Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
M ost of the people face career related dilemmas in the contemporary corporate scenario. This is due
several factors like the wider range of choices available to them, internally in terms of different verticals
and externally in terms of the plethora of companies, both established and start-ups who are on a constant
look-out for talent acquisition. The dilemma is more intense and confusing for the B-School students. M
aking career decisions can be like a walk on the t ight-rope due to lack of experience and multiple,
conflicting sources of information. They need to understand the factors that need to be taken into
consideration while selecting their first job, prioritization of the job related factors and the decision making
process. Proper career planning isn’t easy and involves a lot of thought and right execution of ideas and
decisions.
Even after getting the first job, people may want to change. The job may not meet their expectations or
they may not meet the expectations of the job or the company. One of the typical examples is a sales job.
But they need to make the changes necessary and carry on. This case is a hypothetical case that t ries to
explore the career confusions and ways to deal with the career confusions. It also throws some light on
mid-career changes and adapting to new environments and new responsibilities. The case is writ ten in a
dialogue format between the three characters of the case, Vinay, M ukul and Vamsh. The case t ranscends
across areas of recruitment and selection, individual and organization behavior and personal growth and
inert-personal effectiveness. The prime motive is to bring out career confusion scenarios and also
solutions.
* This case was awarded t he First Prize in “ Bench M ark-2011” a National Level Case Writing Compet i t ion,
conduct ed on 25 t h February 2011 at PSG Inst i tut e of M anagement
2
Case St udy: Job Select ion
and Career planning: Unwinding the
3
JOURNAL OF CONTEM PORARY RESEARCH IN M ANAGEM ENT
July - September, 2011
Vamsh: Cut the crap, Vinay. He is probably going of the people who attempt CAT for the first t ime,
to be very rich, if his plans do work out well. And
what are your plans Vinay?
4
Case St udy: Job Select ion
and Career planning: Unwinding the
5
JOURNAL OF CONTEM PORARY RESEARCH IN M ANAGEM ENT
July - September, 2011
6
Case St udy: Job Select ion
and Career planning: Unwinding the
7
JOURNAL OF CONTEM PORARY RESEARCH IN M ANAGEM ENT
July - September, 2011
Perks and facilit ies offers Vamsh: That ’s seems right M ukul. A company
cannot guarantee you everything, but you need
Financial performance of the company
t o make t he right pay-off decision, which will
The values of the company probably keep you sat isfied.
Opinion of your family members, friends M ukul: What does a pay-off mean, Vamsh?
and experts in that area
Vamsh: A pay-off is a kind of compromise; an
Job Securit y
individual may have to do, in case of a choice or set
of alternatives. For ex: If a person needs to a great
Psychological factors
pay, he may have to work in a night shift . Hence,
Future prospects , and that ’s all I remember working in the night shift is a pay-off that he/ she
makes in order to get a desired outcome, which is
‘great pay’ in this case.
M ukul: Wow, look at the IIM -B effect! Great, I do sums up our point of view.
8
Case St udy: Job Select ion
and Career planning: Unwinding the
9
JOURNAL OF CONTEM PORARY RESEARCH IN M ANAGEM ENT
July - September, 2011
Factors Level of Scores of Scores of got 6 laborers with some borrowed capital
importance Co X Co Y coming from my lovable dad and an enterprise
Package 4 2 3 loan from SBI. And today, I have 5-6 large clients,
1
Case St udy: Job Select ion
and Career planning: Unwinding the
rapport with your suppliers, transporters, laborers, extremely careful and analytical in their approach
clients, is a tough task. And managing your cash
balance is a tougher chore in routine business. So,
more investment is definitely needed and good for
my business, but a later stage, maybe. And when
you and Vinay will be placed in good companies,
earning great salaries, I will have no deart h of
capital. After another five years, I can demand
capital from both my friends. Isn’t it guys?
1
JOURNAL OF CONTEM PORARY RESEARCH IN M ANAGEM ENT
July - September, 2011
1
Case St udy: Job Select ion
and Career planning: Unwinding the
M ukul: Some days ago, I went to at tend a seminar Vamsh: That is some amazing food for thought. At
this juncture, may I take the pleasure of invit ing
by M r. Gururaj Patil, an ex-employee of Co D.
you all t o my house for lemonade? The post
Though he was no longer working with Co D, he
lemonade discussion will concentrate on difference
spoke at lengt h about how Co D encouraged
between job and career.
innovation at workplace, how it gave out a great
pay, how the performance appraisal systems were
Vinay: That ’s a great topic. I think we are going to
flawless and t ransparent. All these stories told me
keep discussing t ill dinner t ime.
a lot about, ‘organizational culture’ than anything
else, like the Co D’s website. At the house of Vamshraj Pujari,
Vam sh: Yes, t hat r ight . Great st ories about Vamsh: Welcome to abode of the Vamsh.
workplaces make up one’s impression of t he
organizational culture of any company. Some t imes Vinay: Thank you. Without wasting much t ime,
the stories are about the leaders, sometimes they please get us some lemonade and some Lays.
are about events, and sometimes the stories are
M ukul: You will never improve. Vamsh is our host,
about the junior employees or t rainees. And they
he will take care of us. Be courteous. It seems you
have a t remendous impact on the minds of the
are ordering a waiter at a hotel.
people. They can make or break the choice of the
company. Vinay: Well, well, he is no host, he is just dost! So
there is no much formality and no much protocol
Vinay: That ’s quit e amazing. St ories and t he
when I come t o his house. And the same rule
profound effect they have on people. St ories may
applies, when he visits my house.
1
JOURNAL OF CONTEM PORARY RESEARCH IN M ANAGEM ENT
July - September, 2011
1
Case St udy: Job Select ion
and Career planning: Unwinding the
1
JOURNAL OF CONTEM PORARY RESEARCH IN M ANAGEM ENT
July - September, 2011
1
Case St udy: Job Select ion
and Career planning: Unwinding the
Periodic Introspection
Vinay: You are right and that ’s what got your
M inor Changes business t icking isn’t it ?
In rare cases, major changes M ukul: No, I was kidding. Luck is just an excuse
for non-achievers and a sign of humility for
It becomes important to ask your self, if you’re achievers.
happy w i t h t he jo b yo u’ r e d oin g. Per iod
ic int rospection helpsyou understand your Vamsh: That ’s such a stark t ruth. Luck is after all
loopholes better, you can improve on your blind an unplanned, uncontrollable and un-accounted
spots, make any minor corrections if necessary , fact or.
like a change in yo ur selling app ro ach, a n ew
d at ab ase management technique etc, and also Vinay: I wonder why people st ill get birth stones;
if you also may have to t ake some major believe in wearing a particular color of clothing for
decisions like a change in your domain, a change being lucky, wait for the right t ime which they think
of company etc. If these decisions are taken at is lucky before beginning any activity and so on.
1
JOURNAL OF CONTEM PORARY RESEARCH IN M ANAGEM ENT
July - September, 2011
1
Case St udy: Job Select ion
and Career planning: Unwinding the
References
h t t p : / / w w w. car e e r 2 . co m / b l o g / t
h e - importance-of-career-planning/
http:/ / careerplanning.about.com/ b/
www.citehr.com
www.careeractionnow.com
1
JOURNAL OF CONTEM PORARY RESEARCH IN M ANAGEM ENT
July - September, 2011