Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Yearbook Phys Anthropol 2007 p162
Yearbook Phys Anthropol 2007 p162
Mummies
Niels Lynnerup*
ABSTRACT Mummies are human remains with and endoscopic techniques, as well as minimally-destruc-
preservation of nonbony tissue. Mummification by natu- tive chemical, physical, and biological methods for, e.g.,
ral influences results in so-called natural mummies, stable isotopes, trace metals, and DNA. This article dis-
whereas mummification induced by active (human) cusses mummification and gives a presentation of vari-
intervention results in so-called artificial mummies, ous key mummy finds and a brief history of mummy
although many cultures practiced burial rites, which to studies. A description of the extant key technologies of
some degree involved both natural and artificial mummi- natural and medical science that are applied in mummy
fication. Since they are so uniquely well-preserved, studies is given; along with a discussion of some of the
mummies may give many insights into mortuary prac- major results in terms of paleopathology. It is also
tices and burial rites. Specifically, the presence of soft shown how mummy studies have contributed much to
tissues may expand the scope of paleopathological stud- the knowledge of the cultural habits and everyday life
ies. Many recent mummy studies focus on the develop- of past populations. Finally the impact of mummy
ment and application of nondestructive methods for studies on analyses of mortuary practices and cultural
examining mummies, including radiography, CT-scan- history is discussed. Yrbk Phys Anthropol 50:162–190,
ning with advanced three-dimensional visualizations, 2007. V 2007 Wiley-Liss, Inc.
C
By definition, mummies are human (or animal) properties, and starting in the 14th and 15th century,
remains with preservation of nonbony tissue. Depending Egyptian mummies were literally ground down to pro-
on mortuary practices, the natural environment and the duce ‘‘mummy powder’’ to be imported to Europe and
time span since death, soft tissue preservation may be sold from apothecaries, something which continued up
excellent or very poor, and there is really no exact bound- into the 20th century (Taconis, 2005).
ary line between a skeleton with some preserved soft tis- Mummies and bog bodies present unique opportunities
sue (skin remnants, ligaments, etc) and a mummy. How- for many scientific fields. Since they are so uniquely
ever, the word mummy is generally used when soft tissue well-preserved, both natural and artificial mummies
preservation is so pronounced that body parts, or the may give specific insights into mortuary practices and
whole body, have somewhat intact skin and some pre- burial rites. This may also be due to a parallel preserva-
served internal structures such as muscle fasciae, liga- tion of associated artifacts like clothing, tools, and uten-
ments, and maybe even tissue of internal organs and sils. The mummified body itself may reveal body orna-
muscle. mentation, such as tattoos and details of hair style, etc.
Soft tissue is preserved when the postmortem condi- The presence of soft tissues may expand the scope of
tions are such that the usual tissue degradation, includ- pathological studies, so that more acute diseases, and
ing the action of bacteria and insects, are hindered. At diseases, which do not affect bone tissue, may be identi-
its most basic, this is a question of tissue dehydration fied (e.g., Cockburn et al., 1998b; Aufderheide, 2003).
overtaking tissue postmortem decay. This may be The mummification and preservation of the various soft
achieved either naturally due to environmental condi- tissues, though, is very variable. Interior organs, parti-
tions, such as a hot or very cold, dry climate, or it may cularly of the digestive system are often completely
be facilitated by mortuary practices that in a fashion decomposed, and organs may be very shrunken and diffi-
mimic these environmental conditions, such as removal cult to identify morphologically due to desiccation. Fur-
of internal organs and drying out of body cavities. Mum- thermore, various funerary rites comprising embalming
mification by the former influences hence results in so- and evisceration may entail the complete removal of
called natural mummies, while mummification induced internal organs and the brain. Generally, the soft tissues
by active (human) intervention results in so-called artifi- most often preserved are tissues with a high content of
cial mummies. The word mummy itself is derived from collagen, like the dermis, muscle fasciae, and tendons.
the old Persian word, mumeia, or mum (Arabian: Still, even just the presence of skin may give important
mumiya) for bitumen or pitch. Medicinal properties were clues to pathology and trauma, e.g., penetrating wounds
ascribed to this substance, which flowed from the
Mummy Mountain in Persia, (David, 1984, 1997). Since
mummies often presented themselves as blackened or *Correspondence to: Niels Lynnerup, Laboratory of Biological
dark because of the desiccation of the skin, it was Anthropology, The Panum Institute, Blegdamsvej 3, DK-2200
thought that bitumen and asphalt were materials used Copenhagen N, Denmark. E-mail: n.lynnerup@antrolab.ku.dk
by the ancient Egyptians in their mummification pro-
cesses, so the word came to designate embalmed bodies DOI 10.1002/ajpa.20728
(David, 1984; Brier, 1998). Unfortunately this meant Published online in Wiley InterScience
that it was thought that mummies also had medicinal (www.interscience.wiley.com).
C 2007
V WILEY-LISS, INC.
MUMMIES 163
and cuts, scars, and even warts. Better soft tissue pres- and nutrients. This is mainly due to the uncoupling of
ervation may also be indicative of good aDNA preserva- the energy-requiring trans-membranal ‘‘pumps,’’ which
tion, perhaps also allowing identification of pathogen enable the cell to maintain the specific in vivo intracellu-
DNA. Finally, gut contents may also be seen, allowing lar environment. Intracellular structures break up, and
for detailed paleodietary studies, which may complement intracellular structures known as lyzosomes ‘‘leak’’ their
stable-isotope-based studies. content of enzymes, including more than 40 hydrolytic
However, the very presence of soft tissue, especially the enzymes such as proteases, lipases, and phosphatises
skin, at the same time makes it difficult to examine the (Alberts et al., 2002). The enzymes initiate an autodiges-
body. One may conduct an ‘‘autopsy,’’ but while such tive process, leading ultimately to complete loss of cellu-
mummy autopsies have been carried out often (Aufder- lar structure. Necrotic cells may also swell and burst,
heide, 2003; David, 1979), most archeologists, conserva- further releasing these enzymes to their immediate envi-
tors, and indeed osteologists and pathologists, are not ronment. Muscle tissue clearly shows these postmortem
always too enthusiastic about this. An autopsy is an inva- changes: a combination of intracellular and extracellular
sive and destructive procedure, meaning that the integ- electrolyte displacement and loss of intracellular ‘‘archi-
rity of the mummy or bog body as an archeological speci- tecture’’ of the myofibrils result in a fixation of the myo-
men may be destroyed. The attitude has perhaps shifted fibrils, i.e., rigor mortis. With ongoing putrefaction and
from an earlier more clinical, medical approach to mum- decay the fixation is then lost (Madea and Henssge,
mies (in a certain sense seeing the body as any other un- 2003). Another outward sign of the breakdown of the
identified body that must be properly examined in a foren- cells is that all metabolic activity stops, which can be
sic way) to one of recognition that a mummy is an invalu- observed as the postmortem body cooling: gradually, the
able archeological artifact. This has meant that more body temperature will equate with the environment.
emphasis is being placed on the development of nondes- Aside from the autolytic processes (sometimes termed
tructive methods for examining mummies, including radi- anaerobic degradation or decay), bacteria contribute to
ography, CT-scanning with advanced three-dimensional the decomposition of the dead body (sometimes termed
visualizations, and endoscopic techniques, as well as mini- aerobic degradation or putrefaction) (Micozzi, 1991). Bac-
mally-destructive chemical, physical, and biological meth- teria are present in large numbers in the gut, but also in
ods for, e.g., stable isotopes, trace metals, and DNA. Many the lungs and the lower urinary tract, as enteric bacte-
of these methods will be familiar to the osteologist. Also, ria. Under conditions where both putrefaction and decay
bone and teeth are as much part of a mummy as the other occur, soft tissue degradation proceeds from within due
(mummified) tissues, so that physical anthropological to the action of the enteric microorganisms, and from
methods dealing with mineralized tissues may play just without by colonization of soil microorganisms (Micozzi,
as great a role in the investigation of a mummy, as these 1991). At a later stage, and depending on how the body
methods would do if a skeleton were being studied. is deposited, arthropod activity will play a part in fur-
This article will fall into six major sections: a discussion ther decay, as may scavenger animals. The end result is
on mummification with a presentation of various key usually that only the mineralized tissues remain intact.
mummy finds; a brief history of mummy examinations To achieve natural mummification the above chain of
and studies; a description of the key technologies of natu- events must be broken. Water is essential for the enzy-
ral and medical science which are applied in mummy matic breakdown and bacterial growth. Soft tissues also
studies; some of the major results in terms of paleopatho- need to retain some water in order for arthropod coloniza-
logy; what mummy studies have meant for the reconstruc- tion and activity. Dehydration of the tissues is therefore a
tion of the cultural habits and understanding of everyday straightforward way to achieve mummification, and this
life of past populations; and finally the impact of mummy may thus occur by desiccation. Other mechanisms leading
studies on our understanding of mortuary practices and to mummification include freezing or the presence of a
cultural history. However, given that a search on microenvironment which hinders bacterial activity. The
‘‘Pubmed’’ for ‘‘mummies’’ results in 720 hits, and almost latter may include an anaerobic environment as found in
200 on ‘‘ScienceDirect,’’ it simply will not be possible to bogs, or fixation by mineral salts. If this blockage of the
cover all aspects, or even just all the most recent publica- normal postmortem decay and putrefaction processes
tions. At the outset it should be mentioned that there are happens at a very early stage, the mummy may present
a number of major publications that provide a thorough, itself with excellent soft tissue preservation, while the
even encyclopedic, overview of mummies and mummy mummy may appear more degraded if decay and putre-
studies: ‘‘The Scientific Study of Mummies’’ (Aufderheide, faction have occurred to some degree.
2003); ‘‘Mummies, Disease and Ancient Cultures’’ (Cock-
burn et al., 1998b); ‘‘The Encyclopedia of Mummies’’ Desiccation. Examples of natural mummification by
(Brier, 1998); and ‘‘The Cambridge Encyclopedia of Paleo- desiccation are not surprisingly found in hot and arid
pathology’’ (Aufderheide and Rodriguez-Martin, 1998). environments. Geographically, such locations are found
near the Equator, such as Nubia (Peck, 1998), the
Canary Islands (Ascenzi et al., 1998), and sometimes in
MUMMIFICATION combination with arid plateaus, such as in northern
Natural mummies Chile/southern Peru (Allison, 1985; Guillen, 1992;
Arriaza et al., 1998). Other mummy finds due to desicca-
Natural mummification occurs when soft tissue is pre- tion are from Amerindian tribes of the American South-
served without human intervention. This is in turn due west, (El-Najjar et al., 1980, 1998).
to certain postmortem-conditions. Basically, the usual The degree of desiccation will often vary over the body.
tissue degradation, including the action of bacteria and The larger the ratio of skin surface is to the underlying
insects, has to be hindered or arrested. At death, the sin- body volume, the more water can be evaporated from the
gle cells of the individual lose their basic cell membrane body segment in question. This means that fingers and
functionality at the termination of the supply of oxygen toes, and the extremities to a lesser degree, will often
pounds with arsenic and mercury salts were used for ‘‘science’’ based on frauds. Blumenbach (‘‘the father of
embalming in the 17th and 18th centuries (present day physical anthropology’’) unrolled some Egyptian mum-
embalming is usually performed with formaldehyde- mies at the British Museum in the 1790s (Taconis,
based liquids). Plastination is a technique whereby tis- 2005), but the first really systematic work began with Dr
sues are first dehydrated and then infused with a poly- Thomas Pettigrew, who was professor of anatomy at the
mer, which then cures. The method was patented by von Charing Cross Hospital in London. He carried out a dis-
Hagens et al. (1987), and has now become quite well- section of an Egyptian mummy in 1833, followed over
known because of some rather spectacular exhibits of the years by 13 more such dissections. He gave lectures
whole plastinated corpses mounted in different postures on the subject and published the first book entirely on
(‘‘BodyWorlds,’’ www.bodyworlds.com). Quigley has given mummies in 1934: ‘‘History of Egyptian Mummies’’ (Auf-
a review of ‘‘modern’’ mummies (Quigley, 1998). derheide, 2003; Brier 1998).
The next wave of serious work came in the early twen-
Natural and artificial mummification tieth century with the work of an impressive trio based
at the Cairo Medical School: Grafton Elliot Smith (pro-
The differentiation between artificial mummies and fessor of anatomy), Armand Ruffer (bacteriology), and
natural mummies, though, is not clear-cut. Many cul- Alfred Lucas (chemistry) (Peck, 1998). Lucas was called
tures have practised what might be termed a sort of mix as a consultant when the tomb of Tutankhamun was
of natural and artificial mummification. This may found (Peck, 1998). Elliot Smith made his first detailed
include treatment of the dead body in a manner in which studies of mummification in 1905 (Peck, 1998). In the
natural mummification is facilitated, e.g., by specifically following years he made examinations of all the royal
placing the corpse in an arid environment (intentional, mummies, and published his finds (Smith, 1912); or per-
natural mummification), or by performing certain rites haps not all the findings: it has been mentioned that
such as partial evisceration or defleshing (Pretty and Elliot Smith was responsible for the examination of more
Calder, 1998; Zimmerman, 1998). The famous Scythian than 30,000 mummies (Dawson, 1938, cit. in Aufder-
mummies from Pacyryk in the Altay mountains of Cen- heide, 2003). Ruffer’s name is still connected with his
tral Asia had been subjected to evisceration, removal of fluid for rehydration and restoration of mummified tis-
the brain, and also partly defleshing of muscle through sue. He also made significant contributions to the emerg-
incisions, which were then stitched. They were then ing field of paleopathology (see below). Another major
placed in a tomb. Preservation was then also further character in the field at that time was Warren R. Daw-
enhanced by the fact that the tomb area was in such an son. He left a legacy in terms of publications including
altitude that there was permafrost (Artamanov, 1965; basically helping Elliot Smith to publish his findings
Rudenko, 1970). (Smith and Dawson, 1924, cit. in Aufderheide, 2003;
Similarly, the Guanches of the Canary Islands took Brier, 1998).
advantage of the arid areas of their islands to place the In the USA, the first major mummy studies came
dead in burial caves, which ensured desiccation, but about as a result of Hrdlicka’s expeditions to the Aleu-
they also performed evisceration before placing the tians in the late 1930s (Hrdlicka, 1941; Hunt, 2003). He
bodies in the caves (Ascenzi et al., 1998). Dessication found many mummies in caves and noted that artificial
may also be achieved by smoking the corpse, which was mummification had taken place, in that the bodies exhi-
done in North America as well as in Australia (Brier, bited evisceration cuts, and that body cavities had been
1998). stuffed with grass. Child mummies were often strapped
In Japan, priests in the 17th century would intention- in their cradle bags or other containers (Frohlich and
ally reduce their intake of nutrition to alter their consti- Laughlin, 2002). Many of the mummies Hrdlıcka found
tution to one where they would become very thin (and are now curated by the Smithsonian Institution (Hunt,
thereby achieving a higher skin surface to body volume), 2003).
which may have made their corpses more resistant to Meanwhile at the Manchester Museum, England,
putrefactory changes, as desiccation would have pro- mummy studies had also been performed. Two Egyptian
ceeded faster (Sakurai et al., 1998). mummies were unwrapped and studied in 1910 (Murray,
1910, cit. in David and Tapp, 1984). Of tremendous
A BRIEF HISTORY OF MUMMY STUDIES importance was the careful planning of this interdiscipli-
nary effort, involving curators, physicians, chemists, and
Modern studies of mummies using natural scientific textile specialists. As such, this examination became a
methods arose in the wake of Napoleon Bonaparte’s template for future mummy studies, in that today there
invasion of Egypt in 1798. Numerous scientists were is a broadening consensus that mummies are best stud-
brought along with his army, and their observations of ied by a team of specialists, including physicians, arche-
monuments, hieroglyphs, tombs, and mummies resulted ologists, conservators, and others. This lesson has been
in a major folio publication (19 volumes) over the follow- repeated more recently with the examinations of, among
ing decades (and also initiated the efforts of Young and others, PUM II (Cockburn et al., 1998a), the Manchester
Champollion to translate hieroglyphic writing). Egypto- Museum Mummy Project (David, 1979), the Tyrolian Ice-
logy and Egyptian artifacts became a la mode. As an man (Spindler, 1994), the Greenland mummies (Hart
aside to this interest in all things Egyptian, so also was Hansen, 1989), bog bodies of Denmark (Asingh and Lyn-
there an interest in mummies. Museums in the western nerup, 2007), and Ireland (to be published). Aside from
world bought mummies for their collections, some of the broad interdisciplinarity and the application of many
which turned out to be fakes. Still, fake mummies could modern natural scientific and medical methods, the
also be ‘‘unrolled’’ for paying onlookers (Aufderheide, establishment of a regular mummy conference in 1992,
2003; Taconis, 2005). Luckily, serious investigations also subsequently held every third year, has also added sub-
began at this time, which probably rescued mummy stance to a field that has sometimes been seen as a
studies from becoming a mere curiosity, or from being a fringe science. Rapid dissemination of new investigative
themselves as flattened structures), and the brain. As heide, 2003). Foreign objects introduced anally or vagi-
noted, because of the high fat content, the brain may nally may also be visible externally [e.g. jade plugs in
undergo adipocerous change. This may result in an Chinese jade mummies (Aufderheide, 2003)].
excellent morphological preservation showing gyri and When perusing the exterior of a mummy, the remains
sulci and main brain parts (hemispheres, hindbrain, me- of hair and nails may often be found (e.g., Brothwell and
dulla oblongata with the pons, etc.) (Padanov et al., Dobney, 1986). Even if there is a somewhat restrictive
1992). The brain may in other circumstances liquefy attitude to invasive procedures, including tissue sam-
postmortem, so that only a hardened ‘‘rim’’ along the pling, the careful removal of a few hairs for further analy-
inside of the skull remains. However, the dura mater ses may be allowed. Hair may provide detailed informa-
may often be well preserved (Aufderheide, 2003). Finally, tion on dietary changes, drug use, or exposure to pollu-
external genitalia may be present (although often very tants, allow for extraction of aDNA, or be used to
dependent on mummification procedures) which permits determine place of origin/ethnicity (Báez et al., 2000; Wil-
a definite sex determination of the individual (Aufder- son, 2005). Keratinized tissues such as hair shaft and
heide, 2003). nails have been shown to have DNA contamination resist-
Comprehensive knowledge about artificial mummifica- ant properties (Gilbert et al., 2004). In desiccated mum-
tion procedures may also be gained by a full autopsy. The mies hair strands may still be attached to the skin and
early autopsies of the Egyptian mummies gave us the scalp, whereas in other cases the hair may have been
first definite descriptions of the mummification proce- sloughed off, which is often the case for bog bodies
dures employed, such as the removal of internal organs (Wilson et al., 2001b). Hair morphology may be studied to
and the trans-nasal removal of the brain (Pettigrew, determine ethnic affiliation (Hrdy, 1978). Bog bodies often
1834, cit. in Aufderheide, 2003; David, 1979). Likewise, it present hair strands of a reddish color. Inherent natural
must also be remembered that many artificial mummies hair coloration is determined by the size, frequency and
may contain various foreign objects, specifically laid into type of pigment granules embedded within the hair fiber,
the body cavities, which may have great archeological and all naturally-pigmented hair contain a mixture of
interest. Much knowledge may now be gained in a nonin- two compounds, black-brown eumelanin and red-yellow
vasive manner, e.g., by the use of endoscopy and radio- phaeomelanin (Wilson et al., 2007). A bog environment
graphy, but such methods will probably never be able to reduces the eumelanin, so that the reddish phaeomelanin
substitute completely for the exact pathological examina- remains, an effect which may be further enhanced by the
tion and specific sampling of target tissues made possible presence of natural tannins (Wilson et al., 2001a), so that
by direct inspection during an autopsy. all bog bodies seemingly have red hair.
Opening and dissection of a mummy may not only Performing an autopsy or not should not be seen as a
enable a direct look at internal organs in terms of paleo- dichotomous question: in reality it represents a contin-
pathological diagnosis; it may also enable the dissection uum. On one hand there may be mummy finds where
and removal of bones or parts of bone for the osteologist. there is an immediate consensus on leaving the mummy
In terms of using many of the standard techniques for entirely intact. Other mummy finds allow for more mini-
age and sex determination, this may be beneficial. Many mal invasive procedures, such as endoscopy, because of
of the ageing methods imply the need to inspect joint existing openings in the skin, or direct inspection of
surfaces, e.g. the auricular surface, the symphyseal sur- some or all the body cavities due to decay of skin or
face, sternal ribends. (Krogman and Iscan, 1986; Buik- breakage of the mummy. Finally some mummies are
stra and Ubelaker, 1994; Mays, 1998; White and Folk- opened in a true forensic pathological fashion.
ens, 2005). While the complete removal of the hip bones
may be difficult, many desiccated mummies actually Endoscopy
present themselves as literally a ‘‘bag of bones’’ (the bag
being the hardened desiccated skin), but with the bones Endoscopy is somewhat associated with autopsy, in
lying disarticulated within, so that single ribs, epiphy- that direct inspection of intracavity structures and organs
seal ends in the case of subadults, etc, may be extracted may be carried out (Manialawi et al., 1978; Notman et al.,
and directly inspected. 1986; Tapp and Wildsmith, 1986; Bonfils et al., 1986–87;
A key point to be kept in mind regarding autopsies is Reyman et al., 1998; Gaber et al., 2003; Kim et al., 2006;
that the term literally means postmortem examination, Isidro et al., 2006). Endoscopes are equipped with lenses,
of which the opening of the body cavities is but one part; resulting in magnification, and furthermore the endo-
careful examination of the surface and skin of the corpse scope can be outfitted with devices allowing cutting and
is also a very important part of the autopsy procedures sampling of tissue (Tapp et al., 1984). Today most endo-
in forensic autopsies (Saukko and Knight, 2004). Conse- scopes are flexible using an optical fiber system. Endo-
quently, while perhaps it is not possible or desirable to scopes are developed mainly for clinical medical proce-
make a complete, invasive autopsy with opening of the dures, so performing an endoscopic examination on a
body cavities, the careful examination of the mummified mummy usually entails this being done in a medical set-
skin and integuments may yield much information on ting or by medical personnel (e.g., Kruse, 2007). In this
trauma, wounds and skin conditions and bodily adorn- respect, it should be noted that endoscopes are used in a
ments (Verbov, 1986; Lowenstein, 2004). Often the skin variety of clinical settings, such as gynecological and ab-
of the extremities is so well preserved that finger and dominal examination and operation, as well as ear and
sole prints can easily be seen. throat examinations and operations. The endoscopes used
Specific imaging methods may be applied, such as in the former procedures are usually larger in diameter
ultraviolet or infrared light, as well as magnifying equip- than the latter. The smaller the diameter of the endo-
ment. Complete visual inspection is also important for scope tube, the less invasive or destructive the procedure,
locating e.g., stones or small metal plates which may and body orifices of smaller dimensions may be accessed
have been placed under the eyelids, just as stones or (e.g., outer ear opening, pharyngeal and nasal cavities)
other foreign objects may be placed in the mouth (Aufder- (Gaafar et al., 1999; Hagedorn et al., 2004), while a larger
Raman spectroscopy
Raman spectroscopy has been used in several mummy
studies, particularly because it is a noninvasive and non-
destructive technique for determining the molecular
composition of tissue samples (Edwards and Munshi,
2005). When comparing mummified tissue specimens
with spectral results of more recent tissues, the degrada-
tion and decay at an ultrastructural and molecular level
may be determined (Edwards et al., 1999). This has been
utilized for the Tyrolian Iceman (Williams et al., 1995),
and the Greenland Mummies (Gniadecka et al., 1997),
although mainly on skin samples and nails (Edwards
et al., 2002).
Fig. 2. Greenland Inuit mummy with facial, linear tattoo-
ings visualized by DV-camera. [Color figure can be viewed in
the online issue, which is available at www.interscience.wiley.
Radiography
com.] Of all the so-called minimally destructive or noninva-
sive techniques used for visualizing the internal struc-
tures of mummies and bog bodies, the most well-known
may be thus visualized easily because of the deeper pen- and longest used technique is radiography. Indeed, it
etration through the skin of IR wavelengths, and took only a few months after William Röntgen discovered
because IR is absorbed by the coloring particles intro- X-rays in 1895 to the first use of X-rays in mummy
duced in the deeper layers of the skin by tattooing research (Koenig, 1896). As the X-rays pass through the
(Dorfer et al., 1998; Lynnerup and Kragegaard Knudsen, object to be examined, they interact with the object in
2002) (see Fig. 2). IR has also been used to investigate terms of scattering and being absorbed, and the com-
resin residues on tissue samples from an Egyptian bined effect of this is expressed as the attenuation. After
mummy (Klys et al., 1999a). passing through the object, the X-rays then strike a pho-
The use of ultraviolet fluorescence (UVF) in mummy tographic plate. Since the X-rays are attenuated differ-
studies also concerns the skin, but in contrast to IR, it is entially by different tissues and materials, they end up
not so much intradermal or subdermal changes that are striking the photographic plate at different intensities,
visualized. Fluorescence is caused by electromagnetic resulting in differing gray-values. After development,
radiation exciting atoms, i.e., moving electrons from a these are rendered from white (tissues or materials with
neutral to a higher level of energy. As the electrons fall high attenuation, e.g., bone) to black (e.g., air in body
back to their original position, the energy is re-emitted cavities). Modern clinical radiographical equipment is
as light with a longer wavelength (Stokes shift, causing now fully digitized, i.e., the X-rays do not end on a pho-
the phenomenon of fluorescence (Krauss and Warlem, tographic plate but rather in special sensors which
1985; West et al., 1992). Fluorescence caused by light in translate the attenuation to direct pixel-based images.
the visible spectrum cannot be discerned. However, The digital equipment can control the beam modalities
when illuminating objects with UV light (UV wave- and the image-building more directly, enabling sharper
lengths cover a spectrum of 400–150 nm) in a dark envi- pictures (e.g., Carlton and Adler, 2001).
ronment, fluorescence can be observed (West et al., Radiography has the advantage of being almost uni-
1992). While advanced UVF equipment is available in versally available, and easily performed. As mentioned
museums and conservational departments, simple porta- earlier, radiography has a long track record when it
ble UV light emitting sources exist, e.g., UV devices comes to mummies and bog bodies, in effect having been
used by philatelists. the only method available for ‘‘looking inside.’’ Flinders
In mummy studies UV fluorescence may be used to Petrie used radiography in his studies of mummies in
achieve a visual separation of tissue and other added 1897 (Petrie, 1898). Moodie published the findings of his
material, for example detection of resins, wax fillings analyses of 17 Egyptian mummies at the Field Museum
and micro-organisms. A surface reflection is seen as the in Chicago in 1931, and this probably constitutes the
radiation from the UV-source activates these substances first systematic radiographic analysis of a major collec-
on the surface of the skin. Depending on the chemical tion of mummies (Moodie, 1931). All the royal mummies
composition of the substances, they will reflect the UV- housed at the Cairo Museum were radiographed in 1967
radiation differently. The Danish bog body, the Grauballe (Harris and Weeks, 1973; Harris and Wente, 1980). Radi-
man, was found to have undergone varnishings of resins ography of mummies has also been performed onsite in
and wax fillings in a hitherto not realized extent to some very remote locations (Notman et al., 1987; Not-
remodel his outward features, including his facial fea- man and Beattie, 1995; Nystrom et al., 2004).
tures, as well as a part of his lower back, which had The primary focus of radiographic studies of mummies
been cut away (Frederiksen, 2007). In a conservational has often been archeological as well as medical; e.g.,
setting, UVF may also be helpful to monitor the status searching for amulets in Egyptian mummy wrappings
of the outer surfaces, e.g. mold or yeasts colonizing and (Christensen, 1969). However, the determination of sex
degrading the mummy (Frederiksen, 2007). Recently, and age, based on skeletal traits, has usually been car-
illumination by laser light has been applied to a bog ried out whenever possible (e.g., Fawcitt et al., 1984).
Sandford and Kissling, 1994). Also, trace element analy- wide range of measures to ensure the authenticity of the
ses may shed light on the use and composition of resins aDNA results is now recommended (Cooper and Poinar,
used in artificial mummification procedures (Klys et al., 2000). In mummies, the preservation of soft tissue has
1999a). Since many trace elements, especially heavy been seen as indicative of well-preserved DNA also. On
metals may reflect industrial pollution because of fossil the other hand, if mummification took place due to hot,
fuel emissions, the quantification and comparison of arid environments, this could be potentially degrading
heavy metals between prehistoric and historic and pre- for DNA, while ‘‘ice mummies’’ should in theory better
sent day human populations may be used to evaluate preserve DNA (Handt et al., 1994; Gilbert et al., 2007).
these trends (e.g., Ericson et al., 1979; Grandjean et al., A specific problem, especially for the more ‘‘famous’’
1979; Chen et al., 1981; Parnigotto et al., 1982; Zimmer- mummies, is that they may have been extensively
man et al., 1982). Diachronic analyses of how diets have handled under conditions that were not designed to pro-
changed are another example. Trace element content in tect the specimens from DNA cross contamination by the
Greenland mummies compared with present-day Green- handlers. An increasing number of studies have demon-
landers can reflect the change from a hunter-society diet strated that DNA contamination in this way presents a
of almost exclusively marine foodstuffs to a more west- serious challenge to aDNA studies, often leading to the
ernized diet. It can also indicate how a modern, highly generation of erroneous results that are derived from the
processed, western diet is deficient in some of the neces- contaminant DNA as opposed to that of the ancient spec-
sary trace elements such as selenium, leading to a imen (c.f. Kolman and Tuross, 2000; Hofreiter et al.,
decrease in the content of these elements in the tissues 2001; Malmström et al., 2005; Gilbert et al., 2005a,b;
between the mummies and modern individuals (Hansen Sampietro et al., 2006). In addition to the degree of han-
and Asmund, 2003). dling exposure, contamination has been linked to sam-
Individual exposure to certain minerals and metals ple-specific issues such as specimen porosity. Therefore
has been used to argue for specific, work-related expo- naturally porous tissues such as bones, teeth and con-
sure. For example, copper enrichment found in the Tyro- ceivably mummified tissue may often rapidly become
lian Iceman’s hair was deemed suggestive of involvement permeated with contaminant DNA. It has also been sug-
in copper working (Brothwell and Grime, 2003), as well gested that hair and nails may be a better source for
as geographic origin (Müller et al., 2003). aDNA than bone (Gilbert et al., 2006; Tahir et al., 1995;
Numerous studies have focused on therapeutics and Jehaes et al., 1998; Gilbert et al., 2007), and hair has
poisonings, and the remains of several historical figures been used as sources of aDNA in specimens that date
have been analyzed. U.S. President Andrew Jackson was back over 64,500 years (Gilbert et al., 2004).
seemingly exposed to mercury and lead due to therapeu- While aDNA may be extracted from bones and teeth,
tic usage of various compounds (Deppisch et al., 1999); and so is not an investigative method exclusive to mum-
King George III’s hair showed high levels of arsenic, mies, relatively intact mummies do allow for some in-
again probably due to medication (Cox et al., 2005); and triguing paleopathological analyses, whereby pathologi-
in the case of Franceso I de Medici and his wife, low con- cal changes of organs and soft tissues may be correlated
centrations of arsenic were found in beard hair, but toxic with demonstration of bacterial aDNA (Donoghue et al.,
concentrations in mummified tissue (Mari et al., 2006). 2004); as well as parasite DNA (Dittmar et al., 2003).
Perhaps one of the most comprehensive cases of this
kind, in terms of the number of publications, is the find-
Examining a mummy
ing of arsenic in Napoleon Bonaparte’s hair (e.g., Weider
and Fournier, 1999; Lin et al., 2004; Kintz et al., 2006). Given all the earlier techniques, and undoubtedly
A general concern about these methods is the fact that many more yet to come, it is important to plan carefully,
the hair and other tissues may have absorbed the trace which examinations are possible, and what analyses are
elements from the environment (Price et al., 1992; Snow, deemed important in connection with the specific
1979). Finally, it is worth noting that some elements, mummy or mummies, all in an interdisciplinary fashion.
perhaps most notably strontium, are virtually only found Securing tissue specimens, especially before conservation
in bones and teeth, so that these analyses must be car- procedures, and ahead of extensive handling, may be im-
ried out on these tissues (e.g., Sealy et al., 1991; portant for future studies. At the Manchester Museum
Schweissing and Grupe, 2003). in the U.K., a tissue bank of mummified tissue samples
has been created (Lambert-Zazulak, 2000). Access to
aDNA such a tissue bank allows researchers to try out small
trials rapidly, e.g., immunohistology (Jesziorska et al.,
Ancient DNA analyses were first performed on Egyp- 2003), and tissue banks may also turn out to be invalu-
tian mummies (Pääbo, 1985, 1986). This generated much able repositories of material for the study of the develop-
interest in the application of DNA-testing on historic ment of diseases.
and prehistoric human remains (Pääbo, 1989). However, Finally, attention should be given to ethical and emo-
the credability of results obtained from ancient DNA tional concerns. If such arise they should be taken seri-
analysis of human remains has suffered considerably ously: on one hand by explaining what may be gained by
during the past 10 years due to the realization that the scientific studies (which may also be important in
many previous results were most likely due to contami- terms of securing preservation of the mummy itself), and
nating modern human DNA (Pääbo et al., 2004; Paken- on the other hand respecting that there may be concerns
dorf and Stoneking, 2005; Willerslev and Cooper, 2005). regarding invasive or destructive procedures.
Fortunately, recent studies have shown that if strict
measures of authentication are taken, it is possible to MUMMIES AND PALEOPATHOLOGY
achieve reliable results on ancient human DNA (Di Ben-
edetto et al., 2000; Kolman and Tuross, 2000; Lalueza- A R.W. Shuffeldt is reported to have used the term
Fox et al., 2004; Haak et al., 2005; Kuch et al., 2007). A paleopathology already in 1892 (Ubelaker, 1982; Thil-
treponematoses, procuring more cases with unambiguous (1992) and Cockburn and Cockburn (1980) and David
soft tissue changes, and the possibilities for further bio- and Contis (1996), and recently with new diagnostic pro-
chemical analyses, would be very desirable. This would cedures (Rutherford, 1999). The disease may cause calci-
also apply to leprosy: while extensively documented in fication of the bladder, a pathological change which has
the osteological record (e.g., Møller-Christensen, 1967; been recorded for a mummy (Isherwood et al., 1979). As
Ortner, 2003), there have been no published reports on for the earlier mentioned other parasitic diseases,
mummified remains with lepromatous changes. research is moving to ever broader sampling, so as to
Smallpox (a viral infection) has also been identified in constitute epidemiological studies (Araujo and Ferreira,
several mummy finds (Field, 1986; Fornaciari and Mar- 1997; Rutherford, 2005).
chetti, 1986; Perrin et al., 1994; Marennikova et al., Leishmaniasis (Zink et al., 2006), as well as several
1990). This is not only due to the identification of skin intestinal parasites (e.g., Giardia, Entamoeba histoly-
lesions, but also, in later publications, to microscopic and tica) have also been identified in mummified remains,
electron microscopic analyses (Horne and Kawasaki, (Goncalves et al., 2003).
1984), and in the most recent, also DNA. Since smallpox Infestations of headlice has been recorded for pre-
is now defined as eradicated, and vaccination is no lon- Columbian Peruvian mummies (Brothwell and Spear-
ger performed, there has been some debate as on man, 1963, Araujo et al., 2005), Aleutian mummies
whether ‘‘over-wintering’’ vira in frozen mummies might (Horne, 1979; Horne and Kawasaki, 1984), and Green-
thaw and unleash new epidemics (Lewin, 1985; Stone, land mummies (Bresciani et al., 1989). Lice were also
2002). The title of a paper by El-Mallakh (1985) says it found in the gut contents of the latter (Lorentzen and
all: ‘‘Night of the living dead: could the mummy strike Rørdam, 1998), indicative of so severe an infestation (and
again?’’ This has, however, never been found to be the indeed one mummy had head lice on every third or fourth
case (Stone, 2002). Finally, mycotic infections have also hair) that lice simply would be ingested accidentally
been identified (e.g., Horne, 1995). when the person was eating (Araujo et al., 2005). The fre-
quency of head lice infestation, as found on the mummies
from two South American populations, has been corre-
Parasitic diseases lated with degree of social contact (Aufderheide and
This is perhaps the ‘‘pièce de résistance’’ of mummy Rodriquez-Martin, 1998). Louse infestation has also been
paleopathology because this field has yielded much confirmed (Reinhard and Buikstra, 2003). Another faith-
knowledge concerning parasitic diseases. Parasitic infes- ful human parasite is the flea. Dittmar et al. (2003) per-
tation and spread of vector-borne diseases often is a formed DNA studies on 1,000-year-old fleas to ascertain
rather complicated mix of different species (including how fleas have evolved (and migrated) with humans,
humans) living and dying under specific environmental although because of lack of sufficient data, no exact spe-
constraints. The identification of parasitic diseases may cies or specimen distribution pattern were established.
not only demonstrate the human afflictions, but may also
illuminate the living conditions and cultural history of Helminth infections
the people afflicted. It can also help to elucidate the natu-
ral history and evolution of the diseases and parasites Helminthic infestations should be detectable in a pale-
themselves (Reinhard, 1990; Chastel, 2004). It must also opathological setting (Reinhard and Aufderheide, 1990;
be remembered, that the parasites themselves, and their Araujo et al., 1998). This is because the agents may end
ova, may ‘‘mummify’’, and thus may be identified in up in calcified shells or cysts, such as is the case for
kitchen-middens and latrines (Bouchet et al., 2003). echinococciasis (tapeworms), where larvae may produce
Trypanosomiasis (Chagas disease caused by the proto- hydatid cysts in soft tissue. These have been reported in
zoan Trypanosoma cruzi), has been diagnosed in a an Egyptian mummy (Tapp, 1986), in a 2,000-year-old
mummy from the Inca culture at Cuzco by Fornaciari tomb near Jerusalem (Zias 1991), and in a Danish medi-
et al. (1992) by immunoflourescence techniques, and the val leprosary (Weiss and Møller-Christensen, 1971). En-
mummy furthermore showed signs of megacolon, megae- teric helminthic infestation is often diagnosed from gut
sophagus, and myocardial fibrosis which are all patho- contents and coprolites, which is similar for reports on
logical changes indicative of trypanosomiasis. Similar trematode infestations, in that ova have been found in
changes have been reported from other South American corpolites from the Atacama desert [see Aufderheide and
mummies (Rothhammer et al., 1985). The application of Rodriquez-Martin (1998) for a full review]. Hookworms
DNA techniques has made paleoepidemiological studies have also been identified (Allison et al., 1974c; Araujo
possible, indicating infestation frequencies of about 41% et al., 2005). This case, pertaining to Brazilian material,
in mummies recovered from the Atacama Desert in Chile highlights that these findings contribute to the discus-
(Aufderheide et al., 2004; Salo et al., 2005), and Brazil sions of how these parasites spread or migrated with
(Araujo et al., 2005). humans, e.g., if the parasites could pass from Asian ori-
Several Egyptian mummies have been tested for gins to the New World via the Beringian landmass, or if
malaria, whereby positive reactions, indicative of falcipa- this would be an unsuitable and perhaps incompatible
rum antigens, was found in 7 out of 18 mummies (Miller environment for the parasites to pass (Aufderheide and
et al., 1994). A similar frequency (40%) was reported by Rodriquez-Martin, 1998). New molecular biological diag-
Cerutti et al. (1999, 2005), when they investigated 135 nostic techniques will without doubt also be applied in
mummies from the Gebelen site in Egypt. Soft tissue this field (e.g., Vray, 2002).
changes would especially include splenomegaly, which
was described by Ruffer as the case for several Coptic Other diseases of visceral organs
mummies (1913), although no organisms have been dem-
onstrated in these cases. Vascular diseases such as arterial degenerative disease
Schistosomiasis was diagnosed by Ruffer in an Egyp- (Sandison, 1967b; Magee, 1998), atheroma and arterio-
tian mummies (1910), more recently by Miller et al. sclerosis (Zimmerman et al., 1971, 1981; Zimmerman and
2003: 153). Clearly, the more one can learn from the mum- respect for the integrity of the corpse. While in earlier
mies, not least in terms of the mummification procedures times mummies were seen as curiosities, they are now
involved, e.g., removal of internal organs, defleshing, the regarded both as important cultural historical and arche-
better an understanding of the mummification ritual ological objects, harboring much information about past
itself, leading perhaps to a better understanding of what peoples, but also as the remains of once living people,
the religious and cultural ideas were. The Egyptians with a claim to being handled with respect (Holm, 2001).
believed in an afterlife, and that the preservation of the Mummies will continue to fascinate and thereby stimu-
deceased’s body in as lifelike form as possible was essen- late the development and application of new scientific
tial (David and Tapp, 1984; de Trafford, 2005). methods for their study (Reyman et al., 1998). This fasci-
Natural mummies may also provide much information nation must certainly also play a part for so many scien-
on past mortuary practices; while perhaps the preserva- tists to involve themselves in the study of mummies.
tion of the body was not always planned, some natural Perusing the literature one is struck by how often the
mummies seem to have been ‘‘deliberately’’ produced, in most advanced scientific methods have been applied rap-
the sense that it was known that disposal in certain envi- idly to examinations and reexaminations of mummies.
ronments or in specific burial constructions, might pre- The scientific fascination perhaps also resides in being
serve the body. The oak coffin burials in the Danish part of a truly cross-disciplinary field: mummy studies
Bronze Age burials may be a case of such knowledge: the exemplify the benefits and huge advances that may be
burial mounds seem to have been specifically constructed made when working ‘‘outside’’ one’s own discipline.
to result in a mound with a very humid, even watery, core Working with mummies—to paraphrase Berglund
environment, which would act to preserve the oak coffin, (2003, p. 98): ‘‘One gets closer to the individual human
skins, hair, and clothing (Jensen, 1995). In a land with being, and one is prompted to ask the questions that
(at that time) lots of watery bogs, it was surely known concern the universal human aspect. Who were you?
that special preservation might take place in the bogs, so What was your life like?’’
that textiles, leather, and even human bodies might be
preserved for a long time. Various procedures for ensur-
ing a slow decomposition, which may have been employed ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
for selected deceased persons, have also been described This paper is dedicated to the late Jens Peder Hart
for North American Indians (Cook, 2005). Hansen, the head of the Greenland mummy investiga-
The Greenland mummies are examples of purely inci- tions in the 1980s, who initated me to the world of
dental mummies, as the Thule culture burial practices mummy studies; and to Art Aufderheide, who continues
seem to have been to place the deceased’s body in a stone to be a great inspiration in the field of mummy studies.
cist, but that natural cists, or caves, or rock shelters
could be used. In the case of the mummies from Qilakit-
soq, a rock shelter was used, but the shelter was covered
up by stone slabs. The bodies thus lay protected from LITERATURE CITED
rain and snow, although allowing exposure to the cold
Aali A. 2005. Salt men. Teheran, Iran: Iranian Center for
arctic winds (Hart Hansen, 1988; Andreasen, 2003). Archaeological Research. p 35.
Indeed, ‘‘we have no reason to interpret the mummy Abraham JL, Hunt A, Burnett B, Allison M, Gerszten E. 1990.
graves as a special religious case in any way (Andreasen, Light microscopic and microanalytic study of lungs from pre-
2003, p. 14). Child mummies have also been studied as Columbian Chilean mummies: correlations with cultural data
special cases of mortuary rites, social constructs and bio- and comparison with contemporary pneumoconiosis. Paleopa-
logical stages (Bourbou, 2005). thol Club Newslett 412:3–5.
Investigating the various burial rituals associated Alberts B, Johnson A, Lewis J, Raff M, Roberts K, Walter P, edi-
with mummy finds, both natural and artificial, has led tors. 2002. The cell. New York, USA: Garland Science.
to various experimental work by applying and testing, Albrethsen S. 1989. Archaeological investigations of 17th cen-
tury whaling on Svalbard. Acta Borealia 1:43–51.
e.g., substances for dehydration, tools, as these have
Allison MJ. 1984a. Case no. 7: Paleopathology in Peruvian and
been found or described in several sources (Zimmerman Chilean mummies. In: Cohen NN, Armelagos GJ, editors.
et al., 1998; Fulcheri et al., 2003; Brier and Wade, 2005; Paleopathology at the origins of agriculture. New York, USA:
Nerlich et al., 2005). Janaway et al., have monitored Academic Press. p 515–529.
postmortem changes in pig carcasses buried in the arid Allison MJ. 1984b. Case no. 16; Emphysema. Paleopathol Club
environments of southern Peru (Janaway et al., 2007) Newslett 19:1.
and peat bogs (Janaway et al., 2003). These have also Allison MJ. 1985. Chile’s ancient mummies. Natural History
been recreated experimentally. Brier and Wade (1995) 94:75–81.
even reconstructed an Egyptian mummification proce- Allison MJ, Bergman T, Enrique G. 1999. Further studies on
dure by using a human body. fecal parasites in antiquity. Am J Clin Pathol 112:605–609.
Allison MJ, Gerszten E. 1982. Paleopathology in south Ameri-
can mummies. Richmond, VA: Virginia Commonwealth Uni-
CONCLUSION versity.
Allison MJ, Gerszten E. 1983. Case no. 13: Hydronephrosis of
People from the past most commonly appear to us in the kidney, trauma, homicide, decapitation, abdominal lacera-
the form of skeletons. These may probably seem more for- tion. Paleopathol Club Newslett 16:1.
eign because we do not see them directly as people. But Allison MJ, Gerszten E. 1984. Case no. 1: Pulmonary emphy-
sema. Paleopathol Club Newslett 19:1.
with a mummy, with skin and hair and perhaps a recog-
Allison MJ, Mendoza I, Pezzia A. 1973. Documentation of case
nizable human face, the situation is different. Investiga- of tuberculosis in pre-Columbian America. Am Rev Respira-
tions of mummies demand much greater care to be taken tory Dis 107:985–991.
concerning all aspects of conservation- and preservation- Allison MJ, Pezzia A, Gerszten E, Giffler RF, Mendiza D. 1974a.
related problems, but they also demand, possibly in an Aspiration pneumonia due to teeth: a report of two cases, 950
unspoken and unreflecting way, a greater degree of AD and 1973 AD. South Med J 67:479–483.