Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1 Aula de Autismo
1 Aula de Autismo
Purpose: To determine whether participation in aerobic exercise before classroom activities improves aca-
demic engagement and reduces stereotypic behaviors in young children with autism spectrum disorder.
Methods: This study employed a within-subjects crossover design, using a treatment condition (aerobic
exercise) and a control condition, across 4 classrooms. The treatment condition included 15 minutes of
running/jogging followed by a classroom task. The control condition included a classroom task not pre-
ceded by exercise. The number of stereotypic behaviors, percentage of on-task behavior, and correct/incorrect
responses were measured. The Wilcoxon signed rank test was used to compare differences between condi-
tions. Results: Statistically significant improvements were found in correct responding following exercise (P
< .05). No significant differences were found for on-task behavior or stereotypic behaviors. Conclusions:
Consistent with findings in older children, these results indicate that aerobic exercise prior to classroom ac-
tivities may improve academic responding in young children with autism spectrum disorder. (Pediatr Phys
Ther 2011;23:187–193) Key words: aerobic exercise, attention, autism spectrum disorder, child, educational
activities, physical therapy/methods, special education, stereotypic movement disorder/therapy
Wilkins and the Section on Pediatrics of the American Physical in children with ASD that make participation with peers
Therapy Association difficult.9 Although few studies have explored the physical
Correspondence: Kathryn N. Oriel, PT, EdD, Department of Physical
activity patterns of children with ASD,5 social constraints,
Therapy, Lebanon Valley College, 101 N College Ave, Annville, PA 17003 more than existing impairments, could be the limiting fac-
(oriel@lvc.edu). tor affecting physical activity.10
Grant Support: This study was funded by the PLEET Grant through
Lebanon Valley College.
The effect of exercise on stereotypic behaviors in chil-
dren with ASD has been explored in the literature. Kern
DOI: 10.1097/PEP.0b013e318218f149
et al11 examined the effect of exercise on 3 children with
Pediatric Physical Therapy Effects of Aerobic Exercise on Academic Performance in ASD 187
Copyright © 2011 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins and the Section on Pediatrics of the American Physical Therapy
Association. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
ASD between 7 and 11 years of age. Results indicated METHODS
that stereotypic behaviors decreased following vigorous Study Design
jogging (mildly strenuous, with the child showing in-
creased breathing rate and/or flushed face) for 15 minutes, This study used a within-subjects crossover design,
although little or no reduction was observed following mild with a treatment condition and a control condition, across
exercise (ball playing, where an adult gently threw a ball 4 early intervention classrooms. Two of the 4 classes were
to a child from a distance of 2-3 m, at a rate of 10-12 randomly assigned to the treatment condition and 2 to
times per minute).11 Watters and Watters12 found similar the control condition for the first 3 weeks of the study.
results in 5 boys with ASD between 9 and 11 years of age. During the subsequent 3 weeks of the study, each class re-
They found that the greatest decrease in stereotypic behav- ceived the opposite condition. The treatment condition in-
ior was found following physical activity (jogging in the cluded 15 minutes of running/jogging followed by a class-
schoolyard alongside teachers for 8-10 minutes) as com- room task. The control condition included participation
pared with academic work or television viewing. Similarly, in a classroom task that was not preceded by aerobic exer-
a study examining three 11-year-old children (2 males and cise. The number of stereotypic behaviors demonstrated,
1 female) with ASD found that stereotypic behaviors de- the percentage of on-task behavior, and the numbers of
creased after 15 minutes of continuous jogging. This study correct/incorrect responses given during academic tasks
also examined carryover of the decreased stereotypic be- for each child were recorded throughout the duration of
haviors and found that the behavior carryover was limited the study, regardless of condition, to allow for comparison.
to 90 minutes postintervention.13 According to Spencer et al,19 the crossover design
Petrus et al4 conducted a current, systematic review minimizes the effects of preexisting differences between
of studies measuring the effects of exercise on stereotypic classrooms, such as academic levels of students, age/grade
behaviors of children with ASD. The 7 studies included a levels, as well as differences in curricula. In this design,
total of 25 subjects. Twenty-two were older children (6-15 each student receives both treatments and serves as his or
years old) with ASD, and 3 were younger children (3-5 her own control, which also minimizes the possibility of
years old). In the 3 studies including younger children, differential attrition within treatment conditions. Finally,
the exercise programs involved walking versus jogging, teacher effects are accounted for since teachers provide the
jogging, and jogging versus ball playing.11,14,15 Only jog- instruction in both conditions.19 In special education class-
ging resulted in a decrease in stereotypic behaviors.15 room research studies, the crossover design has been used
Three of the 7 studies also measured academic performance successfully “to address problems inherent in between-
following exercise.4 Watters and Watters12 reported no ef- classrooms matching.”19-23
fect on academic responding following exercise, but 2 stud-
ies did report improved academic responding following
jogging.15,16 In addition, Rosenthal-Malek and Mitchell16 Participants
documented an increase in on-task behavior after aerobic This study was approved by the Institutional Review
exercise. Board at Lebanon Valley College. A purposive sample of
The effect of exercise on academic performance was convenience was used. The participants in this study were
examined by Kern et al.15 They found that jogging, at recruited from 4 early intervention autistic support class-
a speed that increased the subjects’ breathing rate and rooms. The 24 children in these early intervention class-
elicited flushed faces, decreased stereotypic behavior and rooms had a diagnosis of ASD and were between the ages of
increased appropriate play (ie, on-task time) and academic 3 and 6 years. The families of all children attending these
performance.15 Similar results were found by Elliot et al17 classes were sent a letter explaining the study and a consent
in their study examining 6 adults with ASD. These re- form. All children who returned a signed parental consent
searchers found that aerobic activity increased appropriate form were included in the study. Ultimately, 7 males and
behavior and decreased off-task time in this population. 2 females between the ages of 3 and 6 years (mean age,
Powers et al18 found similar results in an 8-year-old child 5.2 years) participated. Seven of the children had a formal
with ASD. They reported a decrease in stereotypic behavior diagnosis of autism, while 1 had a diagnosis of intellec-
and an increase in on-task performance following a roller tual disability, and 1 had a diagnosis of developmental
skating intervention for 10 minutes. delay. Although 2 of the children had a primary diagno-
Aerobic exercise has been shown to improve correct sis of intellectual disability and developmental delay, all
responding, improve on-task time, and reduce stereotypic children in the early intervention autistic support class-
behaviors in older children (6-15 years old) with ASD, al- rooms met the educational criteria for ASD as defined by
though few studies have explored such an effect in young the Individuals with Disabilities Education Improvement Act
children (3-5 years old).4,11-18 The purpose of this study of 2004.24 Otherwise, they would not be enrolled in these
was to determine whether participation in aerobic exer- classrooms.
cise before classroom activities improves academic engage- To qualify for enrollment in these early interven-
ment and reduces stereotypic behaviors in young children tion autistic support classrooms, children must present
with ASD. with more severe symptoms along the continuum of ASD.
Pediatric Physical Therapy Effects of Aerobic Exercise on Academic Performance in ASD 189
Copyright © 2011 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins and the Section on Pediatrics of the American Physical Therapy
Association. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
TABLE 1
Operational Definitions
Term Definition
Correct academic response A child responds correctly to a directive given by the teacher
Incorrect academic response A child responds incorrectly or provides no response to a directive given by the teacher
Stereotypic behavior Behaviors conducive to autism spectrum disorder, such as hand-and-arm flapping, body rocking, and toe walking
On-task behavior Percentage of time the child is seated and is consistently responding to teacher directives
Fig. 1. Percentage of correct responding during the control and treatment phases for each participant.
stereotypic behaviors in the traditional and exercise con- ing was found to be 71.49 on control days versus 82.57
dition. This nonparametric test was used because the para- on treatment days. These improvements were found to be
metric assumptions of homogeneity and normality were statistically significant (P < .05). Figure 1 displays the
not met. The SPSS statistical program was used and the mean differences for correct responding between the con-
level of significance was set at α = .05. trol and treatment phases of the study for each of the 9
participants.
RESULTS On-task time. No significant differences were found
Interrater Reliability between the 2 conditions for on-task behavior. The mean
percentage of time on task during control days was 94.48
Participants were observed by more than 1 rater to versus 95.92 on treatment days. While statistical signifi-
establish interrater reliability on 83% of observations (10 cance was not observed, visual analysis of the data revealed
of the 12 days). Intraclass correlation coefficients (2,k) that 5 of the 9 participants improved in on-task time fol-
were calculated for correct responses, incorrect responses, lowing the exercise condition. Figure 2 displays the mean
time on task, and number of stereotypic behaviors ob- differences for time on task between the control and treat-
served, and were found to be 0.97, 0.84, 0.96, and 1.0, ment phases of the study for each of the 9 participants.
respectively. These rates were consistent with other stud- Stereotypic behaviors. No significant differences were
ies that reported interrater reliability. Researchers reported observed between conditions for stereotypic behaviors,
collecting interrater reliability data in 50% to 100% of the although only 5 of the 9 participants demonstrated stereo-
sessions and reported reliability rates ranging from 70% to typic behaviors on at least 1 observation day. Table 2
100%.11,13-15 provides a summary of the total number of stereotypic
behaviors observed during the treatment and control con-
Treatment Condition Versus Control Condition ditions. While no statistical significance was observed, 4
Correct/incorrect responses. Seven of the 9 partici- of the 5 participants demonstrated fewer stereotypic be-
pants improved in correct responding following the ex- haviors during the intervention phase of the study. Table
ercise condition. The mean percentage of correct respond- 3 summarizes the results of this study.
DISCUSSION TABLE 2
Total Number of Stereotypic Behaviors Observeda
In this study, 7 of the 9 participants improved in cor-
rect responding following the treatment condition. It is Participant Control Condition Treatment Condition
important to note that the 2 children who did not improve
1 1 0
in correct responding may not have expended as much en- 2 4 0
ergy when exercising. Exercise logs indicate that these 2 3 0 2
children were more difficult to motivate to exercise and, 4 4 0
thus, spent less time exercising than their peers. 5 2 0
While we found statistically significant improvements a Four children exhibited no stereotypic behaviors during observation
in correct responding following 15 minutes of running, times.
similar to other studies described in the literature in which
jogging continued for 20 minutes, shorter durations of ex-
ercise should be explored.15,16 It would be beneficial to dren demonstrated stereotypic behaviors. Even among
educators and school-based physical therapists to know the 5 children who demonstrated stereotypic behaviors,
whether shorter durations of exercise are capable of pro- the stereotypic behaviors observed were few (Table 2).
ducing the same gains in academic responding, as shorter Those stereotypic behaviors observed included hand-and-
durations of exercise would be even more feasible to imple- arm flapping, rocking, and toe walking. Whereas stereo-
ment during the school day. Although academic respond- typic behaviors were observed, there were less stereotypic
ing was not measured by Celiberti et al,14 they found de- behaviors observed following exercise. The total number
creased stereotypic behaviors following jogging for 6 min- of stereotypic behaviors across participants decreased from
utes in a 5-year-old boy with ASD. Further research is 11 during the control days to 2 during the treatment days,
warranted to determine the duration of exercise needed as which may be a clinically significant finding.
well as the intensity to produce academic and behavioral The few stereotypic behaviors observed may have
changes in young children with ASD.16 been a direct result of the structure provided within these
Whereas statistically significant improvements were autistic support classrooms. Teachers used immediate and
not observed in the amount of time on task or in stereotypic consistent verbal prompts (eg, “quiet hands”) when stereo-
behaviors, the trends observed were encouraging. Five of typic behavior began. Use of these prompts may be reduc-
the 9 participants (55.6%) improved in on-task time. This ing or minimizing the demonstration of stereotypic behav-
trend is consistent with the few other studies that have iors, such as hand flapping, over time.
examined the effect of exercise on on-task time in children Further research should also examine the duration of
with ASD.17,18 Similar findings of improved on-task time treatment effects. In this study, improvements in academic
have also been described in children developing typically responding continued for 30 minutes following aerobic
after exercise.26 exercise. Kern et al15 found that self-stimulatory behav-
Given that the children participating in this study ior always decreased following jogging and did not re-
were all enrolled in early intervention autistic support turn to baseline until 90 minutes later. While these re-
classrooms, it was unexpected that only 5 of the 9 chil- searchers also reported that on-task behavior and academic
Pediatric Physical Therapy Effects of Aerobic Exercise on Academic Performance in ASD 191
Copyright © 2011 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins and the Section on Pediatrics of the American Physical Therapy
Association. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
TABLE 3
Summary of Results
responding always increased following jogging, the du- implement, offering a strategy for improving academic re-
ration of these behaviors was not reported. Similarly, sponding.
Rosenthal-Malek and Mitchell16 found statistically signifi-
cant increases in correct responding and number of tasks
completed following aerobic exercise but did not examine REFERENCES
the duration of these effects.
1. Heward W. Exceptional Children: An Introduction to Special Education.
Although the results of this study are encouraging, 9th ed. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Merrill; 2009.
limitations must be noted. This study was of a short dura- 2. Hooper SR, Umansky W. Young Children With Special Needs. 5th ed.
tion, so it is unclear whether improvements in academic re- Upper Saddle River, NJ: Merrill; 2009.
sponding would increase, maintain, or decrease over time. 3. National Institute of Child Health and Human Development.
National Institutes of Health. http://www.nichd.nih.gov/health/
The lack of measurement of exercise intensity was also a
topics/asd/cfm. Published 2008. Accessed April 21, 2009.
limitation of this study. Whereas the measurement of heart 4. Petrus C, Adamson SR, Block L, Einarson SJ, Sharifnejad M, Harris SR.
rate using a pulse oximeter was the original intent of the Effects of exercise interventions on stereotypic behaviours in children
authors, the participants in this study were unable to toler- with autism spectrum disorder. Physiother Can. 2008;60(2):134-145.
ate the use of the device. The device was given to the class- 5. Pan C, Frey GC. Physical activity patterns in youth with autism
spectrum disorders. J Autism Dev Disord. 2006;36:597-606.
room teachers 4 weeks before the initiation of the study
6. Todd R, Reid G. Increasing physical activity in individuals with
in an attempt to improve participant tolerance of its use, autism. Focus Autism Other Dev Disord. 2006;21(3):167-176.
although when the study began, the teachers continued to 7. Berkley S, Zittel L, Pitney L, Nichols S. Locomotor and object con-
report an increase in inappropriate behaviors with the use. trol skills of children diagnosed with autism. Adapt Phys Act Q.
While we used observation to monitor increased breathing 2001;18(4):405-416.
8. Manjiviona J, Prior M. Comparison of Asperger’s syndrome and high-
and flushed faces; consistent with Rosenthal-Malek and
functioning autistic children on a test of motor impairment. J Autism
Mitchel,16 using a more objective means to quantify exer- Dev Disord. 1995;25(1):23-39.
cise intensity should be considered in future studies. 9. Fox KR, Riddoch C. Charting the physical activity patterns of con-
Finally, since few studies have examined the effect of temporary children and adolescents. Proc Nutr Soc. 2000;59:1-8.
aerobic exercise on the academic performance of young 10. Llewellyn A, Hogan K. The use and abuse of models of disability.
Disabil Soc. 2000;15(1):157-165.
children with ASD, further research is recommended
11. Kern L, Koegel RL, Dunlap G. The influence of vigorous ver-
to replicate these results. The National Autism Center’s sus mild exercise on autistic stereotyped behaviors. J Autism Dev
National Standards Project lists exercise as an emerging Disord. 1984;14(1):57-67.
treatment for individuals with ASD and recommends fur- 12. Watters RG, Watters WE. Decreasing self-stimulatory behavior with
ther research in this area.25 Findings from this report also physical exercise in a group of autistic boys. J Autism Dev Disord.
1980;10(4):379-387.
recommend that treatments be applied in the “real world”
13. Levinson LJ, Reid G. The effects of exercise intensity on the stereo-
versus laboratory settings to determine whether the results typic behaviors of individuals with autism. Adapt Phys Act Q.
found in laboratory settings will generalize.25 Therefore, it 1993;10:255-268.
is recommended that future studies of the effects of aerobic 14. Celiberti DA, Bobo HE, Kelly KS, Harris SI, Handleman JS. The differ-
exercise on the academic performance of young children ential and temporal effects of antecedent exercise on self-stimulatory
behaviour of a child with autism. Res Dev Disabil. 1997;18(5):139-
with ASD be conducted by physical therapists and teachers
168.
who educate and support these children daily. 15. Kern L, Koegel RL, Dyer K, Blew PA, Fenton LR. The effects of
physical exercise on self-stimulation and appropriate responding in
autistic children. J Autism Dev Disord. 1982;12(4):399-412.
CONCLUSION 16. Rosenthal-Malek A, Mitchell S. Brief report: the effects of exercise on
self stimulatory behaviours and positive responding of adolescents
Results of this study indicate that aerobic exercise with autism. J Autism Dev Disord. 1997;27(2):193-201.
prior to classroom activities may improve academic re- 17. Elliot R, Dobbin A, Rose G, Soper H. Vigorous, aerobic exercise versus
sponding in young children with ASD. These preliminary general motor training activities: effect on maladaptive and stereo-
typic behaviors of adults with both autism and mental retardation.
results are consistent with similar findings in older chil-
J Autism Dev Disord. 1994;24(5):565-576.
dren. Results of this study help substantiate the impor- 18. Powers S, Thibadeau S, Roase K. Antecedent exercise and its
tance of aerobic exercise in young children with ASD. The effect on self stimulation. Behav Residential Treat. 1992;7(1):
15 minutes of aerobic exercise was feasible and easy to 15-22.
Pediatric Physical Therapy Effects of Aerobic Exercise on Academic Performance in ASD 193
Copyright © 2011 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins and the Section on Pediatrics of the American Physical Therapy
Association. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.