Professional Documents
Culture Documents
R1076
factors initiating the timing and As an exception to the idea that three nrx genes, up to 3,000 splice
location of synapse assembly is, the initiation of synapse assembly variants are predicted to arise as a
at least at first glance, surprising. is organized in a parallel, and thus result of two alternative promoters
However, it should be considered genetically redundant, fashion, and five alternatively spliced
that evolution of the actual synaptic formation of the HSN neuromuscular segments. Nrx knockout mice
machinery predated many aspects synapses in C. elegans, seems to lacking some of the splice variants
of neuronal diversification. Thus, the depend strictly on a heterodimeric, show impaired synapse function,
assembly of the active zone core transsynaptic interaction between while synapse ultrastructure and
scaffold had to be integrated into two cell adhesion molecules, SYG- numbers seemed essentially
the context of the new circuits and 1/SYG-2. The efficacy of synapse unaltered. Autism-associated
neuron types that were evolving. formation correlates with the affinity mutations have been identified
Moreover, during the establishment of the heterophilic complex, which in neuroligin-3 and -4 in human
of principal connectivity, axons and appears to be tuned for proper patients.
dendrites often meet in a ‘crowded function. It will be interesting to In summary, at first glance, subtle
environment’ where delicate choices see whether the specific molecular defects in the tightly balanced
of which axon type forms synapses features of a given transsynaptic physiological and structural state
to which dendrite class have to contact might directly instruct of synapse populations have
be made. One presynaptic neuron details of the active zone scaffold overall drastic consequences for
could even form different synapse architecture. Consistent with such an the behavior-generating circuits
types with different postsynaptic idea, the identity of the postsynaptic and, ultimately, the entire organism.
target cells. Thus, locally secreted neuron can control release site Although the exact mechanism clearly
presynaptic molecules might instruct features in the mammalian cortex. remains to be further investigated,
the formation of the proper synapse Cortical neurons of rodents have appropriate transsynaptic signaling
types. Interestingly, self-avoidance — been shown to build functionally and might well be a key regulator of
organized by an enormous diversity structurally divergent presynaptic synapse formation and function.
of splice isoforms of cell adhesion release sites dependent on the
proteins, such as DSCAMs (Down postsynaptic partners. Assembly and maintenance of
syndrome cell adhesion molecules), presynaptic active zone scaffolds
which have been particularly Synaptic assembly and diseases Following the establishment
well-described in Drosophila, and Evidence has accumulated over of transsynaptic contact and
protocadherins in rodents — also recent years that subtle deficits in communication, active zone scaffold
seems important here. More than the basic molecular and genetic material then has to accumulate at
38,000 isoforms of DSCAMs are set-up of synapses can cause putative sites of synaptogenesis.
expressed in Drosophila due to diseases of the nervous system, Currently, comparatively little
extensive combinatorial alternative while leaving the overall synaptic is known about the transport of
splicing. Their composition on the connectivity untouched. Therefore, active zone precursor material
cell surfaces confers a unique genetic a detailed understanding of the (and components of the release
identity to a given neuronal cell. Self- proteins and pathways involved is machinery, including Ca2+ channels)
avoidance of the axon and dendrite of crucial interest. Several adhesion along the axon and how this feeds
of the same neuron is achieved by molecules that span the synaptic into the active zone assembly
contact-mediated repulsion, initiated cleft have been associated with process. In the early 2000s, Golgi-
by homophilic binding of identical different cognitive diseases, e.g. derived transport packages, so-
DSCAMs on the neuron’s surface. the neurexin/neuroligin cluster called PTVs (Piccolo-Bassoon
Whether the sets of presynaptic with autism spectrum disorders, transport vesicles) (Figure 2),
and postsynaptic transmembrane schizophrenia and Tourette’s were proposed to operate as
interacting proteins are usually similar syndrome. The fact that the same preassembled units of material,
is an interesting question. synaptic protein modules appear but this idea has been challenged
Positive synaptogenic cues in several psychiatric diseases in the last few years. Although it
are needed, however, for the points towards commonalities in is an attractive theory, identifying
establishment of functional the pathological scenarios at the PTV-unique components in order
transsynaptic communication synapse. To date, it remains unclear to subject the theory to rigorous
to guide synapse assembly. The how these different diseases are genetic analysis would be needed as
best characterized of these cues functionally or molecularly related an ultimate proof.
is the heterophilic dimer formed to each other. The question has Regarding the process of active
by presynaptic neurexin and been raised whether autism can be zone assembly, the question arises
postsynaptic neuroligin. Both defined as a qualitatively distinct as to how such a diverse code of
transmembrane proteins interact disease or whether it is at one upstream signals converges into
via their extracellular domains in the end of a spectrum of cognitive the recruitment of an identical set
synaptic cleft, while their cytoplasmic diseases caused by dysfunctional of active scaffold components
regions contain PDZ-binding domains transsynaptic transmission (see throughout all types of synapses.
that interact with PDZ-domain- Südhof, 2008). Several mutations in Cytoskeletal components, most
containing synaptic proteins, such neurexin-1 have been discovered notably F-actin, might form initial
as CASK for neurexin and PSD95 for in patients with autism spectrum cues to confer some avidity to
neuroligin. disorders. While mammals have only nascent scaffolds and provide a
Magazine
R1079
synapses.
Are there direct links between Figure 2. Temporal sequence of synapse formation.
transsynaptic CAM pairs and Cell adhesion molecules (CAMs) function as upstream signals to establish the first cell–cell con-
active zone scaffold components? tact. Complexes of SYD-1 and SYD-2/liprin-a are stabilized when in contact with presynaptic
neurexin, which, in turn, couples to postsynaptic assembly via neuroligin binding. Having passed
At Drosophila and C. elegans
this checkpoint, irreversible synapse maturation involves the further recruitment of presynaptic
neuromuscular synapses, SYD-1 components (i.e. scaffolding proteins such as ELKS/BRP) and postsynaptic components (i.e.
and SYD-2/liprin-a accumulate and important neurotransmitter receptors). Precursors might be transported along microtubules via
are important for the early scaffold PTVs (Piccolo-Bassoon transport vesicles) to deliver packages of presynaptic material.
assembly (Figure 2). Both proteins
therefore are found in common of cytoplasmic and transsynaptic protein that is essential for synaptic
complexes, which are not necessarily machinery might serve as a safety transmission and operates via the
stable but — at least at synapses mechanism, for example, blocking SNARE complex. In contrast to
of the Drosophila neuromuscular precocious or truly erratic assembly. invertebrates, mSYD1A knockout
junction — depend on the direct There are probably additional signals mice have normal active zone
binding of SYD-1 to the carboxyl and proteins both positively and numbers, while synaptic transmission
terminus of neurexin. Clustering negatively feeding into these early is impaired due to a reduced number
of neurexin in turn instructs assembly processes which remain to of docked synaptic vesicles at the
postsynaptic neuroligin to trigger be discovered. active zone. That said, a second
the assembly of the postsynaptic Despite the chance of an ultimately syd locus is present in mammals,
density scaffold. In summary, convergent understanding of and double knockout analysis will
cytoplasmic scaffold assembly and mesoscale (40–100 nm) synapse ultimately be needed to reveal its
transsynaptic signaling appear to be architectures among species, there function.
mutually dependent and concomitant. are also obvious differences in Recently, Bassoon and Piccolo, two
They might collectively establish the molecular function of synapse high molecular weight components
a checkpoint for the maturation of assembly components. Mammalian of the vertebrate active zone scaffold
initial, unstable assemblies into stable mSYD1A, for example, structurally that are distantly related to RIM,
synapses. Effective oligomerization of lacks the PDZ domain conserved were implicated in the structural
SYD-2/liprin-a via its amino-terminal within the carboxy-terminal regions maintenance of active zones. Loss
coiled-coil domains after overcoming of C. elegans and Drosophila SYD- of Bassoon and Piccolo was shown
an intramolecular blockade executed 1 which bind to neurexin. However, to lead to the aberrant degradation
by the carboxy-terminal SAM mSYD1A function critically depends of multiple presynaptic proteins,
domains is a candidate process for on an amino-terminal intrinsically culminating in synapse degeneration.
driving the early scaffold through this disordered domain, which interacts This phenotype is mediated in part
critical phase. Cooperative sensing with NSEC1/MUNC18-1, a soluble by the E3 ubiquitin ligase Siah1, an
Current Biology Vol 24 No 22
R1080
interaction partner of Bassoon and principal orientation and number of machinery, the journey has only just
Piccolo, whose activity is negatively scaffold proteins might soon provide begun.
regulated by their conserved zinc a basis for the integration of scaffold
finger domains. Thus, Bassoon architectures into quantitative Further reading
Baudouin, S.J., Gaudias, J., Gerharz, S., Hatstatt,
and Piccolo might also operate as modeling of synaptic release function. L., Zhou, K., Punnakkal, P., Tanaka, K.F.,
critical regulators of presynaptic The sheer variety of proteins Spooren, W., Hen, R., De Zeeuw, C.I.,
et al. (2012). Shared synaptic pathophysiology
ubiquitination and proteostasis. and pathways implicated in in syndromic and nonsyndromic rodent
synaptogenesis and the apparent models of autism. Science 338, 128–132.
Current challenges and outlook redundancy between different Chia, P.H., Li, P., and Shen, K. (2013). Cell biology
in neuroscience: cellular and molecular
Although many relevant factors and pathways present more challenges mechanisms underlying presynapse
instructive cues have been identified, for the investigator. Elimination of one formation. J. Cell Biol. 203, 11–22.
Chia, P.H., Patel, M.R., Wagner, O.I., Klopfenstein,
our understanding of synapse pathway might be counterbalanced D.R., and Shen, K. (2013). Intramolecular
formation remains incomplete. In or ‘compensated’ by another, causing regulation of presynaptic scaffold protein
order to define new directions of only minor defects in synapse SYD-2/liprin-alpha. Mol. Cell. Neurosci. 56,
76–84.
research, it is necessary to become formation and making it extremely Eggermann, E., Bucurenciu, I., Goswami, S.P.,
aware of the methodological difficult to define a fixed set of and Jonas, P. (2012). Nanodomain coupling
between Ca2+ channels and sensors of
problems of the experimental proteins required for initial assembly. exocytosis at fast mammalian synapses. Nat.
strategies and techniques currently Recently, chromophore-assisted Rev. Neurosci. 13, 7–21.
used. Notably, reconstituted systems acute inactivation in combination with Maglione, M., and Sigrist, S.J. (2013). Seeing
the forest tree by tree: super-resolution light
that recapitulate the delicate controls electrophysiological or ultrastructural microscopy meets the neurosciences. Nat.
regulating synaptogenesis in vivo analyses has been used successfully Neurosci. 16, 790–797.
O’Rourke, N.A., Weiler, N.C., Micheva, K.D., and
are, to the best of our knowledge, to overcome this challenge. Smith, S.J. (2012). Deep molecular diversity
not currently available. The physical Moreover, direct in vivo imaging of mammalian synapses: why it matters and
nature of many proteins involved — of synapse assembly combined how to measure it. Nat. Rev. Neurosci. 13,
365–379.
large proteins which often contain with fluorescence recovery after Owald, D., Khorramshahi, O., Gupta, V.K.,
low-complexity regions — has photobleaching (FRAP) analysis is Banovic, D., Depner, H., Fouquet, W.,
Wichmann, C., Mertel, S., Eimer, S., Reynolds,
unfortunately precluded effective helpful, as it allows the measurement E., et al. (2012). Cooperation of Syd-1 with
X-ray structural analysis. Moreover, of protein entry and exit rates into Neurexin synchronizes pre- with postsynaptic
it has not yet been possible to assembling synapses and, thus, can assembly. Nat. Neurosci. 15, 1219–1226.
Ozkan, E., Chia, P.H., Wang, R.R., Goriatcheva,
analyze larger complexes by using sensitively uncover changes in protein N., Borek, D., Otwinowski, Z., Walz, T., Shen,
cryo-electron microscopy. However, trafficking. In vivo imaging of larval K., and Garcia, K.C. (2014). Extracellular
architecture of the SYG-1/SYG-2 adhesion
super-resolution light microscopy, neuromuscular synapses, for example, complex instructs synaptogenesis. Cell 156,
e.g. stimulated emission depletion showed an increased mobility of 482–494.
microscopy (STED), has proven to neurexin in the absence of SYD- Shapira, M., Zhai, R.G., Dresbach, T., Bresler,
T., Torres, V.I., Gundelfinger, E.D., Ziv, N.E.,
be an especially valuable technique 1, implying a role for cytoplasmic and Garner, C.C. (2003). Unitary assembly
to allow the mapping of protein scaffolds in transsynaptic signaling. of presynaptic active zones from Piccolo-
Bassoon transport vesicles. Neuron 38,
epitopes, at least in mesoscopic In addition, detailed biophysical 237–252.
scales of about 40–100 nm. These analyses, such as Ca2+ uncaging Spangler, S.A., Schmitz, S.K., Kevenaar, J.T., de
analyses allow us to understand how to measure the Ca2+ dependence Graaff, E., de Wit, H., Demmers, J., Toonen,
R.F., and Hoogenraad, C.C. (2013). Liprin-
ensembles of scaffold components of release, are technically difficult alpha2 promotes the presynaptic recruitment
are oriented and how they shape at these synapses. Other model and turnover of RIM1/CASK to facilitate
synaptic transmission. J. Cell Biol. 201,
the local architecture to support synapses where biophysical methods 915–928.
Ca2+ channel tethering and synaptic are more sophisticated suffer from Südhof, T.C. (2008). Neuroligins and neurexins link
vesicle release bays. less flexible genetic approaches and synaptic function to cognitive disease. Nature
455, 903–911.
It is noteworthy that initiation of currently lack the advantages of live Südhof, T.C. (2012). The presynaptic active zone.
synapse assembly is considered imaging at this level. The future lies in Neuron 75, 11–25.
Taru, H., and Jin, Y. (2011). The Liprin homology
to be followed by a sequence of the extensive exchange of concepts domain is essential for the homomeric
maturation steps, reorganizing the and methodology between models. interaction of SYD-2/Liprin-alpha protein
active zone scaffold to switch from a Undoubtedly, the insights that in presynaptic assembly. J. Neurosci. 31,
16261–16268.
loose microdomain coupling to a tight will be gained from research in Waites, C.L., Leal-Ortiz, S.A., Okerlund, N., Dalke,
nanodomain coupling between Ca2+ future years will further improve our H., Fejtova, A., Altrock, W.D., Gundelfinger,
E.D., and Garner, C.C. (2013). Bassoon
channels and synaptic vesicle Ca2+ understanding of how the specific and Piccolo maintain synapse integrity
sensors. Clearly, we need to achieve release site architecture regulates by regulating protein ubiquitination and
a more holistic view of assembly and supports rapid synaptic vesicle degradation. EMBO J. 32, 954–969.
Zhai, R.G., and Bellen, H.J. (2004). The
initiation and maturation, for example, fusion and the coupling of fusion architecture of the active zone in the
by simultaneous covisualization to subsequent vesicle endocytosis. presynaptic nerve terminal. Physiology 19,
262–270.
of several components with That said, interdisciplinary molecular
high resolution. Here, stochastic and biophysical analyses as well as
high-resolution microscopy, e.g. computational modeling studies will be
1 Neurogenetik, Institut für Biologie, Freie
stochastic optical reconstruction crucial to understand how the complex
Universität Berlin, 14195 Berlin, Germany.
microscopy (STORM) should allow nano-architectures at synapses 2 Cluster of Excellence NeuroCure,
for the assessment of exact protein control neurotransmitter release. Thus, Charité–Universitätsmedizin Berlin, 10117
numbers and stoichiometries at the despite the award of the 2013 Nobel Berlin, Germany.
synapse. Knowledge concerning the Prize for work on the synaptic release *E-mail: stephan.sigrist@fu-berlin.de