Professional Documents
Culture Documents
LLC Operations Manual 2022
LLC Operations Manual 2022
Operations Manual
Operations Manual
Table of Contents
The purpose of this Limited Liability Company Operations Manual is to illustrate key concepts
and benefits of using a Limited Liability Company (LLC.) Basic information concerning the
appropriate steps in creating, maintaining, and updating the LLC is included to guide you in
working with your professional advisor team to realize those benefits.
There are numerous reasons why clients undertake LLC planning. Most commonly is the desire
to segregate business assets or an active business for the purpose of asset protection. Clients
may desire to structure their investments to provide for retirement income, acquire assistance in
managing assets, or engage in effective planning to minimize the costs associated with
transferring assets during their lifetime or at death. They may desire to lower income taxes by
spreading income among family members in lower tax brackets. Some clients want to involve
family in the management of family assets or to structure a way for family members to become
involved in the family business to a greater degree without surrendering total control. LLC
planning can accomplish all of these objectives and more.
There are two main forms of Limited Liability Companies: member-managed and
manager-managed. In member-managed, members of the company choose to manage the entity
by membership voting; in manager-managed, members appoint one or more managers to conduct
business for the entity as authorized by the members.
A Manager need not be a Member of the LLC but can be. Even in a member-managed LLC, a
“day to day” manager is sometimes appointed to conduct daily business operations without
decision making management authority. Finally, an LLC has great flexibility in selecting how it
is taxed. Depending on the number of members, it may be a disregarded entity or may be taxed
as a partnership or corporation. This design flexibility is a major reason an LLC is so attractive.
1
(a) Provide Asset Protection and Protect Against Future Creditors of
Members
A Limited Liability Company provides considerable asset protection to members
carrying on a business. The LLC limits the personal liability of members to the
Company’s creditors since members risk only their investment to the creditors of
the company. An LLC also provides some protection from the judgment creditors
of the individual members if a judgment is entered against the member after the
creation of the company.
LLCs protect family assets from claims of future creditors of members as a result
of basic equitable principles. For example, if future creditors of a particular
member were able to acquire assets, all the members would suffer as a result of
the actions, or inactions, of a single member. Basic equitable concepts do not
support punishment of an innocent group of members for the actions of another
member.
The LLC provides asset protection by dictating the rights of a member’s creditor.
Creditors of a member generally have no right to become a member, to demand
company assets, or to compel distributions. Generally, the law of most states
provides that a judgment creditor may only levy on assets that are distributed out
of the company to the member. For many professionals, and for people with
wealth, the asset protection features of the LLC are often the most substantial
business purpose for creation of the entity.
(b) Avoid Living and Death Probate and Maintain Privacy
Creation and funding of an LLC can assist in preventing assets from going
through probate upon the disability or death of a member. Owning LLC interests
or shares can also simplify a guardianship, conservatorship, and probate
proceedings. It is usually in the best interest of the LLC and the members to
simplify such proceedings.
The details of investment activities and the nature of LLC assets themselves are
not part of the public record. The Articles of Organization of the Limited
Liability Company are filed with the state to form the entity, but they generally
contain only basic information required by the state.
An LLC can be a cleaner planning tool to use in controlling property compared to
forms of title such as joint tenancy with right of survivorship (JTWROS.)
JTWROS is commonly used on bank accounts and brokerage accounts as a way
to avoid, or at least postpone, the death probate process. Joint tenancy is not the
optimal way to hold title to many assets for a variety of tax and estate planning
reasons. Doing so can completely frustrate the distribution of an estate. LLC
ownership can effectively thwart the unintended use of joint tenancy.
(c) Restrict the Right of Non-Members to Acquire Interests
The LLC restricts the right of non-members to acquire interests in LLC assets.
The LLC also may prevent the transfer of a member’s interest in the LLC as a
result of a failed marriage. No matter how careful other planning may be,
unexpected divorces, successful creditor claims, and even adverse court rulings
2
can frustrate both business and family intent and force unwanted communications
and relations between ex-family members. Proper planning using an LLC can
streamline and facilitate the settlement process between them.
(d) Prevent Commingling of the Assets of Gift Recipients
The LLC creates a simple way to prevent gifts made to family members from
being commingled in that family member’s marriage. Limited Liability Company
shares or units (LLC units) can be transferred directly in the name of the recipient
family member, or in a separate property trust created for him or her. This
establishes the property as separate property and using a trust to own that property
tends to make it impossible to commingle with other marital assets. Keeping
separate assets separate allows tracking and maintenance of separate property in
case of marital dissolution.
(e) Allow for More Flexible Business Planning
The Limited Liability Company is more flexible than most other available
business planning tools such as a general partnership, limited partnership, or
corporation. Owners of interests in LLCs are not required to recognize gain or
loss in connection with liquidation except to the extent that any cash received or
deemed received exceeds the adjusted basis of a member’s interest in the LLC
immediately before the distribution.
(f) Centralized Management of Investments
The LLC can hold investment assets and be structured to provide for centralized
management. An older generation of family members such as parents or
grandparents that create an LLC may retain fiduciary control of the enterprise and
even introduce descendants to the management process over a period of time.
Business succession planning encourages the founders or older generation of a
family to train successors or descendants and appoint someone to manage
business wealth and monitor decisions. It is important to understand the interplay
between retaining control and making certain that any member also acting as a
manager, whether directly or indirectly through a management trust or entity, acts
as a fiduciary. Recent court rulings and IRS interest makes clear that failure to do
so can result in potentially adverse tax consequences.
Pooling of assets often reduces management costs and may also achieve better
rates of return. It is easier to manage one portfolio than several scattered
portfolios. Furthermore, the use of the LLC as a holding company may result in
lower asset management fees and easier diversification of assets.
(g) Easier to Make Loans or Purchase Shares
The LLC may make loans permitted by the LLC agreement. When a member
needs funds for specific personal needs, for example an education expense, and
the member’s capital account is not sufficient, a loan may be made which could
be repaid from subsequent company distributions, or LLC units may be
repurchased for fair market value (FMV). Loans or purchases must be properly
documented in order to minimize the risk that the IRS will later deem these
3
transactions as gifts or to support an argument that the company is not a business
and should be disregarded.
(h) Valuation Adjustments on Company Interests
If a member transfers an LLC unit by gift or sale or if a member of the LLC dies,
a valuation usually must be made to determine what the transferred interest is
worth. Fair market value of Limited Liability Company units (LLCUs) is lower
on a “going concern” basis (asset value adjusted for lack of marketability of the
LLC units representing ownership in the LLC) than on a “liquidation” basis
(value of the underlying assets.) The reasons for this anomaly are based in
equitable and business principles.
Inherent restrictions on the rights of members under Limited Liability Company
law and the specific limitations imposed on LLC units under the Limited Liability
Company agreement generally result in LLC units having a fair market value that
is substantially less than the value of the underlying assets of the LLC. This is
termed a “discount” or valuation adjustment. An outside buyer of LLC units
faces the reality that although the buyer might gain a good investment in
exchange for a purchase price, he or she could exercise little control over benefits
received or the actual assets the interest represents during the term of the LLC.
Similarly, gifting of LLC units during the donor’s lifetime may result in gift tax
savings. Gift tax savings exist because the gift of a fractional or non-controlling
LLC interest can often be valued at far less than the interest’s fractional share of
the LLC as a whole. For example, if a parent gives a child a 5% interest in the
LLC, the value of the interest will be reduced by adjustments made for lack of
marketability and also for lack of control. If the asset share value is discounted by
fifty percent, for example, the annual gift tax exclusion or the applicable
exclusion amount used to cover the gift is effectively doubled.
(i) Reduce State Taxes
A Limited Liability Company may not be subjected to corporate income tax or
franchise tax in certain jurisdictions while other forms of business might be. (In
some jurisdictions, however, the LLC is subject to taxes which are not applied to
other kinds of business entities.)
(j) Reduce Income Taxes
Income distributed to minority owner members or members who do not
participate in management may not be subject to self-employment tax, which
reduces overall income tax. Spreading income among lower income tax bracket
family members may also reduce income taxes. Younger family members
participate in the growth of all assets in the LLC at income tax rates that may be
lower than the creators of the LLC. This can be done through the use of profit
distributions to members, or through the use of management fees paid to a
manager (which are generally subject to self-employment taxes).
Dissolving a Limited Liability Company taxable as a disregarded entity or
partnership has less onerous tax consequences than dissolving a corporation.
Since a Limited Liability Company taxable other than as a C corporation is a
4
conduit for federal income tax purposes, the tax consequences upon dissolution
may be far less significant than upon the dissolution of a C corporation.
(k) Facilitate Annual Gifting
One of the primary benefits of the LLC is its ability to maximize annual tax-free
gifts to family members. Some people do not want to give up management of
assets while they are alive or do not have sufficient disposable cash on hand to
give it away, but they desire to make gifts to others to reduce their taxable estate,
or for other reasons, and might be willing to make gifts of partial interests of
property.
The LLC facilitates annual gifts through gifts of LLC units either made directly to
beneficiaries or to trusts for their benefit. LLC units are gifted, not the assets held
by the LLC. For the donee, this is similar to receiving shares of stock in a
corporation. The donor owns a percentage of the entire LLC. It is important that
the value of the gift be substantiated by appraisal of the underlying assets
followed by valuation of the LLC units and the donor should consider filing a
Federal Gift Tax Return to start the statute of limitations running for the gift.
LLC management may be structured to allow younger family members, key
employees, or others an increasing investment and business decision-making role
over time. In the family setting, family members may begin to accumulate an
equity interest within the LLC that can be used for education or other needs.
Those who manage the LLC have considerable discretion to retain and reinvest
income from operations or to distribute. Most LLCs make distributions and are
managed to distribute annually at least enough income to pay income tax
attributable to each member’s share of distributable profit or more. It is important
to provide benefits to members to avoid the IRS contention that gifts of LLC units
are future gifts, without a current measurable benefit, usually a bad tax outcome.
The LLC avoids fractionalizing family assets to make annual or other gifts. This simplifies the
process of gifting and property management. Since LLC units are not liquid assets, and are not
freely assignable, the donor of the LLC units retains a degree of control over the gift if in a
position to participate in management of the LLC. Furthermore, in a non-family business
setting, management of the LLC can be performed by non-family members while the family
member gift recipient receives something that provides real present value that is not easily lost or
misspent.
5
Article 2
The Tax Implications of LLC Planning
Section 2.01 Fair Market Value and Limited Liability Company Units
To understand the tax consequences of using an LLC, it is important to define “fair market
value” and its relationship to the LLC. Fair Market Value “FMV” is defined in Treas. Reg.
20.2036-1(b) as:
What a willing buyer would pay a willing seller, when neither is compelled to act
and both understand all of the relevant facts.
The LLC agreement itself limits the economic value of an LLC unit by restricting the rights of
members. For example, the agreement may state that a Member has no right to demand a
distribution, order dissolution of the LLC, participate in the management of the LLC, withdraw
from the LLC, or sell his or her LLC units to anyone without a 100% vote of all members. Thus,
the Member’s interest is not as valuable as the representative share of underlying assets since he
or she lacks the rights of a full owner.
Full value is represented by the actual asset, or fraction thereof, that the member would own if
there were no LLC. Since this is not what the member has, LLC units are “discounted” to a
reasonable fair market value at death to reflect marketplace reality, i.e., that they are not “worth”
full value on an ongoing basis. An informed buyer would not ordinarily be willing to pay as
much for LLC units as for a comparable asset without restrictions on enjoyment of benefits.
6
members are rightfully concerned about the availability of credit and the
temptation to create a lifestyle using it. LLCs are investment tools.
A powerful nontax reason for creating a family business enterprise is that it can be
used to train and prepare family members for success in their investment lives.
Many of our clients use an LLC as a “kitchen table” mechanism to retain control
while providing a forum for family financial and investment planning. This
“glue” can help keep the family together. Information critical to the well-being of
family members can be shared. Using a business structure in the form of an LLC
as a means of creating effective communication and financial goal setting for the
family is one of the primary benefits of this form of planning.
(b) Ease of Gifting
Gifting fractional interests in certain investment assets can be difficult and
problematic. For example, a farm, real estate, or business is hard to split into
fractional interests. To complicate matters, some asset values change on a daily
basis. The LLC allows for gifts of fractional interests of the LLC itself, since
LLC units are similar to shares of stock. The LLC owns the underlying asset
while members own LLC units or a percentage of the entity. A person assigns a
share or part of a share in order to transfer units.
(c) Gift Tax Savings
The law allows annual gifts to be made without paying gift taxes. The limit on
such gifts is $16,000 per gift recipient, per year as of 2022. (Check with your
attorney or tax accountant as this exclusion may change in future years.) If one
spouse makes a gift and the other spouse joins in the gift, the annual gift tax
exclusion increases to $32,000 per year per gift recipient. Thus, a couple with
four children may give away up to $128,000 per year in cash or in kind without
using any portion of their lifetime exemption from estate and gift taxes.
Valuation discounts generally apply to fractional interests in any business,
including a family business, and whether active or passive. For example, if a
valuation discount of 50% applies to LLC units, then a single person making gifts
of LLC units could effectively remove $32,000 in comparable asset value from
his or her taxable estate each year per gift recipient. With that type of discount, a
couple with four children could conceivably gift the equivalent of $256,000 each
year in related underlying assets, by gifting $128,000 of LLC units.
(d) Death Tax Savings
Valuation adjustments may also apply to the remaining LLC units of any deceased
member: % of ownership x FMV x (1 - discount) = Estate Tax Value
(e) Protection of Gifted Interests
Outright gifts of cash or other property can be problematic. The assets or cash
gifted may be wasted, lost to creditors, or lost in divorces. It is difficult to give a
fractional interest in property other than cash. Accordingly, ownership of LLC
units with transfer restrictions can protect the integrity of the LLC structure and
its underlying assets from being lost or wasted by the gift recipients. LLC units
7
cannot be spent, wasted, or obtained by creditors. Restrictions in the LLC
agreement can prevent the transfer of LLC units to those outside the LLC without
the agreement of all members.
(f) Alternative Income Options vs. LLC Distributions
Managing Members are entitled to income in the form of management fees as
compensation for managing the LLC. LLCs can be structured with a “preferred
equity interest” that pays a set percentage of income to holders of that interest.
These potential income sources can provide security to certain members even
though they may have given away a substantial percentage of LLC units.
8
Section 2.07 Franchise Tax Savings Using an LLC
In some jurisdictions there are franchise tax savings associated with LLCs that are not available
to other business entities. However, in some states, LLCs are taxed more heavily than other
forms of ownership. State income tax and franchise tax laws must always be considered.
Depending on the type of income and where it is generated, the LLC may owe franchise taxes in
more than one state and in a state other than the state in which it was formed.
Article 3
Asset Protection and LLC Planning
9
Section 3.02 How Does an LLC Provide Personal Asset Protection?
An LLC can protect assets from personal lawsuit creditors. When a judgment is entered against
a member individually, that individual member’s personal creditor generally cannot seize any
assets of the LLC. Creditors of an individual member usually only have some rights to
distributions from the LLC should any occur. Rights would not typically include any right to
manage the LLC or to demand that distributions be made from it or to vote the LLC interest.
LLC law generally provides a creditor with only one way to collect a judgment; this is what is
referred to as a “charging order.”
A charging order allows the creditor to seize LLC distributions actually made. But there is no
way for the creditor to force a distribution. The creditor would be forced to wait until a
distribution was actually made to the debtor-member.
An LLC agreement generally allows withholding of LLC distributions to members in order to
accumulate revenue for the reasonable needs of the LLC. This would increase the members’
capital accounts. Moreover, under IRS rules, even if a creditor did not receive distributions, the
creditor may be required to pay the income tax associated with the LLC interest that is subject to
the charging order. This leaves the creditor in the unenviable position of paying taxes on money
not received.
10
To avoid the danger of “all eggs in one basket” an LLC may be structured with subordinate
entities to own “risky” assets, i.e., those that create liability. The preferred solution is for the
LLC to own one or more subordinate limited liability companies. An asset protection design can
involve wholly owned subordinate LLCs (taxable as disregarded entities) to hold risky assets.
The subordinate LLC contains the risk. The subordinate LLC is the property owner, so only the
assets of that LLC would be at risk. This arrangement will not work in all jurisdictions, so LLC
members should consult with counsel to obtain more information before implementing an
arrangement of this nature.
Section 3.06 What Options Does a Creditor Have When Suing a Member?
A creditor has three potential outcomes from a successful claim. The creditor could hope to
receive LLC units, could wait until the LLC is liquidated to collect the liquidation value
available, or could obtain a charging order.
(a) Can the Creditor Obtain a Member’s LLC units?
LLC units are personal non-exempt property and as such would appear to be
collectible. Can the creditor really get the LLC units? Since status as a member
depends on the terms of the agreement, a debtor-member would first have to get
permission from the other members before making the transfer to a creditor, an
unlikely result. A creditor might be an assignee, but that is merely a right to
receive distributions, not a right to exercise LLC rights such as voting.
(b) Can the Creditor Obtain LLC Assets from a Member?
Since a member has no right to take assets from the LLC, the creditor does not
have the right to take assets from the LLC either. The creditor could sue the
member, get a judgment, and wait until the LLC is liquidated to collect it as that
member collects his or her share of the liquidated assets. If the LLC is set up to
last for 50 years with a 50-year option, the creditor might not collect for almost
100 years. That is a long time to wait. Will the creditor be willing to wait years,
even decades, to be able to collect? For most people, waiting until liquidation to
collect is not a viable option.
(c) Can the Creditor Obtain a Charging Order?
Most state laws make a charging order the “sole” remedy for a creditor of a
member. Some states have provided that the charging order is the “exclusive”
remedy. The judgment creditor could collect the debtor’s share of any income
distributed by the LLC.
A charging order entitles the creditor to distributions (not management fees,
loans, or sale proceeds) made to the debtor Member. For this purpose, the
creditor is given a status that is the equivalent of an assignee of the debtor’s
member’s interest. The IRS (Rev. Ruling 77-137) is read by many commentators
to suggest that the assignee should receive a K-1 statement showing the assignee’s
share of LLC income, even if no distributions of cash are made from the LLC.
Since the LLC is a pass-through entity for income tax purposes, the debtor’s share
of undistributed income may be taxed to the judgment creditor even though the
11
debtor did not receive the LLC income. This type of income is sometimes
referred to as “phantom income.”
The possibility of “phantom income” can provide a strong disincentive for
someone who sues a person owning interests in an LLC or a strong incentive to
settle early. If the creditor’s share of phantom income is a significant amount, it
may throw the creditor into a higher tax bracket and could even force the creditor
to pay more in income tax in a year than he actually received in income.
Some creditors will not be deterred by a charging order. Some creditors have
significant loss carry-forwards that they will never be able to use. These potential
creditors are rare. A creditor with a tort judgment is the more common creditor of
a member. When we consider who the most likely creditors might be and their
commitment to forcing settlement or receiving an award, the typical creditor will
usually be deterred by the tax consequences of a charging order.
(d) So, What Do Creditors Do?
Many creditors prefer to settle the lawsuit rather than dealing with a charging
order and facing the risk of phantom income. The LLC helps to level the
litigation playing field by forcing a creditor to spend at least the same amount of
money pursuing the claim as the debtor will spend defending it.
12
Risky assets held in a separate or subordinate LLC do not contaminate the safe assets held in the
LLC itself, or in other LLCs, so long as the entities are operated properly.
Similarly, use of an appropriate entity Manager is an added level of protection for persons
serving in that capacity. The use of an asset protection entity makes certain that no individual is
exposed to personal liability. Protecting a Manager and protecting the assets of the LLC from
any potential joint liability goes hand in hand.
13
Article 4
LLC Operational Issues
14
financial advisors should monitor the performance of investment assets held by the LLC. You
must keep in mind that the LLC is a business entity, created for a business purpose, and must be
operated as a business.
(a) Need to Keep Your LLC Current
The tax laws concerning LLCs changes on a regular basis. New opportunities are
regularly created, and some opportunities may be lost. Therefore, do not look at
your LLC plan as something you do and then forget. It is a business. Like any
other business, it requires regular attention.
We suggest that you contact us to calendar annual LLC meetings.
(b) Important Issues to Consider in Operating the LCC
The IRS has enjoyed considerable success in recent years by attacking
partnerships and LLCs that were not properly operated. The following is a
checklist of the items or issues that should be considered to ensure that your LLC
is not one of those:
● Do not transfer all of the senior generation’s assets to the LLC
leaving no assets outside the LLC to provide income to maintain
the senior member’s lifestyle.
● Title to real property or securities intended to be owned by the
LLC should be formally transferred to the partnership.
● A separate set of accounting books and records must be
maintained for the LLC.
● The LLC must have its own separate bank account, and income
generated by the LLC must be deposited into that account.
● Distributions from the LLC to members must be based on pro-rata
membership interests. The following distributions have been
found to be fatal in some recent court cases:
● distributions to pay for personal living expenses of
an LLC member, particularly a senior generation
LLC member
● distributions to pay for special medical needs,
including nursing home expenses.
● distributions to make annual gifts to family
members or to make loans to family members
● indirect distributions in the form of rent-free use of
residential property owned by the LLC.
● Lack of regular meetings of LLC members and recordation
through minutes of discussions of decisions made.
● Failure to compensate managing member for services provided
15
● Failure to properly reflect LLC income on K-1’s to proper LLC
member
16
● Continue to hold an investment that no longer meets the “prudent man”
standards.
● Continue to hold assets transferred to the LLC without an independent
investigation of their quality as LLC investments.
● Delegate investment decisions to others. The LLC agreement instrument
may enlarge or limit investment powers, but you should always keep in
mind the Prudent Person Rule quoted above.
Important Note about Prudent Person Rule: In many states, the Prudent Person Rule applies
to the entire investment portfolio. This may or may not be the same as the business judgment
rule that is generally applied to decision-makers in business entities. When juries make
decisions on these cases, they may consider the entire investment portfolio performance, but if
they find one investment that does not meet the Prudent Person Rule, the jury may find the
Trustee liable. Generally, there is a higher standard for Trustees than for other fiduciaries such as
agents, business managers, general members, etc.
17
Non-business tangible personal use property, like furniture, jewelry, collectibles, and the like
should be kept out of the LLC. Since most clients prefer to continue to use their personal
property, they should keep it out of the LLC in order to avoid having to rent it from the LLC.
Cars and other motor vehicles that are used for personal use should also be kept out of the LLC.
A motor vehicle can produce tremendous personal liability for the owner of the vehicle if an auto
accident happens. By keeping vehicles out of an LLC, our clients avoid having to rent the
vehicles from the LLC, and also protect the LLC itself from incurring liabilities that can exist for
owners of motor vehicles.
Annuities, IRAs, and other qualified retirement plan funds should be kept out of the LLC since
these items must be personally owned for certain tax purposes. Transfer of these assets to an
LLC would result in adverse immediate income taxes.
18
General Questions and Answers
In order to preserve the advantages of doing business as a Limited Liability Company and to
comply with the applicable laws in the course of conducting the LLC’s business, there are certain
fundamental policies and procedures that must be established and followed. Members must read
and observe these policies and procedures to protect the benefits of LLC planning.
Section 5.01 Observe the Formalities to Assure LLC Status as a Separate Legal
Entity
The Limited Liability Company (LLC) is a legal entity or “person,” separate from its members,
managers, any officers, and employees. One advantage of doing business in the LLC entity form
is to prevent LLC obligations from becoming the obligations of its limited members, managers,
officers, and employees. To accomplish this goal, it is essential that the separate existence of the
LLC be recognized and respected.
Any business done by the LLC should be conducted in the LLCs name to preserve its status as a
legal person. Business should not be conducted by the individuals involved in their individual
capacity, but only in their business capacity, such as “Member” or “Manager.”
It is important that receipts and disbursements flow through the correct entities. For example, if
rent is received by the LLC from a property owned by the LLC, the rent should be deposited in
the LLC’s account. Business transactions must always be done through business, not personal,
accounts.
If management fees are payable to a Manager or Member, the LLC should write a check from the
LLC account to that party. That party should deposit the check into its bank account, and then if
it is an entity, write checks to the managers, officers, or Trustees for management fees.
Distribution checks should be written to the members (whether trusts, entities, or individuals) as
distributions are made. Creating this “paper trail” makes it difficult for anyone to argue that
there was no business purpose when in fact the LLC was managed like a business. On the other
hand, if this is not done, it can be argued that there was no business purpose, and that the LLC
should be disregarded as a separate legal entity.
State law decrees that certain written records must be kept and maintained at the principal or
registered office of the LLC. Any member or assignee may make a request of LLC information
at any reasonable time and make copies free of charge.
The records must be in written form or able to be reduced to written form. The laws of each
state vary as to what records are required, but the required records generally include:
(a) Current Lists Which:
States the name of and current address of each Member; and
States the percentage owned by each member; and
States the names of the members of each class or group when two
or more types of LLC interest are created.
19
(b) Copies of Tax Returns
Copies of the Limited Liability Company’s federal, state, and local tax returns for
the most recent six tax years must be kept.
(c) Copies of Specific Documents
Copies of the LLC agreement, Articles of Organization, all amendments,
restatements, copies of any powers of attorney, and any documents that create
classes or groups of members must be kept.
(d) Written Statements
A written statement of the following must be kept:
Cash contributions and agreed value of any other property
contributed and that the members have agreed to make in the
future; and
The time additional contributions are to be made or events
requiring additional contributions; and
Events requiring the LLC to be dissolved and its affairs wound up;
and
The date each member became a member; and
The books and records of the accounts of the LLC.
Another issue to consider is meticulous maintenance of any Member entity’s records. If an entity
is a manager, for example, it is important that books and records be kept up to date, tax returns
be properly filed on time, and all state reports filed timely. Since a Manager (if used) is critical
to the success of the LLC, it is important that it be properly maintained if it is an entity as well.
Even if certain records are not required under state law, the entity’s records should be maintained
with as much detail as possible because failing to do so could make it easier for someone suing
the LLC to pierce the veil and hold the Members liable for the LLC’s debts.
20
Appraisal report prepared by competent business appraiser - This
is another critical factor. This should be done prior to initial
gifting of LLC interests, and it should be updated in future years.
Making gifts based on the underlying asset value sets a precedent
with the IRS that there should be no discount. Gifts made using
the fair market value (FMV) of the underlying assets assist the IRS
argument that the FMV of the underlying assets is the value to use
upon death.
Document business purpose and maintain documentation
supporting any valuation adjustment or discount – Business
purpose is a nontax reason for planning. Appropriate business
purposes are often cited in the LLC agreement. Members should
review these purposes during annual tax preparation, or more often
as appropriate, and make notations in the business records.
Document drafting – Legal documentation pertaining to the LLC
should be reviewed each year or so by your attorney and CPA for
changes in the tax law, the LLC situation, and relevant individual
member issues.
Facts of the case – The facts surrounding creation and operation of
an LLC are germane to the benefits the members receive. Since
members cannot change the facts of the case, it is important to
consider how they affect tax and nontax outcomes. Bad facts can
often be overcome or dealt with through plan design.
Asset mixture – Some assets work better than other assets for LLC
planning. When investment assets are exclusively used to fund the
LLC, consideration must be given to the “anti-diversification
rules” in order to avoid applicability of certain potentially
unfavorable income tax rules on contribution of those assets to the
LLC. Assets that create liability might be better held in a separate
entity, either separate from or subordinate to the LLC.
21
Because of the complexity of the legal requirements relating to disclosure and registration of
offering securities, it is most important that legal advice be obtained when any financing plan is
developed and prior to any contract with any person concerning the possible sale of any LLC
interests. If matters are not properly managed from the outset, opportunities for financing may
be legally foreclosed.
Section 5.06 Deductibility of Fees Paid for Business and Estate Planning
Legal and tax advice fees for business planning is usually deductible in the year that the fees are
paid. Estate planning fees for certain services may be tax deductible. Depending on the amount
spent on the organization of the LLC, the amount spent may be deducted in the first year or
amortized over a period of 60 months from the date the LLC is organized. An election under
section 709 of the Internal Revenue Code will need to be made on the first federal income tax
return of the LLC. These possible deductions should be reviewed with your income tax return
preparer.
22
is easy to see that real estate poses more lawsuit risk to the owner than marketable
securities. It is important to try to classify risk classes and to limit liability in any
situation to the least amount of assets possible. Different types of real estate pose
different levels of risk. How much more risk depends on the real estate, where is
it located, and the circumstances of its use. For example, farmland poses a
different risk level than an apartment building.
General Rule: Segregate different asset risk classes by using multiple entities.
[Note, however, that some state laws do not offer charging order protection to
single member LLCs.]
(b) Basis of Assets
The basis of an asset is the amount paid for that asset or its cost. When you
purchase an asset for $100, your cost basis is $100. When you sell that asset, the
basis is subtracted from the sale price to determine the capital gain. You then pay
taxes on the capital gain. There are factors that can cause the basis to increase
(making capital improvements to an asset) or to decrease such as depreciation
taken on an asset. When the basis of an asset is adjusted for various increases or
decreases, we refer to the basis as an adjusted basis.
When a gift of an asset is made to another person your basis, for determining gain
on the sale of the asset, will transfer to that person. Thus, when they sell it at a
gain, they will calculate their capital gains tax by using your basis. But if the
person sells the asset at a loss, they will use the lesser of your basis or the fair
market value of the asset at the time of the gift, to determine their capital loss.
But if a person inherits an asset, they will receive a step up (or down) in basis,
equal to fair market value of that asset on the date of death or six months after the
date of death in some cases. This means that when inherited property is sold in
the future, gain or loss will be calculated by using this new fair market value
basis.
When you contribute assets to an LLC, those assets have a basis. If members
contribute many different assets in the LLC, each with a different basis, it can
become an expensive administrative nightmare for the CPA. The LLCU you
receive for contribution of the asset also has a basis of its own. Gifted LLC units
transfer the LLCU basis to the gift recipient.
Remember that sales may not occur for years and may include multiple
generations of family members. Some assets will receive a step up or down in
basis following a member’s death. Some assets will retain the original basis. In
some cases, an asset will be mixed with some of the asset receiving the step up in
basis and some receiving a step down in basis. This can create complications
such as additional accounting expense or increasing the chances of IRS attack.
General Rule: Be careful in mixing assets in an LLC or allowing future
contributions of additional assets. Consider use of a different LLC for each basis
class. It costs more money initially and a little more administratively to run each
year but can significantly reduce overall cost and complexity.
23
(c) Diversification and Tax-Free Formation
Transferring assets into an LLC is not usually a taxable event. However, some
transfers do trigger an immediate tax. Current law recognizes a taxable event
when certain “diversification” occurs with securities, for example. The
diversification rules are a trap for the unwary.
(1) The 80% Rule
The first rule is sometimes called the 80% rule. If marketable
securities that are contributed to the LLC make up more than 80%
of its asset value, diversification could be a problem.
Diversification does not occur if 20% or more of the value of the
LLC is made up of real estate. When considering the value, keep
in mind that any other discounts or valuation adjustments applying
to assets must be considered before trying to satisfy this rule.
If more than 80% of the LLCs assets are stocks and securities, the
LLC could be classified as an “investment company”. Transfers to
an investment company can result in immediate recognition of gain
on the transfer of appreciated securities if the transfer is to:
A regulated investment company; or
A real estate investment trust; or
A corporation, partnership, or LLC if more than
80% of the value of its assets are held for
investment and are cash, stocks, or securities.
Under TRA ‘97, the definition of cash, stocks, and
securities was greatly expanded. Stocks and
securities include:
Marketable stocks and securities;
Cash;
All corporate interests;
Evidence of indebtedness;
Options
Forward or futures contracts;
Foreign currency;
Precious metals; or
Interests in any entity if 90% or more of its
assets consist of any of the types of interests
described above.
(2) The Non-identical Assets Rule
Transfers of non-identical assets can cause diversification, unless
the assets are already diversified. This rule is easy to trigger
24
because if one person contributes stock A and another person
contributes stock B, these are not identical assets. Thus, gain must
be recognized on the transfer. There are some exceptions. For
example, by definition, mutual funds are diversified already and
therefore the contribution of mutual funds should not cause
diversification. The transfer of identical assets, however, does not
cause diversification. Therefore, if one or more persons transfer
the identical security the anti-diversification rule is not violated.
(3) The De Minimis Exception
The de minimis exception avoids application of the rule when an
insignificant contribution is made that would technically trigger the
rule. The IRS has accepted a 1% contribution as an insignificant
amount but has rejected an11% contribution as being insignificant.
The area between 1% and 11% is a no-man’s land.
(4) The 25% Test and the 50% Test
Diversification does not occur if the transferors transfer a
diversified portfolio of stocks and securities to the LLC, provided
the 25% and 50% tests are met.
A portfolio of assets is treated as diversified if not more
than 25% of value of total assets is invested in the stock
and securities of any one issuer; and
A portfolio of assets is treated as diversified if not more
than 50% of value of total assets is invested in the stock
and securities of five or fewer issuers.
The diversification rules are one more factor to help determine
how many LLCs or other entities to use in a given case. As a
practical matter, careful consideration of the assets being
contributed avoids this problem. Trying to do too much with one
LLC can create a lot of diversification problems.
(d) Examples of Diversification (a summary of the above)
Will the contribution diversify the contributing person’s assets? If the
contribution does not diversify the contributors’ assets, the investment company
taxation rules do not apply.
Diversification results if two or more persons contribute non-identical assets to
the LLC.
The same diversification rule may apply to contributions from spouses in
non-community property states. In non-community property states,
diversification does not result if spouses contribute assets jointly owned in the
same proportion as their interests in the LLC. Therefore, spouses should transfer
title to joint tenancy or tenants in common before transferring the assets to the
LLC.
25
In community property states, spouses may contribute different community
property assets as the sole LLC assets. Diversification does not result when
spouses contribute community property assets, even if those assets are the sole
assets used to fund the entity. Thus, when spouses contribute community property
assets to fund an LLC, taxation of appreciated assets is rarely an issue.
If one party contributes almost all of the assets to form an LLC other than de
minimis contributions by other members, there is no diversification. If an
individual contributes assets worth less than 1% of the LLC, the de minimis
exception applies. De minimis contributions are not considered for purposes of
determining diversification.
If several individuals contribute identical assets to form an LLC, diversification
does not occur.
Contributing an already “diversified” portfolio of stocks and securities does not
cause diversification. A portfolio is diversified if not more that 25% of the value
of the contributed securities is from one issuer; and not more than 50% of the
value of the assets are the securities of five or fewer issuers.
Mutual funds are diversified by definition. Thus, contributing mutual fund shares
to an LLC should not cause diversification.
If the contribution is “stocks and securities” (see below), which are not identical
in both type and ratio to the assets already in the LLC, and “marketable
securities” comprise over 80% of the value of the LLC, investment company
taxation rules will apply. An entity not diversified at its formation can become
diversified by later contributions, retroactively creating a taxable event. With
other than husbands and wives contributing community property, the contributors
should own the assets to be contributed as joint tenants or tenants in common in
proportion to their ownership interest in the entity before transferring the assets to
the entity.
If the contribution causes diversification, are more than 80% of the assets “stocks
and securities?” If so, the entity will be treated as an investment company.
Analyze the assets to be contributed to an LLC. Are they “stocks and securities”
as defined by IRC 351(e), which includes:
__ cash;
__ stock or securities of any private or public corporation;
__ options;
__ forward or future contracts;
__ precious metals;
__ foreign currency;
__ interests in publicly traded partnerships or LLCs;
__ any interest in a real estate investment trust (REIT), registered investment
company, or common trust fund;
__ bonds and personal notes; and
__ interests in any entity if 90% or more of its assets consist of any of the
types of interests described above.
26
If more than 20% of the total value in an LLC is investment real property or other
assets that are not classified as “stocks and securities,” the entity will not be
treated as an investment company. If possible, contribute at least 20% investment
real property to prevent the LLC from being considered an investment company.
Exercise extreme caution when contributing assets to an already funded LLC.
Article 6
Funding the LLC
Specific funding of assets must be approached on a case-by-case basis. The information in this
section of the manual is general in nature. If you have a revocable living trust and have received
an Operations Manual or Funding Memorandum for that trust, you will notice that much of the
funding information in this document may differ from the information in that manual. To that
extent, these instructions override the funding instructions contained in the manual that came
with your revocable living trust.
It is important that the LLC be funded in order to obtain the benefits of the LLC structure.
27
If you do not want to be burdened with handling all the paperwork involved in getting these
transfers made, your attorney can prepare documents for you and take care of getting the
transfers made. If you prefer, your other advisors including your life insurance professional,
financial planner, or CPA may assist you with transfer of certain types of assets.
(a) Taxpayer ID Number
The LLC must submit form SS-4, titled “Application for Employer’s
Identification Number” to the Internal Revenue Service to obtain a taxpayer
identification number. Each LLC and each other business entity and some trusts,
owning an interest in the LLC, must have its own Taxpayer Identification number.
(b) Tax Returns
By default, an LLC is taxable as a partnership. In this case, a Form 1065 U. S.
Partnership Tax Return must be filed by April 15 of each year and the Tax Matters
Member must issue each member a Form 1065 Schedule K-1. Each member must
use the information from the Form 1065 Schedule K-1 to report LLC tax
information on their annual IRS Form 1040, 1041, 1120, or 1065 Tax Return as
the case may be. Remember to file the appropriate tax return if your LLC is
taxable as something other than a partnership, i.e., a disregarded entity or
corporation.
(c) Future Acquisitions or Sales of LLC Assets
When the LLC acquires a new item of property or opens a new account, be sure to
acquire it in the name of the LLC. The sale of an LLC asset will require that the
entity pass good title to the sold asset. Remember to review such transactions
with your attorney or CPA prior to executing them if you do not know or are
uncertain about legal or tax ramifications.
28
Section 6.04 How is an LLC Funded?
In general, an LLC is funded by taking title to assets in its name. Transfers are generally
accomplished in the same manner by which title was originally obtained. For example, when
you acquire land, you receive a deed. Similarly, the LLC would receive a deed from the
contributing real property owner.
29
When you transfer real estate to any other party or entity, contact your insurance
agent. Ask the agent to make sure the new owner is included as an “insured” or
as an “additional insured” on the insurance policy for each piece of property
transferred.
Warranty deeds, transfers of lien, mineral deeds, and transfers of oil and gas
leases necessary to transfer your real property and related holdings into your LLC
are normally documents that an attorney must prepare and that must be recorded.
If in the future, you should sell any real estate that is in the LLC, or desire to
purchase in-state real estate in the name of the LLC, contact your attorney for
assistance. A lawyer licensed in the appropriate state must prepare out-of-state
real estate deeds.
CAVEAT: Mortgaged Real Estate. If you have a mortgage on your real
property, it is advisable to seek prior approval from your lender prior to recording
the warranty deed. It is essential that you bring your deed of trust or mortgage to
your attorney for review to make certain there is no prohibition against
transferring the real property into the LLC. Violation may result in acceleration
of the mortgage or trust deed through “due on sale” clauses in mortgages or trust
deeds that encumber the property. Approval is almost always granted because the
conveyance does not release existing liability on the debt secured by the
encumbrance.
Every lending institution has different rules and regulations. If you are unsure
about any mortgage, it is better to seek permission from the lender prior to
recording the deed to the LLC. If the lender will not consent to the transfer to the
LLC, then do not record the deed! Simply keep the deed with your LLC papers
and attach a signed and dated memo to it indicating that the deed was
intentionally not recorded.
Under the laws of many states, it is not necessary to record the deed for the
transfer of real estate to your LLC to be effective for transfer purposes. It is,
however, necessary to record deeds for creditor protection purposes and to avoid
title problems. Holding unfiled deeds can be a risky action to take.
(d) Stocks and Bonds
Stocks and bonds and other securities are often transferred to an LLC. Your
stockbroker, the issuing company, or a designated transfer agent will need to
register these assets in the name of the LLC. If you have a stockbroker, the stocks
may be held in a “street name account,” a brokerage account in the LLC name
with the actual stocks held in the brokerage company’s name. This is the safest
way for you to own stock, and there should be little or no cost to you to have the
title changed to the LLC.
(1) Government Bonds
Government bonds may be re-titled in the name of the LLC by
completing an application form that may be obtained from:
Bureau of Public Debt
200 3rd Street
30
Parkersburg, West Virginia 26101
Attention: Transactions and Rulings.
Alternatively, you may be able to find a bank that will manage
such transfer for you. US Government Bonds should normally be
transferred to your LLC formally, rather than retained in the name
of a Member as nominee, unless the total value of such bonds is
very minimal.
(2) Unregistered Bonds
Unregistered bonds (such as municipal bonds and unregistered
treasury bonds) may be assigned to the LLC through use of a
separate piece of paper signed by you and attached to the bond. It
can be typed or handwritten.
(e) Business Assets
Business assets may be transferred as follows:
(1) Sole Proprietorships
Business assets such as a sole proprietorship for which you use a
trade name can be transferred to your LLC as follows:
“I hereby sell, transfer, assign and convey all of my
right, title, and interest in and to [NAME OF LLC],
LLC, a Limited Liability Company.”
Signed,
Your Name Here
After assignment of such assets, you should file a new trade name
affidavit or form with the State and/or any other assumed or
fictitious name filing governmental unit, to reflect that your LLC is
now the owner of such business.
(2) Entity Interests
You can also transfer other LLC, corporate, or partnership interests
to your LLC by an assignment of such interests.
Be sure that a review of other entity agreements is done to
determine what type of consents to such assignments may be
required so that the necessary consent documents are properly
prepared and signed by all of the required parties.
(3) Shareholder Agreements
With any stock that is subject to a buy-sell agreement, or subject to
a shareholder agreement, a proper type of assignment of such stock
will be necessary. Make sure that a stock power is signed and an
amendment is made to the agreement that recognizes the LLC as
the new shareholder.
31
(4) Small Corporation Stock and Professional Corporation
Stock
Do not transfer S Corporation stock or IRC Section 1244 stock
to an LLC without consulting your tax advisor. S corporation
stock should generally be transferred to an intentional grantor
trust such as your revocable living trust.
Professional Corporation stock cannot be transferred to an
LLC.
Other small corporation stock can be transferred to an LLC. Use a
stock power or assignment like that mentioned above for other
corporate stocks.
(f) Savings Accounts and Certificates of Deposit
Savings accounts can be titled in an LLC by executing a new signature card with
the financial institution in which the funds are kept. The ownership of a checking
or savings account is determined by what appears on the signature card on record
at the bank. While it is not important that the LLC name appear on your checks,
it is important that the LLC name appear on you monthly account statements.
A certificate of deposit can sometimes be assigned to the LLC without penalty.
To be sure there is no penalty, check with the financial institution before making
the transfer. Otherwise, to avoid a penalty wait until the certificate matures and
then take out a new CD titled in the name of the LLC.
An assignment of the CD to the LLC can document the intended transfer in the
interim. The assignment may then be attached to the Certificate of Deposit with a
paper clip and retained with the Certificate. When the new CD is formally
reissued in the name of the LLC throw away the assignment.
(g) Notes, Mortgages, and Trust Deeds
Notes and security instruments such as mortgages and trust deeds can be
transferred to an LLC. Notes are assigned subject to their terms or any
restrictions.
A formal assignment should be used to transfer a mortgage or trust deed to the
LLC. It may or may not be necessary to record such an assignment, but the
original should be placed with the original note and security instrument to form a
complete chain of title when it comes time to cancel or release the indebtedness
and encumbrance.
(h) Life Insurance
Life insurance policies have both an owner and at least one beneficiary. Policies
may be assigned to the LLC. Your life insurance agent would provide necessary
forms to make the LLC the owner and the beneficiary of the policy. You will
need both a Change of Beneficiary form and a Change of Ownership form.
32
(i) Annuities
Do not transfer annuities into your LLC without tax or legal advice about the
consequences. There are special rules that apply to annuities, and you may lose
the tax benefit of deferral of income taxes on earnings within the annuity if you
transfer it to your LLC.
(j) IRA’s and Retirement Benefits
Do not transfer any IRAs or retirement plan assets into your LLC without
tax or legal advice. There can be significant adverse income tax effects if you
transfer such assets. There are potentially some strategies that use these assets
with an LLC, but the facts must be carefully considered prior to making such
transfers.
(k) Digital Assets
Digital Assets like cryptocurrency, bitcoin, Ethereum, NFTs, and other digital
assets may either be held as untitled intangible business property, when owned in
a hardware wallet or cold storage, or in an account on an exchange. If they are
held as untitled intangible business property, transfer of these digital assets is best
accomplished with either a Bill of Sale or an Assignment transferring the items
into the LLC. If the digital assets are held in an account on an exchange, then you
should open a new account on the exchange in the name of the LLC and transfers
those assets to the LLC account in accordance with the exchange rules.
33
Article 7
Miscellaneous Issues Regarding Your LLC
34
A distribution of profits taxable to the member; or
As a loan (loans from an LLC to its members are extremely suspect to the IRS,
and unless completely documented have a questionable chance of surviving an
IRS audit). Likewise, cash or property made available to the LLC by its members
will either be considered a contribution to capital or a loan, and all loans should
be properly documented. Properly documented, this also means that the note
should be signed and should bear a market interest rate.
Section 7.05 Does Transferring an Asset Into the LLC Create Tax Liability?
There is normally no tax owed when property is contributed to the LLC in return for an LLC
interest. The transfer of assets to an LLC in exchange for an LLC interest is called a capital
contribution. If someone sells property to the LLC, however, the seller must pay any taxes (such
as capital gains tax) resulting from such sale. It is important that you review several of the prior
articles of this manual for the exceptions to this tax-free transfer rule!
35
following the end of each calendar and an annual unemployment tax return, Form
940, on or before January 31st of each year.
(b) Is the LLC Required to Withhold State Income Taxes?
The Limited Liability Company must normally comply with any state withholding
requirements in all states in which it does business.
36