Professional Documents
Culture Documents
154]
Department of Image, Guangdong Provincial Hospital of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Guangzhou 518100, Guangdong Province, China
Abstract
Balanced acupuncture, a single-acupoint balance therapy, regulates the balance of the cerebral Yongsong Ye★, Master,
Attending physician, De-
center, and is characterized by exerting quick effects and a short treatment course. A total of 20
partment of Image, Guang-
low-back and leg pain patients with lumbar disc herniation were treated with balanced acupuncture dong Provincial Hospital of
or body acupuncture. Central mechanisms of varied acupunctures were compared using rest- Traditional Chinese Medi-
cine, Guangzhou 518100,
ing-state functional MRI. Patients from both groups received functional MRI before and after acu-
Guangdong Province, China
puncture. Functional connectivity in brain regions that were strongly associated with the bilateral
amygdala was analyzed utilizing AFNI software. Visual analogue scale scores were greater in the Corresponding author:
Yongsong Ye, Department of
balanced acupuncture group compared with the body acupuncture group. Function of the endo-
Image, Guangdong Provin-
genous pain regulation network was enhanced in patients in the balanced acupuncture group, but cial Hospital of Traditional
was not changed in the body acupuncture group. This result indicates that the analgesic effects of Chinese Medicine, Guang-
zhou 518100, Guangdong
body acupuncture do not work through the central nervous system. These data suggest that ba-
Province, China
lanced acupuncture exerts analgesic effects on low-back and leg pain patients with lumbar disc ye7yong7song@163.com
herniation by regulating the function of the endogenous pain regulation network.
Received: 2012-02-15
Accepted: 2012-05-13
Key Words (N20120117004/WJ)
balanced acupuncture; body acupuncture; lumbar disc herniation; functional connectivity; amygdala;
Ye YS, Liu B. Analgesic
low-back and leg pain; pain; acupuncture; traditional Chinese medicine; neural regeneration
effects of balanced acu-
puncture versus body acu-
Research highlights puncture in low-back and leg
pain patients with lumbar disc
(1) Balanced acupuncture exerts analgesic effects in low-back and leg pain patients with lumbar
herniation, as assessed by
disc herniation by regulating the function of the endogenous pain regulation network. The results of resting-state functional
balanced acupuncture were better than those of body acupuncture. (2) The function of the endo- magnetic resonance imaging.
Neural Regen Res.
genous pain regulation network was significantly enhanced in patients from the balanced acu-
2012;7(21):1624-1629.
puncture group. No overall changes in the function of the endogenous pain regulation network were
detectable in the body acupuncture group. (3) The analgesic effects of body acupuncture do not www.crter.cn
www.nrronline.org
work through the central nervous system. Thus, balanced acupuncture exerts effects rapidly, and
the effects can last for a long period. However, the effects of body acupuncture occur more slowly. doi:10.3969/j.issn.1673-5374.
2012.21.004
Abbreviations
VAS, visual analogue scale
INTRODUCTION
1624
[Downloaded free from http://www.nrronline.org on Sunday, May 10, 2020, IP: 190.238.16.154]
The amygdala, an important structure of the limbic particular, the hypothalamic-limbic system is an important
system, contains many nuclear groups of different sizes, region involved in balanced acupuncture for analgesia.
of which some nuclear groups are strongly associated Balanced acupuncture activates the nerve-endocrine-
with the coding and modulation of pain. Results from this immune system by changing the excitability of the nervous
study revealed that following balanced acupuncture, the system, inhibiting inflammation, easing pain, balancing the
brain regions that had a strong time correlation with the nerve-endocrine-immune system, adjusting physiological
bilateral amygdala were composed of the putamen, functions, and achieving analgesic effects. Ma et al [12]
thalamus, superior temporal gyrus, insular lobe, brain reported that blood plasma β-endorphin contents
stem, middle temporal gyrus, orbit of superior frontal significantly decreased at 7 days and blood plasma
gyrus, inferior frontal gyrus, cingulated gyrus, ventral adrenocorticotropic hormone contents were significantly
anterior nucleus, ventrolateral nucleus, medial frontal lower at 14 days after balanced acupuncture compared
gyrus and superior frontal gyrus. The frequency of the with the control group. These results indicated that
low-frequency oscillation signal in these brain regions is balanced acupuncture could relieve pain. Balanced
associated with the amygdala in a resting state. That is, acupuncture probably controlled physical stress by
the resting-state brain has a functional network that affecting the secretion and metabolism of the central
correlates with pain regulation and this function is nervous system. In the present study, the function of the
strengthened by balanced acupuncture. The endogenous pain regulation network was obviously
enhancement of functional connectivity in these brain increased following balanced acupuncture, which was
regions suggests that the periaqueductal gray, ventral identical to results from previously published studies[12-13].
tegmental area, compact part of the substantia nigra, Results from this study revealed that brain regions that
peripeduncular nucleus and the tegmentum accept are strongly associated with the bilateral amygdala
amygdala afference. included the left thalamus, left putamen, ventrolateral
The external relation of the amygdala to the temporal nucleus, limbic lobe and cingulated gyrus in the body
lobe cortex and olfactory system is via projections to the acupuncture group. Function of the endogenous pain
hypothalamus and brainstem[11]. In this study, the regulation network was not changed after body
functional connectivity was enhanced in the thalamus acupuncture. This result indicates that the analgesic
and brainstem of patients undergoing balanced effect of body acupuncture does not work through the
acupuncture, suggesting that there was a functional central nervous system. Yan et al [14] showed that the
connectivity between the amygdala, thalamus and mechanism of body acupuncture for rat neuropathic pain
brainstem. The enhancement of functional connectivity in was probably associated with the decreased release of
the ventral anterior nucleus and ventrolateral nucleus excitatory amino acid neurotransmitters and the
suggests the enhanced functions in the periaqueductal increased release of inhibitory amino acid
gray, ventral tegmental area, compact part of the neurotransmitters.
substantia nigra, peripeduncular nucleus and tegmentum. The amygdala is an important component of the
In addition, the amygdaloid complex is widely connected endogenous pain regulation pathway. There are
to many new cortical areas. The afference of the abundant fiber connections in the endogenous pain
amygdaloid complex was from the frontal lobe, cingulum, regulation pathway. Balanced acupuncture exerts
insular cortex and temporal lobe cortex, whereas the analgesic effects by regulating the network function,
efference of the amygdaloid complex is extensively whereas the analgesic effect of body acupuncture does
involved in new cortices. In the present study, the not work through the central nervous system. Thus,
functional connectivity was also enhanced in the balanced acupuncture exerts effects rapidly, and the
hippocampal gyrus, superior temporal gyrus, insular lobe, effects can last for a long period. However, body
middle temporal gyrus, orbit of superior frontal gyrus, acupuncture exerts effects more slowly.
inferior frontal gyrus, cingulated gyrus, medial frontal
gyrus and superior frontal gyrus, which was consistent
with a previous study[11], suggesting that this pain SUBJECTS AND METHODS
regulation-related functional network pathway exists and
its function is fortified. Taken together, the central Design
mechanism of balanced acupuncture exerts analgesia Quasi-experimental study.
effects not through a single brain region, but through a
complex network related to the amygdala. The Time and setting
periaqueductal gray, hypothalamus, somatosensory Experiments were performed at the Department of Image,
cortex I and II areas, motor cortex, caudate nucleus and Guangdong Provincial Hospital of Traditional Chinese
limbic system are important pain regulation centers. In Medicine, China from March to September 2009.
1627
[Downloaded free from http://www.nrronline.org on Sunday, May 10, 2020, IP: 190.238.16.154]
1628
[Downloaded free from http://www.nrronline.org on Sunday, May 10, 2020, IP: 190.238.16.154]
1629