Professional Documents
Culture Documents
or institution/organization will put in place or design. It is this type of curriculum that determines
the shape of the education system in our country. Thu the relationship between our values and
curriculum design cannot be ignored when determining what kind of education (knowledge and
skill) should be imparted to the student learner. In other words, the purpose of education to an
individual learner and ultimately to the nation is closely attributed to the values that individual or
nation holds.
Values differ across countries. It is for reason that even the level of social, political and
economic development vary from one country to the other. Western countries for example tend
to do well in terms of the education system than African countries. It should be noted that the
school curriculum of most African countries that were colonized by western countries is not very
different from the curriculum of most of these western countries. But someone could ask, “Why
are western countries more developed than African countries?’’ It could be that what is learnt in
most of the African schools is not implemented. The students that are said to be agents of change
in the society fail to live the education (knowledge and skill) taught at school. It could also be
that the values that are learnt at home and in the neighborhood through socialization do not blend
well with the knowledge and skill taught at school. The content of the curriculum is not lived
out. It is only there for information or knowledge and not application. Gulati and pant(n, d),
writing about education for values in India, one of the developing countries, concluded that it is
in the process of translating goals into action that the enacted curriculum falls short of the
intended curriculum. “We value those aspects of education that lead to academic excellence and
employment. Those who do not succeed to the extent desired are not valued. Whatever is valued
is taught and is considered more appropriate. Knowledge and information takes over and the
desired values which are important for the development of the individual and health and equity
of society is relegated to the background. For example, children today are taught the skills to
keep up with the increased sophistication of computer but the concern for values and the related
policies are not implemented with the same vigor and enthusiasm. The choice of emphasis
determines the nature of education provided in schools” (Gulati and pant, n, d).
The common fundamental values than govern most of the developing countries turn out to be the
ones that hinder development despite them being good. One of the highest fundamental value in
the southern world for example is respectful dependency. In the respectful dependency, people
are driven by the reality of “being” and not “becoming”. They believe that only someone else
can change something and not I. They have no sympathy for their fellow men, i.e. they reap to
gather for themselves. Under respectful dependency people are not flexible, i.e. they have no
room for change or diversification. They believe in communal survival or subsistence, to have
only enough for today. Learners are taught not ask questions, not to doubt, not to conduct
research or search for the facts. Countries in this circle believe in “tomorrow only god knows”.
They don’t encourage implementing long term plans. They have no courage to fight the wrong
even if something is seen to be wrong. Finally individuals in the respectful dependency don’t
embrace new ideas and creativity. It is these values that have shaped the education system in
most African countries. Despite having some of the good contents in the curriculum, these values
outweigh the contents that aim at changing a nation for better if implemented or put to action.
Therefore it can be said that the curriculum itself may have right knowledge to be transferred to
the student learner, but if the values which an individual learn at home, neighborhood or the
community they grow from outweigh that knowledge or skill, then the learner will only learn in
order for them to know and get employed after school.
On the other hand, the fundamental values for western countries have seen their education
system to greater heights. In the western world, competition is widely encouraged. People are
taught to research as they grow up, i.e. they look out for information. When the student learner is
learning, doubt, skepticism, new ideas, search for facts, questioning, debate, discussion and
rivalry are encouraged. They look for merit, talent, exceptional disposition, i.e. a person who is a
winner. A person is seen as important figure, because he or she is the one with dreams and risks.
An individual is the driving force of anything. These values when infused into the school
curriculum and implemented by those who are the products of the said curriculum may work to
the advantage of a given country.
To be able to achieve this, the education offered the individual should take into consideration the
factors and culture operative in the individual's society. This is because there can be no
meaningful and effective education in the absence of culture
Oninyama and Oninyame (2002) referred to values as the aspect of cultural practices, actions or
objects that are valued in high esteem in the society. These cultural values are so cherished to the
extent that the society wants them not only to be preserved, but wants them transmitted from one
generation to another. They dominate a very wide area of activities among the Africans ranging
from the tradition institutions through virtues to communalism and group solidarity. The modes
of transmission of these values are usual ly by means of indigenous education (Itedjere 1997).
Education itself, according to Okpilike (20002) is a process by which the community seeks to
open its life to all the individuals within it and enables them to take part in it; in attempt to pass
on to them its culture including the standards by which it would have them live. The important
thing in this definition is that where that culture is regarded as final, an attempt is made to
improve on it on the younger minds, where it is viewed as a stage in development; younger
minds are trained both to receive it and to criticize it and improve upon it.
The various African societies including Nigeria had interactions since historical times in the area
of trade, warfare, arts and craft. While these interactions lasted, there were cultural exchanges
but the various societal values were held intact. However, when western education was
introduced most African cultural values were cast aside. Western education is associated with
formal education which is a systematic and planned procedure for transmitting content to achieve
state goals. Western education has to do with teaching and learning in a school system of certain
subject matters with the sole aim of making the individual to live well. But more than this goal,
western education as practiced in Nigeria has gone out of its way to relegate almost all aspects of
African cultural values to the background
The theory of existentialism waters down the value of respectful dependency by most of the
underdeveloped and developing countries. The fact that it questions the existence of God and
ultimately rejects any given answer to existence means that it does not encourage dependency
upon God and upon each other as human beings. It encourages questioning and independent
decision making. It could be that most developed countries have embraced the principle behind
this theory. They keep on questioning by means of researching and wanting to know more. Thus
there values when incorporated into the school curriculum seem to work to the betterment of the
society and their nation at large. Their education system seem to be outstanding and of good
quality.
What is Pragmatism?
By nature, pragmatists are pluralists - they believe that that there are many different realities,
with everyone searching for truth and finding meaning in life according to their experiences.
They place a great deal of emphasis upon change, focusing on the fact that the world is a work in
progress, a reality which is in a constant state of flux. They believe in utilitarian principles - the
greatest good for the greatest number, and the fulfilment and meeting of human need.
Pragmatists believe in experimentation, placing more importance on the notion of being active in
learning, giving more credence to actions than ideas (Educational System, 2013). Pragmatists
judge something to be good if it has achieved what it set out to do; essentially, pragmatism is an
approach towards successfully "… getting things done" (Talisse and Aikin, 2008, p. 1).
Dewey’s philosophy emphasizes the social function of intelligence that ideas are instruments of
living rather than ends in themselves. Education is seen as basically a social process rooted in
problem solving and the exploration of meaning of experience. According to Dewey no
changeable absolutes or universals exist. This philosophy encourages experimentation and
observation by way of scientific research.
Unlike the respectful dependency, Dewey’s philosophy embrace the operational values where
people are taught to consult, evaluate and check others. In the respectful dependency, learning is
by awaiting instruction which make students to only memorize and reproduce that which was
taught. It is difficult to change and innovate things under the respectful dependency because
scientific research is something that has received no critical attention. On the other hand, western
countries seem to have embraced the theory of pragmatism. Research through instrumentalism is
widely encouraged. It could be true that there curriculum is skewed towards research and hence
their education system seem to be progressing and not stagnant.
Talisse, R. B., Aikin, S. F. (2008) Pragmatism: A Guide for the Perplexed. London: Continuum
International Publishing Group
Christopher Panza and Gregory Gale. 2008. Existentialism for Dummies. Canada: Wiley
Publishing, Inc. Pg. 1.