Professional Documents
Culture Documents
V
C 2009 The American Laryngological,
Rhinological and Otological Society, Inc.
Objectives/Hypothesis: The role of the comple- sis of CRSwNP and may contribute to typical features
ment system in nasal polyps (CRSwNP) has so far such as edema and granulocytic inflammation.
scarcely been studied. Because nasal polyps are char- Key Words: Nasal polyposis, chronic
acterized by bacterial colonization, and the comple- rhinosinusitis with polyps, complement, C3a, C5a,
ment system is an effective defense mechanism, it membrane attack complex.
might be involved in the pathogenesis of CRSwNP. Laryngoscope, 119:1753–1758, 2009
This study was designed to investigate the local and
systemic activation of the complement system in
CRSwNP versus control mucosa in relation to the
local and systemic eosinophilic and neutrophilic INTRODUCTION
inflammation and local plasma exudation. The sinonasal cavity is, both in healthy patients and
Methods: Concentrations of complement factors in patients with chronic sinonasal disease, under a per-
C3a desArg and C5a desArg, and of albumin, a2-mac- manent thread of colonization with pathogenic bacteria.
roglobulin, eosinophilic cationic protein, and myelo- Therefore the nasal mucosal lining is defended by an
peroxidase were determined on nasal secretions and innate immune system that supports the adaptive immu-
serum from 12 CRSwNP patients and 10 control nity to clear potential pathogens. The complement system
patients. Tissue cryosections were stained for the is one of the central components of the human innate and
membrane attack complex (C5b9) adaptive immunity. The complement system consists of
Results: We found a significantly higher concen-
more than 30 complement factors and cell membrane pro-
tration of C3a desArg and C5a desArg in nasal secre-
tions from CRSwNP patients compared to controls, teins and has three activation pathways.1 Central in
whereas the serum levels between the two groups did these three pathways is the cleavage and activation after
not differ significantly. Significant correlations were contact with an antigen-antibody complex or mannon on
found between C5a desArg and eosinophil cationic bacterial surfaces of C3 and C5 into C3a, C3b, C5a, and
protein in nasal secretions. Staining for the mem- C5b. The final downstream of complement activation is
brane attack complex revealed a deposition around the formation of the membrane attack complex, which
blood vessels and the basal membrane exclusively in causes lysis of microorganisms by formation of pores.2
nasal polyp tissue. Furthermore, C3a and C5a have proinflammatory func-
Conclusions: These data support the hypothesis tions, such as contraction of smooth muscles, increased
that, in addition to the adaptive immune responses,
vascular permeability, vasodilatation, stimulation of neu-
the complement system is involved in the pathogene-
trophil and eosinophil endothelial adhesion, and
induction of proinflammatory cytokine secretion.3
Chronic rhinosinusitis with nasal polyps (CRSwNP) is a
From the Upper Airway Research Laboratory (URL), Department of chronic inflammatory disease that has clearly been linked
Otorhinolaryngology (T.V.Z, P.G., G.H., P.V.C., C.B), Ghent University Hospital,
Belgium; and Department of Genetics (F.C.), Ghent University Hospital, to bacterial colonization.4 CRSwNP is clinically charac-
Ghent, Belgium. terized by the presence of polypoid structures in the
Editor’s Note: This Manuscript was accepted for publication March paranasal sinuses and nasal cavities. The prevalence
16, 2009.
varies between 1% and 4%, and a clear association has
This work was supported by a grant from the Flemish Scientific
Research Board, FWO, Nr. A12/5-K/V-K17 to Claus Bachert, by a post- been observed with asthma and aspirin intolerance in
doctoral grant of the Research Foundation–Flanders to Philippe Gevaert adults. Nasal polyps show typical histological features,
and by a grant from the research funds of the Ghent University (BOF) such as plasma exudation, paucity of vascular structures,
to Thibaut Van Zele.
Send correspondence to Thibaut Van Zele, MD, Upper Airway
and damage of the respiratory epithelium. Almost 75% of
Research Laboratory (URL), Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Ghent the eosinophils present in nasal polyps are activated,
University Hospital, B-9000, Ghent, Belgium. E-mail: thibaut.vanzele@ causing high levels of eosinophil cationic protein (ECP)
ugent.be
in the polyp tissue.5,6 Besides eosinophils, other inflam-
DOI: 10.1002/lary.20484 matory cells, such as lymphocytes, neutrophils, and mast
C3a desArg (ng/ml) 12985 (8175) 2434.75 (6765.86) 14820 (11065) 6456.62 (7829.35) NS .048 .028 .015
C5a desArg (ng/ml) 6,51 (3.7) 7,27 (32.43) 7,25 (3.01) 35,78 (48.47) NS .035 NS .002
ECP (lg/l) 10,14 (24.42) 214,26 (202.94) 13,9 (12.4) 867,1 (1031.01 NS NS .005 .002
MPO (ng/ml) 9,85 (5.84) 2891,33 (6002.94) 9,76 (6.98) 4823,82 (8158.22) NS NS .005 .002
Albumin (mg/l) 33400 (12875) 4825,01 (10730.77) 38450 (12200) 11803,8 (15161.17) NS .035 .005 .002
a2-macro-globulin (mg/l) 1005 (412.5) 111,91 (366.56) 1015 (400.0) 277,20 (351.27) NS NS .005 .002
Significant differences between serum and nasal secretions for controls and nasal polyps and significant differences between controls and nasal polyps
are indicated with the appropriate P value; nonsignificant differences are indicated with NS. CO ¼ control; CRSwNP ¼ chronic rhinosinusitis with nasal polyps;
ECP ¼ eosinophil cationic protein; IQR ¼ interquartile range; MPO ¼ myeloperoxidase.
significant differences were found for C5a desArg in responses,9 the complement system is locally activated
controls. and involved in the pathogenesis of nasal polyposis.
Similarly the concentrations of C3a desArg albumin The significantly higher concentration of albumin in
and a2-macroglobulin in the CRSwNP group were signif- nasal secretion from nasal polyp patients underlines our
icantly higher in serum compared to nasal secretions (P previous findings of albumin deposition with pseudocyst
¼ .015, P ¼ .002, P ¼ .002, respectively), whereas ECP formation and plasma-exudation in nasal polyps.5,12 Al-
and MPO concentrations were significantly higher in bumin deposition is a typical feature of nasal polyps5,13
nasal secretions of CRSwNP patients (P ¼ .002). Con- and may be regulated by increased C3a and C5a lev-
trary to the findings in controls, nasal secretions of els.2,3 In this study, the strong correlations between C3a
nasal polyp patients contained significantly higher levels desArg and both albumin or a2-macroglobulin and
of C5a desArg compared to serum levels (P ¼ .002). between C5a desArg and a2 macroglobulin in nasal
C5a desArg in nasal polyp patients both in serum secretions nicely show the relationship between plasma
and in nasal secretions were positively correlated with exudation and complement activation in nasal polyps.
ECP concentrations (r ¼ 0.615, P ¼ .033; r ¼ 0.608, P ¼ To assess the local activation or generation of the
.036, respectively). Both in serum and nasal secretions, C3a and C5a, nasal levels of C3adesArg and C5adesArg
a positive correlation (r ¼ 0.671, P ¼ .017; r ¼ 0.846, P were compared to serum concentrations. C3a desArg
¼ .001, respectively) was observed between C3a desArg concentrations were significantly higher in serum than
and albumin in the nasal polyp group, whereas there in nasal secretions, both in controls and CRSwNP
was no correlation between C5a desArg and albumin. patients. For C5a desArg the concentrations in nasal
Inversely a significant correlation was found between secretions of CRSwNP significantly exceeded the serum
C5a desArg and a2-macroglobulin and C3a desArg and levels, suggesting a local generation of C5adesArg in
a2-macroglobulin in nasal secretions from nasal polyp nasal polyp tissue. Since concentrations of C3a desARg
patients (r ¼ 0.692, P ¼ .013; r ¼ 0.902, P ¼ .001, and C5a desArg correlate well with serum markers of
respectively). increased vascular permeability, we cannot exclude that
Immunohistochemistry showed a positive staining high levels of C5a desArg in nasal secretions of CRSwNP
for the membrane attack complex I in all polyp samples, are caused by increased vascular permeability. However,
whereas such staining completely lacked in controls. In one study has shown an extrahepatic expression of com-
polyps, the basal membrane and endothelial cells were plement mRNA in sinonasal tissue.14
specifically stained for membrane attack complex (MAC) C3a and C5a play a major role in the chemotaxis
(Fig. 2). and activation of eosinophils and neutrophils, and in
this study C5a desArg levels in CRSwNP were strongly
correlated to ECP in nasal secretions. There was no sig-
nificant correlation to eosinophilic inflammation with
DISCUSSION C3a desArg. This may be explained by the rapid inacti-
We found a significantly higher concentration of vation of C3a into C3a desArg losing its ability to attract
C3a desArg and C5a desArg in nasal secretions from and stimulate eosinophils, whereas C5a desArg remains
nasal polyp patients compared to controls, whereas the an active eosinophil stimulus. Furthermore, C5a can
serum levels between controls and nasal polyp patients stimulate eosinophils more powerfully than C3a.15,16
did not differ significantly. The MAC was exclusively Several pathomechanisms in CRSwNP could lead to
found in nasal polyp tissue, situated at the basal mem- the activation of complement. First, it has been shown in
brane and around blood vessels. These data support the asthmatics and patients with allergic rhinitis that allergen
hypothesis that, in addition to the adaptive immune exposure in sensitized individuals may induce the local
activation of C3a and C5a.17,18 However, in the current and C5a levels in nasal secretions, supporting the idea that
study no significant difference was found between SPT-pos- factors other than allergy play a role in the complement
itive and SPT-negative nasal polyp patients in terms of C3a activation in CRSwNP.
The complement system can be activated through brane.24 The deposition of the MAC at the basal
three activation pathways, all leading to the generation membrane of nasal polyps might be implicated in epithe-
of C3a.2 There is the classical pathway, which is acti- lial damage and high turnover in nasal polyps. Secondly
vated by immune complexes with IgE or IgG.19,20 In C5b-9 can lead to the overproduction of extracellular
nasal polyps, massive concentrations of polyclonal IgE matrix components, such as collagen IV and fibronectin,
and increased IgG levels are present in the polyp even in the absence of TGF-b over-expression, and cause
tissue12 indicating that complement activation in basal membrane thickening.25 Furthermore, we describe
nasal polyps could partially be due to activation of the for the first time that MAC was also situated around
classical pathway by immunoglobulin complexes. Fur- blood vessels in nasal polyps but not in controls.
thermore, colonization with Staphylococcus aureus, Although nasal polyps have a reduced number of vessels,
frequently found in nasal polyp patients,4,9 can cause a they are characterized by a massive edema with pseudo-
supplementary activation of the complement system cyst formation, filled with large amounts of albumin and
through the alternative pathway. The third pathway other plasma proteins.5 An increased leakage by anaphy-
causing complement activation is the mannose binding latoxins or other inflammatory products might be
lectin pathway, by recognition of foreign carbohydrates. instrumental in causing this edema. The deposition of
Although there is no direct evidence to assume an acti- MAC around these vessels may induce damage of the
vation of this pathway, previous results from our group vascular epithelium, leading to increased vascular per-
showed a significant upregulation of the macrophage meability, as has been described in glomerular kidney
mannose receptor in nasal polyps21 that could lead to disease and demyelination and axonal damage in ische-
the activation of the mannose binding lectin pathway. mic brain injury.26,27
After cleavage of the C5 into the anaphylatoxin C5a
and C5b-9, the membrane attack complex is formed
through the self-association of C5b with proteins C6, C7, CONCLUSION
C8, and C9 and functions mainly as a pore former in cell These data support the hypothesis that, in addition
membranes of pathogens.22 However, C5b-9 can also to the adaptive immune responses, the complement sys-
influence, independently of the engagement of C5a, the tem contributes in the pathogenesis of nasal polyposis.
downstream inflammatory cascade by triggering releases The involvement of complement in nasal polyps is new
of multiple mediators, such as proMMP9.23 In the cur- to the current understanding of the pathophysiology of
rent study, MAC was exclusively found in nasal polyp nasal polyposis, and typical features like edema, vascu-
tissue, mainly situated subepithelially at the basal mem- lar leakage, high epithelial turnover, and the attraction
brane. Earlier histomorphological studies revealed of eosinophils may be influenced by the complement acti-
frequent epithelial damage and a thickened basal mem- vation in CRSwNP.