Fighting in Professional Hockey: Debating the Need for its Removal

Fighting has been an integral part of hockey since the beginning, deeply
ingrained in the sport's tradition and values. It serves as a way to maintain the
physical integrity of the game and act as a form of self-policing. Supporters argue
that fighting acts as a deterrent against cheap shots, excessive roughness, and
dangerous plays, ultimately making the game safer for the players involved.
Furthermore, fighting holds a special place in the cultural identity of hockey,
especially in North America. Many fans appreciate the physicality and intensity that
fighting brings to the game, considering it an essential element of the sport.
Removing fighting from professional hockey could potentially alienate a significant
portion of the fan base, leading to reduced interest and revenue for the sport.
Advocates for fighting argue that its removal might result in an increase in
dangerous plays and a decline in sportsmanship. Without the fear of on-ice
consequences through fighting, players might be more inclined to engage in reckless
behavior, which could lead to higher rates of injuries. Fighting acts as a form of
accountability, encouraging player responsibility and discouraging excessive
aggression that could otherwise go unchecked.
Moreover, fighting can serve as a pressure release valve for players, helping
to diffuse tension and prevent more serious altercations. By engaging in a controlled
fight, players can release pent-up emotions and frustration, potentially reducing the
likelihood of retaliatory actions or escalating violence.
While concerns about stress, health, and violence in hockey are valid, it is
crucial to consider the broader context and cultural significance of fighting in the
professional game. Removing it could have unintended consequences, both in terms
of player safety and fan engagement. Therefore, it is recommended that the
presence of fighting in professional hockey be carefully considered, with measures in
place to address and minimize associated risks, rather than advocating for its
complete removal.

Reference:
Hutchison, M. (2018). The Role of Fighting in Ice Hockey: Perspectives from Fans,
Media, and Players. Journal of Sport and Social Issues, 42(5), 382-402.
doi:10.1177/0193723518795332