Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/7233721
CITATIONS READS
82 290
2 authors, including:
Kimberly R Middleton
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
38 PUBLICATIONS 757 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Kimberly R Middleton on 04 June 2014.
Abstract Introduction
Objectives—This report presents estimates on the availability of pediatric U.S. hospitals receive about 30
services, expertise, and supplies for treating pediatric emergencies in U.S. hospitals. million emergency visits from the
Methods—The Emergency Pediatric Services and Equipment Supplement population under 18 years of age, which
(EPSES) was a self-administered questionnaire added to the 2002–03 National is about one-fourth of the care provided
Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey (NHAMCS). NHAMCS samples in emergency departments. (1) However,
non-Federal, short-stay and general hospitals in the United States. The EPSES little is known about the status of
content was based on the 2001 guidelines for pediatric services, medical expertise, providing emergency pediatric care in
small-sized supplies, and equipment for emergency departments (EDs) developed by EDs. In April 2001, the Annals of
the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) and the American College of Emergency Medicine published ‘‘Care of
Emergency Physicians (ACEP). Combined response rate for both years was children in the emergency department:
86 percent. Estimates were weighted to produce average annual estimates of Guidelines for preparedness,’’ which
pediatric services, expertise, and equipment availability in EDs. was jointly developed by AAP and
Results—One-half of hospitals (52.9 percent) admitted pediatric patients, but did ACEP (2). Although the guidelines did
not have a specialized inpatient pediatric ward. One-third (38.3 percent) admitted not set specific thresholds for
pediatric patients and had a separate pediatric ward; the remainder did not admit preparedness, they did provide
pediatric patients. Among those that did not admit pediatric cases, 30.4 percent were information on services, equipment, and
in counties that had a children’s hospital. One-quarter of EDs had access 24 hours supplies considered essential for
and 7 days a week to a board-certified pediatric emergency medicine attending managing pediatric emergencies. These
physician. Only 5.5 percent had all recommended pediatric supplies, but one-half included recommendations for
had greater than 85 percent of recommended supplies. Most hospitals without pediatricians to be on call in every ED,
pediatric trauma service (90.7 percent) or pediatric intensive care units for all EDs to establish transfer
(97.5 percent) transferred critical pediatric patients to hospitals with these services. agreements with higher-level pediatric
EDs in hospitals with specialized inpatient facilities for children were more likely to facilities to ensure timely access to care
meet the AAP and ACEP guidelines for pediatric ED services, expertise, and for critically ill and injured children, and
supplies. for the availability of age- and size-
appropriate supplies in each ED.
Keywords: Pediatric c children c emergency department c NHAMCS c AAP cACEP
Acknowledgments
The authors wish to acknowledge Daniel Kavanaugh (from the Health Resources and Services Administration), Irma Arispe, and Jennifer Madans
(from NCHS) for helpful comments made on drafts of the manuscript, and Roberto Valverde (from NCHS) for preparing the analytical files. The
report was edited by Klaudia M. Cox, typeset by Annette F. Holman, and the figures were produced by Jarmila Ogburn of the Office of Information
Services, Information Design and Publishing Staff.
Analysis
Associations between hospital
characteristics and pediatric services,
inpatient pediatric structure, expertise,
and supplies were investigated using
Chi-square tests of independence. The Figure 1. Percent distribution of hospital emergency departments by inpatient pediatric
structure: United States, 2002–03
importance of the basic structure of a
4 Advance Data No. 367 + February 28, 2006
having pediatric trauma services, but
EDs within hospitals with separate
pediatric wards were more likely to
have such services (28.4 percent).
Finally, 10.2 percent of EDs were in
hospitals that had a PICU, but the
percentage with a PICU is highest
among EDs within hospitals with
separate pediatric wards (26.0 percent).
The presence of a PICU is also
positively associated with the relative
size of the pediatric volume (more than
10,000) in the ED (data not shown).
Among EDs in hospitals without a
PICU, 51.7 percent had written transfer
agreements with facilities that offer such
services. A small percentage of EDs
nationwide reported using an adult ICU
for children, with this response
occurring more frequently in hospitals
with separate pediatric wards and no
Figure 2. Cross-classification of emergency departments by emergency department PICU (Table 2).
pediatric visit volume and inpatient pediatric structure: United States, 2002–03
Pediatric expertise
The presence of board-certified
emergency medicine (EM), pediatric,
and pediatric emergency medicine
(PEM) attending physicians in the ED
were all positively associated with
pediatric inpatient structure (Table 3).
The availability of PEM attending
physicians was highest among EDs
within hospitals with separate pediatric
wards (34.3 percent). Overall,
62.2 percent of EDs had board-certified
pediatric attending physicians available
in house or on call 24 hours a day and 7
days a week, 23.0 percent had PEM
attending physicians available, and
71.2 percent had board-certified EM
attending physicians available. Among
EDs without the availability of PEM
attending physicians, 53.2 percent had a
board-certified pediatrician attending,
Figure 3. Cross-classification of pediatric emergency department visits by annual size of and 19.9 percent had written protocol
emergency department pediatric visit volume and inpatient pediatric structure: for calling a pediatrician. About
United States, 2002–03 17.2 percent of EDs had no EM, PEM,
or pediatric attending physician. Of
Pediatric services frequently found in hospitals that these, 96.4 percent admit pediatric
admitted pediatric patients (Table 2). patients to their facilities. However,
Between 10 percent and 17 percent
Overall, 16.6 percent of EDs report almost all had written transfer
of EDs have services specifically
having pediatric 23-hour observation agreements to facilities with higher
designed for children such as a pediatric
units, but the presence of such units levels of pediatric care (pediatric trauma
23-hour observation unit, pediatric
ranges from 0 percent in hospitals that service or PICU) (data not shown).
trauma services, or belonging to a
do not admit children to 38.7 percent for
hospital with pediatric intensive care
hospitals with separate pediatric wards.
units (PICUs). These services were more
Overall, 14.2 percent of EDs reported
Advance Data No. 367 + February 28, 2006 5
Pediatric supplies
Table 4 presents the extent to which
EDs had the recommended pediatric
supplies. Only 5.5 percent of EDs
answered ‘‘Yes’’ to all of the items on
the supplies list. EDs were most likely
to have resuscitation medication chart,
tape, or other dose estimation systems
(95.8 percent) and least likely to have
all the vascular access supplies
(12.4 percent). Although supplies may
not have been directly available in the
ED, several hospitals indicated resources
were available from other in-house or
‘‘nearby’’ locations such as neonatal
intensive care unit, obstetrics and
newborn nursery, central supply,
pharmacy, available from ‘‘sister’’
pediatric hospitals, or children’s
hospitals. For some supplies, the smaller
sizes were available less frequently than Figure 4. Distribution of emergency departments by the supply score of pediatric supplies
larger sizes. For example, size 10 available in the emergency department: United States, 2002–03
French nasopharyngeal airways were
available at 53.6 percent of EDs, but
size 28 French nasopharyngeal airways which was similarly high for all In 2002–03, most EDs saw fewer
were available at 73.3 percent of EDs. categories. than 4,000 pediatric visits in a given
Similarly, tracheotomy tubes and Foley year. However, the majority of pediatric
catheters were found more frequently in Discussion visits were to hospital EDs that had a
larger sizes. large pediatric volume (more than
Comparing data from the 10,000). These hospitals were more
The frequency distribution presented
NHAMCS-EPSES to the NEISS study likely to have a separate pediatric ward
in Figure 4 represents the weighted total
indicates lack of significant and PICU, and the EDs were more
percentage of available supplies or
improvement in the ability of hospitals likely to have a board-certified PEM
supply score for EDs. The distribution is
to treat pediatric emergencies between attending physician when compared to
negatively skewed showing that most
1998 and 2002–03. For example, in the average hospital.
EDs had at least 80 percent of
1998 only 10 percent of hospitals had a With regard to the American
recommended pediatric supplies. Table 5
PICU, which remained unchanged 5 Academy of Pediatrics recommendation
presents the mean supply scores for
years later. In 1998, 75 percent (95% for pediatrician coverage, 9.0 percent of
each supply content area and the overall
confidence interval 41–100 percent) of EDs report having a pediatrician in the
score by inpatient pediatric structure.
hospitals without pediatric trauma ED 24 hours a day and 7 days a week,
For example, if an ED had half of all
service had written transfer agreements and 62.2 percent report having a
the recommended fracture management
to send pediatric trauma patients to board-certified pediatric attending
supplies available, its score would be
another hospital. By 2002–03, the physician either in house (within the
50.0. Data indicate that EDs in hospitals
number had not significantly increased hospital) or on call. The low number
that had a separate pediatric ward had a
(83.8 percent). Overall, use of a (25.9 percent) of EDs with written
greater percentage of supplies available
pediatric emergency medicine attending protocols stating when to call a
(88.7 percent of recommended supplies).
physician is limited. In 1998, this pediatrician may indicate a failure to
The lowest supply score was found for
specialty was available in EDs adequately utilize services that are
EDs in hospitals that do not admit
23 percent (95% confidence interval readily available.
pediatric cases. On average these EDs
14–32 percent) of the time; by 2002–03, The AAP encourages all EDs to
had only 63.7 percent of the vascular
the number remained unchanged. (3) establish transfer agreements with
access supplies available. Increasing
However, 2002–03 EPSES data showed facilities with higher levels of pediatric
availability of supplies with increasing
that EDs at hospitals with an inpatient care to ensure timely access to care for
values for the inpatient pediatric
structure that accommodates pediatric critically ill and injured children (7).
structure variable was found for all
inpatient care were more likely to have Overall, 2002–03 EPSES data showed
content areas except the availability of a
ED pediatric services, expertise, and that EDs are doing a good job of
resuscitation medication dosage chart,
supplies for treating children. transferring critically injured pediatric
6 Advance Data No. 367 + February 28, 2006
trauma patients (90.7 percent) and those conjunction with the 2006 NHAMCS so
requiring intensive care (97.5 percent) direct comparisons between the data
when the hospital’s ED is not equipped collected in 2002–03 and 2006 will
for such pediatric services. Admission examine changes in readiness. Further
and transfer of emergency pediatric information about NHAMCS and
cases is a fairly rare outcome. EPSES can be found at www.cdc.gov/
Unpublished data from NHAMCS NHAMCS.
indicates that only 5.2 percent of
pediatric cases are either admitted from References
or transferred to another hospital. The
1. McCaig LF, Burt CW. National
vast majority of cases are treated and
Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care
released. This percentage does not vary
Survey: 2003 emergency department
by inpatient pediatric structure. summary. Advance data from vital
However, within the subgroup of cases and health statistics; no 358.
that are admitted to the hospital or Hyattsville, MD: National Center for
transferred, those that are actually Health Statistics. 2005.
transferred varies from 71.6 percent for 2. American College of Emergency
hospitals that do not admit pediatric Physicians and the American
cases to 16.3 percent for hospitals that Academy of Pediatrics. Care of
have a separate inpatient pediatric ward. children in the emergency
department: guidelines for
preparedness. Ann Emerg Med. Apr;
Limitations 37:423–427. 2001.
An attempt was made to create a 3. Athey JJ, Deal M, Ball J, et al.
fourth structure category containing only Ability of hospitals to care for
pediatric emergency patients. Pediatr
children’s hospitals on the assumption
Emerg Care;17(3):170–4. 2001.
that they would rank highest in
4. Research Triangle Institute (2004).
preparedness for pediatric patients. SUDAAN (Release 9.0) [Computer
Unfortunately, there were not enough Software]. Research Triangle Park,
children’s hospitals in the NHAMCS NC: Research Triangle Institute.
sample to provide a separate estimate. 5. McCaig LF, Burt CW. National
The EPSES will be replicated in 2006 to Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care
include a separate sampling stratum for Survey: 2002 emergency department
children’s hospitals so that separate summary. Advance date from vital
estimates will be available. and health statistics; no 340.
Hyattsville, MD: National Center for
Health Statistics. 2004.
Conclusions 6. McCaig LF, McLemore T. Plan and
In 1993, the Institute of Medicine operation of the National Hospital
provided summary recommendations Ambulatory Medical Care Survey.
National Center for Health Statistics.
that all agencies with jurisdiction over
Vital Health Stat 1(34). 1994.
hospitals ‘‘require that hospital
7. American Academy of Pediatrics.
emergency departments. . .have available Committee on Pediatric Emergency
and maintain equipment and supplies Medicine. Access to pediatric
appropriate for the emergency care of emergency medical care. Pediatrics.
children.’’ (8) Results from the 2002–03 Mar:105(3 Pt 1):647–9. 2000.
EPSES showed that EDs generally had 8. Institute of Medicine, committee on
82.9 percent of the recommended Pediatric Emergency Medical
pediatric supplies, but only 5.5 percent Services. Durch JS, Lohr KN, eds.
of EDs had all recommended pediatric Institute of Medicine Report:
supplies. This indicated that most EDs Emergency Medical Services for
Children. Washington: National
could improve their inventory of
Academy Press. 1993.
recommended supplies. Further analysis
of the EPSES data will describe the
hospital and community factors that are
associated with better preparedness for
treating pediatric emergencies. Also, the
EPSES is being conducted again in
Advance Data No. 367 + January 19, 2006 7
Table 1. Number and percent distribution of emergency departments by hospital characteristics, according to inpatient pediatric
structure: United States, 2002–03
Percent
Number distribution Percent
MSA status:4,5
MSA5 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2,800 57.2 16.7 30.7 52.6
Not MSA5 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2,000 42.8 * 82.6 16.4
Teaching hospital:4
Yes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1,000 20.3 17.8 20.1 62.1
No. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4,000 79.7 8.0 61.2 30.8
Trauma center levels:4
1
Sample size 722 hospitals; 83 do not admit children, 244 admit but do not have a separate pediatric ward, 395 admit children and have a separate pediatric ward.
2
The category separate pediatric ward ‘‘includes’’ children’s hospitals.
3
ED is emergency department.
4
χ2 test of independence with inpatient structure is significant (p<0.01).
5
MSA is metropolitan statistical area.
6
The sampled hospital itself may be the one children’s hospital in the county.
Pediatric trauma services2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.2 (2.3) *0.9 (0.4) *6.9 (3.6) 28.4 (2.9)
1
ED is emergency department.
2
Chi-square test of independence with inpatient pediatric structure is significant at p<0.01.
3
Hospitals without pediatric trauma service (N=4,030).
4
Hospitals without pediatric intensive care units (PICUs) (N=4,102).
Table 3. Percent of emergency departments with pediatric expertise by inpatient pediatric structure: United States, 2002–03
1
ED is emergency department.
2
EM is emergency medicine.
3
χ2 test of independence with inpatient pediatric structure is significant (p<0.01).
4
Available 24 hours a day and 7 days a week either in house or on call.
5
PEM is pediatric emergency medicine.
6
Hospitals with no board-certified pediatric emergency medicine (PEM) attending physician (N=3668).
Percent Standard
Pediatric supplies of EDs1 error
Monitoring
Vascular access
Airway management
Percent Standard
Pediatric supplies of EDs1 error
Airway management—Con.
Resuscitation medications
Medication chart, tape, or other dose estimation system . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 95.8 1.1
Percent Standard
Pediatric supplies of EDs1 error
Fracture management
Miscellaneous
Supplies
Percent of EDs1 fully supplied3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.5 1.1
1
ED is emergency department.
2
ET is endotracheal.
3
Percentage of EDs having all the recommended supplies available.
NOTE: Fr is French, a scale used to indicate the outer diameter of catheters. g is gauge, a standard of measurement for needles.
Table 5. Mean pediatric supply availability scores (with standard errors) for emergency departments by type of supplies and inpatient
pediatric structure: United States, 2002–03
1
ED is emergency department.
2
Trend test for supply score and inpatient pediatric structure is significant (p<0.01).
NOTE: Supply score represents the percentage of each content area that the ED reported having supplies available. (i.e., if an ED had half of the supplies available, its score would be 50.0.)
Technical Notes
Advance Data No. 367 + February 28, 2006 13
14 Advance Data No. 367 + February 28, 2006
Advance Data No. 367 + February 28, 2006 15
16 Advance Data No. 367 + February 28, 2006
Middleton KR, Burt CW. Availability of pediatric All material appearing in this report is in the Director
services and equipment in emergency public domain and may be reproduced or Edward J. Sondik, Ph.D.
Advance data from vital and health statistics; source, however, is appreciated.
no 367. Hyattsville, Maryland: National Center Jennifer H. Madans, Ph.D.
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF
MEDIA MAIL
CDC/NCHS
OFFICIAL BUSINESS
PENALTY FOR PRIVATE USE, $300
06-0052 (2/06)
CS101048
T24408
DHHS Publication No. (PHS) 2006-1250