Professional Documents
Culture Documents
cell/electrolyser system
Revised 16th November 2020
Accepted on 15th January 2021
E-First on 24th February 2021
doi: 10.1049/iet-rpg.2020.0508
www.ietdl.org
Xiangjun Quan1 , Qinran Hu1, Xiaobo Dou1, Zaijun Wu1, Ling Zhu2, Wei Li2
1Southeast University, Nanjing, Jiangsu Province, People's Republic of China
2NARI Group Corporation, Nanjing 210003, Jiangsu Province, People's Republic of China
E-mail: xquan@seu.edu.cn
Abstract: With the rapid development of renewable energy sources (RESs), adopting power-to-gas to improve the penetration
of RESs is promising. This study designs a grid-forming application for the fuel cell/electrolyser (FC/ELZ) system to supply the
frequency support for the grid as well as the voltage source. The detailed control methods including the DC, AC voltage controls
and the power synchronisation control are designed for the FC/ELZ system so that it can operate independently without any
other energy sources. Several simulation results are provided to demonstrate the effectiveness of the designed grid-forming
application of the FC/ELZ system.
IET Renew. Power Gener., 2020, Vol. 14 Iss. 17, pp. 3368-3374 3368
© The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2021
Fig. 1 Studied FC/ELZ system
operate independently to provide services without battery and regulation which is not the subject of this paper. This paper will
ultracapacitor or other energy sources. mainly focus on the control part to realise the grid-forming
In the following content, the studied system is first described in application of the FC/ELZ system.
Section 2, then the control design of the system is demonstrated in
Section 3. Several results are demonstrated in Section 4 to verify 2.2 Model of FC and ELZ
the effectiveness of the proposed control. Finally, the conclusions
are discussed in Section 5. From the perspective of the control design, the model of the FC
and ELZ can be represented by the output voltage–current (V–A)
characteristic. According to [22], the V–A features of FC is:
2 System description
2.1 System configuration uFC_cell = E0 + Kln pH2 pO0.52 − λeiFC_cellH s (1)
Fig. 1 shows the studied FC/ELZ system. The FC and ELZ are
connected to the DC link by boost and buck converters, where E0 and K are functions of temperature, and pH2 and pO2 are
respectively, then the DC link and AC bus are connected via a the effective partial pressures of hydrogen and oxygen,
bidirectional DC–AC inverter. Different from the conventional respectively. The third term in (1) denotes the voltage droop where
grid-following control method of the FC/ELZ system, this paper λe is a constant and H s is a first-order filter with fast time
endeavours to control the FC/ELZ system as a grid-forming constant.
application to offer frequency support for the grid. Furthermore, The electrical model of the ELZ can be expressed (with the
unlike the typical FC/ELZ system, the battery or ultracapacitor is marked current reference direction in Fig. 2):
not configured to reduce the cost. Therefore, the voltage of the DC
link has to be controlled by the FC and ELZ through the boost and r1 + r2T ELZ
buck converters, and the DC–AC inverter will be controlled as a uELZ_cell = urev − iELZ_cell + Kelg 1 − KiiELZ_cell (2)
A
voltage source to realise the grid-forming application. Then the
whole system can operate independently, and the DC and AC ports where urev, TELZ, and A are the reversible voltage, temperature and
can be used to connect other DC and AC sources or loads. area of electrode, respectively. Ke is function of TELZ, and Ki is
To realise the grid-forming control for the FC/ELZ system, a
function of TELZ and A. Other parameters are empirically
system control scheme is designed as shown in Fig. 2. The DC link
voltage is controlled by the dual-loop controller where the outer determined [6].
loop is the DC voltage control and the inner loops include the FC More details and V–A curves of the model of the FC and ELZ
current control and ELZ current control. The ELZ and FC current can be referred to in [6, 22]. From viewpoint of electrical control,
references are limited by [−Imax, 0] and [0, Imax], respectively, to the V–A features of both FC and ELZ can be treated as an offset
voltage in series with a voltage droop and rise, respectively. This
ensure the correct power direction. This dual-loop controller
feature will be a benefit for the next control design.
guarantees the constant DC-link voltage so that the DC–AC
inverter can realise the AC voltage control and the power
synchronisation control (PSC) for the grid-forming application. 3 Control design
The whole control of both DC–DC and DC–AC converters shown 3.1 Current control for ELZ buck converter
in Fig. 2 by blue arrows has fast dynamic response, and achieves
the power balance of the FC/ELZ system. The pressure of the The small-signal block diagram of the ELZ current control is
hydrogen tank can be managed by the energy management system shown in Fig. 3 where the voltage vd2 is used as the control input.
(EMS) which adjusts the power reference of the system to realise The switching frequency averaged model is adopted. The
energy optimisation. The EMS belongs to slow-time-scale disturbance of the ELZ voltage can be neglected because,
IET Renew. Power Gener., 2020, Vol. 14 Iss. 17, pp. 3368-3374 3369
© The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2021
Fig. 3 Small-signal control diagram of the ELZ current
2kpvs + 2kiv
(5)
2 2 2
udc = Gvr s udcref = 2 udcref
Cds + 2kpvs + 2kiv
3.2 Current control for FC boost converter Then defining the state variable of the integrator as
Fig. 4 shows the small-signal diagram of the boost current control ẋc = ec = uCref − uC (8)
for the FC. It can be seen from Fig. 3 and Fig. 4 that the vd1 and vd2
are selected as the control input, so that the boost current control The open-loop system representation of the AC voltage control
has the same TF with the buck current control of the ELZ. This scheme can be formulated as
symmetric design is a benefit for the DC link voltage control since
both FC and ELZ current loops act as the inner loop of the DC −Ra1 − jω −a1 0 a1 0 0
voltage loop but with the different current direction. Therefore, the
FC current loop adopts the same control parameters, and the same ẋ = a2 − jω 0 x + 0 vc + −a2 il + 0 uCref
(9)
model can be used for the outer DC bus voltage control. The 0 −1 0 0 0 1
voltage of vd1 and vd2 can be modulated by the corresponding pulse y = uC = Cx = 0 1 0 x
width modulation (PWM).
where x = [xp xc]T = [iL uC xc]T represents the augmented state
3.3 DC-link voltage control variables. The proposed capacitor voltage control law is
The DC-link voltage control is designed on the basis of a power
model. The power model of the DC-link with a capacitor Cd can be vc = − kp1iL − kp2uC − kc xc + kdil + kruCref (10)
expressed as (the instantaneous powers of the inductors are
neglected) as shown in Fig. 2.
Then the closed-loop system is
2
1 dudc (4)
C
2 d dt
= pd − pi ẋαβ = Ac x + B2cil + Brc yuCref (11)
3370 IET Renew. Power Gener., 2020, Vol. 14 Iss. 17, pp. 3368-3374
© The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2021
−Ra1 − a1kp1 − jω −a1 − a1kp2 −a1kc
Ac = a2 − jω 0 ,
0 −1 0
B2c = a1kd −a2 0 T, Brc = a1kr 0 1 T.
The state feedback gain K = − [kp1 kp2 kc] can be designed by the
well-known pole placement method [23], and then the feedforward
kd and kr can be designed by pole-zero cancellation [23, 24]. Fig. 6 Small-signal diagram of the active power control
According to the closed-loop TF:
Table 1 Circuit parameters of the PVSG system
Parameter Value
−1
uC = C sI − Ac B2cil + BrcuCref
Zd(s)il + Zr(s)uCref (12) L inductance of AC filter 1 mH
= Gdil + Gr yref = C capacitance of AC filter 54 μF
(s − pd)(s − pn)(s − pn∗)
R/Rd inductor resistance 0.05 Ω
where Lg grid-side inductance 1.5 mH
Ld DC-side inductance 1.8 mH
Zd(s) = a2s a1kd − s − jω − a1R − a1kp1 (13)
Cd DC link capacitance 3300 μF
Zr(s) = a1a2 krs − kc (14) fs switching frequency 16,000 Hz
— voltage RMS/frequency 120 V/60 Hz
we have the configurable zeros which are related with kd and kr. — DC link voltage 400 V
Consequently, kd and kr can be determined by pole-zero
cancellation.
4 Verification
3.5 Power synchronisation control To verify the effectiveness of the proposed grid-forming control of
To realise the grid-forming control, the PSC is adopted, since the the FC/ELZ system, several cases are first simulated by MATLAB/
frequency is employed to adjust the active power between the Simulink. The system parameters used in the simulation are shown
inverter and grid [25, 26]. The proposed PSC is shown in Fig. 2. in Table 1. The FC uses the model supplied by MATLAB/Simulink
Neglecting the resistance of the line, the mathematical models with 100 cells which have open-circuit voltage of 220 V and
governing pi and qi are expressed with ΔU = Uc-Ug nominal operating voltage of 180 V. The ELZ model is established
using the model (2).
The damping oscillation frequency of the DC loop is selected as
UCUgΔδ UC UC − Ug
pi + jqi ≃ +j = AΔδ + jBΔU (15) 2000 Hz with critical damping factor, while the DC link voltage
X X loop is designed with a damping oscillation frequency of 200 Hz
which is one-tenth of the current loop. The resulted parameters are
where Δδ denotes the phase difference, and X = ωLg. Consequently,
kpi = 19 Ω, kii = 4.931 × 104 Ωs−1, kpv = 1.8 S, kpi = 491 S s−1. The
the small-signal diagram of the active power control can be
parameters of AC voltage loop are kp1 = 5.245 Ω, kp2 = 0.379, kc =
demonstrated by Fig. 6 where Δωg = ωn − ωg.
−221.68 + j29.279, kr = 1.324 + j0.1, kd = 5.124 + j0.3747 Ω. The
The TF of the active power control can be deduced as
power control is designed to obtain a settling time of 0.1 s. The
pi = Gr p s piref + Gωp s Δωg resulted parameters are kpω = 5.15 × 10–04 kg - 1 m - 2 s2, kiω =
Ak pωs + Akiω 0.0083 kg-1m-2 s, Dp = 10/2π kW/rad s−1(10 kW/Hz).
= piref
s2 + Ak pω + Dpkiω s + Akiω (16)
4.1 Power reference tracking
As + Dp Akiω
+ 2
s + Ak pω + Dpkiω s + Akiω
Δωg . The power reference step is first tested to verify the function of the
proposed control. As shown in Fig. 7, at 0.2 s, the active power and
reactive power references both step from 0 to 10 kW. The real
From (16), it can be observed that Grp(0) = 1 and Gωp(0) = Dp, this
power can track the power reference with settling time of 0.1 s,
proves that the proposed controller can achieve the power reference which accords with the design target, and in this case, the FC
tracking and droop function, Dp denotes the droop coefficient. outputs power since the reference is positive. At 0.4 s, the active
Moreover, different from the conventional power control, the gain power reference changes to −10 kW, correspondingly, the real
kpωis introduced to adjust the damping ratio of the loop, so that Dp active power is regulated to −10 kW according to the power
can be released to only serve as the droop coefficient. Finally, reference step, and the ELZ starts to absorb the power. When the
based on (16), the parameters of the active power control can be active power reference returns to 0 at 0.6 s, the real active power
designed based on the desired droop coefficient, damping goes back to 0, and the current of ELZ also is regulated to 0. The
oscillation frequency and damping factor. result proves that the proposed control can realise the power
The reactive power controller is a simple integrator. The tracking control of the grid-forming application for the FC/ELZ
resulted first-order closed-loop system is system.
IET Renew. Power Gener., 2020, Vol. 14 Iss. 17, pp. 3368-3374 3371
© The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2021
Fig. 7 Result of power reference step
The simulation results are shown in Fig. 12. At time t1, the PV
output power 3.5 kW (PV current 10 A, PV voltage 350 V), the
output power at the AC side is 0, hence the PV power is absorbed Fig. 12 Real-time simulation result of PV change
by the ELZ to produce the hydrogen (ELZ current − 25 A, ELZ
voltage 140 V). Then at t2, the PV has a 10 A current step, as can 6 Acknowledgments
be seen in the ELZ current, the additional power is also absorbed This paper is supported in part by State Key Laboratory of Smart
by the ELZ. At the time of t3, the power reference of the grid- Grid Protestation and Control. This paper is also supported in part
forming controller is set to 7 kW, then all of the PV power is by National Natural Science Foundation of China (52007034).
controlled to flow into the grid, and the current of the ELZ returns
to zero. At last, at t4, the PV power reduces to zero, to sustain the
7 References
output power, the FC starts to supply the energy as shown by the
FC current. Therefore, the results verify the effectiveness of the [1] El-Sharafy, M.Z., Al-Obaidi, A.A., El-Taweel, N., et al.: ‘Optimal scheduling
of bidirectional energy conversion units in energy and ancillary service
proposed method. markets for system restoration within MCESs’, IET Renew. Power Gener.,
The above results prove that the proposed grid-forming control 2020, 14, (3), pp. 427–434
of the FC/ELZ system works well to manage the power of the [2] Xing, X., Lin, J., Song, Y., et al.: ‘Modeling and operation of the power-to-
system. When the system outputs power, the FC acts as a power gas system for renewables integration: a review’, CSEE J. Power Energy
Syst., 2018, 4, (2), pp. 168–178
source. While the ELZ acts as a load when the system absorbs [3] Wang, C., Nehrir, M.H.: ‘Power management of a standalone wind/
power from the grid. Moreover, the grid-forming control of the AC photovoltaic/fuel cell energy system’, IEEE Trans. Energy Convers., 2008,
side supplies the frequency support function and voltage source. 23, (3), pp. 957–967
[4] Haruni, A.M.O., Negnevitsky, M., Haque, M.E., et al.: ‘A novel operation and
control strategy for a standalone hybrid renewable power system’, IEEE
5 Conclusion Trans. Sust. Energy, 2013, 2, (4), pp. 402–413
[5] Mendis, N., Muttaqi, K.M., Perera, S., et al.: ‘An effective power
A grid-forming application is designed for the P2G system. The management strategy for a wind-diesel-hydrogen based remote area power
detailed control method is designed for the FC/ELZ system. The supply system to meet fluctuating demands under generation uncertainty’,
power management is well achieved by the proposed control IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., 2015, 51, (2), pp. 1228–1238
[6] Esmaeilian, H.R., Fadaeinedjad, R.: ‘Resolving power quality issues raised by
method. The good grid-forming results, such as the voltage aerodynamic aspects of wind turbine in isolated microgrids using fuel cell/
establishment and frequency support, are accomplished by the electrolyzer system’, IEEE Trans. Sustain. Energy, 2016, 7, (3), pp. 1274–
designed control scheme. The simulation results verify the 1283
effectiveness of the proposed control.
IET Renew. Power Gener., 2020, Vol. 14 Iss. 17, pp. 3368-3374 3373
© The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2021
[7] Zhou, T., François, B.: ‘Energy management and power control of a hybrid [17] Kpoto, K., Sharma, A.M., Sharma, A.: ‘Effect Of energy storage system
active wind generator for distributed power generation and grid integration’, (ESS) in low inertia power system with high renewable energy sources’. 2019
IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., 2011, 58, (1), pp. 95–104 Fifth Int. Conf. on Electrical Energy Systems (ICEES), Chennai India, 2019,
[8] Trifkovic, M., Sheikhzadeh, M., Nigim, K., et al.: ‘Modeling and control of a pp. 1–7
renewable hybrid energy system with hydrogen storage’, IEEE Trans. Control [18] Sockeel, N., Gafford, J., Papari, B., et al.: ‘Virtual inertia emulator-based
Syst. Technol., 2014, 22, (1), pp. 169–179 model predictive control for grid frequency regulation considering high
[9] Hassan, S.Z., Mumtaz, S., Kamal, T., et al.: ‘Performance of grid-integrated penetration of inverter-based energy storage system’, IEEE Trans. Sustain.
photovoltaic/fuel cell/electrolyzer/battery hybrid power system’. 2015 Power Energy, 2020, 11, pp. 2932–2939
Generation System and Renewable Energy Technologies (PGSRET), [19] Guilbert, D., Yodwong, B., Kaewmanee, W., et al.: ‘Power converters for
Islamabad, 2015, pp. 1–8 hybrid renewable energy systems with hydrogen buffer storage: a short
[10] Hassan, S.Z., Li, H., Kamal, T., et al.: ‘Fuel cell/electrolyzer/ultra-capacitor review’. 2018 Int. Conf. on Smart Grid (icSmartGrid), Nagasaki Japan, 2018,
hybrid power system: focus on integration, power control and grid pp. 28–33
synchronization’. 2016 13th Int. Bhurban Conf. on Applied Sciences and [20] Inci, M., Turksoy, O.: ‘Review of fuel cells to grid interface: configurations,
Technology (IBCAST), Islamabad, 2016, pp. 231–237 technical challenges and trends’, J. Clean Prod., 2019, 213, pp. 1353–1370
[11] Mohiuddin, S.M., Mahmud, M.A., Haruni, A.M.O., et al.: ‘Design and [21] Quan, X., Yu, R., Zhao, X., et al.: ‘Photovoltaic synchronous generator
implementation of partial feedback linearizing controller for grid-connected (PVSG): architecture and control strategy for a grid-forming PV energy
fuel cell systems’, Int. J. Electr. Power Energy Syst., 2017, 93, pp. 414–425 system’, IEEE J. Emerg. Sel. Top. Power Electron., 2019, 8, (2), pp. 936–948
[12] Kamal, T., Hassan, S.Z., Espinosa-Trujillo, M.J., et al.: ‘An optimal power [22] Wang, C., Nehrir, M. H., Shaw, S.R.: ‘Dynamic models and model validation
sharing and power control strategy of photovoltaic/fuel cell/ultra-capacitor for PEM fuel cells using electrical circuits’, IEEE Trans. Energy Convers.,
hybrid power system’, J. Renew. Sust. Energy, 2016, 8, (3), p. 035301 2005, 20, (2), pp. 442–451
[13] Golpîra, H., Seifi, H., Messina, A. R., et al.: ‘Maximum penetration level of [23] Quan, X., Dou, X., Wu, Z., et al.: ‘A novel dominant dynamic elimination
micro-grids in large-scale power systems: frequency stability viewpoint’, control for voltage-controlled inverter’, IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., 2018, 65,
IEEE Trans. Power Syst., 2016, 31, (6), pp. 5163–5171 (8), pp. 6800–6812
[14] Nguyen, H.T., Yang, G., Nielsen, A.H., et al.: ‘Combination of synchronous [24] Quan, X.: ‘Improved dynamic response design for proportional resonant
condenser and synthetic inertia for frequency stability enhancement in low- control applied to three-phase grid-forming inverter’, IEEE Trans. Ind.
inertia systems’, IEEE Trans. Sustain. Energy, 2019, 10, (3), pp. 997–1005 Electron., 2020, doi: 10.1109/TIE.2020.3021654
[15] Denis, G., Prevost, T., Debry, M., et al.: ‘The migrate project: the challenges [25] Harnefors, L., Hinkkanen, M., Riaz, U., et al.: ‘Robust analytic design of
of operating a transmission grid with only inverter-based generation. A grid- power-synchronization control’, IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., 2019, 66, (8), pp.
forming control improvement with transient current-limiting control’, IET 5810–5819
Renew. Power Gener., 2018, 12, (5), pp. 523–529 [26] Zhang, W., Cantarellas, A.M., Rocabert, J., et al.: ‘Synchronous power
[16] Ndreko, M., Rüberg, S., Winter, W.: ‘Grid forming control scheme for power controller with flexible droop characteristics for renewable power generation
systems with up to 100% power electronic interfaced generation: a case study systems’, IEEE Trans. Sustain. Energy, 2016, 7, (4), pp. 1572–1582
on Great Britain test system’, IET Renew. Power Gener., 2020, 14 (8), pp.
1268–1281
3374 IET Renew. Power Gener., 2020, Vol. 14 Iss. 17, pp. 3368-3374
© The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2021