Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
In this work, simulation has been carried out for multipass Gas tungsten Arc Welding of SS316L and their effects were
studied for thermal, and residual stresses and compared with experimental results. The sequentially coupled thermo-
mechanical, transient thermal and static structural analysis was modelled using ANSYS with relevant Ansys Parametric
Design Language coding. Infrared thermography camera was used to obtain the real time temperatures during the
welding. The effect of temperatures and the induced residual stresses of the weldment is measured with X-Ray dif-
fraction technique. Tensile residual stresses have been identified at fusion zone and compressive stresses at heat affected
zone. Pass wise temperature measurements were taken from analysis and experiment the agreement with 7.24%.
The agreement of measured and analysed residual stress had an agreement with 16.66%.
Keywords
Multipass welding, GTAW process, infrared thermography, residual stresses, finite element analysis
Date received: 17 April 2020; accepted: 16 September 2020
Introduction
The weldments are free from defects for both GTAW
Welding process is one of the significant metals join- and EBW processes which is varied by X-ray radiog-
ing techniques used in the industrial sector. Varieties raphy and ultrasonic scan test. The superior mechan-
of welding technique are available for metal joining in ical results are seen for EBW joints, because of its
industrial application, in which Gas Tungsten Arc localised heat input.
Welding (GTAW) is one of the growing popular Many authors have used the finite element analysis
welding techniques extensively used in manufactur- (FEA) as an alternative to reduce the production cost
ing, maintenance and repair industry.1,2 Joining of at the design phase. 3 D weld structure was modelled
stainless-steel materials has an advantage in the using the different boundary conditions with simula-
reduction of weight and cost of the component. tion packages. The non-linear behaviour of tempera-
Stainless steels materials widely used in automobile, ture and residual stresses in the weldment can be
nuclear industries, power and chemical plants. analysed accurately. User subroutine was developed
Welding of thick plates with the single pass is leading with ABAQUS/ANSYS code packages, which are
to defects like weldability, hot cracking which further
leads to structural failures. These complications can
1
be overcome by adopting with multi-pass welding Sri Venkateswara College of Engineering and Technology
(Autonomous), Chittoor, Andhra Pradesh, India
process3–6 with an improved structural and mechani- 2
Sreyas Institute of Engineering and Technology, Hyderabad, Telangana,
cal properties of weldments. Ramesh et al.7,8 had India
3
investigated the effect of heat input on the structural School of Mechanical Engineering, Vellore Institute of Technology,
and mechanical behaviour of 60 mm SS316L plate Vellore, Tamil Nadu, India
4
Institute of Plasma Research, Gandhi Nagar, Gujarat, India
using multipass. The Electron beam welding process
Corresponding author:
is employed for joining the plates, where the EBW Harinadh Vemanaboina, Sri Venkateswara College of Engineering and
process had advantages compared to arc welding pro- Technology (Autonomous), Chittoor, Andhra Pradesh, India.
cess due to its narrow fusion and HAZ of the plate. Email: harinadh.vh@gmail.com
2 Proc IMechE Part E: J Process Mechanical Engineering 0(0)
growing in welding process simulation with coupled or vertical height gauge for distortions. The conical
decoupled thermo-mechanical analysis with volumetric heat source shows promising results when compared
heat flux for thermal analysis.9,10 The temperature- with other heat source models. Suresh et al.21–23 have
dependent thermo-physical properties are used. From established the model for the laser and electron beam
the simulation process, it was observed that martensite welding process to understand the temperature distri-
transformation causes the residual stresses in the weld- bution and residual stresses. The Kaplan model,
ments. The axial stresses in the weldment are Gaussian and frustum heat flux models with circular
experiencing the tension at fusion zone and heat- and line surface loads applying for welding simulation
affected zone undergo compressive compared to the process. Authors concluded with map thermal, distor-
fusion zone, and the weldment goes to compressive tion and stress parameter distributions in the weld-
stress and ends with zero. The temperatures, residual ments for nuclear applications.
stress, and distortions were understood from the exper- During the welding process, the weld bead and
iment using the GTAW process. Accurate measured associated areas experience plastic deformation, due
stress values were obtained using XRD on the top sur- to heating and cooling cycles and thus obtain the
face in the transverse direction. Similar locations were residual stresses. The residual stress in the weldment
used to measure distortion values using the vertical is influenced by heat generated and effect inter lattice
height gauge.11–13 spacing where finally changes in microstructure and
The plastic-strain-range finite element models were the thermo-mechanical stresses obtained. The amount
developed for butt joints for Gas Metal Arc Welding of thermal effect in the weldment can be predicted by
(GMAW) process. The residual stresses distribution thermo-mechanical analysis under given boundary
had reported with the effect of both isotropic harden- conditions using FEA packages.12,16,18 To the best
ing and non-linear kinematic hardening in the weld- of the authors’ knowledge, it is observed that no
ments.14 Experimentation process is carried out with work was reported in the current literature about
GMAW by varying the heat input, voltage and weld- the experiments addressing towards in situ analysis
ing current with three levels of each parameter. of thermal behaviour during GTAW for SS316L
The residual stresses measurement is carried out material which lacks confirmation on simulations
with the hole drilling method. Authors observed for estimation of temperature profiles, and residual
that in all the three specimens the maximum residual stresses. The current proposed works mainly concen-
stress was observed at the top surface and gradually trate on simulation and analysis of multipass welding
decreases moving into the depth of the weld specimen. of SS 316L with GTAW process conditions. The 3D
The FEA and experimental results were compared, analysis includes thermal and Residual stresses distribu-
and a close agreement was obtained. In another tion of the welded parts. The thermo-mechanical anal-
work by Lostado et al.15,16 had developed the finite ysis is carried out with APDL coding in the ANSYS
element models to understand the thermal behaviour package. Measurement of temperatures during the
and its effects on angular distortion and bead geom- welding process using Infrared Thermography. The
etry of the butt weldments with the GMAW process. residual stresses are measured using the X-Ray
Authors had used the genetic algorithms (GA) with Diffraction after the weldment cools to ambient tem-
multi-objective functions for the analysis. The effect perature for validation.
of heat input shows the increasing trend of angular
distortion and bead geometry of the weldments. The
FEA models and experimental results show a prom-
Finite element analysis
ising correlation. Temperature-dependent24 thermal and structural
3D modelled17–19 the welding simulation for stain- properties of the base material were used for this anal-
less steel plate materials using the FEA. Accurate ysis. The FEA is conducted using the APDL in
predictions of the distributions of temperature, dis- ANSYS for modelling and simulation. The transient
tortion and stresses in the butt joint. The stress was thermal analysis is carried out using the SOLID70
varied in the weldment is due to the effect of the heat element and SOLID 45 is used for structural analysis.
input and its thermal boundary conditions. The peak The two types of mesh options are used for the sim-
temperature profile was observed at fusion zone and ulation models. The finer mesh is applied at fusion
residual stresses experiencing compressive stresses at zone with a mesh size of 1.5 mm and coarse mesh is
the edge of the plates. Thermo-elastic-plastic simula- applied rest of the plate with a mesh size of 3 mm as
tions laser butt welding of AISI 316 L by using the shown in Figure 1. In the simulation process, they are
conical, conical with double ellipsoidal and cylindri- two types of loads, the first one is the internal loads
cal shell heat sources by Rahman et al.20 Authors like the connectivity of the meshed parts, displace-
developed model using FEA to understand the ther- ment of the results is taken care of by the ANSYS
mal cycles, residual stresses and distortion in the package. The secondary loads are external loads
welds. Measurements of validation were first estab- called initial loads, boundary conditions, external
lished by using calibrated thermocouple sensors for loads like thermal and mechanical loads has to
the thermal, ultrasonic technique for stresses and defined by the user. The volumetric heat flux is
Vemanaboina et al. 3
qc ¼ hðT T0 Þ (4)
Figure 1. Volumetric meshing of the model used for
simulation.
qr ¼ erðT4 T0 4 Þ (5)
experimentation, the weldment was to cool in the air where n¼ the order of reflection beam, k is the wave-
at a room temperature of 32 C. The chemical com- length of the electrons, d¼ interplanar lattice spacing,
position, thermal and mechanical properties of the and h is on a crystal plane satisfies the Bragg
base material are given Tables 1 and 2. Equation. Residual stresses are measured at the var-
ious zone of weldment on the top surface on weld
Infrared thermography samples, for calculation32,33 of the residual stress,
the following equation (7) was used.
The temperature distribution29,30 can be collected
from the infrared thermography where it detects the m E
infrared energy emitted from the object, and it con- r/ ¼ (7)
d0 1 þ t
verts into temperature distribution. The output of the
thermal camera is in the form of the standard video
The data of d0 unstressed lattice spacing, d0, slope
signal, which shows the temperature distribution of
’m’ is measured by drawing lines between d spacing
the component. FLIR Thermocam was used for mea-
and sin2W, E and are Young’s modulus and
suring the temperature and imager was range from
Poisson’s ratio of the materials.
20 C to 2000 C. The surface emissivity e of 0.7, is
used to calculate the surface temperature. The infra-
red thermography can give thermal images at any Results and discussion
point where on the surface of the plate by drawing
the line in the longitudinal or transverse direction.
Temperature analysis
These results were to analyse the heat generated at The nodal temperature distribution along the weld-
instance distance for understanding the real-time tem- ment for all passes are shown in Figure 4, Figure 4(a)
perature profile in the welding process. illustrates the SS-SS weldment for pass-1. It has been
that the maximum temperature of 1770 C and
Radiography: Weld quality
The weld joint obtained from the experimentation is
verified with visual and X-radiography technique and
weldment is from flaws. X-radiography analysis is
carried out using ASME Sec-VIII standards. The
weldment is free from internal defects like cracks,
blowholes, and porosity was not spotted from radi-
ography as displayed in Figure 3.
Residual stresses
Thermal stresses were developed during the welding
process which causes Residual stresses even after
removing the external load. The measurement was
carried out in transverse direction by using the
X-Ray Diffraction techniques31 as shown in equation
(6) using the Bragg angle.
Figure 3. Weld quality assessment. (a) Final weldment. (b)
nk ¼ 2dsinh (6) Radiography of the weldment.
Material Ni C Mn S Cu Si Cr P Mo
Coefficient of
Materials Thermal conductivity Density Specific heat Yield strength Poisson’s ratio thermal expansion
Figure 4. Temperature distribution in the SS316L to SS316L weldment. (a) Pass-1 Distribution. (b) Pass-2 Distribution. (c) Pass-3
Distribution.
minimum of 30 C, for pass-II the same weldment is weldment of 1663.8 C, and another peak also
illustrated in Figure 4(b) and reported that the max- observed of about 900 C of the filler rod. Figure 5
imum temperature of 1881 C and min minimum tem- (b) shows the temperature of the pass-2 in the longi-
perature of 200 C. The pass-III is reported to be tudinal direction we can measure and understand the
1740 C and a minimum temperature of 220 C. It temperature distribution of 2000 C at the weld zone
has been observed that the final maximum tempera- and filler rod of 1000 C in the transverse direction. In
ture in pass-II is higher than pass-III. The peak tem- line-2 the temperatures are varying from 200 C to
perature was witnessed at the weld zone as observed 1758 C, and temperature peaks are disturbed due to
in the experimental process. The heat is gathered at the interference of the welding torch. In pass-3 the
the fusion zone and conduct in the transverse direc- temperature of the weldment at the fusion zone is
tion which leads to forms HAZ. It was observed that 1850 C, and in the line-2 the temperature is observed
the temperature distribution along the SS side was that variation due to the electrode used is with a tem-
widespread which attributes due to the presence of perature of 1200 C.
large thermal conductivity.
Residual stress
Thermography analysis of SS316L to SS316L Figure 6 illustrates the residual stresses developed
Figure 5(a) to (c) shows the temperature distribution across the transverse direction of the mentioned weld-
of case-A. The pass-1 the temperatures are measured ments. The tensile residual stress spreading exposed at
in both longitudinal and transverse direction. The the fusion zone and compressive stress far from it.
line-1 (Li-1) shows the temperature distribution in This is due to the expansion of the at the fusion
the welding direction and line-2 (Li-2) represents the zone due to the presence of high temperature; howev-
transverse direction. The temperatures are varying er, this expansion is retarded by neighbouring base
from ambient temperature to a maximum of metal region. The material experiences contraction
1937 C at the fusion zone. The line-1 shows the tem- while cooling to maintain the original dimension of
perature is uncertain in the temperature distribution, the plate which generates the plastic deformation.
the weld zone the maximum peak is observed in the At HAZ, undergoes high-stress concentration to
6 Proc IMechE Part E: J Process Mechanical Engineering 0(0)
Supplemental material
Supplemental material for this article is available online.
References
1. Vasantharaja P, Maduarimuthu V, Vasudevan M, et al.
Assessment of residual stresses and distortion in stain-
less steel weld joints. Mater Manuf Processes 2012; 27:
1376–1381.
2. Kumar KG, Ramkumar KD and Arivazhagan N.
Characterization of metallurgical and mechanical prop-
erties on the multi-pass welding of Inconel 625 and
AISI 316L. J Mech Sci Technol 2015; 29: 1039–1047.
3. Harinadh V, Edison G, Akella S, et al. Multipass weld-
ing on Inconel material with pulsed current gas
Figure 8. Comparison of Residual stresses in the SS316L Tungsten arc welding. Mater Today Proc 2017; 4:
weldment. 1452–1458.
8 Proc IMechE Part E: J Process Mechanical Engineering 0(0)
4. Vemanaboina H, Edison G and Akella S. Effect of residual stress analysis. Procedia Mater Sci 2014; 6:
residual stresses of GTA welding for dissimilar materi- 1539–1546.
als. Mater Res 2018; 21: 1–7. 18. Venkatkumar D and Ravindran D. 3D finite element
5. Vasantharaja P, Vasudevan M and Palanichamy P. simulation of temperature distribution, residual stress
Effect of welding processes on the residual stress and and distortion on 304 stainless steel plates using GTA
distortion in type 316LN stainless steel weld joints. welding. J Mech Sci Technol 2016; 30: 67–76.
J Manuf Process 2015; 19: 187–193. 19. Goldak J, Chakravarti A and Bibby M. A new finite
6. Vemanaboina H, Edison G and Akella S. Validation of element model for welding heat sources. Metall Trans B
residual stress distributions in multipass dissimilar 1984; 15: 299–305.
joints for GTAW process. J Eng Sci Technol 2019; 15: 20. Rahman Chukkan J, Vasudevan M, Muthukumaran S,
2964–2978. et al. Simulation of laser butt welding of AISI 316L
7. Buddu RK, Chauhan N and Raole PM. Mechanical stainless steel sheet using various heat sources and
properties and microstructural investigations of TIG experimental validation. J Mater Process Technol
welded 40 mm and 60 mm thick SS 316L samples for 2015; 219: 48–59.
fusion reactor vacuum vessel applications. Fusion Eng 21. Akella S, Harinadh V, Krishna Y, et al. A welding sim-
Des 2014; 89: 3149–3158. ulation of dissimilar materials SS304 and copper.
8. Buddu RK, Chauhan NL and Raole PM. Procedia Mater Sci 2014; 5: 2440–2449.
Investigations of microstructure and mechanical prop- 22. Akella S, Vemanaboina H and Kumar Buddu R. Effect
erties of 60-mm-Thick type 316L stainless steel welded of heat flow condition in analysis of electron beam
plates by multipass tungsten inert gas welding and elec- welding. SREYAS Int J Sci Technol 2016; 26: 1–9.
tron beam welding for fusion reactor applications. 23. Akella S, Vemanaboina H and Kumar Buddu R. Heat
Fusion Eng Des 2014; 65: 248–254. flux for welding processes: model for laser weld.
9. Deng D and Murakawa H. Prediction of welding resid-
SREYAS Int J Sci Technol 2016; 27: 10–15.
ual stress in multi-pass butt-welded modified 9Cr1Mo
24. Capriccioli A and Frosi P. Multipurpose ANSYS FE
steel pipe considering phase transformation effects.
procedure for welding processes simulation. Fusion Eng
Comput Mater Sci 2006; 37: 209–219.
Des 2009; 84: 546–553.
10. Deng D and Murakawa H. Prediction of welding dis-
25. Deng D and Kiyoshima S. Numerical simulation of
tortion and residual stress in a thin plate butt-welded
welding temperature field, residual stress and deforma-
joint. Comput Mater Sci 2008; 43: 353–365.
tion induced by electro slag welding. Comput Mater Sci
11. Bhatti AA, Barsoum Z, Murakawa H, et al. Influence
2012; 62: 23–34.
of thermo-mechanical material properties of different
26. Dehkordi YG, Anaraki AP and Shahani AR.
steel grades on welding residual stresses and angular
distortion. Mater Des 2015; 65: 878–889. Investigation of heat source models and process factors
12. Chen B-Q, Hashemzadeh M and Guedes Soares C. on temperature and residual stress in GTAW of aluminum
Validation of numerical simulations with X-ray diffrac- plates. Russian J Non-Ferrous Met 2019; 60: 450–462.
tion measurements of residual stress in butt-welded steel 27. Ferro P, Berto F and James NM. Asymptotic residual
plates. Ship Offshore Struct 2018; 13: 273–282. stress distribution induced by multipass welding pro-
13. Balram Y and Rajyalakshmi G. Thermal fields and cesses. Int J Fatigue 2017; 101: 421–429.
residual stresses analysis in TIG weldments of SS 316 28. Funderburk RS. The importance of interpass tempera-
and Monel 400 by numerical simulation and experimen- ture. Welding Innovation 1998; 15: 1–2.
tation. Mater Res Express 2019; 6: 0865e2. 29. Balram Y and Rajyalakshmi G. Thermal stress analysis
14. Lostado Lorza R, Corral Bobadilla M, Martınez Calvo of similar and dissimilar welded joints. UPB Sci Bull
M, et al. Residual stresses with time-independent cyclic Ser D 2018; 80: 223–240.
plasticity in finite element analysis of welded joints. 30. Vemanaboina H, Edison G and Akella S. Weld bead
Metals 2017; 7: 136. temperature and residual stresses evaluations in multi-
15. Lostado R, Martinez RF, Mac Donald BJ, et al. pass dissimilar INCONEL625 and SS316L by GTAW
Combining soft computing techniques and the finite using IR thermography and x-ray diffraction techni-
element method to design and optimize complex ques. Mater Res Express 2019; 6: 0965a9.
welded products. ICA 2015; 22: 153–170. 31. Parmar RS. Welding engineering and technology. 2nd
16. Lostado Lorza R, Escribano Garcıa R, Fernandez ed. Delhi: Khanna Publishers, 2010.
Martinez R, et al. Using genetic algorithms with 32. Anderoglu O. Residual stress measurement using X-ray
multi-objective optimization to adjust finite element diffraction. Master’s thesis, Texas A&M University,
models of welded joints. Metals 2018; 8: 230. TX, USA, 2004.
17. Vemanaboina H, Akella S and Buddu RK. Welding 33. Cullity BD. Elements of X-ray diffraction. 2nd ed.
process simulation model for temperature and Menlo Park, CA: Addison-Wesley, 1978.