Professional Documents
Culture Documents
牟宗三:共产国际与中共批判
牟宗三:共产国际与中共批判
/
!"#
$% &'()*+,-./
!"#$%&'()*+,-./0 123&,456!7895,:;<=
,>?,@AB,CDEF=,GHIJKLM0 N"OPQRS6
)*+TUVAW XYZ[\]^_`-ab)*+cdefgh ij kQ
lmnopqh ijrsR,tuvwxyz{|,n}vwh ijtu~W
W , vv/h Ej,a"W ?B,",vv
/j=fgi:On}jh LtuW `j
=C:n,h 23(, ¡¢£h ¤¥¦§n¨©ª«h ¬
5®¯°±,²³h ®¯5=´µ¶·nh =i´µ¸´µ:¹²h :º
»h =CD¼½´µ=,nI½j¾¿,¢ÀÁh ½jÃÄÅ,¶Æ
zÇÁjÈÉÊËÌ,Rͽj¾¿,ÎÏÁÐCÑÒn}ÓÔ
h jÕÖÐ:ÎÏh Ð×lØ=5#ÙnÚRÛÜÝ`Þß0 àÜÝ
`0 tuvw0 áâã,QäåæTç,n}6j=,n
I:èéê£tuvwM0 ½j¾¿,¢Àëìí ÃÄÅ,¶ÆzÇëìM
Á6
n}ÓÔîï,vw0 :ðñêQò,óí Qôa",ó0 Â@Q
òí QIí Qôa",óõö#Ý6)+,nIC:#Ó÷àÛøù
úÔûüýþí lÿí l(,h EMÓ÷àÛ,h jQ
!"#$%&'( )*+,-)./ !"#$%&'()*+,-./
01 23456"7892345:"789
ÏC>@AB,CD/ GaEFGH72,IJ>KLM,CD/ Ga
NOPQ72RR,>S÷~£7TU,VW% XY,vùZ[/ \B]@ù07
!"#$%&'()*+,-./
!"#$%&'( )*+,-)./ !"#$%&'()*+,-./
.0 12345678
!"#$%&'()*+,-./
!"#$%&'( )*+,-)./ !"#$%&'()*+,-./
!"#$%&'()*+,-./01234567 6+8,9:1;<&=>?
@ABCD7 EFGHIJ&1
KLMNOPQRSTUVW&1XJ? YP7 ZS[\]^& _&Q
R`7 EFXBab&\]c&0defg1hNFAB\]c&0defg7
ijkJYP1lm7 KLkJnopqr stuvw xyz{|}~1A
fgS_& i,& ijSab&7 ab_&QRjc
&fg7 j+S\]c&1S & _j`&X Yd& 1
A Yd& i&ow qw tw v7 j}7 S_&Q
Rj`FX 0&1AB7 2oqtv[ Y
d& I 1lS Yd& w 0& joqtv¡
S¢£& TIVW&12¤^9¥w ¦M1]§2TU¨©ª`
«&d¬$% +TSIj¨©ª`«&®¯~°±w ²³¡´µ& ¶
W&)A·¸,¹©ªº»w ©ª¼½)2Ij¾¿6ÀYÁC&©ªÂÃÄ Å
2,UÆ"cN2&ÃÄ]ÇÈXÉd½ ÊA¢£&VWË 2+,UM
N̾¿6ÃÄ ÊA¢£Æ"cVWË1AB¢£& [Í
ÎQRÏSXfg [¿6ÃÄÐÑÒSXfg1AÓÐÑ&ÔÕÖ,×
ÅØÙ,|¸ ]§¾©ª¿6ÃÄ+jAB¢£NÚ ÛËAB¢£
ÜF©ªÃÄSIjFÝÞ&1AB¢£SXßdàw ÝÞw fg&áâ1
2IjNãä&ÝÞz7 ]Tåæw ]çè@ÍÎ7 Å2TUÈéêë&d½
Æ"cìY^ ínísîïÍÎð&YP1ñòð`7 ©ªóôõÁ7 ö
÷ø´&ùàõÁ7 ÜF UAúûw AúJì&7 FüýþU~mw û~m7
6ASì&ÿH !¾&ÿH$"!6UN #¾ÿHFÝÞ&ÃÄ#!KÌ$
%Y^ &A·ßM'1
KLMN(Fá) Yd& w 0&*U+ÍÎÏ&YP
QRj ab&,7 j &9-1Xßdàw ÝÞw fg7 j./Ã
Äw óô0VÃÄ7 A·1
01 234567"8
123ÍS4567Ï8´&ý_1 9@:;<V&C
!"#$%&'()*+,-./
!"#$%&'( )*+,-)./ !"#$%&'()*+,-./
!"#$%&'()*#+,-."/01*234 56789:;<=>5?;
<@5ABC0'DEFG@&'5A>HIJ9@&'5A>KL"/M1NO
#P*4 Q7:R&'ST;<4 U9OVWXC&'()Y9F&'O;<4 K
L&'*Z[J9\]^*_`:a4 &'\b:a>\bc9SdRef4 9S
dRgh$&'iT]^*_`4 5AjT;<$&'FklmnopqZ[r4
Oo9(s*>tklmn*9(sJ9Ouvqw&'*]^x`4 yOuq&
'kWzs4 {9(s|Ouq&'klzs$}%&'*Z[J9Oa(]^*
_`4 ~9OL*ef*HR4 ~9OL*e*4 Ouq 4 L*
4 }%~"Ob>(Lklmn*4 &'GU3]
e=F>&'9t(`#4 0N`#>&'a9t,-
4 ,-=4 }%@&'} *=¡jA4 Y¢9ST;<>&'£
¤¥ ¦=N§¨+*#4 &'©`ª«¬>
'®L¯°±²³²´µ4 ¢9S¶·>¸¹7Oº»¼½¾¿6ÀÁ
©:R4 tUOuq01*ÂÃdRc(Ä*ÅÆ4 ]^*ÂÃHÇÈu(ÄH
R¾0É*ÅÆ4 ¢9Ouqmn*ÊË>KLÌ74 Ív¤w@kmn*¡j4
'Î7ÏTÐÑÒ ÏTÓÔx*Õ2Ö ÏT×Æ*ØÙÖ ÏTÚÛ4 UÜG
O±²*ÝÞ>Kßà ±²*:R4 ¹TÀÉr4 t¸ÂÃdRá*ÝÞ4 ÈH
R:=4 âOzãä*åH4 T9vzwæç*gh>Kß4 ¸Tèé*ê@>¸
~9Oëì>F@º»¼½c¸Tíî4 ï?ðñiTíîCòóôNTíî>
¯°4 M}õö*4 ÷O¸*°rÖ øùr4 Kß4 ¸úOÕW
û*Ôü>tO4 ¯°ýþÿß4 ¸þOê@4 kåH4 'ýþö¾¸U
!4 â9¬v%w"#¯°*$%dR&å>¯°*$%dRÌ7a(0
rc*efrghr>}%¯°('G9S|\ÕWû*Ô!8¸4 ¸(
'GOÂÃdR*23>¸*ÂÃdRÅ4 ¾(¯°±²§Ë*ÀÁ4 ¸
*]dR©¾)*ÓÔ¶*+,>}%±²OÂÃdR*lW4 Oer-.*§
/>¸0dÂÃer>¸9O1]4 ~9O23>4±5(O4±54 ¢9
S6ëq±²>ýOUµ7ò8=4 9£:N;<>'=T®>±²OÂÃd
R*lW4 Oer-.*§/4 '©S?@±²*åHrèér>'\ÂÃ
dRáA%BC*DH4 ~ETÿß4 ©SF]¸9z¶·G ¸OHÝ*åH>I
þT\]^*ÂÃHÇ&]*dRáJA%K®Ö A%L<>I9ö¾UM4
!"#$%&'()*+,-./ !"#$%&'()
*+ ,-./0123.40
OPQRSTUV7WXY&OZ@DEG[\STUV7&]N6^_
N. 0`abc OPd e9fPgR>]hi&D0&j4dklB]j
4. mRn>o&P. ROp. !qROPdOPRir V7st&>]4
udB]vw&4uxDy <4&MN9z y 3{&|}~ft
-& hi& dV7R3&). -R&f
&$. s-RN&d5B]. s-aR)|}&
d)|}. &Nf -qbO2 d¡Rc y¢
£t -qbR>]2&¤¥d-Q¦§R _¨©>ª«f¬d
©QR)|}&d!©f(&¬QR®edy®e9 ]
&^_N¯s_°± 5² a¯s³´µ]N&¶·dV7QR>] ]
N&]dARS]Wqbq>¸¹Z&XYd ]qA
-º&/N !»- º&¼NdQyB º&¼N&½¾¿À9 q
bq>]XYf3dB]XYf3QR OP>4u&hi dB] x
DÁ/ 3{&|}~fÂÃ XY&ÄYtdQy² XY&ÄYt
OP>Å&4ua-&Æ~Nd-qR>]ÇÈ&ÉÊdqb³ËÌY S
ÍNÎ S]&Îx³qµdÏRÆ~&ÄYÐÂ >]Æ~&hij4!
d
yB¸>ѳ´]N >ÑÂÃÒÓ&XYNt <%>7R¯b&d3{
&|}~fÂÃXY!4&ÔZf|} ¯sÕÖ×&¹PØÙÚ ¹
P4Ûf~dyB¹PØÙf~t ÜÝÞß tà~¨MWOáft
¢¬dBx¯scÒÓ>]OV7â B]V7QRtà&ã$¨MWd-
R>]äå&æ> «tàf~dB]V7QROPd¯RyB¸OP
S]N&çèé0qbêëd>M&~ìí qbîïN&ð
ñdòTU&ó(qbôP !ó(õ~4ö÷føã sù4Û
t&¹PØÙ !ó(fqbêë !ó(5qAR B>êú&¬
!"#$%&'( )*+,-)./ !"#$%&'()*+,-./
!"#$%&'()*+,-./ !"#$%&'()
*+ ,-./012345678
GJ6KLMN$-OP( Q*RSTUVW'0X,YZ[\]-^_1`
abcd0e*( fg$hij`abcd0Q*( X,Vkbcd-lm( nV
k`abcdop*GCVq-rst auvbcopwV1GW0xyNAz,
{w1GW( op*GC|}~" |0Xh Rbcd0ZGF
Ma( $MR0R*a#-au0e*( `
abcdCR0X,Ya-( e*( `abcd
C6 0¡¢)N$-6( Vk£op¤¥¦( §X,¨©ht £
Rª«¬( ®R¯¬( °°±±²)³h´GA( µ³h´GA0YZ
)¶·i¸¹`abcd0º»¼$½¾¿¢À" ÁÂÀ( hijz0ÃVÄ
ÅÆ6EÇ¿¢À" ÁÂÀ( ÈFÉ)¶£Rª«¬°±²hÊËz( ÌÉ
-ÍÎvhÏÐVwÑbc-ÒÂ( xyN§ÓYÌX-ÍÎv( hÏÐ
wÑbc-ÒÂ0)¶ÔÀW'( ÕÖÕ×( ÉØÅX¨©h0¨Ù( }ÚG
Û( ÉVkbcd-pm( ÉVE£op¤ÜÝbcdÞß¾àau0ÉYZxy
N-`abcd*-( ØVáZÉ¡[( YÉhijz0
âG" É@kbcdopVEß¾àau( É£op¤ÜÝ( ɾVãhÏ
ÒÂijz0âä" É@k[]nV*£å-Uæ¤ `abcd0|çMV
èé ê-;ë( XVì ê-ê0MXèéíîï-;ë( XÓYð
ñòÂóô0)¶É¼hõXÔÀö÷øùâú" É@kt ûbcdÓYß¾à
au( XP)¶ha#( §V*[]üýþÁ-²¬0Z)¶( º
Vÿ!Éh"6( hê6#" C#0Y( ûÉ£Rª«¬A`abcd
Ci$¹( ɧÕ%à[]Þ&'0(xyN-)*( [\+,ß-üý1.
/( Q)00üý112-34v5406,FxyN60Ó7xyN!m8H
#0Ó)( É)¶ijX( XopV1Ñ0X¼*P+É-,0
Y( +19:O;<|=t []üýþÁV1`abcd( >1`a?
ö@§V1`a( >1XµABC-`aÀ0
!"#$%&'( )*+,-)./ !"#$%&'()*+,-./
!"#$%&'( )*+,-./0#1234056768'9:;<=>
?@ABC;<=D ./&'EFGH>IJ./KLAMNOP6QRSTU
VD -./WX<Y&D Z[+\]^_BC<`a+bc?dedfD gh7
i]Gjklmno./&'D +A?BC8'69:D *+A?pq0r61
2]./&'n4stuAvw=xy6pq$%z]k{|}pq<+~^
<~# ( I^aA|}.66$%z( o$
&'D $%&'4sD ^"6WKLa+$%&'D ^}p
q$%z>
^"6$%za+A0&J06pq$%z>klmw
¡¢£D ¤¥¦ }#$%zAv §¨©ªD v «¬¨©OP>
0&6$zA§®«¬¯°6]±A}²M³´µ¶A·¸M¹]º
»6¼½z¾¿ÀZghMi]ÁD -§¨©ªD -«¬¨©OP6$z
AÂÃÄÅÆ\jBÇÈÉ]OPªWXo$zD tuAqÊËÌ Í
ÎÏ ÐÑ6ÒD Bq A\j $6ÓÔ§®«¬¯°£D ÕMÖ¼
½D ÕMÖ×D tuFÂTØD Ù²a+ÚÛ¥BqÜ5>±AªW
XD Ù²TBqÜ5D ^_Ù²¶ÝÞ߬àhBq$%zá ٲ߬Öâ
Bq A+\ $6>"IJ $Bq D Gj}Ò©ÆD ã
gäâ MiÏ RiÏ åæÏ çÏ ÆèéÆÏ «vêëÏ Y&ìÒD }+,
íî]ïnD ðñw òó6äD }TôõD BA"Gö÷#¼â ø
ùú#¼]M²Tçûü£öD MNTç«ýD þÿ!"-Bǧ#¥D þÿ
$}p6$z!"%j&']
01 234567#89:;<=>?
+(klmpq$zA)[D }*+´,ämç-J$z.$
z/q]¿îJ¦ ðA$z6D A0126D A}3Tùú6]I4D }5
6ä$zD +(0&6$z¿+A}pq$z]M²J}678$
z39:D ;+<ë=$zD ¿$> $z?D @ZABCD6çED
F^+<G]I4D +<HIMD +,!Jk{nKD +,LMîNOP.-
OP@§#¥^1>lQOP6mçÅR]*55SFTUD çVÉWXB^
!"#$%&'()*+,-./
-.
!"#$%&'( )*+,-)./ !"#$%&'()*+,-./
01 2#3456734
!"#$%&'()*+,-./
!"#$%&'()*+,-$.&/0123456789:;< 5=>89?
@< ,-$%&/ABCDE/FGHI5JK?@L :;?@< MNOPQRS
-$.&< 8TUVW< AH4 JXYZ!=[YZ!"#$%&'()'*+',-%.'($//F
G5JXYZ\]^=[YZ_ 5NOPQR-`abS NOPQMcd?@!`
ab/
JeL UeL =[L fgL 6hL iYL ijklL mnXoS Apq4JX
YZ!rstu/AvTUtuq4NOR!TUw=/0xS yz{|}~'
(< / Je4Z< J!J!"
UJe< ,4l ! ^J!"UJe/45 =>+!<
4'(5cd!.L Z ¡!e¢S +!/At4
NOPQ!TU£¤!w=S A{Iy'¥¦S §|¨©ª«!¬/y
®¯°`+o±/l²!³´H4!£'(,µ¶!PQ·/0xS H
4³´!¸¹tuS º»¼½¾¿ÀÁÂÃ1³´/0xS ³´Ä®¯Å
!ÆÇL °`!=hS +o±/ UeH4JeÈÉ,Q?!UJÊ
Ë!PQ/yÌJeS Hz{ÌUe/ÌUeS ÍXoÎÏL NOPQ/y
ÐÑÒÓeS ,ÔÕUÉe/y®¯Å!L ÒÓe!ÆÇS Ö×ØS M
S +Ù±UÉeS y Ue4ÚÛÜ×Ø!ÝÞ/yAß < Ð4y
!6à,àJ/ÒÓez{4 !ÒÓe/A#ÒÓeáUÉeÑTâã!
äT/åæçT< èéUe/®¯Å!ÒÓeåæçTq4àêc< 0
x< q4ëC!ÒÓe< Ð4TUì|í TUî¾/
ÌUe< Í6hiY/, 6h!¤ÝZz{4ïð6ñ,+! Y
É6hòz{Ue< óôJÑYÉ6hõ/,ö÷:;!øùZú»
û*üý:í þ[Í&ÿ6h< 4!!"#$í Xo#$/iYz{Ap6
hÑ !"!#%< H4 < z{Ap6h< Î&^'í ()
*+í ,-.í /012í /03&< ,Ã1ëC!iY< Ñ&4¤5í Ñ!"
6?e!iY/»6hiY4NOPQ!!"#$< Ä4TU£¤!NOw
=/y®¯7`+o±/
NOPQ986hiY!Ã^< H499:;ÝZ! ijkl!Ã^/5
<ä!#j=9ijklP>NO!Ã?/»ijkl4;PNOá=e<
Ä4NOPQ!!"#$/@4AT×Bë?!CDí ×ØEF!G
01
!"#$%&'( )*+,-)./ !"#$%&'()*+,-./
!"#$%&'()*+,-./ !"#$%&'()
*+ ,-./01234
'(e%gkÂ`Ã+ÄiÅAÆjOk)*M'()*Ç,-./_GÈÉ
>ÊÇ,-./MË+,-./NÌOPÍw" h_GÎÏÐ+M
ÑÒÃÓ ÎÏÐW+ÔÕTg¿t WÖ+ÔFGWO×+ÔMØ
ng!7ÃËGÎÏ+MÙNTÚ+ÛÜÝ6hÞßDàMáâãäNå¹+æq
Ìçè+éêMëGhÞìítîU ämRØï+{Ñ*gFðñQhÞÃÓ ñ
GgW¿òT7óÎÏU ñGgô¿ò¢T7óÎÏ{ôU NGõôO×+ôOö
£÷U ÌÔ¢TGÎÏ+ø NGõÈÉ+ùúûü0ô÷U !_Gý¾0ôU Æ
þk+ô{h¶¢Ø`ïÔ{ËFG¿¶]ÿ ¿¶!{"_ý¾0ô÷U ñ
Gý¾]^Ø`ïÎÏ{g #ý¾+$%k6& ÃÎÏ{=#ý¾+$%_
GÈÉ+>Ê '(+)*{gh'>Ê(U ¿± ý¾0)O*+,î
S-.`ï #ý¾0)O}EEWWLU ¿_±/01Ö`m+''
234567Æ8{` _gh'>Ê(U _N¶9Ö+:ò;gÓ ¿òGý¾
0ôU ¿òG<Ü=Æ<>?+/01Ö{_g@ABh:òyU 6N'()*&
÷U Ì,-6GÎÏ+{ÎÏFNgh¶éêkó{CDh¶éêU äGßDà
Øõï+{
!"#$%&'( )*+,-)./ !"#$%&'()*+,-./
--
!"#$%&'()*+,-./
!"#$%&'( )*+,-)./ !"#$%&'()*+,-./
-.
!"#$%&'()*+,-./
!"#$%&'( )*+,-)./ !"#$%&'()*+,-./