Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/262752490
CITATIONS READS
18 7,545
3 authors:
Patrick Beales
Kantey and Templer Pty Ltd, South Africa
3 PUBLICATIONS 22 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Comparative Assessment of Single & Double Interface Shear Strength Properties: A Case Study of a Landfill Project in the Western Cape View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Charles MacRobert on 20 October 2015.
46 Journal of the South African Institution of Civil Engineering • Volume 53 Number 1 April 2011
Table 1 Test sites data. This was not seen as a source of error,
but rather an acknowledgement that in
Test Site Investigation Description
practical geotechnical investigatory work,
Bellville, Cape Town, Kantey & Templer conducted an investigation on a 0,1 ha site for a proposed painstakingly calibrating testing equipment
South Africa office development.
is not often viable. The research therefore
Gope, Central Kalahari Extensive investigations on a 450 ha site by Anglo American Civil absorbed these errors and presents a
Desert, Botswana Engineering Department for a proposed diamond mine.
practical solution. Table 1 describes various
Beluluane Industrial Park, Extensive investigation by Golder Associates Africa on an 11 ha site for a aspects of the test sites from which data was
Matola, Mozambique proposed steel mill. obtained.
Milnerton, Cape Town, Kantey & Templer conducted an investigation on a 0,3 ha site for a proposed In many of the investigations studied,
South Africa ground flare. the exact location of each probing was given
on respective site diagrams, and therefore
Parow, Cape Town, South Kantey & Templer conducted an investigation on a 0,4 ha site for a proposed
Africa office development. adjacent tests, within 5 m of one another,
could be easily determined. However, when
Umdloti, Durban, Franki Africa carried out an investigation on a 0,4 ha site for a proposed
South Africa retaining wall behind an apartment block. this was not the case, the mean, maximum
and minimum values from each set of test-
Chicala, Illha de Luanda, Franki Africa carried out a limited investigation on a compact site for a ing were compared. In the latter cases the
Angola proposed hotel.
investigated sites were compact, as defined
by the Site Investigation Code of Practice
as described above, conforms to most of the equivalence between the two tests so that (2009), and hence small enough to assume
DPSH-B provisos. One difference is that the correlations between design parameters homogeneity of geotechnical parameters.
cone used has an apex angle of 60o instead of and the respective penetration resistance SPTs were either undertaken every 1 or
90o (MacRobert et al 2010). This makes the values can be used interchangeably. This was 1,5 m within a profile, whereas the DPSH
apex angle similar to that used in the SPT. done by examining field data in which both tests gave a continuous record. It was
Further research by Aggarwal (1982) showed tests were conducted in slightly silty sand therefore necessary to create continuous
that apex angle has negligible effect on pene- material formed in different depositional and comparable data. This can be done by
tration resistance. Eurocode 7 Part 2 (EN1997- environments in southern Africa. The data either averaging the N30SB values over the
2:2007) further suggests that the blow count came from countries that included Angola, depth closely matching the SPT N value or
be recorded over 100 mm or 200 mm. DP test Botswana, Mozambique and South Africa, estimating the SPT N values between results,
method and penetration distance are incor- and the maximum distance between two of which can then be compared to individual
porated by two subscripts following a capital the sites was roughly 4 000 km. N30SB values. The latter method was adopted
N, for instance N20SB. South African practice, as it did not decrease the amount of collected
however, is to record DPSH penetration values data. One method to do this is with a natural
over 300 mm, making the correlation with the AIMS AND OBJECTIVES cubic spline which has four constants and
SPT N value easier, as the blow count depth The aim of the study was to evaluate the hence has enough flexibility to satisfy the
increments are the same. The Eurocode 7 equivalence between SPT N and N30SB differentiability requirement at the data
Part 2 (EN1997-2:2007) nomenclature is thus values, and hence to determine an empirical points (Theobald 2008). A number of simul-
adopted in this paper and DPSH n values are method to correlate data between the two taneous equations needed to be solved and
referred to as N30SB. tests. Wroth (1988) stated that any empirical this was done with the aid of a computer
The most widely used of the two tests correlation should be: (1) based on physical program, resulting in data that could then be
has been the SPT. This was due mainly to insight, (2) set against a theoretical back- compared.
the publication of Terzaghi and Peck’s Soil ground, and (3) expressed in dimensionless Borehole logs accompanied all the SPT
Mechanics in Engineering Practice (1948), form. These three considerations formed the data collected. The more extensive geo-
which led to a great deal of research into objectives of the study. technical studies included test pits, grading
the test and ensuing empirical relation- testing, and microscopic and mineralogy
ships (Broms & Flodin 1988). However, the testing. These sources of both qualitative and
popularity of the DPSH has grown as it METHODOLOGY AND TEST SITES quantitative data allowed a comprehensive
closely models the SPT, providing cheap and To correlate the data between the DPSH discussion of the trends to be undertaken.
easy data (Warren 2007). The Franki Blue and SPT, it was necessary to collect data This was then used to set the theoretical
Book, a widely used geotechnical engineering in which both tests had been carried background to the correlation, as well as to
manual in southern Africa, suggests that out within 5 m of each other. This was give physical insight into the phenomenon as
the two tests should be taken as roughly assumed to be close enough for similarity per the objectives of the study.
equivalent in initial design (Braatvedt et al of geological conditions. Eight different The data was correlated in a method
1995). This equivalence is based on the fact data sets from different geological similar to that used by Cearns and McKenzie
that the same drive energy is imparted to depositional and weathering environments (1988) for DPSH and SPT results in sand
the probe per blow. This, however, assumes were analysed. Data was obtained from and gravel material in East Anglia, England.
that energy losses due to friction along previously conducted geotechnical site More recently the same method was used by
the drive rods are the same. A survey of investigations undertaken by various Warren (2007) in fine clayey sands with some
engineers in South Africa has shown that practitioners, as carrying out the tests on clayey layers at Aldershot Garrison, England.
the uncertainties around energy losses due the scale required for analysis was not The papers written by these authors provided
to friction are the biggest stumbling block in financially feasible. Testing was therefore a description of the statistical method used
adopting the DPSH in design (MacRobert et not carried out in a controlled manner by and hence it was easy to adopt and change the
al 2010). This paper develops an empirical the authors, but was instead actual field method as necessary. Cearns and McKenzie
Journal of the South African Institution of Civil Engineering • Volume 53 Number 1 April 2011 47
where a and b are the slope and intercept of
SPT N N30SB
the linear regressions respectively.
0 50 100 150 0 50 100 150
0 0
N30SB
Equivalent SPT N = (2)
1 1 K DPSH
Depth (m)
5 5
The effectiveness of using the proposed
6 6 correction formula was then compared to
the graphically interpreted correction values
7 7
determined by Cearns and McKenzie (1988)
8 8 and Warren (2007). An example is then given
illustrating how one of the collected data
9 9 sets was corrected, showing how similar the
10 10 corrected N30SB values were to the respective
SPT N values.
Figure 1 Continuous SPT N data – Gope site Figure 2 Raw N30SB data – Gope site
3
Fine grained sand – Copeland 1998). Mineralogy analysis found
aeolian/lacustrine the sand to be between 96-98% quartz and
4 with minor pedogenis
2-4% smectite interstratified clays. The fines
content was roughly 7% but increased to
5 roughly 40% in the calcified regions. Data
presented in Figures 1 and 2 are from a
number of different adjacent test pairs over
6
a large area between 100 and 1 300 m apart,
which explains the variation in resistance
7 values in each test. The minimum resistance
values from both tests generally agree over
Fine grained sand and the entire profile. However, it was found that
8 CaCO3 powder with occasional
cemented nodules/concretions – at set instances the N30SB values were much
aeolian/lacustrine with pedogenis higher than the corresponding SPT N values.
9
It is evident that the instances with high
SPTN N30SB N30SB values on closer inspection appeared
to coincide with the regions of calcified sand,
Figure 3 Larger N30SB values coinciding with calcified regions located at different depths for each test pair,
as illustrated by Figure 3.
plotted the SPT N/N30SB ratio against the K DPSH value, was plotted on the y axis
respective N30SB value. Plotting the data in against the respective N30SB value on the x Matola site
this manner produced an inverse relationship axis. This resulted in a simple linear relation- The site comprised an extensive silty sand
that was then fitted with a curve to determine ship, defined by Equation 1, which was easier dune deposit which became progressively
the correlation factor at each N30SB value. The to analyse. Various linear regression signifi- consistent with depth. Investigations showed
mathematical formula of the fitted curve was cance tests were then used to determine how that the soil had an open-voided structure
not presented in their papers, and therefore well the relationship fitted the data. This which results in a medium to high collapse
only a graphical interpretation of the correla- produced a non-dimensional function that potential (Golder Associates Africa 2008).
tion factors could be readily determined. gives the correlation factor at each N30SB Respective SPT N and N30SB data undertaken
Changes to this method were deemed value, defined by Equations 2 and 3, as per at Natural Moisture Content is presented in
necessary, as a formula would be easier the final aim of the paper. Figures 4 and 5. The SPT N values increased
to apply practically. The ratio was thus slightly with depth; however, the results
reversed, and so the N30SB/SPT N ratio, K DPSH = a × N30SB + b (1) became more scattered with depth. The
48 Journal of the South African Institution of Civil Engineering • Volume 53 Number 1 April 2011
SPT N SPT N Blow count
0 50 100 150 0 50 100 150 0 50 100 150
0 0 0
2 2 0,5
4 1,0
4
6 1,5
6
8 2,0
Depth (m)
Depth (m)
Depth (m)
8
10 2,5
10
12 3,0
12
14 3,5
14
16 4,0
16 18 4,5
18 20 5,0
SPT N (NMC) SPT N (SAT) N30SB SPT N
Figure 4 Continuous SPT N data – Matola site
Figure 6 SPT N values after artificial saturation Figure 8 Continuous SPT N values and raw
(after Golder Associates 2008) N30SB values – Milnerton site
N30SB
0 50 100 150
0
Ratio Blow count
0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 0 50 100 150
2 0 0
4 2 0,5
4 1,0
6
Depth (m)
6 1,5
8
8 2,0
Depth (m)
Depth (m)
10 10 2,5
12 12 3,0
14 3,5
14
16 4,0
16
18 4,5
Journal of the South African Institution of Civil Engineering • Volume 53 Number 1 April 2011 49
Blow count Blow count Blow count
0 50 100 150 0 50 100 150 0 50 100 150
0 0 0
0,5 1
1
1,0
2
1,5 2
3
2,0
4 3
2,5
5
Depth (m)
Depth (m)
Depth (m)
3,0 4
3,5 6
4,0 5
7
4,5
8 6
5,0
9
5,5 7
10
6,0
8
6,5 11
7,0 12 9
N30SB SPT N N30SB SPT N N30SB SPT N
Figure 10 Continuous SPT N values and raw Figure 11 Continuous SPT N values and raw Figure 12 Continuous SPT N values and raw
N30SB values – Bellville site N30SB values – Chicala site N30SB values – Umdloti site
Chicala site 4
A fine- to medium-grained sand covered the
entire Chicala site to a depth roughly between 2
18,5 and 21 m, with abundant shell fragments
scattered over the profile. The ground water 0
table was at a depth of between 16 and 12,5 m, 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160
and hence probing was assumed to be in N30SB
essentially dry material (Franki Africa 2008).
A number of DPSH and SPT probes were Figure 14 Correlation graph – Matola site
conducted at this site and the data produced
are presented in Figure 11. Although on all particularly higher. The N30SB values also fragments, randomly scattered in the profile,
the other sites the N30SB values tended to show a great deal of scatter. The borehole log will come into contact with the continuous
be higher than the respective SPT N values, recorded a large fraction of shell fragments in DPSH probe than the SPT probe carried
for the Chicala site the N30SB values were the profile. It is more probable that the shell out at set intervals. The shell fragments will
50 Journal of the South African Institution of Civil Engineering • Volume 53 Number 1 April 2011
12 from this site are presented in Figure 12. The
K DPSH = 0,03 N30SB + 1,0 borehole log from this site was very limited,
R 2 = 0,5 but note that the profile consisted of fine
10
moist material which has been shown to
8 result in larger N30SB values.
K DPSH
6
DEVELOPING AN EMPIRICAL
4 RELATIONSHIP
Correlation factors for each site, KDPSH
2 values, were determined and plotted on the
y axis against the respective N30SB values on
0
the x axis as illustrated in Figures 13 through
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 to Figure 19.
N30SB During the analysis of trends from each
individual site it was envisioned that each
Figure 15 Correlation graph – Milnerton site site would result in site-specific correlation
factors due to the different depositional
12 environments. However, the trends obtained
K DPSH = 0,03 N30SB + 0,9 appeared to be very consistent with one
R 2 = 0,6 another, barring data from the Chicala site.
10
The Chicala site correlations showed a great
8 deal of scatter and were much larger relative
to all the other data sets. The large shell
K DPSH
Journal of the South African Institution of Civil Engineering • Volume 53 Number 1 April 2011 51
20 to collapse into the air annulus around
K DPSH = 0,05 N30SB + 4 the DPSH rods. The fines fraction then
R 2 = 0,2 exerted a frictional force on the rods,
15 resulting in steadily increasing N30SB
values which were not observed in the
SPT N values. The fact that the SPT
K DPSH
52 Journal of the South African Institution of Civil Engineering • Volume 53 Number 1 April 2011
Table 2 Regressions statistics – combined data Table 3 Comparison of correlation factors
R Square 0,5 Values Standard Error t-Stat P-Value Average Correlation
Factor over N30SB range
Standard Error 1,0 Intercept 0,8 0,048 17 2,4E-62 N30SB
C & M† Warren Proposed
Observations 1212 Slope 0,02 0,001 38 1,2E-208 (1988)§ (2007)§ Function*
Depth (m)
2,5 2,5
It can be seen that the correlation func-
3,0 3,0 tion transforms the N30SB values to equiva-
lent SPT N values with relative satisfaction.
3,5 3,5
4,0 4,0
CONCLUSIONS
4,5 4,5 The aim of this paper was to evaluate the
5,0 5,0 equivalence between the SPT and DPSH tests
Uncorrected N30SB SPT N Corrected N30SB SPT N and hence determine an empirical correlation
to account for the different energy losses dur-
Figure 21 Raw SPT N and uncorrected N30SB Figure 22 Raw SPT N and corrected N30SB ing testing. This was accomplished by analys-
data – Parow site values – Parow site ing various data sets from around southern
Africa. Penetration resistance values were not
obtained in such material. Therefore a to the results obtained in this study. The just correlated statistically. Instead, quantita-
local knowledge of the underlying geology comparison is presented in Table 3. tive and qualitative geotechnical information
must always take precedence when inter- It is clear that the correlation factors gathered during the investigations was used
preting SPT N and N30SB values. obtained with the formula fit closer to the to obtain physical insight to set a theoretical
Although a number of factors have been out- correlation presented by Warren over the background to the discrepancies in energy
lined to influence the penetration resistance entire range of N30SB values. The Cearns losses. It was proposed that, because the SPT
results, there appears to be a common trend and McKenzie’s correlation factors up to is carried out in a borehole, the extension
in the data. Data from all the sites, except the a N30SB value of 45 are similar to the ones rods do not come into contact with the soil.
Chicala site, were therefore combined (see obtained by the equation. Above this the cor- Although the DPSH is carried out with rods
Figure 20 for the resulting correlation graph). relation factors diverge. However, very few of a smaller diameter than the cone, material
A number of linear regression statistical data points above a N30SB value of 30 were falls into the annulus surrounding the rods
tests were undertaken on the data and these presented by Cearns and McKenzie. Reading due to the dynamic nature of the test and
are presented in Table 2. The regression values from the graphs could have intro- ensuing vibration of the rods during impact.
statistics showed that the linear model fits duced errors, as could the different geologies This material then exerts a rod friction
the data well, albeit with a relatively large and testing procedures. The research by resulting in larger energy losses in the DPSH
standard error in y. This can be expected, Cearns and McKenzie, and by Warren, than in the SPT. Probing in sandy material
due to the variable nature of geotechnical appears to validate the research reported. from a number of different depositional and
properties and testing practices. weathering environments was analysed and
Using the values for the slope and inter- different mechanisms are proposed that can
cept from the correlation graph for the com- APPLICATION EXAMPLE lead to the rod friction:
bined data, the correction function, Equation To obtain equivalent SPT N values, raw ■ pedogenic layers with fines and weak
3, could now be fully defined: N30SB values (unaltered for rod friction by cementations
methods such as re-drive or torque correc- ■ collapsible sands with a considerable fines
N30SB
Equivalent SPT N = (4) tions) are entered into the function defined content
0,02 ´ N30SB + 0,8
by Equation 4. The equivalent SPT N values ■ partially saturated and saturated sands
Cearns and McKenzie (1988), as well as can then be used in various empirical design Although the proposed mechanisms varied,
Warren (2007), presented graphical cor- methods and correlated with various design the statistical correlation showed a close
relations based on smaller data sets in sand parameters. Raw data from the Parow site is relationship. However, a few anomalies did
and gravel and fine clayey sands with clayey presented in Figure 21 and it is clear that dif- exist. At one site an abundance of shell
layers respectively. Although these tests ferences between the two tests exist due to fragments in the profile appeared to result
sites were formed in different geological different energy losses during testing. Figure in excessively high N30SB values and hence
depositional and weathering environments to 22 shows the N30SB values corrected for the a local knowledge of geology is required for
southern Africa, the results can be compared energy losses by the proposed function. any interpretation of penetration resistance
Journal of the South African Institution of Civil Engineering • Volume 53 Number 1 April 2011 53
values. The effects of moisture content Braatvedt, I H, et al 1995. A Guide to Practical Golder Associates Africa 2008. Geotechnical inves-
must also be analysed, as radical changes Geotechnical Engineering in Southern Africa, 3rd ed. tigation for proposed Mittal steel plant Beluluane
in soil strength can result, which will affect Johannesburg: Frankipile South Africa. Park, Matola, Maputo, Mozambique. Johannesburg:
the penetration resistance recorded by Brink, A B A 1985. Engineering Geology of Southern Golder Associates Africa.
either test. The close statistical relationship Africa, Vol. 4. Silverton: Building Publications. Kantey & Templer 2007. Report on geotechnical inves-
between the majority of the data allowed for Broms, B B & Flodin, N 1988. History of soil pen- tigation for Senate Building at CPUT Bellville. Cape
the development of a correlation function. etration testing. Proceedings, 1st Symposium on Town: Kantey & Templer.
This function allows for equivalent SPT N Penetration Testing, Orlando, FL, Amsterdam: Kantey & Templer 2008. Report on geotechnical investi-
values, which can be used in design, to be A A Balkema, pp 157–220. gation for new ground flare, Milnerton Refinery. Cape
obtained from N30SB values, making this Cearns, P J & McKenzie, A 1988. Application of Town: Kantey & Templer.
cheap and easy test even more practical. dynamic cone penetrometer testing in East Anglia. Kantey & Templer 2009. Report on geotechnical inves-
Proceedings, Geotechnology Conference: Penetration tigation for UNISA, Phase 2 Development. Parow,
Testing in the UK, Birmingham, London: Thomas Cape Town: Kantey & Templer.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Telford, pp 123–127. MacRobert, C J 2009. Correlations between the dynamic
The authors wish to acknowledge Anglo Clayton, C R 1995. The Standard Penetration Test probe super heavy test and the standard penetration
Technical Services (45 Main Street, Marshall (SPT): Methods and Use. London: CIRIA. test and their application within southern Africa.
Town, Johannesburg, South Africa), Golder Decourt, L, Muromachi, T, Nixon, I K, Schmertmann, Undergrduate thesis, Cape Town: University of Cape
Associates Africa (244 Surrey Ave, Ferndale, J H, Thorburn, S & Zolkov, E 1988. Standard Town.
Randburg, South Africa), Kantey & Templer Penetration Test (SPT): International reference MacRobert, C J, Kalumba, D & Beales, P 2010.
Consulting Engineers (3rd Floor BDO test procedure. Proceedings, 1st Symposium on Penetration testing: test procedures and design use
House, 119 Hertzog Boulevard, Foreshore, Penetration Testing, Orlando, FL, Amsterdam: in South Africa. Civil Engineering, 18(3):29–38.
Cape Town, South Africa), as well as Franki A A Balkema, pp 3–26. Rust, E, Heymann, G & Jones, G 2005. Collapse
Africa (688 Main Pretoria Road, Wynberg, EN1997-2:2007. 2007. Eurocode 7: Geotechnical design. potential of partly saturated sandy soils from
Johannesburg, South Africa) for kindly pro- Part 2: Ground investigating and testing. Mozal, Mozambique. Journal of the South African
viding the analysed data. Acknowledgement Fourie, P M & Copeland, A M 1998. Geotechnical Institution of Civil Engineering, 47(1): 8–14.
also goes to Anglo American for their finan- investigation report for mining infrastruc- SAICE – Geotechnical Division 2009. Site investigation
cial support. ture at the Gope prospect in central Botswana. code of practice, 1st ed. Working paper.
Johannesburg: Anglo American Civil Engineering Terzaghi, K & Peck, R A 1948. Soil Mechanics in
Department. Engineering Practice. New York: Wiley.
REFERENCES Franki Africa 2003. Raw SPT and DPSH records for Theobald, M 2008. MAM3080F Numerical Methods
Aggarwal, V 1982. Two decades of dynamic cone pen- project name: Apartments Umdloti (T06/1205). Course Notes. Cape Town: University of Cape Town.
etration testing in India. Proceedings, 2nd European Obtained from Franki archives in Johannesburg after Warren, G 2007. Heavy weight. Ground Engineering,
Symposium on Penetration Testing, Amsterdam: discussions with Gavin Byrne and Nicol Chang. 40(3): 36–39.
A A Balkema, pp 215–222. Franki Africa 2008. Raw SPT and DPSH records for Wroth, C P 1988. Penetration testing – a more rigor-
Bloomfield, E M & Jeremy, C A 2003. Geotechnical project name: Chicalla, Illha de Luanda. Obtained ous approach. Proceedings, 1st Symposium on
properties of the northern KwaZulu-Natal coastal from Franki archives in Johannesburg after discus- Penetration Testing, Orlando, FL, Amsterdam:
sand dunes, South Africa. Heavy Minerals, 29–32. sions with Gavin Byrne and Nicol Chang. A A Balkema, Vol 1, pp 303–311.
54 Journal of the South African Institution of Civil Engineering • Volume 53 Number 1 April 2011