ease the access of
service and disassembly points, use material and joining methods that do not
break down during service, and use standardized components that are easy to
store and do not need special tools to be disassembled.
• Design a service system that can respond rapidly and accurately. For example,
integrate “smart” applications in the artifacts that can warn when malfunction
is about to occur, monitor the artifacts during use, and schedule preventive
maintenance; include more resources to perform preventive maintenance rather
than unplanned maintenance, which would cost the IPSO provider more; and
37 Product Design Considerations 679
make service manuals accessible through the internet with clear and easy-to-
follow instructions.
The artifacts can be adapted in several ways for the product life cycle according to
existing design-for-x methodologies (DfX), for example, design for service, design
for repair, design for remanufacturing, and design for recycling (Huang 1996). In
the same manner, the service part of an IPSO and the surrounding support system
can facilitate the life cycle phases of the IPSO in order to make it work well from
both the IPSO provider’s and customer’s perspectives.
Raw
Parts Products
Materials
Product Assembly/
Part Manufacture Use
Remanufacture
Disposal:
Incineration,
Re-use
Landfill or
Storage
Recycling of parts
Recycling of material
Fig. 37.4 The physical product (artifact) life cycle (Sundin 2004)
680 M. Lindahl and E. Sundin
4.6 Guidelines
To summarize the above, IPSO developers need to consider the following five
general guidelines:
1. Manage service and product-related requirements in an integrated way.
2. Identify requirements with a life cycle approach.
3. Develop and evaluate integrated offering concepts.
4. Develop offerings to facilitate service and maintenance.
5. Develop offerings to facilitate end-of-life.
5 Practical Examples
This section describes three cases and how the five general guidelines above have
been considered in those cases.
selling through the concept of functional sales, Polyplank collaborates closely with
their customer and the paper mill and can thus take advantage of the core plugs
when the paper mill’s customers send them back to the paper mill. Normally, the
core plugs go back and forth three times between the paper mill and their customers
before the plugs return to Polyplank. When a core plug is returned from the paper
mill’s customer, they are washed and checked before reuse, as seen in Fig. 37.5.
There are three main scenarios for the paper mill’s customers’ used core plugs:
• Disposal by the paper mill’s customer – In some cases, used core plugs at the
paper mill customer disappear or are discarded. This quantity is very small.
• Reuse by the paper mill (sent out to new customers) – The most common scenario
is when core plugs, after a period out at the paper mill customer, are returned to
the paper mill; after washing and quality control, these core plugs can be reused
for new customers. If the core plug is worn out, it is returned to Polyplank where
it is recycled. Normally, the core plug is reused several times. Because of its
business model, Polyplank aims to achieve a level of quality that will enable their
core plugs to be reused several times. Even the paper mill’s customers benefit
from this approach; instead of the cost and handling associated with discarding
core plugs, they can easily send them back.
• Recycling by Polyplank – When core plugs are finally discarded, they are
returned to Polyplank where they are grinded down and sent to injection molding
in order to become new core plugs. In practice, almost 100% of all incoming
used core plugs become new core plugs.
When Polyplank developed their IPSO, they worked very closely with their
main customer to identify, from a life cycle perspective, the requirements that were
important for the IPSO as a whole. One consideration was the fact that some of the
ISPOs are actually delivered by the customer (e.g., the take back system of used
682 M. Lindahl and E. Sundin
Fig. 37.6 Left – First version of the core plug. Right – Final version of the core plug
core plugs from the paper mill’s customer, cleaning of used core plugs and control).
Examples of identified requirements were that core plugs must be easy to clean and
check and that they must not crack, resulting in a loss of paper. Another was to
develop a core plug with an optimal life cycle.
The first version of the core plug (Fig. 37.6) was not optimal, as it was designed
based on the paper mill’s initial requirements for single-use core plugs. After some
discussions with the paper mill company, Polyplank managed to convince them that
another design would be more suitable. Even though Polyplank creates their IPSOs
based on recycled material, they prefer to use as little material as possible in their
offerings. Polyplank had performed advanced finite element method analysis to find
a design that could improve the core plugs’ durability while also making the core
plug easier to wash, produce, and transport. The result was a core plug that was 35%
more durable and at the same time 30% lighter. The higher durability implied more
loops between the paper mill and their customers, and the reduced weight meant
less transportation and production costs since less material needs to be managed in
the production process, for example, in the injection molding used for producing the
core plug.
Since the material used in the core plugs is reusable, Polyplank has focused on
designing an IPSO that takes into account a high degree of used core plugs coming
back to them. If not used for new core plugs, Polyplank can reuse the material for
other products.
To conclude, Polyplank’s material has several environmental benefits; in or-
der to verify their claims, they have conducted a life cycle assessment (LCA)
and a life cycle cost (LCC) study. In comparison with a single-use core plug
of virgin plastic, Polyplank’s business model/solution results in approximately
80–90% less environmental impact, and their cost for providing the core plug is also
approximately 80–90% less. The largest gain with core plugs based on Polyplank’s
material is the use of recycled compared to virgin plastics, resulting in a significantly
37 Product Design Considerations 683
reduced overall environmental impact. The more times the plug’s material can be
reused, the less the environmental impact. Polyplank’s business model has increased
their ability to take full advantage of their material. Since the Polyplank core plug
can be reused, the overall environmental impact per use is decreased; however,
reusability puts greater requirements on quality with regard to durability. It has been
confirmed that the core plug that Polyplank manufactures has sufficient quality to
withstand at least five reuses, which helps reduce the overall environmental impact.
Fig. 37.8 Left – First version of the soil compactor. Middle – Second version of the soil
compactor. Right – Third version of the soil compactor
have longer service intervals, and components and material will be chosen to ensure
that they last throughout a normal life cycle.
Swepac have worked extensively with their product adaptation. In order to avoid
unnecessary costs for maintenance work and remanufacturing, the company has
introduced new materials to replace the traditional selection. Figure 37.8 shows how
these design improvements have progressed for a type of soil compactor of similar
size.
The Hood – In the first design version, the hood was made of painted steel. To
reduce the amount of visual scratches and repainting jobs, the hood was changed to
colored plastic; this also enabled faster replacement of the hood if necessary.
The Chassis – the chassis is of the first design version, made of painted steel,
just as the hood. This type of chassis was found to be easily damaged, and when
remanufacturing the soil compactor, much time and effort was put into the repainting
operations needed to return it to newly manufactured condition. To increase quality
and reduce damage as well as the need for repainting, a rubber bellow was added as
seen in the second design version. For the third design version, the designers also
decided to galvanize the painted steel with zinc. The galvanized steel was found
to reduce scratches even more than the rubber bellow and to keep the maintenance
needs to a minimum, since the zinc has a self-healing effect when damaged.
The Lifting Device – The first design version had a solid metal loop for the user
when grabbing and lifting the soil compactor up and down from the ground. This
is usually accomplished with a tractor or a forklift truck. The loop, however, was
hard to reach, and if missed, the soil compactor could be damaged. In the second
design version, a foldable textile strap with a chain was introduced, along with a
larger loop area (see the right-hand figure in Fig. 37.7 above). This allowed for
easier transport with less chance of damage. However, one of the drawbacks with
this design solution was that it could eventually wear out and thus was a bit tricky
to change. For the third design version, the designers introduced a foldable metal
loop which was not as strongly attached to the soil compactor as in the first design
version. The benefit with this type of lifting device is that it is long-lasting and can
be easily replaced if necessary.
37 Product Design Considerations 685
Some previous design adaptations in all of the design versions for IPSOs
conducted by Swepac were already made. For example, the base plate was made
of Hardox steel which is very hard and will not require any maintenance and/or
replacement during the soil compactor’s technical lifetime. In addition, the filter for
the air inlet to the engine was enlarged to stop more particles. Also, the air inlet
was placed at a spot where fewer particles were flying around in the air. Since the
compactors are used in an extremely particle-filled environment, this kind of filter
significantly prolonged the technical lifetime of the engine. Since Swepac was not
an expert in the area of engines and how to service them, this was a good option
for them to reduce maintenance and repair efforts. To summarize, given the design
evolutions made by Swepac designers, one can conclude the following advantages:
• Less visible damage during use
• Reduced need for repainting during remanufacturing
• Easier replacement of the hood during maintenance and remanufacturing
• Reduced wear during transport and easier replacement of the lifting device
While investigating one of the soil compactors at Linköping University, researchers
found some minor areas for improvement. During a product analysis (Sundin et al.
2010), several design improvements were highlighted, for example:
• Introducing snap-fits on the strap cover for the strap between the motor and the
chamber of revolving vibration cylinders. Using snap-fits would eliminate the
use of tools, hence making the assembly and disassembly of the cover more time-
efficient. Snap-fits are preferable if they provide the same quality as the existing
four screws.
• Standardize the screws used in the entire compactor design. This would reduce
the number of tools used for the assembly and disassembly of the compactor
parts. In addition, costs would be reduced due to a lower number of articles to
keep track of in databases and storage facilities.
This case concerns an automatic teller machine (ATM) sold as a service in, for
example, a Japanese convenience store. It is important to identify the different
stakeholders of the ATM, for example, the users, the bank, the money transfer staff,
and the convenience store staff, the IPSO developers, manufacturers, and service
providers. An example of an ATM in Japan can be seen in Fig. 37.9.
Some physical requirements for the ATM machine could be:
• Amount of space that is needed for the ATM
• Type of power supply that is needed
• Security that surrounds the ATM machine
From a service perspective, it is valuable for the developers to know what kinds of
service are required, for example:
• Withdrawals from credit card and bank accounts
• Available notes
• Maximum amount of withdrawal
686 M. Lindahl and E. Sundin
Design artifacts that are easy to conduct end-of-life processes on. In practice,
this means that test diagnoses should be easy to perform in order to understand
which parts need to be cleaned and replaced before the next IPSO use. Several more
parts, for example, might need to be replaced than with normal maintenance. The
parts must be easy to access and disassemble, and the parts that need to be cleaned
must be easy to clean and withstand the cleaning process several times so they can
be used several times. In addition, the joining methods should facilitate several
disassembly and reassembly instances in order to get efficient use of resources.
Screws and other joints should be standardized to avoid errors in reassembly and
to lower the costs of component storage.
Design the take back system and end-of-life processes to match the IPSO. In
practice, this means that to achieve efficient service as well as an efficient take back
system and end-of-life process, information for the specific ATM’s design, usage,
and maintenance data needs to be stored during its life cycle. This could be, for
example, the number of monetary transactions, the number of monetary refills, or
the number of planned and unplanned services. This could also include records on
which components have been changed during service.
Summary
References
M.M. Andreasen, Machine design methods based on a systematic approach (In Danish) Ph.D.
thesis, University of Lund, 1980
M.M. Andreasen, L. Hein, Integrated Product Development (IFS Publications Ltd., Bedford, 1987)
J.C. Aurich, C. Fuchs, C. Wagenknecht, Life cycle oriented design of technical product-service
systems. J. Clean. Prod. 14(17), 1480–1494 (2006)
B. Bergman, B. Klefsjö, Quality from Customer Needs to Customer Satisfaction (Studentlitteratur
AB., Lund, 2003)
A. Collaine, P. Lutz, J.-J. Lesage, A method for assessing the impact of product development on
the company. Int. J. Prod. Res. Taylor & Francis 40(14), 3311–3336 (2002)
R.G. Cooper, S.J. Edgett, E.J. Kleinschmidt, Portfolio Management for New Products (Perseus
Books, Reading, 1998)
ENDREA, ENDREA nomenclature (ENDREA – Engineering Research and Education Agenda,
Linköping, Sweden, 2001)
688 M. Lindahl and E. Sundin
European Union, Directive 2000/53/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 18
September 2000 on end-of life vehicles. Off. J. Eur. Communities 43(L269), 34–42 (2000)
European Union, Directive 2002/96/EC of the European Parliament and the Council of 27 January
2003 on waste electrical and electronic equipment (WEEE). Off. J. Eur. Union 46, 24–38 (2003)
F.J.M. Gonzalez, T.M.B. Palacios, The effect of new product development techniques on new
product success in Spanish firms. Ind. Mark. Manag. 31(3), 261–271 (2002)
G.Q. Huang, Design for X – Cuncurrent Engineering Imperatives (Chapter 1: Introduction)
(Chapman Hall, London, 1996)
H. Larsson, Kartläggning av miljö- och kostnadsfördelar som ett Integrerat Produkt- och
TjänsteErbjudande av en hylsplugg ger jämfört med traditionell försäljning, LIU-IEI-R–
09/0076–SE (Industriell miljöteknik, Institutionen för ekonomisk och industriell utveckling,
Linköpings universitet, Linköping, 2009)
M. Lindahl, Environmental effect analysis – an approach to design for environment licentiate
thesis, Royal Institute of Technology, 2000
M. Lindahl, E. Sundin, T. Sakao, Y. Shimomura, An application of a service design tool at a
global warehouse provider, in Proceedings of the 15th International Conference on Engineering
Design (ICED05), Melbourne, 2005
M. Lindahl, E. Sundin, Y. Shimomura, T. Sakao, An outline of an interactive model for service
engineering of functional sales, in International Design Conference – Design 2006, Dubrovnik,
2006
M. Lindahl, E. Sundin, T. Sakao, Y. Shimomura, Integrated product and service engineering versus
design for environment – a comparison and evaluation of advantages and disadvantages, in
Advances in Life Cycle Engineering for Sustainable Manufacturing – From proceedings of the
14th CIRP Life Cycle Engineering Conference, Tokyo, ed. by S. Takata, Y. Umeda (Springer,
London, 2007), pp. 137–142
M. Lindahl, T. Sakao, A. Öhrwall Rönnbäck, Business implications of integrated product and
service offerings, in CIRP Industrial Product-Service Systems (IPS2 / Conference, Cranfield
University, Cranfield, 2009
S. Lingegård, M. Lindahl, E. Sundin, Organizational changes in connection with integrated product
service offerings, in CIRP’s 2nd IPS2 Conference (CIRP, Linköping, 2010)
S. Lingegård, T. Sakao, M. Lindahl, Theoretical environmental comparison of integrated product
service offerings vs traditional sales, in 7th International Symposium on Environmentally
Conscious Design and Inverse Manufacturing (EcoDesign 2011), Kyoto, 2011
H. Meier, Lifecycle-based service design for innovative business models. Ann. CIRP 53(1), 393–
396 (2004)
M. Norell, Managing integrated product development, in Critical Enthusiasm – Contributions
to Design Science, ed. by N.H. Mortensson, J. Sigurjónsson (Department of Product Design
Engineering, Norweigian University of Technology and Natural Science, Norway, 1999)
F. Olsson, Systematic design (In Swedish: Systematisk konstruktion) Doctoral, University of Lund,
1976
T. Sakao, M. Lindahl (eds.), Introduction to Product/Service-System Design (Springer, London,
2009)
T. Sakao, H. Birkhofer, V. Panshef, E. Dörsam, An effective and efficient method to design services:
empirical study for services by an investment-machine manufacturer. Int. J. Internet Manuf.
Serv. 2(1/2), 95–110 (2009)
G.J. Stalk, T.M. Hout, Competing Against Time – How Time-Based Competition is Reshaping the
Global Markets (The Free Press, A Division of Macmillan Inc., New York, 1990)
E. Sundin, Product and Process Design for Successful Remanufacturing Doctoral thesis, Linköping
University, 2004
E. Sundin, Life-cycle perspectives of product/service-systems, in Design Theory. Introduction to
Product/Service-System Design, ed. by T. Sakao, M. Lindahl (Springer, London, 2009a), pp.
31–49
37 Product Design Considerations 689
Abstract
Increasing consumption of consumer products and services with significant
environmental and social impacts is a key contributor to many of today’s
sustainability challenges e.g., climate change, resource depletion (energy, water,
biomass, metals, land use, and biodiversity loss), waste, pollution and social
inequities. Consumer products are among those with the most significant en-
vironmental and social footprint. In particular, production and consumption of
high-impact products and services, e.g., food, our homes, how we heat/cool
them, the electronics we use, transport, clothing and tourism are recognized
contributing factors to our most critical environmental and social challenges.
Sustainable consumption and production (SCP) provides one set of solutions
to tackling this. Supply side sustainable production measures to improve the
sustainability performance of products across supply chains can only bring us
so far. The role of the consumer in shifting consumption patterns so we can
live ethically within our “one planet” means as well as the wider infrastructure
to support this is also a key part of the solution. For this reason, influencing
a shift to sustainable lifestyles is a growing focus for policy makers and other
stakeholders with strong influence on consumer choice, e.g., retailers, brand
manufacturers, educators and the media. Outside of this, the debate is growing
on the inherent conflict between a traditional market economics system that
continues to drive growth as resource limits become more obvious. This is
forcing a more sophisticated approach to the new business and consumer models
we are likely to need beyond SCP to meet our sustainability challenges as our
population expands to an anticipated nine billion by 2050. In order to enable SCP
D. Maxwell
Founder and Director of Global View Sustainability Services Ltd., London, UK
Lecturer at Imperial College London MSc Environmental Science, Centre for Environmental
Policy, London, UK
e-mail: dorothymaxwell@gv-ss.com, www.gv-ss.com
demand and supply side measures to work, a paradigm shift in our economic
system is needed. Key changes include internalizing environmental externality
costs of production and consumption to send accurate market signals, remove
perverse fiscal incentives, and actually motivate sustainable behavior change
financially. In addition, our measures and indicators of success at country and
business levels need to go beyond economic indicators, e.g., gross domestic
product (GDP) alone, to incorporate not only financial but natural and social
capital, as well as ensuring the required prioritization of these in practice. A re-
evaluation of human needs and wants is part of this paradigm shift with new
definitions for how consumers and producers measure “value” reflected in new
business and consumer models.
1 Introduction
Based on a review of the latest international, EU, and UK evidence, Table 38.1
illustrates those products and services with the highest environmental impacts
(Defra 2010).
The extent of environmental damage caused is largely dependent on the type of
product or service, the volumes produced, and its consumption patterns. Both con-
sumer and commercial products and services are included in the high-environmental
impact product groups.
Studies focusing on the UK, EU, and internationally show household consumption
typically has high environmental impacts (UNEP 2002; Worldwatch Institute
38 Sustainable Consumption 693
(WWI) 2004; Weidema et al. 2005; UNEP 2005; Carbon Trust 2006; WWF
2006; SERI 2009; Defra 2010). For this reason, household consumption is a
crosscutting priority focus and highlights the importance of targeting household
consumer products and services with high impacts. For the EU, consumer products
within the product groups of food and drink, transport, housing, and electrical
and electronic equipment are consistently identified as high-environmental impact
contributors across a range of environmental indicators (JRC/IPTS 2006; EEA
2010; Weidema et al. 2008; Nemry et al. 2008a, b). The EU milestone study on
the Environmental Impacts of Products (EIPRO) (JRC/IPTS 2006) identified the
products and services consumed in the EU that have the greatest environmental
impacts across their life cycle based on both private and public expenditure and
volume consumed. From this, the following three product groups are consistently
the most significant contributors environmentally in terms of global warming,
acidification, photochemical oxidation, and eutrophication:
• Food and drink: 20–30% of the environmental impacts measured
• Private transport: 15–20%, depending on the impact category
• Housing (building and appliances): 20–35% of the impacts of all products for
most impact categories
694 D. Maxwell
Within food and drink, transport, and housing, EU priority products and con-
sumption activities are:
• Food: meat and dairy
• Transport: cars (air transport data was limited in EIPRO but known to be
significant)
• Energy use in and around the house: cooling/heating and electronic appli-
ances/ICT
• House building, renovation, and demolition.
All other areas of consumption together account for approximately 20–30% of
most environmental impacts in the EU with the next level of priority product groups
including clothing, restaurants/hotels, and recreation/leisure (including tourism)
(JRC/IPTS 2006).
While the specific environmental impacts vary per product group, these include
greenhouse gas emissions causing climate change, resource depletion (energy,
water, minerals, metals, land, biomass, and species loss), waste, and pollution. The
impacts of products occur across their life cycle from raw materials acquisition to
end of life. As an example, Fig. 38.1 illustrates the life cycle impacts occurring
across the supply chain of clothing. The impacts include those associated with raw
material processing (e.g., growing cotton or polyester processing from fossil fuels to
make fiber and fabric), garment production, distribution (by shipping, road, and air
transport), purchasing by the consumer at retail stores, “in use” impacts of clothes
cleaning, and finally reuse, recycling, or disposal when the garment is at its end of
life. At each life cycle stage, materials and resources are input and environmental
impacts result.
Fig. 38.1 Lifecycle impacts of clothing (Source: Global View Sustainability Services 2010)
38 Sustainable Consumption 695
For consumer products and services, the consumer influences the “in use” life
cycle stage environmental impacts in particular. For some products and services,
the “in use” impacts can be significant and therefore makes the consumers role in
reducing this particularly important. Examples are energy services in the home for
heating/cooling air and water as well as to run electronics appliances; fuel use in
cars; and laundering clothing. Washing and tumble-drying clothes use resources
(energy and water), generate greenhouse gas emissions and water pollution from
detergents. Therefore, influencing consumer laundering practices is one part of
the solution needed to prevent or reduce these impacts. Consumers also play an
important role in enabling extended product lifetimes and, when no longer suitable
for use, sound environmental end of life management. This is particularly relevant
for products, e.g., electronics, clothing or DIY gadgets. Extending the useful
lifetime of these goods, enabling their reuse and recycling are key to enabling closed
loop approaches that have significant resource and waste saving benefits (Braungart
and McDonough 2002). Another example is food waste. In the UK, approximately
one third of food bought per annum is thrown away as waste to landfill generating
greenhouse gas emissions (WRAP 2008). Providing the infrastructure for the best
end of life solutions, e.g., composting food waste and empowering consumers to use
this, is essential for preventing or reducing this impact.
the actual cost much higher. To date from the environmental perspective, we only
price greenhouse gas emissions, water, and some wastes (including waste electrical
and electronic equipment) using crude fiscal instruments and only in some parts
of the world. Outside of this, the cost of environmental impacts of producing and
consuming consumer products and services are not valued (TEEB 2010). The gap
in incorporating all externalities, as well as the nonuniform approach in what are
global consumer product markets, is causing artificially low prices, efficiency-based
risk management approaches in the main, and market uncertainties that limit our
ability to finance the transition that is needed for sustainability.
1992
1994
1996
1998
2000
2002
2004
2006
Fig. 38.2 Trends in appliance energy efficiency and ownership – EU-27 (Source: EEA 2010)
38 Sustainable Consumption 697
There are multiple ways to influence consumer behavior and to promote sustainable
lifestyles. These include:
• Awareness raising and information campaigns associating positive feelings with
certain products or activities.
698 D. Maxwell
are shifting spending to products and services with a lower environmental burden.
For example, in the EU, media campaigns and fiscal drivers are being used to
increase expenditure on electric and hybrid vehicles.
The link between consumer awareness of the environmental and ethical footprint
behind the products and services they buy and their purchasing power is of
increasing interest to retailers and brand manufacturers. This is seen as one factor in
maintaining customer loyalty and growing the customer base. This is resulting in an
increased trend in brands and retailers using communications e.g., marketing cam-
paigns in-store, online, and ecolabels to influence consumers. Examples include:
• Levi’s “Care for Our Planet” program which uses garment tags, in-store and web
information to encourage consumers to wash less, wash in cold water, line dry
when possible, and donate clothing to charity when no longer needed (Levis’s
2011)
• Patagonia “Common Threads Recycling” program which includes consumer
information combined with the infrastructure for in-store product take-back and
recycling (Patagonia 2011).
Studies indicate that the effectiveness of these communication approaches varies
with a range of factors including cultural background, market segments, and
affluence levels. For example, consumer research in the UK shows a growing
fraction of consumers are aware of the ethical and environmental impacts products
have (Mintel 2009a; WWF 2009). However, this consumer awareness is not yet
strong enough to be sufficient to drive the required level of improvement. Price,
functionality, and convenience are still the primary factors influencing consumer
choice. Further, consumers have a hard time understanding the sustainability
concept to begin with, do not understand the majority of ecolabels, and get frustrated
and cynical with the myriad of these and wider green claims on the market. In
the case of clothing, Mintel’s research shows that while value clothing customers
are likely to care about ethical and green issues, they are less likely to boycott a
store on ethical reasons. This also showed that customers had more awareness of
ethical impacts, e.g., childlabor over environmental ones and lower income groups
claim not to be in a financial position to think about ethical or environmental issues,
particularly under-35s. These are among the most likely to be customers of the value
clothing chains (Mintel 2009b). Taking this complex mix of factors into account
is key to influencing behavior change effectively in the mass population vs. the
niche.
There are several major barriers to sustainable lifestyles that need to be recognized
in order to understand the benefits achievable from leveraging consumer behavior
change in reality. These include failures in the capital markets system to reflect
700 D. Maxwell
5 Summary
are product service systems (PSS) as distinct from products alone (Brezet et al.
2001; Dobes and Majer 2002; Mont 2002; Maxwell and van der Vorst 2003).
• Greater consumer involvement, education, and information to shift the mindset
of consumers from being owners of products to being users of the services they
provide (Mont 2002).
• Business coalitions, networking, and interaction with a wider group of stake-
holders in the supply chain directly and on a crosscutting basis. This includes
the financial services sector and the media who have not not yet been engaged
effectively on sustainability (Brezet et al. 2001; Dobes and Majer 2002).
These characteristics are consistent with ecological modernization theories,
which propose a framework for sustainable development requiring transformation of
social, political, technical, and economic parameters. In particular, for sustainability
improvement, this promotes a transformation of policies (e.g., those relating to
environment, economics and international development), changing roles of institu-
tions and incorporating new stakeholders as change agents for sustainability reform.
This incorporates not only the traditional role of government but other stakeholders
such as the private sector, (e.g., industry, insurers, and bankers), and political
modernization, e.g., flexible decentralized governance structures versus the more
traditional top down and technical innovations (Barry and Paterson 2003; Mol and
Sonnenfeld 2000).
Overall, this paradigm shift has fundamental implications for how human value,
wealth, and success are measured plus the role of economic and other indicators to
do this. The role of current indicators, e.g., GDP, as measures of economic success
based on the value of goods and services produced in a country per annum pose
conflicts for sustainable development as does the goal of ever increasing GDP
growth. Incorporation of other indicators including natural and social capital, and
how we ensure the required prioritization of these factors in practice, needs to
be determined (Elkington 1997; WWI 2004; EC 2011). A re-evaluation of human
needs and wants is part of this equation with new definitions for how consumers and
producers measure value reflected in new business and consumer models. These new
business and consumer models would measure success by generation of community
wealth, protection and restoration of natural systems, as distinct from the bottom
line alone. On the sustainable consumption and growth agenda, we need to ask:
What is the goal of our society? At present, the economic priority is for maximum
growth in consumption and production. In reality, this is inherently in conflict with
our planet of limited resources.
6 Cross-References
References
J. Barry, M. Paterson, The British state and the environment: new labour’s ecological modernisation
strategy. Int. J. Environ. Sustain. Dev. 2(3), 237–249 (2003). ISSN 1474 6778
M. Braungart, B. McDonough, Cradle to Cradle Remaking the Way we Make Things (North Point
Press, New York, 2002)
J.C. Brezet, A.S. Bijma, J. Ehrenfeld, S. Silvester, The design of eco-efficient services – Method,
tools and review of the case study from designing eco-efficient services project, in The
Netherlands: Design for Sustainability Programme, Delft University of Technology (2001)
Carbon Trust, The Carbon Emissions in all we Consume University of Surrey (2006)
DEFRA, The diffusion of environmental behaviours; the role of influential individuals in so-
cial networks report 1: key findings, Brook Lundhurst for UK Defra (2007), http://www.
brooklyndhurst.co.uk/media/3b1ffea0/Mavens%20summary.pdf
Defra, A Framework for Pro-environmental Behaviours Defra, London, HM government publica-
tions (2008)
Defra, Product groups/sectors to target for maximising environmental improvement in prod-
ucts, Global View Sustainability Services for UK Defra (2010), http://www.defra.gov.uk/
environment/economy/products-consumers/
Degrowth (2010), http://www.degrowth.net/
V. Dobes, H. Majer, A framework for analysing the relations between networks, learning,
innovation and sustainable production, in European Round Table on Cleaner Production,
Conference Proceedings, Clean Technology Centre, Ireland, 8–11 October 2002
EEA, The European environment — State and Outlook 2010: consumption and the environment.
European Environment Agency, Copenhagen, November 2010
European Commission (EC), EU Resource Efficiency Roadmap (2011) http://ec.europa.eu/
environment/resource efficiency/index en.htm
J. Elkington, Cannibals with Forks, the Triple Bottom Line of 21st Century Business (Calstone
Publishing Limited, Calstone, 1997). ISBN 1-900961-27-X
T. Jackson, Motivating sustainable consumption. A review of evidence on consumer behaviour and
behavioural change. A report to the Sustainable Development Research Network (2005), http://
www.comminit.com/en/node219688
T. Jackson, Prosperity without Growth: Economics for a Finite Planet Earthscan, Lon-
don (2009). http://www.sd-commission.org.uk/publications/downloads/prosperity without
growth report.pdf
JRC/IPTS, Environmental impacts of products (EIPRO). Analysis of the life cycle environmental
impacts related to the total final consumption of the EU-25. EUR 22284 EN. Institute for
Prospective Technological Studies, Sevilla (2006),http://ec.europa.eu/environment/ipp/pdf/
eipro report.pdf
JRC/IE, Electricity consumption and efficiency trends in the European union. Status Report. JRC
Scientific and Technical Reports, EUR 24005 EN. Joint Research Centre, Institute for Energy,
Ispra (2009), http://re.jrc.ec.europa.eu/energyefficiency/pdf/EnEff Report 2009.pdf
Levis, Planet care programme, Levi’s (2011), http://www.levistrauss.com/sustainability/product/
re-use
D. Maxwell, Developing sustainable products and services in industry, PhD thesis, Imperial
College, London (2004)
704 D. Maxwell
WWF-UK, Counting consumption CO2 emissions, material flows and ecological footprint of the
UK by region & devolved country, 2006
WWF, Deeper luxury (2009), www.wwf.org.uk/deeperluxury
WWI, Worldwatch institute, The state of consumption today by Gary Gardner, Erik Assadourian,
and Radhika Sarinin in State of the World 2004
WWI, World watch institute state of the world 2009
Sustainable Design Engineering: Design
as a Key Driver in Sustainable Product 39
and Business Development
Abstract
Sustainability has become a “hype” topic these days (Steeger 2004). However, al-
though sustainable considerations are clearly on the agenda of many researchers
as well as managers, the corporate sustainability map is still characterized by
some considerable “blind spots” (Waldron et al. 2008). One of these blind
spots is the role design plays in developing sustainable products, and how the
efficiency and sustainability of new product development (NPD) is increased by
consequently and strategically integrating the design function into the innovation
process. Starting from this fundamental perception, the intention of this chapter
is to outline a theoretical and practical framework for a new understanding of
sustainable product design, which should not be driven by purely ethical or
technical considerations only but needs to be grounded on business strategy and
economic objectives likewise.
Although the sustainability issue is, today, heavily referred to in political, societal,
as well as corporate contexts, the term “sustainability” is vague, and very dif-
ferent concepts and understandings may be linked to this single term (Basiago
2006). As Stuart Hart puts it, there “can be little doubt that sustainability is
one of the most frequently used but least understood terms of our time” (Hart
2005, p. 57). Fresner et al. (2006) have shown on the basis of an empirical
study that indeed the sustainability term may create very different associations in
Fig. 39.1 Product innovation as an integral part of a holistic business approach to sustainability (Source: Montgomery 2009)
709
710 C. Herrmann and G. Moeller
and/or sustainability economics often miss the link to product innovation – many
treatises on design engineering and on ecodesign often do not clearly position a
sustainability-oriented design to where it usually takes place, namely, in the business
context.
Following a consequent business orientation, there is a clear need for a different
definition of sustainable design engineering, taking the design process itself far
beyond the will to just develop sustainable product design results (Manzini 1999).
Without changing the processes itself as well as the business objectives behind, any
intention to increase the sustainability of the products designed will consequently
fall short. “The keyword is synergistic, synergy between form and function, between
construction and production, between engineering and market etc.” (Grimheden
and Hanson 2005, p. 28). What has generally be defined by Martin Grimheden
and Mats Hanson as the core idea of any design engineering activity especially
applies for sustainable design engineering. The automotive industry is delivering
good examples for that. From Toyota’s hybrid cars to BMW’s i-series, such
revolutionary new product concepts would never have become reality if not the
design process was recalibrated, bringing design away from a short-term project
thinking to accepting it as a continuous improvement task fully integrated into
a company’s long-term innovation process based upon steadily evolving product
roadmaps.
Instead of a one-sided approach to sustainability, a triangular understanding
is needed according to which technical considerations (technology, materiality,
safety, etc.), aesthetical aspects (shape, ergonomics, functionality, etc.), and business
objectives (cost, market potential, revenues, strategic fit, etc.) are directly and
continuously linked to one another, jointly focussing on making the results of
new product development processes more efficient (in terms of energy-/material-
/resource- as well as production-/recycling-efficiency), increasing a product’s qual-
ity, reliability, and overall life span and most important its marketability and revenue
power (see Fig. 39.2).
How can a company make sure that these objectives are clearly integrated into
the processes of product conception and product development? Why is design an
important factor within these processes? And which effects does a sustainability-
driven design engineering have on the overall efficiency of innovation management?
It is these important aspects of modern innovation management this chapter is
focussing on.
design offers for business success. Especially in capital goods’ and technical goods’
contexts, design is often perceived as an additional and purely aesthetical activity
to be carried out by some outside “creatives” (Herrmann and Moeller 2005, 2006,
2009; Herrmann et al. 2009).
Following a strictly industrial understanding, design, however, plays a much
more fundamental role within product innovation and development processes.
It encompasses not only the outward form-giving but also the definition of a
product’s functionality, construction, user interfaces, ergonomics, and materiality,
assembly/disassembly. Within modern design theory and everyday work, this broad
understanding of design is often referred to as “design engineering” or “engineering
design” (Grimheden and Hanson 2005; Seeger 2005; Skerlos et al. 2005).
However, industrial design has an even broader function than just bridging the
gap between a product’s internal technical live and its outward appearance. In a
modern industrial understanding of design, the design activity is central to the
process of product conception, i.e., not only its future technical, and aesthetical
but also strategic configuration, thus having a significant influence on the future
innovativeness, quality, degree of sustainability, as well as potential market success
and revenue of a new product to be developed (see Fig. 39.3).
It is not only technical consumer goods companies such as Apple or Audi
but increasingly capital goods manufactures such as Gildemeister (machine tools),
Heidelberg (printing machines), Kuka (industrial robotics), or MAN (commercial
vehicles) which are following such an understanding (see Fig. 39.4). Accordingly,
they do no longer regard design as a “nice to have” add-on to an otherwise fixed
set of management and engineering tools but clearly integrate it into their overall
strategy and innovation systems (Herrmann et al. 2009).
712 C. Herrmann and G. Moeller
Fig. 39.3 A modern industrial conception of design (Source: Herrmann et al. 2009, p. 31)
Fig. 39.4 Dymatrix die-cutter – an example for strategic design engineering by Heidelberg
(Source: Heidelberger Druckmaschinen AG)
manufacturing problems but from conceptual flaws in the early phases of the value
chain. In order to prevent this from happening, the design function (and a conceptual
approach linked to it) is crucial (Bapuji 2008).
As shown in Sects. 2 and 3 of this chapter, design generally plays an important role
in product conception and development processes. But what is its contribution in
making the results of these processes more sustainable? Following the above sus-
tainability definition, design may contribute to a sustainable product development
in that it either influences the efficiency/cost side (in terms of energy-/material-/
resource- as well as production-/recycling-efficiency) or by increasing a product’s
quality/reliability/life span and most important its marketability and revenue power.
As far as the efficiency/cost side is concerned, designers probably have a
considerable influence on the overall development cost. Although Hollins and
Pugh (1990) have shown that the pure design concept costs only make up for
approximately 12% of the overall product cost, design decisions heavily influence
future cost (such as cost for assembly/disassembly, component cost, warranty cost,
etc.) on the manufacturer’s side as well as the potential cost of ownership on the
client’s side. By looking for ways how to design a technologically and functionally
similar product solution differently, design can heavily alter the overall efficiency
not only in terms of manufacturing cost but also with reference to energy-/material-/
quality-efficiency.
Also as regards the revenue potential of a new product design solution is con-
cerned, designers can make an important contribution to increase the marketability
and thus return on investment (ROI) in product development and engineering. It
has been a considerable problem in the past that more environmentally friendly and
sustainable product solutions were often perceived as being less attractive. Through
changing the design of the product (not only in terms of its look but also in terms
of its usability, interfaces, ergonomics, functionality, etc.) design adds value in that
it increases the marketability and sales potential of a sustainable product solution
(see Fig. 39.5).
Here are the following three examples out of many underlining that: When
Nokia launched its mobile phone 3110 Evolve (the first mobile phone made from
recycled materials) in 2008, it looked by no way like a typical eco-product. On the
contrary, its design had clear references to modern high-tech benchmarks of that
time, therefore increasing its mass-market sales potential (Trivedi and Unhelkar
2008). Bosch Thermotechnology has over the last years not only increased the
eco-friendliness of its products (e.g., by combining traditional heating systems
with solar-thermic components) but also invested into an innovative design of its
products, not only with reference to the exterior but also the interior life of its
products, following the example of an advanced engine bay design within the
automotive industry (Herrmann et al. 2009). Finally, MAN Nutzfahrzeuge Group,
through a radical redesign of their cabs did not only increase drivers’ comfort but
have also lowered fuel consumption of their truck fleet (MAN 2007).
39 Sustainable Design Engineering 715
Fig. 39.5 Design contribution to an increased return on sustainability (ROS) in strategic design
engineering
Siemens, USM, and Volkswagen have been successful in the past (and still are)
because they did and do not only look for short-term successes by always throwing
new products on the market but also because they follow a sustainable product and
assortment strategy.
A long-term oriented product and design policy allows companies to raise the
product longevity and therefore operating efficiency on clients’ side to achieve an
easier payback of increased development expenditure, to reduce disposal cost, to
benefit from increased customer contentment and loyalty, to charge higher price
premiums, to sell extra services, and last but not the least, to meet changing
consumer tastes (such as the LOHAS – lifestyles of health and sustainability trend).
Whenever the total delta of these advantages clearly outweighs the disadvantage
of a reduced per-period repurchasing rate to the same clients, the net sustainability
profit (sustainability returns - sustainability cost) will be a positive one (Arnold et al.
2001; Burschel et al. 2004; Epstein and Roy 2003; Figge et al. 2001; Schäfer 2005).
Of course, design does not automatically lead to all of these advantages. Apart
from the fact that a designer may be equally short-term oriented as businessmen
often are, design sometimes leads to consequences which do not positively but
negatively influence the overall sustainability balance (id est a company’s overall
relation of environmental assets and liabilities). For example, in today’s short-cycle
market economies, products are often repacked or redesigned just to increase their
marketing opportunities, which may deteriorate the overall sustainability balance
(Bhamra 2009; Lewis et al. 2007). Again, here it is the responsibility of the respec-
tive product managers, designers, and engineers to clearly look for solutions which
outbalance these effects (e.g., through ecologically friendly packaging solutions or
a complete product redesign leading to reduced material usage) in order to keep
the overall balance positive. A benchmark example for that is Apple: “Over the
past decade, Apple’s designers and engineers have pioneered the development of
smaller, thinner, and lighter products. As our products become more powerful,
they’re using less material to produce and generating fewer carbon emissions. For
example, although today’s 21.5-inch iMac is more powerful and has a much larger
screen than the first-generation, 15-inch iMac, it is designed with 50 percent less
material and generates 50 percent fewer emissions. Even the iPad became 33 percent
thinner and up to 15 percent lighter in just one generation, producing 5 percent fewer
carbon emissions” (Source: http://www.apple.com/environment/).
The arguments outlined above are of a considerable importance for the organiza-
tion of design within the engineering and innovation context. Design should no
longer be seen as an add-on activity to be brought in at the end of a product
development process but be clearly treated as an integral part of innovation man-
agement, generally as well as especially within sustainability-oriented innovation
contexts.
39 Sustainable Design Engineering 717
Fig. 39.6 Sustainability as part of a stage-gate-oriented design process at ABB (Source: Karlson 2002, p. 12)
C. Herrmann and G. Moeller
39 Sustainable Design Engineering 719
6 Summary
7 Cross-References
References
W. Arnold, J. Freimann, R. Kurz, Sustainable balanced scorecard (SBS), Strategisches
Nachhaltigkeitsmanagement in KMU, in Umwelt Wirtschafts Forum 4/01 (Springer,
Berlin/Heidelberg 2001)
H. Bapuji, Toy Recalls, Is China the problem? White Paper, Asper School of Business, University
of Manitoba, 2008
A.D. Basiago, Methods of defining sustainability. Sustain. Dev. 3(3), 109–119 (2006)
T. Bhamra, The role of innovation in the move towards sustainable design of packaging, Paper,
IDS Packaging, Information Resource for the Packaging Industry (2009), www.idspackaging.
co.in
J. Birkeland, Design for Sustainability, A Sourcebook of Integrated, Ecological Solutions (Earth-
scan, Sterling, 2002)
B. Borja de Mozota, Design Management, Using Design to Build Brand Value and Corporate
Innovation (Kindle Edition, Paris, 2003)
M. Bruce, J. Bessant, Design in Business, Financial Times (Prentice Hall, New York, 2002)
C.J. Burschel, D. Losen, A. Wiendl, Betriebswirtschaftslehre der nachhaltigen Unternehmung
(Odenbourg, München, 2004)
M. Charter, T. Clark, Sustainable innovation, key conclusions from sustainable innovation
conferences 2003–2006 organised by: the Centre for Sustainable Design, University College
for the Creative Arts, May 2007, www.cfsd.org.uk
M. Charter, U. Tischner, Sustainable Solutions, Developing Products and Services for the Future
(Greenleaf, Sheffield, 2001)
R. D’Aveni, Hypercompetition: Managing the Dynamics of Strategic Maneuvering (The Free
Press, New York, 1994
DMI, Design Management Institute Boston (Ed.), Investing in and supporting design innovation.
Des. Manage. Rev. 15, 1, Boston, (2004).
K. Dooley, A. Subra, J. Anderson, Adoption rates and patterns of best practices in new product
development. Int. J. Innov. Manage. 6(1), 85–103 (2002)
M.J. Epstein, M.J. Roy, Making the business case for sustainability, linking social and environ-
mental actions to financial performance. J. Corp. Citizsh. 9, 79–96 (2003)
EU, Directive 2005/32/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 6 July 2005, http://ec.
europa.eu/enterprise/eco design/directive 2005 32.pdf
W. Eversheim, U.H. Bölke, W. Kölscheid, Lifecycle management as an approach for design for
X?, in Life-Cycle Modelling for Innovative Products and Processes, Berlin, ed. by F.L. Kraus,
H. Jansen (Chapman and Hall, London, 1995), pp. 71–79
M. Fargnoli, F. Kimura, Sustainable Design of Modern Industrial Products, Proceedings of LCE,
The University of Tokyo, Department of Precision Engineering, 2006a
M. Fargnoli, F. Kimura, Evaluation of Design Methods for Sustainable Product Development,
Proceedings at the TMCE 2006, Ljubljana (Slovenia) 2006b
F. Figge, T. Hahn, S. Schaltegger, M. Wagner, Sustainability Balanced Scorecard, Wertorientiertes
Nachhaltigkeits-Management mit der Balanced Scorecard, Research Report, Centre for Sus-
tainability Management, CSM, Universität Lüneburg, April 2001
J. Fresner, G. Engelhardt, P. Wolf, R. Nussbaumer, A. Grabner, A. Kumpf, Sustainability
balanced scorecard im Nachhaltigkeitsbereich (Ökoprofit), edited by: BMVIT, Österreichisches
Bundesministerium für Verkehr, Innovation und Technologie, Berichte aus Energie- und
Umweltforschung, 28/2006
M. Grimheden, M. Hanson, What is Design Engineering and How Should It be Taught? Proposing
a Didactical Approach, Proceedings, ICED Conference, Melbourne, 2005
M. Hardt, Do you speak design? in Design Report, Heft 1, 2004, pp. 30–31
S. Hart, Capitalism at the Crossroads: The Unlimited Business Opportunities in Solving the
World’s Most Difficult Problems (Wharton School Publishing, Upper Saddle River, 2005)
39 Sustainable Design Engineering 721
C. Herrmann, Strategic Design, Wie man eine Insel erobert, Oder: Warum die Designtheorie und
die Designausbildung in Deutschland eine strategische Neuausrichtung brauchen, Vortrag an
der Bergischen Universität Wuppertal, 20, October 2004
C. Herrmann, G. Moeller, Design als zentraler Wertschöpfungsfaktor, Frankfurter Allgemeine
Zeitung, Nr. 212. vom 12. September 2005, p. 24
C. Herrmann, G. Moeller, Innovation – Marke – Design (Grundlagen einer neuen Corporate
Governance, Düsseldorf, 2006)
C. Herrmann, G. Moeller, Design Entrepreneuring, Designmanagement als Kernfunktion der
Unternehmensentwicklung, P. Russo, R. Gleich, F. Strascheg (Hrsg.), (Von der Idee zum Markt,
München 2008), pp. 78–99
C. Herrmann, G. Moeller, Design Governance, Design as a Key Factor for Innovation and
Economic Success (ICFAI University Press, Hyderabad, 2009)
C. Herrmann, G. Moeller, R. Gleich, P. Russo, Strategisches Industriegüterdesign, Innovation und
Wachstum durch Gestaltung (Springer, Heidelberg, 2009)
B. Hollins, S. Pugh, Successful Product Design (Butterworths, London, 1990)
G.Q. Huang (ed.), Design for X – Concurrent Engineering Imperatives (New York, 1996)
IÖW, Institut für ökologische Wirtschaftsforschung (IÖW) GmbH (Editor), Nachhaltigkeits-
berichterstattung in Deutschland, Ergebnisse und Trends im Ranking, 2007
ISO/TR 14062, Environmental Management – Integrating Environmental Aspects into Product
Design and Development, ISO International Organization for Standardization, 2002
L. Karlson, ISO/TR 14062 – Product considerations, Presentation, Corporate Research, ABB
Group Services Center, 23 Oct 2002, http://www.sis.se/upload/631709776611250000.pdf
L. Karlson, G. Wisen, Managing environmental aspects in product development – the ABB
experience, proceedings, 7th international conference, towards sustainable product design 7,
28–29 Oct 2002, at the British Standards Institution, Chiswick/London
H. Lewis, L. Fitzpatrick, K. Verghese, K. Sonneveld, R. Jordon (Sustainable Packaging Alliance),
Sustainable packaging redefined, Nov 2007, http://www.sustainablepack.org/default.aspx
U. Lindemann, Der Ingenieur und seine Designer – oder der Ingenieur und seine Partner, ed.
J. Reese, Der Ingenieur und seine Designer (Springer, Berlin, 2005), pp. 297–313
MAN, MAN AG, Sustainability Report, Munich, 2007/2008
E. Manzini, Strategic design for sustainability: towards a new mix of products and services, in
Proceedings, EcoDesign ’99, First International Symposium on Environmentally Conscious
Design and Inverse Manufacturing, Conference Publications, CIR.IS, Politecnico di Milano,
1999
E. Manzini, Design for sustainability, How to design sustainable solutions, Working paper,
INDACO, Politecnico di Milano, (2006), http://www.dis.polimi.it/manzini-papers/06.01.06-
design-for-sustainability.doc
O. Marsili, S. Ammon, The dark matter of innovation: design and innovative performance in Dutch
manufacturing. J. Technol. Anal. Strateg. Manage. 18(5) (2006), pp. 515–534
V. Martinet, Defining sustainability objectives, Working Paper, CIREQ Montreal, January 2009
D. Montgomery, Triple bottom line balanced scorecardr (2009), http://www.resilient-strategies.
com/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/Resilient-Strategies-3BL-Balanced-Scorecard.gif
B. Mutlu, A. Er, Design innovation: historical and theoretical perspectives on products innovation
by design, Paper, 5th European Academy of Design Conference, Barcelona, 2003
J. Paap, R. Katz, Anticipating disruptive innovation. Res. Technol. Manage. 47(5), 13–22 (2004)
E. Pappas, Creative problem solving in engineering design, Proceedings, 2002 ASEE Southeastern
Section Meeting, University of Florida, Gainesville, April 2002
M.E. Porter, Competitive Advantage, Creating and Sustaining Superior Performance (The Free
Press, New York, 1985)
S. Ritzen, C. Beskow, Actions for integrating environmental aspects into product development.
J. sustain. Prod. Des. 1(2), 91–102 (2001)
N. Sawhney, Open collaborative design: understanding the role of online tools and social incentives
towards sustainable design and learning, Ph.D. Thesis, Massachusetts Institute of Technology,
2002
722 C. Herrmann and G. Moeller
Abstract
The automotive industry is confronted with an increasing servitization and rising
mobility needs. Changing customer requirements and a changing awareness
of the environmental impact of transportation generate a demand for new
approaches for the realization of transportation. At the same time, the rapid
development in information technology sets up new possibilities to create telem-
atic solutions and to strike new paths in the development of mobility concepts.
Sustainable product service systems in automotive industry can make a major
contribution to foster resource and energy efficiency in transportation. With the
combination of products, services, and infrastructure, the customer requirements
on mobility can be satisfied and simultaneously the environmental impacts can be
reduced. Thereby, the development of new product service systems in automotive
industry needs to consider automotive-specific characteristics, the mobility of the
automotive, and the exceedingly strong influence of external factors on the main
function of the automobile.
Entire mobility concepts as future additional offers of (automotive) com-
panies build on the basic idea of selling the mobility function instead of
the product. They allow the usage and combination of different mobility en-
ablers to combine with an integrative service and are part of the classifi-
cation of result-oriented product service systems. To ensure a contribution
1 Introduction
Mobility (i.e., the shifting of distance (Braess and Seiffert 2007)) is a basic need
for human beings and our mobility activities are a basic requirement for economic
40 Sustainable PSS in Automotive Industry 725
kilometre per
person [%]
100
individual
traffic, cars
railway
75 public passenger
traffic, waggon
50
individual bus,
new mobility
waggons tram
25 concepts
public transport
Fig. 40.1 The development of passenger traffic since 1820 using the example of Germany
(Burgert 1996) and the expected development in passenger transport until 2050
success (Xu 2000). The goal to move faster, longer distances, with heavy goods
and without physical efforts made humans use the available technical options at
every time in history. With the development of the car at the end of the nineteenth
century the second transport revolution led to more individual and flexible mobility.
Today, more than 80% of passenger transportation (in kilometers) in developed
countries is realized with a car (Eurostat 2011). The individualization of transport
has led to a reduction of service integration during the last century in personal traffic.
Figure 40.1 displays the development of passenger traffic using the example of
Germany since 1820. Today, mobility starts altering rapidly again with the technical
development and living standards in industrial countries as well as in emerging
markets (Bundesministerium für Verkehr and Bau und Stadtentwicklung 2009).
During the last years, changes in the choice of transportation means have been
identified. As shown in Fig. 40.1, it is expected that the integration of new mobility
concepts based on (automotive) PSS may lead to a third transport revolution.
Individual and public transportation could become connected, and the advantages
of both systems, the individual mobility on the one hand and the economic and
ecological advantages on the other hand, get interlinked (Herrmann et al. 2011).
At the same time, a change in the technologies for transportation are expected.
Figure 40.2 displays the adjustment in the sales figures from conventional cars to
hybrid and electrical cars as well as to e-bicycles.
Compared to the overall passenger traffic, in major cities worldwide, only
50% of all driven kilometers are realized with a car. The other half of passenger
transportation is today already covered by public transportation, trains, or by bike
or walking (Ahrens 2009). Moreover, since 2004, a phenomenon of declining car
use per capita can be observed in major cities in developed countries (e.g., in cities
in the USA, in Australia, and also in Germany). Six interdependent factors were
726 C. Herrmann and K. Kuntzky
2,000
e-cars
hybrid cars
e-bicycles
bicycles
conventional
cars
0
1875 1900 1925 1950 1975 2000 2025* 2050*
*expected development
Fig. 40.2 Sales development and expected development of transportation means in Germany
(Radverkehrsplan 2011; ibike 2011; urbanbiking 2011; VDA 2011; KBA 2011)
examined by Newman and Kenworthy (2011) to explain the causes for the peak
in car use:
• The “Marchetti Wall”: cities have a similar average travel time of approximately
1 h. Walking cities therefore cannot be larger than 5–8 km; automobile cities can
reach out to 50 km. If cities grow bigger, fast trains are the only technical solution
to stay in the travel time limits.
• Growth of public transportation: in developed countries (e.g., in the USA,
Australia, and Europe), the public transportation has been growing up to 18%
between 1995 and 2005.
• Reversal of urban sprawl: urban density has extremely declined within the last
50 years in industrial countries. This trend seems to have reversed in the last
years.
• Aging of cities: the average age of people living in the cities of the developed
countries has been getting older. Older people tend to drive less than younger.
• Growth of a culture of urbanization: a movement back into cities from suburbs,
especially performed by the older generation, to a life without car dependence
can be observed.
• Rise in fuel prices: the continuously rising fuel prices lead to urbanization and to
a reduction of car use.
Furthermore, especially for the younger generation, a car is no longer a status
symbol or an expression of life style (FOCUS 2010). Rising ecological awareness
vary the choice for transportation means significantly. More and more customers
are just interested in the satisfaction of their “mobility needs” instead of possessing
a car. The trend leads to a demand-driven request of the needed mobility function
(Herrmann et al. 2009).
40 Sustainable PSS in Automotive Industry 727
Mobility Concept
Mobility
Mobility Enabling Providing
Product (car) Service
(sharing service)
Fig. 40.3 Mobility concept for car sharing (Herrmann et al. 2009)
The average vehicle occupation rate is with less than 1.6 persons per car in
the USA and Europe (European Environment Agency 2011; US Department of
Energy 2011; Department for Transport 2011) at a very low level, most cars are
even registered for five or more passengers. Moreover, the usage time of a car
is in average less than 4% compared to the parking time (assuming a kilometric
performance of 14,200 km/year (Bundesministerium für Verkehr and Bau und
Stadtentwicklung 2009) and an average speed of 50 km/h). Thus, much more
cars are on the market than are needed, which influences on the one hand the
environmental impact when producing the cars and, on the other hand, the needed
parking space for cars and therewith the needed land use, which is limited especially
in urban regions, is higher than necessary.
Due to these changes in the mobility behavior and the mobility needs, the auto-
motive industrial sector is particularly confronted with an increasing servitization,
the adding of value through services to the core product (Vandermerwe and Rada
1988). New “mobility concepts,” which represent an allocation of the function
mobility to the customer, occur on the market. This function is realized with the
integrative combination of a mobility-enabling product (e.g., car) and a mobility-
providing service (e.g., a sharing service, Fig. 40.3). It can be understood as a
product service system (PSS) (Herrmann et al. 2009) (e.g., a car sharing service
system).
Due to motorization and traffic density, the emission of, for example, greenhouse
gases by street traffic is a major problem. In the European Union, the CO2 equivalent
emission by street traffic amounted to 877 million tons per year in 2010 (19%
of the overall CO2 emissions, see Fig. 40.4) (European Environment Agency
2011). The share of CO2 emission is highest in the more developed countries, but
developing countries have the highest emission growth rates (International Energy
Egency 2002). CO2 emissions of street traffic were increasing by 21% during the
last 20 years. In the same time, the overall CO2 emissions were decreasing by
17%. With regard to the whole life cycle of a conventional automobile, the use
728 C. Herrmann and K. Kuntzky
Waste
3%
Industrial Other
Processes 8%
7%
Energy
Industries
31%
Residential
10%
Agriculture
10% Road
Transportation
19%
Manufacturing Other
Industries Transportation
11% 1%
Fig. 40.4 Share of total greenhouse emissions (CO2 equivalent) (%) in 2009 in EU27 (European
Environment Agency 2011)
0,3%
15,1%
driving emissions
15,6% allocation of fuel
production
69,0% recycling/ disposal
Fig. 40.5 Emissions (CO2 equivalent) of VW Golf VI over life cycle phases (Volkswagen 2011)
phase can be identified as the most important phase from an ecological perspective
for detecting reduction potential. This phase causes significant CO2 emissions
compared to the life cycle (see Fig. 40.5).
This clearly indicates the important role of the automotive industry sector with
regard to future efforts in reducing CO2 emissions. Since CO2 emissions per
individual vehicle (especially in new cars) are continuously declining, an exclusive
40 Sustainable PSS in Automotive Industry 729
technical solution is not sufficient. Rather, sustainable automotive PSS are needed
to achieve real success in reducing the environmental impacts of mobility.
The introduction of sustainable PSS can contribute to increase resource and
energy efficiency in automotive industry. With the combination of products, ser-
vices, and infrastructure, the customer requirements on mobility can be satisfied and
simultaneously the environmental impacts can be reduced (Kuntzky and Herrmann
2011). Concurrently, economic and social aspects are of major importance for
sustainable mobility as well. As mobility is a relevant condition for economic
growth in our society, access to mobility is a requirement for personal welfare.
The implementation of automotive PSS reduces obstacles in the access to mobility.
Flexible cost structures, for instance, allow an adopted mobility access for different
social and economic conditions. Therefore, PSS can contribute to a holistic sustain-
able mobility.
Different approaches (e.g., Goedkoop et al. 1999; Mejcamp 2000; Stahel 2011)
assume that PSS generally have a positive influence on ecological impacts. This
idea does not integrate rebound effects, the forfeit of savings due to, for example,
changing customer behavior. The saved money or time may be spent in an unsus-
tainable way (Manzini and Vezzoli 2003). Nevertheless, PSS have the potential to be
a more sustainable solution for the customer demands than a pure product solution
can be. The servitization can lead to a reduction of environmental impacts as well as
a reduction of costs by typically influencing three factors: changes on the physical
product, changes in infrastructure, and changes in the handling of the user (Brezet
et al. 2001). This can also influence the organizational structure and the ownership
structure of the offer (Roy 2000) as well as the total amount of products needed.
While in conventional individual traffic, the driver is mostly the owner (or at least
the lessee) of the vehicle, the driver often becomes a short time renter of the vehicle
or even only of a seat in the vehicle with regard to automotive PSS.
Sustainable PSS therefore can be assigned to different categories, depending on
their way of influence. Different authors decided on various categories for the sus-
tainable PSS. While Roy (2000) categorizes PSS in result services, shared utilization
services, and product life extension services, Behrendt et al. (2003) undertakes a
more differentiated division of product service combinations in services additional
to a product and service substituting a product. Substituting services are divided
into result-oriented and use-oriented services, which are again differentiated into
joint use and individual use services. Williams (2006) classifies sustainable PSS in
product, use, and result-oriented services.
Combining these classifications, sustainable automotive PSS can be structured as
follows:
• Product-oriented automotive PSS: on the one hand, aiming to reduce the impact
of the mobility enabling product itself and on the other hand aiming to extend the
useful product life through maintenance, repair, reuse, and recycling.
• Use-oriented automotive PSS or shared utilization PSS: mainly focus on increas-
ing the usage rate of the single mobility enabling product by, for example, sharing
a car. This leads to higher capacity utilization of the product and therefore reduces
the total amount of products needed.
730 C. Herrmann and K. Kuntzky
With the changing mobility structures, numerous PSS in automotive industry are
marketable. With regard to the product “automobile,” two main characteristics
can be identified that help to describe the requirements for the automotive PSS.
First, the “mobility” of the automobile influences the PSS. As the main function of
automobiles is the transport, automobiles are not stationary. It is not known before
where the automobile is located when a certain PSS function is needed. Therefore,
all PSS have to be adapted to the mobility. Solutions can be that the PSS is as mobile
as the automobile itself (which means the PSS provider has to follow the customer)
or the PSS is omnipresently available (a network of providers offering the PSS).
The second characteristic is the exceeding strong influence of external factors on
the main function of the automobile. The accomplishment of the main function,
mobility, is not only influenced by the automobile properties itself, the driver’s
ability, and the driving style. The transport activity also depends on the infrastructure
(road conditions), the behavior of other road users, road work, or the weather.
As shown in Fig. 40.1, mobility has changed from a public passenger transport
to an individualized means of transportation. Existing PSS in automotive industry
therefore have to integrate the customer demands on individual and flexible
transportation.
A survey with the target group of commercial customers (fleets) in the branches
of passenger transport operators, car sharing providers, and municipalities in
Germany regarding their usage of automotive PSS displayed several customer
demands on automotive PSS (Kuntzky and Herrmann 2011):
• The surveyed target groups are primarily interested in services to reduce the effort
in detecting failures in the vehicle.
• Services simplifying and optimizing the internal processes are as well particu-
larly interesting.
• Environmental orientation is of different relevance in the target groups and can
only be in focus if it is not leading to higher complexity and is easy to realize and
at the same time reduces costs.
• Original equipment manufacturer enclosing solutions for the whole fleet are
demanded.
• Services that lead to a positive impact on the driving behavior without addressing
every driver personally are of interest.
• A positive public image coming with the use of sustainable automotive PSS is
important for commercial customers, which was indicated especially in the target
group of municipalities.
• High initial investments are not tolerated, particularly in small fleets.
40 Sustainable PSS in Automotive Industry 731
200000
180000 5000
160000 user car sharing vehicle
120000
3000
user
100000
80000
2000
60000
40000 1000
20000
0 0
98
99
00
01
02
03
04
05
06
07
08
09
10
11
19
19
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
Fig. 40.6 Development of car-sharing market in Germany (Bundesverband Car Sharing 2011)
Offered automotive PSS in the market started with product-oriented services like
repair or financial services. Use-oriented PSS can be observed in the area of after-
sales services, like maintenance services, concentrating on the reduction of fuel
consumption. With the upcoming usage of telematic devices, use-oriented PSS are
created to enable services like remote diagnostics, reporting of the driving behavior,
or influencing the driving routes toward a more economic or ecological way. Car
sharing offers are part of the use-oriented PSS as well (Kuntzky and Herrmann
2011). The car sharing market in Germany is for example expanding (Fig. 40.6).
High growth rates of 79% in 2007 can also be observed in other important markets
like the USA (Shaheen et al. 2009). First original equipment manufacturers start
to develop special cars optimized for car sharing concepts. Car2go for example
developed the smart in a car2go edition with specific telematic devices for the car-
sharing usage and with solar cells on the roof providing the energy for the telematic
devices (Car2Go 2011).
Entire mobility concepts as future additional offers of (automotive) companies
build on the basic idea of selling the mobility function instead of the product. They
allow the usage and combination of different mobility enablers to combine with an
integrative service and are part of the classification of result-oriented PSS. They are
intensively discussed in literature but not available on the market today or only in
simple and local solution like, for example, park and ride or combined bus and train
tickets (Herrmann et al. 2009).
Therefore, the dimensions of mobility concepts have to be investigated for
applying the technology and market concept. To ensure the aspects of sustainability
(especially the ecological advantage) of the PSS mobility concept, a solution in the
conflicting area between the customer’s requirements and available technologies
is needed. Figure 40.7 illustrates the product “mobility concept” within these
conflicting areas: “technology” and “market.”
With the integration of PSS in automotive industry and at the latest with
introducing entire mobility concepts, new pattern of ownership occurs on the
732 C. Herrmann and K. Kuntzky
Mobility Concept
Mobility
Mobility Enabling
Providing
Product
Service
Fig. 40.7 Components of a mobility concept and market pull, technology push (Herrmann et al.
2009)
market. Starting with leasing systems, the provider gets more interested in designing
durable and resalable vehicles. When car sharing systems are in focus, the ownership
structure is radically changing. The user is only in possession of the car during the
actual usage time itself. Therefore, in total the responsibility for the car is with the
provider. He is also responsible for repair and maintenance. At the same time, car
sharing concepts lead to higher usage time of the car itself. An increasing average
of passengers in the cars can only be reached by ride sharing concepts.
For the area of street mobility, beside the car several other mobility systems
are available. Figure 40.8 represents one hypothesis of the (ancestral) relationship
between those mobility systems. The starting point is represented by the “walker.”
Then two big groups of mobility systems can be differentiated (Herrmann et al.
2011).
Both sectors start with bicycle-based mobility enablers. In the upper sector,
the user is the owner of the product. Here, only the product is providing the
realization of the required mobility. From the starting point, the drives are changing
from muscularity drive and the usage of muscularity of animals to the usage of
electric and combustion engines. Going from left to right the reachable velocity, the
coverable distance and the number of passengers are rising with growing distance
from the starting point as well as the environmental impact and the variable costs.
In the lower sector, systems with a higher level of servitization are displayed and
the point of departure is changing from completely flexible to station-based systems.
The stations itself can be fixed (like busses) or flexible (e.g., taxi). From left to right
the environmental impact, the velocity and the traveled distance are rising as in the
upper sector. In the mobility systems “rickshaw,” “motor rickshaw,” “public bus”
40 Sustainable PSS in Automotive Industry 733
common ancestor
walker
bicycle
horse
carriage
mobility enabling
segway® systems where the
motor scooter user is the owner
and “taxi,” the user is a passenger and is only renting a seat; in “car2go R
,” “rental
cars” or “car-sharing,” the whole vehicle is rented and the user is also the driver.
Further differentiations in this sector are the length of the rental (from short-term
rental, e.g., taxi, to long term, e.g., rental car), the amount of passengers per vehicle
(e.g., one for rental bike to several in busses), and the time and route flexibility of the
system (scheduled and fixed point of departure and arrival, e.g., busses, and flexible
time and point of systems, e.g., rental cars).
This cladogram points out that rental car, car sharing, and car2go c
today are
the most enhanced mobility systems for passenger transportation. This mobility
PSS enable the user to travel with high-velocity long distances and comparatively
flexible. The service complexity is already very high. Due to the allocation of the
car for more than one user, and therefore the sharing of the product part, the cost per
user as well as the environmental impact becomes less. Nevertheless, these systems
are not supporting a higher range of passengers per car. Furthermore, the systems
are based on a single mobility enabler. Therefore, they allow further improvement
in the area of result-oriented automotive PSS.
To control the high service complexity, particularly car sharing and car2go c
are dependent on telematic systems for sharing solutions. Therefore, future devel-
opments in the market of entire mobility systems depend on the development of
telematic systems.
734 C. Herrmann and K. Kuntzky
With the diverse influences on automotive PSS, like changing customer require-
ments to higher importance of sustainability, the technology push, or the handling
of the immaterial service parts, the exposure and the management of sustainable PSS
across all life cycle phases become a serious challenge. To handle this complexity,
a holistic approach for sustainable automotive PSS is needed. Similar to the
approach for total life cycle management (Herrmann 2010), all aspects of the PSS
dimensions, the PSS life cycle, and the different PSS management phases need to
be regarded.
As in a PSS, neither the product nor the service is solely important but the total
system as a result of the product and service combination. A suitable PSS life cycle
management approach brings into focus the management of this multidisciplinary,
sociotechnical system. In various life cycle phases, an exchange and coordination
between the life cycles of offered services and related products are needed. Between
the levels of management, there has to be a link as well. Therefore, the existing
framework for total life cycle management (Herrmann et al. 2007) and the life
cycle of the PSS have to be integrated into one consistent framework for PSS life
cycle management. Therewith, a framework is created supporting the introduction,
implementation, and anchoring of the various management programs and tools in
the PSS life cycle. The framework clarifies all relevant life stages of a PSS and
736
common ancestor
Trip Computer
TomTom© Blue&Me
BMW AG© Professional
TomTom© Carminat 1 Mobile devices in the European market
TomTom© Go 730 Traffic Characters: navigation and automatic reception of required data
TomTom© XXL IQ Route
TomTom© Start
General Motors© CD 70 + Navigon
Volkswagen© RNS310
Mobile devices
Sanyo© NV-SD 10 DT
Characteristics like independent sending and receiving of changes in road
Inkel© W500 3 situations, information provision, or TV reception
KT© Show WiBro
TomTom© Go 950 Live Mobile device
4
Characteristics like vehicle location and IQ Routes.
TomTom© XL Live IQ Routes
Toyota© G-Book mX
BMW AG© Connected Drive Fixed systems, capabilities to communicate with a control centre, emergency
5 call systems and the transmission and reception of changes in road situations
On Star©
DB© Call a bike Systems for sharing services without navigation and information
Greenwheels©
6 provisioning, equipped with: driver identification, monitoring of usage time,
Car2Go telematic system© transmission of reservation status, opening vehicles by PIN or access card.
Claas© Telematics
Cybit©
veovia sales GmbH 7
Brabender software
Telematic systems for commercial vehicles or fleets
AG© R2 compact Functions for navigation, job control and status monitoring, continuous route
observation and monitoring of vehicle data from the CAN. Partially
Bluetooth connectivity, hands-free sets, internet and TV reception
Fig. 40.10 Connected framework of total life cycle management and service life cycle manage-
ment (Herrmann et al. 2010)
Considering PSS in automotive industry, the life cycle phases in the center of
the framework (Fig. 40.11) describe the activities from the idea of an automotive
PSS to the recycling of immaterial service parts and the redistribution, disposal,
738 C. Herrmann and K. Kuntzky
Fig. 40.11 Framework for PSS life cycle management (Herrmann et al. 2010)
and recycling of the automotive parts. The automotive parts can, for example,
be redistributed and disposed, whereas the service or service characteristics are
recycled to be used with another product or starting a new life cycle of another
PSS with new automotive parts. In the development phase, the automotive-related
product parts and the service parts which enable the use of the automotive PSS are
developed and integrated with a particular attention to the interfaces between the
immaterial and the material parts.
In the next life cycle phase, the automotive parts are produced, and a parallel
provision of the required potential for the service part of the automotive PSS, for
example, the infrastructure for the integration of telematic devices and car2-X com-
munication, takes place. This division is ascribed to the different characterization
of services and products. While the product needs to be manufactured before using,
the immateriality of services is linked to the subsequent usage and production phase
and the potential provision phase (Herrmann et al. 2010). Afterward, the automotive
PSS is marketed and the physical parts are distributed to the required positions.
Simultaneously to the usage of the automotive parts by a customer, the isochronous
production of the service parts and the usage take place. The disjunction into two
parts in this phase reflects the integration of the external factor, the customer that
needs to be integrated in the life cycle.
for PSS life cycle management for incorporation of the automotive parts and the
service parts into the management perspective. The customer part is explicitly
considered by the integration of the external factor with its own normative, strategic,
and operational (management) level as well as own structures, activities, and
behavior in the service production and usage. Thus, for example, evolving customer
requirements in terms of environmental awareness or the decreasing importance of
the automobile as a status symbol can be met.
With the integration of life cycle disciplines into the management of automotive
PSS, a holistic view on the automotive PSS is rendered possible. The life cycle
spanning disciplines – process management, information and knowledge manage-
ment, social life cycle evaluation, economic life cycle evaluation, and ecological life
cycle evaluation – take into account the holistic view on the automotive PSS with
regard to the whole life cycle. Thus, trade-off effects over the life cycle or rebound
effects, for example, the possibility for an intensified usage of a car due to lower
initial investments for the customer for car sharing can be disclosed.
The life-cycle-phase-related disciplines PSS management, PSS production man-
agement, PSS after-sales management, and PSS end-of-life management finally
regard the automotive PSS specific management operations. For the optimization
of the PSS over the whole life cycle, these disciplines need to interact. The
management of each of these phases needs to be considered. Only with the
incorporation of each of the life cycle phases in the management disciplines and
with the interaction of the single disciplines all aspects of the automotive PSS –
network, infrastructure product, and service – are included. Properties of products
as well as the service dimensions become part of a harmonized management.
For automotive PSS, the consideration of the framework for PSS life cycle
management therefore is an important aspect with regard to the interaction of the
different management perspectives and for the holistic view on the life cycle of both
aspects, the automotive product and the service.
7 Summary
The influence of changing customer requirements and the need for a more sustain-
able transportation necessitate rethinking in the market of mobility. The demand for
sustainable PSS in automotive industry is rising consistently. It becomes obvious
that new trends and developments in mobility today are more and more relying
on the development in information technology and telematics. The level of service
integration is rising significantly due to new potentials in countervailing the high-
service complexity. In passenger transportation, prospective possibilities to pursue
trends to a product service orientation and to connect technical developments with
service offers can be extended. Furthermore, the developments in telematics depict
740 C. Herrmann and K. Kuntzky
that today’s mobility concepts are only using a part of the available functions in
telematic systems. A great potential for progress in new mobility approaches exists
as well for the improvement of the design and for processes in existing concepts.
For further developments in passenger mobility, it is essential to change the view on
the product “vehicle,” leaving the idea of a single product, coming to the idea of a
combined system with vehicle, telematic system, and services.
New car concepts, like electric vehicles, rely on integrated service structures.
Functionality without distinctive abdications of comfort due to the reduced range
of distance can only be realized with PSS, which allow an omnipresent access to
information about the charging level and other automotive functions.
Obviously, today’s PSS in automotive industry show some deficits:
• The economic benefit of automotive PSS is not sufficiently realized or not
communicated well enough to the potential customers.
• The combination of the mobility offered via cars with mobility offered via other
transportation means is hardly realized.
• The ecological benefit of automotive PSS does not emerge in a clear manner.
• The concepts have significant deficits regarding flexibility and convenience
(compared to the use of the private vehicle).
• The concepts are not implemented all over the country let alone worldwide.
With introducing an entire mobility concept, these deficits can be partially corrected.
Car-sharing concepts for example can be integrated with ride-sharing concepts.
Instead of booking the whole car, the user only books a seat in the car, when the
integrated software tool recognizes that different drivers are about to use the same
route. Those services can also be extended to an individualization of the routes
and schedules of public transportation or to revised opportunities for the personal
adoption of different transportation means.
At the same time, a life-cycle-related view on all aspects of automotive PSS is
distinguished to assure a provision for all life cycle phases and related trade-off and
rebound effects in development and implementation of automotive PSS.
The prospective developments in passenger transportation can reach an increas-
ing rate of servitization without losing the advantages of individualization.
8 Cross-References
References
G.A. Ahrens, Sonderauswertung zur Verkehrserhebung ‘Mobilität in Städten SrV 2008’ –
Städtevergleich. Dresden (2009)
40 Sustainable PSS in Automotive Industry 741
S. Behrendt, C. Jasch et al., Eco-Service Development – Reinventing Supply and Demand in the
European Union (Bookcraft, Midsommer Norton, 2003)
Brabender, (2011), www.brabender-group.com/de/home.html
H. Braess, U. Seiffert (ed.), Handbuch Kraftfahrzeugtechnik (Vieweg, Wiesbaden, 2007)
J.C. Brezet, A.S. Bijma et al., The design of eco-efficient services, Design for sustainability
program. Delft University of Technology, Delft (2001)
Bundesministerium für Verkehr, Bau und Stadtentwicklung (ed.), Verkehr in Zahlen 2009/2010
(Deutscher Verkehrs, Hamburg, 2009)
Bundesverband CarSharing e.V., Jahresbericht 2010. Hannover (2011)
W. Burgert, Tendenzen im Karosseriebau, in VDI-Bericht 1256- 150 Jahre Wilhelm Maybach, ed.
by Verein deutscher Ingenieure (VDI, Düsseldorf, 1996), pp. 29–50
Car2Go, (2011), www.car2go.com
Department for Transport, (2011), www.dft.gov.uk
European Commission, Climat action (2012), http://ec.europa.eu/clima/policies/transport/vehicles/
index en.htm
European Environment Agency, (2011), www.eea.europa.eu
Eurostat, (2011), http://epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu
FOCUS (ed.), Communication Networks 14.0 (FOCUS Magazin Verlag GmbH, München, 2010)
M. Goedkoop, C. van Halen et al., Product services systems, ecological and economic basics,
report 1999/36. The Hague, Zoetermeer (1999)
C. Herrmann, Ganzheitliches Life Cycle Management – Nachhaltigkeit und Lebenszyklusorien-
tierung in Unternehmen (Springer, Berlin/Heidelberg, 2010)
C. Herrmann, L. Bergmann et. al., Total life cycle management – A systems and cybernetics ap-
proach to corporate sustainability in manufacturing, in Sustainable Manufacturing V – Global
Symposium on Sustainable Product Development and Life Cycle Engineering, Rochester (2007)
C. Herrmann, J. Stehr et al., Automotive life cycle engineering – Understanding the interdepen-
dencies between technology and market of environmentally conscious mobility concepts, in
Proceedings of the 6th International Symposium on Environmentally Conscious Design and
Inverse Manufacturing (EcoDesign 2009). Sapporo, (2009), pp. 231–236
C. Herrmann, K. Kuntzky et al., Joint framework for product service systems and life cycle
management, in Proceedings of the 2nd CIRP International Conference on Product-Service-
Systems 2010, Linköping University, Linköping, (2010), pp. 353–359
C. Herrmann, K. Kuntzky et al., Pathways of servitization in mobility systems, in Functional
Thinking for Value Creation – Proceedings of the 3rd CIRP International Conference on
Industrial Product Service Systems 2011, Braunschweig, ed. by Hesselbach J, Hermmann C
(Springer, Berlin/Heidelberg, 2011), pp. 249–254
ibike, (2011), www.ibike.org
International Energy Egency (ed.), Dealing with climate change: policies and measures in iea
member countries 2002. Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development, (2002)
KBA, (2011), www.kba.de
K. Kuntzky, C. Herrmann, Application of eco-services in automotive industry for commercial
customers, in Functional Thinking for Value Creation – Proceedings of the 3rd CIRP
International Conference on Industrial Product Service Systems 2011, Braunschweig, ed. by
J. Hesselbach, C. Hermmann (Springer, Berlin/Heidelberg, 2011), pp. 279–284
E. Manzini, C. Vezzoli, A strategic approach to develop sustainable product service systems:
examples taken from the ‘environmentally friendly innovation’ Italien price. J. Clean. Prod.
11, 851–857 (2003). Elsevier
R. Mejcamp, Changing Consumer Behavior Through Eco-Efficient Services (Delft University of
Technology, Delft, 2000)
J. Mikulski, Using telematics in transport, in Transport System Telematics, 10th Conference, TST
2010, Katowice, ed. by J. Mikulski (2010), pp 175–182
P. Newman, J. Kenworthy, Peak car use: understanding the demise of automobile dependence.
World Trans. Policy Pract. 17(2), 31–42 (2011). Los Angeles
742 C. Herrmann and K. Kuntzky
P. Nijkamp, G. Pepping, The relevance and use of information and telecommunication networks as
strategic tools on the transport sector. Annal Reg. Sci. 30(1), 111–133 (1996). Springer
Radverkehrsplan, (2011), www.nationaler-radverkehrsplan.de
R. Roy, Sustainable product-service systems. Futures 32, 289–299 (2000). Elsevier
S. Shaheen, A. Cohen et al., North American carsharing – 10-year retrospective, in Transportation
Research Record (The National Academy, Washington, 2009), pp. 35–44
M. Siergiejczyk, Quality of telematic services in transport, in Third International Conference on
Dependability of Computer Systems, (Szklarska Poreba, Poland, 2008), pp. 422–429
R.W. Stahel, Sustainability and services, in Sustainable Solutions, ed. by M. Charter, U. Tischner
(Greenleaf, Sheffield, 2011)
urbanbiking, (2011), www.urbanbiking.de
US Department of Energy, (2011), www.eere.energy.gov
S. Vandermerwe, J. Rada, Servitization of business: adding value by adding services. Eur.
Manag. J. 6(4), 314–324 (1988). Elsevier
VDA, (2011), www.vda.de
A.G. Volkswagen, Life cycle assessment of VW golf (2011), www.umweltpraedikat.de
H. Wallentowitz, K. Reif (ed.), Handbuch Kraftfahrzeugelektronik (Vieweg, Wiesbaden, 2006)
A. Williams, Product service systems in the automobile industry: contribution to system innova-
tion? J. Clean. Prod. 15, 172–184 (2006). Elsevier
H. Winner, S. Hakuli et al. (ed.), Handbuch Fahrerassistenzsysteme (Vieweg, Wiesbaden, 2009)
Y. Xu, Development of transport telematics in Europe. Geoinformatica 4(2), 179–200 (2000).
Springer
Section V
Policy and Decision-Making
Policy, Decision-Making, and
Management for Sustainable 41
Engineering: Introduction
Karel F. Mulder
1 Introduction
Technology is the methodological control over the forces of nature (cf. Habermass
1968). As this is a basic presupposition of technology, Habermass regards technol-
ogy to be an “ideology” and not something that is prescribed by the laws of nature.
Such a position is quite contrary to the established beliefs of engineers regarding
their own work: being neutral and objective and just providing society with the
efficient tools it needs. However, the tools are not neutral themselves, as our new
technologies do not just fulfill existing demands, but also create new ones. Engineers
have to be critical how, when, and for what aim new designs are created.
There are good reasons for sustainable engineering to be reflexive regarding
its own goals and operations. Sustainable engineering is not dealing with one
single specific issue as sustainability consists of many articulations (Mulder et al.
2011). Dilemmas between various sustainable development issues and time frames
of evaluation might arise: Is waste prevention a good thing if it takes more
energy? Is cleaner production a good thing if it leads to unemployment? Is
energy efficiency a good thing if it slightly increases risks? Organizations are
often confronted with such dilemmas. Many of these sustainable development
dilemmas cannot be solved by the application of moral principles alone: They are
a matter of choice. However, a choice that often is important for every creature on
this planet. The organization that is confronted with such sustainability dilemmas
should at least pay attention to their interests. Only in that way, organizations
can be successful in developing sustainability visions and developing a sustainable
engineering strategy that could help them in achieving that vision. This volume
aims at providing building blocks for developing such a sustainable engineering
strategy.
K.F. Mulder
Technology Policy and Management, Delft University of Technology, Delft, The Netherlands
e-mail: k.f.mulder@tudelft.nl
a practical problem for making an LCA. (See Life Cycle Thinking for Improved
Resource Management: LCA or?)
Choices for new sustainable technologies also have strong time dimensions:
In order to have alternatives for depleting resources, the development of alternatives
should be initiated in an early stage just as support should be mobilized and
stakeholders should be consulted. But how to mobilize stakeholders in an early stage
and how to create attractive future visions that could contribute to consensus and
guide our efforts toward that vision? Interactive backcasting to develop pathways
that could lead us to attractive future visions is an interesting alternative to bu-
reaucratic planning. (See Backcasting and Scenarios for Sustainable Technology
Development.)
Technology development is a social process, i.e., the outcome of a process that
involves various stakeholders and their perceptions and interests (Bijker 1986).
However, this does not imply that all stakeholders can actually participate in shaping
the sustainable technological solutions that are required. Very often, engineering
design results from the interaction between engineers and customers. However, third
parties might feel the consequences: They suffer from pollution, safety hazards, or
other effects. How to involve communities in the process of shaping technologies
and technological systems? (See Engineers and Community: How Sustainable
Engineering Depends on Engineers? Views of People.)
The implication of recognizing that technology results from the social context
in which it was created is that the transfer of a technology to a different social
context is problematic. Especially the failures in the transfer of technologies from
industrialized societies to developing nations reveal the social factors that were
(unwillingly and unknowingly) poured into the technological design and make the
technology inefficient or unacceptable in the cultural or organizational context of
another nation. How could we find out which technologies suit a specific local
context? How could people from this local context participate in establishing the
needs of this local context? How could feasibility studies be carried out to establish
what it takes to run a technology in that local context and how it will affect local
culture. What learning or training processes need to be in place? How can further
diffusion of this technology be realized? (See Successful Contextual Technology
Transfer and Determinants of Culture.)
For businesses to contribute to sustainable development, long-term value creation
instead of short-term money making is required. This issue is on the agenda of more
and more companies, especially as a result of the economic crisis that hit the various
companies in recent years. Many companies and the people within them desire to
create long-term value and contribute to a better world. They practice sustainable
entrepreneurship. This implies that a company not only aims for economic goals
but also for environmental and social goals. Creating economic value assures the
continuity of the firm. However, executives realize that without dedicated strategies
and measures that improve environmental and social circumstances, there is a risk
of endangering the continuity of the firm. Developing and implementing more
sustainable technologies and systems requires different business models from the
innovator: Wasteful use of consumables should not be the source of income of a
748 K.F. Mulder
business. Recycling efforts could be supported by not selling products but leasing
them. (See New Business Models for Sustainable Development.)
Sustainable engineering requires strategic analysis and long-term strategies, from
companies as well as public authorities and interest groups. Choices of today
might lead to “lock in” and be the irreversibilities of tomorrow. In the growing
complexity of current technological systems, what still seems a minor choice
today could lead to a new technological standard of the future. New and more
sustainable technologies might need some initial protection in order to improve the
technology by learning in practice. In this way, the technologies can be nurtured
to make them ready for market competition. New technologies are sometimes not
introduced as they are too expensive. However, they are too expensive as they are
only produced in small numbers. Change takes bold investments. As these are risky,
a waiting game might develop. More encompassing changes of technological-and
social systems do not only require business to invest but also require adaptations
in (government controlled) infrastructure and changes in consumer behavior. Such
changes are hard to implement and might require long-term concerted efforts. (See
Strategies for Sustainable Technologies: Innovation in Systems, Products, and
Services.) Strategic thinking is crucial for an engineer that aims at contributing to
sustainable development.
References
W.E. Bijker, T.P. Hughes, T.J. Pinch (eds.),The Social Construction of Technological Systems: New
Directions in the Sociology and History of Technology (MIT Press, Cambridge, 1987)
J. Habermas, Technik und Wissenschaft als “Ideologie” (Suhrkamp, Frankfurt am Main, 1968)
K. Mulder, D. Ferrer-Balas, H. van Lente, What is Sustainable Technology, Perceptions, Paradoxes
and Possibilities (Greenleaf, Sheffield, 2011)
Backcasting and Scenarios for Sustainable
Technology Development 42
Jaco Quist
Abstract
This chapter explores the relevance of scenarios and backcasting for sustainable
technology development and sustainable innovation. It argues that backcasting,
due to its normative nature and its focus on desirable futures, is very well
equipped to be applied to sustainability, which is a strongly normative concept
too. The chapter contains a brief overview of backcasting studies and a method-
ological framework is presented. The framework is illustrated by a backcasting
case on meat alternatives and novel protein foods, which was conducted at
the sustainable technology development (STD) program in the Netherlands.
A backcasting methodology is presented that can be easily applied by engineers,
which is also used in engineering education at Delft University of Technology.
1 Introduction
J. Quist
Faculty of Technology, Policy and Management, Section Technology Dynamics and Sustainable
Development (TDSD), Delft University of Technology, Delft, The Netherlands
e-mail: j.n.quist@tudelft.nl
expected due to changing user behavior (Herring and Roy 2007). Another example
is the hole in the ozone layer due to CFC emissions; the negative impact of
technology use by mankind became only evident more than half a century after
its market introduction in the early twentieth century. A third example is growing
wealth in general; it comes along with an increased environmental burden, while
decoupling economic growth from the increasing environmental burden has not
been sufficiently successful until now (Jackson 2009).
Significant reduction of our current environmental burden is obviously required.
Based on the well-known Ehrlich–Holdren equation (Ehrlich and Holdren 1971),
environmental improvement with a factor 10 (Schmidt-Bleek 2008) or even a factor
20 (Weaver et al. 2000) has been proposed as required for sustainable development
on the long term. These kinds of environmental improvement factors do not only
require technological changes, but also cultural, organizational, structural, and
institutional changes. This can neither be achieved by a new product or a product
innovation, nor by the introduction of a specific sustainable technology alone.
Instead, sets of systemic changes are needed at the level of societal systems in order
to achieve significant environmental improvement with a factor 10 or a factor 20. For
instance, most meat alternatives have a considerably lower environmental impact
than meat, but they lead only to significant environmental gains if meat alternatives
substitute meat at a large scale. So, it is not only about single product innovations or
particular technologies, but also about systemic changes in our current consumption
and production patterns and the related socio-technical systems. A shift to large-
scale substitution of meat by meat alternatives also requires behavioral changes,
raising public awareness and decreasing the current livestock and meat processing
industries, as well as supporting policies and education.
Technologies are thus part of larger societal systems that comprise both techno-
logical and social elements and for which the term “socio-technical systems” is used
in this chapter. The social part does not only include people, but also organizations
as well as different kinds of rules and organizational structures. Together with the
technologies, this makes up larger socio-technical systems and eventually society
as a whole. Socio-technical systems can be industries, households, domains like
transportation, mobility, or nutrition, and geographically bound systems like a city
or a region. Within these socio-technical systems, long-term transitions occur, such
as the transition from sailing vessels to steamships that took place between 1780 and
1870 (Geels 2005a), the transition of computers in society from the first operational
computer in the mid-1940s and widespread personal use of PCs starting in the
1990, and the transition in public hygiene and water supply that took place in the
Netherlands and many other industrializing countries between the mid-nineteenth
and mid-twentieth centuries (Geels 2005b).
Aiming at large-scale change of such complex socio-technical systems in
pursuit of sustainable development is often referred to as system innovations or
transitions to sustainability (Elzen et al. 2004; Rotmans et al. 2001; Quist 2007;
Loorbach 2007; Grin et al. 2010). Other terms can be found too, such as indus-
trial transformation, industrial ecology, and shifts toward sustainable consumption
and production systems. Nevertheless, these terms cover more or less similar
42 Backcasting and Scenarios for Sustainable Technology Development 751
concepts and share the idea that realizing considerable environmental improve-
ment on the long term requires changes at the level of socio-technical systems
(Quist 2007).
The focus of this chapter is on approaches that can be applied to explore long-
term transitions and system innovations that contribute to sustainable development.
The strong future orientation of sustainable development is exactly why future
studies, scenarios, scenario assessments, and backcasting are highly relevant for
system innovations and transitions to sustainability. Three types of scenarios and
associated scenario methodologies can be distinguished (e.g., Vergragt and Quist
2011; Linstone 1999).
• The first type of scenarios is about likely futures and relates to the question
what will happen. These scenarios are often based on trend extrapolations using
quantitative methods, which result in surprise-free futures and Business-as-Usual
(BAU) scenarios reflecting major trends.
• The second type of scenario approaches is about possible futures and relates to
the question what could happen. This type of scenario methodologies generally
results in a set of distinct alternative futures reflecting uncertainty and different
perspectives on possible futures. Well-known examples are strategic context
scenarios, as initially developed by the company Shell and the model-based
scenarios, as for instance developed by the IPCC and earlier in “Limits to
Growth,” the first report to the Club of Rome.
• The third type of scenarios is about desirable futures; it relates to the normative
questions what should happen, or what future we would like to have. This type of
scenarios is also referred to as normative scenarios, or future visions. Backcasting
and transition management are widely applied methodologies that generate
desirable futures and explore the related system innovations and transitions to
sustainability.
Approaches like backcasting (Quist and Vergragt 2006; Quist 2007) and transi-
tion management (Rotmans et al. 2001; Loorbach 2007) are thus normative, long
term oriented, system oriented, take a broad view on sustainability and are often
participatory. These approaches combine (Quist and Vergragt 2006: 1028):
1. The involvement of a broad range of stakeholders and actors from different
societal groups including government, companies, public interest groups, and
knowledge bodies, not only when defining the problem but also when searching
for solutions and developing shared visions.
2. Incorporating not only the environmental component of sustainability, but also
its economic and social components.
3. Taking into account the demand side and the supply chain as well as related
production and consumption systems. Backcasting literally means looking back
from the future. A more comprehensive definition is “generating a desirable
future, and then looking backwards from that future to the present in order to
strategize and to plan how it could be achieved” (Vergragt and Quist 2011, see
also Fig. 42.1) or “envisaging a desirable future first, before looking back to how
that future may be achieved, and defining what steps need to be taken to bring
about the envisaged future” (Quist and Vergragt 2006; Quist 2007).
752 J. Quist
Milestones Furture
E Vision
sting
C Backca
O
E
F
F
g
tin
I
C as
c
Explicitly normative
ck
I
Ba
Participatory
E System oriented,
N Desired futures & changes (action-oriented)
C Combines process, design, analysis
Y
Transdisciplinary
2000 2050
TIME
Over the last decades, backcasting has evolved into a major approach to explore
system innovations toward sustainability using normative or desirable futures (e.g.,
Weaver et al. 2000; Quist and Vergragt 2006; Quist 2007; Vergragt and Quist 2011).
As argued by Dreborg (1996) backcasting is particularly useful in case of complex
societal problems, when there is a need for major change, when dominant trends
are part of the problem, when there are side effects or externalities that cannot
be satisfactorily solved in markets, and when longtime horizons allow for future
alternatives that need several decades to develop. Most sustainability problems are
obvious examples of such complex problems.
Backcasting was developed in the 1970s and early 1980s by, for instance, Amory
Lovins in the USA (Lovins 1977), John Robinson in Canada (Robinson 1982),
and Peter Steen in Sweden (Johansson and Steen 1980) in response to the then
dominant practices of energy forecasting that emphasized large-scale electricity
production and nuclear power, and assumed a strong growth of the energy demand.
Whereas Lovins used the term “backwards-looking analysis” (Lovins 1977), it was
Robinson who coined the term “backcasting” (Robinson 1982, 1990). Driven by the
then emerging environmental awareness, frontrunners like Lovins, Robinson, and
others proposed soft energy paths toward alternative futures that emphasized energy
conservation and decentralized renewable energy technologies. They also assessed
these pathways on their feasibility and compared them to regular trend extrapolating
Business-As-Usual (BAU) scenarios; their conclusion was that soft energy paths
were feasible when energy policies would be changed.
In the late 1980s, the emphasis in backcasting shifted toward exploring sus-
tainable futures, for instance, in Canada (Robinson 1990, 2003), Sweden (Dreborg
1996; Höjer and Mattsson 2000), and the Netherlands (Vergragt and Jansen 1993;
Weaver et al. 2000; Vergragt 2005). Since the early 1990s, a shift to stakeholder
involvement in backcasting has also taken place (Vergragt and Jansen 1993; Dreborg
1996; Holmberg 1998; Holmberg and Robèrt 2000; Weaver et al. 2000; Quist et al.
2001; Van de Kerkhof et al. 2002; Robinson 2003; Quist and Vergragt 2006).
Up till now backcasting for sustainability has been applied to a wide range of dif-
ferent topics like river basins (Robinson 2003), transportation and mobility (Höjer
and Mattsson 2000; Geurs and van Wee 2000; Banister et al. 2000), transforming
companies into sustainable ones (Holmberg 1998; Holmberg and Robèrt 2000),
sustainable technologies and sustainable system innovations (Vergragt and Jansen
1993; Weaver et al. 2000), sustainable households (Quist et al. 2001; Green and
Vergragt 2002), climate policy options (Van de Kerkhof et al. 2002), industrial
ecology (Giurco et al. 2011), and urban and rural land-use futures (Carlsson-
Kanyama et al. 2008; Kok et al. 2006; De Graaf et al. 2009; Höjer et al. 2011).
Interestingly, energy backcasting has made a revival too (Anderson et al. 2008;
Gomi et al. 2011). For a recent overview of developments and applications in
backcasting, see Quist and Vergragt (2006) or Quist (2007).
754 J. Quist
The examples show that there is a considerable variety of topics dealt with in
backcasting projects (see also Quist 2007; Vergragt and Quist 2011). There is variety
in whether and how stakeholder participation has been organized, in the number
of steps in which the methodology has been split, in the methods that are used,
in the nature and scale of the systems addressed (e.g., local, regional, national,
consumption systems, or societal domains), in the number of visions developed
and how the visions have been developed, and if the focus is on developing and
analyzing future vision, on learning and raising awareness among stakeholders,
or on realizing follow-up and implementation. Visions can be target-fulfilling
images developed and analyzed by researchers, as well as more general visions
developed and endorsed by a range of stakeholders. In addition, other approaches
like transition management (Rotmans et al. 2001; Loorbach 2007), road mapping
also use normative future visions and pathways on how to get there, though
sometimes without explicitly referring to the term “backcasting”; this makes the
variety even larger.
The extent to which impact and spin-off of backcasting has occurred varies too.
For instance, the impact of backcasting experiments in the Netherlands on meat
alternatives, multiple land use, and sustainable household food consumption has
been evaluated (Quist 2007; Quist et al. 2011). Ten years after the projects, it was
found that there were considerable differences in the degree to which follow-up
and spin-off had occurred. The study showed that participatory backcasting may,
but does not automatically, lead to substantial follow-up and spin-off at the level of
niches in the research-, business-, government-, and public domains (Quist 2007;
Quist et al. 2011).
To deal with the variety in backcasting, four different backcasting approaches
have been analyzed and compared (Quist 2007: 24–30):
• The backcasting approach of Robinson (1990)
• The Natural Step backcasting methodology, as reported by Holmberg and Robèrt
(Holmberg 1998; Holmberg and Robèrt 2000),
• The backcasting methodology applied at the Dutch STD program (Weaver et al.
2000; Vergragt 2005) and
• The backcasting methodology applied in the international Sustainable
Households project (Quist et al. 2001; Green and Vergragt 2002; Vergragt
2005),
Based on this analysis, a more comprehensive methodological framework for
participatory backcasting has been developed (Quist 2007), which is depicted in
Fig. 42.2.
This framework is based on three key elements of participatory backcasting that
also emerged from an earlier literature review (Quist and Vergragt 2006; Quist
2007):
1. The construction and use of desirable future visions or normative scenarios
2. Broad stakeholder participation and stakeholder learning (at the level of paradigms
and values); usually stakeholders from different societal domains like business,
research, government, and society are involved, with the latter including both the
wider public and public interest groups
42 Backcasting and Scenarios for Sustainable Technology Development 755
Five steps:
Fig. 42.2 A methodological framework for participatory backcasting (Quist 2007: 232)
It must be noted that though the approach is depicted stepwise and seems to
be linear, it definitely is not. Iteration cycles are likely to occur, while there is
also a mutual influence between steps following one to another. In addition, the
first step includes defining and bounding the system and includes defining time
horizon, the number of visions to be developed, and developing the transdisciplinary
or multidisciplinary research design.
Furthermore, four groups of tools and methods are distinguished. In each step
of participatory backcasting, methods and tools can be applied from each group.
The four groups of tools and methods that make up a toolbox for backcasting are
(Quist and Vergragt 2006):
756 J. Quist
• Participatory tools and methods. This group comprises all tools and methods
that are useful for involving stakeholders and generating and guiding interaction
and dialogue among stakeholders. It includes specific workshop tools, creativity
tools, discussion tools, and tools supporting stakeholders to conduct backcasting
and participatory envisioning.
• Design tools and methods. This group consists not only of tools and methods for
scenario construction, but also for elaboration and detailing future systems, as
well as for the design of the stakeholder involvement process.
• Analytical tools and methods. This group of tools and methods is meant for
assessing scenarios and designs and includes consumer acceptance methods,
environmental assessments, and economic analyses. It also includes methods for
evaluation of stakeholder interaction and stakeholder analysis.
• Tools and methods for management, coordination and communication. This
group consists of methods and tools that are relevant for managing the project
and the stakeholder involvement process. It includes the methods, which can be
applied for shaping and maintaining stakeholder networks, communication, and
coordination and is sometimes also referred to as organizational tools.
The framework also distinguishes three types of demands: (1) normative de-
mands; (2) process demands; and (3) knowledge demands. Normative demands
reflect the goal-related requirements for the future vision, as well as how sustainabil-
ity is defined in the case under study and how sustainability is turned into principles
or criteria that future visions should meet. Process demands are requirements with
regard to stakeholder involvement and their level of influence in the way issues,
problems, and potential solutions are framed and resolved in the backcasting study.
Knowledge demands can be set to distinguish between the scientific and contextual
knowledge strived for and how these are valued. Stakeholder knowledge and
interdisciplinary knowledge in general does not meet regular disciplinary academic
standards, but is crucial for the process. Most demands need to be specified in
the beginning of a backcasting study. This can be done by the organizers, but
it may also be the outcome of early stakeholder involvement. It is also possible
that demands are partly set by the organizers and are partly based on stakeholder
discussions.
In addition, various goals can be distinguished in backcasting studies, which
can refer to process-related variables, to content-related variables, or to a range of
other variables like knowledge or methodology development. In general, multiple
goals are set in participatory backcasting, though they are not necessarily all equally
important. Possible goals for backcasting studies include:
• Generation of normative options for the future and analyzing these on their
environmental improvement, opportunities, and other consequences
• Putting attractive future visions or normative scenarios on the agenda of relevant
societal and political arenas
• A follow-up agenda containing activities for different groups of stakeholders
contributing to bringing about the desirable future
• Stakeholder awareness and learning with respect to the options, the conse-
quences, and the opinions of other stakeholders
42 Backcasting and Scenarios for Sustainable Technology Development 757
Backcasting was introduced in the Netherlands in the early 1990s at the government
funded sustainable technology development (STD) program as an approach for
long-term thinking on sustainable technology development (Vergragt and Jansen
1993; Weaver et al. 2000). The STD program ran from early 1993 until 2002.
Taking the factor 20 as a challenge for technology development and applying an
interactive and stakeholder-oriented backcasting approach, major societal needs
like nutrition, water, mobility, and housing were explored, searching for future
sustainable alternatives for fulfilling these societal needs. This was done by
developing future visions using the expertise of stakeholders from government,
companies, research organizations, and public interest groups, which was followed
by further elaboration and assessment of technological options with the potential to
meet the factor 20 challenge (Weaver et al. 2000). A major rationale was to turn
visions into actions by the stakeholders involved after a backcasting study had been
completed.
Examples of factor 20 backcasting studies at the STD program are shown in
Table 42.1 (Jansen 2003; Weaver et al. 2000). They include topics like fuel cells
for boats, urban underground freight transport, novel protein foods as vegetarian
meat substitutes, sustainable multiple land use in which function integration and
reduction of the environmental burden in rural areas were combined, sustainable
urban renewal in the city of Rotterdam, biomass-based (C1) chemistry, and sustain-
able municipal water systems. The STD program has been considered successful
in identifying alternative solutions with the potential for achieving a considerable
environmental reduction factor and developing follow-up agendas and strategic
research programs, though the program did not succeed in establishing significant
follow-up in all backcasting studies.
One of the more successful topics was meat alternatives and novel protein foods
(NPFs), which emerged early during the STD program as a sustainable alternative
for meat consumption and production. A backcasting study was initiated to elaborate
this option, which was cofinanced by major Dutch food companies, and ran from
1993 till 1996. Results and stakeholder dynamics of the NPF backcasting study are
dealt with and subsequently structured by the steps of the backcasting framework
presented in Sect. 2.
758 J. Quist
What were major issues and developments in the meat consumption and production
system in the Netherlands in the early 1990s? At that time, meat production and
consumption was increasingly considered a major sustainability problem in the
Netherlands. The country had (and still has) a large intensive livestock breeding
sector, which has huge environmental effects due to emissions especially from
manure, the inefficient conversion of vegetable protein to meat protein, a huge use
of energy, and large land use for growing fodder crops abroad. Effects of livestock
breeding include contributions to acidification, climate change, eco-toxicity, and
nutrification or eutrophication of soils and surface waters, while growing fodder
crops also prohibits using land and crops (biomass) for other applications such as
biofuels or supplying raw materials to the chemical industry. In addition, intensive
livestock breeding was raising serious animal welfare issues and vegetarianism was
gradually increasing, though still limited.
Nevertheless, livestock breeding and meat processing was (and still is) an
important economic sector in the Netherlands. Meat is an important source of
proteins in people’s diet and fulfills a range of non-nutritional requirements among
consumers, such as taste, habit, custom, and status; these are strongly entrenched
42 Backcasting and Scenarios for Sustainable Technology Development 759
in the national culture and not easily changed. Stakeholders in the meat business
have defended their interests by forming powerful alliances that had a strong
influence on government policies and research agendas. In the Netherlands, all
this had made the environmental problems associated with meat production and
consumption extremely complex and persistent. Nevertheless, during the 1990s,
some policies were initiated to mitigate the environmental burden of livestock
production, targeting cattle farmers, for instance, by limiting and regulating when
and how manure could be put on agricultural land.
Meat alternatives were not at all on the food innovation and research agenda in
the Netherlands in the early 1990s, partly due to the large influence of both vested
meat-related interests and incumbent players. Attempts to put soy-based texturized
vegetable protein (TVP) foods on the market by a major Dutch food multinational
in the late 1960s had failed (Aiking et al. 2006: 8, 29; Quist 2007), which had
negatively influenced the interest in this topic in the Dutch food industry. However,
in the early 1990s, several SMEs were producing meat alternatives, as a small
niche market was gradually growing, which was served with foods based on TVP
and single cell protein (SCP) in addition to soy-based tofu. A major breakthrough
was the launch of quorn, a meat alternative based on proteins from a mold.
The range of available meat alternatives was gradually increasing and vegetarian
foods had become available in supermarkets. To a certain extent, this development
was driven by growing animal welfare concerns and livestock epidemics, rather
than by environmental concerns. For instance, environmentalists advocated to eat
organic meat or sometimes (considerably) less meat, rather than encouraging the
consumption of meat alternatives.
Against this background, the idea initiated at the STD program was called meat-
like products, which was inspired by the possibility of meat-in-vitro from tissue
breeding (Quist 2007). The essence of this idea was that if new meat alternatives
could be developed with a low environmental burden but with similar characteristics
and performance as high-quality meat products, consumers would be willing to buy
and consume these foods instead of meat at a substantial level. This would result
in considerable environmental improvement. As fierce resistance from the Dutch
livestock and meat sector was expected, only a small group of carefully selected
stakeholders from business and research was initially consulted by the chair of the
STD program and a senior staff member of the Netherlands Council for Agricultural
Research (NCAR).
Stakeholder consultation led to further development of the idea and early
stakeholder support. As a next step, a feasibility study was commissioned to a
consulting firm. The consultants proposed the term novel protein foods (NPFs)
and studied the technological, cultural, environmental, and consumer-related aspects
through desk research and expert interviews. Twenty potential NPF categories were
identified, each consisting of a combination of a protein source from nonanimal
origin and the technologies that were needed to extract the proteins and to
process them into protein foods. The protein sources ranged from existing single
cell proteins (SCP) and texturized vegetable proteins (TVP) to proteins from
molds, algae, tissue breeding, and de novo protein synthesis in the laboratory.
760 J. Quist
Nearly all categories showed huge potential for environmental improvement, though
they varied substantially in terms of technological maturity, as well as in terms of
estimated development time and costs.
After the feasibility study, a larger backcasting project was initiated for further
development and assessment of the vision. It included further research into techno-
logical and non-technological aspects. The follow-up study was multidisciplinary
and included research into consumer-related and social aspects, food technology
research, environmental life-cycle analysis, economic input–output analysis, and
production costs calculations. A major issue was how to relate and integrate the
results from different disciplines, for which knowledge demands and a research
design were defined.
Normative demands were defined as terms of reference and included (1) develop-
ing alternative protein foods with a factor 20 environmental improvement compared
to the environmental impact of pork meat at that time, (2) developing alternative
protein foods that are attractive to both consumers and producers.
Different ways of stakeholder participation were part of the study, which relates
to process demands though these were not always articulated and sometimes
implicit. First of all, the multidisciplinary research was conducted by seven re-
search groups from different universities and research institutes in the Netherlands.
Involving these research groups was not only done, because of their expertise, but
also because these research groups and their research organizations were major
players in the food innovation system. It was expected that their involvement would
result in support for the outcomes and could also facilitate follow-up research.
A different type of involvement was achieved through funding by several companies
and ministries. The funding organizations were also represented in the advisory
board of the project, which was extended with key persons from research and
public interest groups. Furthermore, a societal panel was established by applying
a dialogue method from the field of constructive technology assessment entitled
“Future Visions for Consumers”; a broad group of stakeholders from business,
research, government, and public interest groups gathered in three meetings of 1 day
and a half for discussing intermediate results, social aspects, opportunities, and
dilemmas. Finally, the project was led by a retired research director from a major
food multinational. He was supported by a project team at the STD program office
and was also responsible for involvement of stakeholders.
During the backcasting project, a more detailed future vision was developed.
The early vision comprised the idea of protein foods from nonanimal sources
having a 20 times lower environmental burden than (pork) meat. The key of the
more elaborated future vision was that novel protein foods – meeting the factor 20
requirement – could replace 40% of Dutch meat consumption in 2035, while 5%
substitution would be obtained in 2005. The market share of 40% was based on
the expectations that the market share of processed meat products would increase
42 Backcasting and Scenarios for Sustainable Technology Development 761
to 75% and that consumers would perceive NPFs as of similar quality as regular
meat. Then NPF products would be capable of conquering half of the processed
meat market. It was also expected that protein food consumption would stabilize
at 117 gram per person per day, similar to the amount of consumed meat in 1995.
An important change in the vision was the focus is on NPFs as a separate food
category. Another change was the shift from meat alternatives toward NPFs as
food ingredients; it was assumed that NPFs would be particularly attractive when
applied as an ingredient in assembled and processed foods. Processed foods are, for
instance, burgers, sausages, and minced meat. Assembled dishes and foods include
pizzas, ready-made meals, soup, etc.
The backcasting analysis, in which is looked backward from the desired future
situation, evolves around the questions “WHAT changes are needed to bring about
the vision?,” “HOW can the changes be brought about?,” and “WHO could or should
contribute to realizing the vision and what activities should they do?” The WHO
question can be extended by asking “who would oppose the required changes and
how can this opposition be dealt with?” It is also possible to add a question on
drivers and barriers for the proposed changes.
Looking from a backcasting perspective, WHAT are the needed changes? At
the STD program a distinction was made between (1) technological changes, (2)
cultural and behavioral changes, and (3) structural changes, which included changes
in institutions, rules, and the organization of the socio-technical system under study.
With regard to technological changes, the future vision implied that food
technology had to be improved considerably enabling to produce vegetarian protein
foods similar or superior in taste and structure to meat, while also having a similar
nutritional value as meat. The vision also implied cultural changes, not only related
to the role and status of meat and meat consumption, but also related to the role and
status of protein foods from other sources than animals. Obviously, a major cultural
and behavioral shift would also be that consumers would (on average) purchase
and consume significant volumes of vegetarian protein foods as part of their diet.
Backcasting analysis also shed light on structural changes, as the meat sector would
considerably decrease, and new protein food chains and a significant vegetarian food
industry would emerge.
The HOW question refers to the overall strategy or mechanism, which could drive
innovation leading to the envisaged 40% meat substitution by 2035. The strategy
developed in the backcasting assumed that producers would take the lead and would
serve a growing market demand. Producers were expected to develop new, more
attractive products and to introduce them into the market in a way that they would
seduce consumers to purchase and consume higher volumes of these vegetarian
protein foods. This would be supported by more fundamental academic knowledge
development and research, as well as by increasing awareness by consumers.
These developments would also be supported by government policies mitigating
762 J. Quist
the socioeconomic effects of the decreasing livestock breeding and meat industry as
well as by policies facilitating the rise of vegetarian foods. Though other strategies
are possible too, such as levying meat, but these were not considered in the
backcasting study.
The answer to the WHO question provided a range of stakeholders needed for
the envisaged system innovation, which were already involved as stakeholders in the
backcasting study. This list included food regulators, supermarkets and other retail-
ers, institutional food catering companies, and public interest organizations. The lat-
ter includes consumer organizations, the environmental movement, and vegetarian
and animal welfare groups. The activities that should be conducted by the different
kinds of stakeholders are included in the follow-up agenda described in step 4.
The production of NPF ingredients begins with crop growing. Following harvesting,
crops are processed. The vegetable-based NPF options are produced using extrac-
tion, mixing, stirring, and texturing techniques. Vegetable-based material can also be
used as the basis for a fermented product or for the cultivation of microbial biomass
to arrive at the microbial NPF options. In principle, hundreds of potential NPFs are
possible, which were clustered in around 20 clusters of a protein source and the
technologies needed to turn them into a protein food ingredient.
Through a step-by-step selection process, a set of seven high-potential NPF
options was generated, using criteria like technological feasibility, environmental
reduction potential, attractiveness to consumers and firms, and structural economic
effects. The seven NPF options are shown in Table 42.2 and are based on different
vegetable and microbial sources like peas, lucerne, lupine, the fungus Fusarium,
and the cyanobacterium Spirulina in combination with different technologies like
fermentation, extraction, extrusion, and others. The seven NPF options were clus-
tered in three types of ingredients. The first one resembled minced meat in structure
and was called Protex. The second type was fibrous and was called Fibrex. The third
one was a fermented ingredient, resembling tempeh and was called Fungopy.
42 Backcasting and Scenarios for Sustainable Technology Development 763
While most of the technologies needed for producing NPF options were already
incorporated in regular production techniques, technological research showed that
it was not yet possible to provide the consumer with products that are sufficiently
attractive to ensure a significant reduction in meat consumption. By translating
consumer demands into product quality standards, a view could be derived of
the areas in which fundamental knowledge was still lacking, namely, sensory and
molecular sciences, nutritional value, scaling-up of production processes of NPFs,
and also further improvement of the environmental impact of NPFs.
Consumer research emphasized that especially taste and convenience will de-
termine whether consumers will be buying and consuming NPFs in 2035. Due
to growing wealth and ongoing individualization, convenience will become more
important and lead to a considerable growth of processed meat products, and
assembled foods and meals. Health, global equity, and environmental concerns will
become more important to consumers. The combination of growing health concerns,
also driven by aging of the population, and convenience thus points in particular to
processed products and assembled meals; some examples are given in Table 42.3.
Environmental research used LCA (life-cycle analysis) to compare the envi-
ronmental impact of the selected NPF options with pork. It showed that the
environmental impact of the options was 5–30 times lower than the environmental
impact of meat (as shown in Table 42.4), when produced in 1995 using regular ways
of crop growing. Nutrification, eco-toxicity, acidification, and global warming made
up the main environmental impacts. In addition, it was found that the environmental
impact of the seven NPF options could be considerably improved, when pesticides,
manure, and transportation would be significantly reduced (see Fig. 42.3).
After the analysis, a pathway was elaborated that described a possible trajectory
in which the future vision would be realized. It is summarized in Table 42.5 and
shows the projected shares of meat and NPF foods in the Netherlands. It also shows
the area of land needed to grow the NPF crops and how the environmental burden
of total protein food consumption including the consumption of meat may evolve.
It makes also clear that environmental efficiency improvements of meat may also
make a significant contribution.
Also, seven clusters of follow-up activities were identified (see Table 42.6). The
listed clusters of activities can be seen as a policy and action agenda for sustainable
technological development around the option of novel protein foods.
764 J. Quist
Table 42.4 Environmental impact of pork meat and the NPF options in 1995
Aquatic Other
eco-toxicity Nutrification Acidification themes Total
Pork meat 67.1 11.1 10.3 11.5 100
(1) Protex from 0.7 0.3 0.4 1.7 3.1
Spirulina
(2/3) Protex from 10.6 2.9 0.5 1.4 15.4
peas
(4) Protex from 9.0 1.8 0.5 1.1 12.4
lucerne
(5) Fibrex from 3.2 0.9 0.6 2.0 6.7
Fusarium
(6) Fungopie from 10.4 2.9 0.4 1.9 15.6
pea
(7) Fungopie from 12.9 6.1 0.5 1.9 21.4
modified lupine
35
Index relative to pork 1995 (%)
0
Pork 1 2/3 4 5 6 7 Pork 1 2/3 4 5 6 7 Pork 1 2/3 4 5 6 7 Pork 1 2/3 4 5 6 7 Pork 1 2/3 4 5 6 7
Fig. 42.3 The environmental impact of NPF options and pork meat expressed as an environmental
index relative to pork meat. Results for several improvement options are also shown
Table 42.6 Action agenda for Novel Protein Foods (Quist 2007: 97)
1. Communication with the general public and supply of adequate information
2. Professional education and transfer of generated knowledge
3. Consumer research and development of marketing instruments
4. Fundamental research and chain organization
5. Novel protein foods product development (both as foods and as ingredients)
6. Improvement of environmental impact of crop growing and LCA instruments for foods
7. Supporting regulation and social measures (facilitating the growth of a novel protein food sector
and the reduction of the meat sector).
Ten years after the completion of the NPF backcasting study in 1996, its follow-
up and spin-off was investigated (Quist 2007; Quist et al. 2011). Briefly, in terms
of impact and spin-off, the backcasting study had been quite successful and various
clusters of follow-up and spin-off activities and related networks of actors could be
identified.
To start with, a large multidisciplinary research program entitled Profetas was
initiated; involving research groups from different disciplines as well as several large
food companies (see also Aiking et al. 2006). A second cluster of activities involved
new R&D collaborations on meat alternatives, NPFs, and related supply chain
management between firms and research institutes. It included the introduction
of a new meat alternative made from dairy proteins by a major dairy firm in the
Netherlands. A third cluster consisted of new activities by SMEs operating in the
area of vegetarian protein foods and meat alternatives. These firms not only extended
their regular activities and market share. They also started new activities, which were
significantly stimulated by the NPF backcasting experiment and its spin-off.
A fourth cluster of activities was found in the government domain, where, as
a spin-off of the NPF backcasting experiment, meat alternatives and vegetarian
protein foods became a topic of policy making on sustainable consumption at the
Ministry of the Environment and on sustainable supply chains at the Ministry of
Agriculture.
766 J. Quist
A fifth cluster was identified in the public domain. Encouraged by the Ministry
of the Environment, environmental organizations became more positive about meat
alternatives and extended their activities on this topic. Vegetarian organizations used
the NPF activities as a bandwagon for pursuing their own agenda and activities.
This step includes setting normative assumptions and targets, which can also be
done through stakeholder participation. This step aims at exploring the problem
from a systemic viewpoint, possible problem definitions, main unsustainabilities,
opportunities, and possible solutions, identifying and involving relevant stakehold-
ers. In addition, it should be analyzed how the problem is perceived by different
stakeholders, how it relates to need and function fulfillment on an appropriate level
– which is often a societal level or the level of socio-technical systems, how other
stakeholders evaluate and judge the different problem formulations according to
their own mind set, values, and interests, and how supply chain and demand side
are interdependent and influence each other. It is important to take an integral
viewpoint, while taking into account related consumption and production systems
and present trends and developments for the whole system. Involving stakeholders
is also important because they are experts in the field or system under study.
The results of the strategic problem orientation step are the starting point for
construction of sustainable future visions in which the identified unsustainabilities
and problems have been solved. Stakeholder participation is important here, so
workshops are an important tool in this step, though other participatory methods
are also possible. The relevant question is how this societal need or function can be
fulfilled in a sustainable way in the far future, assuming that it is always possible to
define a societal need or function in a particular backcasting study.
Furthermore, different types of future visions are possible. For instance, within
the STD program, a generic sustainable future vision was generated that contained
several solutions for different major unsustainabilities, while in the university-based
Sustainable Household (SusHouse) project, several more detailed scenarios were
generated that depicted different sustainable lifestyles that could be seen as each
other’s substitutes. In addition, SusHouse scenarios did not only contain a vision
and a description of main characteristics, but were elaborated with storyboards
42 Backcasting and Scenarios for Sustainable Technology Development 767
depicting daily life stories within a specific scenario, proposals for product-service
systems supporting the sustainable scenario, and sometimes with images. It seems
that generating single visions or several scenarios have each specific advantages and
drawbacks, but a systematic evaluation of this has not been done yet. Furthermore,
quite a number of specific methods are available for constructing future visions
and normative scenarios. Scenarios or future visions can either stress the vision
part, the feasibility, or the creative part. It is also possible to add first estimates
or preliminary assessments for particular aspects like environmental improvement
potential, consumer acceptance, socioeconomic aspects, etc.
Though the overall approach is named after this step, it is actually the step that is
least elaborated and described in the backcasting literature. Methods like elaboration
of future visions, writing essays, explorative research, expert workshops, and
stakeholder workshops have been suggested. Others have proposed to guide the
backcasting step with specific guiding questions like “What are the necessary
changes to make this future vision or scenario become true?” Several varieties can
be distinguished in this step:
• A quick one just meant for identifying attractive solutions or clusters that would
enable radically increased eco-efficiency. This was, for instance, done at the STD
program (Weaver et al. 2000).
• A more elaborated variety, asking for the changes necessary for achieving a
specific future vision or sustainable normative scenario, which was applied in
the SusHouse project (Quist et al. 2001). This meta-question can be split into
specific questions:
• Which technological changes are necessary?
• Which cultural and behavioral changes are necessary?
• Which structural-institutional changes are necessary?
• Which organizational changes are necessary for realizing the desirable sus-
tainable future state?
• A very detailed one defining and describing also in-between states. For instance,
if the final state is set in 2040, reasoning back from 2040 the state of 2030
can be described, before describing the state of 2020 and 2010. Though this
variety is commonly used for explaining backcasting, it has hardly been applied
in professional practice.
Elaboration can take many forms and depends strongly on capacity, budget, and
time available. Assessments, analyses, and feasibility studies are important in the
first part of this step, while defining follow-up activities and agendas that enable
implementation and realization on the longer term are important in the second
768 J. Quist
part of this step. Differences can be noticed too. For instance, in the SusHouse
project, several normative scenarios were elaborated and assessed by small research
teams and the results were fed into another stakeholder workshop. At the STD
program, backcasting was used to identify promising clusters and directions within
a single future vision, and those clusters were subjected to feasibility study and
further elaboration in particular projects. This enabled to involve more specialized
researchers, while stakeholder involvement became more focused too.
5 Conclusions
In this chapter, it has been argued that backcasting is a useful tool for engineers to
develop pathways leading to system innovations and transitions for sustainability.
It has provided an overview of the current variety in backcasting and has presented
a methodological framework that covers most of this variety, which was illustrated
using a backcasting study on novel protein foods and meat alternatives that was
conducted at the STD program in the Netherlands. This chapter has also elaborated
the backcasting framework into a methodology that can be applied to define strategy
processes in engineering design.
It has been argued that backcasting is in particular useful in case of complex
societal problems, when there is a need for major change, when dominant trends
are part of the problem, when there are side effects or externalities that cannot
be satisfactorily solved in markets, and when long time horizons allow for future
alternatives that need several decades to develop. Backcasting is very well equipped
to deal with sustainability, as sustainability is a normative concept and backcasting
is a normative approach to foresight leading to normative scenarios and dealing with
the question what is the future we would like to have. Though very often a problem-
oriented perspective is taken, it is also possible to start a backcasting project with a
socio-technical option.
Backcasting is less well equipped to deal with emerging technologies such as
nanotechnology. Those cases are technology driven, and the dominant direction is
to push the technologies based on the expectation that they fulfill a need, whereas in
backcasting, needs and the articulation of alternative solutions to fulfill those needs
have most added values. In case of emerging technologies like nanotechnology,
GMO’s, and ICT, there are strong normative aspects at play and a constructive
technology assessment approach (see also Chapter 35) is more appropriate in these
cases.
References
H. Aiking, J. de Boer, J. Vereijken, Sustainable Protein Production and Consumption: Pigs or
Peas? (Springer, Dordrecht, 2006)
K.L. Anderson, S.L. Mander, A. Bows, S. Shackley, P. Agnolucci, P. Ekins, The Tyndall
decarbonisation scenarios – Part II: scenarios for a 60% CO2 reduction in the UK. Energy
Policy 36, 3764–3773 (2008)
D. Banister, D. Stead, P. Steen, K.H. Dreborg, J. Åkerman, P. Nijkamp, R. Schleicher-Tappeser,
European Transport Policy and Sustainable Mobility (Spon Press, London, 2000)
A. Carlsson-Kanyama, K.H. Dreborg, H.C. Moll, D. Padovan, Participative backcasting: a tool for
involving stakeholders in local sustainability planning. Futures 40, 34–46 (2008)
770 J. Quist
H.J. De Graaf, M.A.W. Noordervliet, C.J.M. Musters, G.R. de Snoo, Roadmap for interactive
exploration of sustainable development opportunities: the use of simple instruments in the
complex setting of bottom-up processes in rural areas. Land Use Policy 26, 295–307 (2009)
K.H. Dreborg, Essence of backcasting. Futures 28, 813–828 (1996)
P.R. Ehrlich, J.P. Holdren, Impact of population growth. Science 171, 1212–1217 (1971)
B. Elzen, F.W. Geels, K. Green, System Innovation and the Transition to Sustainability (Edward
Elgar, Cheltenham/Northampton, 2004)
F. Geels, Technological Transitions and System Innovations: A Co-evolutionary and Socio-
technical Analysis (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham/Northampton, 2005a)
F. Geels, Co-evolution of technology and society: the transition in water supply and personal
hygiene in the Netherlands (1850–1930) – A case study in multi-level perspective. Technol.
Soc. 27, 363–397 (2005b)
K. Geurs, B. van Wee, Backcasting as a tool to develop a sustainable transport scenario assuming
emission reduction of 80–90%. Innovation 13, 47–62 (2000)
D. Giurco, B. Cohen, E. Langham, M. Warnken, Backcasting energy futures using industrial
ecology. Technol. Forecast. Soc. Change, 7097–818 (2011)
K. Gomi, Y. Ochi, Y. Matsuoka, A systematic quantitative backcasting on low-carbon policy in
case of Kyoto city. Technol. Forecast. Soc. Change, 852–871 (2011)
K. Green, P. Vergragt, Towards sustainable households: a methodology for developing sustainable
technological and social innovations. Futures 34, 381–400 (2002)
J. Grin, J. Rotmans, J. Schot, Transitions to Sustainable Development: New Directions in the Study
of Long Term Transformative Change (Routledge, New York/Oxon, 2010)
H. Herring, R. Roy, Technological innovation, energy efficient design and the rebound effect,
Technovation 27, 194–203 (2007)
M. Höjer, L.-G. Mattsson, Determinism and backcasting in future studies. Futures 32, 613–634
(2000)
M. Höjer, A. Gullberg, R. Pettersson (eds.), Images of the Future City – Time and Space for
Sustainable Development (Springer, Dordrecht, 2011)
J. Holmberg, Backcasting: a natural step in operationalising sustainable development. Greener
Manage. Int. 23, 30–51 (1998)
J. Holmberg, K.H. Robèrt, Backcasting: a framework for strategic planning. J. Sustain. Dev. World
Ecol. 7, 291–308 (2000)
T. Jackson, Prosperity without Growth: Economics for a Finite Planet (Earthscan, London, 2009)
L. Jansen, The challenge of sustainable development. J. Clean. Prod. 11, 231–245 (2003)
T.B. Johansson, P. Steen, Solar Versus Nuclear: Choosing Energy Futures (Pergamon Press,
Oxford, 1980)
K. Kok, D.S. Rothman, M. Patel, Multi-scale narratives from an IA perspective: part I. European
and Mediterranean scenario development. Futures 38, 261–284 (2006)
D. Loorbach Transition Management: A New Mode of Governance for Sustainable Development
(International Books, Utrecht, 2007)
H.A. Linstone, Decision Making of Technology Executives: Using Multiple Perspectives to Improve
Performance (Artech House, Boston/London, 1999)
A.B. Lovins, Soft Energy Paths: Toward a Durable Peace (Friends of the Earth Interna-
tional/Ballinger Publishing Company, Cambridge MA 1977)
J. Quist, Backcasting for a Sustainable Future: The Impact After Ten Years (Eburon Publishers,
Delft, 2007). ISBN 978–90–5972–175–3
J. Quist, P. Vergragt, Past and future of backcasting: the shift to stakeholder participation and a
proposal for a methodological framework. Futures 38(9), 1027–1045 (2006)
J. Quist, M. Knot, W. Young, K. Green, P. Vergragt, Strategies towards sustainable households
using stakeholder workshops and scenarios. Int. J. Sustain. Dev. 4, 75–89 (2001)
J. Quist, C. Rammelt, M. Overschie, G. de Werk, Backcasting for sustainability in engineering
education: the case of Delft University of Technology. J. Clean. Prod. 14, 868–876 (2006)
J. Quist, P. Vergragt, W. Thissen, The impact and spin-off of participatory backcasting: from vision
to Niche. Technol. Forecast. Soc. Change, 883–897 (2011)
42 Backcasting and Scenarios for Sustainable Technology Development 771
J. Robinson, Energy backcasting: a proposed method of policy analysis. Energy Policy 10,
337–344 (1982)
J. Robinson, Futures under glass: a recipe for people who hate to predict. Futures 22, 820–843
(1990)
J. Robinson, Future subjunctive: backcasting as social learning. Futures 35, 839–856 (2003)
J. Rotmans, R. Kemp, M. van Asselt, More evolution than revolution: transition management in
public policy. Foresight 3(1), 15–31 (2001)
F. Schmidt-Bleek, Factor 10: the future of stuff. Sustainability 4, 1–4 (2008)
M. Van de Kerkhof, M. Hisschemoller, M. Spanjersberg, Shaping diversity in participatory
foresight studies: experiences with interactive backcasting on long-term climate policy in the
Netherlands. Greener Manage. Int. 37, 85–99 (2002)
P.J. Vergragt, Back-casting for environmental sustainability: from STD and SusHouse towards
implementation, in Towards Environmental Innovation Systems, ed. by M. Weber, J. Hemmel-
skamp (Springer, Heidelberg, 2005), pp. 301–318
P.J. Vergragt, L. Jansen, Sustainable technological development: the making of a long-term
oriented technology programme. Proj. Apprais. 8, 134–140 (1993)
P.J. Vergragt, J. Quist, Backcasting for sustainabitlity. Technol. Forecast. Soc. Change, 747–755
(2011)
P. Weaver, L. Jansen, G. Van Grootveld, E. van Spiegel, P. Vergragt, Sustainable Technology
Development (Greenleaf Publishers, Sheffield, 2000)
Changing Energy Demand Behavior:
Potential of Demand-Side Management 43
Sylvia Breukers, Ruth Mourik, and Eva Heiskanen
Abstract
There is a great theoretical potential to save resources by managing our demand
for energy. However, demand-side management (DSM) programs targeting
behavioral patterns of energy consumption face several challenges. One of the
most important ones is the challenge of sustaining the changed behavior. People
may respond to intensive incentives and encouragement in the short term, but
if their social and physical context does not change, they will easily revert to
their old behaviors once the interventions end. It is also important to realize that
different types of behaviors depend on different mechanisms: one-shot behaviors
like the purchasing of an energy-efficient appliance are different from routine
behaviors like turning off lights. It is in the latter that achieving lasting change
presents an enormous challenge.
This chapter introduces a socio-technical approach to energy DSM. Rather
than focusing merely on individuals and their motivation to change, a socio-
technical approach acknowledges that individual behaviors are nested within
broader societal change processes. People learn much of their behavior from
other people and from their immediate physical environment. Change interven-
tions need to be accompanied by changes in culturally shared norms and values
S. Breukers
Policy Studies Department, Energy Research Centre of the Netherlands (ECN), Amsterdam,
The Netherlands
e-mail: sylvia.breukers@duneworks.nl
R. Mourik
DuneWorks, Eindhoven, The Netherlands
e-mail: info@duneworks.nl
E. Heiskanen
National Consumer Research Centre (NCRC) Konsumentforskningscentralen, Helsinki,
Helsingfors, Finland
e-mail: Eva.heiskanen@ncrc.fi
1 Introduction
example, rooftop reservoirs to catch rain water – but also changes in daily practices
and behaviors. For instance, using the same water several times: the water flow first
serves drinking purposes, then the water is used for showering; this water is then
used for washing and cleaning, and finally to flush the toilet (mixed with rain water)
(Roestenburg 2008). In recent years, energy efficiency and energy conservation have
gained renewed interest as the cheapest and most feasible ways to meet climate
change mitigation targets (and other environmental objectives). Concerns about se-
curity of supply, “peak oil,” and other resource shortages have added to the urgency
of energy conservation (Geller and Attali 2005). The European Commission’s 2011
Energy Efficiency Plan, which requires all member states to impose some kind of
energy-saving obligations on their energy suppliers (European commission 2011),
has strengthened the implementation of DSM programs focusing on the energy
consumption behaviors and behavioral patterns of households and other small-scale
energy users that hold great potential for energy efficiency. (For more information
about percentages and ranges per target group, see Breukers et al. 2009:26–43.)
One way to achieving energy conservation is through changing the patterns of
energy consumption on the side of the (individual) end users by means of Demand
Side Management (DSM) programs. Breukers et al. (2009) define energy demand-
side management programs as “an organised set of programs and initiatives that
primarily aim to change the quantity and patterns of energy consumption on end-
user level. The programs and initiatives do so by initiating interaction schemes
between end-users and program initiators to motivate and facilitate end-user energy
demand reduction.” Examples of DSM programs range from energy audits being
provided to households, to regional or even national campaigns focusing on the
reduction of energy consumption, to metering and tailored feedback displayed on
smart phones or an in-home display.
DSM programs targeting behavioral patterns of energy consumption face several
challenges. An important challenge is that many interventions to change the
behavior of an individual may be fairly successful as long as they last, but the
individual tends to revert to her/his original behavior once the program has ended
(e.g., Abrahamse et al. 2007; Kurz 2002; Wilhite et al. 2000). In those cases, the
DSM project might have been successful for its duration but it has not contributed
to durable efficiency improvements in energy behaviors and as such might even
be considered a failure. So far, the dominant approach toward energy DSM has
been based on a belief in the unproblematic transfer of expert knowledge on energy
efficiency solutions into end user practices. In contrast, this chapter (based on
extensive research and practical work) argues for a more interactive, user-oriented,
and context-sensitive approach to demand-side management. Here, context refers
to the physical, social, cultural, economic, institutional, and political environment
(including various actors) in which the individual operates. It spans from the
immediate context of the family, household, workplace, and everyday surroundings
to national media and policies and to the global economy. Learning about and
with end users and about the particular context in which a project is implemented
is crucial and for that reason, interactions are needed between experts, designers,
policy makers, and end users.
776 S. Breukers et al.
Next to the end users (consumers targeted in energy DSM projects), a host of
other relevant stakeholders influence the successfulness of DSM projects: from
national and local authorities, utilities and retailers, energy auditing specialists,
manufacturers of energy-efficient products, financial specialists, and the program
designers or intermediaries. In the past, national governments and utilities were
the ones promoting energy efficiency and implementing DSM programs. The
liberalization and privatization of the energy sector in the 1990s has changed this.
Intermediary organizations have emerged that address the demand side of energy
efficiency. Energy intermediaries seek to intervene on either a project basis or
more broadly in energy systems. They do this by, for instance, raising public
awareness, helping the visibility of alternative ways of producing and consuming
energy through pilot projects. Or they promote low energy buildings, via replace-
ment product programs (e.g., energy efficient appliances). Energy intermediaries
encompass a wide variety of organizations, including private, public, and semipublic
organizations that work at different levels (e.g., local pilot project to national
awareness campaigns) and across different time scales (e.g., a short-term 6-month
project to 10 years programs). A wide range of intermediaries can be identified:
specialized energy service companies (ESCOs), government-funded energy agen-
cies, nongovernmental organizations (NGOs), consultancies or organizations that
gain their funding from public benefit charges. They can perform functions like the
provision of energy advice; consultancy activities; energy audits; project prepara-
tion, implementation and management; demonstrations; technology procurement;
installation; promotion; advocacy; lobbying, dissemination and awareness raising;
organizing campaigns; education; training and courses; and network building.
This chapter addresses the question of how DSM programs can achieve lasting
behavioral changes. It focuses on DSM programs targeting behavioral change of
energy end users at small-scale levels. These include households, schools, the
building sector, municipalities, and small- and medium-sized enterprises. When
formulating an answer to this challenge of creating lasting energy consumption
patterns, a first step is to acknowledge that two types of behaviors exist and that
different mechanisms underlie these different behaviors.
– Efficiency behavior: one-shot behavior, for instance, the purchase of energy-
efficient equipment or appliances
– Curtailment behavior: repetitive efforts to change routines and habits to reduce
energy use, for instance, showering less often or long, turning of lights, lowering
the thermostat
Since different mechanisms underlie efficiency and curtailment behavior, dif-
ferent DSM interventions are necessary to effectively change these two types
of behaviors. Purchasing an energy-efficient appliance is a rather discrete event,
usually preceded by significant processing of information and the use of specific
decision rules. DSM interventions that intend to change this behavior therefore need
to target the decision-making process and the rules applied in it. Achieving lasting
change is successful as soon as the investment has been effectuated. Curtailment
behavior, in contrast, refers to habitual and routine behaviors which are less
43 Changing Energy Demand Behavior 777
users “mixed messages” (e.g., Biggart and Lutzenhiser 2007). Thus, individual
end users – even if they are aware of the problems and potential solutions –
may feel unable to individually make a difference and thus can feel helpless,
disempowered, or not responsible for the collective problem.
Thus, while economics and psychology traditions focus on the individual level –
not paying a lot of attention to the context in which behavior is situated –
sociological research stresses the importance of acknowledging the social level in
order to understand individual behavior and opportunities for behavioral change.
Sociological research thus acknowledges that individual change processes are
nested within – and interacting with – broader societal change processes. Build-
ing on these different disciplines, a socio-technical approach acknowledges that
individual behavior interacts with and is shaped by its context. This interaction
between the individual and his or her context defines to great extent a person’s
motivations to save energy, his/her attitude toward energy efficiency and saving, and
his/her capacity for action. As such this interaction coshapes his or her consumption
practice and the possibilities to change the behavior in such a way that the change
lasts (see Breukers et al. 2009). In other words, the potential to change a behavioral
pattern not only lies with individuals. If others do not learn to change too, and
if the change is not accompanied by changes in culturally shared norms and
values, or supported by adequate technologies, policies, regulations, and perhaps
even infrastructures, then the individual will soon revert to his/her “old” behavior
because the context is not supportive of or may even impede the “new” behavior.
Therefore, socio-technical approaches to change address both the individual and
the social levels of change – in order to be able to achieve lasting change. For
example, if someone wants to behave more energy-efficiently but this is regarded
as uninteresting and unimportant by this person’s friends, family, colleagues, and
neighbors, then it is likely to become a lonely battle. If the social norm is to not
worry about a boring issue like energy efficiency, this is not supportive for those
who do worry about energy efficiency. In addition, if there are no technologies or
appliances like for example, more energy-efficient boilers available, or if there are
appliances on the market but no installers that can inform this person properly on
what are the pros and cons of different appliances, then this will discourage the
purchase. Also, if no tailored energy audits can be made, it will be very difficult for
this person to get a clear idea on what else (s)he can do to improve the energy
efficiency of his/her household. Imagine furthermore infrastructural barriers, for
example, that the apartment is heated by block-heating system, which cannot be
controlled at the level of the household, but only at the level of the apartment
block. In this imaginary case, a person who is motivated to change his/her behavior
to become more energy efficient is likely to become disillusioned because of all
the impediments at the social, physical, institutional levels. Only someone who
is extremely motivated has the time and ability to learn and arrange and build
everything him/herself will succeed in actually achieving something. Hence, new
behaviors need to be supported to some extent by existing or newly rising norms,
technologies, policies, and infrastructures to actually enable these behaviors to
become embedded and lasting.
43 Changing Energy Demand Behavior 779
Table 43.1 summarizes the results of the review discussed above, as well as the
practical implications for DSM interventions (Breukers et al. 2009). The table refers
to several DSM instruments that are discussed later on in the text.
Table 43.1 Barriers and possibilities for intervention to improve energy efficiency
1. “Barriers” to Multiple issues:
energy efficiency – Perceptions of risk, of long payback times; limited avail-
ability of capital.
– Market failures: high information costs, externalities (e.g.,
when environmental costs are not reflected in current
prices); transaction costs (e.g., costs of information),
agency issues (e.g., tenants cannot force their landlord to
install energy-efficient applications).
– Psychological issues (lack of feedback or information
processing capacity; lack of social pressure; lack of skills
and opportunities; habits; helplessness).
– Social systems that discourage energy-efficient behavior:
prevailing infrastructures, institutions and networks, “ways
of doing,” norms, culture.
2. How can actors be By addressing issues at different levels.
motivated and – Market failures: providing cheaper information, new insti-
mobilized to save tutions, and incentives.
energy? – Information, feedback and (social or economic) incentives
in suitable formats and combinations.
By aiming a strategy at social interaction and mobilization:
– Collective action.
– Interaction, negotiation, and reorganization of socio-
technical networks (networks around innovations and the
technologies that are part of these innovations).
– Capacity building.
3. What intervention • Measures that transfer risk or that address some of the
instruments are transaction costs and agency problems (e.g., performance
relevant contracting, energy service companies).
• Instruments to correct market failures, e.g., financial in-
struments, information (audits and feedback) and combi-
nations of instruments.
• Instruments that address:
– Pre-disposing factors (motivation, knowledge, norms
and self-efficacy).
– Enabling factors (providing means for change: re-
sources and skills).
– Reinforcing factors (mobilization of resources and
strengthening intentions – feedback).
• Strategies that take account of the broader social system in
which current practices are embedded and that aim at trans-
forming current systems. Focus on interaction between
promoters of solutions, end users and other stakeholders.
• Learning from bottom-up alternatives (e.g., new systems of
co-provision).
• Encouraging processes of learning (group dynamic, user
participation and flexible design).
• Market transformation, transformation of urban
infrastructures.
780 S. Breukers et al.
Below, DSM programs and the considerations that are important from a socio-
technical point of view are first presented. Next, different DSM policy instruments
are addressed in more in depth.
Energy consumption habits are shaped by social and cultural conventions (such
as practices of washing, heating and living, i.e., brushing your teeth twice a day,
cooking around a fixed time). Individuals generally want to behave according to
these culturally shared norms, because the price of not doing might be exclusion, or
at least being labeled “different.” In addition, much of our everyday behaviors and
routines are shaped, guided, and mediated by the collective systems of provision.
Vice versa, our everyday practices sustain or reshape these systems in the long
run (Otnes 1988:131). These systems of provision include collective infrastructures
and institutions providing various types of services and utilities to citizens, such as
our water and sewerage system, the electricity supply system and grid, and waste
management systems (Mont and Power 2010:2240).
Energy DSM programs can be successful if they are based on a proper under-
standing of what conventions shape individual behavior, that is, why people behave
the way they do, of how systems of provision and social norms influence their
behavior. For instance, if intermediaries know that the target group is somewhat
indifferent to energy efficiency issues, but interested in combating health problems
that originate from the unhealthy level of moisture in a house, then a DSM project
can start by informing this household about other ventilation behavior and its
relation to temperature. Through that motivation, a DSM program can continue
discussing energy efficiency and other benefits such as saving money, enhancing
comfort, or saving the environment. In the course of the process, an intermediary
43 Changing Energy Demand Behavior 781
can try to learn more about why people are indifferent and how that might change.
An energy intermediary can attain this improved understanding of the target group
by asking (and inquiring) how the DSM project fits with the existing institutions, the
capacities of the target groups, the existing values and norms (in the local area), and
infrastructures and available technologies. Once it is clear what connections and
lock-ins impede the behavioral change on the individual level, different financial,
informational, and agreement-related instruments can be used to facilitate change
on the individual level.
3.2 Change the Context or Make the Change Fit the Context
Most people do not consciously consume energy and most energy use is invisible
to the users. Rather than being a conscious action, energy use is implicated in all
sorts of activities and practices – and the necessary products and services to enable
these practices. Examples of such practices are cooking, showering, laundering, and
caring for the family and the home (Guy and Shove 2000; Shove 2003). Different
metering and feedback instruments can be used to make energy flows and the impact
of behavioral changes more visible.
Explaining to people the need to use less energy is in itself not sufficient to
get people to change their behavior. It is important to make sure that the target
group sees the benefits of changing their energy consumption. What benefits
are meaningful to the target group differ from individual to individual and can
include economic benefits but also other benefits like home improvement, self-
improvement, green spaces, or national pride. It is therefore key to find out about
problems the target group is facing, and how these might be alleviated through
the reduction or shifting of energy consumption. When assessing these benefits,
attention can be paid to the benefits of new routines and habits, but also to the real
losses people are suffering as a result of their current unsustainable behavior. To be
able to do so a DSM program needs to know its target group. Knowing the target
group helps to define what content to convey and what instruments to use. In a DSM
project in Latvia, the intermediary discovered that peoples’ limited enthusiasm in
investing in energy efficiency strongly related to their lack of trust in the Building
Management Company that was involved as an important stakeholder in the project.
Hence, it was clear that this relationship had to be improved first (Kamenders 2009).
An intermediary can perform a good prior analysis of the (different sets of)
problem(s) that underlie(s) the unsustainable behavior of the target group and what
and who influences this problem. Knowing the target group also entails that the
intermediary learns about their interests, their habits, their social networks, and their
preferred communications channels (Futerra 2005; Mourik et al. 2009). Several
types of interaction schemes can help intermediaries to learn about their target
groups: surveys, interviews, group meetings; user-driven design, familiarity, and
informal interaction with the target group. In addition, a social-learning approach
such as “community-based social marketing” in energy conservation projects,
using peer-to-peer communication, social support, and social pressure, making sure
everyone “does their bit” and participation can be very useful.
There are good times and bad times to start a DSM program. Knowing the
target group also helps to assess when the intervention will be most effective
43 Changing Energy Demand Behavior 783
(timing). A DSM project can take advantage of periods in which the routines are
reevaluated or disrupted, for example, getting married, moving, renovations, new
jobs, and a birth or retiring, and purchasing moments. These “change” moments
provide windows of opportunity because people are more open to reevaluate their
behavioral routines and to consider the uptake of more sustainable equipment. These
change moments can also take place on the social level of change and include, for
example, a neighborhood reconstruction or other regional development initiatives.
Intermediaries can identify suitable change moments with the same techniques
mentioned under the topic “know your target group.” Furthermore it takes time to
achieve lasting behavioral changes. Changing routines does not happen overnight.
The program needs to support the behavioral change at least for several months in a
row, and preferably the monitoring and feedback on the behavioral change needs to
continue after the program officially has ended.
Involve the target group and other key stakeholders from the moment the prepara-
tions of the DSM program start onward to ensure that all the capacities, expectations,
and needs of all relevant stakeholders are taken into account. In addition, par-
ticipation facilitates the empowerment of the target group and the other relevant
stakeholders that influence the target group and helps them to take the change
process into their own hands, to create a sense of ownership (Futerra 2005; Stern
2000). Several DSM projects have trained members of the target group to become
proponents and supporters of the behavioral changes – for instance, a Finnish project
trained volunteers to become energy experts to whom people in the neighborhood
could turn with questions about improving energy efficiency (Anttonen 2009). There
are several participatory methods and tools for user involvement and interactive
learning such as field trials, participatory design, and user participation. Success
of a DSM program also depends on the effective use of already existing (social)
networks. These already established networks can help embed the behavioral change
more quickly and in a durable manner, and in addition these networks are free
multipliers of the change message.
Below, the traditional DSM instruments are presented, and examples are offered
on how these can be used to deal with the issues discussed above. After this, a toolkit
for the design of context-sensitive DSM programs is introduced, which incorporates
both the traditional DSM instruments and additional tools that take into account the
key issues discussed above.
Even though energy efficiency investments are usually profitable to the end user, at
least in the long term, these end users are often impeded by a lack of attention to
information about energy efficiency, expectations for short payback periods, limited
access to capital, and principal-agent problems (for instance, the fact that contractors
do not always act in the principal’s best interests; other agency problems entail that
tenants cannot force their landlord to invest in more energy-efficient appliances).
Different forms of financing energy efficiency investments have therefore gained
increasing attention. One example are specialized energy service companies
(ESCOs) that deliver energy services and/or other energy efficiency improvement
measures in a user’s facility or premises, and takes on all or part of the financial risk
of the investment. Other examples are energy performance contracting, in which an
outside company takes charge of the energy management and bears the related risks
and costs, and shares part of the benefits; and third-party finance where a third party
provides the capital for efficiency measure.
This group of instruments aims to make energy use and efficiency and conservation
efforts (more) visible and generally target habitual and unthinking types of behavior
43 Changing Energy Demand Behavior 785
(frequent behaviors, curtailment behavior). Knowing how much one consumes and
at what costs is a crucial first step toward a more efficient and sustainable everyday
life. Besides the costs, additional information on the environmental impact can be
provided. Feedback, in particular when combined with advice on how to reduce
energy use, can trigger up to 20% electricity savings (Wilhite et al. 1993; Darby
2006; Fischer 2007). The more personalized the feedback is, and the more this is
combined with advice on how to reduce consumption, the better the results.
Voluntary programs and commitments aim to enhance energy end users’ engage-
ment with energy issues and create social support and pressure for change in energy
use patterns. Usually, end users make a commitment to an energy-saving target and
receive some kind of acknowledgment for doing so. Commitments and voluntary
programs aim to increase people’s sense of responsibility for changing their routine
and habitual energy behaviors, although they might also change their efficiency
investment behavior as a result (Bertoldi and Rezessy 2007).
The context, stakeholders, and energy end users you are working with place different
requirements on the DSM program. Because of this, the generic instruments
introduced above need to be tailored to their particular context.
Economic instruments and financial services like ESCOs can be made more
effective if you understand how the end users you are targeting make decisions,
43 Changing Energy Demand Behavior 787
for example, the time frames that they consider when thinking about investments.
Financial support may not be sufficient: the end users may also need detailed
technical support and additional competencies. It is also important to recognize that
people tend to follow the example set by their peers. For example, positive examples
of other similar households’ experiences may encourage hesitant end users to invest.
Nonetheless, the same solution may not work for everyone, so it is important to
allow for tailoring and flexibility to find the right solution for each user or user
group.
Information and education campaigns are usually targeted at broad target groups.
However, intermediaries can take some steps to tailor them to their context.
Messages should build on topical concerns that are relevant to your targeted end
users. Timing can be relevant here: for example, heating issues are more relevant
during the heating season and climate change concerns vary depending on the level
of public debate. Information and education should not place the entire burden
for change on individuals – it is important to show what others are doing. If
the campaign is promoting particular solutions, it is important to make sure that
people can actually follow up on the information, and that the necessary solutions,
support, and services are available. It is also important to make sure that information
sources, media, and messengers are trusted by your target group. This implies that
intermediaries need to be aware of what and whom the targeted end users are likely
to trust.
Metering or other forms of feedback on energy consumption are crucial for
sustaining change in energy use patterns. Yet they, too, need to be tailored to the end
users’ needs and the requirements of the particular context in which you are working
in order to find the best formats for collecting, organizing, and communicating
feedback on energy use. Because energy information is usually quite peripheral to
most energy users, it is important to ensure that the feedback provided actually
gets your target group’s attention and helps them take action. Benchmarks can be
important in helping to make sense of and take action on the basis of energy use
feedback. Hence, information that allows your target group to compare their own
performance with others, or the users’ own previous consumption, can be valuable
and should be highlighted.
Energy audits are similar to metering and feedback insofar as they help energy
end users understand their own energy use. There are many generic audit models,
yet implementation of audit recommendations is always a challenge. For example,
timing can be an issue: good timing can connect the audit to existing investment
cycles and avoid conflicts with other priorities. Actionable audit recommendations
can be produced when the end users are involved in the audit and learn directly
from the process, and not just the audit report. Audit recommendations are also
more likely to be implemented if you can make sure that qualified service providers
are available to help in taking the next steps.
Energy advice involves guidance that is specific to the situation and actions that
can be taken by energy end users. Hence, a first step in tailoring advice to context is
to learn to understand the end users’ practices and find out what advice is needed and
in what form. People need advice at the right time and place and in the right form.
788 S. Breukers et al.
This suggests different advice delivery formats, for example, for reducing electricity
consumption in the home or the office, or for promoting energy renovations. Advice
should be provided through channels that are familiar to the energy end users and
make use of their usual contacts. For example, advice from peers is often more
salient and understandable than advice from distant sources. Advice obtained in
or near the hardware store may reach more people for whom it is relevant than
advice available during working hours at the city hall. In order to ensure relevance,
acceptability, and possibilities to act on the advice, you can also involve energy end
users in the development of advice formats, and should at least test advice formats
and revise them on the basis of feedback gained.
Voluntary programs aim to engage end users by getting them to commit to some
kinds of efforts to reduce their energy use. They can include setting targets or, for
example, competitions on who saves most. The stimulus for participating in such
programs usually relates to the social context – participating households or organi-
zations gain social support and sometimes even admiration. Hence, understanding
the prevailing values in the social context is extremely important when designing
such programs. Voluntary programs should involve efforts that are clearly ahead of
what the mainstream is doing, but may also be a way to introduce and test behaviors
and solutions that later become mandatory. It is worth considering how the behavior
will be institutionalized once the program ends: local intermediaries can be relevant
in keeping the activities going once the program itself is terminated.
Tailoring the DSM policy instruments is, however, only one of the necessary
steps in the design of an effective DSM program that achieves lasting behavioral
changes. Although the traditional instruments do tackle some of the issues discussed
earlier, for example, that energy consumption needs to be made visible, they are
not sufficient to tackle all the issues discussed earlier: that energy consumption is
connected to everything, that the behavioral change needs to either fit the context or
that the context needs to change as well, that the intermediary needs to know and
understand the target group, that all relevant stakeholders need to be engaged, and
that the intervention needs to be timed and take time.
In the introduction, emphasis was placed on the importance of learning about and
with end users and about the particular context in which a project is implemented.
For that reason, interactions are needed between experts, designers, policy makers,
and end users. All that has been discussed in this chapter is the outcome of an in-
tensive 3-year learning process between intermediaries, policymakers, researchers,
and end users (see http://www.energychange.info). This learning process resulted in
a toolkit that effectively addresses all the issues discussed in this chapter and thus
is a valuable aid in the design of a DSM program that actually achieves at changing
energy consumption patterns on the long term (http://mechanisms.energychange.
info). Tailoring the instruments to fit the particular context of the DSM program is
one of the steps in this toolkit. The toolkit shows in concrete detail the steps that can
43 Changing Energy Demand Behavior 789
be taken to learn more about the target group, the project context, and timing as well
as issues in implementation and evaluation. For an overview of the different toolkit
steps, see Table 43.2.
The focus of this chapter has been on energy DSM aimed at demand reduction.
However, DSM can also be aimed at the shifting of demand to other periods,
for instance, to ease the peak demand in electricity at certain points of the day,
and ease the burden on the electricity network. Several smart metering devices
have been brought to the market in recent years, and several of these have been
applied in practice as part of smart grid systems. For instance, in the Dutch town of
Hoogkerken, a pilot is running with households having “smart meters” that provide
household members with information on their energy usage and that provides them
with incentives to shift activities. When it comes to shifting demand, different
behavioral changes are asked for compared to behavioral changes toward more
efficiency and saving. A similarity is however that people are asked to change
their routines, by performing some activities (e.g., turning on the dish washer or
washing machine) on other moments of the day or by adopting a flexible attitude to
postponing activities whenever asked to do so. When use is made of “smart meters,”
care should be taken that these devices offer information and services tailored to the
needs of the recipient and that they do so in a format, at a time and place that fits
the practices of the end user. Ideally, smart meters address different target groups
differently. Different people may differ in their readiness to participate in or be
committed to a smart meter, let alone a smart grid and they may respond differently
to products or services (e.g., tariffs, contracts) offered. The eventual success of a
smart meter as a DSM tool depends on the end users’ readiness to become engaged.
A good understanding of these end users is hence needed in order to align their needs
790 S. Breukers et al.
with the technologies and the information, products, and services offered. Here also,
context-dependent conditions can be relevant, for example, existing social structures
and user practices.
from various disciplines, for example, economics, psychology, sociology and they
are not based on a socio-technical understanding of behavioral change and/or energy
DSM. Therefore, these instruments need to be tailored to the specific contexts in
which they are employed. In addition, they are one element of an overarching toolkit
that is grounded in theory yet is a useful practical aid for DSM program designers
and implementers.
References
W. Abrahamse, L. Steg, C. Vlek, T. Rothengatter, The effect of tailored information, goal setting,
and tailored feedback on household energy use, energy-related behaviors and behavioral
antecedents. J. Environ. Psychol. 27, 265–276 (2007)
C.D. Anderson, J.D. Claxton, Barriers to consumer choice of energy efficient products. J. Consum.
Res. 9(2), 163–170 (1982)
M. Anttonen, Energy expert. Case Study 10 of the CHANGING BEHAVIOUR project (2009),
http://www.energychange.info/casestudies/167-case-study-10-energy-expert-programme
Barcelona’s Water Supply Case (2008) in Collection of Newspaper Clippings for the 1st Interna-
tional Seminar on Sustainable Technology Development, Universitat Polytechnica, Catalunya,
June 2008
F. Bartiaux, G. Vekemans, K. Gram-Hanssen, D. Maes, M. Cantaert, B. Spies, J. Desmedt,
Socio-technical factors influencing residential energy consumption (SEREC). SPSD II Part I
Sustainable production and consumption patterns, Brussels, 2006
P. Bertoldi, S. Rezessy, Voluntary agreements for energy efficiency: review and results of European
experiences. Energy Environ. 18(1), 37–73 (2007)
N.W. Biggart, L. Lutzenhiser, Economic sociology and the social problem of energy inefficiency.
Am. Behav. Sci. 50(8), 1070–1087 (2007)
S. Breukers, E. Heiskanen, R.M. Mourik, D. Bauknecht, M. Hodson, Y. Barabanova, B. Brohmann,
V. Bürger, C.F.J. Feenstra, M. Jalas, M. Johnson, P. Maier, S. Marvin, H. Meinel, J. Pariag,
M. Rask, S. Rinne, S. Robinson, S. Saastamoinen, J. Salminen, I. Valuntiené, E. Vadovics,
Interaction schemes for successful energy demand side management. Building blocks for a
practicable and conceptual framework. Deliverable 5 of the CHANGING BEHAVIOUR project
(2009), www.energychange.info
S. Darby, The effectiveness of feedback on energy consumption. A review for DEFRA of the
literature on metering, billing and direct displays, Environmental Change Insitute, University
of Oxford, 2006
European commission Energy Efficiency Plan 2011, Communication from the Commission to
the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the
Committee of the Regions. Commission of the European Communities: COM(2011) 109 Final,
Brussels, 2011
C. Fischer, Chapter 31: Consumer feedback: a helpful tool for stimulating electricity conservation?
in Proceedings: SCP Cases in the Field of Food, Mobility, and Housing; Workshop of the
Sustainable Consumption Research Exchange (SCORE!) Network, Paris, 4–5 June 2007
Futerra, Rules of the Game. Evidence Base for the Climate Communications Strategy (London:
Futerra, 2005)
T. Gärling, G. Schuitema, Travel demand management targeting reduced private car use: effective-
ness, public acceptability and political feasibility. J. Social Issues 63, 139–153 (2007)
H. Geller, S. Attali, The experience with energy efficiency policies and programmes in IEA
countries, Learning from the Critics, International Energy Agency (IEA), Paris, 2005
W.H. Golove, J.H. Eto, Market barriers to energy efficiency: a critical reappraisal of the rationale
for public policies to promote energy efficiency, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, LBL-
38059, University of California, Berkeley, 1996
792 S. Breukers et al.
S. Guy, E. Shove, The Sociology of Energy, Buildings and the Environment: Constructing
Knowledge, Designing Practice (Taylor & Francis Ltd, New York, 2000)
E. Heiskanen, M. Hodson, T. Kallaste, P. Maier, S. Marvin, R. Mourik, S. Rinne, M. Saastamoinen,
E. Vadovics, A rose by any other name. . . ? New contexts and players in European energy
efficiency programmes, in Eceee 2009 Summer Study: Act! Innovate! Deliver! Reducing Energy
Demand Sustainably Conference Proceedings, Côte d’Azur, 2009
E. Heiskanen, M. Johnson, S. Robinson, E. Vadovics, M. Saastamoinen, Low-carbon communities
as a context for individual change. Energy Policy 38(12), 7586–7595 (2009)
A. Kamenders, Building energy audits project, Latvia. CHANGING BEHAVIOUR Case
Study 20 (2009), http://www.energychange.info/casestudies/177-case-study-20-building-
energy-audits-project
T. Kurz, The psychology of environmentally sustainable behaviour: fitting together pieces of the
puzzle. Anal. Social Issues Public Policy 2(1), 257 (2002)
K. Lucas, M. Brooks, A. Darnton, J.E. Jones, Promoting pro-environmental behaviour: existing
evidence and policy implications. Environ. Sci. Policy 11, 458–466 (2008)
L. Lutzenhiser, Greening the economy from bottom up, in Readings in Economic Sociology, ed.
by N.W. Biggart (Blackwell Publishers, Malden, 2002), pp. 345–356
E. Maibach, Social marketing for the environment: using information campaings to promote
environmental awareness and behavior change. Health Promot. Int. 8(3), 209–224 (1993)
O. Mont, K. Power, The role of formal and informal forces in shaping consumption and
implications for a sustainable society. Sustainability 2, 2232–2252 (2010). www.mdpi.com/
journal/sustainability
R.M. Mourik, S. Breukers, E. Heiskanen, D. Bauknecht, M. Hodson, Y. Barabanova, B. Brohmann,
V. Bürger, C.F.J. Feenstra, M. Jalas, M. Johnson, P. Maier, S. Marvin, H. Meinel, J. Pariag,
M. Rask, S. Rinne, S. Robinson, S. Saastamoinen, J. Salminen, I. Valuntiené, E. Vadovics,
A practical and conceptual framework of intermediary demand-side practice. Conceptueal
framework and model: synthesis report tailored for policy makers as target group. Deliverable
6 of the CHANGING BEHAVIOUR project (2009), www.energychange.info
M. Ornetzeder, H. Rohracher, User-led innovations and participation processes: lessons from
sustainable energy technologies. Energy Policy 34(2), 138–150 (2006)
P. Otnes, The Sociology of consumption: An anthology (Solum Forlag, Oslo, 1988)
R. Parnell, O.P. Larsen, Informing the development of domestic energy efficiency initiatives. An
everday householder-centred perspective. Environ. Behav. 37(6), 787–807 (2005)
A. Roestenburg, Barcelona’s sustainable water solutions in 2050. Thesis, TU Delft, 2008
H. Rohracher, Managing the technological transition to sustainable construction of buildings: a
socio-technical perspective. Technol. Anal. Strateg. Manag. 13(1), 137–150 (2001)
E. Shove, Converging conventions of comfort, cleanliness and convenience. J. Consum. Policy 26,
395–418 (2003)
P.C. Stern, Toward a coherent theory of environmentally significant behaviour. J. Social Issues
56/3, 407–424 (2000)
B. Van Vliet, H. Chappells, E. Shove, Infrastructures of Consumption. Environmental Innovation
in the Utility Industries (Earthscan, London, 2005)
H. Väisänen, W. Christensen, H. Despretz, K.A. Espergen, K. Lytras, E. Reinikainen, M. Sattler,
O. Starzer, AUDIT II Guidebook for Energy Audit Programme Developers. SAVE project
AUDIT II (2003)
J.A. Weiss, M. Ischer, Public information campaigns as policy instruments. J. Policy Anal. Manage.
13(1), 82–119 (1994)
H. Wilhite, R. Ling, A. Uutela, U. Anttila, A. Arvola, in A Nordic Test of the Energy Saving
Potential of New Residential Billing Techniques. Nordiske Seminar- og Arbejdsrapporter, vol.
627 (Nordic Council of Ministers, Copenhagen, 1993)
H. Wilhite, E. Shove, L. Lutzenhiser, W. Kempton, The legacy of twenty years of energy demand
management: we know more about individual behaviour but next to nothing about demand, in
Society, Behaviour, and Climate Change Mitigation ed. by E. Jochem, J.A. Sathaye, J. Bouille
(Kluwer, Dordrecht, 2000), pp. 109–126
Engineers and Community: How
Sustainable Engineering Depends on 44
Engineers’ Views of People
Juan C. Lucena
Abstract
Inspired by the book From Clients to Citizens: Communities Changing the
Course of their Own Development which shows the importance of rethinking
people from clients to citizens in the effectiveness of community development
projects, the central argument of this chapter is that the successes or failures
of sustainable development (SD) engineering projects depend greatly on how
engineers view and engage the people they work with. During the brief history
of engineering involvement in SD, engineers have worked with people, viewing
them mainly as clients and less so as stakeholders, users, or citizens. Each of
these views of people by engineers prescribes the way engineers listen to and
work collaboratively with people to turn SD projects into real sustainability.
After briefly conceptualizing listening as the most important element of dia-
logue and showing how SD might be more sustainable when grounded on specific
localities, this chapter maps the different categories – clients, stakeholders, users,
and citizens – that engineers have used, or could use, to view the people they try
to serve, and how each of these categories shapes the way in which engineers
listen and work with them. While listening to and working with people labeled
“clients” or “stakeholders” might be more empowering for the status of engineers
as experts, it might be less effective in turning SD projects into long-term
sustainability. On the other hand, listening to and working with people as “users”
or “citizens” might be less empowering for engineers but more effective for
sustainability.
J.C. Lucena
Liberal Arts and International Studies, Colorado School of Mines, Golden, CO, USA
e-mail: jlucena@mines.edu
1 Introduction
Interactions among humans are complex and involve cognitive, emotional, social,
political, cultural, and economic dimensions. This chapter will focus on listening
as the key activity that facilitates, if done well, or hinders, if done poorly,
engineers’ interactions with others. Unfortunately, many people in personal, family,
professional, and other forms of social interactions have forgotten, or really never
learned, to listen. Hence, in this chapter on how engineers interact with others
involved in SD, the focus will be on listening.
Many factors have contributed to the diminishing of listening in contemporary
society. In most consumer societies, for example, spoken or written words –
the inputs and outputs of human communication – have become commodities
(news, blogs, presentations, papers, training workshops, etc.). At the same time,
communication technologies have increased human abilities to stay connected, link
796 J.C. Lucena
ing a part, assembling a subsystem, implementing the system, using it, etc. –
happens in specific places, within local ecologies and in interaction with local
communities of workers, subcontractors, regulators, users, and citizens (Acosta
and Leon 2009). This localization of human activity within specific local ecolo-
gies has led SD scholars to conclude that the realization of SD into actual
sustainable practices depends greatly on being localized. Wary that global vi-
sions of SD might work against the actual realizations of sustainable practices,
Yanarella and Levine argue that “the very globalizing vision of ecological think-
ing when transferred to strategizing can militate against the tacking down and
institutionalization of self-sustaining processes at lower scales where sustainable
development may be more realizable and the results more palpable” (Yanarella
and Levine 1992, p. 764). Elaborating further on why the global visions of
SD might serve the interests of SD experts, including engineers, SD scholars
Jeffrey Bridger and A.E. Luloff argue that those who depict sustainability on a
macro-scale
portray environmental problems in such apocalyptic terms that they sometimes revert to
the language of technocratic planning and administration and speak of the need for global
ecological planners in international agencies who must work with national political elites
and multinational corporate leaders to manage these environmental crises . . . The problem
with this kind of solution is that relations of domination are left in place. Those who control
the resources and who are responsible for many of the decisions and actions that have caused
insidious environmental damage are generally charged with cleaning up their mess . . . The
result is a crisis mentality which relies on technological solutions for much larger structural
problems (Bridger and Luloff 1999, p. 380).
Bridger and Luloff’s claims raise the following question: if the future of
sustainability resides in localized practices how might future engineers understand,
798 J.C. Lucena
dialogue, and effectively work toward sustainable solutions with people involved
in SD? In order to begin answering that question, one needs to find out (1) how
engineers have traditionally viewed the people they try to serve, (2) how they
might view them differently, (3) how engineers’ views of people influence how
they interact with each other, and more importantly, (4) how engineers’ views and
interactions with people might have great repercussions in turning SD efforts into
sustainability.
2.1 Background
2.2 Listening
More so than doctors and lawyers who often have one-on-one interactions with
their clients, engineers have come to rely on organizational structures and practices
44 Engineers and Community 799
that shape how listening to a client takes place. In large technical organizations,
listening to clients is often done through a marketing division which translates
clients’ requirements into design constraints. Engineers translate these require-
ments into specifications, incorporate them into designs, and later convey them to
manufacturing. The business interests of corporations, the channels of corporate
communication, and the dominant definition of SD which emphasizes technological
fixes, all prescribe listening between engineers and clients in SD contexts. Here,
listening has taken the form of a two-way act (dyadic). Leydens and Lucena
describe this kind of listening as “basic listening” which “refers to hearing or paying
attention to any speaker, such as a client, local villager, coworker, or instructor;
thus, listening is framed as a dyadic process of speaking (output) and hearing
(input). Basic listening is necessary in any human communicative interaction
but, for reasons explained below, is not sufficient for effective and empathetic
listening in SD (and arguably, most other) contexts” (Leydens and Lucena 2009,
p. 363). Leydens and Lucena summarize the characteristics of basic listening as
follows:
• Emphasizes one-way relation between speaker and receiver of information.
• Hearing and speaking are considered main outcomes of listening.
• Minimally collaborative and usually applied uni-directionally from top-down
(speaker ! hearer).
• Minimal attention to accountability and transparency issues.
• Emphasizes traits such as “good speaker” or “good listener.”
• Situated contextual issues often considered unimportant since focus is on the act
of speaking-receiving information.
• Highlights certain skills (speaking, receiving information) while minimizing
others (observing, self-reflection, contemplation, inviting participation).
• Integration of multiple perspectives beyond engineer-client often considered less
important (Leydens and Lucena 2009, p. 365).
or livelihood producers, into clients in the process” (Mathie and Cunningham 2008,
p. 2; see also Eade and Ireland 1997).
In SD efforts that span beyond a local community, this type of listening is
also problematic as it leads engineers to assume that cultural differences between
speakers and listeners are trivial. As scholars of cross-cultural communications have
shown, even when the language of communication among international teams of
engineers is the same, there are significant cultural differences that shape, and often
impede, knowledge transfer among engineers. For example, Hard and Knie show
how the redesign of British ships during WW II came to a standstill at American
shipyards as US engineers could not understand the cultural assumptions built into
blueprints drawn by their British counterparts. US engineers had to completely
redraw the blueprints in terms that were familiar to them (Hard and Knie 1999).
Clearly US engineers’ commitment to basic listening (a dyadic exchange of infor-
mation between them and the British engineers) made them omit or ignore important
cultural differences of how the two groups conveyed technical information in design
blueprints.
Yet cultural differences play a significant role in how different people, in-
cluding engineers, view and value sustainability. For example, in their study
of the importance of social learning and culture for sustainable water man-
agement, Pahl-Wostl et al. critique prevailing water management models for
their emphasis on unidirectional communication, which reinforces technocratic
control over participation, and the belief that communication inputs can be quan-
tified in order to provide optimal outputs: “ The prevailing command and con-
trol paradigm management is perceived as control. Solutions are technology
driven. There is a firm belief that risks [inputs] can be quantified and that
optimal strategies [outputs] can be chosen. Zero-sum-games in closed decision
space. This cultural framing supports the implementation of controllable and
predictable technical infrastructure (reservoirs, dams) [more outputs] based on
fixed regulations for acceptable risk-thresholds” (Pahl-Wostl et al. 2008, p. 492).
Critical of the main assumptions behind the dominant definition of SD, they
conclude that
There is a growing recognition that in order to address adequately current environmental
problems it is necessary to abandon many of the assumptions of the dominant paradigm
of resource management about their perceived causes, explanations, and possible remedies
and shift toward a more holistic and integrative approach . . . New participatory and adaptive
water management approaches will not be implemented in sustainable fashion unless they
are more deeply rooted in a cultural change in society . . . we cannot understand dynamics
and transition toward new management regimes without understanding the interdependence
between social learning and culture at different scales (Pahl-Wostl et al. 2008, p. 494) (italics
added).
How might engineers socially learn from others in SD contexts and interact with
them in more holistic and integrative approaches in order to achieve sustainability?
Perhaps engineers need to view the people they are interacting with in SD not as
clients but as something else.
44 Engineers and Community 801
2.4 Summary
3.1 Background
3.2 Listening
operational analysis, are making inroads into the engineering literature related to
SD challenging engineers to consider a wider range of stakeholders. Value chain
analysis, for example, focuses on those who derive value from a technological
system, mainly users and investors (shareholders), while operational analysis
includes all those who are involved in the development, implementation, use, and
maintenance of a system (Browning and Honour 2008). Either approach represents
an improvement over the way clients are identified in the engineer-client relationship
where clients often identify themselves by bringing a problem to engineers. In
contrast, stakeholder identification brings into the dialogue perspectives that could
otherwise be excluded.
Second, once engineers have identified stakeholders, their next challenge is to
figure out how to listen to them. Documented cases of stakeholder inclusion show
that listening is still dyadic (speaker-receiver). The main difference is that now
engineers have multiple input-output interactions taking place at the same time as
multiple stakeholders are considered in the analysis.
Third, in these multiple dyadic connections, engineers have to decide what to
listen for. Here the engineer-stakeholder relationship also presents an improvement
over that of engineer-client. Browning and Honour, for example, recognize that
besides requirements or specifications, stakeholders also have values that need to
be recognized and incorporated in system design.
Unlike most engineering parameters, value is a perceived quality stemming from subjective
preferences. Stakeholder preferences are distinct and different from requirements [specs].
Requirements represent a choice made to achieve a specific level of performance and specify
acceptability. A system that meets its requirements will provide different value to different
stakeholders, depending on their preferences. Preferences emanate from individuals, which
makes them less amenable to firm analysis (Browning and Honour 2008, p. 192) (italics
added).
case studies of stakeholder analyses reviewed for this chapter, the incorporation
of stakeholders’ values and preferences into a system is done through a weighting
analysis where key parameters are weighted, first, according to importance to
specific stakeholder groups and, second, incorporated into system design according
to how much the system owner values that particular perspective. For example,
in a case study of cell phone system design, although tower height had a 100%
weight value for environmental activists, it only represented a 2% weight value
for the overall system as assigned by main decision maker: the system owner.
Meanwhile, the perspectives of subscribers, corporate management and share-
holders did not include any parameters related to sustainability, yet they were
assigned weight values of 40%, 25%, and 20% respectively. Clearly, coverage,
service price, and profit trumped sustainability even when the stakeholder analysis
is portrayed as one that includes environmental concerns (Browning and Honour
2008).
There are some important exceptions where the input of less powerful stakehold-
ers was given significant consideration. For example, Suncor, a Canadian energy
firm, developed oil sands operations involving multiple stakeholders and acknowl-
edged that stakeholders could provide the company with cost-saving solutions. Once
the company had extracted the oil from the oil sands, it had to repair the land to
pre-development capability. Aboriginal stakeholders pointed out that “nature rarely
produces straight lines” as Suncor engineers tried to smooth and flat the edges of
the reclamation area in a linear fashion. By listening to aborigines the company
saved money and left the area with a more natural regrowth (Rowledge et al. 1999,
p. 74). Yet it is not clear how the perspective of aboriginal stakeholders would have
been valued, say at the onset of the development project where key decisions were
made about where and how to develop the oil sands. In short, with rare exceptions,
even though there might be an impression that stakeholders’ inputs are seriously
considered, the subjective preferences of system owners tend to override them
quite often.
3.4 Summary
4.1 Background
When designing, building, and operating technical systems, engineers often imagine
three kinds of users: passive users, who accept or reject technological advances
through market forces of supply and demand; reflexive users, who will use the
technologies in the same ways that engineers would (Bardini and Horvath 1995);
and imagined or projected users “with specific tastes, competencies, motives,
aspirations and political prejudices” (Lindsay 2003, p. 31). Different from clients,
who provide specific design requirements, these three kinds of imagined users
are assumed to receive the benefits of technological solutions without providing
explicit input in their designs (other than the projected assumptions that engineers
make about them). The view of users as passive has been reinforced by studies
of production, marketing, and consumption that highlight big companies and
advertising agencies as the forces driving consumption (Strasser 1995; Laird 2001).
“In these studies, consumption was characterized as a passive and adaptive process
and consumers are represented as the anonymous buyers and victims of mass
production” (Oudshoorn and Pinch 2005, p. 13). The view of users as reflexive or
projected has been reinforced by traditional engineering design education where
students are often asked to imagine themselves as users, or make assumptions about
user groups.
Recent scholarship in science and technology studies (STS) has reconceptualized
the concept of user from passive, reflexive or projected to one as complex agent with
creative capacity “[to] shape technological development in all phases of technolog-
ical innovation” (Oudshoorn and Pinch 2005). This scholarship makes visible “how
the co-construction of users and technologies may involve tensions, conflicts, and
disparities in power and resources among the different actors involved” (Oudshoorn
and Pinch 2005, p. 16). This chapter considers a number of important contributions
from this scholarship:
• The findings in Christina Lindsay’s study of present-day users of the TR-80, a
computer introduced by Radio Shack almost 30 years ago and thought obsolete
with the emergence of Windows systems, that users can have multiple identities
and can perform activities and identities traditionally ascribed to designers.
Present-day users of this obsolete computer define themselves as “neo-Luddites”
wanting simplicity and reliability of use, when compared with the complexity of
today’s computer operating systems, or nostalgic wanting to go back in time to
their first computers, or resisters wanting to show new generations of computer
users that Microsoft or Apple are not the only options. In addition to these
identifiers, users also adopted the roles of “designer, developer, marketer, and
technical support” of a computer system (TR-80) that nowadays has no corporate
infrastructure to support it (Lindsay 2003, p. 48).
• Ronald Kline’s study of resistance to telephone and electrification technologies
in rural America and his main finding that instead of being an irrational
44 Engineers and Community 805
4.2 Listening
Engineering education rarely trains students to listen, let alone to listen to multiple
identities as those found among users (Leydens and Lucena 2009). Yet there are
some hopeful signs that engineers are beginning to take users more seriously.
For example, computer engineers have begun incorporating users in the design
of computer systems in ways that acknowledge their agency as co-creators of
technologies (Laplante 2009). After having ignored indigenous farmers at the onset
of a design of irrigation software, one group of engineers engaged them as active
users after the farmers resisted and rejected features of the software at the initial
stages. This engagement led to the co-creation of a more effective irrigation software
that the indigenous farmers embraced and used (Dewulf et al. 2005). But these
attempts by engineers to incorporate users as active agents do not acknowledge
the complexity and diversity of identities that users can adopt, including those of
resisters, rejectors, nostalgic, etc. These possibilities challenge engineers to adopt
new forms of listening that can illuminate these complexities and help them interact
with users in SD contexts more effectively.
Different from basic listening, contextual listening has been defined as “a mul-
tidimensional, integrated understanding of the listening process wherein listening
806 J.C. Lucena
facilitates meaning making, enhances human potential, and helps foster community-
supported change. In this form of listening, information such as cost, weight,
technical specs, desirable functions, and timeline [usually the inputs in basic
listening] acquires meaning only when the context of the person(s) making the
requirements (their history, political agendas, desires, forms of knowledge, etc.)
is fully understood” (Lucena et al. 2010, p. 125). To provide a rich context to
the interactions among engineers and users/nonusers in SD projects, contextual
listening challenges engineers to consider the following dimensions:
• Integrating history and culture, which includes finding out the origins of user
groups, the history of their interactions with engineers and SD projects, their
influence in the different stages of design and implementation, and the diversity
among them.
• Being open to cultural difference and ambiguity, which includes finding out
engineers’ strengths and limitations as listeners, their own degree of openness
to the diversity of perspectives found among users (especially those that will
strongly disagree with the engineers or might want to take the SD project in a
different direction), and engineers’ tolerance for ambiguity.
• Building relationships, which includes developing and maintaining trust, espe-
cially with users who might not have the technical qualifications and expertise
that engineers have, and a willingness to change in order to build more trusting
relationships with the diversity of users.
• Minimizing deficiencies and recognizing capacities, which include learning to
think about users differently, not in terms of what they lack but in terms of
what they can offer to the design, development, implementation, and future
transformations of the SD project in question.
• Foregrounding self-determination, which includes understanding how an SD
project can be initiated, led, and maintained into the future by users.
• Achieving shared accountability which includes learning with the users how
a SD project – its results, impacts, and unintended consequences – can move
from “ours” or “theirs” to OURS where the responsibility is mutually shared by
engineers and users alike.
In contrast to basic listening that clearly shapes the interaction between engineer and
client as one between expert and non-expert, contextual listening blurs the boundary
between expert and non-expert by enabling engineers to acknowledge that users
have great deal of agency in the co-creation of technologies. Leydens and Lucena
summarized the characteristics of contextual listening as follows:
• Emphasizes multidirectional empathic interactions and dialogue and the building
of trust and long-lasting relationships
• Focuses on users’ empowerment and project ownership as desired outcomes
• Allows for challenges to engineers’ expertise by non-engineering users
• Invites accountability and transparency from all parties
• Emphasizes openness to others, trusting non-engineering users and dealing with
ambiguity
44 Engineers and Community 807
• Makes it clear that situated contexts significantly shape individuals’ roles and
abilities to engage in dialogue
• Aimed at unveiling biases in the interactions among engineers and users
• Promotes multi-perspective coming from diversity of users and nonusers
(Leydens and Lucena 2009, p. 365)
How might the interactions among engineers and active users in SD projects,
with their multiple identities and unintended roles, result in more sustainable
solutions? The interactions of engineers with a diverse group of active users will
be more likely to transform a SD project into a sustainable one when grounded
on contextual listening and situated in the locality where the project or system is
to be co-constructed, co-used, and co-maintained. SD scholars Bridger and Lulloff
have shown that for a SD project or initiative to be truly sustainable it needs to
enhance the following five dimensions: local economic diversity, self-determination,
biological diversity and stewardship of resources, reduction of energy use and
materials, and social justice (Bridger and Luloff 1999). So, as Kline’s study of
farmers show, some users with vested interests in the local economy will probably
resist an engineering system if it diminishes the community’s local economic or
biological diversity. Acknowledging this resistance because of their commitment to
contextual listening, engineers might transform the system into one that enhances
these dimensions. Or as Lindsay’s study of the TR-80 users show, some users
could potentially reconstruct, or even resurrect, a system in a way that enhances
community self-determination. Again, enabled by contextual listening, engineers’
interactions with these types of users will likely yield a system that promotes self-
determination. Or as Sally Wyatt’s study of Internet nonusers illustrates, engineers
committed to contextual listening would be able to identify and interact with the
excluded and expelled, and understand how and why a SD project affects social
justice by denying access to some.
4.4 Summary
5.1 Background
watch, listen and learn. Metaphorically, and sometimes actually, they ‘hand over the stick’
of authority” (Francis 2001, pp. 76–77).
• There are complex and conflictive relationships among members and between
members and place.
• Relationships are shaped by differences in power and privilege.
• Members have alliances with particular common purpose(s).
• Members should be more appropriately considered citizens with rights, power to
decide, vote, call projects off, capacity to define problems and propose solutions,
intellectual capital, etc.
Treating community members as citizens is a significant improvement over any of
the relationships analyzed above as the concept of citizen recognizes not only the
diversity and complexities of users but also their rights. By treating community
members as citizens, engineers interacting with them in SD contexts are challenged
to recognize that citizen participation in the different stages of projects is not just
a methodological nicety but a political right. According to Holland et al., treating
community members as citizens
bridges the gulf between rights in principle and development realities . . . it redefines the
roles assigned to and the relationships between the state and other development actors.
Specifically, this challenges the role consistently assigned to marginalized and subordinate
people as clients or beneficiaries of development and offers instead possibilities of shaping
different relationships predicated in the political right to participate in decision-making
processes . . . to act as a citizen involves fulfilling the potential that citizenship rights confer
on the individual. In this sense, participation is the foundation of democratic practice: a
fundamental right that helps to protect and guarantee all others and by doing so highlights
the capacities people have to act as agents in their own development (Holland 2004, p. 255)
(italics added).
5.2 Listening
When interacting with citizens, engineers should also use contextual listening,
focusing on citizens’ rights and looking to understand three key points. First,
citizens’ own identification and assessment of their rights and the contrast among
these, the political rights in a particular locale, and universal human rights.
Second, the obstacles that citizens face in accessing those rights. Third, actions to
support governments and other social institutions involved in SD in the protection,
promotion, and realization of human rights (Holland 2004, p. 257). Hence, in
addition to the dimensions described above under the engineer-user relationship,
contextual listening should focus on citizens’ rights as follows:
• Integrating history and culture, which now includes finding out the origins of
citizens’ political rights in a particular locale and how these rights are exercised
in this particular culture. After all, as Cleaver argues, “rights do not exist in a
vacuum but are embedded in social relations; these very social relations may
either enable or constrain the exercise of such agency” (Cleaver 2004, p. 273).
44 Engineers and Community 811
• Being open to cultural difference and ambiguity, which now includes finding
out engineers’ own degree of openness to cultural diversity in relationship with
the protection of people’s rights, especially in those places that will significantly
diverge from the engineers’ own locale and view of rights.
• Building relationships, which now includes developing and maintaining trust
with citizens, so they feel secure to speak about complex issues related to their
rights, and with officials in institutions involved in the protection, promotion, and
realization of human rights.
• Minimizing deficiencies and recognizing capacities, which now include respect-
ing citizens’ right to participate at different levels in SD projects and view this as
an asset not a deficiency.
• Foregrounding self-determination, which now includes understanding how and
respecting that citizens have the right to initiate, lead, and maintain (and even
terminate) a SD project.
• Achieving shared accountability, which now includes accepting a shared respon-
sibility with the citizens of a community to ensure that a SD project – and its
results, impacts, and unintended consequences – benefits, or at least does not
impede, people’s rights and the environmental rights of a community.
If engineers and citizens interacting in SD contexts recognize how their rights (local
and universal) might be directly linked to the health of the ecosystem around them,
then both will likely advance the interests of the surrounding ecosystem when
participating in SD projects. For example, since no one can aspire to the right to life
or health without potable water or breathable air, engineers and citizens interacting
in the co-creation of a SD project will likely protect their right to life and health by
protecting water and air sources from pollution or over consumption.
Clearly conflict might emerge between citizens’ individual rights and the envi-
ronmental rights of the community. For example, there might be conflict between
individuals’ right to decide on the number of offspring they want to have and the
community’s right to preserve natural resources. Yet, as the examples of community
development by active citizens illustrated by Mathie et al. show, resolution will
likely “come about either because the positive contribution of those previously
excluded has been recognized, or because of the skilled mediation of community
leaders, or because community approval of the activities of individuals and groups
renders them immune to political manoeuvering by an old guard” (Mathie and
Cunningham 2008, p. 360). In fact when people are viewed, and view themselves,
as citizens of a community, rights and responsibilities toward environmental sus-
tainability are likely to be more balanced within the political space of a community.
As Matthie et al. have demonstrated in their illustrative collection of case studies
in sustainable community development, “many of the cases here demonstrate that
rights and responsibilities are intertwined, that citizenship is as much about mutual
support and collective effort as it is about occupying a space to claim rights from
the state. Most of the cases in fact show how these two dimensions of citizenship
812 J.C. Lucena
can overlap or mutually reinforce each other, and how it is community initiative and
community innovation that sets the terms of engagement with state actors rather
than the other way around” (Mathie and Cunningham 2008, pp. 361–362).
By viewing and interacting with people as citizens, engineers can contribute to
enhancing people’s rights in relationship to their environment and their ability to
claim rights from the state. For example, a case study of an engineer facilitating
community mapping for water management in Honduras shows how the engineer’s
view of community members as citizens with rights translates into her giving them
the power to map their own watershed, water use, water habits (cooking, hand
washing, flushing, etc.), water needs for the future, and those in the community
directly responsible for these (e.g., farmers’ fertilizing practices have direct impact
on watershed, teachers’ classroom practices have direct impact on children’s hand
washing, and so on). As this engineer assists community members to create their
own map, the latter come to clearly recognize how their individual rights interact
with the environmental rights of the community (e.g., the impact of individual
practices executed in private property on the watershed) and what rights to claim
from the state (e.g., protection of the watershed, funding for water education in
public schools, etc.) (see Lucena et al. (2010), Chap. 7 for full description and
analysis of this case study).
5.4 Summary
When engineers view and interact with people as citizens with rights, engineers
can make significant contributions to transform SD efforts into sustainable ones.
Citizens will be empowered by their rights to initiate, participate in, and even
terminate if they deem proper, SD projects and be more likely to share responsibility
for the sustainability of their local ecosystem.
Engineers who practice contextual listening with a focus on rights will be able to
recognize conflicts between rights and responsibilities, as they will be in tune with
citizens’ rights and the community’s environmental rights, and to serve as catalysts
in sustainable solutions as they will likely be trusted by community citizens and
their leaders.
6 Conclusions
Linking the global with the local. Supply chains enhance engineers’ ability to
manufacture products with materials, parts, and subsystems that come from different
corners of the globe. Yet at each node in the supply chain, there is a locality,
where people and a local ecosystem will be affected by how the particular part or
subsystem will be manufactured (e.g., the potential waste products released into
the nearby atmosphere and water supply). It is at these nodes where engineers
committed to sustainability can make a difference by viewing and interacting with
people as citizens, respecting their rights, allowing them to take control of their own
44 Engineers and Community 813
destiny, and serving as translators of how global practices affect local communities
and vice versa.
Clearly, there are global problems such as climate change that can hardly be
solved by local practices alone. Engineers could contribute toward the solutions of
these problems by interacting with people as citizens and co-creating sustainable
solutions but only with limited results. These global problems require larger
solutions in the form of concerted policy and investment efforts by officials at the
levels of nation-state, international organizations, and multinational corporations
and radical changes in public opinion, manufacturing, and consumption patterns.
Moving from clients to citizens. This chapter has shown how the dominant defi-
nition of SD reinforces the engineer-client relationship and how basic listening does
not allow engineers to engage others in effective ways to find sustainable solutions.
The engineer-stakeholder relationship is only effective if stakeholder groups bring
sustainability to the table and those groups are taken seriously in the final system
design by those in control of the system. The engineer-user relationship allows for
the inclusion of diverse and complex perspectives and opens the possibility of users
becoming co-creators of technologies and sustainable solutions. This leveling of the
expert-nonexpert relationship might mean a loss of power and status by engineers
but a gain in transforming SD into real sustainability. Meanwhile, the engineer-
citizen relationship recognizes people’s rights and responsibilities of and is more
likely to yield sustainable solutions.
From basic to contextual listening. Hopefully, it has become clear that how
engineers view the people they are trying to serve shapes how they interact with
them in SD projects. When working with clients and stakeholders, engineers are
barely challenged to listen, mainly through basic listening, and will likely maintain
a higher status as experts. When working with (non)users and citizens, engineers
are seriously challenged to adopt a more complex type of listening (contextual
listening), to be on a more equal playing field and in some cases to relinquish
power as users or citizens become co-creators of technologies. A shift from basic
to contextual listening requires more time, work, patience, and commitment (and
perhaps come at the expense of engineers’ status and power) yet it allows engineers
to interact with people in more effective ways toward sustainable solutions.
References
A.D. Abbott, The System of Professions: An Essay on the Division of Expert Labor (University of
Chicago Press, Chicago, 1988)
C. Acosta, V.J. Leon, Global Engineering: Design, Decision Making, and Communication (CRC
Press, London New York, 2009)
A. Mostashari, J. Sussman, Stakeholder-assisted modelling and policy design process for environ-
mental decision-making. J. Environ. Assess. Policy Manage. 7(03), 355–386 (2005)
UN Secretary General Report of the World Commission on Environment and Development: Our
Common Future – A/42/427 Annex – UN Documents: Gathering a body of global agreements,
http://www.un-documents.net/wced-ocf.htm (1987)
ASCE: Code of ethics, http://www.asce.org/Content.aspx?id=7231 (1914)
814 J.C. Lucena
C. Baillie, Engineers Within a Local and Global Society (Morgan and Claypool, San Rafael,
California, 2006)
T. Bardini, A.T. Horvath, The social construction of the personal computer user. J. Commun. 45(3),
40–66 (1995). doi:10.1111/j.1460-2466.1995.tb00743.x
S.R. Barley, G. Kunda, Gurus, Hired Guns, and Warm Bodies : Itinerant Experts in a Knowledge
Economy (Princeton University Press, Princeton, 2004)
J.C. Bridger, A.E. Luloff, Toward an interactional approach to sustainable community develop-
ment. J. Rural Stud. 15, 377–387 (1999)
T.R. Browning, E.C. Honour, Measuring the life-cycle value of enduring systems. Syst. Eng. 11(3),
187–202 (2008). doi:10.1002/sys.20094
D.M. Buede, The Engineering Design of Systems: Models and Methods (Wiley, New York, 2009)
W.J. Carroll, World engineering partnership for sustainable development. J. Prof. Issues Eng. Educ.
Pract. 119(3), 238–240 (1993)
M.M. Cernea, Putting People First: Sociological Variables in Rural Development (Published for
the World Bank [by] Oxford University Press, New York, 1985)
F. Cleaver, The social embeddedness of agency and decision-making, in Participation: From
Tyranny to Transformation (Zed Books, London New York, 2004), pp. 271–277
B. Cooke, U. Kothari. Participation, the New Tyranny? (Zed Books, New York, 2004)
M.L. Dertouzos, R.K. Lester, R.M. Solow, Made in America: Regaining the Productive Edge (MIT,
Cambridge, 1989)
A. Dewulf, M. Craps, R. Bouwen, F. Abril, M. Zhingri, How indigenous farmers and university
engineers create actionable knowledge for sustainable irrigation. Action Res. 3(2), 175–192
(2005)
G.L. Downey, K. Beddoes, What is Global Engineering Education for?: The Making of Interna-
tional and Global Engineering Educators (Morgan & Claypool, San Rafael, 2010)
D. Eade, Capacity-Building: An Approach to People-Centred Development (Oxfam, Ireland, UK
1997)
J. Fiksel, Designing resilient, sustainable systems. Environ. Sci. Technol. 37(23), 5330–5339
(2003). doi:10.1021/es0344819
P. Francis, Participatory development at the world bank: the primacy of process, in Participation,
the New Tyranny? (Zed Books, London New York, 2001), pp. 72–87
R.E. Freeman, Strategic Management: A Stakeholder Approach (Pitman, Boston, Massachusetts,
1984)
T.L. Friedman, The World is Flat: A Brief History of the 21st Century (Farrar, Straus, and Giroux,
New York, 2006)
J.M. Grandin, E.W. Dehmel, Cross-cultural issues in educating engineers for the global workplace.
J. Lang. Int. Bus. 8(2), 1–15 (1997)
M. Hard, A. Knie. The grammar of technology: german and french diesel engineering, 1920–1940.
Technol. Cult. 40(1), 26–46 (1999)
H. Henderson, The Politics of the Solar Age: Alternatives to Economics (Doubleday, Garden City,
New York, 1981)
S. Hickey, G. Mohan, Participation: From Tyranny to Transformation? Exploring New Approaches
to Participation in Development (Zed Books, London New York, 2004)
D. Holland, Beyond the technical fix? Participation in donor approaches to rights-based devel-
opment, in Participation: From Tyranny to Transformation (Zed Books, London New York,
2004), pp. 252–268
R. Kline, Resisting consumer technology in rural America: the telephone and electrification, in
How Users Matter: The Co-Construction of Users and Technology (MIT, Cambridge London,
2003), pp. 51–66
P.W. Laird, Advertising Progress: American Business and the Rise of Consumer Marketing (JHU,
Baltimore, 2001)
P.A. Laplante, Requirements Engineering for Software and Systems, 1st edn. (CRC, Redmond,
2009), http://beta.crcpress.com/product/isbn/9781420064674
44 Engineers and Community 815
E.T. Layton, The Revolt of the Engineers: Social Responsibility and the American Engineering
Profession (The John Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, 1971)
J. Leydens, J. Lucena, Listening as a missing dimension in humanitarian and sustainable
community development efforts: the engineering curriculum as a potential learning inhibitor.
IEEE Trans. Prof. Commun. 52(4), 359–376 (2009)
C. Lindsay, From the shadows: users as designers, producers, marketers, distributors and technical
support, in How Users Matter: The Co-Construction of Users and Technology. Inside Technol-
ogy (MIT, Cambridge London, 2003), pp. 29–50
J. Lucena, G. Downey, A systemic approach to global competency for engineers, in ASEE Annual
Conference and Exposition, Chicago, 2006
J. Lucena, J. Schneider, Engineers, development, and engineering education: from national to
sustainable community development. Eur. J. Eng. Educ. 33(3), 247–257 (2008)
J. Lucena, J. Schneider, J.A. Leydens, in Engineering and Sustainable Community Development,
ed. by C. Baillie (Morgan & Claypool, San Rafael, 2010)
A. Mathie, G. Cunningham, From Clients to Citizens: Communities Changing the Course of their
Own Development (Practical Action, Warwickshire, 2008)
D. Mosse, “People’s knowledge”, participation and patronage: operations and representations in
rural development, in Participation, the New Tyranny? (Zed Books, London New York, 2001),
pp. 16–35
M.P. Nichols, The Lost Art of Listening: How Learning to Listen Can Improve Relationships
(Guilford, New York, 2009)
D.F. Noble, America by Design: Science, Technology, and the Rise of Corporate Capitalism
(Oxford University Press, New York, 1977)
N. Oudshoorn, T. Pinch, in How Users Matter: The Co-Construction of Users and Technology
(MIT, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 2005)
C. Pahl-Wostl, D. Tabara, R. Bouwen, M. Craps, A. Dewulf, E. Mostert, D. Ridder, T. Taillieu, The
importance of social learning and culture for sustainable water management. Ecol. Econom.
64(3), 484–495 (2008)
A. Ramaswami, J.B. Zimmerman, J.R. Mihelcic, Integrating developed and developing world
knowledge into global discussions and strategies for sustainability. 2. Economics and gover-
nance. Environ. Sci. Technol. 41(10), 3422–3430 (2007). doi:10.1021/es0603047
L.R. Rowledge, R.S. Barton, K.S. Brady, J.A. Fava, Mapping the Journey: Case Studies in
Strategy and Action Toward Sustainable Development (Greenleaf Publishing, Sheffield, United
Kingdom, 1999)
L.F. Salmen, Listen to People: Participant-Observer Evaluation of Development Projects (Oxford
University Press, New York, 1987)
A. Saxenian, Silicon Valley’s New Immigrant Entrepreneurs (Public Policy Institute of California,
San Francisco, 1999)
C. Seron, S.S. Silbey, The dialectic between expert knowledge and professional discretion:
accreditation, social control and the limits of instrumental logic. Eng. Stud. 1(2), 101 (2009).
doi:10.1080/19378620902902351
W. Sobkiw, Sustainable Development Possible with Creative System Engineering (CassBeth, New
Jersey, 2008), http://books.google.com/books?id=7WJppXs-LzEC
S. Strasser, Satisfaction Guaranteed: The Making of the American Mass Market (Smithsonian
Institution Press, Washington, DC, 1995)
R. Varma, Harbingers of Global Change: India’s Techno-Immigrants in the United States
(Lexington Books, Lanham, 2006)
World Congress on Sustainable Development–Engineering and Technological Challenges of the
21st Century, in World Congress on Sustainable Development–Engineering and Technological
Challenges of the 21st Century (Tata McGraw-Hill Pub, Calcutta New Delhi, 2000)
E.J. Yanarella, R.S. Levine, Does sustainable development lead to sustainability? Futures 24(8),
759–774 (1992). doi:10.1016/0016-3287(92)90105-O
Impact of New Technologies: How to
Assess the Intended and Unintended 45
Effects of New Technologies?
Karel F. Mulder
Abstract
New technologies change the world irreversibly. These changes do not necessarily
need to be only positive. Herbicides and insecticides raised agricultural yields
but turned out to accumulate in food chains and therefore threatened wildlife.
Chlorofluorocarbons made refrigerators much safer but turned out to deplete the
ozone layer that protects life from solar UV radiation. These technologies created
catastrophic side effects.
A different category of effects is much harder to assess: the effects that are not
directly caused by a new technology itself, but by the changes in human behavior
that it provokes. Cars did not just replace horses and carriages, but created a new
freedom of movement. One of the effects of this new freedom was commuting.
Another was the transfer of downtown shopping areas to outskirt shopping malls.
These impacts dramatically changed cities and the nearby countryside. Generally,
these indirect effects are hardly foreseen.
It is important to assess and discuss the impacts of a new technology in an
early stage of its development: Then, the technologies might still be adapted.
Technology Assessment aims at assessing the impacts of new technologies.
However, impacts of new technology can hardly be assessed in a neutral and
factual way: Assessing all effects is generally impossible but choosing a focus
of impact is a political choice. Moreover, by which standards should effects be
evaluated? Sometimes, new technologies create new issues for which society
has no widely accepted ethical standards. Therefore, not only impacts should be
assessed but also new normative standards should be developed. The involvement
of stakeholders in this process is crucial. Genetic modification introduced the
K.F. Mulder
Technology Policy and Management, Delft University of Technology, Delft, The Netherlands
e-mail: K.F.Mulder@tudelft.nl
1 Introduction
Many social conflicts stem from the problem of allocation of society’s output:
problems in which somehow it should be decided who will benefit from natural
resources and the yields of economic production. The solutions for these allocation
problems form the core of the major ideologies. Technology and technological
innovation do not play a major part in those ideologies. In history, conservatives,
liberals, socialists, and communists were generally all appreciating the increases of
quality and quantity of production, as the bounty to be allocated. A common view
of technological development in the 1950s was that although some individuals were
disadvantaged by the introduction of a specific new technology, it was evident that
society as a whole would always benefit from it: technology meant progress. A good
example of this general attitude to technology was the US chemical company
DuPont’s advertising slogan between 1935 and 1982: “Better Things for Better
Living ...Through Chemistry.”
45 Impact of New Technologies 819
The general consensus was that technology was a blessing for society, “Manna
from Heaven.” The development of new technology was considered not to be a
“zero-sum game” (redistributing a given amount), but something society benefits
from – a “positive-sum game” (redistributing a growing amount). Therefore,
discussing the merits of new technologies was pointless: every doubt concerning
new technologies implied doubting societal progress. The study of the impacts of
new technology was in this view a waste of time and money. What was interesting to
governments and the business sector, however, was to know in which technological
areas breakthroughs were imminent. These breakthroughs would open up new and
interesting commercial or military perspectives. Hence, technological forecasting
was being done on a fairly large scale, just to invest in the “right” technologies, and
be prepared for the changes that it would bring.
Discount card systems might enable retailers to make their marketing efforts more efficient
by targeting the right customers for their products. However, the information that is obtained
might be used to connect customers to certain patterns of behavior. If not forbidden by law,
for example people with unhealthy life styles might be identified and this information might
be sold to health insurance companies. Because of similar threats, some people refuse these
cards, while others swap cards, making the obtained information useless.
In the early 1970s, the increasing public attention for the negative consequences
of technology created a need for a new kind of assessment which would warn
of unwanted effects of new technology, and which would provide options for
controlling its course of development: Technology Assessment.
Technology Assessment is the systematic identification, analysis and evaluation of the
potential secondary consequences (whether beneficial or detrimental) of technology in
terms of its impacts on social, cultural, political, economic and environmental systems and
processes. Technology Assessment is intended to provide a neutral, factual input into the
decision-making process (Vary Coates, quoted by Smits 1984).
Science needs equipment. Big Science (Weinberg 1961) needs big equipment which
consumes large amounts of energy and materials. The Large Hadron Collider (LHC)
of CERN, for example, consumes about 120 MW when it is in operation (Large
Hadron Collider 2010). The impact of space research might also be considerable as
satellite launches require considerable amounts of fuel, and emit their exhaust gases
in most vulnerable layers of the atmosphere.
822 K.F. Mulder
emerge from technology. Some technologies had, for example, unforeseen charac-
teristics. According to the established theory in 1903, flying was impossible when
the Wright brothers took off. In 1921, almost two decades later, the German scientist
Prandtl theoretically explained how wings could carry an aircraft by developing a
new “wing theory” (Darrigol 2005, p. 302 ff.).
There is strong belief that pure knowledge is “good” as it creates more options
for mankind, or liberates mankind from the darkness of ignorance. The “harm”
is then caused by applied science that sometimes uses pure knowledge for “bad”
causes. However, that is clearly a simplification. Around the world, the application
of science in technology is now the main reason for funding it.
Applications of scientific discoveries create fame for researchers. Hence, they
often become strong proponents of the application of their own discoveries.
Disadvantages are then easily forgotten or neglected. As these disadvantages are
often unprecedented phenomena, it might take a while before the public will hear
of them. This postpones controversy, but at the same time, might harm the trust of
the general public in science in general, or in specific scientific disciplines. For that
reason, US biochemists organized the Asilomar Conference on Recombinant DNA
in 1975 and formulated recommendations for scientists that should prevent disasters
caused by the escape of genetically modified organisms from laboratory conditions
(Berg et al. 1975).
Radical
Architectural
Market Niche Innovation
Innovation
Change
Architectural Innovations
Architectural innovations affect both market relations and the technological core
competencies of a firm. This implies that the firm develops both new technologies
and new relations with consumers and suppliers.
The implication is that architectural innovations create both great opportunities
and great risks. The opportunity is in developing a whole new market. The risks are
large as so much can go wrong: Consumers might react in unforeseen ways, other
companies in the supply chain might develop new activities, competitors might react
to that, new regulations might be triggered, etc.
On the technology side, risks might also be considerable: Will the technological
principle work at large scale, will it be providing the service at lowest cost vis-à-vis
competing technologies, and will it be the most efficient technology in the future?
Architectural innovations change the technological system as well as the societal
system in which they are embedded. Successful architectural innovations can be
extremely rewarding for the innovating firm. They might also contribute strongly to
sustainable development as is required by the various authors that argued in favor of
Factor 4, 10, 20, X.
Very often, the revolutionary potential of architectural innovations is not directly
recognized. It was not by coincidence that the first cars looked like horse and
carriage (Fig. 45.2).
Architectural innovation changes the world in an only partially foreseeable way.
It might therefore solve problems while at the same time create new problems
that are initially not recognized. The car was initially considered an environmental
innovation: Horse manure, urine, and horse carcasses left in the streets of cities
Fig. 45.2 Peugeot type 6 Phaeton avec Capote, 1894 (Foto courtesy Louwman Museum,
Den Haag)
826 K.F. Mulder
Niche Innovation
Niche innovation aims at increasing the usability of a product or service by
adapting it to a specific user category. A classic example showing the distinction
between niche and technological systems innovation is in the early development
of the car: While Henry Ford was on a technological systems innovation track,
moving assembly belts into his plants to lower costs, General Motors’ Alfred
Sloan established annual styling changes that boosted the car market. Sloan also
established a structure of car models and prices, which allowed GM to keep their
customers as their buying power and preferences changed as they aged.
Niche innovation can have various SD effects:
• It might optimize the use of a product or service by adapting it to the specific
demands of market segments.
• It leads to a differentiation of products and therefore makes recycling and reuse
harder.
• It boosts consumption (as was GM’s intention) by planned obsolescence: By
giving a product a status value (either by fashion or by price) people can be
persuaded to buy a new car before it is technologically necessary.
Incremental Innovation
Incremental innovations are the daily routines of RTD organizations. Energy
efficiency and materials efficiency are almost always among these routines just as
increasing efficiency of labor, and reducing maintenance costs. The improvements
are generally small but accumulate and are therefore important in the long run.
45 Impact of New Technologies 827
To analyze the impact of new technology it is not sufficient to forecast the likely
course of development of that technology. It is crucial to obtain insight in the views
of groups and organizations, which are relevant stakeholders for the technology.
Their views, in combination with foreseeable dynamics of a technology and market,
are the basis for Socio-technical maps. The following scheme presents a process for
making a Socio-technical map.
0. Bounding of the technical system (will it be a map of the car, the engine, or for
instance the electrical engine) and time frame.
1. Construction of a crude tree showing hierarchy of technical alternatives and
mechanisms, which determine the selection between them, plotted against time,
meaning which alternatives are being worked on and what choices are made
in the process. Attention is also paid to alternatives that can be developed on
separate tracks in other developments.
2. Characterizing the alternatives according to contents (cognitive) and origins
(social). Which stakeholders are trying to get which items onto the agenda?
In the characterization of contents, attention is also paid to expectations, links
between alternative technologies (for instance coupling to base technologies),
and any missing knowledge. In this characterization also the relationships
between stakeholders generating alternatives are included.
3. Does trajectory formation occur (i.e., subsequent technologies based on a similar
idea)? Trajectory formation is often linked to specific expectations regarding
technological progress, which results in disregarding alternative technologies.
Various different actors (legislators, research organizations, or even users) get
involved in the trajectory and adapt themselves toward this development.
4. What are the impacts of the different alternatives? Are these impacts acknowl-
edged by stakeholders, and how are they taken into account?
5. Are there critical episodes in the technological development? How can those
fractures be characterized in both a cognitive and social way? What roles do the
different stakeholders play in this?
6. Which stakeholders are not involved in the development now, but are foreseen to
be involved? How are their stakes taken into account? Has there been any check
if these stakeholders perceived their roles, as is envisaged by the technology
promoters?
828 K.F. Mulder
The making of a Socio-technical map can be carried out with various levels of detail.
For a thorough check, the technology has to be monitored intensely and a large
number of interviews are needed to chart the positions of the different stakeholders.
Often a quicker check is wished for, to see if there should be cause for concern: The
innovation impact checklist presented here consists of three parts:
• Research and development work
• Product
• Production process
“Product” in this case means that which is the intended final result (and usually
is sold); “production process” means the steps taken to produce this product; and
“technology” signifies the product, production process, and knowledge incorporated
into these (Mulder 1996).
A: How acceptable is the research and development work that accompanies the
formation of the new product and its production process?
1) Do counteracting social forces exist against the methods used in the research
and/or development work or against the collection and storage of certain
data?
2) Is the research and development work scientifically interesting or does the
development of this technology provide a special contribution to a technical
and/or scientific discipline(s)?
3) Can it be foreseen that investing in the development of a technology at this
moment could prevent a better alternative from being developed in the future?
A1) These points can be considered in this case:
• Safety of the research for researchers and people living in the neigh-
borhood regarding for instance the release of poison, manipulated
organisms, radiation, etc.
• Abuse of test animals or test subjects (people)
• Possible forms of abuse of research data for socially controversial
ends such as weapons of mass destruction, gaining access to private
information, race-based discrimination, etc.
• Mistrust toward researchers, which are carrying out the research (Cf.,
Faustus, Dr. Jekyll, and Dr. Strangelove)
A2) Disconnected from the eventual results a research or development
project can sometimes provide a powerful stimulus to other technolo-
gies and disciplines. Many examples are known. For instance, the
construction of the closeable Oosterscheldt storm surge barrier in the
Netherlands yielded new hydrological technology that is now applied
for New Orleans sea coast defenses.
A3) This problem occurs quite often: Investing in an improved waste-
incineration process that prevents the forming of dioxins makes de-
veloping a more environmentally friendly alternative to PVC later on
less attractive. Investing in a more efficient petrol engine means that the
development of the electrical car will suffer as a result.
45 Impact of New Technologies 829
11) What does new technology mean for the development of Third World coun-
tries? Are relations between global trade blocks influenced by production?
C9) Items to consider here are unemployment, destruction of capital (both
private and public) in this and other sectors. Reduction of employment
opportunities and/or investments can lead to powerful protests when it
concerns groups that are well organized. When current employment
opportunities can be maintained and the destruction of capital can be
avoided, these protests can be soothed.
C10) Technologies sometimes can radically change the balance of social
power. This is related to C4, also. The position of employees or the
union can be undermined when tightly organized professions become
obsolete, the government gains power over the citizens (and often also
over lower-level governments) by linking databases, and a company
can sometimes reinforce its position regarding its suppliers or clients.
This can lead to resistance within the groups losing their position
of power. Infamous is the resistance of British unions against some
technological changes (for instance in the mining industry).
C11) New technology can spell the death-knell for the development of
regions in the Third World. A more economical use of resources born
of environmental considerations (or a replacement by other resources
such as was the case with phosphates in detergents) can often lead to
a dramatic reduction in exports for an underdeveloped region. New
technology can also have consequences in trade politics.
About halfway through the eighties the claims which were implicit in the definitions
of Technology Assessment (foreseeing all impacts) turned out to be unattainable.
Moreover, Technology Assessment was being criticized as technocratic: By aiming
at a full assessment of consequences of a new technology, it could initiate a process
in which the decision makers could already formulate the replies to various kinds of
objections of stakeholders. So instead of leading toward democratizing technology,
it could lead to “repressive tolerance” (Wynne 1975).
Gradually, discussions with stakeholders regarding impacts of new technologies
and aiming at influencing the course of technology development became more
important. The approach of Constructive Technology Assessment was intended as
an answer to this challenge. It aimed at broadening decision-making processes and
focused on influencing technological decisions in an early stage. The implication
of this change is widening Technology Assessment from mainly a desk activity
to a far more social process involving interactions with various stakeholders (Rip
et al. 1995, See also: Engineers and Community: How Sustainable Engineering
Depends on Engineers Views of People). However, impact analyses, future studies,
creativity tools, etc., remain essential as they create the basis for stakeholder
interaction (Van den Ende et al. 1998).
834 K.F. Mulder
6 Summary
In this chapter the impact of new technologies on society has been discussed and the
way in which this impact has been perceived in the twentieth century. Difficulties
in foreseeing impacts have been discussed, and a checklist, including examples, has
been presented to assess societal impacts of new technologies.
References
W. Abernathy, W. Clark, Innovation: mapping the winds of creative destruction. Res. Policy 14(1),
3–22 (1985)
P. Berg, D. Baltimore, S. Brenner, R.O. Roblin III, M.F. Singer, Summary statement of the asilomar
conference on recombinant DNA molecules. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 72(6), 1981–1984 (1975)
B. Bimber, D.H. Guston, Technology assessment: the end of OTA (special issue). Technol.
Forecast. Soc. Change 54, 2–3 (1997)
G. Böhme, W. van den Daele, W. Krohn, Die Finalisierung der wissenschaft. in Theorien der
Wissenschaftsgeschichte, ed. by W. Diederich (Suhrkamp, Frankfurt, 1974), pp. 276–311
R.L. Carson, L. Darling, Silent Spring (Riverside Press, Cambridge, 1962)
D. Collingridge, The Social Control of Technology (Pinter Publishing, London, 1980)
O. Darrigol, Worlds of Flow, A History of Hydrodynamics from the Bernouillis to Prandtl (Oxford
University Press, New York, 2005)
J. Habermass, Wissenschaft und Technik als Ideologie (Suhrkamp, Frankfurt, 1968)
W.S. Jevons, The Coal Question, an Inquiry Concerning the Progress of the Nation and the
Probable Exhaustion of Our Coal Mines (MacMillan & Co, London, 1866), http://www.
econlib.org/library/YPDBooks/Jevons/jvnCQCover.html. Accessed 18 Feb 2010
Large Hadron Collider website, http://lhc-machine-outreach.web.cern.ch/lhc-machine-outreach/
faq/lhc-energy-consumption.htm. Accessed 16 Feb 2010
R. Meyers, DES: The Bitter Pill (Seaview, New York, 1983)
K.F. Mulder, Maatschappelijke Aanvaarding van Duurzame Technologie (Programma DTO, Delft,
1996), available at: http://www.dto-kov.nl/themas/index-cultuur.htm
NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory, Cassini Equinox Mission (2010a), http://saturn.jpl.nasa.gov/
spacecraft/safety/. Accessed 16 Feb 2010
NASA Scientific and Technical Information (2010b), http://www.sti.nasa.gov/tto/. Accessed 16
Feb 2010
A. Rip, J. Schot, T. Misa, Managing Technology in Society. The Approach of Constructive
Technology Assessment (Pinter Publishers, London/New York, 1995)
R. Smits, De hernieuwde belangstelling voor technology assessment. Wetenschap & Samenleving
11(1), 16–25 (1984)
J. Tarr, C. McShane, The centrality of the horse to the nineteenth-century American City (2009),
http://www.enviroliteracy.org/article.php/578.html. Accessed 5 June 2009
UCS (Union of Concerned Scientists), Scientific Integrity in Policymaking, an Investigation into the
Bush Administration’s Misuse of Science (UCS, Cambridge, 2004), available at: http://www.
ucsusa.org/scientific integrity/abuses of science/scientific-integrity-in-1.html
J. Van den Ende, K. Mulder, M. Knot, E. Moors, P. Vergragt, Traditional and Modern Technology
Assessment, Towards a Toolkit, Technol. Forecast. Soc. Change 58, 5–21 (1998)
45 Impact of New Technologies 835
Abstract
Life cycle assessment (LCA) has become one of the most widely applied
scientific and industrial methods for estimating environmental impacts of prod-
ucts and services. While the necessity to adopt a life cycle perspective as
such was rather quickly accepted, the practical application of LCA has met
considerable doubt and lagged behind. Strong contributing factors for this slow
adaptation have been (i) a poor understanding of the LCA idea as such, (ii) a
lack of useful tools for routine application of LCA, (iii) a lack of useful data
and databases, (iv) poorly developed practices and processes for monitoring and
data acquisition in industry and society in general, and (v) a general resistance to
introduce a new concept. Now that these barriers gradually are being overcome,
there is a need for some second and critical thoughts around the usefulness
and practical applicability of LCA as a standard routine procedure in society.
While doubtlessly having contributed to a revolution in systems thinking, the
practical current application of LCA has several shortcomings: (i) There is a
poor link between estimated emissions and (ia) the geographical location of
them and (ib) the occurrence in time of them, (ii) an LCA rarely discusses the
total emissions from a production site or service system since emissions are
reported and discussed in relation to the functional unit, (iii) the methodology
for LCA demands both categorization of material and energy flows into a
large number of impact categories while in practice only a few are selected
and sometimes in a rather arbitrary way, based more on the availability of
data than based on relevance, (iv) the necessity to pull the assessment through
the impact stage requires considerable extra skills and work by the assessing
B. Frostell
Assistant Professor Industrial Ecology, Department of Industrial Ecology, School of Industrial
Engineering and Management KTH – Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, Sweden
e-mail: frostell@kth.se
industry or agent, (v) when gradually more complex systems are being assessed,
the system boundaries become more difficult to identify and the assessor faces the
challenge to assess life cycles in different dimensions. The chapter describes the
gradual development of life cycle thinking, LCA, and other life cycle thinking
tools. It argues for a more differentiated application of life cycle thinking in
practical tools in order to increase the practical usefulness of this important
approach.
1 Introduction
2. The carbon dioxide concentration in the atmosphere has increased by nearly 30%
since the industrial revolution.
3. More atmospheric nitrogen is fixed by humanity than by all natural terrestrial
sources combined.
4. More than half of all accessible surface freshwater is put to human use.
5. About one quarter of the bird species on Earth have been driven to extinction.
6. Approximately two-thirds of major marine fisheries are fully exploited, overex-
ploited, or depleted.
In a thorough discussion of human impact on the ecological systems of the planet,
Lubchenko (1998) concluded that:
The individual and collective changes described above are so different in magnitude, scale
and kind from past changes that even our best records and models offer little guidance
concerning the scale or even the character of likely responses to these challenges. The
future is quite likely to involve increasing rates of change; greater variance in system
parameters; greater uncertainty about responses of complex biological, ecological, social,
and political systems; and more surprises. The world at the end of the 20th century is a
fundamentally different world from the one in which the current scientific enterprise has de-
veloped. The challenges for society are formidable and will require substantial information,
knowledge, wisdom, and energy from the scientific community. Business as usual will not
suffice.
During the last decade, much focus in the environmental debate has been on
the risks for increasing costs of climate change mitigation (cf. Stern Review 2006).
This has actually overshadowed both the other challenges and more seriously the
compound challenge of all changes as a whole.
Life cycle assessment (LCA) of products and services is a very recent approach to
estimate, analyze, and discuss the environmental impact of products and services.
The start of this development in the late 1960s has been described by Boustead
(1996), and a recent broad survey was published by Finnveden et al. (2009).
A widely used practical guide to LCA was published by Baumann and Tillman
(2004).
Invented and improved by engineers, LCA has later been standardized by
the International Standards Organization (latest version ISO 2006a, b). LCA has
become one of the most widely applied scientific and industrial methods for
estimating environmental impacts of products and services. While the importance
to adopt a life cycle perspective was rather quickly accepted, the practical routine
application of LCA in industry and society has lagged behind. Strong contributing
factors to this slow adaptation have been (i) a poor understanding of the LCA idea as
such, (ii) a lack of useful tools for routine application of LCA, (iii) a lack of useful
data and data bases, (iv) poorly developed practices and processes for monitoring
and data acquisition in industry and society in general, and (v) a general resistance
to introduce a new concept.
In this chapter, life cycle thinking as a basis for and broader concept than LCA
will be presented and discussed, together with possible applications of life cycle
thinking besides LCA.
840 B. Frostell
The main aim of this chapter is to inspire and encourage engineers, economists, and
others to devote more effort to life cycle thinking and a more holistic and systems
oriented work with (mainly) quantitative methods and tools to account for material
and energy flows in connection to human activities. Important objectives of the work
are to:
• Present a pathway of original thinking on how to make the vision of (ecologi-
cally) sustainable development more operational
• Describe and define the term life cycle thinking and its application in practice
with the use of different tools and methods
• Discuss possible explanations to the slow penetration of knowledge from life
cycle thinking to practice
• Suggest a development path for a mandatory more extensive use of life cycle
thinking tools for improved overall resource management
Traditionally, the SD vision has been presented and discussed as the so-called
triple bottom line approach (Elkington 2004; cf. Clift 1998). The term “triple
bottom line” refers to taking responsibility for three different pillars of a sustainable
development: economic, ecological, and social aspects. Typically, this is expressed
as three partially overlapping circles, intuitively giving equal weight to the three
aspects of sustainable development. Later, this view has been questioned and
other interpretations given (Giddings et al. 2002; cf. Strandberg and Frostell
2006).
In Fig. 46.1, an idea transformation path from traditional technical/economic
development to operational sustainability work is presented, showing:
(a) The traditional thinking emphasizing technical/economic development only
(b) The triple bottom line interpretation of sustainable development as based to
equal shares on technical/economic, social, and ecologic issues
(c) A nested interpretation (Giddings et al. 2002), emphasizing the ultimate depen-
dence of both the economic and the social system on the ecological capacity of
the global system
(d) A more detailed interpretation of the nested principal picture, showing the
physical metabolic interaction between human activities (including the formal
economy) and the global system as well as the social interaction between human
activities and the economy
Interpreting sustainable development using the last model in Fig. 46.1d allows
us to start discussing necessary actions to support sustainable development. In
Fig. 46.2, the metabolic expression of sustainable development is shown in more
detail.
46 Life Cycle Thinking for Improved Resource Management: LCA or? 841
a b c
Ecological
Social
Technical/ Social
Ecological
Economical Eco-
nomical
Technical/
Economical
d
Energy interaction
The Globe
Physical
metabolic interactions Human
energy & materials activities
Formal
Social interaction economy
System
Fig. 46.1 A thought path from traditional strive for technical/economic development (a) to the
triple bottom line approach to sustainable development (b), a nested sustainable development view
where economy is dependent on society and both on the environment (c) arriving at an operational
view of sustainability challenges in the form of both a physical metabolic interaction between
human activities and the global system and social interactions between the three parts of the global
system
Human
activities
Energy interaction
Formal
economy
Social interaction
• Social organization
System
• Distribution of resources
• Equity and power distribution
• Emotional interaction
Fig. 46.2 More detailed explanation of important interactions between different subsystems of
the overall global system. In this way of viewing the global system, it comprises human activities
as a subsystem and this in turn comprises the formal economy as a subsystem. Physical metabolic
interaction occurs between the global system and the entire human system (including the formal
economy). The formal economy is exchange of goods and services for money. Life cycle thinking
aims to include as many aspects as possible of the interactions between the human activities and
the global system into resource management and thus into the formal economy
842 B. Frostell
Life cycle thinking is a strive to think in a more holistic way and consider a
broader set of interactions between human activities and the global system, be they
of physical, economic, or social character. Life cycle thinking tries to understand
(i) physical resource interactions and (ii) social resource interactions between
(ia and iia) human individuals and different social groups and entities in the
formal economy, (ib and iib) the formal economy and other human activities, and
(ic and iic) human activities and the global system. Social interactions could be, for
example, formal business activities between different parties, but also well-being
during a mountain hike or fear for wild animals when walking in the forest. Life
cycle thinking is strongly linked to resource management in all aspects relevant to
consider and is thus economy in its broadest sense. In a sustainable development
context, it involves considering economic, ecologic, and social aspects in an
integrated and preferably quantitative way, but also using qualitative considerations
when quantification cannot be achieved. In Fig. 46.3, some currently used methods
in the three core pillars of the triple bottom line approach to sustainable development
are shown.
Life cycle thinking is in practice almost impossible to implement in a satisfactory
way. This is because of the following:
Life Cycle
Thinking
Footprints RA
Fig. 46.3 Important life cycle thinking oriented methods – life cycle costing (LCC), cost-benefit
analysis (CBA), life cycle inventory (LCI), life cycle assessment (LCA), environmental impact
assessment (EIA), strategic environmental assessment (SEA), ecological footprint metrics (Foot-
prints), social impact assessment (SIA), multi-criteria analysis (MCA), and risk assessment (RA)
46 Life Cycle Thinking for Improved Resource Management: LCA or? 843
• The global system (the world including atmosphere, lithosphere, and biosphere
with society) is such an incredibly large and complex entity that we know only
very little about its details and the interactions between different sub-entities.
• A large part of the interactions in the overall global system are of a social
character between individuals, groups of individuals, or based on feelings, where
our understanding of the detailed mechanisms and outcomes is still and perhaps
forever impossible to predict quantitatively and/or with reliability.
• Only very recently have individuals and groups of individuals started to practice
life cycle thinking and thus there is still a subcritical mass of people seeing the
values of it.
• The results and suggestions for change emerging from life cycle thinking
many times stand in contradiction to personal and group interests and thus are
very difficult to accept for individuals and groups that may lose influence and
resources.
• Life cycle thinking favors long-term thinking over short term and therefore is in
contradiction to many aspects of current formal economy.
It is here recognized that life cycle thinking as defined above is extremely broad
and impossible to cover satisfactorily here. For this reason, combined with a belief
that the physical aspects of life cycle thinking – the world’s physical metabolism of
energy and materials – are the most burning issues for social stability and welfare in
the next decades, the following discussion will be focused on life cycle thinking for
improved resource management, here named physical resource life cycle thinking
(PR Life Cycle Thinking).
PR life cycle thinking emphasizes that raw materials and energy may be used and
emissions produced in many different places and parts of the world as a consequence
of operating a production and consumption system. It is thus not enough to discuss
the raw material use and emissions in a specific place. Instead, all the different
phases in a combined production and consumption chain need to be recognized. In
PR life cycle thinking, energy as well as materials metabolism as well as broader
implications of them, such as environmental impacts and economic and social
implications, are considered. From early life cycle–oriented research, it has become
clear that an increased reuse and recirculation of products and materials will result
in a lower overall resource use and emissions and thus higher overall efficiency. In
the future, a decreased raw material use, decreased waste production, and increased
recycling of materials may therefore be foreseen as illustrated in Fig. 46.4.
In Fig. 46.4, the traditional picture of a life cycle of a product system is depicted.
It is important to note that this way of illustrating the life cycle has no spatial
(geographical) connection or definition. This fact – that the traditional LCA does
not locate the resource use and the emissions of a product or service system – has
been a problem in some applications of life cycle thinking and LCA methodology.
A different means of expressing a life cycle system has been used in education at
KTH, The Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm. This way of discussing a life
cycle defines three principal stages in the life cycle with a special emphasis on the
so-called core system (cf. Eriksson and Frostell 2000). Depending on who is the
principal stakeholder – the stakeholder interested in the inventory (and assessment)
844 B. Frostell
Transportation
Distribution
Recycle
Fig. 46.4 The principal life cycle of a product (rearranged and developed from SETAC 1991)
of the entire life cycle system – the core system represents the part of the life cycle
that belongs to this principal stakeholder. The core system therefore could be, for
example, a product line in a factory in a production/consumption chain, a factory in
a production/consumption chain, a service system, or a waste management system
in a production/consumption chain.
Life cycle assessment has gradually developed into a highly standardized procedure
for assessment of environmental impacts of a product or a service (cf. ISO 2006a,
b). Many commercial tools for routine LCA are available and the European
Commission has published an evaluation of different approaches to LCA (Reimann
et al. 2012). In the previously mentioned recent review of LCA, Finnveden et al.
(2009) points at a few important challenges of current LCA practices. The most
important of them were considered to be the following:
• The product system is extended in time and space, and the emission inventory
is often aggregated in a form which restricts knowledge about the geographical
location of the individual emissions.
• The LCA results are also typically unaccompanied by information about the
temporal course of the emission or the resulting concentrations in the receiving
environment.
46 Life Cycle Thinking for Improved Resource Management: LCA or? 845
• The functional unit of the LCA refers to the assessment of an often rather small
unit.
• The LCA thus has to operate on mass loads representing a share (often near
infinitesimal) of the full emission output from the process.
Now that LCA is more widely used, the methodology sees other and perhaps
more serious problems and challenges. While doubtlessly having contributed to
a revolution in systems thinking, the practical application of LCA has several
shortcomings, for example, (i) the current methodology for LCA demands both
categorization of material and energy flows into a number of impact categories
that in practice typically are picked in a rather arbitrary way (an arbitrary selection
of impact categories in practical LCAs), often based rather on the availability
of data than on relevance, (ii) the necessity to pull the assessment through the
impact stage requires considerable extra skills and work by the assessing industry
or agent, and (iii) when gradually more complex systems are being assessed, the
system boundaries become more and difficult to identify and the assessor faces the
challenge to assess life cycles in different dimensions (see more below).
The first footprinting concept that reached a broad worldwide recognition was the
ecological footprint (EF). Originally developed by Wackernagel and Rees (1996),
it has developed into a worldwide activity of accounting, where national footprints
are estimated and summed up to a global footprint by the Global Footprint Network
(GFN 2012).
The ecological footprint is a very pedagogic and illustrative indicator of ecologic
sustainability. It is calculated as the land area needed to provide current social
products and services in a sustainable way (with the best available technology;
Wackernagel and Rees 1996). The EF calculated is compared with the available land
area, and if the latter is smaller than the EF, the current situation is unsustainable.
EFs may be calculated for the world, nations, regions, individuals, and other entities.
Very obvious from EF calculations is that cities need a much larger area than they
occupy themselves and thus are totally unsustainable if not connected to rural areas
where resources for the city can be produced.
Alarmingly, according to the EF indicator, the world grand EF is larger than
the available productive land area on Earth (app. 30% larger). If all people on
Earth lived as in the west, we would currently need four to five earths according
to the EF method. Besides footprints as discussed above, the EF network calculates,
publishes, and discusses the so-called EF overshoot day. The EF overshoot day is
that calendar day of the year when the EF of that actual year is larger than the
available land area to serve the global population under current living conditions.
Calculated according to the EF methodology, the world overshoot day comes earlier
and earlier each year, indicating that from an ecological point of view, we are
846 B. Frostell
still departing from a more sustainable development despite more than 20 years
of intense debate and many years of political commitments to work for a more
sustainable development.
The EF methodology has been criticized as being nonscientific and thus not a
reliable indicator (cf. Van den Bergh and Verbruggen 1999; Ayres 2000). Fiala
(2008) criticizes it as (i) assuming zero greenhouse gas emissions in the technologies
used, (ii) using national and regional boundaries for footprint calculations that do
not account for the flexibility of the current global economy, and (iii) not considering
productivity increases in agriculture and thus not allowing showing the possibilities
of intense agriculture. He proposes to use methods that account more directly for
physical phenomena such as emissions of carbon dioxide and degradation of land.
Nevertheless the EF has reached a widespread application globally, thanks to its
very pedagogic name and indicator (a physical area).
Energetics. Their method is based on energy flow studies in different industries and
on development of energy balances. One study focused on the chemical industry
energy footprint (Energetics 2012) and was much recognized. Triantou (2009)
used LCI cradle to gate system boundaries to calculate energy, carbon, and water
footprints for three AkzoNobel plants producing chemicals for the pulp and paper
industry.
The Greenhouse Gas Protocol (GFN 2012) is an accounting tool for governments
and business leaders to understand, quantify, and manage greenhouse gas emissions.
For more than a decade, the World Resources Institute (WRI) and the World
Business Council for Sustainable Development (WBCSD) have cooperated with
different stakeholders to develop the idea and use it together with businesses,
governments, and environmental groups for combating climate change.
The GHG protocol is supplemented by a number of electronic calculation tools,
freely available on the GHG Protocol website (www.ghgprotocol.org/). Guidance
on calculating GHG emissions from specific sources (e.g., stationary and mobile
combustion, process emissions) and industry sectors (e.g., cement, pulp and paper
aluminum, iron and steel and office-based organizations) is also provided. It covers
the accounting and reporting of the six greenhouse gases covered by the United
Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change.
The carbon footprint is a measure of the total releases of climate impact gases
caused by a business activity or for a product. It may be regarded as a simplified
LCI (life cycle inventory) of carbon (or carbon dioxide equivalents) for the activity
or product. As such, in practice, it may be calculated in different ways. A first
attempt to create a standard for carbon footprinting was presented in a first edition
of The Greenhouse Gas Protocol: A Corporate Accounting and Reporting Standard,
published in 2001 and revised in 2004 (GGPI 2012).
The standard is based on reporting three types of direct and indirect emissions
and covering six greenhouse gases (CO2 , CH4 , N2 O, SF6 , HFCs, and PFCs). For
each of the emissions considered in the carbon footprint, the contribution from the
above-mentioned six compounds is calculated in the form of CO2 equivalents and
added up to the footprint.
In Fig. 46.6, the carbon footprint methodology according to GHG protocol has
been compared to a principal LCI, dividing the entire life cycle of a product,
a process, or a service into the three stages core system, upstream system, and
downstream system. Here it is clear that the carbon footprint methodology to an
important part covers an LCI of climate gases (climate impact LCI), but also
that potentially important flows are non-mandatory or not considered. Of flows
considered are, for example, carbon emissions to water and in waste, that later could
be transformed to CO2 in biological and chemical processes and cause secondary
impact. It would therefore be tempting to have a more stringent definition of the
carbon footprint, preferably in line with a strict life cycle inventory of carbon.
The water footprint (WF) analysis may serve as an indicator of overall water use
for a certain product or service chain, but may also be used to indicate water
consequences of global trade and its links to water resources management. Hoekstra
and Hung (2005) showed that over the period 1995–1999, at least 13% of the
water used for crop production was not used for domestic consumption but was
exported to other countries in virtual form. An important outcome of this finding
was the argument that virtual water trade between nations and even continents could
improve global water efficiency and enhance water security in water-scarce regions;
instead of producing water-intense products, water-scarce countries could adopt a
strategy to import them.
Industry has been increasingly interested in understanding, applying, and adapt-
ing WF methodologies in order to manage production and supply-chain water
issues. By definition, the WF of a product or a product supply chain is the total
volume of freshwater used in all parts of the product or supply chain – generally
expressed per year or per ton of product. WF thus reflects a life cycle perspective,
providing an overall estimate of a product’s water requirements. Besides being used
for industrial water management, calculation of WF is also feasible for different
groups of consumers (individual, family, municipality, nation etc.).
Besides for products and community groups, a WF can also be calculated for
different business operations, giving a picture of both a company’s freshwater
requirements and water use at the product or service scale, offering a business
sustainability indicator (Chapagain and Orr 2009). A corporate or business WF here
corresponds to the total volume of freshwater used directly or indirectly to operate
and support the business; it comprises two components: the operational or direct
WF and the supply-chain or indirect WF (cf. Gerbens-Leenes et al. 2009).
46 Life Cycle Thinking for Improved Resource Management: LCA or? 849
7 Discussion
embedment in the globe system. The practical application of life cycle thinking is
still in its infancy and involves many, many different activities, practices, methods,
and tools. Emanating from the physical resource side, most of the discussion hitherto
has focused on the ecological aspects of life cycle thinking. Important starting points
in this discussion have been the industrial metabolism concept (cf. Ayres 1994)
and life cycle assessments as discussed above. The European Union Joint Research
Centre defines life cycle thinking in the following way: Life Cycle Thinking (LCT)
seeks to identify possible improvements to goods and services in the form of lower
environmental impacts and reduced use of resources across all life cycle stages
(European Commission 2012a). UNEP takes a somewhat broader approach and says
that life cycle thinking . . . is about going beyond the traditional focus on production
sites and manufacturing processes so that the environmental, social, and economic
impact of a product over its entire life cycle, including the consumption and end
of use phase, is taken into account (UNEP 2012; cf. UNEP 2004). An important
point in this chapter is that life cycle thinking needs to develop in all areas of human
activity, now that we live in a globalized economy.
To some extent, life cycle thinking may still be regarded as somewhat irrational
in ordinary business activities, since no economic laws, business operations, envi-
ronmental permits, or other regulations require it. An important first step, however,
toward a more mandatory life cycle thinking may be found in the so-called extended
producer responsibility (EPR) concept that has gradually been introduced in the
environmental laws in different countries. OECD defines EPR as an environmental
policy approach in which a producer’s responsibility, physical and/or financial,
is extended to the post-consumer part of the product’s life cycle (OECD 2001).
In Sweden, that has been a forerunner in this area, EPR has been introduced in
regulation of the following six product groups (cf. SEPA 2005):
• Packages
• Batteries
• Cars
• Electronics
• Drugs
• Radioactive products and noncontrolled radiation sources
In Sweden, the EPR involves a mandatory requirement for producers to collect
and handle used products in an environmentally responsible way. It is an instrument
to reach the national environmental goals and the aim is to motivate producers to
develop products that are less resource demanding, easier to recycle, and do not
contain hazardous compounds.
From a principal point of view, it is interesting to note that the ERP initiative
only extends the responsibility from the core system to the downstream system in
the principal life cycle system depicted in Fig. 46.5. Nothing is stated about the
upstream system and thus the life cycle thinking in ERP is only partial.
46 Life Cycle Thinking for Improved Resource Management: LCA or? 851
Materials Materials
Upstream Core Downstream
FLOWS FLOWS
Energy system system system Energy
Fig. 46.5 An illustration of physical resource life cycle thinking (PR life cycle thinking)
emphasizing the core system complemented by an upstream and a downstream system and thus
allowing a geographical connection of life cycle thinking. The core system is always subject to
mandatory environmental impact assessment (EIA), legal permits, and legal reporting practices
Materials Materials
Upstream Core Downstream
FLOWS FLOWS
Energy system system system Energy
Fig. 46.6 Comparison between the GHG Network definition of carbon footprint ingredients and
a division of the life cycle of products, processes, and services in an upstream, a core and a
downstream system, permitting also a geographical allocation of metabolism
852 B. Frostell
System boundary discussions represent an important aspect of LCA and life cycle
thinking. The system boundaries define what is included in an appraisal or assess-
ment and what is excluded. When a studied system is small and easily understood,
the system boundaries are rather easy to identify and communicate. With LCA –
that in itself by definition represents a system broadening – system boundaries
increasingly cause discussion and problems. Guinée et al. (2002) identified three
major types of system boundaries in the LCI phase of LCA:
• Between the technical system and the environment
• Between significant and insignificant processes
• Between the technological system under study and other technological systems
Finnveden et al. (2009) have a broad discussion of these three types of system
boundaries. They also mention time and geographical limits as potential boundaries,
but regard them as special cases of boundaries toward the environment or other
technological systems.
In application of LCA, the goal and scope definition phase in practice also in-
volves a system boundary definition and that implies selection of impact categories.
An inherent practical problem for all LCA applications is the difficulty to include
all impact categories in the study, most typically because of difficulties with data
availability. Thus, in a typical LCA study, only four to five impact categories are
included, despite at least ten would have a relevance for the outcome of the study.
Which are the main influencing factors in this delimitation of LCAs – and thus
definition of system boundaries – that always take place? Which impact do they
have on the final result and on the conclusions to be drawn?
Further broadening the discussion to general life cycle thinking, the identifi-
cation, decision, and implementation of system boundaries into practices form a
formidable task. This is since from a principal point of view, at least the following
system boundaries will have to be considered in life cycle thinking:
• What principal pillars of sustainability shall be included in the study (the
procedure) – economical, ecological, social?
• In what ways will the economical, ecological, and social pillars be characterized?
Impact categories, flows and stocks calculations, qualitative characterizations of
different aspects, by other means?
• How many different impact categories (flows and stocks; aspects) shall be used
for each pillar of sustainability? Which impact categories (flows and stocks;
aspects) should be selected?
• How shall the retrieved information be processed and communicated? Per func-
tional unit (LCI/LCA), per decision/responsibility unit (accounting approach, per
geographical unit, others?
• How shall the cutoff issues be handled (decisions on where to stop data
retrieval, how to allocate between different products/functions, how to han-
dle compensatory functions included to make a comparative study more
appropriate)?
46 Life Cycle Thinking for Improved Resource Management: LCA or? 853
Looking at the system boundary challenges described above, it becomes clear that
LCA and its discussion cover only a part of life cycle thinking. This makes the
selection and use of methods and tools for life cycle thinking even more difficult
and delicate than LCA application. Thus, it will be very important to find broadly
accepted approaches to practical application of life cycle thinking.
Data availability has for long been a problem in practical application of LCA and
generally for systems oriented quantitative analyses based on life cycle thinking.
This situation is rapidly improving for LCA with a number of initiatives at national
(Australia, Japan, Korea, Singapore, Taiwan, Denmark, Sweden, Switzerland,
Canada, and USA; cf. Curran and Notten 2006) and business raw material level
(aluminum, copper, iron, and steel, plastics, paper, and board; cf. Finnveden et al.
2009). Curran and Notten (2006) prepared a summary of global life cycle inventory
data resources on behalf of SETAC/UNEP. It is a thorough compilation of ongoing
activities in the world until 2006.
The European Reference Life Cycle Database (ELCD core database) has been
compiled and improved into a version II by the EU Joint Research Centre’s
Institute for Environmental and Sustainability (IES), a work that was presented
in early 2009 (European Commission 2012b). The database contains life cycle
inventory (LCI) data from different EU-level business associations and other
sources. Data are provided for key materials, such as energy carriers, transport,
and waste management and a special focus is on data quality, consistency, and
applicability.
The EU LCA Tools, Services and Data homepage (European Commission 2012c)
is an ambitious resource with extensive information on available methods, tools, and
databases for LCA practitioners.
Besides these governmental and industrial branch initiatives, there have been a
great number of different LCA tools developed, sometimes offered for free and
sometimes for a license fee. Often, commercial suppliers of LCA software have
their own databases, access to which forms an important part of the licensing idea.
Two important commercial tools are Simapro (PRé Consultants 2012) and Gabi
software (Gabi 2012). It is very interesting to note that Gabi software at the moment
offers software for a number of different life cycle thinking–related calculation tools
according to the following list (Gabi 2012):
• Life cycle assessment according to ISO 14040/14044
• Product carbon footprint
• Design for environment and ecodesign
• Environmental product declarations
• Resource and energy efficiency
• Water footprint
854 B. Frostell
Table 46.1 Potential uses of life cycle thinking and LCA by different stakeholder groups
(inspired by Wentzel et al. 1997)
Stakeholder group Application Examples
Central and local Policy formulation Resource accounting policies
governments Product policies
Community action plans Incineration versus recycling
Environmentally conscious Cars, office supplies
Public Purchases
Consumer information Ecolabels and Standards
Business Monitoring of progress in a Footprints of different kinds,
broader perspective than e.g., energy, carbon, and water
currently practiced Monitoring of social aspects of the
business
Raise environmental Identify areas for improvement
awareness
Broadening of management Product-oriented environmental
policies Environmental
management
Design choices Concept selection, Component
selection, Material selection,
Process selection
Environmental ISO certification, Ecolabels
documentation
Academia Research on products, Knowledge formation Method
services, and sociotechnical development
systems
Education LCA courses
NGOs and the public Consensus development Own assessments in preparation of
public hearings
Education Reports and results dissemination
With the broad definition of life cycle thinking used here, the number of potential
applications is very high. Hardly any research, development, or practical work
area will do without it. It should become at the center of all future resource
management discussions, be they physical or social resources in line with Figs. 46.1
and 46.2. A compilation of potential uses of life cycle thinking is presented
in Table 46.1.
8 Summary
resources, combined with excessive emissions to air, water, and soil of rest materi-
als. This cannot be sustained in the long run without a radical shift in functioning
of the system (cf. Ayres 1998). Current economic theory and practices have failed
to address this challenge in a satisfactory way, and new theories and practices
for improved overall resource management need to be invented and implemented.
A promising new conceptual approach to improved resource management is life
cycle thinking – the understanding that actions in one place may cause resource use
and emissions in many other places on earth. This new conceptual approach has led
to the development of LCA, a method to assess the overall environmental impacts
of products and services. While increasingly supporting the development of more
resource-efficient product and service systems, LCA has failed to support many
other areas where an improved resource management is important, for example,
organizations and infrastructure systems. For this, there is an urgent need to arrive at
improved information collection, accounting, and reporting practices. A recent more
popular concept is to discuss different footprints of human action. Several different
approaches to so-called footprint analyses have been discussed and promoted, such
as ecological footprints, water footprints, carbon footprints, and energy footprints.
The scientific stringency of these new approaches – as discussed within different
scientific disciplines – is, however, from an overarching industrial ecology point
of view many times doubtful. It is therefore necessary to develop scientifically
more stringent and quantitative metrics for footprints of different kinds, be they, for
example, energy footprints, carbon footprints, water footprints, nitrogen footprints,
phosphorus footprints, and others. These footprints could from a scientific point of
view very well be based on the principles for LCI (life cycle inventory) of material
and energy flows and stocks. Three primary candidates for increased footprinting
work should perhaps be energy, carbon, and water footprints.
References
R.U. Ayres, Industrial metabolism: theory and policy, in Industrial Metabolism: Restructuring for
Sustainable Development, ed. by R.U. Ayres, U.K. Simonis (United Nations University Press,
Tokyo, 1994), p. 3
R.U. Ayres, Toward a zero-emissions economy, Environmental Science & Technology/News, 1 Aug
1998, p. 366
R.U. Ayres, Commentary on the utility of the ecological footprint concept. Ecol. Econ. 3, 347
(2000)
H. Baumann, A.-M. Tillman, The Hitch Hiker’s Guide to LCA, An Orientation in Life Cycle
Assessment Methodology and Application (Studentlitteratur, Lund, 2004)
I. Boustead, LCA – how it came about, the beginning in the UK. Int. J. Life Cycle Assess. 1(3),
147 (1996)
I.L.M. Canals, J. Chenoweth, A. Chapagain, S. Orr, A. Antón, R. Clift, Assessing freshwater use
impacts in LCA: part I – inventory modelling and characterisation factors for the main impact
pathways. Int. J. Life Cycle Assess. 14(1), 28–42 (2009)
A.K. Chapagain, S. Orr, An improved water footprint methodology linking global consumption to
local water resources: a case of Spanish tomatoes. J. Environ. Manage. 90(2), (2009)
R. Clift, Engineering for the environment: the new model engineer and her role. Trans. IChemE
76B, 151 (1998)
856 B. Frostell
M.A. Curran, P. Notten, Summary of global life cycle inventory data resources, report for
SETAC/UNEP life cycle initiative, task force 1: database registry (2006), www.epa.gov/
NRMRL/lcaccess/pdfs/summary of global lci data resources.pdf
P. Dacombe, V. Krivtsov, C. Banks, S. Heaven, in An Energy and Materials Flow Model for
Evaluation of Alternatives for Processing Domestic and Commercial Waste – A Case Study
of Southampton, School of Civil Engineering & the Environment, University of Southampton,
Southampton, 2004, 171p
J. Elkington, Enter the triple bottom line, in The Triple Bottom Line: Does It all Add Up, ed. by A.
Henriques, J. Richardson (EarthScan, London, 2004)
Energetics (2012), Manufacturing Energy and Carbon Footprint, www.energetics.com/
resourcecenter/products/misc/Documents/chemicals footprint.pdf
O. Eriksson, B. Frostell, An approach to sustainability assessment of energy systems, in Chapter
14 in Building Sustainable Energy Systems – Swedish Experiences, ed. by S. Silveria (Swedish
National Energy Administration, Stockholm, 2000)
European Commission, European Platform on Life Cycle Assessment (2012a), http://lca.jrc.ec.
europa.eu/
European Commission, ELCD core database version II (2012b), http://lca.jrc.ec.europa.eu/
lcainfohub/datasetArea.vm
European Commission, LCA Resources Directory (2012c), http://lca.europa.eu/lcainfohub/
directory.vmnormally
N. Fiala, Measuring sustainability: why the ecological footprint is bad economics and bad
environmental science. Ecol. Econ. 67, 519 (2008)
G. Finnveden, M.Z. Hauschild, T. Ekvall, J. Guinée, R. Heijungs, S. Hellweg, A. Koehler, D.
Pennington, S. Suh, Recent developments in Life Cycle Assessment. J. Environ. Manage. 91,
1 (2009)
Gabi (2012), http://www.gabi-software.com
P.W. Gerbens-Leenes, A.Y. Hoekstra, Th. Van der Meer, The water footprint of energy from
biomass: A quantitative assessment and consequences of an increasing share of bio-energy
in energy supply, Ecol. Econ. 68, 1052 (2009)
GFN, Global Footprint Network (2012), www.footprintnetwork.org/en/index.php/GFN/
GGPI, The Greenhouse Gas Protocol Initiative (2012), www.ghgprotocol.org/
B. Giddings, B. Hopwood, G. O’Brian, Environment, economy and society: fitting them together
into sustainable development. Sustain. Dev. 10(4), 187 (2002)
J.B. Guinée, M. Gorrée, R. Heijungs, G. Huppes, R. Kleijn, A. de Koning, L. van Oers, A.
Wegener Sleeswijk, S. Suh, H.A. Udo de Haes, J.A. de Bruijn, R. van Duin, M.A.J. Huijbregts,
Handbook on Life Cycle Assessment: Operational Guide to the ISO Standards. Series: Eco-
efficiency in Industry and Science (Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, 2002)
A.Y. Hoekstra, Water neutral: reducing and offsetting the impacts of water footprints, Value of
Water Research Report Series No. 28, UNESCO-IHE (2008)
A.Y. Hoekstra, P.Q. Hung, Globalization of water resources: international virtual water flows in
relation to crop trade. Global Environ. Change 15, 45 (2005)
ISO, ISO 14040 International standard, in Environmental Management – Life Cycle Assessment –
Principles and Framework, International Organisation for Standardisation, 2006a
ISO, ISO 14044 International standard, in Environmental Management – Life Cycle Assessment –
Requirements and Guidelines, International Organisation for Standardisation, 2006b
A. Koehler, Water use in LCA: managing the planet’s. Int. J. Life Cycle Assess. 13, 451 (2008)
J. Lubchenko, Entering the century of the environment: a new social contract for science. Science
279, 491 (1998)
OECD, Extended Producer Responsibility – A Guidance Manual for Governments (OECD, Paris,
2001)
S. Pfister, A. Koehler, S. Hellweg, Assessing the environmental impacts of freshwater consumption
in LCA. Environ. Sci. Technol. 43, 4098 (2009)
PRé Consultants, SimaPro LCA software (2012), www.pre.nl/default.htm
46 Life Cycle Thinking for Improved Resource Management: LCA or? 857
Abstract
This chapter provides an overview of various ways by which companies can earn
money with sustainable practices.
When a company turns to a more sustainable way of working, up-front
investments and cost often increase and products and markets change. Therefore,
it requires a shift to new business models. If the business model of the
company does not change, the company cannot expect to receive the rewards
of value creation, and the continuation of the activities might be threatened. The
challenge is to contribute to all three sustainability goals of the business model:
environmental goals, economic goals, and social goals. To do so is a challenge,
and not many companies manage to strike the right balance.
Section 2.3 provides examples of innovative business models that aim at
contributing to at least two out of these three goals. It also covers business models
that combine all three strategic goals. Business models are thus given to:
• Achieve economic and environmental goals
• Achieve economic and social goals
• Achieve economic, social and environmental goals
The category where social and environmental goals only are achieved can only
exist if funded by charity, public interest organizations, or government subsidies.
From a sustainable engineering perspective, business models that aim for
economic and environmental goals are the most interesting. Engineering can
especially contribute to a reduction of the environmental burden of companies.
R. van Drimmelen
Section Technology Dynamics & Sustainable Development, Delft University of Technology,
Delft, The Netherlands
e-mail: R.vandrimmelen@tudelft.nl
Business models are grouped into four categories, which correlate to the four
types of strategies a company can choose to implement sustainable practices:
• Eco-efficiency strategy
• Beyond compliance leadership strategy
• Eco-branding strategy
• Environmental cost leadership strategy
These are the existing sustainable business models. Sustainable value in-
novations are totally new strategies and business models, in which economic
and environmental goals are combined, that do not fit into any of the previous
strategies. New companies are often in a better position to go for a completely
new business model. Not being limited by existing protocols, they have the
opportunity to be really creative and think of new sustainable ways of making
money.
Section 2.4 illustrates, using stock market performance data, that new sustain-
able business models do not necessarily lead to better economic performance.
However, economic performance does not get any worse either. This makes
sustainable business models a serious alternative for companies.
Section 2.5 gives an insight on the role of governments in supporting
new business models for sustainable development. National governments have
economic, communicative, and legal policy instruments and can use these either
positively or negatively for specific business activities.
Section 2.6 focuses on public-private partnership as a successful policy tool
to support sustainable business models in large, mostly infrastructural, projects.
1 Introduction
Financial aspects have been dominant in business, and still are, ever since the
abolishment of the guilds. In medieval guilds, admission to crafts was strongly
curbed and price competition was absent. The financial aspects of a craft business
were rather limited. Nowadays, financial aspects are important, but they are not the
only matter of concern. Since the 1960s, ecological and social goals have become
increasingly important. The argument was and is that the earth’s carrying capacity is
itself at risk, and a catastrophic breakdown of the climate and other natural systems
is possible. This would, in the longer term, affect the company itself and thus
challenge its continuity.
There have always been companies that were aware, or were made aware,
of the environmental and social impact of their activities. As a consequence of
this awareness or their direct dependence on natural resources, they adapted their
strategies and processes. For example, the medieval breweries in Delft made sure
that the canals were kept clean because they used the water from the canals to
brew their beer. Various social industrial experiments have taken place in which
entrepreneurs have aimed at developing the abilities of their workers and improving
their social conditions. Information on how sustainable technologies can contribute
to sustainable entrepreneurship is crucial. Implementing new technologies or
improving existing technologies, the concept of sustainable entrepreneurship can
be brought into practice. Examples of these sustainable technologies are:
• Renewable energy generation (including the production of energy from waste
heat)
• Materials recycling technologies (collection and sorting systems; burning timber
waste, reprocessing paper, plastics, and so on; reprocessing organic waste)
• Green product design and applying materials that minimize the environmental
burden of the life cycle of a product (zero-emission buildings, green products)
• Technologies that mitigate the environmental burden of other products (flue gas
cleaning, extracting CO2 to be used for horticulture)
• Products that promote or facilitate the reduction of environmental impacts,
aiming for long-term economic well-being and promoting social awareness
(measuring devices that display energy consumption and energy savings)
The market introduction or implementation of sustainable technologies can be
a large hurdle for companies. Many environmental-impact-reducing technologies
are available, and many would like to see such sustainable technologies being
implemented. But the payback times are not always competitive as compared
to traditional technologies, and risks and uncertainties will be higher, as new
technologies might still contain unknown flaws. The introduction of new products
often means entering new markets that are largely unknown. What legal and social
rules apply there?
To face this risk and/or to make the introduction of the sustainable technologies
possible, there is a need for the development of new business models that combine
a longer term economic perspective with improving social well-being and envi-
ronmental protection – a business model that seduces consumers and companies
to go for sustainable technologies, also referred to as green products and green
technologies.
862 R. van Drimmelen
People
Bearable Equitable
Sustainability
Planet Profit
Viable
The approach is also phrased as people, planet, profit, and alternatively known as
the Triple Bottom Line (TBL). Figure 47.1 illustrates this concept. It will be further
discussed, and brought into practice in the following sections.
To combine economic goals and sustainability goals is a complex task. Despite
its apparent clarity: Sustainability cannot be produced by bankrupt companies, and
companies cannot flourish by devastating the planet that provides labor, capital, and
material resources.
This chapter provides an overview of currently existing business models. It will
illustrate the models using many examples that hopefully will inspire the reader to
work with these new business models or even to develop new sustainable business
ideas.
Technology is not the only solution to the current sustainability challenges.
Various other measures might be taken by companies, but they will get less attention
here. An example of sustainable entrepreneurship that is not related to technology is
offered by the airline KLM: It collects unused frequent flyer points of its customers
and donates the value to charity programs.
The ideas of sustainable entrepreneurship have a large overlap with the ideas
referred to as corporate social responsibility (CSR). Under the title of CSR, an
international quality standard has been developed within the International Stan-
dardization Organization (ISO 26000 2010), although in 2010 it was still not used
for official certification. Figure 47.2 shows the seven subjects that this standard
focuses on.
As shown in Fig. 47.2, the ISO standard for CSR deals with a broad range
of topics. It not only contains human-social elements, but also compliance with
environmental issues. Consequently, the business that embraces CSR takes on the
responsibility for the impact of its activities on consumers, employees, communities,
the environment, and other stakeholders. Also, the business promotes public interest
by encouraging community growth and development, and by voluntarily eliminating
practices that harm the human and natural environment. CSR aims at supporting an
47 New Business Models for Sustainable Development 863
Holistic approach
4.4*
Community
4.3*
involvement
Human rights
and development
6.3* Organizational
6.3* 6.4*
Consumer ORGANIZATION Labour
issues practices
governance
6.6* 6.5*
Fair operating The environment
practices
Interdependence
• Light Pollution
• Legal workforces
• Education
• Ergonomics
• Charity
• Transparency
• Fair salaries
Social
Fig. 47.4 Goals for a company to aim for while practicing sustainable entrepreneurship (examples
are given for greenhouse horticulture)
This term is often used these days, but has no clear explicit definition. In this chapter,
the following definition is used:
A business model describes the rationale of how an organization creates,
delivers, and captures value – economic, social, and environmental or other forms of
value (Osterwalder and Pigneur 2009). The process of business model design is, as
866 R. van Drimmelen
explained in the previous section, part of business strategy. The business model takes
into account purpose, offerings, strategies, infrastructure, organizational structures,
trading practices, and operational processes and policies. A business model refers
to the total setup of a company, its position in the market and how it creates value
in terms of money and other values in the shorter and longer term. So how does
this combine with sustainability? This will be further explained in the following
sections.
Before a company can develop a business model, the company strategy has to first
be devised. Naturally, when sustainable entrepreneurship is what is aimed for, this
strategy should be of a sustainable character as well and should be formulated
around the three values – economic, ecologic, and social. The challenge is to
combine these three values in such a way that they reinforce each other and do not
deteriorate. The following sections explain how these three values can be combined.
First, business models are analyzed based on a pair of two values, and then business
models that aim at combining all three values leading to complete sustainable
business models are analyzed.
SUSTAINABLE STRATEGIES
ENVIRONMENTAL
REDUCING COSTS ECO-EFFICIENCY
COST LEADERSHIP
SUSTAINABLE
VALUE
INNOVATION
BEYOND
DIFFERENTIATING COMPLIANCE ECO-BRANDING
LEADERSHIP
PROCESS PRODUCT
Fig. 47.5 Strategies for combining ecological and economical goals (Orsato 2009). For each of
these strategies, business models can be designed
innovation.” Below, these strategies are elaborated and further examples of business
models for each strategy are given.
As mentioned earlier, there are four strategic directions that a company can adapt.
These are further explained in the following and examples are given.
(a) Eco-efficiency business models
The eco-efficiency strategy is basically a cost reduction strategy. It implies
economizing on internal operations. Direct cost savings are achieved by using
less resources and by polluting less, thus saving on purchases and pollution
taxes, respectively.
Examples of eco-efficiency business models are:
• Greenhouse horticulturists in the Netherlands (flower or vegetable growers
that use extensive lighting to make their products grow faster) have been
implementing technologies like heat and electricity cogeneration in combi-
nation with heat buffering tanks in their greenhouses. Waste heat can be used
and electricity generated more or less independently. In the Netherlands,
cogeneration has been stimulated extensively by the government, making
it economically attractive to implement such a technology. Relatively high
electricity prices and relatively low natural gas prices make this eco-efficient
technology the most economically attractive option for heating greenhouses
as long as the relative energy prices for electricity and gas (so-called spark
spread) remain large enough.
• JC Deceaux, a leading outdoor advertising company, aims to optimize the use
of natural resources, by closely managing its consumption of water, energy,
and detergents used for cleaning of its outdoor furniture and by using outdoor
furniture that can easily be recycled. The company pays particular attention
868 R. van Drimmelen
extremely expensive and may sometimes result in rather limited value for
customers.
Examples of eco-branding business models are:
• Hybrid cars with increased fuel efficiency. Toyota set a trend by introducing
the Toyota Prius into the market. Although analysis shows that, including
the environmental harm of mining the heavy metals that are used for the
batteries, the car is equally or even less clean than a fuel-efficient diesel car,
it is recognized by the customer as a green product.
• Tetra Pak, a multinational company based in Sweden, has increased the
recyclability of its drinking containers and uses materials with a low envi-
ronmental impact. The company clearly uses the environmental friendliness
of their product as an important selling argument.
• MarQt is a supermarket that sells biological food. Located at the center of
Amsterdam, it wears a modern look with its environmental friendliness.
It attracts customers with a conscious and trendy lifestyle and combines
the ease of supermarkets with an assortment of environmentally sound
products.
• Interface carpet tiles. By using environment-friendly glues, yarn, transport
methods and dyes, they differentiate themselves from their competitors. Also
they lease out their tiles, making recycling of the tiles easier.
• Ecowasbol. This product is made of ceramic material, and if washing powder
for washing machines is put in it before being put in the washing machine,
it saves up to 50% of washing powder. The special thing about this business
model is that it is sold only via exclusive market channels. There is only
one trendy shop in Amsterdam where it can be bought, which gives it
exclusivity.
(d) Environmental Cost Leadership business models
Environmental cost leadership is a cost reduction strategy that goes a step
beyond the eco-efficiency strategy. It competes explicitly with other companies
by offering the cheapest products that are produced on its own terms. These
extremely low operating costs can be achieved by completely dematerializing
the product or service. Some examples are:
• Various companies producing notebooks made of recycled paper.
• Various companies producing gray toilet paper.
• Various companies producing LED lights for bicycles. These are very cheap
and super low on electricity use.
• Walmart with simple and straightforward but drastic environmental goals: To
be supplied 100% by renewable energy; to create zero waste, to sell products
that sustain people and the environment.
There have been several attempts to measure the performance of sustainable versus
not-sustainable companies over the past decades. One well-known attempt is the
evaluation of the financial performance of the companies that are in the DJSI. The
DJSI is made up by the average stock market values of a subgroup of companies
47 New Business Models for Sustainable Development 873
300 00
DJSI World (in EUR)
200 00
DJGI World (in EUR)
200 00
100 00
48% DJSI
100 00 24% DJGI
00 00
12/93 6/94 12/94 6/95 12/95 6/96 12/96 6/97 12/97 6/98 12/98 6/99 12/99 6/00 12/00 6/01 12/01 6/02 12/02
Fig. 47.6 Dow Jones Sustainability Index. Comparison between the Dow Jones General Index
and Dow Jones Sustainability Index
120
100
80
60
DJSI World 80 (EUR, TR)
Dow Jones Global Titans 50 Index (EUR, TR)
40
Aug- Oct- Dec- Feb- Apr- Jun- Aug- Oct- Dec- Feb- Apr- Jun- Aug-
08 08 08 09 09 09 09 09 09 10 10 10 10
Fig. 47.7 DJSI World 80–Performance. Since Launch, 08/09–08/10 (EUR, Total Return)
claiming to be sustainable. Figures 47.6 and 47.7 show the DJSI for the first years
after its launch and its more recent results (Dow Jones Sustainability Indexes 2010).
Figure 47.6 illustrates that during a long period the participating companies
were indeed outperforming their peers in terms of shareholder value. However, the
gap has been narrowing since 1999. Nowadays, there is no significant difference
between the DJSI and the general Dow Jones index (see Fig. 47.7). Differences are
mainly due to over- and underrepresentation of certain sectors in the DJSI. There is
neither evidence that sustainability is just a cost factor, nor that it brings business
success within a decade.
is also a national market to reduce acid rain and several regional markets in nitrogen
oxides. Markets for other pollutants tend to be smaller and more localized.
In 2005, 374 million metric tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent (tCO2 e) were
exchanged through projects, a 240% increase relative to 2004 (110 mtCO2 e) which
was itself a 41% increase relative to 2003 (78 mtCO2 e). The first emission trading
systems were introduced in the USA during the 1990s after a period of simulation
and testing and have extended to other countries and other industrial sectors ever
since.
2.5.3 Covenants
In the 1990s, “covenants” were made between government and industry to reduce
industrial pollution. A covenant is a solemn promise to engage in or refrain from a
specified action. The reason for using these covenants was that the existing system
of licenses and fines was not effective enough.
These covenants did have some effect, but the sense of urgency was not enough
to really achieve the proposed changes that were aimed for. To overcome this, in
most covenants, over time a deadline was included. If the pollution reduction had
not been reached before the deadline, other governmental measures would follow.
876 R. van Drimmelen
This threat pushed the industry more, although it was not certain that the threat
would actually be implemented.
An example is the litter reduction covenant in the Netherlands. It was signed
in 2002 and was in effect until the end of 2005. It stated: “Industry will introduce
packaging innovations aimed at controlling and reducing litter” (Weever 2006). As
the Dutch government threatened to introduce a deposit system on small plastic
bottles and beverage cans if litter reduction was not achieved, the covenant on
littering initiated a lot of activity from the packaging industry. It mainly resulted
in communication actions to stimulate civilians not to throw their trash on the
streets.
Covenants do not directly lead to new business models, but at least they make
existing business models of all industries in the same sector more sustainable. As
the whole sector contributes, it creates a level playing field. If the sector is not
sufficiently organized, free riders could frustrate the execution of the covenant.
For some transitions toward a sustainable way of living and working, governmental
investments play a major role. Examples are drilling for deep geothermal heat,
waste heat infrastructures, off-shore wind parks, and the development of fuel cells.
The investments in such projects are high and payback times are unacceptable for
industries. On the other hand, the government cannot realize these projects by itself.
The required knowledge is not available within governments, but is more likely to
be found within industries. And in relation, it would not be wise for governments to
carry the risk alone.
There was a clear need for a new business model as problems occurred with tradi-
tional ways of handling large infrastructure projects, especially the ones outsourced
by the government in the Netherlands in the 1980s and 1990s. Because of a lack of
control, prices paid to contractors were too high. Thus, as a solution to this problem,
between 1990 and 2010, new ways of collaboration have been developed and
introduced – the so-called public-private partnerships (PPPs). Positive experiences
have been built up over the last years with these models.
A general definition is:
A Public-Private Partnership (PPP) is a collaboration between the public and the private
sector, while maintaining own identity and responsibility, in order to realize a project with
a clear division of tasks and risks (EU Green Paper 2004).
PPP CONCEPT
CONTROL EXECUTION
CONTRACT
PUBLIC PRIVATE
ORGANIZATION COMPANY
The public sector, on the other hand, realizes social goals and creates an opportunity
to reduce project costs and increase quality.
A PPP project is characterized by an optimized risk allocation and a holistic life
cycle approach. For example, a guaranteed performance of a public road might be
delivered via proper maintenance. The task to maintain that road can often be best
allocated to the private sector.
Also, financing might be a service that a private contractor can deliver to the
public sector in times of crisis when national governments put budgets on hold.
The goals of a PPP are to reach value for money both in providing public
services and in private commerce. Synergies might be found and exploited in the
joint innovative use of resources and knowledge (see Fig. 47.8).
To make public-private partnership projects viable, it is of key importance to act
in a transparent manner, establish mutual trust and complementary goals, and avoid
a strong interdependency of actors as that could lead to unfair business practices.
Further conditions to form public-private partnerships are a good distribution of
risks, clear separation of responsibility and authority, and a market- and success-
oriented thinking. In function, a PPP should have a reliable image and create a sound
revenue flow.
Despite the wide recognition of the superior results of PPPs, it is not the dominant
method in the procurement of governmental infrastructure projects. The main reason
for this is that the small private developers are often not capable of covering the large
financial debt and the large private developers rather work unaccompanied.
878 R. van Drimmelen
3 Summary
References
M. Bennett, P. James (eds), The Green Bottom Line, Environmental Accounting for Management:
Current Practice and Future Trends (Greenleaf, Sheffield, 1998)
V. Dobes, EMPRESS (Praha, Czech Republic, 2010), http://www.energy-base.org/fileadmin/
media/base/downloads/empress flyer.pdf, June 2011
Dow Jones Sustainability Indexes (2010), http://www.sustainability-index.com/djsi pdf/news/
PressReleases/SAM Presentation 100908 Review11 final.pdf, October 2011
47 New Business Models for Sustainable Development 879
EU Green Paper, EU Green Paper on public-private partnerships and community law on pub-
lic contracts and concessions. /* COM/2004/0327 final */ (2004), http://eur-lex.europa.eu/
LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=CELEX:52004DC0327:EN:NOT, June 2011
IKEA Sustainability Report 2010, https://www.credit-suisse.com/ch/privatkunden/
privatebanking/en/produkte/nachhaltige/investieren.jsp, June 2011
ISO 26000, Guidance on Social Responsibility (2010), See www.iso.org (ISO is the International
Standardization Organization), October 2011
R.J. Orsato, Sustainable Strategies – When Does It Pay To Be Green? (Palgrave Macmillan,
Basingstoke, 2009)
A. Osterwalder, Y. Pigneur, Business Model Generation (self published, 2009), http://www.
businessmodelgeneration.com/, June 2011
C.K. Prahalad, The Fortune at the Bottom of the Pyramid (Wharton School Publishing, Upper
Saddle River, 2004)
R. Weever, Prevention of littering through packaging design: A support tool for concept generation,
in Proceedings of TMCE 2006, Ljubljana, Slovenia, 2006, ed. by I. Horváth, J. Duhovnik
Strategies for Sustainable Technologies:
Innovation in Systems, Products, and 48
Services
Karel F. Mulder
Abstract
Engineering is about designing efficient products, processes, and systems. But
if it is not so clear which products, processes, or systems will provide the
most sustainable solutions to the current challenges, engineering efficiency is a
dangerous thing as the wrong things might be designed efficiently, which might
make things worse at the end! The question is what to design to contribute to SD.
Raising this issue might easily lead to a long treatise of definitions of SD.
But clearly SD is an issue that depends on place and time: Contagious diseases,
suppression, and starvation were for long the most pressing sustainability issues.
Now resource depletion, climate change, and inequity appear to be much more
important articulations of sustainability.
To work as an engineer on the whole concept of SD is too encompassing.
More specific articulations of SD, like “energy efficiency,” “zero waste,” and
“accessible for all” could be guiding principles for engineering design. However,
one should be aware not to identify one single SD articulation as the essence
of sustainability. Various articulations of SD always play a role, and dilemmas
between these SD articulations might occur.
A fundamental question is whether an engineer, by consciously altering
a design to make it contribute more to SD, can change the main stream of
technology in a sustainable direction. Many attempts to change the main stream
of engineering design failed. Can anybody actually influence the course of
technology, or are engineers forced to move along in the mainstream of techno-
scientific progress? For long, this has been a heavily debated issue in the history
and philosophy of technology.
K.F. Mulder
Technology Policy and Management, Delft University of Technology, Delft, The Netherlands
e-mail: K.F.Mulder@tudelft.nl
In our time, new technologies are rarely created by a single person. Successful
innovation is often not even just a matter of a single company. It often takes
customer supplier-cooperation, e.g., when new materials are applied to make lighter
or cheaper products or public-private cooperation when infrastructures have to adapt
to facilitate a new technology. Innovation might fail by many reasons that reside
outside the company. Moreover, decisions regarding the development of a new
technology can have far-reaching consequences.
For a company, success in developing a new technology might create the know-
how base and the market position to achieve more successes and become the leader
in that technological area. For society at large the choice of specific standardized
technologies is almost irreversible.
The means for innovation are limited. Research and development are expensive
and so are the costs of innovation failures that will undoubtedly occur. Societies
need to make strategic choices in order to contribute optimally to sustainable
development. Choices have to be made regarding:
1. Prioritization of problems
2. The time frame in which solutions are required
3. The most promising technological way to solve problems: by changing complete
socio-technological systems, technological components, or parts
4. Dilemmas regarding (unintended and unforeseen) side effects that are attached
to various technological solutions
Without being aware of the choices that are behind our efforts to innovate for SD,
innovation intended to support SD could turn out to counteract it.
48 Strategies for Sustainable Technologies 883
“Normal innovation” is very often not as exciting as one thinks reading the
many stories of the great inventors. The images of innovators that are painted by
the glorious stories on inventions do not represent the day-to-day praxis of the
laboratory. “Normal innovation” is generally incremental. It aims at improving
existing technologies by small modifications, removing “bugs” from the production
process, or in general improving efficiency. Incremental innovations are often
almost unnoticeable improvements of details. However, over a longer period, these
small improvements accumulate to significant improvements. For example the
fuel efficiency gains in civil aviation were between 1960 and 1980 in total about
55–67%, between 1980 and 2000 in total about 20–26%. One expects that another
20–26% can be achieved until 2040 (Peeters et al. 2005). The energy efficiency
884 K.F. Mulder
gains of a car are even lower. The energy efficiency of cars improved between 1972
and 2000 with 30% at maximum (Kwon 2006).
If one relates these efficiency improvements to the sustainability challenges that
the world is facing, it is quite clear that the required improvements will not be
produced.
In the early 1970s, scientists debated which factors mainly contributed to
the environmental problems: consumption growth, overpopulation, or the state of
technology. Ehrlich and Holdren (1971) formulated a relationship between these
factors, the so-called IPAT equation:
IDP*A*T (48.1)
What drives technological change? A view that is often implicit in popular media
is that technological change is autonomous. This means that technological change
is not influenced through economic, social, and legal powers. “The progress of
the technology cannot be halted,” or “As Einstein had not invented the general
theory of relativity, someone else would have done it.” Often, the core of this
way of reasoning is the assumption that technology is fed by scientific knowledge.
886 K.F. Mulder
Scientific knowledge is accumulating (as results are published and stored), and
therefore technology development can utilize more and more knowledge. Moreover,
improved technologies help to improve other technologies. Hence, technology will
improve continuously, autonomous of any actor in society. Technology policies
and technology strategies are in this vision futile, as nothing can influence this
process.
One of the best-known philosophers that approached technology as an au-
tonomous force is Jacques Ellul 1967. Ellul’s constant theme in all his publications
is the imminent “technological tyranny over mankind.” Ellul creates a sharp divide
between the traditional (for him: preindustrial) technology and modern technology.
Traditional technology was according to him:
• Limited in its application (because technology had been made for specific
functions on a specific place).
• Only marginally dependent on resources and especially dependent on craftsman-
ship.
• Local in its character (because local circumstances are used, and local culture has
to be taken into account).
• The result was that classic technology allowed the possibility of choice, that is to
say individuals and local communities could to a far extent determine the shape
of the technology that they applied.
Contrasting to traditional technology, Ellul characterized modern technology
through:
• Automatism, i.e., there is only one “best” way to solve a particular problem,
which is compelling wherever one is on this planet.
• Self-replication, i.e., new technology strengthens the growth of other technolo-
gies. The result is exponential growth.
• Indivisibility. In order to participate in modern society, the technological lifestyle
must be accepted completely, with its good and bad sides.
• Cohesion, i.e., technologies of different areas have much in common.
• Universalism, i.e., technology is geographically as well as qualitatively om-
nipresent.
For Ellul this meant that modern technology is devastating human freedom.
In his view, the future of mankind is extremely gloomy, for there is no way
back.
Besides these fatalistic views, there are also very optimistic autonomous tech-
nology views. Especially a number of futurists propagate bright images of future
technologies. Unimaginable speeds of transport, the conquest of space as the “final
frontier,” living at the ocean floor or on Mars, it can all be done. Whether society
really needs these techniques is of no concern. It is imaged as the inevitable
“progress.”
The autonomous technology worldview is dubious:
• It supposes one-way traffic between science, technology, and society. Technology
is the product of scientific growth and technological self-replication. However,
historically this is incorrect: Technology often pre-cedes the formulation of
48 Strategies for Sustainable Technologies 887
underlying scientific principles. This holds for instance for the steam engine that
was already a century in use before Sadi Carnot formulated the Carnot cycle
in 1824. The Carnot cycle explains the transformation of heat in work. The first
airplane flew in 1903, but the aerodynamic theory that explained why this worked
was only discovered by Prandtl around 1920 (Anderson 1997).
• Historical analyses show that technological innovation is not a process that
inevitably leads to one specific result. The context in which a technology is
developed determines the resulting technology.
Governments, companies, but also NGOs and citizen groups can influence the
course of technology. Especially in infrastructures, there are many examples where
this has taken place.
However, this does not imply that “anything goes.” There are strong mechanisms
that limit the options for technological change. One of those is positive feedback:
The more successful a technology becomes, the more production costs can be cut,
the more specially designed accessories (or software) become available, and the
more people are accustomed to the product. This in turn contributes to the success
of the product, which makes the product invulnerable for attempts to replace it
by new technologies. The result is often spontaneous standardization: one product
spontaneously becomes the market standard (DVD, software, batteries, Operating
Systems: “many people hate Windows, but still use it!”). Moreover, the more
a technology is adopted, the more attractive the technology becomes for further
optimization. If companies develop new technologies under conditions of positive
feedback, it typically leads to “winner takes all.” The first on the market will set the
standard that cannot be broken anymore after being accepted. The consequence is
also that the “best” technology does not necessarily win: after a standard has been
established on the market, a better technology has no chance to compete, unless it
is really accepted as being very much better.
Although the autonomous technology view is not very fashionable these days, it
cannot be denied that there is a core of truth in it: In our globalizing society, there is
very little scope for individuals, groups, or even national authorities to influence or
even steer processes of technological change.
Only very few technologies are inherently unsustainable. Very often, the sustain-
ability of a technology is dependent on the SD articulation that is evaluated, and on
the scale of use. For example, the car is one of the main pollutants of the urbanized
society. Around the world, there are about 900 million cars and light vehicles. Given
the rapid growth of motorized transport, especially in Asia, that number will soon
surpass one billion (Plunkett Research 2010). Cars emit CO2 and various other
pollutants, especially in densely populated areas, cause almost one million fatalities
and even far more casualties every year (WHO 2004), and deplete finite resources
like fossil fuels and various ores. This is clearly an unsustainable situation. But is
888 K.F. Mulder
steam liners that greatly spurred emigration to the USA (Cohn 2005). Moreover, the
development of steamers enabled new developments that facilitated steamers: e.g.,
the Suez Canal was not suitable for sailing ships, but shortened the route between
Europe and Asia considerably (Geels 2005).
History shows us many examples of transitions. But can these processes be
initiated and steered in order to produce Sustainable systems, i.e., is transition
management possible? Certainly, this cannot be achieved by management in the
classic sense of using methods that will produce known outcomes. Transition
management is probably able to spur a process of change, but as the complexities
and nonlinearities are so dominant in the process, there is little certainty if the
transition will actually lead to the improvements that were aimed for. That is a risk,
but can be acceptable as there is often no alternative (Cf. Rotmans et al. 2001).
4.2.3 Backcasting
(see Backcasting and Scenarios for Sustainable Technology Development)
Scholars reflecting on innovation emphasize the need to learn from others for a
successful innovation, the necessity to understand the perspectives of others and
cooperate with people with other skills. As there are often high fences created
around innovations, there is a need to tear these down in order to reach these
different perspectives (Cf. “open innovation,” Chesbrough 2003). Especially in SD
innovations, various articulations of SD might play a role, and various public as
well as private actors and NGOs might contribute to valuable learning processes.
Sometimes this requires careful social network creation: Various actors are not
involved in the innovation journey, and some hardly interested in playing a role
in it. Others might have an interest but mainly to derail the process. For instance,
basic scientists are often hardly interested in pushing their results into an innovation
journey, as this would require them to put lots of efforts in developing indications
of commercial prospects. This leads to a phenomenon called “the valley of death”;
promising ideas are not elaborated any further, as serious funding is required to
elaborate the ideas, but very little certainty exists on the commercial prospects.
The early stages of the innovation journey are often dominated by engineers and
scientists. Their perspectives on efficient products and processes are often not in line
with the people that in later stages have to work with these processes and products,
or even the people that have to carry the burden of (side) effects of that innovation.
Radical technological change requires the cooperation of various stakeholders.
Moreover, it requires learning. In order to facilitate these processes in early stages,
when the technology is still malleable, stakeholder involvement is very important,
and sufficient scope for learning constructive technology assessment processes,
consisting of carefully prepared interactions of various actors, can contribute to
reflexive learning in early stages of innovation processes and to a better alignment
of innovations and sustainability demands (Rip et al. 1995).
Innovations for sustainable development, like any other innovations, will not occur
at random spots of our planet. In information technology, biotechnology, and
probably nanotechnology, there are hot spots of innovation. Being a hot spot of
innovation is very attractive for a region, as it brings to the region high-paid jobs
without industrial nuisances such as pollution. Various mayors dream of developing
an innovation hot spot in their municipality.
But what does it take to become an innovation hot spot? Why are innovative
companies concentrated in specific areas?
The best known innovation hot spot is probably “Silicon Valley,” an area South
of San Francisco. This area got its nickname in the 1970s, when it became the world
center of microelectronic development. A little later, Silicon Valley also was the
center of development of computers and various computer appliances, software, and
Internet technology. At first glance, such a concentration seems rather irrational:
The required experts are not available locally, and prices will rise due to growing
demand.
48 Strategies for Sustainable Technologies 893
6 Summary
This chapter has argued that a sound strategy is required in order to work on
innovations that will really contribute to long-term sustainable development. First
it is crucial to recognize various articulations of SD, and recognize that there
could be dilemmas. The chapter has emphasized the need to produce radical
innovations. But to what degree is the progress of technology really a matter
of social choice or an autonomous development? It is claimed that there are
strong forces that prohibit steering of technology in specific directions, but it is
not entirely impossible. Common legitimations for government interference in the
innovation process are provided. As radical innovations are important to innovate
for SD, the chapter discusses three approaches that aim at facilitating/stimulating
(radical) technological innovation processes. Finally, it was discussed what it takes
894 K.F. Mulder
References
J. Anderson, A History of Aerodynamics (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge/New York,
1997)
H. Chesbrough, Open Innovation: The New Imperative for Creating and Profiting from Technology
(Harvard Business School Press, Boston, 2003)
R.L. Cohn, The Transition from sail to steam in immigration to the United States. J. Econ. Hist.
65, 469–495 (2005)
D. Collingridge, The Social Control of Technology. (St. Martin’s Press, New York; Pinter, London,
1980)
R. Coombs, P. Saviotti, V. Walsh, Economics and Technological Change. (MacMillan, Houndmills,
1987), pp. 205–212. Why doe government intervene?
P. Ehrlich, J. Holdren, Impact of population growth: complacency concerning this component of
man’s predicament is unjustified and counterproductive. Science 171, 1211–1217 (1971)
Factor Ten Club, The Carnoules Declaration – Statement to Government and Business Leaders
(Wuppertal Institute for Climate, Environment and Energy, Wuppertal, 1997)
J. Ellul, The Technological Society. Translation John Wilkinson. (Knopf, New York, 1964. Jonathan
Cape, London, 1965. Revised edition: Knopf/Vintage, New York, 1967)
F.W. Geels, Technological Transitions and Systems Innovations, A Co-evolutionary and Socio-
technological Analysis (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, 2005)
M.P. Hekkert, S.O. Negro, Functions of innovation systems as a framework to understand
sustainable technological change: empirical evidence for earlier claims. Technol. Forecast. Soc.
Change 76, 584–594 (2009)
T.-H. Kwon, The determinants of the changes in car fuel efficiency in Great Britain (1978–2000).
Energ. Policy 34(15), 2405–2412 (2006)
E.H.M. Moors, K.F. Mulder, Industry in sustainable development: the contribution of regime
changes to radical technical innovation in industry. Int. J. Technol. Policy Manag. 2(4),
434–454 (2002)
E.H.M. Moors, K.F. Mulder, Ph.J. Vergragt, Towards cleaner production: barriers and strategies in
the base metals producing industry. J. Clean. Prod. 13(7), 657–668 (2005)
K.F. Mulder, Sustainable Development for Engineers (Greenleaf, Sheffield, 2006)
K. Mulder, D. Ferrer-Balas, H. van Lente, What is Sustainable Technology? Perceptions, Paradoxes
and Possibilities (Greenleaf, Sheffield, 2011)
P.M. Peeters, J. Middel, A. Hoolhorst, Fuel Efficiency of Commercial Aircraft. An Overview of
Historical and Future Trends, NLR-CR-2005-669 (Peeters Advies/NLR, Amsterdam, 2005)
Plunkett Research Limited (2010) http://www.plunkettresearch.com/Industries/
AutomobilesTrucks/AutomobileTrends/tabid/89/Default.aspx. Accessed 2 Apr 2010
A. Rip, J. Schot, T. Misa, Managing Technology in Society. The Approach of Constructive
Technology Assessment (Pinter Publishers, London/New York, 1995)
H.W.J. Rittel, M.W. Webber, Dilemmas in a general theory of planning. Policy Sci. 4, 155–169
(1973)
J. Rotmans, R. Kemp, M. van Asselt, More evolution than revolution, transition management in
public policy. Foresight 3(1), 15–31 (2001)
E. von Weizsäcker, A. Lovins, H. Lovins, Factor Four, Doubling Wealth, Halving Resource Use,
(Earthscan, 1997)
P. Weaver, L. Jansen, G. van Grootveld, E. van Spiegel, Ph. Vergragt, Sustainable Technology
Development (Greenleaf, Sheffield, 2000)
WHO, World Report on Road Traffic Injury Prevention (WHO, Geneva, 2004)
Successful Contextual Technology
Transfer and Determinants of Culture 49
Kassahun Y. Kebede, D. J. Ndegwah, and J. O. Kroesen
Abstract
Why do so many projects in which technology transfer is involved, fail? This
chapter analyzes this problem and offers an alternative for well-intended but
unreflected ways of dealing with technology transfer. The authors offer a
comprehensive approach, taking into account the needs of the receiving society
and the sociocultural context in which the technology should be embedded. Many
examples, positive and negative, are mentioned from which such a methodology
should learn and which in turn illuminate the methodology.
The challenge consists in finding the right fit between technology and social
needs, technology and social environment, and in addition to get the right
management capacities and systems in place. This results in a comprehensive
model of technology transfer. Its application requires cooperation between
engineers and sociocultural researchers and takes the involvement of a diversity
of stakeholders.
Topics that are addressed include:
1. Which products and technologies suit the needs of the local society?
2. Which redesign do technologies need to suit a specific local context? How
could institutions of higher education coordinate their efforts in order to
find/invent/design technological products that suit local contexts?
3. What are the real needs and sociocultural requirements of the local context?
People’s participation and sociocultural research supported by NGOs and
other stakeholders should provide the answer. Deep interviews, question-
naires, pilot projects, etc., may be part of this type of research.
4. Feasibility study: what does it take to run a technology – and is this a feasible
option or can a business case be made out of it?
5. What skills are required for the production of contextualized technologies?
6. Capacities and cultural characteristics: along with business skills, what will
be the characteristics of the business culture and how can they be trained?
7. What intercultural learning or training processes need to be in place to make
the technology transfer successful? How can a viable equilibrium be created
between traditional values and a modern business culture, or within a project?
8. How can diffusion of this technology along with skills, capacities, learning
processes, be realized?
The chapter analyzes the historic origin of various value systems and describes
tools to analyze these differences. The value systems and ways of life that have
emerged in history can be considered as a collection of repertoires of dealing with
each other and with technology. Four types of such repertoires are distinguished
in relation to the perspectives of time (past and future) and space (inside and
outside). Different cultures cultivated a different set of such values. In the era
of globalization these repertoires become a common stock for all members
of world society. This approach opens the field for a deliberate trade-off and
choice depending on time and situation between so-called traditional and so-
called modern values. Sometimes training will be necessary in those human
qualities, which may help at some time to speed up the functioning of the
business or at another time slow down the rhythm in order to gain time for mutual
understanding during a meeting. Sometimes collectivism and solidarity may be
necessary, and at other times individual judgment and choice, etc. Successful
technology transfer may depend on the right mix and equilibrium of such human
qualities and values.
1 Introduction
For developing countries, sustainable development first means providing for the un-
derprivileged. To achieve this, the transfer of technology and its introduction in their
economies and societies is high on the priority list. Mostly, developing countries do
not have the R&D resources and facilities for production of their “own” technology.
Hence, they go for the technology transfer option. This does, however, not mean
that experiences with technology transfer are always satisfactory. On the contrary,
many times after a while the transfer appears to have failed and the technology
stands idle (Sharif 2003; Putranto et al. 2003; Mulder 2006). In this contribution the
authors will go into two main causes of such failures. The first is the lack of a proper
49 Successful Contextual Technology Transfer and Determinants of Culture 897
assessment of the needs that have to be fulfilled by the transferred technology and
the second is concerned with the cultural differences and related capacities to deal
with the new technology. Examples will be given of stand-alone technology transfer,
which do not meet the needs and sociocultural requirements of the receiving society.
Against that background a positive contribution is given, which includes practical
and feasible options, which nevertheless are often “forgotten.”
The authors argue that the way forward for policies and projects is to find the
right fit (1) between technology and social needs, and in addition getting the right
management capacities and institutions (2) in place to bridge the gap between the
culture of origin of the technology and the receiving culture.
As part of showing the limitations of the existing technology transfer models,
a special section is devoted to different theoretical models of technology transfer
proposed by different researchers at different times. In the end the authors will
introduce a comprehensive and practical method, constituting a logical order of
steps to be taken into consideration while transferring technology, mainly toward
developing countries. Emphasis is put on needs assessment and on taking into
account cultural values.
humanware, inforware, and orgaware. The team defined the technology com-
ponents as follows:
• Technoware: object-embodied technology such as tools, machines, and phys-
ical facilities
• Humanware: person-embodied technology such as skills, experience, and
wisdom
• Inforware: document-embodied technology such as process specifications and
theories
• Orgaware: institution-embodied technology that facilitates the integration of
the previous three components (Putranto et al. 2003; Boomer et al. 1991)
This team has identified specific factors and emphasized the fit between the
technology being transferred and the infrastructure of the receiving country. They
also argued that technology is a combination of both the physical equipment
(tool) and the associated know-how which helps either to make or use the
technology/tool.
In this chapter, the focus is on the two main aspects: needs and cultural barriers.
After having elaborated on these aspects an integrative model of technology transfer
is developed, taking these proposals into account.
sense, technology transfer was easier in the colonial times, because the process
was coordinated by the colonial authorities, ordering technologies from their home
countries. The advantage was that they were experienced with the technologies on
both sides, and also shared the same cultural outlook (cf. Ravesteijn and Kop 2008).
A proper process of needs assessment should take three key elements into
consideration:
• Firstly, it should identify the needs to be satisfied by the technology.
• Secondly, it should specify these needs into detailed requirements and constraints
• Thirdly, it should specify and assess the direct and indirect effects, which may be
expected of the technology transfer (Awny 2005; Madu 1988).
In many cases, technologies are blindly transferred. After a while it turns out
that they are unsuitable to the national interests of the receiving country. Flag
carrying airlines or the purchase of military equipment may serve as cases in
point. For example, the Indonesian aircraft manufacturer IPTN, which was set up
to supply the Indonesian archipelago with appropriate means of transport, was a
sink for government subsidies; and as such, it could only sell its ill-suited aircraft
by government enforcement (Towery 1998). This example shows that it is also
important to assess who the “owners” of the needs are. In addition, it is important to
distinguish “need” from “demand,” in the process of technology transfer. Demand
is dependent on purchasing power and price levels, but needs have deeper roots in
the society. Part of a proper needs assessment is the evaluation of the technology
under scrutiny within the framework of an integral development plan. A capital
intensive technology, introduced in a country with high unemployment rates, may
not be a good alternative as compared to a labor-intensive technology. Furthermore,
it is important that the needs of all stakeholders are included in the national strategic
development plan (Awny 2005). In the final analysis, it is necessary to identify the
different options that can satisfy the same need by clearly describing the potential
and weakness of each technology.
In industrial societies both formal and informal technology assessment is mostly
conducted before introduction of the technology takes place, as already mentioned
above. On the one hand, informal technology assessment takes place in many
industries, government agencies, and by public opinion, whenever their advantages
and disadvantages and risks are discussed. On the other hand, formal technology
assessment involves the work of experts, and takes place when important decisions
need to be taken, and in cases where the society holds strongly conflicting views.
The reason for this is that policymakers should be able to take an informed decision,
and be aware of unintended consequences, prepare stakeholders for changes, and
facilitate them in decision making (Smits and Leyten 1988). As the situation
stands now, neither formal nor informal technology assessment takes place in
developing countries, as a matter of course, a state of affairs that can have enormous
consequences. Take, for instance, the introduction of the nonindigenous Nile perch
in Lake Victoria, in the 1950s. It created a new fishing industry, but it also had
devastating effects on the local fish stock (Masciarelli 2005).
In order to ensure efficiency, stability, and sustainability, every technology
transfer should fulfill the three basic criteria of environmental soundness, economic
900 K.Y. Kebede et al.
advantage, and social acceptance (IETC 2003). Apart from the above elements,
there is need for appropriate infrastructure for the technology, without which it will
appear to be underutilized and all sorts of inefficiencies will show up. Subsidies,
macroeconomic, and market conditions should also be taken into account, as well
as patenting and licensing of intellectual property rights. The technology should
also be socially acceptable, in the sense that it contributes to the development of the
local community and to the country. This also involves cultural and organizational
characteristics like the level of hierarchy, the working habits, and so on, issues which
will be discussed in the next paragraph.
Culture and technology are inextricably intertwined, and as such, the introduction
of technology is not culturally neutral. Implied in technology as such, and for that
reason in any particular technology, is kind of a script, a set of requirements and
conditions of how to handle the technology. This relates to management skills,
maintenance, and institutional backing, values, and priorities, as well as ways
of being human. That often technologies fail or become detrimental to people’s
livelihood is not due to the technology itself. A case in point is the debate in Kenya,
on the destruction of the Mau Forest, and its resultant environmental catastrophe.
Timber harvesting and charcoal burning have not only destroyed the forest, but
also the livelihood of Kenyans, Ugandans, Sudanese, Ethiopians, and Egyptians
by endangering Lake Victoria and the River Nile. Although the current timber
harvesting is a result of technological development, through the introduction of the
power saw, it is not the technology by itself that causes the damage. Human action
is mostly the root cause of the failures. In every case where scientists and policy
makers concentrate on technical problems and fail to solve them, they are referred
back to the social root causes of the failure. The point here is that social issues
like lack of agreement, lack of cooperation, pursuit of different values and priorities
stand in the way of effective implementation of technical solutions.
Another example may illustrate this statement. In Nairobi a project was recently
implemented for the recycling of plastic by a group of young entrepreneurs; it
was named “Nairobi’s Recyclers.” This project was calculated to be financially
sustainable, providing some 50 young people with employment. However, unex-
pected problems showed up. The young people came from poor families, often
with traumatic psychological experiences, and they frequently needed help from
hospitals and medical clinics. In addition, some of them stole the recycled products
and sometimes the machinery as well. Moreover, the project was heavily dependent
on one person, the only one capable of managing it. Electricity and maintenance
turned out to be more expensive than expected. This, coupled with frequent power
failures, resulted in the machinery standing idle for many hours. In the end it turned
out that although the project was technically sound, the sociocultural capacities to
run it successfully were not in place (Solid Waste Management in Nairobi 2010).
49 Successful Contextual Technology Transfer and Determinants of Culture 901
Culture, values, habits, and capacities were the main impediment for the success of
Nairobi’s Recyclers.
Another example of blind technology transfer can be exemplified by the attempts
of many NGOs in arid and semiarid lands to bring clean water to the people. They
drilled boreholes to ease the problem of women trekking long distances to fetch
water. The assumption was that then these women could spend the extra hours
they gained on more economically productive activities. This brought about two
problems: one, women needed that time for socialization and interaction, but with
water just around the corner it became difficult for them to share their tribulations
and support each other in the face of adversity. Another problem was lack of
technical know-how on the maintenance of the boreholes once they dried up or
when the system broke down. In the case of the latter women were happy to get a
reason to go out and fetch water in far off places and as such also get time to ease
their domestic stress: they did not, therefore, nag their husbands to take action. But
even when they finally did, solutions had to come from as far as the capital city,
which is over 500 km away!
These examples show that technology is not culturally neutral, but is in fact
culturally conditioned. Most technologies, especially if they have some scale, even
apart from their specific makeup, imply cooperation between many stakeholders,
who cooperate anonymously in systems of large-scale labor division. That may
create problems in affective- and particularistic-oriented cultures, in which coop-
eration depends on personal relationships of selective trust. Most technologies,
in addition, require maintenance systems, and this, in turn, requires disciplined
labor and meticulous supervision. Every technology is, in a sense, socio-technology
because it comes with, and requires, a set of social codes to deal with it. There are
specific values that it serves and a specific mentality or mind-set that it promotes.
Even in the technological hardware, there are cultural values that are inscribed and
encoded in it (Winner 1980). Give a ball to a boy and you know exactly what he is
going to do with it, because the ball only asks for, or is oriented to, that specific
function. Technology and codes of behavior, ways of handling the technology,
values, and lifestyles, are always implied in each other and they go together. This
takes place in different ways. At least three ways can be distinguished:
• Sometimes the technological hardware comes first. Specific technologies, after
their design and implementation, often unexpectedly appear to bring about
cultural change. Cell phones, for instance, promote individualism. Increased
connectivity and mobility promotes modernization, turning rural life into city
life and causing, in the long run, the loss of traditional values like family ties.
• It also works the other way around. A set of values may lead, almost automat-
ically, to the adoption of a specific technology, which promotes and articulates
this value. In this case particular values are materialized in the specific design
of a technology. An information management system within a company which
authorizes different people to access information to a different degree, depending
on their place in the hierarchy, reproduces, reinforces, and materializes this
particular type of authority. The value of open communication between scientists
902 K.Y. Kebede et al.
and the value of progress in science have given an important impulse to the
coming into being on the Internet, e.g., (Misa 2004).
• A third case is also possible. Specific technologies may require to be managed
according to a specific set of values. In this case the technology and the
corresponding values and ways of behavior have to be introduced in one package,
at the same time. A particular technology can only be introduced if new values,
ways of behavior, and management are also introduced. This means that if a
specific set of cultural values is not in place, such a technology cannot be dealt
with effectively. The navigation of sixteenth century sailing ships may serve
as an example. It required a disciplined line of action, a division of labor and
machinelike behavior of all the people involved. Only if people are willing to
organize their behavior in such a way can such a technology be handled properly.
An important cause for Spain losing the Armada in the battle against Great
Britain, in 1588, was the fact that the Spanish nobility had separate command
and management lines for firing and navigating. Noblemen would fight for honor,
but not navigate. The British nobility, which was not too proud to combine
the management of firing and navigating at the same time, could move in a
much more flexible way, and thereby won the battle. They named themselves
“Commons” and gathered in the “Lower” House, which to this day is referred to
as the House of Commons. Their values made it possible to deal with technology
in a new way that made it more effective.
Technology transfer, in many respects, requires the introduction of new values and
new ways of behavior. In general, management of technology requires sequential
time management (planning), disciplined labor, and functional action according to
role descriptions. Other requisites for the management of large production systems
are individual responsibility, teamwork, and an open attitude toward novelty and
creativity. Even more important, for sustained efficiency, is a specific equilibrium
between hierarchy and open criticism from bottom to the top in order to prevent the
petrification of hierarchical control.
In this section our goal is to find a framework that enables us to make a conscious
and reflexive deliberation on the cultural heritage (which is value laden) of different
societies throughout the world. Such an exercise has two main functions:
• Firstly, it increases the awareness of the fact that humans have always been on
the move, culturally speaking.
• Secondly, it enables us, depending on time and situation, to make the next – path
dependent – move, making use of our common cultural heritage.
We have always been on the move: although it often is imagined that humanity
has known some “natural state,” a universal static nomadic or rural culture, it is
more suitable to assume that there has always been turmoil, change, divisions, and
49 Successful Contextual Technology Transfer and Determinants of Culture 903
conflicts even in the tribal phase of history. Naturally all tribes refer their present
to an immemorial past, but in reality there are many traces of past conflicts, tribes
splitting up, starting anew, etc., the memory of which has been effaced once the
new order had been established. As to the second point, the heritage of different
cultures, in terms of values and ways of life that are entering global society, becomes
increasingly accessible for all of us. The repertoire of values and ways of life can
be considered as a kind of a common stock from which everybody can draw. In
general it is neither the one nor the other value which makes us more human than the
other, but the right order and rhythm, the right and timely priority between different
values.
located in river valleys like, for instance, the Nile. The Emperor, son of the gods and
of the stars, was at the top of the hierarchy, which indeed literally was a hierarchy,
a sacred order. It was sacred because the secular state had not yet developed
(or more correctly, emerged), and the whole idea of a separation of secular and
sacred was unknown at that time. However, during the axial period of human history
(named for the first time this way by Jaspers), roughly between 500 BC and the
beginning of the Christian era, several traditions emerged which wanted to break
with this cosmopolitical hierarchy. In this way a third more future-oriented layer of
culture emerged in manifold forms. Taoism, Buddhism, Zoroastrianism, and, most
effectively and most pronounced, Judaism emerged as countervailing powers to too
much hierarchy. The imperial powers caused too much suffering and oppression of
the masses of farmers at the bottom of the pyramid. These traditions break with the
cosmopolitan imperial tradition and for that reason, they all point to transcendence
beyond the top of the pyramid – beyond the Emperor and the stars, “above” the
heavens. In the process, they dethrone the gods or the cosmic order, representing
traditional authority and hierarchy, and claim divine power beyond the visible
powers, a divine power which is sensitive to the sufferings of ordinary human beings
or which is not a divine power at all. By doing that they called for change, putting
the acquisition of a new set of future-oriented human achievements and qualities on
the agenda of history.
Is it possible to add still a fourth characteristic to this list? Can something new
be added to the list of (1) orientation toward the past, (2) orientation toward the
world outside, and (3) orientation toward the future? Could it be that only after
these three orientations were fully deployed a fourth one could be added to it, i.e.,
the need of an inner center, which makes it possible to switch between the three
orientations mentioned? Different orientations and different value priorities need
to be combined, and, as it were, married to each other, in a process of dialogue,
a process of gaining support for moving in either this or that direction. This is the
achievement of Western Christian and secular culture. It is the capacity of constantly
reaching compromises and agreements, which only function for the time being, for
a particular period of time. At the moment such a compromise or composition of
different value orientations stops being a living process, and becomes petrified,
a new step is taken, in a revolutionary move forward, and in this way a new
compromise between the values of the past and the needs of the future and also
of the requirements of the world outside is installed. The medieval equilibrium
– and competition – between Pope and Emperor, in their secular and spiritual
jurisdiction, may serve as a case in point (Rosenstock-Huessy 1993; Berman 1983;
Gauchet 1985; Holland 2008). They mutually recognized their different spheres of
jurisdiction, but nevertheless constantly competed and struggled with each other on
where to draw the line between them. An inner center of deliberation and judgment
is necessary to decide between such pluralistic value priorities. The compromise
between Pope and Emperor served this purpose. It came to an end, when, at the
beginning of the Reformation, the authority of the Pope himself was challenged.
At that moment, this particular time span was over and another time period started.
Such temporary compromises constitute a common present, i.e., a common horizon
49 Successful Contextual Technology Transfer and Determinants of Culture 905
of meaning and agreement, which lasts for a while. This characteristic of the West,
constant change and innovation, is what has put the West on the track of modernity.
A new set of capacities was acquired in the process, like rule by law and of
law (universalistic rule instead of particularistic despotism), neutral, non-affective
relationships, i.e., regulated by anonymous rules instead of personal relationships,
and a sequential ordering of time (planning), to mention but a few.
This short historical overview makes it possible to bring some order in the list of
cultural differences, which can be derived from different sources of the prevailing
literature. There are four basic orientations to which such cultural differences
can be attributed. This may give an understanding of their interrelatedness, and
their historical embeddedness. In addition, it prepares the way for a continuous
intercultural dialogue about path-dependent and context-dependent compromises
between these different value priorities. This dialogue is not conducted only in
the academic sphere (like in this chapter), but also, and foremost, in a most
practical way. That is, by the introduction and development/design of a host of
different technologies, as mentioned above. More mobile phones introduce more
individualism; more infrastructures introduce the erosion of family values; and these
introduce more civil society relationships, and so on and so forth.
In this paragraph the cultural differences mentioned in the prevailing literature are
analyzed and are attributed to the four large layers that have been distinguished. In
these few pages this can be done only in a sketchy way. Since often the literature
offers either/or alternatives (for instance individualism versus collectivism), it is
somewhat arbitrary where such alternatives belonging to different layers of culture
are put according to the distinctions that have been made so far. Nevertheless, what
the exercise will render is a rough overview of the achievements and meanings of
those layers of culture (Hofstede 1997; Trompenaars and Hampden-Turner 1999;
Weber 1972; Taylor 2007; Rosenstock-Huessy 1993; Gauchet 1985; Hess and
Hampden-Turner 1995).
1. Uncertainty avoidance. This brings us the question, whether people stick to the
traditional habits or are open to new and challenging situations. When people are
908 K.Y. Kebede et al.
dissatisfied with the status quo and the heritage of the past sooner or later the
time comes to prioritize the unknown future above the well-known present and
the past, which is a painful process. Different cultures made such discoveries,
at different stages of the axial age, devaluing the status quo, by striving for
nothingness (Buddhism), emptiness (Taoism) or an invisible God, promising a
future of justice (Judaism). Everywhere, people who in our time take a risk in
order to attain a better future, turn against the group, and are singled out as
belonging to a future, which is not yet realized, repeat the past performance of
these traditions.
2. Creative or repetitive. This asks the question, are people valued for being
innovation and creativity oriented, or for their adaptation and incorporation
in tradition, and in the common group life? Generally, uncertainty avoidance
stiffens creativity, because thinking “out-of-the-box” often means standing alone.
Many have suffered for such an attitude in the history of humanity, and others
have given their very lives for it. A few examples would suffice: Socrates was
forced to take hemlock, because his thinking did not conform to that of the
society (Läertius 1972, p. 240), while Aristotle was forced to flee his mother-
land, claiming that he would not allow ancient Athenians to sin twice against
philosophy (Copleston 1985, p. 268). Galileo Galilei was excommunicated by
the Church and banished, while Jesus Christ, before him, was crucified among
common thieves, like a criminal. And yet their only crime was that they thought
the unthinkable, and saw what nobody else could see, in their age and milieu.
3. Value of ordinary life. Under this point, one needs to ask two key questions: do
people strive for the top, for status and power, or do they consider ordinary life
and “ordinary” relationships (friends, marriage, and family) as more valuable?
Is service toward others only a matter of obedience, in terms of hierarchy
and collectivism, or is it considered valuable in itself? To reach the stage
where labor, ordinary life, being unnoticed at the top, can become part of the
bloodstream of humanity, people first have to give up their pride, status, and
self-esteem. In order to enter the future a degree of formlessness is required,
a humility and openness for further developments, what is sometimes called
“servant leadership” (Greenleaf 1977). The real leader is not in control but at
the front.
4. Criticism and respect. This point carries three questions as follows: can criticism
only function as criticism from the top to people lower in the hierarchy, or is it
possible to criticize people with high status and power as well? Is criticism the
end of a respectful relationship or can it be integrated into it? Is disagreement
accepted as part of the process of finding agreement or is it “dangerous” and
should it be avoided at all costs? Often people feel they lose face if they are
criticized or make mistakes, because, in many societies, it is culturally not an
accepted fact that nobody is perfect. Criticism is allowed and necessary, however,
in a society that allows a rupture with the past. Perfection, in such a culture,
is beyond reach anyway, hidden in the future. To accept criticism is always
problematic, even in the most progressive societies, because if an individual takes
the next step into the future and goes beyond accepted opinions, nobody will be
grateful.
49 Successful Contextual Technology Transfer and Determinants of Culture 909
5. Sequential or synchronic. This has to do with the way people operate. Are people
doing things in parallel and responding to the requirements of each separate
moment, or do they work in a sequential order according to plan, and do they plan
ahead? By planning, time is dealt with in an instrumental way, i.e., as a means
to reach a goal. The present is valued in its function for realizing a better future.
The importance of future success turns the present into merely a means, which
implies quite a change of attitude. In a synchronic culture the present moment is
more important than the future, in the sense that the person entering the room at
this particular moment, even without an appointment, always deserves priority.
A functional attitude, generally, values the present in function of future goals,
and takes things in space as related to (in function of, analytically) far-off things.
The present becomes a function of the far-off in time and space, and is less lived
as a separate moment to be valued in and for itself.
6. Analytical or metaphorical. In a metaphorical culture, the living experience is
expressed in stories and metaphors, poetic images, and narrative details, whereas
an analytical attitude is looking after the numbers and the data. This analytical
attitude is related to planning and instrumental dealing with time in the sense
that it reduces living reality to its mechanical functions in order to reach a
goal. Generally speaking, if Africans describe poverty, for instance, they use
qualitative metaphors and stories about suffering, and use images of desolation
and hopelessness, whereas Western donors ask quantitative questions, such as
how much food is available, and how much clean water is needed.
7. Voluntaristic or fatalistic. Are people in control of their environment on the basis
of their own initiative (from an inner center, as it were) or are they exposed
to the influences of their environment, without any control, and do they take
things as they are? Fatalism is connected to traditionalism: Whatever happens,
group traditions are repeated and prolonged. Intervening in the usual course of
events, however, comes down to taking a decision from an inner center of action
in response to a future challenge. Where change and going against the group is
not valued, a traditional society becomes more or less automatically fatalistic,
taking things as they are. Thereby life comes to mean repetition of traditional
values (fate literally means what is foretold – what was once foretold determines
our course of action, whatever happens).
The figure beneath shows that human life is always at the crossroads, both
individually and socially (Fig. 49.1). Constantly and irreversibly humans have to
choose either to continue the heritage of the past or to change their ways. And at
the same time constantly decisions have to be made who are partners and who are
adversaries, whom to speak to and whom to compete with, who is inside and who
is outside. Depending on such decisions and priorities humans cling to the different
qualities listed above. This implies that none of these human qualities (or virtues or
modes of behavior) is good or bad in itself. All of them may be temporarily good
and justified, and, at other times, not functional but detrimental. Western history,
for instance, may be considered as equalizing and democratizing, but still there is
hierarchy which is crucial. The country which started with democracy (the French
49 Successful Contextual Technology Transfer and Determinants of Culture 911
Outside: Object
Empires
historical achievements, even if they were taken over, merely been copied. The
adaptation to the indigenous cultural system always requires also a renewal of such
qualities. It needs to get a specific version of such qualities in each new situation.
Even among Western nations there are considerable differences in human types and
qualities, there are different versions of democratic and egalitarian societies. The
integration of different cultural values in the end is a creative process, in which both
the indigenous and the incoming values are innovated, as soon as they are coupled
to each other. Time and again, a new version of these qualities is created. A case
in point is the adaptation of money transfer through the mobile phone handset, in
Kenya, popularly known as M-pesa, needless to mention its variance of M-kesho.
This spread its tentacles to UK and USA, even though it developed, as a response to
the needs of a concrete situation, where money transfer was cumbersome, because
the majority of the people lives in rural areas without bank accounts and never
bothered to buy mobile phones.
NGOs +
University University Government Businesses +
Vocational
Europe Africa Institutions Finance
training
the needs of the receiving society. Basically, the society is the center of analysis,
not the available technologies and not the demand in terms of money available.
In this regard policy makers, politicians, NGOs, universities, the press, in short,
the society in general, have to play a role. None of these agents has a complete
overview, and none can do without each other’s adjustments and criticisms.
2. Analyze how to satisfy the needs (options identification and design). The needs
identified require options to meet them. These options of how to satisfy the
needs may not necessarily be technology related (in its “hardware” aspect).
More often than not, organizational skills and capacities are sufficient to help
people help themselves. If that is not the case, and of course mere transfer of
organizational skills is insufficient, then the first assignment is to design, or
redesign, the incoming technology, to suit the local conditions and sociocultural
requirements. This is to be done primarily by institutes of higher education, and
in this cooperation, universities from the West give an input from the specialized
knowledge they have. Universities from developing countries may not have such
specialized knowledge, but they know much more about the culture and local
conditions, in which the technology is meant to function.
3. Analyze the technology within the bigger perspective of sustainable develop-
ment. The criteria of such an analysis can be contained in a national development
plan of the developing country, or in other policy designs. In general, developing
nations have set their priorities by strategic plans, or development plans. These
plans might constrain the resources that governments are willing to commit to
the options. But these, too, do not necessarily respond to the real needs of a
society. In any case, technology transfers should consider the larger framework
in which they operate. It does not, for instance, make much sense to introduce
tube wells, for large-scale irrigation for one village, if the aquifers clearly do not
contain enough water for the whole region. This is a matter of policy makers,
universities, NGOs, government institutions, and civil societies to sort out.
4. Decide between indigenous production, or transfer/contextualization. Even
though most of the technologies of developing countries are transferred from
914 K.Y. Kebede et al.
overseas, there are technologies that can be developed and used locally. The
“make option” is attractive, if the resources and skills needed to produce it are
locally available, and the technology is of great economic or strategic interest
for the society. However, it is important to point out that investing in the “make
option” only for reasons of strategic interest can lead to disaster.
In the contextualization of the technology, institutes of higher learning, which
design the technology for local use, need local knowledge and experience in
order to make the technology work. Here NGOs, and via them end-users,
should be involved in the design and development process. A good example
of what happens, if that is forgotten, is the building of biogas installations,
which were donated by a foreign NGO as a pilot project to some farmers in
Northern Ethiopia – at a village in Wukro. The NGO paid and the farmers had
to build them. The NGO even provided a small (Western type) cooking stove
for burning the biogas. However, the NGO did not consider that in Ethiopia
cooking stoves should be suitable to baking the large pancake-like Injera, which
the Ethiopians use as bread. Since the cooking stoves were not adapted to this use,
the farmers did not use the biogas installations either. A feasibility study should
show whether the technology can find customers/users, in what ways customers
would like to use the technology, what they are willing to pay, and so on. Such
a feasibility study, in turn, feeds into the design process in order to adapt the
technology to customer preferences, and make it marketable.
But it is not only the end-users that the design and contextualization of the
technology should consider: Availability of materials, maintenance skills, the
option of local production of spare parts, and user-friendliness of the technology
for the local community must also be considered. Other aspects to be considered
are adaptation of maintenance, organization, management, and replacement at
the end of the life cycle to local cultural capacities (or otherwise to develop such
capacities and train them as part of the project, in order to deal with new forms of
management). All of these issues need attention, and should be listed as design
requirements for the proper design of the end product.
At this stage vocational training also has a role to play in the sense that the
technologies should be designed for local production and maintenance as much
as possible, and it is vocational training institutes which have to teach and build
capacities and skills among their students to make, install, and repair them. The
technology should properly be designed to that end. It should, in addition, be
not only economically and socially, but also financially sustainable. In the end, it
should be possible to run an independent business by the use of the technology.
5. Assess the technology considering economic, social, cultural, and environmental
impact. Analyzing the possible impacts of a technology makes it possible to stop
the process timely, if necessary, or otherwise to introduce compensating policies
on the level of economics, environment, as well as culture. Assessing the tech-
nology with economic-related criteria and policies is essential. Countries may
have their priority sectors – for instance, Ethiopia is engaging more on leather
and textile industry and biotechnology, besides agriculture. Developing countries
49 Successful Contextual Technology Transfer and Determinants of Culture 915
Implementation.
7 Conclusion
In this chapter the process of technology transfer has been analyzed and evaluated,
taking into account its complex nature and with special attention for proper needs
assessments and the assessment of cultural differences. An inventory of culture-
specific values has been presented, and it has been pointed out how these values
can function as a common stock to help design a path-dependent way forward, in a
combination of technology transfer and cultural transition. In the end, the steps to
be taken have been listed, consciously and reflexively.
This model could contribute to mutual adaptation processes between technolog-
ical design and social needs, in which the social needs and cultural values of the
receiving culture feed back into the decisions on transfer of the technology, its
49 Successful Contextual Technology Transfer and Determinants of Culture 917
8 Summary
skills, ways of dealing with technology and with other actors, values, and human
qualities, which the technology requires, should be put in place in one package
with the technology itself. This means either adaptation of the technology to the
local culture and habits, or training and education in those human qualities and
values, capacities, etc., which modern technology requires, capacities like planning,
anonymous trust, universalistic rules and regulations, etc. Such equilibria and trade-
offs should be constructed in a path-dependent way building on former experiences.
In many projects often without explicitly knowing such equilibria and trade-offs
are tried, including training of new patterns of behavior and organization. There
are only few projects in which the construction of such trade-offs and equilibria
are made deliberately part of the project itself. More such experiments should be
tried, even if this approach may be somewhat sensitive in that it touches on the
inner core of norms and values of individual persons and cultures. Part of such
experiments should be the question: how did we get here and where do we go from
here? This is an important question for everybody involved in intercultural dialogue.
This question is also important as a matter of further research. The question should
be researched and experimented with, whether on a global scale there can also be a
labor division in terms of values and ways of life, maintaining different paths into
the future. This type of questioning and research is only in an embryonic stage. But
in order to avoid a clash of cultures the question should be put on the agenda. As a
matter of fact, no society has reached its final stage. This type of questioning instead
turns all societies into developing countries.
References
M.M. Awny, Technology transfer and implementation processes in developing countries. Int. J.
Technol. Manage. 32, 213–220 (2005)
H.J. Berman, Law and Revolution – The Formation of the Western Legal Tradition, vol. I (Harvard
University Press, Cambridge London, 1983)
M.R.W. Boomer, R.E. Janaro, D.C. Luper, A manufacturing strategy model for international
technology transfer. Technol. Forecast. Soc. Change 39, 377–390 (1991)
F. Copleston, A History of Philosophy, Vol. I (Westminster, Maryland: Newman Press; New York:
Image Books, 1985)
M. De Jong, J.O. Kroesen, Understanding how to import good governance practices and
Bangladeshi villages, and knowledge. Technol. Policy 19(4), 9–25 (2007)
J. Fried, P. Molnar, Technological and Social Change: A Transdisciplinary Model (Petrocelli
Books, New York, 1978)
M. Gauchet, Le Désenchantement du Monde, une Histoire Politique de la Religion (Gallimard,
Paris, 1985)
R.K. Greenleaf, Servant Leadership: A Journey into the Nature of Legitimate Power and Greatness
(Paulist, New Jersey, 1977)
D.J. Hess, Hampden-Turner, Science and Technology in a Multicultural World (Columbia Univer-
sity Press, New York, 1995)
G. Hofstede, Cultures and Organizations; Software of the Mind (Mc Graw Hill, New York, 1997)
T. Holland, Millennium. The End of the World and the Forging of Christendom (Little Brown and
Company, London, 2008)
49 Successful Contextual Technology Transfer and Determinants of Culture 919
IETC (International Environmental Technology Center), Technology Transfer: The Seven “C” s for
the Successful Transfer and Uptake of Environmentally Sound Technologies (United Nations
Environment Program, Osaka, 2003)
J.O. Kroesen, A. Rozendaal, A cross-cultural management system: the Ubuntu Company as a
paradigm. Int. J. Technol. Policy Manage. 10(3), 284–298 (2010). ISSN 1468-4322
D. Läertius, Lives of Eminent Philosophers, trans. R. O. Hicks (Cambridge, Massachusetts:
Harvard University Press, 1972)
H.A. Linstone, Multiple perspectives: concepts, applications, and user guidelines. Syst. Pract. 2(3),
307–31 (1989)
D.C. Luper, M.R.W. Bommer, R.E. Janaro, A manufacturing strategy model for international
technology transfer. Technol. Forecast. Soc. Change 39, 377–390 (1991)
C.N. Madu, Transferring technology to developing countries – critical factors for success. Long
Range Plann. 22(4), 115–124 (1988)
A. Masciarelli, The rise and fall of the Nile Perch. (BBC News, 2005), http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/
africa/4348289.stm. Accessed 17 June 2008
T.J. Misa, Leonardo to the Internet – Technology and Culture from the Renaissance to the Present
(Hopkins University Press, Baltimore London, 2004)
K. Mulder, Sustainable Development for Engineers- A Hand Book and Resource Guide (Greenleaf,
Sheffield, 2006)
K.E. Putranto, D.F. Stewart, G.A. Moore, R. Diatmoko, Implementing a technology strategy in
developing countries: the experience of the Indonesian rolling stock industry. Technol. Forecast.
Soc. Change 70, 163–176 (2003)
W. Ravesteijn, J. Kop (eds.), For Profit and Prosperity, the Contribution that Dutch Engineers
made to Public Works in Indonesia, 1800–2000 (Aprilis Uitgeverij, Zaltbommel, 2008)
E. Rosenstock-Huessy, Out of Revolution – Autobiography of Western Man (Argo Books,
New York, 1993), (original 1938)
A.C. Samli, Technology Transfer: Geographic, Economic, Cultural and Technical Dimensions
(Greenwood Press, Westport, 1985)
N. Sharif, Book review: development techniques for international technology transfer. Technol.
Forecast. Soc. Change 70, 923–927 (2003)
R. Smits, J. Leyten, Key issues in the institutionalization of TA. Futures 20(1), 19–36 (1988)
Solid Waste Management in Nairobi, Students report. In addition, oral information from
Mr. George Opiyo, from Tangaza College, who took part in the project as a tutor for the waste
management research group, Students Internship Report TU Delft (unpublished, 2010)
M.L. Stackhouse, Creeds, Society and Human Rights, Study in Three Cultures, Eerdmans (Grand
Rapids, Michigan, 1984)
C. Taylor, A Secular Age (Harvard, Cambridge Londen, 2007)
M. Towery, No answers in Indonesia, (Atlanta International Magazine 1998), http://www.
fryconsultants.com/Indonesia.htm. Accessed 16 Feb 2007
F. Trompenaars, C. Hampden-Turner, Riding the Waves of Culture (Brealey, London, 1999)
M. Weber, Die Protestantische Ethik, ed. by J. Winckelmann (Siebenstern, Tübingen, 1972),
(Original 1920)
H.J. Wiarda, Civil Society: The American Model and Third World Development (Westview,
Massachusetts, 2003)
A. Winkler, Geschichte des Westens von den Anfängen in der Antike bis zum 20. Jahrhundert
(C. H. Beck, München, 2009)
L. Winner, Do artifacts have politics? in Modern Technology: Problem or Opportunity?, vol. 109,
issue 1, ed. Daedalus (MIT, Cambridge, 1980), pp. 121–136
A. Wright, The Death of Ramon Gonzalez: The Modern Agricultural Dilemma (University of
Texas, Texas, 1992)
Section VI
Energy Sources of the Future
Energy Sources of the Future:
Introduction 50
Fabio Orecchini
1 Introduction
Going beyond the limitation of the present is the essential feature for an energy
source to be defined as “energy source of the future.”
The limitations of the present energy era are well understood and widely
recognized. As the world energy system is nowadays based approximately at 80%
on coal, oil, and natural gas, the world population is committing its development to
sources:
• Exhaustible
• Geographically not homogeneously distributed
• Primary source of greenhouse gases
The consequent instability on the global economy and political equilibrium and
the inequality on the energy accessibility for the world population are evident
worldwide.
Summarizing all the possible implications, the main limit of the present energy
system, due to the energy sources on which it is based, is the un-sustainability.
In such a way, it comes clearly to light the key feature of the energy sources of
the future: sustainability.
A clear definition of energy sustainability, according to sustainability science, is
to be based on the following pillars:
• Renewability of energy resources
• Efficiency in energy conversion, distribution, and use
• Lowering of environmental impact
• Increasing of energy accessibility
• Tailor-making of energy systems on local social, economic, and environmental
conditions
F. Orecchini
Interuniversity Research Centre for Sustainable Development, University of Rome La Sapienza,
Department of Mechanics and Energy, Guglielmo Marconi University, Rome, Italy
e-mail: fabio.orecchini@uniroma1.it
The present section aims to discuss the energy sources able to match with the
five pillars above, i.e., the renewable resources solar energy, biomass energy, wind
energy, earth energy, and water energy.
Going into the chapter’s details, “Renewability of Energy Resources, Energy
Vectors, and Energy Technologies for Mobility” is the first chapter where the
implications of source’s renewability are discussed.
The connection between the renewable energy sources and the closed cycles,
where the concept of “consumption of the resources and waste” is substituted by the
concept of “use (and endless reuse) of the resources without waste” is discussed. The
role of the energy vectors to satisfy the need of energy transportation and storage,
implied by the fact that the primary resources are generally available in a different
place and in a different time comparing with the energy demand, is highlighted.
Attention is paid to the crucial changes required to the mobility system (responsible
today for more than 60% of world consumption of liquid fuel) to integrate at best
the new energy vectors.
The following five chapters discuss in detail about the energy sources and the
analysis includes the most relevant sources for the energy global balance of the
Earth.
The Earth system, in which the human beings operate, in fact can be considered
a close physical system on the point of view of the matter exchange with the outer
space, but not on the point of view of the energy exchange. On the point of view of
the energy exchange is definitely an open system and a continuous energy input is
guaranteed by different naturally available sources.
The main energy input is from the Sun: the direct solar power accounts for
99.98% of the entire energy available on Earth. The other sources contribute to
the energy balance of the Earth for the remaining 0.02% and include energy from
gravitational interaction, as well as the thermal energy present inside of the Earth,
conveyed to the surface through conduction and convection.
The chapter “Solar Energy” is therefore dedicated to solar power: also, nearly
30% of the solar incident radiation is reflected by the Earth’s surface and dispersed
in the external space; the atmosphere, the surface of the Earth, and the oceans absorb
nearly 47% of the total (roughly 81,00012 W). If only the 0.1% is converted by
current photovoltaic or thermal technologies, the theoretical potential corresponds
to nearly 80 1012 W with an annual energy availability of 7 1014 MWh (5:9
104 Mtep) per year.
The chapter “Biomass Energy” is dedicated to biomass: this source also can
be directly ascribable to the solar power of which nearly 40 1012 W (0.05%) is
transformed by the chlorophyll contained in plants, fixing the carbon in the leaves
and storing the energy as carbohydrates. The biomass is the first energy resource
used by human from time out of mind and also nowadays remains the only energy
source readily available for the most part of the world population. One big limitation
is the low energy density (10–20 MJ/Kg), and also the fact that it is historically
converted into thermal energy, the less flexible kind of energy, but new technologies
are oriented to higher efficiency power and heat-generation processes.
50 Energy Sources of the Future: Introduction 925
Abstract
This chapter gives an overview of biomass resources for the production of
bioenergy with emphasis on the production of electricity from renewable sug-
arcane crop. The benefits of bioenergy production are given after which the
techniques and technologies for the conversion of alternative biomass feedstock
into energy products are outlined. A case study of commercial-scale electricity
generation from sugarcane biomass is then given together with the associated
design aspects, efficiency, performance indicators, benchmarks, and economic
and environmental aspects. The opportunities for replication of such experience
worldwide are finally discussed in particular in the context of sustainable energy
development.
1 Introduction
V. Seebaluck ()
Department of Chemical and Environmental Engineering, University of Mauritius, Le Reduit,
Mauritius
e-mail: v.seebaluck@uom.ac.mu
the creation of rural livelihoods, and offer new development paths that can meet key
environmental goals and sustainable development patterns.
Biomass is present in different forms worldwide but the dominant source is from
crops which draw on the biophysical and climatic advantages of world regions.
However, on average, biomass crops in tropical and subtropical climates are five
times as productive, in terms of photosynthetic efficiency, compared to biomass
produced in temperate regions; Smeets et al. (2004) reported that Africa has
the greatest potential for bioenergy development of any world region while it is
currently highly dependent on inefficient uses of biomass that deliver low-quality
energy services.
The production of modern biomass and biofuels can bring multiple benefits;
at the domestic level these will include health improvements, reduced regional
emissions, and the creation of rural livelihoods while the macroeconomic impacts
will include foreign exchange savings and reduced dependence on imported sources
of energy. There is also significant potential for greenhouse gas (GHG) emission
reductions from expanded use of modern bioenergy, with the latter earning credits
under the Kyoto Clean Development Mechanism (CDM). However, harnessing the
potential of bioenergy requires coordination with respect to economic policy, trade,
and resource practices and regulations.
2 Biomass Resources
cereals), forest plants (eucalyptus), energy crops (sweet sorghum, Arundo donax),
and aquatic plants (algae, seaweeds). Waste biomass will include agricultural
residues, forest wastes, municipal solid waste, animal wastes, and process wastes.
All of these feedstock have the potential for producing bioenergy in different forms.
Biomass resources used for energy production offer many advantages: they
are easily grown, collected, utilized, and replaced fairly quickly over reasonable
period of time without permanently depleting the Earth’s natural resources; they
are more evenly distributed globally compared to fossil sources; they can offer
opportunities for energy self-sufficiency in many countries or as alternative fuel to
reduced dependence on fossil fuels; there exist many commercial, mature, and state-
of-the-art biomass to energy conversion technologies which are in many cases less
capital intensive; they are environment friendly given that they are characterized by
closed carbon cycles with net zero impact that is the CO2 produced when burned
or transformed and used as energy products are sequestered by the plants during
growing phase; they provide multiple socio-economic benefits; they have the ability
to create sustainable livelihoods; and they have wide range of application from
pico-, micro-, medium-, industrial- to large-scale generation. In general, biomass
energy resources offer many crosscutting advantages when compared to other
energy resources including renewable ones.
There are mainly three different biomass to bioenergy conversion routes, namely,
direct combustion/incineration, thermochemical conversion, and biochemical con-
version, as given in Fig. 51.1. These processes differ in practical applications with
respect to the capacity, conversion time, and efficiency among other processing
parameters. While there exist many such commercial technologies for energy
production that have been used for long and have become mature, many others are
also constantly being developed and demonstrated worldwide.
Combustion and incineration is the most common process in biomass to energy
conversion technologies and is the burning through rapid oxidation accompanied
by heat and light to produce heat/steam and electricity for simultaneous usage.
These processes are applicable to solid, liquid, and gaseous fuels but are generally
applied to solid fuels such as sugarcane biomass, wood, or municipal solid waste.
It is generally convenient and economical to burn the solids semi dried or at lower
moisture content in order to derive higher amount of energy from the combustible.
Thermochemical conversion is comprised of two main techniques, namely,
gasification and pyrolysis. Gasification is a process that occurs at high temperature
and pressure to convert carbon-containing fuels into a synthesis or producer gas
consisting primarily of carbon monoxide (CO) and hydrogen .H2 / together with
carbon dioxide .CO2 / and methane .CH4 / as residual gases through incomplete
combustion and reduction. The products of gasification are heat and electricity. The
electricity productivity of the gasification process as compared to the conventional
Rankine steam cycle could be increased by more than two times. Such process
930 V. Seebaluck
Direct
Thermochemical Biochemical
combustion/
conversion conversion
incineration
adds value to low or negative value feedstock and is applicable to low-quality coal,
petroleum-based materials, as well as biomass such as wood or sugarcane fibers.
Pyrolysis is the conversion of biomass into gases, liquids, and solids at temper-
atures of around 500–900ı C by heating in closed vessel in the absence of O2 (e.g.,
pyrolytic destructive distillation of wood into methanol, acetic acid, turpentine, and
charcoal). It can process all forms of organic materials which are difficult to be
handled by other processes. The gases produced are a mixture of H2 , CH4 , CO,
CO2 , and other hydrocarbons while an oil-like liquid is concurrently produced
together with solids similar to charcoal. It produces a high calorific value fuel
.22–30 MJ=m3 / from difficult waste which can be used to produce electricity.
Production of hydrogen as a by-product from the process is seen as an increasingly
valuable fuel.
Biochemical conversion consists of two main processes, namely, anaerobic
digestion and fermentation. Anaerobic digestion is the microbial digestion of
biomass done by anaerobe (a microscopic organism that can live and grow without
external O2 or air) which extracts O2 by decomposing the biomass at low tempera-
ture (up to 65ı C) in the presence of moisture (80%). It generates mostly CH4 and
CO2 with small amount of impurities such as H2 S. The gas is scrubbed to generate
a superior fuel gas .CH4 / which can be directly burnt for electricity generation or
other purposes. Typical potential feedstock used are agricultural biomass/residues,
forest biomass, aquatic biomass, municipal solid waste, and animal waste. Biogas
plants using wastes are very common in developing countries such as India and
China where they use conventional low technologies. On the other hand, modern
high-technology plants such as those processing municipal solid waste are common
in developed countries.
51 Biomass Energy Field 931
Edible Oil
Crops
Oil Bearing Crops Transesterification Biodiesel
Non-Edible
Oil Crops
Fermentation
Sugar & Starch
&
Containing Crops Distilation
Ethanol
Hydrolysis (Acid/ Biofuels
Enzymatic),
Fermentation & (Biodiesel/
Distillation Bioethanol/
Chemicals Biogas)
Low Pressure
Depolymerisation
Pyrolysis
Hydrogenation
Hydrocarbons/
Bio-Oil
Lignocellulosic
Fisher-Tropsh
Crops Steam
&
Bio-Electricity
Combustion
Briquetting/
Pellets
Pelletisation
Combined
Heat & Power
Bio-Heating
Anaerobic
Wet Biomass Biogas
Digestion
Bagasse is the fibrous residue obtained as by-product from a sugar factory after
juice is extracted from cane. It is a mixture of hard fiber, with soft and smooth
parenchymatous (pith) tissue of highly hygroscopic nature and contains mainly
cellulose, hemicellulose, pentosans, lignin, sugar, and minerals. The quantity of
bagasse obtained varies from 22% to 36% of the weight of cane processed and is
affected mainly by the fiber content and the cleanliness of cane supplied, which in
turn depends on the harvesting practices.
Bagasse contains 45–52% moisture as it comes out of the cane-milling plant
and is generally known as “mill wet bagasse.” Most mills produce a bagasse of
48% moisture content, and as such most boilers are designed to burn bagasse with
51 Biomass Energy Field 933
around 50% moisture. The gross calorific value of bagasse is 19,250 kJ/kg at 0%
moisture and 9,950 kJ/kg at 48% moisture. According to Rao (1997), it has varying
gross calorific values (GCVs) in the range of 19,037–19,497 kJ/kg. The net calorific
value or the practical energy that can be derived from bagasse is 7,985 kJ/kg at
48% moisture content. Moisture content is indeed the main determinant of the net
calorific value; a good cane-milling process will result in low moisture content
whereas high moisture content is the result of poor milling efficiency.
Bagasse is difficult to store and is prone to fermentation and chemical reactions
that can trigger slow internal combustion resulting in fire risks. It can be stored up to
a period of 1 year if it is dried to moisture content of less than 30%. Bagasse drying
is generally not practiced in the sugar industry and is currently an area of research
and development. Bagasse has also a low bulk density of around 160 kg=m3 (Paturau
1989) which poses handling and storage problems. Hence, it has historically been
common practice to continuously burn bagasse obtained from the mill in order to
avoid disposing it in stacking areas, which is costly in terms of equipment and
facilities. Due to the inherent low bulk density of the material, compaction and
briquetting can be practiced to reduce handling and storage problems which at
the same time decrease the moisture content. Pelletization is another densification
process that can be adopted to improve the combustion properties of bagasse as well
as facilitating storage (Seebaluck and Thielamay 2010).
The technology for electricity generation using solid fuels, through the Rankine
cycle route, is conventional and is adopted by the power industry worldwide. The
basic alteration in the technology for generating exportable surplus electricity from
bagasse in sugar mills depends on the peculiarities of the material that are addressed
during the design of the furnace in the boiler house. All other technologies and
equipment are similar to the conventional power plants using other solid fuels for
power generation.
Cogeneration is defined as the concurrent production of process heat/steam and
electricity in an industrial plant by the sequential use of energy from a common fuel
source. Depending on the quality of process heat used, cogeneration may be based
on the “topping” or the “bottom cycle.” In the “bottom cycle,” the required process
heat is at high temperatures, and hence, power is generated through a suitable
waste heat recovery system. In “topping cycle,” the required process heat is at low
temperatures, and therefore, power generation is performed first. All sugar mills
employ this cycle for cogenerating power and heat. For sugar mill cogeneration,
a combination of stored and fresh bagasse is usually fed to a specially designed
furnace to generate steam in a boiler at typical pressures and temperatures of usually
between 20 and 87 bars and 350–525ıC, respectively. The high pressure steam is
then expanded either in a back pressure or single extraction back pressure or single
extraction condensing or double extraction cum condensing type turbo generator
934 V. Seebaluck
operating at similar inlet steam conditions. Due to high pressure and temperature,
as well as extraction and condensing modes of the turbine, higher quantum of power
gets generated in the turbine–generator set, over and above the power required for
the sugar process, other by-products, and cogeneration plant auxiliaries. The excess
power generated in the turbine generator set is then stepped up to extra high voltage,
depending on the nearby substation configuration and fed into the nearby utility
grid. As the sugar industry operates seasonally, the boilers are normally designed for
multi-fuel operations, so as to utilize mill bagasse, procured bagasse, other biomass,
coal, and fossil fuel (supplementary fuel or in exigencies), so as to ensure year-round
operation of the power plant for export to the grid.
There are mainly three bagasse cogeneration technologies, namely, extraction
cum back pressure route, extraction and condensing route, and condensing route
based on dual fuel system. In the extraction cum back pressure route, the sugar
factory produces only as much steam as is needed for the sugar processing side. By
upgrading the steam parameters, surplus power is produced after meeting captive
requirements. It is the cheapest option from the point of view of initial cost and
efficiency of the system. However, one major drawback is that fluctuations in surplus
power supply are related to fluctuations in cane supply, process steam demand, etc.
In sugar plants having such configuration, surplus power production is envisaged
only during the crushing season.
In the extraction and condensing system, the sugar factory produces steam from
the entire quantity of bagasse produced during the crushing season. Surplus power
production can be extended during off-crushing season by operating the turbine in
the condensing mode, provided off-crop season fuel is available abundantly and
cheaply. Power can also be generated by using bagasse bought from satellite sugar
mills or bagasse left over during the crushing season. The capital cost for this
configuration is higher compared to the extraction cum back pressure route, but
it ensures the supply of stable surplus power during the crushing season, thereby
reducing fluctuations in sugar plant operation.
The condensing route based on dual fuel system ensures a year-round, stable
surplus power supply through the use of a support fuel. It is a viable option for sugar
mills located near a reliable source of secondary fuel or which can be reliably and
cheaply available. The design aspects of the plant should ensure the availability of
a suitable furnace capable of multi-fuel combustion, particularly the combination
of bagasse and coal or other supplementary and appropriate combustible. The
capital cost of multi-fuel systems, particularly those using coal as support fuel, is
usually high in addition to the connected considerations of pollution control and ash
disposal. Highly skilled manpower is required for the operation and maintenance of
such advanced technology.
Table 51.1 Benchmarks for surplus electricity production from sugarcane bagasse based on
commercial experience
Country Power mode Operating configuration Surplus exportable electricity
Mauritius Continuous 20 bars and 325ı C 25 kWh/tonne cane
Continuous 31 bars and 440ı C 45 kWh/tonne cane
Continuous 45 bars and 475ı C 53 kWh/tonne cane
Firm (CEST) 45 bars and 440ı C 75 kWh/tonne cane
Firm (CEST) 82 bars and 525ı C 130–140 kWh/tonne cane
India CEST 67 bars and 495ı C 90–120 kWh/tonne cane
CEST 87bars and 515ı C 130–140 kWh/tonne cane
Brazil Continuous 22 bars and 300ı C 0–10 kWh/tonne cane
Continuous 42 bars and 440ı C 20 kWh/tonne cane
Continuous 67 bars and 480ı C 40–60 kWh/tonne cane
Source: Seebaluck et al. (2007)
51 Biomass Energy Field 937
but this trend is gradually being reviewed to install higher pressure boilers. In
India, high pressure and temperature configurations in Condensing Extraction Steam
Turbine (CEST) systems have been widely implemented starting in the 1990s, in
part through international technical cooperation programs (USAID 2002).
There are a number of options for increasing the energy potential of cane fibers
for steam and electricity generation which include conservative options like
improving the physico-chemical properties of the combustible or process
efficiency optimization; the use of additional materials like Sugarcane Agricultural
Residues (SAR); and the use of emerging technologies such as gasification. Many
research and development projects are currently being undertaken in a number of
countries for improving the bioenergy potential of cane biomass. The main options
for enhancing the cane fiber energy potential are:
(a) Use of high pressure boilers up to 82–87 bars or even more where higher
electricity productivity is obtained per tonne of combustible.
(b) Optimization of the physicochemical properties of bagasse such as the moisture
sucrose and fiber content. Seebaluck (2009) evaluated that an increase in 1%
moisture in bagasse leads to a drop in 1.07 kWh/TC of surplus electricity while
an increase in 1% sucrose in bagasse leads to an increase in 4.58 kWh/TC
of surplus electricity. The most significant impact is seen with an increase
in 1% fiber in cane which leads to an increase in 13.34 kWh/TC of surplus
electricity.
(c) Combustion or co-firing of Sugarcane Agricultural Residues (SAR) with
bagasse. Seebaluck and Seeruttun (2009) reported the net calorific value of
SAR to be 5,980 kJ/kg at a moisture content of 54.5%. The combustion of a
mixture of 70% bagasse and 30% SAR among different potential options for
SAR conversion to electricity was found to be the most appropriate for the short
term. This option required the collection of 35% of SAR from cane fields that
would increase the share of electricity exported to the grid per tonne of cane
by about 37%. The cost of collection, handling and transportation of SAR was
found to be around 7–8 USD per tonne or around 1 USD/GJ while the additional
equipment required for the processing of SAR prior its combustion in the power
plant was about 16 USD per tonne. The cost of electricity generation from this
mix of bagasse and SAR was estimated to be 0.06 USD/kWh which was found
to be very competitive compared to other renewable energy resources. Besides
being a viable renewable energy business, SAR conversion into electricity favors
green harvesting that avoids significant CO2 emission during cane burning
in fields and its utilization for energy generation displaces around 230 kg of
sub-bituminous coal and 560 kg of CO2 per tonne cane (Seebaluck et al. 2009).
Such project could even qualify for CERs. It has also the potential for the
creation of livelihoods given that one job is likely to be created for each 2 GWh
938 V. Seebaluck
of electricity produced from SAR. This project could be very appropriate for
increasing the revenue and bioenergy potential of the cane industry.
Combustion of SAR has indeed been tried in a number of sugarcane-
producing countries on the international front. In Sao Paulo, Brazil, there are
five sugar mills which are known to produce and sell surplus electricity to the
state by burning mixtures of 20–30% cane trash and bagasse. It was estimated
that the full utilization of bagasse and SAR for the production of electricity
could serve 5.5–7 million people, respectively, per year in Brazil (Ripoli et al.
2000). In 1994, the Cruangi Mill in Brazil used 100% cane trash for combustion,
and it was operated continuously for more than 1 month (Leal 1995). In 1993,
two sugar factories in Hawaii, namely, Ka’u Agn’ Business Co. and Waialua
Sugar Co. burned around 27,000 and 70,976 tonnes of cane trash, respectively,
in addition to bagasse utilization for cogeneration purposes (Rao 1997).
In Brazil, the Sugarcane Renewable Electricity (SUCRE) project will build
on an earlier project, “BRA/96/G31 – Biomass Power Generation: Sugar Cane
Bagasse and Trash” supported by UNDP and the EU (CTC 2005), to catalyze the
transformation of the sugarcane industry in Brazil into one for which supply of
renewable electricity from sugarcane biomass to the grid becomes a significant
and core aspect of their business, alongside sugar and ethanol production. To
maximize the potential of electricity generation from sugarcane, the project will
facilitate the expanded use of bagasse and launch the widespread use of SAR
that have historically been burned in the cane fields (UNDP 2009).
(d) The adoption of bagasse-integrated gasification–combine cycle (BIG–CC)
wherein the electricity productivity could be increased by more than two times.
Research on bagasse gasification has been carried out on pilot scales and this
technology yet need to emerge on commercial scale. In Maharashtra, India,
Nimbkar Agricultural Research Institute (NARI) developed a commercial-scale
(0.3 MW) model of a gasifier in 1997, which can handle both bagasse and cane
residues, for generation of both heat and electricity (Rajvanshi and Jorapur
1997). According to BRIDGE (2010), the BRET COMPACT biomass power
plant having a capacity of 1.0 MW gasifies about 20–25 tonnes of cane biomass
per day to produce electrical and thermal power. Currently, the TPS’s ACFBG
plant in Brazil, having nominal capacity 2 MW, converts approximately 500 kg
dry bagasse into syngas per hour for the generation of heat and power (Hassuani
et al. 2005).
(e) The development and production of high fiber cane of around 30% fiber or
more through genetic engineering as compared to normal cane which contains
around 15% fiber. Research on energy cane from Barbados indicated that the
fiber content of cane can be increased up to around 25% (Albert-Thenet et al.
2006). Seebaluck (2009) reported that an increase in 1% fiber in cane leads to
an increase in 13.34 kWh/TC of surplus electricity.
(f) Energy optimization and conservation in sugarcane plants also provides a
practical approach for enhancing electricity export to the grid. Seebaluck (2009)
evaluated that a decrease in consumption of 100 kg steam/TC leads to an
increase in 14.42 kWh/TC of surplus electricity.
51 Biomass Energy Field 939
10 Summary
Biomass energy resources can play a significant role in diversifying the global
energy mix. There exist many biomass feedstock which are or could be transformed
through available commercial technologies into bioenergy products such as elec-
tricity, heat/steam, and biofuels in the form of bioethanol, biodiesel, and biogas.
The existing potential could be further boosted through the optimal exploitation
of available land and the emergence of promising techniques and technologies
for biomass to bioenergy conversion. It should also be emphasized that biomass
exploitation is not limited to the agricultural and energy sectors but is cross-
sectoral and provides key environmental as well as socioeconomic benefits which
could sustain new developmental paths and contribute to a more dynamic and
competitive economy. In addition, biomass exploitation into energy products offers
high socioeconomic and environmental sustainability compared to other energy
sources. Thus, with the natural endowment and biomass potential in many regions,
development of a viable bioenergy industry is an interesting prospect which could
potentially assist many countries to solve many of their pressing needs in particular
for reducing energy poverty, the energy import bills, and improving energy security
while promoting health, economic growth, and environment protection.
As a case study of biomass to bioenergy conversion in this chapter, electric-
ity production from sugarcane bagasse in cogeneration systems is an attractive,
mature, and well-established undertaking which can supply significant quantum
of electricity to national grids. These systems have already been successfully
demonstrated and implemented in a number of cane-producing countries, and the
challenge is now for other sugarcane-producing countries to replicate, expand,
or adapt similar systems. A wealth of experience exists in those countries that
have successfully developed these systems, and important lessons can be learnt
from those countries that have demonstrated that political commitment to the
exploitation of indigenous resources can achieve far-reaching economic benefits
with the necessary policy framework. The worldwide potential of this resource
is significant with regard to the current state-of-the-art technologies that can be
adopted. The initiation and expansion of biomass cogeneration will nevertheless
require that proper infrastructure and policy measures are in place to facilitate the
markets for independent power production.
References
J.R. Albert-Thenet, C.O. Simpson, P.S. Rao, The BAMC Fuel Cane Project (Ministry of Agricul-
ture & Rural Development, Barbados, 2006), www.agriculture.gov.bb/
W.J. Bond, F.I. Woodward, G.F. Midgley, The global distribution of ecosystems in a world
without fire. New Phytol. 165(2), 525–538 (2005). doi:10.1111/j.1469-8137.2004.01252.x., en.
wikipedia.org/wiki/C4 carbon fixation
BRIDGE, Utility-grade biomass power (2010), www.bridgeret.com
CTC, Biomass power generation: sugar cane bagasse and trash, Copersucar Technology Center,
Project BRA/96/G31, Report to UNDP/MCT/GEF (2005)
940 V. Seebaluck
K. Deepchand, Economics of electricity production from sugarcane tops and leaves – a preliminary
study. Int. Sugar J. 88(1055), 210–216 (1986)
N. El Bassam, Handbook of Bioenergy Crops: A Complete Reference to Species, Development and
Applications (Earthscan, London, 2010)
EUBIA, Conversion routes to bioenergy (2007), www.eubia.org
S.J. Hassuani, M.R.V.L. Leal, I.C. Macedo, Biomass Power Generation: Sugar Cane Bagasse and
Trash (Centro de Tecnologia, Canavieira, 2005)
F.X. Johnson, V. Seebaluck, Bioenergy for Sustainable Development and Economic Competitive-
ness: The Role of Sugar Cane in Africa (Earthscan Publisher, London, 2012)
M.R.L.V. Leal, Brazilian Mill Burns Cane Trash (Winrock International, International Cane
Energy News, United States, 1995), www.winrock.org/clean energy/files/icen1995.pdf
B.L. Legendre, D.M. Burner, Biomass production of sugarcane cultivars and early generation
hybrids. Biomass Bioenergy 8(2), 55–61 (1995)
C.P. Osborne, D.J. Beerling, Review. Nature’s green revolution: the remarkable evolutionary rise
of C 4 plants. Philos. Trans. Biol. Sci. 361(1465), 173–194 (2006). doi:10.1098/rstb.2005.1737
J.M. Paturau, By-products of the Cane Sugar Industry, Elsevier Scientific Publishing Company,
Amsterdam, Netherlands (1989)
A.K. Rajvanshi, R. Jorapur, Sugar Cane Leaf-Bagasse Gasifiers for Industrial Heating Applica-
tions (1997), www.nariphaltan.virtualave.net/Gasifier.pdf
P.J.M. Rao, Industrial Utilisation of Sugar Cane and Its Co-products (ISPCK Publishers &
Distributors, New Delhi, 1997)
T.C.C. Ripoli, W.F. Molina, M.L.C. Ripoli, Energy potential of sugarcane biomass in Brazil.
Scientia Agricola 57, 677–681 (2000), www.scielo.br/pdf/sa/v57n4/a13v57n4.pdf
V. Seebaluck, Study of sugar and energy recovery from sugarcane with emphasis on the milling
department. Ph.D. thesis, University of Mauritius, Mauritius, 2009
V. Seebaluck, D. Seeruttun, Utilisation of sugarcane agricultural residues: electricity production
and climate mitigation. Prog. Ind. Ecol. Int. J. 6, 168–184 (2009)
V. Seebaluck, T. Thielamay, Pelletisation of sugarcane bagasse and cane agricultural residues
for storage and enhanced energy recovery, in Proceedings of the International Conference on
Applied Energy 2010, Singapore, 21–23 Apr 2010, pp. 1484–1496
V. Seebaluck, M.R.L.V. Leal, F. Rosillo-Calle, P.R.K. Sobhanbabu, F.X. Johnson, Sugarcane
bagasse cogeneration as a renewable energy resource for southern Africa, in Proceedings of the
3rd International Green Energy Conference, Malardalen University, Vasteras, Sweden, 17–21
June 2007, pp. 658–670. ISBN 978-91-85485-53-6
V. Seebaluck, R. Mohee, P.R.K. Sobhanbabu, F. Rosillo-Calle, M.R.L.V. Leal, F.X. Johnson,
Bioenergy for sustainable development and global competitiveness: the case of sugarcane
in Southern Africa – Thematic report 2: industry. Cane Resources Network for Southern
Africa/Stockholm Environment Institute special report series. European Commission DG-
research FP5 INCO-DEV, ICA-4-2001-10103 (2008). ISBN: 978-91-86125-01-1
E. Smeets, A.P.C. Faaij, I. Lewandoski, A quickscan of global bio-energy potentials to 2050: an
analysis of the regional availability of biomass resources for export in relation to the underlying
factors, report NWS-E-2004-109 (2004). ISBN: 90-393-3909-0
UNDP, Sugarcane renewable electricity (“SUCRE”), UNDP project document (2009)
USAID, USAID (United States Agency for International Development) International Conference
and Exhibition on Bagasse Cogeneration, New Delhi, India, 2002
Energy from Water
52
Aline Choulot
Abstract
This chapter provides an overview of the current tendencies, potentials, and
technologies to recover energy from water resources, which can be divided into
two main fields: conventional hydropower and ocean energy. A strong focus
is placed on “conventional hydropower” and especially on small hydropower
(SHP), through the description of a case study dealing with a raw wastewater
network. Indeed, marine energy is still in its development phase, even if tidal
currents technology continues making great steps forward.
The chapter begins with the main equations for hydropower and ocean energy.
Then, the historical evolution of water energy recovery is summarized, followed
by worldwide potentials. Environmental issues, especially for SHP, are analyzed,
before a discussion of the best available mature technologies. All the components
of a SHP plant are presented.
With the case study, more details are given on how a SHP project can be led
so as to optimally recover the water energy, even coming from wastewater.
The economic tendencies for SHP are given, based on a recent Swiss analysis
of the market.
Finally, the greater objective of the chapter is to demonstrate the sustainability
of water energy and its technologies.
1 Introduction
Approximately 70% of the earth’s surface is covered with water, the volume
of which can be divided into 96% for oceans and seas, 2.4% ice, and 2% of
underground waters and water streams.
A. Choulot
Mhylab, Mini-Hydraulics Laboratory, Montcherand, Switzerland
e-mail: aline.choulot@mhylab.com
Z0
Z0, p0, v0
ΔZ
gHr0−1
Z3
Z3, p3, v3
Z1, p1, v1
T gHr2−3
gH Z2, p2, v2
Fig. 52.1 Parameters to define the hydropower of a site (0 = upstream level, 1 = upstream from
the turbine, 2 = downstream from the turbine, 3 = downstream level, z = altitude, p = pressure,
v = speed, g = acceleration due to gravity, H = net head, T = turbine, gH = specific hydraulic energy,
gHr = head losses, Z = difference in levels)
The use of this energy by a turbine requires not only a certain amount of water
but also a difference of altitude or pressure and consists in transforming the potential
and kinetic energies in water. But, for example, some hydropower stations exploit
only the kinetic energy, such as the ones on tidal and marine currents.
Figure 52.1 presents the main parameters to define hydropower from Bernoulli’s
equation.
Indeed, Bernoulli’s equation results in defining the specific hydraulic energy, gH,
expressed as:
1 1 2
gH D .p1 p2 / C c1 c22 C g .Z1 Z2 / .J=kg/
¡ 2
In the preceding equation, the term p represents the pressure (Pa), c the speed
(m/s), and Z the altitude (m) with respect to a reference level. The indices 1 and
2 represent the inlet and the outlet of the turbine. They are defined according to
precise international standards.
If we consider the upstream level 0 and the downstream one 3, which are
submitted to the same atmospheric pressure, and that the flow speeds at these points
are zero, the formula below may be simplified to:
c22
gH D gZ gHr .J=kg/
2
where:
Z represents the difference in altitude between point 0 and point 3 (m) gHr
represents the energy loss in the channel and/or pipe between point 0 and point
1 due to the friction and the geometry of the pipe, and between point 2 and
point 3 (J/kg)
944 A. Choulot
c2
Generally, gHr23 is negligible compared with gHr12 . 22 represents the residual
kinetic energy at the outlet of the turbine and that cannot be recovered. For a Pelton
turbine, c2 = 0 m/s.
Finally, hydropower, PH , can be defined by:
PH D ¡ Q gH .W/
with:
¡ = specific weight of water Š 1,000 (kg/m3 )
Q = water discharge (m3 /s)
gH = specific hydraulic energy (J/kg)
where
g = acceleration due to gravity Š 9.81 (m/s2 )
H = net head (m)
Then, this hydropower, PH , decreases with each equipment used within the scheme,
such as the two main ones:
• The turbine, which transforms the hydropower into mechanical energy
• The generator, which transforms the mechanical energy into electrical energy
Each of these main components generates losses, which leads to the following
equation when considering the electrical output, Pe :
Pe D ¡ Q g H ˜t ˜e .W/
with:
˜t = turbine efficiency [-]
˜e = generator efficiency [-]
Some schemes will also have to consider the losses in the transformer, meant to
adapt the voltage from the outlet of the generator to the one of the grid.
In Europe, for small hydropower schemes, the current maximal efficiencies that
are reached are 92% for the turbine and 94% for the generator.
Then, to calculate the energy or the electricity production, one needs to know the
number of hours the output can be obtained. The current average operating hours at
full load for small hydropower in Europe are:
• 4,500 h/year for run of river plants
• Between 2,200 and 8,700 h/year for multipurpose schemes
It appears that the common efficiency, defined as the ratio of the electrical
production and the hydraulic energy, is between 70% and 75% for the whole plant
with the best available technologies.
1
Pe D ¡ R21e C30 Cp ˜n .W/
2
with:
R1e = runner radius (m)
C0 = tidal current (m/s)
Cp = power coefficient of the turbine [-]
˜n = efficiency of the different equipments between the turbine and the electrical
grid [-]
Then, a dimensionless figure is commonly used for this type of ocean energy: the tip
speed ratio, œ (Münch et al. 2009):
¨ R1e
D .W/
C0
with:
¨ = relative velocity (s1 )
One can note that these equations are similar to wind energy. Indeed, the tidal
currents technology is closer to wind energy than to hydropower.
It can also be mentioned that, contrary to conventional hydropower, production
from tidal currents is regular and predictable.
Wave Energy
Wave power devices extract energy directly from the surface motion of ocean or
from pressure fluctuations below the surface.
Salinity Gradient
At the mouth of rivers where fresh water mixes with salt water, energy associated
with the salinity gradient can be harnessed using a pressure-retarded reverse osmosis
process and associated conversion technologies. The principle is the exploitation of
the entropy of mixing freshwater with salt water (EU OEA 2012).
Hydropower has played an essential role in the development of humanity. The first
hydraulic machines appeared more than 2,000 years ago, both in the Mediterranean
basin and in China. Their great diversity attests to the ingenuity and skill of the
artisans who built them. These machines, in relieving man of painful and repetitious
tasks, played a vital role in industrial evolution (CHy and SSHL 2011).
The simplest form of hydraulic machine is the water wheel, utilized in the ancient
Greek and Roman civilizations. A first advancement appeared in the second century,
when the wheel was no longer fed from beneath, but rather by its upper part,
causing the production output of a few tens to several hundreds of Watts. Until
the middle of the nineteenth century, these small hydraulic schemes evolved only a
little and supplied mechanical energy to several tens of thousands of mills, saw mills,
tanneries, and so on. The first real turbines appeared during the nineteenth century,
around 1820, with the Fourneyron turbine that would later evolve to become the
Francis turbine. The Pelton turbines appeared around 1880 and the Kaplan made its
appearance at the beginning of the twentieth century. This development took place
on the European continent, essentially to satisfy the growing need for mechanical
energy for industries in full development. The countries of the continent had to
develop their own solutions to respond to the growing mechanization of English
industries that were benefiting from Watt’s steam engine.
Therefore, before the appearance of efficient generators on the market, most
factories were situated close to rivers, where they could find the energy essential
to their operations.
Thereafter, the development of large power stations for energy production and
of electric networks allowed enterprises to obtain an abundant energy source that
was reliable and affordable. This advancement led the users of these small stations
to relinquish their own means of energy production in favor of this “convenient”
form of energy. The Swiss, for example, at the beginning of the twentieth century,
had more than 7,000 hydraulic schemes (water wheels or small turbines). In 1985,
the date of a new census report, this number had gone down to about a thousand
(Chenal et al. 2009).
Currently, thanks to a stronger interest in renewable energies, the market has
opened up to other alternative techniques for small hydropower sites that have
the common point of being less expensive than the techniques from the large hy-
dropower. Among them, the cross flow turbines, reverse pumps, and the Archimedes
screws.
Compared with conventional hydropower, ocean energy is just at its beginning.
The first tidal power plant that uses the potential energy between the high and the
low tides was commissioned in 1967 in France, La Rance, with an installed output
of 240 MW (24 bulb Kaplan turbines of 1 MW each) (Andre 1978). Since then, few
plants have been built. The biggest one was commissioned in 2011 in Korea: Sihwa,
equipped with 10 bulb Kaplan-type turbines, with a capacity per unit of 26 MW
(Schneeberger 2008).
52 Energy from Water 947
Since the late 1970s, tidal currents technology has been investigated due to the
low cost of civil works and the limited ecological impact compared with the tidal
dams (Lissaman and Radkey 1979). The first commercial tidal turbine in a free
stream was commissioned in 2008 in Northern Ireland: Seagen, 1.2 MW. This plant
became in 2009 the first-ever marine renewable energy project to be accredited by
the United Kingdom energy regulator (Münch et al. 2009).
Another example is the technology based on salinity gradient with significant
research between 1975 and 1985 (European Ocean Energy Association, EU-OEA,
www.eu-oea.com, 2012).
2.3 Potentials
(with 188 GW). On a worldwide level, the power tidal currents could add approxi-
mately 100 GW (Münch et al. 2009), while the salinity energy potential is estimated
at 2 TWh/year (EU OEA 2012).
Photo 52.1 Trois-Torrents powerhouse (75 kW, Switzerland), set on the drinking water network
of the commune
c Mhylab
The impact of weirs and dams can be mitigated by the implementation of fish
by-passes.
This implies that this kind of environmental impacts due to schemes integrated
into existing infrastructures (multipurpose schemes) (Choulot et al. 2012) are
limited.
Another impact of conventional hydropower schemes is on the landscape, due
mainly to the penstock and the power house. Great efforts are made nowadays to
hide the penstock and the powerhouse. Photo 52.1 shows a powerhouse that looks
like local houses – a Swiss chalet, whereas Photo 52.2 shows to a semi-buried
powerhouse.
Apart from these negative impacts, we may add here that conventional hy-
dropower schemes can be also used to:
– Secure and maintain the banks
– Reduce flood impact
– Evacuate sediment and floating waste
– Develop regional employment
– Maintain the existing heritage
– Finance measures to guarantee the life of the biotopes
– Take part in the energy challenge for the twenty-first century
Finally, if they are well-studied, small hydropower projects can even impact posi-
tively on the environment by improving the state of a water stream. Therefore, SHP
can be considered as able to reach the environmental objectives of sustainability.
Photo 52.2 Armary powerhouse (68 kW, 454,000 kWh/year, Switzerland), set on the irrigation
water network
c Mhylab
Generally, small hydropower projects result in positive social impacts. First they can
involve different engineering offices, as specialists in hydromechanics, electronics,
civil engineering, and environment. Then they create work for local mechanical
workshops and civil works enterprises. Furthermore, SHP projects are a source
of revenue for the owners, whose panel is wide: cities, water network groups,
associations, electricity suppliers, families, and so on. They do not imply movement
of population, as some large hydropower projects do, but integrate themselves
into the environment, and, especially for refurbishment projects, they even tend
to maintain the heritage. Moreover, SHP projects allow decentralization of the
electricity production, which is especially interesting for isolated sites in countries
that lack an electrical grid.
Therefore, SHP can be considered as able to reach the social objectives of
sustainability.
2.7.1 Weirs
A weir, the equivalent of a dam for large hydropower, built in the riverbed, is meant
to maintain a minimum elevation for the upstream level for a run-of-river plant. In
accumulation plants, the weir is meant to create a storage space.
Compared with large hydropower dams, the techniques to build weirs for small-
hydropower sites are the standard ones of the civil engineering.
952 A. Choulot
Photo 52.3 Fish by-pass on the Arnon river (Switzerland) for the migration of trout
c Mhylab
52 Energy from Water 953
2.7.3 Intake
The water intake has two main roles: to guarantee that water enters the pipe in the
most efficient possible way and to prevent floating debris (leaves, branches, rubbish,
etc.) from reaching the turbine. The classic solution consists of furnishing the intake
with a trash rack to stop the debris before it enters the intake pipe. The rack must be
cleaned at regular intervals and to eliminate the collected trash (Chenal et al. 2009).
A Tyrolean intake (Photo 52.5) is not greatly affected by floating debris. It creates
almost no visual impact since it is beneath the surface of the river (Chenal et al.
2009).
2.7.4 Penstocks
To fulfill the requirements of hydropower generation, a penstock should have the
following characteristics:
• A nominal pressure sufficient to resist to the static pressure and to the overpres-
sure defined by the set safety system,
• A wall roughness that limits the head losses,
954 A. Choulot
• An internal diameter that also limits the head losses. Head losses are determined
by empirical formulas or measurements at the site. They are proportional to the
square of the flow speed in this pipe, or they are inversely proportional to the
diameter to the power of five. For instance, a diameter increase of 20% leads to a
head losses decrease of 60%.
• A minimal number of section and direction changes. Indeed, singularities as
elbows or forks tend to increase head losses and to decrease the quality of the
hydrodynamic flow and thus the turbine efficiency if close to the turbine.
In general, head losses are acceptable if at nominal discharge they are lower than
10% of the difference in levels, or, in other words, if the penstock efficiency is higher
than 90%.
Often, a penstock is made of synthetic material when the head is low or of steel
for a high head.
Nowadays, a real effort is made to hide the penstock. One possibility is to bury
it, using the technique of directional drilling, as with the project Rivaz II, planned
to be started in 2012–2013. This refurbishment project, led by Romande Energie, a
Swiss utility, is situated in a UNESCO area (cf. Photo 52.6).
2.7.5 Turbines
According to the available head, turbines operate in two different ways (Chenal et al.
2009):
– Action turbines for high heads, which use the hydraulic energy made available
only in the form of kinetic energy. These turbines have out-of-water runners that
turn in an atmospheric pressure housing or in a slight vacuum;
– Reaction turbines for low and medium heads, which use the hydraulic energy
made available in the form of pressure and kinetic energy. The runners of these
turbines are submerged in the flow.
52 Energy from Water 955
Photo 52.6 Rivaz II, Switzerland, in a UNESCO zone: the refurbishment project includes
burying a DN500 penstock in the vineyards.
c Mhylab
Water Wheel
The water wheel (cf. Photo 52.7) is not, strictly speaking, a hydraulic turbine, given
its method of operation. If, in the case of a turbine, kinetic energy, and/or continuous
pressure in water are used, the water wheel uses only the mass of water coming to
fill each bucket.
This equipment is adapted to relatively low heads and discharges, with outputs
of several tens of kW.
The hydraulic wheel built according to modern techniques has an efficiency of
around 70%. Even if this type of machine is an old technique, it often makes it
possible to revive, at low cost, abandoned schemes and to preserve the legacy of
these sites.
956 A. Choulot
Photo 52.8 Francis turbine with a spiral casing (0.4 m3 /s, 11 m, 18 kW, 156,000 kWh/year,
Vallorbe, Switzerland, turbine integrated into the drinking water system)
c Mhylab
Francis Turbines
A Francis turbine (cf. Photo 52.8) is a reaction machine, especially adapted to heads
between 25 and 250 m. It is preferred over Pelton turbines for heads that are higher
than 60 m when the discharge is especially important and not very variable.
The water arrives in a spiral casing and then goes into mobile guide vanes, used
to regulate the discharge, before arriving at the runner. At the runner outlet the water
goes into the draft tube before being returned to the river.
This type of turbine is also frequently seen in very old low-head schemes with
a configuration as a water chamber, which is without a spiral casing, due to the
technique evolution.
Although this type of turbine, common for the large hydropower, is often seen
in small schemes, it is, because of its geometric complexity, not the best turbine for
small hydropower.
The small Francis turbines, developed in a laboratory, may reach a mechanical
efficiency of 92%.
Pelton Turbines
This turbine (cf. Photo 52.9) is an action machine, especially adapted to heads
between 60 and 1,000 m.
The runner, composed of buckets, is driven by one or more jets coming from
nozzles. The number of nozzles varies between 1 and 6, according to a relationship
linked to the head and the discharge. The nozzles regulate the discharge arriving on
the runner with a needle. The water is then returned into the river.
The small Pelton turbines, coming from laboratory development, can reach a
mechanical efficiency equal to or even higher than 90%.
Generally, a Pelton runner operates in the air, at atmospheric pressure, but if a
higher outlet pressure is required for the existing infrastructure, a counter-pressure
52 Energy from Water 957
Photo 52.9 Pelton runner with three nozzles (0.3 m3 /s, 217 m, 465 kW, 1,800,000 kWh/year,
La Zour, Savièse, Switzerland, turbine integrated into the drinking water system).
c Savièse,
Gasa SA
turbine can be set (cf. Photo 52.10). Here, the runner rotates in an air volume
maintained at the requested downstream pressure.
Kaplan Turbine
This turbine (cf. Photo 52.13) is also a reaction machine, especially adapted to
heads between 0.5 and 30 m. There are two large categories of Kaplan turbines:
diagonal turbines, turbines with a spiral casing, such as the Francis turbine, and
axial turbines, such as bulb turbines. For an axial turbine, the water flows into the
axis of the supply pipe and goes through the guide vanes before arriving at the
runner. At the exit from the runner, the water goes into a draft tube before being
returned to the river.
Unlike the Francis turbine, it is possible to set two regulating devices, which
leads to a greater adaptability regarding head and discharge variations. As for the
Francis, the first is the guide vanes, and the second is the blades of the runner, from
4 to 8, the orientation of which can be modified. A turbine with a regulation due to
guide vanes only, is especially called a propeller.
The small Kaplan turbines, developed in laboratory, may reach a mechanical
efficiency of 90%.
The setting of a Kaplan turbine is limited by cavitation (cf. Photos 52.11 and
52.12), which is the transformation of liquid water into steam, through a pressure
decrease (Franc et al. 2000). The phenomenon is usually noisy, and always fluctuates
strongly. The vapor bubble implosion close to the blade is responsible for its erosion,
and for the deterioration of the turbine performances. And the erosion will keep on
growing, while the production will keep on decreasing.
958 A. Choulot
Photo 52.10 Counter-pressure Pelton turbine (0.075 m3 /s, 106 m, 75 kW, 160,000 kWh/year,
Morges, Switzerland, turbine integrated into the drinking water system).
c Mhylab
Photo 52.12 A Kaplan turbine blade, manufactured without hydraulic laboratory techniques,
eroded by cavitation after a few months operation
c Mhylab
Photo 52.13 Kaplan turbine (0.38 m3 /s, 28 m, 44 kW, Poggio Cuculo, Italy, set as a by-pass of
an existing valve in a drinking water network)
c Mhylab
960 A. Choulot
Photo 52.14 S-shaped diagonal turbine (scale model set on Mhylab’s test bench)
c Mhylab
But cavitation is not a fatality. Laboratory tests can identify turbine cavitation
behavior and improve it with an appropriate design. Manufacturers of laboratory-
developed turbines can then define with accuracy the maximal height regarding the
downstream water level at which the runner can be set without damages due to
cavitation.
This turbine is common in the large and the small hydropower areas.
Diagonal Turbine
This turbine (cf. Photo 52.14) is also a reaction machine, but is especially adapted
to heads between 25 and 100 m.
As with the Kaplan, the diagonal turbine, composed of a runner from 8 to 12
blades, can be composed with a spiral casing or can be axial (or S-shaped), and
doubly regulated as the Kaplan.
The small diagonal turbines, developed in a laboratory, may reach a mechanical
efficiency of 92% (Cottin et al. 2011).
The setting of diagonal turbines regarding the downstream water is also limited
by the cavitation phenomenon as for Kaplan turbines.
This type of turbine is still new and not frequently seen on small hydropower
schemes. It is more common with large hydropower.
52 Energy from Water 961
Reverse Pump
The reverse pump (cf. Photo 52.15) is a pump that has been adapted to work as a
turbine. It can be an affordable solution for sites, below 30 kW, where the discharge
and the head are steady. Indeed, it does not have any regulation device, apart from a
valve needed to start and shut down the machine.
The efficiency at a reverse pump is about 75% at its nominal discharge and head.
This equipment is often found within water networks.
Archimedes Screw
The Archimedes screw presents a certain similarity to the water wheel, as it uses
only the mass of water to drive the screw. It is adapted to relatively low heads and
Photo 52.15 Reverse pump (0.29 m3 /s, 94 m, 220 kW, Nyon, Switzerland, set on treated wastew-
aters)
c Mhylab
962 A. Choulot
average discharges. With an efficiency of about 70%, it has some tens or hundreds
of kW in output.
2.7.6 Generators
For generators, small hydropower projects tend to use the standard equipment
available on the market. For an operation at fixed rotation speed, the asynchronous
generators are usually used below an output of 100 kW. For higher outputs,
synchronous ones will be preferred.
Nowadays, the maximal efficiency of these generators can reach 94%. The
improvement in the level of efficiency of the generators also remains a major subject
of research and development, especially for generators with permanent magnets
(Chenal et al. 2009).
If the required rotation speed is lower than 428 rpm for an output lower than
circa 150 kW, the high number of poles can imply a large and expensive machine. If
this type of generator continues to be improved, speed increasers (belt or teeth gear
systems) can offer economical solutions. However, this supplementary equipment
implies more losses; the current efficiency being around 95%.
For low speeds, another solution consists of coupling the generator directly to the
turbine and to multiply the frequency by an electronic converter. Here, the efficiency
is often higher, to that of the speed increaser (Chenal et al. 2009).
Systems with variable rotation speeds tend also to develop, especially for low-
head sites characterized by wide ranges of discharges and/or heads due to regular
flooding, for example. Indeed, thanks to a variable speed, the operating area of the
turbine will be managed so as to be optimal regarding efficiencies and hydrodynamic
behavior (especially regarding cavitation). This operation requires the use of a
frequency converter.
As ocean energy technology is still in its development stage, many different kinds
of projects have appeared and are being tested worldwide. The most advanced ones,
are described here, and they mainly concern tidal energy.
Tidal plants, which use the potential energy are based on the same technology as
conventional hydropower.
Concerning the tidal currents field, the turbines, which can be free-stream or
ducted, can be closer to wind energy technology. They may be suspended from a
floating structure fixed to the sea belt, or they can be directly set on the ground.
Among the research going on are the following projects and prototypes:
The “MWatForce” project, (cf. Figure 52.2) currently developed in France and
Switzerland (Münch et al. 2009), is based on a ducted tidal turbine set on the
ground of the ocean. This turbine drives a multi-stage pump that supplies hydraulic
energy to coastal power stations equipped with Pelton turbines. This means that
this technology does not use an underwater electrical device. The horizontal-axis
The case study Le Profray, owned and operated by the Services Industriels de
Bagnes (CH), is an interesting example of a project dealing with raw wastewaters.
Situated in Switzerland, on the raw wastewaters of Verbier ski resort, the project,
originally commissioned in 1993 and completely refurbished and improved in 2007,
gives feedback on the management of this specific type of waters.
The first step of a SHP project is to define the main characteristics of the site: the
difference in levels, Z, the nominal discharge, and the corresponding net head, H.
52 Energy from Water 965
The wastewater from the outlets of the Verbier ski resort are collected in a storage
basin of 400 m3 , equipped with a 6-mm trash rack to remove most of the floating
material (cf. Photo 52.16). This basin is also used as a forebay for the hydro scheme,
the water level of which is maintained steady by the turbine regulation (Denis and
Choulot 2010). This is the upstream water level.
The downstream level is at the entrance of the treatment process. Thus, the
available head for Le Profray project is 449.5 m.
The nominal discharge of a SHP plant is chosen from the flow duration curve.
Generally, it corresponds to the discharge available between 50 and 80 days per
year. But for the initial project, the nominal discharge was defined as similar to the
wastewater treatment plant, at 240 l/s. This takes into account the sudden discharge
changes due to storms and snow melting, and also the important population
increase due to the winter touristic activities. With an average annual volume of
1,330,000 m3 , the average wastewater discharge is only 42 l/s. Therefore, the turbine
was only working a few days per year at its nominal discharge. Moreover, during
the dry season, the limited available discharge was meant to be stored at the forebay
966 A. Choulot
Photo 52.17 The power house with the ski resort in the background
c Mhylab
This means that the net head at 240 l/s is 376.9 m, and the penstock efficiency is only
of 83.9%, whereas with the new discharge, the nominal net head becomes 429.5 m,
and the efficiency, 95.6%.
For this head of 449.5 m, Kaplan and diagonal turbines, for example, are not
suitable because of the cavitation phenomenon. A Pelton turbine is the most suitable
technique thanks to its efficiency regarding the range of discharges, its adaptability
with raw wastewaters, and its manufacturing simplicity compared with a Francis
turbine, for instance. Then, the flow duration curve leads to choosing a two-nozzle
Pelton turbine.
For this project, the turbine design (cf. Photo 52.18) comes from a laboratory
development achieved by Mhylab between 1997 and 2001, which aims is to provide
a turbine design specific to the site, with guarantees of efficiency (cf. Fig. 52.3) and
Photo 52.18 The runner and generator during the setting of the group
c Gasa SA SIB
968 A. Choulot
0.91
0.90
0.89
2 adjustable
0.88 nozzles in
operation
Turbine efficiency (-)
0.87
Q = 0.100 m3/s
1 adjustable
0.86 ΔZ = 450 m
nozzle in
operation Hn = 430 m
0.85
N = 1500 rpm
0.84
0.83
Accuracy on the efficiency measurement: + –1%
0.82 Values guaranteed by laboratory tests,
transposed according to the IEC 60193 standard
0.81
0.80
0.000 0.020 0.040 0.060 0.080 0.100 0.120
Discharge Q (m3/s)
Fig. 52.3 Evolution of the turbine efficiencies for the Le Profray site
these applications because of its simple shape and the progressive flow acceleration,
notably in its manifold. Here, the manifold is essentially composed of standard
parts in stainless steel – tubes, two elbows, and one tee from the shelf – so as to
reduce cost. Then, the nozzle guide vanes had to be suppressed and replaced by a
specific smooth system, which maintains the needles without generating obstacles
to the flow.
Regarding the security system, deflectors have been chosen, specially adapted so
as to be efficient even if wastes are caught in them (cf. Photos 52.19
and 52.20).
970 A. Choulot
3.3 Maintenance
The casing of the turbine is equipped with two hand-holes made especially to
evacuate the wastes that may have accumulated in the runner without dismantling
the machine.
For this case study, in operation since 1993, the average usual maintenance
amounts to about 40 h per year. The interventions are linked to the electrical output.
Indeed, when the output is lower than that one for the available discharge, it means
that the waste accumulation is not acceptable and that the turbine must be cleaned.
3.4 Overview
With an output of 665 kW, the initial project generated an electricity production of
580 MWh/year. With the refurbished project of 357 kW, a gain has been observed
from the first year with a production increase of 45% (850 MWh/year – or the
electricity consumption of approximately 190 European households), although the
nominal discharge is 2.4 times lower.
4 Economic Analysis
To give general economic figures for projects that recover energy from water is not
an easy exercise considering the large range of site types and the different available
techniques on the market. That is why it was chosen to present here some tendencies
and figures for small hydropower in Switzerland.
One observation is that the investment tends to increase with the electrical output.
It tends also to increase with the decrease of the heads, as shown on Fig. 52.4.
For the case study Le Profray, with a head of 449.5 m and an output of 357 kW,
about CHF 600,000 were invested for the refurbishment, including the turbine, its
generator, and the new control panel, but excluding the penstock of 2.3 km (or 5.1
times the head). It can be mentioned that the required price for the complete turbine
hydraulic profile supply includes the effective work, as well as a contribution to
research and development costs, calculated as a function of the machine output.
This amount remains low, however, relative to the plant construction costs.
The investments can be divided into the different following areas:
– 30–60% toward civil works, with a time of depreciation of 30–40 years
– 20–50% toward electromechanical equipment, with a time of depreciation of
25–30 years (12 years for electronic equipment)
– 10–20% toward studies
– 10–20% toward unexpected costs
Maintenance and operation costs will be reduced with sustainable equipment
especially designed for the site. For example, and as mentioned previously, the
maintenance of the Le Profray plant corresponds to about 40 h per year, achieved
by the team of the wastewater treatment plant.
The cost price of the kWh produced varies greatly according to the head and
the output of the scheme. What can be pointed out is that generally multipurpose
schemes are more cost efficient than plants set on water streams, in that they can
reuse the existing infrastructures.
We can demonstrate in Fig. 52.5 that the lower the head and the output, the higher
the cost price. Because these schemes represent the largest potential remaining in
Europe, it is necessary to implement tools that allow remuneration of the energy
972 A. Choulot
8000000
7000000
6000000
5000000
Investment [CHF]
H=5m
10
4000000 20
50
100
250
3000000
H = 500 m
2000000
1000000
0
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000
Electrical output P [kW]
Fig. 52.4 Evolution of the investment (CHF = Swiss Francs) regarding the electrical output (kW)
and the head (H, in meters) for sites in Switzerland where the length of the penstock is lower than
3 H (Chenal 2003)
produced at a price that makes the development of these plants favorable (Chenal
et al. 2009).
Consequently, the development of new schemes must come from establishing
rate measures that allow making the small schemes profitable. For example, in
Switzerland, the selling price depends on the electricity production of the plant,
the head, and the part of the civil works in the total investment.
Furthermore, the rate should be guaranteed for the long term to give investors
confidence and allow them to obtain the necessary bank financing. In fact, small
hydraulics, in the manner of other renewable energies, is characterized by major
investments that are amortized over periods of 20–40 years. It may be pointed
out that the higher the purchase price, the more the realizable economic potential
becomes important. A high rate also allows guaranteeing excellent measures for
environmental integration. To be efficient, the guaranteed price measures should be
accompanied by a performance bonus motivating the owners to optimize their sites.
A second tool, already in place in several European countries, requires certain
participants (producers, suppliers, consumers) to produce or acquire electricity from
renewable energy sources (Chenal et al. 2009).
Therefore, if the existing SHP plants can be considered sustainable from an
economic point of view, most future ones will be sustainable only if political
measures support them, in front of the increasing investment in environment
protection.
52 Energy from Water 973
30
29
28
27
26
25
24
23
22
21
20
r = cost price [ ct/kWh]
19
18
17 H=5m
16
15
14 10
13 20
12
50
11 100
10 250
9
8
H = 500 m
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000
P = electrical output [kW]
Fig. 52.5 Evolution of the cost price in Switzerland (ct CHF/kWh) regarding the electrical output
(kW) and the head (H, in meters) for sites where the length of the penstock is lower than 3 H
(Chenal 2003)
5 Summary
Water energy has lead to the development of many different kinds of technologies
worldwide. The large hydropower field can be considered as the most mature
technology for water energy recovery and this area continues to be developed
regarding the worldwide stakes in the electricity markets, although the remaining
potentials start to be limited.
This technology is followed by the small hydropower field. Based on the
large hydropower knowledge, its technology is now site-specific and already
mature. Remaining potentials are still interesting worldwide, especially on existing
infrastructures (multipurpose schemes) and for isolated sites in countries with a
lack of electrical grids. Small hydropower sites are also environmentally friendly,
especially if politicians implement financial incentives to invest in environmental
measures. The technology along with administrative and environmental issues are
still studied so as to achieve optimal projects, met on a rather short delay. Today,
small hydropower can be considered as a sustainable technology, mainly from its
long background. Indeed, the present knowledge and market address environmental,
social, and economic issues.
A new energy is currently developing: marine energy, for which operating sites
are still rare but increasing. Its technology is based on large and small hydropower
974 A. Choulot
and also on wind energy, or even thermal cycles. Today, the tidal currents turbines
appear to be the most developed and promising. But the maturity of the whole
domain is still ahead of us.
References
H. Andre, Ten years of experience at the “La Rance” tidal power plant. Ocean Manag. 4, 165–178
(1978)
Andritz Hydro, Hydronews, nı 21/04-2012, (2012), p. 2
R. Chenal (2003) Evaluation du coût de construction d’une petite centrale hydro-électrique
nouvelle et complète et du prix de revient du kwh (p < 1,000 kw)
R. Chenal, A. Choulot, V. Denis, N. Tissot, Section 8, Small hydropower, in Renewable Energy
Technologies, ed. by J.-C. Sabonnadière (Iste, Wiley, 2009). ISBN:978-1-84821-135-3
A. Choulot, V. Denis, P. Punys, Integration of small hydro turbines into existing water infrastruc-
tures, in Hydropower, Practice and Application, chapter 12, ed. by H. Samadi-Boroujen (Intech,
2012). ISBN:978-953-51-0164-2
Commission d’hydrologie, CHy, Société suisse d’hydrologie et de limnologie, SSHL, Les effets du
changement climatique sur l’utilisation de la force hydraulique, Rapport de synthèse, Matériaux
pour l’Hydrologie de la Suisse, Nı 38, Bern, 2011, p. 28. ISSN:1421–1130
C. Cottin, B. Reul, A. Choulot, Mhylab, Laboratory results of the DIAGONAL project: a step
towards an optimal small hydro turbine for medium head sites (25–100 m), in Proceedings of
the International Conference HYDRO 2011, Prague, Czech Republic, 17–19 Oct 2011
N. Crettenand, The Facilitation of Mini and Small Hydropower in Switzerland: Shaping the
Institutional Framework (with a Particular Focus on Storage and Pumped-Storage Schemes),
Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne, 2012, http://infoscience.epfl.ch/record/176337
V. Denis, A. Choulot, Mhylab, Energy Recovery in Existing Infrastructures with Small Hydropower
Plants. Multipurpose Schemes – Overview and Example (Shapes, ESHA, Sixth Framework
Programme, European Directorate for Transport and Energy, 2010)
S. Descloux, V. Chanudet, A. Petitjean, Electricité de France, Greenhouse gas emissions from
hydropower reservoirs located in the sub-tropical area: recent findings and modelling, in
Proceedings of the International Conference HYDRO 2011, Prague, Czech Republic, 17–19
Oct 2011
ESHA, Stream Map for Small Hydropower in the EU-27 in the View of 2020 Targets (ESHA,
Intelligent Energy Europe, 2012)
ESHA, Studio Frosio, Austrian Association promoting small hydropower, in Environmental
Integration of Small Hydropower Plants (ESHA, Intelligent Energy Europe, 2005)
European Ocean Energy Association, http://www.eu-oea.com/2012
European Union Energy in Figures, Statistical Pocket Book 2012, (2012). ISBN:978-92-79-22556-7,
http://europa.eu
F.P. Franc, F. Avellan, B. Belahdji, J.Y. Billard, L. Briançon-Marjollet, D. Fréchou, D. H. Fruman,
A. Karimi, J.L. Jueny, J.M. Michel, La Cavitation, Mécanismes physiques et aspects industriels
(2000), p. 582. ISBN:978 2 868834515. Collection Grenoble Sciences (in French)
International Energy Agency, Renewables for Power Generation, Status & Prospects (International
Energy Agency, Paris, 2003)
International Energy Agency, 2011, Key World Energy Statistics, http://www.iea.org/publications/
freepublications/publication/name,20938,en.html (International Energy Agency, 2011)
P.B.S. Lissaman, R.L. Radkey, Coriolis program: a review of the status of the ocean turbine energy
system, in Oceans ’79, San Diego, CA, USA, 1979, pp. 559–565
C. Münch, M. Vonlathen, J. Gomes, R. Luquet, P. Guinard, F. Avellan, Design and performance
assessment of a tidal ducted turbine, HES SO Valais, Sion, Switzerland, EPFL, Laboratory
of Hydraulic Machines, Lausanne, Switzerland, DGA Bassin d’essais des careens, Val de
Reuil, Guinard Energies, Brest, France, in 3rd IAHR International Meeting of the Workgroup
52 Energy from Water 975
on Cavitation and Dynamic Problems in Hydraulic Machinery and Systems, Brno, Czech
Republic, 2009
Maxiscience 2012, http://www.maxisciences.com/edf/edf-va-lancer-une-2e-phase-de-test-de-
son-hydrolienne mrm108875.html
Renewable Energy Policy network for the 21st century, Renewables 2011 Global Status Re-
port, http://www.ren21.net/REN21Activities/Publications/GlobalStatusReport/GSR2011/tabid/
56142/Default.aspx
J.-M. Ribi, J.-L. Boillat, P. Armin, A. Schleiss, Attractivité de refuges à poissons aménagés dans
les berges de rivières soumises aux éclusées hydroélectriques. Wasser Energie Luft 4, 320–326
(2011)
M. Schneeberger, Andritz, Sihwa Tidal Turbine and Generator: For the World Largest Tidal Power
Plant (British Hydropower Association, Bristol, 2008)
Thematic Network on Small Hydropower, ESHA, Ademe, MHyLab, ISET, EPFL, LCH, IT power,
Austrian Small Hydropower Association, SCTPH, SERO, Studio Frosio, Guide on how to
develop a small hydropower plant, CDRom (2005), www.esha.be (available in English, French,
German and Swedish)
Ensuring Sustainability of Bioenergy
in Practice 53
Francesca Farioli
Abstract
Access to energy that is sustainable, secure, and affordable is a critical catalyst
for economic growth and development. Nevertheless, today 2.7 billion people,
mainly in poor countries, still rely only on inefficient and pollutant forms of
energy for their basic needs. The development of modern forms of bioenergy
for heat, electricity, and liquid fuel for transportation offers an option to address
energy poverty and the interrelated issue of lack of development opportunity and
environmental degradation. However, this option entails risks and opportunities
for African countries that at the beginning of the twenty-first century contain
some of the poorest and most technically backward regions in the world and
where 80% of population still depend on charcoal and firewood to fulfill their
energy needs.
The sustainability of bioenergy largely depends on how the risks associated
with its development are managed and opportunities enhanced. It depends also on
the crop grown, the land used, the technology employed, and how the bioenergy
supply chain is integrated into agricultural, social, and economic system.
A number of approaches and mechanisms aiming to driving sustainability of
biofuels in developing countries have been put forward, including market-based
certification, national policy formulation, national legislation, good practice
guidelines, impact assessments, sustainability planning, and land use planning.
They present weaknesses and strengths. Drawing from Competence Platform on
Energy Crop and Agroforestry Systems for Arid and Semi-arid Ecosystems in
Africa (COMPETE) experience, this chapter examines and elaborates on two
of them: (1) the strategic land use mapping aimed to identify available and
F. Farioli ()
Interuniversity Research Centre on Sustainable Development (CIRPS), Sapienza Università di
Roma, Roma, Italy
Department Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Sapienza Università di Roma, Rome, Italy
e-mail: francesca.farioli@uniroma1.it
1 Introduction
ensure sustainability need to be put in place, and safety nets need to be established
to protect the world’s poorest and most vulnerable people to ensure their access to
adequate food.
Certification and verification systems offer a tool to assure sustainability of
bioenergy production, but fail to consider perceptions of communities, and are
unable to incorporate smallholders in value chains. This chapter focuses on sustain-
ability considerations in Africa for bioenergy crops, examines practical approaches
to ensure sustainability of bioenergy initiatives, and elaborates on what is considered
regionally and locally as a good practice. Possible improvement and way forward
are considered.
1.0
Iceland
Italy Finland United States
0.9 France Belgium
Singapore
Argentina Hungary
Slovak Republic
0.8
Russia
Brazil Ukraine
0.7
Gabon
HDI
0.6
Zimbabwe
0.5
Nigeria
0.4
Mozambique
0.3
0.2
0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 8000 9000 10000 11000 12000 13000
Per capita energy consumption (kgoe/capita)
Fig. 53.2 Relationship between HDI and energy consumptions (Source: Adapted from UNDP
(2004))
Table 53.2 Number of people without access to electricity and relying on traditional use of
biomass, 2009 million
Number of people lacking Number of people relying on
access to electricity the traditional use of biomass
Africa 587 657
Sub-Saharan Africa 585 653
Developing Asia 799 1; 937
China 8 423
India 404 855
Other Asia 387 659
Latin America 31 85
Developing countries 1; 438 2; 679
World 1; 441 2; 679
Source: adapted from IEA, UNDP, UNIDO (2010)
between energy consumption and economic growth are achievable (Johnson and
Lambe 2009). On the other hand, for poor countries, energy services increase and
are linearly correlated with dramatic human development improvements.
Improving human welfare requires better energy distribution in terms of acces-
sibility, availability (continuity of supply and quality and reliability of service),
acceptability (social and environmental goals), and affordability (energy expendi-
ture of householders compatible with their income levels and no higher than the
cost of traditional fuels) (WEC Millennium statement in WEC 2002). Poor peoples
in least developed countries tend to rely on low-quality fuels such as animal dung,
agricultural wastes, and fuelwood, for their basic needs of nutrition, warmth, and
light. As shown in Table 53.2, the majority of them live in sub-Saharan Africa and
Developing Asia. The extensive use of biomass in traditional and inefficient ways
and the limited availability of modern fuels are manifestations of poverty. They also
restrain economic and social development.
The human implications of insufficient energy choices in the presence of extreme
poverty are immediate and pressing. For example, the use of inefficient devices for
cooking, using low-quality fuel, often results in harmful health and environmental
impacts (Farioli and Dafrallah 2012).
It is estimated that 1.45 million deaths per year (of which 60% are female)
in developing countries are associated with the inhalation of indoor smoke from
the use of solid fuels (WHO 2004, 2008). Unsustainable use of fuelwood can
accelerate deforestation and lead to soil erosion, desertification, and increased
risks of flooding and biodiversity loss. Reliance on traditional biomass can also
further entrench existing gender disparities, deriving from gender-ascribed roles
and cultural practices that tend to make women and girls responsible for the most
labor-intensive and time-consuming household chores. Hundreds of millions of
women and young girls spend an average of 6 h a day just gathering fuelwood
and carrying water for basic subsistence needs. These are often the same women
and girls who have to spend considerable amounts of time and effort manually
984 F. Farioli
Bioenergy covers all energy forms produced directly or indirectly from biomass –
organic fuels of biological origin; it comprises both purpose-grown energy crops
and multipurpose plantations and by-products (residues and wastes) (FAO 2000)
(see chapter Biomass Energy Field in this handbook).
986 F. Farioli
which endowed favorable climatic condition, and lower costs of production (Smeets
et al. 2007; Hoogwijk et al. 2005; FAO 2008) which has subsequently pro-
vided stimulation for feedstock cultivation and/or biofuel productions in these
regions.
The development of modern bioenergy systems promises to be a solution option
to address the complex interrelated problems of limited access to energy sources,
low level of quality of life, lack of livelihood opportunities in rural areas in Africa,
and degradation of arid and semiarid ecosystems caused by unsustainable land
use practices, thanks to opportunities offered for sustainable sources of energy for
local needs (in the form of fuel, electricity, or heat), investment, and infrastructure
improvements in agriculture with the promise to diversify agricultural production
and thus to stimulate socioeconomic development.
On the other hand, concerns exist that bioenergy (biofuels) expansion may
have severe negative impacts on biodiversity and food security through increasing
competition over land and water resources.
Opportunities and risks exist. The potential contribution to socioeconomic sus-
tainability deriving from expansion of bioenergy (Mapako et al. 2012; Mwakasonda
and Farioli 2012) will be determined in part by the ability of modern bioenergy
markets to extend into poor communities in developing countries, in order to
revitalize rural economies, which are often set back due to unreliable energy
services.
On the one hand, biofuels may imply:
• The increase of income and job opportunities in the agricultural sector – feed-
stock production, handling, and transportation – through the use of
previously unused resources (e.g., intercropping, degraded land) or the pro-
duction of high-value bioenergy cash crops as well as in the processing,
distribution, and marketing sectors. These new positions would include high-
skill science, engineering, and business-related employment, depending on the
scale of production and degree of mechanization (Utria 2004; GTZ/worldwatch
2006; AGAMA 2003). As the Biomass Cogeneration Program in Mauritius
and the Brazilian Pro-alcohol Program show, a consistent creation of unskilled
and skilled jobs is possible (Moreira 2005; Woods et al. 2008). In a study
conducted by AGAMA on the employment potential of renewable energy in
South Africa, the number of gross direct jobs/MW (and/GWh) for biomass is one
gross direct job/MW (or 5.6 jobs/GWh) (AGAMA 2003), showing bioenergy is
possibly the most labor intensive energy source, compared to fossil fuels and
other RES.
• The provision of bioenergy in various forms, such as commercial heat and
electricity production for rural electrification (to light homes, schools, and health
clinics), as fuel for use in engines (for income-productive activities), and as
transportation fuel. Turning to the domestic activities, it is easy to imagine that
cooking and water heating may become less time consuming and cheaper with
equipment driven by modern fuels. Improved light may facilitate homework
and extend business or domestic activities into the evening hours. Access to
electricity also facilitates the use of media – for both information collection and
988 F. Farioli
leisure activities – and allows for charging of cellular telephones. With respect
to water, improved energy facilities may facilitate irrigation and water access
for domestic purposes. Finally, the switch to modern fuels reduces the need to
allocate time into fuelwood collection activities, especially for women (Farioli
and Dafrallah 2012) as well as reduces indoor air pollution from inefficient
traditional stoves that cause severe health problems mainly for women and
children.
• An increase in investment and capacity building in the agricultural sector,
leading to the application of best management practices and an increase in
agricultural productivity.
• Improved balance of payments and currency valuation thanks to lower oil import
bills which are particularly a drain on developing countries’ economies and
farmers’ budgets.
• An economically rewarding way to regenerate Africa’s vast areas of degraded
land (e.g., grass has notable potential for regeneration of degraded soils, and
plants such as Agave and Jatropha can grow on particularly dry land).
• Lessened conflict, which is widely recognized as both a cause and an effect of
hunger and poverty in Africa. Using bioenergy to improve both food security
and economic security could help replace a vicious cycle with a virtuous one.
• Reduction in price volatility associated with agricultural commodities, thanks to
a new demand, generated by biofuels, for agricultural products that go beyond
traditional food, feed, and fiber uses, therefore reducing the risk for poor farmers
(Clancy 2008).
However, when bioenergy crops encroach on valuable ecosystems or food crops,
or when land clearing or transformation is used to obtain fast profits, there can be
negative consequences for environmental and socioeconomic sustainability.
Social sustainability concerns are mainly linked to expansion of agricultural
land for production of energy crops and centralization of agriculture that could
exacerbate conflicts over land rights and “landlessness” issues in several developing
countries, forcing rural dwellers and pastoralists to migrate, losing their access
to key forest resources and ecosystem services. The risk of exacerbating existing
inequities in land access, compounded by land’s historical, political, cultural, and
spiritual value, is particularly evident in rural Africa, where land tenure is often
characterized by a high level of insecurity, as a result of the colonial legacy of
centralized ownership of land by the state, coupled with weak mechanisms for
accountability and enforcement of land rights.
The increasing competition over land and water resources can lead also to food
insecurity, especially when food crops are cultivated for biofuel production.
Poor labor conditions and unfair distribution of the benefits along the value chain
are additional concerns for socioeconomic sustainability.
Major environmental concerns derive from intensive feedstock cultivation lead-
ing to:
• Biodiversity loss, usually associated with large-scale cultivation and the expan-
sion of agricultural land for production of energy crops
• Water consumption and reduced water flows, especially for irrigated crops
53 Ensuring Sustainability of Bioenergy in Practice 989
The Competence Platform on Energy Crop and Agroforestry Systems for Arid and
Semi-arid Ecosystems in Africa (COMPETE) project was an international biofuels
initiative that addressed the interrelated problems of low quality of life, limited
energy access, and lack of livelihood opportunities in rural Africa. The project was
funded through the EU’s 6th Framework Programme and ran 3 years (2007–2009)
(http://www.compete-bioafrica.net/). It involved 44 partners, including scientists,
practitioners, companies, and policy makers from Europe, Africa, Brazil, India, and
Mexico.
The objective of COMPETE was to stimulate sustainable bioenergy implemen-
tation in Africa through the establishment of a platform for policy dialogue and
capacity building.
COMPETE carried out a comprehensive, multidisciplinary, assessment of current
land use, energy demand, and technology innovation focused on Africa to identify
pathways for the sustainable provision of bioenergy, which aimed to:
• Improve the quality of life and create alternative means of income for rural
populations in Africa
• Aid the preservation of the critical functions of arid and semiarid regions in
Africa as intact ecosystems
• Enhance the equitable exchange of knowledge between EU and developing
countries
Being bioenergy a complex issue that needs to be addressed through a comprehen-
sive and systemic approach, the project produced comprehensive and interrelated
knowledge and understanding including different perspectives, considering the
various linkages and trade-off among involved sectors and issues, about which
agricultural crops can be used for energy purpose in some African countries in a
way that is not detrimental for environment, does not compete with food production
and alternative land and water uses, and at the same time increases opportunities for
creation of local added value.
Another objective of the project was to identify policy approaches that foster
“win–win” outcomes with respect to bioenergy, food security, and poverty reduc-
tion. This is particularly challenging considering that Africa is the most vulnerable
and poor continent in the world. Although potentially productive land is rather
plentiful in much of Africa, hunger and lack to food access is the main problem,
with lack of development as the most important underlying cause.
Arid and semiarid regions in Africa are the target region of COMPETE; those
regions seem to have large potential but are also some of the poorest and most
technically backward in the world. Eighty percent of the population still rely on
traditional forms of energy, charcoal and firewood, to fulfill their energy needs
(Woods et al. 2007).
53 Ensuring Sustainability of Bioenergy in Practice 991
Table 53.4 Availability of land for energy crop production in semiarid and arid regions of eight
sub-Saharan African countries
Burkina Africa
Country Senegal Faso Mali Kenya Tanzania Zambia Botswana South
Total area 196,013 272,339 1,252,281 581,871 941,375 751,920 587,337 1,221,361
km2
Arid and 111,147 149,973 637,960 457,908 316,738 160,281 581,605 901,345
semiarid
km2
Km2 arid 15,783 22,756 192,438 379,698 147,252 67,383 291,860 722,874
and semiarid,
available and
suitable
% arid and 14 15 30 82 46 42 51 79
semiarid,
available
and suitable
Source: Watson, Diaz-Chavez (2011). See also www.compete-bioafrica.net/
a wide range of data sets (GLC database, FAOSTAT), aerial photograph and field
verification, an extensive literature review, and a wide range of stakeholders.
Areas considered unavailable for feedstock production and those agriculturally
unsuitable for such production were filtered out. Areas were considered unavailable
on the basis of their importance in terms of biodiversity, carbon stocks, environ-
mental services, food security, and rural livelihoods. They included all categories
of protected areas, biodiversity hotspots, forests and wetlands outside of protected
areas, and cropland and pasture land.
Localities where bioenergy feedstock production would be at risk, due to
legal, archeological, cultural, and/or policy constraints, were also identified and
superimposed to the identified available and suitable land.
Table 53.4 shows area available and suitable for cultivation of feedstock for
bioenergy in the eight countries where investigation has been carried out. The share
of total area ranges from 15% for Western African countries (Senegal e Burkina
Faso) to more than 80% in Kenya (Watson et al. 2011).
The table indicates that there is available and suitable land, but concerns exist.
Using GIS to interrogate 1 km2 database provides a cheap, effective, and quick way
to identify where land is potentially available and suitable. But Watson affirms that
accuracy is affected by dynamics of savannas, leading to inability to safeguard high
biodiversity grasslands. The characteristic of savanna, very common in this part of
Africa, is vegetation type made of tree and grass, and the composition depends on
how often the land is burnt and raised. Regular burn and raise leads to grassland;
less intensive burn and raise favors predominance woodland (see difference in
vegetation cover between left and right side in Picture 53.1). Using 1 km2 database
this difference cannot be captured as showed in Picture 53.1.
53 Ensuring Sustainability of Bioenergy in Practice 993
Picture 53.1 Showing temporally dynamic savanna, Watson (2012) presentation at ICSS2012
Other concern related to the use of 1 km2 resolution is that it does not allow to
capture scattered small-scale, subsistence farming occurring in the areas considered
available and suitable according to the applied land-mapping methodology. A
simple confrontation with images given from Google Earth showed different uses of
this land, in terms of lot of small-scale cultivation, and presence of important natural
resources.
In summary it can be stated that the application of land use mapping proved to
be effective in safeguarding large-scale food and cash crop production, while on the
contrary it was not appropriate to adequately safeguard the livelihoods of traditional
land users and small-scale famers (Watson and Diaz-Chavez 2011). Field visits and
Google Earth examination of a large number of places, identified as available and
suitable for biofuel feedstock production, revealed, in fact, human habitation and/or
use of natural resources in a substantial portion of them.
This is particularly relevant if we consider that natural plant and animal resources
make a very significant contribution to food security and income generation,
particularly for poor rural and especially female-headed households in African
countries.
A wide range of plants and plant parts, and animals are collected and hunted
for a wide range of purposes. Rural households and those of the urban poor are
particularly dependent on these natural resources for food security and income
generation. The reliance on and demand for these resources are likely to continue to
increase. According to Watson and Diaz-Chavez (2011), land use mapping approach
needs to be improved through employing of higher-resolution remotely sensed data,
a wide range of local information sources, as well as ground verification in order to
verify that land that appears to be unoccupied and unutilized actually is, before it is
cleared for biofuel crops.
994 F. Farioli
Another concern regards protected areas (PA) that are usually not fenced in
Africa (except in South Africa), so animals move freely from outside to inside most
of PA. The corridors of animal routes should also be excluded, and this was not
captured in the above-described land use mapping.
Following the above considerations, the land availability assessment carried out
in COMPETE has highlighted that communal grazing land, areas, and routes used
by gathers, hunters, and nomadic pastoralists, as for example most community-
based natural resource management areas that border unfenced protected areas
where communities are given licenses to hunt, should all be excluded from biofuel
feedstock production consideration. Maasai communities, for example, move with
their cattle through Kenya and Tanzania, but they do not follow the same route,
depending on the seasonality (rainy or dry season). This makes the land use mapping
more difficult (e.g., during dry periods, they move on the cost, conflicting the land
with cattle breeders). Therefore, in identifying land available for biofuel feedstock
production, routes traditionally used by the Maasai in both “normal” rainfall periods
and severe droughts should be excluded. Some of them practice also agriculture and
could also benefit from production of feedstock for bioenergy as additional source
of income.
The land use assessment described above is an important tool for ensuring sustain-
ability in the decision-making process, avoiding food–fuel conflicts, and ensuring
food security and bioenergy development in African countries.
Another tool aimed to ensuring sustainability in the decision making process is
sustainability assessment.
It offers support in acquiring a better insight into sustainability complex issues
as those involved in bioenergy development. A plethora of methodologies, methods,
models, tools, and indicators for sustainability assessment have been developed over
the past 30 years.
We continue moving toward an “indicator zoo” characterized by a multitude
of approaches, allegedly comprehensive in addressing sustainability, but still with
only limited impact on policy and outcomes that are priorities for sustainable
development (Pintér et al. 2005).
Terms such as integrated assessment and sustainability assessment, and sustain-
ability appraisal are used to label “new” approaches to impact assessment that are
designed to direct planning and decision making toward sustainable development
(Hacking and Guthrie 2008; Sala et al. 2012). Although sustainable development
is not a destination, but a dynamic process of adaptation, learning, and action,
objectives and goals toward a more balanced integration between nature and human-
kind have to be agreed upon and set both at societal and policy level.
Therefore, an optimal sustainability assessment method should be
multi-scale, that is, able to deal with different and wide spatial and temporal scale
53 Ensuring Sustainability of Bioenergy in Practice 995
Research Demonstration
Enforcement
Data & indicators
Enforcement
Environmental Management tools (EIA, SA)
• Environmental impacts
• national,
• LCA and supply chain • LCA Social
regional and • policies
impacts
• Production, transport local economy plans &
and use • GHG and other
• livelihoods projects
emissions
• GHG and other (health) • Incentive • Directives
emissions (e.g. NOx,
• social • Barriers • Incentives
particulates)
organisation • Barriers
• Waste
• Institutional
capacity
Fig. 53.3 Framework for sustainability appraisal for bioenergy projects (Source: COMPETE
2008; Diaz-Chavez 2011)
(Hacking and Guthrie 2008), integrating global and local perspective, and provide
insight into linkages between events on both the macro- and microscale, accounting
for different time horizons, time preferences, discounting, and consistency with key
concepts of sustainability (intergenerational equality) (Sala et al. 2012).
Sustainability assessment, unlike environmental impact assessment, is a tool that
can be used expressly to prepare and design a biofuel development policy, plan,
program, or project with sustainability as the desired outcome rather than merely to
prevent or mitigate potential environmental impacts (Pope and Grace 2006).
The approach defined in the COMPETE project is based on the framework
for sustainability appraisal for bioenergy projects, plans, and policies showed in
Fig. 53.3.
It identifies a number of issues that need to be considered to ensure a sustainable
production and use of biomass to produce energy in order to fulfill energy needs and
contribute to make MDGs achievable.
It considers the integration of four themes (environmental, economic, social, and
policy and institutions) but is not treated independently and emphasizes the causality
links. Policy and institutions is considered not as drivers for decision making but as
an integral part of sustainable development (Diaz-Chavez 2011).
It is based on previous studies that have identified a strong need for approaches
with a developing country perspective which assess impacts in a locally oriented,
996 F. Farioli
assessment for policies, plans, and programs), while others are diverse but at the
same time limited to specific activities or products (e.g., life cycle assessment)
(Diaz-Chavez and Woods 2012).
Another concern with standard is whether they generate barriers for trade and
result in discrimination (Van Dam et al. 2009).
The main flaw with existing voluntary standards is their inability to incorporate
smallholders in value chains, due to inherent costs and complexity (Beall 2011).
A simpler and less time-consuming option to address sustainability concerns
of biofuel development and ensure that modern bioenergy development enhances
opportunities and safeguards against potential risks is provided by the good practice
approach. The Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) defines good practices
as “Any collection of specific methods that produce results that are in harmony
with the values of the proponents of those practices. In agriculture, it means the
application of available knowledge to addressing environmental, economic, and
social sustainability for on-farm production and post-production processes resulting
in safe and healthy food and nonfood agricultural products” (FAO/Netherlands
Conference 2005).
A number of good practices can be implemented throughout the bioenergy
supply chain. A set of environmental and socioeconomic good practices have been
documented and analyzed by FAO’s Bioenergy and Food Security Criteria and
Indicators (BEFSCI) and COMPETE projects (FAO/BEFSCI 2011; FAO/BEFSCI
2012; Farioli and Portale 2009; Farioli 2009). They can be adopted by bioenergy
feedstock producers and in order to minimize the risk of negative environmental and
social impacts from their operations and to ensure that modern bioenergy delivers
on its climate change mitigation, rural development, and food security potential.
These practices can improve the efficiency and sustainability in the use of land,
water, and agricultural inputs for bioenergy production, thus reducing the potential
competition with food production, as well as the inclusiveness of production mode
and equal distribution of profits (see Table 53.6).
Good Practice Guidelines have been produced by COMPETE project following
the above-illustrated approach (Fig. 53.3). They aimed to provide a general assess-
ment through principles that reflect a more balanced view including the perspectives
of different stakeholders to what is considered necessary to assure sustainability
issues in practice for a bioenergy project.
For an effective sustainability assessment, there must be clear delineated prin-
ciples and decision criteria based on well-integrated understanding of the key
requirements for sustainability.
Table 53.5 presents the principles selected in the framework of COMPETE
project through a participatory approach aimed to reflect a balanced view including
perspectives of different stakeholders to what is considered necessary to assure
sustainability issues in practice for a bioenergy project, plan, and program. Princi-
ples identified through the above-mentioned process and based on the sustainability
framework illustrated in Fig. 53.3 intend to provide a clear and balanced guideline
for good practices. Some of the principles have clear links among them, especially
regarding the compliance with policies and regulations (Principles 10 and 11).
998 F. Farioli
Table 53.5 presents the 12 principles and the topic they are related to (environmental,
social, economic, policy and institutions). One interesting point is that some of
the principles and criteria widely discussed in the EU and the USA context do
not present the same relevance for developing countries. For instance, GHG is
not considered as an important issue in many developing countries, whereas the
participation and opinion of the community, and the conservation of local resources,
is highly regarded. Moreover, social issues may also be valued differently: for
instance, child labor concerns are not seen in the same context as long as children
collaborate (not under exploitation circumstances) with the family tasks in the farms
and do not neglect their studies (Diaz-Chavez 2010).
Table 53.6 Principles, criteria, and indicators for sustainability assessment of bioenergy initiatives
Item Sustainable principles and criteria Description Indicators
1. (Principle) Good agroecological and forestry practices This principle considers that the basic
(biodiversity, soil) environmental characteristics to grow
Key question: Does bioenergy activity bioenergy crops will be followed according
safeguard biodiversity and environmental to the agroecological and forestry
conditions? conditions of each country, region, or
community willing to grow them
Criteria
1.1 Criterion Bioenergy crops are grown according to High risk areas for feedstock production in The project area does not fall in High Con-
agroecological zoning (http://www.fao.org/ terms of potential damage to vital servation Areas, Protected Areas, or other
nr/land/databasesinformation-systems/aez- ecosystem functions should be clearly “high risk” areas identified through land
agro-ecological-zoning-system/en/) and delineated and mapped suitability assessment, agro-ecological zon-
53 Ensuring Sustainability of Bioenergy in Practice
land suitability assessment. Not negative No-go areas identified ing of the country
effect on biodiversity Preservation of habitats in production areas Evidence of implementation of appropriate
for species to survive management practices to assist conservation
of ecosystems and preservation of habitats
throughout the production site which are
connected (a corridor) to enable species to
migrate.
No introduction of invasive species or
genetically modified species
(continued)
999
1000
4.2 Criterion The communication process with the Modalities of communication with the Documented evidence of communication
community is appropriate and accessible community use appropriate and accessible channels and dialogue: use of forms of pub-
tools and schemes licity to disseminate information about the
Consultations among the project proponents project (communication channels), access
and the affected parties are public to information (use of native language and
appropriate mediums)
Evidence of democratically established rep-
resentatives in communication or negotia-
tion or in audit situations
Distance of project site from consultation
sites
(continued)
1003
1004
assistance to small-scale liquid biofuel tion activities of oil (if realized) and business
feedstock producers, through dissemination activities, training and capacity-building ex-
of best practices, facilitation of ercise to train local technicians for an auton-
farmer-to-farmer participatory learning, and omy maintenance of equipments installed
encouraging and addressing farmers’ Evidence of monitoring on yield, pest,
requests for technical advice disease, water and land management.
Monitoring and reporting on progress of
training and level of satisfaction of farmers
and villages (formation and business
training turn into practical opportunities for
them?)
(continued)
1005
1006
10.1 Criterion Bioenergy activities have to be in line with Bioenergy is at the intersection of many Evidence of collaboration and participation
national bioenergy plans and policies (if policies and a broad range of political, by bioenergy stakeholders to policy discus-
existing) and allow the participation of all economic, environmental and social sion and initiatives in related areas (e.g.,
stakeholders involved in the definition and interests. All of these factors combine to agriculture, transport, environment, energy,
updating of guidelines appropriate to the create a complex decision-making arena land-use planning, economic development,
country’s situation and context involving significant trade-offs, in which trade and fiscal policy, ect).
there is the potential for conflict and where Presence in the country of ministerial task
choices with potentially wide-ranging force and a central office that supply the
implications must be made. Coordination support and procedures to be followed by
between the different branches of bioenergy investor in compliance of
policymaking is essential. cross-sector-based bioenergy policies and
regulations
11. (Principle) Compliance with local programs, Working with the national, regional, and
regulations, and/or plans in place local authorities is considered to be
Key question: Is the development and important to be aware of all programs,
implementation of the bioenergy activity in plans, and regulations at local level.
line with the local plans and policies that Compliance with them will strength the
may influence directly or indirectly the bioenergy initiative and will avoid conflicts
bioenergy development of the country? with the different stakeholders and the
regulators
11.1 Criterion Bioenergy stakeholders participate to local Bioenergy is at the intersection of many Evidence of collaboration between projects
initiatives aimed to coordinate bioenergy policies and a broad range of political, developers and local authorities Evidence
policies with other policies at local level economic, environmental, and social of bioenergy stakeholders participation in
interests. All of these factors combine to local government consultation to definition
create a complex decision-making arena of local bioenergy policies
involving significant trade-offs, in which
there is the potential for conflict and where
choices with potentially wide-ranging
implications must be made. Coordination
between the different branches of policy
making is essential
F. Farioli
12. (Principle) Respect land rights and avoid displacement The debate on land rights in developing
Key question: Do investors follow fair and countries (mainly in Africa) led to this
proper procedure to get use of land for their principle to be considered by communities,
bioenergy initiative, so that community governments, and investors. It considers to
rights over land are safeguarded? avoid displacement and to leave it to the
authorities’ decision in case this is needed
to be done after studies for this have been
conducted. In such case adequate
compensation and further studies for
relocation need to be included according to
international practice (e.g., such as the
guidelines from the World Bank 2008)
12.1 Criterion The right to use the land by the bioenergy In all types of acquisition or lease of land Evidence of appropriate levels of
investor has to be clearly demonstrated (State, private or customary land) for consultation and stakeholder engagement.
bioenergy projects, negotiations are carried Evidence of consultation with community
out with the formal owner (individual or (if the land is subjected to customary land)
communal owner), or traditional authorities Evidence of an agreement with the
allowed to make a decision, as well as with authorities (if the land is subjected to
53 Ensuring Sustainability of Bioenergy in Practice
Good Practice Guidelines have been tested through appraisal of five bioenergy
projects against the above principles (see COMPETE website http://www.compete-
bioafrica.net/bestpractice/bestpractice.html).
The appraisal has been conducted with a standard form through a qualitative
score system. Examples of appraisal vary with respect to type of production
and scale. There were initiatives of NGOs as the one developed by TaTEDO in
Tanzania (Janssen 2009 retrieved in http://www.compete-bioafrica.net/bestpractice/
bestpractice.html) but also private initiatives as that from Diligent in Tanzania and
Marli Investment in Zambia (Farioli and Portale 2009; Farioli 2009 retrieved in
http://www.compete-bioafrica.net/bestpractice/bestpractice.html).
As one of the main concerns in Africa is land tenure, many of the private
initiatives had to deal with this, addressing the issue through adoption of outgrower
scheme (an agreement between farmers and processing and/or marketing firms
for the production and supply of agricultural products under forward agreements,
frequently at predetermined prices, fixed and indicated in the contract or determined
by reference to spot-market prices) (Eaton and Shepherd 2001) and providing at the
same time inputs to local livelihood.
The appraisal provided a useful and easy tool that can be used by stake-
holders when considering to initiate a project and monitor or review an ongoing
project/initiative. It is not exhaustive, and principles may change under different
contexts, experts’ opinion, and local condition; anyway, the appraisal allowed seeing
different perceptions of the local production (Diaz-Chavez and Woods 2012).
Another important outcome achieved is the generation of a set of criteria and
indicators for the COMPETE initiative based on the results from the sustainability
appraisal (Table 53.6). The indicators identified (Table 53.6) can be used to evaluate
how and to what extent a farm producer or company prove that the conditions
(criteria) to achieve the tenets (principles) are met.
4 Summary
5 Cross-References
References
AGAMA, Employment Potential of Renewable Energy in South Africa, ed. by G. Austin, A.
Williams, G. Morris, R. Spalding-Fecher, R. Worthington. Prepared for the Sustainable Energy
and Climate Change Partnership Johannesburg, AGAMA, Nov 2003
AGECC, Energy for a Sustainable Future (The Secretary-General’s Advisory Group on Energy
and Climate Change/United Nations Industrial Development Organisation, New York, 2010),
available at http://www.unido.org/fileadmin/usermedia/Services/EnergyandClimateChange/
EPP/Publications/AGECCReport.pdf
B. Amigun, J.K. Musango, W. Stafford, Biofuels and sustainability in Africa. Renew. Sustain.
Energy Rev. 15(2), 1360–1372 (2011)
M. Bazilian, A. Sagar, R. Detchon, K. Yumkella, More heat and light. Energy Policy 38(10), 5409–
5412 (2010)
E. Beall, Smallholders in global bioenergy value chains and certification: evidence from three case
studies. Environment and natural resources working paper no. 50 – FAO, Rome, 2011
T. Buchholz, E. Rametsteiner, T.A. Volk, V.A. Luzadis, Multi criteria analysis for bioenergy
systems assessments. Energy Policy, 37(2), 484–495 (2009)
J. Clancy, Are biofuels pro-poor? Assessing the evidence. Eur. J. Dev. Res. 20(3), 416–431 (2008)
COMPETE, Task Report on WP3 Activities on Sustainability Analysis of Alternative Land Use
(2008), available at http://www.compete-bioafrica.net/sustainability/sustainability.html
L. Cotula, N. Dyer, S. Vermuelen, Fueling Exclusion? The Biofuels Boom and Poor People’s
Access to Land (FAO/IIED, Rome/London, 2008)
B. Dalal-Clayton, S. Bass, Sustainable Development Strategies: A Resource Book (Organisation for
Economic Co-operation and Development/Paris and United Nations Development Programme,
New York, 2002)
R. Diaz-Chavez, F. Rosillo-Calle, Biofuels for transport-sustainability and certification, in Where
Are We Now and Where Are We Going. Department for Transport, UK, 2009
R.A. Diaz-Chavez, Assessing biofuels: aiming for sustainable development or complying with the
market? Energy Policy 39(10), 5763–5769 (2011)
R. Diaz-Chavez, Good practices principles, COMPETE project (2010), Available on the
Internet at http://www.compete-bioafrica.net/bestpractice/COMPETE-032448-GoodPractice-
Principles.pdf. Accessed 12 Sept 2012
R. Diaz-Chavez, J. Woods, Keynote introduction: sustainability considerations for biofules produc-
tion in Africa, in Bioenergy for Sustainable Development in Africa. ISBN:978-94-007-2180-7
C. Eaton, A.W. Shepherd, Contract Farming: Partnerships for Growth (FAO, Rome, 2001)
53 Ensuring Sustainability of Bioenergy in Practice 1015
EC, in DIRECTIVE 2009/28/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 23 April
2009 on the Promotion of the Use of Energy from Renewable Sources and Amending and
Subsequently Repealing Directives 2001/77/EC and 2003/ 30/EC, 2009
ECCM, in Environmental Standards for Biofuels. A Report Commissioned by the LowCVP. The
Edinburgh Centre for Carbon Management, IIED, ADAS, Imperial College, 2006
ETSF, in Criteria for sustainable biomass production. Project Group Sustainable Biomass Produc-
tion, Final Report (The Energy Transition Task Force, The Netherlands, 2006)
S.E.H. Eriksen, H. Watson, The dynamic context of southern African savannas: investigating
emerging threats and opportunities to sustainability. Environ. Sci. Policy 12, 5–22 (2009)
FAO, Environmental and Natural Resource Services. The energy and agriculture nexus (FAO,
Rome, 2000)
FAO, The State of Food and Agriculture, Biofuels: Prospects, Risks and Opportunities (Food and
Agriculture Organization of the United Nations Publication, Rome, 2008)
FAO/BEFSCI, Good Socio-Economic Practices in Modern Bioenergy Production- Minimizing
Risks and Increasing Opportunities for Food Security, ed. by E. Beall, A. Rossi. FAO policy
brief, FAO, 2011, available at http://www.fao.org/docrep/015/i2507e/i2507e00.pdf
FAO/BEFSCI, Good Environmental Practices in Bioenergy Feedstock Production – Making
Bioenergy Work for Climate and Food Security, ed. by A. Rossi, Environment and Natural
Resources Working Paper No.49 – FAO, Rome, 2012
FAO/GBEP, A review of the current state of bioenergy development in G8+ 5 countries. G8 Global
Bioenergy Partnership (GBEP) Report, Rome, 2007
FAO/Netherlands Conference, Water for Food and Ecosystems, The Hague, 31 January–4 February
2005 retrieved in http://www.fao.org/ag/wfe2005/glossary en.htm
J. Fargione, J. Hill, D. Tilman, S. Polasky, P. Hawthorne, Land clearing and the biofuel carbon
debt. Science 19, 1235–1238 (2008)
F. Farioli, Good practice assessment for bioenergy projects – Zambia Jatropha oil production of
Marli Investment Zambia Ltd. COMPETE documents, 2009, available at http://www.compete-
bioafrica.net/bestpractice/bestpractice.html
F. Farioli, T. Dafrallah, Gender issues of biomass production and use in Africa, in Bioenergy for
Sustainable Development in Africa (Springer, 2012). ISBN:978-94-007-2180-7
F. Farioli, E. Portale, Good practice assessment for bioenergy projects – Diligent Tanzania Jatropha
oil production COMPETE documents, 2009, available at http://www.compete-bioafrica.net/
bestpractice/bestpractice.html
U.R. Fritsche, K. Hünecke, A. Hermann, F. Schulze, K. Wiegmann, Sustainability standards for
bioenergy, Öko-Institut for WWF GERMANY, 2006
GTZ/worldwatch, Biofuels for transportation: global potential and implications for sustainable
agriculture and energy in the 21st century (2006)
T. Hacking, P. Guthrie, A framework for clarifying the meaning of triple bottom-line, integrated
and sustainability assessment. Environ. Impact Assess. Rev. 28(2–3), 73–89 (2008)
J.A. Harrison, G.P. von Maltitz, L. Haywood, A. Sugrue, R. Diaz-Chavez, J.M. Amezaga,
Mechanisms for driving sustainability of biofuels in developing countries. Renew. Energy Law
Policy Rev. 197, 197–210 (2010)
P. Hazell, R.K. Pachauri, Bioenergy and Agriculture: Promises and Challenges. 2020 Focus 14
(International Food Policy Research Institute, Washington DC, 2006)
J.P. Holdren, G.C. Daily, P.R. Ehrlich, The meaning of sustainability: biogeophysical aspects, in
Defining and Measuring Sustainability: The Biological Foundations, ed. by M. Munasinghe,
W. Shearer (UN/World Bank, Washington DC, 1995), pp. 3–17
M. Hoogwijk, A. Faaij, B. Eickhout, B. De Vries, W. Turkenburg, Potential of biomass energy out
to 2100, for four IPCC SRES land-use scenarios. Biomass Bioenerg. 29(4), 225–257 (2005)
IEA, Energy and Poverty, World Energy Access Outlook (IEA, Paris, 2002)
IEA, UNDP, UNIDO, Energy poverty – how to make modern energy access universal? in Special
Early Excerpt of the World Energy Outlook 2010 for the UN General Assembly on the
Millennium Development Goals (International Energy Agency, Paris, 2010), available at http://
www.worldenergyoutlook.org/docs/weo2010/weo2010poverty.pdf
1016 F. Farioli
R. Janssen, Good practice assessment for bioenergy projects – Leguruki Village Multifunctional
Platform- TaTEDO Tanzania, COMPETE documents, 2009, http://www.competebioafrica.net/
814bestpractice/bestpractice.html
F.X. Johnson, F. Lambe, Energy Access, Climate and Development, the Commission on Cli-
mate Change and Development (2009), available at http://www.ccdcommission.org/Filer/
commissioners/Energy.pdf
M. Junginger, in Overview of Biomass–Related Sustainability Certification Efforts and Policy in
IEA Bioenergy. Task 40 member countries. Project Groep Duurzame Import Biomasss, 2006
S. Karekezi, W. Kithyoma, Renewable energy strategies for Rural Africa: is a PV-led renewable
energy strategy the right approach for providing modern energy to the rural poor of Sub-Saharan
Africa? AFREPREN/FWD secretariat. Energy Policy 30(10–11), 1071–1086 (2002)
I. Lewandowski, A. Faaij, Steps towards the development of a certification system for sustainable
bio-energy trade. Biomass Bioenerg. 30, 83–104 (2006)
M. Mapako, F. Farioli, R. Diaz-Chavez, Socioeconomic and environmental impacts and
contributions to sustainability, in Bioenergy for Sustainable Development and Economic
Competitiveness: The Role of Sugar Cane in Africa, ed. by F.X. Johnson, V. Seebaluck
(Routledge/Earthscan, London, 2012)
V. Modi, S. McDade, D. Lallement, J. Saghir, Energy services for the millenniumdevelop-
ment goals. Energy sector management assistance programme, United Nations Development
Programme, UN millennium project, and World Bank (2005), available at http://www.
unmillenniumproject.org/documents/MPEnergyLowRes.pdf
J.R. Moreira, The importance of bio-energy for the World Development and Sustainability,
National Reference Center on Biomass, CENBIO/IEE-USP. Presentation given during IEA
Task 30, 31 & 40 workshop, Campinas, Brazil, 30 Nov–2 Dec 2005, available at www.
bioenergytrade.org
S. Mwakasonda, F. Farioli, Social impacts of biofuel production in Africa, in Bioenergy for
Sustainable Development in Africa, ed. by R. Janssen, D. Rutz (Springer, Heidelberg, 2012).
ISBN:978-94-007-2180-7
F. Orecchini, A “measurable” definition of sustainable development based on closed cycles of
resources and its application to energy systems. Sustain. Sci. 2, 245–252 (2007)
F. Orecchini, Energy sustainability pillars. Int. J. Hydrog. Energy 36, 7748–7749 (2011a).
Hydrogen Energy Publications, LLC. Published by Elsevier Ltd
F. Orecchini, A. Santiangeli, V. Valitutti, Sustainability science: sustainable energy for mobility
and its use in policy making. Sustainability 3, 1855–1865 (2011b). ISSN 2071–1050
L. Pintér, P. Hardi, P. Bartelmus, Sustainable development indicators: proposals for a way forward.
Discussion paper prepared under a consulting agreement on behalf of the UN division for
sustainable development, IlSD, Winnipeg, CDN: 1–11, 2005
J. Pope, W. Grace, Sustainability assessment in context: issues of process, policy and governance.
J. Environ. Assess. Policy Manage. 8, 373–398 (2006)
RSB, Land Rights Assessment Guidelines RSB Technical Report 12-11-2009 version 1.0, 2009
Rural Electrification Funds – World Bank’s Public Private Partnership in Infrastructure Resource
Centre, retrieved Oct 4 (2012), http://ppp.worldbank.org/public-private-partnership/sector/
energy/laws-regulations/rural-electrification-funds
S. Sala, F. Farioli, A. Zamagni, Progress in sustainability science: lessons learnt from current
methodologies for sustainability assessment (Part I). Int. J. Life Cycle Assess. 29 sept 2012.
doi: 10.1007/s11367-012-0509-5
I. Scoones, Sustainable rural livelihood. A framework for analysis. IDS working paper 72, 1998
SE4All technical report for task force 1, Apr 2012, available at http://www.sustainableenergyforall.
org/about-us
T. Searchinger, H. Ralph, R.A. Houghton et al., Use of U.S. croplands for biofuels increases
greenhouse gases through emissions from land-use change. Science 319(5867), 1238–1240
(2008)
53 Ensuring Sustainability of Bioenergy in Practice 1017
E.M.W. Smeets, A.P.C. Faaij, I.M. Lewandowski, W.C. Turkenburg, A bottom-up assessment and
review of global bio-energy potentials to 2050. Prog. Energy Combust. Sci. 33(1), 56–106
(2007)
D.S.G. Thomas, Sand, grass, thorns, and : : : cattle: the modern Kalahari environment, in
Sustainable Livelihoods in Kalahari Environments: Contributions to Global Debates, ed. by
D. Sporton, D.S.G. Thomas (Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2002), pp. 21–38
UNDP (2004) World Energy Assessment: Overview 2004 update United Nations Development
Program, New York, ISBN: 92-1-126167-8, www.undp.org/energy.
Un-Energy (United Nations-Energy), The energy challenge for achieving the millennium develop-
ment goals (2005), http://www.un-energy.org/sites/default/files/share/une/un-enrg paper.pdf
United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), 2005, Energizing the Millennium Devel-
oping Goals: A Guide to Energy’s Role in Reducing Poverty, New York, NY: UNDP
retrieved from http://www.undp.org.cu/eventos/biomasa/Energizing%20the%20Millennium
%20Development%20Goals%20-%20A%20Guide%20to%20En.pdf
B. Utria, Modern biomass energy for sustainable development and poverty alleviation, in IEA Task
40- business forum, ed. by A. Faaij, G. Best. Held FAO, Rome 28 to 29 Oct 2004. IEA Task 40,
2004, www.fairbiotrade.org
J. Van Dam, Background Document from: Dam et al., 2010, from the Global Efforts on
Certification of Bioenergy Towards an Integrated Approach Based on Sustainable Land Use
Planning. Task 40, Utrecht, 2010
J. Van Dam, M. Junginger, A. Faaij, I. Jurgens, G. Best, U. Fritsche, Overview of recent
developments in sustainable biomass certification. Biomass Bioenerg. 32(2008), 749–780
(2009)
H.K. Watson, Second task report on WP1 current land use patterns and impacts. UKZN
COMPETE, Report to WIP – Renewable Energies, 2008
H. Watson, Lessons Learnt from Attempts to Identify Potential Areas for Sustainable Biofuels Feed-
stocks Production in Africa Presentation given During ICSS2012 (Arizona State University,
Phoenix, 2012)
H.K. Watson, R. Diaz-Chavez, An assessment of the potential of drylands in eight sub-Saharan
African countries to produce bioenergy feedstocks. Interface Focus 1, 263–270 (2011)
WHO (World Health Organization), Indoor Smoke from Solid Fuel Use: Assessing the Envi-
ronmental Burden of Disease. Environmental burden of disease series, No. 4 (World Health
Organization, Geneva, 2004)
WHO, The Global Burden of Disease: 2004 Update (World Health Organization, Geneva, 2008)
J. Woods, R. Diaz-Chavez, P. Helm, A. Hofer, D. Rutz, R. Janssen, COMPETE - competence
platform on energy crop and agroforestry systems - Africa, in Proceedings of the 15th European
Biomass Conference and Exhibition, Berlin, Germany, 2007, pp. 2680–2682
J. Woods, R. Diaz-Chavez, M. Mapako, F. Farioli, E. Bocci, F. Zuccari, F.X. Johnson, Bioenergy for
sustainable development and global competitiveness: the case of sugar cane in Southern Africa.
A Compilation of Results from the Thematic Research Network Cane Resources Network for
Southern Africa (CARENSA). CARENSA/SEI special report series CARENSA/SEI 2008-04,
2008
Geothermal Energy
54
Hakim Saibi, Stefan Finsterle, Ruggero Bertani, and Jun Nishijima
Abstract
This chapter presents general information about the recent methods applied for
geothermal systems. Geothermal engineering can be separated into two groups:
research about the underground geothermal reservoir using geophysical and
numerical methods and the use of a geothermal power plant as a technology to
produce electricity from the underground hot waters. In this chapter, both aspects
are presented.
Twenty-four countries are currently generating electricity from geothermal
resources and 78 countries are using geothermal energy for heating purposes.
The total installed geothermal capacity worldwide is 10.7 GWe.
This chapter is divided into four parts:
The first part, the introduction, discusses the current use of geothermal
electricity and the trend of installed geothermal capacity in the world. It also
explains the main concepts of geothermal engineering and presents the different
types of hydrothermal systems.
H. Saibi ()
Earth Resources Engineering, Laboratory of Exploration Geophysics, Faculty of Engineering,
Kyushu University, Nishi-ku, Fukuoka, Japan
e-mail: saibi-hakim@mine.kyushu-u.ac.jp, saibi.hakim@gmail.com
S. Finsterle
Hydrogeology Department, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Earth Sciences Division,
Berkeley, CA, USA
e-mail: safinsterle@lbl.gov
R. Bertani
Geothermal Center of Excellence, Enel Green Power S.p.A., Pisa, Italy
e-mail: ruggero.bertani@enel.com
J. Nishijima
Faculty of Engineering, Laboratory of Geothermics, Kyushu University, Nishi-ku, Fukuoka,
Japan
e-mail: nisijima@mine.kyushu-u.ac.jp
The second part describes geothermal engineering technology and its compo-
nents. This part presents direct utilization, geothermal heat pumps, electric power
generation and combined heat and power generation, the numerical modeling of
geothermal systems, the current state of practice, recent advances, and emerging
trends in geothermal reservoir simulation and hybrid-microgravity monitoring
applications at geothermal field.
The third part presents a case study of Húsavı́k Energy in Iceland.
In the fourth part, the economic analysis is presented.
1 Introduction
Geothermal energy, defined as heat from the Earth, is clean and sustainable. The
energy demand by the world population is increasing due to the expansion of
economies and population growth of the planet Earth and advancements in energy-
intense technologies. Between 2008 and 2035, the world’s energy use is expected
to grow by approximately 53 % with half of the increase attributed to India and
China (International Energy Outlook 2011). Much of the energy growth comes
from developing countries. Fossil fuels are expected to supply approximately 80 %
of world energy use in 2035. Renewables are the world’s fastest-growing energy
source, at 2.8 % per year, with the renewable’s share of the world energy supply
growing to approximately 15 % in 2035 (International Energy Outlook 2011).
Renewable energy in general and geothermal energy in particular could play a
significant role in supplying a clean and environmentally sustainable source of
energy to satisfy the world energy demand and its challenges.
The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) performed a compre-
hensive study on climate. Their models assumed an increase in temperature of
approximately 2–4ı C for the period 2000–2100 with high CO2 concentration values
ranging from 550 ppm (which is twice the preindustrial level) to 850 ppm. The
increases in temperature and CO2 concentrations are mainly attributed to CO2
emissions from fossil-fuel energy production systems. Geothermal energy is one
recommended approach to decrease CO2 emissions.
Geothermal energy is the most versatile renewable energy and has been used for
thousands of years for washing, bathing, cooking and health: the direct utilization
of hot water is long lasting and still growing with different application ranges.
The world’s first geothermal district heating system was started in the fourteenth
century at Chaudes-Aigues, France, and the first geothermal well was drilled
near Reykjavik, Iceland, in 1755. However, only in the twentieth century has
geothermal energy been harnessed on a large scale for space heating, electricity
production, and industrial use. The first large municipal district heating service
was initiated in Iceland in the 1930s and currently provides geothermal heat to
approximately 99 % of the 200,000 residents of Reykjavik. The first commercial
plant to produce electricity became available in 1913 in Larderello, Italy. The use of
geothermal energy has increased rapidly since the 1970s. During the period 2000–
2010, the globally installed direct-use capacity tripled from 15 to 50 GWth , whereas
the installed capacity for electricity production increased from 8.0 to 10.7 GWe .
54 Geothermal Energy 1021
“Geothermal” comes from the Greek words geo (Earth) and therme (heat). Thus,
geothermal means Earth heat. Geothermics can be defined as the study of the tem-
perature distribution in the Earth and the phenomena that influence that distribution.
The Earth’s heat is continuously radiated from within, and each year rainfall
and snowmelt supply new water to geothermal reservoirs. Production from in-
dividual geothermal fields can be sustained for decades and perhaps centuries,
which explains the renewability of this resource (Geothermal Education Office
2001) (Fig. 54.4).
The major characteristics of geothermal energy are its renewability and sustain-
ability and its environmental friendliness (with few CO2 emissions). Its various
utilizations include power generation (conventional steam turbine, combined cycle),
direct heat use for space heating, greenhouses, aquaculture and tourism (swim-
ming pool).
There are mainly two types of geothermal systems: convective and conductive.
The convective geothermal systems include vapor-dominated and water-dominated
systems. The conductive geothermal system is represented by the hot dry rock
system. To form a geothermal reservoir, three components are necessary:
– Heat represented by the thermal energy itself, conductive heat transfer, and
convective heat transfer (fluid transport)
1024 H. Saibi et al.
– Fluid that helps to transfer energy by convection and recharging the water
– Open, permeable paths, which allow fluid to flow through porous and fractured
systems
can be said that in the geothermal power generation, the Earth itself plays a role
of a boiler. Generally, the deeper in the Earth, the higher the temperature gets. It is
assumed to be about 1,000ıC at the depth of 30–50 km, where it can be regarded
as a large thermal storage. To use geothermal energy taken to the ground surface
from production wells for power generation, there are some generation systems
depending on characteristics of geothermal fluid (temperature, pressure, flow rate,
etc.) such as single-flash system, double-flash system, dry steam system, and binary
cycle system.
Geothermal heat pumps (GHPs) use the relatively constant temperature of the Earth
to provide heating, cooling, and domestic hot water for buildings. A small amount
of electricity input is required to run a compressor.
A closed loop of pipe is placed vertically (50–70 m deep) in the ground, and
a water-antifreeze solution is circulated through the plastic pipes to either collect
heat from the ground in the winter or reject heat to the ground in the summer. The
efficiency of GHP units is described by the coefficient of performance (COP), which
is the ratio of the output energy divided by the input energy (electricity for the
compressor). The ratio varies from 3 to 6 with the present equipment (the higher
the number, the better the efficiency). In comparison, an air-source heat pump has
a COP of approximately 2 and is dependent upon backup electrical energy to meet
peak heating and cooling requirements (see Fig. 54.7).
1026 H. Saibi et al.
HEAT EXCHANGER
REFRIGERANT/AIR
(EVAPORATOR)
EXPANSION VALVE
REFRIGERANT
DOMESTIC HOT WATER
REVERSING VALVE
EXCHANGER
(DESUPERHEATER)
HEAT EXCHANGER
REFRIGERANT/WATER
(CONDENSER)
IN
OUT
DOMESTIC WATER
REFRIGERANT TO / FROM GROUND
COMPRESSOR HEAT EXCHANGER
(GEOTHERMAL)
The share of each category in the total installed capacity, the annually produced
electricity, and the total number of units is are presented in Table 54.1. In addition,
the average values per unit for the installed capacity and the annually produced
electricity are given. From this overview, the hybrid plants (those using more than
one form of energy) are excluded, but their share is currently approximately zero.
More recently, the use of combined heat and power plants (CHP) has made low-
temperature resources and deep drilling more economical. District heating using the
spent water from a binary power plant can make a marginal project economical,
as demonstrated at Neustadt-Glewe, Landau, and Bad Urach in Germany and Bad
Blumau in Austria. A similar outcome was found for high-temperature combined
heat and power plants in Iceland. Options for cascading are shown in the Fig. 54.11,
1028 H. Saibi et al.
Fig. 54.8 Steam plant using a vapor- or dry steam-dominated geothermal resource
Fig. 54.9 Single-stage flash steam plant using a water-dominated geothermal resource with a
separator to produce steam
54 Geothermal Energy 1029
Fig. 54.10 Binary power or ORC plant using a low-temperature geothermal resource and a
secondary fluid of a low-boiling-point hydrocarbon
Table 54.1 Average capacity and electricity produced per plant category and the share of each
category
Average
electricity
Average production Share of the Share of the Share of the
capacity per per unit number of total capacity electricity
Type of plant unit (MW) (GWh/year) plants (%) (%) produced (%)
Binary plant 5 27 44 4 4
Back pressure plant 6 50 5 5 6
Single-flash plant 31 199 27 25 26
Double-flash plant 34 236 12 28 30
Dry steam plant 46 260 12 38 34
capture the key features and processes affecting coupled fluid and heat flow in
the reservoir and in the injection and production wells. Numerical models can
be employed to study generic issues of geothermal reservoir dynamics, including
two-phase water-steam flow through fracture networks; heat transfer mechanisms
between the hot rock matrix and fluids in the fractures; reactive geochemical
transport including scaling due to mineral dissolution and precipitation; coupled
thermal-hydrological-mechanical processes, specifically microseismicity associated
with reservoir stimulation; and interactions between the reservoir, wells, and surface
facilities. In addition to the use of numerical models to increase the fundamental
understanding of these complex systems, simulators are extensively used to model-
specific geothermal fields (O’Sullivan et al. 2001). During exploration, preliminary
geological information and data from geophysical surveys, surface manifestations,
and exploration boreholes can be used for resource estimation and the initial
well field design. Once additional data are available from drilling, well testing,
and well completion, the reservoir properties can be determined, and a natural-
state simulation can be performed to examine the convection patterns, upflow
and recharge regions, the presence of flow boundaries, and the initial condi-
tions prior to exploitation. Predictive simulations can be performed for research
estimation and planning of the field development. Once production is initiated, the
54 Geothermal Energy 1031
step in the process because it ultimately determines the mathematical model, the
selection of the computer code, and the data needed for the model calibration and the
confidence-building exercise. Simulations usually proceed in multiple steps, starting
with reproducing the pre-exploitation, natural state of the reservoir, which yields the
initial conditions for the subsequent simulation of the exploitation phase, provides
the main calibration data, and is used for reservoir management purposes. The time
horizon of these simulations can be extended to look at additional scenarios, the
sitting of additional wells, and long-term predictions of reservoir performance for
resource assessment. These predictive simulations may be accompanied by a formal
uncertainty analysis, which in turn may be used to improve the monitoring systems
and the collection of additional calibration data to improve parameter estimations.
This workflow is approximate as certain stages may be skipped or executed in a
different order, depending on the modeling purpose. Moreover, the process of model
development, calibration, and prediction is iterative, accompanying the exploration,
development, exploitation, and assessment of the actual geothermal reservoir.
54 Geothermal Energy 1033
2.5.6 Example
An example of a numerical model of a synthetically enhanced geothermal system
is shown in Fig. 54.13. It consists of a central injection well and two peripheral
production wells. The reservoir is hydraulically and thermally stimulated, leading
to an ellipsoidal region of fractured rock that is modeled using a dual-permeability
approach. In addition, a discrete wide-aperture zone with increased permeability
is formed, providing potential pathways for fast fluid flow that lead to an early
thermal breakthrough. The heat exchange between the wells and the formation
above the model domain is accounted for using an efficient semi-analytical solution
for radial heat transfer. The figure shows the computational mesh on the faces of the
model domain, along with the temperature isosurfaces that reveal reservoir volume
undergoing heat mining. The simulations were performed using the TOUGH code
(Pruess et al. 1999).
2.5.7 Outlook
Although numerical modeling in support of geothermal reservoir engineering can
be considered a mature technology, the need to manage reservoirs in a sustainable
manner or to engineer them poses significant challenges that can be partly addressed
by advanced simulation capabilities. In particular, the ability to numerically examine
coupled thermal-hydrological-geochemical-mechanical effects allows scientists and
engineers to better understand the reservoir behavior to analyze the monitoring data
for an improved characterization of the formation and the fluid and heat flows
under natural state and production conditions and to manage and optimize the
reservoir operations with a reduced risk to the resource and the nearby communities.
Integrating the geophysical information in a quantitative manner into the reservoir
models is another recent advance that has the potential to further improve the
reliability of the predictions made in support of the exploration, characterization,
and prediction of the geothermal reservoir behavior.
54 Geothermal Energy 1035
T [°C]
190
−4000 180
170
160
Depth [m]
150
−4500 140
130
120
110
−5000
−1000
−2000 −500
−1500
−1000 0 ]
−500 [m
Y [m 0 500 X
] 500
1000 1000
Fig. 54.13 Numerical model of a synthetically enhanced geothermal system with the temperature
isosurfaces after 30 years of heat mining by the injection of cold water from the central well and
production from two peripheral wells that intersect the stimulated fracture zone
The gravity method is a potential-field geophysical method. Over the last four
decades, many applications in geothermal, volcanological, and engineering prob-
lems have been applied. Time-lapse microgravity surveys in the geothermal field
showed good results by monitoring the gravity changes with time and estimating
the underground mass changes (Saibi et al. 2005). The gravity method is a nonde-
structive geophysical technique that measures differences in the Earth’s gravitational
field at specific locations.
Microgravity measurement is one of the procedures for geothermal reservoir
monitoring. The production and reinjection of geothermal fluid causes mass move-
ment and redistributions, which can cause measurable gravity changes on the
surface. The mass balance can be monitored, especially the relationship between
production and recharge, in the geothermal reservoir (Fig. 54.14). Microgravity
monitoring has been performed in some geothermal fields. Gravity decreased
approximately 1,000 gal after 30 years in the Wairakei geothermal field in New
Zealand (Allis and Hunt 1986).
1036 H. Saibi et al.
Combined utilization of heat and power for geothermal production (CHP) is not a
new application, but recently it has been widely extended in the low-to-medium-
temperature range of the resource, covering different project sizes.
The main reason for a CHP plant is the more efficient use of the entire geothermal
energy extracted from the reservoir fluid, from its initial temperature down to that
of the water discarded to the reinjection stream. In this way, it is possible to strongly
improve the economics of the entire system, making even small temperature
resources exploitable, even if the electricity revenues alone are not enough for a
reasonable payback of the investment.
In the selected case study, a quite complex system is highlighted, the Húsavı́k
Energy CHP system in Iceland (Hjartason et al. 2005).
54 Geothermal Energy 1037
4 Economic Analysis
As with other renewable energy technologies, geothermal projects have high up-
front costs (mainly due to the cost of drilling the wells) and low operational costs.
These operational costs vary from one project to another due to the size, the quality
1038 H. Saibi et al.
H1
75°C
128°C
Gas
10 l/s
H10
80°C
124°C 95 l/s 121°C 80°C
Industry
Gas separator
35°C
H16
Hot springs
210 l/s
115°C 80°C
30°C
19 l/s 16 l/s
100°C 60°C Control
house
100°C
190 l/s
9 l/s
75°C
3 l/s
30°C
75°C
Bathing lagoon
6 l/s
Green houses
35°C Fish farm Industry
Farms Farms 20 l/s
of the geothermal fluids, and so on but are predictable compared with power plants
that use traditional energy sources, which are usually subject to market fluctuations
in the fuel price.
4.1 Electricity
success rate of 70–90 %. Factors influencing the cost include well productivity
(permeability and temperature), well depth, rig availability, vertical or directional
design, the use of air or special circulation fluids, the use of special drilling bits,
the number of wells, and the financial conditions in a drilling contract.
– Surface facilities and infrastructure: This component includes gathering steam
and processing brine, separators, pumps, pipelines, and roads. Vapor-dominated
fields have lower facility costs because brine handling is not required. Factors
affecting this component are reservoir fluid chemistry, commodity prices (steel,
cement), topography, accessibility, slope stability, average well productivity
and distribution (pipeline diameter and length), and fluid parameters (pressure,
temperature, chemistry).
– Power plant: This component includes the turbines, generator, condenser, electric
substation, grid hookup, steam scrubbers, and pollution abatement systems.
The power plant design and construction costs depend upon the type (flash,
back-pressure, binary, dry steam, or hybrid) and the cooling cycle used (water
Table 54.2 Breakdown of current capital costs for typical turnkey geothermal-electric projects
(2005 US$)
Component
Exploration Drilling Surface
and (1.5–3 km facilities and
Typea Concept confirmation depth) infrastructure Power plant Total
1 US$/kWe 475 1,275 350 1,225 3,325
% capex 14 % 38 % 11 % 37 % 100 %
2 US$/kWe 30 1,275 350 1,225 2,880
% capex 1% 44 % 12 % 43 % 100 %
3 US$/kWe 25 1,008 300 1,175 2,508
% capex 1% 40 % 12 % 47 % 100 %
4 US$/kWe 24 800 274 1,782 2,880
% capex 1% 28 % 10 % 61 % 100 %
5 US$/kWe 205–560 750–1,500 205–750 1,215–2,240 2,025–3,750
% capex 10–15 % 20–40 % 10–20 % 40–60 % 100 %
6 US$/kWe 275–425 750–1,700 425–850 1,500–2,600 3,400–4,300
% capex 8–12 % 20–40 % 10–20 % 40–60 % 100 %
7 US$/kWe 530 3,350 1,350 4,720 9,950
% capex 5% 34 % 14 % 47 % 100 %
a
Type:
(1) Greenfield project, 40-MWe single-flash power plant, 200ı C, wells to 2 km depth
(2) Expansion project, 40-MWe single-flash power plant, 200ı C, wells to 2 km depth
(3) Expansion project, 4 25 MWe single-flash power plant (100 MWe), wells to 2.2 km depth
(4) Expansion project, 25-MWe single-flash power plant, wells at 1.8 km depth on average
(5) Greenfield project, 10–50 MWe condensing power plants
(6) Greenfield project, 10–20 MWe binary cycle power plants
(7) Greenfield project, 4 MWe binary cycle power plant, low temperature, wells to 2,750 m depth
1040 H. Saibi et al.
or air cooling). Other factors affecting power plant costs are fluid enthalpy
(resource temperature) and chemistry, location, cooling water availability, and
the economies of scale (a larger size is cheaper).
Table 54.2 presents the breakdown of current capital costs (capex) for typical
geothermal-electric projects in 2005 US$.
Labor and material costs are estimated to account for 40 % each of the total
project construction costs. Labor costs can increase by 10 % when a resource is
remotely located. In addition to raw materials and labor, the choice of power plant
size is a key factor in determining the ultimate cost of a plant. For example, using
a single 50-MWe plant instead of multiple 10-MWe plants can decrease the power
plant costs per kilowatt by approximately 30–35 % for binary systems. The installed
cost per kilowatt for a 100-MWe flash steam plant can be 15–20 % less than that of
a 50-MWe plant.
Direct-use project costs have a wide range, depending upon the specific use, the
temperature and flow rate required, the associated O & M and labor costs, and the
income from the product. In addition, the costs for new construction are usually less
than those for retrofitting older structures. The cost figures given below in Fig. 54.16
are based on a temperature climate typical of the northern half of the United States or
Europe, and the heating loads would obviously be higher for more northern climates,
such as Iceland, Scandinavia, and Russia. Most figures are based on the cost in the
United States (expressed in 2005 US$) but would be similar in developed countries
and lower in developing countries.
5 Summary
Geothermal heat is an energy source that – if properly managed – has the potential to
be abundant, versatile, environmentally acceptable, cost-effective, and sustainable
Its sustainability is mainly a result of the vast amount of heat stored in the
subsurface. Extracting this heat, however, is challenging and requires advances in
exploration and drilling technology, novel approaches to stimulate reservoirs, and
potentially new working fluids. Moreover, exploitation of thermal energy must be
optimized and carefully managed, which in turn requires good characterization
methods of the geologic formation and fluid movements within the reservoir.
In addition to high-temperature hydrothermal or engineered geothermal systems
(EGS) for electricity production, residual heat from deep geothermal fluids or low-
temperature resources at shallow depths can be used for a vast variety of applications
and joint uses on different temperature levels for a high overall degree of efficiency.
Finally, reinjection of geothermal fluids closes the loop, providing pressure support
and the working fluid for a sustainable energy production system.
The use of computer modeling in the planning and management of the develop-
ment of geothermal fields has become standard practice during the last 20–35 years.
Geothermal reservoir simulation was recently used in reservoir engineering practice
with more complex three-dimensional models with a graphical interface. Reservoir
evaluation is an important phase prior to installing a geothermal power plant.
Geophysics is an important study phase of the perspective geothermal field. Main
methods include the following:
– Microgravity method: It is an effective geophysical technique that helps monitor
the geothermal reservoirs by measuring the underground mass changes using the
Gauss theorem in the geothermal reservoirs due to the production and injection
phases and natural recharge or discharge. Repeated microgravity measurements
at geothermal fields are recommended to maintain and advance the sustainable
utilization of geothermal resources.
– Electromagnetic method: Monitoring surveys can give information about fluid re-
distributions, flow rates, and flow directions caused by production and reinjection
in the geothermal reservoir from the changes of underground electrical resistivity
and spontaneous potential at the surface. The shallow survey is preferably
performed using transient electro magnetic soundings. Deep survey is made by
Magneto-Tellurics and can also be applied to delineate faults.
– Microseismic method for the evaluation of the heat source, fluid-flow channels’
permeability, and reservoir properties. Combining geothermal reservoir simula-
tors with geophysical postprocessors will enhance the numerical modeling of the
geothermal reservoirs and help managers to make good decisions about the future
plan of the geothermal power plant.
1042 H. Saibi et al.
Geothermal projects have high up-front costs (mainly due to the cost of drilling
the wells) and low operational costs. The geothermal plants have low recurring fuel
costs. The costs of heat from direct uses of geothermal heat are competitive with
market energy prices.
More international courses on geothermal energy need to be developed and also
need to increase the number of engineers all over the world by developing university
undergraduate programs in the geothermal field to teach younger generations to take
responsibility when using this natural and sustainable energy for the safety of the
human race.
6 Cross-References
Geothermal Energy
References
R.G. Allis, T.M. Hunt, Analysis of exploitation-induced gravity changes at Wairakei geothermal
field. Geophysics 51, 1647–1660 (1986)
R. Bertani, Geothermal power generation in the world 2005–2010 update report. Geothermics 41,
1–29 (2012)
GEO-Geothermal Education Office, Geothermal energy introduction (2001), http://geothermal.
marin.org/index.html
GEA, Global Energy Assessment – Toward a Sustainable Future. (International Institute for
Applied Systems Analysis, Vienna, Austria and Cambridge University Press, Cambridge and
New York, 2012), p. 1888
B. Goldstein, G. Hiriart, R. Bertani, C. Bromley, L. Gutierrez-Negrin, E. Huenges, H. Muraoka,
A. Ragnarsson, J. Tester, V. Zui, Contribution to special report renewable energy sources
(SRREN), International panel on climate change (IPPC) (2012)
H. Hjartason, R. Maack, S. Jóhannesson, GHC Bull. 26, 7–13 (2005)
International Energy Outlook, U.S. Energy Information Administration, 292 (2011)
J.W. Lund, D.H. Freeston, T.L. Boyd, Direct utilization of geothermal energy 2010 worldwide
review. Geothermics 40(3), 159–240 (2010)
M.J. O’Sullivan, K. Pruess, M.J. Lippmann, State of the art of geothermal reservoir simulation.
Geothermics 30, 395–429 (2001)
F. Pirajno, Hydrothermal Mineral Deposits (Springer, Berlin, 1992), p. 709
K. Pruess, C. Oldenburg, G. Moridis, TOUGH2 user’s guide, version 2.0, report LBNL-43134,
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA (1999)
H. Saibi, J. Nishijima, S. Ehara, Reservoir monitoring by repeat microgravity measurement at
Obama geothermal field, southwestern Japan. Geothermal and volcanological research report
of Kyushu University, 1, No. 14, 27–31 (2005)
Renewability of Energy Resources,
Energy Vectors, and Energy Technologies 55
for Mobility
Abstract
By understanding and using the concepts of an “open cycle” and a “closed
cycle” of resources, the sustainability of an energy system can be assessed.
Key to setting up sustainable energy systems is the use of renewable energy
resources with the integration of energy vectors in the flow chain. Three
important energy vectors – hydrogen, electricity, and heat-exchanging materials –
can be integrated in an energy system through sustainable energy engineering,
resulting in a zero-emission conversion technology in the final use. The dual
condition of “zero consumption, zero emission” is necessary for sustainability.
From this perspective, the difference between consumption and emissions of an
electric/electrified vehicle versus a gasoline vehicle of the same segment, along
with an economic analysis, is shown in a case study.
F. Orecchini ()
Interuniversity Research Centre for Sustainable Development, University of Rome La Sapienza,
Department of Mechanics and Energy, Guglielmo Marconi University, Rome, Italy
e-mail: fabio.orecchini@uniroma1.it
A. D’Orazio
SEM – Energy and Mobility Systems (GEA – Energy & Environment Group), CIRPS –
Interuniversity Research Centre for Sustainable Development, Sapienza University, Rome, Italy
e-mail: annalisa.dorazio@uniroma1.it
V. Valitutti
SEM – Energy and Mobility Systems, CIRPS – Interuniversity Research Centre for Sustainable
Development, Sapienza University, Rome, Italy
e-mail: valeria.valitutti@uniroma1.it
C. Fiori
SEM – Energy and Mobility Systems (GRA – Automotive Research Group), CIRPS –
Interuniversity Research Centre for Sustainable Development, Sapienza University, Rome, Italy
e-mail: chiara.fiori@uniroma1.it
1 Introduction
This means that the sustainability level of a system can be measured by measuring
its capacity to avoid the consumption of resources. Zero consumption is a necessary
condition for sustainability, and it brings about as a side effect the highly desired
“zero-waste” result. The solution of moving toward a new, sustainable energy
paradigm is the realization of closed cycles of resources, which can be achieved
in the energy sector by exploiting renewable resources and structurally integrating
energy vectors. The inclusion of energy vectors (to be produced from several
primary resources) in the energy system chain becomes a key concept of the entire
human development model (Orecchini et al. 2011).
The energy system must be able to extract energy from the initial resource,
make it flow in the appropriate form, and deliver it with the needed characteristics
for its final use that allows the supply of the desired useful effect. In its most
complete representation, an energy system is constituted by the set of primary
energy resources, processes, and technologies for conversion, transport, storage, and
final uses of energy, waste production, and interactions with the environment in all
the phases. The primary resource is generally located at a different place than the site
of the energy demand, thus the need for energy transportation. The requirement for
continuous and instant satisfaction of energy demand necessitates energy storage.
To achieve the availability of a primary resource everywhere, an energy vector
that allows the transfer, in space and in time, of a quantity of energy is necessary.
Thus, energy vectors make energy available for use at a time and space distant
55 Renewability of Energy Resources 1045
from the resource, meaning the point of availability of the primary resource in
nature (see schematic in Fig. 55.1). Energy vectors include fossil fuels, oil, and
derivatives; natural gas and derivates; coal and derivates; electricity, hydrogen
and other synthetic fuels; heat-exchanging fluids; mechanical transmissions; oil-
dynamic transmissions; pressure-dynamic transmissions; and radiation. All of these
are considered energy vectors in the transportation and storage of energy. Different
forms of energy can be stored and transported, and different vectors allow a variety
of modes and have different limits (in terms of problems related to portability and
storage time) (Orecchini and Santiangeli 2011) (Table 55.1).
The realization of closed cycles of resources can be achieved in energy systems
by exploiting renewable resources and structurally integrating energy vectors. In
this case, a given amount of available primary energy can even be said to be
“used,” whereas a nonrenewable resource would be “consumed.” Furthermore, the
energy amount “paid” to produce the eventually needed energy vector is amply
compensated by the renewability of the resource and its endlessness of availability
for humankind.
1046 F. Orecchini et al.
In the light of what has been said about the importance of energy vectors for
realizing a “closed cycle of resource,” some example of useful vectors will be
described for integration with renewable energy sources, especially for the storage
of chemical energy, electrical energy, and thermal energy (Orecchini 2007).
A case study will be dedicated to a comparison between the consumption
and emissions of an electric vehicle and a gasoline-powered vehicle of the same
segment, from the perspective of zero consumption and emissions. An economic
analysis of the case study highlights the economic benefits of an electric vehicle
with respect to cost, despite the fact that the initial price of a gasoline-powered
vehicle is lower. Three different scenarios will be described and compared.
2.1 Hydrogen
Hydrogen is the most abundant element in the universe (around 75% of the total
baryonic mass) and shows a high capability of storage of chemical energy per
unit mass, around 142 MJ kg1 , more than three times that of liquid hydrocarbons
(around 47 MJ kg1 ). This theoretical capability cannot be exploited fully, however;
in fact, hydrogen at normal conditions is a rarefied gas tending to migrate to the
upper atmosphere. At room temperature and atmospheric pressure, 1 kg of hydrogen
would occupy 11 m3 . The most common storage system thus far has been in gaseous
phase, but the low density limits have driven research efforts toward different
systems for storage in liquid and solid phases. For the present work, if not explicitly
specified, please refer to Broom (2011), Orecchini and Naso (2011), Orimo et al.
(2007) and Züttel (2004). The main characteristics of hydrogen storage systems are
the following:
• Storage capacity: the percentage of the hydrogen mass in respect to the total mass
of the storage and vector system;
• Volumic energy density: amount of energy per volume unit of the storage system;
• Energy density in mass: amount of energy per mass unit of the storage system,
including the vector.
Containment by steel cylinders under high pressure is the current technology for
hydrogen storage in the gaseous phase. Standard cylinders for the most common
applications are charged at 20 MPa (200 bar). Such cylinders weigh about 55 kg and
have a capacity of about 50 L. The hydrogen content is around 10 m3 , corresponding
to a net weight of 0.731 kg, equivalent to a content of energy around 126 MJ. To
understand how much energy is stored by this solution, it can be compared to the
amount of energy stored by a standard 30 L petrol tank for a small car. This kind
of tank, with a gross weight of about 30 kg, can store a content of energy around
576 MJ.
Better performance can be achieved with an increase of the pressure, but higher
pressure requires greater strength for the cylinder wall, and, if volumetric density
grows with the increase of compression capacity, the gravimetric density decreases
with the increase of the weight of the cylinders. Simply increasing the thickness of
containers is not the solution; innovative containers are multi-layer cylinders.
The typical structure of innovative cylinders consists of an inner layer (the liner)
made of polymeric materials, a second layer, for containment, made of carbon
fibers, and a third layer made of aromatic polyamides (e.g., the so-called “aramid”
characterized by a tensile strength close to 3,500 MPa versus the approximately
700 MPa of a steel alloy). Such a device can weigh around 110 kg, with a volumetric
density for hydrogen of about 35 kg m3 and a gravimetric density of about 6%
of the total mass. The energy cost of compression must be taken into account.
1048 F. Orecchini et al.
Table 55.2 Energy density of some gaseous, liquid, and solid storage systems
Energy density in Energy density in
Hydrogen storage system volume (MJ/m3 ) mass (kJ/kg)
200 bar cylinder1 1,419 1,884
700 bar cylinder2 4,200 7,200
Liquid hydrogen1 5,900 8,868
Metal hydride tank (commercial)1 312 1,218
Complex hydride tank (experimental)2 4,320 2,520
1
(Orecchini 2011)
2
http://www.storhy.net/finalevent/workshop1.php
With an isothermal process, between 0.1 and 80 MPa is needed around 7.96 MJ/kgH2
and more is required under real conditions. Table 55.2 presents the volumetric and
gravimetric energy density for gaseous storage systems, compared with liquid and
solid systems.
Storage in liquid phase requires ambient pressure, but low temperature, that is,
around 21.2 K. The volumetric density of hydrogen at liquid phase is 70.8 kg/m3 ,
noticeably higher than the gaseous state and also slightly higher than the hydrogen
density at solid state, 70.6 kg/m3 . The difficulties with this method of storage are
related to different aspects.
Low temperature is not easy to maintain in everyday applications. High energy is
required for the liquefaction process, along with thermal insulation of containers to
decrease boiling loss of the liquid and the energy lost in the atomic spin orientation
of the hydrogen. In fact, the configuration of anti-parallel spins (para-hydrogen) is
the ground state of the hydrogen molecules (ligant state) at 0 K. At temperatures
other than zero, the coexistence of molecules in para-hydrogen state with molecules
in ortho-hydrogen state can be observed, with the electrons arranged with parallel
spins. These two configurations of spin have different energies, which leads to
different physical properties, in particular, the boiling point and melting of the
ortho-hydrogen is higher than the other of roughly 0.1 K. At different temperatures,
the percentage of coexistence changes: from 25% of para-hydrogen and 75% of
ortho-hydrogen at room temperature up to 0.2% of ortho-hydrogen at 21.2 K. The
heat of ortho-para conversion depends on the temperature. At ambient conditions
it is around 270 kJ kg1 , but it increases with decrease of temperature up to
519 kJ kg1 at 77 K. Below this temperature, it remains approximately constant
at around 523 kJ kg1 . These values are unfortunately higher than the latent heat
of evaporation at the normal boiling point, and if hydrogen is placed in a container
without being spin oriented, the heat of conversion from the ortho state to the para
state is sufficient for the evaporation of the liquid. The process of transformation
55 Renewability of Energy Resources 1049
from ortho into para makes the liquefaction process energetically more costly (e.g.,
the Linde process or the magnetic process).
Another point to take into account is that the ratio between the amount of
evaporated hydrogen and that remaining at liquid phase also depends on the
geometrical shape of the container. In fact, as evaporation is a surface process,
the container must have the maximum volume and the minimum surface. Such a
condition is realized by a spherical container; in a spherical Dewar with a double
layer of insulating vacuum, the losses are of the order of 0.4% per day on a volume
of 50 m3 , 0.2% on a volume of 100 m3 , and 0.06% on a volume of 20,000 m3 . For
practical reasons, however, the use of cylindrical containers is often preferred over
spherical ones. In any case, these numbers make liquid hydrogen suitable where
usage times are low and cost is less important, such as in aeronautical and space
applications or for scientific purposes.
Solid state storage is currently the main candidate to match the 2,020 goal fixed by
the DoE (U.S. Department of Energy) for the development of new and hydrogen-
based energy systems (see Table 55.3).
One possible method of storing hydrogen in solid state is to trap the hydrogen
molecules or hydrogen atoms inside different types of supports. The physical
process involved can be surface adsorption (physisorption) based on the van der
Waals interaction, bulk absorption by the diffusion process, or chemical bounding
by chemical transformations.
Nano-composite Porous Materials: These compounds are able to trap hydrogen
by absorption at the material’s surface. The physical interaction involved in
physisorption is quite weak and the process is favored by low temperature (low
kinetic energy of absorbed molecules).
• Activated carbon has a high specific surface between 500 and 1,400 m2 /g and is
able to achieve up to 5.5 weight % of hydrogen. To achieve the best performance,
a very low temperature (77 K) is required, too low for practical applications.
• Carbon nanotubes can be divided in single-walled nanotubes (SWNT) similar
to a graphite cylinder and multi-walled nanotubes (MWNT) made of different
concentric wall-bounded SWNT. These structures have a theoretical Young
module close to 4 TPa and a tensile strength around 100 times greater than steel,
features useful for building a capillary structure able to adsorb gas. But these
materials also suffer a too low operating temperature (as before, the best results
are around 77 K) and a weight percentage no higher than 4% or 5%.
• Zeolites are material based on AlO4 and SiO4 tetrahedra, and the term is extended
to similar structures based on different elements as, for example, P, Ga, Be, Ge,
all showing an ordered crystalline structure with uniform cavities and channels,
that are highly porous, and have high specific surface and high thermal stability.
Zeolites are also useful for adsorption studies, with maximum storage capability
around 2.6–2.8 weight % and low temperature requirements.
• Metal organic frameworks are a family of crystalline inorganic-organic hybrid
solids made by metal ions or clusters linked by organic bridges. These materials
show good cycling resistance but also less thermal stability compared with
zeolites. The higher storage capability has been estimated around 7% weight at
77 K.
Interstitial Hydrides: These compounds are able to trap hydrogen in the lattice
interstitial space. The molecular hydrogen dissociates at the surface of the hydrides
and the atomic hydrogen enters the bulk via the diffusion process. Typical com-
pounds are made of two metallic elements, usually indicated by A and B, that
arrange with hydrogen in the general formula Am Bn Hl .
• AB5 compounds generally show good cycling resistance, good impurity contam-
ination resistance, and high volumetric storage density. The most studied AB5
compound is LaNi5 , which converts to LANi5 H6 . The reversible hydrogenation
process offers a low gravimetric density, around 1.25 weight %, but a volumetric
density around 0.1 kg/l. For these compounds, the DoE targets for 2,020 have
not yet been achieved, but due to their positive features of volumetric density,
stability, cycling, and the possibility of use with fuel cells, they have been an
effective reversible storage material employed for practical uses. More than 470
compounds are entered in the hydride database of Sandia Laboratories.
• AB2 compounds are usually formed by the element A from group 4 or lanthanides
and the element B by transition or non-transition metals, as, for example, ZrMn2 .
More than 620 AB2 compounds are known and the main properties of interest for
practical application are reversibility of the hydrogenation process, fast kinetics,
and good long-term cycling. Gravimetric density is low, however, no higher than
1.8%, and the cost of the materials is quite high, so they are not practical for
widespread use.
• AB compounds are less common than AB5 and AB2 ; less than 180 compounds
are currently entered in the Sandia database. The activation energy is quite high
and resistance to impurities is lower than in AB5 compounds. The representative
compound for this group is TiFe, with a total gravimetric capability of 1.85%
and a reversible capability around 1.5%. Partial substitution of Fe showed
improvement in cycling resistance and stability.
• Binary hydrides are the simplest case with the formula MHn , where M is a metal
directly bound to the hydrogen atoms. A typical binary hydride is AlH3 , known
since the 1940. The absorption capability of these compounds is generally quite
55 Renewability of Energy Resources 1051
favorable (around 10.1% weight in the case of AlH3 ) and the de-hydrogenation
process is usually at temperature not critical. One troublesome feature is the
absorption process, which requires too high pressure for practical application
(on the order of GPa).
Complex Hydrides: Complex hydrides are usually salt compounds where many
hydrogen atoms show a covalent bound with a different element, in such a
way that the hydrogen and the other element form a complex anionic group.
This anionic group establishes an ionic or covalent bound with a third element.
They are interesting because of their high gravimetric density, however, the high
energy barrier for carrying on the hydrogenation/dehydrogenation processes is a
negative feature. Doping the compound has shown good results for improving the
hydrogenation/dehydrogenation kinetics.
• Alanates are hydrides composed of the complex group [AlH4 ] , as LiAlH4 ,
NaAlH4 , Mg(AlH4 /2 , Ca(AlH4 /2 . Dehydrogenation occurs between 200ıC and
300ı C, but a critical point is that for many compounds it is not reversible. In
some cases as for NaAlH4 , the process is reversible, but the pressure of hydrogen
release is too low for practical application. Some improvement is reported for
example through doping with titanium.
• Amides are hydrides composed of the complex group [NH2 ] and alkali metals,
frequently from the first and second groups of the periodic table. The gravimetric
density of hydrogen is generally smaller than other complex hydrides, and
frequent double-step desorption reactions involving intermediate compounds
make the release of the total stored hydrogen inconvenient. The operating
conditions for temperature, pressure, and kinetics are usually more favorable than
for other hydrides.
• Borohydrides are hydrides composed of the complex group [BH4 ] and an
element of the first or second group of the periodic table, or rare earth elements
or transition metals. They show the highest gravimetric density in between the
hydride family, but a limitation is their high reactivity.
2.5 Electricity
Storage of electricity can be carried out directly or indirectly. Indirect ways use
the electrical power to perform work in a system in order to make it able to
generate new work (change in the potential energy of the system). An example
is hydro-pumping for hydro-electrical plants in order to exploit the peak power
availability that cannot go directly to the grid, or transformatio to mechanical energy
by the charge of a flywheel. In this section, only direct electricity storage will be
considered, performed by accumulators able to provide back, on demand, electrical
energy.
Batteries: Electricity has historically been stored by batteries, where the electronic
current is generated by the chemical energy of electrolytes. Conventional batteries
use a metallic electrode interacting with an ionic solution (electrolyte); two distinct
ionic solutions (oxidizing and reducing, respectively) are separated by a porous
1052 F. Orecchini et al.
media. The potential difference established between the respective electrodes is the
“electromotive power” of the battery, able to move the electron if the electrodes
are connected to an electrical circuit. Many different materials can be used for
both electrodes and electrolytes (not only liquid). Some examples of the most
common batteries are as follows (for more detail, please refer to Reddy 2010,
Chen et al. 2009, Scrosati and Garche 2010 and Jayalakshmi and Balasubramanian
2008):
• Lead acid batteries: Here, the anode is made of Pb, the cathode is made of PbO2 ,
and the electrolyte is sulfuric acid (H2 SO4 ). The storage capability depends on
the size of the battery, and a number of sizes are available, from 1 Ah to more
than 100 Ah. The cell potential is the highest in the battery with liquid electrolyte,
equal to 2.2 V, with an electrical efficiency around 60%. Positive features are the
low cost of the materials, good performance for fast discharge, and effectiveness
at both high and low temperature. The limitations are limited cycling lifetime and
limited gravimetric energy density (around 30–40 Wh/kg).
• Nickel cadmium batteries: The anode in these batteries is Cd based, the cathode
is Ni based, and the electrolyte is an alkaline compound. The available sizes are
from 12.5 Ah to more than 100 Ah, and the cell potential is equal to 1.2 V. It is
possible to use these batteries at 20ı C to 45ı C and they are frequently used
for portable devices (laptops, radios). Positive features are long cycle life and
long-term storage, but they suffer a low energy density, cost more than lead-acid
batteries, and require special disposal as the cadmium residuals are hazardous.
• Nickel-metal hydride batteries: As with the previous, the anode in these accu-
mulators is Ni based, but the anode, adsorbing hydrogen, is an alloy that is
usually made of metals and rare earth material. NiMH batteries have a higher
capacity than NiCd batteries. Their advantages are, having no cadmium, minimal
environmental problems, a rapid recharge capability, and long cycle life. The
nominal voltage is 1.2 V up to 1.0 V in discharge (1.3 V is the maximum at
maximum charge and open circuit); partial discharge can produce a memory
effect, decreasing the capability.
• Nickel zinc: These are a variant of nickel batteries where the anode is made of
zinc. This battery is characterized by a nominal voltage around 1.6 V (1.7 at open
circuit) and is usually employed for mechanical devices (motorized bicycles,
scooters, lawnmowers, etc.) due to a good specific energy (50–70 Wh/kg). The
lifecycle is more than 500 cycles at maximal density of discharge and more than
double that at smaller density of discharge.
• Lithium ion batteries: A wide variety of alloys are used for the cathode and the
anode of lithium ion batteries. The name of such accumulators is due to the
fact that, while lithium is not present in the metallic state, it is exchanged in
between anode and cathode in the ionic state. Usually, the accumulators present
an intercalation of many electrodes and the current is generated by the removal-
insertion of Li ions in between the anode and cathode, across the electrolyte,
which can be either liquid or solid material. The voltage is higher than the
batteries listed above and can reach 4 V, with a specific energy between 100
and 150 Wh/kg1 and temperature operation range between 30ı C and 60ı C.
55 Renewability of Energy Resources 1053
Due to their high energy content, Li-ion batteries have been used most recently
for electronic devices (laptop, mobile phones, etc.) (Table 55.4).
• Sodium sulfur: A sodium-sulfur accumulator has liquid sulfur melt on the cathode
and liquid sodium melt at the anode. In the middle the electrolyte is a ceramic
solid (“ alumina based). The nominal voltage is around 2 V and it works at high
temperature (around 300ı C), with a specific density around 130 Wh/kg.
Super-capacitors: Along with batteries, another device capable of accumulating
electrical power is a capacitor. Traditional capacitors are constituted by two parallel
metallic electrodes, separated by an insulating material (dielectric) able to accu-
mulate charge (depending on the electrode surface area and dielectric thickness).
The storage capability of traditional capacitors is limited to the range of 0.1–1 F
(micro-farads) and they are usually employed for signal filtering and to smooth the
circuits of power supplies, but nowadays new generations of super-capacitors, able
to store a higher amount of energy, are employed to supply power during the peak
of demand in association with the batteries. Examples include their use in hybrid-
electric cars and in industrial application such as transpallets, forklifts, cranes, etc.
The technology is not yet mature, and improvements can be made to battery lifetime,
rated voltage, range of operating temperature, and energy density. Nevertheless,
super-capacitors play a key role in the development of electricity-based mobility
systems. Following are some examples of super-capacitors.
• Electrolytic capacitor: The difference between these and traditional super-
capacitors is the presence of an electrolyte as the conductor between the
dielectric and the electrode. Electrolytic super-capacitors with electrodes made
from aluminum and tantalum are available and the electrolyte can be either solid
1054 F. Orecchini et al.
Storage of heat cannot be maintained for a long time or over long distances.
Important features of the system can be summarized as follows:
• Good storage capability, which means high energy density of storage medium
• Good efficiency, which means heat transfer between heat transfer fluid (HTF)
and storage medium
• Good cyclability, which means mechanical and chemical stability of storage
material
• Safety, which means compatibility between HTF, heat exchanger, and/or storage
• Lifetime, which means complete reversibility of a good number of charg-
ing/discharging cycles
In general, the storage systems can be divided into three categories: the sensible heat
system, the latent heat system and the chemical storage systems. For more details,
please refer to Gil et al. (2010), Medrano et al. (2010), Hasnain (1998), and Pinel
et al. (2011).
Sensible heat storage systems: Sensible heat storage systems are characterized
by an increase of the temperature of the storing medium, which depends on the
stored energy. For this reason, the medium should have a high specific heat capacity,
together with long-term stability under thermal cycling. Depending on the medium
phase, sensible heat storage systems can be divided into liquid media systems and
solid media systems. Typical liquids are water, oil-based fluids, and molten salts
and the temperature range can go from 25ı C to 90ı C for water-based fluids and
up to 300ı C for oil-based fluids and molten salts. Storage capability depends on
the tank size (large-scale storage applications can reach the order of millions of
cubic meters). Typical solids include rocks (by packed bed systems), in which
the temperature can reach up to 1,000ıC; ceramic brick (e.g., olivine, magnesite,
feolite), which is mainly employed in building heat management; and metals (e.g.,
aluminum, magnesium, zinc), for temperatures between 120ı C and 1,400ıC.
55 Renewability of Energy Resources 1055
Latent heat storage systems: Latent heat storage systems are characterized by the
constant temperature of the storing medium, which undergoes to a phase transition.
The temperature depends on the phase transition temperature of the material.
The systems can exploit solid–solid, liquid–gas and solid–liquid transitions. The
most common are the solid–liquid systems for practical reason of a modest
volume change. A large number of different materials are employed for latent heat
application, the major categories being inorganic compounds (e.g., salt hydrates,
metals, alloys), organic compounds (e.g., paraffins, polyalcohols), and eutectic or
inorganic-organic compounds (a mixture of two or more compounds having definite
melting-freezing points). This kind of system has the advantage of allowing the
storage of a large quantity of energy in a relatively small volume, with a positive
impact on the costs.
Chemical heat storage systems: Chemical heat storage systems, based on chemical
reactions, employ material that undergoes a complete reversible reaction. The
typical application is for storing solar energy; solar radiation excites an endothermic
reversible reaction and the products of the reaction are available to give back the
stored energy. The advantage of this kind of application is a high energy density and
the possibility of longterm storage of the energy. For this reason there is interest in
coupling this system with continuous (24-h) power-generating systems. Materials
that can be used for this kind of application are, for example, those able to perform
the tranformation metal oxide–metal. For example,
Ammonia is also of interest due to its low cost and long experience with large-
scale industrial production. Heat storage involves the dissociation of the ammonia
in nitrogen and hydrogen:
The chemical storage systems can reach a high operating temperature; for example,
the temperature of dissociation of SnO2 takes place at around 700ı C.
In fact, compared with internal combustion engine vehicles, vehicles with a high
degree of electrification consume lower quantities of energy and emit a lower
amount of carbon dioxide (http://web.mit.edu/evt/summary wtw.pdf) these latter
are, in fact, more efficient and sustainable than other conventional solutions. In
addition, the energy used could be provided by renewable sources.
The advantages of vehicles with a high degree of electrification can be summa-
rized as follows:
• Reduction or absence of emissions at the local level;
• Increased efficiency in the transmission of energy;
• Reduction of vibrations during operation;
• Much longer life expectancy;
• Recovery of braking energy.
Most automotive brands have developed a hybrid or electric vehicles, which helps
to address the crisis caused by the increasing cost of oil.
The role of these vehicles in transportation in cities is fundamental to achieving
the increasing constraints related to emissions of pollutants. Analyses focused on
this sector have highlighted how consumption and emissions of electric vehicles
are smaller than those of a gasoline vehicle of the same segment. Also, among the
advantages of vehicles with a high degree of electrification is the greater energy
efficiency obtained by energy recovery during braking (Brusaglino et al. 2009; Chau
and Wong 2002).
The aim of this case study is to perform a well-to-wheel analysis of two different
kinds of power train: electric vehicle and ICE (internal combustion engine) vehicle.
The well-to-wheel analysis takes into account the complete energy cycle, starting
from the energy source up to the useful effects and includes the well-to-tank
analysis (from the source up to the car) and the tank-to-wheel analysis (from the
energy stored on board up to the useful effects). The variables considered for
comparison are as follows: consumption, efficiency, and CO2 emissions. To carry
out the comparison, the ICE gasoline vehicle and the electric vehicle analyzed have
approximately the same power. Taking into account the typical power segment of
the electric vehicles, the power of the vehicles is similar to a City Car.
The characteristics of the gasoline vehicle are presented in Table 55.5 and the
characteristics of the electric vehicle, with a lithium-ion battery and an electric
permanent magnet synchronous motor are listed in Table 55.6.
Table 55.7 provides the efficiency of an electric vehicle and that of a gasoline
vehicle.
The efficiency of an electric vehicle is greater than the gasoline vehicle because
the power-train components are electrical/electronic, and these components have a
higher single efficiency (about 90%). Also, there is no mechanical transmission,
which is the main source of the loss of efficiency in gasoline vehicles.
55 Renewability of Energy Resources 1057
In an electric vehicle, the tank-to-wheel analysis shows that CO2 emissions are zero,
whereas in the well-to-tank analysis there is a certain amount of CO2 emitted.
The capacity of the battery of the electric vehicle considered is equal to
17.6 kWh, whereas the charging and discharging of the same occurs for a value
of the SOC (state of charge), between approximately 20% and 80%. It is necessary
to consider that the energy to be loaded is equal to about 10.56 kWh consumed
(Orecchini et al. 2012). Considering the efficiency of the charging system, distribu-
tion losses (MISE 2009), the percentage of energy produced from RES (renewable
energy sources,) GSE (2010) and the average efficiency of Italian thermal power
plants (Manna 2009), the total kWh consumed in the well-to-tank analysis will
be approximately 19.52 kWh. Furthermore, with zero local emissions, as is clear
from the tank-to-wheel analysis, the total emissions at the global level will be the
same as those of well-to-tank. In relation to energy consumption, the calculated CO2
emissions expressed in g/km are equal to approximately 70 g/km, as can be seen in
Fig. 55.2.
A different result is obtained in the well-to-wheel analysis on the gasoline
vehicle. The tank-to-wheel analysis of this vehicle is characterized by an emission
of CO2 higher than the electric vehicle (approximately 97 g/km of CO2 ). The CO2
emissions in the well-to-tank analysis will be smaller than in the electric vehicle
because only the efficiency of extraction and refining of fuel and transportation and
distribution are taken into account. The results can be seen in Fig. 55.3.
In Fig. 55.4, a comparison of the results in the two cases is shown.
1058 F. Orecchini et al.
70
CO2 consumption [g/km]
60
50
40
30
20
10
−
CO2 emissions Well To CO2 emissions Tank To CO2 emissions Well To
Tank analysis [g/km] Wheel analysis [g/km] Wheel analysis [g/km]
100
CO2 consumption [g/km]
80
60
40
20
0
CO2 emissions Well To CO2 emissions Tank To CO2 emissions Well To
Tank analysis [g/km] Wheel analysis [g/km] Wheel analysis [g/km]
4 Economic Analysis
This economic analysis of the case study above is intended to highlight the economic
benefits of to the purchase of an electric vehicle versus that of a gasoline vehicle,
despite the cost of acquisition of the latter being lower.
55 Renewability of Energy Resources 1059
100
CO2 consumption [g/km]
80
60
40
20
−
CO2 emissions Well CO2 emissions Tank To CO2 emissions Well To
To Tank analysis [g/km] Wheel analysis [g/km] Wheel analysis [g/km]
Fig. 55.4 Comparison between CO2 emissions of an electric and a gasoline city car
The cost of buying an electric city car is approximately 19,000 e, whereas that
of the same class of vehicle with a gasoline engine is approximately 13,000 e (the
costs mentioned do not include VAT). The amortization, shown below, is calculated
considering that a liter of gasoline in Italy is about 1.928 e (average price of
gasoline on 3 September 2012 (http://www.prezzibenzina.it/), corresponding to a
cost of 0.23 e per kWh (http://www.qualetariffa.it/quanto-costa-un-kwh-con-enel-
energia/)) and that the Italian city cars, on average, yearly travel about 15,000 km,
(ACI, Association of Italian Auto-vehicles). Knowing the vehicle consumption, the
costs of gasoline, and kWh, it is been possible to calculate the total cost of fuel
required to travel 15,000 km.
Below are three repayment plans for three possible scenarios:
• Scenario 1: amortization schedule considering only the fuel savings due to the
use of electric vehicles instead of gasoline.
• Scenario 2: amortization schedule considering, in addition to fuel savings, the
incentive to have free stamp of the vehicle for the first 5 years after purchase.
• Scenario 3: amortization schedule considering, in addition to fuel savingsand free
stamp of the vehicle for 5 years, the incentive of an insurance premium reduced
by 50% for the entire life of the vehicle.
4.1 Scenario 1
With fuel savings only, the payback time for the higher expense of purchase of
electric vehicles is 6 years, as can be seen in Fig. 55.5. The payback time will be
1060 F. Orecchini et al.
−1000
−2000
−3000
−4000
−5000
−6000
Years
3000
2000
1000
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Euro
−1000
−2000
−3000
−4000
−5000
−6000
Years
Fig. 55.6 Fule savings and road tax free for 5 years
reduced by the increase in mileage per year, taking into account that the reference
value is 15,000 km per year.
4.2 Scenario 2
By saving fuel and being free from road tax for 5 years, the payback time for the
higher cost of purchase of electric vehicles is 5 years, as can be seen in Fig. 55.6.
The payback time will be reduced by the increase in mileage per year, taking into
account that the reference value is 15,000 km per year.
55 Renewability of Energy Resources 1061
Saving fuel, road tax free for five years and the reduction of the
insurance premium of 50%
10000
8000
6000
4000
Euro
2000
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
−2000
−4000
−6000
Years
Fig. 55.7 Fuel savings, road tax free for 5 years, and the reduction of the insurance pre-
mium of 50%
4.3 Scenario 3
By saving fuel and with road tax free for 5 years and by the reduction of the
insurance premium of 50%, the payback time for the higher cost of purchase of
electric vehicles is 4 years, as can be seen in Fig. 55.7. The payback time will be
reduced by the increase in mileage per year, taking into account that the reference
value is 15,000 km per year.
It is important to note that this result is lower than the average life of a car, which
in Italy was estimated to be 7.5 years by the ACI (http://www.aci.it/, http://www.
omniauto.it/magazine/7748/quanto-sono-vecchie-le-auto-degli-italiani), in which
case the investment is definitely favorable.
4.4 Comparison
By the comparison of the above three scenarios, the last is the most advantageous,
as shown in Table 55.8 and Fig. 55.8. Figure 55.8 shows the fuel savings alone in
red, the fuel savings and road tax free for 5 years in green, and in violet the fuel
savings and road tax free for 5 years and the reduction of the insurance premium
of 50%.
It is important to note that other incentives are possible. For example, a money
bonus with the purchase of the vehicle (5,000 e in Italy, an amount that can almost
cancel the price difference between the electric and the gasoline vehicle), free
parking, and access to the ZTL (Limited Traffic Zones) and to the bus lanes.
1062 F. Orecchini et al.
Economic analysis
10000
8000
6000
4000
Euro
2000
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
−2000
−4000
−6000
Years
5 Summary
In this chapter, the role of energy vectors in the framework of the closed cycle,
matching the sustainability criteria, has been discussed. The more suitable vectors
for the exploitation of the renewable energy sources have been described, in
particular with regard to the storage aspects. The hydrogen vector has been
discussed for the storage of chemical energy, batteries and super-capacitors for the
storage of the electricity, and thermo-vector materials for thermal storage for the
exploitation of sensible, latent, and chemical heat. A case study has been provided
to compare the performance of an electric vehicle and a gasoline vehicle of the same
55 Renewability of Energy Resources 1063
segment, with particular regard to the efficiency and the difference of consumption
and emissions. The economic analysis of the case study has been executed, stressing
the convenience of the adoption of electric vehicle from an economic point of view.
References
D.P. Broom (ed.), Hydrogen Storage Materials. Green Energy and Technology (Springer, London,
2011)
G. Brusaglino, G. Pede, E. Vitale, Sistemi di propulsione elettrica ed ibrida. Dalla sorgente a borda
all’attuazione meccanica (2009). ISBN:9788882862053
K.T. Chau, Y.S. Wong, Overview of power management in hybrid electric vehicles. Energ. Convers.
Manage. 43(15), 1953–1968 (2002). Elsevier, ISSN:0196-8904
H. Chen, T.N. Cong et al., Progress in electrical energy storage system: a critical review. Prog. Nat.
Sci. 19(3), 291–312 (2009)
A. Gil, M. Medrano et al., State of the art on high temperature thermal energy storage for power
generation. Part 1–concepts, materials and modellization. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 14(1),
31–55 (2010)
GSE, Fuel Mix Disclosure: Determinazione Del Mix Medio Energetico Nazionale Per Gli Anni
2008–2009. Energy Services Provider, (2010)
S. Hasnain, Review on sustainable thermal energy storage technologies, part I: heat storage
materials and techniques. Energy Convers. Manage. 39(11), 1127–1138 (1998)
M. Jayalakshmi, K. Balasubramanian, Simple capacitors to supercapacitors-an overview. Int. J.
Electrochem. Sci. 3(1), 196–191 (2008)
C. Manna, Rapporto energia e ambiente analisi e scenari (2009). ISBN:978-88-8286-233-6
M. Mapako, F. Farioli, R. Diaz-Chavez, Socioeconomic and environmental impacts and contri-
butions to sustainability, in Bioenergy for Sustainable Development and Economic Compet-
itiveness: The Role of Sugar Cane in Africa, ed. by F.X. Johnson, V. Seebaluck (Earthscan,
Routledge, 2012)
M. Medrano, A. Gil et al., State of the art on high-temperature thermal energy storage for power
generation. Part 2—case studies. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 14(1), 56–72 (2010)
MISE-Ministero per lo Sviluppo Economico-Department of Energy, Bilancio energetico nazionale
(2009)
F. Orecchini, The era of energy vectors. Int. J. Hydrog. Energy 31, 1951–1954 (2006). ISBN:
1-56700-230-7
F. Orecchini, A “measurable” definition of sustainable development based on closed cycles of
resources and its application to energy systems. Sustain. Sci. 2, 245–252 (2007)
F. Orecchini, Energy sustainability pillars. Int. J. Hydrog. Energy 36, 7748–7749 (2011)
F. Orecchini, V. Naso, La società no oil. Un nuovo sviluppo è possibile ma senza petrolio, 2nd edn.
(2006). ISBN:9788888774381
F. Orecchini, V. Naso, Energy Systems in the Era of Energy Vectors: A Key to Define, Analyze
and Design Energy Systems Beyond Fossil Fuels (Springer, London, 2011). ISBN:978-085729-
243-8
F. Orecchini, A. Santiangeli, Beyond smart grids – the need of intelligent energy networks for
a higher global efficiency through energy vectors integration. Int. J. Hydrog. Energy 36,
8126–8133 (2011)
F. Orecchini, A. Santiangeli, V. Valitutti, Sustainability science: sustainable energy for mobility
and its use in policy making. Sustainability 3, 1855–1865 (2011). ISSN:2071–1050
F. Orecchini, A. Santiangeli, C.A. Fiori, Analisi energetica di un veicolo ibrido plug-in in un ciclo
reale urbano, 67ı Congresso Nazionale ATI – Associazione Termotecnica Italiana, 2012
S. Orimo, Y. Nakamori et al., Complex hydrides for hydrogen storage. Chem. Rev. Columb.
107(10), 4111–4132 (2007)
1064 F. Orecchini et al.
P. Pinel, C.A. Cruickshank et al., A review of available methods for seasonal storage of solar
thermal energy in residential applications. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 15(7), 3341–3359
(2011)
T.B. Reddy, Linden’s Handbook of Batteries (McGraw-Hill, New York, 2010)
S. Sala, F. Farioli, Zamagni (2012), Life cycle based methods: where are we in the context of
sustainability science progress? (Part I). Int. J. Life Cycle Assess
B. Scrosati, J. Garche, Lithium batteries: status, prospects and future. J. Power Sources 195(9),
2419–2430 (2010)
A. Wiek, F. Farioli, K. Fukushi, M. Yarime, Bridging the gap between science and society. Sustain.
Sci. J. 7(1), 1–4 (2012)
A. Züttel, Hydrogen storage methods. Naturwissenschaften 91(4), 157–172 (2004)
Solar Energy: Harvesting the Sun’s
Energy for Sustainable Future 56
C. S. Psomopoulos
Abstract
The solar energy that reaches the earth exceeds by far humankind’s needs and
other energy sources at ground level, such as geothermic or tidal energy, nuclear
power, and fossil fuels. Solar energy is a renewable and sustainable form of
energy. Solar irradiance includes infrared radiation and thus provides adequate
energy to operate solar thermal technologies requiring reduced solar energy.
Thus, many regions of the world have enough solar irradiance to utilize solar
heating and cooling technologies. Most of the developing and some of the devel-
oped countries lie within the tropical belt of the world where the solar radiation
is higher. Technologies requiring higher irradiation are suitable for these regions,
providing significant utilization potential for both solar heating/cooling applica-
tions and solar electricity through concentrating solar power and photovoltaics.
A significant part of these regions are also semi-arid or desert, allowing the
implementation of large-scale facilities, and thus potential utilization is highly
increased, since these areas are commonly vast, with small inclinations and high
temperatures and almost no seasonal changes in solar irradiation. These areas
have the potential to cover a significant part of their needs in heating, cooling, and
electricity. For electricity, production may be great enough to allow significant
exports also. This chapter presents the basic technologies for harvesting solar
energy and exploiting this almost unlimited potential for energy utilization.
The market available technologies are presented, explaining the basic opera-
tional characteristics providing the main and most common applications. Basic
economics, cumulative installed power, and market values are also presented.
The benefits of utilization are presented along with the physical and technical
barriers to market expansion. The chapter provides a review of the current
condition of commercially available solar energy harvesting technologies.
C.S. Psomopoulos
Department of Electrical Engineering, T.E.I. Piraeus, Egaleo, Greece
e-mail: cpsomop@teipir.gr; cpsomop@gmail.com
1 Introduction
The sun is the star in the center of our solar system. The sun’s rays keep our
planet warm and make life possible in this small corner of the universe. The solar
energy that reaches the earth has been estimated at around 173 1012 kW and
exceeds by far humankind’s needs. The world’s total primary energy demand
(TPED) was 12,300 million tons of oil equivalent (Mtoe) in 2008, including non-
commercial biomass, equivalent to a continuous power consumption of 13.75 TW
as was estimated by the IEA (2010a). Solar energy vastly exceeds other energy
sources at ground level, such as geothermic or tidal energy, nuclear power, and
fossil fuels. If the fact that sunrays also are responsible for wind power and biomass
growth is considered, then the potential for energy harvesting is more than obvious.
Solar energy is a renewable and sustainable form of energy because it will be
available as long as the sun continues to shine. Estimates for the life of the main
stage of the sun are another 4–5 billion years (Greenpeace 2008; IEA 2010a; Patel
1999; Philibert 2006; Sen 2008).
Sunlight hits the earth’s surface in two ways: directly and indirectly. The sun’s
light passes the atmosphere through numerous reflections and deviations. Direct
radiation is the amount of solar radiation received at any place on the earth directly
from the sun without any disturbances. Indirect solar radiation or diffuse insolation
is the sunlight that is reflected by other surfaces and molecules in the air to arrive
at the surface from all angles. On clear days, direct irradiance represents 80–90%
of the solar energy reaching the earth’s surface. On a cloudy or foggy day, the
direct component is essentially zero, whereas the indirect irradiance is almost 100%.
The sun’s total energy is composed of 7% ultraviolet (UV) radiation, 47% visible
radiation, and 46% infrared (heat) radiation. UV radiation causes many materials
to degrade, and it is significantly filtered out by the ozone layer in the upper
atmosphere, while visible and infrared radiation is used for energy production in the
earth’s surface by humans and the nature. Even though the amount of solar energy
reaching the earth is very high, the available amount varies with latitude, elevation,
shape of the surface, and season of the year in addition to time in a particular day.
Thus, the potential utilization varies not only with the weather conditions but also
with the geographical characteristics of each area (Greenpeace 2008; IEA 2010b;
Patel 1999; Philibert 2006).
Solar irradiance includes infrared radiation and thus provides adequate energy to
operate solar thermal technologies requiring reduced solar energy. This way, many
regions of the world have enough solar irradiance to utilize solar heating and cooling
technologies. The most typical example are the flat-plate, unglazed, collector-based
systems, including most solar water heating systems, which can use both direct and
diffuse solar radiation, so even under cloudy conditions there is some resource
available for conversion into heat. The amount of solar radiation at the earth’s
surface that is theoretically available is illustrated by averaged irradiance maps such
as the one shown in Fig. 56.1. These maps identify regions of solar irradiance at the
earth’s surface and indicate good or less suitable potential locations for each solar
technology (IEA 2003, 2009; IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC 2011; Philibert 2006).
56 Solar Energy: Harvesting the Sun’s Energy for Sustainable Future 1067
A close look at these maps will show that most of the developing and some of the
developed countries lie within the tropical belt of the world where the solar radiation
is higher. The United States, Southern European countries, and the Mediterranean
area are some typical examples. Thus, these countries have the potential to exploit
this source in the most beneficial ways. On the other hand, about 75% of the world’s
population lives between latitudes 35ı N and 35ı S, an area also known as the world’s
“Sun Belt.” These regions receive the sun’s radiation for almost 3,000–4,000 h/year.
In solar power density terms, this is equivalent to an average 2,000 kWh/m2 per year,
corresponding to several thousand times the world’s energy demand: a resource that
currently presents limited exploitation. In the mid-long term, these technologies will
play an important role in these areas. On the other hand, significant changes are
introduced in the current energy systems to mitigate their negative impact on the
environment and the world’s climate. A large part of this enormous free energy
could be harvested through solar energy technologies, used in a sustainable way
(EPIA-Greenpeace 2011; ESTELA 2012a; Greenpeace 2008; IEA 2010a, 2011;
IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC 2011; Philibert 2006).
Technologies requiring higher irradiation are suitable for these regions, providing
significant utilization potential for both solar heating/cooling applications and solar
electricity through concentrating solar power and photovoltaics. A significant part
of these regions are also semi-arid or desert, allowing the implementation of large-
scale facilities, and thus potential utilization is highly increased, since these areas
are commonly vast, with limited vegetation growth, small inclinations, high tem-
peratures, and almost no seasonal changes in solar irradiation. These areas present
1068 C.S. Psomopoulos
the potential to cover a significant part of their needs in heating, cooling, and
electricity. Especially for electricity, the production can be high enough to also allow
for significant exports (ESTELA 2012a; EPIA-Greenpeace 2011; Greenpeace 2008;
IEA 2010a, 2011; IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC 2011).
The work presented here presents the basic technologies for harvesting solar en-
ergy and exploiting this almost unlimited potential for energy utilization. The market
available technologies are presented, explaining the basic operational characteristics
providing the main and most common applications. Basic economics, cumulative
installed power, and market values are also presented. The benefits of utilization
are presented along with the physical and technical barriers to market expansion.
The work is a review of the current condition of commercially available solar energy
harvesting technologies.
The basic concept of concentrating solar power is relatively simple, as CSP devices
concentrate energy from the sun’s rays to heat a receiver to high temperatures.
This heat is transformed first into mechanical energy (by turbines or other engines)
and then into electricity. CSP also holds potential for producing other energy carriers
(solar fuels). CSP is a proven technology. The basic parts that concentrated solar
power installations consist of are reflectors and receivers. The receivers transfer the
heated fluid to the steam generator. The rest of the power plant is similar to a typical
steam power plant where the steam drives a steam turbine that transforms the heat
into mechanical rotation and then to electricity through a generator. At present, there
are four main CSP technology families, which are usually categorized by the way
they focus the sun’s rays (linear or point) and the receiver’s movement capability
(mobile or fixed). Figure 56.2 presents these four market available technologies
(ESTELA 2012a; EU-SETIS 2012a, b; IEA/OECD 2012; IEA 2010b; IPCC 2011;
Patel 1999; Arvizu et al. 2011a).
Parabolic trough systems are the most commonly used CSP technology; these
are line focused, mobile receivers and consist of parallel rows of mirrors (reflectors)
curved in one dimension to focus the sun’s rays. Their size usually varies from
50 to 300 MW, and they have been a proven utility-scale technology in commercial
operation since 1984 (ESTELA 2012b; EU-SETIS 2012b; IEA 2010b; IPCC 2011).
The mirror arrays can be more than 100 m long, with the curved surface typically
5–6 m across. The parabolic reflectors concentrate the sun 70–100 times onto a heat-
collection element (HCE) placed along the reflector’s focal line where the absorber
tubes are installed (ESTELA 2012b; IEA 2010b; IPCC 2011). The absorber tubes,
manufactured from stainless steel pipes with a selective coating, serve as the heat
collectors. The coating is designed to allow the pipes to absorb high levels of solar
radiation while emitting very little infrared radiation. The pipes are insulated in
56 Solar Energy: Harvesting the Sun’s Energy for Sustainable Future 1069
a b
Reflector
Absorber Tube Curved Mirrors Curved Mirrors
Solar Field
Piping
c d
Central Receiver
Reflector
Receiver/Engine
Heliostats
Fig. 56.2 Schematic diagrams showing the underlying principles of four basic CSP configu-
rations: (a) parabolic trough, (b) linear Fresnel reflector, (c) central receiver/power tower, and
(d) dish systems (Arvizu et al. 2011a)
an evacuated glass envelope to minimize heat loss. The reflectors and the absorber
tubes follow the sun’s path as it crosses the sky in one axis (ESTELA 2012a, b;
EU-SETIS 2012a, b; IEA/OECD 2012; IEA 2010b; IPCC 2011).
The majority of parabolic trough plants currently in commercial operation use
synthetic oil to transfer the heat (the heat transfer fluid) from collector pipes
to heat exchangers. This synthetic oil circulating through the tubes is heated to
approximately 400ı C. In the heat exchangers, the water is preheated, evaporated,
and then superheated. The superheated steam runs a turbine, which drives a
generator to produce electricity. After being cooled and condensed, the water returns
to the heat exchangers. A plant’s operation after the heat exchangers is almost
the same as a conventional steam turbine power plant, independent of the energy
source (coal, nuclear, gas, biomass, etc.) (ESTELA 2012a, b; EU-SETIS 2012a, b;
IEA/OECD 2012; IEA 2010b; IPCC 2011; Patel 1999). However, most existing
plants rely on combustible fuel as a backup to ensure capacity, as they have little
1070 C.S. Psomopoulos
or no thermal storage. In Spain, for example, the SCP leader in EU, all CSP plants
derive 12–15% of their annual electricity generation from natural gas utilization.
Some newer plants in South Greece and Spain have significant thermal storage
capacities, allowing production of up to an additional 7.5 h of nominal power after
sunset. Molten salts are normally used as storage fluid in a hot-and-cold two-tank
concept (ESTELA 2012b; EU-SETIS 2012b; IEA 2010b).
Linear Fresnel reflectors (LFRs), which are line focus with fixed receivers, are
a more recent commercially available system approximating the trough systems.
The difference from parabolic troughs is the fixed absorber position above a field of
horizontally mounted flat mirror stripes, collectively or individually tracked to the
sun. The LFRs use long rows of flat or slightly curved mirrors to reflect the sun’s
rays onto a downward-facing linear, fixed receiver. A more recent design, known as
compact linear Fresnel reflectors (CLFRs), uses two parallel receivers for each row
of mirrors and thus needs less land than parabolic troughs to produce a given output.
The LFR systems have a simple design of flexibly bent mirrors and fixed receivers,
which require lower investment costs and facilitate direct steam generation (DSG),
thus eliminating the need for – and cost of – heat transfer fluids and heat exchangers.
Even though these advantages are notable, LFR plants are less efficient than troughs
in converting solar energy to electricity and it is more difficult to incorporate
storage capacity into their design. This is a significant disadvantage that affects the
technology selection in case thermal storage will be selected (ESTELA 2012a, c;
EU-SETIS 2012a, b; IEA/OECD 2012; IEA 2010b; IPCC 2011).
Another commercially available and proven technology is solar towers, also
known as central receiver systems (CRS). These systems are point focus with
fixed receiver and their size is usually between 10 and 50 MW. Solar towers use
hundreds or thousands of reflectors called heliostats, larger than 100 m2 in many
cases, to concentrate the sun’s rays on a central receiver placed atop a fixed tower.
Each mirror tracks the sun on two axes and reflects the light onto a fixed receiver
on top of a tower. The working fluid temperature depends on the type of fluid
that is used to collect the energy and is within the range of 500–600ıC, although
temperatures of more than 1,000ıC can be reached. The commercial tower plants
now in operation use either DSG in the receiver; or molten salts as both the heat
transfer fluid and storage medium. Point-focus collectors such as central receivers
are able to generate much higher temperatures than troughs and linear Fresnel
reflectors. Central receivers can generate temperatures of advanced steam turbines
and can be used to power gas turbine (Brayton) cycles. The concentrating power of
the tower concept presents higher efficiency than the parabolic trough and Fresnel
systems due to the very high temperatures achieved, and the cost of thermal storage
is reduced for the same reason. In addition, the concept presents flexibility as the
engineers can choose from a wide variety of heliostats, receivers, transfer fluids,
and power blocks. Some plants have several towers that feed one power block, as
in case of the Solucar Complex in Seville, Spain, where the first commercial power
station using this technology is located (IEA/OECD 2012; IEA 2010b; ESTELA
2012a, d; EU-SETIS 2012a, b; IPCC 2011; Patel 1999).
56 Solar Energy: Harvesting the Sun’s Energy for Sustainable Future 1071
Parabolic dishes are point focus with mobile receiver systems that concentrate
the sun’s rays at a focal point propped above the center of the dish using curved
paraboloid-shaped glass mirrors. The entire apparatus tracks the sun, with the dish
and receiver moving in tandem. The parabolic dish tracks the sun throughout the
day and concentrates the radiation onto the heat absorption unit of a Stirling engine.
The focused solar thermal energy is then converted to grid-quality electricity. The
conversion process involves a closed cycle, high-efficiency solar Stirling engine
using an internal working fluid (usually hydrogen or helium) that is recycled through
the engine. The working fluid is heated and pressurized by the solar receiver, which
in turn powers the Stirling engine. This design eliminates the need for a heat transfer
fluid and for cooling water (IEA 2010b; ESTELA 2012d; EU-SETIS 2012b; IPCC
2011; Patel 1999).
Parabolic dishes present very high solar-to-electric conversion performance in
CSP systems. The Stirling engine dish system achieved a 31.25% efficiency rate in
2008. Parabolic dishes are limited in size (typically 10–25 kW) and each produces
electricity independently, which means that hundreds or thousands of them would
need to be co-located to create a large-scale plant. In contrast, other CSP designs can
have capacities covering a very wide range, starting as low as 1 MW. The optimal
size of troughs, LFRs, and towers, typically from 100 to 250 MW, depends on the
efficiency of the power block. Dish Stirling systems are flexible in terms of size and
scale of deployment. They are capable of small-scale distributed power output and
are also suitable for large, utility-scale projects with thousands of dishes arranged in
a solar park. Their modularity allows them to be installed in areas with higher slope
than the other technologies, with greater availability in cases of failure or scheduled
maintenance. In addition to their compact size, their other features include the
absence of cooling water, low compatibility with thermal storage, and hybridization,
which puts parabolic dishes in competition with PV modules as much as with other
CSP technologies. Table 56.1 presents a comparison of the alternative solar thermal
power systems technologies (IEA 2010b; ESTELA 2012a, e; EU-SETIS 2012b;
IPCC 2011; Patel 1999).
Thermal storage is an important attribute of CSP. All CSP plants have some
ability to store heat energy for short periods of time and thus have a “buffering”
capacity, primarily for operational purposes, providing 30 min to 1 h of full-load
storage. This allows them to smooth electricity production and eliminate short-
term variations other solar technologies exhibit during cloudy days or transients
to the grid. Plants are now being designed for 6–7.5 h of full-load storage, which
is enough to allow operation well into the evening when sunlight is very limited or
absent. The concept of thermal storage is simple: throughout the day, excess heat is
diverted to a storage material (e.g., molten salts). When production is required after
sunset, the stored heat is released into the steam cycle and the plant continues to
produce electricity. In thermal storage, the heat from the solar field is stored prior
to reaching the turbine. Storage media include molten salt (presently comprising
separate hot and cold tanks), steam accumulators (for short-term storage only), solid
ceramic particles, and high temperature concrete. The heat can then be drawn from
1072 C.S. Psomopoulos
Table 56.1 Comparison of alternative solar thermal power system technologies (Patel 1999)
Solar concentration Operating temperature Thermodynamic
Technology (x Suns) on the hot side (ı C) cycle efficiency
Parabolic trough 100 300–500 Low
receiver
Linear Fresnel
reflectors
Power tower central 1,000 500–1000 Moderate
receiver
Dish receiver with 3,000 800–1,200 High
engine
the storage to generate steam for a turbine as and when needed. Studies proven
that, in locations with good sunlight (high DNI), extending electricity production to
match this demand requires a storage capacity of 2–4 h. In slightly less sunny areas,
storage could be larger, as it also helps compensate for the somewhat less predictable
resource. The solar field is larger compared with the rated electrical capacity to
ensure sufficient electricity production. As a result, at maximum sunlight power,
solar fields produce more heat than their turbines can absorb, and the produced
heat can be stored. In the absence of storage, on the sunniest hours, plant operators
need to “defocus” some unneeded solar collectors, thereby losing this energy.
Storage avoids this loss of energy while also allowing for extending production after
sunset. For example, some trough plants in Spain store enough heat in molten salts
to produce power at the rated capacity of the turbine (50 MWe) for more than seven
additional hours (IEA/OECD 2012; IEA 2010b; EU-SETIS 2012a, b; IPCC 2011).
Fig. 56.3 Schematic diagram of thermal solar collectors: glazed flat-plate (Arvizu et al. 2011b)
Fig. 56.4 Schematic diagram of thermal solar collectors: unglazed tube-on-sheet and serpentine
plastic pipe (Arvizu et al. 2011c)
better than flat-plate collectors in low irradiation conditions, so are most suitable in
locations with overcast skies (ESTTP 2007; IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC 2011).
Solar irradiation is also used for air heating applications. Solar air heating
systems collect the sun’s energy in an absorbing medium and use it to heat air.
This heated air can be used in process heat applications, for example, for drying or
preheating, and in buildings for space heating or air conditioning. The collectors of
solar air heating systems are commonly divided into two basic categories: unglazed
and glazed. Unglazed air collectors consist of a metal or plastic absorber without a
covering. They are commonly used to heat ambient air for commercial, industrial,
agricultural, and process applications. Glazed air collectors are usually used to heat
recirculating (conditioned) building air and are primarily for space heating. These
collectors often have an energy collecting surface integrated into the building’s
façade (IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC 2011).
56 Solar Energy: Harvesting the Sun’s Energy for Sustainable Future 1075
ter
d Wa
Heate
Insulation
y
Energ sfe r Copper
Solar Tran
Heat Sleeve in
sfe r Manifold
Tran
Heat Aluminium
op
e s to T Header
r Ris
Vapo Botto
m Casing
rns to
uid Retu
ens ed Liq
Cond Copper
Manifold
Fig. 56.5 Schematic diagram of thermal solar collectors: evacuated-tube collectors (Arvizu et al.
2011d)
The most commonly used solar collectors have a nominal peak thermal power
production of 0.7 kWth /m2 . This is a nominal peak power value, whereas the actual
thermal energy production varies depending on the installation parameters and the
available solar radiation. Other parameters affecting the thermal energy production
from the collector areas in operation are the outside temperature, the application,
and the solar thermal technology used. Typical examples of the estimated annual
thermal production for glazed flat-plate collectors are 1,000 kWhth /m2 in Israel,
700–1,000 kWhth /m2 in Australia, and 525 kWhth /m2 in Germany (ESTTP 2007;
IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC 2011; Philibert 2006).
performance. This requirement limits the areas for feasible and viable implemen-
tation of such technologies. A compound parabolic concentrator (CPC) is also
available, which is reflector that uses most of the diffuse radiation, not just direct
radiation. This reflector type is used with both non-evacuated flatplate collectors and
evacuated tube collectors. The CPC is typically designed for a concentration ratio
<2, which allows for stationary mounting and does not necessarily require tracking
systems. A special CPC design is the so-called maximum reflector collector,
which can achieve higher efficiencies in spring and autumn while preventing
overheating in summer due to an asymmetric reflector trough. This concentrator can
be used in expanded areas considering other concentrating technologies, as diffused
radiation is used (ESTELA 2012a; EU-SETIS 2012a; IEA/OECD 2012; IEA 2010b;
IPCC 2011).
Solar Solar
A Close-Coupled Collector Energy
Solar Water
Heater
Solar Energy
To Taps
Controller
Tank
Boiler
Fig. 56.6 Generic schematics of thermal solar systems. Left: passive (thermosiphon). Right:
active system (Arvizu et al. 2011e)
densities can be more than four times higher than sensible heat storage in water,
and thus their commercial development will increase the capabilities of heat storage
in solar heating and cooling systems (ESTTP 2007; IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC 2011;
SOLAIR 2009).
Thermochemical heat storage systems store energy through a chemical reaction.
Most common thermochemical storage systems present storage densities 8–10 times
higher than water, while there some chemicals that present densities that can be even
20 times higher than water. This storage technology is still in the development stage
and few systems have been demonstrated. Salts existing in anhydrous and hydrated
form are the materials under investigation for implementation on these technologies
(ESTTP 2007; IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC 2011; SOLAIR 2009).
Solar thermal systems in building applications come in two main types: ther-
mosiphon or natural circulation and pumped (forced circulation) systems (Fig. 56.6,
Arvizu et al. 2011e). Thermosiphon systems, common in frost-free climates, operate
using the law of physics that states that heated liquids are lighter than cooler ones
in order to circulate the heat transfer fluid to the heat storage. This avoids the
need for pumping, but requires that the heat storage needs to be placed above the
collector, limiting its size because of the weight. These systems do not consume
energy for fluid recirculation, but they could present heat losses if they are not
well insulated. Pumped circulation systems allow the separation of the collector
and the heat storage, so the storage can be placed within the dwelling. They are
more complicated because they require pumps and a control system to optimize
operation. Both the control system and the pump (or pumps) consume electricity.
The ancillary solar equipment consists of a controlling microprocessor, temperature
sensors, and actuators (typically pumps and valves). The maximization of the
system’s output and minimization of components losses and consumption are the
critical parameters to optimize the system and maximize efficiency. Here it must be
noted that solar thermal systems are always a part of a larger heating, ventilation,
56 Solar Energy: Harvesting the Sun’s Energy for Sustainable Future 1079
and cooling (HVAC) system, which is also a part of a larger system, usually a
building. Technologies aiding the integration of solar heating and cooling systems
into HVAC systems installed in buildings are important factors in widespread
deployment of solar heating and cooling systems and will support the effort for a
cleaner more sustainable environment (ESTTP 2007; IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC 2011;
SOLAIR 2009).
Photovoltaics are of great interest because the sun freely provides light in huge
quantities and it is expected to shine for the next 4–5 billion years. There is
more than enough solar irradiation available to satisfy the world’s energy demands.
According to several studies (EPIA-Greenpeace 2011; Luque and Hegedus 2003;
Sen 2008; Šúri et al. 2007), the earth is exposed to enough sunlight to generate
annually, using currently available technology, electricity with an average value
equal to 1,700 kWh/m2 of land. A large amount of statistical data on solar energy
reaching earth’s surface has been collected globally for many years and for many
areas. For example, the US National Solar Radiation database contains 30 years
of solar irradiation and meteorological data from 237 US sites. The European
Joint Research Centre (JRC) also collects and publishes European solar irradiation
data from 566 sites (EPIA 2011). Figure 56.7 presents the solar irradiation and
photovoltaic power generation potential in the EU in kWh/kWp of installed power,
as given by Šúri et al. (2007) and the JRC. Higher solar irradiation corresponds to
higher power generation potential. Europe receives average annual energy around
1,200 kWh/m2 , while the Middle East received 1,800–2,300 kWh/m2 per year. Even
though only a rather small part of solar irradiation can be used for electricity
production, this “efficiency loss” does not actually waste a finite power resource,
as with the use of fossil fuels. The reduced efficiency, however, has an impact
on the cost of the PV systems (EPIA 2011; EPIA-Greenpeace 2011; Sen 2008;
Šúri et al. 2007).
Photovoltaic (PV) systems consist of cells that convert sunlight into electricity.
Each of these cells is manufactured by layers of a semi-conducting material,
specially produced in order to develop an electric field across the layers when
sunlight falls on the cell. This electric field causes electricity flow and thus power
is produced. The electric field is generated by the following mechanism (EPIA-
Greenpeace 2011; Luque and Hegedus 2003; Sen 2008): When the cell is exposed
to light, photocarriers are generated and this carrier separation within the cell layers
produces a photovoltage and charge motion produces a photocurrent, which runs in
reverse through the diode junction (Lotsch et al. 2005; Luque and Hegedus 2003;
Rocket 2010; Sen 2008). The sunlight’s intensity determines the amount of electrical
power each cell generates. A photovoltaic system does not need bright sunlight in
order to operate. It can also generate electricity on cloudy and rainy days from
1080 C.S. Psomopoulos
Fig. 56.7 Solar irradiation and photovoltaic power generation potential in the EU (JRC, Šúri et al.
2007)
reflected sunlight (EPIA-Greenpeace 2011; Luque and Hegedus 2003; Sen 2008).
A typical rooftop PV installation is shown in Fig. 56.8.
The basic and key parts of a solar electricity generation system are the photo-
voltaic modules to collect and transform the sunlight and the inverter to transform
the produced direct current (DC) to alternate current (AC). The support structures to
orient the PV modules towards the sun and the system components required for the
connection of the PV to the grid are also required. Where the PV system is a stand-
alone one, a set of batteries with a regulator–charger is also required. The system
components, excluding the PV modules, are referred to as the balance of system
(BOS) components (EPIA 2011; EPIA-Greenpeace 2011; Greenpeace 2008; Lotsch
et al. 2005; Luque and Hegedus 2003).
The solar cell is the basic unit of a PV system. PV cells are generally made either
from crystalline silicon, sliced from ingots or castings, from grown ribbons, or from
alternative semiconductor materials deposited in thin layers on a low-cost backing
56 Solar Energy: Harvesting the Sun’s Energy for Sustainable Future 1081
Fig. 56.8 Rooftop installation (2011) over ceramic rooftiles in Kalivia – Attica Greece. Installed
power 9.46 kWp (Courtesy of ArvisSolar Ltd)
(thin film). Cells are connected together to form larger units called modules. Thin
sheets of ethyl vinyl acetate (EVA) or polyvinyl butyral (PVB) are used to bind cells
together and to provide weather protection. The modules are normally enclosed
between a transparent cover (usually glass) and a weatherproof backing sheet
(typically made from a thin polymer). Modules can be framed for extra mechanical
strength and durability. Thin film modules are usually encapsulated between two
sheets of glass (EPIA 2011; EPIA-Greenpeace 2011; Greenpeace 2008; Krauter
2006; Lotsch et al. 2005; Luque and Hegedus 2003).
The typical connection between modules is an array, where they are connected to
each other in series in order to increase the output voltage produced by the system.
The current produced by the system is increased when the arrays are connected in
parallel. The connections present similarities with the batteries’ connection types
to increase the output voltage and current of a battery system (EPIA 2011; EPIA-
Greenpeace 2011; Krauter 2006; Luque and Hegedus 2003). The power generated
by PV modules depends on the module size, the power density measured in Wp/m2 ,
and the technology used and varies from a few watts (typically 20–0 Wp) up to
300–350 Wp per module. Low-wattage modules are typically used for stand-alone
applications where power demand is generally low. Standard crystalline silicon
modules contain about 60–72 solar cells and have a nominal power ranging from
120 to 320 Wp depending on size, efficiency, and power density. Standard thin film
modules have lower nominal power (60–150 Wp) and their size is generally smaller.
Modules can be sized according to the site where they will be placed and installed
1082 C.S. Psomopoulos
power increases, the inverter retains the new voltage and current values. If the PV
generator loses power, the inverter continues operating with the original values until
the next measuring interval. MPP tracking operates extremely reliably and all well-
known inverter manufacturers use it. Recently, some larger inverters (over 8 kW)
have divided their power input connector in two sections and incorporated two MPP
systems (EPIA 2011; EPIA-Greenpeace 2011; JRC 2010; SMA 2012).
In cases where the PV system is not connected to the electricity grid, the system
is considered to be stand-alone. In order for such a system to supply electricity for
consumption, additional systems are required for storing the excess energy produced
by PV system so that it can be used when production is lower or when there is no
production. The equipment required includes batteries and charge controllers. Lead
acid batteries are typically used in such installations due to lower cost and relative
high operational life, although new high-quality batteries, designed specifically for
solar applications and with a life of up to 15 years, are now available. Batteries are
connected to the PV array via a charge controller. The charge controller protects
the batteries from overcharging or discharging and monitors the condition of the
batteries. The controller can also provide information about the state of the system
or the electricity consumption. The controller has a significant role in the system
because it manages the batteries’ charging and discharging conditions, and thus
affects the actual lifetime of the batterie (EPIA 2011; JRC 2010; Krauter 2006;
Lotsch et al. 2005; SMA 2012).
PV systems as they have been described previously can be divided in two main
types based on their installation, that is, whether they are grid connected or are
off-grid or stand-alone installations. The off-grid or stand-alone installations can be
divided further based on whether they are used for domestic consumption or non-
domestic consumption. The grid-connected systems can be divided in distributed PV
systems and centralized PV systems (EPIA 2011; EPIA-Greenpeace 2011; Krauter
2006; Lotsch et al. 2005; Zahedi 2006).
Off-grid domestic photovoltaic systems provide electricity to households and
villages located in rural areas that are not connected to the national electricity
grid. Theses PV systems are usually designed to provide electricity for lighting,
refrigeration, and other low-power domestic loads. The systems require all the
equipment previously mentioned. These types of PV systems have been installed
in thousands of places worldwide and they are often the most appropriate tech-
nology to meet the electricity demands of off-grid communities. Off-grid domestic
systems are typically around 2–3 kW per household, in size and generally offer
an economic alternative to extending the electricity distribution grid (EPIA 2011;
EPIA-Greenpeace 2011; Krauter 2006; Lotsch et al. 2005; Zahedi 2006).
Off-grid non-domestic PV systems are common in many applications requiring
small amounts of electricity and the distribution network is far, and the PV
commercial cost is competitive with other small generating sources. These systems
were the first commercial application for terrestrial PV systems. They provide power
at a low maintenance for a wide range of applications, such as telecommunications,
water pumping, vaccine refrigeration, and navigational aids. In recent years, this
type of installation has also been used to supply illumination installations such
1084 C.S. Psomopoulos
as street lights, plaza lights, and so on in urban areas in an effort to reduce the
use of electricity from fossil fuels (EPIA 2011; Krauter 2006; Lotsch et al. 2005;
Zahedi 2006).
Grid-connected distributed photovoltaic systems are usually installations up
to few hundreds of kW in size. These installations are typically residential or
commercial and are connected to the electricity grid. In most of cases, the electricity
produced by the PV is fed back to the utility grid, while the consumption is
covered by the grid. In some cases, the PV system covers part of the whole of
the consumption, and if there is additional need for electricity this is covered by
the grid, or electricity is fed back into the utility grid when the on-site generation
exceeds the demand of the load. These systems are usually integrated into the
built environment and supply electricity to residential houses and commercial and
industrial buildings. The costs of these systems are lower compared with an off-grid
installation because there is no need for battery storage in these PV systems (EPIA
2011; EPIA-Greenpeace 2011; Krauter 2006; Lotsch et al. 2005; Zahedi 2006).
Grid-connected centralized photovoltaic systems or large industrial and utility-
scale power plants are large PV installations requiring huge free spaces. These types
of PV electricity generation plants present installed power from many hundreds
of kilowatts (kW) to several megawatts (MW). The solar panels for industrial
systems are usually mounted on frames on the ground or are installed on large
industrial buildings such as warehouses, airport terminals, or railway stations. These
systems can make double-use of an urban space and provide electricity into the grid
where energy-intensive consumers are located, strengthening the utility distribution
network locally. These systems can produce enormous quantities of electricity
at a single in an environmentally friendly manner. They are also installed as an
alternative to conventional centralized power generation or adjacent to central power
stations powered by fossil fuels to reduce the emissions by the stations (EPIA 2011;
EPIA-Greenpeace 2011; Krauter 2006; Lotsch et al. 2005; Zahedi 2006).
The sun has produced energy for billions of years and it is expected to continue
for a few billion more. Solar energy is the radiant light and heat from the sun. This
energy can be converted into other forms of energy, such as heat and electricity,
using the appropriate equipment. Solar energy technologies include solar heating
and cooling, solar electricity, and solar daylight architecture (EPIA-Greenpeace
2011; Greenpeace 2008; IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC 2011).
Small-scale, low-temperature solar thermal systems can supply heat for domestic
hot water. The collectors can be installed in various kinds of systems almost always
including a hot water tank. Individual domestic hot water systems have a collector
56 Solar Energy: Harvesting the Sun’s Energy for Sustainable Future 1085
size between 3 and 6 m2 , with storage of between 150 and 300 L. These systems
work either with thermosiphon (natural circulation) or pumped (forced circulation)
systems, usually in cases where the storage cannot be installed over the collectors.
Natural flow systems (thermosiphon, monoblock, or with separate collector and
storage areas) work without any need for pumps or control stations. Solar domestic
hot water systems can be designed to cover from 30%, in combination with a
back-up system, to close to 100% of domestic hot water demand, depending
on collector area, storage size, and climate. The backup is usually electricity in
industrialized countries, or even biomass and fossil fuels, but in a majority of
systems in developing countries, solar water heaters are often the sole source of hot
water (ESTTP 2007; Greenpeace 2008; IEA 2009; IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC 2011;
Philibert 2006; Singhal 2011; Weiss and Mauthner 2012).
Solar heating systems for combined domestic hot water and space heating, also
called “combisystems,” are almost identical to solar heaters for sanitary water. These
systems present the same type of collectors and the circuit for transporting the
produced heat to the storage. The basic difference is the usually required pumped
(forced circulation) systems. A solar combi-system requires a larger collector
area and generally larger storage to meet the space heating needs, considering
that sanitary hot water averages only 20% of the total space and water heating
demand in existing buildings in OECD countries. These systems always use an
auxiliary energy source, typically biomass or fossil fuels, to cover the part of the
heating demand not covered by the solar thermal system. In typical single-family
homes in a mid-European climate, such systems can provide energy savings (non-
renewable energy) in the range of 25–30%. In central and northern EU countries
(e.g., Germany, Austria) where combi-systems account for around 50% of annually
installed capacity, the use of solar combi-systems is not widespread. One reason for
this is the lack of low-cost compact thermal storage. Here it must be noted that these
systems are well suited to middle and high latitudes, due to significantly higher solar
radiation in the transitional periods around winter (September–October and March–
May) and the significant heating demand in these latitudes at that time (ESTTP
2007; Greenpeace 2008; IEA 2009; IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC 2011; Philibert 2006;
Singhal 2011; Weiss and Mauthner 2012).
Solar thermal systems supplying heating or even cooling to the building sector
can also be found in large-scale applications used for district heating, mainly in
multifamily buildings or even tertiary sector buildings. These systems have several
1086 C.S. Psomopoulos
collector areas, which can vary from tens to hundreds of square meters and also
have large storage systems. These systems now have an important share in some
European markets such as in France (ESTTP 2007; IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC 2011;
Philibert 2006; Uniclima 2012). Solar energy is an attractive low-cost source of heat
for district heating systems, where typical working temperatures range from 30ı C
to around 100ı C for water storage. Important factors include the high cost of fossil
fuels and biomass that allows rather small payback times, as well as environmental
concerns related to greenhouse gas emissions. Large-scale solar thermal plants
can also be used if thermally driven district cooling systems are implemented.
The large scale of the solar collector fields and associated storage offer improved
economics due to a better ratio of storage volume to collector surface (ESTTP 2007;
IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC 2011; Philibert 2006; Uniclima 2012).
There are a lot of regions around the earth that experience water shortages, and
the need for water desalination is expected to continue growing. These regions
often have high solar resources and DNI. These solar resources can provide a
notable advantage in desalination processes that are thermally driven. In these
56 Solar Energy: Harvesting the Sun’s Energy for Sustainable Future 1087
areas, concentrated solar thermal technologies can be used for thermal desalination
processes such as distillation. Distillation is preferred for more saline water over
reverse osmosis technology. Furthermore, the use of solar resources greatly reduces
the desalination’s energy cost, a process that is energy intensive and thus costly
(ESTELA 2012a; IEA 2010b, 2011; IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC 2011; Philibert 2006).
Swimming pools are an interesting application for solar thermal systems. In the
EU, North America (United States and Canada), and Australia this application is a
growing solar thermal application. The sun’s energy heats the water collectors and
can yield a temperature increase of up to 20ı C compared with the environment, even
though the common increment is around 10ı C. In North America and Australia,
unglazed water collectors for swimming pool heating are the dominant application
of solar thermal technology (IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC 2011; Weiss and Mauthner
2012).
heat-driven cooling cycles and high-efficiency systems (higher COP and thus higher
temperature difference) are required (IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC 2011; Philibert 2006).
The basic concept of solar thermal power is relatively simple: concentrating solar
power devices concentrate energy from the sun’s rays to heat a receiver to high
temperatures. This heat is transformed first into mechanical energy (by turbines or
other engines) and then into electricity. Even though the first commercial plants
began operating in California in the period from 1984 to 1991, supported by
federal and state tax incentives and mandatory long-term power purchase contracts,
there was over a decade without almost any market development. Starting in
2006, new installations in Spain and the United States, in response to government
measures such as feed-in tariffs (Spain) and policies obliging utilities to obtain
some share of power from renewables, largely from solar, re-merged the market.
These installations are always rather large ones, over a few MW of installed power,
connected to the grid, providing electricity to several thousands of households. Due
to the requirements for high values of DNI these can be installed only in areas
included in the sun’s belt, a large-scale area that extends from latitudes 35ı N to
35ı S. But even though this area is limited, the potential for electricity from CSP is
great enough that the power demand of numerous countries can be satisfied. As an
example, a small part of North Africa in the Sahara Desert is enough to produce
the electricity needs of all of Europe. The potential of investments and applications
towards a more sustainable and carbon-free future Are significant (ESTELA 2012a;
EU-SETIS 2012a; Greenpeace 2008; IEA 2010b, 2011; IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC
2011; Philibert 2006).
Photovoltaic systems are widespread around the world. They provide electricity in
small houses and villages in rural areas and powering research facilities spread
in every corner of the planet. They are building-integrated, installed in buildings’
rooftops, and there are also large-scale utility-size installations. These facilities can
be found as grid connected or off-grid or stand-alone installations. The off-grid
or stand alone installations can be divided further considering if they are used for
domestic consumptions or non domestic consumptions. The grid-connected systems
can be divided in distributed PV systems and centralized PV systems. The off-grid
photovoltaic systems are usually located in rural areas that are not connected to the
national electricity grid. These types of PV systems have been installed in thousands
places worldwide and they are often the most appropriate technology to meet the
electricity demands of off-grid communities and a wide range of applications, such
as telecommunication, water pumping, vaccine refrigeration, and navigational aids.
Recent years this type of installation is used to supply illumination installations
56 Solar Energy: Harvesting the Sun’s Energy for Sustainable Future 1089
such as street lights, plazas’ lights, etc. inside urban areas, in an effort for reducing
the use of electricity from fossil fuels (EPIA 2011; EPIA-Greenpeace 2011; IPCC
2011; Krauter 2006; Lotsch et al. 2005; Zahedi 2006).
Concentrating solar power systems have been commercially available since the
middle of the 1980s. The first new major concentrated solar thermal electricity
plants were Nevada Solar One, with an installed capacity of 64 MW in the United
States, and the PS 10 plant of 11 MW in southern Spain, built in 2007. Spain’s
Central Government with the Royal Decree 661/2007, dated 25 March 2007,
provided a driving force for the current CSP plant construction and the ambitious
expansion plans, through a guaranteed feed-in tariff of 0.269 e/kWh for 25 years.
This has made Spain the world leader in installed CSP capacity (ESTELA 2012a;
EUROBSERV’ER 2012b; EU-SETIS 2012a, b; IEA 2010a, 2011; IPCC 2011;
REN21 2012).
At the end of spring 2010, the cumulative capacity of all CSP plants was about
867 MW, with another 1,170 MW under construction. In addition, another 8 GW
are in the planning stage for realization in 2015. The CSP market continued its
steady growth during 2011, following the trend of the past few years. More than
450 MW of CSP was installed, increasing total global capacity by 35% to just over
1,760 MW. The majority of CSP facilities currently under construction are located
in Spain. Spain is leading the global market with 1151.4 MW in operation in 2011
(EUROBSERV’ER 2012b), corresponding to over 65% of the globally installed
power, and this dominance is expected to continue over the coming years as projects
with a total capacity of 15 GW have applied for interconnection. This is in line with
the European Solar Industry Initiative, which aims at a cumulative installed CSP
capacity of 30 GW in Europe, of which 19 GW would be in Spain. Also in Spain,
the first CSP plant with 24-h power production, under certain conditions, has been in
operation since 2011, mainly due to a 15-h storage capability (Fig. 56.9) (ESTELA
2012a; EUROBSERV’ER 2012b; EU-SETIS 2012a, b; IPCC 2011; REN21 2012).
The second largest market for CSP, with an installed capacity in 2011 of
28.8% of global power, is the United States, with 507 MW in operation. The first
commercially available CSP installation was located in the United States. In addition
to the installed capacity, an additional 1.3 GW of CSP is under construction.
In the rest of the world, around 100 MW of installed CSP plants were in
operation at the end of 2011. Algeria has 25 MW in operation, Egypt and Morocco
20 MW each, Iran 17 MW, Thailand 9.8 MW, Italy 5 MW, Australia 3 MW, and
India 2.5 MW. In the coming years, the installed CSP capacity is expected to rise
further globally, as many countries are planning or have under construction CSP
plants. In some cases, these CSP facilities are integrated with coal- or gas-fired
plants (hybrid systems) or with biomass power plants. These hybrid systems present
1090 C.S. Psomopoulos
Fig. 56.9 Gemasolar plant in operation: central tower, salt receiver, and heliostat technology,
19.9 MW rated power and 110 GWh of annual production, located in Andalusia, Spain (Courtesy
of Torresol Energy)
many advantages, especially the 24-h operation and reduced emissions, and seem
attractive to the markets (ESTELA 2012a; EUROBSERV’ER 2012b; EU-SETIS
2012a, b; IPCC 2011; REN21 2012).
Parabolic trough plants dominated in the early stages and continue to do
so, having a share of almost 90% of the installed plants. However, competing
technologies, especially linear Fresnel reflectors, present lower costs and power
towers can achieve higher temperatures and thus higher efficiency, and are emerging
for these reasons. Market trends tend to have more or less equal shares all these
three technologies for CSP in large-scale installations, even though dish systems
are becoming increasingly attractive (ESTELA 2012a; EUROBSERV’ER 2012b;
EU-SETIS 2012b; IPCC 2011; REN21 2012).
Even though solar heat can be captured by a variety of technologies and utilized in
a wide number of applications, the most mature technology is the solar domestic
hot water system. This technology has a long history, and was first deployed on a
large scale in the 1960s in countries such as Australia, Japan, and Israel (IEA 2011;
IEA/OECD 2012). Since then, the introduction of long-term subsidy schemes or
solar obligations (e.g., subsidies in Austria and Germany, and solar obligations in
Israel) and the competitive advantages of solar hot water systems over alternative
56 Solar Energy: Harvesting the Sun’s Energy for Sustainable Future 1091
technologies (e.g., in Cyprus and Greece), has lead to a significant increase of the
installed capacity in some markets. In 2010, glazed water collectors provided an
estimated 150 TWh (540 PJ) of heat annually (IEA 2011; IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC
2011; REN21 2012).
By the end of 2010, the solar thermal collector capacity in operation worldwide
was estimated to be 195.8 GWth , corresponding to 279.7 million square meters;
By the end of 2011, it was estimated to have grown by 25%, to 245 GWth
according to Weiss and Mauthner (2012) or 232 GWth according to REN21 (2012),
whose estimates are more conservative. The dominant technologies in the market,
with 88.3% of the total installed capacity, are flat-plate collectors (FPC) and
evacuated tube collectors (ETC). Unglazed and glazed water collectors have 11%
and 0.7% shares of the market, respectively (EUROBSERV’ER 2012b; IEA 2011;
IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC 2011; REN21 2012; Weiss and Mauthner 2012). The global
leader in installed glazed and unglazed water and air collectors is China, with
117.6 GWth (135.5 GWth in 2011 according to REN21 2012), followed by Europe
with 36.0 GWth , and the United States and Canada with 16.0 GWth , mostly with
unglazed collectors. These regions together account for 86.6% of total installed
capacity worldwide. The market for solar heating technology has seen substantial
growth over the past decade, and the leaders were Europe and China. In Europe, the
market size more than tripled between 2002 and 2008 according the data provided
by IPCC (2011). Although the 2008 financial crisis affected the solar heating
systems market, resulting in decreases of 10% in 2009 and 13% in 2010, the market
saw an average 12% increase per year from 2000 to 2010 according to ESTIF’s data
(2011). In China, the use of solar domestic hot water systems is growing rapidly,
mainly because these systems have considerably lower average annual costs than
competing technologies of gas and electric water heaters, according to IEA data
(IEA 2010a; IEA/OECD 2012) with $27 for solar, $82 for gas, and $95 for electric
(ESTIF 2011; EUROBSERV’ER 2012b; IEA 2011; IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC 2011;
REN21 2012; Weiss and Mauthner 2012).
Another interesting parameter of the market is the evaluation of the global market
based on installed power per capita. This analysis provides interesting results.
Globally, Cyprus was the leading solar heating economy, with 0.575 kWth /capita in
2010, followed by Israel with 0.394 kWth /capita. The leader in continental Europe
was Austria, with 0.337 kWth /capita, followed by Greece with 0.266 kWth /capita
and Germany with 0.112 kWth /capita. China was among the top 10 for per capita
installed capacity for the first time in 2010, with 0.088 kWth /capita (EUROB-
SERV’ER 2012b; IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC 2011; REN21 2012).
The solar space heating and cooling market has seen notable growth, especially
the last 5 years. The most advanced solar thermal markets are in Germany, Spain,
and Austria, where advanced applications – such as water and space heating
for dwellings of all sizes, hotels, and large-scale plants for district heating, as
well as air conditioning and cooling – account for a substantial share of each
market. Worldwide, the market share for systems that provide both water and space
heating is about 4% and rising, with installations in established markets in Europe
1092 C.S. Psomopoulos
(Germany, Spain, Austria, Greece, Cyprus), South America (Brazil, Mexico), and
Asia (China, India, Japan) (EUROBSERV’ER 2012b; IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC
2011; REN21 2012).
Europe is also leading the market in large-scale systems (>0.035 MWth /, with a
combined capacity of 215 MWth in 149 operating systems in 2010. Among these,
80 solar heating and cooling plants were larger than 700 kWth . In Denmark and
Sweden, solar heat is fed into district networks, and a number of German providers
purchase or offer to “store” their customers’ solar heat (EUROBSERV’ER 2012b;
IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC 2011; REN21 2012).
Solar cooling systems represent a more recent technology and, consequently, the
installed capacity is limited. In 2011, about 750 solar cooling systems were installed
worldwide. This number includes small-capacity installations up to 20 kW (Mugnier
and Jakob 2012; IEA/OECD 2012). A number of very large-scale installations
have been completed or are under construction. Two typical examples are the
solar cooling system at the headquarters of the CGD bank in Lisbon, Portugal
(cooling capacity 400 kW and collector field 1,560 m2 /; and the solar cooling system
installed at the United World College in Singapore, completed in 2011 (cooling
capacity 1,470 kW and collector field 3,900 m2 /. The Singapore installation has
proven its economic viability, as the installation was reported fully cost competitive.
Another interesting fact with regard to this facility is that it was executed on
an energy services company (ESCO) model under which the customer is not
exposed to equipment or project costs, and the ESCO sells the resultant cooling
capacity to the customer. In market terms, large solar cooling systems have to
date been more favorable than small, due to economies of scale and demand
and equipment limitations in smaller capacities. The small scale (<20 kW) solar
cooling installations, also known as solar cooling “kit” systems, which are for
residential application, have increased considerably the recent years, especially
in Spain, according to Henning and Wiemken (2007). However, this trend almost
completely halted in 2008 due to the economic crisis, and the market has since been
a shrinking one. A very limited market of several hundred kits still exists in 2011,
mainly in Central Europe and in dry and sunny climates (Middle East, Australia, the
Mediterranean islands) (EUROBSERV’ER 2012b; Henning and Wiemken 2007;
IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC 2011; Mugnier and Jakob 2012; REN21 2012).
ROW USA
Japan 3,2 GW, 8% 2,5 GW, 6%
China
France 3,6 GW, 9% 0,9 GW, 2%
1,1 GW, 3%
Czech
2 GW, 5% ROEU
1,3 GW, 3%
Italy
3,5 GW, 9%
Spain
4 GW, 10%
Germany
17,4 GW, 44%
Fig. 56.10 Global cumulative installed PV capacity through 2010, with market share (%). ROW
Rest of World, ROEU Rest of EU (EPIA 2011; EUROBSERV’ER 2012a)
Capital investment for solar-only reference systems is rather high compared with
other energy sources, but, on the other hand, offers considerable long-term benefits
because of minimum fuel costs for backup/hybridization. The cost per MWe
installed is decreasing as the installed capacity is increasing. For example, an
installation of 50 MWe without storage is currently of the order of e4,800/kWe,
varying from e2,100 to 6,000/kWe, depending on the different parameters and
especially the technology used. The existence of storage capacity increases the
capital cost significantly (EU-SETIS 2012b). The DNI is a parameter that de-
termines significantly the production cost. A study presented by Salazaar (2008)
showed that the cost of electricity production for parabolic trough systems is
currently of the order of e0.18–0.20/kWh in Southern Europe in regions with
DNI of 2,000 kWh/m2 /a. For DNI in the range of 2,300–2,700 kWh/m2 /a, as
encountered in the Sahara region or in the US, the current cost could be decreased by
20–30%. Stoddard et al. showed, in 2006, a cost reduction of the order of
25–35% for parabolic trough plants is achievable due to technological innovations
and process scaling up to 200 MWe, for a given DNI (EU-SETIS 2012b; Salazaar
2008; Stoddard et al. 2006).
56 Solar Energy: Harvesting the Sun’s Energy for Sustainable Future 1095
an IEA/OECD study for large trough plants, as this CSP technology dominates the
market numbers that are most readily available. The actual cost depends mostly on
the available sunlight. The impact of storage on generating costs is not as simple
as it may seem, because even though the investment costs are increased with the
added storage capacity, the same applies with the yearly electrical output, and thus
the energy cost changes only marginally. The main advantage of storage is that
allows solar plants to compete with fossil-fuel plants by supplying base-load power
in the not-too-distant future. According to the IEA/OECD study, the US Department
of Energy has set an objective for its CSP program to reach competitiveness with
fossil fuels by 2015 for intermediate loads (accounting for around 50% of the total
load demand), at around US$100/MWh, and by 2020 for base loads (accounting
for around 40% of the total load demand), at around US$50/MWh. Considering
the peak loads (accounting for the remainig 10% of the total load demand), CSP
technologies’ costs are close to the conventional sources due to the very high costs
that these present for the peak loads (EU-SETIS 2012b; IEA 2010b).
Solar heating of sanitary water is by far the most attractive application of renewable
technology that also reduces consumers’ energy expenses. Like many renewable
energy technologies, solar water heating presents higher investment costs and
lower operation and maintenance costs than conventional technologies, while in the
regions inside the sun’s belt the “fuel cost” is almost zero due to the high irradiation
from the sun. Analyzing the total investment costs for a typical solar thermal system,
there three basic categories:
Cost of basic equipment, including the solar collectors;
Cost of additional equipment such as collector mounting components, storage
vessels, and plumbing;
Installation labor costs, which may include system design, assembly, and scaf-
folding.
In domestic solar water heating applications, collectors, storage vessels, and
collector mounting are in one package and thus one cost category (ESTIF 2011;
ESTTP 2007; IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC 2011; REN21 2012).
Investment costs for solar water heating depend on system design and application
characteristics (and thus the complexity of the chosen technology) and market con-
ditions in the region of operation. Thermosiphon systems require lower investment
costs because they use natural circulation, avoiding the need for pumping and the
associated equipment, installation, and operating costs, but these are mainly limited
to frost-free climates. In other regions, higher-cost forced-circulation systems will
be required, even for small-scale applications. In some cases, the chosen application
requires forced circulation even in regions that can have thermosiphon systems
(ESTIF 2011; ESTTP 2007; IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC 2011).
Labor costs, design characteristics, and the size of the local solar heating and
cooling market can also considerably influence the overall investment costs. In small
56 Solar Energy: Harvesting the Sun’s Energy for Sustainable Future 1097
5.3 PV Technology
The technology developed by the PV industry was among the most expensive in
the first stages of development and use. Over the past 30 years of operation, the
PV industry has achieved impressive price decreases in the modules costs, which
has lead consumers to consider PV installations as a possibility for electrification.
According to a EPIA-Greenpeace report (EPIA-Greenpeace 2011), the price of PV
modules is reduced by 22% each time the cumulative installed capacity (in MW)
1098 C.S. Psomopoulos
The main benefit of CSP systems is obvious. They can replace the power generated
by fossil fuels in a stable and highly predictable way and thus reduce the greenhouse
gas emissions causing climate change. As it has been estimated in the study
presented by Greenpeace et al. (2009), each square meter of concentrator surface,
for example, avoids 200–300 kg of CO2 each year, depending on its configuration.
Typical concentrated solar power plants are made up of hundreds or even thousands
of concentrators arranged in arrays, thus the reductions can be severe. CO2
emissions during the manufacture, installation, and servicing over the average
20-year lifecycle of a solar power plant are “paid back” after the first 3–6 months
of operation. The life-cycle assessment of the components together with the land-
surface impacts of CSP systems indicate that it takes around 5 months to “pay back”
the energy used to manufacture and install the equipment. Considering that plants
could last 40 years, as demonstrated in the Mojave Desert plants in United States,
which have operated since 1984, this is a good ratio. Most of the CSP solar field
materials can be recycled and used again for further plants, as a typical plant is made
of mainly of metals, concrete, and mirrors, all of which are recyclable (ESTELA
2012a; Greenpeace et al. 2009; IEA 2010b; IPCC 2011; Stoddard et al. 2006).
CSP electricity generation presents some significant advantages in addition
to the aforementioned benefit of replacing fossil fuels. It is highly predictable,
based on the sun irradiation values, and thermal storage capacity is continuously
improving and can worked together (hybridization) with gas and fossil fuels or
biomass, enabling stable energy production in national or international electricity
networks. Solar thermoelectric plants (CSP) respond well to variable load demand,
especially in peak load demands as well as intermediate load demands. Especially
for the peak loads, present, with the current technology, costs comparable with
fossil fuels. Demand can be met at any time, day and night, if there is adequate
storage capacity, and can supply electricity at peak hours if needs are anticipated.
Furthermore, these plants can contribute to the electrical systems’ stability as they
are using steam generators. This type of generation allows the local grids to accept
additional amounts of electricity produced by other renewable sources that affects
the grids’ stability (ESTELA 2012a; Greenpeace et al. 2009; IEA 2010b; IPCC
2011; Stoddard et al. 2006).
Most of the developing and some of the developed countries lie within the
tropical belt of the world, where the solar radiation is higher. About 75% of
the world’s population lives in the world’s “sun belt.” These regions receive the
sun’s radiation for almost 3,000–4,000 h/year. In solar power density terms, this is
1100 C.S. Psomopoulos
Solar heating technologies are the most common applications of sun’s energy
utilization, and solar cooling systems have become an emerging market. The
technical potential for solar heating and cooling energy systems is enormous,
depending mainly on the application and the region of implementation. The land
56 Solar Energy: Harvesting the Sun’s Energy for Sustainable Future 1101
and/or roof space availability and the proximity of heating and cooling demand can
limit the implementation of the technical potential. The benefits from increasing
the penetration of solar heating and cooling technology, especially in the building
sector, are significant. The market available technology could cover most of the
needs of indoor heating and sanitary hot water in new and even retrofitted houses
provided that energy efficiency and energy savings measures, including good
insulation, have significantly decreased domestic thermal energy demand. The
penetration of solar heating and cooling systems will decrease the consumption
of fossil fuels like oil and natural gas, and electricity used for indoor heating and
cooling and for sanitary hot water (ESTIF 2011; ESTTP 2007; EU-SETIS 2012c;
IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC 2011; REN21 2012).
There is a long list of the advantages that can be ascribed directly solar thermal
systems. Solar thermal technologies always lead to a direct reduction of primary
energy consumption and energy costs, as they rely on the sun, which is freely
available and almost infinite (it will continue to shine for a few more billion years).
These systems can be combined with many kinds of back-up heat sources available
in the market and do not consume other energy sources. Even when circulation is
required in solar thermal systems, the increase in electricity demand is very limited,
considering the power generation and transmission capacities avoided. Only few
inhabited areas worldwide with only a small fraction of the earth’s population cannot
be benefit from the sun with the market available solar thermal technologies, but
it is expected that even these limitations will be overcome through research and
development of the related technologies. The life-cycle environmental impact of
solar thermal systems is extremely low. And if the economic part of the investment
is also considered, then it is well known that solar thermal prices are predictable at
the moment of the investment since the future prices of fuels do not affect them,
while local jobs are created through the value chain (ESTIF 2011; ESTTP 2007;
IEA/OECD 2012).
In addition to solar thermal applications, solar cooling technologies present
a number of attractive features compared with the alternatives. Solar cooling
requires high solar radiation, and high solar radiation corresponds to high ambient
temperatures. Thus, it is obvious that maximum solar radiation usually coincides
with peak cooling demand and, this way, solar cooling can help reduce electrical
network peaks associated with conventional cooling, as it offers air-conditioning
that is not based on electricity. If solar cooling is widely deployed, the need for
expensive additional electricity network resources associated with electrically pow-
ered cooling will be reduced. For example, the electricity-driven air conditioning
installed in Greece during the last 3 years has a consumption corresponding to
a 400 MW power plant. Avoidance of this increased electricity demand due to
peak cooling loads will lead to reduced peak power production, mainly from fossil
fuels today, and thus a reduction in greenhouse gas emissions, and avoidance of
reinforcement of transmission and distribution network, thus leading to substantial
cost reductions and beneficial environmental impacts (ESTIF 2011; ESTTP 2007;
IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC 2011; Greenpeace 2008; Mugnier and Jakob 2012; Singhal
2011; SOLAIR 2009).
1102 C.S. Psomopoulos
Moreover, if thermal storage is used, the solar thermal cooling system can also
deliver cooling in the evening. Solar cooling systems can also be used for other
heating purposes, such as domestic hot water or space heating, in other seasons
besides summer. Open-cycle solar cooling systems provide humidity management
as well as space cooling. Also, solar thermal cooling, as an absorption chiller, does
not use refrigerants (CFCs and HCFCs, used in electric compression chillers), which
are harmful greenhouse gases and require special treatment in case of a leakage,
and thus their environmental impact is further decreased. The major disadvantage
that limits the use of solar cooling is that it is still in the early stages of market
development; costs need to be reduced through further development and increased
deployment. The technology is not yet effective and developed adequately in order
to be used in single-family and multi-family dwellings in a competitive way, and
thus achieve widespread deployment (IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC 2011; Greenpeace
2008; Mugnier and Jakob 2012; Singhal 2011; SOLAIR 2009).
The EU-27 is leading the way in legislative measures and awareness campaigns
in order to make the most of these benefits. The installed capacities of solar-thermal
systems for the EU-27 are expected to be 52 GW in 2020 and 135 GW in 2030.
The estimated maximum potential for solar-thermal systems in the EU-27 is up
to 320 GW by 2020 and 700 GW by 2030. This represents about 3% and 7% of
projected EU heat demand by 2020 and 2030, respectively, and can lead to savings
of approximately 25 Mtoe of fossil fuel use in 2020, 47–50 Mtoe per year by
2030, with a maximum cumulative fossil fuel avoidance of 500 Mtoe, for the period
2010–2030 and 126 Mtoe per year by 2050. If the maximum potential is realized,
solar heating and cooling systems could potentially avoid up to 30 Mt/year CO2
in 2020 and 65 Mt/year CO2 in 2030. The corresponding maximum cumulative
avoided CO2 emissions for the period 2010–2030 would be up to 600 Mt CO2
(ESTIF 2011; ESTTP 2007; IEA/OECD 2012; IPCC 2011; Greenpeace 2008;
Henning and Wiemken 2007; Mugnier and Jakob 2012).
6.3 PV Technology
policies. This ability will become a significant advantage in the effort to increase
renewable energy share in the power mix in order to support sustainability in power
production (EPIA 2011; EPIA-Greenpeace 2011; Fthenakis and Bulawka 2004;
Rigby et al. 2011; Šúri et al. 2007).
Small-scale PV systems can be installed in every urban area as long as there
is no shade. This possibility is extremely helpful where decentralized electricity
generation is considered. Decentralized electricity production systems are among
the key points of the smart grids, and can support the heavy power demand that is
increasing continuously. Since small-scale photovoltaic systems can be connected
directly to a low-voltage distribution network, they can be easily spread out the
network, providing support to specific network positions and reducing the need for
local capacity increase, due to increased demand in many cases (EPIA 2010, 2011;
EPIA-Greenpeace 2011; Rigby et al. 2011). This deployment of small-scale PV
systems will support the effort to make cities greener. The EU, where the majority
of studies have been executed, has a capacity of over several GWp of PV systems
to be installed on 40% of all building roofs and on 15% of all facades that are
suitable. If the more than 22,000 km2 total ground floor area in the EU-27 cities are
added to the above mentioned areas, the potential capacity of PV systems that could
be installed in EU-27 will reach or exceed 1.5 TWp. If this scenario is applied,
then the resulting electricity generation could potentially exceed the 1,400 TWh,
an amount corresponding on the 40% of the electricity demand predicted for 2020.
The key point is that PV systems, especially the small scale ones can seamlessly
integrate into the densest urban environments. Domestic and tertiary consumptions
such as but not limited to lighting, air-conditioning, office equipment, refrigerators,
food processing equipment, and so on are responsible for a significant amount of
energy consumed globally; thus resulting in significant amounts of greenhouse gases
emissions through the use of fossil fuels. If the abovementioned scenario for PV
installation were to be applied, totally or even partially, then these emissions would
be decreased notably. Additionally, installation of small-scale photovoltaic systems
in buildings is one of the key factors in the effort to develop sustainable, low or even
zero emission buildings (EPIA 2010, 2011; EPIA-Greenpeace 2011; Fthenakis and
Bulawka 2004; Rigby et al. 2011; Šúri et al. 2007).
International Energy Agency (IEA) calculations showed that if 4% of the world’s
very dry desert areas were used for PV installations, the world’s total primary energy
demand could be met. Following this report and considering the fact that are huge
free areas without any use; the untapped potential is already very high. These vast
areas, such as but not limited to roofs, building surfaces, fallow land, and desert,
could be used to support solar power generation (EPIA 2011; EPIA-Greenpeace
2011; Greenpeace 2008; IEA 2003, 2010a; JRC 2010; Šúri et al. 2007).
Summary
The solar energy that reaches the earth exceeds by far humankind’s needs and
other energy sources such as geothermic or tidal energy, nuclear power, and fossil
fuels. Solar energy is a renewable and sustainable form of energy. Solar irradiance
1104 C.S. Psomopoulos
includes infrared radiation and thus provides adequate energy to operate solar
thermal technologies requiring reduced solar energy. This way, many regions of the
world have enough solar irradiance to utilize solar heating and cooling technologies.
Most of the developing and some of the developed countries lie within the tropical
belt of the world where the solar radiation is higher. Technologies requiring
higher irradiation are suitable for these regions, providing significant utilization
potential for both solar heating/cooling applications and solar electricity through
concentrating solar power and photovoltaics. A significant part of these regions
are also semi-arid or desert, allowing the implementation of large-scale facilities,
and thus potential utilization is highly increased, since these areas are commonly
vast, with small inclinations and high temperatures, and almost no seasonal changes
in solar irradiation. These areas present the potential to cover significant part of
their needs in heating, cooling, and electricity. Electricity production could be
high enough to allow significant exports also. The benefits from harvesting the
sun’s energy are enormous: the use of fossil fuels can be significantly reduced,
resulting significant reductions in greenhouse gas emissions; electricity networks
can be strengthened and improved by implementing both solar thermal electricity
and PV; energy security is greatly increased as the consumption of fossil fuels
is reduced and thus the existing quantities can last longer. The widespread use
of solar heating and cooling as well and small-scale PVs can reduce the living
costs in the domestic sector, while in a more general approach the utilization of
sun energy reduces directly and instantly the energy costs in every activity. Local
communities can be benefit through jobs and income creation from solar energy
implementation. Increased environmental and economic benefits, along with the
social benefits, prove the role of the sun’s energy in a sustainable future. But this
future requires more than the sun’s energy to become reality. Sustainable production
and consumption, use of the energy from wind and biomass, sustainable water
management and sustainable engineering education, are only part of what it is
required in addition to sun’s energy harvesting.
7 Cross-References
References
3TIER, Global solar irradiance map (2012), http://www.3tier.com/static/ttcms/us/images/support/
maps/3tier solar irradiance.pdf
D. Arvizu, P. Balaya, L. Cabeza, T. Hollands, A. Jäger-Waldau, M. Kondo, C. Konseibo,
V. Meleshko, W. Stein, Y. Tamaura, H. Xu, R. Zilles, Direct solar energy, in IPCC Special
Report on Renewable Energy Sources and Climate Change Mitigation, ed. by O. Edenhofer,
R. Pichs-Madruga, Y. Sokona, K. Seyboth, P. Matschoss, S. Kadner, T. Zwickel, P. Eickemeier,
G. Hansen, S. Schlömer, C.V. Stechow (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2011a).
Figure 3.7
D. Arvizu, P. Balaya, L. Cabeza, T. Hollands, A. Jäger-Waldau, M. Kondo, C. Konseibo,
V. Meleshko, W. Stein, Y. Tamaura, H. Xu, R. Zilles, Direct solar energy, in IPCC Special
Report on Renewable Energy Sources and Climate Change Mitigation, ed. by O. Edenhofer,
R. Pichs-Madruga, Y. Sokona, K. Seyboth, P. Matschoss, S. Kadner, T. Zwickel, P. Eickemeier,
G. Hansen, S. Schlömer, C.V. Stechow (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2011b).
Figure 3.3a
D. Arvizu, P. Balaya, L. Cabeza, T. Hollands, A. Jäger-Waldau, M. Kondo, C. Konseibo,
V. Meleshko, W. Stein, Y. Tamaura, H. Xu, R. Zilles, Direct solar energy, in IPCC Special
Report on Renewable Energy Sources and Climate Change Mitigation, ed. by O. Edenhofer,
R. Pichs-Madruga, Y. Sokona, K. Seyboth, P. Matschoss, S. Kadner, T. Zwickel, P. Eickemeier,
G. Hansen, S. Schlömer, C.V. Stechow (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2011c).
Figure 3.3b
D. Arvizu, P. Balaya, L. Cabeza, T. Hollands, A. Jäger-Waldau, M. Kondo, C. Konseibo,
V. Meleshko, W. Stein, Y. Tamaura, H. Xu, R. Zilles, Direct solar energy, in IPCC Special
Report on Renewable Energy Sources and Climate Change Mitigation, ed. by O. Edenhofer,
R. Pichs-Madruga, Y. Sokona, K. Seyboth, P. Matschoss, S. Kadner, T. Zwickel, P. Eickemeier,
G. Hansen, S. Schlömer, C.V. Stechow (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2011d).
Figure 3.3c
D. Arvizu, P. Balaya, L. Cabeza, T. Hollands, A. Jäger-Waldau, M. Kondo, C. Konseibo,
V. Meleshko, W. Stein, Y. Tamaura, H. Xu, R. Zilles, Direct solar energy, in IPCC Special
Report on Renewable Energy Sources and Climate Change Mitigation, ed. by O. Edenhofer,
R. Pichs-Madruga, Y. Sokona, K. Seyboth, P. Matschoss, S. Kadner, T. Zwickel, P. Eickemeier,
G. Hansen, S. Schlömer, C.V. Stechow (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2011e).
Figure 3.4
European Photovoltaic Industry Association, Global market outlook for PV until 2014 (2010),
http://www.epia.org/fileadmin/EPIA docs /public /Global Market Outlook for Photovoltaics
until 2014.pdf
European Photovoltaic Industry Association, Global market outlook for PV until 2015 (2011),
http://www.epia.org /fileadmin /EPIA docs/public/Global Market Outlook for Photovoltaics
until 2015.pdf
European Photovoltaic Industry Association – Greenpeace, Solar generation. Solar photovoltaic
electricity empowering the world (2011), http://www.epia.org/EPIA docs/documents/SG6/
Solar Generation 6 2011 Full report Final.pdf
European Solar Thermal Electricity Association, Concentrated solar power technology (2012a),
http://www.estelasolar.eu/index.php?id=25
European Solar Thermal Electricity Association, Parabolic troughs (2012b), http://www.
estelasolar.eu/index.php?id=26
European Solar Thermal Electricity Association, Fresnel (2012c), http://www.estelasolar.eu/index.
php?id=27
European Solar Thermal Electricity Association, Tower technology (2012d), http://www.
estelasolar.eu/index.php?id=29
European Solar Thermal Electricity Association, Dish stirling (2012e), http://www.estelasolar.eu/
index.php?id=28
1106 C.S. Psomopoulos
ESTIF, Solar Thermal Markets in Europe, Trends and Market Statistics 2010 (ESTIF, Brussels,
2011). European Solar Thermal Technology Platform
ESTTP, Solar Heating and Cooling for a Sustainable Energy Future in Europe (ESTTP, Brussels,
2007)
EUROBSERV’ER, Photovoltaic barometer, April 2012 (2012a), http://www.eurobserv-er.org/pdf/
baro208.asp
EUROBSERV’ER, Solar thermal and concentrated solar power barometer, May 2012 (2012b),
http://www.eurobserv-er.org/pdf/baro209-ST H.pdf
EU-SETIS, Information system for the European strategic energy technology plan (2012a), http://
setis.ec.europa.eu/newsroom-items-folder/concentrated-solar-power-technology-information-
sheet/at download/Document/CSP final.pdf
EU-SETIS, Information system for the European strategic energy technology plan (2012b), http://
setis.ec.europa.eu/newsroom-items-folder/concentrated-solar-power-generation/at download/
Document/ConcentratedSolarPower.pdf
EU-SETIS, Solar heating and cooling (2012c), http://setis.ec.europa.eu/technologies/Solar-
heating-and-cooling/info
V.M. Fthenakis, A.O. Bulawka, Environmental Impact of Photovoltaics, Encyclopedia of Energy,
vol. 5 (Elsevier, Amsterdam, Boston, 2004), pp. 61–69
Greenpeace, Implementing the Energy [R]evolution, ed. by S. Teske (Greenpeace International,
Amsterdam, 2008)
Greenpeace International, SolarPACES and Estela, Concentrating Solar Power Global Outlook 09
(Greenpeace International, Amsterdam, 2009)
H.-M. Henning, E. Wiemken, Solar cooling, in ISES Solar World Congress, Beijing, China, 2007
IEA, International Energy Agency, Energy from the desert, feasibility of very large scale
photovoltaic power generation (VLS-PV) systems, IEA-PVPS Task 8, 2003
IEA, Renewable energy essentials: solar heating and cooling (OECD/IEA, Paris, 2009). http://
www.iea.org/papers/2009/Solar heating cooling.pdf.
IEA, World Energy Outlook 2010 (OECD/IEA, Paris, 2010a)
IEA, Technology Roadmap, Concentrating Solar Power (OECD/IEA, Paris, 2010b)
IEA, Solar Energy Technology Perspectives (OECD/IEA, Paris, 2011)
IEA/OECD, International Energy Agency, Technology Roadmap, Solar Heating and Cooling
(International Energy Agency, Paris, 2012). http://www.iea.org/publications/freepublications/
publication/2012 SolarHeatingCooling Roadmap FINAL WEB.pdf
IPCC, in IPCC Special Report on Renewable Energy Sources and Climate Change Mitigation.
Prepared by Working Group III of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, ed.
by O. Edenhofer, R. Pichs-Madruga, Y. Sokona, K. Seyboth, P. Matschoss, S. Kadner, T.
Zwickel, P. Eickemeier, G. Hansen, S. Schlömer, C. von Stechow (Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge/New York, 2011), pp. 1075
JRC, The JRC ‘PV status report 2010’ (2010), http://re.jrc.ec.europa.eu/refsys/pdf/PV%20reports/
PV%20Report%202010.pdf
A.T. Kearney, European solar thermal electricity association, solar thermal electricity
2025 (2010). http://www.estelasolar.eu/fileadmin/ESTELAdocs/documents/Cost Roadmap/
2010-06-29 - Press Release ATK-ESTELA - ENG.pdf
S.C.W. Krauter, Solar Electric Power Generation – Photovoltaic Energy Systems (Springer,
Berlin/Heidelberg/New York, 2006), http://www.springerlink.com/content/978-3-540-31345-
8/contents/
H.K.V. Lotsch, A. Goetzberger, V.U. Hoffmann, Photovoltaic Solar Energy Generation
(Springer, Berlin/New York, 2005). doi:10.1007/b137803
A. Luque, S. Hegedus, Handbook of Photovoltaic Science and Engineering, 1st edn. (Wiley,
Hoboken, 2003), p. 1138
D. Mugnier, U. Jakob, Keeping cool with the Sun. Int. Sustain. Energy Rev. 6(1), 28–30
M.R. Patel, Wind and solar power systems (CRC, Boca Raton, 1999)
C. Philibert, Barriers to technology diffusion: the case of solar thermal technologies. OECD/IEA
information paper, Paris, 2006
56 Solar Energy: Harvesting the Sun’s Energy for Sustainable Future 1107
Abstract
Wind farms have seen their extreme growth and development since the signing
of the Kyoto protocol. In 5 years (2007–2011) the capacities have more than
tripled. In 2011, about 75 countries worldwide had commercial wind power
installations, and 22 countries in the world already have more than 1,000 MW
of installed capacities. Europe has also seen an increase of offshore markets.
This is mainly related to the UK, Denmark, and Belgium. When the shares of
production technologies for electricity production are analyzed, the proportion of
the use of wind energy in the world is 2.2%. With the development of technology,
technical characteristics of wind turbines and wind parks have significantly
improved. Special attention is nowadays paid to those elements of wind turbines
that showed certain shortcomings during the previous period, i.e., transmission
mechanisms, generators, blades, etc. The availability of the present wind turbines
is 98%, and the level of utilization is constantly increased, as well as the
economic life with the modern machines that are nowadays projected for 25-year
time period. There is currently an intensive work underway on new construction
designs.
Wind turbine economics are changing rapidly, because of the new turbine
producers, expansion of wind energy, initiatives for RES, etc. Nevertheless, it
can be concluded that the price of electricity generated from wind farms becomes
more and more comparable with the price of electrical energy produced from
“conventional” fossil fuels. However, the only cases where they are completely
comparable are the very large wind parks that are located at places with excellent
wind characteristics.
Central critical points of some wind turbine project are turbine purchase
contract, financing, liquidity, wind turbine repair, and annual variations of
E. Zlomusica
University Dzemal Bijedic of Mostar, Mostar, Bosnia and Herzegovina
e-mail: elvir.zlomusica@unmo.ba
wind climate. Also, other factors affect the economics of wind farm, including
depreciation, income taxes, and initiatives.
Wind turbines have some negative as well as positive impacts on the envi-
ronment. Benefits of wind energy are different and very important. Experience
in the implementation of wind projects in the EU shows that social acceptance
is very important for the successful development of wind energy. Three key
dimensions of social acceptance have been identified: community acceptance,
market acceptance, and sociopolitical acceptance. The chapter presents the state
of the art, design, wind turbine parts, efficiency, emissions, and economic
analysis on these issues.
1 Introduction
The first attempts at generation of electrical energy from wind date back to the end
of the nineteenth and the beginning of the twentieth century (James Blyth, Scotland,
Charles F. Brush, Cleveland, USA, Poul la Cour, Denmark, etc.).
This was followed by a long time period with a huge number of different
construction designs of wind turbines. Among others, it was noted that in 1940
in Vermont (USA), air-profile blades were introduced in the construction of wind
turbines (Smith-Puntam).
Big energy crises in 1970s placed the wind turbines more in the spotlight.
A period with different construction solutions (single-blade, double-blade, three-
bladed, horizontal, vertical, and other wind turbines) ensued. An aspiration was
toward big dimensions and powers. Some of those solutions were more; others were
less successful. Some of them were very expensive. In any case, the construction
technology did not sufficiently go hand in hand with the constructive elements
design.
EU was the first one to recognize the possibilities and the importance of
renewable energy sources, the energy of the wind among them. Thus, EU was the
first to set its goals in mid-1990s. Until now, these goals have been fulfilled every
time by the set deadlines. On the other hand, the goals set at the beginning of the new
millennium (Directive 2001/77/EC) have been a subject of intensive discussions for
a number of years already. In 2008, the biggest number of capacity was added in the
wind energy for the first time in EU.
Wind farms have seen their extreme growth and development since the signing
of the Kyoto protocol (1997), Fig. 57.1. In some countries and/or their parts, this
growth is comparable even with the development of mobile telephony.
At that time, Denmark set up an example of its own. One can say that Denmark
found itself “at the right time at the right place.” So, even today Danish companies
are bigger producers of wind turbines in the world. As an example, almost 26% of
the electric energy supply in Denmark comes from the energy of the wind (Wind
in Power 2011) (38% in January 2007 or according to the information from the
system operator web site, in the morning of 13 September 2011, the wind turbines
in Denmark generated 64% of total electricity production).
57 Wind 1111
10,000 50,000
Cumulative MW
8,000 40,000
MW per year
6,000 30,000
4,000 20,000
2,000 10,000
0 0
1983 1990 1995 2000 2005
Source: BTM Consult ApS - March 2006 Year
Among other countries, one should especially mention Germany, which, in 2008,
had the biggest number of installed capacities in the world. Namely, in these
countries, the space resources for installing the wind parks are almost completely
exhausted. They are setting their future goals on the basis of repowering and opening
of offshore markets.
At the end 2011, wind farms with a the total of 238,351 MW were installed
throughout the world (Global Wind Statistics 2012). For the sake of comparison, in
2006 there were 74,052 MW installed, Fig. 57.2. So, in 5 years the capacities have
more than tripled. Thus, all realistic expectations were surpassed. If it is looked at
the values from 11 years ago (18,000 MW in the year 2000), the results are even
more significant. Globally, the ten countries with the most installed wind capacity
are shown in Table 57.1. For the first time, in 2011, Denmark is not among the
top 10.
By the end of 2002, 75% installed capacities were in Europe, 15% in USA, and
10% in the rest of the world. In 2006 the data was as follows: 65% in Europe,
15.6% in USA, and 19.4% in the rest of the world (with a significant share of
India with 6,270 MW or 8.4% and China with 2,604 MW or 3.5%). Therefore, that
proportion has changed and keeps changing, so that in 2011 in Europe there was
1112 E. Zlomusica
250,000 [MW]
200,000
150,000
100,000
50,000
0
1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
6,100 7,600 10,200 13,600 17,400 23,900 31,100 39,431 47,620 59,091 74,052 93,820 120,291 158,864 197,637 238,351
Fig. 57.2 Capacities installed in the world on 1996–2011 (Global Wind Statistics 2012)
40.5%; in Asia, 34.6% (26.3% in China, 6.7% in India); and in USA, 19.7% installed
capacities of total installed capacities in the world. Of total capacities added in 2011,
China installed 44%.
Today, about 75 countries worldwide have commercial wind power installations.
There are 22 countries in the world already, of which in Europe as many as 15
countries, with more than 1,000 MW of installed capacities. Five years ago, this
was 13 countries, of which 8 in Europe. As far as Europe is concerned, Germany
and Spain have more than 50% of total installed capacities (Wind in Power 2011).
In the EU, 9,616 MW of wind energy capacity was installed in 2011, for a total
installed capacity of 93,957 MW – enough to supply 6.3% of the EU’s electricity,
according to the European Wind Energy Association (EWEA).
Thanks to the 16,500 MW added in 2010, a few years before the estimates were
made, China took over the first position by installed capacities from the USA,
and the USA took over that place from Germany in 2008. In 2011 China added
“incredible” approx. 18,000 MW. Also, China has considerable plans in the next
period, 100 GW by the year 2020 (China Increases Its Wind Power 2009; China
Boosts Wind Power Target to 100 GW by 2020). Also, in 2010 China became the
world’s largest producer of wind turbines.
57 Wind 1113
30%
28% Approximate Wind Penetration, end of 2010
Estimated Wind Electricity as a Proportion of
20%
18%
16%
14%
12%
10%
8%
6%
4%
2%
0%
U.S.
Netherlands
Denmark
Germany
Portugal
Sweden
Australia
Ireland
Greece
France
Poland
canada
Turkey
TOTAL
Spain
China
Brazil
Japan
India
Italy
UK
Source: Berkeley lab estimates based on data from BTM Consult, EIA, and elsewhere
Fig. 57.3 Top 20 countries using the wind energy (2010 Wind Technologies Market Report)
Europe has also seen an increase of offshore markets. This is mainly related
to the UK, Denmark, and Belgium (Wind in Power 2011). EU has set its goals
for RES by 2020. Specific values have been set for each EU member country.
As for the energy of the wind, the estimates and forecasts are both different and
optimistic (180–230 GW). This implies creation of over 2,000,000 new jobs in this
sector by 2020. These optimistic goals can be achieved by intensifying offshore
markets and by opening offshore parks, the implementation of which is currently
below expectations.
Figure 57.3 shows 20 countries that use the wind energy for electricity generation
the most. As previously said, Denmark is in the first place and is followed by
other European countries (Portugal, Spain, Ireland, Germany, etc.), while the first
non-European country taking the tenth place is India. According to the diagram in
Fig. 57.3, and according to the other available data, when the shares are analyzed of
production technologies for electricity production, the proportion of the use of wind
energy in the world is 2.2%.
90
80
70
60
50
40
30 Rotor Diameter
20 Hub Height
10
0
COD: 1998-99 2000-01 2002-03 2004-05 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Turbines: 1,418 1,982 1,686 1,942 1,515 3,190 5,004 5,733 2,855
Capacity: 1,014 MW 1,756 MW 2,080 MW 2,779 MW 2,440 MW 5,249 MW 8,348 MW 9,993 MW 5,113 MW
Fig. 57.4 Increase in rotor diameter and hub height (2010 Wind Technologies Market Report)
18%
Domestic Regional Global
16% Supplier Supplier Supplier
14%
Global Market Share
12%
VESTAS (DK)
2%
0%
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
Fig. 57.5 Top 10 wind turbine market share in 2010 (BTM Consult 2010)
Wind turbines have some negative as well as positive impacts on the environment.
The possible negative impacts of wind turbines are visual impact, noise, bird and
bat kills, shadow effect and pollution during manufacturing and installing the wind
turbines, land use, electromagnetic interference, marine mammals, etc. A number
of studies have concluded these impacts are minor or easy to avoid (Boyle 2004).
Wind turbines are highly visible elements with rotating blades in the landscape.
In flat areas often wind turbines are placed in simple geometrical layout, and in hilly
areas better layout is the turbines follow the altitude contours of the landscape. Big
wind turbines with low blade rotation speed and similar size and type fit better in
the surrounding than bigger number of small turbines with higher rotation speed, in
terms of their visual effect as an environmental factor.
In Denmark there are several examples of birds nesting in cages mounted on
wind turbine towers. Some birds get accustomed to wind turbines very quickly;
others take a somewhat longer time. A number of studies (including offshore wind
farms) have concluded that birds almost always modify their migratory routes,
but migratory routes of birds should be taken into account when siting wind
turbines.
Wind turbines cast a shadow on the neighboring area when the sun is visible.
The rotor blades cause a flickering (blinking) effect while the rotor is in motion.
1116 E. Zlomusica
Table 57.2 Emissions avoided using wind farms to produce electricity (Environmental issues
2009)
Emissions Benefits
Average wind
(onshore and Hard
offshore) coal Lignite NGCC vs. coal vs. lignite vs. NGCC
CO2 , fossil (g) 8 836 1; 060 400 828 1; 051 391
SF6 , fossil (mg) 8 2; 554 244 993 2; 546 236 984
NOx (mg) 31 1; 309 1; 041 353 1; 278 1; 010 322
NMVOC (mg) 6 71 8 129 65 3 123
Particulates (mg) 15 147 711 12 134 693 6
SO2 (mg) 32 1; 548 3; 808 149 1; 515 3; 777 118
Source: CIEMAT
In Germany the judge tolerated 30 h of shadow flicker per year. Also, there are
possibilities of computing a shadow map.
The energy balance of wind energy is very positive. The energy consumed in the
whole chain of wind plants is recovered in several average operational months.
Environmental benefits of wind electricity can be assessed in terms of avoided
emissions compared to other alternative electricity generation technologies (CO2 ,
SO2 , NOx , and other pollutants). Emissions avoided using wind farms to produce
electricity instead of coal or natural gas power plants are quantified in Table 57.2
(NGCC – natural gas combined cycle, NMVOC – nonmethane volatile organic
compounds). The CO2 emissions related to the manufacture, installation, and
servicing over the average 20-year life cycle of a wind turbine are offset after a
mere 3–6 months of operation, resulting in net CO2 savings thereafter.
Wind energy also avoids significant amounts of external costs of conventional
fossil fuel-based electricity generation.
Windmills, wind turbines, or devices for conversion of wind energy into mechanical
work can be classified according to various criteria. The most common is accord-
ing to:
• Aerodynamics
• Rotor axis position
According to the aerodynamic impact, they can be divided into those using:
• Resistance
• Uplift force
• Combination
One way to classify wind turbines is in terms of the axis around which the turbine
blades rotate:
• Horizontal axis wind turbine (HAWT)
• Vertical axis wind turbine (VAWT)
57 Wind 1117
a b
Wind Wind
Most modern wind turbines are horizontal axis wind turbines of upwind type,
Fig. 57.6.
In the recent decades construction development concept of wind turbines,
influenced mainly by technological-technical factors, has been developing in several
lines (Gasch and Twele). The best concept proved to be the Danish one, or
the concept of horizontal three-bladed wind turbine with transmitter-multiplicator.
Attempts to apply the wind turbine concept with one- or two-bladed rotor have not
been successful so far.
6 Wind Power
Wind turbines transform kinetic wind energy into mechanical work, so it should start
from the kinetic energy expression, proportional to the multiplication of mass (m)
and squared wind speed (v/.
1
E D m v2 (57.1)
2
Since the power is a product of energy divided by time, it is
1
Pv D P v2
m (57.2)
2
m
P D vA (57.3)
1
Pv D A v3 (57.4)
2
1118 E. Zlomusica
For standard meteorological conditions at the temperature of 15ı C and the pressure
of 1,013.3 hPa, air density is 1,225 kg/m3 . Table 57.3 shows the power per meter of
cross section (W/m2 ) for different wind speeds, a quantity that is called the specific
power or power density.
Kinetic wind energy turns into mechanical work at the rotor blades, which is the
result of lowering of the wind speed due to the impact of wind against the rotor
level.
It is normal that the entire wind energy cannot be used at the rotor, i.e., air
flow cannot be stopped. Thus, in the expression (57.4) the coefficient of power of
aerodynamic transformation Cp , it needs to be added, and its value is going to be
discussed further:
1
Pv D A v3 Cp (57.5)
2
Wind turbines use kinetic wind energy for getting of needed power to start an
electric power generator. Depending on constructive solutions, there are several
types of wind turbines, a horizontal one being the most widely used (rotor axe is
parallel to horizontal line).
In theoretical studies of aerodynamic characteristics of wind turbines, the turbine
is replaced by an ideal one that represents a circular discontinuous area of pressure.
That is the simplest aerodynamic wind turbine model, so-called Rankine-Froude
disc model. This model is also known as the actuator disc model. Rotor is shown as
a rotating disc with infinite number of immeasurably thin blades whose resistance
57 Wind 1119
i
e
ni np
ne
pi pe
Fig. 57.7 Diagram of streamlines, speeds, and pressures for an idealized wind flow through the
wind turbine rotor (Technical Encyclopedia 10 1982)
equals zero and whose tip speed is higher than the wind speed. This model assumes a
sudden drop of pressure at the rotor disc. Flow speed is constant in radial direction,
changing slowly from the period prior to the blade impact to the one after blade
impact. It is calculated that flow speed remains the same beyond the flow boundaries.
Thus, an ideal wind turbine is a mathematical discontinuous surface of pressures
through which the wind flows at a constant speed, without any friction or whirls.
Figure 57.7 shows a diagram of streamlines, speed, and pressures for idealized
airflow through the rotor of a wind turbine with a horizontal axis. External
streamlines turn toward edges in the rotor zone, due to obstacles. They go around
rotor and do not take part in energy transformation. Sections i i and e e are
placed far enough from the rotor. The wind power at the rotor is
F D m
P .vi ve / (57.6)
where m P (kg/s) is a flow of air mass through a control volume, and vi and ve (m/s)
are wind speeds in the sections i i and e e. By evening power absorbed by an
ideal rotor with change of kinetic wind energy in its flow through the control volume
limited by the sections i i and e e, formula is taken from
v2i v2e
P D F vp D m (57.7)
2
1120 E. Zlomusica
v2i v2e
P .vi ve / vp D m
m (57.8)
2
vi C ve
vp D (57.9)
2
m
P D Avp (57.10)
It can be written as
vi C ve
m
P D A (57.11)
2
By adding the expression (57.11) into the expression (57.7), the result is
1
P D A .vi C ve /.v2i v2e / (57.12)
4
8
27
A v3i 16
Cp max D 1
D or 59:3%
2
A v3i 27
This regularity was formulated by the German physicist Albert Betz in 1919, and
it called Betz’s law which says that a maximum of 59.3% of kinetic wind energy
can be turned into mechanical energy. Of course, due to different kinds of losses of
wind turbines, this level is lower today and its maximum is 50%.
The best constructive solution is a lift-based wind turbine with a rotor placed on the
front (upwind) side of the tower and which is parallel to the horizontal line, Fig.57.8.
For that reason, mostly this type of turbine will be taken into consideration.
In this section will be discussed. These main parts are:
57 Wind 1121
Blade
Gearbox
Generator
Wind Nacelle
Yaw drive
Tower
Foundation
• Rotor
• Gearbox
• Generator
• Regulation system
• Tower
• Foundation
Figure 57.8 shows the basic functional parts of a horizontal wind turbine.
Figure 57.9 shows basic components and functional elements of Vestas turbine
V90-3.0 MW, and more details on this type can be found in the Table 57.4.
Table 57.4 shows the main characteristics of some types of wind turbines that
can be found on the market.
9 Rotor
Wind turbine rotor is made of certain number of blades connected to the shaft
through hubs. Rotor speed is one of the main project parameters of any wind turbine.
Since the wind turbine power equals a multiplication of rotor torque and rotor speed
P D M D M 2n; (57.14)
it can be concluded that the power will increase with increased force – load on
the rotor blade, e.g., higher wind speed and longer rotor diameter. Since the wind
1122 E. Zlomusica
17
16
14
6 13
10
5 8 11
1
7
9 12 15
speed cannot be affected, longer rotor diameter might be a solution. Limits are
technological and mechanical characteristics of equipment and material.
A very significant parameter for aerodynamic designing of rotor blades is tip
speed ratio. It represents ratio of the rotor blade tip speed and the wind speed (value
of so-called undisturbed streamline):
2nR R
D D (57.15)
v1 v1
Also, the formula proves that rotor speed can be connected to the tip speed ratio.
Wind turbines with a small number of rotation have a low (ca 1), with a high start
torque. For these reasons it comes to a bigger number of blades and, consequently,
a high rotor thrust. A typical example is American windmill with 20–30 blades,
Fig. 57.10. Wind turbines with D 5 8 have no such problems, and they have
just few tall and well-shaped blades. Another reason for usage of rotors with a small
57 Wind
Table 57.4 Characteristics of wind turbines (Wind Turbine Market 2005, 2007, nordex.de)
Type Enercon E-70 Nordex N80 Repower 5M Vestas V90/3 MW
Hub height 57/64/85/98/113 m 60/80/100/115 m (lattice) 100/120 m onshore 80/105 m
Rated power (kW) 2,300 2,500 5,000 3,000
Tower construction Concrete, tubular steel Conical tubular steel, lattice Conical tubular steel Conical tubular steel
Tower weight 140/232/336/1,171 t 115/193/281/205 t 175/275 t
Nacelle weight (t) 66 86 290 70
Cut-in wind speed (m/s) 2.5 4 3.5 4
Rated wind speed (m/s) 13.5 15 13 15
Cut-out wind speed (m/s) 28–34 25 25 25
Rotor blade type 3 E-70/4 LM 38.8/or/NR 40 3 LM 61.5 RISÖ P + FFA-W3
Rotor diameter (m) 71 80 126 90
Swept area (m2 ) 3,959 5,026 12,469 6,362
Rotor speed (rpm) 6–21.5 10.9–19.1 6.9–12.1 8.6–18.4
Blade tip speed (m/s) 22–80 80 80 75.7
Blade weight (kg) 6,000 8,700 19,000 6,600
Rotor speed control Variable by MC-System Variable by MC-System Variable by MC-System OptiSpeedTM
Overspeed control Pitch Pitch Elec. pitch, independent blade feathering Pitch
(continued)
1123
1124
number of blades is their high price. Costs of three-blade rotor represent about 20%
of total costs of a wind turbine.
Also, sound level is in relation to the tip speed ratio. Number of revolution of
a rotor is regulated with a favorable aerodynamic system, which will be also more
discussed later.
10 Blades
Basic function of blades is to turn kinetic energy of wind into mechanical work
needed for rotation of rotor. Today’s blade types are designed aerodynamically so
they can be moved by uplift force. The most widely used are three-bladed rotors.
1126 E. Zlomusica
11 Gearbox
Gearbox is fixed between the main shaft and the generator. It is one of the most
important wind turbine components. Its main function is multiplication of rotation
number of the main shaft which does not exceed 100 min1 to the speed required by
the generator, which is, depending on the generator type, usually about 1,500 min1 .
For different types of wind turbines, there are different transmission relations and
different power of gearboxes. The most frequently used are high ratios, such as
Vestas V90-3 MW which has the ratio 1:104.5.
Gearbox has been very often a problematic component. Lately it has been given
more attention, especially its tribological characteristics, cooling, efficiency, and
lower noise level. Special attention is paid to its control (measurement of noise and
vibrations).
The two main types of gearboxes are those with cylindrical tooth profiles and
planetary ones. Cylindric gearboxes are simple, easier to maintain, and cheaper,
while planetary one is compact, produces less noise, and has lower mass and higher
efficiency, Fig. 57.11.
57 Wind 1127
Today’s modern big turbines have mostly combination of planetary and cylindric
transmission. The first part is planetary and the other two are cylindric.
Some types of wind turbines (direct drive working at low rotor speeds) have no
gearbox.
12 Generator
Today’s turbines use often so-called Danish concept. That implies directly con-
nected asynchronous generator (with cage rotor) to the grid.
Asynchronous generators have different speed of magnet flow rotation and
the rotor. The difference in speed represents sliding. That is a very important
characteristic since it enables more flexible transmission of the rotation torque
and reduces mechanical damage of the teethed transmission. They are connected
to the rotor through gearbox. They are often designed in the form of 2 poles and
1,500 min1 . Its advantages are:
• Simple primary electric power equipment, since asynchronous generator is not
excited and has less demanding cage rotor.
• It has no equipment for excitement and synchronization.
• It uses less demanding equipment for connecting to the grid, as well as protection
and program management.
Disadvantages of this generator type are:
• It spends inductive reactive power from the grid or compensation plant.
• Gearbox overloaded.
• It is not suitable for independent running.
57 Wind 1129
Modern wind turbines lately use more and more double-feed wounded rotors.
Selection of a certain type of generator for specific wind turbine depends partially
on application of desired outgoing characteristics and the cost.
13 Regulating System
Regulating system includes all the wind turbine systems which manage mechanical
components. They can be divided into:
• Yawing system
• System for aerodynamic regulation of the rotor speed
• System for mechanical and aerodynamic braking
• Control and management system
Yawing system turns the housing (nacelle) and consequently rotor according to
the wind direction, aiming at adjustment of rotor running. Older types of turbines
and today’s small turbines (battery chargers, etc.) do that by means of rosette or
wind vane. Today’s huge horizontal wind turbines usually solve that through electric
engine or hydraulic transmission whose final teeth is linked with a teethed ring fitted
between the housing and the tower (transmission ratio is high and reaches a value of
up to 4,000). This system prevents sudden turns of housing in a situation of quickly
changing wind directions.
Based on the data measured at the met station on the top of the housing, controller
orders turning of the housing (at the speed of ca 1ı /s) for a given angle in relation to
the horizontal line. The housing is stopped in a needed position, thanks to specially
designed brakes.
In case of high wind speed, dangerous for some components or the entire
wind turbine, this system is used for braking, together with the whole system for
aerodynamic regulation of speed of the rotor revolving.
System for aerodynamic regulation of the rotor speed. Wind turbines are designed
to provide a maximum (nominal) power at the wind speeds of about 15 m/s
(depending of the type and producers). Wind turbine designer designs it for these
speeds since high wind speeds are rare and can damage turbine structure. That
means that a favorable system of regulation needs to solve rotor speed as well.
System for aerodynamic regulation of rotor speed (power) can be designed in
two ways:
• Passive control (stall)
• Active control (pitch, active stall)
Both principles have pros and contras. In regulation by passive stall, blades are
fastened with screws to the rotor hub. At higher wind speed, the angle of attack of
the wind is increased, which further causes turbulence and reduction of lift force and
increase of resistance, Fig. 57.13. All this leads towards decreasing rotation torque
and power.
Advantages of this system are:
• Simpler system without movable parts and complex control systems
• Lower price
1130 E. Zlomusica
v = 8 m/s
v = 24 m/s
Disadvantages are:
• In some cases too heavy dynamic thrust on the rotor due to aerodynamic forces.
• Less usable nominal turbine power. Power starts to decrease slowly when it
reaches its nominal value. It is impossible to sustain a stable output, Fig. 57.14.
Today this system is used for low-power (small size) turbines.
57 Wind 1131
v
v = 8 m/s
v = 24 m/s
Regulation with turning of blades has two ways: pitch and active stall. The
entire blade turns around its axis for a certain angle, depending on the wind speed,
Fig. 57.15. At the high wind speed, blades turn so that wind attack increases, which
decreases aerodynamic forces on the blades and consequently on the wind turbine
rotor.
Pitch mechanism driven by hydraulic engine will perform turning of the rotor
blade to a desirable angle, depending on the wind direction change, in order to
maximize output for a specific speed.
In addition to adjustment of speed, the system can serve to stop the rotation, by
bringing blades into a position where flow breaks down on the back side of blades.
Basic advantages are less loaded rotor, Fig. 57.16, which leads to a possibility to
reduce material and mass in the basic structure. This system is also more flexible
and efficient as compared to the stall regulation. Its disadvantage is high cost and
possible stalls (special design of the shaft, hub, bearings, etc.)
The first generation of pitch regulation had a central system for simultaneous
turning of all blades. For the reason of different wind speeds at different heights
and consequently different loads, possibility of turning of each blade separately has
been introduced later. Along with other improvements, better usability is obtained,
safety, etc.
Active stall regulation is increasingly used in today’s big megawatt turbines,
Fig. 57.17. It is like pitch regulation, since blades turn around their longitude axis
1132 E. Zlomusica
too. At low wind speed, in this regulation, blade turns around its axis just like in
pitch regulation. When a set power is reached, the blade starts turning in the opposite
direction in comparison to pitch regulation. This form of regulation enables more
precise regulation than in pitch, and it is simpler and avoids some aerodynamic
problems that appear in pitch regulation.
System of Mechanical and Aerodynamic Braking. System of mechanical braking
represents an obligatory component of wind turbines. It has disc brakes hydrauli-
cally driven. They are fixed at the generator shaft, because of its lower torque at the
teeth and its turning mechanism.
In addition to mechanical braking, there are aerodynamic brakes in rotor blades.
Blades which have pitch regulation system, it functions as an aerodynamic brake by
means of slow (gradual) increase of resistance force and decreased torque.
Control and management system aims at maintaining the turbine within an
operating range, i.e., it regulates and controls internal components of a wind turbine
57 Wind 1133
and connects them with external systems. That means limiting of rotor speed, torque,
power, and rotor thrust, which is especially related to high-speed wind.
The system processes all the data needed for wind turbine operating (wind
speed, wind direction, cooling device temperature, air humidity, rotor thrust, various
control signals, etc.) and sends the signals to the central processing unit which
manages components of all regulation systems.
14 Tower
Tower is the most massive and after rotor the biggest component of a wind turbine.
In the course of time and development of turbines, various mast and tower types
have been tested. Tower of horizontal wind turbine is usually tubular and conic in
structure, in order to increase its bearing capacity and reduce material cost. Tubular
towers have a low aerodynamic resistance, maintenance is simple, they are tall
and elegant, and their mounting is quick and simple. They are made of steel and
concrete.
A less common structure is lattice. Recently tubular structures are made in several
segments, for easier transport and technical conditions of mounting.
Electrical wiring is placed inside the tower, as well as stairs and lift to
the housing, controlling units, steering device, measuring equipment, and safety
installation.
Conic tubes are made of steel panels of 40–20 mm thickness and different widths.
After cutting of steel sheets, roll machine makes tubular shape and these sections
are welded by using powder welding technique. After that, welded sections are
connected by circular welding into bigger sections of 20–30 m and mass of up to
70 t, Fig. 57.18.
What follows is an ultrasound and x-ray control of the welded points, anti-
corrosion protection, and trial assembling section at the locality of the manufac-
turing plant. Then these sections are transported to the locality, mounted by cranes
and joined with bolts.
For a Vestas turbine of V90-3.0 MW, the height of the tower is 105 m, weight
of 285 t, and tower diameter of 3.98–2.3 m. Tower has a significant economic share
in wind turbines. About 20% of the total price goes to the tower, and for towers
higher than 50 m, additional $15,000 is calculated for every additional 10 m. Its
height depends on wind characteristics at the locality and of the rotor dimensions.
When selecting tower height, it is necessary to determine an optimum solution as
compared to the price and outgoing characteristics of electric power from a certain
turbine type.
15 Foundation
Because of the need to install wind farms on complex terrains and in specific wind
conditions, there is a requirement to have special research in these circumstances
and consequently, a special analysis of behavior of the selected equipment in these
conditions.
There is currently an intensive work under way on new construction designs,
for example, the new offshore wind turbine of the company “Vestas” V164 7 MW,
which has a 164 m diameter rotor, which means that it has a size almost like three
football fields (vestas.com).
“Direct drive” wind turbines present another special example; their biggest
manufacturer is German “Enercon.” Their program also includes the development
of a prototype of machine of 7.5 MW with rotor diameter of 127 m, hub height of
135 m, rotational speed of 5–11.7 rpm, and storm control of 28–34 m/s (enercon.de).
It should mention and projects as Sway Turbine AS, 10 MW, (swayturbine.no),
Windtec SeaTitan, 10 MW, (windtec.at), etc.
One of the possible solutions that has been subject of intensive work in the past
years is a shrouded wind turbine, in Fig. 57.20 (flickr.com), that would be much
more efficient than the present “conventional” wind turbines. Either way, it will
certainly take a number of years before the new construction designs are put to
commercial production.
17 Case Study
18 Economic Analysis
Wind turbine economics are changing rapidly, because of the new turbine producers,
expansion of wind energy, initiatives for RES, etc. Wind turbine economics contains
costs and incomes.
• Costs:
• Pre-investment costs
• Investment (capital) costs
• Operation and maintenance (O and M) costs
• Dismantling costs
Pre-investing costs embrace wind potential assessment, technical project de-
velopment, economic project development, feasibility study including wind speed
measurements, turbine selection, and financing.
Investment costs embrace project development, area, financing costs, contract
preparation, wind turbines, grid connection, roads, foundations, cranes for turbine
eraction, installation, and commissioning.
Income in wind park projects:
• Payments for production
• Insurances
• Service interruption
• Break of machinery
• Guarantee payments
• Power curve
• Production guarantees
• Availability
The main incomes are payments for production of electricity of wind park.
Production of wind park depends of wind potential (assessment, long-term behav-
ior), power curve of wind turbines (contract, surveillance), and availability of wind
turbines in wind park (contract, surveillance, fast service), Fig. 57.21. The quality
of the contracts determines the economy of the whole project.
57 Wind 1137
Financing; Project
4% development
Foundation;
,...;5%
5%
Grid
connection;
8%
Turbine
78%
Reserves;
Rents; 20% Maintenance;
5%
59%
Insurance;
7%
Wind farm
management;
9%
price of electrical energy produced from “conventional” fossil fuels. However, the
only cases where they are completely comparable are the very large wind parks
that are located at places with excellent wind characteristics. For offshore wind
parks there is not yet sufficient statistical data. Hence, wind energy projects still
need some financial help (incentives) to come up with market prices, and many
governments provide incentives for wind-produced electricity (kWh). Wind energy
has low contribution of greenhouse gas emission and air pollution, and wind-
generated electricity has a benefit for neutralizing the environmental impact. Also,
other important arguments in favor of wind energy are the industry’s job creation
potential and the security of supply.
Figure 57.24 shows average values of the price of electricity produced in wind
farms during the period 1999–2010. As presented in the diagram in Fig. 57.24, the
data relate to a different number of projects (from 11 to 232) and different number
of installed capacities (from 594 to 17,033 MW).
The rated power of new wind turbines is increased. It means the corresponding
capital cost per kW dropped. The labor required for new (larger) wind turbine is
not much higher than for a smaller one. The cost of a rotor is proportional to
diameter as well as power delivered. Also, taller towers of wind turbine increase
energy faster than cost increase, etc. But, due to the intensifying installation of wind
farms, lower wind speed sites, the use of state-of-the-art technology in the past few
years, discussed above in this chapter and other factors, at the beginning of 2006,
the wind turbines got even more expensive, which, due to the big influence on the
overall cost, also increased the cost of electricity produced in wind parks, Fig. 57.24.
It is difficult to make a realistic forecast of the movement of prices in the future
period for the wind farms, as this involves many influencing factors; it is especially
difficult to make their comparison with fossil fuels. However, there are a lot of such
1140 E. Zlomusica
Fig. 57.24 Cumulative capacity-weighted average wind power prices (2010 Wind Technologies
Market Report)
120
113
101
100
82 79 75
80
68
€/MWh
60
40
20
0
2015. 2030. 2015. 2030. 2015. 2030.
Coal Gas Wind
Fig. 57.25 Electricity generating cost in the EU, 2015 and 2030 (Krohn et al. 2009)
forecasts that are more than optimistic (Van Kuik et al. 2006; World Energy Outlook
2009; International Energy Outlook 2010).
IEA in its review from 2008 assumed price increase of constructive costs of
the newly built plants in EU. The assumed price of emission is $30/t of CO2 plus
$30/MWh of production costs for coal-based plants, while for gas-based plants the
cost is $15/MWh.
Figure 57.25 shows prognoses for electric power production costs in EU for 2015
and 2030 (source: IEA World Energy Outlook 2008). The diagram shows that new
57 Wind 1141
capacities of wind turbines in the period 2015–2030 are expected to have lower
production price in comparison to the coal and gas technologies.
19 Summary
Wind turbines have their extreme growth and development. In 5 years (2007–2011)
the capacities have more than tripled. With the development of technology, technical
characteristics of wind turbines and wind parks have significantly improved. There
is currently an intensive work underway on new construction designs.
Wind turbine economics are changing rapidly, because of the new turbine
producers, expansion of wind energy, initiatives for RES, etc. The generation cost
of wind turbines approaches the cost of coal-fired generation.
Wind turbines have some negative as well as positive impacts on the environment.
Benefits of wind energy are different and very important. Experience in the
implementation of wind projects in the EU shows that social acceptance is very
important for the successful development of wind energy.
References
2010 Wind Technologies Market Report, U.S. Department of Energy
G. Boyle, Renewable Energy, Power for a Sustainable Future (Oxford, 2004). ISBN 0-19-926
178-4
C. Ender, International development of wind energy use – status 31.12.2005, DEWI magazine nr.
29, pp. 38–44, Aug 2006
C. Ender, International development of wind energy use – status 31.12.2007, DEWI magazine nr.
33, pp. 43–53, Aug 2008
C. Ender, International development of wind energy use – status 31.12.2008, DEWI magazine nr.
35, pp. 28–33, Aug 2009
C. Ender, Wind energy use in Germany – status 31.12.2011, DEWI magazine nr. 40, pp. 30–43,
Feb 2012
European Parliament, Directive 2001/77/EC, Renewable energy: the promotion of electricity from
renewable energy sources (2001), http://europa.eu/legislation summaries/energy/renewable
energy/l27035 en.htm. The Kyoto Protocol to the Framework Convention on Climate Change,
http://unfccc.int/essential background/kyoto protocol/items/1678.php
R. Gasch, J. Twele, Wind Power Plants – Fundamentals, Design, Construction and Operation.
(Solarpraxls AG, Berlin (ISBN 3-934595-23-5)/James and James, London (ISBN 1-902916-
38-7))
Global Wind Statistics, 7.2.2012, http://www.gwec.net
http://www.swayturbine.no
http://www.windtec.at
http://www.flickr.com/photos/mass cec/5762452246/
http://www.enercon.de
http://www.nordex.de
http://www.vestas.com
International Energy Agency, World Energy Outlook 2009 (Paris, 2009), p. 128
1142 E. Zlomusica
The increased awareness about global effects on the environment calls for techno-
logical innovations in the materials science field. Considering that the development
of science and technology has centered on materials and energy, it is necessary
to develop human-friendly and environment-conscious materials with excellent
properties and functional performance. In this sense, two global risks are of priority:
weather risk and resource risk. The former risk is attributed to changes in Earth’s
climate, which in turn are due to the continuing rise in the atmospheric concentration
of greenhouse gases by fossil fuel burning. Several ecomaterials and ecoprocesses
have been introduced with the aim of reducing greenhouse gas emissions to a
significant extent. The latter risk is due to the limited number of natural resources
of rare-earth elements and commodity substances. Hence, materials design is being
prioritized in the development of alternative materials. These global problems are
driven by two essential factors: population increase and the increasing demand for
energy in the developed and developing countries.
The aforementioned risks have frequently been noted since the middle of the
last century. The first World Summit on Sustainable Development (Earth Summit)
held in 1992, in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, brought together a number of leaders from
business and nongovernmental organizations. At the Earth Summit 2002 held in
Johannesburg, South Africa (“Rio+10”), the world leaders discussed a wide range
of issues that had to be resolved, including environmental pollution, energy, and
countermeasures against global warming. “Rio+20,” which will be held in 2012
once again in Rio de Janeiro, aimed at securing renewed political commitment,
to assess the progress toward internationally agreed goals and to address new and
emerging challenges for sustainable development.
A. Suzuki ()
Department of Materials Science & Research, Institute of Environment and Information Sciences,
Yokohama National University, Yokohama, Japan
e-mail: asuzuki@ynu.ac.jp
and the most recent nuclear disaster triggered by the Great East Japan earthquake
and tsunami. These experiences taught us many valuable lessons. The best thing
that materials scientists and engineers can do in this tragic phase is to dedicate the
accumulated knowledge and skills to technological advancements for the betterment
of the society and the environment.
The section on new materials includes some typical examples of the recent
achievements and innovations in advanced materials research and technology. The
chapters can be divided into three main areas: Energy, Resources, and Computer-
Aided Materials Design; Renewable and Biodegradable Materials and Nature
Technology; and Resource Consumption and Alternative Materials. The first area
consists of three chapters: Advanced Energy Devices: Lithium Ion Battery and
High Energy Capacitor, Advanced Materials for Fuel Cells, and Computational
Materials Science and Computer-aided Materials Design and Processing. The sec-
ond area consists of two chapters: Biopolymers for Environmental Applications:
Highly Functional Polyactic Acid Composites Used for Durable Products, and
Mechanisms of Organisms as Environment-Friendly Materials Design Tools. The
third area consists of two chapters: Thermodynamics and Resource Consumption:
Concepts, Methodologies, and the Case of Copper, Alternative Materials Devel-
opment Utilizing Advanced Nanotechnology.
High power density and high energy density are required as a power sources for
hybrid electric vehicle and electric vehicle. The advanced energy device chapter
focuses on lithium ion battery and high-energy capacitor. The positive electrode
materials and their synthesis by the solution process including the hydrothermal and
solvothermal methods are discussed. The hybrid capacitors such as metal oxide-
doped graphene and PANI/graphene nanocomposites with their electrochemical
performances are presented.
Fuel cells are devices for direct conversion of the chemical energy of a fuel
into electricity by an inverse reaction of the electrolysis of water. The fuel cell
chapter introduces the present status and future prospect on the basis of the materials
science of fuel cells. Among the several types of fuel cells, the solid oxide fuel cell
(SOFC) is focused because of its higher efficiency. The usefulness of the combined
approach of microanalysis, simulation, and processing route design is presented for
a breakthrough in the SOFC field.
The computer simulation chapter introduces recent rapid advances in computer
technology that have given rise to numerous opportunities in materials science
research. The advantages of simulation can be evaluated based on its ability to
rapidly and accurately predict the properties of novel functional materials in a
cost-effective way because simulations are easy to perform, even for very complex
systems. As for a typical example, this chapter deals with the recent achievements
in the study of hydrogen clathrate hydrates.
Bioplastics using renewable plant resources have distinct advantages as an
alternative to petroleum-based plastics. The bioplastics chapter introduces highly
functional polylactic acid composites as advanced bioplastics that offer high
performance with keeping environmental friendliness. The methods to improve heat
1148 A. Suzuki
Cross-References
Abstract
The development of modern technology toward energy production and storage
is essential to support human life with wide impact on the environment,
human health, and world’s economy. Through the development of the advanced
energy systems, human life can be ensure in a networked society even more
conveniently. In the electric and energy field, secondary batteries will play a
critical factor in reducing the environmental hazard and enable the effective
construction of the green energy society. At present, high power density and high
energy density are required as a power sources for the hybrid electric vehicle
(HEV) and electric vehicle (EV). As we know, Li-ion battery has high energy
density but low power density. The energy density of Li-ion battery decreases
with the increase in rate capability, but electric double-layer capacitor has high
power density but low energy density. So, this chapter focuses on the advanced
energy devices such as lithium-ion battery and high energy capacitors beginning
with brief introduction.
The importance of the solution process mainly including the hydrothermal
and solvothermal method as sustainable chemistry toward the processing of
the positive electrode materials for lithium-ion batteries has been discussed.
The requirement and different techniques of the carbon coating using different
carbon sources to improve the electrochemical property of the positive electrode
materials have been focused. The electrochemical property of the olivine-
structured cathode materials affected by different particles size and morphology
has been addressed. The concept of using graphene-based compounds for
the electric double-layer capacitor applications and electrochemical capacitor
1 Introduction
The rapid growth of science and technology during the last several decades in the
world is keep changing the human life by contributing to their needs to enjoy
their living. Recently, the development of the advanced energy devices becomes
critical to global human development including the ecosystems, economic growth,
employment, and prosperity of the present and future generation. In addition, the
slow diminishing of available energy resources is an alarm to change the present
energy system to the sustainable and renewable one for a long-term energy supply
for the mankind. Moreover, realization of the “low carbon society” based on
the advanced technologies for the sustainable development is one of the greatest
challenges at present.
The key technology for this challenge is to develop the next generation of clean
energy storage devices with high power density, high energy density, and high safety
for the hybrid electric vehicles (HEV), plug-in hybrid electric vehicles (PHEV), and
pure electric vehicles (PEV) (Aric-o et al. 2005). The practical realization of these
applications involves the development of the advanced energy functional materials
for the high energy storage and for a long-term performance. Lithium-ion battery
and capacitors are considered as the future advanced energy storage systems for
various next generation electronic and electrical applications.
Lithium-Ion Battery: Lithium-ion (Li-ion) batteries are comprised of cells that
employ lithium intercalation compounds as the positive and negative materials. As
a battery is cycled, lithium ions (LiC ) exchange between the positive and negative
electrodes. They are also referred to as “rockingchair” batteries as the lithium ions
“rock” back and forth between the positive and negative electrodes as the cell is
charged and discharged. The positive electrode material is typically a metal oxide
with a layered structure, such as lithium cobalt oxide (LiCoO2 ), or a material with
a tunneled structure, such as lithium manganese oxide (LiMn2 O4 ), on a current
collector of aluminum foil. The negative electrode material is typically a graphitic
carbon, also a layered material, on a copper current collector. In the charge/discharge
process, lithium ions are inserted or extracted from the interstitial space between
atomic layers within the active materials (Ehrlich 2001).
The mechanism involved in Li-ion battery is shown in Fig. 59.1. Where the
lithium metal was substituted with other insertion compounds, such as graphite
or non-graphitic carbon, LiCoO2 was used as the cathode material. The entire
electrochemical process would involve the reversible transfer of lithium ions
between the two electrodes. During the charge process, lithium ion is de-intercalated
from the cathode layers, then transported and intercalated into the carbonaceous
anode. While the discharge process occurred, the lithium ions are deintercalated
from the carbonaceous anode and intercalated again to empty site between layers of
the cathode materials (Park 2010).
59 Advanced Energy Devices: Lithium Ion Battery and High Energy Capacitor 1151
e− e−
A
− LixC6 Li1−xCO2 +
Li+
e− charge e−
e−
e−
Li+ discharge
e− e−
Fig. 59.1 Schematic representation of Li ion battery showing discharge intercalation mechanism
(Ehrlich 2001)
Among the batteries, especially secondary batteries have been essential part of
the power source for the advanced energy devices. In the future, they will become
a key factor to pursue comfortable human life. The electric power source will
be produced by the environmentally friendly wind generation and solar cell, and
the produced electric power can charge the batteries which are not harmful and
friendly to the environment. In the electric and energy field, secondary batteries
will play a critical factor in reducing the environmental hazard and enable the
effective construction of the green energy society (Park 2010). After three decades
of development in battery technology, the Li-ion battery technology has emerged
as one of the most popular battery technologies (Tarascon and Armand 2001).
They are widely used in various electronic devices because of their good cycle
life, high energy density, and high capacity over any other battery technologies.
The Li-ion battery technology that now dominates much of the portable battery
business has matured enough over the last 5 years to be considered for the short-
term implementation in the hybrid electric vehicles (HEV) and electric vehicles
(EV) applications (Tarascon and Armand 2001).
High Energy Capacitors: The discovery of a so-called condenser, now referred
to as a capacitor that electric charges could be stored on the plate, was made in
the mid-eighteenth century during the period when the phenomena associated with
“static electricity” were being revealed. The embodiment known as a condenser is
attributed to Musschenbroek (Encyclopedia Britannica 1926) in 1746 at Leyden in
the Netherlands, hence the name “Leyden jar.” The electrochemical capacitor was
supposed to boost the hybrid electric vehicle to provide the high or strong power
for acceleration and additionally allow the recovery of braking energy. The electric
double-layer capacitor consisting of a single cell with a high surface area electrode
material is loaded with electrolyte (Kotz and Carlen 2000). The schematic diagram
1152 M.K. Devaraju et al.
←
polarizing
collector electrodes collector
+ separator + -
−
+ − electrolyte + -
+ − − + -
+ − − + -
+ − + -
+ +
+ − + -
Fig. 59.2 Schematic representation showing basic structure of electric double layer (Kotz and
Carlen 2000)
Among the battery components, the cathode materials are the one which are crucial
in determining the high power, safety, longer life, and cost of the battery that satisfies
the requirements of the larger battery system. These can be applicable to the electric
vehicles, power tools, energy storage equipment, and so on (Padhi et al. 1997).
There are various types of materials being used as the positive electrode materials
for the lithium-ion batteries as shown in Fig. 59.3 (Tarascon and Armand 2001).
The structural, chemical stability, availability of redox couples at a suitable energy,
specific capacity, operating voltage, and safety issues are the primary considerations,
and these properties are different among the positive electrode materials shown
in Fig. 59.3. Lithium-based electrodes have four types of structure which have
lithium insertion voltage of above 3 V. They include layers of lithium metal oxides
such as LiCoO2 , LiNiO2 , LiCoNiO2 , and LiMnNiO2 ; the zigzag layers structure
of LiMnO2 ; the three-dimensional spinel type, LiMn2 O4 and Li1=2 Mn3=2 O4 ; and
the olivine structure of LiMPO4 (M=Fe, Mn, Co, and Ni). Recently, Li2 MSiO4
(M=Fe, Mn, and Co) based cathodes have been investigated, which are envisaged
as the potential cathode candidate for the high-power batteries (Dominko 2010).
This is because of their overwhelming advantages such as high theoretical capacity
(>330 mAh g1 which is possible while extracting more than one LiC ion per
formula unit), high thermal stability through strong Si–O bonding, safety, cost-
effectiveness, eco-friendliness, and ease to synthesize. This chapter discusses the
olivine-structured LiMPO4 cathode materials.
Li1−xMn2−yMyO4
Positive material:
Positive materials
Li1−xCo1−yMyO2
4
Li1−xNi1−y−zCoyMzO4[M=Mg,AI,...] of Li ion
3
Vanadium oxides
MnO2 [V2O5, LiV3O8] Li-metal
Li-ion
potential potential
2
Negative material:
3d-Metal oxidea
Negative materials
of Li ion
Composite alloys [Sn(O)-based] ( limited cycling)
[Sn(M)-based]
of Li metal
1
Carbons Nitrides LiMyN2
Graphite
Li metal
0
0 200 400 600 800 1000 3,800 4,000
Capacity (A h kg−1)
Fig. 59.3 Voltage vs. capacity of some cathode materials (Tarascon and Armand 2001)
to some degree. However, they are still problematic due to their compositions.
To overcome these disadvantages and problems, the olivine-structured lithium metal
phosphate cathode materials are considered as the attractive cathode materials
because they are in low cost, abundant in nature, exhibit high theoretical capacity
(170 mAh g1 ) (Padhi et al. 1997), high thermal stability owing to the presence of
a strong P–O covalent bond, and easy to synthesize.
LiMPO4 (M=Fe, Mn, Co, and Ni) belongs to the orthorhombic structure, which
consists of the hexagonal closed packing (HCP) of the oxygen atoms with LiC and
M2C cations located in half of the octahedral sites and P5C cations in one eighth of
the tetrahedral sites (Fig. 59.4). This structure may be described as chains (along the
c direction) of edge sharing MO6 octahedra that are cross-linked by the PO4 groups
forming a three-dimensional network. Tunnels perpendicular to the [010] and [001]
directions contain octahedrally coordinated LiC cations (along the b-axis), which
are mobile in these cavities (Jin and Jiang 2009). Among the phosphates, LiFePO4
is considered most stable, low cost, and high compatibility with the environments.
Since the demand for the cathode materials for lithium-ion battery is increasing
continuously, various methods have been developed to prepare lithium metal
phosphate nanoparticles, such as the sol–gel method (Choi and Kumta 2007),
59 Advanced Energy Devices: Lithium Ion Battery and High Energy Capacitor 1155
Fig. 59.4 The schematic representation of the crystal structure of LiMPO4 (M=Fe, Mn, Co, and
Ni) compounds showing the HCP oxygen array with MO6 and PO4 groups (Jin and Jiang 2009)
FURNACE/OVEN
Teflon
Precursors Autoclave
liner
Fig. 59.5 Showing experimental scheme of hydrothermal and solvothermal process for the design
of nanoparticles with various shapes (Author unpublished work)
using the hydrothermal and solvothermal methods are shown in Fig. 59.5, where
morphology, size, and other experimental parameters can be easily controlled.
Moreover, low-temperature solution process is environmentally friendly, low energy
consuming, and easy to perform for the large-scale production.
The concept of the hydrothermal process for the preparation of LiFePO4 was
first realized by Yang et al. in (2001). However, preparation of the nanocrystalline
particles ranging from 500 to 1,500 nm was reported by Tajimi et al. (2004) under
the hydrothermal reaction condition at the reaction temperature of 150–220ıC for
several hours using various amounts of polyethylene glycol (PEG).
Recently, monodispersed particles of LiFePO4 were prepared using a mixture of
isopropanol and aqueous solution by controlling the RH factor (Zhang et al. 2009).
The monodispersed LiFePO4 particles were controlled from 1 to 4 m in length
and 1–2 m in diameter. Small particles of LiFePO4 measuring 400–1 m with
the shape of discrete short rods were obtained at the RH factor of 1 (Fig. 59.6a).
However, several attempts have been made to obtain cathode materials with different
size and morphology. In this regard, the rodlike LiFePO4 particles with 100 nm
of uniform diameter and 5–10 nm of the aspect ratio were synthesized by the
hydrothermal reaction at 220ıC (Huang et al. 2010), and the rodlike morphology
can be seen in Fig. 59.6b.
In order to reduce the reaction time and to obtain homogeneous monodispersed
particles, a few attempts have been made to synthesize the cathode materials at a
shorter reaction period. Hence, a rapid production of the cathode materials by the
59 Advanced Energy Devices: Lithium Ion Battery and High Energy Capacitor 1157
Fig. 59.6 LiFePO4 cathode materials with different morphology synthesized by hydrothermal
method (Reproduced with permission from Zhang et al. (2009), Huang et al. (2010) and Xu et al.
(2008))
Fig. 59.7 (a) Nanoarchitectured of LiFePO4 (b) and (c) nanoplate and nanorods of LiMnPO4
and (d) sphere-like particles of LiCoPO4 synthesized by supercritical method (Reproduced with
permission from Rangappa et al. (2010a) and Rangappa et al. (2010b) and LiCoPO4 from author’s
unpublished work)
Fig. 59.8 (a) Platelet like of LiMnPO4 nanoparticles synthesized by microwave hydrothermal
method (b) large nanorods of LiFePO4 synthesized by microwave solvothermal method (c)
platelike LiFePO4 synthesized by polyol method (d) thin plate like LiFePO4 synthesized by
solvothermal method (Reproduced with permission from Ji et al. (2011), Murugan et al. (2008),
Lim et al. (2011) and Nan et al. (2011))
possessing different shape are promising to behave much differently than the
bulk materials. Hence, from the nanocrystalline materials, improved and surprising
physicochemical reaction can be expected, which could play a vital role in various
technological and chemical applications.
The practical capacity and high rate performance of the olivine-structured lithium
metal phosphates are not impressive due to its low electronic conductivity
1160 M.K. Devaraju et al.
Fig. 59.9 Carbon-coated LiFePO4 materials using (a) sugar, (b) ascorbic acid, (c) D-gluconic acid
lactone, and (d) PEDOT polymer (Reproduced with permission from Jeon et al. (2007), Rangappa
et al. (2009), Saravanan et al. (2009) and Murugan et al. (2008))
which can contribute as carbon source during the synthesis of the cathode materials.
High-boiling point solvents like glycols can be beneficial as the carbon source and
to achieve better in situ coating at the time of synthesis.
3.5
2.5
Charge
2.0
1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 1.9 2.0
x in LixFeSiO4
Fig. 59.10 Typical galvanostatic charge–discharge curve of LiFeSiO4 at a C/20 rate (Reproduced
with permission from Dreyer et al. (2010))
and then with the binder to make electrode paste. The electrode paste will be
pressed on Ni mesh and then cell assembled in the argon glove box. For the
charge/discharge measurement, the current rates of the cathode materials will be
calculated based on its theoretically calculated specific capacity in various time
spans and considering the amount of the cathode material present in the electrode
paste. The cut-off voltages used for the measurements are adapted according to the
type of the measured cathode material. It is important to note that materials that can
be cycled at high C-rates and operating in the voltage window of commercially used
electrolytes are desirable. During the galvanostatic cycling, structural change occurs
inside the electrode material as a result of the LiC insertion/extraction (lithium metal
is used as a counter electrode – anode). The results from the measurements can be
plotted in the galvanostatic charge/discharge curves (voltage vs. capacity, voltage
vs. composition as shown in Fig. 59.10 (Dreyer et al. 2010), and capacity vs. cycle
number). Important parameters that can be determined from these curves are specific
capacity, voltage, and reversibility (e.g., polarization, voltage gap between charge
and discharge).
The LiMPO4 (M=Fe and Mn) cathode materials with similar crystal structure
synthesized by various solution routes show different electrochemical property.
The discharge capacity is not only dependent on the structure of the cathode
materials, but other facts also influence the electrochemical property of the cathode
materials, for example, crystal size, morphology, and method of carbon coating. For
example, the charge/discharge profile of the LiFePO4 nanorods shown in Fig. 59.10a
shows the discharge capacity of 140 mAhg1 (Fig. 59.11a) for the first cycle and
decreases to 130 mAhg1 after 20 cycles (Huang et al. 2010). The potential voltage
gap between the charge and discharge profile is wide. This might be due to low
conductivity, and it can be overcome by proper conductive carbon coating to
59 Advanced Energy Devices: Lithium Ion Battery and High Energy Capacitor 1163
a 5.0 b 4.5
4.5
0.5C 4.0
4.0
3.5
3.5
Voltage (V)
Voltage (V)
First cycle
3.0 3.0
2.5
2.5
2.0
2.0
1.5
1.0 1.5
−20 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160
Capacity (mAh/g)
4.5
c d
4.5
1
50
Cell Voltage (V vs. Li/Li+)
4.0 25
Voltage (V vs. Li/Li+)
4.0
3.5 3.5
3.0
3.0 1
25
50
2.5 Charge-discharge at 0.1C
2.5
0 60 120 180 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70
Capacity (mAhg−1) Capacity (mAh/g)
Fig. 59.11 Charge–discharge curves of (a) LiFePO4 nanorods, (b) sphere-like LiFePO4 /C,
(c) thin plate like LiFePO4 /C, and (d) colloidal nanocrystal of LiMnPO4 (Reproduced with
permission from Huang et al. (2012), Rangappa et al. (2009), Saravanan et al. (2009) and Rangappa
et al. (2010a))
shows the discharge capacity of around 70 mAhg1 (Fig. 59.11d). The development
of new strategy of conductive carbon coating can enhance the discharge capacity
of LiMnPO4 materials. The intrinsic electronic conductivity of LiMnPO4 is very
low due to the Jahn–Teller distortion, and it is not possible to achieve full
theoretical capacity of LiMnPO4 . However, further study is necessary to improve
the electrochemical property of the LiMnPO4 cathode materials.
4 Electrochemical Capacitors
Carbons and carbon-based composites materials are the most widely used owing
to their high surface area, moderate cost, and ecofriendly nature. A variety of
carbon morphologies with different surface area and chemical nature such as carbon
nanotubes, carbon nanofibers, carbon fibres, onions, and nanohorns have been
investigated (Simon and Gogotsi 2008; Zhang et al. 2009). Similarly, activated
carbons, mesoporous carbon, template carbon, and chemically derived carbon have
been examined. The carbons used in EDLC are generally pretreated to remove
moisture, and most of the surface functional groups are present on the carbon surface
to improve stability during cycling.
The presence of functional groups will result in increased serious resistance and
capacitance fading during aging. The double-layer capacitance of activated carbon
reaches 100–120 F/g in organic electrolytes; this value can exceed 150–300 F/g in
aqueous electrolytes, but at a lower cell voltage because the electrolyte voltage
window is limited by the water decomposition. The research on carbon materials
was directed toward increasing the pore volume by developing high surface area
59 Advanced Energy Devices: Lithium Ion Battery and High Energy Capacitor 1165
carbon and refining the activation process. However, the capacitance increase was
limited even for the most porous samples (Simon and Gogotsi 2008). From a series
of activated carbons with different pore sizes in various electrolytes, it was shown
that there was no linear relationship between the surface area and the capacitance
owing to the inability of electrolyte access to the entire surface through smaller
pores. Also, the poor conductivity of the porous carbon materials limits the high
capacitance. Thus, high surface area carbon material with optimum pore size and
conductivity is essential to realize the high capacitance.
The key to reaching high capacitance by charging the double layer is using high
surface area carbon materials with electronically conducting electrodes. Graphitic
carbon satisfies all the requirements for this application, including high conductivity,
electrochemical stability, and open porosity that offer huge surface area (Simon
and Gogotsi 2008). Thus, graphene-based supercapacitors are under intensive
investigation as potential alternative to the activated carbon that is used in the
current supercapacitor electrodes. The effective surface area of graphene materials
should depend highly on the number of layers, that is, single- or few-layered
graphene sheets with less agglomeration might be expected to exhibit higher
effective surface area. The recent research reports on clean graphene materials
with specific capacitance ranging from 120 to 250 F/g. The chemical nature of the
graphene nanosheets and its purity greatly depend on the method of preparation and
subsequent processing of the resulting graphene sheets.
As mentioned earlier, the presence of functional groups on the graphene surface
greatly influences on its capacitance. In general, the presence of oxygen containing
functional groups result diminishes the capacitance and cycle life (Pandolfo and
Hollenkamp 2006). Wang et al. (2009) reported a maximum specific capacitance
of 205 F/g with an excellent long cycle life along with 90% specific capacitance
retained after 1,200 cycle tests. Also, it is confirmed that the interfacial capacitance
of the multilayer graphene sheets is found to depend on the number of layers. In
addition to the graphene quality, the fabrication of electrodes and its structure also
influences the performance of the resulting supercapacitors. Recently, P.M. Ajyan
group reported an “in-plane” fabrication approach for ultrathin supercapacitors
based on electrodes comprised of pristine graphene and multilayer reduced graphene
oxide (Yoo et al. 2011). And this approach allows for the formation of an efficient
electrical double layer by utilization of the maximum electrochemical surface area
and results a maximum specificapacitance of 247 F/g. The research on supercapac-
itors using graphene nanosheets is under tremendous progress. Combining high-
quality graphene sheets with suitable electrode fabrication technique will lead to the
commercial production of EDLC capacitors with high capacitance in the near future.
In the row of various chemical modification processes, doping of hetero-atoms,
such as nitrogen, sulfur, and boron, into the graphene backbone is another possible
route. Also, the heteroatom doping in the carbon materials (CNTs, graphene)
and metal oxides has always created excitement in the material chemistry as the
materials property can be tuned significantly. Recently, studies have focused on
direction, and several possible routes have been identified for the effective N- or
B-doping in the graphene sheets (Hulicova et al. 2006; Kwon et al. 2009).
1166 M.K. Devaraju et al.
MnO2
nanocrystals
Growth
N2H4
NPG
Mn7+ N2H4
Fig. 59.12 Schematic showing the fabrication process for nanoporous gold/MnO2 hybrid mate-
rials by directly growing MnO2 onto nanoporous gold (Reproduced with permission from Lang
(2011))
MnO2 nanosheets
Mn4+
GO-MnO2
Graphene oxide
Mn2+
(i) Aniline
GO-PANI
Fig. 59.13 Schematic representation of polyaniline formation on graphene surface via oxidative
polymerization of aniline by MnO2 (Reproduced with permission from (From author’s work))
Aniline
Aniline anion
GO sheet
a b
Nucleation
Growth
Growth further
Fig. 59.14 Schematic illustration of nucleation and growth mechanism of PANI nanowires:
(a) heterogeneous nucleation on GO nanosheets; (b) homogeneous nucleation in bulk solution
(Reproduced with permission from Xu (2010))
0.5 3
0.4 a b c
0.3 2
Current Density (A g−1)
0.2
1
0.1
0.0 0
−0.1
−0.2 −1
−0.3
−2
−0.4
−0.5 −3
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 −1.0 −0.8 −0.6 −0.4 −0.2 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
Voltage (V) Potential (V vs. SCE)
Fig. 59.15 Schematic representation of polyaniline formation on graphene surface via oxidative
polymerization of aniline by MnO2 (Reproduced with permission from Wu et al. (2010))
59 Advanced Energy Devices: Lithium Ion Battery and High Energy Capacitor 1171
Fig. 59.16 Schematic illustration of two key steps for preparing hybrid graphene/MnO2 -
nanostructured textiles as high-performance EC electrodes. (i) Conformal coating of solution-
exfoliated graphene nanosheets (gray color) onto textile fibers. (ii) Controlled electrodeposition
of MnO2 nanoparticles (yellow dots) on graphene-wrapped textile fibers (Reproduced with
permission from Yu et al. 2011)
(Wu et al. 2010). These ECs can be cycled reversibly in the high voltage region of
0–2.0 V (Fig. 59.15a). The resulting energy density of 30.4 Wh/kg is much higher
than those of the symmetric ECs based on graphene//graphene (2.8 Wh/kg)
(Fig. 59.15b) and MnO2 –graphene//MnO2–graphene (5.2 Wh/kg) (Fig. 59.15c) and
higher than those of other MnO2 -based asymmetric ECs. These findings open
up the possibility of the graphene-based composites for applications in safe
aqueous electrolyte-based high-voltage hybrids systems with high energy and power
densities.
Yu et al. (2011) demonstrated the solution-processed graphene/MnO2 nanos-
tructured textiles for the high-performance electrochemical capacitors applications.
In their study, solution-exfoliated graphene nanosheets (5 nm thickness) were
conformably coated on the three-dimensional, porous textiles support structures,
and pseudocapacitive MnO2 nanomaterials was deposited by the controlled elec-
trodeposition (Fig. 59.16). This technique offers high loading of active electrode
materials and facilitates the easy access of electrolytes to those materials. The hybrid
graphene/MnO2-based textile yields high-capacitance performance with specific
capacitance up to 315 F/g. Also, they have fabricated asymmetric electrochemical
capacitors with the graphene/MnO2-textile as the positive electrode and single-
walled carbon nanotubes (SWNTs)-textile as the negative electrode in an aqueous
Na2 SO4 electrolyte solution. These devices exhibit promising characteristics with
a maximum power density of 110 kW/kg, an energy density of 12.5 Wh/kg, and
excellent cycling performance of 95 % capacitance retention over 5,000 cycles.
These kinds of low-cost, high-performance energy textiles-based nanostructures
offer great promise to realize the future large-scale energy storage devices.
1172 M.K. Devaraju et al.
5 Conclusions
In conclusion, this chapter began with the brief introduction of the advanced energy
devices such as lithium-ion batteries and high energy capacitors. The importance of
the positive electrode materials and their synthesis by the solution process including
the hydrothermal and solvothermal method were discussed. These methods are
popularly used for the preparation of various inorganic materials owing to their
advantages such as size-controlled synthesis, morphology-controlled synthesis,
safety, easy synthesis, environmentally benign, and cost-effectiveness.
Among the lithium-ion batteries, cathodes are essential parts of the batteries.
The olivine-structured lithium metal phosphates are very much attractive due to
their cheap, environmentally friendly, and high theoretical capacity. The carbon
coating of lithium metal phosphates using different carbon sources via in situ or
ex-situ coating techniques has been discussed. The electrochemical property de-
pended on the morphology of LiFePO4 and LiMnPO4 cathodes has been discussed.
Most of the LiFePO4 nanomaterials less than 100–250 nm in diameter exhibited
the discharge capacity close to the theoretical capacity (170 mAhg1 ). Thin plate
and rod morphology provides short diffusion length for the LiC -ion insertion and
exertion process. The discharge capacity of LiMnPO4 is not very impressive due
to its low intrinsic conductivity. New strategy development could improve the
electrochemical property of LiMnPO4 for commercial purpose.
In the electrochemical capacitors, graphene-based compounds such as metal
oxide-doped graphene and PANI/graphene showed excellent capacitance when
compared to the other capacitors. In addition, asymmetric hybrid capacitors are
promising with higher capacitance for various powder density electric and electronic
devices. Further, continuous study of graphene could enable to understand its
physicochemical property for the electrochemical applications. New breakthrough
in these fields can change the performance of the energy devices and thus can make
human life more comfortable.
References
A.S. Aric-o, P.G. Bruce et al., Nat. Mater. 4, 366 (2005)
G.M. Ehrlich, in Lithium Ion Batteries in Handbook of Batteries, ed. by D. Linden, T.B. Reddy
(McGraw-Hill Handbooks, New York, 2001)
G. Park, Thesis Saga University, Japan, 2010
J.M. Tarascon, J.-M. Armand, Nature 414, 359 (2001)
Encyclopedia Britannica, COLE to DAMA, vol. 6, 14th edn. (New York Press, 1926), p. 216
R. Kotz, M. Carlen, Electrochim. Acta 45, 2483 (2000)
C. Liu, F. Li et al., Adv. Mater. 22, E28 (2010)
A. Yoshino, Electrochemistry 72, 716 (2004)
A.K. Padhi, K.S. Nanjundaswamy et al., Electrochem. Soc. 144, 1188 (1997)
R. Dominko, Proc. SPIE 7683, 76830J (2010)
B. Jin, Q. Jiang, in Lithium Batteries: Research, Technology, ed. by R. Greger Dahlin et al. (Nova
Science Publishers Inc., 2009)
D. Choi, P.N. Kumta, J. Power Sources 163, 1064 (2007)
59 Advanced Energy Devices: Lithium Ion Battery and High Energy Capacitor 1173
Abstract
Present status and future prospect in the fuel cell field were introduced in this
chapter. To explain the important future prospect in the materials science of fuel
cells, the authors focused on the materials science in the solid oxide fuel cell
field after briefly summarizing present status of research and development in
the fuel cell field. Also the authors reintroduced the research results to highlight
the important role of the ultimate analysis of microstructure, simulation for a
reasonable conclusion of microanalysis, and the processing route design based
on microanalysis. The usefulness of the combined approach of microanalysis,
simulation, and the processing route design is presented.
1 Introduction
Fuel cells, as devices for direct conversion of the chemical energy of a fuel into
electricity by the inverse reaction of the electrolysis of water, are one of the
key enabling technologies for the transition to a sustainable society. This fuel
cell device consists of electrolyte and electrodes (i.e., anode and cathode). The
oxidation reaction of fuel takes place at the anode and creates the ion and electron.
T. Mori ()
Fuel cell materials group, Battery materials unit, National institute for materials science (NIMS),
Tsukuba, Ibaraki, Japan
Hetro-interface design group, batteries and fuel cells field, global research centre for environment
and energy based on nano-materials science, National institute for materials science (NIMS),
Tsukuba, Ibaraki, Japan
e-mail: MORI.Toshiyuki@nims.go.jp
J. Drennan
Centre for Microscopy and Microanalysis, The University of Queensland, St. Lucia, QLD,
Australia
e-mail: j.drennan@uq.edu.au
The electron moves around the external circuit and reaches the cathode to participate
in the reduction reaction of oxygen or air. This electron in the external circuit can be
used for generating electricity using the fuel cell devices. In this process, the mobile
ion such as proton (HC ), hydroxyl ion (OH ), carbonate ion (CO2 3 ), or oxide ion
(O2 ) moves through the liquid or solid electrolytes to make water molecules at the
anode side or cathode side.
The major types of fuel cells being developed are the proton exchange membrane
fuel cells (PEMFCs), direct alcohol fuel cells (DAFCs), alkaline fuel cells (AFCs),
phosphoric acid fuel cells (PAFCs), molten carbonate fuel cells (MCFCs), and solid
oxide fuel cells (SOFCs).
PEMFCs are actively developed in the industry because of its low operating
temperature (<100ıC), fast start-up/shutdown, and low local emissions. Automobile
companies have tried to use this device as hybrid-type engines in their big vehicles
such as shuttle bus and trailer. However, the development of PEMFCs slowed down
due to unsatisfied durability, poor reliability, and its low power density (Miller and
Bazylak 2011). It is still in the stage of demonstration applications. Alternatively,
practical use for the residential-scale generator application of PEMFCs has already
started in Japan. Gas Company started business for the development of the home
energy management system in the family houses in Japan. It is one of the successful
examples of practical use of PEMFCs. To make the best use of PEMFCs, the
advanced PEMFCs for intermediate temperature operation (i.e., 100–200ıC) have
actively developed in the research field (Dupuis 2011).
For the development of the portable power generators, DAFCs (Yu et al. 2010)
which are operated around 60ı C have been developed by the household electrical
appliance manufacturers. In this case, fuel is alcohol (methanol (Scott et al. 1997)
and ethanol (Neburchilov et al. 2007)) or ethylene glycol (Serov and Kwak 2010).
Since DMFCs can use liquid fuels which are easy to store and transport for its
operation, it is useful as a long-life battery in the portable electric devices. However,
DMFCs have big problems such as the alcohol crossover from the anode side to
the cathode side and its low power density as compared with PEMFCs. Also, the
production cost of DMFCs is much higher than that of the conventional batteries in
the portable electric devices. As a consequence, it appears to be hard to use DMFCs
instead of the conventional batteries.
The AFCs (using aqueous KOH as electrolyte) were developed for the NASA
Apollo space program. The AFCs systems were used for the shuttle missions in
the space program. The main advantage of the AFCs is the high reaction kinetics
at the electrodes in the alkaline condition. The non-precious metal electrodes such
as Ni can be used for this device instead of Pt. Also, the operation temperature of
the AFCs is relatively low (i.e., 23–70ıC) compared with that of the PEMFCs and
DMFCs. However, the mobility of OH will be drastically decreased by the reaction
between electrolyte of the AFC and carbon dioxide (CO2 ) in the air. To overcome
this problem for the industrial applications such as the vehicle engine application,
recent research has focused on the development of an AFC based on the anion-
conducting polymer electrolytes to replace the KOH solution. Considerable efforts
in this field improved the conductivity using hydroxyl ion in electrolyte and the
60 Advanced Materials for Fuel Cells 1177
resistance against CO2 of the system (Merle et al. 2011). However, conspicuous
degradation of the performance of AFC has been observed due to the low chemical
stability of the anion-conducting polymer electrolytes under the high pH condition.
PAFCs and MCFCs have a long development history for its practical use.
However, it is hard to improve the efficiency of the generation of PEMFC (operation
temperature: below 200ı C) and poor durability of MCFCs (operation temperature:
650ıC).
In the basic research field, micro-fuel cells using polymer electrolytes
(Grinbergz and Skundin 2010) have attracted attention for the development of a
new miniaturized power source which can withstand the development competition
with the other batteries such as lithium-ion and lithium-polymer batteries. Also,
other unique fuel cells named enzymatic fuel cells (or biofuel cells) which employ
enzymes as catalysts have been examined for an implantable power source in the
medical device application (Ivanov et al. 2010). Both fuel cells are only for the
research purpose and are unlikely to use in the industry yet.
The efficiency of power generation of SOFCs is the highest of all the afore-
mentioned fuel cell devices (Steele and Heinzel 2000). Also this device can create
electricity using a variety of fuels. As a consequence of this, it is believed that
SOFC is a promising fuel cell device for the development of sustainable society.
However, this fuel cell has some technical problems such as unsatisfactory durability
and reliability. To get the significant share of the electricity market, high durability
(up to 100,000 h at the operation temperature) is required. To meet this challenge,
the fuel cell material design is a key issue. Many fuel cell materials (i.e., solid
electrolytes, cathodes, and anodes) have been developed in this field (Jacobson
2010; Sun et al. 2010). However, the old style SOFC material development did
not create decisive solution for this challenge, so far. It is because the trial and
errors for the development of SOFC materials lacks of the careful analysis of
microstructure in the produced materials. For the development of the advanced
SOFC materials, careful microanalysis and processing route design must be com-
bined. Here, the authors reintroduce the previously reported results for the design of
advanced SOFC materials based on micro-analysis (Mori et al. 2003, 2005, 2006,
2008; 2010; Ou et al. 2006, 2007; Ye et al. 2008, 2010; Wang et al. 2006;
Li et al. 2010, 2011a, b, c, d, e, f).
Gd-doped ceria and Y-doped ceria electrolytes are representative electrolytes for the
development of an intermediate temperature (300–500ıC) operation of solid oxide
fuel cell devices. In general, oxide ionic conductivity is described by
X=0.25 X=0.2
YxCe1−xO2−x/2
(111)
(220) (311) x=0.25
(200) (420)
(222) (400) (331)
Intensity (a.u.)
x=0.20
x=0.15
X=0.1 X=0.15
x=0.1
20 30 40 50 60 70 80
2θ (Cu Kα, degree)
Fig. 60.1 (a) X-ray diffraction patterns and SEM images observed for Y-doped ceria. (b) Selected
area electron diffraction patterns recorded from Yx Ce1x O2x=2 sintered bodies <112 >F zone
Since doped ceria has cubic symmetry, the shape of primary particles must be
cubic. Also the secondary particles consist of a group of cubic-shaped primary
particles. In the SEM images of Fig. 60.1, however, the surface of round-shaped
particles of doped ceria was quite smooth. This suggests that the amorphous thin
film covered the surface of secondary particles and nanoscale heterogeneity remains
in the Y-doped ceria particles which were prepared by the coprecipitation method.
During the sintering process of those easily sinterable powders, the nanoscale
heterogeneity was developed and would make microdomain or nano-domain area
in the sintered bodies. It was concluded that the micro-domain formation process
strongly depends on the processing route, and the reliability of solid electrolytes
1180 T. Mori and J. Drennan
Fig. 60.2 High-resolution TEM images of Yx Ce1x O2x=2 sintered bodies. White dashed line
areas indicate micro-domains
Fig. 60.3 EELS-TEM images observed for 25% Y-doped ceria sintered body which was sintered
at 1,400ı C. Black arrows indicate the agglomeration area of dopant at nanoscale
−2.0
log σ / S cm−1 at 500°C
−2.5
−3.0
−3.5
−4.0
−4.5
−5.0
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2
Average grain size / μm
80
Activation Energy /KJ mol−1
70
60
50
40
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2
Average grain size / μm
Fig. 60.4 Relationship between microstructure and electrolytic properties observed for PECS
specimens and conventional sintering specimens, PECS specimen (4, N) and conventional
sintering specimen (); bold white arrows and dashed white arrows indicate the reflection from
the fluorite structure and reflections from nano-domains into the fluorite phase, respectively
1182 T. Mori and J. Drennan
Fig. 60.5 Grain boundary analysis of Gd-doped ceria sintered body using high-resolution TEM
shown in Fig.60.4. This clearly indicates that the combined method of microanalysis
and the processing route design provide researchers and developers a big chance to
see the breakthrough in the fuel cell field.
In the SOFC devices, the microstructure design in the grain boundary region and
at the interface between electrolyte and electrodes (i.e., anode and cathode) is also
quite important. The formation of nano-sized domains which sizes are less than
approximately 2 nm in the grain boundary was observed using the high-resolution
analytical TEM as shown in Fig. 60.5 (Li et al. 2011a). The continuous bright
contrast of which width is within 2 nm was observed in the grain boundary. This
bright continuous line means that the nano-sized domains with ordered structure
of oxygen vacancies exist at the grain boundary. So far, this nano-heterogeneity
was not always discussed well. As a consequence, reliability of solid electrolytes
cannot be controlled well. To improve reliability of the fuel cell materials, this
nanoscale heterogeneity should be recognized and fabricated with the high-quality
solid electrolytes in the SOFC devices based on carefully microanalyzed data.
In addition, the interface design between solid electrolytes and electrodes (i.e.,
anode and cathode) is a key for the development of the SOFC devices.
Figure 60.6 presents the microanalysis results of the interface between Gd-doped
ceria (GDC) solid electrolyte and Ni-GDC anode particles using STEM-EELS (Li
et al. 2011b, d). The equal length diffusion between electrolytes and electrodes was
observed. In general, interdiffusion into the hetero-interface can be observed. In the
case of interdiffusion at the interface between electrolyte and electrode, Ni element
which is the main component of the anode diffused into the electrolyte side through
the grain boundary. The authors thought that the diffusion of the components of
the electrolyte into the electrodes would be quite small. It can be a negligible level.
However, almost same length diffusion from both sides were observed, even though
atomic weight of each element (i.e., Ni:58.7, Gd:157.3, Ce:140.1) is quite different,
and the diffusion constants of the Ni cation in the anode side and the Gd and Ce
cations in the electrolyte side are different as well.
To conclude why the equal length diffusion which is named as “mutual diffusion”
was observed at the interface, the detailed defect structure of the interface was
characterized by using the high-resolution TEM. The TEM analysis suggests
60 Advanced Materials for Fuel Cells 1183
a reduced
b reduced
Fig. 60.6 Interface characterization of Gd-doped ceria using STEM-EELS analysis technique
that superstructure was formed in the interface area (Li et al. 2011b, c). Since
superstructure consists of aggregation of the ordered oxygen vacancy clusters,
the formation of the ordered oxygen vacancy clusters must be formed during
the diffusion of components at the interface. In the case of the standard inter-
diffusion, there is no need to consider the superstructure formation. In the case of the
diffusion phenomena at the interface of the fuel cell materials, the aforementioned
equal length diffusion (i.e., “mutual diffusion”) proceeded with the superstructure
formation. The rate-determining step would be the formation of superstructure
at the interface. That is why the equal length diffusion was observed at the
interface of electrolyte and anode in the SOFC device. Similar diffusion phenomena
were observed around the interface between electrolyte and La0:6 Sr0:4 Co0:8 Fe0:2 O3
cathode (Li et al. 2011a, b). Based on all the microanalysis results, the authors
believe that microstructural features at the atomic scale for the design of high-quality
SOFC devices should be taken into account.
To develop a model for the design of high-quality fuel cell materials, computer
simulation technique has to be applied for detail conclusion about the short-range
ordering structure which is observed by TEM. Two representative examples of the
simulation works from the author’s research team are reintroduced here (Ye et al.
2010; Li et al. 2011f). One is the simulation for the superstructure formation at
the interface of electrolyte and anode (Ye et al. 2010). In general, the interaction
of anion and cation in the ionic materials can be discussed using the Bucking-
ham potential. The short-range ordering parameters of Ce4C –O2 , Ni2C –O2 ,
Gd3C –O2 , and O2 –O2 were calculated using the Buckingham potential. Also
the polarization parameters, space group, atomic coordinates, and lattice constants
1184 T. Mori and J. Drennan
a b
Ce4+
3rd
Ni2+ ΔE = 3.18 eV ΔE = 4.15 eV
st O2− c d
1
2nd
Vo” Ce4+
Ni2+
O2−
Fig. 60.7 Defect cluster energy calculation for a conclusion of super-structure formation in the
interface
were used for the simulation. To discuss the stability of the ordered oxygen vacancy
clusters, binding energy of clusters (E) were estimated using
where ˙Eisolated is the formation energy of the isolated oxygen vacancy clusters and
Ecluster is the formation energy of the ordered oxygen vacancy cluster. This equation
indicates that stable cluster has high binding energy.
Various arrangements of the ordered oxygen vacancy clusters were examined (Ye
et al. 2010). The clusters with the highest binding energy are shown in Fig. 60.7.
It can be seen that the cluster shown in Fig. 60.7b is the most favorable one of
all the clusters, indicating that adjacent oxygen vacancies in (2NiCe 00 2VO ¨) are
energetically favorable to be separated by <110>/2 (i.e., one-half of the distance
between atoms in <110> direction into the unit cell).
This simulation result clearly indicates that the superstructure formation is the
key step to conclude the mutual diffusion phenomenon for the interface design in
the SOFC devices.
The second example is the simulation of the phase transformation from the
conductive phase to the isolated phase in the solid electrolyte. In the case of Y2 O3
stabilized ZrO2 , Sc2 O3 stabilized ZrO2 , and Gd-doped ceria solid electrolytes, the
isolated phase (i.e., tetragonal phase, monoclinic phase, or C-type rare earth phase)
appeared in the conductive phase (i.e., the fluorite phase) of the aforementioned
solid electrolytes which consist of the fluorite related structure during long-time
operation at elevated temperature. For a long time, it was hard to understand
why the phase transformation from the conductive phase to the isolated phase
was observed in the electrolyte after long time operation test at the operation
temperature. The author’s research team tried to conclude this challenging subject
using this simulation technique (Li et al. 2011f). The authors compared the biding
60 Advanced Materials for Fuel Cells 1185
Chain model
Zr4+ or Ce4+
Dopant cation
O2−
Vo”
Dumbbell model
Fig. 60.8 Comparison of traditional cluster model (i.e., chain model) and dumbbell model
energies of the two cluster models (i.e., chain model and dumbbell model) in the
fluorite structure as demonstrated in Fig. 60.8. In Gd-doped ceria, the dumbbell
model which was proposed by the authors has the largest binding energy in the
ceria matrix. Also, this simulation result indicates that low conductive phase can
be observed when the dumbbell-type clusters are connected with each other and
become a long stable chain in the material. This clearly indicates that combination
of microanalysis, simulation, and the processing route design is the key approach to
see a big breakthrough in the fuel cell materials science.
4 Summary
In this chapter, present status of the development of the fuel cell materials was
explained at first. Then, the authors focused on solid oxide fuel cell materials
because of its higher efficiency of the SOFC devices as compared with the other
types of fuel cells. The authors reintroduced the previously reported results to
introduce the advanced approach for the design of the breakthrough fuel cell
materials in the SOFC field. In the research and development field of the SOFC
technology, fuel cell materials were designed based on the ideal crystal structure
model. However, heterogeneity at the atomic scale was observed in the bulk, grain
boundaries, and interfaces in the SOFC devices. As briefly mentioned in this chapter,
the authors believe that the combined approach of careful microanalysis, simulation,
and the processing route design will provide researchers and developers a big chance
to see a breakthrough in the SOFC field.
Acknowledgments
Professor Ding Rong Ou (Chinese Academy of Sciences, China), Professor Jin Zou
(The Queensland University, Australia), Dr. Graeme Auchterlonie (The Queensland
University, Australia), and Dr. Zhipeng Li (National Institute for Ma terials Science,
Japan).
5 Cross-References
References
A.C. Dupuis, Proton exchange membranes for fuel cells operated at medium temperatures:
materials and experimental techniques. Prog. Mater. Sci. 56, 289–327 (2011)
V.A. Grinbergz, A.M. Skundin, Microfuel cells: modern state and future development (review).
Russ. J. Electrochem. 46(9), 963–978 (2010)
I. Ivanov, T. Vidaković-Koch, K. Sundmacher, Recent advances in enzymatic fuel cells: experi-
ments and modeling. Energies 3, 803–846 (2010)
A.J. Jacobson, Materials for solid oxide fuel cells. Chem. Mater. 22, 660–674 (2010)
F. Li, T. Ohkubo, Y.M. Chen, M. Kodzuka, F. Ye, D.R. Ou, T. Mori, K. Hono, Laser-assisted three-
dimensional atom probe analysis of dopant distribution in Gd-doped CeO2 . Scr. Mater. 63(3),
332–335 (2010)
Z.P. Li, T. Mori, G. Auchterlonie, J. Zou, J. Drennan, Direct evidence of dopant segregation in
Gd-doped ceria. Appl. Phys. Lett. 98(9) (2011a). article number 093104
Z.P. Li, T. Mori, G. Auchterlonie, Y. Guo, J. Zou, J. Drennan, M. Miyayama, Mutual diffusion and
microstructure evoluation at the electrolyte-anode interface in intermedaite temperature solid
oxide fuel cell. J. Phys. Chem. C 115(14), 6877–6885 (2011b)
Z.P. Li, T. Mori, G. Auchterlonie, J. Zou, J. Drennan, Superstructure formation and variation in
Ni-GDC cermet anodes in SOFC. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 13(20), 9685–9690 (2011c)
Z.P. Li, T. Mori, G. Auchterlonie, J. Zou, J. Drennan, Two types of diffusions at the cath-
ode/electrolyte interface in IT-SOFCs. J. Solid State Chem. 184(9), 2458–2461 (2011d)
Z.P. Li, T. Mori, G. Auchterlonie, J. Zou, J. Drennan, Mutual diffusion occurring at the interface
between La0:6 Sr0:4 Co0:8 Fe0:2 O3 cathode and gd-doped ceria electrolyte during IT-SOFC cell
preparation. ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces 3(7), 2772–2778 (2011e)
Z.P. Li, T. Mori, F. Ye, D.R. Ou, J. Zou, J. Drennan, Structural phase transformation through defect
cluster growth in Gd-doped ceria. Phys. Rev. B 84, 1–5 (2011f). article number: 180201(R)
G. Merle, M. Wessling, K. Nijmeijer, Anion exchange membranes for alkaline fuel cells: a review.
J. Membr. Sci. 377(1–2), 1–35 (2011)
M. Miller, A. Bazylak, A review of polymer electrolyte membrane fuel cell stack testing. J. Power
Sources 196(2), 601–613 (2011)
T. Mori, J. Drennan, Y. Wang, G. Auchterlonie, J.G. Li, A. Yago, Influence of nano-structural
feature on electrolytic properties in Y2 O3 doped CeO2 system. Sci. Technol. Adv. Mater. 4(3),
213–220 (2003)
60 Advanced Materials for Fuel Cells 1187
T. Mori, T. Kobayashi, Y. Wang, J. Drennan, T. Nishimura, J.G. Li, H. Kobayashi, Synthesis and
characterization of nanohetero-structured Dy doped CeO2 solid electrolytes using combination
process of spark plasma sintering and conventional sintering. J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 88(7), 1981–
1984 (2005)
T. Mori, J. Drennan, D.R. Ou, F. Ye, Design of high quality doped CeO2 solid electrolytes with
nano-hetero structure. Int. J. Nucl. Res. (NUKLEONIKA) 51, S11–S18 (2006)
T. Mori, R. Buchanan, D.R. Ou, F. Ye, T. Kobayashi, J.D. Kim, J. Zou, J. Drennan, Design
of nano-structured ceria based solid electrolytes for development of IT-SOFC. J. Solid State
Electrochem. 12(7–8), 841–849 (2008)
T. Mori, D.R. Ou, F. Ye, J. Zou, J. Drennan, A.N. Cormack, Nano-structure design of doped ceria
solid electrolytes for intermediate temperature operation of solid oxide fuel cell. Trans. Mater.
Res. Soc. Jpn. 35(3), 431–441 (2010)
V. Neburchilov, J. Martin, H. Wang, J. Zhang, A review of polymer electrolyte membranes for
direct methanol fuel cells. J. Power Sources 169(2), 221–238 (2007)
D.R. Ou, T. Mori, F. Ye, M. Takahashi, J. Zou, J. Drennan, Microstructures and electrolytic proper-
ties of yttrium-doped ceria electrolytes: dopant concentration and grain size dependences. Acta
Mater. 54(14), 3737–3746 (2006)
D.R. Ou, T. Mori, F. Ye, J. Zou, J. Drennan, Evidence of intragranular segregation of dopant cations
in heavily yttrium-doped ceria. Electrochem. Solid-State Lett. 10(1), 1–3 (2007)
K. Scott, W. Taama, J. Cruickshank, Performance and modeling of a direct methanol solid polymer
electrolyte fuel cell. J. Power Sources 65(1–2), 159–171 (1997)
A. Serov, C. Kwak, Recent achievements in direct ethylene glycol fuel cells. Appl. Catal. B
Environ. 97, 1–12 (2010)
B.C.H. Steele, A. Heinzel, Materials for fuel-cell technologies. Nature 414, 345–352 (2000)
C. Sun, R. Hui, J. Roller, Cathode materials for solid oxide fuel cells: a review. J Solid State
Electrochem. 14, 1125–1144 (2010)
Y. Wang, H. Kageyama, T. Mori, H. Yoshikawa, J. Drennan, Local structures around Y and Ce
cations in10 mol% Y2 O3 doped ceria ceramics by XAFS spectroscopy. Solid State Ion. 177(19–
25), 1681–1685 (2006)
F. Ye, T. Mori, D.R. Ou, J. Zou, G. Auchterlonie, J. Drennan, Compositional and structural
characteristics of nano-sized domains in gadolinium-doped ceria. Solid State Ion. 179(21–26),
827–831 (2008)
F. Ye, T. Mori, D.R. Ou, J. Zou, J. Drennan, S. Nakayama, M. Miyayama, Effect of nickel diffusion
on the microstructure of Gd-doped ceria (GDC) electrolyte film supported by Ni-GDC cermet
anode. Solid State Ion. 181(13–14), 646–652 (2010)
E.H. Yu, U. Krewer, K. Scott, Principles and materials aspects of direct alkaline alcohol fuel cells.
Energies 3, 1499–1528 (2010)
Alternative Materials Development
Utilizing Advanced Nanotechnology 61
Shunichi Arisawa
Abstract
In this chapter, recent technologies in developing alternative materials utilizing
nanotechnology are described. Here, an “alternative material” refers to the
materials composed of abundant and ubiquitous elements with which replace
conventional ones containing minor elements. The methods of the development
of the alternative materials are focused on utilizing computational materials
science, advanced nanotechnology for the fabrication, and nano-characterization
technique. Further, some actual cases of recent developments will be discussed.
Developments of such materials are not a dream now. In this chapter, what the
alternative materials are and how humankind can develop them will be described.
1 Introduction
Recently, much attention has been paid to resource problems of rare earth elements
and other minor metals. During the last decade, problems of oligopolistic and
eccentrically located natural resources, especially rare earth elements, moved further
and the prices of them increased rapidly. As a result of the oligopoly, minor metals
are now sometimes regarded as a diplomatic card. If a material containing such
minor elements can be substituted by an other one composed of only abundant
elements, which are so-called ubiquitous elements, the minor metals are not so
eagerly sought for. Thus, replacement of advanced functional materials, usually
containing minor metals, with materials made of abundant elements is quite impor-
tant for industries and national strategy. From long time ago, problems concerning
natural resources such as iron ore, coal, oil, and natural gas have been major issues
S. Arisawa
Electronics Group, Superconducting Properties Unit, Environment and Energy Materials
Division, National Institute for Materials Science, Tsukuba-shi, Ibaraki, Japan
e-mail: arisawa.shunichi@nims.go.jp
and sometimes lead to a war. It is very important for countries to hold interests for
such resources. Nowadays, minor metals are indispensable for the advanced high-
tech products, and supply disruption of minor metals directly brings on a supply
chain collapse. Prices and supplied amounts of minor metals tend to be decided by
a small number of countries just like the situation of oil. For example, dysprosium
is usually added to magnets used in hybrid cars to keep the performance even at
high temperature. Industries do need stable supply of materials. Elements cannot
be produced except by nuclear reaction, which is far from practical in reality. It is
thus important to develop alternative materials which do not contain such elements.
But what is called “alternative materials” is not a kind of imitation. It is a kind
of development of material exhibiting new functions. Bone china was invented in
eighteenth century to save kaolin by adding animal bone ash to the raw material.
The bone china was found to exhibit excellent characteristics for tableware. It was
at first carried out in order to save the raw material. This substitution of material,
however, resulted in a creation of new products made of a new material with
increased marketability. Materials without minor metals have additional advantage
when the used end products are recycled. In general, small amount of minor metals
are added to the base material. It requires much energy to extract dilute elements
from the recycled matter. From this point of view, recyclability is also a definite
advantage of developing alternative materials. The fields of industries range widely
from transparent conductors to motors for hybrid cars. The optimal approaching
methods depend on case by case (Halada and Kasai 2010; NIMS 2007; Kim et al.
2007; Mihara et al. 2011).
In this chapter, “alternative materials” means materials which exclude or use smaller
amount of minor metals and/or noble metals to replace conventional materials.
Rare earth elements are especially important among minor metals. The alternative
materials are expected to be composed of abundant and ubiquitous elements.
So-called nanotechnology is used for designing, fabricating, and characterizing the
alternative materials in a proactive manner. In addition to the performance as a
material for a specific purpose, the alternative materials should be cost-effective,
harmless, highly productive, and recyclable compared to the original material.
There are three reasons why the alternative materials should be developed. They are
demand-side, supply-side, and recycle-side reasons.
Firstly, the demand-side reason is very critical these days. Modern sophisticated
products such as digital gadgets and hybrid cars require in many cases minor metals.
61 Alternative Materials Development Utilizing Advanced Nanotechnology 1191
Thus, the demands for minor metals, especially rare earth elements, are increasing.
Since the economy grows rapidly in the emerging countries, demands for the
industrial products are also growing amazingly. Most of the emerging countries hold
a large population, and the growth speed is quite rapid and the demand for minor
metals are also growing, while the supply of them is limited. To meet the large
amount of the growing market, the amount of the products should be increased,
but in some cases, increase of the products is limited by material containing minor
metals.
Secondly, the supply-side issue is sometimes rather political. As pointed out in
the introduction, resource problem becomes major issues in the globalized world
of supply chains of industrial products. As for rare earth elements, most of them
are now produced in China. Since the production costs in China are low, a lot of
mining companies in the developed countries stopped producing rare earth metals
in recent years. As a result, oligopoly proceeded. The price and the supplied amount
are affected by delicate situations. It is sometimes said that rare earth elements
are eccentrically located. But in a sense, this is not true. It is basically a matter
of playability and competitiveness of mining. As for the demands in the emerging
countries, low-cost supply is very important. Alternative materials are sometimes
more expensive compared to conventional ones. If prices of minor metals increased,
competitiveness of alternative materials will also be increased.
The last reason is the matter of recyclability. If a large amount of consumer
products including dilute rare earth elements are trashed and recycled, it takes
much energy and cost to extract such diluted elements from, for example, used
cell phones. In this case post consumer energy can be saved. If they are made from
abundant materials, extraction can be omitted and great advantage economically and
environmentally seen from a life cycle of the materials. One of the most successful
results was reported by Hosono et al. (Matsuishi et al. 2003).
such energy is slightly varied depending on the matrix materials. By making use of
this effect, displacement can be made since some rare earth elements are really rare,
while others are not.
Since the Bronze Age, development of materials had long been based on the
empirical methods, and even nowadays the empirical method remains the major
way. Methods such as composition change, working, heat treatment, mixture,
composite, atmosphere, surface processing, and so forth have been used widely
around the world. In the Japanese metallurgy societies, a phrase of “Copper-Iron
Principle” is widely known. This means that research is made by substituting one
element for another one. Although the empirical way will have remained a main
method for the development of materials in the future as well, contribution of the
computational materials science will be increased drastically.
Recent advances in the computational materials science (see Chap. 63) are amaz-
ing. In former days, it was sometimes said that the computational materials science
was not applicable for materials design, but only for explanation of the experimental
results. However, it is not true these days. There are three major points of the reason
why the computational materials science reached the stage of practical applications.
The first point is the evolution in the supercomputer performance. Super parallel
computers make it possible to treat increased number of atoms. The maximal speed
of the fastest computers is getting close to 10 petaflops in 2012. The second one
is the progress of modern algorithms of calculation. It is closely related to the
advances of the speed of supercomputers. The number of atoms in a model can be
increased for this reason. First principle calculation without empirical parameters
can be carried out. The last point is the advances of nanotechnology, especially
fabrication technique.
In spite of the developments in the calculation speed and algorithms, the number
of the atoms is limited. But fortunately, recent advances in nanotechnology make it
possible to treat nanostructured region of materials. The world of the computational
materials science is now large enough to be realized by nanotechnology, and
the world of nanotechnology is small enough to be treated by the computational
materials science. Many structures are proposed by many theorists, but very few of
them have been realized. Experimentalists are generally unwilling to try to fabricate
what theorists proposed. Why so? It is generally thought that the computationally
proposed structures are not necessarily easy to synthesize, stable, equilibrium or
qasi-equilibrium. Sometimes, scale of the proposed structure is not the same as the
experimental scale.
61 Alternative Materials Development Utilizing Advanced Nanotechnology 1193
3.4 Syntheses
If the computational materials science can predict new alternative materials, fabri-
cation of real material is of course necessary for the practical applications. In the
field of the materials science, numerous methods have been tried and carried since
the historical ages. As for the fabrication technique using so-called nanotechnology,
there are two approaches. They are called as the bottom-up nanotechnology and top-
down nanotechnology. The former is based on self-assembly. The latter is usually
nano-sized fabrication utilizing, for instance, semiconductor technology. Generally
speaking, materials for the consumer products should be produced in mass. Thus,
methods for the mass production are required. Yields are limited, for example, by
picking up and placing atoms one by one using STM.
from the source of the material. Interface engineering has been progressing rapidly
in the layered oxide materials. The characteristics of the film strongly depend on the
state of the top-layer termination and interface in the multilayered thin films. As for
the oxide materials, proper selection and proper treatment of substrate is extremely
important for the crystal growth of the film.
3.4.2 Nanoparticles
Development of nanoparticle materials is also very important for developing alter-
native materials. Since the number of atoms in a particle is limited, nanoparticles
are suitable for designing by the computational materials science. Since the surface-
to-volume ratio of nanoparticles is very large, catalytic applications are promising.
3.4.3 Self-assembly
So-called self-assembly is promising and useful compared to the top-down
nanotechnology in some fields. As for the organic and biomimetic materials, self-
assembly utilizes the polarity or electric charge of organic molecules. The concept of
self-assembly ranged rather widely. For metal and ceramic materials, self-assembly
is generally realized by the preferred orientation, surface tension, etc. These days,
self assembly is also realized by the thin-film growth technique such as the pulsed
laser deposition. Nanostructured crystals are fabricated based on the crystal growth
mode such as Volmer-Weber growth, and vapor-liquid-solid growth. This is also
a promising method for fabricating self-assembled nanostructures to realize novel
materials with unique properties. Langmuir-Blodgett technique is a very classical
method but rather important as well in the era of molecular designing to handle
monolayer level molecules.
3.5 Characterization
4 Promising Applications
Magnetic materials are one of the most significant and promising areas for
developing alternative materials. Nd-Fe-B is the strongest and widely used magnet
material. For magnet used in the hybrid car motors, dysprosium is added to this
system. Dysprosium is added to the magnet for the hybrid car motors, which are
used at higher temperatures. Neodymium belongs to the lanthanide series but not so
severely thought to be running short. But the supply of dysprosium is quite limited,
and price is getting even higher these days. Alternative materials to reduce the use
of dysprosium are eagerly studied for this reason, and some successful results are
known.
4.2 Catalysts
Fluorescent lights are widely used. Recently market for the LED light bulbs is
rapidly growing. In fluorescent light tubes, fluorescent powders are used to convert
61 Alternative Materials Development Utilizing Advanced Nanotechnology 1197
ultraviolet to visible light. White LEDs require materials to convert blue light to
yellow one. Of course, other conversion paths also exist depending on the product.
Basically fluorescent characteristics are defined by the element since the energy
difference between excited state and ground state is fixed depending on the kind
of element, and usually rare earth elements are used for this purpose. Thus, it is
difficult to be substituted by other elements. However, even such characteristics can
be tuned by the neighboring atoms especially at very low concentration. Alternative
materials using this effect are sought.
5 Example Cases
5.1 Superconductors
5.1.1 Materials
Superconductivity was discovered in 1911 by Kamerlingh Onnes (1911). Supercon-
ductors are known to exhibit zero resistance, but this is only one aspect of its unique
characteristics. They are, for example, Josephson effect, and quantized magnetic
flux. SQUID (superconducting quantum interference device) can be fabricated by
making use of the Josephson junction. SQUID is a highly sensitive magnetic sensor.
As for the conventional low superconducting transition temperature (Tc) metallic
superconductors, Nb, NbN, Nb-Ti alloy, and Nb3 Sn intermetallic compound are
widely used for practical applications. Since the discovery of high-temperature
oxide superconductors (HTS) in 1986, much effort has been made to develop
new materials. Exploration of family oxide superconducting materials is usu-
ally substitution of elements. For example, as for yttrium-based superconductors
(YBa2 Cu3 O7 : Y-123), yttrium can be substituted by any other lanthanides to
form the phase (RE-123). The substituted phases exhibit superconductivity except
for praseodymium. Characteristics are varied but they exhibit superconductiv-
ity transition temperature around 90 K. As mentioned above, displacement of
elements is a fundamental way of oxide superconductor chemistry. The super-
conducting properties of oxide superconductors strongly depend on the hole
concentration. Hole concentration can be changed by the substitution by dif-
ferent element in the same period as well as change in oxygen content. An-
other family of HTS is bismuth-based oxides. Three types of bismuth-based
superconductors are known. They are Bi2 Sr2 CuO6 (Bi-2201), Bi2 Sr2 CaCu2 O8
(Bi-2212), and Bi2 Sr2 Ca2 Cu3 O10 (Bi-2223).
5.1.7 Prospects
Up to now, Nb-based low-Tc superconductors are widely used in research in the
Josephson junction devices. One of the biggest reasons why high-temperature oxide
superconductors are hardly used in practical field is the materials problem. It is
difficult to fabricate materials’ in large scale and highly reproducible manner. The
advantage of using high-temperature superconductor is that the devices can be used
without liquid helium. Since helium is one of the precious elements and the price of
it is increasing constantly, helium-free operation is quite advantageous in terms of
the helium resource problem. In the field of the Josephson junction device, it will
take a little more time to replace low-temperature superconductors with HTS.
If one wishes to develop an alternative material, one should devise the material
from the comprehensive viewpoints. Short sighted strategy for the development
of alternative material makes no sense. When peasants directly appealed to Marie
Antoinette that they had no bread, it was told that she had who responded: “Let
them eat brioche.” These days, this story is regarded as a hoax or an urban legend
but widely disseminated. Replacing bread with brioche is obviously meaningless
when they were starving, but under a complicated situation just like a real-world
1200 S. Arisawa
supply chain, the story is not as simple as Marie Antoinette’s case and sometimes
leading to an unpractical conclusion.
For example, zinc-coated steel is used for cars. But zinc is running short,
and manufacturers are trying to reduce the use of zinc by developing alternative
material. On the other hand, zinc oxide is studied for electronic materials such
as semiconductors and transparent electrodes as alternative materials of composite
semiconductors and indium tin oxide. Some insist that it makes no sense to develop
alternative material by using zinc since the use of zinc itself should be reduced. But it
is not true. Effectiveness and industrial necessity for the development of alternative
materials strongly depend on the relative mass, market size, price, and so forth.
When alternative materials are studied, this fact should always be kept in mind.
7 Summary
As the economy and industry grow rapidly especially in the emerging countries,
resource problems are becoming severer and severer these days. The key to the
future alternative materials is based on the fusion of the computational materials
science, nano-syntheses technology, and nano-characterization. Development of
such materials can be achieved by fully utilizing nanotechnology. For this purpose,
assortment of the computational materials science, nano-level synthesis technique,
and nano-characterization techniques is indispensable. Development of alternative
material is extremely important for the sustainable engineering in the twenty-first
century.
8 Cross-References
Acknowledgments
The author would like to thank Dr. K. Halada (National Institute for Materials
Science), Prof. Y. Kawazoe (Tohoku Univ.), Prof. A. Suzuki (Yokohama National
Univ.), Dr. S. Hara (National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Tech-
nology), Profs. K. Yamaguchi and A. Yamaguchi (Iwate Univ.), Prof. M. Kamiko
(Univ. of Tokyo), Dr. H. Yoshida (Japan Science and Technology Agency), and
Ecomaterials Forum.
61 Alternative Materials Development Utilizing Advanced Nanotechnology 1201
References
S. Arisawa, K.S. Yun et al., Trans. Mater. Res. Soc. Jpn. 35, 195–196 (2010)
M.N. Baibich, J.M. Broto et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 61, 2472–2475 (1988)
G. Binasch, P. Grünberg et al., Phys. Rev. B 39, 4828–4830 (1989)
W.H. Butler, X.-G. Zhang et al., Phys. Rev. B 63, 054416 (2001)
K. Endo, H. Yamasaki et al., Nature 355, 327 (1992)
K. Endo, P. Badica et al., Trans. Mater. Res. Soc. Jpn., 35, 993 (2008)
K. Halada, J. Kasai, Rare Metals: Strategy for Alternative Materials (The Nikkan Kogyo Shimbun,
Tokyo, 2010) (Written in Japanese)
B.D. Josephson, Phys. Lett. 1, 251 (1962)
S.W. Kim, S. Matsuishi et al., Nanoletters 7, 1138 (2007)
R. Kleiner, F. Steinmeyer et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 68, 2394–2397 (1992)
H. Koinuma, I. Takeuchi, Nat. Mater. 3, 429 (2004)
J. Mathon, A. Umerski, Phys. Rev. B 63, 220403R (2001)
S. Matsuishi, Y. Toda et al., Science 301, 626–629 (2003)
Y. Mihara et al., Special issue on minor metals. J. Jpn. Soc. Tribol. 56, 459–488 (2011)
H. Nakamura, K. Hirota et al., IEEE Trans. Magn. 41, 3844–3846 (2005)
H.K. Onnes, Commun. Phys. Lab. Univ. Leiden 12, 120 (1911)
L. Ozyuzer, A.E. Koshelev et al., Science 318, 1291 (2007)
Report on elemental strategy by National Institute for Materials Science (2007), http://www.nims.
go.jp/publicity/publication/outlook elemental-strategy.html (In Japanese)
H. Sepehri-Amina, T. Ohkuboa et al., Scr. Mater. 63, 1124 (2010)
M.H.F. Sluiter, Y. Kawazoe et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 94, 187204 (2005)
S. Yuasa, T. Nagahama et al., Nat. Mater. 4, 868 (2004)
K.S. Yun, B.D. Choi et al., Appl. Phys. Lett. 80, 61 (2002)
K.S. Yun, T. Hatano et al., Supercond. Sci. Tech. 21, 075006-1-4 (2008)
Biopolymers for Environmental
Applications: Highly Functional 62
Polylactic Acid Composites Used
for Durable Products
Masatoshi Iji
Abstract
Highly functional biomass-based plastics (bioplastics) based on renewable plant
resources, advanced polylactic acid (PLA) composites, have been developed for
use in durable products such as electronic instruments. The PLA composites
exhibit high practicability including good heat resistance, strength, and flame
retardancy while fully preserving high biomass-based component ratio and
chemical safety. They also possess desirable new properties such as good shape
memory and thermal diffusivity for use in upcoming instruments. Moreover,
a self-assembling siloxane nano-sized particle (nanoparticle) was developed
to increase the tenacity of the PLA composites. Adding natural kenaf fiber
increased heat resistance and elastic modulus of PLA, and using a PLA-polyester
copolymer improved the impact strength of the PLA composite. High flame
retardancy and other important characteristics including strength and moldability
were successfully achieved by adding heat-absorbing aluminum hydroxide and a
phenol novolac-type charring agent in PLA. Combinations of the shape memory
and recyclability (thermoplasticity) were performed by cross-linking PLA using
a thermoreversible bond for the use in wearable devices, which are deformable
and recyclable. Also, a high thermal diffusivity comparable to that of stainless
steel was achieved by including carbon fibers cross-linked by natural amide
compound as a binding agent in PLA to improve heat release issues caused
by small and thin electronic devices. Furthermore, self-assembling siloxane
nanoparticles with three phases (high-density siloxane phase, elastomeric sili-
cone phase, and caprolactone oligomer phase) increase the tenacity of PLA to
advance the application of the PLA composites for thin-sized equipments.
M. Iji
Smart Energy Research Laboratories NEC Corporation, Tsukuba, Ibaraki, Japan
e-mail: m-iji@bk.jp.nec.com
1 Introduction
To enable PLA to be used for the housings of durable products including elec-
tronic equipments, it is necessary to significantly improve its heat resistance and
strength characteristics. New PLA composite material, kenaf fiber-reinforced PLA
HO H
O
n
Scheme 62.1 Structure of
polylactic acid (PLA) O
62 Biopolymers for Environmental Applications 1205
Heat Flame
Plant resource resistance Adding aluminum retardancy
hydroxide
Starch, etc
Adding kenaf fiber
Fermentation
Polymerization
Poly lactic
Cellular phone
acid Lighting PC
New functions
Shape Thermal
memory diffusivity
Including cross-linked
carbon fiber
Device Heat Housing
Thermo-reversibly
cross-linking of
Wearable products PLA Small and thin type products
Kenaf
Fiber
other countries around the world, mainly as a substitute for the existing materials
for uses such as paper fiber and livestock feed.
The results of the tests conducted by kneading kenaf fiber (crushed kenaf, under
5 mm long) with PLA to enhance stiffness show that addition of 15% or more of
the fiber results in better heat resistance (deformation temperature under load) and
elastic modulus than that of the petroleum-based ABS resin (Table 62.1). This was
not only from the fact that kenaf fiber inhibits the deformation of PLA but also
by its ability to promote crystallization of PLA. Also, removal of kenaf particles
(use of cut kenaf: 5 mm long) and addition of a biomass-based flexible agent (a
PLA/polyester copolymer) to promote ductility resulted in the improved impact
strength (see Table 62.1). The kenaf-PLA composite has been used in the housings
of some electronic equipments such as cell phone and lighting devices.
Plastics used for the housings of medium-sized and larger electronic equipments
such as personal computers require a high degree of flame retardancy to prevent
fire. Since PLA is quite easily flammable, its flame retardancy needs to be improved
before it can be used for such applications. Conventional flame retardants such as
halogen compounds are environmentally unsafe, and then, a flame-retardant PLA
composite without using these substances was developed (Yanagisawa et al. 2009).
After investigating a variety of safe materials to enhance the flame-retarding
ability of PLA, a formula that displays a high degree of flame retardancy (UL
standard: 94 V-0/1.0 mmt) as well as other important and useful properties was
successfully developed by the combination of specific metal hydroxide: aluminum
62 Biopolymers for Environmental Applications 1207
200
150
Adding V-1
100 PN resin or
V-2
50
5wt%
10wt% V-0
0
0 40 50 60 70
ATH Concentration in PLA (wt%)
Fig. 62.3 Flame retardancy of PLA composites with aluminum trihydrate (ATH) and phenol
novolac resin (PN) as charring agent
Shape memory plastics are plastics with the following ability. If they are deformed
using heat and external force, then cooled and hardened, when they are heated
again, they return to their original shape. Generally, this characteristic is seen in
plastics having a cross-linked structure (mesh structure). Unfortunately though, due
to their cross-linked structure, such plastics do not melt, even at high temperatures,
so recycling them (remolding them in differently shaped metal molds) is difficult.
Needing to solve this problem, a technology to achieve thermoreversible cross-
linking based on the Diels-Alder reaction (Engle and Wagner 1993; Chujyo et al.
1990) in the structure of PLA was developed, resulting in materials displaying a
combination of shape memory and recyclability (Fig.62.4) (Inoue et al. 2008, 2009).
Thanks to this cross-linked structure, the material can be deformed and restored to
its original shape by heating at a temperature of a hair dryer (approximately 60 ı C),
1208 M. Iji
Molecules of PLA
Thermo-reversible bond
(Diels-Alder reaction) Heating at
high temp.
O O
O
O + N
N
Cooling
O O
Fig. 62.5 Shape memory and recycling performed with thermoreversible cross-linked PLA
composite
but if heated to a typical molding temperature (160 ı C), the cross-linked structure
dissociates, causing the material to melt, thereby enabling easy recyclability
(Fig. 62.5).
This recyclable shape memory PLA composite allows users to freely deform
the material into any shape they like, making possible all kinds of new prod-
ucts and applications, like futuristic wearable electronic equipments for example
Fig. 62.6.
62 Biopolymers for Environmental Applications 1209
Fig. 62.6 Wearable mobile equipments in future using shape memory PLA composite
The rapid reduction of the size of electronic products is increasing the difficulty
of dissipating the heat they produce. Because small and slim products such as
the latest mobile phones and personal computers cannot easily be equipped with
conventional cooling devices like fans and coolers, many of the plastic parts used
in these products need to be able to conduct heat away from the electric parts.
While adding conductive fillers such as metals oxides and carbon fibers to plastics
increases their thermal diffusivity and thermal conductivity (Bigg 1995; Hill and
Supancic 2002; Goyanes et al. 2001; Kumlutaş et al. 2003; Ishida and Rimdusit
1998), adding sufficiently large amounts of these fillers also increases the density of
the plastics and reduces their mechanical strength and moldability.
A PLA composite which realizes thermal diffusivity higher than that of stainless
steel was developed by including cross-linked carbon fibers in PLA (Nakamura
and Iji 2009; Iji et al. 2011a, b). The material is expected to make electronic
equipments more environmentally sound while improving conventional heat release
issues. Creation of a cross-linked structure of carbon fibers (several millimeters
long) through the use of a unique biomass-based binder, a natural amide compound
(N,N’–ethylene bis-stearamide), in PLA achieves high heat diffusion (with carbon
fiber of 10% and 30%, the heat diffusion ability of the PLA composite is comparable
to and double that of stainless steel respectively) (Figs. 62.7 and 62.8). The
gravities of the composites with carbon fibers are between 1.3 and 1.5, which
are less than half the values comparing with the previous heat-conductive plastic
composites containing high contents of heat-conductive fillers to perform the same
heat diffusions.
1210 M. Iji
a b
50 µm 50 µm
c d
50 µm 100 µm
Fig. 62.7 Micrographs of PLA composites: (a) PLA, (b) PLA with 5 wt% of amide binder, (c,d)
PLA with 10 wt% of carbon fiber (6 mm long) and 5 wt% of amide binder
Specimen(2mmt)
a b c d
Heat Flow
Observation
Maximum temp.
Fig. 62.8 Infrared thermography of PLA composite plates and stainless plate (2:07:00:2 cm):
(a) PLA, (b) PLA with 10 wt% of carbon fiber (CF:6 mm long), (c) PLA with 10 wt% of CF and
5 wt% of amide binder, and (d) stainless steel
62 Biopolymers for Environmental Applications 1211
7 Summary
a PMPS Me
PrO Si O Pr
8
OPr
OMe 2) 1)
O
MeO Si NCO HO Bu
O 4
OMe
IPTS CLO
b IPTS CLO c
PMPS
Fig. 62.9 Preparation of organosiloxane with three units (a) and self-assembly of three-
phased nanoparticles through aggregation (b) and condensation (c) of organosiloxane. (IPTS:
isocyanatepropyltrimethoxysilane, PMPS: polymethylpropyloxysiloxane, CLO: caprolactone
oligomer)
The next subject of bioplastics is changing the resource from edible plant ingredi-
ents to inedible ones. PLA and current other major bioplastics use starch as the main
resource, and starch is produced from plants that are generally edible. However,
fears for future food shortages are driving an effort to use plant resources that are
not edible. As inedible plant resources with stable supply, cellulose is the most likely
candidate because it is the main component of most plants and the largest amount
of nonfood plant resources produced in the ground. Cellulose is a polysaccharide
like starch, but because of hydrogen bonding within and between its molecules,
it forms a rigid crystalline structure, which is not suited to consumption as food
and thus can be used as biomass resources. Therefore, research and development
to convert cellulose to current bioplastics including PLA and new bioplastics are
62 Biopolymers for Environmental Applications 1213
a b
120
i ii
100
Stress / MPa
80
60
40
20
iii
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Elongation / %
Fig. 62.10 (a) Flexural test of PLA nanocomposites containing nanoparticles (5 wt%): (i) PLA,
(ii) PLA nanocomposite containing three-phased nanoparticle, (iii) PLA nanocomposite containing
silica nanoparticle. (b) Test piece of PLA nanocomposite with three-phased nanoparticle after
flexural test
required. For example, a new advanced cellulose-based resin has been studied,
which is produced by bonding cellulose and a nonfood plant oil: cardanol derived
from cashew nuts shell, an agricultural by-product (Iji et al. 2011b).
References
D.M. Bigg, Adv. Polym. Sci. 119, 1 (1995)
Y. Chujyo, K. Sada, T. Saegusa, Macromolecules 23, 2636 (1990)
L.P. Engle, K.B. Wagner, J.M.S.-Rev. Macromol. Chem. Phys. 33(3), 239 (1993)
S.N. Goyanes, J.D. Marconi, P.G. König et al., J. Polym. 42, 5267 (2001)
R.F. Hill, P.H. Supancic, J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 85, 851 (2002)
F. Hussain, M. Hojjati, M. Okamoto et al., J. Compos. Mater. 40, 1511 (2006)
M. Iji, N. Morishita, H. Kai, Polym. J. 43, 101 (2011a)
M. Iji, S. Moon, S. Tanaka, Polym. J. 43, 738 (2011b)
K. Inoue, M. Yamashiro, M. Iji, Polym. J. 40, 657 (2008)
K. Inoue, M. Yamashiro, M. Iji, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 112(2), 876 (2009)
H. Ishida, S. Rimdusit, Thermochim. Acta 320, 177 (1998)
J. Jordan, K.I. Jacob, R. Tannenhaum et al., Mater. Sci. Eng. A 393, 1 (2005)
D. Kumlutaş, İ.H. Tavman, M.T. Çoban, Compos. Sci. Technol. 63, 113 (2003)
T. Lam, K. Hori, K. Iiyama, J. Wood Sci. 49, 255 (2003)
S. Li, W. Ernst, P Martin, Biofuels Bioprod. Biorefining 4(1), 25 (2010)
A. Nakamura, M. Iji, J. Mater. Sci. 44, 4572 (2009)
A. Nakamura, M. Iji, J. Mater. Sci. 46, 747 (2011a)
A. Nakamura, M. Iji, J. Mater. Sci. 46, 1439 (2011b)
P. Rosso, L. Ye, K. Friedrich et al., J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 100, 1849 (2006)
S. Serizawa, K. Inoue, M. Iji, Appl. Polym. Sci. 100(1), 618 (2006)
A. Usuki, N. Hasegawa, M. Kato, Adv. Polym. Sci. 179, 135 (2005)
T. Yanagisawa, Y. Kiuchi, M. Iji, Koubunshi Ronbunshu 66(7), 49 (2009)
Computational Materials Science and
Computer-aided Materials Design and 63
Processing
Abstract
With tremendous progress in computer technologies and applications during the
last decade, atomistic-level simulation is rapidly becoming an essential tool in
materials science for the study of the physical and chemical properties of various
materials. Moreover, in parallel with the experimental efforts, computer-aided
materials design is also an important factor in the fabrication of novel materials,
to be applied in driving engineering innovations and urgent technological needs
for achieving a sustainable society. Here, an original approach has been demon-
strated that allows us to construct a p T phase diagrams of various hydrates
with complex gas compositions. In order to evaluate the parameters of weak
interactions, a time-dependent density-functional formalism and local density
(TDLDA) technique entirely in real space have been implemented for the cal-
culations of frequency-dependent polarizabilities and van der Waals dispersion
coefficients for atoms within the all-electron mixed-basis approach (TOMBO
code) developed at the Institute for Materials Research, Tohoku University.
The combination of both methods enables one to calculate thermodynamic
properties of clathrate hydrates without resorting to any empirical parameter
fittings. Using the proposed method, it is possible to not only confirm the existing
experimental data but also predict the unknown region of thermodynamic
stability of clathrate hydrates, and also propose the gas storage ability as well
1 Introduction
Rapidly developing modern society poses problems to the scientific and engineering
organizations in that many of the currently used technologies and perspective
engineering innovations need to be directed in a more sustainable way. Time
required for solving these tasks must be drastically reduced in connection with the
aggravation of the ecological problems which are caused by the rapidly increasing
population and intense economic growth. Without solution, it will not be possible to
prevent the negative effects of such development. Therefore, sustainable engineering
and materials science will continue to play an important role in five key thematic
areas such as energy, transportation, housing, materials resources, and health.
Global demand for energy is growing even faster than the population and an
increasing number of observations have given us general understanding of the
dramatic and catastrophic consequences that may occur if society continues to focus
on consumption of energy mostly produced from fossil fuel reserves. The reduction
of the use of fossil fuels and the replacement of that with the alternative and
sustainable energy sources is one of the present grand energy challenges. Hydrogen
is an ideal candidate for this substitution, and, therefore, the technology of using
hydrogen as an environmentally clean and efficient fuel is an active research area
worldwide. However, it is important to overcome many scientific and technological
hurdles that exist between the present state of hydrogen production, utilization, and
storage capabilities and those required for a competitive and sustainable hydrogen
economy (Ockwig and Nenoff 2007).
In order to realize efficient energy technologies, experimentalists should make
much effort to bring new ideas and development of new materials with desired
properties. Theorists can aid in this search by narrowing the field through accurate
prediction of the chemical and physical properties of materials with different
composition. Recent rapid advances in computer technology have given rise to
numerous opportunities in the materials science research. This involves going
from the analytical description of a model system to the representation of the
realistic molecular structures and associated physical and chemical properties by
the computational modeling. The value of simulation can be evaluated based on
its ability to rapidly and accurately predict the properties of the novel functional
materials in a more cost-effective way than is experimentally possible.
Computational materials science combines all numerical methods based on
quantum mechanics (QM), molecular dynamics (MD), Monte Carlo (MC), lattice
dynamics (LD), and molecular mechanics (MM) simulations for the prediction of
the structure, electronic, and thermodynamic properties of materials. Basic principle
of these simulations is an estimation of the total energy of an investigated system.
63 Computational Materials Science 1217
There is a cost scale to the computational materials science because so many physi-
cal properties are related to the total energies. While just one piece of the theoretical
tool is necessary to calculate all the physical properties that are related to the total
energies, completely different pieces of the experimental tools are required to mea-
sure each class of the physical properties of a material. This represents an enormous
advantage of the computational materials science over the experimental measure-
ments (Payne et al. 1992). Simulations are easy to perform, even for very complex
systems; often, their complexity is no worse than that of the physical description.
As the capabilities of computers expand, simulations of many-body systems will be
able to treat more complex physical systems at higher levels of accuracy.
Materials scientists today employ essentially the entire periodic table in creating
modern technology. Thus, instead of synthesizing and testing a large number of
potential candidates, it is possible to use various computational approaches to screen
a large number of candidates including very expensive elements. Experiments only
need to be performed on a small number of the most promising candidates. Using
powerful computers and highly accurate methods, scientists can accelerate the
realization of novel materials and propose these materials for different applications.
Application of these materials for generation, storage, and supply of energy is one
of the great opportunities for researchers, both theorists and experimentalists.
One of the major challenges in establishing a hydrogen-based economy is the
effective storage and delivery of hydrogen. There are several candidate groups
for the hydrogen storage materials, each with the positive and negative attributes.
Traditional hydrides have excellent H-volume storage capacity, good and tunable
kinetics and reversibility, but poor H-storage by weight. Highly porous carbon
and hybrid materials have the capability of high mass storage capacity, but since
adsorption is of molecular hydrogen, they can only work under the cryogenic
conditions. Light metal alloys have the required mass density but poor kinetics and
high absorption temperatures/pressures. Finally, complex hydrides undergo chem-
ical reactions while desorbing/adsorbing, thus restricting kinetics and reversibility
(Eberle et al. 2009).
Clathrate hydrate is another type of material which has the potential for the
hydrogen storage. This is a guest-host or inclusion compound in which water
molecules form a three-dimensional host structure where the molecules (guests)
can be encaged in the empty voids (Sloan and Koh 2008). Recently, it has been
reported that the clathrate hydrate of structure II (CS-II) can store around 4.96 wt%
of hydrogen at 220 MPa and 234 K. Following these works, many experimental and
theoretical studies of hydrogen hydrates (see Fig. 63.1) using different methods
have been conducted (Struzhkin et al. 2007). Much of the work concentrated on
accurate estimation of the hydrogen capacity of the CS-II clathrate hydrate and
under what conditions the maximum capacity can be achieved. Other work focused
on the formation of hydrogen hydrates at lower pressures since the high-pressure
conditions for pure hydrogen hydrate formation place a limiting constraint on its
practical application. A nearly two orders of magnitude reduction in the hydrate for-
mation pressure was found in the tetrahydrofuran (THF) – hydrogen – water system.
Thus, the possible formation of hydrogen hydrate with different structures by adding
various guest molecules suggests the practical feasibility of the binary hydrate as a
1218 R.V. Belosludov et al.
Recently, fundamental role of the van der Waals (vdW) interactions at separations
beyond an interatomic bond length has been recognized in materials science
(French et al. 2010). These interactions are important in the synthesis and the
63 Computational Materials Science 1219
stability of the inclusion compounds with weak guest-host interactions, and their
manipulation is essential for the design of useful hydrogen storage materials. The
van der Waals interactions act between neutral atoms. At short distance, where
overlap of the electronic clouds is non-negligible, atoms repel and at distance
where overlap is negligible, atoms are attracted by mutual polarization of their
electronic clouds. There is a fundamental difference between these repulsive and
attractive interactions. The description of the repulsive interactions is performed
within the framework of quantum chemistry, while the attractive or van der Waals
interactions are described with the rules of the quantum electrodynamics. There
are numerous possible approaches for the calculations of short-range repulsive
interactions (Dobson et al. 2001). Long-range attractive van der Waals interactions
can be evaluated through the quantum fluctuations of the electrodynamic field
(Parsegian 2006).
In the framework of the general theory of van der Waals forces (Dzyaloshinskii
et al. 1961), neutral atoms in vacuum with the electromagnetic field fluctuations
absorb and emit photons. By absorption of photons, atoms are transferred into
excited states. This can lead to the appearance of virtual multipole moments whose
interactions determine the attractive van der Waals interactions. Therefore, long-
range interactions appear due to interactions between electrons of the atoms in the
excited states, while short-range interactions are due to the repulsion interaction
between electrons of the atoms in their ground states.
In the approximate accounting for interactions of the induced dipoles, the
interaction energy between two atoms can be represented in the form of C6 /R6 ,
where C6 is the van der Waals coefficient and R is the distance between atoms.
Different approaches have been employed for the calculation of the van der Waals
dispersion coefficients C6 within time-dependent density functional theory. The
knowledge of the static and dynamic dipole-dipole polarizability at imaginary
frequencies suffices to compute the van der Waals interaction. For the purpose of
calculating C6 coefficients, matrix formulation of the linear response theory has
been employed (Casida 1995), yielding oscillator strengths and excitation energies,
sufficient ingredients for the computation of the dynamic polarizability. Linear-
response theory within the time-dependent density functional formalism and the
local density approximation (TDLDA) has been implemented to compute transition
energies and optical absorption spectra for many different systems within the higher-
order finite-difference pseudopotential method (Vasiliev et al. 2002). The TDLDA
technique has been implemented entirely in real space for calculations of the
frequency-dependent polarizabilities and van der Waals dispersion coefficients for
atoms within the all-electron mixed-basis approach. In this method, the one-electron
wave functions are expressed in terms of both localized nucleus-centered functions
and plane waves (Bahramy et al. 2006).
functions k .Er 0 /. The true excitation energies I , which correspond to the poles of
the dynamic polarizability, may be obtained from the solution of the Casida equation
(Casida 1995) as shown in (63.1),
lk D n nk is the difference between the occupation numbers, and ! lk D "k "l
is the difference between the eigenvalues of the l-th and k-th single-particle states;
Kij;kl is the adiabatic coupling matrix (Hartree atomic units are used throughout the
section, unless otherwise stated).
The analytic expression for the adiabatic coupling matrix in (63.3),
ZZ !
1 ı 2 Exc Œ 0 0
Kij;kl D i .E
r / j .Er / ˇ ˇC k .E
r / r /d rEd rE0
l .E
ˇrE rE0 ˇ ı.Er /ı.Er 0 /
(63.3)
can be split into two parts in (63.4),
.1/ .2/
Kij;kl D Kij;kl C Kij;kl : (63.4)
1
The first term represents a six-dimensional integral of is shown in (63.5) as
jrEEr 0 j
ZZ !
.1/ 1 0 0
Kij;kl D i .E
r / j .Er / ˇ ˇ k .E
r / r /d rEd rE0 :
l .E (63.5)
ˇrE rE0 ˇ
2 X ˇˇ T 1=2 ˇˇ2
3
fI D ˇBˇ R FI ˇ ; (63.7)
3
ˇD1
where, FI are the eigenvectors of the Casida equation (63.1) as shown in (63.8),
63 Computational Materials Science 1221
Z
.Bˇ /ij D ‰i .Er /rˇ ‰j .Er /d rE; (63.8)
s
mCjmj 2l C 1 .l C jmj/Š 1 d ljmj
Ylm .Or / D .1/ 2 i l
.1/jmj l sinjmj ./
4 .l jmj/Š 2 lŠ .d cos /ljmj
1 X k X l i.G E G
E 0 /E
r
lk
PW;PW
.Er / D cG cG 0 e ; (63.13)
G 0 G
1 X X E0
PW;AO
lk .Er / D p cGl00 e i G rEcnk0 l 0 m0 ˆn0 l 0 m0 .Er /
N 0 n0 l 0 m0 G 00
1 X X E0
C p c k 00 e i G rE cnl0 l 0 m0 ˆn0 l 0 m0 .Er / (63.14)
N 0 n0 l 0 m0 G 00 G
1 X l X
lk
AO;AO
.Er / D cn0 l 0 m0 ˆn0 l 0 m0 .Er / k
cnlm ˆnlm .Er /: (63.15)
N 00 0
nl m nlm
As the radial part of the AO is nonzero only inside the sphere of radius r0 , G E rE
2.l1 C l2 C l2 / Lr00 and in case Lr00 < 1, choosing definite number of the reciprocal
lattice vectors so that GE rE < 1, one can approximate exponentials in (63.14) by units,
then (63.16) results
1 X X
lk
PW;AO
.Er / p cGl00 cnk0 l 0 m0 ˆn0 l 0 m0 .Er / C cGk 00 cnl0 l 0 m0 ˆn0 l 0 m0 .Er / :
N 0 n0 l 0 m0 G 00
(63.16)
In this approximation, the plane-wave part of the wave function is considered
approximately as a constant inside the sphere. Using the identity as shown in
(63.17): Z
1 1 d qE i qE.Er Er 0 /
ˇ ˇD e ; (63.17)
ˇrE rE0 ˇ 2 2 q2
and substituting (63.12) into (63.15) one gets the following expression for the
coupling matrix K in the all-electron mixed-basis approach as shown in (63.18)–
(63.24):
where Z
0 .1/ 1 d qE PW;PW PW;PW
Kij;kl D .E
q /lk .E
q /; (63.19)
2 2 q 2 ij
Z
00 .1/ 1 d qE h PW;PW i
Kij;kl D .E
q / PW;AO
.E
q / C AO;PW
.E
q / PW;PW
.E
q / ; (63.20)
2 2 q 2 ij lk ij lk
63 Computational Materials Science 1223
Z
000 .1/ 1 d qE h PW;PW i
Kij;kl D .E
q / AO;AO
.E
q / C AO;AO
.E
q / PW;PW
.E
q / ; (63.21)
2 2 q 2 ij lk ij lk
Z
Q
0 .1/ 1 d qE PW;AO PW;AO
Kij;kl D .E
q /lk .E
q /; (63.22)
2 2 q 2 ij
Z
00 .1/ 1 d qE h PW;AO i
KQ ij;kl D 2 2
ij .E AO;AO
q /lk q / C ijAO;AO .E
.E PW;AO
q /lk .E
q/ ; (63.23)
2 q
Z
000 .1/ 1 d qE AO;AO
KQ ij;kl D .E
q /lkAO;AO
.E
q /; (63.24)
2 2 q 2 ij
R
where .E q / D d rE exp.i qErE/.Er / is Fourier transform of .Er /. The first three terms,
0 .1/ 00 .1/ 000 .1/
Kij;kl C Kij;kl C Kij;kl in (63.18) corresponds to the interaction of the plane waves
between themselves and the interaction of the plane waves with the atomic orbitals.
For these terms integration can be reduced from six to three dimensions. For the
first term, integration over rE reduces to the integral for delta-function. Then, the
expression for the delta-function takes the following form (63.25):
.2/3 X k X l E
PW;PW
lk .E
q/ D c c 0 ı.G GE 0 C qE/: (63.25)
G G 0 G
G
0 .1/ 2.2/4 X i X j 1 X
E ¤G
E0
Kij;kl D cG 0 cG ˇ ˇ2 cGl00 cG
k
E G E 00
E 0 CG
at G
ˇ E E 0 ˇ
G 0 G ˇG G ˇ G 00
and
D0 at E DG
G E0 (63.26)
2
Z X X
00 .1/ 4 6 j 1 E GE 0 /E
Kij;kl D 4 d rE cGi0 cG ˇ ˇ2 e
i.G r PW;AO
lk .Er /
ˇE Eˇ
0 ˇ
G0 G ˇG G
3
Z X X 1 E 000 G
E 00 /E 7
C ijPW;AO .Er / cGl00 cGk 000 ˇ ˇ e
.i G r
d rE5
ˇ E 000 E 00 ˇ2
G 000 G 000 ˇG G ˇ
2
Z X X j
4 6 1
4 d rE cGi0 cG ˇ ˇ2 lk
PW;AO
.Er /
ˇ E E 0 ˇ
G 0 G ˇG G ˇ
1224 R.V. Belosludov et al.
3
Z X X 1 7 E ¤G
E0
C ijPW;AO .Er / cGl00 cGk 000 ˇ ˇ d rE5 at G
ˇ E 000 E 00 ˇ2
G 00 G ˇG G ˇ
and
D0 at E DG
G E0 (63.27)
2
Z X X
000 .1/ 4 6 j 1
Kij;kl 4 d rE cGi0
cG ˇ AO;AO
ˇ2 lk .Er /
ˇ E G Eˇ 0 ˇ
G0 G ˇG
3
Z X X 1 7 E ¤G
E0
C ijAO;AO .Er / cGl0 cGk ˇ ˇ2 d rE5 at G
ˇ ˇ
G0 G ˇGE 000 GE 00 ˇ
and
D0 at E D GE 0
G (63.28)
Substitution of (63.15) and (63.16) into (63.27) and (63.28) and integration over rE
gives the following expression for the first three terms of (63.18) yielding (63.29)
and (63.30):
8
ˆ
0 .1/ 00 .1/ 000 .1/ 4 <X i X j 1 X
Kij;kl C Kij;kl C Kij;kl D cG 0 cG ˇ ˇ2 cGl00 cG
k
E G E 00
E 0 CG
:̂ 0 ˇ E E 0 ˇ
G G ˇG G ˇ G 00
X 1 Xh j l j
i
C ˇ ˇ2 cGi0 cG cnlm k
cnlm i
C cnlm cnlm cGl0 cGk
ˇE E 0 ˇˇ nlm
GIG 0 ˇG G
X X 1 n l k
i j k l
C An 0 0 ˇ ˇ2 cG 0 cG cG 00 cn0 00 C cG 00 cn0 00
ˇE E 0 ˇˇ
n0 GIG 0 IG 00 ˇG G
9
h i o>=
j j E ¤G E0
C cGi00 cn0 00 C cG 00 cni0 00 cGl0 cGk at G
>
;
and
D0 at GE D G
E 0; (63.29)
where
p Zr0
2
Anl D p r 2 drRnl .r/: (63.30)
0
0
63 Computational Materials Science 1225
Z "
PW;AO E 1 Er
X X
i GE
Qlk .G/ D p d rEe cGl00 cnk0 l 0 m0 ˆn0 l 0 m0 .Er /
0 0 n0 l 0 m0 G 00
#
X X
C cGk 00 cnl0 l 0 m0 ˆn0 l 0 m0 .Er / (63.34)
n0 l 0 m0 G 00
Z X X
AO;AO E E
lk .G/ D d rEe i GEr l
cnlm ˆnlm .Er / cnk0 l 0 m0 ˆn0 l 0 m0 .Er /: (63.35)
0 nlm n0 l 0 m0
1 M
X X DL
Er
i GE O LM .Or /
e D 4 i L jL .Gr/YLM .G/Y (63.36)
LD0 M DL
into ( 63.34) and ( 63.35) and integrating over the angular variables, one can get
(63.37)–(63.40):
PW;AO E
X Xh i
lk .G/ D .i /l Bnl .G/ c lE0 cnlm
k O C c k cnlm
.1/l Ylm .G/ l
Y l
m O
. G/ ;
G E0 G
nlm GE0
(63.37)
1
X X X
AO;AO E mm0 n0 l 0
O BQ nl .G; L/ LIlmIl 0 m0 ;
lk .G/ D 4 iL l
cnlm cnk0 l 0 m0 YL .G/
LD0 nlm n0 l 0 m0
(63.38)
1226 R.V. Belosludov et al.
where
Z
4 ˇ ˇ
Bnl .G/ D p r 2 drRnl .ˇrEˇ/jl .Gr/;
0 0
Z
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
BQ nnll .G; L/ D r 2 drRnl .ˇrEˇ/Rn0 l 0 .ˇrEˇ/jL .Gr/;
0 0
(63.39)
0
Z=2
L;lm;l 0 m0 D sin d‚LImm0 ./‚l 0 m0 ./‚lm ./: (63.40)
=2
onefold simple integration over to find coefficients LIl 0 m0 ;lm . After substitution
of (63.37) and (63.38) into (63.31)–(63.33), the 4-, 5- and 6-th terms of the coupling
matrix K from (63.18) take the form
0 .1/ 1 1 X 1 X l Xh j
KQ ij;kl D .i / Bnl .G/ O
c iE0 cnlm .1/l Ylm .G/
2 2 .L0 /3 G2 G
E
G nlm GE0
i X Xh
j
i O l0 0
O 0
Cc E0 cnlm Ylm .G/ .i / Bn0 l 0 .G/ cGl0 00 cnk0 l 0 m0 .1/l Ylm0 .G/
G
n0 l 0 m0 G 0 00
0
i
CcGkN 0 cnl0 l 0 m0 Ylm
0
O ;
.G/ (63.41)
1
(
00 .1/ 2 1 X LX 1 X 00 m0
KQ ij;kl D i .i /l cnl00 l 00 m00 cnk0 l 0 m0 YLm O
.G/
.L0 /3 LD0 G2
E GE0
G; nlmI n0 l 0 m0 I
n00 l 00 m00
0 0
h
j O
BQ nn00ll 00 .G; L/ LIl 00 m00 Il 0 m0 Bnl .G/ c iE0 cnlm .1/l Ylm .G/
G
i 0
j i
C c E0 cnlm O C cnlm
Ylm .G/ i j O BQ nnl0 l 0 .G; L/ LIlmIl 0 m0 .i /l 00
cn0 l 0 m0 YLmm .G/
G
)
h i
l k l 00 m00 O k l m00 O
Bn00 l 00 .G/ c 0 00 c 00 00 00 .1/ Y 00 .G/ C c N 0 c 00 00 00 Y 00 .G/
G n l m l G n l m (63.42)
l
1
000.1/ 8 X 1 X L L0
KQ ij;kl D i i
.L0 /3 G2 0
E
G L;L D0
X j 0 00 m000
i
cnlm O m
cn0 l 0 m0 cnl00 l 00 m00 cnk00 l 00 m00 YLmm .G/Y O
.G/
L0
nlmIn0 l 0 m0
n00 l 00 m00 In000 l 000 m000
63 Computational Materials Science 1227
0 0 000 000
BQ nnll .G; L/BQ nn00 ll00 .G; L0 / LIlmIl 0 m0 L0 Il 00 m00 Il 000 m000 : (63.43)
In ( 63.41)–( 63.43) sums over the GE - vectors can replace by integrals over qE
3 E
(d qE D .L0 / , G D qE ) and, after integration over the angular variables and
,
one gets (63.44)–(63.50):
0 .1/ 1 X X n0 l X h j
KQ ij;kl D Knl .1/m cGi cnlm cGl0 cnk0 lm
2 2 0 0 nlm n G;G
i
j
i j j
C cG cnlm cGl cnk0 lm C cGi cnlm cGk cnl0 lm C .1/m cG cnlm
i
cGk 0 cnl0 lm (63.44)
00 X X h
.1/ i j
KQ ij;kl D Nnl
00 00 0
n l ;n l 0 .l 00
/ 00 0 0
l k
l Il m Ilm cG cn00 l 00 mm0 cnlm cn0 l 0 m0
nlmIn0 l 0 m0 In00 l 00 G
0 j j
C .1/m m cG cnlm
i l k i l k
0 m cnlm cn0 l 0 m0 C cnlm cn0 l 0 m0 cG cn00 l 00 m0 m
0
i
j
C .1/m m cnlm
i
cn0 l 0 m0 cGk cnl00 l 00 m0 m (63.45)
1
X X
000 .1/ j 00 00 000 l 000
KQ ij;kl D 8 i
cnlm cn0 l 0 m0 cnl00 l 00 m00 cnk00 l 000 mm0 Cm00 …nnl;nl 0 l;n0
LD0 nlmIn0 l 0 m0
n00 l 00 m00 In000 l 000
where
Zr0 Zr0
n0 l .4/2 2
Knl D r dr Rnl .r/ r 02 dr 0 Rn0 l .r 0 /Jl l .r; r 0 /; (63.47)
0
0 0
Z
8 ˇ ˇ
Nnl
00 00
n l ;n l0 0 .l 00
/ D p r 2 drRn00 l 00 .ˇrEˇ/
0 0
Z
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
r 02 dr 0 Rnl .ˇrE0 ˇ/Rn0 l 0 .ˇrE0 ˇ/Jl 0 l 00 .r; r 0 /; (63.48)
0
Zr0j Zr0j
00 00 000 000
…nnl;nl 0 l;n0 l .L/ D r 2 drr 02 dr 0 Rj 0 nl .r/Rj 0 n0 l 0 .r/
0 0
Z1
0
Jl l .r; r / D dqjl .qr/jl .qr 0 /; (63.50)
0
l
d sin.x/
jl .x/ D .1/l x l : (63.51)
xdx x
To perform integration over r and r 0 in (63.47)–(63.49), one needs initially to per-
form integration over q in order to find Jl l 0 .r; r 0 / and over in (63.50) and (63.40)
to find LIlm;l 0 m0 . For the choice of s; p; d atomic orbitals (l; l 0 ; l 00 ; l 000 D 0; 1; 2)
as the basis functions for the construction of the Kohn-Sham wave functions,
summation over L in ( 63.46) is restricted to five terms L D 1, 2, 3, 4 because
the Gaunt coefficients Cl 0 m0 ;Lm0 m;lm D 2 LIlm;l 0 m0 are nonzero only under the
following conditions the (63.52):
l0 C L l 0 l0 L C l 0 l 0 C L C l 0: (63.52)
That implies that for the fixed values of l 0 ; l the maximal value of L is equal to
L D l C l 0 . The maximum of these values is reached at l 0 D 2; l D 2 and is
equal to Lmax D 4. For l; l 0 ; D 0, 1, 2 and L D 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, the expressions for
Jl l 0 .r; r 0 / integrated over q in (63.50) and expressions for LIlm;l 0 m0 integrated over
in (63.40) are obtained analytically.
In order to find the oscillator strengths fI using (63.7), one needs to calculate the
eigenvectors FI of the Casida equation ( 63.1) and the tensor of dipole moment
.Bˇ /ij . Substituting ( 63.9) into ( 63.8), after some transformations one gets the
following expression (63.53):
2
Z X E G/E
E r X Er
1 j e i.G i j e i GE
.Bˇ /ij D rˇ d rE 4 cGi cG C cnlm cG ˆnlm .Er / p
N 0 0
GIG 0 GInlm
3
X j e Er
i GE X 7
i j
C cGi cnlm ˆnlm .Er / p C cnlm cn0 l 0 m0 ˆnlm .Er /ˆn0 l 0 m0 .Er /5 :
GInlm
0 nlmI
n0 l 0 m0
(63.53)
As the radial part of the AO is nonzero only inside sphere of radius r0 , in the
used approximation Lr00 < 1, it is possible to replace exponentials in ( 63.53) by
units and perform integration over rE. For the choice of s; p; d atomic orbitals
63 Computational Materials Science 1229
i
.2/3 i X @cGE j
.Bˇ /ij c C .rˇ00 /ij C .rˇ000 /ij ; (63.54)
@Gˇ G
E
G
r
00 2 X Q h i j j
.x /ij D i Rn1 ‰ .0/cn11 ‰ i .0/cn11 cn11
i
‰ j .0/
3 n
i
i
Ccn11 ‰ j .0/ ; (63.55)
r
00 2 X Q h i j j
i
.y /ij D Rn1 ‰ .0/cn11 C ‰ i .0/cn11 C cn11 i
‰ j .0/ C cn11
i
‰ j .0/ ;
3 n
r (63.56)
X h i
j
.z00 /ij D i RQ n1 ‰ i .0/cn10 cn10
i
‰ j .0/ ; (63.57)
3 n
XX 1 h j j j
.x 000 /ij D i p cni 0 11 cn00 Dn0 1n0 C cni 0 11 cn00 Dn0 1;n0 C cni 0 00 cn11 Dn0 0;n1
n n0
6
i 7 p5 h
i j j j
cn0 00 cn11 Dn0 0;n1 C cni 0 22 cn11 Dn0 2;n1 C cni 0 11 cn22 Dn0 1;n2
4 8
i 1 h i j
j j
C cni 0 22 cn22 Dn0 2;n2 cni 0 2 cn22 Dn0 1;n2 C p cn0 20 cn11 Dn0 2;n1
2 30
io
j j j
cni 0 11 cn20 Dn0 1;n2 cni 0 20 cn11 Dn0 2;n1 C cni 0 11 cn20 Dn0 1;n2 , (63.58)
XX 1 h j j j
000
.y /ij D i p cni 0 11 cn00 Dn0 1n0 C cni 0 11 cn00 Dn0 1;n0 C cni 0 00 cn11 Dn0 0;n1
n n0
6
i 7 p5 h
i j j j
C cn0 00 cn11 Dn0 0;n1 C cni 0 22 cn11 Dn0 2;n1 C cni 0 11 cn22 Dn0 1;n2
4 8
i 1 h i j
j j
C cni 0 22 cn22 Dn0 2;n2 C cni 0 2 cn22 Dn0 1;n2 C p cn0 20 cn11 Dn0 2;n1
2 30
io
j j j
C cni 0 11 cn20 Dn0 1;n2 C cni 0 20 cn11 Dn0 2;n1 C cni 0 11 cn20 Dn0 1;n2 ;
(63.59)
1230 R.V. Belosludov et al.
1 X X n i j j
.z000 /ij i p cn0 10 cn00 Dn0 l1;nl0 C cni 0 00 cn10 Dn0 0;n1
2 3 n n0
1 h j
p j
C p cni 0 20 cn10 Dn0 2;n1 C 3cni 0 10 cn20 Dn0 1;n2
5
p io
j j
C cni 0 21 cn11 Dn0 2;n1 3cni 0 11 cn21 Dn0 1;n2 ; (63.60)
where
Z
1 X i
‰ i .0/ D p cG ; RQ nl D r 3 drRnl .r/;
0 G
Z
Dn0 l 0 ;nl D r 3 drRn0 l 0 .r/Rnl .r/: (63.61)
The exact expression (Casimir-Polder integral) for the leading isotropic C6 (A, B)
term describing the vdW interaction between two atoms or molecules A and B
(Casimir and Polder 1948) is expressed as in (63.62):
Z 1
3
C6 .A; B/ D ˛A .i !/˛B .i !/d!; (63.62)
0
where I is the true excitation energy and fI is the oscillator strength determined
from the Casida equations (63.1) and (63.7). Substituting (63.63) into (63.62) and
performing integration over !, the coefficient C6 .A; B/ can be obtained in the form
of (63.64):
Z 1
3X X d!
C6 .A; B/ D fIa fIB 2 2 /.2 C ! 2 /
I I 0 . IA C ! IB
A B
3X X 1
D fIa fIB : (63.64)
2 I I
IA IB .IA C IB /
A B
63 Computational Materials Science 1231
As it can be seen, the main contribution to sums over IA and IB give excitations
with low energies I and large oscillator strengths fI .
2.5 Results
The method described above was applied for determining the dispersion coefficients
C6 for oxygen and hydrogen atoms. First, the Kohn-Sham energy levels were
obtained using the TOMBO program, and the values of the first ten levels for both
oxygen and hydrogen atoms were presented in Table 63.1. It shows that the TOMBO
program accurately estimates the occupied energy levels and underestimates the
unoccupied ones that is a well-known shortcoming of the density-functional theory.
The obtained energy levels and the Kohn-Sham wave functions were used to
construct the coupling matrix within the Casida approximation. The part of the
coupling matrix corresponding to the transition between the atomic energy levels
was calculated by providing the real space integration over the radial part of the
wave function. For this purpose, the analytically received Gaunt coefficients were
used. After obtaining elements of the coupling matrix, calculation of the excitation
energies was performed and the excitation energies with nonzero oscillator strengths
for the hydrogen and oxygen atoms in comparison with the experimental data
(Moore 1993) are summarized in Table 63.2. Oscillator strengths obtained by
using real space representation of the TOMBO wave functions ‰i .Er / were also
presented in Table 63.2. It can be seen that the difference between the calculated
and experimental data are small and insignificantly increases for higher levels.
Using the obtained oscillator strengths and excitation energies, calculation of
the C6 dispersion coefficients were performed using (63.64). The coefficients, C6 ,
for hydrogen atoms, H–H, hydrogen H2 –H2 , oxygen O2 –O2 , and water H2 O–
H2 O molecules dimmers are listed in Table 63.3. The presented C6 dispersion
coefficients are in the Rydberg atomic units (au). For hydrogen molecules, three
types of the molecule orientations were considered: collinear, complanar-cross, and
perpendicular. (jj, j n, j —). For all three cases, the C6 coefficients were considered
Table 63.1 The Kohn- No of level Energy (eV) (oxygen) Energy (eV) (hydrogen)
Sham energy levels
1 581.39309 13.32031
2 24.30421 7.99471
3 24.30391 7.93797
4 24.30242 7.93318
5 20.04238 5.11129
6 14.27128 5.08495
7 3.90444 5.07699
8 3.5812 2.99982
9 2.73858 2.99568
10 1.3097 2.95741
1232 R.V. Belosludov et al.
Table 63.2 The excitation energies and related oscillator strengths for hydrogen and oxygen
atoms (Experimental data was taken from Moore (1993))
Excitation energy Oscillator Excitation energy Oscillator
(cm1 ) strength, f (cm1 ) strength, f
Experiment Calculated Calculated Experiment Calculated Calculated
Hydrogen atom Oxygen atom
82,259 83,242 0.4626 76,795 78,946 0.1355
97,492 96,307 0.4626 86,625 83,621 0.1329
102,824 109,541 0.4626 88,631 87,385 0.1396
105,292 109,725 0.1088 95,476 94,998 0.1317
109,678 109,893 0.1088 96,225 96,301 0.0024
– – 97,420 102,754 0.0029
– – 97,488 106,071 0.0029
Table 63.3 Dispersion coefficient C6 (A-B). The SPCE, TIP4P, ST2 and BNP are semi-empirical
potentials commonly used for describing water-water interaction
C6 (H–H) (au) C6 (H2 –H2 ) (au) C6 (O2 –O2 ) (au) C6 (H2 O–H2 O) (au)
14.6 (Present work) 29.25 (Present work) 94.7 (Present work) 83.25 (Present work)
12.0 (Andersson 29.0 (Andersson 71.6 (Platteeuw and 89.8 (SPCE)
et al. 1996) et al. 1996) van der Waals 1958)
13.0 (Bishop and 34.3 (Murata et al. 97.48 (Hohm 1994) 88.5 (TIP4P)
Pipin 1993) 2002)
23.0 (Hohm 1994) 80.5 (Bussery and 38.96 (ST2)
Wormer 1993)
22.28 (BNS)
at near equilibrium in the gas hydrates position 3 Å. The C6 coefficient was
evaluated as the average value and was found to be 30.33 au.
For a distance when the molecules orientation can be neglected the C6 coefficient
found to be C6 D 29:25 au. This value is in good comparison with the previous
calculation data obtained within the framework of long-range density-functional
theory (Andersson et al. 1996). For oxygen molecules the C6 interaction coefficient
was found to be 94.7 au at long distance. This value overestimates the semi-
empirical C6 parameter of Lennard–Jones potential (71.6 au) usually used for
the O2 –O2 interaction (Platteeuw and van der Waals 1958). The value obtained
within the present approach was also higher than that the value received using the
Hartree-Fock molecular orbital calculations (Bussery and Wormer 1993) (80.5 au)
but close to the value obtained using the quantum mechanical simulation (Hohm
1994) (97.48 au). Also were directly calculated the C6 coefficients for O–O and
H–O dimers that were found to be equal 47.3 and 30.4 au respectively. Based
on the calculated O–H and H–H dispersion coefficients, the H2 O–H2 O dispersion
coefficient of the van der Waals interaction at the large distances can be found
using the standard summation rule. The C6 dispersion coefficient for water dimer in
comparison with different atom-atomic interaction potentials were also summarized
63 Computational Materials Science 1233
in Table 63.3. The results are in good agreement with the dispersion coefficient of
the van der Waals interaction within the SPCE and TIP4P potentials that verified
the validity of the proposed formalism for realization of the Casida approach within
TOMBO program.
In conclusion, the Casimir-Polder integral has been employed to obtain the van
der Waals dispersion coefficients of atoms C6 . The TDLDA technique (Casida
formalism) has implemented entirely in real space within the all-electron mixed-
basis approach. This scheme can be used to improve the description of the oscillator
strengths and true excited states. The true excitation energies of many-electron sys-
tems are computed from the conventional, time-independent Kohn-Sham transition
energies and wave functions. Electronic wave functions are expressed directly in
real space on a regular, cubic grid. The Casida formalism is easier to implement
on parallel computer platforms and, compared to other theoretical methods for
the excited states, the TDLDA technique requires considerably less computational
effort and can be applied for accurate calculation of the oscillator strengths and true
excited states.
The clathrate hydrates of natural gases are receiving special attention aiming at
solving environmental and energy resource-related problems. For example, natural
gas hydrates (GHs) are a potential source of energy based on the experts estimates
where the reserves of GHs in the interior of the Earth and on the floor of the
World Ocean contain the equivalent of 2 1016 m3 . This indicates one of the
largest sources of “clean” hydrocarbons on Earth. The stability of gas hydrate is
sensitive to the thermodynamic conditions as well as guest compositions and even
small changes in temperature or pressure may cause them to decompose. Many
gases, such as hydrogen, formed hydrate at high pressure and low temperature,
and as noted above a high-pressure experimental study of the phase diagram of
the multicomponent clathrate hydrates in detail is still a challenging task due to
their complexity (Struzhkin et al. 2007). Thus, it is clearly important to study
theoretically the P T phase diagram of clathrate hydrates.
Currently, theoretical models used for the description of the phase diagrams of
gas hydrates are based on the statistical model of the ideal solid clathrate solutions of
the van der Waals – Platteeuw (vdWP) (Van der Waals and Platteeuw 1959). In this
approach, agreement with the experimental data for concrete systems is achieved
using the phenomenological parameters specified for each system. This theory
and all of its subsequent derivatives embody four main assumptions: (a) the cages
contain at most one guest, (b) the guest molecules do not interact with each other,
(c) the host lattice is unaffected by the nature as well as by the number of encaged
guest molecules, and (d) classical statistics is valid. To date it has been shown
by many researches that the first three assumptions are violated for gas hydrates,
especially in the cases of multiple cage occupancy by guest molecules. Several
1234 R.V. Belosludov et al.
studies were performed to generalize the original vdWP in order to overcome these
limitations. Thus, the influence of the guest molecules on the host lattice in the
description of the thermodynamics properties of gas hydrates was taken into account
(Zele et al. 1999). Later, this approach was extended to several multicomponent gas
hydrates (Lee et al. 2006).
Recently, the phase behavior of various binary hydrates was reproduced using
the thermodynamic model based on the nonideal hydrate solid solution model
for the multiphase equilibrium (Strobel et al. 2009). In that work, instead of
the variation of parameters used in different models, a single set of consistent
parameters within the framework of a single model was proposed. The extension
of the vdWP statistical thermodynamical model without specific phenomenological
parameters was formulated (Tanaka and Kiyohara 1993a, b). Within the harmonic
approximation, the vibrations of the guest molecules in cavities and the effect of
the guest-host interactions on changes in the host framework vibrations were taken
into account. However, calculation of Langmuir constants is relatively easy only
in the case of single occupancy. Further extension to multiple guest occupancy of
a single cavity makes the integration difficult to perform. Another approach that
allows the accurate estimation of the thermodynamic properties of clathrate hydrates
with multiple filling within the cages has been proposed recently (Belosludov et al.
2007). This method is also based on the vdWP theory with some modifications that
account for the multiple cage occupancy, host lattice relaxation, and the description
of the quantum nature of guest behavior in the cavities. The validity of the proposed
approach was confirmed for methane and xenon hydrates with single occupancy
(Belosludov et al. 2007), for argon and krypton with both single and double
occupancy (Subbotin et al. 2009). The obtained results were in agreement with the
known experimental data.
In this model only one of the assumptions of the vdWP theory is used that the
contribution of guest molecules to the free energy is independent of the mode of
occupation of the cavities at a designated number of guest molecules (Van der Waals
and Platteeuw 1959). This assumption allows one to separate the entropy part of the
free energy (63.65):
m
" n X
k
! n X
k
!
X X X
1 k
F D F1 V; T; y11 ; : : : ; ynm C kT Nt 1 ylti ln 1 ylti
t D1 lD1 i D1 lD1 i D1
n X
k
#
X ylti
C ylti ln ; (63.65)
iŠ
lD1 i D1
63 Computational Materials Science 1235
where F1 is the part of the free energy of clathrate hydrate for the cases where
several types of cavities and guest molecules exist, and a cavity can hold more
than one guest molecule. The second termıis the entropic part of the free energy
arising from the guest subsystem. ylti D Nlti Nt is the degree of filling of the t-type
cavities by the i cluster of the l-type guest molecules; Nt is the number of the t-type
cavities; and Nlti is the number of the l-type guest molecules which are located in the
1 k
t-type cavities (Belosludov et al. 2007). The free energy F1 .V; T; y11 ; : : : ; ynm / of
the crystal can be calculated within the framework of the lattice dynamics approach
in the quasiharmonic approximation (Leifried and Ludwig 1961; Belosludov et al.
1994) as shown in (63.66),
1 k
F1 V; T; y11 ; : : : ; ynm D U C Fvib (63.66)
1X X
Fvib D „!j .E
q / C kB T ln 1 exp.„!j .E
q /kB T/ (63.67)
2
j qE j qE
where !j .Eq / is the j -th frequency of crystal vibration and qE is the wave vector.
In the quasiharmonic approximation, the free energy of crystal has the same
form as in the harmonic approximation, but the structural parameters at fixed
volume depend on the temperature. Equation of state can be found by numerical
differentiation of free energy (63.68):
1 k
!
@F V; T; y11 ; : : : ; ynm
P.V; T/ D : (63.68)
@V
0
The subscript “0” implies constancy of all thermodynamic parameters except those
relative to which differentiation is performed. After obtaining the free energy values
one can calculate ilt – the chemical potentials of the i -cluster of the l-type guest
molecules which are located on the t-type cavities (63.69) and (63.70),
1 k
!
@F V .P/; T; y11 ; : : : ; ynm
ilt 1
P; T; y11 k
; : : : ; ynm D
@Nlti
0
ylti
D Q ilt C kT ln ; (63.69)
P
n;k
0
i Š.1 yli0 t /
l0i 0
1 k
!
@F1 V .P/; T; y11 ; : : : ; ynm
Q ilt D : (63.70)
@Nlti
0
1236 R.V. Belosludov et al.
Knowing the Helmholtz free energy F and equation of the state of the system,
1 k
the relation between Gibbs free energy ˆ P; T; y11 ; : : : ; ynm and the chemical
potentials of the host and guest molecules is expressed by (63.71):
m
X n X
X k
1 k
ˆ P; T; y11 ; : : : ; ynm D NQ Q C Nt ylti ilt
t D1 lD1 i 1
1 k
DF V .P/; T; y11 ; : : : ; ynm C PV .P/ : (63.71)
Substituting (63.65) for free energy into (63.71), allows one to obtain the chemical
potential of the host molecules Q (63.72) and (63.73):
m
" n X
k
!#
X X
1 k
Q P; T; y11 ; : : : ; ynm D Q Q C kT
t ln 1 ylti ; (63.72)
t D1 lD1 i D1
m n X k
PV .P/ 1 1 k
X X
Q Q C F1 V .P/; T; y11 ; : : : ; ynm
t ylti Q ilt ; (63.73)
NQ NQ t D1 i 1 lD1
ı
t D Nt NQ is the ratio between number of cavities of type t, Nt and number of
water molecules in the original hydrate, NQ .
Based on this formalism, the different phase equilibria of hydrates can be
obtained. The curve P(T) of monovariant equilibrium can be found from the equality
of the chemical potentials. In the case of gas hydrates, it can be written as (63.74)
and (63.75),
ilt P; T; y11
1 k gas
; : : : ; ynm D il .P; T/ Ult ; (63.74)
1 k
Q P; T; y11 ; : : : ; ynm D ice
Q .P; T/; (63.75)
gas
where l is the chemical potential of guest molecules in the gas phase, and
ice
Q .P; T/ is the chemical potentials of water molecules in ice. For the case of
multiple filling of cages, it is important to account for the interaction between guest
molecules into the cavity. As first approximation, the chemical potential of a cluster
is equal to ilt Š ilt Ult (Ult is the interaction of guest molecules inside cluster in
cavities). The guest gas phase has been considered as a nonideal gas for calculation
of the chemical potential (Prigogine and Defay 1954) (63.76):
" 3=2 # 2
gas P 2„2 2kT X
l .P; T/ D kT ln xl C Blk xk (63.76)
kT ml kT V
kD1
where xl – concentration of the l-type guest in the gas phase, and Blk are the second
virtual coefficients (63.77),
63 Computational Materials Science 1237
Fig. 63.2 The H2 –H2 interaction potential with the short-range repulsion taken from (Murata et al.
2002) (solid line) and estimated within TOMBO method (dashed line)
Z 0
Wlk .r/
Blk D 2 1 exp r 2 dr; (63.77)
1 kT
Fig. 63.3 The p T phase diagram of H2 O–H2 system related to Ih –CS-II transition.
Experimental data was taken from Lokshin and Zhao (2006) (crosses) and Barkalov et al. (2005)
(open and filled circles). The dotted line presents ice Ih – liquid water equilibrium phase transition
(Reprinted with permission from J. Chem. Phys. 132, 244510 (2009). Copyright 2009 American
Institute of Physics)
may be related to the kinetic difference between the formation and decomposition
of hydrate (Belosludov et al. 2009).
The gas hydrate with cubic structure II (CS-II) have two types of cavities,
the pentagonal dodecahedron (512 ) and hexakaidecahedron (512 64 ), commonly
classified as small and large cages, respectively. Calculations of the thermodynamic
properties of the CS-II propane + hydrogen hydrates with a single propane and dif-
ferent hydrogen occupations have been performed after full structure optimization
of both the host framework and the positions of the guest molecules inside the
cavities (Belosludov et al. 2007). Only a very small concentration of propane in
the gas phase and the high-temperature region have been considered, which seems
to be most attractive from the viewpoint of hydrogen storage. At a low propane
concentration in the gas phase, it has been found that in the low-pressure region,
the large cavities are mainly filled by propane molecules and hydrogen occupies
only the small ones. The filling of the large cages by hydrogen molecules increases
consecutively from one to four hydrogen molecules with increasing pressure. In
contrast to hydrogen, the propane filling decreases with increasing pressure, and in
the high-pressure region, the propane molecules are gradually expelled by hydrogen
molecules. The tuning of large cage occupancy can be attributed to the “composition
tuning mechanism” (Lee et al. 2005). Figure 63.4 shows that the pressure value, at
which the tuning can be observed, depends on the propane concentration in the gas
phase. Decreasing propane concentration from 2% allows one to reduce the com-
position tuning pressure. Based on these results, it can be proposed that the tuning
pressure will rapidly increase with the increase of propane concentration, and hence
the tuning effect will occur at higher pressure. Since the thermodynamic behavior
of the propane-hydrogen-water system is similar to that of the THF-hydrogen-water
system, the present results can explain discrepancy in the experimental data related
to the hydrogen composition in binary THF + hydrogen hydrate.
The chemical potential curves of the water molecules in ice Ih and in the mixed
propane + hydrogen CS-II hydrate as a function of pressure at T = 260 K are shown
in Fig. 63.5. The occupation of large cavities by propane drastically affects the
stabilization of the hydrate structure, resulting in a substantially decreased formation
pressure. At a low propane concentration of 0.1% in the gas phase, the binary
hydrate becomes stable at a pressure about four times lower than that needed to
form the pure hydrogen clathrate with the CS-II structure at the same temperature.
By analogy with THF, propane brings the hydrate formation conditions closer to
the ambient conditions, and it is undoubtedly favorable for the hydrogen storage
material.
Figure 63.6 shows the hydrogen storage capacity of the mixed propane +
hydrogen CS-II hydrate at various propane concentrations. The hydrogen content
continues to increase due to hydrogen filling of the large cages. The mass percentage
of hydrogen in the mixed CS-II propane + hydrogen hydrate can amount up to
3.5 wt% at T = 260 K and lower concentrations of propane in the gas phase and a
pressure of 100 MPa. This value is comparable with the hydrogen content (3.5 wt%)
estimated for pure hydrogen hydrate at the same temperature. Therefore, the
introduction of propane as a second guest component in the binary hydrogen hydrate
does not only reduce the formation pressure but also reproduces the hydrogen
storage ability of the pure clathrate hydrate (Belosludov et al. 2009).
1240 R.V. Belosludov et al.
Fig. 63.4 Degree of filling of the small and large cavities of the propane + hydrogen CS-II hydrate
at a propane concentrations of 0.1% (a) and 2% (b) in the gas phase at T = 200 K (Reprinted
with permission from J. Chem. Phys. 132, 244510 (2009). Copyright 2009 American Institute of
Physics)
There are several types of the gas hydrate structures with different cage shapes,
and some of these hydrate structures can hypothetically store more hydrogen than
the hydrate of structure CS-II. Most of the gas hydrates have two structures: the
cubic I (CS-I) and cubic II (CS-II) structures (Sloan and Koh 2008). There is a
pentagonal dodecahedron (a polyhedron with 12 pentagonal faces 512 ) in these
hydrate structures as the basic small cavity. The basic 512 cavities combine with
512 62 cavities to form the CS-I structure and with 512 64 cavities form the CS-II
one. Assuming that the 512 62 and 512 64 cages can accumulate a maximum of four
63 Computational Materials Science 1241
Fig. 63.5 Pressure dependence of the chemical potentials of water molecules at T = 260 K for Ih ,
CS-II propane + H2 hydrates including the entropy terms at various propane concentrations in the
gas phase (Reprinted with permission from J. Chem. Phys. 132, 244510 (2009). Copyright 2009
American Institute of Physics)
Fig. 63.6 Hydrogen storage capacity of the CS-II propane + hydrogen hydrate as a function of
pressure for various propane concentrations at T = 260 K (Reprinted with permission from J. Chem.
Phys. 132, 244510 (2009). Copyright 2009 American Institute of Physics)
Fig. 63.7 Pressure dependence of the chemical potentials of water molecules at T = 250 K for Ih
(solid line) and the hydrogen CS-I (dashed line) and CS-II (dotted line) hydrates (Reproduced from
Belosludov et al. (2012). With permission from Taylor & Francis)
T = 250 K are shown in Fig. 63.7. The intersection of the chemical potential curves
of ice Ih and the CS-I hydrate has been found at pressure 98.4 MPa which defines
the formation pressure of the hydrogen hydrate at a given temperature. The CS-I
structure is thermodynamically unstable as compared with the CS-II one. At a
temperature of 250 K, the hydrogen CS-II hydrate stabilizes at pressure of 84.1 MPa.
Moreover, the hydrogen CS-II hydrate is also more stable than that of the CS-I one
in the lower temperature region. This result can explain the experimental realization
of the hydrogen CS-II hydrate only.
In order to reduce the hydrate formation and stabilize the CS-I structure, a second
guest component should be selected according to the following conditions. In pure
form, this guest is able to form both the CS-I and CS-II hydrates, and the CS-I
hydrate with this guest being more stable than that of the CS-II structure. Based on
these assumptions, the mixed ethane + hydrogen hydrates with the CS-I and CS-II
structures have been investigated with different ethane and H2 concentrations. From
the viewpoint of hydrogen storage, only a small concentration (up to 5%) of ethane
in the gas phase has been considered (Belosludov et al. 2012).
It has been found that the formation pressures of the binary ethane + hydrogen
CS-I and CS-II hydrates depend on ethane concentration in the gas phase and
with increasing ethane concentration in the gas phase were found to be lower in
comparison with the pressure of pure hydrogen hydrate formation. Higher stability
has been observed for the mixed ethane + hydrogen the CS-I hydrate. Due to the
fact that the size of ethane molecule is well fitted with large cavity (512 62 ) of
CS-I structure, the occupation of these cavities by ethane drastically affects the
stabilization of the hydrate structure, resulting in a substantially decreased formation
pressure. At an ethane concentration of 1% in the gas phase, binary hydrate becomes
stable at a pressure around 32.9 MPa and a temperature T = 250 K. This pressure is
63 Computational Materials Science 1243
Fig. 63.8 Pressure dependence of the chemical potentials of water molecules at T = 250 K: (a)
for Ih (solid line) and the CS-I C2 H6 + H2 hydrate; (b) for Ih (solid line) and the CS-II C2 H6 + H2
hydrate at various ethane concentrations in the gas phase (Reproduced from Belosludov et al.
(2012). With permission from Taylor & Francis)
three times lower than that needed to form pure hydrogen clathrate with the CS-I
structure (p D 98:4 MPa) in the same temperature region (see Fig. 63.8a).
In the case of the CS-II structure, stabilization of the binary ethane + hydrogen
hydrate occurs at a pressure about two times lower than the formation pressure of
the pure hydrogen hydrate at an ethane concentration of 2% in the gas phase as
shown in Fig. 63.8b. At low ethane concentrations, the mixed ethane + hydrogen
CS-I hydrate is more thermodynamically stable than the CS-II hydrate with the
same composition of guest molecules and hence the presence of ethane in the gas
mixture leads to a structural phase transition between the CS-II and CS-I structures
in the C2 H6 H2 H2 O system. At an ethane concentration of 5% in the gas phase,
the formation pressure of 5.9 MPa for the binary ethane + hydrogen hydrate can
1244 R.V. Belosludov et al.
Fig. 63.9 Hydrogen storage capacity of the C2 H6 + H2 hydrate with (a) CS-I and (b) CS-II
structures as a function of pressure for various ethane concentrations (Reproduced from Belosludov
et al. (2012). With permission from Taylor & Francis)
be achieved. At the same ethane concentration, the pressure of 26.7 MPa needs to
stabilize the same binary hydrate with the CS-II structure (see Fig. 63.8b). These
values are in good agreement with the experimentally reported formation conditions
(10 MPa bar at 278 K) for the binary ethane + hydrogen hydrate with 10% of
ethane (Skiba et al. 2010).
Figure 63.9 shows the hydrogen storage capacity of the mixed ethane + hydrogen
CS-I and CS-II hydrates at various ethane concentrations at 250 K. Hydrogen
content continues to increase due to hydrogen filling of the large cages for both
cases. The mass percentage of hydrogen in the mixed ethane + hydrogen CS-I
hydrate can amount to 2.5 wt% at T = 250 K and ethane concentrations of 1% in
the gas phase and a pressure of 300 MPa. The hydrogen content of 0.17 wt% for the
CS-I ethane-hydrogen hydrate was estimated from the experimental measurements
63 Computational Materials Science 1245
at 12 MPa and 270 K (Park and Lee 2007). This is in agreement with the calculations
for the CS-I structure at the same pressure-temperature conditions as shown in
Fig. 63.9a. The stored hydrogen amount depends on the ethane concentration in
the gas phase as well as the thermodynamic conditions of the hydrate formation. At
concentrations of less than 1% stabilization of the CS-II structure can be realized
and hence the mass percentage of hydrogen in the C2 H6 H2 H2 O system can
amount up to 3.5 wt% at T = 250 K (Belosludov et al. 2012).
3.4 Conclusions
4 Summary
CO2 formation by the combustion of the fossil fuels. Thus, replacement of CH4
with CO2 in the hydrate framework derives double the benefit. Such deposition of
CO2 can prevent the transport of CO2 from returning back to the surface due to the
formation of CO2 clathrate hydrate capping layer that reduces migration. Using the
methodologies presented in this chapter, it is possible not only confirm the existing
experimental data but also predict the unknown region of the thermodynamic
stability of pure and binary CO2 hydrates, and further, an ideal gas composition
can be proposed at which a high-stability region may be achieved. From this point
of view, these techniques are useful for understanding the physical and chemical
properties of the binary hydrate, and it can support the realization of the efficient
CO2 storage materials based on the clathrate hydrates.
Acknowledgments
The authors would like to express their sincere thanks to the staff of the Center
for Computational Materials Science of the Institute for Materials Research,
Tohoku University for their continuous support of the SR16000-M1 supercomputing
facilities. This work has been supported by the New Energy and Industrial Technol-
ogy Development Organization (NEDO) under “Advanced Fundamental Research
Project on Hydrogen Storage Materials”.
References
Y. Andersson, D.C. Langreth et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 76, 102 (1996)
M.S. Bahramy, M.H.F. Sluiter et al., Phys. Rev. B 73, 045111 (2006)
O.I. Barkalov, S.N. Klyamkin et al., JETP Lett. 82, 464 (2005)
R.V. Belosludov, I.K. Igumenov et al., Mol. Phys. 82, 51 (1994)
R.V. Belosludov, O.S. Subbotin et al., J. Chem. Phys. 131, 244510 (2009)
R.V. Belosludov, R.K. Zhdanov et al., Mol. Simul. 38, 773 (2012)
V.R. Belosludov, O.S. Subbotin et al., Mater. Trans. 48, 704 (2007)
D.M. Bishop, J. Pipin, Int. J. Quantum Chem. 45, 349 (1993)
B. Bussery, P.E.S. Wormer, J. Chem. Phys. 99, 1230 (1993)
M.E. Casida, Time-dependent density functional response theory for molecules, in Recent
Advances in Density Functional Methods, Part I, ed. by D.P. Chong (World Scientific,
Singapore, 1995), pp. 155–192
H.B.G. Casimir, B. Polder, Phys. Rev. 73, 360 (1948)
J.F. Dobson, K. McLennan et al., Aust. J. Chem. 54, 513 (2001)
I.E. Dzyaloshinskii, E.M. Lifshitz et al., Adv. Phys. 10, 165 (1961)
U. Eberle, M. Felderhoff et al., Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 48, 6608 (2009)
R.H. French, V.A. Parsegian et al., Rev. Mod. Phys. 82, 1887 (2010)
U. Hohm, Chem. Phys. 179, 533 (1994)
H. Lee, J.W. Lee et al., Nature 434, 743 (2005)
J.W. Lee, P. Yedlapalli et al., J. Phys. Chem. B 110, 2332 (2006)
G. Leifried, W. Ludwig, Theory of Anharmonic Effects in Crystal (Academic, New York, 1961)
K.A. Lokshin, Y.S. Zhao et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 125503 (2004)
K.A. Lokshin, Y.S. Zhao, Appl. Phys. Lett. 88, 131909 (2006)
S.G. Louie, K.M. Ho et al., Phys. Rev. B 19, 1774 (1979)
63 Computational Materials Science 1247
Naoe Hosoda
Abstract
Organisms are attractive models for the development of advanced materials
because they have high-efficiency, high-performance, and low-energy func-
tions. The expression of these functions produces characteristics many times
those of the original material through a characteristic microstructure, self-
repair/self-destructive functions (fail-safe functions), self-cleaning functions
(efficient retention of functionality), mechanisms that produce form with a
low environmental burden (substance creation at ordinary temperatures and
pressures, self-organization), and reversible adhesion. The understanding of bio-
logical manufacturing is now at a stage where it is expected to start substantially
influencing the development of technologies that exert a low environmental load.
In this chapter, the materials research and technological developments regarding
attachment/detachment learned from organisms are introduced.
1 Introduction
Organisms are being used as models to advance research in a diverse range of fields.
The following are some examples of biomimetics research that is being undertaken
on material systems: mimicking organisms’ formation of inorganic compounds such
as diatoms (Sumper and Brunner 2006; Gower 2008) and bones for application to
ceramics synthesis at low temperature by aqueous processing (biominerals), bone
repair (Kikuchi et al. 2001), and artificial photosynthesis (Gust et al. 2001); new
coloring methods (structural color) using the body colors of fish (Fudouzi 2011) and
insects (Saito 2011) and the development of sensors applying these methods; the
N. Hosoda
Hybrid Materials Center, National Institute for Materials Science (NIMS), Tsukuba-shi, Ibaraki,
Japan
e-mail: Hosoda.Naoe@nims.go.jp
a 70
60
50
Number 40
30
20
10
0
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
Year
Published items in each year
(key words:Gecko, adhesion)
b 70
60
50
Number
40
30
20
10
0
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
Year
Published items in each year
(key words:Lotus, hydrophobic)
c 70
60
50
Number
40
30
20
10
0
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
Year
Published items in each year
(key words:Butterfly, structural color)
Fig. 64.1 The number of papers related to (a) gecko and adhesion, (b) lotus and hydrophobic,
(c) butterfly and structural color, included to the Web of Science database over the past 20 years
1252 N. Hosoda
a
ROBOTICS
POLYMER SCIENCE
ZOOLOGY
LIFE SCIENCES BIOMEDICINE OTHER TOPICS
MECHANICS
ENGINEERING
PHYSICS
CHEMISTRY
SCIENCE TECHNOLOGY OTHER TOPICS
MATERIALS SCIENCE
0 50 100 150 200
Number
Published items in each research areas
(key words:Gecko, adhesion)
b
BIOCHEMISTRY MOLECULAR BIOLOGY
PLANT SCIENCES
INSTRUMENTS INSTRUMENTATION
MECHANICS
ENGINEERING
POLYMER SCIENCE
SCIENCE TECHNOLOGY OTHER TOPICS
PHYSICS
CHEMISTRY
MATERIALS SCIENCE
0 50 100 150 200 250
Number
Published items in each research areas
(key words:Lotus, hydrophobic)
c
ENGINEERING
ZOOLOGY
CHEMISTRY
LIFE SCIENCES BIOMEDICINE OTHER TOPICS
EVOLUTIONARY BIOLOGY
ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES ECOLOGY
MATERIALS SCIENCE
OPTICS
SCIENCE TECHNOLOGY OTHER TOPICS
PHYSICS
0 10 20 30 40 50
Number
Published items in each research areas
(key words:Butterfly, structural color)
Fig. 64.2 The number of papers per subject fields related to (a) gecko and adhesion, (b) lotus and
hydrophobic, (c) butterfly and structural color, included to the Web of Science database over the
past 20 years
64 Mechanisms of Organisms as Environment-Friendly Materials Design Tools 1253
Since the adhesion energy when the Van der Waals force works between two
flat surfaces in contact is inversely proportional to the square of the separation
(Israelachvili 1992), the way in which the surfaces are made to approach each other
is important to consider.
Incidentally, in order to raise the strength of adhesion/bonding (peel strength)
of an artificial bonding technology, it is generally necessary to (1) increase the
adhesion of the parts that make contact, (2) raise the binding force between the two
solids, and (3) ensure the stress that occurs in the vicinity of the interface is small.
In normal-temperature direct bonding in mechanical engineering, it is necessary to
make both surfaces strictly flat prior to contact in order to increase the adhesion.
In general, electropolishing or chemical polishing is performed after mechanical
polishing of the surface to remove scratches, and precise polishing conditions must
be established as the chemical and polishing conditions vary depending on the
materials to be joined. As a surface roughness of more than a few nanometers or
residual polishing scratches influence the result of bonding, this surface polishing
can be said to be the key technology for normal-temperature direct bonding. In the
case of materials with uneven surfaces, the bonding that occurs at the interface,
which is an important factor in adhesion force (peel strength), develops according
to the deformations in the contact part. Thus, adhesion develops more easily for
soft and deformable materials. For a contact part that is made to completely adhere
by load, the adhesion condition of the interface after unloading differs according to
the material and the amount of deformation: some materials remain in a completely
adhered state and others in a partially adhered state. This is because peeling occurs
due to the elastic energy stored by the deformation. The condition in which peeling
occurs can be considered from the balance of the interface energy of the contact
part and the elastic energy due to the deformation. When the interface energy
is higher than the elastic energy due to the deformation, the material adheres
completely; when the elastic energy is higher, separation occurs and the material
remains partially adhered. If the conditions for complete adhesion according to the
energy balance in the case of contact between aluminum and sapphire are calculated,
adhesion progresses due to the deformation of aluminum in the case of uneven
aluminum and flat sapphire. If the unevenness of the surface is considered as a sine
wave and the half wavelength is 25 nm, complete adhesion only occurs when the
depth of the surface roughness is less than a few nanometers. The result of this
calculation coincides well with the results of bonding experiments (Hosoda et al.
1999).
In contrast to this, the strategy that creatures assume toward adherence differs
completely (Fig. 64.3). In order to increase adherence, the contact part is segmented
and a long thin hairy-shaped surface is created in order to easily deform. This long
thin hairy structure is characteristically produced at an angle to the contact surface.
The gecko is one such organism that utilizes hairy structures for adherence.
The Gekko gecko (Reptilia, Squamata, Gekkonidae, Gekko) is the most studied
of all geckos. Its fine hairy structures, or setae, are composed of “-keratin (Maderson
1964) and are 110 long and 4.2 m wide with 200 nm spatula tips. The force acting
between the setae tips and the surface has long been the subject of discussion;
1254 N. Hosoda
Room temperature
direct bonding
Technology Creature
splitting of a contact
Prepare an even
Increase the area and thin and
surface in an atomic
contact areas long shape of
level
contact parts
Al
Al
Fig. 64.3 Comparison of the adhesion mechanism of the feet of small animals and artificial
bonding technologies
however, in recent years the Van der Waals force has been demonstrated to be the
principal force, as mentioned above (Autumn et al. 2002). Since an absorbed layer
of water exists on surfaces in humid environments, the effect of water has also been
considered, and a thin adherent layer of water has been demonstrated to increase
the adhesion of the gecko hairy attachment system (Huber et al. 2005a). It has
been reported that the adhesion force per spatula is 10 nN (Huber et al. 2005b) and
200 N per seta (in a horizontal direction) (Autumn et al. 2000).
64 Mechanisms of Organisms as Environment-Friendly Materials Design Tools 1255
The way in which a long, narrow, and inclined shape contributes to adherence can
be considered from the effective Young’s modulus of the material. The following
equation shows the effective Young’s modulus, Eeff , according to the cantilever
model and expresses the effect of the angle made with a long thin structure
(Autumn et al. 2006):
3EID sin
Eeff D
L2 cos2 Œ1 ˙ tan
The fine hair attachment system of the gecko is also useful in keeping the joining
surface of the sole of the foot clean. It is known that the gecko foot has a self-
cleaning mechanism and does not require grooming (Hansen and Autumn 2005).
In research by Hansen et al. on the adhesion of gecko setae due to the accretion
of alumina-silica microspheres (Hansen and Autumn 2005), the adhesion force of
the setae was observed to drop remarkably when microspheres were attached to
them, but thereafter it returned with the number of steps taken when the gecko was
made to walk on glass. By their nature, setae have a strong adhesive capability, and
therefore, the reason for the microspheres adhering to the glass and not remaining on
the setae was of interest. Hansen et al. calculated the interaction produced at the two
interfaces bordering the microspheres (i.e., the glass–microsphere and microsphere–
seta interfaces) as a Van der Waals force and demonstrated that “dry cleaning”
arises from the energy imbalance of the interfaces in contact with both sides of
the microspheres. They also pointed out that since the setae have a hydrophobic
property, the microspheres on the setae might be removed by contact with water. In
contrast, in mechanical engineering methods the surface layer is removed/activated
by ion irradiation (Suga 1990).
to consider the relationship between the elastic constants of the material and the
aspect ratio of the hair in order to prevent mutual adhesion, which occurs easily
(Sitti and Fearling 2003), as well as consider a form of tip that increases adhesion.
According to Campodel’s research on tip form and adhesion, form (e) has been
reported to produce the greatest adhesion force from within the six forms proposed
(see Fig. 64.6) (Campodel et al. 2007). Inclined hairs have a weak adhesive force
in the vertical direction and a strong force in the horizontal direction, similar to
those of the gecko (Santos et al. 2007). In recent years, hairy-shaped surfaces with a
more complex layered structure such as that shown in Fig. 64.3 have been developed
(Jeong and Suh 2009).
The features of gecko-type hairy structures can be summarized as follows (Gorb
et al. 2007a):
1. Dimension and density
2. Aspect ratio
3. Slope
4. Hierarchy
5. Shape of the contact
6. Asymmetry
7. Proper movements
8. Gradient materials
9. Supplementary nanostructures
1258 N. Hosoda
All of these features have been observed at normal temperature in geckos, but they
remain difficult to achieve artificially. A mushroom-type hairy structure in which
a thin layer corresponding to feature 5 is formed at the tip has been reported to
afford repeated adhesion, and adhesion is restored by washing with water when
dirty (Gorb et al. 2007b). Gecko-type adhesion should be reversible adhesion,
but achieving high peel strength is difficult even when considering the bonding
mechanism: incorporating an adhesive from the mussel-mimic polymer into a hairy-
shaped structure only results in 120 nN (per pillar) at most (Haeshin et al. 2007).
However, gecko-type adhesion remains an attractive topic for application to the
walking of robots on vertical surfaces, adhesive parts that must repeatedly and
strongly adhere and medical adhesives.
Fig. 64.7 (a) Cerasus jamasakura (Siebold ex Koidz.). (b) A base of leaf petiole (leaf stem).
(c) Close section view of the abscission layer
Spontaneous
separation
Fig. 64.8 The schematic view of leaf fall inspired joining technology
Fig. 64.9 (a) The separation process of abscission layer using liquid metal embrittlement by
gallium. (b) Removal of a LSI chip from an used PCB at room temperature using gallium
4 Summary
Although the fusion of different fields is, by its very nature, essential for research in
biomimetics, actual interdisciplinary research is only rarely undertaken. The reason
for this lies in the barrier formed by differences in the language and culture used
in different fields. As can be seen from changes in the number of research papers
published, new discoveries of the functions of organisms are clearly a trigger for
the new field of biomimetics research. However, the lack of a process to unite
64 Mechanisms of Organisms as Environment-Friendly Materials Design Tools 1261
this research with engineering is a limiting factor in the field’s development. In the
example of a gecko-type adhesive structure, physics translated the language between
different fields and fulfilled the role of combining biology with engineering.
Lowering interdisciplinary barriers is key to growth and continuous development
of the field of material systems mimetics.
References
T. Akatsu et al., J. Mater. Sci. l34, 4133 (1999)
K. Autumn et al., Nature 405, 681 (2000)
K. Autumn, J. Full et al., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 99, 12252 (2002)
K. Autumn et al., J. Exp. Biol. 209, 3558 (2006)
A. Campodel et al., Langmuir 23, 10235 (2007)
L. Feng et al., Adv. Mater. 14, 24 (2002)
H. Fudouzi, Sci. Tchechnol. Adv. Mater. 12, 064704 (2011)
H. Gao et al., Mech. Mater. 37, 275 (2005)
A.K. Geim et al., Nat. Mater. 2, 461 (2003)
N.J. Glassmaker et al., J. R. Soc. Interface 1, 23 (2004)
S. Gorb et al., Bioinspir. Biomim. 2, S117 (2007a)
S. Gorb et al., J. R. Soc. Interface 4, 271 (2007b)
L.B. Gower Chem. Rev. 108, 4551 (2008)
D. Gust, T.A. Moore, A.L. Moore, Acc. Chem. Res 34, 40 (2001)
L. Haeshin et al., Nature 448, 338 (2007)
W.R. Hansen, K. Autumn, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 102(2), 385 (2005)
J.G. Hardy, et al., Polymer 49, 4309 (2008)
N. Hosoda et al., Adv. Sci. Technol. 9th Cimtec: getting into the 2000’s-Part C, 15, 1091 (1999)
N. Hosoda et al., in Proceedings of the 2004 IEEE International Symposium on Electronics &
the Environment, Phoenix, AZ, 166 (2004)
N. Hosoda, A. Miyajima, in Electronics Goes Green 2008+, Berlin, 703 (2008)
G. Huber et al., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 102(45), 16293 (2005a)
G. Huber et al., Biol. Lett. 1, 2 (2005b)
J.N. Israelachvili, Intermolecular and Surface Forces (Academic, London, 1992)
E.H. Jeong, Y.K. Suh, Nano today 4, 335 (2009)
H. Kakisawa, T. Sumitomo, Sci. Tchechnol. Adv. Mater. 12, 064710 (2011)
K. Kendall, J. Phys. D Appl. Phys. 4, 1186 (1971)
M. Kikuchi et al., Biomaterials 22, 1705 (2001)
P.F.A. Maderson, Brit. J. Herp. 4, 151 (1964)
M.W. Markus et al., Am. J. Bot. 93(10), 1455 (2006)
C. Neinhuis, W. Barthlott, Ann. Bot. 79, 667 (1997)
K. Rampf, et al., J. Bionic Eng. 8, 242 (2011)
A. Saito, Sci. Tchechnol. Adv. Mater. 12, 064709 (2011)
D. Santos et al., J. Adhes. Sci. Technol. 21(12–13), 1317 (2007)
M. Sitti, S.R. Fearling, J. Adhes. Sci. Technol. 18(7), 1055 (2003)
T. Suga, Bull. Jpn. Inst. Met. 29(11), 944 (1990)
M. Sumper, E. Brunner, Adv. Funct. Mater. 16, 17 (2006)
Y.C. Tsai et al., 2006 IEEE 19th International Conference on Micro Electro Mechanical Systems,
Istanbul, 2006, p. 926
Thermodynamics and Resource
Consumption: Concepts, Methodologies, 65
and the Case of Copper
Stefan Gößling-Reisemann
Abstract
Analysis and minimization of resource consumption is an essential aspect of
sustainability. Engineers in this field need to be equipped with concepts and
methodologies for assessment and sustainable design of products and processes.
Thermodynamics offers these concepts and methodologies. In the current debate
on material flows, the throughput of matter and energy is the primary focus.
Consumption, however, starts when material and energy is transformed and
loses its potential to be useful in further products or processes. On the physical
level, this loss of potential utility is well described by entropy production or
exergy destruction, two related concepts from thermodynamics. Using these
concepts, methodologies for analyzing resource consumption were constructed
and have been successfully applied to a large number of processes, products,
and services. Here, a very brief introduction to thermodynamics is given to
enable the interested reader to understand the underlying concepts and help in
the application of thermodynamics to analyze resource consumption. Established
measures for resource consumption can be grouped into those approaches which
are based on the first law of thermodynamics (the conservation of energy
and matter) and those approaches which are based on the second law of
thermodynamics (entropy production and the devaluation of energy and matter).
A brief summary of the currently used approaches is given and how they
relate to the thermodynamic interpretation of resource consumption. Exergy and
entropy analysis are introduced as analytical tools and also briefly explained,
with recommendations for further self-study to get more familiar with the
methodologies. An example, copper making from sulfidic ore concentrates is
presented as a case study for the application of entropy analysis, and the results
S. Gößling-Reisemann
Faculty of Production Engineering, Division of Technological Design and Development, artec j
Research Center for Sustainability Studies, University of Bremen, Bremen, Germany
e-mail: sgr@uni-bremen.de
1 Introduction
The purpose of this little thought exercise is to highlight the importance of the
irreversible nature of consumption. It also shows that consumption is a gradual
concept: goods can be partly consumed and partly remain in the products which have
been produced from them. The degree of consumption obviously has some relation
with the irreversibility of the transformation of the goods. The examples here
were deliberately oversimplified: in reality, you would need many more material
resources to produce paper from wood and water, for example. Also, one should note
that the transformations leading to the loss of potential utility cannot in all cases be
quantitatively linked with the actual loss of potential utility. Small transformations
can have dramatic consequences for the usability of the economic goods involved,
like in the case of dispersing a tiny amount of toxic substances with drinking water.
The main observation remains true, however: consumption is about irreversible
transformations.
The irreversibility of the consumption process is a defining characteristic and
thus a good starting point for measuring consumption itself. In economics, it
was Georgescu-Roegen who first drew attention to this (Georgescu-Roegen 1971),
leading to a scientific debate about resources and their finality which still goes on
today (see, e.g., the discussion between Arrow et al. (2004), Daly et al. (2007) and
Arrow et al. (2007)).
This chapter is concerned with physical resources, not economic goods. How-
ever, the meaning of consumption is basically the same: it is about irreversibly
changing the structure and quality of material and energy flows making them
less available for further processing. Taking the above dictionary definition as
a starting point and applying it to physical resources, the key to understanding
(physical) consumption lies in understanding the changes in the physical resources
by destruction, deterioration, or transformation.
When the above definition of consumption is applied to all process stages from
extraction of resources to disposal and recycling of discards, it becomes clear that
all material and energy flows can be interpreted as resources, although to a different
degree. Thus, consumption is not localized to one defined area of the economic
system (as it might appear from the economically motivated dictionary definition),
but is happening wherever there are material and energy flows transformed and thus
lose potential utility.
In summary of the above paragraphs, the terms resource and consumption can
now be defined in a concise and meaningful way for the following discussion:
Resources in this context are to be understood as reservoirs or flows of matter and energy
that are used to produce products and services. Material resources can appear in the form
of raw materials, semi-products, final products, auxiliary materials, or wastes. Energetic
resources can appear as chemical energy stored in energy raw materials, heat, radiation,
potential energy, or any other form of physical energy.
Consumption is to be understood as the transformation of resources resulting in a loss
of possible further pathways for producing products and services. This loss in potential
utility comes about by chemical and physical processes, like dissipation, dilution, mixing,
chemical reactions, structural changes, heat transfer, and others.
material flows with regard to their transformation and conversion (Kondepudi and
Prigogine 1998). The above-mentioned irreversible “loss of potential utility” as a
measure for resource consumption has a more rigorously defined counterpart in
thermodynamics: entropy production. Economic resource consumption can then be
approximated by physical resource consumption, and entropy production can be
introduced as a measure.
4 Thermodynamics Background
interpretation is that every conceivable process will always result in the loss of
potential physical work. The mathematical formulation of the second law uses the
concept of entropy as the measure for the “unavailability” of energy. This physical
quantity was introduced by Clausius (1850) to describe the limited efficiency of
steam engines, and he discovered that entropy is only conserved in a process when
the process is reversible. Reversible processes can be run “backwards,” meaning
that the changes in their state variables and all exchanges of matter and energy
with other systems can be passed though in reversed order. Entropy itself is a state
variable, that is, it is only dependent on the state of the system, not on its path of
evolution. It is an empirical observation that there are no reversible processes, even
if some processes can be made to approach reversibility arbitrarily close. Following
Clausius, the second law can be expressed more elegantly with the help of entropy:
The entropy of the universe can only increase and approaches a maximum.
The meaning of the second law goes beyond energy conversion processes, as
could be inferred from its definition. When pure materials are mixed, for example,
the entropy increases, too. The simple interpretation is that the sum of the energies
stored within the pure material flows is generally less available to further processing
when the flows are mixed. The availability can, in the reversible case, remain
constant, but it cannot increase. The irreversibility of the process is obvious from
the fact that one would have to spend additional energy to de-mix the material flows;
a spontaneous de-mixing will not occur.
One consequence of the second law is that in any real process, the availability
of energy can only decrease. The amount of the loss of availability is directly
proportional to the entropy produced during the process. The entropy increase can
be brought about by all kinds of physical or chemical transformations: mixing,
combustion, chemical reactions, phase changes, heat transfer, etc.
The third law of thermodynamics simply states that as the temperature of a
perfect crystal approaches the absolute zero of temperature (0 K), the entropy of
the crystal also approaches zero (Kondepudi and Prigogine 1998). This then defines
the absolute zero of the entropy scale. Real materials do not necessarily satisfy the
“perfect crystal” condition, that is, they do not have a unique ground state. In gen-
eral, quantum mechanics predicts “degenerate” ground states for systems containing
particles with half-integer spins (like electrons). Degenerate means, that for a given
energy, several physical configurations of the constituents are possible. Even if
thus the entropy of many systems does not approach zero for the absolute zero of
temperature, the third law defines an absolute zero for entropy. This is different from
the definition of energy, where there is no “natural” zero level and all comparisons
(and measurements!) have to be made with respect to a chosen baseline.
65 Thermodynamics and Resource Consumption 1269
Especially the first law and the second law have relevancy for assessing resource
consumption. The first law offers a way to close the balance on material and energy
flows entering and leaving a system. It is therefore useful in setting up resource
balances or resource accounts for systems. Balances derived in this way highlight
the throughput of matter and energy as the basis for assessing consumption, without
addressing the change in quality of material and energy flows. The second law,
on the other hand, addresses precisely this defining characteristic of resource
consumption: the devaluation of matter and energy due to transformation of physical
flows.
There have been many attempts to find an adequate measure for resource consump-
tion. These can broadly be distinguished by those measures that are based on the first
law of thermodynamics (conservation of energy or mass) and those that are based
on the second law of thermodynamics (irreversibility and entropy generation).
Since the first law of thermodynamics does not address the change in quality of the
materials and energy flows, the methodologies derived from it cannot really measure
resource consumption as defined above. They rather measure resource throughput
or resource use. However, this distinction is rarely made, and, in general, one will
find these methodologies usually being discussed within the context of resource
consumption. The application range of these measures varies from the product or
service level up to the level of nation states and the worldwide economy. A few
typical examples include:
Cumulative energy demand (CED): developed in the 1990s, mainly by the Öko-
Institute in Germany (VDI 1997), it measures the aggregated input of all primary
energy into the production, distribution, use, and disposal of products or services.
Raw material flows are only considered when they are principally suitable as
energy carriers, which include natural gas, crude oil, and rapeseed oil but ex-
cludes, for example, iron ore or freshwater. The CED distinguishes nonrenewable
from renewable energies, like solar, wind, and hydro. The methodology is usually
applied on the product or service level.
Material intensity per service unit (MIPS): developed at the Wuppertal Institute
in Germany and part of the material-intensity-analysis framework (MAIA)
(Schmidt-Bleek and Klüting 1994; Schmidt-Bleek 1998; Ritthoff et al. 2002;
Wuppertal Institut 2011), it measures all material movement associated with
the production, use, and disposal of products or services. The methodology
focuses on the movement of material flows, which are further distinguished into
biotic, abiotic, water, air, and moved soil. Transformation of these flows is not
1270 S. Gößling-Reisemann
considered. The methodology has been applied to the product level, to regions,
and whole economies.
Direct material input (DMI) and domestic material consumption (DMC): mea-
sures developed within the framework of material flow accounts (European
Commission 2001), used primarily to measure the input and consumption of ma-
terials in national economies. DMI measures all material flows of economic value
(i.e., which are used for production and/or economic consumption, excluding
water) entering a national economy, aggregated on mass basis. DMC is calculated
from the physical trade balance (direct material input less exports) and domestic
extraction of resources. The methodology is typically applied to nation states, but
other regional scopes are used (the methodology is extensively used for assessing
material flows for the EU as a whole, for example).
The approaches based on mass and energy conservation are merely balancing
inputs and outputs without considering qualitative changes in the material and
energy flows. Methodologies based on the second law of thermodynamics can thus
complement these balances by including an actual reference to the consumption as
defined above: the loss of potential utility.
The exergy of a system is thus dependent on the state of its environment, which must
be individually defined for each system under investigation. Furthermore, exergy has
the same units as energy, but it is not a conserved quantity, very much like entropy.
The difference is that while the entropy of an isolated system is always increasing,
its exergy is constantly decreasing. In an isolated system, exergy can be destroyed,
but never be created. This feature makes exergy destruction a promising candidate
for measuring resource consumption.
The (specific) exergy flow " of a material flow can be partitioned into different
contributions, reflecting the physically independent equilibration processes: poten-
tial, kinetic, thermal, mechanical, and chemical exergy:
The potential and the kinetic exergy of a flow are equal to its potential and kinetic
energy. The thermal contribution "th is the work rate extractable by reversible
processes when bringing the material flow to thermal equilibrium with the reference
environment without changing either its composition or its other thermodynamic
parameters. The mechanical contribution "mech is defined similarly for the work rate
obtainable from reversible equilibration of pressure differences. The sum of "th and
"mech is also called physical exergy and denoted "ph . It can be derived from the
specific enthalpy h and the specific entropy s of the flow
where the subscript 0 denotes the values in the reference state of the environment
and m P is the mass flow rate (mass/time).
The chemical exergy flow rate of a material flow can be obtained from analyzing
the chemical reactions leading from the material flow’s chemical composition to
the chemical composition of the reference environment. This can be achieved by
using the chemical potentials of the flow’s components j at reference temperature
T0 ; j 0 , the component’s chemical potential in the reference environment, j 00 , and
the respective mass fractions xj of the components:
X
"ch D m
P .j 0 j 00 /xj :
j
The reader is referred to the books by Szargut et al. (1988) and Brodyansky (1994)
for a detailed description.
q
The exergy flow "s of a heat flow q across a surface area s at temperature Ts is
obtained from the Carnot factor:
T0
"qs D 1 q:
Ts
With the above expressions, the exergy flow balance of a steady-state system can be
set up, and the exergy destruction is obtained from
X X X
"in
i "out
i "qs WP IP D 0;
i i s
with "in
i denoting the various incoming exergy flows, "i
out
outgoing exergy flows,
P P
W physical work (rate), and I denoting exergy consumption rate. For nonsteady-
state systems, the 0 on the right hand side has to be replaced by "sys the exergy
change of the system itself. With the help of the Gouy-Stodola theorem, the exergy
consumption rate can be related to the entropy production SP rate of the system:
IP D T0 SP :
1272 S. Gößling-Reisemann
Exergy analyses have been performed on many systems, with the longest and most
successful tradition in analyzing and optimizing energy conversion technologies
and chemical processing (see Brodyansky 1994; Kotas 1995; Szargut 2005; Borel
and Favrat 2010), and are now successfully applied to assess natural resources
and resource consumption in life-cycle assessments (Bösch et al. 2007; Dewulf
et al. 2007) and in natural resource accounting and analysis (see the extensive
bibliography on http://www.exergoecology.com).
In the case of ideal, that is, reversible, processes, the internal production term is
zero. In all real processes, however, entropy is produced. In many cases, the entropy
change of the system itself can be neglected .Ssys D 0/. This is especially true for
steady-state processes, where the system state is static, or cyclic processes, where
the system is repeatedly going through the same states such that for an appropriately
chosen time interval, the net change in entropy is zero. The latter definition holds,
for example, for batch processes.
A general process can be thought of as a control volume with material flows m Pk
(mass/time), heat flows eq (energy/time), and radiation flows es (energy/time) enter-
ing and leaving the system. The thermodynamic measure for resource consumption
is then given by the internally produced entropy. With Ssys D 0 (steady-state or
cyclic process after full number of cycles), this quantity can be calculated from the
entropy balance (cf. Gößling 2001):
0 1
Z Z X 4 es;j X 4 es;j X
di S eqout eqin out in
i S D dtD @ C C P k A dt
sk m
dt T0 T0 j
3 Ts;j
out
j
3 Ts;j
in
k
in;out
where the eqin;out are the heat flows in and out of the system, respectively, es;j are
the incoming and outgoing flows of (assumedly black body) radiation
in;out
received/emitted at surface area j , with Ts;j being the temperature of the
received/emitted radiation, and sk being the specific entropy of material mk .
derived from balancing the enthalpy of the incoming and outgoing flows, including
the incoming and outgoing radiation, and correcting for the internally dissipated
electrical energy eqel :
X
eqin eqout D eqel esin C esout C hk m
Pk
k
with hk being the specific enthalpy of material mk . The emitted radiation flows esout
can be derived from the temperature of the partial surface areas Aj with uniform
temperature (Kondepudi and Prigogine 1998):
X
out 4
esout D Aj .Ts;j /
j
where sigma is the Stefan-Boltzmann constant. The same formula holds for the
received radiation when the temperature is exchanged accordingly. The radiation
energy balance then becomes
X h i
out 4 out 4
esout esin D Aj .Ts;j / .Ts;j / :
j
8 9
1 <X X =
sk D nk yjk sNj R nk yjk ln.yik /
mk : j j
;
1274 S. Gößling-Reisemann
with R being the universal gas constant (8.314472 J/K/mol). The latter sum in the
above formula represents the entropy of mixing and is solely due to the mixing
of components in the material flow. The entropy of mixing can also be used for
assessing the quality of material flow management systems, for example, in waste
incinerators (Rechberger 1999), in recycling processes (Gößling-Reisemann et al.
2011), or on the level of economy-wide substance flows (Rechberger and Graedel
2002).
Table 65.1 Most relevant material flows for mining, beneficiation, and metallurgy of copper
(model description and data sources in Gößling (2001) and Gößling-Reisemann (2008b))
Input Output
Mining and beneficiation
Overburden 76.8 t Overburden 76.8 t
Crude ore 101.2 t Tailings 97.5 t
Final energy 10.7 GJ Ore concentrate 3.8 t
Electricity 8.3 GJ Discarded water 150.0 t
Diesel 2.4 GJ
Fresh water 150.0 t
Lime (CaO) 0.1 t
Metallurgy
Ore concentrate 3.8 t Copper (cathodes) 1.0 t
Flux (SiO2 ) 0.5 t Slag 2.1 t
Final energy 9.1 GJ Offgas (to sulfuric acid plant) 3.9 t
Electricity 1.3 GJ Offgas (to filter/environment) 7.2t
Fossil fuels 7.8 GJ
Electricity production (for mining, beneficiation, and metallurgy)
Primary energy 25.9 GJ Electrical energy 9.6 GJ
Cooling water 618.4 t Cooling water discharge 223.2 t
Steam 395.2 t
Table 65.2 Composition of typical ore concentrate, molar entropies of the components, and specific entropy of the concentrate. Composition derived from
elemental composition (Davenport and Partelpoeg 1987) and recalculated to account for chemical compounds typically found in ores (cf. Gößling 2001)
(Entropies taken from Barin (1995) and Linstrom and Mallard (2010))
Component CuFeS2 SiO2 C Al2 O3 ZnS PbS H2 O As2 S3 Ni CaO
Mass fraction (wt%) 84:42 7:40 2:30 2:24 2:12 0:35 0:30 0:30 0:05 0:52
Molar entropy (J/K/mol) 125:0 41:4 5:7 50:9 57:7 91:3 70:0 164:0 29:8 38:2
Molar weight (g/mol) 183:521 60:0843 12:0107 101:9613 97:44 239:3 18:0153 246:038 58:6934 56:077
Sum of specific component entropies (J/K/g) 0.679
Specific entropy of mixing (J/K/g) 0.091
Specific entropy (J/K/g) 0.770
Entropy of 3.8 t concentrate (MJ/K) 2.928
S. Gößling-Reisemann
65 Thermodynamics and Resource Consumption 1277
P5:Energy-
Resources
6.52 MJ/K
417 MJ/K
P3:Suphuric Acid Plant
29.1 MJ/K
51.8 MJ/K
P7: Flash smetter slag
5.05 MJ/K
T1:Flash Smelter
P6
T3: Converter
P7:Converter slag
24.6 MJ/K
P1:Metallurgical
Resources
35.3 MJ/K
10.8 MJ/K
19.6 MJ/K
T4:Anode Furnace
5.27 MJ/K
T5:Electrolysis
P13: Cathodes
Fig. 65.1 Entropy flows of the metallurgy stage for copper production. All arrow widths are
proportional to the respective entropy flow, except for the hatched arrow from electricity mix to
emissions
Table 65.3 Entropy production along the process chain for producing refined copper from
sulfidic copper ore. Basis was the calculation in Gößling-Reisemann (2008b) with improved data
on efficiencies and material compositions. Also the model in Gößling-Reisemann (2008b) has been
updated so that the system border now includes the upstream process of electricity production and
the heat loss from the offgas treatment
Stage Entropy production (per ton of refined copper)
Mining and beneficiation
Direct processes 36.9 MJ/K
Electricity production (upstream) 58.0 MJ/K
Metallurgy
Flash smelter 18.2 MJ/K
Converter 15.8 MJ/K
Anode furnace 8.7 MJ/K
Electrolysis 4.4 MJ/K
Electricity production (upstream) 10.4 MJ/K
Offgas treatment (heat loss) 33.0 MJ/K
Sum 185.3 MJ/K
1278 S. Gößling-Reisemann
Technically, this is probably not fully feasible, but there are options for optimization:
the temperature difference between the flows and the surroundings could be used
for energy recovery (e.g., by producing steam or electricity), and the anode and
converter furnace can be equipped with more efficient offgas capture systems. Once
the flows have a uniform temperature, their heat content can further be used in heat
recovery systems, as long as their temperature does not fall below the optimum for
the subsequent sulfuric acid plant.
There have been other attempts at using thermodynamics to assess the resource
consumption of copper making. Most of them have used exergy analysis, but the
results are comparable since the entropy production can be calculated from the
exergy destruction via the Gouy-Stodola equation (see above). One of the earliest
studies was performed by Kolenda et al. (1992), in which three distinct processes
of copper making were analyzed: blast furnace, converter, and anode furnace.
The blast furnace is an outdated technology, which explains the poor results of
the exergetic analysis. A comparison with the entropy analysis above is given in
Table 65.4. Taking into account the distance in time between the two analyses (the
data in Gößling-Reisemann 2008b is from between 1999 and 2006), the agreement
is quite good, and the differences are probably explained by improvements in
process technology (note that the upstream process of electricity production and
the downstream process of offgas treatment are not included).
Another exergy analysis was performed by Ayres et al. (2006) with a technolog-
ical setup very close to the one analyzed here and with data from around the same
period (around 1999). A comparison of their results with the one presented here
can be found in Table 65.5. The differences are quite remarkable and can only be
explained with more detailed knowledge of the processes analyzed. It is interesting
to note, however, that the ratio between entropy productions in the metallurgy stage
and the mining stage is between 1.27 and 1.40, respectively, and is thus in fairly good
agreement. This probably indicates a systematic difference between the process
models.
Table 65.4 Comparison of entropy production from an analysis performed by Kolenda et al.
(1992) with the analysis presented in this chapter (updated model of Gößling-Reisemann (2008b))
Kolenda et al. (1992) Gößling-Reisemann (2008b) + model update
Blast furnace 39.2 MJ/K/t Flash smelter 18.2
Converter 17.1 MJ/K/t Converter 15.8 MJ/K/t
Anode furnace 11.0 MJ/K/t Anode furnace 8.7 MJ/K/t
Total 67.3 MJ/K/t 42.7 MJ/K/t
65 Thermodynamics and Resource Consumption 1279
Table 65.5 Comparison of entropy production from an analysis performed by Ayres et al. (2006)
with the analysis presented in this chapter (updated model of Gößling-Reisemann (2008b)). Note
that in the data taken from Ayres et al., upstream and downstream processes (electricity production
and offgas treatment/sulfuric acid production) have not been included to achieve comparable
system boundaries
Process stage Ayres et al. (2006) Gößling-Reisemann (2008b) + model update
Mining and beneficiationa 99.1 MJ/K/t 36.9 MJ/K/t
Metallurgy a 138.6 MJ/K/t 47.1 MJ/K/t
a
Only direct entropy production
Interpretation of the results from thermodynamic analyses can be done with different
goals. Historically, thermodynamics was used to optimize processes, most notably
energy conversion processes. This is still the main application also of analyses using
exergy or entropy (see, e.g., the long-standing tradition of the ECOS conferences
– International Conference on Efficiency, Cost, Optimization, Simulation, and
Environmental Impact of Energy Systems). In the paragraphs above, however, the
focus is explicitly on resource consumption of products, processes, and services
under a life-cycle perspective. The goal is to find an answer to the question of
how much resources are going to be destroyed in the satisfaction of a specific
demand. If different products or services are to be compared, the absolute amount
of resource consumption is less important; only the relative differences are relevant
for a decision. Still, the absolute value of the entropy production or exergy loss has
meaning, too.
As stated above, exergy and entropy are not conserved. The exergy available
for economic processes is limited mainly by the regeneration rates of terrestrial
resources, which again is dependent on the solar irradiation rate. For entropy,
something similar holds. Every living system is dependent on the expulsion of
the internally produced entropy (Ebeling et al. 1990; Glansdorff and Prigogine
1971; Nicolis and Prigogine 1977), or otherwise it collapses under accumulating
entropy waste. This expulsion rate is usually limited, for example, by physical limits
to the exchange of material and energy with the environment. The development
of lakes, amphibian eggs, and humans has been studied in this respect (Aoki
1991, 1995, 2008), and the analysis shows that the entropy production rate of these
biological systems varies with the developmental stage: early in their life, these
systems steadily increase their entropy production rate until it reaches a maximum,
after which the organisms seem to gradually optimize their resource consumption
and the entropy production rate converges toward a much lower stable value. If
this is translated into economic terms, nature seems to favor material growth in
early stages of development, without concern for resource consumption at all. In
later developmental phases, however, efficiency and resource conservation are the
guiding principles.
1280 S. Gößling-Reisemann
How does this relate to the global economic system? Firstly, also the entropy
disposal rate of the earth is limited. The disposal of entropy occurs mainly via
the emission of long-wave radiation from the earth atmosphere into space. For
the current biophysical conditions, including the earth’s surface temperature, the
average entropy disposal rate of one square meter of surface area is around 1.2 W/K
(cf. Gößling-Reisemann 2008b). For different conditions, this might change; for
example, a higher surface temperature might change the atmospheric system and
induce currently unknown convective patterns in the atmosphere, leading to a higher
disposal rate of entropy. However, the transition from the current state of the climate
system to the “improved” state probably comes with intermittent turbulence, and the
resulting climatic system might be less favorable to humans than the one us humans
are used to. Precaution thus dictates to preserve the state of the climate system as
much as possible. This implies a limit to the amount of entropy produced globally,
which in turn basically fixes the amount of entropy we as humans should be allowed
to produce. There is currently no rigorously defined limit for the sustainable human
entropy production rate, but for the argument of resource conservation, it suffices
to know that there is a limit at all. If there is consensus that the average entropy
production density on earth should not be above 1.2 W/K/m2 , this “natural” limit can
be used to give the entropy production of economic processes a new meaning, and
it can simultaneously be used as a “yardstick” to compare the entropy production of
all processes.
The above example calculation of the resource consumption for copper making
can be compared to this yardstick. The entropy production of 185.3 MJ/K per ton
of refined copper corresponds to the yearly disposal capacity of approximately
5 m2 of earth’s surface. The global annual copper production in 2004 was about
10 million tons, according to Graedel et al. (2004). This would imply the permanent
“occupation” of approximately 50 million m2 or 50 km2 of earth surface. For
comparison, the world primary energy consumption rate in 2008 was approximately
15 terawatt (BP 2009). If it is assumed that the primary energy is almost completely
transferred into heat at ambient temperature, the resulting “entropy footprint”
amounts to around 42;000 km2 .
In this manner, human activities and economic processes can be evaluated against
a naturally given limit, and the resource side of sustainability can be assessed by
using thermodynamic principles and measures.
7 Further Reading
energy conversion systems (see Szargut et al. 1988; Kotas 1995; Bejan et al. 1996;
Szargut 2005; Borel and Favrat 2010).
Along the same lines, but on a more general level, entropy analysis has been
suggested to be used in finding the optimal design of a broader class of processes.
Bejan introduced entropy production (he uses the term entropy generation) as a
means of thermodynamically assessing and optimizing the losses connected with
heat transfer, fluid flow, and mass transfer irreversibility (Bejan 1996). Bejan’s
entropy generation minimization (EGM) approach is basically a way to optimize
the design of systems and to assess their efficiency. It requires knowledge of the
geometrical setup of the machines and the thermodynamic properties of the internal
flows of matter and energy inside the analyzed system (or model).
Exergy analysis is still developed further and finds its ways into ever more
applications. It is combined with economic evaluation in the field of exergoeco-
nomics (Tsatsaronis 1999; Rosen 2010), and it is also used within the field of
life-cycle assessment (Cornelissen 1997; Cornelissen and Hirs 2002; Dewulf and
van Langenhove 2002a, b; Stewart and Weidema 2005; Bösch et al. 2007). Also
entropy analysis is applied to life-cycle assessment (Gößling-Reisemann 2011).
8 Summary
References
S.H. Amini, J.A.M. Remmerswaal, M.B. Castro, M.A. Reuter, Quantifying the quality loss and
resource efficiency of recycling by means of exergy analysis. J. Clean. Prod. 15(10), 907–913
(2007)
G. Angerer, L. Erdmann, F. Marscheider-Weidemann, M. Scharp, A. Lüllmann, V. Handke, M.
Marwede, Rohstoffe für Zukunftstechnologien: Einfluss des branchenspezifischen Rohstoffbe-
darfs in rohstoffintensiven Zukunftstechnologien auf die zukünftige Rohstoffnachfrage. ISI-
Schriftenreihe Innovationspotenziale (Fraunhofer Verlag, Stuttgart, 2009)
I. Aoki, Entropy principle for human development, growth and aging. J. Theor. Biol. 150(2),
215–223 (1991)
I. Aoki, Entropy production in living systems – from organisms to ecosystems. Thermochim. Acta
250(2), 359–370 (1995)
I. Aoki, Entropy law in aquatic communities and the general entropy principle for the development
of living systems. Ecol. Model. 215(1), 89–92 (2008)
K. Arrow, P. Dasgupta, L. Goulder, G. Daily, P. Ehrlich, G. Heal, S. Levin, K. Mäler, S. Schneider,
Are we consuming too much? J. Econ. Perspect. 18(3), 147–172 (2004)
K. Arrow, G. Daily, P. Dasgupta, P. Ehrlich, L. Goulder, G. Heal, S. Levin, K. Mäler, S. Schneider,
D. Starrett, B. Walker, Consumption, investment, and future well-being reply to Daly et al.
Conserv. Biol. 21(5), 1363–1365 (2007)
R.U. Ayres, L.W. Ayres, A. Masini, An application of exergy accounting to five basic metal
industries, in Sustainable Metals Management: Securing Our Future – Steps Towards a Closed
Loop Economy, ed. by A. von Gleich, R.U. Ayres, S. Gößling-Reisemann. Eco-Efficiency in
Industry and Science, vol. 19 (Springer, Dordrecht, 2006), pp. 141–194
I. Barin, Thermochemical Data of Pure Substances, 3rd edn. (VCH, Weinheim, 1995)
A. Bejan, Entropy Generation Minimization: The Method of Thermodynamic Optimization of
Finite-Size Systems and Finite-Time Processes. Advanced Topics in Mechanical Engineering
Series, vol. 2 (CRC, Boca Raton, 1996)
A. Bejan, G. Tsatsaronis, M.J. Moran, Thermal Design and Optimization (Wiley, New York, 1996)
L. Borel, D. Favrat, Thermodynamics and Energy Systems Analysis: From Energy to Exergy
(EFPL/CRC, Lausanne, 2010)
M.E. Bösch, S. Hellweg, M.A.J. Huijbregts, R. Frischknecht, Applying cumulative exergy demand
(CExD) indicators to the ecoinvent database. Int. J. Life Cycle Assess. 12(3), 181–190 (2007)
BP, BP Statistical review of world energy June 2009: spreadsheet file (2009), http://www.bp.
com/liveassets/bp internet/globalbp/globalbp uk english/reports and publications/statistical en
ergy review 2008/STAGING/local assets/2009 downloads/statistical review of world energy
full report 2009.xls. Accessed 28 May 2011
V.M. Brodyansky, The Efficiency of Industrial Processes: Exergy Analysis and Optimization
(Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1994)
M.B.G. Castro, J.A.M. Remmerswaal, M.A. Reuter, U.J.M. Boin, A thermodynamic approach to
the compatibility of materials combinations for recycling. Resour. Conserv. Recycl. 43(1), 1–19
(2004)
Centre for Research in Computational Thermochemistry (CRCT), F*A*C*T – facility for the
analysis of chemical thermodynamics: online database (2011), http://www.crct.polymtl.ca/fact/
R. Clausius, Über die bewegende Kraft der Wärme. Ann. Phys. 79, 368–397, 500–524 (1850)
L. Connelly, C.P. Koshland, Exergy and industrial ecology—part 1: an exergy-based definition
of consumption and a thermodynamic interpretation of ecosystem evolution. Exergy 1(3),
146–165 (2001a)
L. Connelly, C.P. Koshland, Exergy and industrial ecology—part 2: a non-dimensional analysis of
means to reduce resource depletion. Exergy 1(4):234–255 (2001b)
R.L. Cornelissen, Thermodynamics and sustainable development – the use of exergy analysis and
the reduction of irreversibility. Dissertation, University of Twente, 1997
65 Thermodynamics and Resource Consumption 1283
R.L. Cornelissen, G.G. Hirs, The value of exergetic life cycle assessment besides LCA. Energy
Convers. Manag. 43(9), 1417–1424 (2002)
H. Daly, B. Czech, D. Trauger, W. Rees, M. Grover, T. Dobson, S. Trombulak, Are we consuming
too much-for what? Conserv. Biol. 21(5), 1359–1362 (2007)
W.G. Davenport, E.H. Partelpoeg, Flash Smelting: Analysis, Control and Optimization (Pergamon,
Oxford, 1987)
J. Dewulf, H. van Langenhove, Assessment of the sustainability of technology by means of a
thermodynamically based life cycle analysis. Environ. Sci. Pollut. Res. Int. 9(4), 267–273
(2002a)
J. Dewulf, H. van Langenhove, Quantitative assessment of solid waste treatment systems in the
industrial ecology perspective by exergy analysis. Environ. Sci. Technol. 36(5), 1130–1135
(2002b)
J. Dewulf, M.E. Bösch, B. de Meester, G. van der Vorst, H.V. Langenhove, S. Hellweg,
M.A.J. Huijbregts, Cumulative exergy extraction from the natural environment (CEENE) a
comprehensive life cycle impact assessment method for resource accounting. Environ. Sci.
Technol. 41(24), 8477–8483 (2007)
W. Ebeling, A. Engel, R. Feistel, Physik der Evolutionsprozesse (Akademie-Verl., Berlin, 1990)
European Commission, Economy-Wide Material Flow Accounts and Derived Indicators:
A Methodological Guide (Office for Official Publications of the European Communities,
Luxembourg, 2001)
European Commission, Critical Raw Materials for the EU: Report of the Ad-hoc Working Group
on defining critical raw materials, Brussels (2010)
R.P. Feynman, R.B. Leighton, M.L. Sands, The Feynman Lectures on Physics. The Definitive and
Extended Edition (Addison-Wesley, San Francisco/Harlow, 2009)
N. Georgescu-Roegen, The Entropy Law and the Economic Process (Harvard University Press,
Cambridge, 1971)
P. Glansdorff, I. Prigogine, Thermodynamic Theory of Structure, Stability and Fluctuations (Wiley,
London, 1971)
S. Gößling, Entropy production as a measure for resource use: method development and application
to metallurgical processes. Dissertation. University of Hamburg, 2001, http://www.sub.uni-
hamburg.de/opus/volltexte/2004/1182/
S. Gößling-Reisemann, What is resource consumption and how can it be measured?: Theoretical
considerations. J. Ind. Ecol. 12(1), 10–25 (2008a)
S. Gößling-Reisemann, What is resource consumption and how can it be Measured? Application
of entropy analysis to copper production. J. Ind. Ecol. 12(4), 570–582 (2008b)
S. Gößling-Reisemann, Entropy production and resource consumption in life cycle assessments, in
Thermodynamics and the Destruction of Resources, ed. by B. Bakshi, T. Gutowski, D. Sekulic
(Cambridge University Press, New York, 2011)
S. Gößling-Reisemann, A. von Gleich, V. Knobloch, B. Cebulla, Bewertungsmaßstäbe für metallis-
che Stoffströme: von Kritikalität bis Entropie, in Methoden der Stoffstromanalyse: Konzepte,
agentenbasierte Modellierung und Ökobilanz, ed. by F. Beckenbach. Stoffstromanalysen, vol.
1, 1st edn. (Metropolis, Marburg, 2011)
T. Graedel, D. van Beers, M. Bertram, K. Fuse, R. Gordon, A. Gritsinin, A. Kapur, R. Klee, R.
Lifset, Multilevel cycle of anthropogenic copper. Environ. Sci. Technol. 38(4), 1242–1252
(2004)
C. Hagelüken, The challenge of open cycles – barriers to a closed loop economy demonstrated for
consumer electronics and cars, in R’07 World Congress: Recovery of Materials and Energy for
Resource Efficiency (EMPA, Davos, 2007)
C. Hagelüken, M. Buchert, H. Stahl, Stoffströme der Platingruppenmetalle: Systemanalyse und
Maßnahmen für eine nachhaltige Optimierung der Stoffströme der Platingruppenmetalle;
Endbericht (GDMB-Medienverl., Clausthal-Zellerfeld, 2005)
W.M. Haynes, D.R. Lide, CRC Handbook of Chemistry and Physics: A Ready-Reference Book of
Chemical and Physical Data (CRC, Boca Raton, 2010)
1284 S. Gößling-Reisemann
D. Janke, L. Savov, M.E. Vogel, Secondary materials in steel production and recycling, in
Sustainable Metals Management: Securing Our Future – Steps Towards a Closed Loop
Economy, ed. by A. von Gleich, R.U. Ayres, S. Gößling-Reisemann. Eco-Efficiency in Industry
and Science, vol. 19 (Springer, Dordrecht, 2006), pp. 313–334
Z. Kolenda, J. Donizak, A. Holda, J. Szmyd, M. Zembura, An analysis of cumulative energy and
exergy consumption in copper production, in International Symposium ECOS’92: Conference
Proceedings, Zaragoza (The American Society of Mechanical Engineers, New York, 1992),
pp. 275–282
D. Kondepudi, I. Prigogine, Modern Thermodynamics: From Heat Engines to Dissipative Struc-
tures (Wiley, Chichester, 1998)
T.J. Kotas, The Exergy Method of Thermal Plant Analysis (Krieger Publishing, Malabar, 1995)
P. Linstrom, W. Mallard (eds.), NIST Chemistry WebBook (http://webbook.nist.gov): NIST
Standard Reference Database Number 69, June 2010. National Institute of Standards and
Technology, Gaithersburg, 20899 (2010)
Merriam-Webster, Definition of “consumption” (2011), http://www.merriam-webster.com/
dictionary/consumption. Accessed 28 May 2011
National Research Council (NRC), Minerals, Critical Minerals, and the U.S. Economy (The
National Academies Press, Washington, DC, 2008)
G. Nicolis, I. Prigogine, Self-organization in Non-equilibrium Systems: From Dissipative Struc-
tures to Order Through Fluctuations (Wiley, New York, 1977)
Z. Rant, Exergie, ein neues Wort für technische Arbeitsfähigkeit. Forschung. Ing. Wesen 22, 36–37
(1956)
H. Rechberger, Entwicklung einer Methode zur Bewertung von Stoffbilanzen in der Abfall-
wirtschaft. Wiener Mitteilungen, vol. 158 (Technical University Institute für Wassergüte und
Abfallwirtschaft, Wien, 1999)
H. Rechberger, T. Graedel, The contemporary European copper cycle: statistical entropy analysis.
Ecol. Econ. 42(1), 59–72 (2002)
M.A. Reuter, U.M.J. Boin, A. van Schaik, E.V. Verhoef, K. Heiskanen, Y. Yang, G. Georgalli,
The Metrics of Material and Metal Ecology: Harmonizing the Resource, Technology and
Environmental Cycles (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 2005)
M. Ritthoff, H. Rohn, C. Liedtke, Calculating MIPS: Resource Productivity of Products and
Services. Wuppertal Spezial, vol. 27 (Wuppertal-Institute for Climate, Environment and Energy,
Wuppertal, 2002)
M.A. Rosen, Economics and Exergy: An Enhanced Approach to Energy Economics (Nova Science
Publisher’s, Hauppauge, 2010)
F. Schmidt-Bleek, MAIA: Einführung in die Material-Intensitäts-Analyse nach dem MIPS-Konzept.
Wuppertal Texte (Birkhäuser, Berlin, 1998)
F. Schmidt-Bleek, R. Klüting, Wieviel Umwelt braucht der Mensch?: MIPS – das Maß für
ökologisches Wirtschaften (Birkhäuser, Berlin, 1994)
T. Seager, T. Theis, A uniform definition and quantitative basis for industrial ecology. J. Clean.
Prod. 10(3), 225–236 (2002)
M. Stewart, B.P. Weidema, A consistent framework for assessing the impacts from resource use –
a focus on resource functionality. Int. J. Life Cycle Assess. 10(4), 240–247 (2005)
J. Szargut, Exergy Method: Technical and Ecological Applications. Developments in Heat Transfer,
vol. 18 (WIT, Southampton, 2005)
J. Szargut, D.R. Morris, F.R. Steward, Exergy Analysis of Thermal, Chemical and Metallurgical
Processes (Hemisphere Publishing, New York, 1988)
G. Tsatsaronis, Design optimization using exergoeconomics, in Thermodynamic Optimization
of Complex Energy Systems, ed. by A. Bejan, E. Mamut. Proceedings of the NATO
Advanced Study Institute on Thermodynamics and the Optimization of Complex Energy
Systems, Neptun, July 1998. 3, High Technology, vol. 69 (Kluwer, Dordrecht/Boston, 1999),
pp. 101–115
65 Thermodynamics and Resource Consumption 1285
A B
ABB, 715, 717, 718 Backcasting, 749–769
Abscission layer, 1258–1260 Backcasting analysis, 755, 761–762, 767, 768
Access to energy, 979–989 Backcasting methodology
Adhesion, 1250–1258 applied at the Dutch STD program, 754
Advanced materials research, 1147 applied in the international Sustainable
Advanced technologies, 1150 Households project, 754
Agriculture, 197, 199, 203, 207, 249–252, Balanced sustainability scorecards, 708
254, 255 Ball milling, 525, 527–530
Algorithm of inventive problem solving Banki or cross-flow turbine, 961
(ARIZ), 453, 455 Behaviour, 773–791
All-electron mixed-basis approach, 1218–1233 Beneficial, 1158–1159, 1161
Alternative materials, 1189–1200 Beyond compliance strategy, 866, 868
Aluminum hydroxide, 1206–1207, 1211 Bill of material (BOM), 373, 375, 387
Analytical tools and methods, 755, 756 Binary hydrate, 1217–1218, 1234, 1238, 1239,
AO. See Atomic orbitals (AO) 1242, 1244, 1246
Apple, 711, 716 Binder removal, 526–530, 533, 535, 538, 539
Archimedes screw, 946, 961–962 Bioavailability, 139, 142, 144, 146, 148, 158
Architectural innovations, 824–826 Bio-energy, 92, 96, 98–104, 927–929, 931,
ARIZ. See Algorithm of inventive problem 932, 937–939
solving (ARIZ) Bio-energy good practices, 977–1014
Arsenic, 182–193 Biofuels risks and opportunities, 986, 987
metabolism, 192, 193 Biological monitoring, 191–193
toxicity, 183, 186–190, 193 Biomagnification, 150, 155, 156
Articulations, 883, 887, 888, 892, 893 Biomass, 927–939
Assembly/disassembly, 711, 714 Biomimetics, 451–468, 1249, 1256–1258,
Assessment of the needs, 897–899, 912–913, 1260
916, 917 Bioplastics, 1204, 1205, 1211–1213
Atomic orbitals (AO), 1221–1223, Blue water, 849
1228–1229 BMW, 710
dispersion coefficients, 1230–1231 BOM. See Bill of material (BOM)
oscillator strengths, 1228–1229 Bonding, 1250–1256, 1258–1260
Attitudes, 96, 97, 106, 109 Brand strategy, 717
Audi, 711, 719 Brominated material, 304, 305, 307, 320, 321
Automotive, 723–740 Buildings, 693, 694
Axial age, 908 Bulk, 1177–1183, 1185
Axial period, 905 Business, 747–748
Axial period of human history, 904 activity, 619–621, 623, 629–630
models, 598, 604, 611, 859–878 Compact fluorescent lamps (CFLs), 820
practices, 401–404 Compact unit, 213, 220–225,
strategy, 708 227–241, 243
Complexity, 92, 96, 98, 494–496, 498,
501–504, 516, 517
C Complex societal problems, 753, 769
CAI. See Computer-aided innovation (CAI) Component structures, 502, 508–511, 514
Capacitance, 1149–1150, 1152, 1161, Computational materials science, 1192–1194,
1164–1169, 1171, 1172 1200
Capacitor, 1149–1172 Computational support, 635–638, 650
Capacity training, 897, 913–915, 918 Computer-aided innovation (CAI), 451–468
Capital goods, 272, 282 Concentrated solar power (CSP), 1067–1072,
Carbon footprint, 262, 266, 847–848, 851, 1088, 1089, 1099–1100, 1104
853, 855 Concentrated solar thermal, 1075–1076,
Carbon footprint methodology, 848 1086–1087, 1089
Carbon source, 1160–1161, 1163, 1172 Conductive polymer, 1160, 1168
Carry-over parts, 494, 495, 509, 511, 514, Constructive Technology Assessment, 833
516, 517 Consumer products, 272, 275, 282
Car sharing, 727, 730–733, 735, 739, 740 Consumption, 575–594, 775–778, 780–782,
Case base, 629, 631 784, 785, 787, 788, 790,
Case studies, 33, 46, 47 1263–1281
Casida approach, 1219–1221, 1233 Consumption efficiency, 578, 582
Casimir-Polder integral, 1230, 1233 Context, 775, 777, 778, 781, 786–791
Cathode materials, 1150, 1153–1164 Contradiction, 452, 454, 460
Causal-loop diagram (CLD), 618–620, 623, Contribution analysis, 374, 383, 385, 386
625–630 Control dilemma, 820
Cause-effect pattern library, 617, Control system, 951, 962, 968
621–627, 630 Conventional hydropower, 942–946, 948–949,
CBA. See Cost-benefit analysis (CBA) 951, 963
CED. See Cumulated energy demand (CED) Conventional products, 1204
CFLs. See Compact fluorescent lamps (CFLs) Copper, 1263–1281
Change, 773–791 Copper recovery, 315–316, 319
Change across the curriculum, 8, 15 Corporate social responsibility, 433, 437,
Charge/discharge, 1150, 1161–1164, 1167, 438, 448
1169 Cost accounting, 355, 359, 368
Chemical applications, 1159, 1172 Cost-benefit analysis (CBA), 842
Chemical industry energy footprint, 847 Cost calculation, 353, 365
Chemical potential, 1235, 1236, 1239, Costs, 270, 271, 273–276, 278–280,
1241–1243 414–416, 418, 419, 421, 425, 710,
Chiapas, 163–179 713–716
Chlorine, 117–135, 163, 164, 167, 172–173, Courtesy of ArvisSolar Ltd., 1081
177, 178, 214, 218, 223, 225–228, Covenants, 875–876
230–234, 237–243 Criteria and indicators, 996, 997, 999–1012
Citizens, 797, 799, 808–813 CSP. See Concentrated solar power (CSP)
City planning, 251 Cultural institutions, 897, 900, 903,
Clathrate hydrate, 1217, 1218, 1233–1246 909, 915
CLD. See Causal-loop diagram (CLD) Culture, 91–109
Clients, 794, 798–802, 804–806, 809, Cumulated energy demand (CED), 1269
810, 813 Currents, 942, 943, 947
Climate change, 692, 694, 698, 701 Curriculum change, 15
Clothing, 693–695, 697, 699, 701 Curriculum reform, 68, 70–72
Coating technique, 1160, 1172 Curtailment, 776, 777, 784, 785
Co-creation, 602 Customers, 410–419, 421, 425
Collaboration, 92, 94–97, 106, 108 Cyanide gold plating, 304, 310–312, 321
Index 1289
Quality, 410–413, 415, 417, 418, 425 Restriction of hazardous substances (RoHS),
Quality Function Deployment (QFD), 285–300 302, 303, 307, 321
Quality Function Deployment for Environment Return on sustainability (ROS), 715
(QFDE), 262–264, 285–300 Reuse, 116, 326, 335, 337–339, 345, 347,
Quality management, 355 409–425
Quality of life, 579–581, 585 Reuse (Quagan), 265
Quantitative evaluation, 635 Reuse and recovery strategies, 339, 345, 348
Quantitative reduction, 324, 326, 337, 339, Reverse pump, 961
346, 348 Reverse supply chain, 434
Quantity, 352, 353, 355–363 Risk assessment (RA), 842
Risk management, 429, 436, 440–442, 447
Road mapping, 754
R RoHS. See Restriction of hazardous substances
RA. See Risk assessment (RA) (RoHS)
Rapid, 1150, 1153, 1156–1157, 1160 RoHS Directive, 416
Rare earth elements, 1189–1192, 1197 Room temperature bonding, 1254
R&D. See Research and development (R&D) ROS. See Return on sustainability (ROS)
R&D agendas, 752, 768–769 Routine, 776–777, 780, 782, 783, 785, 789
Reactive sintering, 520, 536, 539
Rebound effect, 820, 827
Recovery, 326, 335, 338, 339, 345, 348 S
Recycle-based society, 430, 437 Sacred order, 904
Recycling, 324, 326, 335, 338, 339, 345, Safety factor, 336, 337
347, 348 Sample curriculum, 10, 15, 16, 21
method, 304, 317–320 Sanitation, 251–253
of scrapped PCB, 316–321 Satisfier, 577–580, 582, 583, 586, 588–591
Reduction, 326, 337, 338, 342, 343, Satisfier efficiency, 580, 581, 584–586
345, 348 SCALES, 577, 588–592
Reference flow, 374–376, 379–382, 384 Scenario methodologies, 751
Reflexive, 745 Scenarios, 749–769
Registration, Evaluation, Authorization and SCP. See Sustainable consumption and
Restriction of Chemicals production (SCP)
(REACH), 302, 321 SD. See Sustainable development (SD)
Rehabilitation, 119, 120, 211–245 SEA. See Strategic environmental assessment
Reliability, 412, 422 (SEA)
Remaining working life, 412, 418 Secondary batteries, 1151, 1152
Remanufacturing, 262, 265, 610, 611, 672, Secondary market processes, 390–392
679, 680, 683–685 Second law of thermodynamics, 1267–1274
Renewability, 1022–1024, 1043–1063 Security system, 951, 963, 969
Renewable and biodegradable materials nature Self-cleaning, 1250, 1256
technology, 1147 Service, 549–573, 598–611, 669–687
Requirement analysis, 551–558, 572 complexity, 733
Requirements, 671, 676–678, 680–683, conceptual design, 551, 552, 558–561, 572
685, 686 design, 653–657, 659, 661–667
Research, 1135 design process, 551–552, 572
Research and development (R&D), 91–109, detailed design, 551, 552, 565, 572
598, 611 engineering, 546, 550–572, 600, 654,
Resilient enterprise, 430 662, 667
Resources, 452, 454, 455, 461, 463, 465, Explorer, 665–667
1263–1281 life cycle, 737
allocation, 550, 551, 561–566, 570–572 life cycle management, 737
consumption, 1263–1281 Service CAD. See Service computer-aided
depletion, 692, 694, 701 design (Service CAD)
efficiency, 364 Service-centered design, 653–667
1296 Index
U Water
Undergraduate research, 62–64 disinfection, 212, 214
University-level change, 15 energy, 941–974
Upcoming instruments, 1203 and food crisis, 199, 200, 207, 248, 253,
Use efficiency, 579, 580, 586 255
User behaviour, 750 intake, 951, 953, 954
Users, 797, 801, 802, 804–807, 810, 813 networks, 946, 949–951, 959, 961
User value (UV), 474, 475, 477–482, 486–488, quality, 118, 122–124, 132
619–623, 626, 627, 630 reuse, 248–252, 255, 256
Utility value, 521, 522 stream, 941, 942, 947–952, 964, 971
UV. See User value (UV) sustainability, 137, 138, 159
treatment, 119, 121–124, 126, 129, 133,
163, 171
V treatment plant, 213, 220–225, 227, 228,
Value chain, 372, 374, 384, 386, 387, 431–433 241–242
Values, 91–109, 599, 600, 603–607, 609–611 Water footprint (WF), 847–849, 853, 855
van der Waals (vdW), 1219, 1233, 1245 Wave, 942, 945, 947, 964
force, 1250, 1253, 1254, 1256 WBCSD. See World Business Council for
interaction, 1218–1233 Sustainable Development (WBCSD)
van der Waals-Platteeuw (vdWP) theory, Wearable devices, 1203
1232–1234, 1245 WEEE. See Waste electrical and electronic
vdW. See van der Waals (vdW) equipment (WEEE)
Vehicle, 1046, 1055–1063 WEEE Directive, 415, 416
Virtues, 903, 910 Well to tank analysis, 1056, 1057
Visions, 751, 752, 754–757, 760–761, 763, Well to wheel analysis, 1056–1058
766–768 Wet jet milling, 529, 530, 539
VOC. See Voice of customer (VOC) WF. See Water footprint (WF)
Voice of customer (VOC), 287–291, 293–295, Wind energy, 1110, 1112, 1113, 1116–1120,
299, 300 1136, 1139, 1141
Voltage window, 1162, 1164, 1166 World Business Council for Sustainable
Development (WBCSD), 838, 847
World installed capacity, 1020, 1021, 1027,
W 1040
Waste electrical and electronic equipment
(WEEE), 302, 303, 316, 321
Waste Framework Directive, 416, 422 Z
Waste from packaging, 324–327, 337 Zugspitze declaration, 196, 202, 203, 205