You are on page 1of 8

Original Article

Parenting Challenges and Reasons for Not


Availing Rehabilitation Services Among
Families of Adolescents with Autism
Spectrum Disorder: A Qualitative Study
Fathima Noori1, Shivani Tiwari1 , Sebastian Padickaparambil2 and Dan Isaac Pothiyil2

ABSTRACT the rehabilitation services and parental discontinuation of rehabilitation services


as well as various parenting challenges
challenges among primary caregivers
Background: Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) of adolescents with ASD, and their among primary caregivers of adolescents
is a lifelong condition requiring continued corresponding subthemes. The reasons for with ASD relevant to the Indian context.
rehabilitation services. However, children discontinuation of rehabilitation included These findings have implications for
with ASD who seek rehabilitation services financial difficulties, difficulties in handling mental health care professionals and
tend to drop out once they enter puberty, the child, and a lack of improvement in the policymakers.

A
because of varying reasons, some of which child. A few of the parental challenges were
are unknown. This study intended to explore utism spectrum disorder (ASD) is
disruptive behaviors and associated medical
the reasons for not availing of rehabilitation a neurodevelopmental disorder
conditions of the child and difficulty in
services in families of adolescents with ASD managing changes during adolescence. characterized by impairments in
and the parental challenges in taking care of verbal and nonverbal communication,
adolescents with ASD. Conclusion: The study revealed several
social interactions, as well as restrictive
reasons as well as potential barriers to
Method: The study followed a descriptive or repetitive behaviors that persist well
avail rehabilitation services in Indian
qualitative research design by conducting families of adolescents with ASD. The data into adulthood.1 Early rehabilitation ser-
in-depth interviews with 12 primary further unveil related parenting challenges vices are always preferred for children
caregivers of adolescents with ASD (10 to specific to the Indian context. Further, with ASD; yet, the need for ongoing reha-
19 years; mean age 16.3 years) who were implications for service providers and bilitation services planned explicitly for
not availing of any direct rehabilitation policymakers are discussed. adolescents with ASD cannot be under-
services. All interviews were conducted
Keywords: Adolescents, autism spectrum estimated. Given the range of difficulties
by telephone, and data obtained were
disorder, rehabilitation, parental challenges and issues that change over time, there
subjected to thematic analysis.
is a need to provide continuous rehabil-
Results: The results showed two major Key Messages: Findings from the
study reveal salient reasons for the itation services to make adolescents with
themes, viz. reasons for discontinuing

1
Dept. of Speech and Hearing, Manipal College of Health Professions, Manipal Academy of Higher Education, Manipal, Karnataka, India. 2Dept. of Clinical
Psychology, Manipal College of Health Professions, Manipal Academy of Higher Education, Manipal, Karnataka, India.

HOW TO CITE THIS ARTICLE: Noori F, Tiwari S, Padickaparambil S and Pothiyil DI. Parenting Challenges and Reasons for Not Availing
Rehabilitation Services Among Families of Adolescents with Autism Spectrum Disorder: A Qualitative Study. Indian J Psychol Med.
2023;45(3):263–270.
Address for correspondence: Shivani Tiwari, Dept. Speech and Hearing, Manipal
Submitted: 30 Jul. 2021
College of Health Professions, Manipal Academy of Higher Education, Manipal,
Accepted: 09 Apr. 2022
Karnataka 576104, India.
Published Online: 23 Jun. 2022
E-mail: tiwarishivani.2009@gmail.com

Copyright © The Author(s) 2022

Creative Commons Non Commercial CC BY-NC: This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative ACCESS THIS ARTICLE ONLINE
Commons Attribution- NonCommercial 4.0 License (http://www.creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/)
Website: journals.sagepub.com/home/szj
which permits non-Commercial use, reproduction and distribution of the work without further permission
provided the original work is attributed as specified on the Sage and Open Access pages (https:// DOI: 10.1177/02537176221096769
us.sagepub.com/en-us/nam/open-access-at-sage).

Indian Journal of Psychological Medicine | Volume 45 | Issue 3 | May 2023 263


Noori et al.
ASD lead independent or semi-indepen- facilities. This brings us to the research experienced by primary caregivers
dent lives in adulthood.2 While several question, “What are the reasons for was prepared based on the literature
children with ASD seek rehabilitation nonavailing of rehabilitation services in search and expert opinion (Appendix A,
services, many tend to drop out once families of adolescents with ASD?” Given online-only supplementary material).
they enter puberty3 because of varying this need, this study aimed to explore the Permissions were obtained from the
reasons that often remain unknown. It is reasons for not availing of rehabilitation respective centers for collecting data. All
assumed that availing of long-term sup- services and parental challenges and primary caregivers were screened as
port services for adolescents with ASD issues in families of adolescents with per the study criteria. After obtaining
may be compromised because of parent- ASD within the cultural context of India. consent, the first author carried out one-
or client-related issues.4 to-one in-depth telephonic interviews at a
Families of adolescents with ASD Method time provided by individual participants
experience significant difficulties in tran- This study employed a qualitative design as per their convenience. The interview
sitioning to adult medical care. A few where data was collected using in-depth started by explaining the purpose of the
barriers to accessing health or rehabili- interviews and was subjected to the- study, guaranteeing confidentiality, and
tation services are financial hardships to matic analysis.13 seeking demographic details. As the ques-
cover services for their children, difficulty tioning strategy was responsive to each
in getting insurance reimbursement for Participants participant, the interviewer used probes
needed services,5 and unavailability of to clarify comments and elicit in-depth
services.6 Other barriers faced by families Participants were recruited from an ASD explanations. An android application,
include lack of information on the tran- (parent) support group and a special Cube ACR, was used to record the consent
sition process, difficulty finding a service school (previous records of children with and the complete telephonic interviews.
provider with sufficient ASD knowledge, ASD who discontinued schooling) in the The data were collected from January to
lack of coordination and communication South-Indian state of Kerala. A purposive March 2021.
between service providers,7 and difficulty sampling procedure was used to recruit
the participants. Participants for the
in receiving transition plan for adoles-
study were the parents or the primary Coding and Analysis
cents with ASD.5
Primary caregivers of children with caregivers (who took care of and spent All obtained samples were played back
ASD play a key role in facilitating con- most time of the day with the patient) and transliterated offline to ensure the
tinued access to various rehabilitation of adolescents (age range 10 to 19 years, accuracy of information. All transcripts
services to facilitate overall develop- as per the WHO14) with ASD who had were further read and verified against
ment. Providing intensive and adequate received the diagnosis of ASD from a the audio recordings by an external
care to an adolescent with ASD is always psychiatrist and/or clinical psychologist, reviewer and native speaker of the lan-
an enduring task for the parents or care- who were not availing of any direct reha- guage of the interview. Saturation of
givers. Many parents reported a negative bilitation services (i.e., speech therapy, data was observed after the ninth par-
impact on their recreational activities, occupational therapy, special education ticipant. However, data were collected
finances, physical and mental health, services at school, behavioral therapy, for additional three participants to ascer-
marital relationships, and personal and vocational training) for a minimum tain the same. The verified transcripts
development.8 Furthermore, parental period of two years. The details on were read systematically and analyzed
misconceptions and guilt,9,10 behavioral autism severity in adolescents with ASD using a six-phase thematic analysis.15
problems, and social and emotional dif- were obtained from the medical records. These steps involved familiarizing with
ficulties11 in adolescents with ASD could Families having adolescents with ASD the data (transcripts), followed by the
lead to unfavorable effects on the mental having severe degenerative conditions generation of names/initial codes that
and physical health and quality of life of (e.g., Rett’s disorder, childhood disinte- addressed respective research questions.
the parents, especially the mother.12 grative disorder, or Fragile X-syndrome) Statements that illustrated the essence of
There is a lack of information regard- and/or with vision or hearing impair- each code were highlighted and assigned
ing access barriers to rehabilitation ment(s) were excluded. The interview numbers to locate the codes within the
services in parents of adolescents with was carried out in the local language, transcripts. Subsequently, these initial
ASD not receiving rehabilitation ser- Malayalam, by the first author, a native codes were reviewed by the second
vices. The above-presented literature speaker of the language. author in order to retain the diversity of
is largely from the families who either the initial codes. Finally, the codes were
never availed of or were availing of reha-
Procedure checked and discussed by all the authors.
bilitation services for adolescents with The study protocol was approved by the Verification of data integrity was done
ASD. To the best of our knowledge, none Institutional Research and the Insti- with the involvement of an external
of the studies have particularly inves- tutional Ethics Committee (589-2020) reviewer. The codes from the external
tigated the reasons for discontinuing and registered under the Clinical Trials reviewer were compared, and discrepan-
rehabilitation services in this popula- Registry-India (CTRI/2021/01/030172). cies were discussed within the research
tion. This particular gap in knowledge is A semi-structured interview guide team. A code list was generated after
more crucial in a developing nation with eliciting reasons for not availing of reha- coding the entire data. For the purpose
limited resources and health insurance bilitation services and parental challenges of analysis and presentation of the
264 Indian Journal of Psychological Medicine | Volume 45 | Issue 3 | May 2023
Original Article
result, all participants were anonymized, care of adolescents with ASD, and cor- Reaching there and getting back on time
and excerpts were identified by the nota- responding subthemes, as provided in was all difficult for me …” (M11)
tion of mother (M) and father (F) with Table 2.
an accompanying participant number
(Appendix B, online-only supplementary Reasons for Discontinuing Need for the Parent to
material). Rehabilitation Services Accompany the Child
Accompanying the child to the rehabil-
Results Caregivers described a range of reasons
itation center was difficult for working
for the discontinuation of the rehabili-
A total of 12 primary caregivers (11 parents and mothers with household
tation services, which are discussed in
mothers and one father) of adolescents responsibilities, who also had to attend
forthcoming sections.
with ASD (mean age = 16.3 years; SD = to the needs of younger siblings or old
2.74 years) participated in the interview. parents. As in the case of participant M6,
As reported by them, the commonly Logistic Difficulties the child could not be sent to school unac-
availed rehabilitation services (before Caregivers stated logistic reasons like companied because of repeated seizures,
discontinuation) included school-based distant rehabilitation center, difficulty which the mother believed would be
special education, speech and language in dropping and bringing the child back troublesome for the teachers to handle.
therapy, occupational therapy, and phys- home, difficulty staying at a distant place The parents, too, could not accompany
iotherapy. The average duration for each (from home) to avail rehabilitation ser- the child to the special school; hence, they
interview was approximately 45 min. vices, and long wait time, e.g., one of the stopped the services. Parents had to spare
Table 1 presents the demographic details parents had to wait for six months before time in the midst of their busy sched-
of caregivers and adolescents with ASD. starting the therapy, though they were ules, as rehabilitation centers and special
The results revealed two main themes, interested in continuing the rehabilita- schools demanded the parents be with the
i.e., major reasons or barriers for not tion services. child all the time, which was not feasible.
availing the rehabilitation services and “Because of travelling issue, I couldn’t “To whichever school we took him,
challenges faced by parents in taking take him to special school afterward. whenever we asked, they informed that

TABLE 1.

Details of Primary Caregivers and Adolescents with ASD.


Primary Caregiver Adolescent with ASD
Associated health
Relation to Educational Place of Family Age Age at Autism conditions/
S. No. the child Age (years) qualification living type Sex (years) diagnosis severity comorbidity
M1 Mother 36 Graduate Urban Nuclear Male 19 3 years Moderate Irritable bowel
9 months syndrome
M2 Mother 39 Graduate Urban Nuclear Male 14 4 years Mild –
F3 Father 43 10th standard Rural Joint Female 19 9 years Severe Epilepsy, cerebral
palsy
M4 Mother 40 Fifth stan- Rural Joint Male 19 3 years Severe Epilepsy, intellectual
dard disability
M5 Mother 38 Eighth stan- Rural Joint Female 18 3 years Severe Difficulty to walk,
dard epilepsy
M6 Mother 45 Graduate Rural Joint Male 12 2 years Moderate Epilepsy
5 months
M7 Mother 42 Graduate Urban Joint Male 15 1 year Moderate –
6 months
M8 Mother 38 Graduate Urban Joint Male 13 5 years Severe Epilepsy, intellectual
disability
M9 Mother 39 Graduate Urban Nuclear Male 13 3 years Mild –
M10 Mother 37 10th standard Rural Joint Female 18 8 years Severe Intellectual dis-
ability
M11 Mother 49 Graduate Rural Nuclear Female 17 3 years Moderate Epilepsy

M12 Mother 51 Eighth stan- Rural Nuclear Male 19 4 years Moderate –


dard
ASD, Autism Spectrum Disorders.

Indian Journal of Psychological Medicine | Volume 45 | Issue 3 | May 2023 265


Noori et al.
TABLE 2.
“With father’s low-income work, it is
difficult for us to meet daily therapy
Overview of Themes and Subthemes Identified. charges, and expenses are unaffordable
Themes Subthemes for us…” (M6)
Reasons for discontinuing Logistic difficulties
rehabilitation services Need for the parent to accompany the child Family Commitments
Difficulty in handling the child
Caregivers expressed their involvement
Financial difficulties
Family commitments with household commitments resulting
Lack of satisfaction with the existing treatment in an inability to spare time for attend-
Lack of improvement ing rehabilitation services. One of the
Adverse effects of medication mothers reported that she had to discon-
Parental challenges in taking care Difficulty in managing the changes during adolescence tinue the child’s therapy after delivering
of the child Disruptive behaviors of the child the second child. Another mother stated
Difficulty to manage the child outdoors
Associated medical conditions of the child that it was difficult for her to take her
Worries about the cognitive abilities of the child child to a special school as she had to care
Feeling embarrassed at societal responses for her sick mother-in-law at home.
Comparison with other children causes emotional turmoil
Being apprehensive about the child’s uncertain future “I was the only one there to take care
Insecurity regarding the safety of the child of his sick and bedridden mother...
Absence of guidance by service providers So I couldn’t manage to take him for
Loss of confidence
therapy…” (M6)

Lack of Satisfaction with


the child cannot attend the therapy or for the mother to take him for therapy
the school without parent…told me on time, which often resulted in the can- the Existing Treatment
to be with him throughout the school cellation of the sessions and eventually Parents narrated varied experiences and
time…” (M8) led to the discontinuation of therapy. levels of satisfaction with the treatment
A few parents (M4 and M8) reported and rehabilitation team. Many parents
Difficulty for Parents that the toileting and behavioral issues (M1, M4, and M7) were not satisfied with
were unmanageable such that the child
and Service Providers could not be sent to school or anywhere
the services the child received at the reha-
bilitation center and reported enrolling
in Handling the Child in outside. A mother recollected an incident their child in the rehabilitation center as
Rehabilitation Centre when special educators in her son’s class a bad decision. Parents expressed concern
resigned from their job because of the about the child not getting enough atten-
Many parents expressed difficulty han- child’s behavioral and toileting issues. tion from the service providers. Another
dling a child with ASD as a major reason Another parent eventually had to dis- mother (M1) stated that contrary to her
for discontinuing the rehabilitation continue rehabilitation as the child’s expectation (of the child getting indi-
services. Behavioral issues, toileting behavior deteriorated remarkably fol- vidual attention), the special educator
issues, health issues like irritable bowel lowing the relapse of epilepsy. One of was available only once a week. One
syndrome, sleep disorder, and frequent the mothers was interested in restarting parent expressed her discontent over the
seizures were some of the major chal- intervention, yet worried if the new ther- treatment while expecting to have a reha-
lenges faced by the parents, making apist would be able to handle the child bilitation professional who would be able
it difficult for the parents and service like the previous therapist. to handle the child properly. She also had
providers to manage the child, which expectations of learning more about a
ultimately led to the discontinuation of Financial Difficulties few of the Alternative and Augmentative
rehabilitation services.  Communication (AAC) programs, which
Financial problem was yet another
“His condition is such that he cannot reason for discontinuing the rehabilita- were not met.
be left in the school alone because he tion therapy or not enrolling children “I thought he would get more attention
falls down following seizure… That with ASD in any centers because charges at special school than normal school,
being the case, it might be difficult for for speech therapy and occupational and special educators would be more
the teachers to handle him in such situ- therapy were fairly high and unafford- understanding and skilled to handle
ations…” (M6) able for many parents (M4 and M6). It such children with special needs.
was an enormous expense for the family With all these thoughts, I put him in
A mother explained an incident when her to meet the cost of the individual therapy a special school. What to say…Most
child with ASD became unmanageably session(s) with the father’s low income. of the time, he was left unattended at
violent on the way to the special school, Some parents expressed financial con- special school…special educators and
after which the child was not sent to the straints to meet travel expenses and administrators will be engaged in their
rehabilitation center. Another parent accommodation costs, in order to avail of work...not every child was getting indi-
stated that because of the sleep disorder therapy at distant places, in addition to vidual attention. Further, there was no
experienced by the child, it was difficult the therapy charges. training provided…I used to even get
266 Indian Journal of Psychological Medicine | Volume 45 | Issue 3 | May 2023
Original Article
phone calls from the school, complain- constantly look after adolescents with parents (M1, M5, M7, and M8) reported
ing that he hurts other children at the ASD. The following sub-themes emerged that the child’s behavioral issues wors-
special school...” (M1) in relation to this theme. ened when they reached adolescence.
Another parent (M9) rather observed
Lack of Improvement Difficulty in Managing positive changes in the child’s behav-
ior during adolescence, such as reduced
Nearly all participants echoed the lack the Changes During temper tantrums and hurting others,
of improvement in the child’s condi-
tion as another concern. Many of the Adolescence being considerate toward the younger
sibling, and even starting to control his
parents (F3, M4, M8, and M11) decided
Parents felt anxious as the child reached anger and aggressiveness (M1).
not to take the child to the rehabilitation
adolescence, and it was difficult for the “He makes the other kids at the school
center as they found no improvement
parents and children to cope with the cry by pushing them away, hitting
in the child’s life skills. A caregiver (M1)
physical and mental changes that occur their head against the wall or floor,
concluded that enrolling the child in a
during adolescence. Parents of female and pinching them …and he starts
special school was of no help to the child,
adolescents with ASD (F3, M5, M10, laughing at them when the kids cry
as there was no reduction in the child’s
and M11), in particular, stated that their …” (M8)
tantrums after he was enrolled in the
children are not capable of maintaining
special school and, therefore, discontin- According to the parents, toileting
personal hygiene themselves during
ued. Another mother (M7) felt that all issues were quite difficult to manage
the time of menstruation. A mother
therapy efforts tried for the child were in and, at times, embarrassing. The
(M5) mentioned that her child would
vain (after the child showed regression), adolescents were reluctant and nonco-
not cooperate with her in maintaining
so she had no desire to continue therapy operative to clean themselves because
personal hygiene, and she often had to
for the child. Another parent (M8) felt of sensory issues, which was a matter of
change the child’s dress several times
sad as no improvements were seen for worry for many parents.
while she showed aggressive behaviors,
her child while treatment was beneficial Some parents (M4, M8, and M10) con-
temper tantrums, and sensory issues.
for other children with ASD. veyed their anxiety over behaviors such
Few of the parents (M1 and M8) stated
“It was so sad that there were only neg- that their adolescents with ASD would as getting undressed in inappropriate
ative results from all the treatments.” engage in sexual behaviors, like mas- situations and hurting others. A parent
(M8) turbating, in inappropriate situations, (M4) expressed her anxiety regarding
which was very embarrassing for the planning for the next child, as her ado-
Adverse Effects of parents. lescent with ASD hurts other children.
Two parents (M1 and M8) reported
Medication “She tears apart the sanitary pad into issues such as anger; increased tan-
pieces and throws it somewhere…she trums; behaviors like jumping around,
Many parents reported adverse effects
knows nothing about it…she smears running around, screaming, and clap-
of medications, including sleepless-
it over her face and puts in her mouth ping hands, and showing aggression
ness, drowsiness, aggravation of acidity
…” (M5) when the child feels discomfort because
issues, weight gain, and irritability,
which made some parents discontinue Parents reported varied experiences in of acidity issues or indigestion. Another
the medications. A parent (M2) reported making their children understand the parent (M4) expressed her distress over
that instead of improving the hyperac- bodily changes of adolescence. A few the child’s noncooperation with groom-
tivity in her child, the medication caused parents tried to make the adolescent ing, such that even barbers refused to
drowsiness and hindered the child’s par- aware of bodily changes following sec- cut the child’s hair and the mother had
ticipation at the rehabilitation center. ondary sexual development and the need to groom him.
Another parent (M11) stopped taking her to keep personal hygiene. Two of the When discussing aggressive and
child to the special school as he was not parents (M2 and M12) reported that their disruptive behaviors, a parent (M8)
being engaged in any activities at school children showed curiosity related to the informed that the child is so violent
because of drowsiness as a result of the bodily changes (like hair growth on the that two or three people are required to
medication. face and legs) while they explained it to control him and bring him to the room;
the children. else, everything within his reach would
“There was no benefit out of med- be destroyed, and the child rolls on the
icines... while given tablets and Disruptive Behavior of the ground if left outside. Many parents (F3,
medicines, she used to get tired, and M4, M5, M8, M10, and M12) reported
most of the time she sleeps in special Child that adolescents with ASD showed
school...” (M11) Most of the parents expressed their self-injurious behaviors like head
concerns when adolescents with ASD banging, self-biting, and putting their
Parenting Challenges in showed disruptive behaviors like aggres- head in between doors when frustrated
siveness, temper tantrums, crying for no and emotionally overwhelmed. Some
Taking Care of the Child apparent reason, inappropriate laughter, parents (M4 and M8) reported confin-
This theme is about the experienced noncooperativeness, self-injurious behav- ing adolescents with ASD in a room to
parental challenges and the need to iors, and hurting others. Some of the control them.

Indian Journal of Psychological Medicine | Volume 45 | Issue 3 | May 2023 267


Noori et al.
Difficulty to Manage the cognitive abilities like executive toileting with minimal support, their
functions, theory of mind, logic and rea- child could not. Another parent (M9)
Child Outdoors soning skills, and comprehension. A few stated that she felt upset when other
Caregivers expressed differences in parents (F3 and M8) felt that, although children did not involve her child with
opinion in terms of handling adoles- their child appeared to understand a few ASD while playing.
cents with ASD outdoors. While most things, was ignorant at times. A parent
“Other children say… go away from
parents (M4, M6, M8, and M10) hesitated (M9) felt anxious that her child could not
here…you don’t have to come with us
to take their children out for social gath- understand what was right and wrong.
to play…I feel sad that if my child had
erings, some (F3, M5, M7, M11, and M12) Another mother worried that she could
been like them, he could have played
believed in taking adolescents with ASD not identify any skills her child was good
with them…” (M9)
as other children, in spite of the difficulty at.
in handling. Many parents (M4, M6, M8,
and M10) reported that they stopped
“Sometimes, she answers our ques- Parent Apprehensive About
tions in 4-5 words utterance. After that,
attending family functions because of
she starts speaking something else. Child’s Uncertain Future
embarrassment caused by disturbance
Sometimes I feel that she has no diffi- Parents reported that they were worried
to others or difficulty in handling them.
culty understanding, but at some other about the future of their child. Parents
One of the parents (M1) stated that
times ... she can’t understand....” (F3) were anxious about what would happen
she could not take her child with ASD
to their children in their absence and how
outside after her second child was born,
and if at all she took the children out, she Parent Feels Embarrassed long they would remain healthy enough
to look after their children with ASD.
had to take only one at a time. at Societal Responses Some parents worried about the safety
“I can’t take him to any marriage The parents believed that many people issues as the children with ASD grew as
functions, as he won’t sit still. He eats around were less understanding, showed adolescents. One of the mothers (M2)
others’ food… It is so embarrassing for unwarranted sympathy, and stared at pointed out that she felt anxious when
us.” (M4) their children. A parent (M4) reported that she thought about her child’s future,
she was hesitant to take her child even to marriage, employment, and indepen-
Associated Medical a relative’s house, as she felt embarrassed dent life. Another parent (M1) said that
about the response from relatives toward she became more apprehensive about
Condition of the Child the child’s behavioral issues. Furthermore, her child’s future when she understood
Most adolescents with ASD presented questions from others who are unaware of more about autism.
with comorbid medical conditions ASD were distressing for the parents (M1
“After a period of time…gradually I
(like constipation, irritable bowel syn- and M11). Some people even believed that
could understand that this is such a
drome, gastroesophageal reflux disease, children with ASD are incapable of doing
condition due to which most probably
indigestion and acidity issues, urinary anything of their own. A mother (M10)
his future would be lost …”
incontinence, and seizures) that needed recollected an incident where she felt
attention from parents. Repeated sei- miserable that her own family members
zures were one of the major causes of accused her of being careless and unre- Insecurity Regarding the
concern for parents. One parent (M8) sponsive to her child’s injurious behaviors Safety of the Child
reported that her child often develops toward other children.
Many parents feared about the child’s
diarrhea followed by seizure attacks.
“I take my child only to my relatives’ security in public and hence would
Comorbid psychopathologies like hyper-
house. No one seems pleased. Every- not leave their child alone. A few of the
activity, anxiety, mood disorders, and
one used to stare at children like this parents (M4, M7, M8, M9, and M10)
even sleep disorders were seen. Often,
and show sympathy. Not every parent mentioned that they never left their
the parents had to stay awake at night,
might feel good at others’ sympathy…” child with ASD with anyone and used
felt tired the whole day, and felt helpless
(M8) to accompany the child always, as they
as it affected the sleep of others at home.
worried about the child’s safety. Two of
“Sometimes he won’t sleep at night. He Comparison with Other the parents (M4 and M7) shared their
won’t let me sleep; he walks all around Children Causes Emotional fear about the child’s obsessiveness with
and pulls all others out of bed…” (M4) vehicles and that the child would run
Turmoil toward the road whenever he heard the
sound of any vehicle, with little regard
Worries About the A parent (M9) expressed her sadness
for safety.
when she saw other children of her
Cognitive Abilities of the child’s age having fun and wished her “He likes to travel in vehicles. He
Child child to be like them. A few parents (M4, sits in an autorickshaw although it
M6, and M8) stated that they felt bad is someone else’s. He will go with
Many parents informed that adoles- that, while most of the children with
cents with ASD remained poor in their anyone…that’s what I’m afraid of…”
ASD at special school were able to do (M4)
268 Indian Journal of Psychological Medicine | Volume 45 | Issue 3 | May 2023
Original Article
Absence of Guidance by Discussion along with lack of guidance (as apparent
from the responses of a few caregivers),
Service Providers This study provided a descriptive was another reason for not availing of
account of primary parental perspectives rehabilitation services among families of
Nearly all parents in the study reported
on reasons for not availing of rehabilita- adolescents with ASD.16 Evidence-based
not having received any guidance from the
tion services for adolescents with ASD intervention models17,18 exist for children
rehabilitation centers regarding strategies
and potential access barriers to rehabili- and families of ASD in the Indian context,
to cope with the physical and psychologi-
tation services. The results also revealed yet there is a gap between research and
cal changes in adolescents with ASD. A few
several challenges in the parenting of practice.
parents (M4 and M11) had not received any
adolescents with ASD. Other reasons that emerged from this
sort of guidance from service providers
Results on reasons for discontinuing study included logistic difficulties, dif-
regarding the diagnosis of autism in their
rehabilitation services provided a broader ficulty in handling the child, the need
child. Other parents (M1 and M10) came to
understanding of various reasons why for the parent to accompany the child,
know about the diagnosis of ASD very late
families of adolescents with ASD failed and family commitments. These issues
because of the delay in receiving a referral
to continue rehabilitation services. The restricted the caregivers from attending
from the consulting medical doctor. In the
financial difficulties as one reason to dis- rehabilitation services for their children
case of another parent (M8), although the
continue rehabilitation services showed even though they wished to. Dissatisfac-
doctor had diagnosed the child at the age
convergence with the literature on finan- tion with the existing treatment, lack of
of three years, neither of the parents was
cial constraints as an access barrier to improvement, and adverse effects of med-
informed.
avail rehabilitation services.2,6 Specific ications were other factors reported by
Two parents (M11 and M12) got to know
financial difficulties faced by the parents some of the parents as reasons to discon-
about the availability of rehabilitation for
in this study included difficulty to meet tinue rehabilitation. While these findings
children with ASD very late. A few others
the daily therapy charges, travel/accom- reflect the quality of services provided to
(M1 and M4) had no clue as to what could
modation expenses as they are forced to adolescents with ASD, it also reveals insuf-
be done to improve the child’s commu-
hire a private vehicle owing to the child’s ficient knowledge in caregivers, thereby
nication skills, as they were misguided
behavioral issues, the cost to avail reha- leading to unrealistic expectations.
by the consulting doctor that there was
bilitation at distant places, and being Findings on the parenting challenges
no treatment to improve the child’s con-
unable to go for work in order to look theme indicated difficulty in manag-
dition. Another parent (M4) expressed
after the child. The financial difficulties ing the changes during adolescence
her surprise when she got to know about
reported in the literature, however, were along with disruptive behaviors, in the
speech and language therapy during the
difficulty in getting insurance reim- absence of availability of proper guid-
study and the difference it can cause in a
bursement, absence of a transition plan ance by service providers. Apprehension
child’s communication skills.
for adolescents with ASD,5 and inability about the child’s uncertain future, con-
“Although regular consultation by the to afford the payments for services and stant worry about the child’s insecurity,
doctor was done from 2-3 years of age, debts.5 The difference in the nature of disruptive behaviors, and associated
it was only at the age of eight years that financial difficulties could be attributed medical conditions of the children were
the doctor told that the child requires to the lack of insurance schemes covering a few enduring challenges faced by the
training…” (M10) rehabilitation services for children with parents of adolescents with ASD. For
ASD in India. The government schemes some parents, comparison with children
Parent Losing Confidence on monthly financial assistance, aids, of a similar age group caused emotional
and devices are not sufficient enough to turmoil. Some parents reported feeling
A few parents (M1 and M8) reported feeling cover the regular expenses of the rehabil- embarrassed at societal responses, indi-
apprehensive because of the increase in itation services. Further, there are only a cating the public’s lack of awareness
the child’s aggressive behavior as the few government-run schools for children and acceptance of the special children. A
child reached adolescence. A parent (M4) with special needs to avail of free services. few parents reported losing confidence,
indicated that she felt hopeless as the ado- Other barriers to avail of medical and revealing their anxiety and mental
lescent with ASD could not carry out basic rehabilitation services for adolescents status. Our findings were in agreement
life skills like dressing on his own. One of with ASD, as documented in the litera- with the literature reporting perceived
the parents (M6) expressed her helpless- ture, are remaining on a waiting list for a burden, depression, and stress in fami-
ness regarding the lack of improvement long time and unavailability of services.6 lies of children with ASD.11,19–22
in the child’s condition. Another parent This was also the case for one of the par- Our findings provide a first-hand,
(M10) stated that, unlike earlier, her con- ticipants in our study, where the parents in-depth account of parental perspectives
fidence in dressing and taking the child on reasons for discontinuing medical
were asked to wait and start therapy after
out has come down because of the child’s and rehabilitation services in the cultural
six months. This particular factor reflects
physical appearance. context of India. It has several implica-
the lack of available rehabilitation ser-
tions for authorities and professionals in
“Isn’t the disorder of autism a special vices and personnel for children with
the educational and mental health reha-
disease which is very difficult to special needs. Unawareness about the
bilitation service sector. There is a need
handle?” (M6) condition of ASD and its rehabilitation,
for the rehabilitation sector to address

Indian Journal of Psychological Medicine | Volume 45 | Issue 3 | May 2023 269


Noori et al.
these issues by improving the training clinical care. J Autism Dev Disord 2002;
facilities for adolescents with ASD, train- ORCID iD 32(4): 299–306.
ing professionals to address the needs of Shivani Tiwari https://orcid.org/0000-0002- 12. Baghdadli A, Brisot J, Henry V, et al. Social
4345-5000 skills improvement in children with
families with ASD, conducting awareness
high-functioning autism: A pilot
programs for parents and health care
Supplemental Material randomized controlled trial. Eur Child
professionals about the available reha-
Supplemental material for this article is available Adolesc Psychiatry 2013; 22(7): 433–442.
bilitation services, and addressing the
online. 13. Sandelowski M. Focus on research
physical and mental health of caregivers. methods: Whatever happened to qualita-
Additionally, these results help policy- References tive description. Res Nurs Health
makers identify the needs and plan for 2000; 23: 334–340.
the welfare of adolescents with ASD. Our   1. American Psychiatric Association.
14. World Health Organization, WHO.
Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental
results further emphasize the need for Recognizing adolescence, https://apps.
disorders. 5th ed. American Psychiatric
scaling up mental health services for the who.int/adolescent/second-decade/
Publishing, 2013; 31-86.
families of adolescents with ASD.22 section2/page1/recognizing-adolescence.
  2. Subramanyam A, Mukherjee A, Dave
One of the limitations of this study was html (1989).
M, et al. Clinical practice guidelines
that the diagnosis and severity of ASD 15. Barun V and Clark V. Using thematic anal-
for autism spectrum disorders. Indian J
ysis in psychology. Qual Res Psychol 2006;
were based on secondary data. Likewise, Psychiatry 2019; 61(8): 254.
3(2): 77–101.
the diagnosis of comorbid psychopa-   3. Laxman DJ, Taylor JA, DaWalt LS, et al.
16. Mahapatra P, Pati S, Sinha R, et al.
thology was parent-reported. The direct Loss in services precedes high school exit
Parental care-seeking pathway and
assessment was, however, not feasible, for teens with ASD: A longitudinal study.
challenges for autistic spectrum disorders
given the pandemic and lockdown during Autism Res 2020; 12(6): 911–921.
children: A mixed method study from
the study period. The findings of the   4. Picardi A, Gigantesco A, Tarolla E, et al.
Bhubaneswar, Odisha. Indian J Psychiatry
study are applicable to the Indian context. Parental burden and its correlates in
2019; 61(1): 37–44.
families of children with autism spectrum
However, differences may be noticeable 17. Rahman A, Divan G, Hamdani SU, et
disorder: A multicentre study with two
based on the geographical area and socio- al. Effectiveness of the parent mediated
comparison groups. Clin Pract Epidemiol
economic status of the sample. intervention for children with autism
Ment Health 2018; 14: 143–176.
spectrum disorder in south Asia in India
Conclusion   5. Mademtzi M, Singh P, Shic F, et al.
Challenges of females with autism: A
and Pakistan (PASS): A randomised con-
trolled trial. Lancet Psychiatry
This study provided a range of reasons parental perspective. J Autism Dev Disord
2015; 3(2): 128–136.
for the discontinuation of rehabilitation 2018; 48(4): 1301–1310.
18. Manohar H, Kandasamy P,
services (such as logistic difficulties, finan-   6. Roddy I and O’Neill C. Predictors of
Chandrasekaran V, et al. Brief parent-me-
cial difficulties, family commitments, unmet needs and family debt among
diated intervention for children with
difficulty handling the child, lack of sat- children and adolescents with an autism
autism spectrum disorder: A feasibility
spectrum disorder: Evidence from Ireland.
isfaction with the existing treatment, study from south India. J Autism Dev
Health Policy 2020; 124(3): 317–325.
and lack of improvement) and potential Disord 2019; 49: 3146–3158.
  7. Kuhlthau KA, Delahaye J, Erickson-
barriers to avail rehabilitation services 19. Pandey S and Sharma C. Perceived burden
Warfield M, et al. Health care transition
and parenting challenges (viz. difficulty in caregivers of children with autism
services for youth with autism spectrum
in managing the changes during ado- spectrum disorder in Kathmandu valley. J
disorders: Perspectives of caregiv-
Nepal Health Res Counc 2018; 16(2): 184–189.
lescence, disruptive behaviors of the ers. Pediatrics 2016; 137(Supplement):
20. Johnson N, Frenn M, Feetham S, et al.
child, difficulty to manage the child out- S158–S166.
Autism spectrum disorder: Parenting
doors, associated medical conditions   8. Meiring M, Seabi J, Amod Z, et al.
stress, family functioning and health-re-
of the child, and worries about the cog- Transition for adolescents with autism
lated quality of life. Fam Syst Health 2011;
nitive abilities of the child)  relevant to spectrum disorder: South African
29(3): 232–252.
the Indian context. These findings have parent and professional perspectives.
21. Desai MU, Divan G, and Patel V. The
implications for professionals in the edu- Front Psychiatry 2016; 7: 93, https://doi.
discovery of autism: Indian parents’
org/10.3389/fpsyt.2016.00093.
cational and mental health rehabilitation experiences of caring for their child with
  9. Hastings RP. Child behaviour problems
sector as well as policymakers to support an autism spectrum disorder. Transcult
and partner mental health as
rehabilitation services and improve the Psychiatry 2012; 49(3–4): 613–637.
correlates of stress in mothers
quality of life for families of adolescents 22. Adiukwu F, Filippis Renato de, Orsolini L,
and fathers of children with
with ASD. et al. Scaling up global mental health ser-
autism. J Intellect Disabil
vices during the COVID-19 pandemic and
Res 2003; 47(4–5): 231–237.
Declaration of Conflicting Interests beyond. Psychiatry online. Advance Online
10. McStay RL, Dissanayake C, Scheeren A, et
Publication, 2021, https://doi.org/10.1176/
The authors declared no potential conflicts of al. Parenting stress and autism: The role
appi.ps.202000774.
interest with respect to the research, authorship, of age, autism severity, quality of life and
and/or publication of this article. problem behaviour of children and ado-
lescents with autism. Autism 2013; 18(5):
Funding 502–510.
The authors received no financial support for the 11. Ghaziuddin M, Ghaziuddin N, and
research, authorship, and/or publication of this Greden J. Depression in persons with
article. autism: Implications for research and

270 Indian Journal of Psychological Medicine | Volume 45 | Issue 3 | May 2023

You might also like