Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Michael Hodges
To cite this article: Michael Hodges (2015) An Innovative Strategy for Teaching Health-Related
Fitness Knowledge in Elementary Physical Education Classes, Strategies, 28:4, 19-25, DOI:
10.1080/08924562.2015.1044145
Download by: [New York University] Date: 15 March 2016, At: 09:16
AN INNOVATIVE STRATEGY FOR TEACHING
Health-Related Fitness Knowledge
in Elementary Physical Education Classes
By Michael Hodges
A
ccording to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (2008),
the majority of adolescents (81.8%) do not engage in the recommended 60 minutes of
physical activity each day. As a result, the United States saw obesity rates almost triple
from 1980 to 2011, from 7% to approximately 18% (Ogden, Carroll, Curtin, Lamb, & Flegal,
Downloaded by [New York University] at 09:16 15 March 2016
2010). Due to inactivity, poor nutritional choices and other unhealthy factors, public health
organizations and health initiatives (e.g., Let’s Move) have been developed and are calling for
efficient and cost-effective methods to increase children’s healthy and active behaviors. Accord-
ing to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2011), public schools have been identi-
fied as ideal settings in which to promote healthy lifestyles, with the schools’ physical education
programs and physical education teachers being main catalysts to fighting childhood inactivity.
Volume 28 • July/August 19
ity (SHAPE America, 2014). However, many physical edu-
SCAVENGER HUNT MAP A cation teachers continue to face difficult teaching conditions
(e.g., small teaching spaces, large class sizes, minimal prepara-
Clue
#1-‐
To
lift
a
weight
many
times
you
need…muscular
ENDURANCE! tion time, very little equipment, etc.) that make it more chal-
lenging for teachers to reach this goal. More specifically, stu-
Clue
#2-‐
You
just
passed
all
5
components
of
a
health-‐related
fitness
dents’ health-related fitness knowledge (HRFK) and HRFK
test;
you
should
now….
set
new
goals
to
IMPROVE
your
fitness
level!!
instruction have been negatively affected, largely due to time
conflicts (Hodges, Kulinna, van der Mars, Lee, & Kwon, in re-
Clue
#3-‐
When
you
want
to
become
stronger,
you
should…OVERLOAD
view 2015). The term HRFK can be described as the health
your
muscles!
content in physical education that encompasses the necessary
Clue
#4-‐
If
you
are
fit….
you
have
more
CHOICES
to
be
physically
knowledge for individuals to remain physically active for life.
active!
For example, HRFK could include knowledge of the benefits of
aerobic fitness, moderate-to-vigorous activities, and the effects
that different exercises have on the body.
RIDDLE –
“P.E. STRENGTHENS MY HEART AND MAKE ME _ _ A _ _” Researchers have found HRFK to be lacking among students
of all developmental levels, from elementary to collegiate. For
Figure 1. Scavenger Hunt instructional aid. example, Placek and colleagues (2001) interviewed 40 urban
sixth-grade students on their notions of fitness components.
Results indicated that 82% of students could not accurately ex-
Downloaded by [New York University] at 09:16 15 March 2016
Quality physical education programs should prepare indi- plain what muscular endurance was and had misconceptions
viduals for lifelong physical activity and healthy behaviors. Ac- of what physical fitness meant. Students explained that they
cording to SHAPE America – Society of Health and Physi- thought physical fitness meant “looking good and thin” (Placek
cal Educators, the goal of physical education is to develop et al., 2001). Additional elementary-level studies have exam-
physically literate individuals who have the knowledge, skills ined HRFK with the use of portfolio tasks and revealed similar
and confidence to enjoy a lifetime of healthful physical activ- results (Brusseau, Kulinna, & Cothran, 2011; Kulinna, 2004).
Remarkably, these findings have been recognized for more than
a decade (Hopple & Graham, 1995).
At the secondary level, Stewart and Mitchell (2003) ex-
Body Composition amined students at 62 different high schools, using a written
HRFK statewide test. The class means were analyzed, and out
Avengers! of the 270 classes, only 43% of students were able to identify all
health-related fitness components. Furthermore, the majority
• To keep a good body composition score you need to of students had problems applying basic training principles to
eat and burn the same calories EVERY DAY. improve a health-related fitness component (Stewart & Mitch-
• Your body composition is made up of bones, ell, 2003). Similar results were found at the collegiate level, as
muscle, and fat. Miller and Berry (2000) examined 117 college students in al-
lied health professions using an expertly constructed HRFK
test. Results showed that athletic trainers, physical therapists
and nursing participants were scoring relatively low on the test,
with total correct mean scores of 64%, 72.5% and 58.5%, re-
spectively.
Instruction of HRFK has been documented to be beneficial
for children and adolescents. Many researchers have found that
HRFK provides individuals with a foundation for intelligent
decision making and is a potential determinant of leisure-time
physical activity engagement (Dale & Corbin, 2000; Dale,
Corbin, & Cuddihy, 1998; DiLorenzo, Stucky-Ropp, Vander
Wal, & Gotham, 1998; Keating et al., 2010; Liang et al., 1993;
Pearman et al., 1997; Thompson & Hannon, 2012). For ex-
ample, DiLorenzo and colleagues (1998) conducted a two-
How to play: Run and grab ONLY ONE muscle from the other
phase longitudinal study by soliciting families of fifth- and
team’s hoop or grab a FAT from yours to place it in their hoop!
sixth-grade children by telephone. The researchers discovered
How to win: Have more MUSCLE on your skeleton than FAT! in the first phase of the study that exercise enjoyment was a
significant predictor of physical activity. However, in the sec-
Figure 2. Body Composition Avengers instructional ond phase (three years later), families were interviewed again
aid. and the then eighth- and ninth-grade students indicated that
20 Strategies
TAKE YOUR HEART RATE
Instructions:
Quickly
choose
an
aerobic
activity.
Perform
that
activity
for
30-‐45
seconds
then
check
your
pulse
on
either
your
wrist
or
neck.
BPM
Calculation-‐
Count
number
of
beats
for
10
seconds
and
multiply
that
by
6.
Downloaded by [New York University] at 09:16 15 March 2016
• Vigorous
physical
activities
like
running,
riding
bikes,
swimming
and
jumping
jacks
strengthen
your
heart
and
greatly
increase
your
pulse!
• Moderate
physical
activities
like
walking
briskly,
yard
work
and
shooting
baskets
are
good
but
do
not
improve
your
aerobic
fitness!
exercise knowledge was the only predictor of physical activity. Knowledge in Action Fitness
Thompson and Hannon (2012) found similar trends when they
Knowledge in Action (KIA) fitness is a series of student-
investigated the HRFK and physical activity of high school
centered fitness lessons that enhance all five components of
students. A self-report physical activity questionnaire was used
fitness and teach HRFK in a short segment of the physical
to assess students’ physical activity and a 100-point pencil-and-
education class period. Knowledge in Action provides each
paper test was used to assess students’ HRFK. Results showed student with an opportunity to be successful and learn at his
a moderate positive correlation, r(168) = .438, between HRFK or her own pace, as it is based on cognitive mediating theory
and physical activity, indicating that students with more HRFK (Doyle, 1977). This theory takes into account the countless
report higher levels of physical activity (Thompson & Hannon, mediating factors that may inhibit learning and places the
2012). After additional analyses, it was also found that students student in the driver’s seat while the teacher is the facilitator
in the low-HRFK group reported significantly less physical ac- of learning. The design of KIA fitness is simple: it involves
tivity than students in the high-HRFK group, who exhibited a total of seven lessons, with each lesson composed of four
higher documented physical activity levels (Thompson & Han- different health-enhancing stations that are situated in the
non, 2012). four corners of the playing area. These four activities are self-
Despite the continued marginalization of the physical edu- sufficient and require minimal equipment. The KIA activities
cation field, teachers should remain optimistic and determined are accompanied by an instructional aid (e.g., visual prompt,
to teach HRFK, as each health-related component can contrib- sign, etc.) with conceptual health statements, informing the
ute to getting students active and healthy for a lifetime. How- student how to conduct the activities (see Figures 1–7 for the
ever, the question still remains, how can teachers reach their KIA fitness instructional aids). After completion of the seven
goal with such little contact time with students? The purpose KIA lessons, the teacher can use PE Metrics (National As-
of this article is to answer this question and offer elementary sociation for Sport and Physical Education [NASPE], 2010),
physical education teachers a newly tested strategy for teaching a SHAPE America-endorsed pencil-and-paper test to assess
HRFK while still maintaining high levels of physical activity. students’ HRFK acquisition.
Volume 28 • July/August 21
Benefit
Pick-‐Up
Soccer,
swimming,
and
running
are
great
aerobic
fitness
activities
that
require
a
lot
of
Aerobic
Endurance
and
helps
strengthen
your
heart.
Students’ health-related fitness
Skip
and
touch
the
opposite
wall
and
skip
back.
knowledge (HRFK) can be
Benefit
Pick-‐Up
Being
stronger
allows
you
to
throw
farther.
Slide
to
the
closest
wall
and
described as the health content
overload
your
muscles
with
(8)
wall
push-‐ups.
in physical education that
Benefit
Pick-‐Up
Your
heart
will
benefit
from
daily
physical
activity.
Hop
over
and
give
a
encompasses the necessary
high-‐five
to
your
teacher
for
participating
in
activity
today.
knowledge for individuals to
remain physically active for life.
Benefit
Pick-‐Up
To
test
the
fitness
of
your
heart,
try
to
run
(aerobic
activity)
2
times
around
the
gym.
Benefit
Pick-‐Up
To
build
aerobic
endurance
you
should
increase
the
amount
of
vigorous
activities
you
engage
in.
Complete
20
treadmills
in
your
own
space.
Time breakdown
Physical education teachers can be seen spending approxi-
Downloaded by [New York University] at 09:16 15 March 2016
Benefit
Pick-‐Up
Being
fit
allows
you
to
have
more
choices
of
activity.
Either
crab
walk,
1
mately one or two minutes describing the four activities posi-
bear
crawl,
or
seal
walk
in
a
circle
around
your
station.
tioned in the corners of the playing area. The duration of each
station should be approximately 1 minute and 30 seconds each
Benefit
Pick-‐Up
(6 minutes in total for all four stations). During the transitions,
Aerobic
activity
reduces
your
stress
and
tension.
Relax
and
jog
to
get
a
teachers check for understanding by giving students time to
(5)
second
drink
of
water.
critically think about the concepts they are learning. This is ex-
pected to last no more than 30 seconds each (2 minutes in to-
Figure 4. Benefit Pick-Up instructional aid. tal). Therefore, the total duration of a KIA fitness lesson should
be approximately 10 minutes.
Lesson description
Each KIA lesson contains four KIA activities organized in a
sequential rotation, removing the oldest activity following each
Just a lesson. For example, if Lesson 1 included Stations 1, 2, 3 and 4,
the following lesson (Lesson 2) would introduce a new activ-
Roll of the Dice!! ity, Station 5, in place of the first activity. This would result in
HOW TO PLAY: Take turns rolling the dice. Quickly roll Stations 2, 3, 4 and 5. The subsequent lesson (Lesson 3) would
and add up the dice. Choose from the specific then introduce a new activity, Station 6, thus removing Station
component of fitness and perform that number rolled. 2 to have Stations 3, 4, 5 and 6. This allows students to be ex-
---------------------------------------------- posed to each activity more than once (four times total) during
ODD #: the duration of the KIA fitness (see Table 1 for a breakdown of
Choose from- Aerobic Fitness Exercises: Jumping each KIA activity).
jacks, treadmills, shuttle run… Teachers are encouraged to play preselected music for the
OR activity period of 1 minute and 30 seconds and to have 30 sec-
Choose from- Muscular Endurance Exercises: Wall sits, onds of silence for the transition period. This aids in uniformity
lunges, power jumps, hopping on one foot… and allows the teacher to focus on the students during activity
-------------------------------------------------------- time. Checking for understanding during transitions can be ac-
EVEN #: complished through quick question-and-answer segments that
Choose from- Muscular Strength Exercises: Push-ups, align with the newly introduced concepts. Questions for stu-
curl ups, partner resistance exercises… dents can be categorized by concept taught. Table 2 provides
OR some ideas for questions the teacher could ask to facilitate criti-
Choose from- Flexibility Exercises: Windmills, toe
cal thinking between activities.
touch, shoulder stretch…
Lesson effectiveness
The effectiveness of KIA fitness was examined in one sub-
urban school district with 10 physical education teachers and
Figure 5. Roll the Dice instructional aid. their respective fifth-grade physical education classes. A total
22 Strategies
<LE5>Figure 5. Roll the Dice instructional aid.</LE5>
BEARING
the
WEIGHT
Table 1. Description of KIA Fitness Activities
Instructions:
Participate
in
the
weight-‐bearing
exercises
listed
below.
Try
to
1. Scavenger Hunt: Following a map, students work
complete
ALL
tasks
before
you
move
on.
with a partner and hunt for different activities
ü
Build
muscle
and
strengthen
your
bones
with
this
weight-‐bearing
activity.
Perform
10
curl-‐ups!
scattered throughout the gym. Once they find an
activity, students perform the task before moving
ü
Softball
is
a
great
weight-‐bearing
sport.
Perform
a
pitch,
homerun
catch,
swing,
field
a
groundball!
on. Students need to find all activities to answer
the final riddle.
ü
Build
muscular
endurance
with
(15)
fast
WALL
JUMPS
over
and
over
again.
2. Body Composition Avengers: Students in this
ü
Hold
your
body
weight
by
staying
in
the
middle
of
a
push-‐up
for
10
station are divided and positioned at opposing
seconds.
Hula-Hoops spaced approximately 20 feet apart.
ü
Running
is
another
great
weight-‐bearing
activity.
Jog
in
place
for
20
The hoops contain six yellow beanbags (fat) and six
seconds!
red beanbags (muscle). One hoop contains 6 red
bags (muscle), and another hoop contains 6 yellow
(fat). Students run and attempt to gather more red
Figure 6. Bearing the Weight instructional aid. (muscle) bean bags than yellow (fat) in their hula
hoop. Students may only grab on red bag at a time
and get rid of one yellow bag. Whichever team gets
Downloaded by [New York University] at 09:16 15 March 2016
of 30 fifth-grade classes and 633 students participated. Physical more red bags wins.
education teachers were selected and randomly divided into ei-
3. Take Your Heart Rate: Students immediately
ther the intervention group (implementing the KIA fitness) or
choose either a moderate (e.g., walking, playing
control group (no changes to the already existing lessons). Stu-
catch) or vigorous (e.g., jump roping, or agility run)
dents were assessed before and after the intervention using PE
activity that is available at the station. Students
Metrics (NASPE, 2010), and NL-1000 accelerometers were
engage in their chosen activity and stop just before
used throughout the duration of the study to assess students’
the end of the station and check their heart rate.
physical activity levels. This device provides step counts, as well
as time spent in moderate-to-vigorous activity (any movement 4. Benefit Pick-Up: Students grab one card from
from brisk walking to a more strenuous exercise), which has several that are scattered face down inside a Hula-
previously been validated for this age group (Hart, Brusseau, Hoop. Each card has a health benefit (e.g., running
Kulinna, McClain, & Tudor-Locke, 2011). Teachers who par- faster, prevent injuries) and an activity to perform
ticipated in the intervention group were provided with lesson (e.g., standing hamstring stretch; reach and touch
plans and YouTube videos a week before the upcoming KIA your toes). Once the student reads the benefit
lesson. Physical educators were also given the instructional aids card, he or she puts the card back face down and
and equipment (if needed) to teach the KIA fitness lessons. The performs the activity. Once completed, the student
training was seen to be very effective, as identified across the picks up another card and continues this process as
interview data (Hodges et al., in review 2015). many times as they can.
5. Roll the Dice: Students quickly begin by rolling
the big foam dice. If the dice land as an odd
number, the roller decides between either an
QUIZ YOUR PARTNER! aerobic or muscular endurance exercise. If the
dice land on an even number, the roller chooses a
Walk or jog with your partner (in your own space) and take turns asking each
other questions. If they get the answer right, perform 2 jumping jacks! weight-bearing or flexibility exercise.
Question 1: Name 3 aerobic fitness-type activities/sports.
Answer: Jumping jacks, soccer, rope jumping, running, vigorous swimming, etc.
6. Bearing the Weight: Students read the sign (task
sheet) posted on the wall and perform the task
Question 2: What happens to your body when you exercise vigorously? listed. All activities listed on the sign are weight-
Answer: Increase pulse, sweat, you get hot, breathe hard…
bearing activities (e.g., sit-ups, performing a softball
pitch, wall jumps). Information regarding weight-
Question 3: True or False: Being physically fit makes you feel better and
allows you to do a wide variety of activities? bearing activity can also be found on the sign.
Answer: True; feel better, play in many different activities
7. Quiz Your Partner: Students partner up and walk
Question 4: Name two places on your body where can you check your pulse. while reading and quizzing each other on the given
question on a card.
Answer: Wrist & neck
Volume 28 • July/August 23
Table 2. Conceptual Questions to Engage Students’ Critical-Thinking Skills
Concept Conceptual Questions
Choosing to be physically • What is the best activity you can do when you get home?
active outside of school • If you want to get better at football, what sort of activity should you do?
Describing personal responses • Does your heart beat faster or slower when you perform vigorous activities?
to physical activity • How can you tell from your body that you are exercising hard?
Improving personal fitness • What do you think people should do to be more flexible?
• What sorts of activities benefit the heart the most?
• To keep a good body composition, what do people need to eat?
Identifying personal health- • Where can you find your pulse on your body?
Downloaded by [New York University] at 09:16 15 March 2016
Identifying the principles • When you lift a weight many times, are you trying to improve your flexibility or your
associated with improving muscular endurance?
physical fitness • When you run a mile or long distance, what area of fitness are you working on?
• If you want to get stronger, what do you think you should do?
• What parts of the body make up body composition?
Identifying specific benefits • What are you capable of doing when you get stronger?
associated with each health- • How do you feel when you are physically fit?
related fitness component • Are you more susceptible to injuries when you are more or less flexible?
Results from this study indicated that students from the accrued significantly more physical activity, F(245) = 32.38,
KIA group improved their test scores by 20%, which was signif- p < .001, and gained more steps on average (871.20) than
icantly different than the comparison students’ scores (Hodges
the control group (762.38) and more minutes in moder- 1
et al., in review 2015). See Figure 8 for a graph showing the ate-to-vigorous physical activity, F(245) = 16.18, p < .001.
improvement between students’ pretest and posttest scores. See Figure 9 for a group comparison of physical activity
Furthermore, researchers found that students in the KIA group 1
levels.
100
Pretest
Mean HRFK Scores
80 1000
Posttest
Student Mean Steps
60 900
800
40
700
20 CONTROL
600 INTERVENTION
0 500
Brad Ruth Jessica Mike Gabby 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
KIA Lesson Segments
Figure
<LE8>Figure 8. Student
8. Student pretest
pretest and and
posttest PE posttest
Metrics PE assorted
mean scores Metricsby
mean scores assorted by Knowledge in Action teachers. Figure 9. Comparison of physical activity levels in
Note.
Knowledge HRFK
in Action = health-related fitness knowledge.
teachers. Knowledge in Action fitness assorted by lessons.
<LE9>Figure 9. Comparison of physical activity levels in Knowledge in Action
Note. HRFK = health-related fitness knowledge.</LE8>
(KIA) fitness assorted by lessons.</LE9>
24 Strategies
ing physical activity in 10-11-year-old children. Research Quarterly
for Exercise and Sport, 82, 600–609.
Knowledge in Action (KIA) Hodges, M., Kulinna, P. H., van der Mars, H., Lee, C., & Kwon, J. Y.
(In review, 2015) Professional development and teacher perceptions
fitness is a series of student- of experiences teaching health-related fitness knowledge. Journal of
Teaching Physical Education.
centered fitness lessons that Hopple, C., & Graham, G. (1995). What children think, feel, and
enhance all five components know about physical fitness testing. Journal of Teaching in Physical
Education, 14, 408–417.
of fitness and teach HRFK in a Keating, X. D., Castro-Pinero, J., Centeio, E., Harrison, L., Jr.,
Ramirez, T., & Chen, L. (2010). Health-related fitness knowledge
short segment of the physical and its relation to student physical activity patterns at a large U.S.
Southern state university. Journal of Research, 5, 3–9.
education class period. Keating, X. D., Harrison, L., Jr., Chen, L., Xiang, P., Lambdin, D.,
Dauenhaurer, B., . . . Castro Pinero, J. (2009). An analysis of re-
search on student health-related fitness knowledge in K–16 physical
education programs. Journal of Teaching in Physical Education, 28,
333–349.
Conclusion Kulinna, P. H. (2004). Physical activity and fitness knowledge: How
In an effort to increase pupils’ academic achievement, many much 1–6 grade students know. International Journal of Physical
school districts have cut children’s physical activity opportu- Education, 41, 111–12.
Downloaded by [New York University] at 09:16 15 March 2016
Volume 28 • July/August 25