Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Jane Eyre and Romantic Love
Jane Eyre and Romantic Love
REFERENCES
Linked references are available on JSTOR for this article:
http://www.jstor.com/stable/463696?seq=1&cid=pdf-
reference#references_tab_contents
You may need to log in to JSTOR to access the linked references.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide
range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and
facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
https://about.jstor.org/terms
is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Tulsa Studies in Women's
Literature
Jean Wyatt
Occidental College
Jane Eyre has been a focus for feminist literary analysis from the first: early
texts that have subsequently become models of feminist criticism, like
Elaine Showalter's A Literature of Their Own, Ellen Moers' Literary Women,
Patricia Spacks' The Female Imagination, and Sandra M. Gilbert and Susan
Gubar's A Madwoman in the Attic, all give Jane Eyre a central place. Gilbert
and Gubar take their title from Jane Eyre because of its psychological
relevance: they rightly point out that its imagery of enclosure and escape
and its doubling of the female self into the good girl Jane and the criminally
passionate Bertha reflect the experiences and corresponding psychic pat?
terns of women living under patriarchy.1 The note of self-recognition in
many women's emotional responses to Jane Eyre seems to corroborate the
critics' sense of its psychological significance. Harriet Martineau said, in her
autobiography published in 1877, "I was convinced that it was by some
friend of my own, who had portions of my childish experience in his or her
mind."2 A century later, Adrienne Rich reported she was "carried away as by
a whirlwind" when she read Jane Eyre as a child; she returned to it in her
twenties, her thirties, and again in her forties, drawn by "some nourishment
I needed and still need today."3 Jane Lazarre found in "that adored book of
my childhood, Jane Eyre," self-validation, an affirmation of her own rebel
identity; like Rich she reread it twenty years later to find a new perspective
on her own problems.4 These women echo voices from my own experience:
students in Women in Literature classes, as well as female colleagues a
generation older, respond to Jane Eyre passionately, feel it has something
important to say about their own lives.
I want to explore the interaction between novels and female fantasy
patterns by asking two related questions about reader response to Jane Eyre.
First, how can we explain that women widely separate in time and nation?
ality share psychic patterns that make them recognize in Jane Eyre hidden
truths about their own inner lives? Second, since girls often read Jane Eyre at
a formative time in their lives, what fantasies does it offer them? Does it
reinforce fantasy patterns acquired from growing up female in the Western
nuclear family, or does its appeal come from the pattern of resistance to
199
200
201
"Woman is the Sleeping Beauty, Cinderella, Snow White, she who receives and submits.
In song and story the young man... slays the dragon, he battles giants: she is locked in a
tower, a palace, a garden, a cave, she is chained to a rock, a captive, sound asleep: she
waits.11
And when he enters, of course, "real life" begins. The romantic pattern
recapitulates the distribution of power and mobility to father and daughter:
he comes and goes as he likes, she remains cooped up in the house, awaiting
his return. His arrival injects some of the glamor of the outside world into
the domestic round, so that at the moment of his homecoming life seems
intensified.12
Rochester slips right into the slot prepared for him in the reader's
unconscious: "I am old enough to be your father," he reminds Jane at
202
The ground was hard, the air was still, my road was lonely.... the charm of the hour lay
in its approaching dimness.... I was... in a lane noted for wild roses in summer, for
nuts and blackberries in autumn.. .but whose best winter delight lay in its utter
solitude and leafless repose. If a breath of air stirred, it made no sound here; for there was
not a holly, not an evergreen to rustle, and the stripped hawthorn and hazel bushes were
as still as the white, worn stones.... Far and wide, on each side, there were only fields,
where no cattle now browsed.... in the absolute hush I could hear. .. thin murmurs of
life [from the distant village of Hay].... A rude noise broke on these fine ripplings and
whisperings... a positive tramp, tramp; a metallic clatter, which effaced the soft wave-
wanderings. (11445)
203
204
With a fierce cry.. . the clothed hyena rose up... . the maniac bellowed.... I recog?
nized that purple face ?those bloated features.... "That is my wife" said
[Rochester].... "and this is what I wished to have. . . this young girl.... Compare these
clear eyes with the red balls yonder?this face with that mask?this form with that
bulk." (295-96)
"This young girl," or the reader identifying with her, can rest secure with this
unambiguous declaration of preference: the desired father considers her a
fresh pure radiance, his wife a monster. Rochester wants to keep Jane
innocent, "wants to find in her the very opposite of that aggressive sexuality,
that uncontrollable passionate will that has its form in Bertha," as Helene
Moglen says (127). So he defines her femininity as elfin?that is, confined to
a world of fantasy that excludes sexuality?or childlike: "a little sunny-faced
girl with. . . dimpled cheeks and rosy lips" (260), "this one little English girl"
(271). He thus underlines, continuously, his attraction to a childlike Jane,
reinforcing the parallel with a father's flattering attentions to his female
child. Oedipal fantasy has it both ways, as usual in Jane Eyre: the father
figure makes a clear statement of undivided love for his girl; yet the existence
of Bertha prohibits his acting it out.
How does Charlotte Bronte manage a reader's oedipal anxiety in the end,
then, when?Bertha dead?Jane returns to marry Rochester? Jane's adven?
tures alone, after the discovery of Bertha, follow the plan of a child leaving
the parental home to establish his/her own place in the world. Jane leaves
the patriarchal mansion governed by Rochester to find work and establish a
family of her own. But, unlike a girl who has to leave an adored father
behind forever, Jane unexpectedly discovers that her new family (Diane,
Mary, and St. John Rivers) are actually blood relations?cousins, or, as she
affectionately calls them, "brother and sisters." Bronte thus turns the newly
established family unit into Jane's original one, which Jane must now leave
to marry an exagomous lover?Rochester after all. By thus manipulating the
blood-lines of Jane's kinship chart Bronte effectively disguises what is after
all the fulfillment of the oedipal dream, eternal and exclusive union with the
father figure.
205
206
I,. .fancied myself in idea his wife. Oh! it would never do! As his curate, his com?
rade .... my heart and mind would be free. I should still have my unblighted self to turn
to: my natural unenslaved feelings with which to communicate in. moments of lone?
liness. There would be recesses in my mind which would be only mine, to which he
207
"If I were to marry you, you would kill me. You are killing me now." (415)
All this was torture to me?refined, lingering torture. It kept up a slow fire of indigna?
tion, and a trembling trouble of grief, which harrassed and crushed me altogether. I felt
how?if I were his wife, this good man.. .could soon kill me. (413)
Jane brings out the full emotional weight of pain and indignation implicit in
the image of Bertha's "slow fire." Bertha's death borrows meaning retro?
spectively from Jane's images of violent annihilation. Jane feels not only
"banished," but "banned" (414) by St. John?deleted like Bertha from the
rolls of patriarchy for transgressing patriarchal limits on female behavior.
208
209
I have now been married ten years. I know what it is to live entirely for and with what I
love best on earth. I hold myself supremely blest?blest beyond what language can
express: because I am my husband's life as fully as he is mine. No woman was ever nearer
to her mate than I am; ever more absolutely bone of his bone, and flesh of his flesh. I
know no weariness of my Edward's society: he knows none of mine, any more than we
each do of the pulsation of the heart that beats in our separate bosoms; consequently, we
are ever together. To be together is for us to be at once as free as in solitude, as gay as in
company. We talk, I believe, all day long: to talk to each other is but a more animated
and an audible thinking. All my confidence is bestowed on him, all his confidence is
devoted to me; we are precisely suited in character?perfect concord is the result. (454)
I have quoted the passage at length because the tone is important. Karen
Rowe claims that by the time Jane marries, Bronte has found the fairytale
210
211
His form was of the same strong and stalwart contour as ever: his port was still erect, his
hair was still raven black. . .not in one year's space, by any sorrow, could his athletic
strength be quelled, or his vigorous prime blighted. But in his countenance, I saw a
change. . . that reminded me of some wronged and fettered wild beast or bird, dan?
gerous to approach.... The caged eagle. . . might look as looked that sightless Samson.
(434)
212
213
NOTES
1The Madwoman in the Attic (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1979). I am indebted to
Gilbert and Gubar's analysis of Bronte's structures of confinement and rage, and more generally
to the inspiration of their example in unearthing the female psychic patterns reflected in
women's literature.
2Quoted from Martineau's Autobiography (1877) in Ellen Moers, literary Women (Garden
City, New York: Doubleday, 1977), 99.
3"Jane Eyre: The Temptations of a Motherless Woman," Ms. 2 (October, 1973), 68.
4"'Charlotte's Web': Reading Jane Eyre over Time," in Between Women (Boston: Beaco
Press, 1984), 223.
5Dianne SadofT points out the father-daughter configurations in Villette and Shirley as well
as Jane Eyre, arguing persuasively that Bronte's dependence on her own father as well as he
angry need to free herself from that dependency inspire certain recurrent patterns of interac?
tion with father figures (or real fathers, in the case of Polly Home in Villette). Sadofffocuses on
different set of parallels with father-daughter arrangements than I do, highlighting patterns of
fathers abandoning and punishing their daughters and daughters in turn punishing their fathers
in "narrative castrations [thatl appear to be an exaggerated attempt to free [Bronte's] heroin
214
215
216