You are on page 1of 7

Journal of Nursing Management, 1996,4, 11-17

Nurse absence-the causes and the consequences

M. BEIL-HILDEBRAND RGN, Nursing Administration (Germany), MSC


PhD student, Department of Nursing Studies, University of E d ~ ~ b u r g U
h ,R

Correspondence BEIL-HILDEBRAND M. Journal of Nursing Management 4,ll-17


M . Beil-Hifdebrand Nurse absence-the causes and the consequences
Landshuter Strasse 44
93053 Regensburg This paper addresses nurse absence as it occurs in health care organizations and as a form
Germany of withdrawal behaviour from work. Absence represents a traditional domain of conflict
between nursing management and their employees in day-to-day practice. The aim of the
following discussion is to extend nursing management’s understanding of the topic as a
precondition for well-balanced schedules and effective human resource planning. A
discussion of planned and unplanned absence thus arises and appropriate types of
measurement, taking employee absence behaviour into account, are outlined. The
implications of the arguments, developed in detail in the first part of the paper, are
applied in the second part using a hypothetical account. In order to illustrate the
importance of managing absence by nursing management, a method for calculating
schedules is described which investigates the organizational control of planned and
unplanned absence. This method proposes a seven stage calculation and highlights the
processes that are essential for taking absence into account.

28 September 1995
Accepted for pub~~cat~on:

Introduction is directly relevant to the effectiveness and efficiency of


human resource management in hospitals. Great oppor-
Since the beginning of the 1980s it is been the aim to
tunities and a challenge for nursing management are given
reorganize the National Health Service (NHS) and hospi-
through the creation of a new kind of schedule. These
tal management boards have concentrated intensively on
new schedules allow nursing management to examine and
the finances and organizational control of their corporate
plan with two different absence variables as a prerequisite
health care systems. Financial and economic balance, the
for well-balanced human resource planning.
introduction of a market economy as well as the trans-
formation into self-governed trusts seem to be the strategic
objectives in this decade. In this current flurry the rapid
What is absence?
political changes within the NHS have led to the growth
of an independently managed service as well as to Absence is a pervasive problem in all working organiza-
increased competition in health care. These changes tions. In the UK alone, about 300 million working days
within the NHS raised questions about the relationship are lost per year, i.e. 13.5 days per employee or about
between cost, quantity and the quality of care delivered 6% of the contracted working hours per year (Argyle
by nursing services. Nevertheless, the absence of nurses 1989).The situation in the United States industry is better
remains a phenomenon rarely addressed, even though it with an absence rate of about 2.5%, and worse in Italy

D 1996 Blackwell Science Ltd 11


M. Beil-Hildebrand

with 14% (Pluecker 1990). This variety of absences would Why does unplanned absence occur?
be a challenge for research since the worldwide diversity
The effects of unplanned nurse absence on the employing
of human beings provides a complex material for dis-
organization can be significant in terms of the impact 011
covering forms of absence behaviour related to the norms
the organizational workflow and in relation to the qualit?,
of cultural life.
and continuity of care provided, since service and atten-
Furthermore, it has been recognized for many years
that absence in industry is a widespread and an increasing tion to patient’s needs cannot be postponed. In many
problem (Froggatt 1970; Jones 1971) and its cost is roughly ways, unplanned absence is disruptive to the working
equivalent to the total expenditure of the National Health environment because of its unpredictability and sud-
Service (Taylor 1974). Reports from the Industrial Society denness. Surveys undertaken by the Institute of Manpoweir
(1993) and the Confederation of British Industry (1993) Studies show that the reported incidence of unplanned
described a higher employee absence in the NHS than in absence is higher within the National Health Service antl
most other sectors of the economy. The absence rates in within hospital nursing than in non-NHS nursing antl
the US health sector are just as high as other areas in US community settings (Seccombe & Buchan 1993). However,
industry, although a comparison of absence rates across the explanation for higher unplanned absence rates in
industry is pointless because of different workforce com- NHS institutions may reflect the fact that the occurrence
positions and work patterns (Seccombe & Buchan 1993). of absence could be dependent on several causes. Although
some current articles reflect concern about absence vari-
ables, hard data or national statistics on nursing absencl:
describing the incidence, patterns and troublesomeness of
Definitions
absence among hospitals and other health care agencies
Many related terms are used to describe absence, such is unavailable. Most published research assumes that
as absenteeism, non-attendance, sickness absence, non- some portion of unplanned absence is preventable and
sickness absence, and short/long-term absence, etc. voluntary and researchers have made attempts to identify
(Redfern 1978). It can be claimed that absence is one the contributory causes (Cohen-Mansfield & Rosenthal
specific phrase which is applied to describe a variety of 1989; Hackett, Bycio & Guion 1989; Lee & Eriksen 1990::.
behaviours that take place in organizational life. In exam- Hackett et al. (1989) refers to three related theoretical
ining nurse absence, a broad distinction can be made factors that attempt to advance the understanding of the
between planned absence, such as holidays, study leave, absence phenomenon. They pointed out that first, absence
public or statutory holidays, where management have had represents a flight from negatively valued aspects of work
notice of absence and can influence it by accurate planning
experience; secondly, absence is a result of organizational
procedures, and unplanned absence, often short-term and
socialization and other adaptive processes to job demand?;;
sometimes voluntary in nature, when nurses call in sick
and thirdly, absence results from a rational decision or
at short notice, or do not arrive at their place of work
choice process directed toward the attainment of valued
(Eichhorn 1975; Pluecker 1990; Seccombe & Buchan
goals.
1993).Literature has supplied several definitions: Taunton,
That means that the first two perspectives tend to
Krampitz and Woods (1989: p. 14) defined absence as ‘a
emphasize the importance of employees’ affective reaction
failure to appear for a scheduled work day’ and Cannavo
to hidher work environments. The third component
(1970) circumscribed absence as the failure to report for
the job when the employer has no reason to expect that highlights the purposive, volitional aspect of absence
the employee will not be available at the specific time. behaviour (Hackett et al. 1989). In contrast, Redfern
As can be seen from the above, both definitions refer (1978) recognized factors associated with absence and
to unplanned absence that results from sickness, illness grouped them in three categories; first, personal and
or staying away from the workplace due to (un-)specific demographic characteristics: i.e. grade, age and tenure,
reasons. In the attempt to define absence it can be claimed sex, marital status and family responsibility, absence
that absence is every day or hour for which work was proneness and personality. Secondly, work context varr-
contracted with an employee, which must be paid for by ables: i.e. size and type of organization and work unit;
the employer without getting performance from an full/part-time status, hours and shifts of employment,
employee at hidher place of work. In other words, absence supervision, job satisfaction, days of the week and rest
is the planned and unplanned time which is going to be days. Thirdly, external variables: i.e. travelling to work,
financed by the employer, although the institution does and unemployment, medical certificates. In doing so,
not get anything in return. Redfern (1978) has developed the generated categories in

12 0 1996 Blackwell Science Ltd, Journal of Nursing Management, 4, 11-1 7


Nurseabsence-thecausesandtheconsequences

a more comprehensive picture and considered the internal (1968) reviewed absence-related aspects (sickness absence
and external surroundings of an individual employee. levels, causes and costs) and found a sickness absence
correlation with age, part-time employment, and staff
turnover. Brookes and Gardener (1972) examined the
The measurement of absence
incidence rates, time-lost percentages, seasonal and daily
The precondition for wo/man power planning and sched- patterns and mentioned problems of analysis due to
uling is accurate monitoring and measurement of deficient record-keeping. Moreover, the Maplin report of
employee absence variables. There are a number of the Department of Health and Social Security (1977)
measurement options open to managers faced with nurse pointed out that absence is measured in a variety of ways.
absence. In deciding which one is most appropriate, There were 16 methods outlined, which have been used
considerations of employee absence behaviours must be in institutions of the National Health Service. It can be
balanced against impact on the human resource planning claimed that the use of multiple techniques make com-
procedures and attendance management strategies. parisons and meaningful statistics between studies or
Attempts have been made to classify absence by institutions impossible.
expressed cause, or to distinguish between voluntary or The review of research undertaken in the past and
unavoidable absence on the one hand, and voluntary and recently (Sadik 1981; Cohen-Mansfield & Rosenthal 1989;
avoidable absence on the other. Redfern (1978) refers to Taunton et al. 1989; Seccombe & Buchan 1993) employed
Jones’ (1971) investigation and states that classifying either a time-lost index or a frequency of incidents
unplanned absence by cause is unreliable because it is measurement, or both. Redfern (1978: p. 233) defined
impossible to ensure that the expressed cause is the true frequency rates as ‘the number of absences in a given
cause. Chadwick-Jones, Brown and Nicholson (1973) time period per 100 employees’. This technique has been
differentiated unavoidable/avoidable absence in a type A found to be a reliable measure, because it presents the
and type B dichotomy as an apparently simple matter spells of absence per month or year and is suitable to
since illness, sickness, medical treatment, compassionate attendance management strategies. Chadwick-Jones
leave (bereavement), and jury service (lay assessor), etc. (1971) identified the so-called attitudinal index, i.e. the
are obviously unavoidable. In practice it is difficult to numbers of one or two day spells of absence, and
classify certain unplanned absences, especially sickness described it as fairly reliable, although less so than the
absence, because individual criteria of sickness vary enor- frequency index. It is a relatively reliable element of
mously and people are not always absolutely honest. This voluntary absence and, possibly, morale. Furthermore,
means that an investigation by management to identify Chadwick-Jones et al. (1971) described the time-lost index
various absences (specifically by sickness) is only of as the numbers of hours or days lost in a period expressed
significance if a correct statistical examination can be as a percentage of total man hours or days required. It
employed. Redfern (1978) described three meaningful measures absence duration with a particular emphasis on
types of absence; first, scheduled or unscheduled absence; the total absence hours (planned and unplanned) per year
secondly, short-term (i.e. 3 days or less) or long-term (i.e. in order to estimate the effective or actual working hours
4 days or more) absence; and thirdly, certified and uncerti- for the calculation of nursing staff or the scheduling of
fied absence. Unscheduled absence can be regarded as holidays. The time-lost index can be regarded as the most
unplanned and is therefore a totally independent factor, reliable quantitative measure because it presents the sum
i.e. it occurs, in contrast to scheduled absence, auton- of total absence hours or days. This is the criterion which
omously from the working situation. Short/long-term has to be applied in human resource planning procedures
absence can be considered as dependent on and indepen- in order to achieve a balance between supply of and
dent of the working situation, but it is a problem in its demand for nursing staff. Such information is obviously
own right and research revealed that approximately 80% vital for nursing managers in order to plan and schedule
of all unplanned absences were for 1-7 days (Benbow strategically.
1989). A certificate for sickness or jury service has to be The calculation of the time lost index is presented as
obtained from medical doctors or public authorities and a practical example; 5 working days per week, a 15%
thus can be precisely measured. planned absence rate and a 6% unplanned absence rate
per employee and 8.0 shift hours are used as a hypotheti-
cal account:
Review of research
In the National Health Service concentration on the 365 days per year
problem of absence started in the late 1960s, when Brown - 105 Saturdays/Sundays

0 1996 Blackwell Science Ltd, Journal of Nursing Management, 4, 11-17 13


M.6ei~"HiIdebran~

-10 public and statutory holidays per year the interest of nursing management to ensure that counter-
=250 working days per yearifuII-time employee active poticy and practices are going to be followed.
Sometimes sanctions of absence-a sequence of oral ancl
As can be seen, there are 250 working days per year
written warnings may be used, Seccombe and Buchart
for every full-time employee. If one working day involves
(1993: p. 6) refer to the 'good practice guide' published
8.0 hours on average, one full-time employee has to
by the MDG (1993) of the Scottish health service, and
work 2000 contracted working hours per year (i.e. 250
pointed out that there is a need for attendance manage-
days x 8.0 h=2OOO hf.
ment to be 'at the heart of every line manager's objectives'
20oQ.00 h contracted working hours per fuI1-time in an organization where performance management i 4
empf oyeeiyear becoming a priority. But is influence by management
-420.00 h. 21% absence rate {planned 1SX and indeed possibIeZ Different types of ~ ~ are ~ ~
unplanned 6 % ) required at different levels in the organization. At thz
= 1580.00 h egective working hours per employeeiyear nursing director level, information is required compara -
= 131.66 h effective working hours per employeel tively infrequently but in an aggregate form, for dis-
month cussions in clinical directorate meetings and for strategic
One full-time employee has to work the contracted human resource planning. Detailed information for ward
2000.00 h per year. If 15% planned absence and 6% sisters is necessary on a daily or weekly basis. In Seccombc
unplanned absence are lost, 1580.00 effective working and Buchan's (1993) survey it was found that in unics
hours per year, which is equivalent to 131.66 effective where absence is regularly reviewed, aggregate monitoring
working hours per month ( i s . 1580h-12 month= is applied. For an optimal review in practice, an adequate
131.66 h) are left. An absence rate, e,g. of 21% evolves and comprehensive information and communication
by adding up all planned and uiip~annedabsence hours system is necessary in order to allow nursrng manage men^
lost in a 1 year period and expressing this as a percentage to react and act according to their responsibilities. It can
of the total contracted working hours from all employees be said that most managers have taken a reactive view,
per year. rather than attempting to reduce absence rates by positive,
active interventions in employment practice. The active
involvement of ward sisters can be seen as the key to
Minimizing unplanned absence by successful human resource management. Examples of
organizational control active involvement are regular contact between absentee
What leads to the decision to go to work? Hackett et aE. and ward sister, informal discussion and formal review
(1989) identified two interrelated perspectives which con- of absence, reviewing alternative work patterns, or occu-
firm the individual's choice and desire to be absent from pational health attendance (Seccombe & Buchan 1993).
work. The first stage can be considered as stimultis event Furthermore, employees should notify the ward sister of
producing a desire to be absent; stage two i s the actual their inabiky to come in for duty and this information
decision either to report for u7ork or t o stay away (Hackert be duly passed on, Management attendance must include
et al. 1989). This means that if the first stimulus event a proactive approach to absence, identi€ying the reasons
Ieaves the individual no choice, a decision must be made. of unplanned absence, and preventing and covering
Therefore, the employee must decide whether the stimulus absence where a scope for positive intervention is possible.
event justifies the absence or not by considering the costs Therefore, management action could include the proper
and benefits desired, education and training of all staff, the provision of flexible
hours, the counselling of frequent absentees, back to work
interviews, or target setting in problem areas.
Employer casts
When unplanned absence occurs, the hospital may pay
overtime to nursing personnel or premium pay to an
Organizational control taking planned absence
agency, or a repl~cementnurse may be available. These
into account
cover options may have adverse effects on the quality of
care and OKIstaff morale but also on the budget because The permission to be absent is often very easy to get and,
covering of unplanned absence leads to non-prospective in the past, nursing managers made no comment following
calculated casts (Seccombe & Buchan 1993). Therefore, the scheduiing of planned absence. However, the schedul-
nurse absence can represent and be reflected as significant ing of planned absence can be seen as a challenge in
costs to an employer in terms of money. It must be in balancing cost with positive impact on che quality and

14 0 1996 Blackwell Science Ltd, Journai of Nuning Management, 4 1 1 -1 7


Nurseabsence-thecausesandtheconsequences

continuity of care, since scheduled absence has caused an = 21a/‘ absence


enormous sway in productivity and continuity of care in 21% absence=420.00 h nurselyear (see Figure 1)
the past. The following model considers the calculation 420.00 h absence per nurse/year
of planned absence as a method of calculating schedules x 15.31 nurses (see number 2)
in day-to-day management practice and is used in practice = 6430.20 h
in the following German hospitals: North and South
If the ward has, on average, a 21% rate of planned
Clinic of the city of Nurnberg and the St Joseph Hospital
and unplanned absence per year and 15.31full-time nurses
in Regensburg.
are employed, then 6430.00 h total absence hours are
going to occur.
The scheduling of planned absence in February 1995
Second step in the calculation:
Within a 1-month schedule there are a specific number of
6430.20 hours absence
shifts available for scheduling planned absence and there
+ 8.00 daily shift hours
is a time budget for unplanned absence which can be
= 803.78 absence shifts per year
used in a flexible manner. The method of calculating
schedules is presented as a practical example; 5 working In dividing the total absence hours of the ward by 8.0
days per week, 15% planned absence rate, 6% unplanned hours for every day shift, a total of 803.78 absence shifts
absence rate, 8.0 shift hours, minimum of three nurses in per year results. But before doing so, the amount of
every shift, 30 holiday shifts per employee/year are used holiday shifts for 15.31 employees must be calculated.
in this hypothetical case.
Third and final step in the calculation:
1. How many nurses have to be on schedule? 15.31 nurses
3 full-time nurses early shift x 30 holiday shifts per nurse/year
+3 full-time nurses late shift = 459.30 holiday shifts per year in total
+3 full-time nurses night shift 803.78 absence shifts per year for all 15.31
=9 full-time nurses per day as minimum for all employees (100.00Y0)
three shifts - 459.30 holiday shifts total/year for planned absence
x 8.0 shift hours per nurse (57.14%)
=72.0 shift hours per day for nine full-time nurses = 344.48 shifts available for unplanned absence
x 28 days per month (February ’95) (42.86%)
= 2016.00 hours
With a minimum of three nurses on every shift on
If the demand for nursing personnel is based on optimal every day of the year, 803.78 absence shifts per year
nursing care with a minimum of three nurses in every (100%) are possible; 15.31 employees are going to take
shift (with 8.0 h) necessary, then 2016.00 h are worked 459.30 holiday shifts in 1 year as planned absence
effectively on this ward during the 28 days in February (57.14%); therefore 344,48 shifts for unplanned absence
1995. (42.86%) are calculable for a period of 12 months.
2. How many nurses are essential for February 1995? 4. How many contracted working hours must be
worked in February 1995 by 15.31 full-time nurses?
2016.00 hlward
- 131.66effective working hours per nurse (see calcu- 15.31 full-time nurses
lation 1 on pp. 13-14) x 20 contracted working days/February
= 15.31 full-time nurses x 8.0 shift hours
= 2449.60 hours
2016.00 effective working hours on this ward in February
1995 divided by 131.66 effective working hours per nurse/ If 15.31 full-time nurses have to work an average of
month = 15.31 full-time nurses, given that a minimum of 20 days in February and every shift lasts 8.0 hours, then
three nurses per shift on this ward are needed for a period 2449.60 working hours have to be rendered.
of 28 days, with 21% rate of absence taken into account.
5 . How many absence hours in February 1995 can be
3. How many absence days occur per year in the case o f tolerated?
15.31 full-time nurses? 2449.60 contracted hours for 15.31 full-time nurses
First step in the calculation: - 2016.00 effective shift hours per month (see

15% planned absence point 1)


+ 6% unplanned absence = 433.66 hours absence is possible in February 1995

0 1996 Blackwell Science Ltd, Journal of Nursing Management, 4, 1 1 -1 7 15


M. Beil-Hildebrand

15.31 full-time nurses had to work 2449.00h in the trend. Various methods of measurement are available and
month of February 1995, but for a minimum of three it is especially necessary to build up and keep a time-losr
nurses in every shift, 2016.00 h are actually necessary. index. So that planning and scheduling procedures can bt
Thus, there are 433.66 h available to absorb 15% planned carried out in order to achieve a balance between supplj
and 6% unplanned absence rates. of and demand for nursing staff. The method of planned
absence analysis and calculating schedules, which I see a?,
6. How many absence shifts in February 1994 are
being the pursuit of the qualitative argument by quantitat
possible?
ive means, guarantees effectiveness and efficiency based
433.66 possible absence hours
on human resource planning. In short, it achieves ari
+ 8.0 shift hours
enhanced and improved utilization of wo/man power. A.;
= 54.20 possible planned absence shifts in February195
an end in itself in day-to-day practice, wards will be run
There are 433.66 hours available for planned and on a minimum of staff and will enable those who are i r i
unplanned absence in the month of February 1995. By charge of it to improve the workflow organization. Taking
dividing 433.66 h by 8.0 (the number of hours per shift) absence into account will have significant implications for
we arrive at the total of 54.20, i.e. the amount of possible a more balanced organization as well as for the quality
absence shifts in the month of February 1995. and continuity of nursing care provided.

7 . How many planned absence shifts in February can


be scheduled?
References
54.20 possible absence shiftdmonth
x 57.14°/~for planned absence Argyle M. (1989) T h e Social Psychology of Work. 2nd edn. Penguin
= 30.97 planned absence shifts (e.g. holidays) Group, London.
54.20 possible absence shiftdmonth Benbow E. (1989) Absent Friends. Health Service Journal February
x 42.86% for unplanned absence 2, 144-45.
Brookes R. & Gardener J. (1972) Sickness and absence levels of
= 23.23 unplanned absence shifts
nursing staff for the mentally handicapped in the Birmingham
If 54.20 shifts of absence are possible in the month of Region. Nursing Times January 20, pp. 9-12.
Brown, I (1968) Hospital staff sickness absence. T h e Hospitai',
February 1995, then 54.20 absence shifts have to be
March, pp. 94-97.
co-ordinated according to the planned and unplanned Cannavo J.J. (1970) Absenteeism and benefit claims controi.
absence rates described in point 3. It is therefore possible Occupational Health Nursing 18, 11-16.
to schedule 30.97-30.00 holiday shifts in the month of Chadwick-Jones J.K., Brown C.A. & Nicholson N. (1973) Absence
February 1995. While an average rate of 6% unplanned from work: its meaning, measurement and control. Znternationd
-
absence occurs every month, 23.23 23.00 unplanned Review of Applied Psychology 22, 132-154.
Chadwick-Jones J.K., Brown C.A., Nicholson N. & Sheppard C.
absence shifts are possible in order to keep a minimum (1971) Absence measures: their reliability and stability in a n
of three nurses on schedule. It is therefore, obvious that industrial setting. Personnel Psychology 24, 463-470.
accurate and precise planning throughout the whole year Cohen-Mansfield J . & Rosenthal, A.S. (1989) Absenteeism of nurs-
can be carried out, with the minimum of three full-time ing staff in a nursing home. International Journal of Nursing
nurses in every shift still in place. Studies 26, 187-194.
Confederation of British Industry (1993) Too Much Time Our.
CBI, London.
Conclusion Department of Health and Social Security (1977) Absence from
Work. Manpower Planning and Personnel Information, N o 1,
In this article I have discussed planned and unplanned Second Report of the Joint DHSS/NHS Subgroup, London.
absence and its measurement. Furthermore, I have pre- Eichhorn S. (1975) Krankenhausbetriebslehre: Theorie und Praxis
sented a method for calculating schedules. Background des Krankenhausbetriebes. 2nd edn. Verlag W Kohlhammer,
Koln, pp. 381-435.
knowledge, such as the accurate definition of both forms Frogatt P. (1970) Short-term Absence from Industry: Literature,
of absence, is essential, because absence comprises Definitions, Data and the Effect of age and Length of Service.
unplanned and planned hours or days which are going to British Journal of Industrial Medicine 27, 199-201.
be financed although the employer does not get any work Hackett R.D., Bycio P. & Guion R.M. (1989) Absenteeism among
in return. Moreover, the occurrence of unplanned absence hospital nurses: an idiographic-longitudinal analysis. Academy of
Management Journal 32, 424-453.
has disruptive effects on the organizational workflow and
Industrial Society (1993) Wish You Were Here. Industrial Societv,
the continuity of care provided. However, a proactive Egbaston.
management approach in employment practice is most Jones, R.M. (1971) Absenteeism. Department of Employment
likely to achieve a decrease in the unplanned absence Manpower Papers, No. 4 HMSO, London.

16 0 1996 Blackwell Science Ltd, Journal of Nursing Management, 4, 11 -1 7


Nurse absence-the causes and the consequences

Lee J.B. & Eriksen L.R. (1990) The effects of a policy change on Sadik, A.M. (1981) Sickness and Absenteeism Survey. Nursing Times
three types of absence. journal of Nursing Administration 20, June 11, pp. 1023-1025.
37-41. Seccombe I. & Buchan J. (1993) Absent nurses: the costs und
MDG-Management Development Group (1993) Attendance consequences. University of Sussex, Institute of Manpower
Management: Good Practice Guide. MDG, Edinburgh. Studies.
Pluecker W. (1990) Fehlzeiten im Krankenhaus. Kranken- Taunton R.L., Krampitz S.D. & Woods C.Q. (1989) Absenteeism -
hausumschau 46. retention links. Journal of Nursing Administrution 19, 13-20.
Redfern, S.J. (1978) Absence and wastage in trained nurses: a Taylor P.J. (1974) Sickness Absence: Facts and Misconceptions.
selective review of the literature. Journal of Advanced Nursing Journal of the Royal College of Physicians 8, 315-333.
3 , 231-249.

0 1996 Blackwell Science Ltd, Journal of Nursing Management, 4, 11-1 7 17

You might also like