Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract—The Conductor on Rounded Core (CORC) cables Cable (TSTC) [4], [5] and the Conductor on Round Core
manufactured by Advanced Conductor Technologies with current (CORC) cable [6], [7]. In brief, in the TSTC concept, the
densities beyond 300 Amm−2 at 4.2 K, and bending diameter of cable contains several coated conductors stacked on top of each
up to 3.5 cm, are considered as one of the strongest candidates for
the next generation of high field power applications and magnets. other, after which the bundle is twisted for improving bending
In this paper, we present a full 3D FEM model for their monolayer performance. On the other hand, the ROEBEL cable is fairly
and bilayer CORC cables made with up to three and six super- inflexible when bent in plane of the stacked coated conductors,
conducting tapes respectively, disclosing the full curve of AC losses limiting therefore the range of magnets suitable for this kind of
for the monolayer cable at magnetic fields beyond 60 mT, and the cables. Finally, due to the simplicity and low cost, the CORC
actual distribution of current density along and across the thickness
of the superconducting tapes in both designs. The model is based cable represents the most attractive option regarding to the
on the so-called H-formulation, allowing to incorporate the true bending features, as by wounding the 2G-HTS tapes around an
three-dimensionality of the tapes without recurring to 2D thin-film elastic rounded-former of e.g., copper or stainless steel, a full
approaches where non-physical surface currents that do not follow transposition of the tapes along the cable length can be obtained
the celebrated Bean’s model for type-II superconductors appear. [8], [9]. In fact, it has been already proved that CORC cables
Likewise, good agreement with the experimentally measured AC-
losses for the monolayer and bilayer cable have been obtained, with can be wounded in a small diameter coil with high magnetic
all the details of the model disclosed in this paper. fields up to 20 T [10], [11].
Additionally, for the development of high-power supercon-
Index Terms—CORC Cable, AC losses, 3D Modelling, H-
Formulation.
ducting cables, there is another requirement to consider which
is attaining very low AC-losses at high transport currents and
high magnetic fields. This is because significant hysteresis losses
I. INTRODUCTION are caused when either the self or any external magnetic field is
HE development of High Temperature Superconducting perpendicular to the wide surface of the HTS tapes that compose
T (HTS) applications for ultra-lightweight generators, mo-
tors, or high field magnets, demand of a deep understanding of
the cable. This is partially solved by the tapes’ transposition
in the CORC cable [12], [13], with further solutions such as
the convoluted performance of superconducting cables either striating the tapes for a higher reduction on their AC-losses [14].
for power connections, transmission lines, or for their large However, the designing of multilayer CORC cables with elec-
variety of coil windings, opening routes for multiple designs tric contact between the tapes, generate coupling currents and
in the competition for the best high power superconducting hence adds more AC losses. Still, current sharing between the
cable. Nowadays, the default HTS tapes used for high current tapes is essential for cable stability with the inter-tape contact
capacity and high magnetic field applications is the set of the resistive parameter. All of this make the CORC cable geometry
so-called second generation (2G) coated conductors available a complex structure without possible analytical solution for the
in the market, whose theoretical limit for the upper critical field calculation of AC losses, and for which topological reductions
Bc2 is above 100 T [1]. from the actual 3D geometry into 2D abstractions of the coated
Over time there has been three major cabling concepts put conductors (or the entire cable), can result in rather complex
forward, the ROEBEL cable [2], [3], the Twisted Stacked Tape theoretical predictions with doubtful distributions of current
density which do not seem to follow the celebrated Bean’s model
Manuscript received September 20, 2021; revised November 22, 2021, De-
for type-II superconductors [15]–[19]. This is precisely the case
cember 18, 2021, and January 12, 2022; accepted January 18, 2022. Date of in all previous attempts to model the full tree-dimensionality of
publication January 25, 2022; date of current version February 9, 2022. This CORC cables with the acclaimed H-formulation [20]–[23], as
work was supported by the U.K. Research and Innovation, Engineering and
Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) under Grant EP/S025707/1 led
either the minimum length of the finite elements across the 1
by H.S.R. (Corresponding author: H. S. Ruiz.) micron thickness of the superconducting film seem to match the
The authors are with the College of Science and Engineering and Space thickness of the renormalized layer or, not sufficient elements
Park Leicester, University of Leicester, LE1 7RH Leicester, U.K. (e-mail:
dr.harold.ruiz@leicester.ac.uk).
have been defined across this dimension to allow the actual
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TASC.2022.3145309 penetration of magnetization currents.
1051-8223 © 2022 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission.
See https://www.ieee.org/publications/rights/index.html for more information.
Authorized licensed use limited to: Universidad Nac de Educación a Distancia (UNED). Downloaded on March 22,2023 at 10:07:13 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
8200205 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON APPLIED SUPERCONDUCTIVITY, VOL. 32, NO. 4, JUNE 2022
Authorized licensed use limited to: Universidad Nac de Educación a Distancia (UNED). Downloaded on March 22,2023 at 10:07:13 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
FAREED et al.: 3D FEM MODELING OF CORC COMMERCIAL CABLES WITH BEAN’S LIKE MAGNETIZATION CURRENTS 8200205
HTS tapes in Section III. In the same section, we show the AC Then, for modelling the mono and bi-layer CORC cables
loss analysis with direct comparisons between the measured manufactured by Advanced Conductor Technologies and char-
samples and our computational results, disclosing the actual acterized at the Ohio State University by Majoros et al., [24],
AC losses of the 1-layer CORC cable at high magnetic fields, it is necessary to describe its general structure. The mono layer
where the reported experimental measurements were affected by cable contains 3 tapes as seen in Fig. 1 b, each made by the
an unintended heating effect. On the other hand, for the 2-layer 4 mm wide SuperPower tape (SCS4050) with a critical cur-
CORC cable our numerical results show a good agreement with rent of 25 A per mm width, measured at self-field and LN2
the experimental measurements, showing the potential of this temperature (77 K). The bi-layer version contains 3 tapes per
model to predict the electromagnetic response of CORC cables layer (Fig. 1 c) with each layer wound in counter direction.
with many more tapes or layers. Finally, Section IV is devoted Cable dimensions and twist pitch measurements can be found
to summarize the main conclusions of this study. in Table I, where all CORC cables were measured with open
ends [24] allowing a straightforward representation of the cables
II. COMPUTATIONAL MODEL AND SAMPLE GEOMETRY within the 3D computational model. The actual thickness of the
SCS4050 is of ∼100 μm, including a ∼1.8 μm Ag top-coating
The 3D electromagnetic modelling of CORC cables in the layer and a 20 μm Cu stabilizer layer, the latter coating the
H-formulation has been implemented by the Partial Differential YBCO tape which is deposited on a ∼ 0.2 μm proprietary
Equation (PDE) solver provided by COMSOL Multiphysics, it buffer over a ∼ 50 μm Hastelloy C-276 substrate. As neither the
mainly due to its large popularity in the community of applied metallic, buffer, or substrate layers have a magnetic signal nor
superconductivity but mostly due to its easy adaptation of di- are expected to carry electrical currents under transport current
verse Finite Element Methods (FEM). The state variables of the conditions below Ic , these layers can be modelled with the same
H-formulation or Magnetic Field are commonly well known. physical properties of what in the jargon for electromagnetic
Therefore, we will focus on their implementation inside the PDE modelling is called as the “air” domain, i.e., a no magnetic
module, where the general PDE form for the COMSOL interface highly resistive media. However, for reducing the computing
is stated as: time and meshing requirements of the models, the thickness
∂2H ∂H of the YBCO layer in the SCS4050 tape has been increased
ea 2
+ da +∇·Γ=f, (1) from 1 μm to 50 μm, renormalizing the critical current density
∂t ∂t
accordingly, but ensuring the YBCO tape is placed in the middle
where ea is called the mass coefficient, da is the damping coef- of the ∼ 100 μm thickness reserved for the SCS405 tape, such
ficient, Γ plays the role of a conservative vectorial flux, and the that its impact on the calculation of the H-field around the
function f allows to define any source terms. The state variables superconducting tapes is minimized.
of the magnetic field in Cartesian coordinates are represented From the physical point of view, a further caution must be
as the matrix vector H = [Hx , Hy , Hz ], and hence Γ in the (1) taken in what concerns to the minimum length of the finite
must be transformed to resemble the left side of Faraday’s law elements used for meshing the superconducting domain. In fact,
∇ × E = −μ0 ∂t H, in the same matrix notation. if the mesh is not sufficiently fine and the minimum length of
For this reason, starting with the divergence of the conser- the devised finite elements is not less than the thickness of the
vative flux vector Γ = [Γx , Γy , Γz ], which in the most general renormalized layer (i.e., 50 μm), then the solution of Ampere’s
way implies the existence of non-isotropic components with law will be artificially forced in such way that proper Bean’s like
space-dependent derivatives, i.e., loops of magnetization current would not be able to appear. Nev-
⎡ ⎤ ertheless, by significantly reducing the minimum length of the
∂x Γ11 + ∂y Γ12 + ∂z Γ13 finite elements, e.g., to clearly fit more than one element across
∇ · Γ = ⎣ ∂x Γ21 + ∂y Γ22 + ∂z Γ23 ⎦ , (2) the thickness of the SC layer, this can easily render to the same
∂x Γ31 + ∂y Γ32 + ∂z Γ33 computational issues derived from the aspect-ratio problem for
which the thickness of the SC layer was initially renormalized.
it is possible to infer between the left side of Faraday law and
In this sense, finite elements with minimum lengths close to
Γ, that the conservative flux vector results defined by
the thickness of the renormalized layer can be used as long the
⎡ ⎤ ⎡ ⎤ higher degree of shape function (Lagrange elements) of at least
Γ11 Γ12 Γ13 0 Ez −Ey
Γ = ⎣ Γ21 Γ22 Γ23 ⎦ = ⎣ −Ez 0 Ex ⎦ . (3) quadratic order are used [26], otherwise by using reduced finite
Γ31 Γ32 Γ33 Ey −Ex 0 element approaches such as the curl-elements, these could also
limit the occurrence of loops of magnetization currents across
Likewise, by assuming the mass coefficient ea = 0, the sec- the thickness of the SC. On the other hand, as the experimen-
ond time derivative in (1) is neglected, leaving only the damping tal measurements have shown negligible losses in the SS304
term da ∂t H which resembles the right side of Faraday’s law by (stainless-steel) former, the electrical resistivity of it and the
μ0 ∂t H with outer domain have been assumed as the one of ‘air’ as it is custom
⎡ ⎤ ⎡ ⎤ in the electromagnetic modelling of superconductors at LN2
da11 da12 da13 μ0 0 0 conditions. Thus, for the meshing of sample B, i.e., the one-layer
da = ⎣ da21 da22 da23 ⎦ = ⎣ 0 μ0 0 ⎦ . (4) cable, our simulations have considered a COMSOL physics-
da31 da32 da33 0 0 μ0 controlled mesh with a total of 10832 mesh vertices for 61283
Authorized licensed use limited to: Universidad Nac de Educación a Distancia (UNED). Downloaded on March 22,2023 at 10:07:13 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
8200205 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON APPLIED SUPERCONDUCTIVITY, VOL. 32, NO. 4, JUNE 2022
Authorized licensed use limited to: Universidad Nac de Educación a Distancia (UNED). Downloaded on March 22,2023 at 10:07:13 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
FAREED et al.: 3D FEM MODELING OF CORC COMMERCIAL CABLES WITH BEAN’S LIKE MAGNETIZATION CURRENTS 8200205
and their AC losses. The experimentally measured monolayer [7] D. C. van der Laan, X. F. Lu, and L. F. Goodrich, “Compact
and bilayer cables of 3 and 6 tapes, respectively, have been GdBa2 Cu3 O7−δ coated conductor cables for electric power transmission
and magnet applications,” Supercond. Sci. Technol., vol. 24, no. 4, 2011,
modelled with the original manufacturer dimensions and physi- Art. no. 042001.
cal properties introduced in COMSOL Multiphysics. Local and [8] C. Kovacs, M. Majoros, M. D. Sumption, and E. W. Collings, “Magnetiza-
global electromagnetic quantities such as the three-dimensional tion measurements of CORC and roebel type YBCO cables for accelerators
using a ±3-T dipole magnetometer,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Supercond., vol. 29,
distribution of current densities along and across the HTS tapes, no. 5, Aug. 2019, Art. no. 8200905.
and the overall AC losses of the CORC cable have been dis- [9] J. Šouc et al., “Superconducting hts coil made from round cable cooled
closed. Our results allow to elucidate the actual paths of the mag- by liquid nitrogen flow,” Supercond. Sci. Technol., vol. 30, no. 10, 2017,
Art. no. 105014.
netization currents in helical arrangements of superconducting [10] T. Mulder, J. Weiss, D. van der Laan, M. Dhallé, and H. T. Kate, “Develop-
tapes, and how these resemble the classical Bean-like and critical ment of ReBCO-CORC wires with current densities of 400-600 A/mm2 at
state model observations in bulk and other coated conductor 10 T and 4.2 K,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Supercond., vol. 28, no. 3, Apr. 2018,
Art. no. 4800504.
arrangements, without the need to recurring to artificial surface [11] D. C. van der Laan, J. D. Weiss, and D. M. McRae, “Status of CORC cables
currents that occur in 3D to 2D mathematical reductions of the and wires for use in high-field magnets and power systems a decade after
general PDE system, when for instance the thickness of the HTS their introduction,” Supercond. Sci. Technol., vol. 32, no. 3, Feb. 2019,
Art. no. 033001.
tapes is reduced to an infinitely thin film approach. Moreover, [12] C. B. Cobb et al., “Hysteretic loss reduction in striated YBCO,” Physica.
good agreement with the experimentally measured AC losses C., Supercond., vol. 382, no. 1, pp. 52–56, 2002.
for all magnetic fields applied to the bilayer CORC cable has [13] J. Šouc et al., “Low AC loss cable produced from transposed striated CC
tapes,” Supercond. Sci. Technol., vol. 26, no. 7, 2013, Art. no. 75020.
been reported, what has allowed as to complete the curve of [14] M. Vojenčiak et al., “Magnetization AC loss reduction in HTS CORC
AC-losses for the monolayer cable at high magnetic fields, which cables made of striated coated conductors,” Supercond. Sci. Technol.,
as reported in [24] suffered of unintended heating effects. Thus, vol. 28, no. 10, 2015, Art. no. 104006.
[15] Q. Li, H. Tan, and X. Yu, “Effect of multilayer configuration on AC losses
with computing times no longer than 20 h for the entire hysteretic of superconducting power transmission cables consisting of narrow coated
process of a bilayer 6-tapes CORC at 80 mT in a standard PC of conductors,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Supercond., vol. 24, no. 5, Oct. 2014,
3.6GhZ clock speed and 32 Gb RAM, the model here presented Art. no. 5400604.
[16] S. Fukui, T. Noguchi, J. Ogawa, M. Yamaguchi, T. Sato, and O. Tsukamoto,
can be used with confidence as a benchmark for the modelling “Analysis of AC loss and current distribution characteristics of multi-layer
of CORC cables. The computing time can be greatly reduced triaxial HTS cable for 3-phase AC power transmission,” IEEE Trans. Appl.
by either considering larger time stepping, reduced meshing, Supercond., vol. 16, no. 2, pp. 135–138, Jun. 2006.
[17] Z. Jiang, N. Amemiya, and M. Nakahata, “Numerical calculation of AC
reduced field, or enhanced computational power, but differences losses in multi-layer superconducting cables composed of coated conduc-
in the same order of magnitude for the computing time are tors,” Supercond. Sci. Technol., vol. 21, no. 2, 2008, Art. no. 025013.
of no importance as it is the physical validness of what must [18] A. Stenvall, M. Siahrang, F. Grilli, and F. Sirois, “Computation of self-
field hysteresis losses in conductors with helicoidal structure using a 2D
prevail. finite element method,” Supercond. Sci. Technol., vol. 26, no. 4, 2013,
Art. no. 45011.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT [19] Y. Wang, M. Zhang, F. Grilli, Z. Zhu, and W. Yuan, “Study of the mag-
netization loss of CORC cables using a 3D T-A formulation,” Supercond.
The authors acknowledge the use of the High-Performance Sci. Technol., vol. 32, no. 2, 2019, Art. no. 25003.
[20] J. Sheng, M. Vojenčiak, R. Terzioglu, L. Frolek, and F. Gömöry, “Numer-
Computing Cluster Facilities (ALICE) provided by the Uni- ical study on magnetization characteristics of superconducting conductor
versity of Leicester. M.U.F and M.C thanks the CSE and on round core cables,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Supercond., vol. 27, no. 4,
EPSRC-DTP studentships provided by the University of Jun. 2017, Art. no. 4800305.
[21] M. Tian et al., “Magnetization loss characteristics in superconducting
Leicester. M.U.F and M.K. shared first authorship. conductor on round core cables with a copper former,” IEEE Trans. Appl.
Supercond., vol. 31, no. 8, Nov. 2021, Art. no. 4803204.
[22] M. Tian et al., “Analysis on the effect of superconductor layer thickness
REFERENCES on the AC loss of conductor on round core (CORC) cables,” IEEE Trans.
Appl. Supercond., vol. 31, no. 8, Nov. 2021, Art. no. 5901604.
[1] D. Larbalestier, A. Gurevich, D. M. Feldmann, and A. Polyanskii, “High- [23] J. Yang et al., “Analysis of AC transport loss in conductor on round core
Tc superconducting materials for electric power applications,” Nature, cables,” J. Supercond. Novel Magnetism, vol. 35, no. 1, pp. 57–63, 2021.
vol. 414, no. 6861, pp. 368–377, 2001. [24] M. Majoros, M. D. Sumption, E. W. Collings, and D. C. van der Laan,
[2] W. Goldacker et al., “Roebel assembled coated conductors (RACC): Prepa- “Magnetization losses in superconducting YBCO conductor-on-round-
ration, properties and progress,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Supercond., vol. 17, core (CORC) cables,” Supercond. Sci. Technol., vol. 27, no. 12, Nov. 2014,
no. 2, pp. 3398–3401, Jun. 2007. Art. no. 125008.
[3] W. Goldacker, F. Grilli, E. Pardo, A. Kario, S. I. Schlachter, and M. Vo- [25] M. Fareed, M. Kapolka, B. Robert, M. Clegg, and H. Ruiz, “3D modelling
jenciak, “Roebel cables from rebco coated conductors: A one-century-old and validation of the optimal pitch in commercial CORC cables,” IOP
concept for the superconductivity of the future,” Supercond. Sci. Technol., Conf. Series: Mater. Sci. Eng., vol. 757, Nov. 2021. [Online]. Avaialble:
vol. 27, no. 9, 2014, Art. no. 93001. https://arxiv.org/abs/2111.06834
[4] M. Takayasu, L. Chiesa, L. Bromberg, and J. V. Minervini, “HTS twisted [26] K.-J. Bathe, Finite Element Procedures. Ukraine: Prentice Hall, 2006.
stacked-tape cable conductor,” Supercond. Sci. Technol., vol. 25, 2012, [27] B. C. Robert, M. U. Fareed, and H. S. Ruiz, “How to choose the supercon-
Art. no. 014011. ducting material law for the modelling of 2G-HTS coils,” Mater., vol. 12,
[5] M. Takayasu, L. Chiesa, P. D. Noyes, and J. V. Minervini, “Investigation no. 17, p. 2679, 2019.
of HTS twisted stacked-tape cable (TSTC) conductor for high-field, high- [28] A. Badĺa-Majós, C. López, and H. S. Ruiz, “General critical states in type-II
current fusion magnets,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Supercond., vol. 27, no. 4, superconductors,” Phys. Rev. B, vol. 80, Oct. 2009, Art. no. 144509.
Jun. 2017, Art. no. 6900105. [29] H. S. Ruiz, A. Badĺa-Majós, Y. A. Genenko, H. Rauh, and S. V. Yampolskii,
[6] D. C. van der Laan, “YBa2 Cu3 O7−δ coated conductor cabling for low ac- “Superconducting wire subject to synchronous oscillating excitations:
loss and high-field magnet applications,” Supercond. Sci. Technol., vol. 22, Power dissipation, magnetic response, and low-pass filtering,” Appl. Phys.
no. 6, 2009, Art. no. 065013. Lett., vol. 100, no. 11, 2012, Art. no. 112602.
Authorized licensed use limited to: Universidad Nac de Educación a Distancia (UNED). Downloaded on March 22,2023 at 10:07:13 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.