Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Derision, Nonsense, and Carnival in The Work of Greg Curnoe, Katie Cholett
Derision, Nonsense, and Carnival in The Work of Greg Curnoe, Katie Cholett
Association of Canada)
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
AAUC/UAAC (Association des universités d’art du Canada / Universities Art Association of Canada) is
collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to RACAR: revue d'art canadienne /
Canadian Art Review.
http://www.jstor.org
Résumé
Danslesannées1960,l'artiste canadien GregCurnoeétaitle protagoniste dutrèsdynamique milieu de London
artistique enOntario.Ilycréa
uneséried'ateliers indépendants,
y exposa sesœuvres dansdifférents
lieuxet yconçut performances
plusieurs audacieuses.Curnoe étaitune
personnalité extravertie
quiadhéraitde façon aux
inconditionnelle principesdu mouvement Dada : de
rejet normes adhésion
esthétiques, à
« l'anti-art
», du
utilisation de
hasard, et
l'aléatoire de l'absurde.
Cependant, sesœuvres empreintesd'humour toutcomme ses à
activitésparfum
anarchique, nerelevaient passimplement d'unesprit moqueur Curnoeeutrecours
toutau longde sa carrière,
Eneffet, à desstratégieshumo-
ristiques de Dadaetà certains
inspirées aspects ducarnavalesquevisantà contester
le milieu
desarts,maisaussià brouiller
lesfrontières
entre
créerunecommunauté
l'artet lavie.Parlà,ilentendait danslaquelle
d'esprit ilpourrait faire
librement évoluer
sa pratique.Ce textese donne
pourobjectif de mettre enévidence le rôlecentralqu'ontjouélesstratégies dumouvement
inspirées Dadaet le carnavalesquedanslavieet
l'œuvre de cetartiste.
53
54
55
FigureI.Greg
Curnoe,Hurdle
forArt 9 April
Lovers, 1962.
Assemblage castiron,
ofwood, oil-based
belt,
plastic silver
ink,
paint, stainless-
knives,
steelknives
withwoodenandplastic aluminum
handles, bamboo
needles,
knitting silver
stick, steelscrewdriver
spoons, andmastic
blade, knife,
99X158.5 X26.5cm.Ottawa,
National © Estate
ofCanada.
Gallery ofGreg
Curnoe /SODRAC(2011).(Photo © National ofCanada).
Gallery
56
57
3.Greg
Figure DADA!!
Curnoe, Late1964.
Oilpastel
onnewsprint, 4.Greg
Figure MOTHER!
Curnoe, Late1964.
Oilpastel
onnewsprint,
X89.3cm.London,
134.6 Collection
Ontario, ofMcintosh
Gallery, 134.6
X89.3cm.London, Collection
Ontario, ofMcintosh
Gallery,
TheUniversity
ofWesternOntario.
Gift
ofSheila 2009
Curnoe, TheUniversity
ofWesternOntario.
Gift
ofSheila 2009
Curnoe,
© Estate
(Photo: ofGreg
Curnoe/SODRAC(2011)). © Estate
(Photo: ofGreg
Curnoe/SODRAC(2011)).
hadallthearguments
wewerehelpless
todo muchexcept The NihilistParty, Gereinreported,was planning"to runfor
back.
argue It me
rankled for
weeks
until
wegotbackatthe modelparliament - withouta platform
thisyear and notas a
copina minorway, him
letting knowthathisauthority
was member ofa party."39
questioned.38 Performance was one of thefundamental activities
of the
Dada movement, and,as wasthecasewiththeearlierCelebra-
WhiletheNihilistPartyhadseriousconceptual underpin- tion, performance wouldbe keyto thesummergatherings of
nings,it oftenappearedas a light-heartedsocialorganization theLondonNeo-Dadaiststhattookplacefrom1965 to 1967
witha looseconstituency.Becauseoftheanarchistic styleofor- atNo Haven,a cottageinPortStanley, a smallvacationtownon
ganizationitwas to
difficult establish who
exactly the members LakeErie.On 1 August1965,thefirst ofmanyNihilist Picnics
orsympathizers were.In 1964theNihilistPartymadethelocal washeldin PortStanley at Invererie
HeightsPark.Thepicnics
newswhenitorganized a banquetandballat "a secretmeeting featured mockspeeches,sporting events,and generalrevelry.
place."CharlesGereinoftheLondonFreePress calleditan "anti- To markthe occasionof the firstpicnicProfessor Kenneth
organization"with no leader, centralphilosophy,or doctrine. Hilbournof theUniversity ofWestern Ontariogavea speech
58
59
5.GregCurnoe,
Figure Sutherland
Jean Boggs,
Judy andPierre
LaMarsh, atthe11May1967
Théberge ofthe
opening
Three
HundredYears
ofCanadian
Artexhibit
attheNational ofCanada.
Gallery Gelatin
silver
print.
Photographed
Ottawa.
Evans,
byJohn © Library
andArchivesCanada.
John
HenryEvans
Studio
fonds/Accession
1994-435/ltem
2331-29. with
Reproduced thepermission
ofLibrary
andArchives
Canada. © National
(Photo ofCanada.)
Gallery
60
61
andturns, andbaffling contradictions ofcapitalism."78 Thecar- 13 LenoreCrawford, "Spoofs RevealArtist: Odd ObjectsExhibit
nivalesqueprovided similar techniques, belonging, as Bakhtin Startles
Art Lovers," The London FreePress, 4 November 1961.
states,"totheborderline between artandlife It is lifeitself." 14GregCurnoe, Souwesto (16mm,colour, silent,30 min)1969.
Carnivalesque humour, withitsritualsbasedon laughter, of- *5 BeatriceK. Otto,Fools areEverywhere: TheCourt Jester Around the
fered"a completely different, nonofficial, extraecclesiastical and World (Chicago, IL,2001), 38.
extrapolitical aspectoftheworld,ofman,and ofhumanrela- 16 HelenMolesworth, "From Dada toNeo-DadaandBackAgain,"
tions...[allowing themto] builda secondworldand a second October 105,Dada(Summer 2003),180.
lifeoutsideofficialdom."79 Duringthe1960sCurnoeusedde- 17 Theexhibition ranfrom 21 December 1961to 9 January 1962.
risiveand nonsensical humoristic devices,in particular a com- DonnaluWigmore, ed.,IsaacsSeen:50 Years on theArtFront
binationof elements fromDada and thecarnivalesque, in all (Toronto, 2005),158.
aspects of hislife and art as a form of social criticism intended 18 Curnoes work mayreference JasperJohns's Drawer , anassemblage
to express hispoliticalbeliefs, shakeup thestatusquo, collapse on canvas from1957.ThetitleofJohns's workreferred to both
theboundaries betweenartand life,and createan interpretive and to
undergarments draughtsmanship, appearance while in it
community withinwhichhe couldpromote hisart. reproduced a non-functioning dresserdrawer. SusanHapgood,
Neo-Dada: Redefining Art1958-62(Scottsdale, AZ, 1994),18.
Acknowledegments 19 MichelSanouillet, "TheSignof Dada at theIsaacsGallery,
Toronto," Canadian Art19,2 (March-April 1962),111.
I wouldliketothankSSHRC s DoctoralFellowship programme 20 Robert Fulford, "World of Art:Anarchy," TorontoDailyStar , 23
and theNationalGalleryof Canadas Fellowship in Canadian December 1961.
Artprogramme forfinancial assistance withthisproject. 21 Fulford,"World ofArt:Anarchy."
22 Fulford,"World ofArt:Anarchy."
Notes 23 Barbara Rose,"Dada,Thenand Now,"ArtInternational 7, 1
(January 1963),24.
1 Amendments 1,3,and6. GregCurnoe, "Amendments toContin- 24 Hapgood, "Neo-Dada," 56.
entalRefusal/Refus Continental," reprinted in 20 Cents Magazine 25 Rose,"Dada, Then and Now," 24.
4,4 (April 1970),unpaginated. 26 Rose,"Dada, Then and Now," 24.
2 IreneMcKim, a Kingston artist, reported that most of the small 27 Hapgood, "Neo-Dada," 44.
localaudience responded withdisfavour to Boyle's andCurnoe's 28 RonMartin, "ARemembrance," Carnet 1,2 (1993),28.
readings.Shenoted, however, thatalthough theyshocked people, 29 Herman Goodden, "Arts Section,"London FreePress, 26 Novem-
"noonewillforget thenight Curnoe andBoyle cametoKingston." ber1988.
IreneMcKim,"Curnoe andBoyleSpeakin Kingston," 20 Cents 30 Curnoe s choice ofthisincident wasundoubtedly anhomage tothe
4, 4
Magazine (April 1970), unpaginated. French Dadaist Marcel Duchamp, whose nickname was theMar-
3 GregCurnoequotedin"GregCurnoe: A FileInterview," File2, chand duSelorsaltseller. In fact,
a fewyears earlier,in 1958,his
1-2(April-May 1973),46. goodfriend, therenowned Dada scholar MichelSanouillet, had
4 HenriBergson, An
Laughter: Essay on the Meaning ofthe Comic editeda volume of writings byDuchamp entitledMarchand du Sel.
(originallypublished intheRevue deParisin1900),trans. Cloud- PierreThéberge, Greg Curnoe: Retrospective(Ottawa, 1982),14.
esley Brereton andFredRothwell (Rockville,MD, 2008),12. 31 Goodden, "Arts Section."
5 Mikhail Bakhtin, Rabelais andHisWorld , trans.HélèneIswolsky 32 MichelSanouillet, e-mailcorrespondence withJudith Rodger, 4
(Bloomington, IN, 1984), 5. February 2000, quoted in JudithRodger, "Chronology," in Reid
6 Bakhtin, Rabelais andHisWorld , 5. andTeitelbaum, eds.,Greg Curnoe:LifeandStuff, 147.
7 Bakhtin, Rabelais andHisWorld , 14. 33 KatieCholette, interview with 6
TonyUrquhart,February 2005.
8 Terry Eagleton, Walter Benjamin: Or, Towards a Revolutionary 34 Curnoe quoted in Sarah Milroy, "Time Machines," in Reid and
Criticism (London, UK,1981),148. Teitelbaum, eds.,Greg Curnoe: LifeandStuff, 35.
9 Arthur AsaBerger, AnAnatomy ofHumour (NewBrunswick, NJ, $5 OliverC. Speck, "TheJoyofAnti-Art: Subversion through Hu-
andLondon, UK,1993),10. mourinDada,"inGabyPailer, Andreas Böhn,Stefan Horlacher,
10 RossWoodman, "Greg Curnoe," essayfortheexhibition Greg Cur- andUlrich Scheck, eds.,Gender andLaughter: Comic Affirmation
noe's Series
(London, Canada, 1967, 3. and Subversion in Traditional andModern Media (Amsterdam and
11 Stanley Fish, "IsThere a Text in This Class?" TheStanley Fish Read- New York, NY, 2009), 378.
er, ed.H. Aram Veeser (Maiden, MA,1999). 36 GregCurnoe, "Region=Regionalism," TheGazette (University of
12 LisaAppignanesi, TheCabaret {London, UK,1975),83. Western Ontario), 15March1963.
62
63