You are on page 1of 11

Page 1

_____________________________________________________________________________________________

Minutes of the Federal Open Market Committee


June 13–14, 2023

A joint meeting of the Federal Open Market Committee Julie Ann Remache, Deputy Manager, System Open
and the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve Sys- Market Account
tem was held in the offices of the Board of Governors
Jose Acosta, Senior Communications Analyst, Division
on Tuesday, June 13, 2023, at 10:30 a.m. and continued
of Information Technology, Board
on Wednesday, June 14, 2023, at 9:00 a.m. 1
Gianni Amisano, Assistant Director, Division of
Attendance Research and Statistics, Board
Jerome H. Powell, Chair
John C. Williams, Vice Chair Philippe Andrade, Senior Economist and Policy
Michael S. Barr Advisor, Federal Reserve Bank of Boston
Michelle W. Bowman Alyssa Arute, 2 Manager, Division of Reserve Bank
Lisa D. Cook Operations and Payment Systems, Board
Austan D. Goolsbee
Patrick Harker Penelope A. Beattie, 3 Section Chief, Office of the
Philip N. Jefferson Secretary, Board
Neel Kashkari Carol C. Bertaut, Senior Adviser, Division of
Lorie K. Logan International Finance, Board
Christopher J. Waller
Jennifer J. Burns, Deputy Director, Division of
Thomas I. Barkin, Raphael W. Bostic, Mary C. Daly, Supervision and Regulation, Board
and Loretta J. Mester, Alternate Members of the
Committee Marco Cagetti, Assistant Director, Division of Research
and Statistics, Board
James Bullard and Susan M. Collins, Presidents of the
Federal Reserve Banks of St. Louis and Boston, Mark A. Carlson, Adviser, Division of Monetary
respectively Affairs, Board
Kelly J. Dubbert, Interim President of the Federal Juan C. Climent, Special Adviser to the Board, Division
Reserve Bank of Kansas City of Board Members, Board
Joshua Gallin, Secretary Daniel M. Covitz, Deputy Director, Division of
Matthew M. Luecke, Deputy Secretary Research and Statistics, Board
Brian J. Bonis, Assistant Secretary Stephanie E. Curcuru, Deputy Director, Division of
Michelle A. Smith, Assistant Secretary International Finance, Board
Mark E. Van Der Weide, General Counsel
Richard Ostrander, Deputy General Counsel Ahmet Degerli, Economist, Division of Monetary
Trevor A. Reeve, Economist Affairs, Board
Stacey Tevlin, Economist Cynthia L. Doniger, Principal Economist, Division of
Beth Anne Wilson, Economist Monetary Affairs, Board
Roc Armenter, James A. Clouse, Brian M. Doyle, Rochelle M. Edge, Deputy Director, Division of
Beverly J. Hirtle, Andrea Raffo, Chiara Scotti, and Monetary Affairs, Board
William Wascher, Associate Economists
Jon Faust, Senior Special Adviser to the Chair, Division
Roberto Perli, Manager, System Open Market Account of Board Members, Board

1 The Federal Open Market Committee is referenced as the 2 Attended through the discussion of developments in finan-

“FOMC” and the “Committee” in these minutes; the Board cial markets and open market operations.
of Governors of the Federal Reserve System is referenced as 3 Attended through the discussion of the economic and finan-

the “Board” in these minutes. cial situation and all of Wednesday’s session.
Page 2 Federal Open Market Committee
_____________________________________________________________________________________________

Erin E. Ferris, Principal Economist, Division of Michelle M. Neal, Head of Markets, Federal Reserve
Monetary Affairs, Board Bank of New York
Jonas Fisher, Senior Vice President, Federal Reserve Edward Nelson, Senior Adviser, Division of Monetary
Bank of Chicago Affairs, Board
Glenn Follette, Associate Director, Division of Nicolas Petrosky-Nadeau, Vice President, Federal
Research and Statistics, Board Reserve Bank of San Francisco
Jennifer Gallagher, Assistant to the Board, Division of Achilles Sangster II, Senior Information Manager,
Board Members, Board Division of Monetary Affairs, Board
Carlos Garriga, Senior Vice President, Federal Reserve Zeynep Senyuz, Deputy Associate Director, Division
Bank of St. Louis of Monetary Affairs, Board
David Glancy, 4 Principal Economist, Division of Margie Shanks, Deputy Secretary, Office of the
Monetary Affairs, Board Secretary, Board
Christopher J. Gust, Associate Director, Division of Nitish Ranjan Sinha, Special Adviser to the Board,
Monetary Affairs, Board Division of Board Members, Board
Valerie S. Hinojosa, Section Chief, Division of A. Lee Smith, Senior Vice President, Federal Reserve
Monetary Affairs, Board Bank of Kansas City
Jane E. Ihrig, Special Adviser to the Board, Division of Hiroatsu Tanaka, 5 Senior Economist, Division of
Board Members, Board Monetary Affairs, Board
Michael T. Kiley, Deputy Director, Division of Mary H. Tian, Group Manager, Division of Monetary
Financial Stability, Board Affairs, Board
Don H. Kim,2 Senior Adviser, Division of Monetary Robert L. Triplett III, First Vice President, Federal
Affairs, Board Reserve Bank of Dallas
Edward S. Knotek II, Senior Vice President, Federal Clara Vega, Special Adviser to the Board, Division of
Reserve Bank of Cleveland Board Members, Board
Andreas Lehnert, Director, Division of Financial Daniel J. Vine, Principal Economist, Division of
Stability, Board Research and Statistics, Board
Paul Lengermann, Assistant Director, Division of Jeffrey D. Walker,2 Associate Director, Division of
Research and Statistics, Board Reserve Bank Operations and Payment Systems,
Board
Kurt F. Lewis, Special Adviser to the Board, Division
of Board Members, Board Fabian Winkler, Principal Economist, Division of
Monetary Affairs, Board
Geng Li, Assistant Director, Division of Research and
Statistics, Board Alexander L. Wolman, Vice President, Federal Reserve
Bank of Richmond
Laura Lipscomb, Special Adviser to the Board,
Division of Board Members, Board Paul R. Wood, Special Adviser to the Board, Division
of Board Members, Board
Brent Meyer, Assistant Vice President, Federal Reserve
Bank of Atlanta Rebecca Zarutskie, Special Adviser to the Board,
Division of Board Members, Board
Bernardo C. Morais, Principal Economist, Division of
International Finance, Board

4 Attended Tuesday’s session only. 5 Attended from the discussion of the economic and financial
situation through the end of Tuesday’s session.
Minutes of the Meeting of June 13–14, 2023 Page 3
_____________________________________________________________________________________________

Developments in Financial Markets and Open penditures (PCE) inflation in the second and third quar-
Market Operations ters of this year, while projections for later quarters were
The manager turned first to a review of developments in little changed.
financial markets. Policy-sensitive rates increased over
The manager then turned to money market develop-
the intermeeting period, reflecting indications of contin-
ments and policy implementation. The median respond-
ued resilience in the economy, persistently elevated core
ent to the Desk surveys expected the three-month bill
inflation, and reduced downside tail risks following the
yield to increase slightly relative to the similar-maturity
resolution of the debt limit. The shift in policy expecta-
overnight index swap (OIS) rate and to remain above it
tions contributed significantly to higher Treasury yields.
into the fourth quarter. This expectation likely reflected
The increase in nominal yields primarily reflected higher
a combination of rising net supply of bills as part of the
real rates rather than inflation compensation. Broad eq-
Treasury Department’s plan to rebuild the Treasury
uity prices rose, although the outperformance was con-
General Account (TGA) following the resolution of the
centrated in a handful of companies with a large market
debt limit and expectations for healthy investor demand
capitalization. Cyclical sectors fared better than sectors
for bills. The overnight reverse repurchase agreement
that tend to appreciate in a downturn, suggesting some
(ON RRP) facility, which continued to support effective
reduced investor concern about downside risks to
policy implementation and control over the federal
growth. Investor sentiment about the banking sector
funds rate, saw somewhat lower participation since the
improved as perceived tail risks regarding regional banks
resolution of the debt limit, consistent with the historical
appeared to have receded. Equity prices for regional
experience that ON RRP participation is typically re-
banks rose over the intermeeting period but were still
sponsive to changes in money market conditions. The
well below early March levels. Financial conditions in-
median respondent to the Desk’s Survey of Primary
dexes were roughly unchanged, as higher rates and a
Dealers expected ON RRP participation to trend lower
stronger dollar were offset by higher equity prices and
over the rest of this year. The staff assessed that the
narrower credit spreads.
replenishment of the TGA and the ongoing balance
The vast majority of respondents to the Open Market sheet runoff, among other factors, were likely to subtract
Desk’s Surveys of Primary Dealers and Market Partici- from reserves more than the decline in ON RRP partic-
pants expected no rate change at this meeting. While the ipation would add to them. On net, the staff judged that
median path from the surveys pointed to no rate changes reserves at the end of the year were likely to remain
through early 2024, there was significant dispersion abundant. Uncertainty surrounding the outlooks for
across respondents, and respondents saw a clear proba- both reserves and ON RRP participation was substan-
bility of additional tightening at coming meetings. Re- tial.
spondents’ average probability distribution for the level
By unanimous vote, the Committee ratified the Desk’s
of the peak policy rate shifted higher since the May meet-
domestic transactions over the intermeeting period.
ing and respondents on average assigned about 60 per-
There were no intervention operations in foreign curren-
cent probability to the peak being above the current tar-
cies for the System’s account during the intermeeting pe-
get range. The market-implied path for the policy rate
riod.
continued to show some decline this year but less so
than it had in recent months. Measures of uncertainty Staff Review of the Economic Situation
about the path of the policy rate derived from options The information available at the time of the June 13–14
remained very elevated, though they came down some meeting suggested that real gross domestic product
over the intermeeting period. (GDP) was expanding at a modest pace in the second
quarter. Labor market conditions remained tight in re-
Desk survey respondents still saw a recession occurring
cent months, as job gains were robust and the unem-
in the near term as quite likely, but the expected timing
ployment rate was low. Consumer price inflation—as
was again pushed later, as economic data pointed to the
measured by the 12-month percent change in the price
continued resilience of economic activity. Overall, re-
index for PCE—continued to be elevated in April.
spondents generally continued to expect that any down-
turn would be neither deep nor prolonged. With regard Labor market conditions remained tight in April and
to inflation expectations, respondents marked up their May. Total nonfarm payroll employment increased at a
projections for quarterly core personal consumption ex- robust pace during those two months. The unemploy-
ment rate edged up, on net, but was still at a low level of
3.7 percent in May. On balance, the unemployment rate
Page 4 Federal Open Market Committee
_____________________________________________________________________________________________

for African Americans moved up to 5.6 percent, while panding more slowly in the second quarter than its ro-
the jobless rate for Hispanics moved down to 4.0 per- bust first-quarter pace. For the first half as a whole,
cent. In aggregate, the labor force participation rate held PDFP growth seemed to be more resilient than in the
steady in April and May, and the employment-to- second half of last year.
population ratio ticked down. The private-sector job
The annual revisions to international trade statistics sug-
openings rate in April—as measured by the Job Open-
gested that net exports contributed positively to U.S. real
ings and Labor Turnover Survey—was unchanged from
GDP growth in the first quarter, with real exports re-
its relatively high first-quarter average, though it was
bounding more strongly than real imports following
lower than a year earlier.
their fourth-quarter declines. In April, however, the
Recent measures of nominal wage growth continued to nominal trade deficit widened notably, as nominal ex-
be elevated, although lower than their highs last year. ports decreased and nominal imports rose further.
Over the 12 months ending in May, average hourly earn-
Foreign economic growth rebounded in the first quarter,
ings for all employees increased 4.3 percent, below its
reflecting in part the reopening of China’s economy
peak of 5.9 percent early last year. Over the year ending
from its COVID-19-related shutdowns and strong
in the first quarter, compensation per hour in the busi-
services-sector activity in other Asian countries, Canada,
ness sector increased 3.2 percent, down from 5.5 percent
and Mexico. In the euro area, however, real GDP con-
a year earlier.
tracted modestly for a second consecutive quarter amid
Consumer price inflation remained elevated. Total PCE a pullback in consumer spending. Indicators pointed to
price inflation had eased since the middle of last year, a step-down in the pace of foreign economic growth in
reflecting declines in consumer energy prices and soften- the second quarter, with the impetus from China’s reo-
ing consumer food price inflation, but recent readings pening dissipating and global manufacturing activity re-
for core PCE price inflation—which excludes changes maining weak.
in consumer energy prices and most consumer food
Global prices for energy and agricultural commodities
prices and usually provides a better signal about future
were little changed, on net, over the intermeeting period,
inflation than the more volatile total inflation measure—
while prices for metals fell further. Declines in retail en-
were little changed. Total PCE price inflation was
ergy prices since the beginning of the year contributed
4.4 percent over the 12 months ending in April, and core
to a notable easing in headline consumer price inflation
PCE price inflation was 4.7 percent—the same as the
in the foreign economies. By contrast, core inflation had
12-month percent change recorded in January. In May,
yet to materially decline from its recent highs in many
the 12-month change in the consumer price index (CPI)
economies. In this context, and with tight labor market
was 4.0 percent, and core CPI inflation was 5.3 per-
conditions, foreign central banks underscored the need
cent—only slightly below its January reading. The
to raise policy rates further or hold them at sufficiently
trimmed mean measure of 12-month PCE price infla-
restrictive levels to bring inflation back to their respec-
tion constructed by the Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas
tive targets and be well positioned in case inflation failed
was 4.8 percent in April. Survey-based measures of
to decline as expected.
longer-term inflation expectations in May from the Uni-
versity of Michigan Surveys of Consumers and the Fed- Staff Review of the Financial Situation
eral Reserve Bank of New York’s Survey of Consumer Over the intermeeting period, market participants ap-
Expectations remained within the range of their values peared to interpret incoming data as signaling, on bal-
reported in the decade before the pandemic; near-term ance, more resilience in economic activity than previ-
measures of inflation expectations from these surveys ously assumed and viewed communications from
moved down in May and continued to be below their FOMC participants overall as pointing to a tighter path
peaks seen last year. for policy than expected. As a result, Treasury yields and
the expected future path for the federal funds rate
Real GDP appeared to be increasing modestly in the sec-
shifted upward significantly. Meanwhile, broad equity
ond quarter following its stronger first-quarter gain. Pri-
prices also increased notably. Financing conditions re-
vate domestic final purchases (PDFP)—which includes
mained moderately restrictive, but credit availability gen-
PCE, residential investment, and business fixed invest-
erally remained solid.
ment and often provides a better signal of underlying
economic momentum than GDP—looked to be ex- The expected path of the policy rate implied by market
quotes moved up notably over the intermeeting period.
Minutes of the Meeting of June 13–14, 2023 Page 5
_____________________________________________________________________________________________

A straight read of federal funds futures rates suggested In domestic credit markets, borrowing costs for busi-
that market participants expected that the federal funds nesses, households, and municipalities increased notably
rate would be roughly flat over the course of the rest of over the intermeeting period. Interest rates on newly
this year. The year-end expected rate was about 70 basis originated bank loans to businesses and households in
points higher than the year-end expectation before the the first quarter rose further above their peaks from the
May FOMC meeting. Beyond this year, the policy rate previous tightening cycle, and yields on leveraged loans
path implied by OIS quotes also moved up, to about also rose, reaching levels close to their peak at the onset
3.7 percent by the end of 2024. Similarly, nominal of the pandemic. Rates also moved up on a broad array
Treasury yields rose significantly. The rise in nominal of fixed-income securities, including investment- and
yields mostly reflected an increase in real yields, as speculative-grade corporate bonds, municipal bonds,
measures of inflation compensation were little changed, both agency and non-agency commercial mortgage-
on net, amid somewhat mixed news on inflation. backed securities (CMBS), and agency residential
Measures of uncertainty about the path of interest rates mortgage-backed securities. The increases in yields on
remained very elevated by historical standards. these instruments over the intermeeting period were
generally in line with, or less than, the changes in their
The S&P 500 stock price index increased sizably, on net,
Treasury benchmarks. Small businesses and households
over the intermeeting period, led by technology-related
saw continued increases in their borrowing costs. Rates
stocks. The VIX—the one-month option-implied vola-
on 30-year conforming residential mortgages stepped
tility on the S&P 500 index—edged down, on balance,
up, broadly in line with increases in comparable-duration
and ended the period near the 30th percentile of its his-
Treasury yields. Interest rates on credit card offers con-
torical distribution. Bank equity price indexes moved up
tinued to rise through April, and auto loan interest rates
notably, on net, over the intermeeting period. Stock
moved sideways during the intermeeting period. Both
prices for large banks were only somewhat below their
credit card and auto loan interest rates stood at, or near,
levels before the failure of Silicon Valley Bank (SVB),
their highest levels since the Global Financial Crisis.
while those for regional banks remained below their lev-
els in early March. Banks’ ability to fund loans to businesses and consumers
appeared to have stabilized in recent weeks but remained
Market-based policy rate expectations rose notably in
somewhat strained relative to before the closure of SVB
most advanced foreign economies, as core inflation data
in March. Although banks continued to experience out-
surprised to the upside in some countries and central
flows of core deposits, the pace of those outflows mod-
bank communications were perceived as pointing to
erated substantially relative to March, suggesting some
more restrictive policy than expected. Notwithstanding
easing of bank funding pressures. Banks also continued
the rise in global yields, foreign equity prices, credit
to attract inflows of large time deposits, reflecting higher
spreads, and risk sentiment in foreign markets were little
interest rates on new certificates of deposit. Total bank
changed over the intermeeting period. The staff’s trade-
assets were little changed, on net, over the intermeeting
weighted broad dollar index was also little changed, on
period.
net, but the exchange value of the dollar appreciated sig-
nificantly against the Chinese renminbi amid increased In capital markets, funding had generally been resilient.
investor concerns over China’s economic growth pro- Issuance of nonfinancial investment-grade corporate
spects. bonds rose at a robust pace in May after slowing in April,
partly due to the “earnings blackout” period. Specula-
Conditions in overnight bank funding and repurchase
tive-grade issuance increased in late April and in May but
agreement markets remained generally stable over the in-
remained subdued by historical standards. Gross issu-
termeeting period. The 25 basis point increase in admin-
ance of municipal bonds was solid in April and May.
istered rates at the May FOMC meeting fully passed
through to overnight money market rates. Spreads and Conditions in the leveraged loan and CMBS markets
issuance volumes in unsecured short-term funding mar- were somewhat more strained. Leveraged loan issuance
kets stayed within their typical ranges. In May, yields of remained subdued, reflecting weak investor demand
Treasury bills maturing in June and thus potentially af- amid concerns over the credit worthiness of borrowers.
fected by the federal debt limit rose sharply before Both agency and non-agency CMBS issuance volumes
largely retracing those increases after an agreement was were low in May relative to pre-pandemic levels. In ad-
reached to suspend the debt limit. dition, for small businesses, credit availability continued
to show signs of tightening.
Page 6 Federal Open Market Committee
_____________________________________________________________________________________________

Credit remained easily available in the residential mort- and further moderation in food price inflation, total in-
gage market for high credit score borrowers who met flation was projected to run below core inflation this year
standard conforming loan criteria. For borrowers with and the next. In 2025, both total and core PCE price
lower scores, credit availability tightened slightly in April inflation were expected to be close to 2 percent.
but remained close to pre-pandemic levels. In consumer
The staff continued to judge that uncertainty around the
credit markets, conditions stayed generally accommoda-
baseline projection was considerable and still viewed the
tive, with credit available for most borrowers.
risks as being influenced importantly by the potential
The credit quality of most businesses and households re- macroeconomic implications of banking-sector develop-
mained solid, although market participants appeared to ments, which could end up being more, or less, negative
expect some deterioration in the coming quarters, which than assumed in the baseline. Given the continued
could weaken lender balance sheets and possibly weigh strength in labor market conditions and the resilience of
on credit availability. A measure of the May CMBS de- consumer spending, however, the staff saw the possibil-
linquency rate showed about a 50 basis point increase, ity of the economy continuing to grow slowly and avoid-
driven by a sharp rise in the delinquency rate for office ing a downturn as almost as likely as the mild-recession
buildings. baseline. On balance, the staff saw the risks around the
baseline inflation forecast as tilted to the upside, as eco-
Staff Economic Outlook
nomic scenarios with higher inflation appeared more
The economic forecast prepared by the staff for the June
likely than scenarios with lower inflation and because in-
FOMC meeting continued to assume that the effects of
flation could continue to be more persistent than ex-
the expected further tightening in bank credit condi-
pected and inflation expectations could become unan-
tions, amid already tight financial conditions, would lead
chored after a long period of elevated inflation.
to a mild recession starting later this year, followed by a
moderately paced recovery. Real GDP was projected to Participants’ Views on Current Conditions and the
decelerate in the current quarter and the next one before Economic Outlook
declining modestly in both the fourth quarter of this year In conjunction with this FOMC meeting, participants
and first quarter of next year. Real GDP growth over submitted their projections of the most likely outcomes
2024 and 2025 was projected to be below the staff’s es- for real GDP growth, the unemployment rate, and infla-
timate of potential output growth. The unemployment tion for each year from 2023 through 2025 and over the
rate was forecast to increase this year, peak next year, longer run. The projections were based on their individ-
and remain near that level through 2025. Current tight ual assessments of appropriate monetary policy, includ-
resource utilization in both product and labor markets ing the path of the federal funds rate. The longer-run
was forecast to ease, with the level of real output moving projections represented each participant’s assessment of
below the staff’s estimate of potential output in 2025 and the rate to which each variable would be expected to
the unemployment rate rising above the staff’s estimate converge, over time, under appropriate monetary policy
of its natural rate at that time. and in the absence of further shocks to the economy. A
Summary of Economic Projections (SEP) was released
The staff’s inflation forecast was little revised relative to
to the public following the conclusion of the meeting.
the previous projection, and supply–demand imbalances
in both goods markets and labor markets were still In their discussion of current economic conditions, par-
judged to be easing only slowly. On a four-quarter ticipants noted that economic activity had continued to
change basis, total PCE price inflation was projected to expand at a modest pace. Nonetheless, job gains had
be 3.0 percent this year, with core inflation at 3.7 per- been robust in recent months, and the unemployment
cent. Core goods inflation was forecast to move down rate had remained low. Inflation remained elevated.
further this year and then remain subdued. Housing ser- Participants agreed that the U.S. banking system was
vices inflation was considered to have about peaked and sound and resilient. They commented that tighter credit
was expected to move down over the rest of the year. conditions for households and businesses were likely to
Core nonhousing services inflation was projected to weigh on economic activity, hiring, and inflation. How-
slow gradually as nominal wage growth eased further. ever, participants agreed that the extent of these effects
Reflecting the effects of the easing in resource utilization remained uncertain. Against this background, partici-
over the projection, core inflation was forecast to slow pants concurred that they remained highly attentive to
through next year but remain moderately above 2 per- inflation risks.
cent. With expected declines in consumer energy prices
Minutes of the Meeting of June 13–14, 2023 Page 7
_____________________________________________________________________________________________

In assessing the economic outlook, most participants Regarding the business sector, various participants said
noted that real GDP growth had been resilient in recent that reports from their contacts were mixed, with some
quarters. Participants generally judged that growth pointing to softening economic conditions and others
would be subdued over the remainder of this year. They indicating greater-than-expected strength. Many partic-
assessed that the cumulative tightening of monetary pol- ipants noted that developments in the banking sector ap-
icy over the past year had contributed significantly to peared to have had only a modest effect so far on credit
more restrictive financial conditions and lower demand availability for firms. Some participants remarked that
in the most interest rate sensitive sectors of the econ- the effect of high interest rates on the housing sector ap-
omy, especially housing and business investment. Par- peared to be bottoming out, with home sales, builder
ticipants also acknowledged uncertainty about the lags sentiment, and new construction all having improved a
with which monetary policy affects the economy and little since the start of the year.
discussed the extent to which the full effects of mone-
In their discussion of economic activity, several partici-
tary tightening on the economy had been realized. While
pants pointed out that recent GDP readings had been
total inflation had moderated over the past year, core in-
stronger than expected earlier in the year, while gross
flation had not shown a sustained easing since the begin-
domestic income (GDI) readings had been weak. Of
ning of the year. With inflation well above the Commit-
those who noted the discrepancy between GDP and
tee’s longer-run 2 percent objective, participants ex-
GDI, most suggested that economic momentum may
pected that a period of below-trend growth in real GDP
not be as strong as indicated by the GDP readings. In
and some softening in labor market conditions would be
discussing that possibility, a couple of these participants
needed to bring aggregate supply and aggregate demand
also cited the recent subdued growth in aggregate hours
into better balance and reduce inflationary pressures suf-
worked.
ficiently to return inflation to 2 percent over time.
Participants noted that labor market conditions re-
Participants generally noted that banking stresses had re-
mained very tight, with robust payroll gains and the un-
ceded and conditions in the banking sector were much
employment rate still near historically low levels. Nev-
improved since early March. Participants generally con-
ertheless, they noted some signs that supply and demand
tinued to judge that a tightening in credit conditions
in the labor market were coming into better balance,
spurred by banking-sector stress earlier in the year would
with the prime-age labor force participation rate moving
likely weigh further on economic activity, but the extent
up in recent months and further reductions in rates of
remained uncertain. Several participants mentioned that
job openings and quits, and declines in average weekly
credit conditions had not appeared to have tightened sig-
hours. A couple of participants conveyed that they
nificantly beyond what would be expected in response
heard at a recent Fed Listens event that, in various parts
to the monetary policy actions taken since early last year.
of the country, the lack of affordable housing in the area
Some participants judged that it was still too early to as-
was preventing some lower-income workers from relo-
sess with confidence the eventual effects of tighter bank
cating to accept jobs. Similarly, a few participants noted
credit conditions on economic activity and noted that it
that their District contacts reported less difficulty in hir-
would be important to monitor closely the potential ef-
ing and retaining workers, lower turnover rates, and
fects of banking-sector developments on credit condi-
some layoffs. Some participants pointed out that payroll
tions and economic activity.
gains had remained robust but noted that some other
In their discussion of the household sector, participants measures of employment—such as those based on the
generally noted that consumer spending so far this year Bureau of Labor Statistics’ household survey, the Quar-
had been stronger than expected. Several participants terly Census of Employment and Wages, or the Board
noted that aggregate household wealth remained high, as staff’s measure of private employment using data from
equity and home prices had not declined much from the payroll processing firm ADP—suggested that job
their recent highs. A few participants mentioned that growth may have been weaker than indicated by payroll
while, overall, the household sector still retained much employment. Participants anticipated that employment
of the excess savings it had accumulated during the pan- growth would likely slow further, consistent with their
demic, there were signs that consumers were facing in- projections of below-trend economic growth. Partici-
creasingly tighter budget constraints, given high inflation pants noted that nominal wage growth had shown signs
and, especially for low-income households, depleted sav- of easing but observed that it was still running at a pace
ings. that, given current estimates of trend productivity
growth, was above what would be consistent over the
Page 8 Federal Open Market Committee
_____________________________________________________________________________________________

longer run with the Committee’s 2 percent inflation ob- potentially contributing to a slowdown in economic ac-
jective. Participants expected supply and demand con- tivity that reduces inflationary pressures.
ditions in the labor market to come into better balance
In their consideration of appropriate monetary policy ac-
over time, easing pressures on wages and prices.
tions at this meeting, participants concurred that while
Participants agreed that inflation was unacceptably high inflation had moderated since the middle of 2022, it re-
and noted that the data, including the CPI for May, indi- mained well above the Committee’s longer-run goal of
cated that declines in inflation had been slower than they 2 percent. Economic activity had continued to expand
had expected. Participants observed that although core at a modest pace. The labor market remained very tight,
goods inflation had moderated since the middle of last with robust job gains in recent months and the unem-
year, it had slowed less rapidly than expected in recent ployment rate still low, but there were some signs that
months, despite data and reports from business contacts supply and demand in the labor market were coming
indicating that supply chain constraints had continued to into better balance. The economy was facing headwinds
ease. Some participants noted the recent moderation in from tighter credit conditions, including higher interest
housing services inflation and expected this trend to rates, for households and businesses, which would likely
continue. However, a few participants pointed to upside weigh on economic activity, hiring, and inflation, al-
risks to the outlook for housing services inflation asso- though the extent of these effect remained uncertain.
ciated with near-record low inventories of homes for Against this backdrop, and in consideration of the sig-
sale, solid housing demand, and less-than-expected de- nificant cumulative tightening in the stance of monetary
celeration recently in measures of rents for leases signed policy and the lags with which policy affects economic
by new tenants. Additionally, some participants re- activity and inflation, almost all participants judged it ap-
marked that core nonhousing services inflation had propriate or acceptable to maintain the target range for
shown few signs of slowing in the past few months. Sev- the federal funds rate at 5 to 5¼ percent at this meeting.
eral participants noted that longer-term measures of in- Most of these participants observed that leaving the tar-
flation expectations from surveys of households and get range unchanged at this meeting would allow them
businesses remained well anchored. Participants empha- more time to assess the economy’s progress toward the
sized that, with appropriate firming of monetary policy, Committee’s goals of maximum employment and price
well-anchored longer-term inflation expectations would stability. Some participants indicated that they favored
support a return of inflation to the Committee’s 2 per- raising the target range for the federal funds rate 25 basis
cent longer-run goal over time. points at this meeting or that they could have supported
such a proposal. The participants favoring a 25 basis
Participants generally noted a high degree of uncertainty
point increase noted that the labor market remained very
regarding the cumulative effects on the economy from
tight, momentum in economic activity had been stronger
both already-enacted monetary policy tightening and the
than earlier anticipated, and there were few clear signs
potential additional tightening in credit conditions stem-
that inflation was on a path to return to the Committee’s
ming from recent banking-sector developments. Partic-
2 percent objective over time. All participants agreed
ipants noted that the full effects of monetary tightening
that it was appropriate to continue the process of reduc-
had likely yet to be observed, though several highlighted
ing the Federal Reserve’s securities holdings, as de-
the possibility that much of the effect of past monetary
scribed in its previously announced Plans for Reducing
policy tightening may have already been realized. Re-
the Size of the Federal Reserve’s Balance Sheet.
garding downside risks to economic activity, participants
noted the possibility that the cumulative and rapid tight- In discussing the policy outlook, all participants contin-
ening of monetary policy would eventually affect eco- ued to anticipate that, with inflation still well above the
nomic activity more than expected, and that the addi- Committee’s 2 percent goal and the labor market re-
tional effects of the tightening of bank credit conditions maining very tight, maintaining a restrictive stance for
could prove more substantial than anticipated. Regard- monetary policy would be appropriate to achieve the
ing risks to inflation, with inflation remaining well above Committee’s objectives. Almost all participants noted
the Committee’s longer-run goal, some participants that in their economic projections that they judged that
mentioned the possibility that longer-term inflation ex- additional increases in the target federal funds rate dur-
pectations could become unanchored, particularly in ing 2023 would be appropriate. Most participants ob-
light of stronger-than-expected consumer demand and a served that uncertainty about the outlook for the econ-
still-tight labor market. Several participants cited the omy and inflation remained elevated and that additional
possibility of delayed effects of tighter credit conditions
Minutes of the Meeting of June 13–14, 2023 Page 9
_____________________________________________________________________________________________

information would be valuable for considering the ap- Committee Policy Actions
propriate stance of monetary policy. Many also noted In their discussion of monetary policy for this meeting,
that, after rapidly tightening the stance of monetary pol- members agreed that economic activity had continued to
icy last year, the Committee had slowed the pace of tight- expand at a modest pace. They also concurred that job
ening and that a further moderation in the pace of policy gains had been robust in recent months, and the unem-
firming was appropriate in order to provide additional ployment rate had remained low. Inflation had remained
time to observe the effects of cumulative tightening and elevated.
assess their implications for policy. Participants agreed
Members concurred that the U.S. banking system was
that their policy decisions at every meeting would con-
sound and resilient. They also agreed that tighter credit
tinue to be based on the totality of incoming information
conditions for households and businesses were likely to
and its implications for the economic outlook as well as
weigh on economic activity, hiring, and inflation, but
the balance of risks. They also emphasized the im-
that the extent of these effects was uncertain. Members
portance of communicating to the public their data-
also concurred that they remained highly attentive to in-
dependent approach. Most participants observed that
flation risks.
postmeeting communications, including the SEP, would
help clarify their assessment regarding the stance of Members agreed that the Committee seeks to achieve
monetary policy that is likely to be appropriate to bring maximum employment and inflation at the rate of 2 per-
inflation down to 2 percent over time. cent over the longer run. In support of these goals, the
members agreed to maintain the target range for the fed-
Participants also discussed several risk-management
eral funds rate at 5 to 5¼ percent. Members agreed that
considerations that could bear on future policy deci-
holding the target range steady at this meeting allowed
sions. Almost all participants stated that, with inflation
the Committee to assess additional information and its
still well above the Committee’s longer-run goal and the
implications for monetary policy. In determining the ex-
labor market remaining tight, upside risks to the inflation
tent of additional policy firming that may be appropriate
outlook or the possibility that persistently high inflation
to return inflation to 2 percent over time, members con-
might cause inflation expectations to become unan-
curred that they will take into account the cumulative
chored remained key factors shaping the policy outlook.
tightening of monetary policy, the lags with which mon-
Even though economic activity had been resilient re-
etary policy affects economic activity and inflation, and
cently and that the labor market remained strong, some
economic and financial developments. In addition,
participants commented that there continued to be
members agreed that the Committee will continue to re-
downside risks to economic growth and upside risks to
duce the Federal Reserve’s holdings of Treasury securi-
unemployment. Despite the receding of the stresses in
ties and agency debt and agency mortgage-backed secu-
the banking sector, some participants commented that it
rities, as described in its previously announced plans. All
would be important to monitor whether developments
members affirmed that they are strongly committed to
in the banking sector lead to further tightening of credit
returning inflation to their 2 percent objective.
conditions and weigh on economic activity. Some par-
ticipants noted concerns about the potential risks stem- Members agreed that, in assessing the appropriate stance
ming from weakness in commercial real estate. of monetary policy, they would continue to monitor the
implications of incoming information for the economic
A number of participants observed that the resolution
outlook. They would be prepared to adjust the stance of
of the federal government debt limit had removed one
monetary policy as appropriate if risks emerge that could
source of significant uncertainty for the economic out-
impede the attainment of the Committee’s goals. Mem-
look. A few participants noted that there could be some
bers also agreed that their assessments will take into ac-
upward pressure on money market rates in the near term
count a wide range of information, including readings on
as the Treasury issued more bills to meet expenditures
labor market conditions, inflation pressures and inflation
and return the balance in the TGA to the Treasury’s pre-
expectations, and financial and international develop-
ferred level. Those participants observed that upward
ments.
pressure on money market rates relative to the rate of-
fered on the ON RRP facility could lead to a decline in At the conclusion of the discussion, the Committee
usage of the facility. voted to direct the Federal Reserve Bank of New York,
until instructed otherwise, to execute transactions in the
System Open Market Account in accordance with the
Page 10 Federal Open Market Committee
_____________________________________________________________________________________________

following domestic policy directive, for release at businesses are likely to weigh on economic ac-
2:00 p.m.: tivity, hiring, and inflation. The extent of these
effects remains uncertain. The Committee re-
“Effective June 15, 2023, the Federal Open
mains highly attentive to inflation risks.
Market Committee directs the Desk to:
The Committee seeks to achieve maximum em-
• Undertake open market operations as nec-
ployment and inflation at the rate of 2 percent
essary to maintain the federal funds rate in
over the longer run. In support of these goals,
a target range of 5 to 5¼ percent.
the Committee decided to maintain the target
• Conduct standing overnight repurchase range for the federal funds rate at 5 to 5¼ per-
agreement operations with a minimum bid cent. Holding the target range steady at this
rate of 5.25 percent and with an aggregate meeting allows the Committee to assess addi-
operation limit of $500 billion. tional information and its implications for mon-
etary policy. In determining the extent of addi-
• Conduct standing overnight reverse repur- tional policy firming that may be appropriate to
chase agreement operations at an offering return inflation to 2 percent over time, the
rate of 5.05 percent and with a per-counter- Committee will take into account the cumula-
party limit of $160 billion per day. tive tightening of monetary policy, the lags with
• Roll over at auction the amount of principal which monetary policy affects economic activity
payments from the Federal Reserve’s hold- and inflation, and economic and financial devel-
ings of Treasury securities maturing in each opments. In addition, the Committee will con-
calendar month that exceeds a cap of tinue reducing its holdings of Treasury securi-
$60 billion per month. Redeem Treasury ties and agency debt and agency mortgage-
coupon securities up to this monthly cap backed securities, as described in its previously
and Treasury bills to the extent that coupon announced plans. The Committee is strongly
principal payments are less than the committed to returning inflation to its 2 percent
monthly cap. objective.
• Reinvest into agency mortgage-backed se- In assessing the appropriate stance of monetary
curities (MBS) the amount of principal pay- policy, the Committee will continue to monitor
ments from the Federal Reserve’s holdings the implications of incoming information for
of agency debt and agency MBS received in the economic outlook. The Committee would
each calendar month that exceeds a cap of be prepared to adjust the stance of monetary
$35 billion per month. policy as appropriate if risks emerge that could
impede the attainment of the Committee’s
• Allow modest deviations from stated goals. The Committee’s assessments will take
amounts for reinvestments, if needed for into account a wide range of information, in-
operational reasons. cluding readings on labor market conditions, in-
• Engage in dollar roll and coupon swap flation pressures and inflation expectations, and
transactions as necessary to facilitate settle- financial and international developments.”
ment of the Federal Reserve’s agency MBS Voting for this action: Jerome H. Powell, John C.
transactions.” Williams, Michael S. Barr, Michelle W. Bowman, Lisa D.
The vote also encompassed approval of the statement Cook, Austan D. Goolsbee, Patrick Harker, Philip N.
below for release at 2:00 p.m.: Jefferson, Neel Kashkari, Lorie K. Logan, and
Christopher J. Waller.
“Recent indicators suggest that economic activ-
ity has continued to expand at a modest pace. Voting against this action: None.
Job gains have been robust in recent months, Consistent with the Committee’s decision to leave the
and the unemployment rate has remained low. target range for the federal funds rate unchanged, the
Inflation remains elevated. Board voted unanimously to maintain the interest rate
The U.S. banking system is sound and resilient. paid on reserve balances at 5.15 percent, effective
Tighter credit conditions for households and June 15, 2023. The Board also voted unanimously to
Minutes of the Meeting of June 13–14, 2023 Page 11
_____________________________________________________________________________________________

approve the establishment of the primary credit rate at


the existing level of 5.25 percent.
It was agreed that the next meeting of the Committee
would be held on Tuesday–Wednesday, July 25–26,
2023. The meeting adjourned at 10:20 a.m. on June 14,
2023.
Notation Vote
By notation vote completed on May 23, 2023, the Com-
mittee unanimously approved the minutes of the Com-
mittee meeting held on May 2–3, 2023.

_______________________
Joshua Gallin
Secretary

You might also like