Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Gender Training Tyc
Gender Training Tyc
Note carefully:
These are only a few terms used in gender mainstreaming.
There are many others that are used to refer to concepts used.
A clear understanding of the terms used is fundamental to
understanding gender dynamics in youth livelihoods
programming.
Acknowledge that often terminology can be a barrier to talking
about gender equality.
Facilitator’s talking notes
Gender concepts and terms sometimes do not translate easily from
one language to another. However, it is not the term itself that is most
important but the idea behind it, and debates around terminology can
actually be an excellent way of creating in-depth understanding of the
meaning behind the words.
Gender: The socially constructed roles, behaviors, activities, and
attributes that a given society considers appropriate for girls, boys,
women, and men. Example: In some countries, women are not allowed
to drive while men can.
Sex: The biological and physiological characteristics that identify a
person as male or female. Example of a sex trait: The fact that many
females can give birth and breastfeed is a biological characteristic.
While aspects of sex will not vary substantially between human societies,
aspects of gender do. Social constructions of gender affect all of us every
day, in everything that we do, from the time we are born into a particular
family, culture, and community. Gender roles are learned, and can change
over time. While social constructions of gender vary from place to place,
inequalities occur everywhere.
Gender affects girls and boys, men and women. Sometimes we tend to
think gender is only a women’s issue, but this is not the case. Gender
affects whole communities as it is about how we relate to one another and
the roles that we play within our society. It is for this reason, that it is so
critical that work on gender equality targets not only women and girls but
whole communities.
While gender inequalities are most pronounced for girls and women, boys
and men face many gender stereotypes and inequalities as well. Gender
both intersects with and magnifies other forms of discrimination, including
race, ethnicity, religion, caste, age, (dis)ability, sexual orientation, and/or
socio-economic status. With this, we need to be cautious of assumptions
that all women or all men have the same experiences.
Gender equality refers to the absence of discrimination on the basis
of sex. For example, girls, boys, women and men receive the same
salary when they do the same work. Further, gender equality is when
girls, boys, women, and men have equal rights, obligations and
opportunities to:
Security and good health;
A viable livelihood and dignified work;
Participate in the care of home and dependent family members;
Take active part in public and political life;
Learn and participate in relevant education; and
Live a life free from violence
Gender equality does not simply mean equal numbers of men and women
or boys and girls in all activities. It means that men and women are equally
valued in society and both have opportunities to realize their full potential
and contribute to national, political, economic, social and cultural
development, and to benefit from the results.
It signifies an aspiration to work towards a society in which neither women
nor men suffer from deprivation and poverty in its many forms, and in
which women and men are able to live equally fulfilling lives.
Equality does not mean ‘sameness’. Gender equality means recognizing
that men and women, girls and boys, often have different needs and
priorities, face different constraints, have different aspirations and
contribute to reconstruction and development in different ways.
Equality is our ultimate goal, and is also a process in and of itself.
Equity is a tool/mechanism we can apply to help support us in reaching
this goal.
Gender equity: The process of being fair to girls, boys, women, and men. To
ensure fairness, strategies and measures must be available to compensate
for discrimination against girls and women that prevent girls, boys, women,
and men from otherwise living equally. Equity leads to equality. Example of
gender equity: A quota to increase the number of girls in a students’
organization is a gender equity measure aimed at compensating for
discrimination which results in girls’ restricted opportunities for participation
in decision making spheres.
Gender roles: Behaviors, attitudes and actions society feels are appropriate
or inappropriate for a girl, boy, woman, or man, according to cultural norms
and traditions. Gender roles are neither static nor universal but vary between
cultures, over time, between generations, and in relation to other social
identities such as social class, socio-economic status, ethnicity, sexual
orientation, religion, ability, and health status. Gender roles may also shift
with
processes of urbanization or industrialization, and the fluid nature of gender
roles requires careful and ongoing gender analysis.
Example: In many societies, girls and women are expected to be
responsible for cooking, cleaning, and childrearing, while boys and men are
responsible for earning money for the household. In those contexts, the
gender roles of girls and women are linked to ‘reproductive’ work, while the
gender roles of boys and men are. related to ‘productive’ work.
Productive work/ roles relates to any work that generates an income. Men’s
productive work commonly takes place outside the sphere of the household
and more commonly generates monetary income. Young women’s
productive work commonly occurs within the household sphere and is
generally less valued, and often not even taken into account.
Reproductive work/ roles relates to work in the household, raising children,
cooking and cleaning. It is commonly assumed to be the responsibility of
women, yet young and old men also often perform reproductive work, for
instance, taking care of machines or washing the car/ bicycle.
Reproductive work generally does not generate any income, yet has an
impact on family (and societal) economy. As it is associated with the
women’s sphere, it is less valued than productive work and often not
considered. Girls often have to take on the reproductive tasks if the mothers
are to engage in productive work.
Community work/ roles relates to work and time devoted to political, religious
or social work in organizations, community work or other work that both
women and men engage in. Commonly, young and old en’s engagement in
community work is more valued than women’s engagement, and therefore
considered in planning.
Gender norms are social principles and rules that govern the behavior of
girls, boys, women, and men in society and restrict their gender identity into
what is considered to be an appropriate gender role at the time. As with
gender roles, gender norms are neither static nor universal and change over
time.
Gender barrier: A gender barrier is any circumstance or obstacle which
prevents girls, boys, women or men, based on their gender, from claiming
their equal rights to services, resources, information, opportunities or
systems.
3. HOLISTIC APPROACHES
Acknowledging that gender equality is about relationships, transformative gender
approaches require working with whole communities, and at all levels, equally
engaging female and male stakeholders in culturally-sensitive gender equality
policy and program work.
MEANINGFUL PARTICIPATION
Girls and boys are active citizens. They must be equally engaged in dialogue
around gender and have equal opportunity to participate and to promote gender
equality.
Presentation by facilitator
Below are the questions you ask when assessing Gender equality during
program design & proposal research?
1. What constraints limit women’s / men’s / girls’/ boys’ full involvement along all
parts of the value chain / livelihood option in question?
2. What are appropriate areas for intervention, so that these constraints can be
mitigated?
Information from a gender perspective to gather during a proposal research/
information gathering/ reconnaissance trip includes:
……………..Gender Equality Considerations in Youth Livelihoods
National and cultural policies around inheritance
How do young women and men spend their time?
What activities are they involved in in the home and the community?
How young women organize childcare (i.e., Will women watch each other’s
children? Is an older child left behind? Can small children come to meetings/
trainings/ places of employment?).
Women’s mobility (i.e., How far are young women able to travel for trainings,
to deliver milk, etc.? Are they able to travel alone or do they need to be
accompanied?)
The literacy and numeracy skills of target stakeholders.
National policies around young women’s access to finance/loans.
Some gender barriers and opportunities when working with young
women and men Gender roles and responsibilities
Girls and young women are expected to be nurturers, “good” wives and
mothers in future and this impacts on their choices in education and livelihood
option
Perceptions that girls and young women should mainly focus on small
businesses and trades while boys and men should have large enterprises
Typically, heavy reproductive workloads for girls and young women affects
time available for education, productive and community work, rest and
recreation
Men are usually expected to be providers and key decision makers in families
– boys follow this path and begin engaging in productive roles early in life to
the detriment of their education and training opportunities
Some gender barriers and opportunities when working with young
women and men Gender roles and responsibilities
Girls and young women are expected to be nurturers, “good” wives and
mothers in future and this impacts on their choices in education and livelihood
option
Perceptions that girls and young women should mainly focus on small
businesses and trades while boys and men should have large enterprises
Typically, heavy reproductive workloads for girls and young women affects
time available for education, productive and community work, rest and
recreation
Men are usually expected to be providers and key decision makers in families
– boys follow this path and begin engaging in productive roles early in life to
the detriment of theireducation and training opportunities
Patterns of decision making
Women in leadership – low participation of women in politics and leadership in a
country is indicative of women’s participation in decision making in public life; there
tends to be low participation of young women and girls in committees and decision-
making groups and this is often reflected in project activities
Selection of livelihood options is strongly influenced by gender norms on roles and
responsibilities as well as restrictions on mobility e.g., girls and young women select
business enterprises that are near the home, that do not require travel to distant
locations and that are an extension of their reproductive roles.
Boys and young men select male oriented enterprises such as mechanics; only one
girl in the Youth in Action program in Mwanza has chosen motor vehicle mechanics
as a livelihood option.
There are social expectations that a girl/ young woman should have a small business
enterprise and this limits their vision compared to the expectation that a boy/ young
man should have a large enterprise that brings in much more profit.
Parents have a high influence on selection of livelihood options for girls/ young
women and should therefore be also exposed to non-traditional options for girls/
young women and boys/ young men.
For boys and young men, acquiring basic self-care skills would challenge
gender norms on reproductive roles and support them and their partners in the
future.
Generally, girls and young women see themselves as having fewer
livelihood options compared to boys and young men who see themselves as
having many more options
Access to and control over resources, information, services and assets
Access to education – transition to higher levels of education and completion
is low for both girls and boys for different reasons; however, consequences for
girls are multiplied due to other limitations and roles they have e.g., girls may
face challenges such as early marriage and pregnancies as well as rigid
gender norms that restrict their mobility and activities; they are also more
often encumbered by reproductive roles in the home.
Recruitment of program facilitators and mentors is affected by education
requirements so flexible criteria should be adopted especially for
females
Credit – access to credit by adolescents is limited to families due to age
restrictions in accessing public funds in most contexts
Sexual and reproductive health information and services are necessary
– many girls and young women get married and/or pregnant while in
livelihoods training programs; information on sexual and reproductive
health (SRH) should be provided in livelihoods training programs to help
them transition into the child bearing phase and better manage life and
work e.g., links to contraception, maternal and child health information,
menstrual health management, etc
Recruitment of program facilitators and mentors is affected by education
requirements so flexible criteria should be adopted especially for
females
Credit – access to credit by adolescents is limited to families due to age
restrictions in accessing public funds in most contexts
Sexual and reproductive health information and services are necessary
– many girls and young women get married and/or pregnant while in
livelihoods training programs; information on sexual and reproductive
health (SRH) should be provided in livelihoods training programs to help
them transition into the child bearing phase and better manage life and
work e.g., links to contraception, maternal and child health information,
menstrual health management, etc
Role modeling and a supportive environment
Role modelling – there tend to be few female business owners to role
model for girls and young women especially in rural areas
Supportive environment – appreciation for gender equality and women’s
empowerment in communities is generally limited especially in
conservative communities; this makes it difficult for youth to model
gender equitable behaviors as they may receive sanctions for this.
Individual vs Group Enterprises
Individual enterprises tend to favor girls and young mothers more compared to
the group enterprise model.
Program reports on group dynamics show that gender relations between boys
and girls in group enterprises lead to lower participation of girls in decision
making and activities.
In addition, reproductive roles of girls and young mothers mean that they may
not have the opportunity to manage their time in line with scheduled group
activities and therefore they are sometimes absent from group meetings and
activities.
Individual enterprises provide them with the flexibility to balance their
productive and reproductive roles in terms of time and location.
Exercise
What do you think are the divers of young women’s failure to effectively participate in
livelihoods programs and projects in your organization or community?
TYC experience in implementing other project on girls and young women social
inclusion shows the following as the drivers of women failure to effectively participate
livelihoods programs and initiatives:
Domestic violence in homes has been cited as a reason for inconsistent participation
by youth in learning activities such as school or other training opportunities.
Marriage of girls in livelihoods training programs has contributed to drop outs from
the
program.
Girls with babies find it difficult to participate in livelihoods training programs because
of child care responsibilities.
N:B There is anecdotal information from some Regions of Tanzania that shows that
participation in the program by girls contributes to a delay in early marriage and early
pregnancy among girls as marriages are postponed to enable a girl complete
the program.
Key Gender Considerations in Youth Livelihoods Programming
Conduct a gender assessment at the beginning of the project to identify any gender
gaps that need to be addressed and any potential harm as a result of the project
Develop a gender equality strategy and action plan to address these gender gaps and
barriers
Ensure collection of sex and age disaggregated data
Conduct continuous monitoring of impact of activities on girls and boys
Select learning centres that are deemed safe for girls and boys by parents in terms of
accessibility, safety and timing of classes
Select respected local facilitators who guarantee the safety of girls and boys in the
learning centres; Having a majority of female facilitators in the YiA program has
encouraged parents about the safety of their daughters.
Sometimes there is need to have flexible selection criteria for female facilitators as
they may have lower education levels but can undertake their roles effectively.
Single sex classes for girls have worked enormously well in the some youth livelihoods
especially because of the rigid gender norms around social interaction;
however, they involve more work which program and partner staff resist.
Provision of child care support during the learning phase for young mothers in the
Livelihood program has highlighted as a major advantage by young
mothers. This should be factored in programming for livelihoods programs.
Exposure visits to other villages and successful business have played a big role in
exposing girls and boys to what is possible. They develop new dreams and visions for
their future.
Facilitators, trainers and program staff also have their own gender biases and gender
issues that they need to deal with and which influence their engagement with youth in
livelihoods program. Without training and awareness on gender equality they may become
barriers to the livelihoods’ program being gender sensitive.
TYC experiences shows that training facilitators on the different learning
processes of girls and boys in the YLP programs has helped to increase
the participation of girls.
Follow up on drop outs and absenteeism by facilitators in the program
has significantly reduced drop outs as challenges are addressed.
Transferable skills in livelihoods’ programs enable growth in confidence
and communication skills especially among girls.
Consider specific life skills, information and services that may be
needed by girls and boys in the program that could be provided by
external facilitators or through linkage and referral. These include but
are not limited to the following:
osexual and reproductive health
ocommunication and negotiation skills
omanaging alcohol and substance abuse
opreventing and responding to gender based violence
oearly pregnancies and early marriage
omenstrual health management
oSafe migration
Consider gender norms regarding mobility of girls and women as well
as social interaction in mixed sex classes
Consider gender matching of mentors and facilitators for beneficiaries
depending on the social context
Role modelling for girls and boys is important in helping them visualize
what is possible and aspire for new goals
Consider ways of encouraging uptake of non-traditional livelihood
options for girls and boys as these challenge prevailing gender norms
e.g., young women can be encouraged to start up a barber shop business
or trade in building materials while young men can open laundry shop
businesses
Community awareness on promoting gender equality and addressing
gender based violence (GBV) in the program is crucial for providing an
enabling environment free of violence for both young women and men to
achieve their livelihood goals
Work with local partners to address GBV and gender inequality e.g., in
conducting community outreach activities and providing GBV prevention
and response services
Consider providing guidance in safe navigation of social media and
internet technology to avert cyber bulling and GBV; these can be provided
by local partners who have a strength in this.
Promote networking and linkage opportunities for girls and boys to
access markets and new opportunities
Incorporate advocacy opportunities in youth livelihoods programming
by marking events such as
o International Women’s Day (8th March)
o International Youth Day ( 12th August)
o Day of the African Child (16th June)
oNational Youth Week (7th to 14th October)
o International Day of the Girl Child (11th October)
o 16 Days of Activism against Gender Violence (25th November – 10th
December)
Session 7: Addressing Gender based Violence in Youth Livelihoods
Programs
This session seeks to share knowledge on gender based violence (GBV), how
to prevent it and respond to it. During the session, constant reference to the
youth livelihoods program should be made. GBV is often invisible and
participants may indicate that it does not happen among beneficiaries. This is
contrary to statistics and the fact that many cases are not reported.
Perpetrators are usually male but it should be emphasized that men and boys
also experience GBV. The content in this session can also be used as a basis
for community awareness.
Divide the groups into male and female groups the group do a role play of how
gender violence in the community the first from a young woman’s perspective
and the other from the young mans perspective.
Young woman’s perspective:
Create a role play that addresses questions such as the following:
o Who is the young woman?
o What is her history?
o What are her options?
o What do others say to her about the violence she experiences?
o What has made her vulnerable to violence?
Young man’s perspective:
Create a role play that addresses questions such as the following:
o How did he become violent?
o What made him violent?
o How does he treat other people?
o What do other people say about his violence?
o How does he feel when he is being violent?
o What is his life like, beyond the incidence of violence?
Key points to remembers
GBV has many forms and can happen to women, men, girls and boys
Many cases of GBV are unreported and you will find silent GBV survivors in
every social setting
GBV is a result of gender inequality and use of power in a negative way e.g.,
the increase of a young woman’s income and decision making capacity can
result in her male partner feeling threatened by her new independence and
ability and result in domestic violence
The program should always create a safe and enabling environment free
from GBV for staff and beneficiaries.
We need to work with local partners in raising awareness on the importance
of gender equality and women’s empowerment, how to prevent and respond to
GBV including setting up referral systems to support GBV survivors amongst
our female and male youth
Facilitator’s talking notes
Gender-based violence (GBV) is any verbal or physical act that results in bodily,
psychological, sexual and economic harm to somebody just because they are female or male.
GBV can be done by an intimate partner (husband/wife or boyfriend/girlfriend), a family
member, a neighbor, an acquaintance or a stranger.
GBV happens because one person chooses to exercise power and control over
another person. In our society, men and women are not yet equal. More value is given
to men than to women. As long as there is an imbalance of power between men and
women, GBV will continue.
GBV also happens when people do not know how to solve conflicts peacefully, or how
to build and maintain healthy relationships based on mutual respect. Learning these
skills will give people an alternative to GBV.
GBV also happens because we do not discuss it openly in our communities. When we
treat GBV as a private issue, we allow it to continue.
It is possible for men to experience GBV. However, most GBV is directed at women
and girls.
Why do we say ‘GBV survivors’ instead of ‘GBV victims’?
The word ‘victim’ can be stigmatizing because it implies that a person is powerless.
However, the word ‘survivor’ focuses on the future, and not on the abuse. This is
empowering.
Forms of GBV
Physical
Pushing, hitting, grabbing, beating, hair pulling, banging head on the floor or wall,
kicking, choking, burning, twisting arms, use of a weapon, female genital mutilation,
sexual cleansing or other harmful traditional practices, child neglect, etc.
Sexual
Forced sex/rape, marital rape, unwanted touching, grabbing sexual parts of the body,
inserting objects into someone’s private parts, coercion, unfaithfulness, making
someone do sexual things against their will, refusal to have protected sex, forced
prostitution, forced marriage, defilement, etc.
Why do we say ‘GBV survivors’ instead of ‘GBV victims’?
The word ‘victim’ can be stigmatizing because it implies that a person is powerless.
However, the word ‘survivor’ focuses on the future, and not on the abuse. This is
empowering.
Forms of GBV
Physical
Pushing, hitting, grabbing, beating, hair pulling, banging head on the floor or wall,
kicking, choking, burning, twisting arms, use of a weapon, female genital mutilation,
sexual cleansing or other harmful traditional practices, child neglect, etc.
Sexual
Forced sex/rape, marital rape, unwanted touching, grabbing sexual parts of the body,
inserting objects into someone’s private parts, coercion, unfaithfulness, making
someone do sexual things against their will, refusal to have protected sex, forced
prostitution, forced marriage, defilement, etc.
Economic
Withholding family finances, stopping someone from getting or keeping a job,
making someone ask for money or an allowance, demanding someone’s
earnings, spending jointly- earned family income without your spouse’s consent,
preventing someone from owning property or inheriting land, not allowing
someone to have money, denial of opportunities, such as education, etc.
Psychological
Shouting, swearing, insults, threatening violence, humiliating, locking someone
out of the house, criticizing, extreme jealousy, threatening to hurt the children,
threatening abandonment, constant questioning about someone’s activities,
child neglect, etc.
What are the causes of GBV?
It is widely understood that GBV is not caused by any single factor. Rather, it is a
combination of several factors that increase the risk of a man or woman
committing violence and the risk of a woman or man experiencing violence
o At the individual level these factors include the perpetrator being abused as a child
or witnessing marital violence in the home, having an absent or rejecting father, and
frequent use of alcohol.
o At the level of the family and relationship, cross-cultural studies have cited male
control of wealth and decision-making within the family and marital conflict as strong
predictors of abuse.
o At the community level women's isolation and lack of social support, together with
male peer groups that condone and legitimize men's violence.
o At the societal level studies around the world have found that violence against
women is most common where gender roles are rigidly defined and enforced and
where the concept of masculinity is linked to toughness, male honor, or dominance.
Other cultural norms associated with abuse include tolerance of physical punishment
of women and children, acceptance of violence as a means to settle interpersonal
disputes, and the perception that men have “ownership” of women.
At the root of GBV is the lack of recognition that men and women have equal
rights to life, dignity, protection, education, health and to actively participate in
family and community life.
What are the consequences of GBV?
Individuals who are abused – or who have been denied opportunity – cannot
fully participate in community life. Their ability to share their energy, ideas,
skills, talents and opinions with their families, communities, places of worship
and in the political process is lost when their bodies and minds are damaged
by GBV. GBV survivors often face stigmatization and discrimination. Violence
can cause health problems (including exposure to HIV infection), sadness,
isolation, and a loss of self-confidence and income in individuals.
In families, GBV creates an unpredictable and frightening environment.
Children learn to fear the abuser, and they worry about the parent who is
being abused. Children who grow up in violent homes learn that violence and
aggression are acceptable ways of expressing emotions or resolving conflicts.
These children are more likely to leave home at an early age and to commit
acts of violence in their own homes when they become adults.
Our community also pays a high price for GBV. Businesses lose money due
to the ill health of employees who are abused. Responding to GBV including
law enforcement, health services, court and legal proceedings, and social
services requires both money and staff.
Violence is not a sign of discipline and love; it is a sign of domination and
control.
Although GBV usually happens in private, it is NOT a private issue. It affects
families, communities, and the entire country.