You are on page 1of 5

How do writers use experimentation to expand or question the boundaries of

genre construction?

Writers have always used Literature as a field of experimentation with innovative and unique
ideas, forms, and styles. This experimentation has been used throughout history to broaden
the boundaries and constraints of genre construction and to challenge the expectations and
experiences of readers and audiences. This process can be utilized in different ways and take
many different forms such as the subversion of traditional genres, unconventional language
and style, or alternative language and style. Through the use of Experimentation and
questioning the boundaries of the Literary genre, Playwrights and writers are enabled and
encouraged to create timeless works which are both aesthetically innovative and intellectually
stimulating, Particularly Oscar Wilde’s “Lady Windermere’s Fan” in which the conventions
and normalities of the comedy and manners genre are confronted and innovated while the
customs and morals of the Victorian era are subversed. Additionally in Suzanne Collin’s
“The Hunger Games” the author uses experimentation with form and technique to create a
compelling dystopian narrative.

Genres are categories used to classify literary works based on their shared features, such as
form, style, subject matter, or intended audience. They provide useful frameworks for
understanding literature and help readers and writers communicate about certain patterns and
expectations within a particular type of literature, However, genres can also limit creativity
by imposing expectations that lead to formulaic and predictable works. To expand the
boundaries of genre, writers may experiment with form, style, and content. This can involve
blending multiple genres, playing with structure or form, subverting reader expectations, or
creating entirely new genres. Such experimentation challenges readers to think critically
about the nature of the genre and its role in shaping our understanding of literature.

Wilde’s “Lady Windermeres Fan is a perfect exemplification of the effects and rich benefits
of experimentation in drama. The play has several unique and striking features such as its use
of combinations from different genres. It incorporates elements of drama, melodrama, and
comedy in a way that defies any plain categorization. Wilde uses witty dialogue and
humorous situations, staple features of A Comedy of Manners piece like this, while
simultaneously exploring deeper, meaningful themes such as betrayal, forgiveness, and
morality, ideas that are usually considered and conveyed in dramatic works.

In addition to the genre-bending content of the play, traditional boundaries of structure and
techniques in drama are also called into question and challenged. Four acts each with
distinctive contrasting tones divide the play. Act One introduces the characters and main
conflicts of the play, while Act Two manifests into a darker, serious tone, investigating some
of the secrets and intrigues of the characters as the plot begins to unravel and thicken. Act
Three contains the climax of dramatic scenes and events, exploring consequences, before Act
Four draws the story to a highly surprising yet satisfying close, tying up loose ends. This
structure ventures from the traditional, strict Three-Act structure that was usually made up of
plays of the Comedy of Manners genre at the time. This experimentation allowed the
playwright to convey and explore new tones and themes which created a more nuanced and
complex experience for the audience to enjoy, outside of the usual constraints of the genre.
Furthermore, Wilde also pushed boundaries in this play in his characterization and dialogue.
Characters in plays of the Comedy of Manners genre were usually and primarily defined
completely by their social status and wit. However in “Lady Windermeres Fan” Wilde uses
the characters and their words as a tool to critique and subvert the social normalities and
conventions of Victorian Society. The characters he creates are much greater than mere
caricatures of their class and position as they strive to explore and review the very society
they are a part of through their interactions and dialogue.

For example, Lord Darlington’s character is elevated from a simple, typical gentleman to a
harsh critic of the rigid social hierarchy that he himself lives and benefits from. LORD
DARLINGTON: “we are all in the gutter, but some of us are looking at the stars.” (Wilde, Act
II) Darlington suggests that despite the social status one is born into there are people who
aspire to be greater than their current circumstances, it implies that he believes people born
with nothing are capable of achieving anything. Mrs Erlynnes character, despite on the
surface appearing as an average femme fatale is also revealed to be a victim of the cruel
double standards that women face in this Victorian society. DUCHESS OF BERWICK: “ for
she is absolutely inadmissible into society. Many a woman has a past, but I am told that she
has at least a dozen and that they all fit.” (Wilde, Act I). Wildes's dialogue is incredibly witty
yet incredibly profound as his characters unravel and deepen as his plays unfold.

By doing so, Wilde challenged his era's expectations of what a Comedy of Manners could be
and directly confronted the boundaries of the genre. He designed a work that was both
entertaining and socially relevant and paved the way for future playwrights to experiment
with characterization and dialogue in new and innovative ways. “Lady Windermeres Fan” is
a testament to the effective nature and importance of experimentation in genre construction
and a powerful hallmark of the results of pushing constraints and social norms in art and
society.
In her hugely successful novel “The Hunger Games”, Suzanne Collins deploys first-person
present-tense narration, with protagonist Katniss Everdeen acting as the story's narrator. As
dystopian fiction is more commonly viewed from a third-person perspective, this angle
creates a fresh sense of intimacy between reader and author and creates a sensation of
heightened stakes straight from the beginning of the novel.

Collins also blends elements from various genres, including dystopian fiction, science
fiction, and romance. This meeting of genres allows the novel to appeal to a wider audience
and makes it pointless to categorize the novel into a single genre. The novel also subverts
traditional genre expectations, with elements of romance and a focus on character
relationships that are not typically explored with great importance in dystopian or science
fiction works

The novel's themes and core values are also enhanced through experimentation with
technique and form, including symbolism and allegory. Also through exploration of themes
such as power, inequality, and oppression as well as the harsh portrayal of violence and its
varying effects on characters.

Symbolism and Allegory are utilized to highlight more profound themes as the novel
progresses. The “Mockingjay” is used as a symbol of resistance and defiance against the
oppression of the Capitol. Similarly the general extravagance and excessive nature of the
Capitol’s fashion and makeup, along with the Hunger Games themselves serve as symbols
and reminders of the Corrupt and superficial world that these characters exist in. Through
these techniques, Collins is able to convey more demanding and complex themes in a way
that is accessible to all readers.

The story tackles the Harsh realities of a Dystopia that push the boundaries of genre
constructions. The Hunger Games themselves are an explicit example of the Capitol’s power
and control over the districts, with children forced to fight to the death simply for the
entertainment and satisfaction of the Capitol. Collins details how the society-wide effects of
this Iron Fist tyrannical regime that her characters live under. She makes particular reference
to the effects of hunger and poverty on the characters, for example when Katniss desperately
ponders: "What must it be like, I wonder, to live in a world where food appears at the press
of a button? How would I spend the hours I now commit to combing the woods for
sustenance if it were so easy to come by?” (Collins, 61) as well as the use of Propaganda in
an effort to sway public thinking and opinion. Through these themes, the author is
highlighting and reminding us of the importance of standing up against injustice and fighting
for a better world.
Violence and its effects on characters are portrayed in a brutally realistic and nuanced way.
The Games themselves are a traumatizing and savage experience for the young unwilling
contestants. Many of the characters in the story struggle with the emotional weight and
psychological fallout that they experience whether it be witnessing or partaking in it. Through
this cruel and harsh honesty, the author is able to emphasize the devastating effects of
violence and conflict. Many works of this genre shy away from the harrowing effects of
abandonment or destruction yet Collins is able to convey them in an empathetic accessible
manner, confronting and pushing the boundaries of the dystopian function genre.

The Hunger Games demonstrates how experimentation with dystopian fiction conventions
can create new and innovative narratives that challenge traditional genre boundaries. It
achieves this through the subversion of the “Heroe’s Journey” convention. Unlike most
dystopian novels or sci-fi epics, Katniss is reluctant to be the hero and initially would want
nothing to do with it. She only takes up the mantle in an effort to protect her sister. This
contrasts with most dystopian novels where central characters eagerly await adventure and
whatever mayhem lies ahead of them. This subversion of the traditional hero's journey
narrative helps to make The Hunger Games a more refined and satisfying story and adds to
the novel's overall impact. It also allows readers to see the character of Katniss as a more
realistic and relatable protagonist, rather than a one-dimensional hero figure.

The author also purposefully blurs the lines between ally and enemy in this story, another
example of pushing back against the constraints to make for a more interesting narrative.
Katniss does not have any allies going into the Games, yet grows to form complicated
alliances along the way, often involving difficult choices and sacrifice. Furthermore, Katniss’
relationships with characters outside of the games are also complex, Haymitch, her mentor,
initially appears to be useless to Katniss, even hindering her survival in the games, but she
grows to understand his perspective and eventually begins to rely on him for support. Collins
introduces a fascinating dynamic in the relations between ally and enemy, one that is often
overlooked by other dystopian writers. Having the characters grow and change and learn,
adds an emotional depth and complexity to the story that is much more dynamic and
appealing to a reader.

The most harrowing and effective use of Experimentation that Collins uses in this story is the
use of sacrifice. Sacrifice is a key theme in The Hunger Games, as many of the characters are
forced to make difficult choices at their own loss to protect or save a loved one. Aside from
Katniss volunteering in place of her sister at the beginning of the story the most moving
example of Sacrifice comes at the end of the book where Peeta and Katniss are willing to
sacrifice themselves in exchange for the other to survive and win the Games. This is a
significant departure from the usual tropes of the dystopian genre, which often celebrate
meaningless acts of violence as a means of achieving justice or survival.

By experimenting with these genre boundaries, Collins is able to design a story that is
thrilling yet poignant. She invites readers to think about the true costs of violence and
rebellion and to consider what it means to be a true hero in a world that is as cruel and
unforgiving as the one depicted in the story. This experimentation with genre boundaries is a
major reason why the book has become such a beloved classic of modern literature.
The broader implications of challenging genre structure in cases like this are hugely
significant, in addition to its obvious room for more creativity and originality it marks and
reflects on changing values and morals in society. Our expectations and perceptions of
literature move and change alongside our society and experimentation in genre structure is an
important part of making these changes remain relevant.

You might also like