Professional Documents
Culture Documents
sociology
a brief introduction
10th edition
Richard T. Schaefer
DePaul University
TM
Understanding
Sociology 1
Today you may have thought about what to wear. But did you ask your-
self where those garments came from, or who made them?
Journalist Kelsey Timmerman offers some answers to these questions.
His book speaks to the way we see ourselves, not only in the mirror
when we’re getting dressed, but in the world at large.
I was made in America. My Workers flood the narrow alley beside the Delta Apparel Factory in
Jingle These Christmas boxers San Pedro Sula, Honduras. They rush to catch one of the many waiting
were made in Bangladesh. buses at the highway. Merchants hoping to part them from a portion of their
I had an all-American daily earnings—$4 to $5—fight for their attention. Vehicles push through the
childhood in rural Ohio. My crowd. A minivan knocks over a girl in her midtwenties and then runs over
all-American blue jeans were her foot. She curses, is helped to her feet, and limps onto a waiting bus.
made in Cambodia. The buildings behind the fence are shaded in Bahamian pastels
I wore flip-flops every day and very well kept. The shrubs have been recently shaped, and the
for a year when I worked as grass trimmed. In the bright Honduran sun, they seem as pleasant as
a SCUBA diving instructor in a factory can get.
Key West. They were made in The lady at Delta Apparel, based in Georgia, giggled at me on the
China. phone when I told her my plans. She was happy to tell me that their
One day while staring at Honduran factory was located in the city of Villanueva just south of
a pile of clothes on the floor, I noticed the tag of my favorite T-shirt: San Pedro Sula. She even wished me good luck.
“Made in Honduras.” Now that I’m in Honduras, the company doesn’t think it’s very funny.
I read the tag. My mind wandered. A quest was born. I stand among the chaos overwhelmed. A thousand sets of eyes
Where am I wearing? It seems like a simple question with a simple stare at me; perhaps they recognize my T-shirt. The irony that this is
answer. It’s not. Tattoo’s tropical paradise wore off long ago—somewhere between the
The question inspired the quest confrontation with the big-bellied
that took me around the globe. It Where am I wearing? This isn’t so much a question guards at the factory gate who
cost me a lot of things, not the least had guns shoved down their
related to geography and clothes, but about the people
of which was my consumer inno- pants like little boys playing cow-
cence. Before the quest, I could put who make our clothes and the texture of their lives. boy and the conversation with the
on a piece of clothing without read- tight-lipped company representa-
ing its tag and thinking about Arifa in Bangladesh or Dewan in China, about tive who failed to reveal much of anything about my T-shirt or the peo-
their children, their hopes and dreams, and the challenges they face. ple who assembled it. There was no way I was getting onto the factory
Where am I wearing? This isn’t so much a question related to geog- floor. All I learned was that eight humans of indiscriminate age and sex
raphy and clothes, but about the people who make our clothes and stitched my shirt together in less than five minutes.
the texture of their lives. This quest is about the way we live and the
way they live; because when it comes to clothing, others make it, and (Timmerman 2009:xiii–xiv, 14) Additional information about this excerpt can be found
we have it made. And there’s a big, big difference. . . . on the Online Learning Center at www.mhhe.com/schaeferbrief10e.
In his book Where Am I Wearing? A Global Tour to the Coun- that documents the existence and extent of inequality around the
tries, Factories, and People that Make Our Clothes, Timmerman world. Social inequality has a pervasive influence on human inter-
recounts his travels to the countries where his jeans, T-shirts, and actions and institutions. Certain groups of people control scarce
flip-flops—the uniform of today’s young adult—were made. From resources, wield power, and receive special treatment.
Honduras to Bangladesh, from Cambodia to the United States, he Although it might be interesting to know how one individual,
tracked down the factories and befriended the seamstresses who like Kelsey Timmerman or a foreign factory worker, is affected
labored there. Though owners were reluctant to allow him on the by social inequality, sociologists consider how entire groups of
factory floor, they couldn’t prevent him from visiting workers’ people are affected by such factors, and how society itself might
homes and families. Timmerman found that both inside and out- be altered by them. Sociologists, then, are not concerned with
side the factory, garment workers lived in what would be consid- what one individual does or does not do, but with what people
ered substandard conditions in the United States. He argues that do as members of a group or in interaction with one another,
global apparel companies should take responsibility for conditions and what that means for individuals and for society as a whole.
at their suppliers’ factories, even if those factories are located half- For example, sociologists have considered how, together, college
way around the world (Fairtrade Foundation 2010). students have taken sociology with them, organizing to confront
Timmerman’s book focuses on an unequal global economy, the sportswear companies that underpay the overseas workers
which is a central topic in sociology. His investigative work, like the who create their team uniforms and the T-shirts proclaiming
4 work of many other journalists, is informed by sociological research their school pride (Esbenshade 2008; Silverstein 2010).
As a field of study, sociology is extremely broad in scope. sociology as both a field of inquiry and an exercise of the “socio- 5
You will see throughout this book the range of topics soci- logical imagination.” We’ll look at the discipline as a science and
ologists investigate—from suicide to TV viewing habits, from consider its relationship to other social sciences. We’ll meet four
Understanding Sociology
Amish society to global economic patterns, from peer pressure pioneering thinkers—Émile Durkheim, Max Weber, Karl Marx, and
to genetic engineering. Sociology looks at how others influence W. E. B. DuBois—and examine the theoretical perspectives that
our behavior; how major social institutions like the government, grew out of their work. We’ll note some of the practical applications
religion, and the economy affect us; and how we ourselves affect for sociological theory and research. Finally, we’ll see how sociology
other individuals, groups, and even organizations. helps us to develop a sociological imagination. For those students
How did sociology develop? In what ways does it differ from interested in exploring career opportunities in sociology, the chapter
other social sciences? This chapter will explore the nature of closes with a special appendix.
Aging and the Life Course Environment and Technology Peace, War, and Social Conflict
Understanding Sociology
Alcohol, Drugs, and Tobacco Ethnomethodology and Conversation Analysis Political Economy of the World-System
Altruism, Morality and Social Solidarity Evolution, Biology and Society Political Sociology
Animals and Society Family Population
Asia and Asian America Global and Transnational Sociology Race, Gender, and Class
Body and Embodiment History of Sociology Racial and Ethnic Minorities
Children and Youth Human Rights Rationality and Society
Collective Behavior and Social Movements International Migration Religion
Communication and Information Technologies Labor and Labor Movements Science, Knowledge, and Technology
Community and Urban Sociology Latino/a Sociology Sex and Gender
Comparative and Historical Sociology Law Sexualities
Crime, Law, and Deviance Marxist Sociology Social Psychology
Culture Mathematical Sociology Sociological Practice and Public Sociology
Disability and Society Medical Sociology Teaching and Learning
Economic Sociology Mental Health Theory
Education Methodology
Emotions Organizations, Occupations, and Work
The range of sociological issues is very broad. For example, sociologists who belong to the Animals and Society section of the ASA may study the animal rights
movement; those who belong to the Sexualities section may study global sex workers or the gay, bisexual, and transgendered movements. Economic sociologists may
investigate globalization or consumerism, among many other topics.
Source: American Sociological Association 2012.
Think about It
Which of these topics do you think would interest you the most? Why?
(New Orleans), the percentage of working people aged 16 to 64 are disabled—56 percent. Moving wheelchair-bound residents
dropped significantly during the recession. When friends and co- to safety requires specially equipped vehicles, to say nothing of
workers are laid off, carpools shrink and more people end up driv- handicap-accessible accommodations in public shelters. Clearly,
ing to work alone (El Nasser and Overberg 2011). officials must consider these factors in developing evacuation
Sociologists would take a similar approach to studying epi- plans (Bureau of the Census 2005b).
sodes of extreme violence. In April 2007, just as college students Sociological analysis of the disaster did not end when the
were beginning to focus on the impending end of the semester, floodwaters receded. Long before residents of New Orleans
tragedy struck on the campus of Virginia Tech. In a two-hour staged a massive anticrime rally at City Hall in 2007, researchers
shooting spree, a mentally disturbed senior armed with semi- were analyzing resettlement patterns in the city. They noted that
automatic weapons killed a total of 32 students and faculty at returning residents often faced bleak job prospects. Yet families
Virginia’s largest university. Observers struggled to describe the who had stayed away for that reason often had trouble enrolling
events and place them in some social context. For sociologists in their children in schools unprepared for an influx of evacuees.
particular, the event raised numerous issues and topics for study, Faced with a choice between the need to work and the need to
including the media’s role in describing the attacks, the pres- return their children to school, some displaced families risked
ence of violence in our educational institutions, the gun control sending their older children home alone. Meanwhile, opportun-
debate, the inadequacy of the nation’s mental health care system, ists had arrived to victimize unsuspecting homeowners. And the
and the stereotyping and stigmatization of people who suffer city’s overtaxed judicial and criminal justice systems, which had
from mental illness. been understaffed before Katrina struck, had been only partially
Besides doing research, sociologists have a long history of restored. All these social factors led sociologists and others to
advising government agencies on how to respond to disasters. anticipate the unparalleled rise in reported crime the city expe-
Certainly the poverty of the Gulf Coast region complicated the rienced in 2006 and 2007 (Jervis 2008; Sarah Kaufman 2006).
huge challenge of evacuation in 2005. With Katrina bearing Throughout this textbook, you will see how sociologists
down on the Gulf Coast, thousands of poor inner-city residents develop theories and conduct research to study and better
had no automobiles or other available means of escaping the understand societies. And you will be encouraged to use your
storm. Added to that difficulty was the high incidence of disabil- sociological imagination to examine the United States (and other
ity in the area. New Orleans ranked second among the nation’s societies) from the viewpoint of a respectful but questioning
70 largest cities in the proportion of people over age 65 who outsider.
edge of it. All of us might well have theories about why people answer is that people inherit the desire to kill themselves. Another
become homeless, for example. Our theories and opinions typi- view is that sunspots drive people to take their lives. These expla-
cally come from common sense—that is, from our experiences nations may not seem especially convincing to contemporary
and conversations, from what we read, from what we see on tele- researchers, but they represent beliefs widely held as recently
vision, and so forth. as 1900.
In our daily lives, we rely on common sense to get us through Sociologists are not particularly interested in why any one
many unfamiliar situations. However, this commonsense knowl- individual commits suicide; they are more concerned with iden-
edge, while sometimes accurate, is not always reliable, because it tifying the social forces that systematically cause some people to
rests on commonly held beliefs rather than on systematic analy- take their own lives. In order to undertake this research, sociolo-
sis of facts. It was once considered common sense to accept that gists develop a theory that offers a general explanation of sui-
the earth was flat—a view rightly questioned by Pythagoras and cidal behavior.
Aristotle. Incorrect commonsense notions are not just a part of We can think of theories as attempts to explain events, forces,
the distant past; they remain with us today. materials, ideas, or behavior in a comprehensive manner. In soci-
Contrary to the common notion that women tend to be ology, a theory is a set of statements that seeks to explain prob-
chatty compared to men, for instance, researchers have found lems, actions, or behavior. An effective theory may have both
little difference between the sexes in terms of their talkativeness. explanatory and predictive power. That is, it can help us to see the
Over a five-year period they placed unobtrusive microphones on relationships among seemingly isolated phenomena, as well as to
396 college students in various fields, at campuses in Mexico as understand how one type of change in an environment leads to
well as the United States. They found that both men and women other changes.
spoke about 16,000 words per day (Mehl et al. 2007). The World Health Organization (2010) estimates that
Similarly, common sense tells us that today, violent crime holds almost a million people die from suicide every year. More than
communities on the border between the United States and Mexico a hundred years ago, a sociologist tried to look at suicide data
in a kind of death grip, creating an atmosphere of lawlessness rem- scientifically. Émile Durkheim ([1897] 1951) developed a highly
iniscent of the old Wild West. Based on televised news stories and original theory about the relationship between suicide and
on concerns expressed by elected officials throughout the south- social factors. Durkheim was primarily concerned not with the
western United States, this assertion may sound reasonable; how- personalities of individual suicide victims, but rather with sui-
ever, it is not true. Although some communities in Mexico have cide rates and how they varied from country to country. As a
fallen under the control of drug cartels, the story is different on the result, when he looked at the number of reported suicides in
U.S. side of the border. All available crime data—including mur- France, England, and Denmark in 1869, he also noted the total
der, extortion, robbery, and kidnapping rates, whether reported population of each country in order to determine the rate of
or documented in victim surveys—show that in the hundred- suicide in each nation. He found that whereas England had only
mile-deep border area stretching from San Diego to Brownsville, 67 reported suicides per million inhabitants, France had 135 per
Texas, crime rates are significantly lower than in similar U.S. cities million and Denmark had 277 per million. The question then
outside the area. Furthermore, the crime rate has been dropping became “Why did Denmark have a comparatively high rate of
faster near the border than in other similar-size U.S. communities reported suicide?”
for at least the last 15 years (Gillon 2011; Gomez et al. 2011). Durkheim went much deeper into his investigation of sui-
Like other social scientists, sociologists do not accept something cide rates. The result was his landmark work Suicide, published
as a fact because “everyone knows it.” Instead, each piece of informa- in 1897. Durkheim refused to accept unproved explanations
tion must be tested and recorded, then analyzed in relation to other regarding suicide, including the beliefs that inherited tenden-
data. Sociologists rely on scientific studies in order to describe and cies or cosmic forces caused such deaths. Instead, he focused on
understand a social environment. At times, the findings of sociolo- social factors, such as the cohesiveness or lack of cohesiveness of
gists may seem like common sense, because they deal with familiar religious, social, and occupational groups.
facets of everyday life. The difference is that such findings have been Durkheim’s research suggested that suicide, although it is a
tested by researchers. Common sense now tells us that the earth is solitary act, is related to group life. He found that people with-
round, but this particular commonsense notion is based on centu- out religious affiliations had a higher suicide rate than those who
ries of scientific work that began with the breakthroughs made by were affiliated; the unmarried had much higher rates than mar-
Pythagoras and Aristotle. ried people; and soldiers had a higher rate than civilians. In addi-
tion, there seemed to be higher rates of suicide in times of peace
than in times of war and revolution, and in times of economic
instability and recession rather than in times of prosperity.
thinking CRITICALLY Durkheim concluded that the suicide rates of a society reflected
the extent to which people were or were not integrated into the
What aspects of the social and work environment in a group life of the society.
fast-food restaurant would be of particular interest to Émile Durkheim, like many other social scientists, developed
a sociologist? How would the sociological imagina- a theory to explain how individual behavior can be understood
tion help in analyzing the topic? within a social context. He pointed out the influence of groups
and societal forces on what had always been viewed as a highly
personal act. Clearly, Durkheim offered a more sci- society. He coined the term sociology to apply to the science of 9
entific explanation for the causes of suicide than human behavior.
that of inherited tendencies or sunspots. His Writing in the 1800s, Comte feared that
Understanding Sociology
theory has predictive power, since it sug- the excesses of the French Revolution had
gests that suicide rates will rise or fall permanently impaired France’s stability.
in conjunction with certain social Yet he hoped that the systematic study
and economic changes. of social behavior would eventually
Of course, a theory—even lead to more rational human inter-
the best of theories—is not a actions. In Comte’s hierarchy of the
final statement about human behav- sciences, sociology was at the top. He
ior. Durkheim’s theory of suicide is no excep- called it the “queen,” and its practitioners “scien-
tion. Sociologists continue to examine factors tist-priests.” This French theorist did not simply give soci-
that contribute to differences in suicide rates ology its name; he presented a rather ambitious challenge to
around the world and to a particular society’s rate of sui- the fledgling discipline.
cide. In Las Vegas, for example, sociologists have observed that
the chances of dying by suicide are strikingly high—twice as Harriet Martineau Scholars learned of Comte’s works largely
high as in the United States as a whole. Noting Durkheim’s through translations by the English sociologist Harriet Martineau
emphasis on the relationship between suicide and social isola- (1802–1876). But Martineau was a pathbreaker in her own right:
tion, researchers have suggested that Las Vegas’s rapid growth she offered insightful observations of the customs and social prac-
and constant influx of tourists have undermined the commu- tices of both her native Britain and the United States. Martineau’s
nity’s sense of permanence, even among longtime residents. book Society in America ([1837] 1962) examined religion, politics,
Although gambling—or more accurately, losing while gam- child rearing, and immigration in the young nation. It gave special
bling—may seem a likely precipitating factor in suicides there, attention to social class distinctions and to such factors as gender
careful study of the data has allowed researchers to dismiss that and race. Martineau ([1838] 1989) also wrote the first book on
explanation. What happens in Vegas may stay in Vegas, but the sociological methods.
sense of community cohesiveness that the rest of the country Martineau’s writings emphasized the impact that the econ-
enjoys may be lacking (Wray et al. 2008, 2011). omy, law, trade, health, and population could have on social
problems. She spoke out in favor of the rights of women, the
emancipation of slaves, and religious tolerance. Later in life,
deafness did not keep her from being an activist. In Martineau’s
thinking CRITICALLY
([1837] 1962) view, intellectuals and scholars should not simply
Can you think of any other explanation for the high offer observations of social conditions; they should act on their
suicide rate in Las Vegas? Does that explanation convictions in a manner that will benefit society. That is why
agree with Durkheim’s theory? Martineau conducted research on the nature of female employ-
ment and pointed to the need for further investigation of the
issue (Deegan 2003; Hill and Hoecker-Drysdale 2001).
Early Thinkers
Auguste Comte The 19th century was an unsettling time in
France. The French monarchy had been deposed in the revolu-
tion of 1789, and Napoleon had suffered defeat in his effort to
conquer Europe. Amid this chaos, philosophers considered how
society might be improved. Auguste Comte (1798–1857), cred-
ited with being the most influential of the philosophers of the Harriet Martineau, an early pioneer of sociology who studied social behavior
early 1800s, believed that a theoretical science of society and a both in her native England and in the United States, proposed some of the
systematic investigation of behavior were needed to improve methods still used by sociologists.
10 Herbert Spencer Another important early contributor to the individual’s family and the state—that would provide a sense of
discipline of sociology was Herbert Spencer (1820–1903). A belonging for members of huge, impersonal societies. Unions
relatively prosperous Victorian Englishman, Spencer (unlike would be an example of such groups.
Chapter 1
Martineau) did not feel compelled to correct or improve soci- Like many other sociologists, Durkheim did not limit his
ety; instead, he merely hoped to understand it better. Drawing interests to one aspect of social behavior. Later in this book we
on Charles Darwin’s study On the Origin of Species, Spencer will consider his thinking on crime and punishment, religion,
applied the concept of evolution of the species to societies in and the workplace. Few sociologists have had such a dramatic
order to explain how they change, or evolve, over time. Similarly, impact on so many different areas within the discipline.
he adapted Darwin’s evolutionary view of the “survival of the
fittest” by arguing that it is “natural” that some people are rich Max Weber
while others are poor.
Another important early theorist was Max Weber (pronounced
Spencer’s approach to societal change was extremely popu-
vay-ber). Born in Germany, Weber (1864–1920) studied legal
lar in his lifetime. Unlike Comte, Spencer suggested that since
and economic history, but gradually developed an interest in
societies are bound to change eventually, one need not be
sociology. Eventually, he became a professor at various German
highly critical of present social arrangements or work actively
universities. Weber taught his students that they should employ
for social change. This viewpoint appealed to many influential
verstehen (pronounced fair-shtay-en), the German word for
people in England and the United States who had a vested inter-
“understanding” or “insight,” in their intellectual work. He
est in the status quo and were suspicious of social thinkers who
pointed out that we cannot analyze our social behavior by the
endorsed change.
same type of objective criteria we use to measure weight or
temperature. To fully comprehend behavior, we must learn the
Émile Durkheim subjective meanings people attach to their actions—how they
Émile Durkheim made many pioneering contributions to soci- themselves view and explain their behavior.
ology, including his important theoretical work on suicide. The For example, suppose that a sociologist was studying the
son of a rabbi, Durkheim (1858–1917) was educated in both social ranking of individuals in a fraternity. Weber would
France and Germany. He established an impressive academic expect the researcher to employ verstehen to determine the
reputation and was appointed one of the first professors of soci- significance of the fraternity’s social hierarchy for its mem-
ology in France. Above all, Durkheim will be remembered for bers. The researcher might examine the effects of athleticism
his insistence that behavior must be understood within a larger or grades or social skills or seniority on standing within the
social context, not just in individualistic terms. fraternity. He or she would seek to learn how the fraternity
To give one example of this emphasis, Durkheim ([1912] members relate to other members of higher or lower status.
2001) developed a fundamental thesis to help explain all forms While investigating these questions, the researcher would take
of society. Through intensive study of the Arunta, an Australian into account people’s emotions, thoughts, beliefs, and attitudes
tribe, he focused on the functions that religion performed and (L. Coser 1977).
underscored the role of group life in defining what we consider We also owe credit to Weber for a key conceptual tool: the
to be religion. Durkheim concluded that like other forms of ideal type. An ideal type is a construct or model for evaluat-
group behavior, religion reinforces a group’s solidarity. ing specific cases. In his works, Weber identified various char-
Another of Durkheim’s main interests was the consequences acteristics of bureaucracy as an ideal type (discussed in detail
of work in modern societies. In his view, the growing division of in Chapter 5). In presenting this model of bureaucracy, Weber
labor in industrial societies, as workers became much more was not describing any particular organization, nor was he
specialized in their tasks, led to what he called “anomie.” using the term ideal in a way that suggested a positive
Anomie refers to the loss of direction felt in a society evaluation. Instead, his purpose was to provide a use-
when social control of individual behavior has become ful standard for measuring how bureaucratic an actual
ineffective. Often, the state of anomie occurs during a organization is (Gerth and Mills 1958). Later in
time of profound social change, when people have lost this book, we will use the concept of ideal type
their sense of purpose or direction. In a period to study the family, religion, authority, and
of anomie, people are so confused and economic systems, as well as to analyze
unable to cope with the new bureaucracy.
social environment that they Although their professional
may resort to suicide. careers coincided, Émile Durk-
Durkheim was concerned heim and Max Weber never met
about the dangers that alien- and probably were unaware of
ation, loneliness, and isolation each other’s existence, let alone
might pose for modern indus- ideas. Such was not true of the
trial societies. He shared Com- work of Karl Marx. Durkheim’s
te’s belief that sociology should thinking about the impact of the
provide direction for social division of labor in industrial
change. As a result, he advo- societies was related to Marx’s
cated the creation of new social writings, while Weber’s con-
groups—mediators between the cern for a value-free, objective
Understanding Sociology
Émile Durkheim Max Weber 1864–1920 Karl Marx 1818–1883 W. E. B. DuBois
1858–1917 1868–1963
Academic Philosophy Law, economics, history, philosophy Philosophy, law Sociology
training
Key works 1893—The Division of Labor 1904–1905—The Protestant Ethic 1848—The Communist Manifesto 1899—The Philadelphia Negro
in Society and the Spirit of Capitalism 1867—Das Kapital 1903—The Negro Church
1897—Suicide: A Study 1921—Economy and Society 1903—Souls of Black Folk
in Sociology
1912—Elementary Forms
of Religious Life
sociology was a direct response to Marx’s deeply held convictions. clearly was an outsider in British society, a fact that may well
Thus, it is not surprising that Karl Marx is viewed as a major fig- have influenced his view of Western cultures.
ure in the development of sociology, as well as several other social In Marx’s analysis, society was fundamentally divided
sciences (Figure 1-1). between two classes that clashed in pursuit of their own inter-
ests. When he examined the industrial societies of his time, such
Karl Marx as Germany, England, and the United States, he saw the factory
Karl Marx (1818–1883) shared with Durkheim and Weber a as the center of conflict between the exploiters (the owners of
dual interest in abstract philosophical issues and the concrete the means of production) and the exploited (the workers).
reality of everyday life. Unlike them, however, Marx was so criti- Marx viewed these relationships in systematic terms; that is, he
cal of existing institutions that a conventional academic career believed that a system of economic, social, and political relation-
was impossible. He spent most of his life in exile from his native ships maintained the power and dominance of the owners over
Germany. the workers. Consequently, Marx and Engels argued that the
Marx’s personal life was a difficult struggle. When a paper he working class should overthrow the existing class system. Marx’s
had written was suppressed, he fled to France. In Paris, he met influence on contemporary thinking has been dramatic. His
Friedrich Engels (1820–1895), with whom he formed a lifelong writings inspired those who would later lead communist revolu-
friendship. The two lived at a time when European and North tions in Russia, China, Cuba, Vietnam, and elsewhere.
American economic life was increasingly dominated by the fac- Even apart from the political revolutions that his work fos-
tory rather than the farm. tered, Marx’s significance is profound. Marx emphasized the
While in London in 1847, Marx and Engels attended secret group identifications and associations that influence an individu-
meetings of an illegal coalition of labor unions known as the al’s place in society. This area of study is the major focus of con-
Communist League. The following year they prepared a plat- temporary sociology. Throughout this textbook, we will consider
form called The Communist Manifesto, in which they argued that how membership in a particular gender classification, age group,
the masses of people with no resources other than their labor racial group, or economic class affects a person’s attitudes and
(whom they referred to as the proletariat) should unite to fight behavior. In an important sense, we can trace this way of under-
for the overthrow of capitalist societies. In the words of Marx standing society back to the pioneering work of Karl Marx.
and Engels:
W. E. B. DuBois
The history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class Marx’s work encouraged sociologists to view society through the
struggles. . . . The proletarians have nothing to lose but their chains. eyes of those segments of the population that rarely influence
They have a world to win. working men of all countries, unite!
decision making. In the United States, some early Black sociolo-
(Tucker 1978:473, 500).
gists, including W. E. B. DuBois (1868–1963), conducted research
After completing The Communist Manifesto, Marx returned that they hoped would assist in the struggle for a racially egali-
to Germany, only to be expelled. He then moved to England, tarian society. DuBois (pronounced doo-boyss) believed that
where he continued to write books and essays. Marx lived there knowledge was essential in combating prejudice and achieving
in extreme poverty; he pawned most of his possessions, and tolerance and justice. Sociologists, he contended, needed to draw
several of his children died of malnutrition and disease. Marx on scientific principles to study social problems such as those
Twentieth-Century Developments Jane Addams (right) was an early pioneer both in sociology and in the settle-
Sociology today builds on the firm foundation developed by ment house movement. She was also an activist for many causes, including
Émile Durkheim, Max Weber, Karl Marx, and W. E. B. DuBois. the worldwide campaign for peace.
However, the field certainly has not remained stagnant over the
past hundred years. While Europeans have continued to make sociologists, in particular, often took active roles in poor urban
contributions to the discipline, sociologists from throughout the areas as leaders of community centers known as settlement
world and especially the United States have advanced sociologi- houses. For example, Jane Addams (1860–1935), a member of the
cal theory and research. Their new insights have helped us to American Sociological Society, cofounded the famous Chicago
better understand the workings of society. settlement house called Hull House.
Addams and other pioneering female sociologists commonly
Charles Horton Cooley Charles Horton Cooley (1864–1929) combined intellectual inquiry, social service work, and political
was typical of the sociologists who came to prominence in the activism—all with the goal of assisting the underprivileged and
early 1900s. Born in Ann Arbor, Michigan, Cooley received his creating a more egalitarian society. For example, working with the
graduate training in economics but later became a sociology Black journalist and educator Ida Wells-Barnett, Addams success-
professor at the University of Michigan. Like other early soci- fully prevented racial segregation in the Chicago public schools.
ologists, he had become interested in this new discipline while Addams’s efforts to establish a juvenile court system and a women’s
pursuing a related area of study. trade union reveal the practical focus of her work (Addams 1910,
Cooley shared the desire of Durkheim, Weber, and Marx to 1930; Deegan 1991; Lengermann and Niebrugge-Brantley 1998).
learn more about society. But to do so effectively, he preferred to By the middle of the 20th century, however, the focus of the
use the sociological perspective to look first at smaller units— discipline had shifted. Sociologists for the most part restricted
intimate, face-to-face groups such as families, gangs, and friend- themselves to theorizing and gathering information; the aim of
ship networks. He saw these groups as the seedbeds of society, transforming society was left to social workers and activists. This
in the sense that they shape people’s ideals, beliefs, values, and shift away from social reform was accompanied by a growing
social nature. Cooley’s work increased our understanding of commitment to scientific methods of research and to value-free
groups of relatively small size. interpretation of data. Not all sociologists were happy with this
emphasis. A new organization, the Society for the Study of Social
Jane Addams In the early 1900s, many leading sociologists in Problems, was created in 1950 to deal more directly with social
the United States saw themselves as social reformers dedicated inequality and other social problems.
to systematically studying and then improving a corrupt society.
They were genuinely concerned about the lives of immigrants Robert Merton Sociologist Robert Merton (1910–2003) made
in the nation’s growing cities, whether those immigrants came an important contribution to the discipline by successfully com-
from Europe or from the rural American South. Early female bining theory and research. Born to Slavic immigrant parents
in Philadelphia, Merton won a scholarship to Temple Univer- Today sociology reflects the diverse contributions of earlier 13
sity. He continued his studies at Harvard, where he acquired his theorists. As sociologists approach such topics as divorce, drug
lifelong interest in sociology. Merton’s teaching career was based addiction, and religious cults, they can draw on the theoretical
Understanding Sociology
at Columbia University. insights of the discipline’s pioneers. A careful reader can hear
Merton (1968) produced a theory that is one of the most Comte, Durkheim, Weber, Marx, DuBois, Cooley, Addams, and
frequently cited explanations of deviant behavior. He noted dif- many others speaking through the pages of current research.
ferent ways in which people attempt to achieve success in life. Sociology has also broadened beyond the intellectual confines
In his view, some may deviate from the socially approved goal of North America and Europe. Contributions to the discipline
of accumulating material goods or the socially accepted means now come from sociologists studying and researching human
of achieving that goal. For example, in Merton’s classification behavior in other parts of the world. In describing the work of
scheme, innovators are people who accept the goal of pursuing these sociologists, it is helpful to examine a number of influen-
material wealth but use illegal means to do so, including rob- tial theoretical perspectives, also known as approaches or views.
bery, burglary, and extortion. Although Merton based his expla-
nation of crime on individual behavior that has been influenced
by society’s approved goals and means, it has wider applications.
thinking CRITICALLY
His theory helps to account for the high crime rates among
the nation’s poor, who may see no hope of advancing them- What kinds of social and cultural capital do you
selves through traditional roads to success. Chapter 7 discusses possess?
Merton’s theory in greater detail.
Merton also emphasized that sociology should strive to bring
together the macro-level and micro-level approaches to the study
of society. Macrosociology concentrates on large-scale phenom- Major Theoretical Perspectives
ena or entire civilizations. Émile Durkheim’s cross-cultural study
of suicide is an example of macro-level research. More recently, Sociologists view society in different ways. Some see the world basi-
macrosociologists have examined international crime rates (see cally as a stable and ongoing entity. They are impressed with the
Chapter 7) and the stereotype of Asian Americans as a “model endurance of the family, organized religion, and other social institu-
minority” (see Chapter 10). In contrast, microsociology stresses the tions. Other sociologists see society as composed of many groups in
study of small groups, often through experimental means. Socio- conflict, competing for scarce resources. To still other sociologists, the
logical research on the micro level has included studies of how most fascinating aspects of the social world are the everyday, routine
divorced men and women disengage from significant social roles interactions among individuals that we sometimes take for granted.
(see Chapter 5) and of how a teacher’s expectations can affect a stu- These three views, the ones most widely used by sociologists, are the
dent’s academic performance (see Chapter 13). functionalist, conflict, and interactionist perspectives. Together, these
approaches will provide an introductory look at the discipline.
Pierre Bourdieu Increasingly, scholars in the United States have
been drawing on the insights of sociologists in other countries. Functionalist Perspective
The ideas of the French sociologist Pierre Bourdieu (1930–2002) Think of society as a living organism in which each part of the
have found a broad following in North America and elsewhere. organism contributes to its survival. This view is the functionalist
As a young man, Bourdieu did fieldwork in Algeria during its perspective, which emphasizes the way in which the parts of a
struggle for independence from France. Today, scholars study society are structured to maintain its stability.
Bourdieu’s research techniques as well as his conclusions. Talcott Parsons (1902–1979), a Harvard University sociolo-
Bourdieu wrote about how capital in its many forms sustains gist, was a key figure in the development of functionalist theory.
individuals and families from one generation to the next. To Parsons was greatly influenced by the work of Émile Durkheim,
Bourdieu, capital included not just material goods, but cultural Max Weber, and other European sociologists. For more than
and social assets. Cultural capital refers to noneconomic goods, four decades, he dominated sociology in the United States with
such as family background and education, which are reflected in a his advocacy of functionalism. Parsons saw any society as a
knowledge of language and the arts. Not necessarily book knowl- vast network of connected parts, each of which helps to main-
edge, cultural capital refers to the kind of education that is valued tain the system as a whole. His approach, carried forward by
by the socially elite. Though a knowledge of Chinese cuisine is cul- German sociologist Niklas Luhmann (1927–1998), holds that if
ture, for example, it is not the prestigious kind of culture that is val- an aspect of social life does not contribute to a society’s stability
ued by the elite. In the United States, immigrants—especially those or survival—if it does not serve some identifiably useful func-
who arrived in large numbers and settled in ethnic enclaves—have tion or promote value consensus among members of society—it
generally taken two or three generations to develop the same level will not be passed on from one generation to the next (Joas and
of cultural capital enjoyed by more established groups. In com- Knöbl 2009; Knudsen 2010).
parison, social capital refers to the collective benefit of social net- Let’s examine an example of the functionalist perspective.
works, which are built on reciprocal trust. Much has been written Many Americans have difficulty understanding the Hindu prohi-
about the importance of family and friendship networks in pro- bition against slaughtering cows (specifically, zebu). Cattle browse
viding people with an opportunity to advance. In his emphasis on unhindered through Indian street markets, helping themselves to
cultural and social capital, Bourdieu’s work extends the insights oranges and mangoes while people bargain for the little food they
of early social thinkers such as Marx and Weber (Bourdieu and can afford. What explains this devotion to the cow in the face of
Passerson 1990; Field 2008). human deprivation—a devotion that appears to be dysfunctional?
14 The simple explanation is that cow worship is highly functional We view many dysfunctional behavior patterns, such as
in Indian society, according to economists, agronomists, and homicide, as undesirable. Yet we should not automatically
social scientists who have studied the matter. Cows perform two interpret them in this way. The evaluation of a dysfunction
Chapter 1
essential tasks: plowing the fields and producing milk. If eating depends on one’s own values, or as the saying goes, on “where
beef were permitted, hungry families might be tempted to slaugh- you sit.” For example, the official view in prisons in the United
ter their cows for immediate consumption, leaving themselves States is that inmate gangs should be eradicated because they
without a means of cultivation. Cows also produce dung, which are dysfunctional to smooth operations. Yet some guards have
doubles as a fertilizer and a fuel for cooking. Finally, cow meat come to view prison gangs as a functional part of their jobs.
sustains the neediest group in society, the Dalit, or untouchables, The danger posed by gangs creates a “threat to security,” requir-
who sometimes resort to eating beef in secrecy. If eating beef were ing increased surveillance and more overtime work for guards,
socially acceptable, higher-status Indians would no doubt bid up as well as requests for special staffing to address gang problems
its price, placing it beyond the reach of the hungriest. (G. Scott 2001).
Understanding Sociology
writings of Ida Wells-Barnett (1862–1931).
Following her groundbreaking publications
in the 1890s on the practice of lynching
Black Americans, she became an advocate
in the women’s rights campaign, especially
the struggle to win the vote for women.
Like feminist theorists who succeeded her,
Wells-Barnett used her analysis of society as
a means of resisting oppression. In her case,
she researched what it meant to be Black,
a woman in the United States, and a Black
woman in the United States (Giddings 2008;
Wells-Barnett 1970).
Feminist scholarship has broadened
our understanding of social behavior
by extending the analysis beyond the
male point of view. Consider sports, for
example. Feminist theorists consider how
watching or participating in sports rein-
forces the roles that men and women play
in the larger society:
• Although sports generally promote fit-
Those who take the Marxist view ask “Who benefits, who suffers, and who dominates?” How would a Marxist
analyze the situation at this homeless encampment in Reno, Nevada? ness and health, they may also have an
adverse effect on participants’ health. Men are more likely to
resort to illegal steroid use (among bodybuilders and baseball
allied with the conflict perspective. Proponents of the feminist players, for example); women, to excessive dieting (among
view tend to focus on the macro level, just as conflict theorists do. gymnasts and figure skaters, for example).
Drawing on the work of Marx and Engels, contemporary feminist • Gender expectations encourage female athletes to be pas-
theorists often view women’s subordination as inherent in capi- sive and gentle, qualities that do not support the emphasis on
talist societies. Some radical feminist theorists, however, view the competitiveness in sports. As a result, women find it difficult
oppression of women as inevitable in all male-dominated socie- to enter sports traditionally dominated by men, such as Indy
ties, whether capitalist, socialist, or communist. or NASCAR.
• Although professional women athletes’ earnings are increas-
ing, they typically trail those of male athletes.
Interactionist Perspective
Workers interacting on the job, encounters in public places
like bus stops and parks, behavior in small groups—all these
aspects of microsociology catch the attention of interaction-
ists. Whereas functionalist and conflict theorists both analyze
large-scale, society-wide patterns of behavior, theorists who
take the interactionist perspective generalize about every-
Ida Wells-Barnett explored what it meant to be female and Black in the United day forms of social interaction in order to explain society as a
States. Her work established her as one of the earliest feminist theorists. whole. Today, given rising concern over the cost and availability
16 of gas, interactionists have begun to study a form of commuter While the functionalist and conflict approaches were initiated in
behavior called “slugging.” To avoid driving to work, commut- Europe, interactionism developed first in the United States. George
ers gather at certain preappointed places to seek rides from Herbert Mead (1863–1931) is widely regarded as the founder of
Chapter 1
complete strangers. When a driver pulls into the parking area the interactionist perspective. Mead taught at the University of
or vacant lot and announces his destination, the first slug in line Chicago from 1893 until his death. As his teachings have become
who is headed for that destination jumps in. Rules of etiquette better known, sociologists have expressed greater interest in the
have emerged to smooth the social interaction between driver interactionist perspective. Many have moved away from what may
and passenger: neither the driver nor the passenger may eat or have been an excessive preoccupation with the macro (large-scale)
smoke; the slug may not adjust the windows or radio or talk on level of social behavior and have redirected their attention toward
a cell phone. The presence of the slugs, who get a free ride, may behavior that occurs on the micro (small-scale) level.
allow the driver to use special lanes reserved for high-occupancy Erving Goffman (1922–1982) popularized a particular
vehicles (Slug-Lines.com 2011). type of interactionist method known as the dramaturgical
Interactionism (also referred to as symbolic interactionism) approach, in which people are seen as theatrical performers.
is a sociological framework in which human beings are viewed The dramaturgist compares everyday life to the setting of the
as living in a world of meaningful objects. Those “objects” may theater and stage. Just as actors project certain images, all of us
include material things, actions, other people, relationships, and seek to present particular features of our personalities while
even symbols. Interactionists see symbols as an especially impor- we hide other features. Thus, in a class, we may feel the need to
tant part of human communication (thus the term symbolic project a serious image; at a party, we may want to look relaxed
interactionism). Symbols have a shared social meaning that is and friendly.
understood by all members of a society. In the United States, for
example, a salute symbolizes respect, while a clenched fist sig- The Sociological Approach
nifies defiance. Another culture might use different gestures to
convey a feeling of respect or defiance. These types of symbolic Which perspective should a sociologist use in studying human
interaction are classified as forms of nonverbal communication, behavior? Functionalist? Conflict? Interactionist? Feminist? We
which can include many other gestures, facial expressions, and simply cannot squeeze all sociological thinking into three or
postures (Masuda et al. 2008). four theoretical categories—or even ten, if we include several
Manipulation of symbols can be seen in dress codes. Schools other productive approaches. However, by studying the three
frown on students who wear clothes displaying messages that major frameworks, we can better grasp how sociologists seek to
appear to endorse violence or drug and alcohol consumption. explore social behavior. Table 1-2 summarizes these three broad
Businesses stipulate the attire employees are allowed to wear on approaches to sociological study.
Although no one approach is correct by itself, and sociologists
the job in order to impress their customers or clients. In 2005,
draw on all of them for various purposes, many sociologists tend
the National Basketball Association (NBA) adopted a new dress
to favor one particular perspective over others. A sociologist’s the-
code for the athletes who play professional basketball—one that
oretical orientation influences his or her approach to a research
involved not the uniforms they wear on court, but the clothes
problem in important ways—including the choice of what to
they wear off court on league business. The code requires “busi-
study, how to study it, and what questions to pose (or not to pose).
ness casual attire” when players are representing the league. Indoor
Box 1-1 (page 18) shows how researchers would study the 2010
sunglasses, chains, and sleeveless shirts are specifically banned
Gulf Coast oil spill from different sociological perspectives.
(Crowe and Herman 2005:A23).
Whatever the purpose of sociologists’ work, their research
will always be guided by their theoretical view-
points. For example, sociologist Elijah
Anderson (1990) embraces both the
SPOTTING interactionist perspective and the
groundbreaking work of W. E. B.
TREND
Understanding Sociology
View of Society Stable, well integrated Characterized by tension and Active in influencing and affecting
struggle between groups everyday social interaction
Level of Analysis Macro Macro Micro, as a way of understanding the
Emphasized larger macro phenomena
Key Concepts Manifest functions Inequality Symbols
Latent functions Capitalism Nonverbal communication
Dysfunctions Stratification Face-to-face interaction
View of the People are socialized to perform People are shaped by power, People manipulate symbols and create
Individual societal functions coercion, and authority their social worlds through interaction
View of the Maintained through cooperation Maintained through force Maintained by shared understanding
Social Order and consensus and coercion of everyday behavior
View of Social Predictable, reinforcing Change takes place all the time and Reflected in people’s social positions
Change may have positive consequences and their communications with others
Example Public punishments reinforce Laws reinforce the positions People respect laws or disobey them
the social order of those in power based on their own past experience
Proponents Émile Durkheim Karl Marx George Herbert Mead
Talcott Parsons W. E. B. DuBois Charles Horton Cooley
Robert Merton Ida Wells-Barnett Erving Goffman
RESEARCH TODAY
1-1 Looking at the Gulf Coast Oil Spill from Four Sociological Perspectives
The Gulf Coast oil spill, which began on April 20,
2010, dominated the national news in the
United States for much of that year. Like other
disasters, the huge spill had social effects that
can be analyzed from the four major sociological
perspectives.
Functionalist Perspective
In evaluating the effects of the Gulf Coast oil
spill, functionalists would stress society’s sup-
portive function. For example:
• Functionalists might expect a revitalization of
the environmental movement, as happened
in the early 1900s after the damming of the
Hetch Hetchy Valley just outside Yosemite,
and later in the 1990s, after massive wild-
fires swept through the Everglades.
• Functionalists might note full employment in
selected occupations, such as the manufac-
ture of containment booms, even when jobs
in other industries were scarce.
• Functionalists would observe that churches • Conflict theorists would note that although it shaped personal relations and day-to-day
and other charities along the Gulf Coast pro- news outlets tend to focus on oil spills social behavior:
vided both spiritual and material support to that affect wealthy industrial countries,
households affected by the spill. • Interactionists would note that difficult times
often the worst spills afflict communities
often strengthen ties among neighbors and
• Functionalists would not be surprised that in disadvantaged developing nations, such
family members.
because offshore oil drilling is an integral as Nigeria.
part of the Gulf Coast economy, the governor • At the same time, stressful events can contrib-
of Louisiana strongly opposed a moratorium Feminists would note that during ute to social breakdowns, including divorce or
on deep-sea drilling, despite questions about times of economic upheaval even suicide—a pattern researchers observed
its safety. in the aftermath of the Exxon Valdez oil spill in
and dislocation, women bear 1989.
a disproportionate share of the
Conflict Perspective Despite their differences, functionalists, con-
burden in their role as caregivers. flict theorists, feminists, and interactionists would
Because conflict theorists see the social order in
all agree that disasters like the Gulf Coast oil
terms of conflict or tension between competing Feminist Perspective spill are a worthy subject for sociological study.
groups, they would emphasize the coercion and
Feminists would note that during times of eco-
exploitation that underlies relations between
nomic upheaval and dislocation, such as the Gulf LET’S DISCUSS
the oil companies and Gulf Coast communities:
Coast oil crisis, women bear a disproportionate 1. Which of the four sociological perspectives
• The oil industry, conflict theorists would note, share of the burden in their role as caregivers: seems most useful to you in analyzing the
is a form of big business, in which profits Gulf Coast oil crisis? Why?
• As family wage earners leave home to seek
are more important than workers’ health and 2. For many people, the worldwide economic
work elsewhere, women with children or elderly
safety. crisis that began in 2008 had disastrous
dependents are left to cope as best they can.
• Conflict theorists would emphasize the personal consequences. Use the four
• With time, the physical separation these sociological perspectives to analyze what
often-overlooked effect of the spill on
families experience may turn into marital happened to you, your family, and your
minority groups living in inland commu-
separation. community during the Great Recession.
nities, including Vietnamese Americans,
Native American tribal groups, and African
Americans. These groups, which were living Sources: Capriccioso 2010; Freudenburg
a marginal existence before the spill, Interactionist Perspective
and Gramling 2010; Greenemeier 2010; Jopling
endured particularly significant economic Interactionists would examine the Gulf Coast and Morse 2010; Liptak 2010; Molotch 1970;
setbacks after the spill. oil spill on the micro level, by focusing on how Samuels 2010; N. Wallace 2010.
18
Understanding Sociology
A shrinking job market in the academic world has made such
alternative career routes appealing.
Applied and clinical sociology can be contrasted with basic
sociology (also called pure sociology), which seeks a more pro-
found knowledge of the fundamental aspects of social phenomena.
This type of research is not necessarily meant to generate specific
applications, although such ideas may result once findings are ana-
lyzed. When Durkheim studied suicide rates, he was not primarily
interested in discovering a way to eliminate suicide. In this sense,
his research was an example of basic rather than applied sociology.
FIGURE 1-2 SOCIOLOGY DEGREES CONFERRED States have graduate programs in sociology
that offer PhD and/or master’s degrees. These
IN THE UNITED STATES BY GENDER programs differ greatly in their areas of spe-
30 cialization, course requirements, costs, and
28 the research and teaching opportunities avail-
Total degrees conferred able to graduate students. About 71 percent of
26 the graduates are women (American Socio-
Men
24 logical Association 2005, 2010a).
Women Higher education is an important source
22
of employment for sociologists with gradu-
20 ate degrees. About 83 percent of recent PhD
Number in thousands
for good reason—their children often grow up in stepfamilies. specialize—in order to assess everything from community needs to
Cherlin’s research shows that children who are raised in stepfami- the morale of the agency’s workers. In addition, people with socio-
lies are no better off than those in single-parent families. He sees logical training can put their academic knowledge to effective use
government efforts to promote marriage as a politically motivated in probation and parole, health sciences, community development,
attempt to foster traditional social values in a society that has and recreational services. Some people working in government or
become increasingly diverse. private industry have a master’s degree (MA or MS) in sociology;
For sociology graduates who are interested in academic careers, others have a bachelor’s degree (BA or BS).
the road to a PhD (or doctorate) can be long and difficult. This Currently, about 15 percent of the members of the American
degree symbolizes competence in original research; each candidate Sociological Association use their sociological skills outside the
must prepare a book-length study known as a dissertation. Typi- academic world, whether in social service agencies or in market-
cally, a doctoral student in sociology will engage in four to seven ing positions for business firms. Increasing numbers of sociologists
years of intensive work, including the time required to complete the with graduate degrees are employed by businesses, industry, hospi-
dissertation. Yet even this effort is no guarantee of a job as a sociol- tals, and nonprofit organizations. Studies show that many sociology
ogy professor. graduates are making career changes from social service areas to
The good news is that over the next 10 years, the demand for business and commerce. For an undergraduate major, sociology is
instructors is expected to increase because of high rates of retire- excellent preparation for employment in many parts of the business
ment among faculty from the baby boom generation, as well as the world (Spalter-Roth and Van Vooren 2008b).
anticipated slow but steady growth in the college student popula- Whether you take a few courses in sociology or complete a
tion in the United States. Nonetheless, anyone who launches an degree, you will benefit from the critical thinking skills devel-
academic career must be prepared for considerable uncertainty and oped in this discipline. Sociologists emphasize the value of being
competition in the college job market (American Sociological Asso- able to analyze, interpret, and function within a variety of working
ciation 2009). situations—an asset in virtually any career. Moreover, given rapid
Of course, not all people who work as sociologists teach or hold technological change and the expanding global economy, all of us
doctoral degrees. Take government, for example. The Census Bureau will need to adapt to substantial social change, even in our own
relies on people with sociological training to interpret data for other careers. Sociology provides a rich conceptual framework that can
government agencies and the general public. Virtually every agency serve as a foundation for flexible career development and assist you
depends on survey research—a field in which sociology students can in taking advantage of new employment opportunities.
For more information on career opportunities for individuals with a background in sociology, visit
TM
the Online Learning Center at www.mhhe.com/schaefer10e. Go to “Student Edition,” and in the
section titled “Course-wide Content,” click on “Web Resources.” Then click on “Career Opportuni-
ties,” which will provide you with numerous links to sites offering career advice and information.