Professional Documents
Culture Documents
& Auditing
Prepared By:
Pavel Vardinov,
SID: 8469430
Module Leader:
James Milne
March 2022
1. Introduction 1
1.4.4 Lighting 3
3. Recommendations 11
List of References 17
Appendices 18
Appendix 1 18
Appendix 2 18
ii
Executive Summary
The Energy Audit report is prepared for the building manager of Coventry University
Student Centre, 1 Gulson Rd, Coventry CV1 2JH.
The building, completed in 2006, has 2040 operational hours per year. The total energy
consumed for 2021 was 484,852 kWh which equals to £51,274. Total carbon emissions
were 99.8 tonnes. After data analysis, consisting the following elements, goals for 15%
reduction in 1 year and 50% in 5 years were communicated:
• Historical energy usage
• Comparison between energy consumption for 2020 and 2021
• Regression analysis
• Gas Consumption vs Average Temperature
• Half-hourly data analysis
• Carbon footprint
According to the analysis and the NPI index of 95.95, the current building performance is
considered as good.
Although, the current energy performance of CUSC is good, there are a number of
measures that could be taken in order to achieve the goals set.
iii
1. Introduction
Financial advantages:
• Lower fuel and electricity bills.
• Lower maintenance and operational costs for
boilers, due to fewer hours of operation.
There are 6 triple windows, located on the West side of the ground oor as well.
There is a set of windows located on the rst oor of the East side, covering
approximately 40% of the facade. Identical set of windows is placed on the West side of
the rst oor. There are no openings on the attic extension, which is located at the south-
west corner of the building.
Figure 7. CUSC Desktop Computers. Source: Figure 8. CUSC O ce Printer. Source: Own
Own Photo, 2022. Photo, 2022.
In this chapter you can see the current electricity and gas consumption, supported by
benchmarking of the data available and explanation how and why it is changing over the
Page 4
fi
ffi
ffi
fi
ffi
time period from December 2019 to November 2021. Following up, you can nd carbon
footprint data analysis. In Table 3 are presented the current energy use and carbon
emissions for the past 1 year (December 2020 to November 2021).
Table 3. Current energy usage and carbon emissions (2021) (Own Table, 2022)
Utility Type Consumption CO2e Emissions Cost p/kWh
(kWh) (Tonnes) (£)
For this time of the year it is normal to have decrease in the gas usage due to higher
temperatures (5ºC for March to 9.1ºC for April). Although, this data explains the
decreased demand of gas (Figure 9), the lockdown announced is the reason for the drop
Page 5
ff
ff
fi
fi
ff
in the electricity demand. This surge happens mainly due to the shock, which the
unexpected event causes, as in the following year (also in lockdown conditions) the
decrease does not happen.
The post-lockdown conditions in April 2021 are a reason for a huge spike of about 300%
in the gas use. Despite this event, leading to people coming back to normal for the rst
time in months, the main factor, responsible to the higher demand is the signi cantly
lower temperature (9.1ºC in April 2020 vs 5.4ºC in April 2021). This statement is
supported by the higher average temperature in March 2021 (5.9ºC).
Closer look into gure 9 shows a big spike of energy consumption in December & January
2020/21 and November 2021 vs December & January 2019/20. Calculating the Hour
Degree Day (HDD) (Figure 10) for these months it can be concluded that lower
temperatures (317 HDD for Jan 20 vs 420 HDD for Jan 21) are once again the reason for
the signi cantly higher gas consumption (electricity use stays relatively similar) in these
months.
Overall, it can be said that the number of lockdowns that occurred, together with the
colder winter in 2021 (see Figure 10) are the reasons for the unexpected energy demand
uctuations over the past 2 years.
Although the building occupancy level has been much lower in the rst quarter of 2021
due to the lockdown, the gas consumption is about 50% higher than in 2020. The reason
for that is the colder winter in 2021 (Figure 10).
Figure 12. Gas Consumption for 2020 vs 2021. (Own Chart, 2022)
Page 7
fi
fi
fi
Figure 13. Regression Analysis. (Own Chart, 2022)
R² Value is 0.84. Considering that it is under and close to 1it can be concluded that it is
good.
Figure 13 was created using linear regression and is speci c to CUSC. Using this
function, the expected energy consumption for any future time period can be calculated,
compared to the actual energy consumed, and any necessary corrective action could be
made (Al-Shemmeri, 2011).
Figure 14. Gas Consumption (Dec 19 - Nov 21) Figure 15. Average Monthly Temperature
(Own Chart, 2022) (Dec 19 - Nov 21) (Own Chart, 2022)
Page 8
fi
fi
fi
maintenance sta are the reason for the incline of the energy consumption at about 7 am.
After the building o cially opens at 8:30 am up to 11 am can be seen the peak of the
energy demand. It can be tracked that the line stays considerably at until 4 pm and then
it drops gradually to its night time levels.
On gure 17 can be monitored the weekly trend. It shows 3 consistent peaks (Monday,
Tuesday and Thursday), based on the daily consumption data analysis. There is some
abnormality in the Wednesday and Friday curves. On Wednesday, due to the late opening
- 11 am, the peak starts 1.5 h later. The highest demand is also lower over the course of
the day. Compared to other random picked weeks, this abnormality is not seen. Looking
deeper into the data available, it can be assumed that warmer weather conditions on the
speci c day are the reason for the lower demand. On the Friday curve, you can see 3
separate drops after the peak, which are not observed during the other weekdays. The
reason for it is the shortened working time, sta leaving earlier as well as lower interest
from students on Friday afternoons. During the weekends, although there are some signs
of activity on Saturday, CUSC is presumably unoccupied as the line follows the levels
form weekdays nights.
Page 9
fi
fi
ff
ffi
ff
fl
2.1.6 Normalised Performance Index
The NPI (Table 4) can used as a future reference, in comparison of CUSC with other
similar buildings. The gure describes the amount of energy consumed by the building
per m2 within standard conditions. Benchmarking the NPI (Appendix 2) for CUSC (95.95
kWh/m2) with other similar buildings, the fair performance range is 189-261. The
percentage of energy used for space heating is 55.1% which is under the average of
75%.
Page 10
ti
ti
fl
ti
ti
ti
ti
ti
ti
fi
3. Recommendations
Reduced energy use makes great business sense; it saves money, boosts corporate
reputation, and aids everyone in the ght against climate change (Carbon Trust, 2017). In
this nal chapter of the energy audit, you can nd recommendations on how to tackle
current issues leading to high energy consumption and increased carbon footprint. The
proposals will be in line with the current EN16247 - EU Energy Audits Standards.
1. Boilers
2. Heating Coils
3. Radiators
4. Cooling Equipment
5. Cooling Coils
6. Ventilation System
7. Cooling Tower/Condenser
Note.From Carbon Trust, By Carbon Trust, 2017, (https://prod-drupal- Source: Carbon Trust (2017)
les.storage.googleapis.com/documents/resource/public/Heating-Ventilation-
guide.pdf)
Page 11
fi
fi
ffi
fi
fi
Table 6. HVAC System - Saving Opportunities. (Own Table, 2022)
Energy Saving Opportunities Implementation and E ect
Designing a system, where nature provides
most of fresh air and temperature
Passive Heating, Ventilation and Cooling requirements. The “expensive to run” arti cial
and mechanical systems can then operate to
adjust the temperature to the exact desired
levels.
Identifying where excess heat comes from.
Then shading windows from the outside or
Reducing Overheating installing special heat-re ective glass to
prevent heat build-up. All signi cant energy
using equipment (major heat emitters) with low
energy e ciency pro le have to be replaced
for ones with high pro le.
Daylight blinds allow natural light to enter the
space by re-directing it onto the ceiling,
Installing Daylight Blinds relieving any discomfort caused by direct
sunlight. Many daylight blinds contain
perforated blades to keep the employee's
vision out the window intact.
Many buildings have troublesome zones with
variable time and temperature requirements,
despite the fact the building has one overall
heating or cooling control system. A approach
is to divide the building into 'zones,' with
di erent time and temperature controls for
“Zoning” the Building
each zone is crucial.
Zoned places can improve conditions since
people in each zone have more in uence over
their immediate environment. It will also save
money because HVAC in unoccupied zones
can be turned down or o .
Page 12
ff
ffi
fi
fi
ff
ff
fl
fi
fl
fi
3.2 Lighting Systems
The lighting system at CUSC accounts for about 12% of the total electricity usage (Table
1,3). The uorescent lights installed at the building are good solution, but nowadays we
have a number of alternatives (like LED) and actions to be taken for achieving energy
e ciency (Table 7).
Table 7. Lighting System - Saving Opportunities (Own Table, 2022)
Page 13
ffi
ffi
fl
fl
fi
ff
ff
ff
fi
ff
3.3 Building Envelope
CUSC’s shell consists of large number of windows (conventional) and entrances. The
facade is brick. All of these, together with the large external surface area indicate for
medium to high heat loss, which leads to high energy consumption. Table 9 suggests
options for improving the thermal insulation of the building.
Improved Productivity
Page 14
fi
fl
ff
fi
fl
fi
ff
fi
ff
fi
fl
fi
fi
3.4 Behavioural Change
As stated in the EN16247, raising sta awareness is a key concept in achieving the
common goal. Figure 20 (by Les Robinson, 1998), demonstrates the steps that people go
through when changing their behaviour. The following recommendations on how to
improve sta awareness (Table 9) will be prepared in line with Les Robinson’s theory.
Implementation of bonuses and bene ts for Allocating funds from recent energy savings to a
sta , willing to lead the change and in uence bonus & bene ts scheme could have a huge impact
others. in short term and contribute to the e ects of step 1.
Page 15
fi
ff
ff
ff
fi
ff
ff
fi
ff
ff
ff
ff
fi
fl
ff
ff
ff
Steps to be taken Implementation and E ect
Monthly rankings of top 5 employees, contributing
Creating a monthly rankings (by voting) of top to the savings will not only increase the sta
employees, contributing to the decrease of awareness, but also make people feel that they are
energy demand. actually part of the change, which will lead to more
people join.
Electricity 217,547 50.6 41,116 18.9 184,915 43.0 34,949 108,774 25.3 20,558
Gas 267,305 49.2 10,158 3.8 227,209 41.8 8,634 133,653 24.6 5,079
Overall 484,852 99.8 51,274 - 412,124 84.8 43,583 242,427 49.9 25,637
Page 16
ff
ff
ff
ff
List of References
• Carbon Trust. (2013). Low Carbon Behaviour Change: The £300 million opportunity.
https://prod-drupal- les.storage.googleapis.com/documents/resource/public/
L o w % 2 0 C a r b o n % 2 0 B e h a v i o u r % 2 0 C h a n g e % 2 0 -
%20The%20%C2%A3300%20million%20opportunity%20-%20REPORT.pdf
• Carbon Trust. (2017). Heating, ventilation and air conditioning. Saving energy without
compromising comfort. https://prod-drupal- les.storage.googleapis.com/documents/
resource/public/Heating-Ventilation-guide.pdf
• Carbon Trust. (2017). Lightning. Bright ideas for e cient illumination. https://prod-
drupal- les.storage.googleapis.com/documents/resource/public/Lighting-guide.pdf
• Carbon Trust. (2018). Building fabric. Energy saving techniques to improve the energy
performance of buildings. https://prod-drupal- les.storage.googleapis.com/
documents/resource/public/Building-Fabric-Guide.pdf
• SEAI. (n.d.). Undertaking an Energy Audit. In SEAI, Energy Audit Handbook, (pp. 5-9).
Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland.
Page 17
fi
fi
fi
ffi
fi
Appendices
Appendix 1
HH Energy consumption data for 1 year.
Appendix 2
NPI Estimations Table.
Page 18