Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Whitepaper
02
Raw materials and formulations ······ 6
03
Test methods ······································· 8
04
Compounding ······································ 9
05
Cross-linking ········································ 11
06
Results ···················································13
07
Viscoelastical properties ·················· 19
08
Silica dispersion ·································· 21
09
Discussion ··········································· 23
10
Summary ············································· 26
Whitepaper “The influence of silica surface properties on physical performance of tire tread compounds“, © 2021 Elkem Silicon Products 2
The influence of silica surface
properties on physical performance
of tire tread compounds
G. Schmaucks[1], C. Maczkiewitz[2]
Abstract
Such new tire tread formulations were tested by tire producers and in
some cases patented.
Whitepaper “The influence of silica surface properties on physical performance of tire tread compounds“, © 2021 Elkem Silicon Products 3
01
Introduction
Sidistar® Sustain-
ability
All electricity used to produce
is an amorphous silica and is Sidistar® comes from hydro-
classified as non-hazardous power
Whitepaper “The influence of silica surface properties on physical performance of tire tread compounds“, © 2021 Elkem Silicon Products 4
01 Introduction
New formulation
Elkem is ranking in the top 5% of the DCP A list providing The production of Sidistar® is
transparency on climate change mitigation ISO9001 and 14001 certified
Whitepaper “The influence of silica surface properties on physical performance of tire tread compounds“, © 2021 Elkem Silicon Products 5
02
Raw materials and
formulations
Silica surface properties
Whitepaper “The influence of silica surface properties on physical performance of tire tread compounds“, © 2021 Elkem Silicon Products 6
02 Raw materials and formulations
Formulations
25 150
Whitepaper “The influence of silica surface properties on physical performance of tire tread compounds“, © 2021 Elkem Silicon Products 7
03
Test methods
Si Sidistar®
Provides dynamic fatigue
improvement
• Improves rheology/pro-
cessing acts like a physical
processing aid
Silicon is the 2nd most • Provides synergistic improve-
common element on earth ments in flame retardancy
Whitepaper “The influence of silica surface properties on physical performance of tire tread compounds“, © 2021 Elkem Silicon Products 8
04
Compounding
3500
3000
mixing energy, kJ/kg
2500
2000
1500
1000
500
0
precipitated silica R300 R300, double Si69® R320U XP320ST69
Stage 1 Stage 2
Whitepaper “The influence of silica surface properties on physical performance of tire tread compounds“, © 2021 Elkem Silicon Products 9
04 Compounding
40
35
ML(1+4) 100ºC
30
25
20
15
10
0
precipitated silica R300 R300, double Si69® R320U XP320ST69
Whitepaper “The influence of silica surface properties on physical performance of tire tread compounds“, © 2021 Elkem Silicon Products 10
05
Crosslinking
Looking at the curves in Figure 3 and the numbers in Table 4, one can
observe that all Sidistar® grades increase scorch safety as compared
to precipitated silica aside from the surface modified Sidistar® product.
Furthermore, one can identify differences in the position of the torque
plateau at times larger than 15 minutes. The increase in delta torque
as a measure of crosslink density of compound 5 with Sidistar®
R300, 2phr Si69® loading as compared to compound 4 (1phr Si69®)
could be considered as an effect of the additional sulfur originating
from Si69® and gives higher reinforcement. However, the compound
with Sidistar® R320U (clean silica surface) and 2phr Si69® loading
exhibits a maximum torque even higher than that and close to that
of the reference compound 1 with precipitated silica, even though
Sidistar®R320U has a considerably lower specific surface area (only ca.
60% of that of the precipitated silica).
Whitepaper “The influence of silica surface properties on physical performance of tire tread compounds“, © 2021 Elkem Silicon Products 11
05 Crosslinking
0,9
0,8
0,7
Torque (Nm)
0,6
0,5
0,4
0,3
0,2
0,1
0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
Time (min)
Whitepaper “The influence of silica surface properties on physical performance of tire tread compounds“, © 2021 Elkem Silicon Products 12
06
Results – physical
properties of vulcanizates
The physical properties of the vulcanized compounds were measured
according to the standards listed in Table 3. Figure 4 shows the
hardness. The hardness of our compound series turned out to be much
lower than anticipated and typical for tire tread compounds. A typical
Shore A hardness for a SBR tire tread compound would lie around
65 +/-5. This was unintended and is probably related to the rubber
polymer used (the polymer specified in the patent was unavailable at
the time and had to be substituted; a polymer with comparable styrene
content and viscosity was selected as replacement). The polymer
specified in the patent is special and has a glass transition temperature
below -60° C. The low hardness might also have impact on various
other physical properties and limits the assessment of the compound
for tire tread applications. With regard to comparability with the data
provided in the patent, no compound hardness was specified there.
Whitepaper “The influence of silica surface properties on physical performance of tire tread compounds“, © 2021 Elkem Silicon Products 13
06 Results – physical properties of vulcanizates
50
45
40
35
Hardness, Shore A
30
25
20
15
10
0
precipitated silica R300 R300, double Si69® R320U XP320ST69
Whitepaper “The influence of silica surface properties on physical performance of tire tread compounds“, © 2021 Elkem Silicon Products 14
06 Results – physical properties of vulcanizates
1200 25
1000
20
Elongation at break, %
5
200
0 0
precipitated R300 R300, double R320U XP320ST69 Michelin R300, Michelin
silica Si69® patent patent
Figure 5: Tensile properties, the unfilled bars show data from the
patent of limited comparability (hardness data were not provided)
Whitepaper “The influence of silica surface properties on physical performance of tire tread compounds“, © 2021 Elkem Silicon Products 15
06 Results – physical properties of vulcanizates
7
Reinforcing effect, M300/M100
0
precipitated silica R300 R300, double Si69® R320U XP320ST69
Salten
Whitepaper “The influence of silica surface properties on physical performance of tire tread compounds“, © 2021 Elkem Silicon Products 16
06 Results – physical properties of vulcanizates
40
35
Tear strength, kN/m
30
25
20
15
10
0
precipitated silica R300 R300, double Si69® R320U XP320ST69
25 45
40
20 35
30
Compression set, %
Rebound resilience
15
25
20
10
15
5 10
0 0
precipitated silica R300 R300, double Si69® R320U XP320ST69
Whitepaper “The influence of silica surface properties on physical performance of tire tread compounds“, © 2021 Elkem Silicon Products 17
06 Results – physical properties of vulcanizates
250
200
Abrasion, mm3
150
100
50
0
precipitated silica R300 R300, double Si69® R320U XP320ST69
Figure 9: Abrasion
> 110
Whitepaper “The influence of silica surface properties on physical performance of tire tread compounds“, © 2021 Elkem Silicon Products 18
07
Viscoelastical properties
1,4
1,2
0,2
1 0,18
0,16
tan d
0,8 0,14
0,12
0,6 0,1
50 55 60 65 70
0,4
0,2
0
−80 −60 −40 −20 0 20 40 60 80 100
TºC
Whitepaper “The influence of silica surface properties on physical performance of tire tread compounds“, © 2021 Elkem Silicon Products 19
07 Viscoelastical properties
0,160
0,140
0,120
Tan delta at 60ºC
0,100
0,080
0,060
0,040
0,020
0,000
precipitated R300 R300, R320U XP320ST69 Michelin R300,
silica double Si69® patent Michelin
patent
In Figure 11 the tanδ at 60° C values of the compounds, for which data
were published in the patent, are also shown for comparison. One
difference between the DMA measurements in this study and those
from the patent is that they were conducted with different strain, 1 %
here as compared to 8 % for the patent. We are therefore unsure, if the
data can be compared, but believe that the relations between the tanδ
data would be similar when obtained with the same strain.
Whitepaper “The influence of silica surface properties on physical performance of tire tread compounds“, © 2021 Elkem Silicon Products 20
08
Silica dispersion
Whitepaper “The influence of silica surface properties on physical performance of tire tread compounds“, © 2021 Elkem Silicon Products 21
08 Silica dispersion
Sidistar®
Whitepaper “The influence of silica surface properties on physical performance of tire tread compounds“, © 2021 Elkem Silicon Products 22
09
Discussion
The result presented in the previous sections indicate that the silica
surface plays an important role for the performance properties of tire
tread compounds. One way to compare the different silica surfaces
listed in Table 1 is in terms of their compatibility to the SBR polymer.
Considering this, the following conclusions can be drawn:
The details of the carbonaceous molecular top layer are not known.
Results show that the surface modification with Si69® silane added
during processing to improve compatibility of the silica surface with
the polymer is less (or not at all) efficient for Sidistar® R300, exactly
because of the presence of the carbonaceous molecular layer on its
surface. It is possible that the Sidistar® R300 product leads to better
compatibility with other rubber polymers, but not with SBR. Sidistar®
R300 may also work well in rubber formulations, where a silanization is
not required.
Whitepaper “The influence of silica surface properties on physical performance of tire tread compounds“, © 2021 Elkem Silicon Products 23
09 Discussion
For the Sidistar® R300 product it might have been interesting to have
prepared a compound without Si69® silane in order to learn more on
the nature of the carbonaceous molecular layer. Furthermore, exact
Si69® loading dependence for that product needs to be investigated
further.
Best compatibility to the SBR polymer was obtained with the Si69®
modified silica surface.
Whitepaper “The influence of silica surface properties on physical performance of tire tread compounds“, © 2021 Elkem Silicon Products 24
09 Discussion
abrasion
180
160
140
120
100
80
Whitepaper “The influence of silica surface properties on physical performance of tire tread compounds“, © 2021 Elkem Silicon Products 25
10
Summary
1 2 3
Sidistar® products can For silica fillers with similar
exactly be characterized as specific surface area
low specific surface area/ have shown that different
low structure silica, and surface characteristics can
work as expected in the new Observed excellent dispersion have significant impact on
patented formulations without in the SBR matrix down to performance of tire tread
plasticizer primary silica spheres compounds
4 5 6
est tire tread performance
B
was obtained with modified
Si69® surface modification of Sidistar® XP320 ST69,
he surface properties
T the silica before processing which shows outstanding
are rated in terms of their works more effective as performance in the
compatibility to the SBR compared to addition of the combination of abrasion and
matrix silane during compounding viscoelastic properties
Whitepaper “The influence of silica surface properties on physical performance of tire tread compounds“, © 2021 Elkem Silicon Products 26
10 Summary
Whitepaper “The influence of silica surface properties on physical performance of tire tread compounds“, © 2021 Elkem Silicon Products 27
Acknowledgements
Sincere thanks are expressed to ERT B.V. for compounding of the
formulations, measurement of the performance properties and
constructive discussions.
References
[1] gs-chemconsult, Germany
[2] Elkem ASA, Silicon Products, Germany
[3] US 20190030953A1, Michelin patent
[4] EP 2336231 A1, Goodyear patent
[5] EP 1 551 912 Cl. C08K 3/34, Elkem patent
[6] US 8 053 507 B2 Cl. C01B33/113; C08K3/36, Elkem patent
[7] G. Schmaucks, Tire Technol. Int. Annual Review, p.58f, 2004, Optimizing the
balance between processability and performance
[8] G. Schmaucks, Rubber World 241 (2010) 5, p. 27 - 30, Special low surface silica as
filler in fluoroelastomers
[9] E. Gallo, B. Schartel, G. Schmaucks, K. von der Ehe and M. Böhning; Plastics,
Rubber and Composites Vol. 42 (2013) 1, p. 34 – 42; Effect of well dispersed
amorphous silicon dioxide in flame retarded styrene butadiene Rubber
[10] G. Schmaucks, A. Aamodt, A. Freitag, K. Zoumis; Noxtite-Hochtemperatur ACM
und Spezialkieselsäure SIDISTAR R mit niedriger Oberfläche; Gummi, Fasern
Kunststoffe 4/2013, p. 229 – 232
[11] Specialty silica for processing improvement and reduction in mixing energy,
A. Freitag, G. Schmaucks, Cost reduction in rubber processing, TechnoBiz
Communications Co. LTD, p 107-129; 2014
[12] G. Schmaucks, B. Friede, H. Schreiner, J.O. Roszinski; Gummi Fasern Kunststoffe
11/2007, 719 – 724; Unkonventionelle Kieselsäure – eine neue Möglichkeit zur
Optimierung hochwertiger Gummimaterialien
[13] G. Schmaucks, B. Friede, H. Schreiner, J.O. Roszinski, R. Ristic, N. Djenadic; Tire
Technology International 2007 Annual Review, p. 90 – 92; The effect of specialty
silica on winter tread compound properties and performance
[14] Eshwaran Subramani Bhagavatheswaran, Meenali Parsekar, Amit Das, Hai Hong
Le, Sven Wiessner, Klaus Werner Stöckelhuber, Gerd Schmaucks, Gert Heinrich;
Journal of Physical Chemistry C; 2015; Construction of an Interconnected
Nanostructured Carbon Black Network: Development of Highly Stretchable and
Robust Elastomeric Conductors
[15] A. Aamodt, A. Freitag, G. Schmaucks; DKT2015 proceedings, Amorphous Silicon
Dioxide as Multifunctional Additive for High Performance Rubber Compounds
[16] EP 0501227, Michelin patent
Whitepaper “The influence of silica surface properties on physical performance of tire tread compounds“, © 2021 Elkem Silicon Products 28
For more information about the materials in this
whitepaper, visit www.sidistar.com or reach out to
info@sidistar.com
www.elkem.com/contact
Whitepaper “The influence of silica surface properties on physical performance of tire tread compounds“, © 2021 Elkem Silicon Products 29