Professional Documents
Culture Documents
IJERM0509009
IJERM0509009
Index Terms—NDT, PDT, Rebound hammer test, B. For assessment of corrosion condition of reinforcement
Ultrasonic Pulse Velocity Test. and to determine reinforcement diameter and cover
Area : CTM- Civil Engineering (i) Resistivity meter test
(ii) Test for carbonation of concrete
INTRODUCTION (iii) Ferro-scan
Non-Destructive Testing (NDT) techniques can be used
effectively for investigation and evaluating the actual Non Destructive Evaluation (NDE) Methods
condition of the structures. These techniques are relatively Concrete technologists practice NDE methods for
quick, easy to use, and cheap and give a general indication of (a) Concrete strength determination (b) Concrete damage
the required property of the concrete. This approach will detection
enable us to find suspected zones, thereby reducing the time
and cost of examining a large mass of concrete. The choice of Strength determination by NDE methods:
a particular NDT method depends upon the property of Strength determination of concrete is important because its
concrete to be observed such as strength, corrosion, crack elastic behaviour & service behaviourcan be predicted from
monitoring etc. its strength characteristics. The conventional NDE methods
typicallymeasure certain properties of concrete from which an
estimate of its strength and othercharacteristics can be made.
Manuscript received Sep 25, 2018 Hence, they do not directly give the absolute values of
Er. Neha Goyal, Scholar M.Tech. –in Construction Technology & strength.
Mgmt., HCTM Technical Campus,Kaithal, Kurukshetra University Roll
no.–17162408 ,Haryana, India
Er. Bhavana Arora, Astt. Professor CED, HCTM Kaithal-Haryana STRUCTURAL AUDIT
Dr. Sanjay Sharma, Head of Dept. - Civil Engineering ,National Structural audit is the technical survey of the building in
Institute of Technical Teachers Training & Research (NITTTR), order to check its strength and stability. Structural audit is the
Chandigarh, India.
Dr. Arvind Dewangan, Director (Prof. in Civil Engg.)- Yognanda
first step in repairing procedure of the building. Structural
College of Engineering & Technology, Akhnoor Road, Jammu (J & K) audit is generally recommended for older buildings.
30 www.ijerm.com
Performance Evolution and Audit of Structure by NDT Methods
Structural audit was first introduced by Indian society of detection of concrete strength (b) detection of concrete
structural engineers. Structural audit helps in improving the damage. He conducted tests on specimens and on columns,
safety, efficiency and gives idea about the strength of the beams and on double story building's slab in NIT Rourkela by
structure by detailed technical inspection. In present study the means of ultrasonic pulse velocity and rebound hammer
attempt have been made to carry out structural audit of the old test. Different strength of 6 cubes were casted and conducted
RCC building by carrying out site inspection, performing the compressive strength with rebound hammer and velocity.
NDT on the structure. Building is modelled and analysed He also plotted it two graphs, one between velocity versus
using ETABS and Demand to capacity ratio is determined. compressive strength and the second one between rebound
hammer versus compressive strength. thereafter, they casted
Structural Audit By ETABS Software with the grade of M20 add m25 concrete, again rebound
The innovative and revolutionary new ETABSis the ultimate hammer and velocity test were conducted on these and then
integrated software package for the structuralanalysis and they compared these results with, without reinforcement tests.
design of buildings. This latest ETABS offers unmatched3D with the help of these results, it was witnessed that ultrasonic
object based on modelling and visualization tools, fast linear pulse velocity's variation was around 16. 1 % and for the
and nonlinear analytical power, sophisticated rebound hammer it was around 3. 6%. after that this work
andcomprehensive design capabilities for a wedge-range of performed on the real structure and got required assessment.
materials,and insightful graphic displays, reports, and Denys. Breysse stated that how and why non-destructive
schematicdrawings. CAD drawings can be directly converted testing, in measuring of in-situ strength of concrete is
into ETABSmodels. Design of steel and concrete frames, important. mainly it's by:- (a) clear review of existing models
composite beams,composite columns, steel joists and (b) data collected on in-situ and collected in Labs (c)
concrete and masonry shearwalls, as is the capacity check for illustrating real data and the development or analysis of
steel connections and baseplates. Comprehensive and design considerations to reproduce main pattern whereas by
customizable reports are availablefor all analysis and design controlling dependable parameters main factors which
output, and construction drawings offraming plans, details, influence the quality of strength estimate are known. there
and cross sections are generated for concreteand steel were two main techniques, one is UPV the another one is
structures. rebound which have preferences. it is vivid that errors in
measurement have a great influence on the estimate of quality
Need for Structural Audit the arena real structure. suggestions and recommendations are
Structural audit is carried out in order to given in the case of Son Reb combined approach.
To increase life of property Varalakshmi V et.al(2014) analysed a G+5 storey
To know the health of building and its expected life. residential building and designed the various components like
To check actual reliability of the structure. beam, slab, column and foundation. The loads namely dead
In order to recommend rehabilitation techniques. load and live load were calculated as per IS 875(Part I &
In order to highlight the critical areas and repair them II)-1987 and HYSD bars i.e. Fe 415 are used as per IS
immediately. 1986-1985. They concluded that the safety of the reinforced
concrete building depends upon the initial architectural and
NDE Methods in Practice structural configuration of the total building, the quality of the
Visual inspection:The first stage in the evaluation of a structural analysis, design and reinforcement detailing of the
concrete structure is to study the condition of concrete, to note building frame to achieve stability of elements and their
any defects in the concrete, to note the presence of cracking ductile performance.
and the cracking type (crack width, depth, spacing, density), Chandrashekar et.al (2015) analysed and designed the
the presence of rust marks on the surface, the presence of multi-storeyed building by using ETABS software. A G+5
voids and the presence of apparently poorly compacted areas storey building under the lateral loading effect of wind and
etc. Visual assessment determines whether or not to proceed earthquake was considered for this study and analysis is done
with detailed investigation. by using ETABS. They have also considered the chances of
The Surface hardness method:This is based on the principle occurrence of spread of fire and the importance of use of fire
that the strength of concrete is proportional to its surface proof material up to highest possible standards of
hardness. The calibration chart is valid for a particular type of performance as well as reliability. They suggested that the
cement, aggregates used, moisture content, and the age of the wide chances of ETABS software which is very innovative
specimen. and easier for high rise buildings so that time incurred for
The Pull-out test:A pull out test involves casting the designing is reduced.
enlarged end of a steel rod after setting of concrete, to be MhammadrezaHamidian, in this research paper, authors
tested and then measuring the force required to pull it out. The compared two results one is conducted by the use of
test measures the direct shear strength of concrete. This in ultrasonic pulse velocity test and rebound hammer test on one
turn is correlated with the compressive strength; thus a particular specimen and previously made structure, which
measurement of the in-place compressive strength is made. gives compressive strength of concrete and form comparison
The test may cause damage to the specimen which needs to be with the actual compressive strength which is conducted by
repaired. compressive testing machine. The structural health
monitoring by UPV and RSH conducted both in laboratory
LITERATURE REVIEW and on-site. The experimental examination using NDT test
showed much better result and showed relation between
Mrs. Ayaz Mahmood, stated in his thesis, method of
compressive strength. UPP methods are supposed to be best
Non-destructive evaluation (NDE) methods are used for (a)
31 www.ijerm.com
International Journal of Engineering Research And Management (IJERM)
ISSN: 2349- 2058, Volume-05, Issue-09, September 2018
for both under construction and made structures with the The test for reinforcement scanning is done with help of
accuracy ranges from ±20% whereas SRH showed ±15% to HILTI PS 200 Ferroscan, a portable system for detecting
±20 %. rebar in concrete structures. HILTI PS 200 Ferroscan record
the depth and positions of rebars over long stretches and
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY obtain average coverage and statistics. The major analysis and
Thesystematicapproachfortheperformance evaluation and conclusion is done on the computer on the analysis software
structural auditingofthestructureasidentifiedfrom to produce reports of the data recorded which is further
theliteraturesurveywillbefollowed.Researchmethodologyfort submitted to the Structural Consultant for Preparation of
heproposedprojectswillconsistof the followingsteps:- Structural Drawing and thereby establishing the Stability of
the Structure. The limitations of this test are interferences may
occur in images due to scraps of reinforcement in concrete, tie
wires where rebars cross, aggregates with Ferro magnetic
properties.
The results have been presented in a tabular form. The
rebound hammer values, ultrasonic pulse velocity test values
and ferro-scanning test result as determined by tests on
different locations.
32 www.ijerm.com
Performance Evolution and Audit of Structure by NDT Methods
This test gives a measure of the surface hardness of the conditions. Therefore, whenever the actual moisture
concrete surface. Although there is no direct condition of the field concrete or specimen is unknown, the
relationshipbetweenthismeasurementofsurfacehardnessandstr surface should be pre-saturated for several hours before
ength,anempirical relationship exists. testing. A correlation curve for tests performed on saturated
Rebound hammer isthe best known methodsof comparing the surface dried specimens should then be used to estimate the
concrete indifferent parts of a compressive strength.
structureandindirectlyassessingconcretestrength.Therebound 5. Type of coarse aggregate
hammershouldbeconsidered as a means of assessing Even though the same aggregate type is used in the concrete
variations of strength within a structurerather than an accurate mix, the correlation curves can be different if the source of the
means of assessing the strength. aggregate is different. An example is shown in Fig. 4.5 where
correlation curves for four different sources of gravel are
ULTRASONIC PULSE VELOCITY TESTER plotted.
Ultrasonic instrument is handy, battery operated and portable 6. Type of cement
instrument used for assessing elastic properties or concrete High alumina cement can have a compressive strength 100%
quality. The apparatus for ultrasonic pulse velocity higher than the strength estimated using a correlation curve
measurement consists of the following based on ordinary Portland cement. Also, super sulphated
A. Electrical Pulse Generator cement concrete can have strength 50% lower than ordinary
B. Transducer- one pair Portland cement.
C. Amplifier 7. Carbonation of the concrete surface
D. Electronic Timing Device In older concrete the carbonation depth can be several
Although thereisnofundamentalrelationshipbetween millimetres thick and, in extreme cases, up to 20 mm thick. In
pulsevelocityandstrength,an estimationof strengthcanbe such cases the rebound numbers can be up to 50% higher than
obtainedbycorrelation.The methodhasperhapsagreater those obtained on an uncarbonated concrete surface.
potentialforcomparingknownsoundconcretewithaffected
concrete.Ultrasonicpulse
velocityisameansofassessingvariationsin
theapparentstrengthofconcrete.Thequality
gradationofconcrete can beappraisedatbestqualitatively as
`excellent', `good', `medium' or`doubtful'.
Themeaningsoftheterm`excellent',`good',`medium'and`doubtf
ul' are based onultra-sonic pulsevelocity measuredat site
andareas perthenomenclatureofIS13311(part-1): 1992.
33 www.ijerm.com
International Journal of Engineering Research And Management (IJERM)
ISSN: 2349- 2058, Volume-05, Issue-09, September 2018
Ground Floor
34 www.ijerm.com
Performance Evolution and Audit of Structure by NDT Methods
The pulse velocity method is an ideal tool for 16. Hamidian M, Shariati M, ArabnejadKhanouki M, Shariati
establishing whether concrete is uniform. It can be A (2011). Assessment of high strength and light weight
used on both existing structures and those under aggregate concrete properties using ultrasonic pulse
velocity technique. Int. J. Phys. Sci., 6: 5261-5266.
construction.
17. Handbook on Non Destructive Testing of Concrete”
Ultrasonic pulse velocity tests have a great potential (second edition) by V.M. Malhotra and N.J. Carino.
for concrete control, particularly for establishing 18. Helal, J., Sofi, M. and Mendis, P., 2015. Non-destructive
uniformity and detecting cracks or defects. Its use testing of concrete: A review of methods. Electronic
for predicting strength is much more limited. Journal of Structural Engineering, 14(1), pp.97-105.
19. Holický, M., Návarová, V., Gottfried, R. and Kronika, M.,
REFERENCES 2014. Basics for assessment of existing structures. Base of
1. Mr. Ayaz Mahmood , “Structural Health Monitoring using Reliability Theory and Risk Evaluation (Ed. KI CTU
Non-destructive testing of concrete”, Department of Civil Prague, 2013).
engineering –National Institute of Technology –Rurkela- 20. Harshada, K. And Kumar, K.S., 2015. Non-Destructive
2008. Evaluation Of Structural Health Of A Building Using
2. Aydin F, Saribiyik M (2010). Correlation between Schmidt Rebound Hammer.
Hammer and destructive compressions testing for 21. Helal, J., Sofi, M. and Mendis, P., 2015. Non-destructive
concretes in existing buildings. Sci. Res. Essays, 5: testing of concrete: A review of methods. Electronic
1644-1648. Journal of Structural Engineering, 14(1), pp.97-105.
3. Akhtar, S., 2013. Review of nondestructive testing methods 22. Harsha, B.S. and Vikranth, J., 2014. Study and comparison
for condition monitoring of concrete structures. Journal of of contruction sequence analysis with regular analysis by
construction engineering, 2013. using etabs. International Journal of Research Sciences
4. Ahad, S.A., Tabrej, H.S.A.P., Vikhar, S.A.S. and Bidve, S., and Advanced Engineering [IJRSAE] Volume, 2,
2017. Analysis and Design Of Multistory Apartment pp.218-227.
Building Using ETABS. International Journal Of 23. IS-1311 (Part-1): 1992 Non-Destructive Testing of
Engineering And Computer Science, 6(5). Concrete -methods of test, Part-I,
5. Abhay Guleria, Structural Analysis of Multi-storeyed 24. Ultrasonic Pulse Velocity.
Building using ETABS for different Plan configurations 25. IS 13311 (Part-2): 1992, Non-Destructive Testing of
International Journal of Engineering and Technology Concrete –methods of test, Part 2, Rebound hammer.
(IRJET) ,Volume: 3 Issue: 5, May 2014. 26. I.S. 456-2000 -Code of Practice for Plain and Reinforced
6. Balaji and Selvarasan (2016), “Design and Analysis of Concrete
multi-storeyed building under static and dynamic loading 27. I S 1893-2003 -Criteria for Earthquake Resistant Design
conditions using ETABS”, International Journal of Structure
Technical Research and Applications e-ISSN: 2320-8163, 28. I S 13920-1993 -Ductile Detailing of Reinforced Concrete
www.ijtra.com Volume 4, Issue 4, PP. 1-5 Structures subjected to Seismic forces.
7. Balaji &Yelisetty, Ajitesh. (2014). Condition Assessment
Of Existing Structures Using NDT Techniques.
8. Denys Breysse, Mathilde Larget et al, “Quality of NDT
measurements and accuracy of concrete physical BIOGRAPHY
properties” NDTCE 2009, Non-Destructive Testing in
civil engineering Nantes, France, June 30th - July 3rd,
2009.
9. Denys Breysse, MariosSoutsos et al, “ How to improve the
quality of concrete assessment by combining several NDT
measurements,” NDTCE 2009, Non-Destructive Testing
in civil engineering Nantes, France, June 30th - July 3rd,
2009.
10. .Ehiorobo J.O, Izinyon O. C and Ogirigbo R.O.,
“Measurement and Documentation for Structural Corresponding Author Er. Neha
Intergrity Assessment of In-Service Building At Risk”, Goyal is a scholar of M.Tech. in Haryana College of Tech. &
TS07E - Engineering Surveying 1 – 6638, Nigeria-6th Management, Kaithal.
May 2013.
11. Proverbio, V.Venturi, “Reliability of Non Destruction test
for on-site concrete strength assessment” 10 DBMC
International Conference on Durability of Building
Materials and components LYON (France) 17-20 April
2005.
12. Ferreria, Almir P. et al, “Application of NDT to Concrete
Strength Estimation” NDT .net-Feburary 2000, Vol.5
No.02.
13. Geethu S N, Depthi M, Abdul Nasir N A and Izzudeen K
M(2016) “Comparative study on design and analysis of
multi storied building by STAAD.Pro and ETABS
softwares”.
14. Graham-Jones, J. and Summer scales, J. eds., 2015. Marine
applications of advanced fiber-reinforced composites.
Woodhead Publishing.
15. Giovanni Pascale, Antonio Di Leo, Roberto Carli,
“Evaluation of Actual Compressive Strength of High
Strength by NDT” Roma 2000 15th WCNDT.
35 www.ijerm.com