You are on page 1of 16

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/339271499

WOMAN-NATURE INTERFACE: AN ECOFEMINIST STUDY

Book · January 2019

CITATIONS READS

0 1,407

1 author:

Dipak Giri
Raiganj University
16 PUBLICATIONS   2 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE

All content following this page was uploaded by Dipak Giri on 27 April 2020.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


WOMAN-NATURE INTERFACE
AN ECOFEMINIST STUDY
WOMAN-NATURE INTERFACE
AN ECOFEMINIST STUDY

- Edited by -
Dipak Giri
WOMAN-NATURE INTERFACE
AN ECOFEMINIST STUDY

Edited by
Dipak Giri
Dedicated to...
Published by:

My Sweet
Head Office:
AABS PUBLISHING HOUSE
Daughter Diya
Kolkata, West Bengal, India-712121
Email: aabspubshouse@gmail.com
support@aabspublishinghouse.com
Visit us: www.aabspublishinghouse.com

ISBN: 978-93-88963-60-2
Price: < 899 | $ 20
Copyright © Author
First Edition 2019

No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in or introduced


into a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form, or by any means
(electrical, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise) without
the prior written permission of the publisher. Any person who does
any unauthorised act in relation to this publication may be liable to
criminal prosecution and civil claims for damages.
All the matters related to publication shall be settled under the under
the jurisdiction of Kolkata (India) court only.
FOREWORD

Writing a foreword is a tricky enterprise,


especially on a book like Woman-Nature Interface:
An Ecofeminist Study. Now, we have to begin
somewhere and I would like to quote a few
sentences from Adrienne Rich’s book On Woman
Born: Motherhood as Experience and Institution. She
outlines the, “simple idea that women are as
intrinsically human as men, that neither women
nor men are merely the enlargement of a contact
sheet of genetic encoding, biologically givens.
Experience shapes us, randomness shapes us, the
stars and weather, our own accommodations and
rebellions, above all, the social order around us”.
Dipak’s book does just that. The collection of
essays focuses on studies on ecology with
emphasis on global perspectives and environmental
activism, apart from woman centered narratives
in select female novelists and in other narratives,
like ballads of Bengal. The essays focus on diverse
authors like Katherine Mansfield, Sarojini Naidu,
Kamala Das, Anita Desai, Roy and several others.
However, the nexus between nature and woman
had been the focus of ancient Indian literature as
is shown in the study of Kalidasa’s Shakuntala.
Whereas the character of Shakuntala has been
sketched from a natural perspective, Shakespeare’s
plays like The Tempest and The Taming of the Shrew
analyse the woman as well as nature from a male
point of view. Such literature has been aptly
substantiated by articles on ecofeminism and CONTENTS
environmental movements in India and Pakistan
in agricultural and economic sectors. There is also
a return to historical narratives as well as a fresh
Foreword
insight into the nature versus culture debate
Introduction
within the context of rapid globalization.
Finally, the author-cum-editor has been quite 1. An Ecofeminist Scrutiny of Katherine
proficient in recent years with the publication of Mansfield’s ‘Prelude’
several books on Indian writing, especially novel Chinmayee Nanda 29
and drama within the ambience of postcolonial
studies. Collected editions on gender studies, 2. Woman and Nature: Exploring the Connections
Diasporas, homosexuality and transgender issues in the Study of Roy’s Fol ded Earth and
have been edited by him. Markandya’s Nectar in a Sieve
This book on Woman Nature Interface illustrates Sanjukta Bala 38
how woman centered narratives can be
contextualized within the parameters of ecology 3. Woman-Nature Parallelism: An Ecofeminist
and environment. The role of the woman becomes Insight into Anita Desai’s Fire on the Mountain
amplified in the dialectics between nature and and K. R. Usha’s Monkey Man
culture. The editor has aptly summarized the Bhaskar Ch. Sarkar & 51
rationale of the book in his introduction where he Nabanita Barman
writes that ecology and the woman are burning
issues today. The message, which the book conveys 4. A Multidimensional Projection of Land: A
can be paralleled by an observation from Vandana Reading of Gone with the Wind in the Light of
Shiva, where she says that the liberation of the War
earth, the woman, as well as humanity is a step Mahendran U. 62
towards freedom and peace. Let us read this book.
Soumyajit Samanta 5. In Search of an Abode in Nature: The Theme
Retired Professor of Matriarchal Nourishment and the
North Bengal University, West Bengal Interference of Patriarchy in Mahua the Gypsy
Girl
Jyoti Biswas 73
6. In Custody: An Ecofeminist Study 14. An Interfacial Reading of Woman and Nature
Parimal Kumar 83 from Ecofeminist Perspective
Shefali Sharma & Dr. Uma Mishra 187
7. A Re-conceiving and Re-visioning of both the
Feminism and the Environmental Ethics as 15. Historical Responsiveness through Tribal
the Power and Promise of Ecofeminism: A Identity: A Study on Deori Women of North
Detailed Study Bank of Brahmaputra Valley in Assam
Dr. Shantanu Siuli 94 Guptajit Pathak 194

8. Women-Nature Affinity in Anita Desai’s Fire 16. A Study of Woman–Nature Similitude in


on the Mountain: A Study in Postcolonial William Shakespeare’s The Tempest and The
Ecofeminist Perspective Taming of the Shrew
Manas Barik 105 Debasis Samaddar 208

9. Creator’s Unbearable Hostilities: An 17. Ecofeminism in the Poems of Kamala Das and
Ecofeminist Story Sarojini Naidu with the Five main Steams of
Dipika Ghosh 125 Ecofeminism
Raghabendra Garai 228
10. Ecofeminism and Environmental Movements
in India: A Theoretical Study 18. Impact of Globalization on Woman and Nature
Lucky Dey 135 Biplob Ghosh 251

11. Shakuntala and the Natural Sublime: 19. Subversion of Gender Binary in Relation to
Representations in Literature and Media Nature/Culture Dichotomy: An Ecofeminist
Subhrajit Samanta 151 Study of Anita Desai’s Fire on the Mountain
Dipak Giri 261
12. Feminization of Agriculture and Its
Implications on Economic Well Being of Notes on Contributors 273
Households
Atanu Ghosh 167

13. Social Position of Pastoral and Town Working


Females in Pakistan
Dr. Mohd. Azam 180
INTRODUCTION

In last few decades, Ecofeminism as a


philosophy and a movement has gained much
momentum. As an offshoot of third wave feminism,
Ecofeminism sets its ideal like any other feminism
as both feminism and Ecofeminism involve the
development of world views and practices that are
not based on male biased models of domination.
Drawing parallelism between feminism and green
movements, Ecofeminism links the exploitation and
degradation of the natural world with the
subordination and oppression of women and hardly
sees any difference between them. Soon after its
emergence in the mid 1970s, Ecofeminism gained
fast momentum as both ecology and woman are
the need of the hour. At initial stage it laid an
emphasis on the feminine instinct for nurture and between nature/woman and culture/man to show
holistic knowledge of nature as curative processes how the writer puts more emphasis on the former
for removal of split between nature and culture. of the dualisms through the valorization of women
However, modern outlook comes in opposition and nature. In “Prelude”, she has presented the
against such essentialism concentrating more story of the Burnell family shifting from town to a
on intersectional questions, such as how the new house with a garden, Mansfield focuses on
nature-culture split enables the oppression of the connectedness of the ecology and persona. The
female and nonhuman bodies. proximity of the natural with man-made,
The term ‘Ecofeminism’ was first coined by particularly the garden and the aloe tree in this
French Feminist Francoise d’Eanboune in her book story, reflects the frame of mind of the characters
Le féminisme ou la mort in 1974. Next it was as well as the divergent associations between the
developed by Ynestra King, an activist, teacher individual and the place s/he lives in. Eco-
and writer from New York City in about 1976 and feminism, which dovetails the issues of ecology to
finally it took the form of a movement in 1980. For the situation of women, highlights that the
the growth and development of this movement the evolvement of characters cannot be ideated in
first ecofeminist conference – “Women and Life isolation rather physical surroundings play a
on Earth: Eco feminism in the 80s”, at Amherst, pivotal role.
Massachusetts, US was held and as a result of Sanjukta Bala’s article tries to explore the link
this conference the movement earned global between woman and nature in reference to Roy’s
recognition. In India, the most visible advocate of Folded Earth and Markandya’s Nectar in a Sieve.
eco-feminism is Vandana Shiva, an environmental Ecofeminism primarily explores the connections
activist and anti-globalization author. Her work between women and nature. From time
comes closest to cultural ecofeminism in the immemorial women have been seen as similar with
Indian context. that of nature as both are giving, sacrificing
This present volume of eighteen essays presents entities. Besides this both nature and women are
a critical insight into the works of many writers of seen as life bearing. But in Ecofeminist thinking
repute. All essays are woman and ecocentric where this equation has been challenged variously. They
both woman and ecology are critically discussed. believe that women and nature share grounds of
Along with literary essays, the volume also commonality but those grounds cannot be
presents essays on other disciplines of learning. explained in plain terms. There are differences in
Hopefully this volume would try to reach many how the ecofeminists themselves define the
unexplored areas of knowledge and serve larger grounds. Some find a special spiritual bond
sections of humanity. between them. Western ecofeminists mostly
believe that both nature and women share a
The very first article of Chinmayee Nanda “Feminine Principal”. This has been termed as
analyzes Mansfield’s story “Prelude” from an spiritual connection between them. They believe
ecofeminist perspective by highlighting the analogy
that if we could find this divine “Feminine construct and have found the ways to liberate both
Principal” within nature or begin to see nature as women and nature from false ideologies.
living spiritual being we can never harm it. They Mahendran U’s article on Margaret Mitchell’s
talk about regenerating that spiritual conception Gone with the Wind tries to analyse the difficulties
within nature which is feminine in nature. of war time along with the shattered world of
Secondly some believe that from the inception of women in such condition. The major characters
modernity man has created this binary of culture- like Scarlett O’Hara, Ashley and Rhett Butler and
nature. Nature is now perceived as an obstacle in their sense of belonging to the land is being
his way to establish himself as superior. Thus highlighted. However, the other unspoken side of
nature became an object to control, to dominate. war and its consequences are also touched. The
And on the other hand women too in cultures are love which occurs at the time of appalling
seen as inferior to man. Their shared history of predicament is slightly explained. An attempt has
oppression is a thread that connects them. Thirdly, been made to the best of the researcher’s ability
many believe that women work within nature more to show/indicate the fact that wars have
intimately than man. In countries like India women contributed hugely to the destruction of the earth.
depend on nature more closely for their survival
and that is why when nature is affected their lives Jyoti Biswas’s article on Mahua The Gypsy Girl,
are affected too. This has been termed as material a ballad written by Dvija Kanai, a medieval Bengali
bond between them. These theoretical approaches poet and compiled and edited in Eastern Bengal
when applied to literature many other aspects Ballads (1923) by Dinesh Chandra Sen, shows how
emerge that help to broaden the peripheries of woman-nature interface sustains harmony in a
Ecofeminism itself. Bala’s article tries to find out natural setting on one hand, and the man-nature
the connection shared by women and nature as a interface disrupts it on the other. Mahua, a gypsy
complex and dynamic thing rather than plain and girl and Naderchand, a Brahmin landlord fell in
simplistic. In Roy’s Folded Earth and Markandya’s love with each other when the former came to
Nectar in a Sieve we get an array of such complex visit the latter’s place, village Baman Kandi and
relationship between women and nature. This show acrobatic skills along with her foster father,
helps us better understand how women and nature Homra and other gypsy members from their native
connect in a third world country. place in Jainta Hills which is but an eastern
continuation of the Garo and Khasi Hills.
The joint article of Bhaskar Ch. Sarkar & Throughout the text, two dominant forces work
Nabanita Barman on Anita Desai’s Fire on the opposite to each other, namely the affluence of
Mountain and KR Usha’s Monkey Man explores to nature and her nourishment in the life of Mahua
bring out how the Indian women novelists have like a mother and the powerful presence of Homra,
portrayed the exploitation of women and nature Mahua’s foster father, interfering in her searching
in the materialistic Indian Society. They have also for an abode of peace with her lover, the Brahmin
identified woman-nature connection as a cultural landlord Naderchand in this affluent natural world.
The life of Mahua gets trapped in these two the female characters to pursue a dignified living
contradictory forces: the matriarchal nourishment or career. The paper endeavours to lay bare how
amidst the world of nature and patriarchal natural hazards wreck the female characters’
interference in her love with Naderchand and in standard of living exposing them to suffer endlessly.
wider sense, in her attachment to nature for Shantanu Siuli’s article reconceives and
survival. The setting of the plot rests entirely in revisions feminism and environmental ethics as
the abundance of greenery, a symbol of both the power and promise of ecofeminism.
simplicity and harmony, but the development of Ecofeminism is a holistic value system in which
the plot shows that both Mahua and Naderchand significance and action are indissoluble; one
submitted before the dominant patriarchy amidst cannot care without acting. Ecofeminism redefines
the very pastoral world that in turn became an ethical shift from granting moral consideration
disharmonious with this interference. The life of to nonhumans absolutely on the grounds of some
Mahua and her interaction with the natural world similarity they share with human beings to a highly
seem to be an integral part of a daughter-mother contextual account to see clearly what a human
relation, whereas Homra becomes a dominant being is and what the non-human world might be,
patriarchy causing the tragic death of the lovers. morally speaking, for the human beings. The very
Parimal Kumar’s article studies Anita Desai’s concept of ecofeminism is based on the proposition
In Custody through the lens of ecofeminism. In that person and planet are dangerous to each
Custody, as the title suggests, depicts a world other- a toxic and obnoxious mindset of domination
where all the characters are incarcerated in their and control that degrades both women and nature.
own way. It distinctly portrays a world which is Ecofeminism creates problems and seeks solutions
bare, desolate and bears the mark of to determinate the problems of human beings on
environmental imbalance. Since the society is a universal basis. Ecofeminists insist that the sort
dominated by patriarchy, the women suffer more of logic of domination used to justify the domination
meekly. Imtiaz Begum has to earn a livelihood by of humans by gender, racial or ethnic, or class
dancing and reciting poetry but her merit both as status is also used to justify the domination of
an artist or a poet never achieves legitimacy by nature. Ecofeminist theory emphasizes and begins
the male dominated world. Rather visitors flock to with what is seen as the inextricable link between
her inclined by her lustrous beauty of the youth, the many and varied types of violence against
while her husband scarcely contributes the family women and the contempt with which humans treat
financially. Safia Begum has to adopt tricky ways the earth.
of securing money as she is also at the verge of Manas Barik’s article on Anita Desai’s Fire on
bare necessity. Sarla has to manage the entire the Mountain studies woman-nature relationship
household of Deven but she is disregarded and from postcolonial ecofeminist perspective. In the
never receives even any emotional support by her Third World countries Earth is represented as
husband. The ecological imbalance never allows female, “Mother Earth” and “virgin land”, upholding
the interconnectedness of women and nature. affinity in the novel was unfolded through a
Both women and nature suffered abject crisscrossing between the present and the past,
exploitation and violence at the hand of the uneventful mundane present and supposedly
patriarchal, capitalist society since times glamorous past, between reality and
immemorial. The urgent need of ‘Ecofeminism’ in reminiscences. To solace her tormenting neglected
1970s was basically a protest against the society past, Nanda Kaul, the protagonist, took refuge in
where there was no liberation for women, no the lonely spheres of Carignano enfolded by the
identity of their own, and no solution of the scented sibilance of the pine trees and the
ecological crises. The term embodied women’s invisible music of cicadas. Later on Raka, the great-
capacity for bringing about an ecological revolution grand-daughter, joins Nanda and tries to recover
to ensure human survival on the planet, so that it her pain-afflicted soul by scrambling up the hill
entails new relations between women and men, like a wild animal. Tara suffered from a chronic
humans and nature. Postcolonial Ecofeminism still nervous breakdown that emanated from the
follows the Euro-American point of view of marital disharmony. Ila Das was raped and
domination and includes postcolonial ecocriticism murdered at the very end of the novel.
and ecofeminism under singular shade unveiling Dipika Ghosh’s aerticle “Creator’s Unbearable
the exploitation of Nature and subjection of Women Hostilities: An Ecofeminist Story” tries to uncover
intimately linking class, caste, race, colonialism the ecofeminist’s clandestine kinship with nature
and neo-colonialism. From 20 th century onwards and their protest against bars, composed by power
myriads of women writers and social workers over minded people through the sagas of deities and
the globe shot to seek female subjectivity in order its performative cults. Women, a designation of
to substantiate an identity and raise voice against ecofeminist and an imbibed soul by the limbs of
the environmental depletion. Medha Patakar, patriarchy, impeded against the corrosions of
Mahasweta Devi, Arundhati Roy, C. K. Janu, environment for the bloomy milieus of their future
Vandana Shiva, Wangari Maathai, and Ken Saro- generations. India, a clime of rich cultures,
Wiwa carefully contextualized contemporary social traditions and values with all religions defrayed
issues in their writings and took active the abyssal bracing of dual dames-women and
participation in environmental problems. As a ecology and their struggle for healthy existence
postcolonial women writer, Anita Desai, embedded from occlusions, composed by different edifications
in Indian sensibility, addressed patriarchal social of beliefs.
set-up, women’s issues, portrayed myriad faces of
the new women and their close nexus with Nature. Lucky Dey’s article attempts to understand the
In Fire on the Mountain, Anita Desai portrayed four theoretical concept of ecological feminism and
generations of women: Nanda Kaul & Ila Das, Asha, discuss the active participation of women in various
Tara and Raka; all of them were the victims of environmental movements in India. It shows how
patriarchal social set-up. The Women-Nature Ecofeminism as an interdisciplinary movement
represents the synthesis of the radical movement
in ecology and feminism; how it unmasks and tries approaching out of their homes in order to attain
to dismantle the abstract framework of the financial independence as well as their civil
supremacy, oppression, commodification etc., and liberties and rank like men in society and in family.
how it mainly aims at eliminating all forms of Today one finds females in wide range of livelihood
domination from all spheres of life putting forth other than teachers and doctors. Women happen
the fact of interdependence and connection of to work in middle level occupations which were
human beings to the earth. regarded as male professions only few years ago.
Subhrajit Samanta’s essay focuses on The entrance of women in labour market has
Kalidasa’s representation of Shakuntala, which basically distorted the status of women in the
diverges from Vyas’s portrait of her in Mahabharata. family as well in the society. However women are
Scholars have highlighted Kalidasa’s portrayal of facing new challenges concerning their social
human feelings in the context of nature. status which varies from country to urban areas
Shakuntala illustrates both love in separation and and females of various families in one area.
love in union. This theme has been the focus of Joint article of Shefali Sharma and Dr. Uma
scholars like Romila Thapar and others. In the Mishra presents woman-nature study from the
final section the focus is on different perspective of past movements participated by
representations of Shakuntala in the light of her Indian woman to save nature and environment held
appeal to Indian as well as Western psychology. in India.
Dr. Atanu Ghosh’s article “Feminization of Guptajit Pathak’s paper is an attempt to focus
Agriculture and Its Implications on Economic Well the historical perception of Deori Women on the
Being of Households” carries out a study in North Bank of Brahmaputra Valley in Assam.
selected blocks of Bankura districts to understand Debasis Samaddar’s article analyses the literary
the implication of feminization of agriculture on works of Shakespeare from the perspective of
its socioeconomic dimensions at household and ecofeminism. Shakespeare’s The Tempest and The
community level. The finding revealed that Taming of the Shrew survey the dominance of woman
feminization of agriculture has improved the and nature by male ideology. The deconstruction
economic wellbeing of the household but has less of patriarchy and its power to create a difference
or no impact on economic freedom and decision between civilized-uncivilized, intelligence-
making power of women. It has negative impact foolishness, domestic-wild is established through
on status of women at the community level. these plays. In The Tempest, the wild nature is
Dr. Mohd. Azam’s article presents the social dominated and in The Taming of the Shrew, the
position of pastoral and town working females in Shrew of the play, Kate is supposed to be a wild
Pakistan. The paper shows how in Pakistan female animal and is dominated by male power. This study
contribution in marketplace has enlarged due to examines The Tempest and The Taming of the Shrew
increased service opportunities. Women are in terms of ecofeminism, bringing the relation
between domination of nature and domination of Biplob Ghosh’s article discusses the impact of
woman by male power. globalization on woman and nature. The paper tries
Raghabendra Garai’s article aims to study and to explore how Ecofeminism seeks solution to the
illustrate how ecofeminism and its practices in glaring issues of why women do 65% of the world’s
post-modern era play a significant role in today’s work for only 10% of its wages, why the rape case
culture and facilitate to understand its major has increased an incredible, how the role of the
contribution in literature, society, culture, gender, state has decided by the multinational, why the
race, etc. spontaneously for flourishing a concept of ‘Mother India’ has been changing, how
spectacularly unassailable life of all humans. This violation affected nature and women of Kashmir,
approach is growing within us gradually that helps why glocalization is not local-glocalized, why soils
to formulate the course of civilization and society are losing her organic character, why Amazon rain
from male chauvinism centric world to eco-cultural forest is on fire, why indigenous people are
development of all notions. In this respect of India becoming homeless refugees, why farmers are
and any other thriving countries, ecofeminism is forced to suicide, what is the relation between
exigent to disclose the absorptions and aggressions the right of ‘Mother Earth’ and the right of
over our ecology and its possessing, by the booming corporation and militarized states.
countries in the approaches of spatial inequality, Lastly Dipak Giri’s article on Anita Desai’s Fire
urbanization, political and cultural aspects of life. on the Mountain tries to explore not only the fight
In such a way, to analyse the fact that gender and struggle of women to set them free along with
discrimination is a big question today, it is very nature from the subjugation and oppression of
important to uncover the relation of nature with masculine culture but also their attempts to
all living beings. Today, ecofeminism is playing a subvert the age-old gender binary in terms of
vital role in the importance of the integration of nature/culture dichotomy. Since the feminist
nature and women through which the attitude of movement in the late 1960s, one issue over which
the dictatorship of a patriarchal society is eroded. discussion has often been held is to what extent
Garai’s paper focuses on the selected poetries of the oppositional role of women and men can be
Kamala Das and Sarojini Naidu, which are conceived of in terms of nature-culture dichotomy
fecundated with the essence of ecofeminism with and what implication this dichotomy actually gives
its post- colonial progeny in the Indian socio- as regards to the position of women in society. As
political and cultural environment that create a per this dichotomy, masculine culture/feminine
path against subalternity and male-chauvinism nature binary appeared later and this binary gave
society with confessional motifs through the major birth to many binaries like mind/body, objective/
streams of ecofeminism: Radical ecofeminism, subjective, rational/emotional, public/private, in
Spiritual ecofeminism, ecofeminist theology, social each of which the former is indicative to masculine
ecofeminism and socialist ecofeminism. culture, whereas the later to feminine nature. By
this formulation, women are victims of universal
devaluation that stems out from the patriarchal to express my heartfelt love and regard to all my
way of looking woman as nature-identified and family members for their adequate support by
perceiving them as such, male society is devaluing creating congenial atmosphere around me from
and derogating them in comparison to culture intial to final stage of this project. Last but not
which as per this logic, is completely under the the least I want to be thankful to all my contributors
domain of man, can mould nature and woman as whose strong and deep faith on me helps me to
per its requirement and thus establish its bring out this anthology to its final shape.
superiority over them. Disregarding this nature- Dipak Giri
culture dichotomy, ecofeminism seeks plea for the December, 2019 Cooch Behar (WB), India
equality of woman with men and in this regard, it dipakgiri84@yahoo.in
differs from liberal feminism which only believes
in the freedom of women. As an ecofeminist text,
Anita Desai’s Fire on the Mountain presents the
struggle of characters in accepting this nature-
culture dichotomy. This struggle is apparent in
their role and action. The female characters in
the novel, being identifiable with nature, seek
solace and freedom in nature in order to escape
masculine culture, whereas men go to the extreme
to control them. In this struggle and fight, women
do not retreat even in adverse situation, though
they are succumbed to masculine culture and are
even made victim of death and destruction. The
paper tries to explore not only the fight and struggle
of women to set them free along with nature from
the subjugation and oppression of masculine
culture but also their attempts to subvert the age-
old gender binary in terms of nature/culture
dichotomy.
Before coming to the conclusive word of this
introductory note, let me first thank to the
Almighty God for His constant Benedictions from
the beginning of this anthology to its fruitful end.
I also want to express my special thanks and
gratitude to AABS Publishing House, Kolkata for
bringing this anthology timely and elegantly. I want

View publication stats

You might also like