You are on page 1of 10

M u s c u l o s k e l e t a l I m a g i n g • P i c t o r i a l E s s ay

Jamadar et al.
Pitfalls in Musculoskeletal Sonography

Musculoskeletal Imaging
Pictorial Essay
Downloaded from www.ajronline.org by 187.131.160.44 on 07/20/23 from IP address 187.131.160.44. Copyright ARRS. For personal use only; all rights reserved

Musculoskeletal Sonography:
Important Imaging Pitfalls
David A. Jamadar 1 OBJECTIVE. The purpose of this article is to describe the pitfalls that may be encoun-
Brian L. Robertson tered when performing musculoskeletal sonography.
Jon A. Jacobson CONCLUSION. Sonography of the musculoskeletal system is a useful diagnostic tech-
Gandikota Girish nique, but awareness and understanding of the pitfalls will minimize errors in diagnosis.
Brian J. Sabb
Yebin Jiang

L
earning musculoskeletal sonog- used, although in the hands and feet, higher-
Yoav Morag
raphy can be challenging. The frequency transducers (15–17 MHz) provide
Jamadar DA, Robertson BL, Jacobson JA, et al. sonographic properties of soft exquisite anatomic detail, and occasionally
tissues, tendons, and ligaments in obese patients, particularly when exam-
result in pitfalls that have to be recognized. ining the hip, a lower-frequency transducer
Pitfalls may occur for a variety of reasons. (5–9 MHz) may be necessary.
The sonographic properties of different tis-
sues may be similar, as may be found in the Shoulder
shoulder. Anatomy may be nonintuitive, as Lying between the supraspinatus and the
in the elbow and hip, and anisotropy [1, 2] acromion and deltoid muscles is the subac-
may result in misleading appearances. romial–subdeltoid bursa, which extends be-
Anisotropy is the sonographic property of yond the distal insertion of the supraspinatus
linearly organized tissues, such as tendon tendon [5] (Fig. 2). Sometimes it is difficult
and ligaments (and to a lesser extent nerves) to differentiate tendon from bursa lying on
in which sonographic appearance is deter- its superficial surface because the echoge-
mined in part by the angle of insonation of nicity and contour may be similar. Overes-
the ultrasound beam [3] (Fig. 1). We present timation of the thickness of the tendon as
important pitfalls that we have encountered well as misinterpretation of the echogenici-
over the past decade of our practice. ty of the tendon may result (Figs. 3 and 4).
By identifying the bursa that passes beyond
General Considerations the supraspinatus insertion on the greater tu-
Before starting the sonography examina- berosity and extrapolating proximally on a
tion, a short focused patient history is elic- long-axis image of the supraspinatus tendon,
ited and the area of concern is examined. one can get a reasonable idea of what consti-
Keywords: musculoskeletal, pitfalls, sonography A protocol-driven comprehensive sonog- tutes bursa and what is the actual supraspi-
raphy examination is required when imag- natus tendon.
DOI:10.2214/AJR.09.2712
ing the shoulder and is advocated with other The long head of the biceps brachii tendon
Received March 9, 2009; accepted after revision joints as well to identify causes of referred is found in the bicipital groove of the proximal
July 13, 2009. pain, develop an efficient examination, un- humerus. When the tendon of the long head of
1
derstand normal structures, and allow iden- the biceps is dislocated or torn, there can be
All authors: Department of Radiology, University of
tification of subtle pathology; however, the linear echoes in the bicipital groove that may
Michigan Hospitals, 1500 E Medical Center Dr., Ann
Arbor, MI 48109. Address correspondence to patient is asked to indicate a point of most simulate intact tendon fibers, although much
D. A. Jamadar (djamadar@med.umich.edu). discomfort because this will often identify thinner compared with the normal biceps ten-
the site of the abnormality [4]. The patient is don [6, 7] (Fig. 5). Careful evaluation medial
AJR 2010; 194:216–225 placed in a comfortable position that facili- to the proximal humerus for a dislocated ten-
0361–803X/10/1941–216
tates an easy examination as well as allow- don is necessary to exclude a dislocated bi-
ing dynamic maneuvers. A high-frequency ceps tendon. A long-standing tear of the long
© American Roentgen Ray Society linear transducer (10–12 MHz) is typically head of the biceps brachii tendon may result

216 AJR:194, January 2010


Pitfalls in Musculoskeletal Sonography

in increased echogenicity of part of the biceps Hip and Thigh Foot and Ankle
muscle, a combination of retracted tendon and The rectus femoris muscle originates prox- The insertion of the tibialis posterior ten-
fatty change, which is a clue that the tendon imally from two tendons: a direct (straight) don is complex, fanning out and inserting di-
may have been torn (Fig. 6). head from the anterior inferior iliac spine that rectly onto the navicular and also possibly an
Additional pitfalls that can be encountered courses approximately parallel to the over- accessory ossicle. The tendon also sends a
when scanning the shoulder include mistak- lying skin and an indirect (reflected) head slip (deeper lateral division) to insert more
Downloaded from www.ajronline.org by 187.131.160.44 on 07/20/23 from IP address 187.131.160.44. Copyright ARRS. For personal use only; all rights reserved

ing anisotropy at the base of the supraspina- that originates from the lateral acetabulum distally at the middle cuneiform and the
tus tendon for a tear (Fig. 7); the anisotro- and courses at an angle to the overlying skin. bases of the second, third, and fourth meta-
py resulting in a hypoechoic biceps tendon in This orientation of the tendons results in the tarsals. This complicated insertion (distal
the long axis, simulating tendonosis or mak- straight head being easily identified by its 1.5–2.0 cm) results in the tendon appearing
ing the tendon difficult to visualize (Fig. 8); echogenic parallel linear appearance, where- thicker than it does along its more proximal
and the normal anatomy of the multipennate as the indirect head usually shows marked length, and the different orientation of its fi-
subscapularis tendon simulating clefts in the anisotropy (Fig. 16), which may be misin- bers often shows anisotropy [13] (Figs. 23
tendon or tendonosis (Fig. 9). terpreted as acoustic shadowing from calci- and 24), which should not be misinterpreted
fication [9] or ossification or the shadowing as tendinosis or tear.
Elbow caused by refraction of sound at the edge of
The deep branch of the radial nerve, the a tendon tear. By scanning more laterally and Conclusion
posterior interosseous nerve, becomes flat- obliquely angling the transducer, the reflected There are many pitfalls in musculoskeletal
tened as it passes through the supinator, and head may be identified (Fig. 17). sonography due to misinterpretation of nor-
in long-axis imaging it appears to narrow af- At the anterior recess of the hip, the anteri- mal anatomic structures as well as misinter-
ter entering this muscle (Figs. 10 and 11). or joint capsule reflects back superiorly along pretation of pathologic conditions. Knowl-
Awareness of this normal anatomic feature the femoral neck. In the absence of an effu- edge of such pitfalls will improve accuracy
of this specific nerve will prevent a misdi- sion, the two layers of the capsule lying on in the sonographic diagnosis of musculo­
agnosis of entrapment syndrome due to the each other may give the impression of com- skeletal disorders.
apparent change in caliber of the nerve as it plex fluid or synovitis in the hip joint (Fig.
passes into the supinator muscle. 18). Joint fluid may be identified separating Acknowledgments
these two layers (Fig. 19). It has been shown We thank Tracy Boon, Rita Lewis, Alli-
Wrist that a measurement of the thickness of the son Berry, Heidi Ehrich, and Yinghui Bian
The extensor retinaculum at the wrist is tissue adjacent to the anterior femoral neck for their help and support during the prepa-
a fibrocartilaginous sling that holds the ex- should measure more than 7 mm. Asymme- ration of the manuscript.
tensor tendons close to the dorsal wrist and try of this measurement of more than 1 mm
prevents bowstringing. This normally hyper- between both sides suggests the diagnosis of References
echoic structure may appear hypoechoic be- fluid in the hip joint [10]. 1. Garcia T, Hornof WJ, Insana MF. On the ultra-
cause of anisotropy and may simulate a com- The sciatic nerve is proximate to the ham- sound properties of tendon. Ultrasound Med Biol
plex fluid collection or tenosynovitis [3] (Fig. string insertion at the hip. Knowledge of the an- 2003; 29:1787–1797
12). Profound thickening of the extensor reti- atomic relationship of the sciatic nerve to the 2. Crass JR, van de Vegte GL, Harkavy LA. Tendon
naculum without much underlying tenosyno- hamstring tendon is necessary to avoid confus- echogenicity: ex vivo study. Radiology 1988;
vitis may be a presentation of de Quervain’s ing these linear fibrillar structures [11] (Fig. 167:499–501
tenosynovitis. 20A). More proximally, the structures are even 3. Robertson BL, Jamadar DA, Jacobson JA, et al.
At the wrist, it is possible to confuse the closer (Fig. 20B), emphasizing that care should Extensor retinaculum of the wrist: sonographic
median nerve with one of the long flexor ten- be taken with needle placement at the hamstring characterization and pseudotenosynovitis appear-
dons and vice versa. This can be avoided by origin when a medial approach is prudent. ance. AJR 2007; 188:198–202
recognizing that the median nerve is the only 4. Jamadar DA, Jacobson JA, Caoili EM, et al. Mus-
long linear structure at the wrist that changes Knee culoskeletal sonography technique: focused versus
anatomic planes more proximally in the fore- The semimembranosus tendon curves an- comprehensive evaluation. AJR 2008; 190:5–9
arm. This nerve is initially superficial at the teriorly to attach to the posterior tibia where 5. van Holsbeeck M, Strouse PJ. Sonography of the
wrist but lies between the flexor digitorum anisotropy may make it hypoechoic, simulat- shoulder: evaluation of the subacromial–subdel-
superficialis and flexor digitorum profundus ing a Baker cyst (Fig. 21A). By angling the toid bursa. AJR 1993; 160:561–564
more proximally in the forearm [8] (Fig. 13). ultrasound beam along the long axis of the 6. Farin PU. Sonography of the biceps tendon of the
The long flexor tendons may also be distin- semimembranosus tendon, anisotropy [12] shoulder: normal and pathologic findings. J Clin
guished from the median nerve because they can be visualized confirming that this hy- Ultrasound 1996; 24:309–316
merge with their respective muscles more poechoic structure is a tendon (Fig. 21B). 7. Armstrong A, Teefey SA, Wu T, et al. The effica-
proximally and display anisotropy. The me- When examining the lateral knee in a su- cy of ultrasound in the diagnosis of long head of
dian nerve does not show as much anisotro- pine patient, the knee may be slightly flexed the biceps tendon pathology. J Shoulder Elbow
py as the adjacent flexor tendons, which is and in valgus so that the fibular collateral lig- Surg 2006; 15:7–11
useful in differentiating between these struc- ament may have a wavy contour (Fig. 22). 8. Jamadar DA, Jacobson JA, Hayes CW. Sono-
tures (Fig. 14). These changes also affect a This is a normal appearance and does not in- graphic evaluation of the median nerve at the
bifid median nerve (Fig. 15). dicate a tear or laxity of the ligament. wrist. J Ultrasound Med 2001; 20:1011–1014

AJR:194, January 2010 217


Jamadar et al.

9. Sarkar JS, Haddad FS, Crean SV, Brooks P. Acute 11. Miller SL, Gill J, Webb GR. The proximal origin viewing human tendon with high frequency linear
calcific tendonitis of the rectus femoris. J Bone of the hamstrings and surrounding anatomy en- array ultrasound. Br J Radiol 2001; 74:183–185
Joint Surg Br 1996; 78:814–816 countered during repair: a cadaveric study. J Bone 13. Patel S, Fessell DP, Jacobson JA, Hayes CW, van
10. Koski JM, Anttila PJ, Isomaki HA. Ultrasonogra- Joint Surg Am 2007; 89:44–48 Holsbeeck MT. Artifacts, anatomic variants, and
phy of the adult hip joint. Scand J Rheumatol 12. Connolly DJA, Berman L, McNally EG. The use pitfalls in sonography of the foot and ankle. AJR
1989; 18:113–117 of beam angulation to overcome anisotropy when 2002; 178:1247–1254
Downloaded from www.ajronline.org by 187.131.160.44 on 07/20/23 from IP address 187.131.160.44. Copyright ARRS. For personal use only; all rights reserved

A B
Fig. 1—Sonography in 54-year-old woman with normal long head of biceps tendon (arrow) showing anisotropy. GT = greater tuberosity, LT = lesser tuberosity,
Del = deltoid muscle, Sub = subscapularis muscle.
A, In sonogram obtained with tendon fibers at right angles to beam, tendon appears echoic.
B, In sonogram obtained with tendon fibers at angle to beam, tendon appears hypoechoic.

Fig. 2—63-year-old woman with shoulder pain and bursal thickening. Sonogram Fig. 3—43-year-old man with right shoulder pain and bursal thickening.
in long axis of supraspinatus tendon (SST) shows subacromial–subdeltoid Sonogram in long axis of supraspinatus tendon (SST) shows bursal thickening
bursal thickening (all arrowheads) extending beyond insertion of supraspinatus (all arrowheads) extending beyond insertion of supraspinatus tendon on greater
tendon on greater tuberosity (GT) of humerus. Bursa is easily differentiated tuberosity (GT) of humerus. Bursa in this patient is not as easily differentiated from
from supraspinatus tendon. Note outer layer of supraspinatus tendon (black supraspinatus tendon. Note visualized outer layer of supraspinatus tendon (white
arrowheads) is echogenic but less so than peribursal fat layer (white arrowheads). arrowheads) is echogenic but less so than peribursal fat layer (black arrowhead).
Bursa lies between these two echogenic interfaces. D = deltoid muscle. D = deltoid muscle.

Fig. 4—39-year-old woman with right shoulder injury, pain, and bursal thickening.
Sonogram in long axis of supraspinatus tendon (SST) shows bursal thickening
(arrowheads) extending beyond insertion of supraspinatus tendon on greater
tuberosity (GT) of humerus. Bursa and peribursal fat in this patient are difficult to
differentiate from supraspinatus tendon because echogenic interface between
supraspinatus tendon and bursa is not appreciated. D = deltoid muscle.

218 AJR:194, January 2010


Pitfalls in Musculoskeletal Sonography
Downloaded from www.ajronline.org by 187.131.160.44 on 07/20/23 from IP address 187.131.160.44. Copyright ARRS. For personal use only; all rights reserved

A B
Fig. 5—73-year-old man with right shoulder injury and dislocated biceps tendon.
A, Long-axis sonogram through bicipital groove shows linear echoes (arrows) not
consistent with tendon fibers. Hum = humeral diaphysis.
B, Short-axis sonogram through bicipital groove (curved arrow) shows echoes
(straight arrows) not consistent with normal tendon. Long head of biceps brachii
tendon (arrowhead) lies over lesser tuberosity (LT).
C, Long-axis sonogram through dislocated biceps tendon (arrows) shows normal
tightly packed linear appearance lying over lesser tuberosity proximally.

A B
Fig. 6—85-year-old woman with right shoulder pain after fall, with long-standing complete tear of long head of biceps brachii tendon.
A, Long-axis sonogram through bicipital groove shows linear echoes (arrows) but no visualization of normal biceps tendon. Hum = humeral diaphysis.
B, Axial sonogram through biceps muscle shows echogenicity of long head (LH arrow) secondary to fatty change. Normal-appearing short head of muscle (SH arrow) is
seen medially representing normal short head of biceps brachii. Curved arrow indicates humeral diaphysis.

AJR:194, January 2010 219


Jamadar et al.
Downloaded from www.ajronline.org by 187.131.160.44 on 07/20/23 from IP address 187.131.160.44. Copyright ARRS. For personal use only; all rights reserved

A B
Fig. 7—54-year-old woman with normal supraspinatus tendon. SST = supraspinatus tendon, Delt = deltoid, Gt Tub = greater tuberosity.
A, Inserting supraspinatus tendon fibers curve away from ultrasound beam and appear hypoechoic (arrows), which should not be interpreted as tear.
B, By angling transducer to bring orientation of these fibers at right angles to ultrasound beam, hypoechoic area fills in with normal-appearing tendon (asterisk).

A B
Fig. 8—54-year-old woman with normal long head of biceps tendon showing anisotropy.
A, When long head biceps tendon (arrows) is at right angle to ultrasound beam, normal echogenic fibrillar pattern is seen.
B, When long head biceps tendon (arrows) is oriented at angle to ultrasound beam, echogenic fibrillar pattern is not as well seen or is lost, simulating tear or tendonosis.

Fig. 9—42-year-old man with normal subscapularis tendon imaged in short


axis. Multipennate tendon shows echogenic tendon slips (T) with intervening
hypoechogenic slips of muscle that may simulate cleft or tear. Delt = deltoid
muscle, Les Tub = lesser tuberosity of humerus.

220 AJR:194, January 2010


Pitfalls in Musculoskeletal Sonography

Fig. 10—20-year-old woman with medial right forearm subcutaneous nodule.


Sonogram in long axis shows normal posterior interosseous nerve before (curved
arrow) and after (straight arrow) entering supinator muscle (Sup). Apparent
change in caliber is normal because nerve becomes flattened in supinator muscle.
Rad = radius, C = capitellum.
Downloaded from www.ajronline.org by 187.131.160.44 on 07/20/23 from IP address 187.131.160.44. Copyright ARRS. For personal use only; all rights reserved

A B

Fig. 11—61-year-old man with left medial elbow pain. Sup = supinator muscle.
A, Sonogram along long axis of normal posterior interosseous nerve shows
apparent narrowing of nerve as it enters supinator muscle. Curved arrow indicates
nerve before entering supinator, and straight arrow indicates nerve after entering
supinator.
B, Sonogram along short axis of normal posterior interosseous nerve (curved
arrow) before it enters supinator muscle shows rounded appearance. Arrowheads
indicate radius.
C, Sonogram along short axis of normal posterior interosseous nerve (arrow)
within supinator muscle shows more flattened appearance. Rad = radius.
C

AJR:194, January 2010 221


Jamadar et al.

Fig. 12—78-year-old woman with normal extensor retinaculum. Sonogram


through long axis of extensor digitorum tendons (ED) shows extensor retinaculum
as hypoechoic structure (arrows). This should not be misinterpreted as fluid
collection or tenosynovitis. Rad = distal radius, Carp = carpal bones.
Downloaded from www.ajronline.org by 187.131.160.44 on 07/20/23 from IP address 187.131.160.44. Copyright ARRS. For personal use only; all rights reserved

A B
Fig. 13—51-year-old asymptomatic man with normal sonographic anatomy
at wrist. Fl Dig = flexor digitorum superficialis and flexor digitorum profundus
tendons, PL = flexor pollicis longus, A = radial artery, Pro Quad = pronator
quadratus muscle, Rad = radius, U = ulna, Fl Dig Sup = flexor digitorum superficialis
muscle, Fl Dig Prof = flexor digitorum profundus muscle, MN = median nerve.
A, Axial sonogram just proximal to distal volar wrist crease shows median nerve
(curved arrow) lying superficial (anterior) to flexor digitorum superficialis and
flexor digitorum profundus tendons, lateral to palmaris longus tendon (straight
arrow), and medial to flexor carpi radialis (arrowhead) and flexor pollicis longus.
B, Axial sonogram obtained more proximally shows median nerve (curved arrow)
lying between flexor digitorum superficialis muscle and flexor digitorum profundus
muscle, having moved proximally to deeper anatomic plane. Palmaris longus
tendon (straight arrow) and flexor carpi radialis tendon remain in same superficial
plane. Flexor carpi radialis tendon has now merged with its muscle (arrowhead).
C, Sonogram along long axis of median nerve shows median nerve passing from
superficial at wrist (right of image) to lie between flexor digitorum superficialis and
flexor digitorum profundus more proximally. C

A B
Fig. 14—51-year-old man with normal median nerve and flexor tendons showing effect of anisotropy. T = flexor tendons, Uln = ulna, Rad = radius.
A, Sonogram with ultrasound beam at right angles to median nerve (curved arrow) and long flexor tendons (T) including flexor carpi radialis (arrowhead) shows normal
cross-section appearances. Straight arrow indicates radial artery.
B, By angling transducer, flexor tendons (T, arrowhead) show marked anisotropy, becoming hypoechoic. Median nerve (curved arrow) shows much less anisotropy.
Straight arrow indicates radial artery.

222 AJR:194, January 2010


Pitfalls in Musculoskeletal Sonography

Fig. 15—Sonogram in 62-year-old woman shows bifid median nerve (N) lying
superficial to flexor digitorum tendons. Note small persistent median artery
(arrow).
Downloaded from www.ajronline.org by 187.131.160.44 on 07/20/23 from IP address 187.131.160.44. Copyright ARRS. For personal use only; all rights reserved

A B
Fig. 16—28-year-old man with right inguinal pain with normal rectus femoris origin.
A, Axial sonogram just distal to origin of rectus femoris muscle shows echogenic tendon (S) of direct (straight) head lying adjacent to area of intense anisotropy (A) of
indirect head of same muscle. Sar = sartorius muscle.
B, Sagittal sonogram at origin of rectus femoris muscle shows tendon of direct (straight) head (S) and area of intense anisotropy (A) of indirect head. AIIS = anterior
inferior iliac spine.

Fig. 17—Sonogram in 18-year-old woman shows normal tendon of reflected head


(arrowheads) of rectus femoris muscle (RF). Curved arrow indicates acetabular
labrum. Acet = acetabulum, Fem = femoral head.

AJR:194, January 2010 223


Jamadar et al.
Downloaded from www.ajronline.org by 187.131.160.44 on 07/20/23 from IP address 187.131.160.44. Copyright ARRS. For personal use only; all rights reserved

Fig. 18—28-year-old man with right inguinal pain. Sonogram of normal anterior hip Fig. 19—3-year-old girl with hip joint effusion. Anterior hip joint capsule is
joint shows capsule (arrowheads) over anterior femoral neck (Fem) with trace of composed of two layers. Large arrowheads indicate anterior layer and small
fluid (arrow). H = femoral head. arrowheads indicate posterior layer, shown separated from each other by effusion
(Eff). A = acetabulum, Fem = femoral neck.

A B
Fig. 20—23-year-old man with normal proximal posterior thigh. Axial images show relationship between sciatic nerve and adjacent structures. F = femur, AM = adductor
magnus muscle, BF = biceps femoris muscle, Glut = gluteus maximus muscle.
A, Note similarity in echogenicity between sciatic nerve (curved arrow) and semimembranosus tendon (straight arrow) and conjoint tendon of biceps femoris long head
and semitendinosus (arrowhead).
B, More proximally, sciatic nerve (curved arrow) is very close to semimembranosus tendon (straight arrow) and conjoint tendon (arrowhead).

A B
Fig. 21—23-year-old man evaluated to rule out Baker cyst. G = medial head of gastrocnemius muscle, Fem = medial femoral condyle, A = popliteal artery, SM =
hypoechoic structure.
A, Sonogram over popliteal fossa reveals hypoechoic structure that may be interpreted as complex fluid-filled Baker cyst lying adjacent to tendon (arrow) of medial head
of gastrocnemius muscle.
B, In axial plane, by angling transducer in cranial caudal direction, hypoechoic structure becomes hyperechoic and is shown to be tendon of semimembranosus muscle.

224 AJR:194, January 2010


Pitfalls in Musculoskeletal Sonography
Downloaded from www.ajronline.org by 187.131.160.44 on 07/20/23 from IP address 187.131.160.44. Copyright ARRS. For personal use only; all rights reserved

Fig. 22—75-year-old woman with normal fibular collateral ligament. Sonogram Fig. 23—51-year-old man with fifth-toe pain. As normal tibialis posterior tendon
along long axis of fibular collateral ligament (straight arrows) shows normal wavy approaches its insertion into navicular bone (N), it widens (arrowheads and
appearance, which should not suggest tear. Ligament merges with tendon of arrows), with deepest fibers showing anisotropy (arrows). These deeper fibers
biceps femoris (asterisks) to insert into fibula (out of field of view). Curved arrow (arrows) are composed of lateral division of tendon insertion and run at oblique
indicates popliteus tendon. Fem = femur, Tib = tibia. angle to larger and more superficial fibers (arrowheads). This thickening and
hypoechoic appearance should not be routinely misinterpreted as tendinosis.
T = talus.

Fig. 24—Sonogram with extended field of view of normal tibialis posterior tendon
in 56-year-old woman shows echogenic linear fibrillar echotexture of tendon (large
arrowheads) and effect of mild anisotropy on tendon (curved arrows).
Distally, tendon appears hypoechogenic from more marked anisotropy of complex
insertion of tendon (small arrowheads) into navicular bone (Nav). Tal = talus, Sp =
superomedial calcaneonavicular component of spring ligament.

AJR:194, January 2010 225

You might also like