Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Introduction High altitude (HA) is an ex‑ of view.1 Conversely, the responses of peripheral
treme environment, challenging for the human circulation and, in particular, of systemic arte‑
body. Cold, low air humidity, and high ultravio‑ rial blood pressure (BP) have received much less
let radiation levels may all make the adaptation attention. Contrary to pulmonary hypertension,
to this condition difficult. However, the fore‑ changes in BP have not been so far clearly asso‑
most factor underlying physiological respons‑ ciated with pathological responses to HA. From
es to HA is the low atmospheric pressure and an epidemiological point of view, however, even
the consequent proportional reduction of oxy‑ minor BP changes induced by HA stay might af‑
gen partial pressure in the inspired air (hypo‑ ter all be relevant. This is because in the general
baric hypoxia; FIGURE 1).1,2 This occurs even though population, each mm Hg increase in systemic BP
the relative air composition remains the same has a significant prognostic impact and also be‑
Correspondence to: as at sea level, with oxygen content being about cause the number of people exposed to elevat‑
Prof. Grzegorz Bilo, MD, PhD, 21%. The ensuing hypoxemia and tissue hypoxia ed altitudes is nowadays considerable, including
University of Milano‑Bicocca,
Department of Medicine and
trigger numerous regulatory mechanisms, which a relevant proportion of those with cardiovascu‑
Surgery, Istituto Auxologico in most cases favor adaptation but may some‑ lar risk factors or diseases, such as arterial hy‑
Italiano, IRCCS; Department times evolve into pathological conditions such pertension.3,4 On one hand, brief HA exposures
of Cardiovascular,
as acute mountain sickness (AMS) or chronic have become common due to the development
Neural and Metabolic Sciences,
San Luca Hospital, mountain sickness (Monge disease). of mass mountain tourism and high‑altitude in‑
Piazzale Brescia 20, 20 149 Milan, Pulmonary hypertension is one of the key dustries (eg, mining). On the other hand, mil‑
Italy, phone: +39 02 619112903, features characterizing both AMS and chron‑ lions of people permanently live at HA, main‑
email: g.bilo@auxologico.it
Received: May 7, 2019.
ic mountain sickness and is the key pathoge‑ ly in Asia, South America, and Ethiopia. These
Accepted: May 8, 2019. netic factor in one of the most severe forms of highland populations were in the past character‑
Published online: May 17, 2019. AMS, that is, high‑altitude pulmonary edema. ized by healthy lifestyles from a cardiovascular
Kardiol Pol. 2019; 77 (6): 596-603
Because of that, pulmonary circulation in HA point of view. However, the economic changes
doi:10.33963/KP.14832
Copyright by Polskie Towarzystwo has been extensively investigated over the years over the last decades have led to easier availabili‑
Kardiologiczne, Warszawa 2019 both from a pathophysiological and clinical point ty of poor quality food and to less active lifestyle,
Peripheral Cold,
chemoreceptors exercise
Increased Sympathetic
ventilation activation
- BP
Respiratory - HR
alkalosis - Cardiac output
- Myocardial twist
not accompanied by adequate health education. mean arterial pressure changes little during
As a consequence, these populations are now fac‑ acute hypoxia (simulated altitude), despite im‑
ing an unprecedented epidemic of obesity and portant changes that occur in systemic hemody‑
spread of cardiovascular risk factors, including namics. This is because a significant increase in
arterial hypertension. cardiac output, mostly driven by a sympathetic
Beside these epidemiological considerations, ‑mediated increase in heart rate (stroke volume
the study of cardiovascular responses to hypoxia remains largely unchanged), is contrasted by
in healthy people may represent a useful model a drop in peripheral vascular resistance, due to
for assessing complex hypoxia-related process‑ direct hypoxic vasodilation. The net effect on
es, which are common in pulmonary and cardio‑ BP is thus near zero.5
vascular diseases. The advantage of such a mod‑ While laboratory research provides a very de‑
el is the possibility to investigate responses to tailed insight into physiological changes in BP
hypoxia without the interference by major con‑ and its regulatory mechanisms, this information
founding factors commonly present in hypox‑ cannot be readily extrapolated to real HA expo‑
ic patients, which may per se affect systemic BP sure of human beings. This is because: 1) the du‑
levels (eg, obesity, sleep apnea, and heart failure). ration of simulated exposure is typically short
On this background, the present article (usually much less than 24 hours); therefore, it
provides an overview of principal physiologi‑ does not take into account changes that occur
cal and clinical aspects related to systemic BP in regulatory mechanisms over longer time; 2)
control and changes at HA, focusing mainly laboratory studies usually do not consider nu‑
on the acute exposure. In particular, the paper merous other factors that may play a significant
discusses the studies documenting BP changes role in the extreme environment of high moun‑
at rest and during exercise, as well as addresses tains, such as cold, physical exertion, emotional
the underlying mechanisms and possible clini‑ stress, changes in food and water intake. To ad‑
cal implications. dress these limitations, a number of field studies
were performed to assess the impact of HA on BP.
Blood pressure and its regulation at high alti- Studies on conventionally measured BP in‑
tude Numerous laboratory studies addressed dicated a possible pressor effect of HA expo‑
the impact of hypoxia on BP in animals and hu‑ sure, although the data were not always con‑
mans. Classic physiological studies showed that sistent.1,5,6 However, in a clinical setting, spot
mm Hg
*** ***
120 110
***
110 100 *
100 90
SLpre SLpost Namche BC1 BC2 SLreturn SLpre SLpost Namche BC1 BC2 SLreturn
* * 4 ***
6.5 °
*
° 3
6 *
2
5.5 *
1
5 0 ***
SLpre SLpost Namche BC1 BC2 SLreturn SLpre SLpost Namche BC1 BC2 SLreturn
Telmisartan Placebo
FIGURE 2 Changes in systolic blood pressure (SBP) during the day (A) and night (B) in healthy participants of the HIGHCARE-HIMALAYA study randomized to
placebo (blue lines) or telmisartan, 80 mg once daily (red lines). Lower panels show parallel changes occurring in the levels of noradrenaline (C) and renin (D). Data
obtained at sea level pretreatment (SLpre), at sea level posttreatment (SLpost), at 3400 m (Namche), at Mount Everest base camp, 5400 m, during the first 3 days
(BC1) and after 11 to 12 days (BC2), and immediately after return to sea level (SLreturn). Different symbols indicate significance of differences between groups (cross
symbols) and of differences between altitudes considering the SLpost as reference (circles and asterisks). Modified from Parati et al.9
measurements in resting conditions are known daytime, and nighttime BP was seen already
to provide a very limited view of the individu‑ at 3400 m, with a further BP increment after ar‑
al’s BP status, being confined to a single mo‑ rival at 5400 m. Blood pressure values remained
ment during the day and affected by both ran‑ stably elevated also after a prolonged stay at HA
dom and systematic errors, including white coat (FIGURE 2).9 The increase in BP with altitude seems
effect. Conventional BP measurements are thus thus to be continuous and proportional to the al‑
ill suited to accurately explore the effects of en‑ titude reached. In fact, in a more recent study in
vironmental factors, such as barometric pres‑ healthy volunteers, we observed that even the ex‑
sure, air temperature, and pollution, on BP lev‑ posure to about 2000 m (eg, moderate altitude)
els. A more reproducible and extensive evalua‑ may induce a modest but significant 24‑hour BP
tion of BP can be achieved by means of 24‑hour increase (unpublished data). Furthermore, an in‑
ambulatory BP monitoring, which has the ad‑ crease in 24‑hour BP was also found by our group
ditional advantage of assessing BP under dai‑ in patients with hypertension acutely exposed
ly life conditions, including daytime challeng‑ to an altitude of 3200 m (see below).10
es and nighttime sleep. A more detailed analysis of HIGHCARE
On this background, several research groups ‑HIMALAYA data revealed that at very high al‑
applied this technique to evaluate BP chang‑ titudes (5400 m), BP increase was particularly
es at HA. Wolfel et al 7 and Veglio et al8 provid‑ evident during the night, leading to a reduced
ed initial evidence of BP increase during HA ex‑ nocturnal fall in BP (dipping). This phenome‑
posure. Following these studies, our group per‑ non was not observed during acute exposure to
formed a study in Nepal (HIGHCARE [HIGH al‑ 3400 m in the same study or in individuals ex‑
titude Cardiovascular Research]-HIMALAYA) in posed to an altitude of 2000 m.9
47 healthy volunteers evaluated at sea level, af‑ Physiological mechanisms involved in BP con‑
ter a short (2–3 days) exposure to an altitude of trol are complex and their contribution in medi‑
3400 m, then immediately after reaching 5400 m ating a BP increase at altitude was the object of
(Mount Everest base camp), and after 12‑day several studies. From a hemodynamic point of
stay at this altitude. A clear increase of 24‑hour, view, increased peripheral resistance seems to
190
‑air activities. Second, many people at advanced
age or affected by pathological conditions wish
170
to go to HA. This raises several questions such
as: 1) whether the effect of altitude exposure is
150 the same as in healthy young people; 2) wheth‑
er the extra burden imposed on the cardiovas‑
130
cular system to achieve acclimatization may be
detrimental in these patients; and 3) whether
treated hypertensive individuals should mod‑
110 ify antihypertensive therapy to prevent exces‑
0 5 10 15 20 25
sive BP increase and, if yes, how.2
VO2, ml/kg/min Focusing on elderly individuals, it is widely
accepted that BP increases with age because of
FIGURE 3 Schematic representation of changes in systolic blood pressure (BP) during the combined effect of atherosclerotic changes,
exercise at high altitude. With increasing workload and oxygen consumption (VO2, x axis) large artery stiffening, renal function impair‑
at altitude BP increases more steeply (dotted lines) than at sea level (continuous line). However, ment, and arterial baroreflex dysfunction, with
peak exercise BP is similar in both conditions because the achieved peak VO2 is lower at altitude. older people having on average higher systol‑
In individuals under antihypertensive treatment (blue lines), the pattern is similar but BP is ic BP values than younger ones.41,42 Few stud‑
shifted towards lower values. Modified from Caravita et al.27 ies evaluated the effects of altitude exposure
in the elderly, sometimes with conflicting re‑
sults, and most of them focused on moderate
normalizing BP increase at altitude for the met‑ altitude instead of HA. Levine et al 32 found that
abolic demands imposed by exercise, BP trajec‑ elderly individuals (mean age, 68 years) accli‑
tories of hypertensive lowlanders exercising at matized well and fully after 5 days at 2500 m.
altitude are shifted upwards and become steep‑ In that study, acute hypoxia induced a decrease
er compared with those observed at sea level.27 of BP, with BP values returning to baseline lev‑
This means that if BP is not adequately controlled els during a 5‑day stay at HA. At the same time,
at sea level, it will be even more so during exer‑ heart rate slightly increased. A similar pattern
cise at altitude (FIGURE 3). of changes was maintained also during exercise
Very few studies addressed the effect of phar‑ in both conditions. In another study, conducted
macological treatment on BP during exercise by Roach et al43 in 97 elderly individuals (mean
at altitude.29 In this perspective, it should be age, 70 years), during a multiday exposure to
acknowledged that some drugs (in particular, an altitude of 2500 m, BP increased on the first
nonselective β ‑blockers) may have deleterious day of stay and decreased over the subsequent
effects on exercise physiology at altitude, nega‑ days. The values were much higher in hyperten‑
tively affecting the ventilatory control and oxy‑ sive individuals. Finally, in a study by Veglio et
gen diffusion at the alveolar‑capillary membrane al,8 the BP response to moderate‑altitude expo‑
level.37 Conversely, a combination treatment sure (2950 m) was the same in older and younger
with telmisartan and nifedipine GITS proved adults (mean age, 65.2 years [range, 60–83 years]
to have a good safety and efficacy profile, being and mean age, 40.2 years [range, 32–45 years],
able to produce a downward shift in the BP re‑ respectively), both during daytime and night‑
sponse to exercise and to improve muscle oxygen time, although the sample size of this study
delivery. 33,36,38 Acetazolamide, which is frequent‑ was too small to allow a robust comparison be‑
ly prescribed for the prevention of HA illnesses, tween groups.
has BP‑lowering capabilities, both at rest and The topic of patients with preexisting cardio‑
during exercise, which may come either from vascular conditions who wish to reach HA lo‑
its diuretic properties or as a consequence of cations has been extensively discussed in a re‑
improved oxygenation at altitude.38‑ 40 However, cent consensus statement of experts and scien‑
especially at higher doses, it can promote meta‑ tific societies.2 In fact, even if the increase in
bolic acidosis, which can have a detrimental ef‑ BP observed during HA exposure, although im‑
fect on exercise performance. portant, should not, per se, represent a risk for
a healthy person, this may not necessarily be
Clinical implicationsSeveral factors must true for diseased individuals. For example, hy‑
be considered when assessing the clinical pertensive patients may be more susceptible to
creased sympathetic drive leads to a persis‑ 8 Veglio M, Maule S, Cametti G, et al. The effects of exposure to moderate al‑
titude on cardiovascular autonomic function in normal subjects. Clin Auton Res.
tent increase in BP mostly mediated by vaso‑ 1999; 9: 123-127.
constriction and elevated heart rate, despite 9 Parati G, Bilo G, Faini A, et al. Changes in 24 h ambulatory blood pressure
the concomitant suppression of the RAAS (at and effects of angiotensin II receptor blockade during acute and prolonged high
‑altitude exposure: a randomized clinical trial. Eur Heart J. 2014; 35: 3113-3122.
very HA) and loss of plasma volume. This phase
10 Bilo G, Villafuerte FC, Faini A, et al. Ambulatory blood pressure in untreat‑
is characterized by a particularly pronounced ed and treated hypertensive patients at high altitude. Hypertension. 2015; 65:
BP increase at night, with a reduced nocturnal 1266-1272.
dipping, and by accentuated pressor response 11 Halliwill JR, Minson CT. Effect of hypoxia on arterial baroreflex control of
heart rate and muscle sympathetic nerve activity in humans. J Appl Physiol. 2002;
to exercise. Less is known about long‑term ad‑ 93: 857-864.
aptations of BP to altitude, but some studies 12 Bilo G, Revera M, Bussotti M, et al. Effects of slow deep breathing at high al‑
imply that living at higher altitudes may favor titude on oxygen saturation, pulmonary and systemic hemodynamics. PLoS One.
2012; 7: e49074.
the development of arterial hypertension with
13 Bourdillon N, Yazdani S, Subudhi AW, et al. AltitudeOmics: baroreflex sensi‑
a possible role of polycythemia and increased tivity during acclimatization to 5,260 m. Front Physiol. 2018; 9: 767.
blood viscosity. 2 3,50 14 Boussuges A, Molenat F, Burnet H, et al. Operation Everest III (Comex ’97):
Finally, the prognostic impact of an altitude modifications of cardiac function secondary to altitude‑induced hypoxia. An echo‑
cardiographic and Doppler study. Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 2000; 161: 264-270.
‑related BP increase is unknown. Although ini‑
15 Osculati G, Revera M, Branzi G, et al. Effects of hypobaric hypoxia exposure
tial evidence is available on the effects of BP at high altitude on left ventricular twist in healthy subjects: data from HIGHCARE
‑lowering drugs in this condition, it is unclear study on Mount Everest. Eur Hear J Cardiovasc Imaging. 2016; 17: 635-643.
whether specific pharmacological interventions 16 Zaccaria M, Rocco S, Noventa D, et al. Sodium regulating hormones at high al‑
titude: basal and post‑exercise levels 1. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 1998; 83: 570-574.
might be beneficial in hypertensive patients ex‑ 17 Bruno RM, Ghiadoni L, Pratali L. Vascular adaptation to extreme conditions:
posed to elevated altitudes. Reasonably, an in‑ the role of hypoxia. Artery Res. 2016; 14: 15-21.
dividualized approach should be preferred, with 18 Yanamandra U, Singh SP, Yanamandra S, et al. Endothelial markers in
high altitude induced systemic hypertension (HASH) at moderate high altitude.
some degree of caution being warranted in hy‑ Med J Armed Forces India. 2017; 73: 363-369.
pertensive patients at particularly high risk of 19 Lewis NC, Bailey DM, Dumanoir GR, et al. Conduit artery structure and func‑
cardiovascular events due to the presence of or‑ tion in lowlanders and native highlanders: relationships with oxidative stress and
gan damage or comorbidities. Having said this, role of sympathoexcitation. J Physiol. 2014; 592: 1009-1024.
20 Revera M, Salvi P, Faini A, et al. Renin-angiotensin-aldosterone system is not
in most patients, the presence of cardiovascu‑ involved in the arterial stiffening induced by acute and prolonged exposure to
lar conditions, including hypertension, is not high altitude: novelty and significance. Hypertension. 2017; 70: 75-84.
a contraindication to HA exposure. Except for 21 Corante N, Anza‑Ramírez C, Figueroa‑Mujíca R, et al. Excessive erythrocyto‑
sis and cardiovascular risk in Andean highlanders. High Alt Med Biol. 2018; 19:
some very high‑risk patient categories, practic‑ ham.2017.0123.
ing physicians must not discourage their patients 22 Siques P, Brito J, Banegas JR, et al. Blood pressure responses in young adults
from HA travel. Instead, they should provide in‑ first exposed to high altitude for 12 months at 3550 m. High Alt Med Biol. 2009;
10: 329-335.
formed advice on the few key safety rules to be
23 Aryal N, Weatherall M, Bhatta YK, Mann S. Blood pressure and hyperten‑
followed in this challenging but also inspiring sion in adults permanently living at high altitude: a systematic review and meta
environment. ‑analysis. High Alt Med Biol. 2016; 17: 185-193.
24 Cheong HI, Janocha AJ, Monocello LT, et al. Alternative hematological and
ARTICLE INFORMATION vascular adaptive responses to high‑altitude hypoxia in East African highlanders.
Am J Physiol Cell Mol Physiol. 2017; 312: L172‑L177.
CONFLICT OF INTEREST None declared.
25 Insalaco G, Romano S, Salvaggio A, et al. Blood pressure and heart rate during
OPEN ACCESS This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of periodic breathing while asleep at high altitude. J Appl Physiol. 2000; 89: 947-955.
the Creative Commons Attribution‑NonCommercial‑NoDerivatives 4.0 Interna‑
tional License (CC BY‑NC‑ND 4.0), allowing third parties to download articles and 26 Naeije R. Physiological adaptation of the cardiovascular system to high alti‑
share them with others, provided the original work is properly cited, not changed tude. Prog Cardiovasc Dis. 2010; 52: 456-466.
in any way, distributed under the same license, and used for noncommercial pur‑ 27 Caravita S, Faini A, Baratto C, et al. Upward shift and steepening of the blood
poses only. For commercial use, please contact the journal office at kardiologiapol‑ pressure response to exercise in hypertensive subjects at high altitude. J Am Heart
ska@ptkardio.pl. Assoc. 2018; 7: e008 506.