You are on page 1of 2

August 1967 BOOK REVIEWS 435

cularly the attitude of a representative position and function of the law in our
group of American workers, as well as society, and the organization of policing
that of William Sargant in Great Britain, services. There has been an over-all and
in mid-1965. It is timely, well presented, progressive widening of scope i n the field
the type is clear, the volume is not too of investigation. Hope is expressed that
long and it is recommended to all who the extension of interest to attempt to
are interested in these topics. reach an understanding of criminal
G. J. SARWER-FONER, M.D. phenomenon and the criminal will, with
Montreal. the persistence of criminological re­
search, serve as a basis for a program of
crime prevention, treatment and control.
Proceedings of the Fourth Research
In several of the presentations, prob­
Conference on Delinquency and
lems are posed to which realistic solu­
Criminology. Institute P i n e 1, 800
tions, based on the studies presented, are
Gouin Blvd., Montreal, P.Q. $5.00.
available. This applies mainly to the
This conference took place in Mont­
detention of individuals prior to judicial
real in 1964 and its proceedings were
decision and their custody and/or treat­
published in 1965. A total of thirty-eight
ment following disposal by the Courts.
papers were presented, nineteen in
French and nineteen in English. The It remains for the public authorities,
one disappointing feature about the pub­ Federal and Provincial especially, to act
lication is the absence of a short sum­ on the basis of present knowledge and
mary of each paper in either English or assume the responsibility of encouraging
French so that the substance of all further research and treatment in the
presentations would be available to all field of criminology.
readers. These proceedings encompass the most
recent and progressive thinking in the
Comparing the First and the Fourth
fields of Criminology and Penology
Conference, it is worthy of note that
and should be read by jurists, lawyers,
the number of contributors has increased
and other professionals interested in
about seven-fold, from seven to forty-
criminology and Forensic Psychiatry.
seven. This is due in part to increased
E. P. HOUSTON
participation by individuals from centres
Ottawa.
in Ontario, such as Toronto, where an
Institute of Criminology has been estab­
lished, and . Penetanguishene where Neurotic Styles. David Shapiro; Basic
there has been a progressively increasing Books Inc., New York 1965 (The
interest in the etiology, detection, pre­ Austin Riggs Center Monograph Series
vention, and treatment of delinquency No. 5.) In Canada by General Publish­
and criminology. A list of participants ing Co. Ltd., Don Mills, Ontario, pp.
at the Conference would include crim­ 207. $6.35.
inologists, jurists, lawyers, penologists, In effect this book describes, under
psychiatrists, and members of the para- the heading of "Neurotic Styles", a ty­
psychiatric disciplines from Canada and pology of character which is already
the United States. used informally in psychiatry. The
It would prove too formidable an author takes the commonly used adjec­
undertaking to attempt a resume of all tives 'obsessive compulsive', 'paranoid',
the papers presented. Generally, in con­ 'hysterical' and 'impulsive' and describes
trast to earlier conferences, the contri­ the modes of cognition, affect and cona­
butors have concerned themselves less tion which the personalities described
with clinical problems and more with by these terms tend to show. He attempts
the problems of judicial administration, to describe in detail what goes on in
the etiology of criminal behaviour, the the people who show these modes as life
436 CANADIAN PSYCHIATRIC ASSOCIATION JOURNAL Vol. 12, No. 4

styles. His approach is orthodox and he ing on the one hand a defensive and
does not bring forward any controver­ protective function, and on the other to
sial material. He sticks rather to ampli­ direct activity. The book will prove of
fying what is already accepted. In doing considerable use to residents in psychia­
this he clarifies the terms and adds a try and is recommended reading.
wealth of clinical description and mater­ WILLIAM FORSTER, M.B.
ial which is not readily available in text­ Petei-borough, Ont.
books. He has thus rendered the average
reader a considerable service, since the
terms are frequently bandied around in Heirs to Freud. Essays i n Freudian
psychiatric discussion, but often with Psychology. Editor — Hendrick M.
only an approximate notion of what Ruitenbeek: New York. Grove Press,
they mean. Under the heading of the Inc. In Canada by Saunders of Tor­
obsessive compulsive style he emphasizes onto. 1966. pp. 269. $9.00.
the rigidity, the driven activity and the The Editor, a member of the staff of
lack of real autonomy, in a way which New York University and of the Insti­
would suggest an origin in Erikson's tute for Practising Psychotherapists, has
second nuclear conflict. In the 'paranoid' brought together papers by Abraham,
style he emphasizes the suspicious cogni­ Alexander, Anna Freud, Hartmann, Hit-
tion, or readiness to perceive 'clues', the schmann, Jones, Melanie Klein, Putnam,
localized loss of reality, the constant sur­ Hans Sachs and Waelder, all first pub­
veillance of the environment and the lished before the war, and one by Bona­
behaviour which is always controlled parte published in 1952.
towards an end. In the 'hysterical' style His purpose is to introduce readers to
the cognition is impressionistic, lacking the ways in which Freud's nearest col­
in intellectual concentration and leads leagues and some early analysts elabor­
to suggestibility while favouring repres­ ated or extended various aspects of his
sion. The hysteric tends towards living work, and in an introductory chapter
in a faiiy tale and takes an unperturbed there may be an attempt to state a link­
attitude to his symptoms and emotional ing theme. This does not, however,
outbursts. The 'impulsive' styles cor­ develop much beyond stating whether
respond to a group of disorders: psycho­ the chosen authors became critical of
paths, passive-neurotic characters, nar­ Freud's orthodoxy (e.g. Ferenczi) or
cissistic characters, certain male homo­ remained simply elaborators. He men­
sexuals, alcoholics and possibly addicts. tions the differences of opinion between
A l l have in common a style of cognition Anna Freud and Melanie Klein concern­
and subjective experience of action. ing child psychoanalysis, but, after men­
Action is experienced without a clear tioning Jones' suggestion that Freud's
sense of motivation, but rather after the lack of interest in the 'Kleinian' approach
fashion of a whim, the experience of may not have been unconnected with
wanting, choosing or deciding being his daughter's interest in the same area,
only partial. Cognition is egocentric and it is hard to keep from pointing out how
virtually simultaneous with conclusion interested Freud would have been to
to the act. From the theoretical stand­ note that, although he states that he is
point, the author sees 'neurotic styles' placing Anna Freud's article last, it is in
as being more than simply the outcome fact Melanie Klein's article which closes
of libidinal and social factors, and he the book.
discusses the concepts of Freud, Hart- Such a collection may interest a
man, Erikson, G . Klein and others in this student who has as yet restricted his
respect. The 'style' is designed to control reading to Freud's own writings and to
and channel tensions automatically, serv­ outlines of psychoanalysis in psychiatric

You might also like