Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BACKGROUND: After performing more than 500 robotic radical prostatectomy and robotic radical cystopros-
tatectomy in men, we attempted to develop the technique of robot-assisted radical cystectomy
in women. This article describes two techniques of robot-assisted radical cystectomy for
women, conventional and with preservation of the uterus and vagina. To the best of our
knowledge, this is the first case series of robot-assisted radical cystectomy and urinary diversion
in women.
STUDY DESIGN: Robot-assisted radical cystectomy was undertaken in three female patients with transitional cell
carcinoma of the urinary bladder. The operation was performed with the conventional anterior
approach in one patient and with a new technique in two patients, which allows preservation of
urethra, uterus, vagina, and both ovaries. As planned, the radical cystectomy was done roboti-
cally, using the da Vinci Surgical System (Intuitive Surgical). The bladder was entrapped in an
Endocatch bag and removed through a small subumbilical incision. Urinary reconstruction was
performed extracorporeally after exteriorizing the bowel through the incision used for retrieving
the specimen. In two patients, the reconstructed pouch was placed in the pelvis and the
abdominal incision was closed. Urethroneovesical anastomosis was done robotically, using a
technique described previously for men.
RESULTS: The average operating time for the robotic radical cystectomy was 160 minutes and the mean
operating times for ileal conduit and orthotopic neobladder were 130 minutes and 180 min-
utes, respectively. The mean blood loss was less than 100 mL. The mean number of lymph nodes
removed was 12 (range 3 to 21). Surgical margins were free of tumor in all three patients.
CONCLUSIONS: This approach incorporates advantages of minimally invasive and open surgery. Performing the
radical cystectomy with the robot allows precise and rapid removal of the bladder with minimal
blood loss. Extracorporeal reconstruction of the urinary tract reduces operative time at this stage
of evolution of laparoscopic and robotic instrumentation. In the future, with the development
of technology, instrumentation, and with additional refinement of our technique, the entire
procedure may be done completely intracorporeally with equal efficiency. ( J Am Coll Surg
2004;198:386–393. © 2004 by the American College of Surgeons)
The classic operation for invasive bladder cancer in muscle-invasive bladder cancer because urethral, vagi-
women is anterior exenteration with removal of the nal, or cervical involvement is unusual.2 Although lapa-
bladder, urethra, uterus, vagina, and both ovaries.1 Ad- roscopic radical cystectomy in women has been reported
vances in surgical technique have allowed urethral and by various authors, robotic radical cystectomy in women
vaginal-sparing operations in female patients with has not.3-10 We have previously reported our experience
with both laparoscopic radical prostatectomy and ro-
No competing interests declared.
botic radical cystoprostatectomy in men.11-14 The en-
couraging results from this experience led us to develop
Received May 7, 2003; Revised November 3, 2003; Accepted November 3,
2003. a robotic approach to radical cystectomy in women. Af-
From the Vattikuti Urology Institute, Detroit, MI, and Urology Nephrology ter performing one anterior pelvic exenteration, we felt
Center, Mansoura, Egypt.
Correspondence address: Mani Menon, MD, FACS, Vattikuti Urology Insti-
that the precision offered by robotic technology would
tute, 2799 West Grand Boulevard, K-9, Detroit, MI 48202. allow us to preserve the uterus and the vagina in most
Characteristic 1 2 3
Age (y) 59 60 66
Preoperative diagnosis,
tumor stage (clinical) T3b T3b T3b
Body mass index 31 30 28
Number of ports 6 6 6
Operative time (min)
Radical cystectomy 150 160 170
Urinary diversion 130 190 170
Blood loss (cc) 150 250 100
Type of urinary diversion Ileal conduit W-Pouch, neobladder T-Pouch
Surgical margins Negative Negative Negative
Number of lymph nodes
removed, pathologic
status 13, negative 21, negative 3, negative
PT2, Grade 2, transitional PT1, Grade 2, transitional PT3a, Grade 3, transitional
Final histopathology cell carcinoma cell carcinoma cell carcinoma
Complications or conversion None None None
Hospital stay (d) 5 7 8
women with bladder cancer. This report of robotic rad- pression stockings are applied. Under general, intubated
ical cystectomy and continent urinary diversion (ortho- anesthesia a nasogastric tube and perurethral Foley cath-
topic neobladder) in women with carcinoma of bladder eter are inserted at the beginning of the operation. The
is the first report in the world literature to the best of our patient is positioned (Fig. 1) in lithotomy with both
knowledge. arms adducted, tucked, and padded, and the table
flexed, which opens the area between umbilicus and the
METHODS pubis. The table is tilted in steep Trendelenburg’s
Radical cystectomy with robot-assistance was performed position.
in three women (Table 1) with muscle-invasive transi-
Creation of pneumoperitoneum, peritoneoscopy,
tional cell carcinoma of the bladder. In one woman, a
and port placement
conventional anterior pelvic exenteration was done,
A six-port transperitoneal approach is used. Pneumo-
whereas in two, a nerve-sparing technique that preserved
peritoneum is created with a Veress needle (Ethicon
the vagina and uterus was used. Urinary diversion was
Endo-Surgery) introduced at the proposed site of the
achieved by orthotopic neobladder in two patients and
ileal conduit in one patient.
The operation was performed using the da Vinci Sur-
gical System (Intuitive Surgical). All robot-assisted rad-
ical cystectomies and the ileal conduit were performed
by a single surgeon (MM), experienced in robotic tech-
niques, but a second surgical team created the urinary
diversion (ileal conduit and orthotopic neobladder).
Posterior dissection
Our previous experience in performing robot-assisted
radical cystectomy in men14 convinced us that a poste-
rior approach, through the cul-de-sac, allowed for easier
mobilization of the bladder. We reasoned that the angled
lenses, combined with the wristed instrumentation
would allow us to develop the rectovesical or uterovesical
plane and begin the preservation of the neurovascular
bundles even before the anterior and lateral bladder dis-
section was performed. The posterior dissection is done
with the 30-degree lens, looking downward. Using the
wristed da Vinci hook, an inverted U-shaped incision is
made in the peritoneum of the cul-de-sac between the
bladder and the uterus. In many patients, the course of
the lower ureters can be seen as a peritoneal fold that Figure 3. Depicting ureterovesical junction, obturator nerve (ob.N.),
extends from the iliac bifurcation to the posterior blad- and bladder.
Vol. 198, No. 3, March 2004 Menon et al Robot-Assisted Radical Cystectomy in Women 389
allows us to accomplish watertight, running (clockwise and was done extracorporeally and those in which the diver-
counterclockwise) urethroneovesicostomy. sion (ileal conduit or orthotopic neobladder) was done
intracorporeally. The operating time with extracorporeal
RESULTS ileal conduit and neobladder diversion has ranged from
The average operating time for the robotic radical cys- 6 to 9 hours and 6.5 to 12 hours, respectively, and for
tectomy was 160 minutes, and the mean operating times completely intracorporeal ileal conduit and neobladder
for ileal conduit and orthotopic neobladder were 130 diversion has ranged from 10 to 11.5 hours and 7.4 to 12
minutes and 180 minutes, respectively. The mean blood hours, respectively (Table 2). The blood loss has ranged
loss was less than 100 mL. The bilateral pelvic lymph- from 300 to 1,200 mL.
adenectomy was performed as described earlier in all We have stated previously the reasons behind using
cases and mean number of lymph nodes removed was 12 robotic technology for complex oncologic cases and
(range 3 to 21). The histopathologic examination of have reported our extensive experience with laparo-
these nodes was negative in all cases. The surgical mar- scopic radical prostatectomy and more modest experi-
gins of the specimen were free of tumor in all patients. ence with robotic cystoprostatectomy and urinary diver-
sion in men.11-14 Although laparoscopic radical
DISCUSSION cystectomy and urinary diversion has been reported by
Radical cystectomy and urinary diversion are among the various authors in women, robotic cystectomy has
most difficult procedures being performed in laparo- not.3-10 In attempting to develop this procedure in
scopic urology. The complexity of the procedure in- women with less operative time and blood loss, we es-
creases with the number of suture lines and reaches its chewed the urge to perform the entire procedure intra-
apotheosis when an orthotopic bladder is constructed. corporeally. Although most individuals find suturing
Laparoscopic surgeons appear to have taken a staged much easier with the robot than with conventional lapa-
approach to its evolution, starting with simple cystec- roscopy, it still is not as easy as with open operations. The
tomy, and progressing through radical cystectomy to major advantage of a completely intracorporeal proce-
complete intracorporeal neobladder reconstruction.3-10,16,17 dure appears to be the avoidance of a small abdominal
Every group has raised concerns that these procedures are incision of 5 to 8 cm and the surgical specimen can and
technically demanding, take a long operating time, and has been removed transvaginally, transanally, and by
require great laparoscopic skills. small abdominal incision; the cost is an additional 2 to 3
The first case reports of laparoscopic simple and rad- hours in the operating room. Additionally, no one has
ical cystectomy were described by Parra and colleagues examined the impact of vaginal operations on female
in 19923 and by Sanchez de Badajaz and colleagues6 in sexual dysfunction. Given this, we preferred to remove
1993 respectively. From 1995 onward, various authors the bladder through a small subumbilical incision. This
have reported small series of laparoscopic radical cystec- incision has allowed us to do the urinary reconstruction
tomies with extracorporeal reconstruction of ileal con- extracorporeally. Even the Mansoura group, with a sur-
duit and urinary diversion in women.4-6,10 In 2000, Gill gical experience of more than 700 orthotopic bladders,
and colleagues8 first described the technique of laparo- found it impossible to perform the urethroneovesicoc-
scopic radical cystoprostatectomy and intracorporeal il- tomy without extending the incision to the pubis. This is
eal conduit in two cases. From Europe, Turk and col- why we did this final portion robotically after closing the
leagues7 reported first series of laparoscopic radical incision.
cystectomy and continent diversion (rectosigmoid Definitive treatment of bladder cancer in women
pouch) with extraction of the bladder through a recto- conventionally includes removal of the uterus, the ova-
tomy, avoiding an abdominal incision in 2001. Later, ries, and much of the vagina. The reasons for this are not
Gill and colleagues9 also described laparoscopic cystec- clear because bladder cancer rarely extends into these
tomy with intracorporal construction of a continent or- organs. Additionally, there is no evidence that excision of
thotopic urinary diversion in another two patients. The the female reproductive tract results in a greater cure rate
case series of laparoscopic cystectomy and urinary diver- than for men, in whom such a wide excision is not pos-
sion (ileal conduit, continent, or orthotopic neobladder) sible (Ghoneim and Abol-Enein, unpublished data).
fall into two categories—those in which the diversion The major reason for removing the uterus and the upper
392 Menon et al Robot-Assisted Radical Cystectomy in Women J Am Coll Surg
Table 2. Important Series of Laparoscopic, Robotic Radical Cystectomy, and Urinary Diversion
First Operation, Retrieval of Operation No. of Hospital
author Case profile n urinary diversion specimen time (h) ports stay (d)
Parra3 Pyocystis 1 Lap. simple cystectomy — 2.2 — 5
Puppo5 Lap. assisted transvaginal
Transitional cancer 5 radical cystectomy Mini-lap 6–9 — 7–18
Badajoz6 Lap. radical cystectomy Enlarged port
⫹ extracorporeal ileal site and flank
Transitional cancer 1 conduit incision — — —
Hemal10 Transitional cell Lap. radical cystectomy
cancer (9) and ⫹ extracorporeal ileal Infraumbilical
squamous (1) cancer 10 conduit incision 6.48 5–6 10.88
Gill8 Lap. radical cystectomy
Transitional cell ⫹ intracorporeal ileal Abdominal
cancer 2 conduit incision 11.5, 10 6 6
Gill9 Lap. radical cystectomy
⫹ continent orthotopic
neobladder, 1 case
Transitional cell extracorporeal Indiana Abdominal
cancer 2⫹1 pouch incision 8.5, 10.5, 7 6–7 5, 12, 6
Turk7 Lap. radical cystectomy
Transitional cell ⫹ intracorporeal rectal
cancer 5 sigmoid pouch None 7.4 6 10
Abdel-Hakim16 Transitional cell
cancer (men) (8) and Lap. radical cystectomy
squamous cancer ⫹ extracorporeal
(women) (1) 9 reconstruction of pouch Minilaparotomy 6.5–12 (median 8.3) 5–6 —
Gaboardi17 Lap. radical cystectomy
Transitional ⫹ extracorporeal
cell cancer reconstruction ileal Supraumbilical
(T1-Grade 3) 1 ONB incision 7.5 5–6 7
Menon14 Nerve-sparing robotic
radical cystopros-
tatectomy with urinary
diversion in male (ileal
conduit, 2; T-pouch, 2; 5-6 cm RRC, 140 min; ileal
W-pouch, 9; T-pouch, suprapubic conduit, 120 min;
— 14 1) incision ONB, 168 min 6 —
Present study Roboticradical
cystectomy with urinary
diversion in women (ileal RRC, 160 min; ileal
Transitional cell conduit, 1; W-pouch, 1; Subumbilical conduit, 130 min;
cancer 3 T-pouch, 1) incision ONB, 180 min 5 6.7
Lap., laparoscopic; ONB, orthotopic neobladder; RRC, robotic radical cystoprostatectomy.
vagina appears to be to enter a better dissection plane, ual function in women who want it. These are the rea-
avoiding troublesome vaginal bleeding. We reasoned sons behind our developing the technique of uterus-
that the superior hemostasis that accompanies robotic sparing radical cystectomy.
operations would afford us the opportunity of leaving The technique of robotic radical cystectomy in
the female reproductive structures intact. We saw several women reported in this article reflects our current ap-
advantages with this approach—the specimen is smaller, proach. An additional benefit of this technique is its
and can be removed through a smaller incision, the surgical accuracy because of the remarkably stable and
uterus and vagina provide backing to the neobladder and precise movement of the “endowrist” instruments (Intu-
prevent kinking of the urethraneovesical anastomosis, itive Surgical), which allow the surgeon to dissect, di-
reducing, in theory at least, the likelihood of urinary vide, suture, and anastomose. Incorporation of these
hypercontinence, and, last, it allows maintenance of sex- steps has resulted in improvement in our own perfor-
Vol. 198, No. 3, March 2004 Menon et al Robot-Assisted Radical Cystectomy in Women 393
mance of this operation (ie, decreased blood loss, oper- urology, 8th ed. vol IV. Philadelphia: Saunders; 2002:2832–
2838.
ative time, and incontinence). We believe that a careful 2. Schoenberg M, Hortopan S, Schlossber GL, et al. Anatomical
detailing of our approach would be of some value to anterior exenteration with urethral and vaginal preservation: il-
individuals who are first embarking on robotic radical lustrated surgical method. J Urol 1999;161:569–572.
3. Parra RO, Andrus CH, Jones JP. Laparoscopic cystectomy: ini-
cystectomy in women, and that this will translate into tial report on a new treatment for retained bladder. J Urol 1992;
decreased operative time and complications for their pa- 148:1140–1144.
tients. It will also help to overcome the obstacles of the 4. Vara-Thorbeck C, Sanchez de Badajoz E. Laparoscopic ileal
learning associated with this. loop conduit. Surg Endosc 1994;8:114–115.
5. Puppo P, Perachino M, Ricciotti G, et al. Laparoscopically
We have developed an original technique for per- assisted transvaginal radical cystectomy. Eur Urol 1995;27:
forming robotic radical cystectomy (standard and 80–84.
uterus-preserving) in women using the da Vinci system 6. Sanchez de Badajoz E, Gallego Perales JL, et al. Laparoscopic
cystectomy and ileal conduit: case report. J Endourol 1995;9:
(Intuitive Surgical) and for constructing an ileal and 59–62.
orthotopic neobladder. This technique allows precise 7. Turk I, Deger S, Winkelmann B, et al. Laparoscopic radical
and rapid removal of the bladder with minimal blood cystectomy with continent urinary diversion (rectal sigmoid
pouch) performed completely intracorporeally: the initial 5
loss and combines the advantages of the minimally in- cases. J Urol 2001;165:1863–1866.
vasive approach with those of open operations. We were 8. Gill IS, Fergany A, Klein AE, et al. Laparoscopic radical cys-
able to exteriorize the bowel segment and construct the toprostatectomy with ileal conduit performed completely intra-
corporeally: the initial 2 cases. Urology 2000;56:29–30.
urinary pouch through the small incision necessary to 9. Gill IS, Kaouk JH, Meraney AM, et al. Laparoscopic radical
extract the surgical specimen from the abdomen. Per- cystectomy and continent orthotopic ileal neobladder per-
forming this part of the operation extracorporeally re- formed completely intracorporeally: the initial experience.
J Urol 2002;168:13–18.
duces operative time. 10. Hemal AK, Singh I, Kumar R. Laparoscopic radical cystectomy
and ileal conduit reconstruction—preliminary experience. J En-
dourol 2003;17:911–916.
Author Contributions 11. Menon M. Robotic radical retropubic prostatectomy. BJU Int
Study conception and design: Menon, Hemal, Tewari, 2003;91:175–176.
Ghoneim 12. Menon M, Shrivastava A, Tewari A, et al. Laparoscopic and
robot assisted radical prostatectomy: establishment of a struc-
Acquisition of data: Tewari, Shrivastava, Shoma tured program and preliminary analysis of outcomes. J Urol
Analysis and interpretation of data: Hemal, Tewari, 2002;168:945–949.
Abol-Ein 13. Tewari A, Peabody JO, Hemal AK, et al. Technique of da Vinci
robot-assisted anatomic radical prostatectomy. Urology 2002;
Drafting of manuscript: Menon, Hemal 60:569–572.
Critical revision: Menon, Hemal 14. Menon M, Hemal AK, Tewari A, et al. Nerve-sparing robot-
Supervision: Menon assisted radical cystoprostatectomy and urinary diversion. BJU
Int 2003;92:232–236.
Surgical team: Menon, Hemal, Tewari, Shoma, Abol- 15. Van Velthoven RF, Ahlering TE, Peltier A, et al. Technique for
Ein, Ghoneim laparoscopic running urethrovesical anastomosis: the single
knot method. Urology 2003;61:699–702.
16. Abdel-Hakim AM, Bassiouny F, Abdel-Azim MS, et al. Laparo-
scopic radical cystectomy with orthotopic neobladder. J En-
REFERENCES
dourol 2002;16:377–381.
1. Jiminez VK, Marshall FF. Surgery of bladder cancer. In: Walsh 17. Gaboardi F, Simonato A, Galli S, et al. Minimally invasive lapa-
PC, Retik AB, Darracott Vaghan E Jr, Wein AJ, eds. Campbell’s roscopic neobladder. J Urol 2002;168:1080–1083.