Professional Documents
Culture Documents
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: A new environmentally friendly sound absorbing material designed for vehicle noise absorption and
Received 10 January 2020 insulation applications is presented and its acoustic properties are studied in this paper. First the general
Accepted 23 April 2020 physical properties of the relatively light and soft material are introduced. Scanning electronic micro-
Available online xxxx
scope (SEM) imaging results are provided to expose the internal structure of the material with fibrous
nature, composed of reticulated natural leather collagen based foam.
Keywords: The principal part of the paper presents a complete acoustic study of the novel material and describes
acoustic material
adequate methods to experimentally determine the main acoustic properties of this type of materials.
insulation
ecofriendly
Measurement procedures are followed by analysis of characteristics and results obtained from the exper-
vehicle NVH iments.
absorption coefficient Finally the acoustic effect of the material is validated by the applicational tests, fitted inside motorcycle
sound transmission helmets.
The results of the acoustic study demonstrate the appropriateness of the material for a variety of vehi-
cle NVH implementations were noise absorption and transmission insulation are required.
Ó 2020 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the 2nd International Con-
ference on Advances in Mechanical Engineering and Nanotechnology.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matpr.2020.04.632
2214-7853/Ó 2020 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the 2nd International Conference on Advances in Mechanical Engineering and Nanotechnology.
Please cite this article as: H. Rämmal and J. Lavrentjev, Acoustic study of novel eco-friendly material for vehicle NVH applications, Materials Today: Pro-
ceedings, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matpr.2020.04.632
2 H. Rämmal, J. Lavrentjev / Materials Today: Proceedings xxx (xxxx) xxx
rate <4 inch/min [3]. The material is stable in a wide temperature reverberation rooms with the volume greater than 150 m3, prefer-
range of -70...+120°C and is is a heat insulator: ably 200 m3 and more. The US standard ASTM C432 requires smaller
thermal conductivity – 35-40 mW/Km minimum room volume (125 m3) but also recommends the volume
heat capacity – 3000 J/kgK 200 m3 and more [10], with the minimum sample size of 5.57 m2.
thermal diffusivity – 210-7 m2/s There has been a certain interest in the development of smaller
reverberation chambers for sound absorption measurements. A
1.2. Characterization methods for acoustic materials smaller room enables to use smaller specimens, thus allowing the
reduction of the manufacturing costs of new material prototypes.
In general two important acoustic properties of the absorbing The test procedure described in SAE standard J2883 201504 [11]
materials are: the noise absorption inside the material layer and has been developed for measurements in rooms with the volume
the noise reduction when it transmits through the material layer. between 6m3 and 25m3 and the frequency range of interest between
Different methods exist to experimentally determine these acous- 250 Hz and 8000 Hz. A few small test chamber methods have been
tic properties of acoustic materials. The most commonly used developed [12,13], the most famous one being probably the Alpha
methods are based on acoustic one-ports [4], experimentally stud- Cabin widespread in the automotive industry [14]. It has a standard
ied by the impedance tube technique or alternatively on the meth- volume of 6.5 m3 and the frequency range 400 to 10000 Hz with the
ods requiring reverberation rooms, described below. specimen size of 1.2 m2. It is however known the overestimation of
Following the classical wave decomposition techniques [4–6] the absorption coefficient in Alpha Cabin and other small reverber-
developed for acoustic characterization of one-port elements, the ant rooms, particularly in the low and middle frequency range com-
usual method to determine the absorption coefficient for materials, pared to large reverberation rooms [15].
is an impedance tube method described in details in ISO 10534- The transmission loss (TL), as one of the most common param-
2:1998 [7]. The main advantage of the method is the requirement eters for acoustic characterization of flow duct elements [16–19] is
for only small size test specimens. The second option is to perform usually expressed as the sound reduction index (Rw) of the mate-
measurements in the reverberant room [8]. The main difference of rial. Hereby also the impedance tube can be utilized, but it is how-
the methods is that in the impedance tube only direct incident field ever more common to apply the reverberation room method
is considered while in the second case the absorption coefficient is following ISO 10140-2:2010 [20]. By using the transmission loss
determined in random incident sound field conditions. The most determination method method for induct samples mentioned
precise method including the lower frequency region is following above, test specimens with relatively small area (usually the
ISO 354:2003 [8]. The method is usable in the frequency range from cross-section of test pipes) can be used for the measurements,
100 to 5000 Hz. Another standard, which integrates ISO 354:2003 is although the accuracy of the results may decrease at lower fre-
ISO 17497-1:2004 [9] aimed for determination of the sound- quencies in comparison to [20] followed in this study and
scattering properties of surfaces. Both standards assume a large described in section 2.2.
Figs. 1-4. Images of the new absorbing material consisting of reticulated natural leather foam. 10mm insulation layer ca 4X magnified (a), internal structure 200X magnified
(b), internal structure 1000X magnified (c), internal structure 10000X magnified (d).
Please cite this article as: H. Rämmal and J. Lavrentjev, Acoustic study of novel eco-friendly material for vehicle NVH applications, Materials Today: Pro-
ceedings, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matpr.2020.04.632
H. Rämmal, J. Lavrentjev / Materials Today: Proceedings xxx (xxxx) xxx 3
where:
c1 and c2 are the propagation speeds of sound in the air (m/s) for
empty and filled room conditions,
m1 and m2 are the acoustic power attenuation coefficients cal-
culated according to ISO 9613-1 using the atmospheric conditions
of the empty and filled room correspondingly.
Thereafter the sound absorption coefficient is obtained by
dividing the equivalent sound absorption area by the absorbing
area S of the test specimen fitted inside the room:
Figs. 6-8. An Impedance tube testrig implemented to determine the absorption AT
coefficient of the porous material samples fitted onto the rigidly closed test sample
aS ¼
S
holder at the tube termination (images on the right side).
Please cite this article as: H. Rämmal and J. Lavrentjev, Acoustic study of novel eco-friendly material for vehicle NVH applications, Materials Today: Pro-
ceedings, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matpr.2020.04.632
4 H. Rämmal, J. Lavrentjev / Materials Today: Proceedings xxx (xxxx) xxx
Fig. 12. The porous material layer sample (S1) tested in between the source room
(depicted here) and the receiver room during the sound transmission index
determination experiments using omnidirectional source (LS), tripod mounted 1/2”
microphone (M) and sound field diffusers (R).
2.2. Determination of sound transmission index 2.3. Application tests with motorcycle helmets
A rectangular reverberation room in TalTech Acoutec Lab is con- In order to test the efficiency of the material in vehicle NVH
structed of mansonry concrete block walls (see photo 9), with the application, exposed to relatively high levels of propulsion system
specific mass of walls greater than 400 kg/m2 (class: heavy). The and aerodynamic noise, the material layers were fitted inside a
dimensions of the room are: 2.8 x 4.0 x 5.9 m and the total area typical modular type motorcycle helmet (see Figs. 15-18). During
of the walls: 55.4 m2, with the floor area: 23.6 m2 and the cealing road tests based experiments where a test motorcycle (see
area: 23.6 m2. Fig. 20) was driven at two determined highway speeds (90km/h
The standard reverberation room method according to ISO and 110km/h) on straight highway test section (see Fig. 21) closed
10140:2010 was followed using the same room acoustics measure- for public transport, the sound pressure level inside the helmet
ments equipment described in section 2.1, with additional tripod was measured by using 1⁄2” condenser microphone inserted inside
mounted 1/2” condenser microphone Brüel & Kjær 4189. In the the helmet and pointed at the location of the riders left ear (see
source room (See Fig. 9 and 12), pink noise was again emitted by Fig. 19). The equivalent noise level was recorded by sound level
Fig. 10-11. Test facility at TalTech Acoustics Lab designed for the determination of acoustic properties for noise absorption and insulation materials, including the
omnidirectional source (LS), tripod mounted microphone (M) and the material sample layer (S) fixed on the ground by universal tape. The photos exhibit the layout of the
novel acoustic material fixed on the floor during absorption coefficient determination experiments.
Please cite this article as: H. Rämmal and J. Lavrentjev, Acoustic study of novel eco-friendly material for vehicle NVH applications, Materials Today: Pro-
ceedings, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matpr.2020.04.632
H. Rämmal, J. Lavrentjev / Materials Today: Proceedings xxx (xxxx) xxx 5
Figs. 13-14. The porous material layer fixed between the reverberation rooms during the sound transmission index experiments. A view to the installed material from the
source room side, (left) and from the receiver room side (right), exhibiting the metal wire support frame and the wooden insert structure in the standard opening.
Figs. 15-18. The modular type of helmet (2 images on the left) used for the experiments and the region of the helmet around the location of rider´s ear exhibited without (left
image) and with (right image) the acoustic material installed.
Figs. 19-21. Acoustic condenser microphone installed inside rider’s helmet and pointed onto the opening of the left ear (left). A classical sport bike (Honda CBR1000F, middle
image) was driven by 1,84m tall rider wearing test helmet with and without the absorbing material inserts in road tests on straight highway section closed for public
transport (right).
meter carried by the rider in the backpack. The measurement per- (VBOX Sport). 3 measurements were performed for both riding
iod during each test riding cycle was chosen 20 seconds. speeds and averaged results were thereafter calculated.
The equipment used for the in-helmet sound pressure level
experiments consisted of: sound level meter Brüel & Kjær 2270, 3. Results
1⁄2” microphone Brüel & Kjær 4189, acoustic calibrator Brüel &
Kjær 4231 and additionally, a purpose-built data acquisition sys- The absorption coefficient experimentally determined for the
tem for acoustic data processing. The riding speed was recorded by new material layer by the impedance tube method is presented
motorcycle mounted GPS based vehicle dynamics analysis system in Fig. 22. According to ISO 10534-2:1998 the weighted sound
Please cite this article as: H. Rämmal and J. Lavrentjev, Acoustic study of novel eco-friendly material for vehicle NVH applications, Materials Today: Pro-
ceedings, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matpr.2020.04.632
6 H. Rämmal, J. Lavrentjev / Materials Today: Proceedings xxx (xxxx) xxx
Fig. 22. An absorption coefficient of the material (blue solid line) experimentally
determined by the standard impedance tube method and compared to the
reference curve (red dashed line) according to the standard.
Fig. 24. Sound transmission through the material experimentally determined by
the standardized 2-chamber method for the studied layer with 4% material density
(blue solid line) and for a comparison layer with 2% material density (red dashed
absorption coefficient of the material was found to be 0.20(H),
line).
indicating a modest absorption class E. The absorption coefficient
result obtained from the reverberation room experiments is pre-
sented in Fig. 23. A remarkably good correlation between the
results obtained by following the two different measurement tech-
niques can be observed. Both absorption coefficient curves
approach a respectable value of 0,70 at ca 2000Hz, respectable
for such a relatively thin material layer.
The sound transmission index characteristics experimentally
determined for the acoustic material layers composed of 2% and
4% base material per volume are presented in Fig. 24. The transmis-
sion index results exhibit an adequate noise insulation capability,
reaching up to ca 12dB’s, considering the type of relatively thin
and highly porous low-density material layer tested (Fig 25 and
Fig 26).
Expectedly, the material with higher density (4%) and lower Fig. 25. A-weighted sound pressure level measured inside the motorcycle helmet at
porosity provides ca 2dB higher noise insulation across almost riding speed 90km/h: with (red dashed line) and without the material inserts (blue
solid line).
the entire frequency range studied. Despite of a few peaks at
around 125Hz and 200Hz the material offers a relatively frequency
independent sound transmission index often preferable for broad-
band noise (e.g. vehicle tire – road noise and aerodynamically gen- inside the modular helmet, in the most critical region of the riders
erated noise) control applications. ears. Fig. 27 evidently shows the noise cancellation effect of the
The sound pressure level results, obtained from the in-helmet material inserts inside the helmet, almost similarly in in both the
noise measurements clearly indicate the new material’s capability riding speeds, offering from notable few dB’s at low frequencies
to suppress the dominantly aerodynamically induced noise level to outstanding 20dB’s in the high frequency region.
Fig. 23. Absorption coefficient of the material experimentally determined in the reverberation room and presented in the 1/3 octave centre frequencies according to the
standard.
Please cite this article as: H. Rämmal and J. Lavrentjev, Acoustic study of novel eco-friendly material for vehicle NVH applications, Materials Today: Pro-
ceedings, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matpr.2020.04.632
H. Rämmal, J. Lavrentjev / Materials Today: Proceedings xxx (xxxx) xxx 7
Acknowledgements
References
[1] http://www.eficuir.com/.
[2] BS EN ISO 17235:2015, Leather. Physical and mechanical tests. Determination
of softness.
[3] Flammability of interior materials, FMVSS No. 302.
[4] H. Rämmal, M. Åbom, Characterization of Air Terminal Device Noise Using
Acoustic One-Port Source Models, Journal of Sound and Vibration 300 (2007)
727–743.
[5] H. Tiikoja, J. Lavrentjev, H. Rämmal, M. Åbom, Experimental Investigations of
Sound Reflection from Hot and Subsonic Flow Duct Termination, Journal of
Sound and Vibration 333 (3) (2014) 788–800.
[6] F. Auriemma, H. Tiikoja, On the acoustic impedance of a fibreless sound
absorptive element, SAE International Journal of Engines, 8 (5): 2268-2275,
doi:10.4271/2015-24-2462.
[7] ISO 10534-2:1998, Acoustics. Determination of sound absorption coefficient
Fig. 27. Silencing effect of the material fitted inside the motorcycle helmet at riding and impedance in impedance tubes; Part 2: Transfer-function method.
speed: 90km/h (red solid line) and 110km/h (green dashed line). [8] ISO 354:2003, Acoustics - Measurement of sound absorption in a reverberation
room.
[9] ISO 17497-1:2004, Acoustics - Sound-scattering properties of surfaces - Part 1:
Measurement of the random-incidence scattering coefficient in a
Table 1 reverberation room.
Sound pressure level measured inside the helmet with and without the absorption [10] ASTM C423 – 17, Standard Test Method for Sound Absorption and Sound
material inserts at 90km/h and 110km/h. Absorption Coefficients by the Reverberation Room Method.
[11] SAE standard J2883 201504, Laboratory Measurement of Random Incidence
Speed, km/h SPL, withour insulation, dBA SPL, with insulation (S1), dBA Sound Absorption Tests Using a Small Reverberation Room.
90 98 93 [12] A. Rasa, Development of a small-scale reverberation room, Proceedings of
110 103 99 ACOUSTICS 2016, 9–11, Brisbane, Australia, 2016.
[13] R. Rey, J. Alba, L. Bertó, A. Gregori, Small-sized reverberation chamber for the
measurement of sound absorption, Materiales de Construcción, Vol. 67, issue
328, 2017.
[14] D. Arnaud Rondeau, JF. Bossart, R. Deshayes, G. Lhuillier, F. Gagliardini, et. al.,
Vehicle Acoustic Synthesis Method 2nd Generation: an effective hybrid
The respectable noise reduction by using the new material simulation tool to implement acoustic lightweight strategies, 2005.
inserts in helmet is also confirmed by the A-weighted sound pres- [15] R. Veen, J. Saha, et al., Feasibility of a Standardized Test Procedure for Random
sure level results compared in Table 1. Incidence Sound Absorption Tests Using a Small Size Reverberation Room, SAE
Paper (2003–01-1572,) 2003.
[16] H. Rämmal, H. Tiikoja, M. Åbom, H. Bodén, Experimental Facility for the
Complete Determination of Sound Transmission in Turbochargers, Society of
4. Conclusions Automotive Engineers, (SAE) Technical Paper Series, Paper (2010–01-1424,
2010.).
[17] J. Lavrentjev, H. Rämmal, H. Tiikoja, The Passive Acoustic Effect of Automotive
Sound absorption and sound insulation properties of a new eco- Catalytic Converters, SAE Technical Paper (2011–24-0219, 2011.).
friendly acoustic material are experimentally determined in this [18] J. Lavrentjev, H. Rämmal, On experimental techniques to determine acoustic
paper providing the complete data for the acoustic characteriza- performance of small exhaust silencers, SAE Technical Paper Series, 16, 2009.
[19] R. Kabral, H. Rämmal, J. Lavrentjev, Acoustic Studies of Micro-Perforates for
tion of this material. Small Engine Silencers, SAE Technical Paper 2012-32-0107, 2012.
The absorption coefficient was measured in comparison of two [20] ISO10140-2:2010, Acoustics, Laboratory measurement of sound insulation of
standard methods: the impedance tube method and the reverber- building elements; Part 2: Measurement of airborne sound insulation.
[21] F. Auriemma, H. Rämmal, J. Lavrentjev, Micro-Grooved Elements - A Novel
ation room method and the results exhibit a good correllation and
Solution for Noise Control, SAE Int. J. Mater. Manuf. 6 (3) (2013) 599–610.
the material’s ability to offer adequate noise absorption. By per- [22] A. Aruniit, J. Kers, D. Goljandin, M. Saarna, K. Tall, J. Majak, H. Herranen,
forming a standard transmission index determination, the mate- Particulate Filled Composite Plastic Materials from Recycled Glass Fibre
Reinforced Plastics, Materials Science (Medžiagotyra) 17 (3) (2011) 276–281.
rial’s suitability for noise insulation applications was proven.
[23] K. Karjust, M. Pohlak, J. Majak, Adhesion process optimization in reinforced
It has also been demonstrated that an outstanding noise level composites, Proceedings of the 8th International Conference of DAAAM Baltic
reduction can be achieved inside motorcycle helmet in a wide Industrial Engineering, 19-21 April 2012, Tallinn, Estonia, 633638, 2012.
Please cite this article as: H. Rämmal and J. Lavrentjev, Acoustic study of novel eco-friendly material for vehicle NVH applications, Materials Today: Pro-
ceedings, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matpr.2020.04.632