Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Landscape 2021 Report VF Landscape Report Micro Insurance
Landscape 2021 Report VF Landscape Report Micro Insurance
The Landscape of
Microinsurance
2021
Supported by
Published by: Microinsurance Network
The publication is protected by the law of the 18th April 2001 of the Grand-Duchy
of Luxembourg concerning copyright databases and related laws. It is strictly
prohibited to reproduce an article from this publication, in whole or in part,
without the written consent of the publisher.
The quantitative information presented in this paper does not represent an absolute
number of products, clients, or other data. Rather, this paper reports what the
team was able to identify as microinsurance. Although the data for this study is
not an absolute measure of microinsurance in the three regions studied, the data
set is large enough to represent the “landscape” of microinsurance and provide,
for the most part, an accurate picture of these markets and their components.
Disclaimer: The views, opinions, and theories of all outputs of the Landscape Studies as contained
herein are solely the views, opinions, and theories of the authors, and do not necessarily reflect
the views, opinions and theories of the Microinsurance Network, its members and/or its affiliated
institutions as well as sponsors and their related entities. In addition, the country and territory
names, borders, and/or scaled sizes depicted in this paper are for illustrative purposes and do not
imply the expression of any opinion on the part of the Microinsurance Network, its members and/or
its affiliated institutions as well as sponsors and their related entities, concerning the legal status of
any country or territory or concerning the delimitation of frontiers or boundaries. The Microinsurance
Network makes no representation as to the accuracy, completeness, or reliability of any information,
views, opinions, and theories as may be contained herein. The Microinsurance Network hereby
disclaims any liability in this regard.
ISBN 978-2-9199658-4-7
Contents
Acknowledgements 5
Glossary 8
1. Executive summary 11
2. Methodology 13
3. Global view 17
4. Africa 57
5. Asia 67
We recognise the dedicated contributions of our country Finally, we thank the members of the Microinsurance
researchers: Adrian Montesinos (Bolivia), Aisha Bashir (Nigeria), Network Landscape Best Practice Group for their
Ali Basharat (Pakistan), Angie Carolina Caro (Colombia), contributions and feedback throughout this study, including
Antimaria Kajuna (Tanzania), Bagus Santoso (Indonesia), in reviewing drafts of this document: AM Best; Access to
David Mureriwa (Zimbabwe), Guillaume Dugu (Rwanda), Insurance Initiative (A2ii); Appui au Développement Autonome
Illiana Butanda Ochoa (Mexico), Jacquiline Roberts Singh (ADA); AXA Emerging Customers and AXA S.A.; Germany’s
(India), James Irungu Kimani (Kenya), Jemma Maclear Federal Ministry for Economic Cooperation and Development
(Cambodia and Thailand), Jonan Kisakye (Uganda), (BMZ); Belgian Raiffeisen Foundation (BRS); Centre for
Joseph Chikonde (Zambia), Kingsley Kwabahson (Ghana), Financial Regulation and Inclusion (Cenfri); Center for the
Livio Bellandi (Brazil), María José Lagos (El Salvador), Economic Analysis of Risk (CEAR) at Georgia State University;
Marius Bai Kora (Côte d’Ivoire), Mark Robertson (Jamaica Confederação Nacional das Empresas de Seguros Gerais
and South Africa), Moustapha Mbengue (Senegal), (CNseg); Denis Garand & Associates; Fundación para el
Patricia Inga Falcón (Peru), Pierre Bonzom (Morocco), Desarrollo Productivo y Financiero (Fundación PROFIN);
Prashansa Jain (Philippines), Prechhya Mathema (Nepal), Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit
Silvia Canales (Costa Rica), Sisili Rahman (Bangladesh), (GIZ); Guardian Life Insurance; ILO’s Impact Insurance Facility;
Thanuja Krishnaratna (Sri Lanka), Trần Hương (Vietnam), International Fund for Agricultural Development (IFAD);
Yasmine Badr (Egypt). Katie School of Insurance & Financial Services at Illinois State
University; Microinsurance Catastrophe Risk Organisation
We further thank the experts interviewed for providing their
(MiCRO); MicroInsurance Centre at Milliman; Microinsurance
perspectives on the development of microinsurance markets,
Master; MicroNsure; Munich Re Foundation; National Insurance
including Anne Kamau and Barbara Chesire-Chabbaga (AB
Commission, Nigeria (NAICOM); National University of
Consultants), Hannah Grant (Access to Insurance Initiative),
Science and Technology, Zimbabwe; Swiss Capacity Building
Dominik Wehgartner (Allianz), Carlos Iván Gay (Asociación
Facility (SCBF); United Nations Development Programme
Mexicana de Instituciones de Seguros), María José Lagos Ayala
(UNDP); and Women’s World Banking (WWB).
(Asociación Salvadoreña de Empresas de Seguros),
Laura Rosado (AXA), Mathilda Ström (BIMA), Jeremy Gray
(Cenfri), Lenin Enrique Marquez Mendicuti (Comisión Nacional
de Seguros y Fianzas, Mexico), Mabyr Valderrama Villabona
(Federación de Aseguradores Colombianos), Erika Pacheco
(Fundación PROFIN), Pranav Prashad (ILO’s Impact Insurance
Facility), Vance Abissa (Inclusive Guarantee), Orville Johnson
(Insurance Association of Jamaica), Astrid Zwick (InsuResilience
Global Partnership), Roshaneh Zafar (Kashf Foundation),
Queenie Chow and Mariah Mateo Sarpong (MicroInsurance
Centre at Milliman), Bert Opdebeeck (Microinsurance Master),
Kamalakar Sai Palavalasa (MicroNsure), Lorenzo Chan
(Pioneer), Miguel Solana (United Nations Development
Programme), Gilles Renouil (Women’s World Banking),
and Craig Thorburn (World Bank).
List of tables
Table 1 Focus countries for this year’s Landscape report
Table 2 Estimated proportion of the population and market captured in the countries studied in each region
Table 3 The median number of people covered and premiums collected per product, and median premium
per person covered for each region in 2019 and in 2020 (USD)
Table 4 The percentage increase or decrease seen in policies issued, people covered, and premiums received for
companies that reported for both 2019 and 2020
Table 5 The median percentage of female policyholders and of women covered in each region
Table 6 Median claims ratios by region
Table 7 Claims metrics by region
Table 8 Claims turnaround times by product line
Table B1 Number and proportion of products reported by product line
Table B2 Proportion of products for which data was not available by region
List of boxes
Box 1 Why is the number of people reached given as a range?
Box 2 People covered
Box 3 Following the spirit rather than the letter of hospital cash insurance
Box 4 Female policyholders and women covered
The increase stems mainly from the products have now taken over in
inclusion of data on additional countries, many countries as the first choice for
as well as an improved response rate: insurers and FinTechs launching new
224 insurance providers submitted microinsurance schemes. The appeal
data on 704 products, compared to of health insurance has only increased
194 insurers who provided data on as COVID-19 has raised consumers’
589 products the previous year.1 awareness of health risks.
1
Data is not directly comparable year-on-year. More detail on changes in the sample and methodology, and on the comparisons made, is given in the following sections.
In each region, efforts were made has been included this year. Argentina In South Africa, also significantly
to collect primary data on the and Chile were replaced by Costa Rica impacted by COVID-19, information
microinsurance products available and El Salvador based on engagement was received from more insurers than
in each target country. All products with sector representatives in last year, but many insurers were still
that fit the Study’s definition of the region. not able to participate.
microinsurance (see Glossary) were
In some cases, despite best efforts, For India and Mexico, publicly available
considered, including national and
it proved impossible to obtain data from the regulators was used to
government-led schemes that met
responses from a representative determine the total number of insured
these criteria. Not all insurers or
number of insurers. Limited primary people in the two countries, but it was
national schemes provided responses.
data was collected in several countries, not possible to carry out further analysis
Uganda, Costa Rica, and El Salvador such as India, Nepal, and Mexico, without primary data.2
were added to the list of target countries which were severely affected by
In total, 224 insurers provided self-
this year. No data on Senegal was COVID-19 lockdowns during the data
reported product-level data on their
received for the previous Landscape collection window in the second
microinsurance products. Data covered
Study, whereas data from the country quarter of 2021.
a 12-month period: either the calendar
year 2020, or a 12-month period of the
insurer’s choice between 2020 and 2021,
TABLE 1
where the company’s standard reporting
FOCUS COUNTRIES FOR THIS YEAR’S LANDSCAPE REPORT
periods made it easier for data to
be provided in that way.3 Primary
AFRICA ASIA LATIN AMERICA & researchers based in each country
THE CARIBBEAN or region engaged with insurers to
Côte d’Ivoire Bangladesh Bolivia encourage and support their
participation, and to ensure as
Egypt** Cambodia Brazil
much consistency as possible in the
Ghana India** Colombia interpretation of the questions and
Kenya Indonesia** Costa Rica of the data inputs.
Morocco** Nepal* El Salvador
Nigeria Pakistan Jamaica
Rwanda Philippines Mexico**
Senegal** Sri Lanka Peru
South Africa** Thailand**
Tanzania** Vietnam
Uganda
Zambia
Zimbabwe
Notes to Table 1: 2
Note that for some countries not included in this study,
*
Countries for which no data was submitted;
national studies on the microinsurance market are
**
Countries with low response rates for which our findings may understate the state of the national
available, such as the Landscape of Inclusive Insurance
microinsurance market
in Mozambique published by Financial Sector Deepening
Moçambique (2021).
3
For the remainder of this report, this 2020/2021 data
will be referred to simply as 2020 data.
These customers were reached through Despite the increase in people covered,
a total of 90 million policies, including the total premiums collected in 2020
almost 8 million group policies. This only increased by 6.5% year-on-year:
represents a considerable increase on USD 1.129 billion in microinsurance
the 2020 study, which found that 162 premiums compared to USD 1.060
to 253 million people were reached billion in 2019. This is partly because
through 60 million policies in 28 several very large schemes reported
countries. The increase results mainly only the number of people reached
from the inclusion of data from Costa and not premium income in 2020, and
Rica, El Salvador, Senegal, and Uganda partly because the median premium
and an increased sample size of 224 collected per person insured fell. In
insurance providers and 704 products, 2020, a median average of USD 9.71
compared to 194 insurers and 589 was collected,6 down from USD 14.00 in
products the previous year. The 2019 (Table 3). This reduction reflects
additional responses included some several factors:
very large schemes for which data was
• Changes in exchange rates, as many
not previously made available.
currencies depreciated against the
The number of people covered by dollar in 2020. The number of
microinsurance in the last year
represents between 6% and 14% of the
• The change in product mix in 2020, people covered by
target population5 in the countries
with a larger share of relatively microinsurance
low-priced health products.
studied. The corresponding figures
in the last year
for each region are given in Table 2. • Reduced incomes of customers
because of COVID-19, and the represents between
response of many insurers who 6% and 14% of the
decided to reduce coverage amounts
and corresponding premiums, or to
target population
grant premium holidays. in the countries
• Gaps in coverage as clients failed studied.
to make premium payments, or
coverage that ended and was not
renewed, leading to lower premiums
collected throughout the year.
4
This number includes between 104 million and 206 million people based on responses received from 224 insurance providers, as well as data from regulators in India and Mexico,
and publicly available data from Allianz in countries where it was not provided locally.
5
For the purposes of this study, the microinsurance target population is calculated as the number of people earning between 2 and 20 international dollars per day on a purchasing
power parity basis (Int. $). The underlying income distribution data is sourced from Pew Research Center and adjusted for contemporary population estimates. Pew Research Center
provides a more detailed breakdown, defining low-income as Int. $ 2 to Int. $ 10 and middle-income as Int. $ 10 to Int. $ 20 per day (PPP).
For each individual product, the average premium per life covered was calculated. These figures are the median values for each region of the product averages.
6
TABLE 2
ESTIMATED PROPORTION OF THE POPULATION AND MARKET CAPTURED IN THE COUNTRIES
STUDIED IN EACH REGION
This value is based on the median premium per person covered calculated for each region in this study (USD 11.60 in Africa, USD 3.80 in Asia, and USD 19.83 in Latin America).
7
The frequency distributions of lives covered per product show the regional differences and changes from year to year more
clearly (Figures 1 to 4).
TABLE 3
THE MEDIAN NUMBER OF PEOPLE COVERED AND PREMIUMS COLLECTED PER PRODUCT, AND MEDIAN PREMIUM PER
PERSON COVERED FOR EACH REGION IN 2019 AND IN 2020 (USD)8
2019 2020 Year- 2019 2020 Year- 2019 2020 Year- 2019 2020 Year-
on-year on-year on-year on-year
change change change change
Median 7,700 6,000 -22% 12,500 16,000 28% 39,600 5,600 -86% 17,200 7,600 -56%
number
of people
covered per
product
Median total 72,300 79,500 10% 94,000 43,700 -54% 760,300 123,400
-84% 141,700 74,600 -47%
premium
collected
per product
(USD)
Median 14.00 11.60 -17% 8.80 3.80 -57% 18.92 19.83 5% 14.00 9.71 -31%
premium
per person
covered
(USD)
Information on the sample sizes for all data points are provided in Appendix B.
8
30
Share of all products (%)
20
10
20
10
0
0-999 1,000- 10,000- 100,000- 1 million+
9,999 99,999 999,999
Number of lives covered per product
Travel insurance includes cover for short trips on public transport or commuter travel, as well as longer journeys.
9
30
Share of all products (%)
20
10
0
0-9,999 10,000- 100,000- 100,000,000- 10 million+
99,999 999,999 999,999,999
Premium collected per product (USD)
FIGURE 4
FREQUENCY OF PREMIUMS COLLECTED PER PRODUCT IN 2020
(AS SHARE OF TOTAL PRODUCTS IN EACH REGION)
40
30
Share of all products (%)
20
10
0
0-9,999 10,000- 100,000- 100,000,000- 10 million+
99,999 999,999 999,999,999
Premium collected per product (USD)
Property
17,322
118,985*
8,327
Life
71,889*
7,800
Funeral
146,933*
Health
7,095
12,358*
Personal 6,075
accident 27,838*
Investment/ 3,077
Savings 209,495*
2,750
Agriculture
110,218*
652
Travel
6,205*
Other
30,700
112,785*
10
The category “other” includes a range of products, the majority of which offer combined covers. A relatively small number of products were recorded under this category,
and the results for this category should therefore be interpreted with caution.
TABLE 4
THE PERCENTAGE INCREASE OR DECREASE SEEN IN POLICIES ISSUED, PEOPLE COVERED, AND PREMIUMS RECEIVED
FOR COMPANIES THAT REPORTED FOR BOTH 2019 AND 2020
Only insurers reporting in both years were considered, but, in some cases, they did not report on the same number of products in both years. All products reported by these insurers
11
were included in this analysis, as it is not always possible to match products year-on-year.
12
One major product was excluded from the 2020 data for Latin America and the Caribbean as it was clearly a new product not included in 2019 and skewed the results.
13
One major product was excluded from the 2020 data for Latin America and the Caribbean as it was clearly a new product not included in 2019 and skewed the results.
Policies include both individual and group policies, so one policy may account for a large number of people covered. The total number of people covered through those policies is
14
Regulators and supervisors faced many of the same challenges as insurers and
other businesses in 2020 and 2021, having to adapt to staff working from home and
interacting virtually with stakeholders. In some countries, operations slowed as a
result, particularly new product approval processes.
In addition, regulators needed to In India, for example, the regulator Regulators put in place specific
ensure that customers continued to designed several products to provide measures to enable digital processes
be protected and to communicate protection for COVID-19 and mandated during the pandemic, allowing
with insurers about how they should insurers to launch them. The Indian e-signatures, digital fulfilment
respond to the pandemic. Regulators regulator also made efforts to fast- of “know your customer” (KYC)
released communications for customers track the approval of new COVID- requirements, and digital sales and
clarifying the coverage to which related products designed by insurers, onboarding, on a permanent or
they were entitled. They requested reducing the approval turnaround temporary basis. A total of 44% of
additional information from insurers time to just a matter of days. Finally, regulators surveyed by the Access to
to track the market closely as the the regulator mandated insurers to Insurance Initiative (A2ii) in June 2021
pandemic developed, as well as speed up claims settlement since had introduced electronic signatures
releasing guidance on the introduction hospitals were requiring confirmation because of COVID-19 (another 18%
of new COVID-related products, and of payment in order to release patients had already introduced electronic
instructions on what insurers and from hospitals already at full capacity. signatures before the pandemic, and
reinsurers should cover in relation to 19% were considering doing so).15
COVID-19.
32 21
ASIA-PACIFIC ASIA-PACIFIC
UNDER DEVELOPMENT
IMPLEMENTED
Cambodia Bangladesh
China Fiji
Chinese Taipei Papua New Guinea
Sri Lanka
India
Vietnam
Indonesia
Malaysia LATIN AMERICA
Mongolia & CARIBBEAN
Nepal Bolivia
Pakistan Chile
Philippines Colombia
Thailand El Salvador
Guatemala
Honduras
LATIN AMERICA Jamaica
& CARIBBEAN Paraguay
Argentina
Belize MIDDLE EAST
Brazil & NORTH AFRICA
Costa Rica Jordan
Morocco
Mexico
Tunisia
Nicaragua
Peru SUB-SAHARAN AFRICA
Venezuela Kenya
Lesotho
MIDDLE EAST Namibia
& NORTH AFRICA Uganda
Egypt Zambia
SUB-SAHARAN AFRICA
CIMA*
Eswatini
Ethiopia
Ghana
Madagascar
Malawi
Mozambique
Nigeria
Rwanda
South Africa
Tanzania *CIMA is counted as one jurisdiction (Benin, Burkina Faso, Cameroon,
Central African Republic, Chad, Congo, Equatorial Guinea, Gabon, Guinea Bissau,
Zimbabwe Ivory Coast, Mali, Niger, Senegal, and Togo)
18
While the A2ii uses reasonable efforts to include accurate and up-to-date information in this map, it makes no warranties as to the completeness of content, errors, or omissions.
In mapping the inclusive insurance developments worldwide, the A2ii welcomes insurance supervisors’ inputs.
Life and credit life insurance have been the product lines that covered the most
people in past Landscape of Microinsurance Studies.
This year, the numbers of lives covered The 224 insurance providers who
through life and credit life insurance responded to the survey across the
remained fairly stable. However, health three regions jointly reached over
microinsurance took over, becoming 104 million people through health
the largest product line in terms of microinsurance products. This apparent
people covered, followed by personal explosion in lives covered through
accident insurance (see Figure 7). health insurance is largely a result of
the inclusion in the data of a small
It should also be noted that the number
number of major health schemes,
of people covered by each product line
notably in Asia and some led by state
is not directly comparable to those
insurers, which were not included in
reported in previous years, as the way
previous Landscape Studies. Five health
in which this information is recorded
products in Africa and Asia reached
has changed (e.g., for bundled
more than a million clients each and
products) for this report to increase
are jointly responsible for 96% of the
accuracy. Nonetheless, the overall
BOX 2 people reported as covered by health
picture in terms of the most important
products. Most of these five schemes
People covered product lines can be compared.
were launched from 2018 onwards
Insurers were asked to provide the Health microinsurance became the and are delivered through a range
number of people covered by each most important product in both Africa of distribution channels, including
of their products. This includes and Asia, whereas in LAC, life insurance microfinance and financial institutions,
the policyholder as well as others continued as the dominant product mobile payment providers, NGOs,
insured under the policy. For line, with health microinsurance agents, and brokers.
example, a life or health insurance reaching a relatively low number of
policy may cover additional family customers (as explored further in
members. In the case of livestock section 6.2).
and crop insurance, people covered
refers to the number of farmers or
livestock owners who have taken
out the insurance. FIGURE 7
MICROINSURANCE PRODUCT LINES RANKED BY THE NUMBER OF PEOPLE
REACHED IN 2019 AND 2020
2019 Rank 2020
Life 1 Health +4
Funeral 4 Life -3
Health 5 Funeral -1
Property
(non-Agri) 54.68
Motor 28.63
Investment/
Savings 5.98
Climate &
natural disaster
4.31
Travel 0.22
Legal 0.03
Other 15.52
It should be noted that data was not provided for several large national agriculture schemes covering smallholder farmers.
19
Some schemes may also be funded through premium subsidies or other subsidy types in addition to direct premium income from customers.
20
Andrew Wight (2020). This Doctor’s App Is Helping Libya Triage Its Coronavirus Patients (Forbes)
22
23
Michal Matual, Niti Pall (2021). An Ironic Impact of COVID-19: Will the Pandemic Put Digital Health (Finally) on the Path to Reducing Health Inequalities at Scale in Emerging Markets?
(Next Billion)
24
Although it should be noted that there were some changes to the way in which bundled products were categorised in the most recent questionnaire which may impact on the
products categorised as credit life.
Press Trust of India (2020). Coronavirus: PhonePe partners with Bajaj Allianz for hospitalisation insurance policy
25
Maelis Carraro (2020). How are inclusive fintech start-ups responding to COVID-19?
26
IDF (2019). The IDF, UNDP & BMZ Tripartite Programme: Increasing insurance protection in climate-exposed countries.
27
UNDP (2021). UNDP launches new Insurance and Risk Finance Facility.
28
WFP (2020). Casual labourers in Bangladesh to benefit from newly launched flood insurance scheme
29
Hafiz Ali Hassan (2019). Takaful models: Origin, progression, and future
31
Despite the challenges of social distancing, the same types of channels continue
to be most used to distribute microinsurance. Agents are used as part of the
distribution strategy of almost half the products, with brokers and financial
institutions used for 39% of products, and microfinance institutions for 22% of
products (Figure 11). This is a similar picture to the one observed in the data
for 2019.
FIGURE 11
THE PROPORTION OF PRODUCTS IN ALL THREE REGIONS WHICH MAKE USE
OF EACH DISTRIBUTION CHANNEL TYPE32
Agents 49%
Financial
institution
39%
Brokers 39%
Microfinance
institution 22%
Community organisation
or association 8%
NGO 8%
MNO 5%
Aggregator 5%
Retailer 3%
Funeral fund 2%
Travel agency 2%
Hospital 2%
Syndicate 1%
Other 13%
Travel agency refers to an agency or sales office which sells tickets for travel, including both short trips on public transport and longer journeys.
32
33
The Grameen Crédit Agricole Foundation, ADA, Inpulse (2021). COVID-19: The impact of the crisis on microfinance institutions. Analyses and perspectives.
34
Asia Insurtech Podcast (2021). EP 120 – Gustaf Agartson – Founder & CEO at Bima – Combine the Digital Approach with the Human Touch.
35
Tech Financials (2020). MTN sees more value in a mobile micro-insurance firm Ayo, raises stake to 75%
36
Access to Finance Rwanda (2021). Microinsurance: The Customer-Centric approach in Rwanda (LEAD webinar series)
FIGURE 12
THE PROPORTION OF PRODUCTS FOR WHICH CHANGES WERE MADE
IN RESPONSE TO COVID-19
Climate &
29%
natural disaster
Travel 25%
Health 25%
Life 23%
Property
(non-Agri) 14%
Personal
13%
accident
Investment/
Savings 12%
Agriculture 10%
Funeral 9%
Credit Life/
7%
Loan Protection
Other 8%
Female policyholders
and women covered
The following figures show the
proportion of women who are
named as the policyholder, as
well as the proportion of women
among total people covered. The
latter reflects the fact that many
insurance policies may include
coverage for other family members
beyond the policyholder. Both
indicators are relevant — women
benefit from coverage taken out
by family members which includes
them, but a focus on insuring
women directly as policyholders
is also important as it speaks to
women’s decision-making power
in selecting and managing their
insurance protection.
TABLE 5
THE MEDIAN PERCENTAGE OF FEMALE POLICYHOLDERS AND OF WOMEN
COVERED IN EACH REGION
The Grameen Crédit Agricole Foundation, ADA, Inpulse (2021). COVID-19: The impact of the crisis on microfinance institutions. Analyses and perspectives
37
FIGURE 14
Most commercial THE MEDIAN PROPORTIONS OF WOMEN REACHED BY DISTRIBUTION CHANNEL38
Aggregator 46%
are reaching. 43%
45%
Travel agency
65%
45%
Syndicate
45%
Microfinance 45%
institution 49%
45%
Brokers
50%
45%
Agents
50%
43%
Funeral fund
57%
Financial 41%
institution 45%
Community organisation 41%
or association 40%
40%
NGO
40%
40%
MNO
40%
Other 44%
45%
Some channels are not included where very little data was available
38
TABLE 6
MEDIAN CLAIMS RATIOS BY REGION
REGION Claims ratio Percentage point Percentage point Claims ratio for
change from 2019 change from 2019 products launched
(all data) (only insurers before 2020
that reported in
both years)
TABLE 7
CLAIMS METRICS BY REGION
39
For the purpose of this study, claims ratios were calculated automatically as claims paid during the reporting period as percentage of premiums received in the same period.
This year, insurers were also given the option to override this calculation and provide a more accurate claims ratio.
Insurers provided information on their average claims size for each product. This figure is the median for each region of those averages.
40
41
Insurance providers were asked to provide the claims turnaround time as the total number of days between a claim incident occurring and the pay-out being received by the
beneficiary. However, in many cases insurers notified us that they do not have that information and can only provide the turnaround time from when they receive claims documents
to when they pay the claim.
FIGURE 15
FREQUENCY OF CLAIMS RATIOS BY REGION
(AS A SHARE OF TOTAL PRODUCTS IN EACH REGION)
80
Share of total products (%)
60
40
20
0
0-19% 20-39% 40-59% 60-79% 80-99% 100-1,000% 1,000%+
Claims ratio ranges
42
As a point of comparison, the national median claims ratios for non-life business in European countries in 2019 ranged from 42% to 79% according to the European Insurance and
Occupational Pensions Authority’s European Insurance Overview 2020 (though these rates cannot be directly compared with microinsurance claims rates for many reasons, including
the different lines of business covered).
FIGURE 17
MEDIAN CLAIMS RATIO BY DISTRIBUTION CHANNEL
(FOR ALL PRODUCTS AND FOR PRODUCTS LAUNCHED BEFORE 2020)
23%
Funeral fund
23%
Community organisation 17%
or association 22%
Microfinance 20%
institution 19%
21%
Hospital
19%
Aggregator 13%
19%
23%
Agents
18%
15%
MNO
15%
Retailer 6%
14%
15%
NGO
14%
Brokers 19%
14%
13%
Syndicate
13%
Financial 15%
institution 12%
7%
Travel agency
7%
Other 10%
4%
Investment/
Savings 306
Personal
301
accident
Travel 296
Climate &
natural disaster
247
Health 79
Other 307
43
Note that, for some product lines – particularly agriculture – claims may be paid on a group rather than individual basis, resulting in a larger average claim size. It is not possible to
be sure where this is the case in the Landscape data.
FIGURE 19
FREQUENCY OF CLAIMS TURNAROUND TIMES BY REGION
(AS A SHARE OF TOTAL PRODUCTS IN EACH REGION)
80
Share of total products (%)
60
40
20
0
0-9 10-19 20-29 30-39 40-49 50-100 100+
Claims turnaround time ranges (days)
Health 1 11 258
Property (non-Agri) 2 14 60
insurer participation.
Funeral 7,800
A total of USD 557.4 million was
Life 7,656
collected in microinsurance
premiums. The potential value of the Health 5,994
microinsurance market in the countries Investment/
included in the study is estimated at Savings 4,476
44
This figure includes between 16.8 and 34.4 million people covered reported by the 132 insurers who responded to the questionnaire, as well as publicly available data from Allianz
(where not reported locally).
This value is based on the median premium per person covered (USD 11.60) across all countries in Africa included in this study.
45
See, for example: ILO Impact Insurance Facility (2019). Making a profitable inclusive insurance business: a case study of Britam, Kenya
46
FIGURE 21
MEDIAN PREMIUM COLLECTED PER PERSON COVERED BY PRODUCT LINE
IN AFRICA (USD)47
Property
(non-Agri)
50
Investment/
36
Savings
Funeral 27
Climate &
natural disaster 20
Life 19
Personal
accident
10
Agriculture 8
Travel 7
Credit Life/
Loan Protection
6
Health 3
Other 6
For each individual product, the average premium per life covered was calculated. Then, the median of these averages was taken for each product line and is presented in this figure.
47
FIGURE 22
MICROINSURANCE PRODUCT LINES RANKED BY THE NUMBER OF PEOPLE
REACHED IN 2019 AND 2020 IN AFRICA
2019 Rank 2020
Life 2 Funeral +1
Funeral 3 Life -1
FIGURE 23
PEOPLE COVERED BY PRODUCT LINE IN AFRICA (MILLIONS)
Health 16.76
Funeral 10.23
Life 2.14
Credit Life/
1.99
Loan Protection
Agriculture 1.12
Personal
accident
0.81
Climate &
natural disaster
0.41
Investment/
Savings 0.11
Property
(non-Agri) 0.09
Travel 0.01
Other 0.73
FIGURE 24
With reduced PREMIUMS COLLECTED BY PRODUCT LINE IN AFRICA (USD MILLIONS)
Credit Life/
13.3
Loan Protection
Personal
2.1
accident
Investment/
Savings
1.3
Property
(non-Agri) 1.3
Travel 0.2
Climate &
0.1
natural disaster
Other 2.2
Of all regions, MFIs in Africa were most Despite pressure to move towards
able to resume normal operations digital solutions, particularly due to
during 2020, with more than 60% the pandemic, human interaction has
reporting that by December 2020, they remained vital. Many new InsurTechs
had gone back to operating as before have been entering the African
the pandemic. Nonetheless, MFIs’ microinsurance market in recent years
clients were hard-hit by the crisis and offering entirely digital solutions.
this in turn impacted MFIs’ lending Nonetheless, these companies often
activities and profitability. Only around partner with aggregators who have
12% of MFIs in Sub-Saharan Africa in-person contact with clients and
reported that over half of their clients the continued importance of these
were able to repay their loans.48 aggregators is clear.
Microfinance
institution 24%
MNO 9%
Aggregator 9%
Community organisation
or association 8%
NGO 8%
Funeral fund 4%
Hospital 4%
Retailer 2%
Syndicate 1%
Travel agency 1%
Other 5%
The Grameen Crédit Agricole Foundation, ADA, Inpulse (2021). COVID-19: The impact of the crisis on microfinance institutions. Analyses and perspectives
48
The lower proportion of female clients partly reflects lower financial inclusion
of women compared to men in the region. In 2017, in Sub-Saharan Africa, 37% of
women had access to an account with a financial institution or through a mobile
money service, compared to 48% of men. This 12-percentage point gap is higher
than the 11-percentage point gap for South Asia, 4-percentage point gap for East
Asia and 7-percentage point gap for Latin America.49
FIGURE 26
THE MEDIAN PROPORTIONS OF WOMEN REACHED BY PRODUCT LINE
IN AFRICA
Credit Life/ 64%
Loan Protection 66%
Investment/ 52%
Savings 50%
Funeral
50%
50%
Travel
45%
67%
Health
43%
43%
38%
Life
46%
Personal 37%
accident 26%
Property 35%
(non-Agri) 44%
Agriculture
35%
28%
30%
Motor
Asli Demirgüç-Kunt, Leora Klapper, Dorothe Singer, Saniya Ansar, Jake Hess (2018). The Global Findex Database 2017: Measuring Financial Inclusion and the Fintech Revolution
49
The region also has the fastest relatively high median claims ratio In the past, MNO-linked freemium
turnaround time for claims, at a of 25% (Figure 28). However, median products were criticised for low claims
median of 3 days compared to a global claims ratios are worryingly low for ratios. Although based on a relatively
median of 10 days. Products that have health insurance (15%), the product small sample size, the MNO-linked
been around longer in the region have line covering the highest number of products currently on the market have
higher claims ratios, with products people, and life insurance (9%). Despite the highest median claims ratios of
launched before 2020 having a median the relatively low median claims ratios all distribution channels, at 30%
claims ratio of 24%. for health, the ratio does compare (Figure 29). This is likely due to
favourably with health microinsurance changes in the types of MNO-linked
Funeral insurance, the second most
in Asia (at 6%) and in Latin America and products sold in the region. Those
significant product line in terms of
the Caribbean (at 3%). sold through joint ventures may offer
people reached in the region, had a
better value as the MNO has a stake
in ensuring that its customers benefit
from the products. Products that are
FIGURE 28 actively sold, as opposed to freemium
MEDIAN CLAIMS RATIOS IN AFRICA BY PRODUCT LINE products, also generally result in
higher levels of customer awareness
Investment/ and therefore claims.
Savings
39%
Climate &
29% The median value of individual claims
natural disaster
is shown in Figure 30. Higher claims
Funeral 25% amounts in agriculture reflect that it
Personal is a product covering catastrophic and
17%
accident therefore, high-value, low-frequency
Health 15% claims events. It is also possible
that some payments were group
Credit Life/
15% payments. The low value of claims
Loan Protection
pay-outs in health products reflects
Agriculture 12%
the predominance of low-cost products
Property providing relatively small, fixed pay-
11%
(non-Agri)
outs. Relatively low individual claims
Motor 11% payments do not necessarily imply low
value, especially where claims are paid
Life 9%
out more frequently, as is usually the
Travel 3% case for hospital cash products. The
low claims value of personal accident
Other 32%
products suggests that most are low-
cost, likely bundled products, with
relatively low coverage amounts.
MNO 30%
Community organisation
or association
26%
Hospital 25%
Aggregator 22%
Syndicate 19%
Agents 18%
Microfinance
institution
17%
Life 383
Investment/
Savings 282
Travel 176
Personal
accident 51
Health 38
Other 318
Note that, for some product lines – particularly agriculture – claims may be paid on a group rather than individual basis, resulting in a larger average claim size.
51
These customers were reached through A total of USD 288.3 million was
a total of 55.7 million policies. Almost collected in microinsurance premiums
7 million of these were group policies, across these nine Asian countries. The
in many cases covering very large potential value of the microinsurance
numbers of customers. market in these countries is estimated
at USD 7.7 billion, based on the entire
In these nine countries (Bangladesh,
target population being covered by
Cambodia, India, Indonesia, Pakistan,
one insurance product.53 In these
the Philippines, Sri Lanka, Thailand,
countries, current microinsurance
and Vietnam), it is estimated
premiums represent about 4% of that
that between 7% and 15% of the
potential market.
target population is covered by a
microinsurance product. This compares
to between 147.0 million and 201.1
million people recorded in 2019, which
represented between 8% and 11% of
the potential market in the countries
studied in the previous Study.
52
This figure includes between 87.3 million and 146.4 million people covered by the 48 insurance providers that responded to the questionnaire in the region, as well as data from the
Indian regulator and publicly available data from Allianz.
This value is based on the median premium per person covered across all countries in Asia included in this study of USD 3.80.
53
Funeral 82,646
Credit Life/
44,055
Loan Protection
Health 33,030
Motor 20,747
Personal
accident 18,966
Life 6,831
Scale Investment/
Savings 2,949
Each microinsurance product in Asia
reached a median of 16,000 people Agriculture 816
and generated a median of USD 43,700
Other 30,700
in premiums. Property insurance
products achieved the greatest scale,
with a median of over 131,000 people
reached per product (Figure 31),
followed by funeral and credit life FIGURE 32
insurance. Agriculture products in MEDIAN PREMIUM COLLECTED PER PERSON COVERED BY PRODUCT LINE
Asia reached the lowest scale at 816 IN ASIA (USD)54
people, but it should be noted this
Investment/
does not include several very large 67
Savings
government-supported schemes that
Motor 26
were not included in the analysis.
Agriculture 15
Premiums Property
11
(non-Agri)
The median premium per person
covered in Asia is USD 3.80 during Funeral 7
For each individual product, the average premium per life covered was calculated. Then, the median of these averages was taken for each product line and is presented in this figure.
54
insurance products.56
Health 4 Life -3
Funeral 5 Motor55
Motor was not included as a product line in the previous Landscape Study.
55
Vikram Kapur, Alex Boulton (2020). Covid-19 Accelerates the Adoption of Telemedicine in Asia-Pacific Countries (Bain and Company)
56
Health 5.85
Investment/
Savings
3.66
Motor 2.70
Funeral 0.93
Legal 0.03
Other 0.23
Sania Nishtar (2020). COVID-19: Using cash payments to protect the poor in Pakistan (World Economic Forum)
57
Both insurers and their distribution With these licences in place, many
partners were forced to turn to have developed successful low-cost
digital solutions where possible, insurance products catering to all
including mobile payments and the segments of the population.
submission of claims documentation
Asia’s “super app” players are also
via alternative channels like WhatsApp.
proving important drivers of insurance.
Since customers had varied levels of
These applications offer services like
digital literacy and comfort, as well
ride-hailing and reach vast numbers
as connectivity, insurers and their
of customers. Some have introduced
partners often had to adopt several
insurance, often automatically bundled
different methods for processing
with their services (such as accident
payments, assessing claims and
insurance for the duration of a trip).
communicating with clients, including
Gojek, a ride-hailing platform for
digital tools as well as some priority
scooters in Indonesia, for example,
in-person meetings. Interactions
introduced free automatic accident
with agents also moved online, with
insurance for riders and drivers in 2020.58
onboarding and training processes
carried out remotely during the
pandemic, a shift that shows few signs
of being reversed. FIGURE 36
As noted previously, microfinance THE PROPORTION OF PRODUCTS WHICH MAKE USE OF EACH
DISTRIBUTION CHANNEL TYPE IN ASIA
institutions suffered during the
lockdowns imposed because of Agents 35%
COVID-19. However, MFI and bank
Microfinance
lending rebounded in 2021 and experts institution 28%
interviewed in July 2021 shared that Financial
insurance business with MFIs and institution 26%
Travel agency 1%
Retailer 1%
Other 22%
Gojek (2020). Peace of mind with free accident coverage powered by Marsh and underwritten by AIG
58
The gender gap in microinsurance Median percentage of female policyholders by product line
Median percentage of women covered by product line
stems from more general gender
discrepancies in financial inclusion in
the region. In East Asia, the gender gap
in financial account ownership (through
FIGURE 38
a financial institution or mobile money
THE MEDIAN PROPORTIONS OF WOMEN REACHED BY DISTRIBUTION CHANNEL
service) is 4 percentage points, and in
IN ASIA
South Asia it is 11 percentage points.59
90%
Aggregator
60%
Microfinance 70%
institution 60%
60%
Hospital
Retailer 50%
60%
Agents 42%
47%
Financial 41%
institution 40%
40%
Travel agency
67%
Community organisation 40%
or association 38%
40%
Brokers
39%
39%
NGO
39%
Funeral fund
73%
29%
Other
29%
59
Asli Demirgüç-Kunt, Leora Klapper, Dorothe Singer, Median percentage of female policy holders by distribution channel
Saniya Ansar, Jake Hess (2018). The Global Findex Median percentage of women covered by distribution channel
Database 2017: Measuring Financial Inclusion and
the Fintech Revolution
Aggregator 6%
NGO 3%
Brokers 3%
Other 18%
Note that, for some product lines – particularly agriculture – claims may be paid on a group rather than individual basis, resulting in a larger average claim size.
60
These customers were reached through A total of USD 284 million were
a total of 15.2 million policies. Around collected in microinsurance premiums
64,000 of these were group policies, across the eight countries. The
in many cases covering very large potential value of the microinsurance
numbers of customers. market in these countries is estimated
at USD 6.8 billion, based on the entire
In the eight countries in the region
target population being covered by
for which data was submitted (Bolivia,
one insurance product.62 In these
Brazil, Colombia, Costa Rica, El
countries, current microinsurance
Salvador, Jamaica, Mexico, and Peru),
premiums represent about 4% of that
it is estimated that between 4% and
potential market.
12% of the target population is covered
by a microinsurance product. The interviews conducted for this
study, as well as individual country
The number of people covered
data, suggest that demand for
increased from between 6.3 and 22.5
microinsurance in LAC fell in 2020, as
million people reported in 2019, as a
the low-income sector was severely
result of a larger sample size and the
impacted by COVID-19. In Colombia,
addition of Costa Rica and El Salvador
for example, overall spending on
to the study. At the same time, the
insurance dropped slightly (by 0.3%)
premiums collected fell by more than
in 2020, while the number of active
half (from USD 674 million in 2019).
microinsurance policies fell by 11%
the same year.63
61
This figure includes between 14.3 million and 25.6 million people covered by the 44 microinsurance providers that responded to the questionnaire as well as data from the Mexican
regulator and publicly available data from Allianz.
62
This value is based on the median premium per person covered across all countries in Latin America and the Caribbean included in this study of USD 19.83.
63
Banca de las Oportunidades (2021). Reporte de Inclusión Financiera 2020
Investment/
71
Savings
Health 66
Travel 37
Funeral 30
Life 17
Personal
15
accident
Climate &
15
natural disaster
Property
(non-Agri) 14
Credit Life/
9
Loan Protection
Other 30
For each individual product, the average premium per life covered was calculated. Then, the median of these averages was taken for each product line and is presented in this figure.
64
Climate &
In addition to launching new products, 4.20
natural disaster
insurers modified existing products,
Motor 1.31
often adding COVID-19 coverage to
Investment/
products like unemployment insurance. Savings 1.01
Health insurers increased the
availability of telemedicine and Funeral 0.30
This likely reflects the acute Online and mobile insurance sales recognised by Google as a success story
challenges experienced by MFIs in increased in some countries, especially in digital transformation during 2020,
the region during 2020. Operational where insurers had already been having achieved 45% of its sales through
difficulties were particularly hard to working on strengthening these its mobile channel, representing an
overcome for MFIs in LAC, where 20% channels. Seguros Mundial in Colombia increase of 756% compared to 2019, and
of MFIs reported that their activities was particularly successful in doing reducing its policy acquisitions costs by
were still very limited by December so. In April 2021, the company was more than 60%.68
2020, compared to around 5% globally.
MFIs in the region experienced
around a 15% loss in their client base,
compared to 3%, globally.67 FIGURE 47
THE PROPORTION OF PRODUCTS WHICH MAKE USE OF EACH DISTRIBUTION
The use of retail channels also fell, CHANNEL TYPE IN LATIN AMERICA AND THE CARIBBEAN
from 13% in 2019 to 8% in 2020. In LAC,
microinsurance is sold through retail Brokers 46%
channels like department stores and Financial
44%
shops selling household appliances. institution
These were forced to close entirely Agents 39%
or convert to online sales during the
Microfinance
worst of the pandemic and sales fell as institution 14%
a result.
Retailer 8%
Although the same channels continued
Community organisation
to be used, the pandemic accelerated 6%
or association
digitalisation both by insurers and their Travel agency 4%
distribution partners. For example,
many companies have adopted virtual NGO 4%
claims processes, allowing photographs
of damage to be sent and documents Aggregator 3%
The Grameen Crédit Agricole Foundation, ADA, Inpulse (2021). COVID-19: The impact of the crisis on microfinance institutions. Analyses and perspectives
67
ACIS (2021). Seguros Mundial es reconocida por google como caso de éxito en su estrategia de transformación digital
68
Agriculture 22%
Funeral
45%
14%
Other
14%
FIGURE 50
MEDIAN CLAIMS RATIOS IN LATIN AMERICA AND THE CARIBBEAN
BY PRODUCT LINE
Climate &
80%
natural disaster
Agriculture 61%
Credit Life/
Loan Protection
55%
Motor 35%
Life 27%
Travel 17%
Funeral 15%
The median claims ratio in 2020 is
slightly higher than the 10% claims Property
10%
(non-Agri)
ratio recorded in 2019. As a result
Personal
of COVID-19, claims ratios for credit accident
5%
life and life products increased
Health 3%
dramatically from 20% in 2019 to
55% in 2020 and from 9% to 27% Investment/ 1%
Savings
respectively. This increase has been
felt acutely by life insurers who Other 3%
tend to retain all, or at least the
vast majority, of the risk in these
product lines, in comparison to lines
usually seen as likely to experience
catastrophic claims, like agriculture
and climate products, which depend to
a much higher degree on reinsurance.
Brokers 19%
Figure 52 shows the median value
of individual claims in the region
Aggregator 19% by product line. The median claims
payment for agriculture insurance is
NGO 17%
particularly high and some of these
Microfinance
17% may represent group payments. Median
institution
health claims are higher in LAC than
Financial
institution
14% in other regions because of the nature
of the products. These are largely
Travel agency 12%
higher-value products, such as cancer
Agents 10% insurance or comprehensive health
insurance, with higher pay-outs than
MNO 6% the product types more common in
other regions.
Syndicate 3%
At 9%, median claims rejection rates
Hospital 1%
were higher in the region than the
Other
global median of 3%. These were
particularly high for agriculture
(43%) and health (33%), though these
numbers should be treated with
caution as they are taken from small
FIGURE 52 sample sizes. Looking at products
MEDIAN VALUE OF INDIVIDUAL CLAIMS BY PRODUCT LINE according to their distribution channel,
IN LATIN AMERICA AND THE CARIBBEAN (USD)70 those distributed through aggregators,
hospitals, and retailers had particularly
Agriculture 6,219 high median rejection rates (at 41%,
48% and 48%, respectively).
Motor 2,800
Claims turnaround times were higher
Travel 2,500 in the region than in others, at a
Life 1,560
median of 15 days compared to 10 days
across all regions. The longest claims
Health 1,262 turnaround times were for agriculture
Credit Life/ products (60 days median) and the
1,232
Loan Protection fastest were for motor, at 2 days.
Personal
707 By distribution channel, the longest
accident
median claims turnaround times
Property
(non-Agri) 468 were for products distributed through
Investment/ aggregators (35 days) and community
Savings 380
organisations (30 days), and the fastest
Funeral 284 were recorded for hospitals (5 days)
and retailers (7 days).
Climate &
natural disaster 87
Other 154
Note that, for some product lines — particularly agriculture — claims may be paid on a group rather than individual basis, resulting in a larger average claim size.
70
ASIA
Bangladesh 64 11 10
Cambodia 26 4 5
India 63 29 1
Indonesia 144 144 8
Nepal 39 19 0
Pakistan 48 6 6
Philippines 104 52 8
Sri Lanka 27 13 6
Thailand 78 78 1
Vietnam 49 17 3
Credit Life/Loan
Protection 70 10% 35 11% 30 15% 5 3%
Agriculture 52 7% 39 12% 10 5% 3 2%
Property 42 6% 13 4% 5 2% 24 13%
Motor 30 4% 23 7% 5 2% 2 1%
Investment/Savings
17 2% 8 3% 5 2% 4 2%
Travel 8 1% 4 1% — 0% 4 2%
Climate/Natural
7 1% 3 1% — 0% 4 2%
Disaster
Legal 1 0% — 0% 1 0% — 0%
Other 12 2% 7 2% 2 1% 3 2%
TABLE B2
NUMBER AND PROPORTION OF PRODUCTS FOR WHICH USABLE DATA WAS PROVIDED FOR EACH INDICATOR
Premiums collected
690 98% 304 97% 198 98% 188 100%
Premium per
person covered 501 71% 179 57% 177 87% 145 77%
Percentage of
female clients 371 53% 158 50% 106 52% 107 57%
Claims ratio 582 83% 274 88% 150 74% 158 84%
Claims rejection rate 344 49% 139 44% 101 50% 104 55%
Claims
turnaround time
464 66% 222 71% 142 70% 100 53%
Contact us
info@microinsurancenetwork.org
@NetworkFlash
YouTube