Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract: The history of learning biology through distance education is documented. A review of terminology and
unique problems associated with biology instruction is presented. Using published research and their own teaching
experience, the authors present recommendations and best practices for managing biology in distance-based formats.
They offer ideas on resources for content, laboratory activities, safety and interaction among class participants. The
need for research on the efficacy of virtual labs and simulations in adult biology education is noted.
Key words: online biology instruction, online science instruction, web based teaching, distance education
options are available too. Further solutions include practices, especially those offered to undergraduates
creating review activities and assignments that build and non-majors. As uncomfortable as it may be to
on lectures or apply the material to real-world admit, Cancilla & Albon (2008) reminded us that
problems. seat-based lab practices are often rushed, prescribed
From Transmission to Application: Moving and lacking in authenticity. Lab activities in any
Beyond Memorization format always require careful planning. Some of the
Many distance activities reinforce content and choices for distance courses will be discussed below.
allow students to apply knowledge. These include Hybrid, Power-Lab and Mentoring Options
web-based review centers provided by text An easy solution is to offer a traditional
publishers, online content quizzes, narrated (and laboratory meeting via a hybrid class (Kennephol &
often interactive) animations, links to web content, Shaw, 2010). A variation is the power lab. These
and discussion board activities. These create are required, extended lab meetings (Cancilla &
opportunities that would be difficult to incorporate Albon, 2008) which may be offered several times per
into traditional classes, but they must be carefully semester, in the evenings, or on weekends. Students
employed to ensure effectiveness. For instance, satisfy the laboratory component in a traditional way
Muchovej (2009) found that optional online quizzes despite the unconventional scheduling. If only one or
did not significantly improve scores when quiz a few lab objectives require a traditional solution, a
questions were recycled on exams. A low number of laboratory mentor working with individual students
students completed the optional quizzes, suggesting may be an option. For example, if a teacher places
that how the learning strategies are employed is high value on microscope use, students may locate a
important. site for completion of such work (e.g. high-school
Web-based technologies allow instructors to teachers or hospital lab technicians are eager to assist
utilize sequentially built knowledge and skills. An our students). Colleges and universities have been
example from one of our freshman biology courses is sending students to clinics, classrooms, labs, field
summarized in Table 3. Notice that the activities, in stations and other locales to enhance their on-campus
this case centered on learning genetics content, build studies for decades. You may wish to invest time to
upon one another to progress from knowledge to formulate a preapproved list of off-campus mentors
application. or lab sites. Safety and liability issues should be
Laboratory Activities considered when having students work off-campus.
Published research concerning labs in distance- Instructor responsibilities for safety are the same
based science courses is spotty (Kennepohl & Shaw, whether lab is conducted in a traditional or a distance
2010). Reuter (2009) reported no significant setting. Specific challenges related to liability and
differences between online and traditional lab grades insurance are too complex for this article, but
in various science courses. In a small study, educators and institutions should examine their
Lunsford & Bolton (2006) reported similar success practices to ensure that students are not exposed to
rates on biology content exams for nonmajors taught unreasonable risk. A good overview is provided by
traditionally and online. By its nature, science the National Science Teachers Association (NSTA)
involves frequent laboratory work, a fact reflected in (nsta.org/about/positions/liability.aspx). Table 4 also
most biology courses. Providing laboratory provides some tips.
experiences is challenging in a web-based course Virtual Labs, Simulations & Demonstrations
(Kennepohl & Shaw, 2010). Specifically concerns By definition, a virtual or simulated experience
about lab content, materials, and safety arise. The is approximated by a computer. Virtual labs are
quality of a class may suffer if planning is not done becoming commonplace in distance-learning
carefully (Miller, 2008). We recognize these (Anderson, 2008). In online and traditional classes,
concerns while challenging our colleagues to we recommend limited use of simulations. We prefer
honestly question the quality of seat-based lab to utilize simulations as a supplement, as we have
30 Volume 39(1) May 2013 Hallyburton & Lunsford
Table 4. Tips for safety and liability concerns involving off campus lab or field work.
General Safety Tips Working From Home Potential Legal Issues Safety at Home
Remember that all lab Enclose required safety Require students to view a Post contact information for
activities (even paper and materials such as goggles or safety video or attend a the Poison Control Center on
pencil materials) could have gloves in lab kits. safety training session, even the class web site.
some potential safety or legal Supply detailed instructions at off campus facilities. Post a flow chart concerning
risks. for disposal of chemicals or Require students to sign a first aid procedures and when
Strive to keep use of specimens. safety contract specifying it is necessary to call 911 for
chemicals, sharp objects, Put Material Safety Data liability and attesting that a safety emergency.
heat, etc. to a minimum. Sheets (MSDS) in lab kits or they understand safety Provide specific precautions
If your labs require a lot of post them on the class web procedures. in lab procedures such as
potentially dangerous items site. Requires students to “Do not mix with other
consider an on campus, a Supply demonstration videos purchase and maintain chemicals” or “Avoid
hybrid or a power lab option. to emphasize safety for accident insurance if contact with eyes” or “See
specific lab procedures. appropriate. MSDS”.
Ask off campus sites to treat
students as they would treat
employees concerning safety
and liability.
found virtual activities ranging from useful to homemade pH indicators. Be sure to supply students
terrible. One can access quality film images of with a list of required materials in advance.
dissections online at no cost (e.g., Another option involves offering materials
exploratorium.edu/learning_studio/cow_eye/step01.h (slides, reagents, dissection specimens, etc.) to
tml). Also, teachers have the option of filming their students as lab kits (Kennepohl & Shaw, 2010).
own demonstrations (Kennepohl & Shaw, 2010). In Teachers may mail kits to students, distribute them
other cases publishers offer flashy, expensive during face-to-face meetings or collaborate with
computer simulations that, in general, are heavy on college bookstores for dispensing. There is a
production but ineffective at building scientific growing industry involving the commercial
process skills. We are not aware of a recent, quality packaging of laboratory kits. One source with a
study of the efficacy of virtual labs and simulations in variety of options is Hands on Labs/LABPAQ
adult biology education. Clearly there is a need for (holscience.com). While all of these alternatives
research. Asbell-Clarke & Rowe (2007) noted a require a significant commitment from instructors,
study comparing traditional and virtual labs for the outcomes allow students flexibility in scheduling.
introductory chemistry classes. Students, by and Also, labs can be sequenced into the flow of lectures,
large, learned no lab skills or techniques but did pick and lab results can be discussed online.
up additional content knowledge about chemistry. Instructors should provide safety instructions.
Reuter (2009) reported that virtual labs are coming to Directives on organization of work areas, chemicals,
be viewed as secondary in value to authentic lab and clothing, equipment, and clean-up may be needed.
field experiences. One advantage is that students are Teachers may also consider a safety contract which
able to access simulations asynchronously and must be completed by students to show they have
therefore at their own convenience (Cancilla & Albon understanding of safety considerations. Another
2008). approach is the use of a pre-lab safety quiz which
Working at Home: Kitchen Labs, Remote could be easily integrated into many distance-
Instrumentation and Other Options learning platforms. An excellent example of safety
Though some courses do not lend themselves to considerations specifically focused on distance-
web-based lab assignments due to need for learning labs is given by Hands-On Labs, mentioned
equipment or concerns for safety (e.g., above. Table 4 provides more suggestions.
microbiology), many freshman-level labs can be Remote instrumentation is commonplace in
easily and safely completed by students in their own biology and involves manipulation of scientific
homes. So called kitchen science labs tend to require apparatus from distant locations. Control and data
little to no specialized equipment. They are transmission are usually accomplished via the
particularly common in non-majors courses (Reuter, internet. Examples include sensors, cameras,
2009). Asbell-Clarke & Rowe (2007) found that well chromatographs and machinery for collecting
planned kitchen activities can promote mastery of samples. (Educase Learning Initiative, 2006;
inquiry skills. From their homes our students have Kennepohl & Shaw, 2010). Remote instrumentation
completed labs concerning scientific measurement, fits well with distance-based learning. Equipment is
observation of metamorphosis, experiments involving usually accessible at any time and data are often
diffusion, mark and recapture modeling, and use of easily shared. In fact they may be shared and