Professional Documents
Culture Documents
a Young
Researchers Club, Khorramabad Branch, Islamic Azad University, Khorramabad, Iran; b Department of
Critical Care Nursing, Faculty of Nursing and Midwifery, Lorestan University of Medical Sciences, Khorramabad,
Iran; c Providence Saint Joseph Medical Center, Burbank, CA, USA; d Department of Biostatistics, School of Health
and Nutrition, Lorestan University of Medical Sciences, Khorramabad, Iran; e Department of Neurology, Lorestan
University of Medical Sciences, Khorramabad, Iran; f Social Determinants of Health Research Center, Lorestan
Values represent mean ± SD, n (%), or median [IQR]. a One-way ANOVA test. b Chi-square test.
essential oil 2%, basil essential oil 4%, basil essential oil 6%, and tacks from the previous visit to the current one. Information was
placebo groups. The subjects were asked to apply the drugs topi- collected and recorded by the research assistant.
cally to the frontal and temporal areas every 8 h for a length of 3
months. Individuals of all groups received acetaminophen pills Sample Size Estimation
325 mg every 12 h as well. The sample size was estimated to be about 30 in each group
A three-part questionnaire was prepared. The first part con- based on a similar study [39] and a table from a book entitled Ap-
tained tree variables such as age, gender, and body mass index plied Linear Statistical Models [40] (r = 4, ∆/σ = 0.84 ≈ 1, σ = 2.39,
(BMI). The second part of the questionnaire consisted of the VAS, ∆ = 2, α = 0.05, β = 0.1). However, considering average attrition of
which measures the pain intensity from a scale of zero to 10. The 20%, 36 individuals for each group and a total of 144 people for the
last part of the questionnaire contained inquiries about the fre- purpose of the study were selected ultimately.
quency of the migraine attacks. The content validity of the ques-
tionnaire was evaluated by ten faculty members at Lorestan Uni- Randomizing Method
versity of Medical Sciences. Sampling was done in a non-probability sampling technique.
Participants were allocated randomly to four groups according to
Plant Material stratification method [41, 42]. Stratification was done based on
Aerial parts of basil (Ocimum basilicum L.; Lamiaceae family) variables such as gender, BMI, baseline pain intensity, and fre-
were purchased from a local market in Khorramabad, western quency of attacks. In each stratum, a permutation blocks method
Iran. The plant sample was identified by an herbalist and a vouch- was used. The blocks were quadruple. Since there are 24 different
er sample. A voucher specimen was kept at Razi Herbal Medicine permutations of the letters A–D, the following method was used
Research Center, Khorramabad, Iran. to select any permutations (ABCD: 0–3, ABDC: 4–7, and DABC:
93–96). Eligible participants were assigned randomly to basil es-
Drug Preparation and Analysis sential oil 2% (n = 36), basil essential oil 4% (n = 36), basil essential
The leaves and stem were separated by hand from one another. oil 6% (n = 36), and placebo (n = 36) groups from March to De-
The samples were dried in the shade then hydro-distilled for 4 h, cember 2017. A biostatistician designed the random allocation
using a Clevenger-type apparatus. The chemical composition of procedure and enrolled participants. Research assistants assigned
the basil essential oil was analyzed using gas chromatography participants to groups.
method. The main components through gas chromatography in-
cluded cineole 3%, gamma-terpinene 1.5%, linalool 1.5%, estragole Blinding Method
93%, and eugenol 1%. The extract appeared liquid, clear, and yel- Different doses of basil essential oil and placebo were placed in
lowish. The essential oil was then prepared in doses of 2, 4, and 6%. dark bottles by a research assistant. Each bottle was coded confiden-
The essential oils and placebo were poured in 30-mL bottles. Basil tially (A, B, C, or D) and drug codes remained with the research as-
essential oil was prepared and analyzed at Abatag pharmaceutical sistant until the end of the analysis. The researchers, the biostatisti-
commercial company, Tehran, Iran. The placebo consisted of cian, and participants were all unaware of the content of the bottles.
identical liquid containing pharmaceutical paraffin. The appear-
ance and odor of the placebo were designed by Abatag Company Data Analysis
to match that of the basil essential oil. In this study, the intention-to-treat approach was used to ana-
lyze the data, while we utilized imputation for the missing data (last
Outcome Measures observation carried forward). To compare the groups in terms of
The subjects were asked to visit the clinic at 2, 4, 8, and 12 weeks underlying and demographic variables, univariate tests like chi-
of the intervention. During the visit, they were asked to find the square, one-way analysis of variance, and Mann-Whitney and
most severe headache attack from the previous visit to the current Fisher’s exact tests were used. A longitudinal data analysis was
visit based on the VAS. They were also asked for the number of at- used to compare changes in the severity and frequency of pain be-
130.238.7.40 - 3/12/2020 4:31:00 PM
tween the four groups over time. This analysis method included Results
marginal model for data modeling and generalized estimating
equations for parameter estimation procedure.
We applied the main effects of the “dose” and “time” factors, as
One hundred forty-four patients were included in this
well as the interaction between dose and time factors in the model. study (Fig. 1). The mean age of participants was 33.6 ± 9.3
Since, the nature of pain was of an ordinal type, a cumulative logit years. Male patients constituted 73% (103 persons) of the
link function was used in the marginal model. As the number of study population. No statistically significant differences
attacks was a count variable, the negative binomial link was recog- were observed between groups in terms of age (p = 0.859),
nized as the best option. Likewise, an exchangeable covariance ma-
trix structure was employed to account for the intra-individual
gender (p = 0.923), BMI (p = 0.985), baseline pain inten-
correlation of the observations. SPSS version 22 was deployed for sity (p = 0.814), and baseline frequency of attacks (p =
data analysis. p values less than 0.05 were considered as statisti- 0.904) (Table 1). Figures 2 and 3 show the intensity of
cally significant. pain as well as the frequency of migraine attacks in the
130.238.7.40 - 3/12/2020 4:31:00 PM
Table 3. Effects of dose and time factor on frequency of migraine attacks using marginal model
four groups at various times. The results of the marginal basil dose and the effect of time agent on the pain inten-
model indicate that the interaction between the dose and sity and frequency of attacks was significant, it has been
time factors was significant on both pain intensity (p < certainly not possible to talk about the superiority of a
0.001) and frequency of attacks (p < 0.001). basil dose compared to other doses. Therefore, according
Based on significance of interaction term in the afore- to the results, over time and higher doses of basil essential
mentioned model, the effect of dosage on pain intensity oil would reduce both the severity and frequency of mi-
varied over time. In other words, the odds ratio (OR) of graine attacks. In vivo studies have also shown that basil
higher pain intensity in the intervention groups compared essential oil may inhibit pain due to migraine by reducing
to the placebo group depended on time and followed a the level of amino acids that interfere with pain [28, 43].
subsequent formula where t is the time of measurement of It has been observed that basil plant may relieve pain
pain intensity per week, which can take values of 0, 2, 4, 8, through interaction with the opioid system in the brain
or 12. For example, in the fourth week (t = 4), the OR of [44]. During the course of the trial, when we increased the
pain intensity was lower by 87% in the basil 4% group dosage, the severity and frequency of pain both decreased.
compared to the placebo group (OR = 0.13) and in the Likewise, as time went on, a lower percentage of patients
eighth week (t = 8), the OR of pain intensity was lower by were suffering from pain. As such, none of the partici-
90% in the basil 2% group compared to the placebo group pants in the basil essential oil 6% group expressed severe
(OR = 0.10) (Table 2). Likewise, the rate ratio (RR) of at- pain by the 12th week.
tacks in the intervention groups compared to the placebo In traditional Iranian medicine, basil is used as a seda-
group was a function of time. Put differently, the RR of tive and analgesic drug [28]. Previous studies on the im-
attacks in the intervention groups compared to the pla- pact of other herbal medication on controlling migraine
cebo group depended on time and followed a subsequent headaches have brought up similar results [10, 23]. An in
formula. For example, in the second week (t = 2), the RR vivo study by Abdolmaleki et al. [45] shows that the an-
of occurring migraine attacks was lower by 34% in the ba- algesic and anti-inflammatory effects of peppermint de-
sil 6% group compared to the placebo group (RR = 0.66) pend on dosage [41], and since basil has the same family
and in the twelfth week (t = 12), the RR of occurring mi- as peppermint, this would apply to basil as well. Likewise,
graine attacks was lower by 80% in the basil 4% group the impact of rose on the intensity of pain was studied
compared to the placebo group (RR = 0.2) (Table 3). among migraine patients, which indicated that the sever-
ity of pain decreases as time goes on [9]. Similarly, when
lavender extract is taken orally, it can gradually reduce the
Discussion pain and frequency of migraine attacks by the passage of
time and higher doses [10].
This clinical trial was conducted to investigate the ef- The analgesic effect of basil has been attributed to its
fect of basil essential oil on reducing the frequency and compounds. Cineole, geraniol, flavonoids, and estragole
severity of pain in migraine patients. Since the effect of have anti-inflammatory properties [45–49]. Extract of
130.238.7.40 - 3/12/2020 4:31:00 PM