Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Five men undertook two intensive interval training bility to infection, and increased susceptibility to
sessions per day for 10 days, followed by 5 days of active stress fractures3.
recovery. Subjects supplied a venous blood sample and We have previously presented evidence that
completed a mood-state questionnaire on days 1, 6, 11 and intensive training can cause perturbations in phy-
16 of the study. Performance capabilities were assessed on siological processes involving the immune system
days 1, 11 and 16 using a timed treadmill test to exhaustion and central nervous system16. In this article, we
at 18kmh-1 and 1% grade. These individuals became
acutely overtrained as indicated by significant reductions present additional findings on immune system
in running performance from day 1 to day 11. The functioning and discuss psychological reactions to
overtrained state was accompanied by severe fatigue, acute overtraining. Physiological processes that may
immune system deficits, mood disturbance, physical be associated with these psychological changes are
complaints, sleep difficulties, and reduced appetite. Mood described, and a rationale for using both physiolog-
states moved toward baseline during recovery, but ical and psychological measures to screen for the
feelings of fatigue and immune system deficits persisted onset of overtraining is established. Recognition of
throughout the study. overtraining in its initial stages may allow interven-
Keywords: Overtraining, mood, immunity, interleukin-2, tion and prevent athletes from progressing to a more
psychoneuroendocrinology serious stage of the overtraining syndrome3.
items associated with each of the seven subscales are Table 1. Symptoms reported during acute overtraining (c.f. Fry
described in detail by Grove and Prapavessis17. Since etal. 1992)16
short-term mood effects were the focus of this study,
we employed the 'how are you feeling today' Category Symptom*
response set.
General fatigue Feel lethargic (all)
Exhausted during the day (2)
Interleukin-2 assay system Ordinary tasks are an effort (2)
Tired in the afternoon (3)
The interleukin-2 (IL-2) assay was adapted from that Just walking around is an effort (5)
described by Gearing, Johnstone and Thorpe19. In Getting out of bed is hard (5)
brief, 50 [il of CTLL cells at 2 x 105 cells per ml were No interest in everyday tasks (5)
Emotionality A bit quick-tempered (1)
seeded into the wells of a 96-well culture plate Emotionally unstable (2)
(Linbro, Horsham, Pennsylvania, USA) and a stan- Shorter fuse than normal (2)
dard recombinant IL-2 preparation was serially Snappiness at work (4)
diluted over the cultures. Samples of serum and Personality change (5)
culture media from peripheral blood leucocytes Concentration Spasmodic concentration (1)
difficulties Failure to remember things (2)
stimulated with concanavalin A were serially diluted Unable to narrow concentration (3)
over a similar set of cultures. After 24h culture at Difficult to focus/hold concentration (4)
370C in a humidified atmosphere of 5% CO2, 0.5 [tCi Concentration 'out the window' (5)
of 3H-6-thymidine (5 Ci mmol-1, Amersham, UK) Physical complaints Sore muscles (all)
were added to all wells, and 18h later the cultures Dehydrated (1)
Heavy feeling in upper legs (2)
were harvested on to glass fibre filter (Whatman, Stomach complaints/nausea (3)
Maidstone, UK) using a Skatron cell harvester Loose bowels (3)
(Skatron, Lieberyen, Norway) and the radioactivity Diarrhoea (4)
incorporated into DNA determined by liquid scintilla- Sleep problems Restless sleeping patterns (1)
Sometimes difficult to get to sleep (2)
tion. The results were expressed as the number of Have trouble getting to sleep (4)
IL-2 units present in the preparations in comparison Appetite changes Loss of appetite (1, 2)
with the standard curve. Not able to eat well (4)
Table 2. Changes in physiological and performance measures during acute overtraining (days 1, 6 and 11) and recovery (day 16)
Values are mean(s.e.m.); FERR, ferritin; GLUC, blood glucose; NA, not available. *Significantly different, P< 0.01; tsignificantly different,
P< 0.001; tindicates significant mean differences from pre-training (day 1) values
training period (day 11) and the recovery period (day Discussion
16) in both the serum and mitogen-stimulated cell
culture supernatants. Plasma glutamine concentra- The overtraining and chronic fatigue syndromes are
tions were significantly depressed on day 6 and day well documented in the medical literature20, and they
11 but had begun to return to before-exercise levels appear to have similar pathogenesis and symp-
by day 16 of the study. Subjects had increasing toms3'21 22. By examining changes that occur during
difficulty completing the prescribed training as the acute overtraining, we may gain insight into the
overload training period progressed, and over the aetiology of these conditions as well as the interrela-
last few days they reported feeling nauseous in the tionships among the immune system, the central
final stages of the training sessions (see Table 1). nervous system and the neuroendocrine axis. It is
known that increased levels of stress can induce a
Mood state responses deranged immunological and neuroendocrine status,
and that such imbalances are sometimes associated
The abbreviated POMS revealed a significant increase with psychopathology6'7'9,'12,20, 22-25 The results of
in the subscale measuring fatigue after the first 5 days this study indicate that acute overtraining can also
of training. Fatigue scores were elevated even further cause imbalances in the immune system and, at the
at the conclusion of the training period (day 11) and same time, produce negative psychological consequ-
then moved toward the baseline during the recovery ences such as mood disturbance, fatigue/lethargy,
phase (day '16). The fatigue ratings after recovery and (perhaps) an inability to concentrate. Similar
were, however, still significantly greater than base- symptoms are known to occur in certain psycho-
line levels. A significant decrease in vigour and a pathological states12'25.
significant increase in total mood disturbance (TMD) The subjects in this study were clearly overtrained
were also evident at the conclusion of training (day as indicated by significantly depressed performance
11), with a return toward baseline following the capacity at the end of the 10-day training period.
active recovery period (day 16). Confusion scores After 5 days of recovery, running performance
tended to increase during the training phase moved toward baseline but was still depressed by
(P < 0.05), but this change was not significant more than 2%. Changes in the psychological vari-
according to the criterion used in this study. (See ables supported these performance findings and
Table 3.) were consistent with findings from other studies of
Table 3. Abbreviated Profile of Mood States measures during acute overtraining (days 1, 6 and 11) and recovery (day 16)
Values are mean(s.e.m.); TMD, Total mood disturbance; *significantly different from day 1 (P< 0.001); ttendency toward difference from
day 1 (P< 0.05); $indicates significant differences from before-training (day 1) values
overtraining in sport26. The comments in Table 1 and feedback loop involved, because it is known that
the POMS responses (Table 3) show that subjects immune system perturbations can affect the produc-
were experiencing negative psychological states as a tion of ferritin. For example, tumour necrosis factor is
consequence of the exercise intervention. All partici- a known enhancer of the gene controlling the
pants referred to concentration difficulties on the production of ferritinM. Decreased ferritin levels may
open-ended symptoms questionnaire, and the POMS affect central nervous system processes via an effect
confusion scores tended to increase between day 1 on the immune system and by the decreased oxygen
and day 11. In addition, TMD, vigour and fatigue delivery which occurs during hypoferraemia.
were significantly altered by the training regimen, In summary, psychological and immunological
and fatigue scores remained elevated even after 5 effects from acute overtraining were obtained in this
days of active recovery. Blood glucose levels fell study, but the time course of these effects differed.
significantly between day 1 and day 11 but returned Changes in immune system activity were apparent
to baseline on day 16. Significant increases in the after 5 days of intensive training and were still
activation level of peripheral blood lymphocytes present after 5 days of recovery. POMS fatigue scores
(CD25+, HLA-DR+, CD3+:CD25+ ratio) and signifi- followed a similar pattern, but POMS confusion and
cant decreases in natural killer cell activity were TMD demonstrated shorter-term changes. On the
evident as early as day 6 and were still present after basis of these findings, we suggest that physiological
recovery. IL-2 levels also increased in response to the mechanisms may mediate some of the mood changes
exercise intervention and remained elevated after associated with overtraining, and that psychological
recovery. monitoring of overtraining can be useful if supported
Nonspecific, general activation of the immune by physiological measurements. We encourage other
system (documented in this study by changes in the researchers to examine psychological and immunolo-
CD25+, HLA-DR+, CD3+:CD25+, serum IL-2, and gical responses to acute and chronic overtraining,
supernatant IL-2 variables) is accompanied by a range since the key to early diagnosis and treatment may lie
of nonspecific symptoms of illness. These symptoms in this area.
include loss of interest in usual activities, poor
appetite, weight loss, sleep changes, decreased social References
investigation, loss of energy, fatigue, irritability and
anorexia4 10'23'2732 Altered immune status is also 1 Parry-Billings M, Blomstrand E, McAndrew N, Newsholme
EA. A communicational link between skeletal muscle, brain,
known to affect the hypothalamic-pituitary and cells of the immune system. Int I Sports Med 1990; 11:
axis7'9,33-39 and may be responsible for the hypo- S122-8.
thalamic-pituitary dysfunction and hypothyroidism 2 Budgett R Overtraining syndrome. Br I Sports Med 1990; 24:
known to occur in overtrained athletes'4"15. Imba- 231-6.
lances in these control systems may cause feelings of 3 Fry RW, Morton AR, Keast D. Overtraining in athletes - an
chronic fatigue and may also be responsible for many update. Sports Med 1991; 12: 32-65.
4 Lever AML, Lewis DM, Bannister BA. Interferon production
of the overtraining symptoms previously reported in postviral fatigue syndrome. Lancet 1988; ii: 101.
including amenorrhoea, osteoporosis, and altered 5 Rabin BS, Ganguli R, Cunnick JE, Lysle DT. The central
testosterone levels3. Hypothyroidism has been re- nervous system-immune system relationship. Autoimmune
ported in both the chronic fatigue syndrome and Diseases: Clin Lab Med 1988; 8: 253-68.
6 Lloyd AR, Wakefield D, Boughton CR, Dwyer JM. Immuno-
overtraining syndrome'0"5 4043 logical abnormalities in the chronic fatigue syndrome. Med J
We have shown elsewhere that acute overtraining Aust 1989; 151: 122-4.
resulted in depressed levels of plasma glutamine for 7 Rabin BS, Cohen S, Ganguli R, Lysle DT, Cunnick JC.
the subjects in this study44, and these findings are in Bidirectional interactions between the central nervous system
and the immune system. Crit Rev Immunol 1989; 9: 279-312.
agreement with those of Parry-Billings and col- 8 Gorman JM, Kertzner R Psychoneuroimmunology and HIV
leagues' who found depressed plasma glutamine infection. Journal of Neuropsychiatry and Clinical Neuroscience
concentrations in overtrained athletes. Glutamine is 1990; 2: 241-52.
an important neurotransmitter precursor and is also 9 Arnason BG. Nervous system-immune system communica-
an essential nutrient for the cells of the immune tion. Reviews of Infectious Diseases 1991; 13: S134-7.
10 Buchwald D, Komaroff AL. Review of laboratory findings for
system45-48. Parry-Billings et al.1 also found that patients with chronic fatigue syndrome. Reviews of Infectious
levels of tryptophan (which is converted in the brain Diseases 1991; 13: S12-18.
to the neurotransmitter 5-hydroxytryptamine) and 11 La Via MF, Workman EA. Psychoneuroimmunology: where
dopamine (another neurotransmitter) are both al- are we, where are we going? Recenti Progressi in Medicina 1991;
82: 637-41.
tered under conditions of excessive exercise stress. It 12 Grafman J, Johnson R, Scheffers M. Cognitive and mood-
is possible that alterations in the concentrations of state changes in patients with chronic fatigue syndrome.
these neurotransmitters may be partly responsible for Reviews of Infectious Diseases 1991; 13: S45-52.
the psychological perturbations observed in this 13 Sperner-Unterweger B, Barnas C, Fuchs D, Kemmler G et al.
study. In particular, there is evidence that 5- Psychiatry Res 1992; 42: 121-8.
14 Barron JL, Noakes TD, Levy W, Smith C, Millar RP.
hydroxytryptamine is the neurotransmitter respon- Hypothalamic dysfunction in overtrained athletes. I Clin End
sible for causing a state of tiredness and sleep in both Met 1985; 60: 803-6.
man and experimental animals2'49. 15 Lathan SR Chronic fatigue? Consider hypothyroidism.
Plasma ferritin concentrations fell progressively Physician and Sportsmedicine 1991; 19: 67-70.
over the course of the experiment to reach their 16 Fry RW, Morton AR, Garcia-Webb P. Craford GPM, Keast D.
Biological responses to overload training in endurance sports.
lowest levels on day 16 (Table 2). Chronic hypofer- Eur J Appi Physiol 1992; 64: 335-44.
raemia can have immunomodulatory effects and 17 Grove JR, Prapavessis H. Preliminary evidence for the
induce feelings of fatigue 053 There may also be a reliability and validity of an abbreviated Profile of Mood