Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Hawkins
Managing Director
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
The aim of this presentation is to
• Discuss some of the common problems that
occur on steam reformers
• Analyze problems associated with
◦ Catalyst
◦ Tubes
◦ Reformer Design
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
Plant Reliability
Many ageing plants
Problems generally
increase towards
end of plant life
Loss of corporate
Life of Plant
knowledge
De-manning
Result is that
number of problems
will increase
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
• Many problems
• Varied causes and effects
• Not always easy to detect
• Can reduce efficiency significantly
• Can affect plant financial profitability
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
• Some typical ones include
◦ Poisoning
◦ Carbon formation
◦ Tunnel problems
◦ Air leaks
◦ Tube failures
• Less common ones include
◦ Tunnel Port Effect
◦ Flue gas Mal-distribution
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
• There are many poisons but most common is
sulfur - must not rule out
◦ Chlorides
◦ Heavy metals - Arsenic/Vanadium
◦ Phosphates
• Will reduce activity
• Raises tube temperatures
• Can lead to hot bands
• And hence carbon formation
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
• Hot bands are formed due to
◦ Loss of activity
◦ Poor heat transfer
◦ Localized high voidage
◦ Too low a steam to carbon ratio
• Once formed they will get worse
• On Top Fired reformers occur about 1/3 down the
tube
◦ Not so much of a problem on Terrace Wall or Side Fired
furnaces as inside tube temperatures are lower
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
Hot Band
Weld
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
• All combustion at top of furnace
• High heat transfer rate at this point
• Measured by heat fluxes
◦ Top fired between 80-140 kW/m²
◦ But some in range 140-160 kW/m²
• Side Fired/Terrace Wall have multiple fuel
combustion points
◦ Heat Fluxes are lower
• Therefore Top Fired more prone to carbon
formation
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
• Can remove by steaming
• Need exit temperature above 700°C = 1300°F
• No feed - Only steam
• Continue for at least 12 hours
• Monitor for CH4 and CO2 exit reformer
• Check process condensate for sulfites and
sulfates
• Add nitrogen as carrier if required
• If really bad may need an air burn
• If even worse - a new charge of catalyst
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
Hot Band Tiger Giraffe Hot Tube Settling
Tailing Necking
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
Nipped
Tube
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
Nipped tubes
run much hotter Coffin
Eventually fail
Normally fall
over
Need to monitor
Shut down if
there is a
problem
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
Occurs if nipping tubes but no firing adjustment
Poor Loading
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
• Next charge used a dense loading technique
• Achieved a very even loading
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
20 50
15 40
30
10
20
5 10
0 0
-20 -15 -10 -5 0 5 10 15 20 -10
-5
-20
-10
-30
-15 -40
-20 -50
Pressure drop variation (%)
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
Catalyst Deactivation
Physical processes
• Tube expansion/contraction
• Expansion during start-up
• Contraction during cooling stresses pellets
After loading
At shutdown
During operation Stressed Pellets
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
Cold Hot Cold
Initial
catalyst level Hot Zone
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
• Catalyst will break in service during
◦ Trips
◦ Steaming
• Will lead to high resistance to flow
• Some tube will have less flow
◦ Therefore will appear hotter
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
Fluegas Fans
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
Double Fan can lead to variation of TWT along
reformer
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
• This occurred on Methanol Plant in Western
Europe
• Plant ran for almost 30 years
• Tubes at the hot points had been replaced 3 times
during the plant life
◦ Average life of these tubes was 7years
• Tubes at the cold points were replaced once or
never at all !
◦ Average life of these tubes was 25-30 years
• Overall cost plant money since tube life not
utilized fully
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
Can also get mal-distribution due to
• Poor fuel header design
◦ Causes fuel mal distribution between cells
• Poor feed header design
◦ Causes feed mal distribution between cells
• Also affects side fired type reformers
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
Poorly Well
Balanced Balanced
Mixed
Parameter Cell 1 Cell 2 Gas
Fuel flow (% of average) 55 45 100 100
Exit temp (oC) 869 810 840 842
Exit temp (oF) 1596 1490 1544 1548
Exit CH4 (mol % dry) 1.5 3.7 2.6 2.3
ATE (oC) 11 11 16 12
ATE (oF) 20 20 29 21
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
• Used to collect flue gas in Top Fired reformers
• Used to collect the flue gas such that furnace
operates in ‘Plug Flow’ regime
• Have proven to be a problem
◦ Mechanically - they have collapsed
◦ Damage can lead to localized mal-distribution
◦ Tunnel port effect
• Some plants have removed them !
◦ Reduces flue gas side pressure drop
◦ Allows uprate of plant
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
Effect on Flow
Effect on Temperature
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
• Kellogg plant in India
• Coffin collapsed
• Side wall and roof bricks rested on the manifold
• Manifold deviated from normal position
• Induced additional stresses
• Manifold did not fail - problem rectified at shut
down just after failure
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
With Coffins Without Coffins
Tubes Coffins
Area of Hot tubes
Fluegas flow patterns
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
• Due to preferential flow of flue gas to the
extraction end
◦ Have more flow
◦ Therefore more heat available
◦ Therefore high temperatures
Temperature
Distance
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
• Common problem on uprated plants
• Lack of ID (Fluegas) fan capacity leads to high
box pressures
◦ -2 or -3 mm water gauge
◦ Normally -10 mm
◦ Safety issue - flames can pass out of box
• Lack of FD (Combustion Air) fan capacity can lead
to low excess air/oxygen levels
◦ Leads to afterburning
◦ In worst case high CO levels in duct
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
• Classic example is a South American Methanol
Plant
◦ Tightly designed plant - 2000 mtpd but operating at
2200 mtpd +
◦ Both fans limited
◦ One end of reformer was at positive (+) pressure
◦ Flames emitted from peepholes
• Outer lane cool - inner’s hot
• Afterburning in centre
• CO inlet duct
• CA ducting symmetrical
• Poor CA distribution
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
• Tube Failures - covered in Tube Design
◦ Can nip the tube
• Tunnel Port Effect
◦ Can be overcome by
Installation of appropriate catalyst - high heat transfer/activity
Design of the tunnel ports
• Weld position - on top fired reformers avoid the
hottest point of tube
• Movement of coffin walls
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
• All streams should be
symmetrical
• Including
◦ Feed, fuel, effluent and combustion
air headers/ducts
◦ Prevents mal distribution of process
flows
◦ Prevents variations in operating
conditions
Tube and exit temperatures
Preferential Flow Path
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
Flow prefferentially Flow starved
passing to this end of reformer at this end
Temperature
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
• Mainly affects Top Fired furnaces
• Two types
◦ #1 - direct impingement of flame on tube
This is the worst since tube wall temperatures will be raised
the most
Can lead to rapid tube failure
◦ #2 - impingement of hot flue gas on tube
Normally observed as shimmering on tube surface
Will lead to premature failure in ‘long term’
• Both raise tube wall temperatures
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
• Causes
◦ Fluegas Mal-
distribution
◦ Poor burner design
◦ Blockage of ports in
burners
◦ Mis-alignment of burner
• Can remove burners
on line
• Allows for repair
• Must be careful
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
• Cause by a localized lack of combustion air
• The fuel is not fully combusted
• Fuel moves on and when it meets oxygen is
combusts
◦ The flue gas/fuel mixture is above auto-ignition
temperature
• Usually observed on surface of the tubes
◦ Can damage tubes
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
• Causes
◦ Lack of Forced Draft (Combustion Air) fan capacity
◦ Poor combustion air header design
◦ Poor burner design
◦ Fuel gas composition deviations
◦ Poor balancing of furnace combustion air
• Can rectify but must identify cause
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
Top entry Side entry
If distance from inlet of
tube to the surface of the
catalyst is too short then
can get milling of the
catalyst
Allow 200 mm for top
entry
Allow 150 mm for side
entry
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
From a South American
Reformer
Had thoroughly wetted catalyst
On restart pressure drop very
high
Catalyst badly damaged
Water had rapidly vaporised
inside pellets
Blew them apart
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
On heating catalyst can be a variety of colors
Carbon
Overheated
Normal
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
1200oC 900oC
1100oC 800oC
1000oC 700oC
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
If tubes receive differential
amounts of heat from
adjacent burner rows
Each side expands differently
Tubes will bow
This increases stress on
outside of bow
GBHE recommends change
tube if more than ID outside
of the centre line of the lane
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
• Damage to refractory
◦ Flame impingement
◦ Poor installation
• Gas tracking behind refractory
◦ Usually due to anchor failure
◦ Refractory moves away from wall
◦ Casing becomes hot - cooling by steam lances
etc
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
• Condensation due to
◦ passing valves
◦ dead legs
◦ too early steam or feed introduction
• Ammonia formation
◦ Problems on demin train
◦ Environmental
• Boxing up reformer
◦ Avoid as can slowly cook tubes
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
• Stress Corrosion
Cracking
◦ Due to condensation - can
eliminate by design
modification
Failure Point Tube tops - insulation
Tube bottoms - use hot
bottom design
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
• Over tensioning of tubes -
premature failure
Failure
• Pigtail failure
◦ Operate in creep regime - will fail
• Header failure - Again in creep
regime
• Poor burner maintenance
◦ Must clean regularly
• Metal dusting of burner tips
◦ Methanol plants only
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
• Modifications to coffins/ports in coffin
◦ Can lead to flow mal-distribution
• Wind changes
◦ Changes temperature - up to 20°C seen
• Leaks in air pre-heaters
◦ Worst on rotary air pre-heaters
◦ Have seen leaks on static heaters as well
• Fouling of duct coils
◦ High DP and low heat transfer
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
• Gas composition analysis has a number of
problems
• Sample shifting
◦ Normally affects only CO and CO2
◦ In worst case can increase CH4
◦ Problem if using CH4 as a constraint in a model
• Hydrogen by difference
◦ Errors in other components will be included in H2
• Inerts (N2 and Ar) poor measurement
◦ Can affect fitting programs
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
• Typical temperature losses are
• Exit tubes 1-3°C
• Sub headers 3-10°C
• Main headers 5-15°C
• Inlet secondary
• Top Fired Reformers 10-20°C
• Foster Wheeler Reformers 15-35°C
• Side Fired Reformers 15-35°C
• Inlet WHB,
• Top Fired Reformers 10-20°C
• Foster Wheeler Reformers 15-35°C
• Side Fired Reformers 15-35°C
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
Main cause of catastrophic tube failure
• This one was at North American Methanol Plant
• Plant trip (loss of feedstock to steam reformer)
due to valve failure
• Feedstock to steam reformer not isolated
adequately by valve
• Set point on reformed gas pressure not reduced
• Steam introduced for plant restart at reduced rate
• All burners lit (deviation from procedure)
• Tubes at 16 bara
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
Steam reformer tubes "looked normal"
Nearly 3x as much fuel going to burners than there should have
been
High calorific value fuel added an extra 15% heat release
30 minutes
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
Reformer exit gas temperature on panel never
exceeded 700°C (1290°F)
Cannot use this instrumentation as a guide to tube
temperature
Reformer start-up at normal operating pressure
Tube failure temperature 250°C (450°F) lower than
normal for start-up
All burners lit
Far too much heat input resulted in excessive
temperatures
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM