Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A policy Brief prepared for the Netherlands Institute For Multiparty Democracy
(NIMD)
By
Prosper Mubangizi, M.A Public Policy
Policy and Advocacy Specialist
Lead Consultant
prospermatwooki@gmail.com
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The 2005 referendum marked the return of political party or multiparty
dispensation in Uganda after political parties had been banned in Uganda and
confined to Kampala by the Museveni led government following the 1986
takeover of government. Currently, more than 29 political parties in Uganda
exist to provide alternative policy direction to the government and nation at
large.
The demographic composition of Uganda where youth and women form the
majority signals the need for political parties not only to draft manifestos and
policy statements into their agenda but to also ensure that women and youth
take centre stage in the formation, running and management of these political
organisations.
In many countries, the political elite is mainly conceived of rather wealthy and
educated middle-aged to senior men of the dominant ethnicity and national
parliaments are arenas that fit this description. This is a scenario that special
interest group representation in Uganda’s parliament sought to provide a
solution to.
The enactment of the 1993 National Youth Council Act as well as the Women’s
Council Act and the subsequent affirmative action policies was seen as a
landmark milestone in ensuring that traditionally disadvantaged groups like
women and youth were brought to and provided a seat at the decision making
table. However, the women structures have been victims of state capture.
Equally, the youth structures, though active, have fallen victim to state capture
and have by extension become a structure of the ruling National Resistance
Movement. This denies the youth and women a chance to be heard and to
participate in the decision making processes of this country. The result is far
fetched policies and legislation that does not respond to the needs of the
people.
The central argument of this policy brief is that, albeit the existence of good
institutional and organizational structures for effective participation of women
and youth, women and youth in Uganda lack the critical resources (economic
1
Africa Youth Development Link and Uganda Youth Network (2014). Audit into Youth Representation.
and civic) to draw on in order to participate meaningfully in political processes.
This has subsequently made them vulnerable to political manipulation by
political elites in the country.
2.0 METHODOLOGY
The Consultant used desk review of policies and government programs, studies
and policy reviews with the intention of probing the factors affecting the
effective and meaningful participation and representation of women and youth
in Uganda’s political space, with particular bias on the legislature and local
councils. The desk review was an investigation into the link between the law
and the structural, religious and cultural impediments to the political
participation and representation of women and youth in Uganda’s political
space.
The policy brief and its recommendations are based on the civic voluntarism
model which views political participation as being largely shaped by citizens’
involvement in non-political institutions such as work, voluntary and religious
organizations. The policy brief argues that certain resources especially time,
money and civic skills are necessary for political participation. Most
fundamental is the acquisition of civic skills, which, according to the theory,
takes place in the non- political institutions outlined above.
What this implies is that for any population group to effectively influence
political processes, they must have economic resources but also civic skills to
enable them engage with the dominant political actors. These civic skills which
among others include skills in; chairing meetings, organizing peaceful
demonstrations, advocacy, lobbying, networking to mention but a few, are
gained through involvement in nonpolitical establishments then replicated
within political organizations for meaningful engagement.
At the Local Government level, there were over 7470 elective positions for
councilors. Male Youth councilors make up a meagre 3%, same with female
Youth Councillors at 3%. Women councilors on the otherhand, make up at
least 30% as shown in the pie chart below
From the above statistics, it is clear that youth and women are failing to break
into the “direct” seat category.
29-33 31 5.9
34-38 65 12.3
49-53 81 15.3
54-58 54 10.2
59-63 29 5.5
64-68 12 2.3
69-73 11 2.1
74-78 9 1.7
79-83 01 0.2
Uganda is a young country 49% of its population is below the age of 14; about
56% below 18 years.3 The youth population (18-30 years) currently constitutes
2
Parliament Watch Uganda (2021). Demographic Analysis Of the 11th Parliament
3
E Kwesiga, R Wamajji, P Mubangizi & G Mwesigye (2019). The State of the Youth Report:
Assessing Government Investment In Young People. Action Aid, Restless Development,
Westminster Foundation for Democracy, Centre For Policy Analysis and Uganda Parliamentary
a significant proportion of the total population (22.5%). Despite its
predominantly young population, Uganda is experiencing the aspect of ‘grey’
cabinets, Parliaments and local councils. This is because despite the
amendment of the Constitution to remove age restrictions on access to political
office as demanded for by the 2016-2021 National Youth Manifesto, the
required structural, legislative and policy actions have not been undertaken to
remove barriers to youth participation in political and governance processes.
Despite the fact that 8.8 million of the estimated 19 million Ugandans eligible
to vote and be voted for in national elections are young people below 35 years,
only 7.3% of Uganda’s Members of Parliament are youth. The 7.3% legislative
composition can be attributed to Article 78 of the 1995 Constitution that
introduced Special Interest Representation for historically marginalized groups
like youth, women, people with disabilities among others. This constitutional
provision ensures that 5 members of Parliament are youth.
3.1.1 Constraints
Youth in civil society and non political institutions like business, culture,
sports and arts and the academia are not well mobilized. This leaves youth
structures weak and without the technical input and participation of the wider
youth demographic.
3.1.2 Recommendations
The 1848 Seneca Falls Convention and its resultant policy and legal
instruments on women’s rights and gender equality heralded an increase in the
participation and representation of women in politics, leadership and
governance. There was deliberate concerted efforts undertaken by both the
international community and national political players to increase the
participation of women in the decision making spaces, mainly through a
plethora of legal and policy instruments, declarations and protocols such as
the Convention on the Elimination of all forms of Discrimination Against
Women (CEDAW), African Charter on Human and People’s Rights, The African
Charter on Democracy, Elections and Governance (ACDEG), The New
Partnership for African Democracy (NEPAD) Declaration to which the Republic
of Uganda is signatory.
The biggest success rate of women in governance has arguably been achieved
in Africa, with Rwanda taking the lead with 64% of women representation in
the legislature.5 Africa also currently has three nations that have achieved a
50% gender parity in cabinet appointments; Ethiopia 6, Rwanda7 and most
recently South Africa.8 According to IPU(2015), four African countries appear in
the top ten countries with the highest numbers of females in national
parliaments.9 Women in Sub-Saharan Africa on average occupy 20.4 percent of
single or lower house seats, an increase from 18.3 percent in 2010 and from
12.4 percent at the beginning of the millennium.10
4
Inter Parliamentary Union. Women in National Parliaments. https://www. ipu.org
5
UN Women. Revisiting Rwanda Five Years after Record Breaking Parliamentary Elections (2018).
6
https://qz.com/africa/1426110/ethiopias-new-cabinet-is-50-women/
7
See Barnes and Burchard(2013)
8
Adebayo, AJ Davie and M Tawfeeq( May 30 th 2019). ‘South Africa Makes history as women make up half of
government for the first time’ CNN.
9
These countries include Rwanda, Namibia and South Africa.
10
See Abduheraim. Study on discrimination against women in law and in practice in political and public life,
including during times of political transitions.
The affirmative action policy enshrined in the Constitution for women’s
representation at parliamentary and local council levels has brought more
women into mainstream politics and key government positions. At the global
level, Uganda’s position in terms of women’s representation in parliament is at
33 out of 190 countries, while within the African continent Uganda is at 9 th
position out of 54 countries. Apart from women’s participation in the electoral
process as candidates, the laws of Uganda enshrine women’s rights to
participate in the electoral process as party agents, election administrators and
election observers.
1989 39 39 2 9 50 230 18 82
1994 39 39 8 3 50 236 17 83
1996 39 39 8 4 51 276 19 81
2001 56 56 3 6 75 304 24 76
2006 79 79 14 1 100 319 31 69
2011 112 112 11 8 131 375 35 65
2016 112 112 18 9 139 428 33 67
Source: Author’s calculations based on various reports
3.2.1 Constraints
Despite the progress made in women’s participation in electoral processes in
Uganda, challenges of discrimination and marginalization remain. Notably,
women largely continue to reside in the margins of decision-making processes
and tend to confront specific hurdles making the election ground unlevelled for
women and men. For women, there are critical social, cultural, economic and
political factors that impact their election journey uniquely hence creating
persistent deficits. Even in office, they have to juggle with a lot of issues such
as family, child upbringing on top of answering to the requirements and
aspirations of the electorate.
Beyond the affirmative seats, women have failed to break through on “open”
seats that require them to compete with the men. This is better illustrated in
the table below;
Contestants for Open Seats by Sex in 2016
Post Number of Number of Number of % of females % of males
Candidates Female Male
contestants candidates
President 8 1 7 12.5 87.5
Member of 1,314 90 1,224 6.8 93.2
Parliament
District LC 376 9 367 2.4 97.6
V/ City
Mayor
Total 1,698 100 1,598 5.9 94.1
Though there has been an increment in numbers of female legislators over the
years, the increase has not been in sync with the demographic composition of
the country. It is a negligible increase. For example, female legislators
increased from 159 in the 10th parliament (2016-2021) to 183 in the 11th
Parliament; a 13% increment which is highly negligible given the rise in
constituencies and administrative units ahead of the 2020-21 General
Elections.
The electoral process is also designed to leave out women. This is because of
the following reasons i) the high cost of politics means that many women are
left out as they cant afford as an average Member of Parliament aspirant needs
at least UGX 500,000,000 to contest for elections and ii) the elections are too
militarized characterized by violence which tends to push women out of
politics.
3.2.2 Recommendations
Political Parties should i) apply affirmative action where women that express
interest in standing for elective positions do not have to pay nomination fees
and ii) develop strong women leaders’ academies where women in leadership
are trained and mentored.
The Electoral Commission (EC) should amplify its oversight mandate to
encourage political parties to promote gender equality in their structures and
activities.
Political Parties should remove requirements for nomination fees for women
and make party primaries as cheap as possible. A 2020 study by NIMD and
WFD found that the average amount of money spent by a candidate during the
2016 primary and general elections was estimated by the study to be 465
million Ugandan shillings (UGX) or 136,084 USD for parliamentary candidates,
and UGX 237.5 million (USD 69,505) for Local Council V (LCV) chairpersons.
At parliamentary level, the study found that candidates from the mainstream
constituencies spent UGX 458.2 million while female counterparts running for
affirmative action district women’s seats spent UGX 496.4 million over both
primary and general elections.
“For example, eastern region has about 34 districts. The Youth MP for the
northern region covers about 28 districts and the national Youth MP covers 112
districts. Under such geographical scope of coverage, they [Youth MPs] cannot
adequately consult and give feedback to the youth in the regions of
representation”11
11
See Performance Audit into Youth Members of Parliament by Uganda Youth Network and African
Youth Development Link.
It should be argued that such large constituencies have affected the
effectiveness of Youth MPs as it hampers their capacity to consult, engage and
give feedback to their constituents. This has culminated into a scenario where
“the participatory quality of the process leading to laws and rules as ensured
by the Youth MPs is still very low” 12 yet the decisions made and actions carried
out by the youth MPs have a binding effect on the community of the youth in
Uganda.
Limited space for independence as the youth MPs in most spaces are
coopted into the state superstructure13. This is worsened by the fusion of the
state and the legislature which has not only affected the performance of Youth
MPs but the entire national legislature which to many has morphed into a
stooge of the ruling government with a strong caucusing system that binds
MPs to a predetermined position. This has downgraded the achievement of
governance accountability which based on the accountability principle as a
form of popular democracy where the government is held accountable to the
citizens through the legislature. As ultimate masters, the citizens remain the
final judge of the performance of the government which principle state co-
option of the existing arms of government has eroded.
The voting process is not very representative. J.S. Mill argued that through
elections, people “possess this ultimate power in all its completeness and thus
are taken as the masters of all the operations”. It should be noted that the
ultimate power lies with the youth, thus the youth are considered to be
sovereign; this popular power is exercised by the selected youth MPs on behalf
of the community of youth in Uganda and the youth MPs are mandated by the
youth through periodical elections, in order to renew popular consent, based
on the performance. However, these three sacrosanct principles have been
13
P Mubangizi and C Okidi (2019). Consolidation or Reversal: Making Sense of Uganda’s Fluctuating
Democracy and Governance Landscape. Center For Policy Analysis and National Endowment for
Democracy.
rendered elitist and unrealistic by use of an electoral college to vote in the
Youth MPs which by implication makes them more of delegates than
representatives. The Electoral College creates a kind of legislative capture in
which the Youth MPs are more answerable to the National Youth Council
Structures that voted them than the 8.8 million Young people of Uganda. it
should be noted that the National Youth Council which votes in Youth MPs is
composed of only 0.003% youth which renders the principle of popular
democracy null and void14, that is to say, only 336 youth get to vote the 5
Youth Members of Parliament.
The basic and ideal assumption is that as the Youth MPs perform their role as
people’s representatives, it is pertinent that they are guided by inter alia, “the
constituency opinions, and rational judgment, consideration of the national
interest and personal convictions or conscience”. However, as any deficiency of
representative democracy, this assumption remains only paper and
inapplicable in reality. This is an ideological deficiency that is clearly
articulated in Col. Muammar Gadaffi’s 15 book “The Green Book” in which he
argues that because, representative democracy is by leaders who have
delegated authority, it is almost next to impossible for leaders to fully reflect
the aspirations, concerns and interests of the led.
14
CCEDU 2018
15
Col. Muammar Gadaffi. The Green Book
That the law be amended to include specific duties and roles of youth
Members of Parliament. This is because giving youth MPs the same roles
as directly elected MPs has crowded out their work, created ambiguities
with no direction towards execution and implementation apart from
legislation, appropriation, oversight and representation which can be
done by the other directly elected MPs. Clearly articulating the mandate
of Youth MPs will go a long way in helping the public appreciate their
contribution in the house.
16
Kenneth Nkumiro (2016). Youth MPs: It is time to work for youth
mandate into a quasi non departmental but government agency that can
act as Civil Society but established with government; can draw funding
from donors and government and have its resolution very binding.
Development Partners and Civil Society Organizations who support the work of
political parties should demand regular evaluation of parties on gender equality
and youth inclusion and advocate for women and youth empowerment action
plans to address gaps.
Civil Society Organizations like NIMD should set up leadership and training
camps for young and female leaders. This is to ensure their grooming and
coaching to rise up into the political sphere.
6.0 CONCLUSION
Using Verbe et al’s model of Political Volunteerism, we conclude that policies
and programs that place emphasis on the involvement of women and youth in
non-political institutions, particularly work, to enhance their capacity to
effectively participate in political processes are needed. These would include a
National Graduate Scheme and Volunteer Program. Drawing from this
analysis, here are some key points to conclude with on this discussion:
It is our earnest belief that women and youth need to play a more critical role
as Uganda seeks to grow her multiparty political system. This can be achieved
through i) mass civic sensitization drives aimed at making the women and
youth aware of the role they can play and avenues through which they can rise
in the political rank and file, ii) structured dialogue processes with political
party actors to realize the need to make women and youth friendly party
structures that can attract the young people to be part and iii) deliberate efforts
to ensure the CSOs most especially youth and women led CSOs take a crucial
role in bringing women and youth to the centre of political party activities.
REFERENCES