Professional Documents
Culture Documents
mmM n.-.vv^s,-^
t*
i.
Managing Change in
Rural Communities
Preface 2
Introduction 4
Ik^ljH.
4a kUllM.«
collaborating with a variety of other specialists, such
as sociologists, economists, and developers, whose
skills are necessary in understanding and bringing about
appropriate change in the built environment.
Whether responding to the needs of a specific site or devel-
Three Oakf JnA PbeK
oping a management plan for a broad area of the countryside,
landscape architects take a comprehensive approach to the envi-
POR
ronment, weighing the functional, cultural, and aesthetic conse-
quences of design alternatives. In doing so, they must often take
into consideration the many diverse and sometimes competing
interests in communities and regions where people care deeply
about their surroundings. As design professionals, they are able
to synthesize and translate their knowledge and the specialized
input of others into comprehensive plans or design concepts that
will meet the varied needs of clients and user groups while also
tions in the three pilot RC&D areas provided a diverse yet fitting
Demonstration Activities
The balance of this booklet highlights some, but not all, of the
activities undertaken by the three landscape architects in the
demonstration areas. During their 2 years in the field, these indi-
viduals responded to a wide variety of projects adopted by their
respective RC&D councils, which also encouraged them to seek
out additional opportunities. Their level of involvement ranged
from informal consultation on site-specific design problems and
opportunities to facilitating comprehensive planning efforts.
During the course of the demonstration project, the Natural
Resources Conservation Service and NEA selected nine projects,
three from each RC&D, for documentation as case studies.
HARRISON
8
PROFILE: Golden Hills RC&D
ft
1
The Golden Hills RC&D
serves eight counties in
southwestern Iowa. Bordered
by the Missouri River, the
area is roughly 90 miles long
and 50 miles wide. Although
the region's population of
190,167 has remained rela-
tively stable since 1900, there
larger cities and towns, where Some of the issues fac- in a distinctive landscape.
72 percent of the people live. ing the region are soil erosion; Mimi Askew and the Golden
The RC&D area derives its the development of recre- Hills RC&D addressed these
name from the deep loess ational and environmental issues in a variety of ways,
soils, very productive but education opportunities; eco- such as educating landusers
highly erosive soils found in nomic diversification to pro- on methods of stabilizing
steep, rolling landscapes. At duce off-farm jobs and stabi- streambanks, providing envi-
its western limit, the loess lize the rural population; ronmental materials for
dreds of feet high, framing part of the economic base; master plan for conversion of
the river with golden hills. and the protection of scenic, abandoned gravel pits into the
r£S%HSiSiSSia^aai@iBg£^i£»i^99saKi2»s:'»&s>ifn&c8»^
Elevated WsilkvvJay
frimary 3w£«5s)crol Area Wooden EloMtiid yia\lway -WildliA Hutifeit P.
Pedeffrvn TwL!
Handiof A££as£>ilol6Trv\il
tetncm FttciUfy-
ServjaKoc*!
Buffer/SOTen
Stream ftwK B-osioi
Forme, it
opportunity t
was an
The Loess Hills region, seven counties which form the
southwestern boundary of Iowa along the Missouri
River, is often called "Iowa's best kept secret." The
increas^a^arei region's soils were formed over 10,000 years ago from rocks laid
down on the nver Rising hundreds of feet above the adjacent Missouri River
floodplain, the hills form a unique environment on the North
bottom if so^'
American continent. The character of the loess soils makes
thing wasn't done. them extremely sensitive to wind and water erosion. Any dis-
turbance of the plant life that protects the surface can be cata-
strophic. In a lifetime, a small drainage ditch can deepen into a
d G^thmon canyon.
For Mimi Askew, who suspected a lack of awareness
Former Mills County "'^Kii.
11
geology, natural resources, and history of the region. The Loess
Hills Scenic Byway was recognized by Scenic America as one
of the nation's "Ten Most Outstanding Scenic Byways" in 1992.
In addition, the Missouri Valley, Iowa, Welcome Center reported
a 237-percent increase in visitors at its facility between 1989
and 1992.
The process of creating the scenic byway revealed that no
information had been gathered concerning natural and cultural
The Loess Hills Scenic Byway
resources in the seven-county area for conservation planning pur-
offers residents and visitors
numerous opportunities to poses. This led to formation of the Loess Hills Alliance, a grass-
discover and explore the roots group concerned with promotion of the scenic byway and
landscape of western Iowa. with land management issues in the region. Volunteers fanned
Whatever their form of out beyond the corridors bordering the scenic byway to collect
transportation, choice of
data and gather information from public and private agencies and
recreation, or length of stay,
tourists give a boost to the
organizations. The study's final report, entitled Loess Hills
rural economy. Landscape Resource Study, explores the resources of the land-
scape in detail, including critical resources maps, attitude surveys
of residents, and a list of residents' favorite places. It is accompa-
nied by a video, "Ours to Care For: The Loess Bluffs of Western
owa.
"We surveyed about 500 households for the landscape
resource study," said Askew, "and found they have very strong
beliefs about land use, scenic value, tourism, and all of the issues
that go along with land management."
12
S.D.
PLYMOUTH
LOESS
DIXON HILLS
>^ SCENIC
C DAKOTA! WOODBURY BYWAY
THURSTON
Designed to promote leisurely
,MONONA^ exploration, the scenic byway
consists of a 221-mile-long
'30 paved "spine" and twelve
excursion loops. With funding
BURT from the Federal Highway
Administration, representa-
1 tives from the seven counties
IOWA are nowdeveloping a corridor
NEBRASKA 1 h
management plan to guide
^
H/RRISON future enhancement, conserva-
tion and development of
'30 resources and amenities along
WASH.
the route.
DOUGLAS
POTTAWATTAMIE
SARPY
1
MILLS
30
CASS
FKEMONT
OTOE
1 '
ATCHISON
&>
NEMAHA MO.
RICHARDSON
29
KANSAS
13
r PROFILE: Oconee River RC&D
Work will be
completed this
summer based on
detailed plan.
14
The Oconee River RC&D my while
Diversifying the econo-
protecting the rural
area comprises 10 coun-
character of the landscape is
Managing growth, protect-
ties in northeastern Georgia.
ing water quality and
Stretching from the South another pressing issue as
preserving rural lifestyles
Carohna border metropoh- Atlanta pushes eastward, and
to are among the issues facing
tan Atlanta and north to the Athens, home to the residents in the RC&D area.
Appalachian foothills, the area University of Georgia, spreads Plan (above) shows place-
covers 2,987 square miles in in all directions. Between ment of artificial wetlands
1980 and 1990, population
on a hog farm to reduce
the heart of the old Cotton
ammonia so water can be
Belt. Poultry production pre- within the 10-county area
reused.
dominates in the northern grew by 20 percent, to
small town.
15
NORTH
Analyzing Highway Alternatives
Comer, Georgia
JL ^
One to
of the quickest ways to change a rural
widen its When the Georgia
major highway.
community is
ting traffic into a pair of east- and west-bound streets; and mov-
get excited.
ing the new highway a block south of the existing route, linking
it with new construction to the existing road.
:_U
16
ONE WAY PAIR
by commercial.
COMER, GEORGIA ©
HIGHWAY 72 IMPACT STUDY ;
17
Krohn also called upon assistance from the preservation
program at the University of Georgia and the Georgia Trust for
Historic Preservation, whose suggestions for potential down-
town Comer enhancements, such as trees, awnings, sidewalk
repairs and building facade restorations also appeared in the
video.
According to Mayor Hartel, the road widening in Comer
has been delayed by GDOT for several years, illustrating the
long-term nature of professional involvement in rural commu-
nity design issues. "The work we did will be brought up
when we talk about economic development. It provides a
baseline for future initiatives," he said.
Although the Comer project has been delayed, it has
been the inspiration for successful downtown revitalization in
$PmMJt'...jL
r72WESTBOUNB
18
PROFILE: Castleland RC&D
19
Enhancing a Flood Control Project
Castleland RC&D, Utah
also asked the Castleland RC&D to look into ways that flood
In Moab, Utal control could be modified to improve recreational opportunities,
there is probably a aesthetic values, and habitat. The 1992 Corps of Engineers
study evaluated a full range of flood protection measures, and
larger mix of out- was used as the basis for a broader Sixteen-Year Flood Control
looks on the envi- Project with Recreational Amenities plan, prepared by RC&D
landscape architect Ken Ruhnke working with Moab city planner
ronment and relat-
Kathlyn Collins. The plan was developed with the help of a citi-
ed values than in zens advisory committee and representatives from the Corps of
Engineers, State Divisions of Wildlife and Water Rights, State
any other town
Department of Agriculture, Grand County Soil Conservation
in Utah. It became District, Moab Irrigation Company, and Castleland RC&D. The
plan developed by Ruhnke and the team identified ways to con-
apparent that
trol flooding without sacrificing aesthetic values or wildlife habi-
we couldn't move ^iii^
tat. It also incorporated recreational opportunities, including a
the public in the "The Mill Creek project demonstrates the expertise that a
landscape architect can bring to a community in non-traditional
decisionmaking, design of flood control alternatives," Ruhnke said. "Small com-
that process as foreign to the public, and citizens sometimes do not learn about
what is going on until the construction equipment is in their
were willing to
backyards." Through production of two videos, one aired on
participate. local cable television; open houses; and a variety of flyers,
Castleland RC&D
20
Existing conditions along iVIill
21
tXISTING PROPOSED
,ir^~ WILL CREEK aOOD CONTROL LEVEE
m—
'-' ;
VEGETATION
BUILDING
o
PARKING AREA
PRIVATE DRIVBVAY
TREES
^\ '•
SCALE
22
&©^'
:^^^*^
>^^-
.^p-'-*f ja>-
Large public works projects, like that proposed for Moab, Conceptual plan for Mill Creek
take years to implement. Another of Ken Ruhnke's activities, (above) uses hiking-biking
to link schools, parks, and
trail
the Downtown Helper, Utah, River Enhancement Project,
neighborhoods to the business
demonstrated how a designer can facilitate community improve- while pinpointing
district,
ment on a much smaller scale. opportunities for improved
"It was originally sold as clean-up of a critical transient wildlife habitat. Left: Mill
problem. But we knew it would be a major tourism draw. It's an Creek Advisory Committee.
incredible bang for the buck," said Ron Cooper, the project's
Below left: Volunteers clear
brush along the trail.
coordinator in Helper. Community leaders in Price and Helper,
about 100 miles from Moab, had long contemplated a hiking/
biking trail to link the two cities, which are 10 miles apart on the
Price River. A wide range of problems, including an unwilling-
ness to spend tax dollars and the diversity of land ownership
along the route, combined to impede the project.
But when Helper residents decided on the more modest goal
of transforming a small section of the river, they gained momentum.
The river in downtown Helper, next to the historic district, offered
the advantages of being city-owned and close to local residents who
would use the facility. And when the new mile-long park, complete
with a pavilion, games areas, and fish habitat enhancements, was
dedicated in May 1994, Helper had changed a community liability
24
Visual Simulation Technology
Visual simulations have The three landscape the image can be moved or
long been a tool in the architects were enthusiastic, deleted, or other images can
arsenal of the professional yet cautious, about the use of be imported to produce alter-
designer, beginning with sim- visual simulation. "I think it's native scenarios.
ple sketches and progressing very valuable," said Iowa's Using the technology
to color renderings. With the Mimi Askew. "In rural design may be time-consuming — it
appearance of affordable desk- and conservation, for example, can take a day's work to create
top computers capable of it can play a very strong role as a high-quality reconstruction
landscape images, visual simu- "It was a tool," echoed greatly extends the reach of
lations have become a practi- Utah's Ken Ruhnke, "and I the designer's ideas by show-
cal, cost-effective way of found that I used it quite a ing both existing conditions
showing the visual conse- bit. The key to image pro- and the impact of alternatives
quences of land use decisions. cessing is to use it when it is in context. The resulting sim-
this technique image process- Using either a video different formats —photo-
ing. The movie industry, for camera or a scanning device graphs, videos, television, or
example, uses it to produce for print photographs or sHdes, cable broadcasts— thereby
special effects. The same images are captured as com- enhancing citizen participation
kinds of three-dimensionaJ puter files. Once in the com- in the planning process.
images provide valuable diag- puter, different elements of
nostic information to the med-
ical profession. The technolo-
compatible
gy useful whenever visual
i's
computer
communication of ideas and
graphics '
videotapes
compatible film recorder/
computer printer
graphics
25
Evaluating Rural Resources
Oconee River RC&D, Georgia
is an emerging
Indevelop plans that would guide future growth. The
Northeast Georgia Regional Development Center had pre-
county, and the pared a comprehensive plan for Madison County by the end of
1990, which included a requirement to update it in 1995. In its
study proved land use section, the plan called for Madison County to "accom-
why a new crop modate natural and planned growth in an efficient, practical and
coherent manner without unreasonable intrusion into the rural,
of people HM home town way of life of its people or destroying in an indiscrim-
inate way the natural beauty evidenced in its landscape of gently
moved here
rolling hills, wooded areas and open spaces."
the important This was the inspiration for the Madison County Land-
scape Assessment, which established a baseline of what residents
qualities of the
thought about their environment in a county where, at least in
or historical-cultural significance.
These photographs then were used to create posters and an
accompanying questionnaire that provided a means of gathering
the opinions of more than 350 county residents at various public
shop and spend their free time." The booklet also high-
lighted residents' concern about the stewardship of his-
torical sites and growing interest in protecting the
Georgia
As a result of the
landscape assessment,
and because of the Survey of county residents
expanding pressures of led to the identification of
vince them that if they didn't have restrictions, they could lose
what they valued most."
A design professional brought a lot to the discussion of the
future in this rural society. "I see a need for similar expertise all
+ 150 RESPONSES
75-149 RESPONSES
20-74 RESPONSES
8-19 RESPONSES
1-7 RESPONSES
V^Sf^RUrZrfrl^
28
Countryside Assessment Process
getting
Countryside
organized Assessment
> Methodology
V understanding
the study area
V
selecting and
calibrating indicators
(
evaluating units and
mapping visual quality
The
Many people associate for
jumping-off point
landscape assessment was
Survey photographs and an
accompanying questionnaire
landscape architecture
with site-specific projects the Natural Resources are used to give the public an
such as public spaces, residen- Conservation Service's coun- opportunity to express prefer-
tial lots, and corporate office tryside assessment process, a ences for different aspects of
parks; not with the broad visual analysis methodology the landscape. The public
resource analysis, planning, keyed to scenic values. also can be offered the oppor-
and design skills used in the Basically, the methodology tunity to visualize the results
demonstration project. The attempts to break down the of potential improvements in
three landscape architects qualities of a landscape into land use, using computer-gen-
were encouraged to use land- its constituent parts: character, erated images.
scape assessment techniques or harmony; uniqueness; The process depends on
where possible to involve fragility, or its ability to absorb the active involvement of the
local residents in the identifi- change; fitness, or how well it people it affects — the resi-
cation of resources and the is cared for; structure, or the dents who, after all, will live
articulation of their signifi- way it looks formally; informa- with the decisions about land
cance. tion, or how it engages the use that are taken. In both
viewer; and, finally^ its mean- the Oconee River and Golden
ing in a cultural sense. Hills RC&D areas, country-
The process of assessing side assessments demonstrat-
a landscape begins with find- ed that pragmatic involve-
ing volunteers willing to sur- ment by design professionals
vey its scenic, natural, and in the rough-and-tumble
cultural resources photograph- of rural politics can make a
29
Conserving Water Through Design
Castleland RC&D, Utah
s
Water is critical
4 to 8 inches of rainfall
Utah average from
each year, and even less during
drought conditions. The availability of water affects
of this project was residents' ability to landscape homes and public spaces, grow
crops, feed livestock, and develop businesses, tourism, and
to demonstrate the industry. For many years, the RC&D Council had listed water
30
One key goal of the educational
campaign was to demonstrate the use
of alternative landscape plants with
low-water requirements appropriate to
the area. To determine whether exist-
Full-sun-tolerant turf
demonstration plots
32
'''^^o;Z-^^.o
Af^Ts
'^07>
Son ""Id .
Earth berm to redirect /.
Wildflower area
/i>v'-i?>«-r!£> 33
Expanding Environmental
Education
Golden Hills RC&D, Iowa
The project has *^ The 25-acre campus of the Iowa School for the Deaf in
where the city is ing center accessible to people of all abilities and to make the
landscape part of the learning experience for 5,100 students at
bringing in two the school.
additional trails Askew prepared an inch-thick report that contains the over-
all conceptual design for the project. Initially, the idea had been
that will use the "to use a very small plot in their backyard." After listening to
school officials discuss the need for environmental education, and
Nature Center as
evaluating the limited opportunities for people with disabilities
part of a trailhead. in the Council Bluffs-Omaha area. Askew proposed that the cam-
pus itself be converted into the Nature Center.
It's amazing the
Instead of one small outdoor classroom, as envisioned in the
number of things original plan. Askew proposed a series of 21 exhibit areas ranging
from a wetland to a prairie plains remnant to an exploration of
that are tying M Loess Hills habitat, all connected by a hard-surfaced path with
together on this ^ accessible side pathways of different challenge levels. The plan,
|
recognized that the quality of the experience for visitors of vari-
project. I've never
ous ages and abilities could be severely compromised unless
seen so many close attention were paid to material selection, siting, construc-
to help. that would complement campus buildings and urged careful con-
sideration of installation and future maintenance requirements.
Having anticipated that phased installation of the Nature
Center would take 5 to 10 years. Superintendent Johnson is
William P. Johnson
optimistic that the timeframe will be much shorter due to local
Superintendent,
enthusiasm for the project. "This grew from a little idea into
Iowa School for something much larger," he said. "We'll probably put a quarter
of a million dollars into it. Right now, I see every penny of it
the Deaf
being donated."
EE
34
m uvm
FUTURE SITE OF:
mm
35
'Si
•^ -
f-
y.
i '••
^
y.
:i '- V.
ir.
b^<? 2 y.
*f«_
C»
ti :-
r^ ^ ~
C A i.
a
y.
c
3
o
c:
cc —
<
o 2:
Ir n i'S ^
'
r^.' \
V UJ
t.
I:
D
c ^
^
'
} UJ 3
u y
^J J Si
> °^
a: O
ID
if xi
o
z
u ?<
r'? ^.5 I-
•3
z
a:
r*
-
H ^2
I UJ
2
:-
§ "?.§ UJ t-
X g -r
H
"
? '1 ililil
ll-llf ^
3 *3
B=?fill
UJ '^,§. _j
-g^'^^sa
<^
-i
<3)
f. vj J3 ^
. 15 -^ ti 2
^ ''^
• - *^ ^
^ \j ~ X: !^
=-s^
s c
~
"-""^
ii CI,-. ^ a
'^ 2 .? is
: p"2>^2
a < o
5 U
Results in Rural America
39
Additional Information
and Assistance
The 275 RG&D offices, The ASLA is a national pro- Architects is the Nation's prin-
appropriate offices of State fessional society representing cipal professional society for
and local government, public private, public, and academic licensed architects, with 301
and development issues also terly newsletter and provides to cities and towns through
are good sources, particularly a forum for members, other two programs. Using volun-
those involved in economic design professionals, and relat- teer architects, the department
development, community ed organizations with an inter- puts together Regional/Urban
development, planning, and est in agriculture and rural Design Assistance Teams that
historic preservation issues. landscape issues. For informa- visit host communities to
Regional councils of govern- tion on the Open Committee, engage citizens in intensive
ment and planning agencies the nearest ASLA chapter, design "charettes" or work-
also are well worth consulting. and accredited undergraduate shops that emphasize a multi-
schools of design offer com- landscape architecture, contact approach to local issues. For
munity service programs, the Society's headquarters in information on this and other
although their scope and Washington, DC. AIA programs or for the
40
American Planning Association National Trust for Historic Design Access
Public Information Office Preservation 401 F Street, NW, Suite 322
1116 Massachusetts Avenue, NW, / 785 Massachusetts Avenue, NW Washington, DC 20001
4th Floor Washington, DC 20036 2021272-5421
Washington, DC 20036 2021673-4000 (FAX) 2021272-5432
2021872-0611 (FAX) 2021673-4038 Design Access is a national
(FAX) 2021872-0643 The National Trust is a private, information and resource cen-
The American Planning non-profit membership organi- ter for the design disciplines,
Association is the Nation's zation chartered by Congress to created under the auspices of
principal membership society foster appreciation of America's the National Endowment for
for professional land use plan- diverse cultural heritage and the Arts and the National
ners. As a non-profit educa- encourage the preservation of Building Museum. It main-
tional and research organiza- its historic environments. The tains a database listing all
tion, the APA is devoted to organization has several special- grants awarded by the
protecting and improving both ized programs that may be of Endowment's Design Program
the built and natural environ- interest to rural communities. and a non-lending library of all
ments. Based in its Chicago These include 1) the Rural final reports and products sub-
office (312/431-9100), the asso- Heritage Program, which pro- mitted. Design Access also
ciation's Planning Advisory vides information and limited maintains a national design
Service provides research assis- technical assistance on rural events calendar and a database
tance and advice to communi- planning and preservation of information on non-profit,
ties across the country. Also issues, including scenic byways professional, academic and
located in Chicago is the and heritage areas; 2) the advocacy organizations serving
Planners Bookstore, which car- National Main Street Center, the design disciplines and
ries a variety of publications which provides publications, related fields. Information
devoted to smalltown and rural training and technical assistance specialists can provide free
planning. The association's on the revitalization of down- searches and print-outs of
Small Town and Rural town and neighborhood com- these databases and will pro-
Planning Division, a network mercial districts; and 3) the duce photocopies of final grant
of planners and community Heritage Tourism Program, reports for a nominal charge.
leaders, publishes a quarterly which assists individual commu-
newsletter examining issues nities and multi-county areas
affecting rural and exurban interested in developing and
areas. The Public Information marketing sustainable tourism
Office in Washington, D.C. can based on cultural and historic
provide addresses for the near- resources. In addition, the
est APA chapter, division Trust operates seven regional
members, and accredited offices, which advise local com-
schools of planning. munities on basic preservation
procedures and are the initial
PO Box 536
Oakland, IA 51560
• Iowa School for the Deaf
Nature Center Master Plan
• Loess Hills Scenic Byway
• Loess Hills Landscape
Resource Study
Castleland RC&D
PO Box 141
652 W. Price River Drive
Price, UT 84501
• Mill Creek Flood Control
and Recreation Project
• Water Conservation Issues
and Techniques
• Crystal Geyser Restoration
and Enhancement
42
Acknowledgments
following individuals as Askew, Mimi W., ASLA, Landscape Architect, NRCS, Iowa
representative of the many Beckwith, John E., Assistant State Conservationist, NRCS, Utah
people who contributed to the Bouchard, Carl E., Asst. Director, Community Assistance and
Project Managers
Hawley, Peter E., Program Specialist, Design Program, NEA,
Washington, DC
Tuttle, Ronald W, FASLA, National Landscape Architect, NRCS,
W^ashington, DC
Production Credits
43
Photo Credits
Moorhead, lA
Council Bluffs, lA
44
The United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) prohibits
discrimination in its programs on the basis of race, color, national
November 1995