Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Cite this article as: PETROL. EXPLOR. DEVELOP., 2018, 45(4): 764–769. RESEARCH PAPER
Abstract: Traditional oil-based drilling muds (OBMs) have a relatively high solid content, which is detrimental to penetration rate in-
crease and reservoir protection. Aimed at solving this problem, an organoclay-free OBM system was studied, the synthesis methods and
functioning mechanism of key additives were introduced, and performance evaluation of the system was performed. The rheology modi-
fier was prepared by reacting a dimer fatty acid with diethanolamine, the primary emulsifier was made by oxidation and addition reaction
of fatty acids, the secondary emulsifier was made by amidation of a fatty acid, and finally the fluid loss additive of water-soluble acrylic
resin was synthesized by introducing acrylic acid into styrene/butyl acrylate polymerization. The rheology modifier could enhance the at-
traction between droplets, particles in the emulsion via intermolecular hydrogen bonding and improve the shear stress by forming a
three-dimensional network structure in the emulsion. Lab experimental results show that the organoclay-free OBM could tolerate tem-
peratures up to 220 C and HTHP filtration is less than 5 mL. Compared with the traditional OBMs, the organoclay-free OBM has low
plastic viscosity, high shear stress, high ratio of dynamic shear force to plastic viscosity and high permeability recovery, which are bene-
ficial to penetration rate increase, hole cleaning and reservoir protection.
Key words: organoclay-free; oil-based drilling mud; rheology modifier; emulsifier; fluid loss reducer; weak gel; reservoir protection
trate reducer. Among them, RM is the main additive. drophilic effect of the fatty acid salt. The HLB was estimated
by Davies base method in this study. HLB base values of the
1.1. Rheological modifier (RM)
hydrophilic functional groups—COOK+, —COONa+, R3N(ter-
1.1.1. Synthesis of RM tiary amine), —COOH, —OH and —O— are 21.1, 19.1,
9.4, 2.1, 1.9 and 1.3, respectively[10].
The RM is high in viscosity due to the intermolecular hy-
drogen bonding between fatty acid dimers and suitable to be Detailed synthesis process of RM is: fatty acid dimer and
used as the rheological modifier for OBMs. However, RM has diethanolamine were mixed at the ratio of 1:2.05 (molecular
poor hydrophilicity. In this study, diethanolamine was used fraction) and placed into a four-necked flask. An electric
for the amidation of RM to increase its hydrophilicity. The mixer, condenser and reflux apparatus and dean stark trap
reaction is shown in equation (1). The hydrophilicity of the were attached to the flask and nitrogen was injected into the
fatty acid dimer is expected to increase with the addition of mixture for 10 min before the reaction was started. The mix-
amide groups according to hydrophile-lipophile balance (HLB) ture was heated by oil bath quickly to the reaction temperature
theory. Theoretically, hydrophilicity of the fatty acid dimer of 175 C to react for 4 hours. During the reaction process,
can be also enhanced using saponification of the fatty acid water in the dean stark trap was removed in time. At the
with a strong base. However, the internal phase of the OBM end of the reaction, the brown thick fluid produced was the
generally is high concentration brine, which reduces the hy- RM.
1.1.2. Effects of RM dosage on emulsion modulus is shown in Fig. 2. Stable emulsion can be formed in the OBM,
# thanks to the synergetic effect of the primary and secondary
An emulsion with an oil-water ratio of 85:15 (5 white oil:
emulsifiers. With an amphiphilic structure, RM can adsorb
water) and 3% (wt/V) of emulsifier SPAN-80 was prepared
onto the oil-water interface. Due to the solubilization of the
using a shearing mixer. Dynamic frequency of the emulsion
emulsifier on the oil-water interface, the concentration of RM
was scanned using a Haake MARS III rheometer in cone plate
mode to test the storage modulus (G') and loss modulus (G'')
of the emulsion. The frequency scanning range was 0.1 to 10
s1 and test temperature was held at 25 C and shear stress was
maintained at a constant 0.1 Pa.
Experimental results are shown in Fig. 1. It can be seen
pure emulsion has a higher G'' compared to G' within the fre-
quency range used in this study. This means the emulsion
mainly has viscous deformation and is in liquid state. After
RM is added, G' is higher than G'', indicating that the emul-
sion would change from a liquid state into a “gel state”. When
the RM concentration is lower than 3 g/L, G' increases with
the increase of RM concentration, but reduces when the con-
centration of RM is greater than 3 g/L. This could be because
the interaction force between the emulsion droplets is overly
large, leading to unstable flocculation of the emulsion and
reduction of G'.
It is reported in the literature [11] that, with the increase of
structural force in an emulsion, the influence of frequency on
G' decreases over time, i.e., the slope of a G' curve decreases.
It can be seen in Fig. 1(a) that the slope of the G' curve de-
creases gradually with the increase of RM content. This indi-
cates that the interaction force in the emulsion increases with
the increase of RM concentration.
Fig. 2. Functional mechanism of rheological modifier (RM). In this study, the primary emulsifier was obtained from the
reaction of fatty acid and maleic anhydride. The synthesis
increases at the oil-water interface. Due to hydrogen bonding method is reported in reference [13]. The hydrophilic groups
between the RM molecules, RM would form a “film” at the are carboxylic acids and the hydrophobic groups are long
oil-water interface. On one hand, RM accumulation on the chain fatty acids. The bivalent soap salt generated by the reac-
interface strengthens the interface film, which is conducive to tion between the carboxylic acid groups and CaO in the OBM
the stability of the emulsion. On the other hand, the hydrogen not only has strong hydrophilic property but also increases
bonding between RM adsorbed on different water droplets emulsion stability based on the directional wedge theory [14].
enhances the droplet-droplet interaction force in the emulsion.
1.2.3. Secondary emulsifier
There are hydroxy groups on particle surfaces, e.g. water-
borne acrylic resin filtrate reducer, calcium carbonate super- The secondary emulsifier in this drilling fluid is a fatty acid
fine powder and barite. In drilling fluid, RM can not only amide. The hydrophilic group is the amide group and the hy-
adhere to the oil-water interface, but also the solid-liquid in- drophobic group is the long chain fatty acid. Its synthesis
terface due to the hydrogen bonding effect. This can streng- principles are: Step 1: partial amidation products are gener-
then droplet-droplet, droplet-particle and particle-particle in- ated through the amidation of fatty acid polyamines and fatty
teractions, thus forming a 3D network structure connected by acids. Step 2: the partial amidation products react with diacid
weak interactions in the emulsion (weak gel structure)[8], en- to amidate the primary amine groups completely and generate
hancing the structural force of the emulsion to serve as shear the secondary emulsifier of fatty acid amides.
stress.
1.2.4. Evaluation of high temperature emulsion
Within the appropriate concentration (03 g/L), RM can
performance
increase emulsion structural force and stability. However,
flocculation occurs when the RM concentration is too high, The following OBM was prepared: base fluid of 5# white
which reduces emulsion stability and emulsion structural oil and 30% CaCl2 aqueous solution at the ratio of 85:15 + 1%
force. organoclay + 1% primary emulsifier + 3% secondary emulsi-
fier + 3% CaO. The OBM was stirred at a rate of 5 000 r/min
1.2. High temperature resistant emulsifier
for 30 min. The prepared OBM was placed into a roller fur-
1.2.1. Design principle of emulsifier resistant to high nace for high-temperature aging. The roller furnace tempera-
temperatures tures were set at 150 C, 180 C and 220 C respectively. At
the end of the aging process, the mixture was stirred for 2 min
Appropriate HLB value: Emulsifiers are the base to main-
at a rate of 5 000 r/min. An electrical stability tester was used
tain emulsion stability and improve other properties of OBM.
to test the electrical stability (ES) of the drilling fluid. Fig. 3
To form stable oil-in-water emulsion, the emulsifier must be
shows the emulsion formed using the primary and secondary
hydrophilic and lipophilic, and be hydrophilic and lipophilic
emulsifiers has a high ES after high-temperature aging. It is
balance under certain conditions. For nonionic emulsifiers, the
superior to SPAN-80 and ONEMUL in high-temperature
HLB value generally ranges between 3.0 and 6.0. The perfor-
emulsification performance.
mance of an ionic emulsifier is highly sensitive to water salin-
ity. For ionic emulsifiers with specific HLB values, the hy- 1.3. Waterborne acrylic resin filtrate reducer
drophilic interaction of the emulsifier decreases gradually
1.3.1. Synthesis of filtrate reducer
with the increase of water salinity. In OBM, two different
emulsifiers (primary and secondary emulsifiers) are generally Under high temperature conditions, without filtrate reduc-
used to form the dense composite membrane[12] to achieve the ers like organoclay, asphalt or lignite, it would be difficult to
best emulsification effect. The primary emulsifier is generally reduce fluid loss. But modified asphalt and organoclay are
a fatty acid or modified fatty acid with a lower HLB value. lipophilic colloids, which would increase the viscosity of the
The secondary emulsifier has a higher HLB value, which can drilling fluid, and thus reduce rate of penetration. A water-
stabilize the emulsion and also wet the solid phase. borne acrylic resin with strong hydrophilic property has been
Strong interaction forces at the lipophilic and hydrophilic developed by introducing hydrophilic monomer acrylic acid
766
SUN Jinsheng et al. / Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2018, 45(4): 764–769
Table 3. Comparison of permeability recovery of cores polluted the same density, organoclay-free OBM containing no colloi-
by the organoclay-free OBM and the traditional OBM. dal solid phase has lower viscosity, which is good for increas-
Initial Permeability Permeability ing the rate of penetration. The traditional OBM has high vis-
Drilling
permeability/ after pollution/ recovery/ cosity before and after aging, which has negative effect on
fluid type
103 µm2 103 µm2 % increasing rate of penetration. Besides, the organoclay-free
72.3 68.2 94.3 OBM has higher yield point, gel strength and higher ratio of
Organoclay-
96.2 92.5 96.2 yield point to plastic viscosity before and after aging than
free OBM
65.1 62.7 96.3 traditional OBMs, which is conducive to cutting-carrying.
86.8 79.8 91.9
Traditional 2.2.2. Reservoir protection performance
87.2 81.2 93.1
OBM
76.2 68.2 89.5 Artificial cores 25 mm in diameter and 50 mm long with
the gas permeability of approximately 50 100 × 103 µm2
Under the same density, high-purity barite has a small im-
were used to test changes of gas permeability of the cores
pact on the viscosity of the drilling fluid, so in this study,
before and after polluted by the organoclay-free OBM and the
high-purity barite with a density of 4.3 g/cm3 was used as the
weighting agent. traditional OBM and compare their performance in reservoir
The following organoclay-free OBM formula was formed protection. Firstly, the initial gas permeability (K0) of the
through lab tests: base fluid (the volume ratio of 5# white oil cores was tested. Secondly, one surface of the man-made core
to 30% CaCl2 aqueous solution is 85:15) + 0.3% RM + 2 % was polluted for 2 h at 60 C and 3.5 MPa using a HTHP
primary emulsifier + 3% secondary emulsifier + 1.5% wetting drilling fluid dynamic damage device (JHMD-II type, Jinzhou
agent + 2% waterborne acrylic resin + 4% calcium carbonate Modern Petroleum Scientific Technology Company). Thirdly,
superfine powder (25 μm) + 4% calcium carbonate superfine the polluted surface was cut and the reverse gas permeability
powder (6.5 μm) + 4% CaO + barite (ρ = 2.2 g/cm3). of the polluted core (K1) was tested. Finally, the permeability
recovery was calculated using the experimental results. Three
2.2. Organoclay-free OBM performance parallel tests were carried out and the mean permeability re-
The rheological property, filtration property and reservoir covery was calculated.
protection property of the organoclay-free OBM were tested, As shown in Table 3, the mean permeability recovery of
and compared with those of traditional OBM with organoclay. cores polluted by the organoclay-free OBM system is greater
The traditional OBM formula used was: base fluid (with the than 95%, while permeability recovery of the traditional OBM
volume ratio of 5# white oil to 30% CaCl2 aqueous solution of is lower than 92%. Therefore, although the traditional OBM
85:15) + 1.0% VGPLUS (organoclay) + 5% ONEMUL has fairly good reservoir protection performance, the organo-
(emulsifier) +1.5% VERSACOAT (wetting agent) + 4% clay-free OBM without organoclay and asphalt colloids can
VERSATROL (fluid loss reducer) + 0.5% SACKBLACK further reduce damage to the formation and has a better res-
(fluid loss reducer) + 4% CaO + barite (ρ = 2.2 g/cm3). ervoir protection performance.
2.2.1. Evaluation of general properties 3. Conclusions
Table 2 shows the general properties of the organoclay-free In this study, a kind of organoclay-free OBM system has
OBM and the traditional OBM before and after aging. The been developed, which contains four key additives (RM, pri-
aging was conducted at 220 C for 16 h. HTHP filter loss was mary emulsifier, secondary emulsifier and filtrate reducer).
tested under 180 C and 3.5 MPa. Rheological performance RM is a modified fatty acid that could replace organoclay in
was tested under 50 C. It can be seen that both OBMs can OBMs, which is prepared by the reaction between dimer acid
tolerate high temperatures up to 220 C, have ES of greater and diethanolamine. After RM is added, the storage modulus
than 400 V after aging and HTHP filter losses within the ac- of the emulsion increases significantly and the emulsion is in
ceptable range. However, compared with the traditional OBM, a “gel state”. The primary emulsifier is a modified fatty acid
the organoclay-free OBM has the following advantages: under and the secondary emulsifier is a fatty acid amide. Both pri-
768
SUN Jinsheng et al. / Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2018, 45(4): 764–769
mary and secondary emulsifiers have strong hydrophilic and horizontal wells. Petroleum Drilling Techniques, 2013, 41(2):
lipophilic groups, and excellent emulsion performance after 17–22.
high-temperature aging, superior to similar commercial prod- [6] JIANG Guancheng, HE Yinbo, HUANG Xianbin, et al. A
ucts made by foreign companies. The filtrate reducer is a kind high-density organoclay-free oil base drilling fluid based on
of waterborne acrylic resin with good emulsion stabilizing and supramolecular chemistry. Petroleum Exploration and De-
fluid loss reducing performance. It can control the HTHP fil- velopment, 2016, 43(1): 131–135.
ter loss in organoclay-free OBMs at less than 5 mL. [7] CUI Minglei. Research on oil based drilling fluid performance
RM is the main additive. The functional mechanism of RM: optimization. Qingdao: China University of Petroleum, 2011.
In organoclay-free OBMs, RM is adsorbed on the oil-water [8] HUANG X, JIANG G, HE Y, et al. Improvement of rheologi-
interface and solid-liquid surface, strengthening the drop- cal properties of invert drilling fluids by enhancing interac-
let-droplet, droplet-particle and particle-particle interactions in tions of water droplets using hydrogen bonding linker. Col-
the emulsion through hydrogen bonding, forming a 3D net- loids and Surfaces A: Physicochemical and Engineering As-
work structure connected by weak interactions, thus strength- pects, 2016, 506: 467–475.
ening the gel structure of the emulsion, improving the rheol- [9] MAGHRABI S S, WAGLE V B, KULKARNI D G. Or-
ogy and stabilizing the performance of the emulsion. gano-clay free invert emulsion fluids: U.S. Patent Application
Performance evaluation experiments show that compared 15/311475. 2017-03-23.
with the traditional OBMs, the organoclay-free OBM has low [10] ZHAO Fulin. Principle of chemistry(Ⅱ). Dongying: China
plastic viscosity, high shear stress, high ratio of yield point to University of Petroleum Press, 1999: 185–192.
plastic viscosity and high permeability recovery, which are [11] MEZGER T G. The rheology handbook for users of rotational
beneficial to penetration rate increase, hole cleaning and res- and oscillatory rheometers. Hannover: Vincentz Network
ervoir protection. GmbH & Co. KG, 2006.
[12] ZHAO Zhenguo. Principle and application of boundary mask.
References Beijing: Chemical Industry Press, 2013.
[13] QIN Yong, JIANG Guancheng, DENG Zhengqiang, et al.
[1] FARROW T C, RASMUSSEN C A, MENKING W R, et al. Synthesis and evaluation of a primary emulsifier for high
Organoclay compositions and method of preparation: U.S. temperature oil base drilling fluid. Drilling Fluid & Comple-
Patent 6036765. 2000-03-14. tion Fluid, 2016, 33(1): 6–10.
[2] CAENN R, DARLEY H C H, GRAY G R. Composition and [14] LI Zhe. Research on oil based drilling fluid with high tem-
properties of drilling and completion fluids. Houston, TX: perature resistance. Qingdao: China University of Petroleum,
Gulf Professional Publishing, 2011. 2011.
[3] FARD S M. Evaluation of fine particles removal from invert [15] HUANG Xianbin, JIANG Guancheng, DENG Zhengqiang.
emulsion drilling fluid by novel technologies. Calgary: Uni- Application of aqueous acrylic resin in invert emulsion drill-
versity of Calgary, 2015. ing fluids. Drilling Fluid & Completion Fluid, 2017, 34(2):
[4] YAN Jienian. Drilling fluid technology. Dongying: China 26–32.
University of Petroleum Press, 2001: 236–260. [16] ZHENG Weiqin, SHEN Yan, LU Wenda. Determination of
[5] WANG Xianguang, LI Xiong, LIN Yongxue. Search and ap- high purity soybean lecithin HLB by NMR. Grain and Oil,
plication of high performance oil base drilling fluid for shale 2007, 135(7): 39–41.
769