Literature Review Matrix

By Group 8:
 Muhammad Abel Pratama
 Frisca Amelia
 Firda Susanti Fauzi
 Giwangga Moch Fernanda
Research Proposal Title: Implementation of Citizen Lawsuit to Resolve Environmental Disputes in Indonesia

Authors, Year
Study overview Study Study
Published & Source Conclusions Limitations Strengths Gap Fulfillment
/purpose methodology participants
Title

Paskalina Google This study aims This study uses Every Although the judges considered that the This study didn't Explaining Our research will
Emadewani Scholar to determine the a type of citizen of citizen's lawsuit was partially granted, mention about how detailed about the discuss regarding
(2019) judge's normative legal Indonesia the judge also gave consideration to the Application of Citizen Lawsuit the Application of
considerations research that is reject the provisional demands Citizen lawsuit in and analysis the Citizen Lawsuit in
in granting part descriptive. submitted by the Plaintiffs. According other countries court decision other countries
of citizen Then regarding to the judge examining the case, the related to Citizen
‘PERTIMBAN lawsuits in the research Lawsuit
GAN HAKIM provisional demands submitted by the
environmental approach, this
MENGABULK Plaintiffs have entered the main point
cases. study uses a
AN GUGATAN case approach of the case.
CITIZEN (case studies). A
LAWSUIT case study
DALAM approach is a
PERKARA study of a case
LINGKUNGA viewed from
N HIDUP ‘ various legal
aspects.
Prisky S. Google This research Normative Every Forms of lawsuits that can be applied This study didn't Discussing about Our research will
Sasuwuk (2018) Scholar was conducted Legal Research citizen of in disputes over damage and analysis the Citizen Comparison of be discuss
Authors, Year
Study overview Study Study
Published & Source Conclusions Limitations Strengths Gap Fulfillment
/purpose methodology participants
Title

with the aim of with a statutory Indonesia, environmental pollution, according to Lawsuit in detailed, every alternative comprehensively
know how approach and a Law the provisions of Law No. 32 of 2009 only in brief dispute resolution the Citizen
‘ALTERNATIF Forms Lawsuits conceptual Enforcement in Environmental Lawsuit in theory
are regarding the right to sue the explanation.
PENYELESAIA for approach, where Officials cases also in practice
N SENGKETA community and environmental
Environmental with this organizations. These two types of
LINGKUNGAN
Pollution and approach lawsuits are a direct application of the
MENURUT
Destruction researchers will
UNDANG- element of interest the law that creates
Disputes and get information
UNDANG NO. a relationship law indirectly. Lawsuit
how are the from various
32 TAHUN 2009 community (class action) and the right
TENTANG
Legal aspects of legal
Arrangements issues that being to sue environmental organizations
PERLINDUNGA
Regarding researched, (legal standing), these two types of
N DAN
Alternative trying to find lawsuits are new known closely since
PENGELOLAAN
LINGKUNGAN Environmental the answer. the issuance of Supreme Court
HIDUP ‘ Dispute Regulation No. 1 of 2002. Then in Law
Resolutions. No. Law No. 32 of 2009 this is
confirmed again through article 91 and
article 92. Besides There is a form of
lawsuit called the government's right to
sue (Article 90) and do the citizen
lawsuit

Faradina Naviah Google This study This research is Every The existence of a legal transplant This study didn't Comprehensively Our research will
(2013) Scholar intends to get an a descriptive citizen of makes the citizen lawsuit mechanism compare the discuss about be discuss
overview of normative or Indonesia, known in the common law legal system Application of Citizen Lawsuit comprehensively
how the citizen doctrinal legal law to be applied in civil procedural law in Citizen Lawsuit in with real cases about comparison
lawsuit research, using a enforcement Indonesia Indonesia is influenced by Indonesia with the application of
‘PENERAPAN mechanism, case approach. officials Citizen Lawsuit in
MEKANISME the civil law legal system. Based on the other countries
which is known Indonesia with
GUGATAN transplant process a law that can
in the common other countries
CITIZEN change according to the transplanted
law legal
LAWSUIT system, can be legal system and is based on on the
DALAM applied to civil imperative or coercive nature of civil
procedural law, the panel of judges
Authors, Year
Study overview Study Study
Published & Source Conclusions Limitations Strengths Gap Fulfillment
/purpose methodology participants
Title

HUKUM procedural law uses the applicable civil procedural law

ACARA in Indonesia as a guideline in examining citizen
PERDATA DI which has been lawsuits.
INDONESIA ‘ influenced by
the civil law
legal system as
well as the
procedural basis
and
considerations
used by judges.
in examining
and deciding
citizen lawsuits
Humaira Google The purpose of This study uses Every Citizen lawsuits in their development This is study only Comprehensively Our research will
Khoirunnisa, Scholar this study is to a normative citizen of are present in countries that adhere to explaining in discuss about how be discuss
Shafa Amalia see the legal research Indonesia, the common law system such as briefly concerning the Citizen comprehensively
Choirinnisa, Implementation method that Law America, Australia and India. In the Comparison of lawsuit can be about comparison
Raden of Citizen aims to obtain enforcement Indonesia, currently there is no special Citizen Lawsuit in applied in the application of
Muhammad Lawsuit where materials in the officials regulation that regulates citizen other countries and Indonesia Citizen Lawsuit in
the regulation of form of Indonesia with
Arvy Ilyasa lawsuits, but there are still several didn't mention
the citizen principles, other countries
(2021) regulations that can be used as reasons about the
lawsuits in theories, and how the
Indonesia itself concepts, and for the presence of such lawsuits, such mechanism of the mechanism of the
‘QUO VADIS: as Article 10 of Law Number 48 of citizen lawsuit
PENERAPAN has not been legal regulations citizen lawsuit
clearly related to the 2009 concerning Judicial Power, Law
CITIZEN Number 32 of 2009 concerning
regulated, but subject matter in
LAWSUIT Protection and Management
this step can be this paper.
SEBAGAI taken as an Environment, etc.
UPAYA alternative to
PERLINDUNG demand the
AN fulfillment of
TERHADAP state
LINGKUNGA responsibilities.
Authors, Year
Study overview Study Study
Published & Source Conclusions Limitations Strengths Gap Fulfillment
/purpose methodology participants
Title

N HIDUP ‘

Rizky Google This study aims This research is Every Citizen lawsuit is a mechanism that This study not This study Our research will
Ramadhani Scholar to provide an a type of citizen of opens up access to justice for people comparing the comprehensively be discuss
Kurniawan overview of the normative legal Indonesia, who are victims of actions (by Application of explain how the comprehensively
(2017) citizen lawsuit research with a Law commission) or negligence (by Citizen Lawsuit in relation between about comparison
in addition to formal enforcement ommission) caused by the state in the Indonesia with Citizen Lawsuit the application of
trying to answer normative officials environmental sector. The link between other countries and Right to Citizen Lawsuit in
questions, how juridical Environment, also Indonesia with
‘Integrasi human rights, citizen lawsuits, and the
is the approach. explaining about other countries
Citizen Lawsuit right to the environment is in the
relationship Citizen Lawsuit is
sebagai Hak between human meaning of state authorities, where in line with
Prosedural atas rights, citizen state authorities that carry out public Indonesia Legal
Lingkungan lawsuits, and the interests need to be monitored using a System
Hidup dalam right to the citizen lawsuit mechanism.
Dimensi HAM ‘ environment;
and how to
integrate citizen
lawsuits into in
national law