Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Toaz - Info The World of Islam in American Poetry PR
Toaz - Info The World of Islam in American Poetry PR
Email: azizbahia@gmail.com
Phone Number:+212659267744
For centuries, the Occident had formed a distorted image about Islam. An
act believed to be fueled by the church, at a time characterized by fear
and anxiety about this religion. The negative image which was portrayed
by the Divine Comedy1 author of the prophet of Islam for example, sums
up an attitude adopted by a generation as a whole not just by an
individual. However, The western attitude did not begin to retreat except
in the Nineteenth century with the growing spirit in research, and the
decline of the Church authority, but this did not mean that the image had
become accurate. The Western literature has generally reflected that
development of this image, turning the Islamic Orient into a space for
those oriental elements that satisfy the exotic view of Western writer.
Then, from the second half of the Twentieth century, Islam became a
religion that is growing in western space as a whole. This contribution is
therefore a demonstration of the transformation that Islam has
experienced in western mindset between two centuries, through two
volumes of two American poets.
The religious theme of Tailor’s collection was also evident through many
poems. which made Tailor supported by some studies concerned about
Islam, perhaps the most important one is the famous book written by the
American Washington Irving23 (life of Mahomet) edited in 1849. Taylor
was a fan of Irving and a reader of his works 24. These poems portrayed
the Arab as a real Muslim feared Allah. The first of these poems was the
poem "The Arab Prayer"25. Which reviews a description of the Muslim
prayer rites:
“La illah il’ Allah !” the muezzin’s call
Comes from the minaret, slim and tall,
That looks o’er the distant city’s wall.
The khalil’s poem26 celebrates an old bedouin, his religious pious was
admired by all, he thanked Allah about his blessings
On God, the Merciful, I call,
To shed his blessing over all:
I praise His name, for He is Great,
And Loving, and Compassionate;
And for the gift of love I give-
The breath of life whereby I live-
He gives me back, in overflow,
His children’s love, where’er I go. (24-31)
The poem "the Wisdom of Ali"27, which celebrates Ali ibn Abi Talib’s
wisdom:
The prophet once, sitting in calm debate,
Said : “I am Wisdom’s fortress; but the gate
Thereof is Ali.” (1-3)
It is clear that this poem was based on a long Hadith translation imitation,
this kind of poetic imitation spred in 19th-century poetry, especially
among the Romantics, who imitated many of the translated Oriental texts,
by reproducing them as poetry28, as Taylor did with this Hadith, narrated
by Salman al-Farsi:"The Messenger of Allah said:"I am the city of
knowledge and Ali is its gate."29 When the Kharijites heard this Hadith,
they envied Ali for that, and ten of them met and said: Everyone asks Ali
one question to look at how to answer us, and if each one of us is
answered by one answer then, we will find out that Ali had no
knowledge. One of them asked, "Oh Ali! knowledge is better or money?
He replied... knowledge is better, and he asked him, "By what evidence?
He said: Because knowledge is the heritage of the prophets and money is
the heritage of Qaron, Haman and Pharaoh. So the man went back to his
companions with this answer, so the second asked him as the first did "O
Ali... [Delete]... The tenth asked, "O Ali! knowldge is better or money?
He said... knowledge, he asked, "By what evidence? He said: Because the
owner of the money is arrogant and glorified himself, and the owner of
the knowledge is modest, so he went back to his companions and told
them that, and they said: Allah and his Messenger are true, and there is no
doubt that Ali is the gate of all knowledge. That's when Ali said... I
swear by Allah, if all the creations had asked me as long as I was alive, I
would have answered each one of them with an answer different to the
other to the end of the world.
Then, the poem "The Birth of the Prophet" 30, which celebrates the birth of
the Prophet Mahomet, where he is accompanied by many miracles;
Taylor seems to have benefited from Irving's book (life of Mahomet) 31, as
some of the divine miracles described in the poem have already been
referred to:
For the oracles of Nature recognize a prophet’s birth –
Blossom of the tardy ages, crowing type of human worth –
And by miracles and wonders he is welcomed to the earth.
(16-18)
Then, the poem "The Sheikh"32, which reviews the monologue of the
Sheikh to his creator in grovel and refraction:
When the might of Evil threatens,
Throw Thy shelter over me:
Let my spirit feel Thy presence,
And my days be full by Thee! (31-34)
Taylor's collection, then, emerged at a time when the Orient was an area
of Western commercial and political activities, and an interesting subject
in 19th-century occidental literature, which made the oriental motives
were seen widely in Western literature in general including American,
which was common in this century, the collection is a response to a
general Western exotic view of the Eastern elements, but Taylor was able
to largely free himself from that superior view that dominated western
literature, This made him with a great success, touching the spirit of the
orient as it is.
poems close to the ordinary audience, which attract him in their daily
details to the transcendence of its sufi narrative. In the end, he admitted
that these poems have created (an outward stretch far beyond the usual
and sad condition of today's American poetry.) . 59
Conclusion
This contribution presented two poets volumes from the American Poetry
circle, one from the 19th century and the other to the 20th century,
through which we draw two sides of America in its dealings with the
Islamic Orient, one side presented by Bayard Taylor, who lived in
America which was relatively late for Western Europe, but ambitious and
seeks to catch up the difference, a racist America that is an extension of
Europe, and recognizes only the white man. This "America" made Taylor
adopted that exotic view towards the Orient, so his direct contact with this
Orient played a major role in ridding him of many of the assumptions that
hung in his mind. The other is Daniel Abdulhay Moore, an American
Muslim, who lived in a superior cosmopolitan America leading the world,
and at the same time suffering from the inside, many contradictions and
displacements, made Moore more realistic, more sympathetic to this other
(Orient) perceived by America as an adversary.
Footnotes:
1
In the twenty-eighth song of Hell, Dante made the character of the Prophet is one of the pissed
off character, and deserved the torture as a punishment for his defection from Christianity, and
his coming with a false religion, see:
- Dante Alighieri . la divine comédie (l’enfer), Translated by: Louis Ratisbonne, 4th edition, paris
1870, p: 379.
22
We have already addressed many aspects of the Qur'anic influence in Western poetry in our
study: (Arab-Islamic influences in European literature: examples of Qur'anic influence in poetry.
Abdelilah kasraoui, Journal of Islamic Literature(Majallat al-adab al-Islāmī), N 99/2018, p: 64-
71.).
33
It is meant to be the poetry of the United States of America.
44
It was delayed compared to French, British, and German Orientalism...
55
The word “Aaraf'” in the title, is a Qur'anic word, indicating a place between paradise and
fire, concerning people who survived from the fire, but who do not deserve paradise. The
“Aaraf” is also the title of a long surah in the Qur'an.
66
Edgar Allan Poe began his poem with words that he thought were a Qur'anic verse.
77
(Edgar Allan Poe) (1809-1849) is an American critic and writer.
88
(Ralph Waldo Emerson) (1803-1882) is an American writer and thinker.
99
(Herman Melville) (1819-1891) is an American writer.
1010
Dorsey Kleitz, “Bayard Taylor,” in Encyclopedia of American Poetry: The Nineteenth
Century, Ed. Eric L. Haralson (Chicago: Fitzroy Dearborn Publishers, 1998), pp: 420–23.
1111
Ibid.
1212
Ibid.
1313
( James Russell Lowell) (1819-1891) is an American poet and writer.
1414
(Richard Henry Stoddard) (1825-1903) is an American poet and critic.
1515
Dorsey Kleitz, “Bayard Taylor,” in Encyclopedia of American Poetry: The Nineteenth
Century (op.cit), pp: 420–23.
1717
Muna Al-Alwan, the Arab Muslim World of Bayard Taylor’s Poems of the Orient, translated
from English into Arab by Abdelilah Kasraoui, Poetry Letters Magazine, N 11/2018, United
Kingdom.
1818
Dorsey Kleitz, “Bayard Taylor,” in Encyclopedia of American Poetry: The Nineteenth
Century (op.cit), pp: 420–23.
1919
Muna Alwan. The Arab Muslim World of Byard Taylor (op.cit).
2020
Taylor, Bayard. Poems of the Orient. Boston: Ticknor and Fields, 1855. p: 19.
2121
Ibid., p:22.
2222
Ibid., P:50.
2323
(Washington Irving) (1783-1859) is an American writer and historian.
2424
Muna Alwan. The Arab Muslim World of Byard Taylor (op.cit).
2525
Poems of the Orient. P: 41.
2626
Ibid., P: 44.
2727
Ibid., P: 77.
2828
for example Pushkin in his poems "imitations of the Qur'an", and George Friedrich Daumer
in Diwan (Hafez) and (Mohammed)... Daniel Moore adopted it in one of his sonnets as he will
come later; We discussed this particular concept of imitation in my Phd: (imitation of the
Qur'anic text in poetry: George Friedrich Daumer as model (translation and study). Abdelilah
Kasraoui, Dissertation in Arts, Faculty of Arts and Humanities, Mohammed V University, Rabat,
2018, p: 15.)
2929
Weak hadith(Ḍaʻīf) : the series of weak and fabricated hadiths and their bad impact on the
nation (Silsalat al-Hadith ad-Da'ifah wa al Mawdu’ah). Nasir Aldin al-Albani, Dar Al Maarif,
Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, first edition/1992, Volume 6, No. (2955). P: 518.
3030
Poems of the Orient. P: 105.
3131
Muna Alwan. The Arab Muslim World of Byard Taylor (op.cit)
.
3232
Poems of the Orient. P:121.
33
33 Lawrence Ferlinghetti, founder of City Lights Booksellers and Publishers.
34 Daniel Abdelhay Moore devoted an important space to providing rich documents and data
34
on his poetic website, in which he wrote about his path before Islam, and after Islam, from which
we extracted the data on his biography, see:
http://ecstaticxchange.com/blog/
3535
This note does not include the poetic manuscripts written by the poet before Islam, which
remained in his possession, and which he did not publish to the public until later.
3636
Spiritual guides.
3737
(Ian Dallas) converted to Islam, became a follower of the Sufi Sheikh Muhammad ibn al-
Habib in Meknes(Morocco), named Sheikh Abdul Qadir al-Sufi, and was a represented of his
sheikh to the followers of the Tariqa in London.
3838
The poet's personal website, see:
http://ecstaticxchange.com/2015/07/04/shaykh-dr-abdalqadir-as-sufi-al-murabit-1930/
3939
An interview with the British magazine q-News, N 367, 2016, see the poet's personal website:
http://ecstaticxchange.com/2015/04/11/q-news-interview-a-sweet-interrogation /
4040
The poet's personal website :
http://ecstaticxchange.com/2015/05/10/authors-introduction-to-laughing-buddha-weeping-sufi/
4141
The poet's personal website, see:
http://ecstaticxchange.com/2010/09/29/the-ecstatic-exchange-words-on-my-life-and-poetry
4242
Ibid.
4343
An interview with the British magazine q-News, the poet's personal website:
http://ecstaticxchange.com/2015/04/11/q-news-interview-a-sweet-interrogation/
4444
It is more likely that this diwan was a ready manuscript before his Islam, because he stopped
writing poetry since 1970 under the guidance of Sheikh Abdul Qadir al-Sufi.
4545
The British magazine q-News' interview, the poet's personal website:
http://ecstaticxchange.com/2015/04/11/q-news-interview-a-sweet-interrogation/
4646
Lawrence Ferlinghetti who published his first two diwans.
4747
Munir al-Akash. American poet Daniel Moore (op.cit). The website of al-Sham Writers
League, which was visited on 20 July 2019:
http://www.odabasham.net
4848
Daniel Abdal-Hayy Moore. Ramadan Sonnets (The Ecstatic Exchange, 2005).
4949
Munir al-Akash. American poet Daniel Moore (op.cit).
5050
he added two sonnets to what he wrote during Ramadan, it becomes the total of the diwan
sonnets as a whole sixty-four sonnets, and the sonnet is a European lyrical form, in the form of a
small song, Or a poem that was put to sing, according to a particular rhythmic structure, that
appeared in the 13th century. This poetic form later became famous with Shakespeare through
his sonnets. Abbas Mahmoud Al-Akkad - while talking about Shakespeare's poems- translated
the sonnets with Mouwachahat . (Seen: Abbas Mahmoud Al-Akkad. The complete works of
Abbas Mahmoud Al-Akkad, Volume 19, Translations and Biography -5- Introduction to
Shakespeare, Dar Al-Kitab Al-Lubnani, Beirut, first edition, 1981, p: 208.); Henry George
Farmer the Arab music historian thinks that the Arabic equivalent of sonneta is the word '
aljuljul' (see: Munir al-Aksh. American poet and writer Daniel Moore (op.cit).
5151
The 33rd Sonnet:
Ramadan Sonnets. p: 60
5252
The introduction of Daniel Abdelhay Moore's diwan:
5454
Munir al-Akash. American poet and writer Daniel Moore (op.cit).
5555
Lawrence Ferlinghetti is an American poet, writer and publisher.
5656
Munir al-Akash. American poet and writer Daniel Moore (op.cit)
5757
Karl Kempton is an American poet and writer.
58 Kempton, Karl. Book Reviews The Ramadan Sonnets, American Journal of Islamic Social
58
6767
A fabricated Hadith, seen: Secrets Raised. Ali al-Qari, supervised by Mohammed Amin al-
Sayed, Dar Al-Kotob Al-Ilmiyah, 1439 H, First Edition, Beirut, p: 236.
6868
A weak hadith, see: Sunan Ibn Majah. Book of Fasting, chapter fasting is the zakat of the
body.
6969
Sahih al-Bukhari. Book of Dress, Chapter: What has been mentioned about musk.
70 A fabricated Hadith see: the series of weak and fabricated hadiths, Volume 3, No. (1164), p:
70
308.
7171
A Weak hadith see: the series of weak and fabricated hadiths, Volume 4, No. (1569), p: 70.
7272
Sahih (( Al-Jami Al-Saghir Wa Ziyadatihi)) ( Al-Fath Al-Kabir). Nasir al-Din al-Albani, Al
Maktab Al-Islami, third edition 1988, vol 1, p: 599.
7373
Previously speaking of this particular meaning of the concept of imitation, see footnote 28
about the poem 'The Wisdom of Ali'.
7474
A weak hadith, al-Albani stated: "All the hadiths in the virtue of reason are not true, and
they revolve between weakness and fabricated,". the series of weak and fabricated hadiths,
Volume1, p: 53.