Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DOI: 10.1002/jsfa.1595
Crete, Greece
3 National Agricultural Research Foundation, Institute of Agricultural Economics and Rural Development, 5 Parthenonos Street, GR-14121
Abstract: The effect of ripening on the chemical characteristics of fruits of the avocado (Persea americana)
cultivars Ettinger, Fuerte and Hass was investigated. A study of some quality parameters of these main
avocado cultivars grown on the island of Crete was performed. As the fruit ripened, a decrease in the
moisture content was observed, with a high degree of correlation for all the cultivars. At the same time an
increase in the fat and protein contents was measured. The content of total sugars was high in the unripe
fruit but decreased during ripening. The fatty acid composition of the oil extracted from the fruit pulp
was determined by gas chromatographic analysis. The oil of the edible portion of the fruit was rich in
oleic, palmitic, linoleic and palmitoleic acids, while stearic acid was present in small quantities. During
the ripening process the amount of palmitic acid decreased and that of oleic acid increased in all the
cultivars. The ratio of polyunsaturated to saturated fatty acids, which is considered as an indicator of
the nutritional value of the fruit, was also calculated. No significant differences were observed between
the cultivars. Principal component analysis was also performed to examine the relationship among the
quality variables of the cultivars. From these data, Fuerte was considered to be the cultivar with the best
characteristics.
2004 Society of Chemical Industry
Keywords: avocado cultivars; Crete; compositional changes; fatty acids; ripening process
∗ Correspondence to: Stavroula A Vekiari, National Agricultural Research Foundation, Institute of Technology of Agricultural Products, 1 S
Venizelou Street, GR-14123 Lycovrissi, Attiki, Greece
E-mail: itap@otenet.gr
(Received 29 July 2002; revised version received 12 August 2003; accepted 19 August 2003)
changes in external appearance. Lee et al 11 examined experimental olive mill to obtain the oil. The fatty
the feasibility of establishing picking dates and acid content of the avocado oil was determined
proposed dry weight analysis as an index of maturity. by gas chromatography after metesterification with
The objective of this study was to obtain information methanol/BF3 reagent.14 The areas under the peaks
on the physicochemical characteristics and fatty acid were calculated by triangulation. A Perkin-Elmer
composition of the fruit of the main avocado cultivars Sigma 3 gas chromatograph equipped with a Sigma 10
grown in Crete. An attempt was also made to evaluate flame ionisation detector (FID) was used. The methyl
the behaviour of these cultivars during the different esters of the fatty acids were analysed isothermally
stages of ripening representative of the physiological at 180 ◦ C on a glass column packed with 10%
state of the fruit. EGSSX Gas Chrom Q 100/120 mesh. The injector
and detector temperatures were 250 and 260 ◦ C
respectively.
EXPERIMENTAL
Sampling Statistical analysis
Fruits of the cultivars Ettinger (early season), Fuerte Data were subjected to one-way analysis of variance
(middle season) and Hass (late season) were harvested
(ANOVA) using the least significant difference (LSD)
at different stages of ripening representative of the
procedure to determine differences between variables
physiological state of the fruit from a plantation located
at P < 0.05. Principal component analysis was also
in Chrysopigi in the Chania Prefecture of Crete. The
performed to evaluate the quality of each variety
sampling period was from September to February for
by comparison of the different variables (moisture,
the Ettinger cultivar, from November to May for the
proteins, sugars, oil content and fatty acids).
Fuerte cultivar and from December to July for the
Hass cultivar. Fruits were collected from three trees of
each cultivar at 20 day intervals and transported to the
laboratory within a few hours for analysis. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Compositional changes
Chemical analyses Typical changes in the main chemical constituents
Samples of 20 fruits were peeled and sliced without of the edible part of the avocado fruit are shown in
stones. A pulp was prepared in a Waring blender and Table 1. The water content of avocado pulp decreases
was used for the determination of moisture and fat as the fat content increases.15 The moisture content
contents, total proteins and total sugars. Standardised varied from 832 to 665 g kg−1 in Ettinger, from 792
methods were used in the analyses of moisture, protein to 593 g kg−1 in Fuerte and from 788 to 642 g kg−1
and fat contents.12 Total sugars were determined in Hass.
according to the anthrone reagent method described The fat content varied from 48 to 270 g kg−1 in
by Roe.13 The caloric content was also calculated. Ettinger, from 101 to 310 g kg−1 in Fuerte and from
127 to 277 g kg−1 in Hass. The average fat content
Extraction of avocado oil during the whole period of ripening was 158 g kg−1 in
Portions of avocado flesh from each sampling Ettinger, 218 g kg−1 in Fuerte and 186 g kg−1 in Hass.
and variety were ground and processed in an These values give a rough average for the whole crop of
187 g kg−1 , which is higher than the value of 162 g kg−1 the percentage fat content, it could be seen that
reported by Slater et al.15 In avocado fruit the oil they were inversely proportional (Fig 1) with a high
content is closely related to fruit development and degree of correlation, especially in the Fuerte cultivar.
maturity.11 Since horticultural maturity is defined as Concerning the moisture content, it can be assumed
the development stage where harvested fruit undergoes from the data that no serious dehydration has
normal ripening and provides good eating quality, the occurred, since the fat–water relationship remains
presence of a high oil content is likely to affect the constant.
eating quality of the fruit.13 The protein content of the three cultivars increased
The sum of the water and fat contents was with increasing fat content and showed a good
constant and ranged from 88 to 94.7%. When correlation in the Fuerte cultivar (Fig 2). At the 5th
the percentage water content was plotted against month of ripening, the protein and fat contents were
900
800
700
y = -0.8927x + 887.63
300 R2 = 0.9404
Fuerte
200
y = -0.8333x + 869.63
R2 = 0.9043
100 Hass
0
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350
Fat (g.Kg-1)
Figure 1. Correlation of moisture and fat contents in avocado cultivars for one harvest period.
60
50
40
Protein (g.Kg-1)
30 y = 0.1178x + 7.1743
R2 = 0.9352
Ettinger
20 y = 0.1834x - 6.9506
R2 = 0,9361
Fuerte
10 y = 0.1467x + 2.349
R2 = 0.8792
Hass
0
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350
Fat (g.Kg-1)
Figure 2. Correlation of protein and fat contents in avocado cultivars for one harvest period.
respectively 33 and 191 g kg−1 in Ettinger, 28 and while stearic acid is present in very small amounts.
231 g kg−1 in Fuerte and 26 and 151 g kg−1 in Hass. The major saturated fatty acid is palmitic acid and the
The avocado fruit is a good source of carbohydrates, main unsaturated fatty acid is oleic acid. During the
but the mechanism of their biosynthesis as well as their ripening process the level of palmitic acid decreased
biological function is still not clear.1 The carbohydrate while the oleic acid content increased (Table 2). The
content in the studied cultivars showed a decrease content of oleic acid varied from 548 to 681 g kg−1
during the ripening process for all the cultivars. It in Ettinger, from 548 to 757 g kg−1 in Fuerte and
ranged from 29 to 8 g kg−1 in Ettinger, from 12 from 612 to 694 g kg−1 in Hass. The content of oleic
to 6 g kg−1 in Fuerte and from 13 to 6 g kg−1 in acid represented 54–76% of the total fatty acids,
Hass (Table 1). According to Biale and Young,1 the which is in agreement with the results of Lozano and
avocado sugars are of hexose, heptulose and octulose Ratovohery,17 who reported that oleic acid accounted
type. The level of sugars not only in avocado but also for 65–80% of the total fatty acids in Mediterranean
in other species such as olive is variable and decreases avocado oil. The contents of the other fatty acids
during ripening.1,2,16 varied as follows: palmitic acid, from 182 to 137 g kg−1
The caloric content was calculated and is shown in in Ettinger, from 149 to 92 g kg−1 in Fuerte and from
Table 1. Values of 9 kcal g−1 for fat and 4 kcal g−1 172 to 130 g kg−1 in Hass; linoleic acid, from 158
for proteins and carbohydrates were used in the to 110 g kg−1 in Ettinger, from 210 to 104 g kg−1 in
calculations. Average values for each sampling and Fuerte and from 150 to 114 g kg−1 in Hass; palmitoleic
cultivar are shown per 100 g of fresh pulp. The caloric acid, from 73 to 51 g kg−1 in Ettinger, from 62 to
value of the avocado is mostly accounted for by its 35 g kg−1 in Fuerte and from 67 to 52 g kg−1 in Hass.
fat content, so the variation in fat content influences
proportionally the caloric content. The caloric content Ratio of fatty acids in avocado oil
increased as the fruit ripened, reaching final values of The ratio of polyunsaturated to saturated fatty acids
261 kcal per 100 g in Ettinger, 307 kcal per 100 g in (P/S) is considered to be an indicator of nutritional
Fuerte and 270 kcal per 100 g in Hass. The average value.17,18 This ratio has been calculated and is
caloric content is correlated with the values reported shown in Table 3. The mean values during the
by Slater et al 15 for the cultivars Fuerte and Hass. whole sampling period were 0.75, 1.09 and 0.93
for Ettinger, Fuerte and Hass respectively. In the
Fatty acid content in avocado oil same table the ratio of unsaturated to saturated fatty
The composition of fatty acids in the oil, expressed as acids (U/S) is also shown. The mean values during
g kg−1 of the total fatty acids of the lipids, is shown in the whole sampling period were 4.42, 6.73 and 5.64
Table 2. The oil of the edible portion of the fruit is for Ettinger, Fuerte and Hass respectively. However,
rich in oleic, palmitic, linoleic and palmitoleic acids, there were no significant differences in the average
Table 2. Variation in composition of fatty acids in oil from avocado cultivars during ripening
Results represent mean values of three replicates ± SD expressed as g kg−1 . ND, not detected.
Table 3. Ratios of unsaturated (U) and polyunsaturated (P) to saturated (S) fatty acids in oil from avocado cultivars during ripening
values for the three cultivars. Thus the avocado fruit Ettinger
has a content of total unsaturated fatty acids that Scree Plot
is about five times higher than its content of total 6
saturated fatty acids. Slater et al 15 verify this for 5
Californian avocados.
4
Eigenvalue
Principal component analysis 3
In order to examine the relationship among the 2
variables of moisture, proteins, sugars, oil content
1
and fatty acids in the three cultivars, the technique
of principal component analysis (PCA) has been 0
applied. PCA is one of the oldest and most widely -1
used multivariate techniques. The basic idea of the 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
method is to describe the variation of a set of Component Number
multivariate data of initially correlated variables in
Fuerte
terms of a set of uncorrelated principal components,
Scree Plot
each of which is a particular linear combination 8
of the original variables. The new variables are
derived in decreasing order of importance and should
6
account for the maximum variance possible of the
Eigenvalue
original data.19
Table 4 shows the aggregate results of PCA for the 4
three cultivars. The set of 11 initial variables comprises
‘moisture’, ‘proteins’, ‘sugars’, ‘oil content’ and ‘fatty 2
acids’ (seven variables). All principal components
with an eigenvalue greater than one account for a
satisfactory percentage of the initial variance, ranging 0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
from 74% for Fuerte to 92% for Ettinger (Fig. 3).
Component Number
For Ettinger, three principal components are chosen
which exhibit eigenvalues greater than one. These Haas
three components account for nearly 92% of the Scree Plot
2.5
initial variance of the data for this variety. The
Kaiser–Meyer–Olkin measure of sampling adequacy
2.0
was 0.463 and Bartlett’s test of sphericity had 0.000
Eigenvalue
Cumulative %
23.925
40.194
54.328
79.345
87.045
93.024
96.603
100.000
67.408
three cultivars.
For Fuerte, of the 11 initial variables, 10 take part in
the first component, which alone accounts for 62.4%
of the initial variance. On the other hand, myristic
acid is the only variable in the second component.
These results indicate that 10 out of the 11 initial
Variance %
23.925
16.269
14.135
5.979
3.579
3.397
13.080
11.937
7.700
altogether define the fruit’s overall quality. In other
words, assuming that the fruit composition in terms
of moisture, proteins, sugars, oils and fatty acids
influences overall Fuerte quality, the latter is nearly
a one-dimensional construct of the type
Eigenvalue
99.997
100.000
62.435
74.295
83.309
89.353
94.291
96.918
98.159
99.305
99.794
strongly negatively.
Variance %
Fuerte
100.000
100.000
100.000
100.000
100.000
100.000
100.000
100.000
46.685
26.323
18.928
8.063
−2.810E-16
acids’, Y2: ‘proteins and fatty acids’ and Y3: ‘oils and
Eigenvalue
5.135
2.896
2.082
0.887
or oils.
5.78 × 10−2
−0.221
−0.110
0.479
0.302
0.492
0.225
−0.368
−0.173
variables (no data were recorded for myristic and
PC5
stearic acids), four take part in the first component
(proteins, sugars, oils and palmitoleic acid), which
alone accounts for only 23.9% of the initial variance.
A single variable participates in the second component
−9.34 × 10−2
(oleic acid). Of the remaining three variables, two
belong to the third component (linoleic acid and
−0.631
0.395
0.165
0.230
0.371
0.438
−0.223
−0.393
PC4
0.382
0.123
0.728
0.575
PC3
0.389
0.171
0.794
−0.217
0.210
0.311
0.646
−0.415
0.172
0.364
PC1
0.444
0.217
0.110
0.639
0.159
0.178
−0.560
−0.116
−0.462
PC2
4.503 × 10−2
−0.515
−0.327
0.592
0.146
0.454
−0.156
0.459
−0.395
0.717
PC3
REFERENCES
Table 5. Results of principal component analysis: component matrix
−0.654
0.320
0.482
−0.378
−0.645
0.390
−0.829
0.571
0.458
0.217
0.215
PC2
−0.900
−0.258
0.864
0.180
0.861
0.973
0.749
PC1
Linoleic acid
Stearic acid
Oleic acid
(1971).
Moisture
Proteins
Variable
Sugars
LV:260–262 (1978).
10 Poiana M, Giuffre AM, Mincione B and Giuffre F, Avocado 16 Marsilio V, Campestre C, Lanza B and De Angelis M, Sugar
oil. Lipidic components evolution during the ripening of the and polyol compositions of some European olive fruit varieties
fruits of some cultivars grown in the south of Italy. Riv Ital (Olea europaea L.) suitable for table olive purposes. Food Chem
Sost Grasse 76:257–275 (1999). 72:485–490 (2001).
11 Lee SK, Young RE, Shiffman PM and Coggins Jr CW, Maturity 17 Lozano Y and Ratovohery J, Composition en acides gras
studies of avocado fruit based on picking date and dry weight. de differentes varietes d’avocats. Evolution au cours du
J Am Soc Hort Sci 108:390–394 (1983). development physiologique du fruit et incidence de la zone
12 AOAC, Official Methods of Analysis, 14th edn. Association of de culture. Rev Fr Corps Gras 10:377–388 (1985).
Official Analytical Chemists, Washington, DC, pp 16, 346, 18 Lapa MAG, Pires de Freitas C, Guerra NB, Vieira R and
352 (1984). Coelho MA, Nutritive value of avocados (Persea americana).
13 Roe JH, The determination of sugar in blood and spinal fluid Rev Brasil Pesq Med Biol 5:205–210 (1972).
with anthrone reagent. J Biol Chem 212:335–342 (1955). 19 Hair JF, Anderson RE, Tatham RL and Black WC, Multivariate
14 Morrison WR and Smith LM, Preparation of fatty acid Data Analysis, 5th edn. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ
methyl esters and dimethylacetals from lipids with boron (1998).
fluoride–methanol. J Lipid Res 5:600–604 (1964).
15 Slater GG, Shankman S, Shepherd JS and Alfin-Slater RB,
Seasonal variation in the composition of California avocados.
J Agric Food Chem 23:468–474 (1975).