Th aoe :
= Mens Q My Economist»
Graphic detail | Daily chart
How India’s men can learn to treat women
better
Classroom discussions about gender stereotypes make boys more supportive
=
Sweeping statements
Effects of gender-stereotype classes in Haryana, India
11-to 13-year-olds, 2014-16, % agreeing
[Schools with gender-stereotype classes Ml Schools without classes,
Changes in attitudes Boys Girls
20 40 6 8 10 0 2 40 60 8 100
Boys should get more opportunities/
resources for education than girls H ft
Awoman's most important role
is being a good homemaker Ht Hi
‘Aman should have the final word
about decisions in his home 4 T Ht
Awoman should tolerate violence
to keep her family together H H
Changes in behaviour Boys Girls
20 40 60 80 100 0 20 40 60 80 100
Allowed to go to school alone/
with friends 1 a
Helped with shopping for household
provisions in last week a +H:
Cooked, cleaned, or washed clothes
in last week H 1
Comfortable talking to students of
the opposite sex Hi tt
Source: "Reshaping adolescents’ gender attitudes: evidence from a school-based experiment in India’,
by Diva Dhar, Tarun Jain, Seema Jayachandran
The EconomistBy THE DATA TEAM
LIFE for Indian women is hard. According to a survey of experts in women’s rights by
Thomson Reuters, the prevalence of rape, human trafficking and forced marriage make
India the world’s most dangerous country for women. Among G20 members, only Saudi
Arabia has a lower rate of female participation in the labour market. Moreover, the share
of Indian women who have jobs in the formal or informal economy has actually fallen in
recent years, from 35% in 2005 to 26% today. Such discrimination inflicts a large
economic cost. The IMF reckons the country would be 27% richer if as many women
worked as men.
How can India solve this problem? Simply educating more girls might not help. Whereas
poor, illiterate women have little choice but to work, those with secondary schooling tend
to marry into families of higher social standing, who insist that they look after the
children. Husbands frequently think that job-seeking wives are a mark of shame.Any solution to India’s gender gap must tackle that stigma. Getting men to do more
housework is crucial. Women currently contribute six of the seven hours required each
day. Data from the OECD suggest that husbands and sons chipping in an extra hour could
increase the female workforce by five percentage points.
Changing the attitudes of India’s 700m men will be tricky. But a working paper by Diva
Dhar, Tarun Jain and Seema Jayachandran shows that it is possible. The three economists
have studied the effects of a programme organised by Breakthrough, a non-profit, that
gave lessons about gender stereotypes to 11- to 13-year-olds. The programme was
randomly allocated to 150 schools in Haryana, a northern state where gender
discrimination is particularly stark. Its teachers, who were mostly male, led 27 classroom
sessions over three years, which focused on economic and human-rights arguments for
treating women fairly.
The intervention seems to have worked. Compared with teenagers at nearby schools,
those who had participated in the programme were much less likely to agree that women
ought to be housewives, and that men should get the final say on decisions. The impact
was similarly large for students with socially conservative parents and those with
progressive ones.
The economists also surveyed students about whether they had helped with chores in the
past week. These effects were smaller, but still statistically significant. Boys at
participating schools were nearly five percentage points more likely to have contributed
to cooking and cleaning than those who had not taken the gender-discussion classes.
Girls also became more likely to help out with shopping, which is usually reserved for
men. The clearest change was an increased comfort in speaking to the opposite sex,
among both boys and girls. If the lot of Indian women is ever to improve, the men will
have to start listening.