Menoodom

on
Reeroent
No
UERSUS
ekhorer. Shakat Ma.
OF CASE THE V
(958. (MAReIAE
AcT
13) SeTsoN UfOER
HINDU OE
BENGOURU CoURT, Farary
JUOE, IRTNCIRAL THE BEFoRE
 TABUE OF CoNTENTS

2. No eolirulo,
List AuthMcdhel
slaBeraernt soesdichon

3
Sunra Aor ernt
Aqumerrt Aduoned

6.
 LsT OE AUTHOerTsES.
OF

V. mUopalea
O Mtopala Uenkald o ano
Scoo (5) ALO183
vedsou
Sokcon -((4a)P 14.
9 Se ocksn V
shu chaon Siaqh
(3) Toqnder koy v
Jocob - (13 AR 9090
Ross oeob V

(5) Ueena kopco U Uooredat kopoot

AR 198a SC 14a.

6 Sonaovua Gulepra khondekas v Gqulopa

Katyeçpa krordekay-(9 42)44 BoMLR GI4
Satyawan Togtop Eas. V Sra. Uimal
gatyuwan Sqlap s
 STATEENT OEUSDICTION
TheTehhone has
hoss oAoached thrs tonble (at
Sechton 300) the tHinou moitage
Act ss.
 TSves Poseð
enttted a dotee
) whethey he husbord

wte ron corrn

ehtuhon
whethes Hirdu morige
Jants urdes sochon
torjol
Aet,14s99
whethey husbond con qet custoðy unoe
3) quosdroeshp Aet ,|56
Kngu mnoscy ord
intei
whethesr Hhe wrte is enfed to
i)
 SUarA o ARGumENTS
cuhethe the husbord
s
enhted to
Undey
1s0) HMA14SS? dMaYee
ehtroNeH has,
Siellered menial ocpy o ythe
oce
elleteo his
both eoal ord
qaesora l lee.

Seehon q
HmA 1955?
he eihione sbra hot the epondeat NO 4 has
to seek Corguqal Srqnts. Cuhen o seous
not t
such as odulty is aleyed.
ollopkor
husoond ar qet Cus,tody undey
Bhue 3!- wrethe
mrmaty orð quasoI 00sIhp Aek, (956?
Hrnu
Cse, it wpud be better
the
Obdere the ok Lave h the tothe
he chldsten/culd to
o moxeovey, he fathet
Ovð his forals: mtekny
s ented to
weh he cule
moin toinente? seous alyokoo
Colc when a
motntotnene shoud
Sohon (a5
Atos-ir, to

40 the
Ao he
Reford
Rfo ent No:1.
ot be gtoated
o+
 ARqumENT ADuAN CED

os voe
uheihe he hussbord is eohted

subma that, te fecte de etexiates

The Vehtone
hete ony to Steason no Seqeakpon.

b) The Peshonen subm Hhek, he ord the Respondert

No. aot ased a p e
iitvals in unuaty a09.
the ekhones ond Resporoect atron qed
me Yehonee iss the CFO e 3utresul stott-up.

on oÔrnnsatne elubue
eeeuhe n a lhosptal rm
,she
yderalo d but soon
(elt the job orð nov to bot oolaYe .
À The Pekhonet ocd srorooent berocne pastents
40 0 doqnker noed roya on mah1S,80AO
The Vehhonet wass YoraoBed as the Ute
Roedeot e he opaey he awas casikrd'
) Tie venhorey Slbrat that, n meon he the
 e pehonest his
ch
hime cf he Romohon
asiness neeôed to
wileto ovest e chid.tere. suquestro Hhe

Oro pebtboney to
fqrt o he pehtonot
espondert No 4 (oo kP ot he ehhoner's oratsoe
n oth hes seelagy, Neel am ord sBastted
Pehhoos hgurr on etta roaritol

isurdesleroirg Ord led to atgormeng.

pastent
The Respondent No 1 move8 bock tohe wntre Dr
sovant thetopy rn a hospital
ploe ord eakorshp
Respondeat No s. he
Soaa9t helped pE Soq (oked
Resp00dent No- 4 ond
befweer the Respondent No4 fod
Griro-maseslal aloy Lato4
J was n t suse
Tie Wehtore
out tu be pteqrort
other the boey"
Obue the
Rules cd
Hhol, Ruleg e the
Pehhoner Subrots Act whch ovees
Haadu makhioqe
unde he
shot!,s re
oullet
otlvoqd
otlolq
Sesponoent,the
the
e
is lurq be mode o Co-brespondernt n the pehhon
n the caoe Mhapala Venkalta orora r MMapola
impleo0rc the ooullet in the Bot
(ed0ietou that
necekcsy oss he necestatey Dasuy
me pekha subn hat uros Seehon (3) tere
)
(oe nvolues, an allequkon & yolun tagy SevalThe
nteose by he spouse wth a g ah:
n speohc
armendment Joes aot alsqaley the eule m
he omenoment coes ot
te4n. To chet ecoto
baame opon the erdoeernert a Rule, thy
hove ory
it conhnues to be m
hat
j) The pehhonet subm 4e thot he rOns moes
it cledt hot euen Srale odet o seual
nte4cose, wh a peson who ond auhom
he knos ot has geaSOr to belieue, to be the
wde onother pesSon, wthaut the (orsernt
(onnNone e tot other ebon, omnk to
vÔU Hes1 which coees eothm the ombt o
Sechon 13 (D ) a he At in the context o
oeer OPpi.t eae or diaMe. Theteby

oQultey (onknuous y to otoct SAon 130)()

 ke oHon re pondere, heas, (ouse
ko the ehhoe cod he doubtk ond
meral

pertoral Ond Praeaorna) lye Ont maye,

Oo%.Qmdent o dt cohch ehtrones s entteo) to

wite con clorrn es,htuhon e

6ohehes

Aet 4SS?
thot, he srporoerrt Oesnt
efhore subm
a ) ne qnk aiek wrat the
canqal
ry oqnt to Seek
rorm the sresQondernt
Dehhone hus ftedl
thxs
oQQattunts to Seek Resporent
has lost he Setone chld he
mayeves, the othet
EUGe . uno the
n
No. 4 sn quesion
such as odul
alleqaio spuseconrut
whern mneshahon d
thut Reopey SpUuse.
Stosed, wrth Othet
sesttukon
fe /ne sreaeoy of
be esce) the
subnds to',
The Pehhoge o
at
not
otd
 a iudreal separahon The mdq (on be
(14a) p 19.
Se Sockson V Socksorn
suoms hat, cn otde t0 gocceed
The pekhonen
show that he s "Sinenel
he pokhoner must
be hes a bono d dese t0 teUrne
i-e, hat
Nceimonal Coabitohor ord to stender he
Aqnts ord duhes o sch conasteton ond a
1ehhoner who s shcere in that Serse i
enkted to o decHee ewen honh the pahes
not haue ony otehon yes eoh other.

) Tn the case a Tindex ouo Vshru chason

Siqn 'AR (966 TEik q5), n thas cse the
huslnd has oceus,e ae aue tlecit seloon
wtth one Lolit Nouyay. The couhel do the ye
sys that n the lote e ths otlephon rtsnet
s
assible o ony cote to qo botk to hen hustonod
ond Lve th hn. The objeet e o decuee to
Seshtuhon o (onjuqal ghts no doubt ss thot
the hasord oro e shoul (ne tocqctthen. Tie

te undren tel gule o

moioigl louw thot one soouse is enhtd to
the
 Tie pethoner Subms tat, e huebor
(t ntoleta ble Ao
lve wtth oO
baouant oÝul4etous, wte.
S0ch a in this C&he ord
pessiel 0 1l
the stoge qd
ueuners it eudence ord
(onnot be Sod thot theye u
teasorable es cue for the
wye to sele
k) (ome bock to he husbono .

3 whethet husbono (on qet Cus,looy vrdei tHnou

roaty ard quaØNanshp Act14s62
) Tre pehbuner sbms thot corsiderq the ek
fhe case ,+ woud be beter othe chld t0
ataosphere hor dothey. mageoey
Stoy in the
ond watos Act, the athe a
Urjr Guandrons
notusal auaMdion &the cold.
Hhe
subras tte, conttollre
ne petihonet the Custady 8 the
COrsider ahon qovenra the. chbtoyen
chtdsen is he weyae heorputers.
tiqnts of
(ontened ond not the ts well
Moe ouelr ,
Socoo V Socob]. conceng the
LOSy mates
the
seted hat rount
the aa
Coðy ona childe
pashuleinfay
ths thot
ol setart copoo|
eleq ytende
Copoasr v
 o, ensted t0 mtetcrm
2) whefhe the ule
wde
montomegnce
whern here
d)TheVeioner aubme hot
as oouty the mom tor'nente
Sehnus alleqohon
ond Sochon lan)
undeH Sechon (8sra) cnd (S) oro
Cs.Rc s not opplaa ble.
5 The Petshunex subms tot the keQondeat to t
n ooul FOe, heee,she os not
enhted yon monterore eom the pehth uner
) when the one the squuse inoulqe in the
edPb-rasittal stteexes oos, thuss spoAe would
ot be entted to the aomtoinen ce.
) he Tehhone subrms that, the sechros (a S(
oro() Cslc eod as tolleu:.
(9 o wle shall be enhted to MeleNe on
ollowore slocn hen hessbod Urda hs seehon

9ent 1eason, she tels e, to lue wth hey

husbond o d tte ate lrey sepaoiels bay
mutual (osert
(5) on oal that ony wqe

oouttyoß1 ttat cotheut sulccert

secescn she ee, tO to tue oth
with he husbond,
o9 thatk they ae. ln sepaalel by mua|
(onsent:
Ke pehhone subrmiH that, he goprerne (Grt
he case Sonaguva qulopga khondecor V
.doopa Ketiyera nondekat, in whch he
o monteone owaMded to the uoe
who odul4y anetled. Te
S,ore found
was

t Val satyooonSoqlop oos

syt.
S
N Tme peshonet sulbm8 thot the pef honer
not loalble o he poyet ot ony e the
Jutute mointerorre - but euen with eqod to
mo intenonee ws oncerned, he
he aeat
be liable to
Dethone, in my opinon, awoul not
vieuw the ato the
tby the Sorme in the (outt.
decision the
the DvisTOn Berch
 he Qehborey humy subrnt that m
wHERE FORE,
the Innt
ond outhaites cited,hl hes Horble Coustt be
gaot the dAvaee ond (us,tody
t0
chrd to Deitones. Futhe mate
the
montoinerne plec ed by
Plesedto dsacss the
he
other adea,,
he best
dschon that t moy deero tit n
(nketest

S-Ntoth bpuc
Abuocote 4otettonet.