Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PRESENTED TO THE
OF AMA BAGUIO
REQUIREMENTS
JUNE 2, 2022
1
INTRODUCTION
The current international system for protecting intellectual property was fashioned during
the age of industrialization in the West and developed subsequently in line with the perceived
needs of technologically advanced societies.1 The Philippines is home to many indigenous peoples
and communities. Away from the megacities of Manila, Cebu, and Davao, there exist indigenous
communities living in far-flung areas and mountainous regions in the Philippines mostly
untouched by the technological advancements of urban life where the internet and skyways are
mostly unheard of. For better or for worse, these indigenous communities have remained mostly
insulated from the rigors of city life and have survived the trials of everyday life using traditional
methods of hunting, fishing, cooking, and expressing themselves through dance, music, and other
rituals. Some have ventured into living in urban towns and cities to experience the harsh realities
of modern living, only to go back to their communities in the mountains to which they truly belong.
In Philippine history, our country has been conquered by the Spaniards for more than three
hundred years. During those times, the manner of making artistic creations by our Filipino
ancestors have been influenced by the Spaniards. The latter, not just only conquered our country
for their benefit, but also helped our ancestors during those times especially to the country's
1
WIPO. Traditional Knowledge and Intellectual Property
2Cruz, C. (2017). Intellectual Property of Indigenous Peoples (IP of IP): Challenges in Protecting
Traditional Knowledge in the Philippines
2
economy, lifestyle and culture. Thus, most of our ancestors’ artistic creations are heavily
influenced by Spanish culture and less than the American and Japanese cultures.
This study aims to identify issues and needs of the Indigenous People for the protection of
their intellectual properties. It is to establish the historical essence which has long been existing,
even before modern technologies emerged as well as for the Philippine government to legislate
measures in giving importance to the recognition of these historical traditions of the Indigenous
peoples. This study will be beneficial to the NGOs, since some of them lacks information on how
to address the social issues with regards to the intellectual property rights of our indigenous people.
It has been repeatedly said, with the right information, we can achieve greater lengths.
Indigenous people in the Philippines have a vibrant and diverse culture. It is reflected in
the various traditional and cultural knowledge, rites, practices, and art. Indigenous peoples have
the right to protect these intellectual properties, including the right to protect such rights against
their inappropriate use or exploitation. This study aims to seek the protection of indigenous
people’s traditional knowledge, rites, practices, and art from commercial exploitation brought by
3
THEORETICAL AND CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK
By studying the laws that are already present in our Philippine Laws and Jurisprudence,
the researcher intends to inculcate the traditions that have been long practiced by the indigenous
people. By studying history and other laws, the researchers would be able to determine the
possibility of creating a new understanding of our Philippine history, that would directly and
Knowledge.
This paper will focus on achieving to answer the historical foundation of the emergence of
intellectual property rights of our indigenous people, by analyzing the laws, especially the
historical traditions for Intellectual Property and their application to the protection of Intellectual
Property and knowledge. Traditional or historical knowledge like the practices and the art are to
be determined as to what kind of artwork will be categorized to determine the extent of protection
it can afford under the present Intellectual Property Code of the Philippines. The inapplicability of
our present laws in protecting this traditional knowledge will then be compared or related with the
historical foundation, influences, and original Filipino culture, that are focused on protecting the
4
HYPOTHESIS
distinction among peoples in the country into mainstream Christian/Muslim and peripheral
communities were deprived of the right to their ancestral domains. Through so-called
“development” activities, they were dispossessed of the land they till for their livelihood . Their
marginalization, dispossession, and other forms of injustices continued long after the colonial rule
had gone.3 In the furtherance of our study, we will learn that there are real advantages brought
about by such countries, especially when it comes to intellectual creations of our ancestors and
also up to today. Since the intention for the creation of artistic and literary works of our indigenous
peoples is to make the exhibition of Filipino everyday life and its surroundings as authentic and as
This study shall be limited to studying further the history of the intellectual property rights
of indigenous people in the Philippines, with regards to their traditional knowledge. How the
history of our country during the Spanish, American, and Japanese conquest. Furthermore, how
5
Intellectual Property Law was made following traditional knowledge and history. As being
implemented for the benefit of the Indigenous peoples’ Intellectual Property rights. How history
The researchers’ data collection is limited to the data collection from a review of existing
related literature, such as publicly available information, peer-reviewed articles, government, and
industry reports, among others, to have a better understanding and appreciation of the issues
regarding traditional cultural expressions on one hand, and the conventional intellectual property
system on the other, there is a need to discuss each separately. After knowing each component, a
discussion of how one intersects with the other shall be made. A survey of the laws on intellectual
property relevant to traditional cultural expressions shall be made followed by an analysis of its
RESEARCH INSTRUMENT
In this research, I, the researcher used different questions with regards to my respondents
and they are further explained in the interviews that are conducted.
RESEARCH QUESTIONS
Interview with one of the persons available, Ms. Rose De Guzman, in Narda’s weaving, located
6
I have thought of interviewing several prospective persons, which are about indigenous
persons and their intellectual creations. The long list continues to belong, but I have chosen a store
that repeatedly catches my attention whenever I pass through the Upper Session Road in Baguio
City. Ms. Rose De Guzman is one of those persons that is available for an interview during such
time. During our talk, she agreed that many people are coming to our country, the Philippines, and
trying to get credit for everything that Indigenous People have, from natural sciences to musical
instruments, from patent laws to copyright laws. Some people come over to harness these materials
that we have and he insists that we must report it to the authorities after confirming with the elders
of the community and gaining free and prior informed consent on the matter. Getting in touch with
the elders and leaders of the community will comply with the requirement of FPIC or free and
She had shared that Narda’s weaving started in the early '70s, when its founder, Narda
Capuyan, which is where Narda’s is named after, was fond of making knits as her hobby. As it
was said that women in the early times are meant to stay at home and for them to be able to keep
themselves busy, aside from doing house chores, is to make knits, resulting in clothes, and similar
to such, by expressing distinct and unique patterns, evincing their creativity and talents, as well as
what indigenous tribe or group they belonged to. I agreed with what Ms. De Guzman explained
and raised a question regarding copyright issues of Sagada Weaving and Narda's as examples of
commercializing the original arts of the Cordillera, specifically their weaving patterns that are used
as designs of bags, sashed, clothes, and other materials. She expounded on connecting traditional
7
designs and techniques with weaving textiles being commercialized. She made mention of having
no concrete laws to define the delineation between what can be controlled by the community and
She had also repeated the fact that those who venture into these businesses, like them,
Narda’s weaving and Sagada weaving are also indigenous peoples themselves. The question here
is, where can we make a compromise so much so that even if entrepreneurs like Narda’s and
Sagada Weaving can develop these materials, there is a way by which they can also share it with
the community because this weaving tradition, for instance, is not just owned by families but by
the whole community just like tattooing. As my interview goes further with Ms. De Guzman, I
have learned that another example of intellectual creations is the cultural dances, which in modern
times, are allowed to be modernized to adapt to present society. That is why the protection
guaranteed in this ritual is among the following: First, people are coming into the office of NCIP
who would like to implement these rituals and traditions, but as a source of protection, and to
ensure cultural sensitivity they have to undergo the NCIP process. There is a need to be culturally
sensitive because there are areas or there are certain rituals or traditions, like traditional
I have also shared with my interviewee the current issue about Whang-od and Nas Daily.
She states that, when it comes to this ritual connected to Wang-Od, there are certain requirements
of the community. For instance, before they can perform one activity or event, they have to appease
the spirits. They have to perform the ritual to ask permission from their ancestors. Whang-od is an
artist, which is widely known as the “mambabatok” doing the traditional way of making tattoos on
8
any part of the body. We cannot prohibit her from working or from performing her craft as a tattoo
artist. She can perform but what NCIP is trying to protect is the Intellectual Property of the
community regarding these tattoo designs. These designs are not only attributed to Apo Whang-
od, but because it belongs to the community in general, they own the designs
Senator Lauren Legarda introduced the house bill with the title An Act Safeguarding the
Traditional Property Rights of Indigenous Peoples which aims at the protection and promotion of
indigenous knowledge, systems, and practices. Under IPRA there is a protection of community
property rights, this includes weaving designs. But these weaving designs, under the existing law
in the intellectual property law, have become community property. In the recent controversy, the
weaving designs, which are hand weaved by IPs, are printed with a machine, which results in the
disregard of the pattern's historical significance. With the Intellectual property law enforceable at
the present, the IPs creation cannot be protected in a way as to give significance to historical
tradition. But the bill introduced by Legarda seeks to address the said issues.
With the active participation of our weavers, at least the attention of the public and the
proper authorities are being called out regarding this issue. If the pattern that is used in the design
is the same as that of the community, the consent of the community is needed and may agree to
some stipulations wherein there will be a benefit-sharing. The right of the indigenous people to
share on the benefits in the utilization of these Intellectual Property Rights or these designs
attributable to them or this literature attributable to them. Under the IPRA, we have protection but
this protection is lacking that is why guidelines are issued on acquisition of consent. But for more
9
protection, there should be registered so that at least these designs of the communities will be
perpetually protected by law, and this is the reason behind the bill which is being pushed by Loren
Legarda.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
1. Researched the different cultures of indigenous people, and how the society protects their
intellectual creation, through online PDFs, journal articles, and Philippine history.
I have further researched certain papers, and topics, on how I would interrelate all the
pertinent facts I have gathered. I have researched the different historical and cultural
traditions existing, at the current time, and the knowledge and literacy of the persons
protection. I have compared the information that I have gathered and collated every
information with each other. Indeed, every law that was established by the government has
similarities but varies depending on the specific rights and interests that are protected, and
most especially, laws are made in connection with the indispensable requirement, that is
10
2. Interview with one of the persons available, Ms. Rose De Guzman, in Narda’s weaving, located
During the interview, I have prepared several questions for the manager of Narda’s
weaving to answer. I have classified the questions in a manner that our interviewee would
be able to smoothly explain the current issues, stand, and ways of protection, with regards
to the intellectual property rights of the indigenous people. The questions focused on her
opinions and stand towards the questions, which is about intellectual property rights of
indigenous persons since they are persons belonging to indigenous groups, who create a
distinct and unique weaving to express their tradition, history, and culture, as well as to
earn profit.
3. Watched several documentary films and videos with regards to the cry of our indigenous
peoples’ protection of their intellectual property rights, which are long not addressed by proper
authorities.
To support my findings on this topic, I have researched the different documentary films
about the battle cry of our indigenous peoples. One of the things these indigenous tribes
are being deprived of is education. Having an education is a privilege and not all of us,
citizens of the Philippines have the privilege to study. It has also been long said that
education is the key to success. Once a person has finished education, at least at the basic
level, he has already a piece of knowledge on how the world revolves and how money and
11
career make the world go around. Having been located in a secluded area where such is far
from the commercial and business areas of a province or a city, our indigenous peoples are
having a hard time adapting to the modern changes brought by science and technology. As
for them, they are contented with the way they live, the way they do things, as well as the
manner of their survival, so long as their basic needs are met. Concerning my topic, their
intellectual creations are easily being copied and exploited by persons who are more
knowledgeable with regards to making money out of such creations. The just compensation
that our indigenous people are entitled to, with regards to their intellectual creations are
being deprived of them, and absent of the recognition that they deserve.
It is embodied in our Philippine history that, our country “recognizes and promotes the
rights of indigenous cultural communities within the framework of national unity and
development.” 4 This aligns with the mandate of the Indigenous Peoples Rights Act stating that
"the State shall protect the rights of ICCs/IPs to their ancestral domains to ensure their economic,
social and cultural well-being and shall recognize the applicability of customary laws governing
property rights or relations in determining the ownership and extent of ancestral domain.” 5 This
cultural well-being should inculcate traditional knowledge as part of the identification being
12
protected and recognized in the laws. But policies are not the primary consideration in the conduct
of this research. The essence of Philippine history continuous to become vague, especially to the
younger generations, that we forget to value our country’s cultural traditions and knowledge with
regards to these matters. If our legislators and proper authorities are knowledgeable enough with
regards to our ancient history with regards to our indigenous persons, then the laws to be made
(1) Literary and artistic works (2) Designs are protected by (3) symbols, names, and
Examples: Examples:
WIPO has defined an
Periodicals and newspapers; aesthetic aspect of an article. services of one enterprise from
13
whether or not reduced in an article, or two-dimensional differentiates the products or
writing or other material form; features, such as patterns, services of one from that of
(d) Letters; (e) Dramatic or lines, or colors.6 another. It creates name recall
6Cruz, C. (2017). Intellectual Property of Indigenous Peoples (IP of IP): Challenges in Protecting
Traditional Knowledge in the Philippines
7 Ibid.
14
dimensional works relative to
geography, topography,
scientific or technical
produced by a process
analogous to photography;
a process analogous to
cinematography or any
15
Indigenous Peoples refer to those who have continuously lived as organized communities
in defined territories (ancestral domains) since time immemorial, and they have retained some or
all of their own social, economic, cultural, and political institutions8. The culture, tradition, and
history of Indigenous peoples that should be protected do not only include their ancestral lands
and domains but extends to their intellectual creations. Further, ICCs/IPs have the right to practice
and revitalize their cultural traditions and customs. Intellectual creations of IPs/ICCs are
considered traditional knowledge which is in the form of traditional expressions, practices, and
beliefs, and which is an important community right of indigenous communities that must be
respected and protected. Furthermore, there is a present insufficiency in recognizing the essence
of Philippine history towards the manner of protection for the intellectual property of our
indigenous people because our legislators also lack the proper knowledge in understanding ancient
As cited above, in the case of Apo Whang-od, while there were settlements made with Nas
Academy, according to Ms. De Guzman, the team handling the case intended to use as legal basis
the free prior and informed consent to litigate the case, premised on the fact that the tattoo design
and traditional method of tattooing are communally owned by a tribe of Apo Whang-od. They did
not intend to use the Intellectual Property Code since traditional knowledge such as the tattoo
16
designs and methods of Apo Whang-od are not protected under that law. However, a problem
arises when all the IPs consented or all their consent was vitiated, which means that the free prior
and informed consent would no longer lie as a defense. By this, we can infer that not only that the
problem lies whether or not the designs made by Apo Whang-od should be protected even though
they shall be copied by Nas Daily, but the fact that the essence or the purpose on how Apo Whang-
od’s art is inspired by her cultural tradition and knowledge towards the indigenous or tribal group
IPs/ICCs, whether by the IPs/ICCs or third persons, still requires the free prior and informed
may be prone to more cases of infringements and unfair competition. As a consequence, the
historical value of the intellectual creations of our indigenous persons has been becoming less, for
it is slowly not being known and recognized. The significance of making such is that indigenous
persons express their cultural knowledge and traditions to making such arts and literary pieces, for
us, the society to recognize. Not only to recognize but to make them feel that they are part of the
As discussed above, Narda’s Handwoven Arts and Crafts are just one of those companies,
wherein an Igorot entrepreneur helped popularize Cordillera's woven fabrics locally and overseas
in the 1970s. Concerning the findings above, weaving is one of how our indigenous people express
17
their traditions, and it also serves as their representation. Sadly, none of our laws specifically
protects such weaving, as an art and expression, created by our indigenous people. The lack of
intellectual property protection gives way for manufacturers in earning a profit, by effortlessly
copying specific designs, through the use of machines and high-technology processes. As
discussed, our country lacks specific intellectual property protection, which is clamored by our
indigenous people.
In essence, most of the people in our society nowadays continue to patronize foreign and
imported goods, well, in fact, domestic goods like the ones made by our indigenous persons should
be patronized first by us, the citizens of the Philippines. We can also learn that, many foreigners
who visit the country are very fond of learning our traditions, cultures, and history, that they go
beyond means to learn such. Eating our traditional foods, learning our traditional or tribal dances,
and even speaking Tagalog, are just ways on how foreign people appreciate the existence of our
traditional cultures, which we, ourselves slowly forget and despise to patronize. It is also very
rampant that many foreign persons gave positive feedback with regards to the history of our
country. We are so busy patronizing and being fond of foreign products and practices that it is the
reason for the extinction of our original culture and historical foundation.
One of the factors that make history forgotten is the fact that people have different beliefs
and lacks the virtue of empathy. One of the famous quotes’ states, "No man is an island.” The
18
cultural property, whether tangible or intangible, of the indigenous peoples is a vital part of their
identity, and therefore, must be protected. Their heritage has been passed on from their ancestors,
and the State as Parens Patriae shall ensure that they will still be passed onto future generations .
We can infer from our findings that our legislators do not give ample importance as regards the
historical foundation of the artistic and literary creations of our ancestors. No man can survive
alone without the help of others, or at least without the presence of others. Even though it can be
easy for us to say that we don't need other people and that we have all the things we want, such
thought hurts our personalities. One of the effects is that people often do not care about what others
are going through mainly because it does not primarily affect them. It is known that these creations
can generate more profit from those technology-based businesses. As such, they are not having
any economic benefits with regards to the artistic works they are creating. They are enduring a lot
of sacrifices in crafting such masterpieces but they do not get any reward, compensation, or
recognition towards such. We are wrong for expecting that they want such, what they only want
is for their works to be protected as well as to equally compete with the modern business in the
The internet is a powerful platform nowadays and especially now, during the time of
pandemic because most individuals are using it either as part of daily routine, for their business,
for education, or for many useful purposes. Some have formed organizations to support and protect
the rights of the indigenous people to their intellectual properties, some have taken advantage of
the weakness of the indigenous people by stealing or misappropriating their traditional knowledge.
19
The help of modern technology, we can educate persons more about the creations of our indigenous
peoples, and how the viewers can help them in exhibiting as well as encouraging them to create
more of them, also as a form of earning for a living and producing products which are from their
original culture and traditions, distinct and genuine from every other indigenous tribe.
Even despite the difficulties that the current copyright system presents, it has a sufficient
basic framework to offer protection to the works of indigenous cultures. The creation of another
system would entail a waste of resources, which most countries could not afford. Another
important advantage to using copyright protection is that the entire world has a uniform system
about works subject to such protection. Efforts to adjust existing legal mechanisms will serve as
the foundation for preventing further violations of the rights of indigenous cultures and for
according respect to their works of art. Providing effective protection for works of indigenous
cultures ensures the survival of their history and gives citizens of developing countries a potential
source of income. With this protection, governments can obtain new economic resources and
promote prosperity in their countries, especially among indigenous peoples who are often forgotten
In our small ways, we can help them by joining conferences, webinars, and other talks
which explain and tells the story of our indigenous peoples' struggles through the years as well as
how they battle with the challenges of the modern world. After all, we are stewards of God’s
creations. Thus, even though the principal subject of this research is about the literary and artistic
9 Ibid.
20
creations of our indigenous people, tangible or not, their creators cannot fully protect them, so we,
the more educated ones, can help them in protecting such as well as to help them address further,
Due to the continuous failure of the government to protect the intellectual creation of our
indigenous peoples, they already lacked the trust and confidence in the former. Our social workers
are known to be skilled in such area, and by this, our indigenous peoples can take baby steps to
trust them as well as to build confidence to be reposed upon them, as representatives that they will
clearly and effectively address such problems, difficulties and challenges to the government, and
for the latter to enact proper measures to help our indigenous peoples. The researchers recommend
to future researchers that the conduct of additional learnings with regards to the way of life,
tradition, practice, and cultural heritage of our indigenous people is an indispensable requirement
for our legislators and proper authorities, to formulate an effective and genuine way to protect the
rights of the indigenous people. One of the effective ways to protect the intellectual art and literary
pieces that our ancestral tribes or groups make is to label them. Labeling them as one of that
precious art that is made creatively, and giving recognition to the indigenous people's talents and
skills, in exhibiting them to the public for consumption as well as returning to our indigenous
21
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Isagani Cruz v. Secretary of Environment and Natural Resources, G.R. No. 135385, December 6,
2000
Background Brief No. 1, Traditional Knowledge and Intellectual Property (2015), WIPO, Geneva,
Switzerland
Britney. (2021, October 18). What did the Philippines create in art? From Arts and Journal:
https://artradarjournal.com/art-education/what-did-the-philippinos-create-in-art/
Fleming, E. (2019). Why is indigenous art in the Philippines important? Indigenous Art in the
Philippines, 1.
Posey, D.A. & Dutfield, G. (1996). Beyond Intellectual Property: Toward Traditional Resource
Rights for Indigenous Peoples and Local Communities. International Development Research
Centre.
Terri Janke. (2006). Indigenous cultural and intellectual property. The Main Issues for the
22
Ty, R. (2010, December). Indigenous Peoples in the Philippines: Continuing Struggle. Hurights
Wiessner, S. (2011). The Cultural Rights of Indigenous Peoples: Achievements and Continuing
World Intellectual Property Office, & Carvalho, A. (2020). Intellectual property and genetic
https://www.wipo.int/edocs/pubdocs/en/tk/920/wipo_pub_920.pdf
23